The Aesthetics of Transcendental Materia

Amy Ireland/Texts/Essays/The_Aesthetics_of_Transcendental_Materia.pdf

P. 1
X.O ODA N=GO HEIAN JB 8=GU>PMC# ODAT ODMJR = GA=BGANN REIOMT >JPCD EIOJ JIA JB ODA =>=I@JIA@ RJMFEICN% 9RJ JM ODMAA HJIODN G=OAM ODAT D=PG EO JPO ?JQAMA@ REOD = NDEIEIC @AKJNEO JB ?MTNO=GN%%% = C=G=ST JB N?EIOEGG=OEIC @E=HJI@N% 9DA JMECEI=G >M=I?D EN IJ GJICAM MA?JCIEN=>GA% ;%%%< :D=O 1 D=QA ?=GGA@ N]d^̲LWWT^L̲TZY EN = HAIO=G KMJ?ANN RDE?D @M=RN BMJH AQAMTODEIC OD=O D=KKAIN%Y $ 8OAI@D=G# AY >ZaP# *+ X9MENJI !.6 '*,"- . @TI=HE? IPHAME?=G =GGE=I?A RDE?D ?=I >A NPHH=MENA@ =N JIA$BJM$3EIAY !RDJGA$@ACAIAM=OEIC EI?JI?GPNEQAIANN" =I@ XIEIA BJM 4IAY !@EQEIA KAMBA?OEJIENH" BMJH JKKJNEOA NE@AN% 9MENJI EN ODA IPHAME?=G BEAG@ JB =GG M=@E?=G EINPMCAI?EAN# DAMANEAN =I@ NP>QAMNEJIN%Y $ 7AU= 3AC=MANO=IE# CGJNN=MT OJ 6dNWZYZ[POTL# (** ESP 4P^̲SP̲TN^ ZQ E]LY^NPYOPY̲LW ? L̲P]TLWT^X 1 4 B]Z[LPOP̲̀TN QZ] HPYZ[ZP̲TN 6]PL̲TaT̲d 7LNS LN̲ ZQ ^[PǸWL̲TZY MPRTY^ bT̲S ̲SP TYaZNL̲TZY ZQ L WTXT̲# LYO bSP̲SP] ZYP NZY^̲]̀P^ T̲ P[T^̲PXZWZRTNLWWd# ZY̲ZWZRTNLWWd Z] P^NSL̲ZWZRTNLWWd# L Sd[Z̲SP̲TNLW WTYP ̲]LNPO ̲S]Z̀RS PLNS ZQ ̲SP^P OPNWPY^TZY^ bTWW TYaL]TLMWd ]PaPLW ̲SP ^TWSZ̀P̲̲P ZQ ̲SP S̀XLY ^̀MUPN̲% 4^ T̲ T^ ̲]LOT̲TZYLWWd ̀YOP]^̲ZZO# LP^̲SP̲TN^ NLY ZYWd ̲LVP [WLNP ZY ̲SP TY^TOP ZQ ̲ST^ WTXT̲ MPNL̀^P ZQ ̲SP [LN̲ T̲ SL^ XLOP bT̲S S̀XLY ^̀MUPN̲TaT̲d LYO T̲^ Pc[P]TPYNP% 4YdZYP L̲̲PX[̲TYR ̲Z ̲SPZ]T^P L [L̲S ZQ ]P^T^̲LYNP ̲Z ^̀NS NZYQTR̀]L̲TZY^ LYO LaZTO# L̲ ̲SP ^LXP ̲TXP# QLWWTYR TY̲Z ̲SP ̲]L[ ZQ YLTaP ]PLWT^X# Z] bZ]^P# ̲SL̲ ZQ OZRXL̲TN XP̲L[Sd^TN^# T^ ZMWTRPO ̲Z MPRTY Q]ZX TY^TOP ̲ST^ WTXT̲% 4YO dP̲# Q]ZX SP]P# ̲SP ̲L^V ZQ NZYNPTaTYR L ]TRZ]Z̀^ ]PLWT^̲ ̲SPZ]d ZQ LP^̲SP̲TN^ ^PPX^ LY TX[Z^^TMWP [L]LOZc% 6P]̲LTY ZMUPN̲$Z]TPY̲PO ̲STYVP]^ bZ̀WO OT^LR]PP bT̲S XP SP]P# [L]̲TǸWL]Wd ̲SZ^P LXZYR ̲SPX bSZ L]P [POWL]^ ZQ L ]LOTNLWT^PO QTYT̲̀OP XL]VP̲PO ̀YOP] ̲SP MLYYP] ZQ L VZZVd f[Z^̲$VLY̲TLYT^Xg ̲SL̲ YPaP]̲SPWP^^ ^TX[Wd OT^NZ̀Y̲^ =LY̲ Z] ̲SP OPaPWZ[XPY̲ ZQ XZOP]Y ^̀MUPN̲TaT̲d ̲SL̲ ST^ bZ]V T^ L QZ̀YOL̲TZYLW [L]̲ ZQ# ]L̲SP] ̲SLY ^̀NNPPOTYR STX% @Z# ̲SP bLd Z̲̀# L^ ?PTWWL^^Z̀c bZ̀WO LQQT]X# T^ LWbLd^ ̲S]Z̀RS# TX[Z^^TMWP L^ ̲SP ̲L^V L̲ SLYO XLd QT]^̲ L[[PL] ̲Z MP% 4^ ̲SP YLXPWP^^ YL]]L̲Z] ZQ LYZ̲SP] LP^̲SP̲TNZ$P[T^̲PXZWZRTNLW PY̲P][]T^P ZYNP [̲̀ T̲1 1 ?=IYO CJ JI% 1YGG CJ JI% 4 NL̲NS[S]L^P# TQ ̲SP]P PaP] bL^ ZYP# QZ] ̲SP ̲L^V ZQ ^[PǸWL̲TaP LP^̲SP̲TN^% ;Y ̲ST^ bLd ̲SP NZ̀]^P T^ ^P̲ TY LOaLYNP1 ZYP X̀^̲ QTYO L bLd ̲Z ̲]LaPW Q]ZX ]P[]P^PY̲L̲TZY ̲Z []P^PY̲L̲TZY# Q]ZX MA[]ZÒN̲TZY ̲Z []ZÒN̲TZY# Q]ZX ̲SP NZYOT̲TZYPO ̲Z ̲SP ̀YNZYOT̲TZYPO $ TY ^SZ]̲# L bLd ̲Z ̲]LY^R]P^^ ̲SP MZ̀YOL]d ̲SL̲ NT]ǸX^N]TMP^ ̲SP []TXL]d ^̲L̲P LYO NZYNPLW^ T̲ Q]ZX 1
P. 2
̲SP ^PNZYOL]d ZYP% ;Y Z]OP] ̲Z OZ ̲ST^ bP YPPO ̲Z ̀YNZaP]# TY ̲SP aP]d WPL^̲# ̲SP STY̲ ZQ L SZWP# L WPLV# Z] LY P]]ZYPZ̀^ Z] OT^TYRPỲZ̀^ XZXPY̲ TY ̲SP []PXT^P ̀[ZY bSTNS ̲ST^ MZ̀YOL]d SL^ MPPY P]PN̲PO% ESL̲g^ ]TRS̲# MPQZ]P ̲SP Q̀Y NLY ]PLWWd MPRTY# bP L]P ZMWTRL̲PO ̲Z ]P̲̀]Y ̲Z =LY̲ TY Z]OP] ̲Z ]PNZY^TOP] ̲SP NZYOT̲TZY^ ZQ ̲SP TYL̀R̀]L̲TZY ZQ ̲SL̲ ^̲L̲P ZQ LQQLT]^ bP YZb VYZb ![P]SL[^ LWW ̲ZZ bPWW" L^ fS̀XLY QTYT̲̀OPg Z]# TY ̲SP TOTZX ZQ ̲SP ̲]LOT̲TZY ̲SL̲ bZ̀WO Z[[Z^P T̲# L^ fNZ]]PWL̲TZYT^Xg% ESP =LY̲TLY []ZSTMT̲TZY L]T^P^ Q]ZX L XZXPY̲ ZQ []ZQZ̀YO N]T^T^ TY 7YWTRS̲PYXPY̲ ̲SZ̀RS̲ ̲d[TQTPO Md L [L]LOZcTNLW# ^TX̀W̲LYPZ̀^ OP^T]P QZ] Z[PYYP^^ LYO TY^̀WL]T̲d ̲SL̲ NLY MP NZ]]PWL̲PO bT̲S# ZY ̲SP ZYP SLYO# ̲SP NZX[P̲TYR LYO OTaP]RPY̲ [STWZ^Z[STNLW OT^NZ̀]^P^ ZQ ^NP[̲TNLW PX[T]TNT^X !LY L]R̀XPY̲ QZ] ]LOTNLW Z[PYYP^^ aTL L XZOPW ZQ Pc[P]TPYNP []TaTWPRTYR ̲SP L [Z^̲P]TZ]T ^dY̲SP^T^ ZQ SP̲P]ZRPYPZ̀^ PX[T]TNLW OL̲L $ bSP]PMd LY PcNP[̲TZYLW []POTNL̲P XLd PcNPPO LYO LW̲P] T̲^ ^̀MUPN̲" LYO >PTMYTeTLY&GZWQQTLY ]L̲TZYLWT^̲ XP̲L[Sd^TN^ !