Nihilism Now!
Monsters of Energy
Edited by
Keith Ansell Pearson and Diane Morgan
Keith Ansell Pearson and Diane Morgan (editors) - Nihilism Now! Monsters of Energy -Palgrave Macmillan (2000)
Other/Keith Ansell-Pearson/Keith Ansell Pearson and Diane Morgan (editors) - Nihilism Now!_ Monsters of Energy -Palgrave Macmillan (2000).pdf
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Nihilism Now!
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Also by Keith Ansell Pearson
GERMINAL LIFE: The Difference and Repetition of Deleuze
KANT TROUBLE: The Obscurities of the Enlightened
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Also by Diane Morgan
Nihilism Now!
Edited by
Keith Ansell Pearson
and
Diane Morgan
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Monsters of Energy
First published in Great Britain 2000 by
MACMILLAN PRESS LTD
Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and London
Companies and representatives throughout the world
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
First published in the United States of America 2000 by
ST. MARTIN’S PRESS, INC.,
Scholarly and Reference Division,
175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010
ISBN 0–312–23209–8
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Nihilism Now! : monsters of energy / edited by Keith Ansell Pearson and Diane
Morgan.
p. cm.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 0–312–23209–8 (hardcover : alk. paper)
1. Nihilism. I. Ansell-Pearson, Keith, 1960– II. Morgan, Diane, 1963–
B828.3 .N447
149'.8—dc21
2000
99–088249
Selection and editorial matter © Keith Ansell Pearson and Diane Morgan 2000
Text © Macmillan Press Ltd 2000
All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made
without written permission.
No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written
permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act
1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright
Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP.
Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to
criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages.
The authors have asserted their rights to be identified as the authors of this work in accordance
with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained
forest sources.
10
09
9
08
8
07
7
06
6
05
5
04
4
03
3
02
2
01
1
00
Printed and bound in Great Britain by
Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
ISBN 0–333–73292–8
!"#$% "& #'$ ("&#)*+,#")%
'(
-&#)".,/#*"&0 #'$ 1$#,)& "2 3"&%#)",% !*'*4*%5
'(((
)
*+% ,+-$$%.(#/ "0 $+% !.1&$-2 ,3+%.%&4 5."22(#/ 0."6 $+%
7%#$.% $"8-.9 :;
64*"# 74+$)#
< =(+(2(&6 *"#(/+$ > > >
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*;
@ =(%$A&7+%B =(+(2(&6 -#9 ,3(.($
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#'
D *+% E"#&$."F& G%H(.$+ "0 =(+(2(&6
8"9&&9 >".?$
J =(+(2(&6 -#9 K(0%4 !"&6"H("2"/1 -#9 L#$"3"(%&(& (#
M%(9%//%.;& !*$#@%/'$
A,'9*4 394*;
N G%'(&($(#/ $+% O(22 $" P"8%.4 Q7$('% =(+(2(&6 -#9 $+%
P."R%7$ "0 *.-#&S+F6-# P+(2"&"3+1
B9&*$4 ("&=9C
C 5P."'"T%9 K(0%;4 UV3.%&&(#/ =(+(2(&6
B*9&$ 3")?9&
? Q P."H2%6 "0 PF.% E-$$%.4 W-&7(&$ =(+(2(&6 (# 7 D'",%9&.
E49#$9,%
8"'& E)"#$F*
X *+% ,F.'('-2 "0 =(+(2(&6
>"=9). (9C?*44
)I ,T(#S=(+(2(&6 ="84 W2-1(#/ $+% W-7% -#9 G%0(/F.(#/ $+% ,T(#
B9F*. <""#')"C.
)) Q.$-F9 -#9 $+% Y63".$-#7% "0 Z%(#/ GF9%
(9#'$)*&$ B94$
)< 5U3(9%6(7& "0 U#"F/+;4 Z%7T%$$(-# ,F00(7(%#7(%&
B9&*$4 G9#@
)
)?
@C
CI
?N
))C
)D<
)NC
)?X
)X?
<)N
<@J
<DX
-&.$H
'
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
!"#$%#$&
!"#$% &"'()% .%7%#$21 7"632%$%9 +(& P+[B 5Q ,7+(A"/%#%-2"/1 "0 M%.%$(7-2
E-$%.(-2(&64 Z%$8%%# Z.F#" -#9 ,3(#"A-B =(%$A&7+%B [%2%FA% -#9 "$+%.
P+(2"&"3+(7-2 G%72F&%&;B -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 O-.8(7T> M% "./-#(&%9 $+%
5[%2%FA%]^F-$$-.( -#9 E-$$%.; !"#0%.%#7% -$ O-.8(7T (# L7$"H%. )XXC -#9
(& %9($". "0 $+% 0".$+7"6(#/ 7"22%7$("# 39#$)*94*%# (9)#"?)9I'*$%> M% 7F..%#$21
$%-7+%& -$ ^"29&6($+;& !"22%/%B \#('%.&($1 "0 K"#9"#>
*(#%+ &,-("" .(/)-$, (& P."0%&&". "0 P+(2"&"3+1 -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 O-.8(7T
-#9 (& $+% -F$+". -#9 %9($". "0 H""T& "# =(%$A&7+% -#9 [%2%FA%> M% (&
7F..%#$21 8".T(#/ "# - &%.(%& "0 %&&-1& "# Z%./&"# -#9 Z%./&"#(&6 (# .%2-S
$("# $" _F%&$("#& "0 6-$$%.B $(6% -#9 %'"2F$("#> M% &%.'%& "# $+% %9($".(-2
H"-.9 "0 !*$#@%/'$JA#,.*$&>
0#1+/)2 3(/)2-4$)%+ (& Q&&"7(-$% P."0%&&". "0 E"9%.# UF."3%-# P+(2"&"S
3+1 -$ $+% Q6%.(7-# \#('%.&($1 "0 P-.(&> M% (& -F$+". "0 B$))*.9 9&. #'$
E"4*#*/94 `)XXNa -#9 !*$#@%/'$ `)XXCaB -#9 (& /%#%.-2 %9($". "0 $+% R"F.#-2
D$;'&$590 9 8",)&94 "2 E'*4"%"I'C 9&. D$/'&"4"?C>
5/6#2 3$$%+)$72 (& ,%#(". K%7$F.%. (# !F2$F.-2 ,$F9(%& -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0
*%%&&(9% -#9 7"S0"F#9(#/ %9($". "0 $+% %2%7$."#(7 R"F.#-2 (,4#,)$ 39/'*&$
`+$$34]]!F2$F.%6-7+(#%>$%%&>-7>FTa> M(& 8".T +-& H%%# 3FH2(&+%9 (# &%'%.-2
R"F.#-2& -#9 7"22%7$("#& -#9 +% (& 7F..%#$21 8".T(#/ "# - 6"#"/.-3+B
(,4#,)$ "& B),?%0 !9)/"J/,4#,)94 A#,.*$% "2 >*?' 3".$)&*#C>
8$4/)2 9/7:#"" (& P."0%&&". (# M(&$".(7-2 -#9 !F2$F.-2 ,$F9(%& -$ ^"29S
&6($+;& !"22%/%B \#('%.&($1 "0 K"#9"#> M% (& $+% -F$+". "0 7)# "2 8,.?$5$&#
`)X?XaB 7 G9&# B*/#*"&9)C `Z2-7T8%22 )XXJaB <$&K95*& 9&. ("4",) `)XX?a -#9
7"S%9($". `8($+ b%($+ Q#&%22 P%-.&"#a "0 D'$ :9#$ "2 #'$ !$= !*$#@%/'$ `)XX@a>
M% (& 7F..%#$21 8.($(#/ - H""TB L$MF*&9% 9&. #'$ E"4*#*/94>
;<-%#, 9"(=(,- /,2 9+)#- >(#? +-'% 8".T%9 $"/%$+%. -#9 -3-.$ "# 2($%.-S
$F.%B #-$("#-2(&6B -#9 G"6-#$(7 -%&$+%$(7&> *+%1 98%22 (# E%2H"F.#% -#9
+-'% H"$+ $-F/+$ -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 E%2H"F.#%>
5/,#(" 9$,4/7 (& P."0%&&". "0 P+(2"&"3+1 -#9 [(.%7$". "0 ^.-9F-$% ,$F9(%&
-$ P%## ,$-$% \#('%.&($1> M% (& $+% -F$+". "0 !*$#@%/'$ 9&. #'$ E"4*#*/94
`)XXCa -#9 !*$#@%/'$N% B9&?$)",% O95$0 E'*4"%"I'C "2 #'$ D=*4*?'# "2 #'$ -."4%
`)XXCa>
'(
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
="$%& "# $+% !"#$.(HF$".&
!"#$% "& #'$ ("&#)*+,#")% '((
;$/,,/ 8$2:( (& G%-9%. (# P+(2"&"3+1 -#9 [(.%7$". "0 G%&%-.7+ -$ E-#7+%&S
$%. E%$."3"2($-# \#('%.&($1> ,+% (& "# $+% %9($".(-2 H"-.9& "0 P"5$&N% E'*4"J
%"I'C 1$F*$= -#9 7&?$49;*> ,+% 8."$% +%. 9"7$".-2 $+%&(& (# LV0".9 "# $+%
7"#7%3$ "0 $.F$+ (# <$*&? 9&. D*5$ -#9 (& $+% -F$+". "0 >$*.$??$) 9&. 6#'*/%
`)XXJa> ,+% (& 7F..%#$21 8".T(#/ "# $+% _F%&$("# "0 $(6% (# 7"#$%63".-.1
$+"F/+$ -#9 "# - H""T %#$($2%9 B$))*.$9& D$5I")94*#*$%>
5/,#(" */%@ (& 7F..%#$21 5E-cd$.% 9% !"#0%e.%#7%&; (# $+% U#/2(&+ [%3-.$6%#$
"0 $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 P(7-.9(% (# Q6(%#&B W.-#7%> M% (& $+% -F$+". "0 &%'%.-2
-.$(72%& "# Z%7T%$$ -#9 "$+%. 6-R". 6"9%.#(&$&B -2"#/ 8($+ $+% .%7%#$ H""TB
A9C*&? - !" 3")$0 A,+K$/#*F*#C 9&. ("&%/*",%&$%% *& #'$ E)"%$ "2 A95,$4 <$/;$##
`)XXXa>
A<+/#" B/"#? $%-7+%& (# $+% [%3-.$6%#$ "0 f(&F-2 Q.$& -$ ^"29&6($+;& !"2S
2%/% "0 $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 K"#9"#>
5#/,( B$):/, (& ,%#(". K%7$F.%. (# !F2$F.-2 ,$F9(%& -$ \#('%.&($1 !"22%/%
=".$+-63$"#> ,+% +-& 8.($$%# &%'%.-2 -.$(72%& "# &FHR%7$& .-#/(#/ 0."6
g 7+#%.B -.7+($%7$F.% -#9 $.-#&/%#9%. -#9 (& $+% -F$+". "0 G9&#
M-6-##B ZF
D)",+4$0 #'$ Q+%/,)*#*$% "2 #'$ 6&4*?'#$&$. `<IIIa>
;$+, .)$%(6# $%-7+%& (# $+% [%3-.$6%#$ "0 W.%#7+ -#9 Y$-2(-# -$ K"F(&(-#,$-$% \#('%.&($1B Z-$"# G"F/%> [F.(#/ )XXJhN +% 8-& - K%'%.+F26% G%&%-.7+
W%22"8 -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 O-.8(7T> M% (& $+% -F$+". "0 D*5$ 9&. 6H#$)*")*#C0
7)*%#"#4$R >$*.$??$)R B$))*.9 `)XXDaB -#9 "0 - #F6H%. "0 -.$(72%& "# -#7(%#$
^.%%T 3+(2"&"3+1B 72-&&(7-2 ^%.6-# 3+(2"&"3+1B -#9 7"#$%63".-.1 W.%#7+
3+(2"&"3+1> M(& #%V$ H""T 8(22 H% "# [%2%FA% -#9 [%..(9->
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
9/%+()#,( 5/"( .%7%#$21 7"632%$%9 +%. P+[ $+%&(& 5Q#$"#(# Q.$-F9 -#9
P+(2"&"3+14 *+% P."H2%6 8($+ *+"F/+$; -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 O%&$%.# ,19S
#%1>
Y#$."9F7$("#4 $+% G%$F.# "0
E"#&$."F& =(+(2(&6
O% 2-7T 7.%-$("#> O% 2-7T .%&(&$-#7% $" $+% 3.%&%#$>
[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.(B P'9# *% E'*4"%"I'CS `)XX)a
M-'% 8% +-9 %#"F/+i ZF$ %#"F/+ "0 8+-$ %V-7$21i L0 "F. 6"F.#(#/ -#9
6%2-#7+"2(-i L0 3"&$6"9%.# #-.7(&&(&6i L0 "F. 9%3.%&&('% (22#%&& -#9 -#V(S
%$(%& "0 #"$ 5H%(#/ $+%.%; -#1 2"#/%.i U#"F/+ "0 %#"F/+j O% #"8 -&T4 8+-$
"0 $+% 0F$F.% "0 $+% +F6-# -#9 "0 $+% 0F$F.% "0 $+% 0F$F.%i Y& ($ #"8 3"&&(H2%
$" 3."9F7% .%'($-2(&%9 8-1& "0 $+(#T(#/ -#9 6"9%& "0 %V(&$(#/ $+-$ +-'%
9(/%&$%9 $+% 9%6-#9 0". $.-#&+F6-# "'%.7"6(#/& -#9 &" -.% -H2% $" #-'(S
/-$% #%8 +".(A"#& "0 '(.$F-2 H%7"6(#/i Y& ($ 3"&&(H2% $" &-'% $+"F/+$ 0."6 ($&
7F..%#$ 9%/%#%.-$('% -#9 '%/%$-$('% &$-$% -$ $+% +-#9& "0 - &6F/ -#9 7"&1
3"&$6"9%.# -7-9%6(7(&6i !-# 8% &$(22 (#'%#$ #%8 7"#7%3$&i
Y0 "#% 0"22"8& 7%.$-(# (#02F%#$(-2 7"#$%63".-.1 -77"F#$&B ($ 8"F29 -33%-.
-& (0 $+% %V3%.(%#7% -#9 _F%&$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 +-'% H%7"6% I9%%$M> Y& #"$ $+%
F./%#71 (#0".6(#/ $+% _F%&$("# "0 $+% 5#"8; "0 #(+(2(&6 .%9F#9-#$ -#9
"$("&%i W". k%-# Z-F9.(22-.9B 0". %V-632%B $+%.% (& #"8 "#21 $+% &(6F2-$("#
"0 - .%-2(&%9 #(+(2(&6 -#9 2($$2% .%6-(#& "0 - 3"&&(H2% #(+(2(&6 `- #(+(2(&6 "0
$+% 3"&&(H2%a (# $+%".1> Y# .%2-$("# $" 3.%'("F& 0".6& "0 #(+(2(&6 h ."6-#$(S
7(&6B &F..%-2(&6 -#9 9-9-(&6 h 8% 0(#9 "F.&%2'%& (# -# 5(#&"2FH2% 3"&($("#;>
LF. #(+(2(&6 $"9-1 (& #%($+%. -%&$+%$(7 #". 3"2($(7-2> *+% -3"7-213&% (& "'%.B
($& $(6% +-& /"#% -#9 2(%& H%+(#9 F&4
*+% -3"7-213&% (& 0(#(&+%9B $"9-1 ($ (& $+% 3.%7%&&("# "0 $+% #%F$.-2B "0 $+%
0".6& "0 $+% #%F$.-2 -#9 "0 (#9(00%.%#7%> `Z-F9.(22-.9 )XXDB )NIa
Z-F9.(22-.9 /"%& "# $" 6-T% $+% 72-(6B $%..(01(#/ (# ($& 0F22 (63".$B $+-$ -22
$+-$ .%6-(#& (& - 50-&7(#-$("#; 0". $+%&% (#9(00%.%#$ 0".6& -#9 0". $+% "3%.-S
$("# "0 $+% &1&$%6 $+-$ -##(+(2-$%& F&>
,F.%21B Z-F9.(22-.9 (& H%(#/ (."#(7 8+%# +% 72-(6& $+-$ $+(& 6"9% "0
#(+(2(&6 (& "F. 7F..%#$ 53-&&("#;i M"8 7-# "#% H% 3-&&("#-$% -H"F$
(#9(00%.%#7% -#9 "#%;& "8# -##(+(2-$("#i Q& Z-F9.(22-.9 -7T#"82%9/%&B $+(&
'(((
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
G$*#' 7&%$44 E$9)%"& 9&. B*9&$ 3")?9&
-&#)".,/#*"& (V
*+% 9(-2%7$(7 &$-/%B $+% 7.($(7-2 &$-/% (& %63$1> *+%.% (& #" 6".% &$-/% > > >
*+% 6-&&%& $+%6&%2'%& -.% 7-F/+$ F3 (# - /(/-#$(7 3."7%&& "0 (#%.$($+."F/+ -77%2%.-$("#> *+%1 -.% $+(& %V7.%&7%#$B 9%'"F.(#/B 3."7%&& $+-$
-##(+(2-$%& -22 /."8$+ -#9 -22 &F.32F& 6%-#(#/> *+%1 -.% $+(& 7(.7F($ &+".$S
7(.7F($%9 H1 - 6"#&$."F& 0(#-2($1>
`Z-F9.(22-.9 )XXDB )N)a<
P%.'%.&%21 3%.+-3&B "F. 9%&(.% (# $+(& '"2F6% (& $" (#&3(.% - .%$F.# $" $+%
%#%./%$(7& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 3."&% -#9 $+% 7.($(7-2 (#$%#&($1 "0 +(& -33."-7+ $"
#(+(2(&6B $" .%&$".% - &%#&% "0 +(& +"3%0F2 6"#&$%.& -#9 $" /('% H-7T $" $+%
0F$F.% ($& .(/+$0F2 0F$F.($1> M"8 7-# $+%.% H% - &%#&% "0 56"#&$."F& 0(#-2($1;
8($+"F$ -# -6H(/F($1 "0 6%-#(#/i Y$ (& 3.%7(&%21 $+% 9"FH2%S#-$F.% "0 #(+(2S
(&6 $+-$ (& 9%&$."1%9 H1 $+% 3"&$6"9%.# &(#/2%S6(#9%9 (66%.&("# (# $+%
6%2-#7+"2(- "0 $+% &1&$%6> L0 7"F.&%B $+%.% (& #" 0(#-2 7-$-&$."3+%> ZF$ $+%.%
-.% /.%-$ %V3%7$-$("#&B -# %V3%.(%#7% "0 $+% /.%-$ #""#$(9%B $+% 3.%6"#($("#
$+-$ 5+% 6F&$ 7"6% "#% 9-1;B $+(& '(7$". "'%. ^"9 -#9 $+% 7F2$ "0 #"$+(#/S
#%&& `=(%$A&7+% )X?XB YY l<Da> Y# 6-.T(#/ &" 7-.%0F221 -#9 9%6-#9(#/21 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# 9/#*F$ #(+(2(&6 -#9 I9%%*F$ &*'*4*%5B =(%$A&7+% 8-& 3.%S
&%#$(#/ -#9 &$-/(#/ -# (63".$-#$ 9(-2%7$(7 "0 #(+(2(&6 9&. 7F2$('-$(#/ /)*#*/94 #(+(2(&6 $""4
=(+(2(&6> Y$ (& 95+*?,",% `@=$*.$,#*?a4
Q> =(+(2(&6 -& - &(/# "0 (#7.%-&%9 3"8%. "0 $+% &3(.($4 -& 9/#*F$ &*'*4*%5>
Z> =(+(2(&6 -& 9%72(#% -#9 .%7%&&("# "0 $+% 3"8%. "0 $+% &3(.($4 -& I9%%*F$
#(+(2(&6>
Y$ 7-# H% - &(/# "0 &$.%#/$+4 $+% &3(.($ 6-1 +-'% /."8# &" &$."#/ $+-$
3.%'("F& /"-2& `57"#'(7$("#&;B -.$(72%& "0 0-($+a +-'% H%7"6% (#7"66%#S
&F.-$% `0". - 0-($+ /%#%.-221 %V3.%&&%& $+% 7"#&$.-(#$ "0 7"#9($("#& "0
%V(&$%#7%B &FH6(&&("# $" $+% -F$+".($1 "0 7(.7F6&$-#7%& F#9%. 8+(7+
"#% 02"F.(&+%&B /."8&B /-(#& 3"8%.a> L. - &(/# "0 $+% 2-7T "0 &$.%#/$+ $"
3"&($ 0". "#%&%20B 3."9F7$('%21B - /"-2B 8+1B - 0-($+>
`=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l<< -#9 <@a
L0 7"F.&%B 0". =(%$A&7+% $+%.% (& &"6%$+(#/ 3%7F2(-.21 &3%7(0(7 -H"F$ $+%
6"9%.# %V3%.(%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 (# ($& -00%7$('% -&3%7$&> =(+(2(&6 %6%./%& -&
- 3&17+"2"/(7-221 #%7%&&-.1 -00%7$ "0 $+% 9%72(#% "0 H%2(%0 (# ^"9> *+% 9(&S
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
(& $+% #(+(2(&6 "0 $+% "H&%.'%. -#9 -77%3$%.> Y$ (& $+% #(+(2(&6 "0 $+% 3-&&('%
#(+(2(&$ 8+" #" 2"#/%. -&3(.%& $"8-.9& - $.-#&7%#9%#7% ". "'%.7"6(#/ "0 $+%
+F6-# `7"#9($("#aB HF$ 8+" &(6321 -##"F#7%& -#9 %#R"1& ($& 9(&-33%-.S
-#7%B $+% &3%7$-$". 8-$7+(#/ $+% &3%7$-72% "0 +(& "8# 9%6(&%>) M(&$".1B
3"2($(7&B 6%$-3+1&(7&B +-'% -22 .%-7+%9 $+%(. $%.6(#-2 3"(#$B -#9 8(22(#/
#"$+(#/#%&& -33%-.& $" H% $+% "#21 9%&(.% "0 $+% 8(22 -'-(2-H2% $" $+% 3"&$S
6"9%.# 6(#94
-&#)".,/#*"&
32%-&F.% 8($+ %V(&$%#7% +-& #"$ H%7"6% -#1 /.%-$%. $+-# 3.%'("F& $(6%&B ($ (&
&(6321 $+-$ 8% 6"9%.#& +-'% 7"6% $" 6(&$.F&$ -#1 56%-#(#/; (# &F00%.(#/
-#9 (# %V(&$%#7% ($&%20> L#% %V$.%6% 3"&($("# (& #"8 &F77%%9%9 H1 -#"$+%.B
%_F-221 %V$.%6% 3"&($("#B "#% $+-$ 7"#&$.F%& %'%.1$+(#/ -& (0 ($ 8%.% *& F9*&> Y$
(& $+(& 5(# '-(#;B -#9 (# 3-.$(7F2-. ($& $(% 8($+ .,)9#*"&B 8+(7+ 7"#&$($F$%& $+%
7+-.-7$%. "0 53.%&%#$S9-1 #(+(2(&6; h ". $+(&B &-1& =(%$A&7+%B (& 8+-$ .%_F(.%& 9%6"#&$.-$("#> *+% 3."H2%6 (& $8"0"29B $+%.%0".%4 ($ (#'"2'%& - 6(&$.F&$ "0 -22
3.%'("F& '-2F-$("#& $+-$ H".9%.& "# $+% 3-$+"2"/(7-2 `-22 '-2F%& -.% #"8 &%%#
-& 2F.%& $+-$ 59.-8 "F$ "0 $+% 7"6%91 HF$ 8($+"F$ H.(#/(#/ ($ 72"&%. $" &"2F$("#;aB -#9B &%7"#921B 59F.-$("# 55(# '-(#;;B 8($+"F$ /"-2 `T*$4a ". 3F.3"&%
`T=$/;aB (& $+% 6"&$ 3-.-21A(#/ (9%-; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B lJJa> Y# &+".$B 8%
F#9%.&$-#9 8% -.% H%(#/ 0""2%9 -#9 1%$ 2-7T $+% 3"8%. &"# $" H% 0""2%9> O%
+-'% H%7"6% $+% '(7$(6& "0 -# %V7%&& "0 T#"82%9/% $+-$ 9"%& #"$ %#-H2% F& $"
".(%#$ -#9 7"63".$ "F.&%2'%& (# #%80"F#9 7"#9($("#& -#9 8% 7F..%#$21 2-7T
$+% .%&"F.7%& $" 7.%-$% #%8 6"9%& "0 T#"8(#/ -#9 -7$(#/> M%#7% 8% 0(#9