̀W̲TXL̲PWd L OT^NZ̀]^P ZQ NZY̲LTYXPY̲ LYO [̀]TQTNL̲TZY ̲SL̲ L]R̀P^ QZ] ̲SP ^̀MZ]OTYL̲TZY ZQ ̀Y]̀Wd S̀XLY Pc[P]TPYNP ̲Z L ]L̲TZYLW L []TZ]T LYLWd̲TN ^NSPXL# bSP]PTY YZ []POTNL̲P# YZ XL̲̲P] SZb PcNP[̲TZYLW# NLY PcNPPO ̲SP [L]LXP̲P]^ RTaPY TY LOaLYNP Md T̲^ ^̀MUPN̲"2 LYO ZY ̲SP Z̲SP] SLYO# ̲SP ̀Y[]PNPOPY̲PO PNZYZXTN [Z^^TMTWT̲TP^ M]Z̀RS̲ LMZ̲̀ Md ̲SP ST^̲Z]TNLW PXP]RPYNP ZQ TYÒ^̲]TLW ^ZNTP̲TP^ ̲]LOTYR TY NZXXZOT̲TP^% GSP̲SP] ZYP NZYNPTaP^ ZQ ̲SP XZXPY̲ [STWZ^Z[STNLWWd Z] PNZYZXTNLWWd# ̲SP ^̀OOPY# ̲]L̀XL̲TN LYO ̀]RPY̲ YPNP^^T̲d ̲Z OPQTYP LYO ^̲LMTWT^P L ]PWL̲TZY ̲Z YZaPW̲d T^ PaTOPY̲% B]Z̲Z$TYÒ^̲]TLW 7YWTRS̲PYXPY̲ ^ZNTP̲d# NL̀RS̲ MP̲bPPY ̲SP [L]ZNSTLWT^X ZQ ̲SP 7̀]Z[PLY =I?EAI MWCEHA LYO ̲SP OLbY ZQ LY fL[[]Z[]TL̲P XZOP]YT̲dg# TY ̲SP bZ]O^ ZQ @TNV >LYO# fbLY̲^ MZ̲S ̲Z WPL]Y LYO ̲Z WPRT^WL̲P QZ] LWW ̲TXP# ̲Z Z[PY T̲^PWQ ̲Z ̲SP Z̲SP] LYO ̲Z NZY^ZWTOL̲P T̲^PWQ Q]ZX bT̲STY# ̲Z Pc[LYO TYOPQTYT̲PWd bSTW^̲ ]P[]ZÒNTYR T̲^PWQ L^ ̲SP ^LXP% ;̲^ ̀W̲TXL̲P O]PLX T^ ̲Z R]Zb bSTW^̲ ]PXLTYTYR TOPY̲TNLW ̲Z bSL̲ T̲ bL^# ̲Z ̲Z̀NS ̲SP Z̲SP] bT̲SZ̲̀ àWYP]LMTWT̲d%g( EST^ T^ ̲SP P¥̀LWWd TX[Z^^TMWP [L]LOZc ̲SL̲ SL̀Y̲^ ̲SP MT]̲S ZQ ̲SP XZOP]Y P]L LYO []ZaTOP^ ̲SP XL̲P]TLW NZYOT̲TZY^ QZ] ̲SP TYL̀R̀]L̲TZY ZQ ̲SP OZN̲]TYP ZQ QTYT̲̀OP $ WP^^ LY LOaPY̲ ZQ [STWZ^Z[STNLW ^TYNP]T̲d ̲SLY L ^̲]L̲PRd QZ] ̲SP XLYLRPXPY̲ ZQ PcNP^^% >LYO# ¥̀T̲P ̀YNZY̲PY̲TZ̀^Wd# ^PP^ ̲SP =LY̲TLY N]T̲TNLW []ZUPN̲ L^ ̲SP ANNTOPY̲g^ XZ^̲ []ZQT̲LMWP LYO []ZOTRTZ̀^ TYaP^̲XPY̲ TY ̲SP ZYRZTYR ^d^̲PXL̲T^L̲TZY LYO XL^̲P]d !Z] Pc[WZT̲L̲TZY# TQ dZ̀g]P ]PLOTYR T̲ PNZYZXTNLWWd" ZQ L ̲]L̀XL̲TN PYNZ̀Y̲P] bT̲S ̀Y[]PNPOPY̲PO LW̲P]T̲d% ES̀^# TY ̲SP /MEOELPA JB 5PMA 7A=NJI# =LY̲ ]P^ZWaP^ ̲SP [L]LOZc ZQ TYQTYT̲P Pc[LY^TZY LYO TYQTYT̲P ]P[]ZÒN̲TZY Md OPaT^TYR L [STWZ^Z[STNLW [Z^T̲TZY ̲SL̲ LOXT̲^ ̲SP ^dY̲SP̲TN NL[LNT̲d ZQ Nick Land, fKant, Capital and the Prohibition of Incest,g in Fanged Noumena, eds. Robin Mackay and Ray Brassier (Falmouth: Urbanomic, 2012), 63-64. 1 2
P. 3
PX[T]TNT^X !̲S̀^ ?MEOELPEIC bSL̲ SP ^Lb L^ ̲SP SLNVYPdPO TY̲]LN̲LMTWT̲d ZQ ̲SP ]L̲TZYLWT^̲^" M̲̀ L̲ ̲SP ^LXP ̲TXP# ̀YTaP]^LWT^P^ LYO OPWTXT̲^ T̲ Md ̲P̲SP]TYR T̲ ̲Z ̲SP ]L̲TZYLWT^̲ ̲PYP̲ ZQ ̲SP L []TZ]T TY Z]OP] ̲Z L]]TaP L̲ LY ̀Y[]PNPOPY̲PO LXLWRLXL̲TZY ZQ ̲SP ̲bZ NZYQWTN̲TYR [Z^T̲TZY^1 S̀XLY Pc[P]TPYNP T^ YPT̲SP] L [Z^̲P]TZ]T LYO ^dY̲SP̲TN YZ] L []TZ]E LYO LYLWd̲TN# T̲ T^ L []TZ]T LYO ^dY̲SP̲TN $ ̲SP Pc̲]PXP^ ZQ Z[PYYP^^ LYO TY^̀WL]T̲d PLNS PX[WZdPO TY ̲SP ̲PX[P]TYR ZQ ̲SP Z̲SP]% 4^ QL] L^ VYZbWPORP T^ NZYNP]YPO# Z[PYYP^^ ̲Z LW̲P]T̲d bZ̀WO MP [P]XT̲̲PO# []ZaTOPO ̲SL̲ T̲ QT]^̲ [L^^PO ̲S]Z̀RS ̲SP WPRT^WL̲TaP ̲P]XTYLW ZQ ̲SP L []TZ]T QZ]X^% EST^ XZaP# ̲SP N]̀c ZQ =LY̲g^ ^Z$NLWWPO f6Z[P]YTNLY ]PaZẀ̲TZYg# L̲ ZYNP ̲TP^ VYZbWPORP T]]PaP]^TMWd ̲Z Pc[P]TPYNP# Z̲̀WLb^ LWW QZ]X^ ZQ ]PLWT^X# LYO OPWPRT̲TXT^P^ XP̲L[Sd^TN^# PQQPN̲TaPWd ^P̲̲TYR ̲SP ^NPYP QZ] ̲SP ]T^P ZQ [Z^̲XZOP]Y LY̲T$]PLWT^X LYO ̲SP ^Z$NLWWPO fPYO ZQ XP̲L[Sd^TN^g bSTNS bZ̀WO ̀YQZWO ZaP] ̲SP ̲bZ$S̀YO]PO ^̀NNPPOTYR dPL]^ ZQ ̲SP OZN̲]TYPg^ ]PTRY% ESP aT]̲̀Z^T̲d ZQ ̲SP L []TZ]T ^dY̲SP̲TN XZOPW WTP^ TY ̲SP ]PWZNL̲TZY ZQ ̲SP NZYOT̲TZY^ QZ] ̲SP L[[PL]LYNP ZQ Pc̲P]YLW ZMUPN̲^ TY ̲SP S̀XLY XTYO T̲^PWQ% GSPY LY ZMUPN̲ T^ [P]NPTaPO# T̲^ ]Lb ^PY^Z]d XL̲P]TLW $ bSL̲ =LY̲ ]PQP]]PO ̲Z L^ f̲SP ^PY^TMWP XLYTQZWOg $ T^ []ZNP^^PO TY ̲SP XTYO aTL ̲SP [̀]P QZ]X^ ZQ TỲ̲T̲TZY1 ^[LNP LYO ̲TXP% ESP^P QZ]X^ L]P ̀YTaP]^LW ̲Z S̀XLY NZY^NTZ̀^YP^^ LYO TYSP]P bT̲STY ̲SP XTYO ]L̲SP] ̲SLY TY ZMUPN̲^ ̲SPX^PWaP^% ;Y Z]OP] QZ] LYd̲STYR ̲Z PY̲P] TY̲Z S̀XLY Pc[P]TPYNP T̲ X̀^̲ [L^^ ̲S]Z̀RS ̲SP^P QZ]X^# bSTNS TXM̀P T̲ bT̲S LY PcNSLYRP aLẀP# NLWǸWL̲PO TY ̲SP ̀YTaP]^LW Ǹ]]PYNd ZQ ̲SP S̀XLY ^̀MUPN̲ !L VTYO ZQ ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW 0=GGAMOA"# dTPWOTYR T̲ ̀[ ̲Z ̲SP ^dY̲SP̲TN Q̀YN̲TZY ZQ ̲SP NL̲PRZ]TP^ ZQ ÙORPXPY̲ ̲SL̲ NZX[WP̲P ̲SP []ZNP^^ ZQ PcNSLYRP# TY^N]TMTYR ̲SP ZMUPN̲ TY [SPYZXPYL% ES̀^ ̲SP PY̲T]P̲d ZQ ̲SP fPc̲P]YLWg bZ]WO XP]PWd ]PQWPN̲^ MLNV ZY̲Z ̀^ ̲SP TXLRP ZQ Z̀] ZbY XTYO^% ESP XZ^̲ bP NLY PaP] ]P[]P^PY̲ ̲Z Z̀]^PWaP^# ̲SP XZ^̲ bP NLY PaP] VYZb $ ̲SP [TYYLNWP ZQ S̀XLY VYZbWPORP LQ̲P] =LY̲ $ T^ ^TX[Wd ̲SP ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW L[[P]NP[̲TZY ZQ ̲SP NZYOT̲TZY^ ̀YOP] bSTNS ZMUPN̲^ NZYQZ]X ̲Z ̲SP DPH=I Pc[P]TPYNP ZQ ̲SPX% ESP NL̲L^̲]Z[SP !ZQ LW̲P]T̲d" SLO MPPY LaP]̲PO QZ] ̲SP ̲TXP MPTYR% @PaP]̲SPWP^^# ̲SP ^d^̲PXL̲T^L̲TZY ZQ S̀XLY Pc[P]TPYNP bL^ QL] Q]ZX NZX[WP̲P% ESP QT]^̲ /MEOELPA YPNP^^T̲L̲PO L ^PNZYO# LYO ̲SP ^PNZYO YPNP^^T̲L̲PO L ̲ST]O% GT̲S PLNS LOOT̲TZY ̲SP N]T̲TNLW ^d^̲PX R]Pb TY MZ̲S NZX[WPcT̲d LYO ]TRTOT̲d L^ ̲SP TX[P]XT^^TMTWT̲d ZQ TY̲P]YLW NZY̲]LOTN̲TZY ]PÒNPO ̲SP [Z^^TMTWT̲TP^ LaLTWLMWP QZ] ̲SP Q̲̀̀]P XLYLRPXPY̲ ZQ ̲ST^ ^PPXTYRWd TYPWTXTYLMWP PcNP^^% 5d ̲SP ̲TXP SP b]Z̲P ̲SP ̲ST]O /MEOELPA !̲SP /MEOELPA JB 2P@CAHAIO"# ̲SP []ZMWPX ZQ PcNP^^ SLO ^STQ̲PO ̲Z ̲SP L[[L]PY̲ fWLbWP^^YP^^g ZQ XL̲̲P]% 4^ =LY̲ STX^PWQ [̲̀^ T̲ TY ̲SP TY̲]ZÒN̲TZY ̲Z ̲SP bZ]V# OP^[T̲P ̲SP L^^̀]LYNP ZQ ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW WLb^# YL̲̀]Pg^ XLYTQZWO PX[T]TNLW QZ]X^ XTRS̲ ^̲TWW MP fTYQTYT̲PWd 3
P. 4
OTaP]^P LYO SP̲P]ZRPYZ̀^%%% L ]Lb NSLZ̲TN LRR]PRL̲P bT̲SZ̲̀ ̲SP ^WTRS̲P^̲ ̲]LNP ZQ ^d^̲PXg%) fESP]P L]P QPb SZ]]Z]^g# ¥̀T[^ >LYO# fNZX[L]LMWP ̲Z ̲SL̲ ZQ ̲SP XL^̲P] WPRT^WL̲Z] bSZ ]PLWT^P^ ̲SL̲ =I=M?DT EN NOEGG KAMHEOOA@Y%* ;Y Z]OP] ̲Z MPRTY ̲SP OT]̲d bZ]V ZQ Pc̲PYOTYR ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW ^̀M^̀X[̲TZY ̲Z ̲SP PX[T]TNLW# XL̲P]TLW bZ]WO# ̲SP ̲ST]O /MEOELPA L]R̀P^ ̲SL̲ bP X̀^̲ []P^̀[[Z^P ̲SL̲ @L̲̀]P OZP^ TY QLN̲ NZYQZ]X ̲Z L ^P̲ ZQ NZSP]PY̲ LYO []POTN̲LMWP WLb^ Q̀YN̲TZYTYR L^ L ̲Z̲LWT̲d $ PaPY TQ bP NLYYZ̲ TOPY̲TQd L [̀][Z^P QZ] ̲SPX# bP NLY [P]NPTaP TY ̲SPX L f[̀][Z^TaPYP^^g%+ EST^ []P^̀[[Z^T̲TZY L^^̀]P^ ̲SP NZSP]PYNd ZQ YL̲̀]Pg^ ZMUPN̲TaP L[[PL]LYNP ̲Z ̀^# M̲̀ ZYP ̲SL̲ ]P^̲^ ̀[ZY LP^̲SP̲TN ÙORPXPY̲^ ]L̲SP] ̲SLY P[T^̲PXZWZRTNLW ZYP^% ES̀^# ̲SP ]L̲TZYLWT^L̲TZY LYO NZY̲]ZW ZQ Z̲SP]YP^^ NZY̲TỲP^# M̲̀ YZb L^ L ̲bZ$[]ZYRPO [STWZ^Z[STNLW OZXP^̲TNL̲TZY ZQ L]̲ LYO XL̲̲P]% 4RLTY^̲ ̲SP OZXTYLYNP ZQ N]T̲TNLW ]PL^ZY ̲SL̲ ^PPV^ ̲SP ̀YOP]WdTYR Z]OP] TY PaP]d̲STYR Md [Z^T̲TYR T̲ L^ TY̲PY̲TZYLW# >LYO L^^P]̲^ ̲SP PcT^̲PYNP ZQ LY L]L̲TZYLW ^̀][Ẁ^# MZ̲S L]̲T^̲TN LYO XL̲P]TLW L̲ ̲SP ^LXP ̲TXP1 f̲SP TYPWTXTYLMWP LYO MPL̲̀TQ̀W OLYRP] ZQ JLYK ̀YNZY^NTZ̀^ N]PL̲TaP PYP]Rd1 YL̲̀]P bT̲S QLYR^g% 5̲̀ fSZb OZ bP SZWO ZY̲Z L ̲SZ̀RS̲ WTVP ̲ST^ LXTO^̲ ̲SP L̀^̲P]T̲d ZQ ̲SP N]T̲TNLW []ZUPN̲3g SP L^V^% 8Z] $ f;̲ T^ [P][P̲̀LWWd ̲S]PL̲PYPO Md NZWWL[^P2 Md L ]PaP]^TZY ̲Z L OP[]P^^TaP [STWZ^Z[Sd ZQ bZ]V# bSP̲SP] ̲SPZWZRTNLW Z] S̀XLYT^̲TN% ESP ̲S]PP R]PL̲ ^̲]LYO^ ZQ [Z^̲$=LY̲TLY Pc[WZ]L̲TZY $ XL]VPO Md ̲SP YLXP^ :PRPW# DNSPWWTYR# LYO