"F.&%2'%& $.-33%9 (# 3-.-21&(#/ 0".6& "0 #(+(2(&6> Y63".$-#$21B =(%$A&7+%
9.-8& "F. -$$%#$("# $" $+% 0-7$ $+-$ 5-7$('% #(+(2(&6; 3.%&F33"&%& - 9%/.%%
"0 5&3(.($F-2 7F2$F.%;B 8+(2% "F. 0%%2(#/ "0 &3(.($F-2 8%-.(#%&& $+-$ +-& 7F26(S
#-$%9 (# 5$+% 6"&$ +"3%2%&& &T%3$(7(&6 .%/-.9(#/ -22 3+(2"&"3+1; (& -2&" - &(/#
"0 "F. H1 #" 6%-#& 2"8 3"&($("# -& #(+(2(&$&4 $" H% - #(+(2(&$ (& $" H% (# 5.%2-$('%21 8%22 "00; 3"&($("#B &3(.($F-221 -#9 7F2$F.-221 &3%-T(#/ `=(%$A&7+%
)XN?B lJJa>
Y$ (& $+% -$$%63$ $" 7F2$('-$% -# -7$('% #(+(2(&6 h $+% -7$('% 50".7% "0
9%&$.F7$("#; -& =(%$A&7+% 7-22& ($ `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l<@a h 8+(7+B 8% -.% $"29
H1 $+% 2(T%& "0 "F. L%9(3-2 6-&$%. $+(#T%.&B (& #" 2"#/%. -# "3$("# 0". F&4
*+%.% (& #" 2"#/%. - &$-/%B #"$ %'%# $+% 6(#(6-2 (22F&("# $+-$ 6-T%&
%'%#$& 7-3-H2% "0 -9"3$(#/ $+% 0".7% "0 .%-2($1 h #" 6".% &$-/% %($+%. "0
6%#$-2 ". 3"2($(7-2 &"2(9-.($14 8+-$ 9" !+(2%B Z(-0.-B $+% H"-$ 3%"32%B
Z"2"/#-B ". P"2-#9 6-$$%.i Q22 "0 $+-$ 7"6%& $" H% -##(+(2-$%9 "# $+%
$%2%'(&("# &7.%%#>
`Z-F9.(22-.9 )XXDB )NDa
ZF$ $+(& &%20S&%.'(#/ -#9 &%20S&-$(&0(%9 6%2-#7+"2(7 #(+(2(&6B "# 0F22 9(&32-1
(# -22 ($& $%..". -#9 F/2(#%&& (# - 3-&&-/% &F7+ -& $+(&B 7-# H% &+"8# $" .%&$ "#
- 9(&-'"8-2 "0 $+% $&$)?C "0 ($& "8# (#'%&$6%#$ (# (#%.$(->@ *+(& (& #"$ 53%.0%7$; #(+(2(&6B $+% T(#9 $+-$ =(%$A&7+% (#'($%9 F& $" 7F2$('-$% -#9 8".T
$+."F/+B HF$ -# %-&1 -#9 2-A1 "#%> Y$ (& #(+(2(&6 .%9F7%9 $" - 7"3(#/ &$.-$%/1>
Y$ (& - 6"9(&+ #(+(2(&6 $+-$ .%02%7$& 2($$2% 6".% $+-# $+% 71#(7(&6 "0 $+%
(&"2-$%9 -#9 9(&%#7+-#$%9 (#$%22%7$F-2> Y$ (& - #(+(2(&6 8($+"F$ /%.6(#-2 4*2$>
Y$ (& - #(+(2(&6 $+-$ 9%&%.'%& $" 9(%>
Z1 7"#$.-&$B $+% %&&-1& /-$+%.%9 (# $+(& '"2F6% -.% -# -$$%63$ $" .%&3"#9
$" =(%$A&7+%;& 2-6%#$& (# D'$ P*44 #" E"=$) -H"F$ -# %$+(7"S3"2($(7-2 -#9
3+(2"&"3+(7-2 52"&& "0 &$(6F2F&;B - 7%.$-(# 2-7T "0 '(/"F. -#9 .(/"F.B - 7.%%3S
(#/ -3-$+1 -#9 2-A(#%&& (# 5"F.; $+(#T(#/ -#9 -33."-7+ $" 2(0%> Y# &"6% &%#&%B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
V
5#(+(2(&6; (& -28-1& 5#"8;B -28-1& 3.%&&(#/ -#9 F./%#$21 7-22(#/ 0". "F.
-$$%#$("#> =(%$A&7+% 7"#$%#9%9 $+-$ #(+(2(&6 (& - 5#".6-2 7"#9($("#; -28-1&
2F.T(#/ "# $+% +".(A"#B #"$ &(6321 -# %V7%3$("#-2 &$-$% "0 %6%./%#71> M"8S
%'%.B +% -2&" 9%&7.(H%9 ($ -& - 3-$+"2"/(7-2 $.-#&($("#-2 &$-/% "#% #%7%&&-.(21
%V3%.(%#7%& "#7% $.-9($("#-2 '-2F%& 9(&(#$%/.-$% F#9%. $+% 3.%&&F.% "0 9(&S
(22F&("#6%#$ -#9 9(&$.%&& `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)@a> =(+(2(&6 (& 6-.T%9 H1 $.-F6-$(7 &32($ 0."6 7"#'%#$("#-2 -&&F.-#7%& 8+(7+ 0".7%& $+% _F%&$("#
P"@,S 8+-$ (& -22 $+(& -H"F$ -#9 8+%.% -.% 8% +%-9(#/ `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B
l<Iai Y$ (& $+% 7"#$%63".-.1 &3%7(0(7($1 "0 &F7+ _F%&$("#(#/ $+-$ $+(& 3.%&%#$
'"2F6% -99.%&&%& 8+(2% -33.%7(-$(#/ $+% -28-1& "#/"(#/ #-$F.% "0 &F7+
&3%7F2-$("#&>
*+% 7"#7%3$ "0 #(+(2(&6 +-& $+% &$-$F& "0 -# 5%'%#$; "8(#/ $" $+% 0-7$ $+-$
($ 7-##"$ H% 6-9% .%9F7(H2% $" ". %_F('-2%#$ 8($+ -#1 -7$F-2(&%9 &$-$% "0
-00-(.&> O+%.%-&B 7F2$F.-221 -#9 &"7("S3"2($(7-221B - 9(&RF#7$("# H%$8%%# $+%
$(.%9 '"7-HF2-.1 58%; +-'% -$ "F. 9(&3"&-2 $" (#$%.3.%$ .%-2($1 -#9 5"F.; -7$F-2
%V3%.(%#7% "0 .%-2($1 (& 0%2$B $+% %'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 -##"F#7%& 5(# - +F#9.%9
&(/#&; - 3.%/#-#$ 0F$F.% 8+(7+ "3%#& #"'%2 -#9 %V7($(#/ 2(#%& "0 $+"F/+$ -#9
2(0%> *+% 7"#7%3$F-2 $""2& -$ 5"F.; 9(&3"&-2 -.% 0"F#9 $" H% (#-9%_F-$%B (#
#%%9 "0 - .%S%#%./(&(#/ 5.%'-2F-$("#; -#9 5$.-#&'-2F-$("#;> Y$ (& - $+(#T(#/ "0
$+% %'%#$ -& H"$+ '(.$F-2 -#9 &3%7$.-2 $+-$ %#-H2%& F& $" H%&$"8 - /%.6(#-2
2(0% F3"# #(+(2(&6> L0 7"F.&%B #(+(2(&6 (& 2(#T%9 8($+ - &$-$% "0 -00-(.&B HF$ ($ (&
"#21 8+%# $.%-$%9 -& -# %'%#$ $+-$ $+% +(&$".1 "0 #(+(2(&6 7-# H% .%#9%.%9
(#$%22(/(H2% -#9 3-&&-H2%m (#9%%9B $+-$ #(+(2(&6 7-# H% /('%# - +(&$".1>
=(%$A&7+%;& -#-21&(& "0 $+% -6H(/F"F& &(/#& "0 #(+(2(&6 (& (#0".6%9 H1 7"632%V $%63".-2 91#-6(7> Q& -# %V3%.(%#7% ($ -33%-.& -& - 0".7% $+-$
7"6%&B 2(T% - &+"7T8-'%B 0."6 $+% 0F$F.%B 9%&$-H(2(&(#/ %&$-H2(&+%9
'-2F%& -#9 3%$.(01(#/ "&&(0(%9 0".6& "0 2(0%> Y# 0-7$B +"8%'%.B #(+(2(&6
0". =(%$A&7+% +-& H%%# 8($+ F& 0". &"6% 7"#&(9%.-H2% $(6%B %V(&$(#/
&3%7$.-221 -& (0 ($ 8-& - /+"&$ "0 2(0% $+-$ +-F#$& $+% 2('(#/ 9%-9 -#9 7"#7%-2%9
(# $+% &$.-$- "0 $(6%B 3-.$ "0 - '(.$F-2 H%7"6(#/ (# 8+(7+ $+% 3.%7(&% 3"(#$&
"0 -7$F-2(&-$("# 7-##"$ H% 3.%9(7$%9 ". 0".%&%%# (# -9'-#7% &(6321
H%7-F&% $+%1 -.% 7"#$(#/%#$ (# .%2-$("# $" - 8+"2% &%.(%& "0 9(&3-.-$%
0".7%&>D
=(+(2(&6 (& (632(7-$%9 (# - 7"632%V '(.$F-2 +(&$".1 $+-$ - #-('%21 %63(.(S
7(&$ +(&$".("/.-3+1 0(#9& ($&%20 F#-H2% $" .%7"F#$> ,$.-#/%21 3%.+-3&B -#9
3-.-9"V(7-221 %#"F/+B ($ (& $+% %'%#$ 8+(7+ (& -H2% $" /('% %6H"9(6%#$ $"
$+% &$-$% "0 -00-(.& `$" /('% 56%-#(#/; $" -# %V3%.(%#7%B (# $+(& 7-&%B $+-$ "0
#(+(2(&6 -& $+% 9%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%&a> *+% %'%#$ (& 9"FH2%B -$ 2%-&$4 %V$.-7$%9
0."6 $+% &$-$% "0 -00-(.& ($ (& 2(#T%9 8($+ ($ 9(&72"&%& $+% 3"&&(H2% "0 $+%
3"&&(H2% -#9 -& 5"&%#)",% h 5$+% 0F$F.% %V(&$& (# - +F#9.%9 &(/#&; `=(%$A&7+%
)XN?B P.%0-7% l<a h -#9 H1 /('(#/ - '(.$F-2 -#9 91#-6(7 H"91 $" $+% &$-$% "0
-00-(.&B ($ +-.#%&&%& $+% 0".7%& $+-$ $.-#&'%.&-221 7"66F#(7-$% -7."&& $+%
&$.-$- "0 /%"2"/(7-2 $(6%> *" 7"#&$.F% +(&$".1 (# $+(& 8-1 (&B 0". =(%$A&7+%B
$+% $-&T "0 F#('%.&-2 &%20S9%$%.6(#-$("#4