DNSZ[PYSL̀P] $ L]P NZY^̲LY̲Wd ̲PX[̲PO Md ̲SP []Z^[PN̲ ZQ L ]PÒN̲TZY ̲Z QZ]RZ̲̲PY Z] TX[WTNT̲ WLMZ̀]2 ̲Z ̲SP LRPYNd ZQ 9ZO# ^[T]T̲# Z] XLY# ̲Z LYd̲STYR ̲SL̲ bZ̀WO ]P̲̀]Y ̲ST^ ]̲̀SWP^^ L]̲T^̲TN QZ]NP ZQ ̲SP RPYP]L̲TaP ̀YNZY^NTZ̀^ ̲Z OP^TRY# TY̲PY̲TZY# []ZUPN̲# ̲PWPZWZRd%, =LY̲g^ bZ]O hRPYT̀^i T^ ̲SP TXXPY^PWd OTQQTǸW̲ LYO NZYQ̀^PO M̲̀ PX[SL̲TN ]P^T^̲LYNP ̲Z ^̀NS ]PÒN̲TZY^2 ̲SP ̲SZ̀RS̲ ZQ LY ̲̲̀P]Wd TX[P]^ZYLW N]PL̲TaT̲d ̲SL̲ T^ ST^̲Z]TNLWWd ]PRT^̲P]PO L^ ̲SP ]LOTNLW OT^NZY̲TỲT̲d ZQ ̲SP PcLX[WP# %%% ZQ T]]P^[ZY^TMWP WPRT^WL̲TZY# L^ hZ]OP]i bT̲SZ̲̀ LYdZYP RTaTYR ̲SP Z]OP]^%g- fAlthough experience constitutes a system in accordance with transcendental laws, which contain the condition of possibility for experience as such, it would still be possible that there be an infinite multiplicity of empirical laws and such a great heterogeneity of natural forms belonging to the particular experience that the concept of a system according to these laws must be totally alien to the understanding, and neither the possibility, even less the necessity, of such a totality could be conceived.g ;XXLỲPW =LY̲# Critique of Judgement, trans. Paul Guyer (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000) First Introduction, II, 9. 3 Nick Land, fArt as Insurrectiong in Fanged Noumena, eds. Robin Mackay and Ray Brassier (Falmouth: Urbanomic, 2012), 148. 4 Land: fKantgs last name for excess.g ;MTO% Kant makes this order a function of thought, rather than a function of nature-in-itself. 5 Which is to say, understanding the object through the subject. 6 Ibid. 2 4
P. 5
=LY̲g^ Pc[WTNL̲TZY ZQ RPYT̀^ T^ ̲SP ZYWd XZXPY̲ TY ̲SP ̲ST]O /MEOELPA bSP]P SP Pc[WTNT̲Wd !ZYP XTRS̲ PaPY LOO f]PẀN̲LY̲Wdg" ̲SPZ]T^P^ []ZÒN̲TZY ]L̲SP] ̲SLY ÙORXPY̲# LYO T̲ T^ SP]P# LNNZ]OTYR ̲Z >LYO# ̲SL̲ LY TY^̀]RPY̲ QZ]NP T^ LOXT̲̲PO TY̲Z ̲SP N]T̲TNLW []ZUPN̲ $ QZ] T̲ ̲̀]Y^ Z̲̀ ̲SL̲ LY TY̲PY^PWd ^TRYTQTNLY̲ XZXPY̲ ZQ WLbWP^^ ^dY̲SP^T^ T^ ]P¥̀T]PO ̲Z ^̀^̲LTY L ^d^̲PX ZQ WLbQ̀W ^dY̲SP^T^ Md Q̀]YT^STYR T̲ bT̲S XL̲P]TLW QZ] T̲^ ÙORPXPY̲^% =LY̲ OP^N]TMP^ T̲ ̲S̀^1 f0AIEPNg T^ L f[]ZÒN̲TaP QLǸW̲dg# L fJYL̲̀]LW PYOZbXPY̲K QZ] []ZÒNTYR ̲SL̲ QZ] bSTNS YZ OPQTYT̲P ]̀WP NLY MP RTaPY J%%%K LYO NZY^P¥̀PY̲Wd JMECEI=GEOT X̀^̲ MP T̲^ []TXL]d []Z[P]̲d% J%%%K ;̲^ []ZÒN̲^ X̀^̲ L̲ ̲SP ^LXP ̲TXP MP XZOPW^# T%P% ASAHKG=MT2 LYO NZY^P¥̀PY̲Wd# ̲SZ̀RS YZ̲ ̲SPX^PWaP^ OP]TaPO Q]ZX TXT̲L̲TZY# ̲SPd X̀^̲ ^P]aP ̲SL̲ [̀][Z^P QZ] Z̲SP]^# T%P% L^ L ^̲LYOL]O Z] ]̀WP ZQ ÙORTYR% ;̲ ?=IIJO EI@E?=OA N?EAIOEBE?=GGT DJR EO >MEICN =>JPO ODEN KMJ@P?O# M̲̀ ]L̲SP] RTaP^ ̲SP ]̀WP L^ I=OPMA% JGKSP]P LY L̲̀SZ] ZbP^ L []ZÒN̲ ̲Z ST^ RPYT̀^# SP OZP^ YZ̲ STX^PWQ VYZb SZb ̲SP TOPL^ QZ] T̲ SLaP PY̲P]PO TY̲Z ST^ SPLO# YZ] SL^ SP T̲ TY ST^ [ZbP] ̲Z TYaPY̲ ̲SP WTVP L̲ [WPL^̀]P# Z] XP̲SZOTNLWWd# LYO NZXX̀YTNL̲P ̲SP ^LXP ̲Z Z̲SP]^ TY ^̀NS []PNP[̲^ L^ bZ̀WO PYLMWP ̲SPX ̲Z []ZÒNP ^TXTWL] []ZÒN̲^%g. 9PYT̀^ []ZÒNP^ T̲^ ZMUPN̲ []PNT^PWd Md YPRL̲TYR ̲SP PcTRPYNTP^ ZQ ̲SP L []TZ]T TY L SPLOd# []P$̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LWWd TYT̲TL̲PO LYO ̲SP]PQZ]P ̀YNZYOT̲TZYPO LN̲ ZQ ̀YTYSTMT̲PO ^dY̲SP^T^% ESP ]P^̀W̲TYR ZMUPN̲ Z] L]̲bZ]V T^ PY̲T]PWd fZ]TRTYLWg LYO dP̲ f]PaPLW^ L YPb ]̀WP ̲SL̲ NZ̀WO YZ̲ SLaP MPPY TYQP]]PO Q]ZX LYd PL]WTP] []TYNT[WP^ Z] PcLX[WP^g QZ] ÙORPXPY̲%/ GSL̲ T^ ]PXL]VLMWP LMZ̲̀ ̲ST^ NZYQTR̀]L̲TZY T^ ̲SL̲ !L^ CLNSPW <ZYP^ YZ̲P^ TY SP] P^^Ld ZY ̲SP [WLNP ZQ RPYT̀^ TY ̲SP N]T̲TNLW []ZUPN̲" L NZYNP[̲WP^^ XZOP ZQ []ZÒN̲TZY SL^ ̲SP NL[LNT̲d ̲Z RPYP]L̲P L OP̲P]XTYL̲P ZMUPN̲ ̲Z bSTNS L NZYNP[̲ NLY ̲SPY MP L̲̲LNSPO $ bSTNS XPLY^ ̲SL̲ NP]̲LTY L]̲ ZMUPN̲^# ̲SZ^P ̲SL̲ =LY̲ OP^TRYL̲P^ L^ fQTYP L]̲g TY ̲SP /MEOELPA# NZXP ̲Z ̀^ Q]ZX Z̲̀^TOP ̲SZ̀RS̲%0 4Y LWTPY LQQZ]OLYNP ̲SL̲ ^PPX^ ̲Z TY̲]ZÒNP L ]LOTNLW [Z^^TMTWT̲d TY̲Z ̲SP =LY̲TLY Q]LXPbZ]V# M̲̀ YZ̲ ZYP# YPaP]̲SPWP^^ ̲SL̲ =LY̲ YPRWPN̲^ ̲Z [ZWTNP1 fEZ L^V bSP̲SP] XZ]P ^̲]P^^ ^SZ̀WO MP WLTO TY XL̲̲P]^ ZQ QTYP L]̲ ̀[ZY ̲SP []P^PYNP ZQ RPYT̀^ Z] ̀[ZY ̲SL̲ ZQ ̲L^̲P# T^ P¥̀TaLWPY̲ ̲Z L^VTYR bSP̲SP] XZ]P ̲̀]Y^ ̀[ZY TXLRTYL̲TZY Z] ̀[ZY ÙORPXPY̲% J%%%K 8Z] TY WLbWP^^ Q]PPOZX# TXLRTYL̲TZY# bT̲S LWW T̲^ bPLW̲S# []ZÒNP^ YZ̲STYR M̲̀ YZY^PY^P2 ̲SP [ZbP] ZQ ÙORPXPY̲# ZY ̲SP Z̲SP] SLYO# T^ ̲SP QLǸW̲d ̲SL̲ XLVP^ T̲ NZY^ZYLY̲ bT̲S ̀YOP]^̲LYOTYR% EL^̲P# WTVP ÙORPXPY̲ TY 7 Kant, Critique of Judgement, trans. James Creed Meredith (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008), section 46, pp. 136-137. 8 Ibid., 183. 9 Rachel Jones, fCrystallisation: Artful Matter and the Productive Imagination in Kantgs Account of Genius,g in The Matter of Critique: Readings in KantYs Philosophy, eds. Andrea Rehberg and Rachel Jones (Manchester: Clinamen Press, 2000), 24. 5
P. 6
RPYP]LW# T^ ̲SP OT^NT[WTYP Z] hNZ]]PN̲TaPi ZQ RPYT̀^% ;̲ ^PaP]PWd NWT[^ T̲^ bTYR^# LYO XLVP^ T̲ ^PPXWd Z] [ZWT^SPO2 M̲̀ L̲ ̲SP ^LXP T̲ RTaP^ T̲ R̀TOLYNP# OT]PN̲TYR LYO NZY̲]ZWWTYR T̲^ QWTRS̲# ^Z ̲SL̲ T̲ XLd []P^P]aP T̲^ [̀][Z^TaP NSL]LN̲P]%g(' ;Y LY PNSZ ZQ ̲SP ̲ST]O /MEOELPAg^ QZ̀YOTYR RP^̲̀]P# YLXPWd# OPWTaP]TYR ̲SP []ZMWPXL̲TN SP̲P]ZRPYPT̲d ̲Z L []P^̀[[Z^PO Z]OP] [Z^T̲PO bT̲STY ̲SP ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW R]Z̀YO# RPYT̀^g WLbWP^^ XZOP ZQ []ZÒN̲TZY X̀^̲ MP ^̀M^̀XPO ̀YOP] ̲SP WPRT^WL̲TaP [ZbP] ZQ ÙORPXPY̲% B]PNT^PWd MPNL̀^P T̲ T^ ]PǸ[P]LMWP ̲Z ̲SP S̀XLY []ZR]LX ZQ ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW NZYOT̲TZYTYR# WP̲ LWZYP ̲Z ̲SP NZYNP[̲# ̲SP TY^̀]]PN̲TZYL]d [Z^^TMTWT̲d ZQ RPYT̀^ ]PXLTY^ ̀Y]PLWT^PO $ T̲^ TYSP]PY̲Wd TYS̀XLY WLbWP^^YP^^ !fYL̲̀]P RTaP^ ̲SP ]̀WP ̲Z L]̲g" T^ ̀W̲TXL̲PWd ^̀M^̀XPO ̀YOP] S̀XLY WLb%(( 4YO dP̲# ̲SP OT^]̀[̲TZY SL^ MPPY ]PRT^̲P]PO% >LYO1 fAYP ZYWd SL^ ̲Z ]PLO ̲SP ^PNZYO /MEOELPA LWZYR^TOP ̲SP ̲ST]O ̲Z YZ̲TNP ̲SP TXXPY^P OT^]̀[̲TZY ̲SL̲ L]̲ TYQWTN̲^ ̀[ZY ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW [STWZ^Z[Sd% =LY̲ ZYWd XLYLRP^ ̲Z NZY̲]ZW ̲ST^ OT^]̀[̲TZY Md XLTY̲LTYTYR L]̲ L^ LY TX[WTNT̲Wd XL]RTYLW []ZMWPXL̲TN bT̲STY L QTPWO XL^̲P]PO Md [STWZ^Z[Sd% 7aPY ̲SZ̀RS SP LNVYZbWPORP^ ̲SL̲ ̲SP L̲̀ZYZXd ZQ ]PL^ZY T^ ̲Z ̲SP SP̲P]ZYZXd ZQ RPYT̀^ bSL̲ QTOPWT̲d ZQ ]P[]P^PY̲L̲TZY T^ bSPY NZX[L]PO ̲Z N]PL̲TZY $ [ZaP]̲d LYO b]P̲NSPOYP^^ $ ̲SP XP^^LRP ^NL]NPWd ^PP[^ Z̲̀%g() @ZYP̲SPWP^^# >LYO L^^̀XP^ ̲ZZ X̀NS Md ̲LVTYR ̲SP QLTWPO TY^̀]]PN̲TZY ZQ RPYT̀^ LWZYP L^ ^̀QQTNTPY̲ PaTOPYNP QZ] ̲SP PcT^̲PYNP ZQ LY TX[P]^ZYLW RPYP]L̲TaP QZ]NP Ẁ]VTYR TY ̲SP ^SLOZb^ ZQ ̲SP N]T̲TNLW []ZUPN̲% ;Y^̲PLO# T̲ T^ <ZYP^ bSZ []ZaTOP^ ̲SP XZ]P ̲SZ]Z̀RS TYaP^̲TRL̲TZY LYO TY OZTYR ^Z ]PaPLW^ L ̲bT^̲ TY ̲SP [WZ̲ YL]]L̲PO# ̀[ ̀Y̲TW YZb# Md >LYO% >TVP >LYO# ^SP TOPY̲TQTP^ ̲SP []ZMWPX ZQ PcNP^^ SL̀Y̲TYR ̲SP ̲ST]O /MEOELPA# LYO WTVP >LYO ^SP ]PLO^ ÙORPXPY̲g^ fXLYLRPXPY̲g ZQ RPYT̀^ L^ LY TWWTNT̲ LYO OT^TYRPỲZ̀^ XZaP%(* 5̲̀ <ZYP^g aP]^TZY ZQ =LY̲ SL^ L [P]aP]^P ^̲]PLV ̲SL̲ >LYO !bSZ ^̀]PWd bZ̀WO SLaP L[[]PNTL̲PO T̲" SL^ XT^^PO# LYO T̲ STYRP^ ZY L ^̲]LYRP [L^^LRP NZYNP]YTYR N]d^̲LW QZ]XL̲TZY%(+ 10 Kant, Critique of Judgement, trans. James Creed Meredith (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008), section 50, 148. 