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-&#)".,/#*"& V(
[(.%7$ &%20S"H&%.'-$("# (& #"$ #%-.21 &F00(7(%#$ 0". F& $" T#"8 "F.&%2'%&4
8% .%_F(.% +(&$".1B 0". $+% 3-&$ 7"#$(#F%& $" 02"8 8($+(# F& (# - +F#9.%9
8-'%&m 8% "F.&%2'%& -.%B (#9%%9B #"$+(#/ HF$ $+-$ 8+(7+ -$ %'%.1 6"6%#$
8% %V3%.(%#7% "0 $+(& 7"#$(#F%9 02"8(#/> Y$ 6-1 %'%# H% &-(9 $+-$ +%.%
$""B 8+%# 8% 9%&(.% $" 9%&7%#9 (#$" $+% .('%. "0 8+-$ &%%6& $" H% "F. "8#
6"&$ (#$(6-$% -#9 3%.&"#-2 H%(#/B $+%.% -332(%& $+% 9(7$F6 "0 M%.-72($F&4
8% 7-##"$ &$%3 (#$" $+% &-6% .('%. $8(7% > > > $+%.% %V(&$& - &FH$2%. -.$ -#9
"HR%7$ "0 $.-'%2 8+(7+ 9"%& #"$ -28-1& .%_F(.% F& $" 6"'% 0."6 32-7% $"
32-7% ". $" $.-'%.&% $+"F&-#9& "0 6(2%&> *+% 2-&$ $+.%% 7%#$F.(%& '%.1
3."H-H21 &$(22 7"#$(#F% $" 2('% "#B (# -22 $+%(. 7F2$F.-2 7"2"F.& -#9 7F2$F.-2
.%0.-7$("#&B 72"&% H%&(9% F&4 $+%1 8-#$ "#21 $" H% 9(&7"'%.%9> Y# 6-#1
0-6(2(%&B (#9%%9 (# (#9('(9F-2&B $+% &$.-$- &$(22 2(% #%-$21 -#9 72%-.21 "#% "#
$"3 "0 $+% "$+%.4 %2&%8+%.% $+%.% -.% 9(&2"7-$("#& -#9 0-F2$2(#%&> > > >
`=(%$A&7+% )X?NB &%7$("# YYB l<<@a
O($+ $+% 7"#7%3$F-2 (#'%#$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 =(%$A&7+% /-$+%.& $"/%$+%.B $+%#B
- &%$ "0 9(&3-.-$% -#9 9(&&"#-#$ 0".7%& $+-$ -.% -$ "#7% +(&$".(7-2B /%"2"/(7-2B
%$+(7-2 -#9 3+(2"&"3+(7-2> G%/-.9(#/ $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 #(+(2(&6;& 7"6(#/ -#9
-..('-2B +% 8(22 #"$ .%&$ 7"#$%#$ 8($+ _F(7T 0(V%& ". %-&1 &"2F$("#&B ". 8($+
7-'-2(%. -#9 +-&$1 -$$%63$& $" H13-&& ($> *+% 2-$$%. "#21 &%.'% $" %V-7%.H-$%
$+% 3."H2%6> L0 7"F.&%B "# "#% 2%'%2 h $+-$ "0 $+% +F6-# ($&%20B "0 +F6-#
7"63.%+%#&("# -#9 (#7"63.%+%#&("# h $+% %V3%.(%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 (& 7-F/+$
F3 (# - 3-$+"2"/1> Y# $+(& .%/-.9 ($ 7-# H% 2(T%#%9 $" - 7"#7%3$F-2 &$".6 (# -#
%V(&$%#$(-2(&$;& $%-S7F3> O+%# 7"#0."#$%9 8($+ - 8".29 $+-$ +-& H%%# F#-#S
7+".%9 -#9 $+-$ 7-# #"8 %V(&$ "#21 -& -7%#$.%9B -#1 7"#$."2 &1&$%6B 0."6
$+% &$-$% (63%.(F6 $" $+% +F6-# 6(#9B 8(22 (#%'($-H21 F#9%./" - 7.(&(& &$-$%>
=(%$A&7+% .(/+$21 9.-8& -$$%#$("# $" $+% 0-7$ $+-$ #(+(2(&6 (& -# -77"F#$ "0
"F. *.$94*%5B -#9 "#% -&3%7$ "0 +(& 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 $-&T -& +% &%%& ($ (& $" 9.-8
"F$ $+% #%7%&&-.1 7"#72F&("#& 0."6 b-#$;& !"3%.#(7-# .%'"2F$("# (#
$+"F/+$> *+%&% 7"#72F&("#&B +"8%'%.B "#21 $-T% F& &" 0-. -#9 $+% 9(&$-#7%
$.-'%22%9 6-1 #"$ H% '%.1 0-. -$ -22> Y9%-2(&6 `(#72F9(#/ 3"&$6"9%.# .%2-$('S
(&6 -#9 &"S7-22%9 53%.&3%7$('(&6;aB 7"#&(9%.%9 -& - 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 &$-#7%B 6-1
&(6321 H% 3-.$ "0 "F. $.-#&+F6-# -9"2%&7%#7% -#9B -& &F7+B 7"6% $" H% &%%#
-& H%2"#/(#/ $" $+% (66-$F.% 3-.$ "0 "F. %#2(/+$%#%9B HF$ "'%.+F6-#B
H%7"6(#/>
*+% %&&-1& 7"22-$%9 +%.% $%&$(01 $" $+% '(.$F-2($1 -#9 /%.6(#-2($1 "0 $+%
%'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6B %&3%7(-221 (# $+% 9(6%#&("# "0 ($& 6"#&$."F& -6H(/F($1> Y#
$+% "3%#(#/ %&&-1 "0 $+% '"2F6% U2("$ Q2H%.$ 7"#$%&$& $+% -77F.-71 "0 "F.
.%-9(#/ "0 - =(%$A&7+%-# 6"9%.#($1 (# $%.6& "0 !"3%.#(7-# -#9 b-#$(-#
.%'"2F$("#&> Y0 $+%.% (& -# %V-7%.H-$("# -#9 (#$%#&(0(7-$("# "0 $+%&% 6"9%.#
%2%6%#$& -#9 $%#9%#7(%& (# =(%$A&7+%;& $+"F/+$ ($ (& #"$ (# $+% 9(.%7$("# "0
&"6% &%20S&%.'(#/ -#$+."3"2"/(&6> Q2H%.$ 7"#$%#9& $+-$ !"3%.#(7F&; .%'"2FS
$("# 8-& #"$ - .-9(7-2 "#% &(#7% ($& %&&%#$(-2 -6H($ 8-& $" 32-7% $+% ,F# (#
.%2-$("# $" $+% 7"&6"& (# %V-7$21 $+% &-6% $%.6& $+-$ +-9 H%%# -&&(/#%9 $"
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
V(( -&#)".,/#*"&
$+% 3.('(2%/%9 U-.$+> *+% %00%7$ (& &$(22 $" $+(#T "0 - 7%#$.%9 -#9 +(%.-.7+(7-2
7"&6"& 8%22S.%/F2-$%9 H1 #%/-$('% 0%%9H-7T -#9 +-.6"#("F& %_F(2(H.(F6&>
*+% 7"#&%.'-$('% #-$F.% "0 !"3%.#(7F&; $+%".1 %&3%7(-221 7"6%& $" 2(/+$
8+%# $+% 7"#$.-&$ (& 6-9% 8($+ $+% +%.%$(7-2 (9%-& "0 ^(".9-#" Z.F#"
`)JD?h)NIIa> b-#$;& &%3-.-$("# "0 0-($+ -#9 T#"82%9/%B "0 6%$-3+1&(7& -#9
&7(%#7%B 8-& - +-20S+%-.$%9 -$$%63$ $" 3.%&%.'% - $.-#&7%#9%#$ .%-26 0."6 /%#F(#% -$$-7T -#9 (##"'-$("#> Y#%'($-H21 (# $+% +-#9& "0 =(%$A&7+% ($&
7"#7%($& -.% .%2%#$2%&&21 -#9 .%6".&%2%&&21 %V3"&%9B -#9 $+(& 0".6& -# %&&%#S
$(-2 3-.$ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 7+%%.0F2 -$+%(&6> M%.% -$+%(&6 9%#"$%& #"$ &" 6F7+ $.-/(7 -002(7$("# -& $+% 3+(2"&"3+%.;& &%.%#($1 -#9 -7+(%'%6%#$> 5="$+(#/ (&
$.F%B %'%.1$+(#/ (& 3%.6($$%9; `=(%$A&7+% )X?XB l<Da (& $+% &2"/-# 8($+ 8+(7+
$+% 8".29B (66-#%#$B -7%#$.%9 -#9 -#"6-2"F&B 7-# 7"6% (#$" H%(#/ -#9
/('% H(.$+ $" ($&%20>
Y# +(& -.$(72% 5L# =(+(2(&6;B Z-F9.(22-.9 &F//%&$& $+-$ #(+(2(&6B T#"8#
3.(6-.(21 (# ($& #(#%$%%#$+S7%#$F.1 /F(&% 5"0 9-.TB O-/#%.(-#B ,3%#/2%.(-#B
0F2/(#"F& 7"2"F.&; (& #" 2"#/%. -# -33."3.(-$% 7-$%/".1 "0 $+"F/+$ 0". $"9-1;&
6(22%##(-2 &"7(%$1 `Z-F9.(22-.9 )XXDB )JXa> G%02%7$(#/ "# $+% H.""9(#/B -3"S
7-213$(7 /2""6 "0 $+% %3"7+ 8+(7+ -##"F#7%9 ^"9;& 9%-$+B +% .%7"/#(&%&
$+-$ 5($ 8"F29 H% H%-F$(0F2 $" H% - #(+(2(&$ (0 $+%.% 8%.% &$(22 - .-9(7-2($1; `(H(9>B
)N@a> ,(6(2-.21B (# $+%(. 8".T "# =%7+-%' -#9 $+% "$+%. 1"F#/ GF&&(-#&
.-9(7-2& -&&"7(-$%9 8($+ $+% )?NI& "./-#(&-$("# 5*+% P%"32%;& f%#/%-#7%;B
kF&$(# !2%6%#& -#9 !+.(& W%(T 3."'(9% F& 8($+ -# -77"F#$ "0 - 7"63%22(#/21
7"2"F.0F2 &FH7F2$F.-2 6"'%6%#$ -#9 -$ $+% &-6% $(6% 8($+ - 8-1 "0 $%&$(#/
#(+(2(&6> *+%1 %V-6(#% #"$ "#21 8+%$+%. #(+(2(&6 7-# H% - 9F.-H2% -#9