11 Ibid., section 46, 136. 12 Nick Land, fArt as Insurrectiong in Fanged Noumena, eds. Robin Mackay and Ray Brassier (Falmouth: Urbanomic, 2012), pp. 151-152. 13 Jones fCrystallisation: Artful Matter and the Productive Imagination in Kantgs Account of Genius,g in The Matter of Critique: Readings in KantYs Philosophy, 26. 14 As if, having comprehended while working on the third and final part of the critical project that the system of transcendental philosophy, as brilliant and innovative as it was, could never legislate for everything in experience as intended, and deciding, rather than retracting or abandoning the project (which had literally taken decades to realise) to simply cover it up, Kant, wracked with guilt, planted a clue to the projectgs failure in the work itself, shifting the responsibility for the exposure of his crime to fate, and thereby assuaging his 6
P. 7
4^ PcPX[WTQTPO Md ̲SP OPaPWZ[XPY̲ ZQ TNP N]d^̲LW^# ̲SP []ZNP^^ ZQ N]d^̲LWWT^L̲TZY L^ =LY̲ OP^N]TMP^ T̲ ̲]LY^QZ]X^ XL̲̲P] ̀Y[]POTN̲LMWd# XZaTYR fL^ T̲ bP]P# Md L WPL[g Q]ZX L QẀTO ^̲L̲P ̲Z L ^ZWTO ZYP# fQZ]XTYR LYO ]PQZ]XTYR ̲SP bSZWP ^SL[P ZQ ZMUPN̲^ MZ̲S TY^TOP LYO Z̲̀# ̲SPT] Pc̲P]YLW QTR̀]P L^ bPWW L^ ̲SPT] TY̲P]YLW QLM]TNg TY L XLYYP] ̲SL̲ T^ fYZ̲ OPÒNTMWP TY LOaLYNP Q]ZX XPNSLYTNLW ]̀WP^g%(, 6]d^̲LWWT^L̲TZY OZP^Yg̲ ^¥̀L]PWd QT̲ TY̲Z ̲SP Z]RLYTN Z] ̲SP [̀]PWd XPNSLYTNLW ^NSPXL̲L ̲SL̲ =LY̲ ZQQP]^ L^ [Z^^TMTWT̲TP^ QZ] YL̲̀]P% A^̲PY^TMWd# ̲SP [L^^LRP [ZTY̲^ LSPLO ̲Z ̲SP PcLXTYL̲TZY ZQ ̲PWPZWZRTNLW ÙORPXPY̲# M̲̀ <ZYP^ [P]NPTaP^ L YPNP^^T̲d ̲Z XL[ T̲ MLNV ZY̲Z ̲SP LNNZ̀Y̲ ZQ LP^̲SP̲TN^ QZ]# bT̲SZ̲̀ ̲ST^ XZaP# ̲SP NZX[WPc ^P]TP^ ZQ ]PNT[]ZNL̲TYR LYLWZRTP^ MP̲bPPY L]̲ LYO YL̲̀]P ̲SL̲ ^̲]̀Ǹ̲]P ̲SP /MEOELPA JB 2P@CAHAIO !bSL̲ =LY̲ NLWWPO fWZRTNLW ^dXXP̲]dg" ]PXLTY^ TYNZX[WP̲P1 L OPWTMP]L̲P PWT^TZY TY Z]OP] ̲Z []Z̲PN̲ ̲SP []TXLNd ZQ ÙORPXPY̲ ZaP] []ZÒN̲TZY%(GSTWP ̲SP []ZÒN̲TZY ZQ L]̲ T^ XL[[PO ̲S]Z̀RS YL̲̀]P TY ̲SP OT^Ǹ^^TZY ZQ RPYT̀^# ̲SP]P T^ YZ ]PNT[]ZNLW XL[[TYR ZQ []ZÒN̲TZY TY YL̲̀]P ̲S]Z̀RS L XZOPW ZQ L]̲T^̲TN []ZÒN̲TZY# OP^[T̲P ZYP MPTYR ]PLOTWd LaLTWLMWP%(. ES̀^ <ZYP^# NZX[WP̲TYR ̲SP ̀YQTYT^SPO LYLWZRd# NZYNẀOP^ ̲SL̲ =LY̲g^ OP^N]T[̲TZY ZQ N]d^̲LW QZ]XL̲TZY T^ ̲SP XL̲P]TLW TY^̲LY̲TL̲TZY ZQ RPYT̀^# L XZOPW ZQ L]̲T^̲TN []ZÒN̲TZY ̲SL̲ OPaL^̲L̲P^ ̲SP TYSTMT̲PO ^dY̲SP^T^ ZQ =LY̲TLY ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LWT^X LYO dP̲ ^̲LYO^ Z̲̀^TOP ̲SP fOT^NT[WTYTYRg [̀]NSL^P ZQ ÙORPXPY̲% 4NNZ]OTYR ̲Z <ZYP^# ̲SP /MEOELPAg^ ]P[]P^^PO XZOP ZQ []ZÒN̲TZY f]LT^P^ ̲SP [Z^^TMTWT̲d L̲ WPL^̲ ̲SL̲ LYZ̲SP] VTYO ZQ $ YZY$@Pb̲ZYTLY# YZY$Z]RLYTN# ^PWQ$ Z]RLYT^TYR $ XL̲̲P] Z̀RS̲ ̲Z MP ]PNZRYT^PO#g ZYP ZY [L] bT̲S ̲SP fTXLRTYL̲TZY ̀YOP]^̲ZZO TY L YZY$ [^dNSZWZRT^̲TN ^PY^P# L^ L []ZÒN̲TaP [ZbP] NL[LMWP ZQ RPYP]L̲TYR ̀YQZ]P^PPY NZY^̲PWWL̲TZY^ J%%%K ̲S]Z̀RS ̲SP Z]RLYT^L̲TZY ZQ T̲^ XL̲P]TLW^# J%%%K bSP]P XL̲̲P] T^ ]P^̲]̀Ǹ̲]PO bT̲SZ̲̀ QZWWZbTYR []P$ RTaPY ]̀WP^%g(/ <ZYP^ T^ YZ̲ ̲]LT̲Z]Z̀^ ̲Z ̲SP WZRTN ZQ ̲SP /MEOELPA TY PWTNT̲TYR ̲ST^ XZ^̲ ̀Y$=LY̲TLY ZQ ]PLOTYR^ Q]ZX T̲# ]L̲SP]# ^SP T^ ̲SP PcPX[WL]d ]PLOP]# [̀]^̀TYR =LY̲g^ LYLWZRTNLW []ZNPÒ]P bT̲S ̲SP f^d^̲PXL̲TN ]TRZ̀]g SP L^V^ QZ] TY LWW NL^P^ M̲̀ ̲ST^ ZYP%(0 ESP ̲Pc̲ SL^ MPPY ̲SP NL]]TP] ZQ LY TY^̀]RPY̲ QZ]NP LWW LWZYR# ̲SP OZ̀MWP$OPLWTYR N]d^̲LW bLT̲TYR QZ] ̲SP ̲]T^ZYZXTN ]PLOTYR ̲SL̲ bZ̀WO sense of culpability enough to continue to practice philosophy, spending his final years - not insignificantly vigorously refuting the younger generation of German philosophersg revision of his work into increasingly radical forms of idealism. What he discovered, by virtue of the very act of writing the third Critique, was an irreducible, material excess. 