%00%7$('% 3"2($(7-2 (#&$.F6%#$ HF$ -2&" 8+%$+%. $+% $%.6 #"8 +-& -#1 7F.S
.%#71 2%0$ 0". F&> !%#$.-2 $" $+%(. -#-21&(& (& $+% 3.-7$(7% "0 5-#-%&$+%$(7&;
8+(7+ $+%1 &%% -& 7+-22%#/(#/ $+% "33"&($("# H%$8%%# HF.%-F7.-71 -#9
-%&$+%$(7&> Z1 7+-.$(#/ +"8 $+% -%&$+%$(7 (#&7.(3$("# "0 HF.%-F7.-$(7 %00%7$&
H"F#9 $+% GF&&(-# #(+(2(&$& $"/%$+%.B !2%6%#& -#9 W%(T -.% -2&" %V-6(#(#/
+"8 $+% 7"66F#($1 8-& 9%&$(#%9 $" -7+(%'% 52($%.-221 #"$+(#/;B #" 2-&$(#/
%00%7$&> *+(& 0".6 "0 #(+(2(&6B ($ (& &F//%&$%9B (& $+% 9%6"#(7 7.%-$F.% "0
6"9%.# HF.%-F7.-71 ($&%20B 3-.-&($(#/ ($& &$.F7$F.%& HF$ -2&" (6($-$(#/ ($&
"./-#(&-$("#> O+%.%-& M-##-+ Q.%#9$ 9(&7F&&%9 $+% HF.%-F7.-$ (# .%2-$("#
$" $+% .-9(7-2 5H-#-2($1 "0 %'(2;B (# $+(& 7"#$.(HF$("# +% (& &%%# -& &$-.$(#/ "F$
-& $+% 1"F#/ #(+(2(&$B -# (9%-2(&$(7 &"8%. "0 3-#9-%6"#(F6B 8+" %#9& F3
F#3."9F7$('%21 &+F002(#/ 3-3%.& 8($+(# -# F#.%-2 HF.%-F7.-$(7 &$.F7$F.%>
M%.% #(+(2(&6 (#9%%9 -33%-.& $" +-'% H%%# .%9F7%9 $" - 6%.% -96(#(&$.-$('%
5-7$('($1 "0 &%7"#9 .-#T; 8+(7+ .%-7$('%21 -9-3$& ($&%20 $" $+% 3.%'-(2(#/
7"#9($("#& "0 2(0% `&%% =(%$A&7+% )X?XB YY l)<a>
G(7+-.9 Z%-.9&8".$+ "00%.& - 7-.%0F2 -#9 +(/+21 (#'%#$('% .%-9(#/ "0
=(%$A&7+%;& $%V$ Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#C> M% -(6& $" 9%6"#&$.-$% $+%
(632(7-$("# "0 $+% _F%&$("# "0 5&3(.($; (# =(%$A&7+%;& -$$%63$ $" $+(#T H%1"#9
". "F$&(9% 6%$-3+1&(7&> M(& "'%..(9(#/ 7"#7%.# (& $" /F-.9 -#9 8-.# -/-(#&$
-#1 %-&1 -33."3.(-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%B &F7+ -& 7+-63("#(#/ $+% 9%-$+ "0 ^"9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-&#)".,/#*"& V(((
(# $+% #-6% "0 - 6"#&$."F& 0F$F.% $+-$ ($ 8"F29 /-(21B HF$ H2(#921 -00(.6> L0
7"F.&%B $+% 0F$F.% 8(22 H% 6"#&$."F&B ($ 7-##"$ H% -#1$+(#/ "$+%.B HF$ 8+-$
7-##"$ H% #-('%21 ". H2(#921 -00(.6%9 0". Z%-.9&8".$+ (& &"6% 7"632%$%21
-+(&$".(7-2 -#9 F#6%9(-$%9 5[("#1&(-#; &%#&% -#9 &%#&(H(2($1 `$+% 8".29 -& 6"#&$%. "0 %$%.#-2 &%20S7.%-$("# -#9 &%20S9%&$.F7$("# H%1"#9 /""9 -#9 %'(2B
0". %V-632%a> O+-$ 7"F29 H% 6".% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 $+-# $+(&i Y# "33"&($("# $"
-# -00(.6-$("# "0 &F33"&%921 $(6%2%&& 7"#9($("# ". $.F$+ h $+% $.F$+ 8+(7+
3."72-(6& $+% 8".29 $" H% 8(22 $" 3"8%. -#9 #"$+(#/ H%&(9%& h Z%-.9&8".$+
(#&(&$& F3"# - .%-9(#/ "0 &3(.($ (# =(%$A&7+%> Y# $+(& 8-1 +% (& -H2% $"
9%6"#&$.-$% $+% #%%9 0". - 6".% #F-#7%9 .%-9(#/ "0 - 3.(#7(3-2 $%V$ 2(T%
$+% O$&$94"?C $+-#B 8($+ $+% "77-&("#-2 %V7%3$("#B +-& +($+%.$" H%%# $+%
7-&%> P-.$ "0 $+% 7"#&%_F%#7% "0 &F7+ -# -$$%#$('% -#9 '($-2 .%-9(#/ (& $+-$
$+% _F%&$("# "0 $+% +F6-# -#9 ($& 0F$F.% 7-##"$ H% 9(&7"F#$%9 ". &(9%S
&$%33%9 (# &"6% 7-'-2(%. -#9 7-&F-2 6-##%.> Y0 8% -.% $" $-T% $+% _F%&$("#
"0 0F$F.($1 &%.("F&21 (# H"$+ ($& +F6-# -#9 3"&$S+F6-# 9(6%#&("#&B $+%#
$+% _F%&$("# "0 %#%./1 7-##"$ H% &%'%.%9 0."6 $+% 6-$$%. -#9 _F%&$("# "0
&3(.($> *+F& &3%-T& Z%-.9&8".$+;& 7+-22%#/%>
PF.&F(#/ 0F.$+%. $+(& %V7%&&('%B HF$ #"$ F#$+(#T-H2%B 2"/(7 "0 $+% 56"#S
&$."F&;B k"-##- M"9/%;& 7"#$.(HF$("# (#$%.$8(#%& =(%$A&7+%-# 3.%$%#&("#&
-#9 -6H($("#& 8($+ $+% 7"#7%.#& "0 M%(9%//%.%-# $+"F/+$ "# $+% "#%
+-#9 -#9 W.%F9(-# $+"F/+$ "# $+% "$+%.> O.($(#/ 0."6 "F$ "0 - 7%.$-(#
3.F9%#7% -#9 3.%7(&("#B M"9/% 7"F#&%2& F& $" 3-1 -$$%#$("# $" $+% "0$%#
"'%.2""T%9 0-7$ $+-$ =(%$A&7+%;& 9(-/#"&(& "0 - 7"#9($("# "0 #(+(2(&6 $"
9%&7.(H% $+% 6"9%.# 6-2-(&% 8-& 7"F7+%9 (# - &3%7(0(7 2-#/F-/% -#9
(9("6B #-6%21B $+-$ "0 - 7F&$"6(&%9 ^%.6-# 7"63"&%9 "0 - KF$+%.-# (#$"S
#-$("# -#9 - 9(&$(#7$21 #(#%$%%#$+S7%#$F.1 3"2($(7-2 21.(7> O+-$ +-33%#&
8+%# $+(& 3%7F2(-. -#9 &3%7(0(7 2-#/F-/% -#9 &$12% -.% $.-#&2-$%9 (#$" $+%
02-$#%&& "0 - 7"&6"3"2($-# U#/2(&+i M"9/%B +-'(#/ .-(&%9 $+% _F%&$("# (# +%.
%&&-1B $+%# 9%'"$%& $+% .%&$ "0 +%. -#-21&(& $" 7"6H-$(#/ - 7%.$-(# '(.-2
(#0%7$("# 3.%'-2%#$ -6"#/&$ F#7F2$('-$%9 -.$(&$S$13%& "0 2-$% 6"9%.#($1B (#
8+(7+ #"$ "#21 (& =(%$A&7+%;& $+"F/+$ $.-632%9 "'%.B $.%-$%9 8($+"F$ .%/-.9
0". ($& $(6% -#9 32-7%B HF$ &" (& $+"F/+$ ($&%20> Q#1 -#9 -22 &(/#& "0 -7$F-2 -#9
-7$('% $+(#T(#/ -.% (# 9-#/%. "0 H%(#/ %.-&%9 0."6 $+% 6%6".1SH-#T& "0 $+%
6-7+(#%& "0 $+% 0F$F.%> W". M"9/% $+% .%-2 6%#-7% 2(%& (# - 57"632%$%9; ".
3%.0%7$%9 #(+(2(&6 $+-$ 8"F29 #" 2"#/%. -H2% $" .%02%7$ F3"# ($&%20 &(#7% ($
8"F29 H% &"#'*&? 5")$ ") "#'$) #'9& #(+(2(&6> *+(& (& 8+-$ &+% 7-22& - 59%6"#(7
#(+(2(&6;B - #(+(2(&6 $+-$ F&F.3& $+% 6"#&$."F& `-6H(/F"F&B 9"FH2%B $8"S
+%-9%9B -7$('% -#9 3-&&('%B %$7>aB -#9 9%&$."1& -22 3"&($("#(#/ -#9 32-7%> ["
8% &$(22 +-'% %-.& 0". =(%$A&7+% -#9 +(& 6F&(7i [" 8% &$(22 +-'% $+%
.%&"F.7%& $" $+(#Ti M-'% 8% H%7"6% $"" &%20S&-$(&0(%9 8($+ -#9 (# "F. #(+(2S
(&6i *+%&% -.% $+% T(#9 "0 F./%#$ _F%&$("#& M"9/%;& %&&-1 %#$(7%& F& $"
7"#0."#$ #"8>
,F+-(2 E-2(T 0"7F&%& +(& -$$%#$("# "# M%(9%//%.;& _F%&$("#(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6B
(# 3-.$(7F2-. "# $+% 7"#0(/F.-$("# "0 +*"% -#9 $+% .%2-$("#&+(3 H%$8%%#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
V(' -&#)".,/#*"&
#(+(2(&6 -#9 4*2$ (# +(& $+"F/+$ -#9 ($& 2%/-71> M"8 -.% 8% $" $+(#T H("/%#S
%&(&i M"8 -.% 8% $" .%2-$% "#$"/%#%&(& -#9 "#$"3"(%&(&i *+% -(6 "0 $+(&
%V-7$(#/ 7"#$.(HF$("# (& $" -..('% -$ $+% H%/(##(#/& "0 - 72%-.%. -#9 6".%
3.%7(&% F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6 (# M%(9%//%. -#9B (# $+(& 8-1B $" 6"'%
H%1"#9 8+-$ (& (#7.%-&(#/21 H%7"6(#/ - 6%.%21 7"#'%#$("#-2 .%-9(#/ "0 "F.
6"9%.#($1 -#9 +(&$".(7($1> Y#($(-221 $+(& .%_F(.%& - .%7T"#(#/ 8($+ M%(9%/S
/%.;& 6"&$ (63".$-#$ 7"#$%#$("#& -H"F$ =(%$A&7+%4 $+-$ +% (& $+% 3+(2"&"S
3+%. "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 "0 2(0% H%7-F&% +% 9%$%.6(#%& H"$+ (# -77".9-#7% 8($+ 2"/(7 "0 '-2F%& `9%'-2F-$("#B $.-#&'-2F-$("#B %$7>am -#9 $+-$ +% -33."-7+%&
$+% _F%&$("# "0 52(0%; #"$ H("2"/(7-221 HF$ 6%$-3+1&(7-221> K(0% +-& #" &$-H2%
".9%. ". '-2F% 0". =(%$A&7+%B +%#7% ($& 2"/(7 (& -28-1& "#% "0 7"632(7-$("#
-#9 %V7%&& `"0 7"F.&%B -& E-2(T 7"#7%9%& (# - #"$%B - 9(00%.%#$ H("2"/1 $" $+%
"#% M%(9%//%. (& 8".T(#/ 8($+ 6(/+$ 6%-# $+-$ $+(& 7"#7%3$("# +-& $" H%
9.-6-$(7-221 .%'(&%9a> *+."F/+ - 7-.%0F2 -#9 -$$%#$('% F#0"29(#/ "0 M%(9%/S
/%.;& 7"#0."#$-$("# 8($+ 6"9%.#($1B E-2(T (& -H2% $" 3."9F7% - +(/+21 #"'%2
-#9 F#&%$$2(#/ %#7"F#$%. 8($+ &"6% "0 $+% %&&%#$(-2 $."3%& "0 "F. $(6%B &F7+
-& -#(6-2(&6B -#$+."3"7%#$.(&6 -#9 0(7$("#-2(&6>
[-#(%2 !"#8-1;& 7"#$.(HF$("# &($F-$%& $+% 3."H2%6-$(7 "0 #(+(2(&6 (#
.%2-$("# $" ($& $.-#&+F6-# 3"$%#$(-2($(%&> M"8 6(/+$ 8% 7"#&$.F% $+% -9'%#$
"0 $+(& %'%#$ "0 -22 %'%#$&B #(+(2(&6B (# "$+%. $+-# 8+"221 ". &(6321 #%/-$('%
$%.6&B $+-$ (&B (# $%.6& 8+(7+ 8(22 $-T% F& -8-1 0."6 -#9 8%22 H%1"#9 "F.
-#$+."3"7%#$.(7 3.%RF9(7%&i *+(& (& -# (63".$-#$ _F%&$("# $" -&TB &(6321
H%7-F&% $+%.% (& -# %'%.S3.%&%#$ 9-#/%. (# .%-9(#/& "0 =(%$A&7+% -#9 #(+(2(&6
$+-$ $+% %V3%.(%#7% -#9 $+% %'%#$ 8(22 H% (#$%.3.%$%9 (# $%.6& $+-$ 6%.%21
7"#0(.6 "F. &%20S7%#$.%9 3.%RF9(7%& -#9 7"#7%($&B -#9 %'%# &%.'% $" %#+-#7%
$+%64 8% 7-# #" 2"#/%. 7"#7%('% "0 "F.&%2'%& -& $+% 7%#$.% "0 $+% F#('%.&%B
#" 2"#/%. H% &F.% $+-$ %'"2F$("# +-& - 3F.3"&%B 2%$ -2"#% - 0(#-2 3F.3"&%
8+(7+ 6(/+$ H% F&> ,21 -$$%63$& $" .%7F3%.-$% &"6% 7"60".$ 0."6 $+%
9-.T%&$ +"F. "0 9%'-2F-$("#B H1 &$%%3(#/ "F.&%2'%& (# 6%2-#7+"2(7 .%02%7$("#
"# "F. "8# %V(&$%#$(-2 6%-#(#/2%&&B "F. 3"(/#-#$ 7"&6(7 (#&(/#(0(7-#7% -#9
$+% 7.F%2 $.-/%91 "0 2(0%B 6%.%21 &%.'% $" .%7"#0(.6 "F. #-.7(&&(&6> ," $+%
7"63F2&("# $" $+(#T H%1"#9 $+% "29 6".-2& -#9 '-2F%& -2&" %#$-(2& $+% $-&T
"0 $+(#T(#/ H%1"#9 $+% +F6-# 7"#9($("# -& 8% +-'% 7"6% $" T#"8 ($ -#9
2('% ($> !"#8-1 -./F%& $+-$ =(%$A&7+% "#21 H%/-# (# +(& 2(0%$(6% $" %V3%.(S
6%#$ -& - &%20S3."72-(6%9 50(.&$ 3%.0%7$ #(+(2(&$; -#9 0-. 0."6 -77"632(&+%9 ".
.%-2(&%9 - $.-#&+F6-# 6"9% "0 $+(#T(#/> Y$ (& (63".$-#$ 0". !"#8-1 $+-$ -&
.%-9%.& "0 =(%$A&7+% 8% -7T#"82%9/% $+% %V$%#$ $" 8+(7+ +(& $+(#T(#/
.%6-(#& 7"#$-6(#-$%9 H1 $+% 9%7-9%#$ 0".7%& ($ %#9%-'"F.%9 $" "'%.7"6%>
*+(& (& $" 8".T -/-(#&$ $+% (9%- "0 $+%.% H%(#/ -#1 3F.%21 $.-#&+F6-#
3+(2"&"3+1B $+-$ (&B "#% #"$ $-(#$%9 H1 +F6-# 3.%RF9(7%&B 9%2F&("#& -#9
%..".&> \2$(6-$%21B $+% "#%& 8+" &%% $+%6&%2'%& -& &%20S"'%.7"6%.& "0 6(2S
2%##(- "0 6".-2($1 -#9 !+.(&$(-#($1 &$(22 0-7% $+% 9(00(7F2$ $-&T "0 "'%.7"6(#/
=(%$A&7+% +(6&%20 h -#9 H1 %V$%#&("#B #(+(2(&6> O% &%20S'('(&%7$("#(&$& 6F&$
&$(22 -$$%#9 $" 6-$$%.& "0 H"91 -#9 &"F2>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-&#)".,/#*"& V'
*+% $.-#&+F6-# (& 0F.$+%. 3F.&F%9 (# [(-#% E"./-#;& 8".T "# $+% 6F7+
#%/2%7$%9 UV3.%&&("#(&$ 3"%$ -#9 9"7$".B ^"$$0.(%9 Z%##> O+(2% !"#8-1
9.%8 "F. -$$%#$("# $" =(%$A&7+%;& 7+-22%#/% $" '(%8 $+% 8".29 50."6 (#&(9%;
-& 58(22 $" 3"8%. -#9 #"$+(#/ %2&%;B E"./-# %V32".%& $+% (632(7-$("#& "0 $+(&
0". - $+(#T(#/ "0 5%V3.%&&('($1;B 7"#'%#$("#-221 7"F32%9 8($+ - 3.(A%9 5(#$%.S
(".($1; HF$ #"8 F#2%-&+%9 0."6 ($& 7"#0(#%6%#$ 8($+(# $+% &$.(7$21 +F6-#
"./-#(&6> Y#9%%9B +-'(#/ -H-#9"#%9 "F. -#$+."3"6".3+(7 (22F&("#& "0
H%(#/ &"6% &".$ "0 57"&6(7 3-.-3+.-&%;B $+% -00(.6-$('% #(+(2(&$ 7-# (#&$%-9
H%7"6%B $" F&% Z%##;& $%.6&B - 50".6-2 #-T%9 /%&$-$("#;B R"F.#%1(#/ $+."F/+
2(0% H%-.(#/ '-.("F& 5-#(6-2 &(/#-$F.%&;B &F7+ -& 502(7T%.(#/ 7(2(-;> *+(& 3(%7%
-9"3$& - 7"#&3(7F"F&21 _F-&(S-3"7-213$(7 $"#%B "#% (#$%#9%9 $" H% $+"F/+$
-2"#/&(9% - 3."3"&%9 .%$F.# $" %&7+-$"2"/1 `9%0(#%9 (# $+% %&&-1 -& 5$+% 0(#-2
3.%&%#$;a -8-1 0."6 $+% 6-33%9S"F$#%&& "0 $%2%"2"/(7-2 $+"F/+$> Y0B $" -9-3$
&"6%8+-$ M%(9%//%.;& 6%2"9.-6-$(7 -#9 +1&$%.(7-2 72-(6B 5"#21 - 7(2(F6 7-#
&-'% F&;BJ $+%# $+(& (& "#21 &" 0-. -& $+% 8".29 "0 H%7"6(#/ (& .%/-.9%9B #"$ -&
0-7(#/ "#% 7-$-&$."3+(7 %#9B HF$ (#&$%-9 -& 5- 3%.3%$F-2 3.%&%#$ 6-9% F3 "0
"#% 7"#$(#F-221 7+-#/(#/ -3"7-213&%; `MFV2%1 )XXDB )Ia> *+(& 9(&$(#7$("#
H%$8%%# $8" $13%& "0 -3"7-213$(7 $+"F/+$ (& (63".$-#$ -& ($ 6-.T& $+%
9(00%.%#7% H%$8%%# "#% 8+(7+ 7"F29 2%-9B -#9 9(9 2%-9 8($+ =-A(&6B $" 6F.9%."F&21S(#72(#%9 H("3"2($(7& (#$%#$ "# - /%#%.-2(&%9 7"#02-/.-$("#B
%#$-(2(#/ $+% &F(7(9% "0 $+% &$-$%B -#9 -#"$+%.B 1%$ $" H% %V32".%9B 2(#% "0
6"#&$."F& H%7"6(#/> *+% &%7"#9 "3%#& ($&%20 $" $+% 3"$%#$(-2 "0 $+% 5H("S
#%/-$('%; $" 53."'"T%; 2(0% (#$" +(/+21 H.%9 `?$@,U/'#$#$a 0".6& 8+(7+ %7&$-$(7S
-221 7.-&+ -/-(#&$ $+% H-..(%. "0 (66-$%.(-2($1> *+(& 8".T 3."'(9%& 0""9 0". .%S$+(#T(#/ "0 %F/%#(7& -& $+% %F2"/1 "0 .$J2")59#*"&B #"$ $+% &%-.7+ 0". $%2%"2"/(7-221 6"$('-$%9 &%-.7+ 0". 53F.($1;> Y$ (& #"$ %#"F/+ $" 9(&6(&&
%F/%#(7& "F$S"0S+-#9 -& $+% 9(&3%#&-H2% H1S3."9F7$ "0 .%3F/#-#$ $+(.$(%&;
3"2($(7&> Y#9%%9B (# -# -/% "0 /%#%$(7 %#/(#%%.(#/B F2$.-&"F#9 &7-#& -#9
-6#("7%#$%&(&]0%$".7"3(%&B %F/%#(7& #" 2"#/%. 6%.%21 &$-#9& -$ $+% 9"".B
8-($(#/ $" H% 2%$ (# ". 9%#(%9 %#$.1> M%#7% Z%##;& 8".T (& 6"&$ $(6%21 (#
($& -$$%63$& $" H.(#/ $+% 9(&7(32(#%& "0 3"%$.1 -#9 6%9(7(#% $" H%-. "#
3.%&%#$ $%7+#"2"/(&%9 6-$$%.`&a>
k"+# P."$%'(;& 7+-3$%. 0"22"8& F3 $+% 3."'"7-$('% -#9 3%.+-3& 3%.32%V(#/
2(#T H%$8%%# #(+(2(&6 -#9 0-&7(&6 6-9% H1 [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( (# $+%(.