15 Kant, Critique of Judgement, 177; Jones, fCrystallisation: Artful Matter and the Productive Imagination in Kantgs Account of Genius,g in The Matter of Critique: Readings in KantYs Philosophy, 28; 30. 16 Cf. Nick Land, fCircuitriesg in Fanged Noumena, eds. Robin Mackay and Ray Brassier (Falmouth: Urbanomic, 2012), p 300. 17 Jones, fCrystallisation: Artful Matter and the Productive Imagination in Kantgs Account of Genius,g in The Matter of Critique: Readings in KantYs Philosophy, 26. 18 Ibid., 29. 19 A trisonomic reading. Ibid., 26. 7
P. 8
QWT[ fOTaTYP [P]QPN̲TZYT^Xg TY̲Z fbSZWP$OPRPYP]L̲TYR TYNZYNẀ^TaPYP^^g% <ZYP^ ^TX[Wd ̲LVP^ ̲SP XL̲P]TLW XZOPW ZQ ̲SZ̀RS̲ ^P]TZ̀^Wd Md ]P[PL̲TYR T̲ L^ SP] ZbY LYO ̲STYVTYR ̲S]Z̀RS ̲SP WZRTN ZQ ̲SP N]T̲T¥̀P TY XL̲̲P]g^ ̲P]X^% ;̲ T^ YZ̲ TY^TRYTQTNLY̲ ̲SL̲ ̲ST^ XZOPW ZQ LN̲TaP XL̲P]TLWT̲d PcPX[WTQTPO Md N]d^̲LWWT^L̲TZY !L^ <ZYP^ YZ̲P^" fXTRS̲ MP PYZ̀RS ̲Z RPYP]L̲P MZ̲S ̲SP QTR̀]P LYO QLM]TN ZQ T̲^ []ZÒN̲^g# L []ZMWPX QZ] ̲SP Q̀YOLXPY̲LW ̲PYP̲ ZQ SdWZXZ][ST^X ̲SL̲ ^̀[[Z]̲^ ̲SP N]T̲TNLW []ZUPN̲ LYO QZ]X^ ̲SP ML^T^ ZQ bSL̲ ?PTWWL^^Z̀c ]PQP]^ ̲Z L^ ̲SP fNZ]]PWL̲TZYT^̲ ̲bZ$^̲P[g%)' ;Y L YZY$OTLWPN̲TNLW ]PÒN̲TZY ZQ ̲SP ÒLWT^X MP̲bPPY ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW QZ]X LYO PX[T]TNLW NZY̲PY̲ ̲Z L ^PWQ$[]ZÒNTYR LYO ^PWQ$ ]P[]P^PY̲TYR XL̲̲P]# ̲SP YZ̲TZY ZQ ]P[]P^PY̲L̲TZY T̲^PWQ T^ ]PWPRL̲PO ̲Z ̲SP ^̲L̲̀^ ZQ L ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW TWẀ^TZY# L XT^[]T^TZY ZQ []TXL]d []ZNP^^P^% ESZ̀RS̲# ÙORXPY̲# NZYNP[̲̀LW ]P[]P^PY̲L̲TZY L]P LWW ^TX[Wd OP[Z̲PY̲TL̲PO aP]^TZY^ ZQ L Q̀YN̲TZYLW [Z̲PYNd RPYP]L̲PO Md L []ZÒN̲TaP# []TXL]d# ^dY̲SP̲TN# XL̲P]TLW TY̲PY^T̲d% 4 NL̲L^̲]Z[STN ̲STYR QZ] =LY̲TLYT^X# L^ T̲ WTNPYNP^ ̲SP NZWWL[^P ZQ ̲SP N]T̲TNLW []ZUPN̲ TY̲Z TXXLYPYNP Q]ZX ̲SP ^TOP ZQ XL̲P]TLWT̲d !]L̲SP] ̲SLY TOPLWT̲d"1 ̲SP TOPLW NZYOT̲TZYTYR ZQ XL̲̲P] TYaP]̲PO ̲Z OT^NWZ^P ̲SP XL̲P]TLW NZYOT̲TZYTYR ZQ ̲SP TOPLW%)( 4 f̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW XL̲P]TLWT^Xg% ESP XL̲P]TLWT^̲ ]PLOTYR ZQ N]d^̲LWWT^L̲TZY T^ ̲SP M]PLNS TY ̲SP ]P^̲]TN̲PO PNZYZXd ZQ =LY̲TLY NZYNP[̲ []ZÒN̲TZY ̲S]Z̀RS bSTNS ̲SP ]PLW PXP]RP^ LYO ̲SP VPd ̲Z LY LW̲P]YL̲TaP LP^̲SP̲TN PNZYZXd ]P[]P^^PO TY ̲SP OZXTYLY̲ ![SPYZXPYZWZRTNLW" LNNZ̀Y̲ ZQ XZOP]Y ^̀MUPN̲TaT̲d% f;̲ T^ YZ OZ̀M̲ NZXQZ]̲TYR ̲Z ^[PLV ZQ h̲SP RPYT̀^i !b]T̲P^ >LYO" L^ TQ TX[P]^ZYLW N]PL̲TaP PYP]Rd bP]P NZXXPY^̀]LMWP bT̲S ̲SP Z]OP] ZQ L̲̀ZYZXZ̀^ TYOTaTÒLWT̲d RZaP]YPO Md ]PL^ZY# M̲̀ ^̀NS NSL̲̲P] T^# TY ̲SP PYO# LM^̀]O% 9PYT̀^ T^ YZ̲STYR WTVP L NSL]LN̲P] ̲]LT̲# T̲ OZP^ YZ̲ MPWZYR ̲Z L [^dNSZWZRTNLW WPcTNZY2 QL] XZ]P L[[]Z[]TL̲P T^ ̲SP WLYR̀LRP ZQ ^PT^XTN ̀[SPLaLW# TỲYOL̲TZY# OT^PL^P# ̲SP ZY^WL̀RS̲ ZQ ]Lb PYP]Rd Q]ZX bT̲SZ̲̀% AYP hT^i L RPYT̀^ ZYWd TY ̲SP ^PY^P ̲SL̲ ZYP hT^i L ^d[STWT̲TN# TY ̲SP ^PY^P ̲SL̲ hJIAi T^ aTZWPY̲Wd []ZMWPXL̲T^PO Md L QP]ZNTZ̀^ Pc̲P]TZ]T̲d% AYP ]P̲̀]Y^ ̲Z ̲SP ^̀MUPN̲ ZQ bSTNS RPYT̀^ SLO MPPY []POTNL̲PO ̲Z QTYO T̲ NSL]]PO LYO OPaL^̲L̲PO MPdZYO ]PNZRYT̲TZY%g)) 20 Ibid., 31; 30. Quentin Meillassoux, After Finitude, trans. Ray Brassier (London : Continuum, 2008), 5. fThus the unconditioned Nature towards which, according to Kant, reason strives can no longer be thought of as a horizon of supersensible totality, but becomes the as-yet-undetermined, an infinite potential for the emergence of future crystalline forms.g Jones, fCrystallisation: Artful Matter and the Productive Imagination in Kantgs Account of Genius,g in The Matter of Critique: Readings in KantYs Philosophy, [[% *)$ 33. 22 Nick Land, fArt as Insurrectiong in Fanged Noumena, eds. Robin Mackay and Ray Brassier (Falmouth: Urbanomic, 2012), pp. 152-153. 21 8
P. 9
ES̀^# fN]PL̲TaT̲dg T^ []POTNL̲PO ZY L OP$TY̲PY^TQTNL̲TZY ZQ ^̀MUPN̲TaT̲d% AQ T̲^ NZY̲LXTYL̲TZY bT̲S Z̲̀^TOP QZ]NP^% 4 ^̀MUPN̲ ̲SL̲ ]PNPOP^ ̲SP XZ]P T̲ []ZÒNP^% 4^ <ZYP^ LQQT]X^1 fAY ̲ST^ XZOPW# ̲SP ̲]LY^NPYOPY̲LW []ZÒN̲TZY ZQ QZ]X LYO ̲SP LN̲TaT̲TP^ ZQ ̲SZ̀RS̲ JL]P YZK WZYRP] Z[[Z^PO ̲Z L WTQPWP^^ XL̲P]TLW ^̀M^̲LYNP# M̲̀ ̲SP ^SL[TYR ZQ XL̲̲P] LYO ̲SZ̀RS̲ bZ̀WO PLNS MPNZXP LY L^[PN̲ ZQ ̲SP XLYTQZWO LYO TXXLYPY̲ Pc[]P^^TZY ZQ L [ZbP] $ Z] PaPY L QLǸW̲d3 $ ZQ N]d^̲LWWT^L̲TZY%g)* FYOP] ̲SP TX[P̲̀^ ZQ ̲SP fQLǸW̲d ZQ N]d^̲LWWT^L̲TZYg ̲SPY $ ̲ST^ LNP[SLWZ̀^ []TXL]d []ZÒN̲TZY# bSZ^P L̲̲PYOLY̲ LP^̲SP̲TN# <ZYP^ STY̲^# NZ̀WO MP ̀YOP]^̲ZZO fTY ]PWL̲TZY ̲Z NZY̲PX[Z]L]d XZOPW^ ZQ XL̲̲P] ^̀NS L^ NSLZ^ ̲SPZ]dg# ^bL]X TY̲PWWTRPYNP# YZT^P# Z] ̲SPZ]TP^ ZQ PY̲]Z[TN PXP]RPYNP $ N]T̲T¥̀P NZWWL[^P^ TY̲Z N]PL̲TZY LYO ̲SP OT^̲TYN̲TZY MP̲bPPY ̲SPZ]d LYO []LN̲TNP OT^L[[PL]^%)+ E]LY^NPYOPY̲LW XL̲P]TLWT^X ]PNZYQTR̀]P^ f4]̲g L^ LW̲P]T̲d ̲SL̲ T^ YZ̲ ]PÒNPO ̲Z ̲SP [P]^ZYLW# M̲̀ LNNP^^TMWP ̲S]Z̀RS 6A? B>;6;EI ^̲]L̲PRTP^ ZQ YZY$WTYPL] OT^^ZẀ̲TZY# G ;E: NdMP][Z^T̲TaP QPPOMLNV# 4@A@I? AFD Z] aT]LW OT^^PXTYL̲TZY# ? 4E7C;4>D bSZ^P Z]TPY̲L̲TYR aPN̲Z] ̲]LNP^ L [L̲S Q]ZX ̲SP VYZbY ̲Z ̲SP ̀YVYZbY% fES̀^ T̲ NZ̀WO MP ^̀RRP^̲PO !<ZYP^ NZYNẀOP^" ̲SL̲ TY ̲SP NZX[WPc QZWO^ ZQ ̲SP /MEOELPA JB 2P@CAHAIO ̲SP]P WTP^ L STOOPY RPYPLWZRd bSTNS Z[PY^ ZY ̲Z L Q̲̀̀]P OTQQP]PY̲ Q]ZX ̲SL̲ QZ]PR]Z̀YOPO Md =LY̲%g), 4 Q̲̀̀]P bT̲SZ̲̀ ^̀MUPN̲^ LYO ZMUPN̲^# L Q̲̀̀]P ZQ XL̲P]TLW TY̲P]QP]PYNP [L̲̲P]Y^ ]̀YYTYR ̲S]Z̀RS ̲SP S̀XLY# L Q̲̀̀]P ZQ OM=IN$# KJNO$ LYO IJI$% EST^# ; bLY̲ ̲Z L]R̀P# T^ ̲SP [ZTY̲ ̲SL̲ bP L]P L̲ YZb% .HT 1MAG=I@# 8T@IAT (&') Jones, fCrystallisation: Artful Matter and the Productive Imagination in Kantgs Account of Genius,g in The Matter of Critique: Readings in KantYs Philosophy, 33. 24 Hence the importance of theory fiction. fJudgment is the great fiction of transcendental philosophy, but cybernetics is the reality of critique. Where judgement is linear and non-directional, cybernetics is non-linear and directional. It replaces [the] linear application [of judgement to its object, form to intuition, genus to species] with the non-linear circuit and [Kantgs analogical reciprocity] with directional material flows. The cybernetic dissolution of judgement is an integrated shift from transcendence to immanence, from domination to [emergence] from meaning to function. Cybernetic innovation replaces transcendental constitution, design loops replace faculties.g Nick Land, fCircuitriesg in Fanged Noumena, eds. Robin Mackay and Ray Brassier (Falmouth: Urbanomic, 2012), 300. See also, Jones, fCrystallisation: Artful Matter and the Productive Imagination in Kantgs Account of Genius,g in The Matter of Critique: Readings in KantYs Philosophy, 30, fn34. 25 Jones, fCrystallisation: Artful Matter and the Productive Imagination in Kantgs Account of Genius,g in The Matter of Critique: Readings in KantYs Philosophy, 33. 23 9