8".T 7 D'",%9&. E49#$9,%> P."$%'( -(6& $" 9%$%.6(#% 8+%$+%. 9%&7.(H(#/
0-&7(&6 -& - 5.%-2(A%9 #(+(2(&6; -99& -#1$+(#/ &FH&$-#$('% $" "F. F#9%.&$-#9S
(#/ "0 H"$+ ". (& 6%.%21 - .+%$".(7-2 02"F.(&+> *+(& .%_F(.%& 3F$$(#/ (#$"
"3%.-$("# - 72"&% .%-9(#/ -#9 7-.%0F2 #%/"$(-$("# 8($+ T%1 &%7$("#& "0 7
D'",%9&. E49#$9,% -#9 ($& 7"#7%3$F-2 (##"'-$("#&> M"8%'%.B 6".% $+-#
7"#7%3$F-2 (##"'-$("# (& -$ &$-T% +%.% &(6321 H%7-F&% [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.(
6-T% $+% 9-.(#/ h -#9 %-&(21 6(&F#9%.&$""9 h 6"'% "0 7"#&$.F(#/ 0-&7(&6 -&
- 3."H2%6 "0 53F.% 6-$$%.; `-& "33"&%9B &-1B $" - 3."H2%6 "0 7F2$F.-2 -#9
3"2($(7-2 +(&$".1 ". 0"2T 3&17+"2"/1a> *+% 56-R".; 7"#$%#$("# 6-9% (& $+-$ $+%
-#-21&(& +-& $" H% "# $+% 2%'%2 "0 - 3+1&(7& "0 $+% 6-$%.(-2($1 -#9 -00%7$('($1
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
V'( -&#)".,/#*"&
"0 H"9(%&> Y# ".9%. $" 9%6"#&$.-$% $+(&B ". -$ 2%-&$ $" H%/(# $+% $-&TB P."$%'(
+-& .%7"F.&% $" 7"632%V($1 $+(#T(#/B F$(2(&(#/ $+% #"$("# "0 &%20S"./-#(&(#/
3."7%&&%&B (# ".9%. $" &F332%6%#$ $+% #%8 7"#7%3$& "0 [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.(
`$+% 5H"91 8($+"F$ "./-#&; -#9 ($& $13"2"/(%&B &$.-$(0(7-$("# -#9 9%&$.-$(0(7-S
$("#B $+% 5.+(A"6%;B $+% 5'(.$F-2; -#9 &" "#a> *+% 7+-22%#/% $+%# (& $" $+(#T
0-&7(&6 #"$ .%9F7$('%21 ". %3(3+%#"6%#-221 -& (9%"2"/1 HF$ -& - 3+%#"6S
%#"# .""$%9 (# $+% 6(7."$%V$F.%& "0 %'%.19-1 2(0% -#9 (632(7-$%9 (# -7$F-2
$%#9%#7(%& "0 6-$$%. -#9 7%.$-(# -&&%6H2-/%& "0 9%&(.%> !"#7%('%9 (# $+%&%
$%.6&B $+% $-&T "0 -.$(7F2-$(#/ -# %$+(7& "0 6-$$%. $+-$ 6(/+$ 0-7(2($-$% $+%
7F2$('-$("# "0 - #"#0-&7(&$ 8-1 "0 2(0% H%7"6%& 3%.+-3& $+% 6"&$ 9%6-#9(#/
%$+(7& (6-/(#-H2%> P."$%'( 7"#72F9%& $+% %&&-1 8($+ &"6% $+"F/+$& "# .%&(&S
$-#7% -#9 ($& '-.("F& 0".6& -#9 0".6-$("#&> *+% (&&F% "0 5A%."; (& -2&" -$ $+%
+%-.$ "0 $+(& 7"#0(/F.-$("# "0 0-&7(&6B #(+(2(&6 -#9 6-$$%.> L#% "0 $+% 6"&$
#"'%2 -&3%7$& "0 P."$%'(;& .%-9(#/ (& $+% 9(&$(#7$("# +% 0"./%& H%$8%%# 52F#-.; #(+(2(&6 `$+% T(#9 9(-/#"&%9 H1 =(%$A&7+%B +% 72-(6&aB 8+(7+ (& #(+(2(&6 "0 .%02%7$("# -#9 9%3.%&&("#B -#9 - 5&"2-.; #(+(2(&6B 8+(7+ (& $+%
5&F(7(9-2; -#9 0.-#$(7 #(+(2(&6 (9%#$(0(%9 8($+ - 0-&7(&6 $+-$ 6-T%& 58-.; -#9
%V$%.6(#-$("# $+% &"2% "HR%7$ "0 $+% 58-. 6-7+(#%;>
Y# +(& 7+-3$%. M"8-.9 !-1/(22 &%$& "F$ $" %V32".% $+% -6H(/F($1 $+-$ 2(%& -$
$+% +%-.$ "0 -#1 -$$%63$ $" &3%-T "0 - &F.'('-2 5"0; #(+(2(&6> M% 9.-8& "F.
-$$%#$("# $" $+% &(/#(0(7-#7% "0 $+% 9"FH2% /%#($('% +%.%> *+(& 6-1 .%0%. $"
"F. 8(22 -#9 9%&(.% $" 2('% "# -#9 7.%-$% #%8 '-2F%& -0$%. #(+(2(&6 +-& H%%#
H."F/+$ $" 3%.0%7$("# -#9 0F221 -7$('-$%9]-7$F-2(&%9B ". ($ 6-1 .%0%. $" ($&
F#7-##1 -#9 3%.3%$F-2 .%$F.#B $+-$ (&B $+-$ ($ &F.'('%& "F. -$$%63$& $" "'%.S
7"6% ($> !-1/(22 $+F& &$.%&&%& ($& 3%.0".6-$('% 7"#$.-9(7$("# h -#1 -$$%63$ $"
.%'-2F% '-2F%& 8(22 6%.%21 .%&F2$ (# #(+(2(&6;& .%$F.# (& +(& 7"#$%#$("# h -#9
&3%-T& "0 ($& 5(#%2F7$-H2% 6"9-2($1;> Y$ (& #"$ 72%-. 8+%$+%. $+(& (& -2&" #"$ $"
3"&($ ($ -$ $+% &-6% $(6% -& -# "#$"2"/(7-2 (#'-.(-#$ -#9 -& 3-.$ "0 &"6%
(#&F3%.-H2% 7"#9($("#> *+% %&&-1 7"#7%#$.-$%& -$$%#$("# "# $+% H(#9(#/
7+-.-7$%. "0 =(%$A&7+%-# #(+(2(&6B 8+(7+ (& $" .%0%. $" ($ H%(#/ &3%22H"F#9
$" $+% '%.1 $+(#/ ($ 8(&+%& $" "'%.7"6%> L#% &%$ "0 +(/+%&$ '-2F%& -.%
9%'-2F%9 "#21 $" H% .%32-7%9 H1 -#"$+%. %_F-221 #(+(2(&$(7 3"&($(#/ "0 +(/+%&$
'-2F%&B (# 8+(7+ $+"&% "0 $+% &3(.($ -#9 $%2%"2"/1 -.% .%32-7%9 H1 $+"&% "0 $+%
H"91 -#9 "0 (66-#%#7%> *+% -./F6%#$ -6"F#$& $" $+% 7"#$%#$("F& 72-(6
$+-$ -#1 -$$%63$ $" "'%.7"6% $.-#&7%#9%#$ 3+(2"&"3+(%& -#9 .%2(/("#& `P2-S
$"#(&6 -#9 !+.(&$(-#($1a #%7%&&-.(21 .%&F2$& (# - 6%.% (#'%.&("#> Q# -$$%63$
$" -00(.6 2(0% 0."6 $+% 3"(#$ "0 '(%8 "0 ($& (66-#%#$ 3."9F7$("# (& RF&$ -&
#(+(2(&$(7 -& $+% +%/%6"#(7 -$$%63$ $" &-'% ($ 0". $.-#&7%#9%#7% `-& (# $+%
&-#7$($1 "0 2(0% 9"7$.(#% 3."6F2/-$%9 (# $+% .%7%#$ f-$(7-# &$-$%6%#$& 9(&S
7F&&%9 (# $+% %&&-1a> !-1/(22 8(&+%&B $+%.%0".%B $" &+"8 $+% %..".& 7"66($$%9
(# -#1 -$$%63$ $" "'%.7"6% #(+(2(&6 $+-$ 9"%& &" (# (/#".-#7% "0 ($& 3"8%.&
"0 .%$F.# -#9 .%3%$($("#> M% 2"7-$%& - 5&"2F$("#; (# =(%$A&7+%;& 3F.&F($ "0
57+%%.0F2#%&&;B - 7+%%.0F2#%&& 0.%% "0 $+% &3(.($ "0 .%'%#/% -#9 ($& .%&&%#$(S
6%#$ $"8-.9& 2(0% `8+%$+%. ($& #%/-$("# ". -00(.6-$("#a> Q $+%"2"/1 h
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-&#)".,/#*"& V'((
8+%$+%. 6%$-3+1&(7-2 ". 3"&$S6%$-3+1&(7-2 h "0 2(0% /('%& 8-1 $" - 3.-V(& "0
2(0% -& (# $+% %V-632% "0 !+.(&$ `$.%-$%9 H1 =(%$A&7+% +(6&%20 (# $+% 6(&2%-9S
(#/21 $($2%9 D'$ 7&#*J(')*%#a> M"8%'%.B =(%$A&7+% -2&" &3%-T&B -#9 -& (& 7($%9
H1 !-1/(22 (# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 +(& #%80"F#9 7+%%.0F2#%&& (# $+% 8-T% "0 $+%
9%-$+ "0 ^"9 `-#9 8+-$ 7"F29 H% 6".% 9%-9iaB "0 +(& 52"#/(#/; -#9 /.%-$
5%V3%7$-$("#&; $+-$ 7-# #"8 H% 3."R%7$%9 -#9 7"#&$($F$%9B -#9 "#% 8"#9%.&
+"8 !-1/(22;& %&&%#$(-221 ,$"(7 .%&"2F$("# "0 $+% 3."H2%6 -#9 3.%9(7-6%#$ "0
#(+(2(&6 7-# -$ -22 -77%&& $+% #-$F.% -#9 7+-.-7$%. "0 $+(& 9%&(.% -#9 %V3%7$-S
$("#B "0 $+% 56%-#(#/; "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 7+%%.0F2#%&& -#9 $+% #-$F.% "0 $+% 5#%8
(#0(#($%; +% 2""T& 0".8-.9 $"> *+(#T(#/ $+% %'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 %#$-(2& #"$
"#21 -# %6-#7(3-$("# 0."6 0%-. -#9 -#V(%$1 HF$ -2&" -# %6-#7(3-$("# "0
9%&(.%>
O".T(#/ $+."F/+ -# F#F&F-2 7"6H(#-$("# "0 Z-$-(22%B Q.$-F9 -#9 K%e'(#-&B
[-'(9 Z""$+."19 0F.$+%. 7"#$.(HF$%& $" $+% _F%&$("# "0 %$+(7& -#9 3"&$S
+F6-#(&6 H1 %V-6(#(#/ $+% %$+(7-2 &(/#(0(7-#7% "0 $+% &T(#> Y# &" 9"(#/
+% (& .%0F&(#/ $+% .%9F7$('% 7"#7%3$("# "0 $+% &%#$(%#$ H"91 3.%'-2%#$ (#
6F7+ 53"&$6"9%.#; $+(#T(#/> W". (#&$-#7%B $+% 3%.0".6-#7% -.$(&$B ,$%2-.7
(#&(&$& $+-$ $+% H"91 -#9 ($& H"F#9-.(%& -.% #"8 .%#9%.%9 "H&%2%$% H1 #%8
$%7+#"2"/(%&4
Q& &F.0-7%B &T(# 8-& "#7% $+% H%/(##(#/ "0 $+% 8".29 -#9 &(6F2$-#%"F&21
$+% H"F#9-.1 "0 $+% &%20> Q& (#$%.0-7%B ($ 8-& "#7% $+% &($% "0 $+% 7"22-3&%
"0 $+% 3%.&"#-2 -#9 $+% 3"2($(7-2> ZF$ #"8 %#)$#/'$. -#9 I$&$#)9#$. H1
6-7+(#%& ,bY= Y, =L KL=^UG *MU ,ELL*M ,U=,\L\, ,\GWQ!U LW
Q ,Y*U LG Q ,!GUU=> ,T(# #" 2"#/%. &(/#(0(%& 72"&F.%>*+% .F3$F.% "0
&F.0-7% -#9 "0 &T(# 6%-#& $+% $)9%,)$ "0 (##%. -#9 "F$%.> Q& (#$%.0-7%B
$+% &T(# (& (#-9%_F-$%
`,$%2-.7 )XXJB X)aN
P.%0-7(#/ +(& 3(%7% 8($+ - /.-3+(7 9(&32-1 "0 $".$F.% -#9 .%6(#9(#/ F& "0
7"#$%63".-.1 -7$& "0 9%6%6H%.6%#$B 0."6 G8-#9- $" Q2/%.(-B Z""$+."19
02(%& (# $+% 0-7% "0 &F7+ .%9F7$('% -#-21&%& -#9 "H2(/%& F& $" 7"#&(9%. '("2%#7%
-& 59(.%7$%9 -/-(#&$ $+% &T(#;> *+% &T(# .%6-(#& 'F2#%.-H2%B 6-.T(#/ - 2(6(#-2
9(00%.%#7% H%$8%%# $+% &-6% -#9 $+% "$+%.B HF$ ($ -2&" 7"#$(#F%& $" H%
F#9%7(9-H2%> Y$ "#7% 0(/F.%& -& $+-$ 8+(7+ H(#9& $+% 56%; $"/%$+%. V,9
%V(&$%#$ -#9 $+-$ F3"# 8+(7+ %V$%.(".($1 7"#&$-#$21 (63(#/%&> U_F-221 ($ (&
$+-$ 8+(7+ &%3-.-$%& 6% 0."6 $+% L$+%. -#9 $+-$ 8+(7+ -22"8& 6% $" 0%%2 0".
$+% L$+%. -#9 $+% (66%9(-71 "0 +(&]+%. 8"F#9(#/> U'%# - 7"#7%#$.-$%9
%V-6(#-$("# "0 &7%#%& "0 &T(# &1&$%6-$(7-221 H%(#/ +-7T%9 -8-1 -#9 3F#7S
$F.%9 "'%. -#9 "'%. -/-(# 9" #"$ 2-1 ($& &(/#(0(7-#7% $" .%&$ -& 9%-$+ ($&%20B
"F$&(9% "0 - 3-.$(7F2-. $+%-$.% "0 (#9('(9F-$("#B (& #"$ -..('%9 -$> *+(& F#9%.S
2(#(#/ "0 $+% (#7"632%$-H(2($1 "0 #%/-$('($1B F#9%.&$""9 -& $+% 5#(+(2(&$(7 8(22
$" #"$+(#/;B 3%.6($& Z""$+."19 $" 3."3"&% 5-# %$+(7& "0 7-.#-2($1;B -# %$+(7&
"0 5H%(#/S(#S-S&T(#;B "#% $+-$ 7"#'"2F$%& 8($#%&& -#9 '(7$(6 "0 '("2%#7%B
(#'"2F$(#/ $+% 3%.3%$.-$". 8($+ $+% "#2""T%.B 9"FH2(#/ $+% &7%#% "0 &F00%.S
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
V'((( -&#)".,/#*"&
(#/B (632(7-$(#/ F& 8($+(# ($> *+% %$+(7-2 6"6%#$ (& 3"&($%9 -& $+-$ 8+(7+
(#$%..F3$& -##(+(2-$("#>
!-$+%.(#% [-2% -2&" 0"7F&%& "# -# (#$%..F3$("# "0 &".$&B "#% $+-$ (& 5.F9%;
-#9 8+(7+ &+"F$& 9"8# 3-$ -#9 0".6F2-(7 9(&7"F.&%& 0". 7"#$."22(#/ 8+-$ (&
3%.7%('%9 -& 6-9#%&&> Q.$-F9 (& 3.%&%#$%9 -& - 0(/F.% 8+"&% 7"#$."22%9 `&%20aS
8"F#9(#/& 3."'(9% F& 8($+ -# -%&$+%$(7 7"."22-.1 $" Z""$+."19;& %$+(7-221S
0"7F&%9 (#$%.'%#$("# "# 5&T(#(+(2-$("#;> Y# - 7"#&(9%.-$("# "0 $+% 0%-&(H(2($1
"0 -# .%S%#%./%$(&%9 -#9 .%S%#%./(&(#/ #(+(2(&6B "#% 7-3-H2% "0 "'%.7"6(#/
$+% (#%.$(- "0 3%&&(6(&6B &+% 0".6F2-$%& $+% 3+.-&% 5- 7"#7%3$F-2 $F.#&$(2%; $"
9%#"$% $+% 3."7%&&& "0 7"#'%.&("# -$ 32-1 8($+(# Q.$-F9;& 8".T> Y# - 7"#S
0."#$-$("# 8($+ -# -3".%$(7 -H1&&B $+-$ (& 8($+ &"6%$+(#/ h &F7+ -& $+-$ "0
$+% 502(7T%.(#/ 0".6 "0 - 6-# HF.#(#/ -$ $+% &$-T%; h 8+(7+ 7-##"$ H% /.-&3%9
-#9 3F$ (#$" - 0F221 7"#7%3$F-2(&%9 0".6B $+% -H&"2F$%#%&& "0 2(0% (& &%%# -& .%S
%6%./(#/> *+(& -H&"2F$% 2(0% (& #"$ "#% $+-$ /%$& H-7T (# .%$F.# 0". +-'(#/
$.-9%9 (# "#%;& &%#$(%#$ H"91 $" $+% 3"2(7%6%# "0 6".-2($1m $+(& (& #"
.%2(/("F&21S9"F&%9 2(0% -0$%. 9%-$+> Y#&$%-9B "F$ "0 $+% 8+(.23""2 "0 57"#7%3S
$F-2 7"#'%.&("#;B 8($+ ($& F#%V3%7$%9 (#'%.&("# "0 .%&3%7$-H2% H%+-'("F.B ($&
.F9% "F$.-/% -#9 8(20F2 -//.%&&("#B HF.&$& - &7-.7%21 7"#$-(#-H2% 2(0%B "#%
$+-$ (& 7"#&$-#$21 (# 6"$("#B (#'"2F$(#/ R"1 8($+ &F00%.(#/B 3-(# 8($+ 3"8%.>
[-2% 7"#72F9%& 8($+ - .%02%7$("# "# 7.($(7&; 9(00(7F2$1 (# .%-9(#/ Q.$-F9 -#9
8"#9%.& 8+%$+%. $+(& 6(/+$ +-'% &"6%$+(#/ $" 9" 8($+ +(& -8-.%#%&& $+-$
.%-9(#/ (& ($&%20 (..%9F7(H21 5.F9%;>
*+% 7"#72F9(#/ 7+-3$%. H1 [-#(%2 b-$A -2&" 7"#7%#$.-$%& "# - 6"9%.#(&$
8.($%. 8+" (& &%%# -& .%&(&$(#/ 7.($(7-2 -33."3.(-$("#> M% .%R%7$& - .%-9(#/ "0
,-6F%2 Z%7T%$$ 8+(7+ 8"F29 -$$%63$ $" .%7F3%.-$% +(& 9(00(7F2$ -#9 %2F&('%
"$,F)$ H1 3F$$(#/ $" 8".T $+% #%/-$('($1 0"F#9 $+%.%(#> b-$A .%0F&%&B -#9
2"7-$%& - .%0F&-2 8($+(# Z%7T%$$ +(6&%20B - .%7F3%.-$('% 2"/(7 8+(7+ .%9F7%&
7"632%V $+(#T(#/ H1 3.%&%#$(#/ ($ -& - &(/#(0(7-#$ h -#9 $+%.%H1 3"&($('%21
(#0F&%9 8($+ 6%-#(#/0F2#%&& h &$-/(#/ "0 $+% (63"&&(H(2($1 "0 6%-#(#/> b-$A
&F//%&$& $+-$ -22 $"" "0$%# $+% &3%7(0(7($1 "0 T%1 6"9%.#(&$ $+(#T%.& +-& H%%#
'($(-$%9 H1 - 7-$7+S-22 0".6F2-(7 0".6 "0 7.($(7(&6 8+(7+ ($&%20 7"F29 H%
9%%6%9 9%&$.F7$('%B (0 #"$ 8%-T21 #(+(2(&$(7B "0 7.F7(-2 -%&$+%$(7 -#9 3+(2"S
&"3+(7-2 %#9%-'"F.& $" 6-(#$-(# - .%2-$("# $" #"$+(#/> Q# -.7+%$13-2 %V-6S
32% "0 &F7+ 7.($(7(&6 (& Q9".#";&B 8+"&% .%-7$("# $" Z%7T%$$;& 8".T (& &F66%9
F3 (# +(& &$-$%6%#$ (# !$?9#*F$ B*94$/#*/% $+-$4 5Z%7T%$$ +-& /('%# $+% "#21
-33."3.(-$% .%-7$("# $" $+% &($F-$("# "0 $+% !"#7%#$.-$("# !-63&B $+-$ +%
#%'%. #-6%&B -& (0 ($ 2-1 F#9%. -# (6-/% H-# `<*4.$)F$)+"#W; `Q9".#" )X?IB
@C@m )XC@B @?Ia> ,F7+ - &$-$%6%#$ $%22& F& #"$+(#/ -H"F$ $+% &3%7(0(7 7"#S
7%.#& "0 Z%7T%$$ `-#9 (#9%%9 Q9".#";& %&&-1 "# Z%7T%$$;& 5U#9/-6%; +-&
3.%7("F& 2($$2% $" 9" 8($+ $+% 32-1 ($&%20 -#9 (& 6".% 3%.$(#%#$ -& - .%-9(#/
"0 W.%#7+ %V(&$%#$(-2(&6a -#9 ($& 9"/6-$(7 /%#%.-2($1 6(/+$ %'%# &$.(T% F& -&
9-#/%."F& #"8-9-1&4 - 0-. $"" /.%-$ -# -&&F63$("# $+-$ $+% ,+"-+ +-&
H%7"6% - 5$"$-2 -3.(".(; 0". 7"#$%63".-.1 $+(#T(#/B $+-$ ($ &$-#9& -& $+%
5(#7"66%#&F.-H2% "'%. -#9 -H"'% -22 %V3%.(%#7%; `Q9".#" )XXCB @)@a (&B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-&#)".,/#*"& V(V
+-20 - 7%#$F.1 -0$%. $+% %'%#$&B 6(&32-7%9 -#9 %'%# 7"F#$%.3."9F7$('%> Y$ 7-#
($&%20 H%7"6% -# "0$ .%3%-$%9 ".$+"9"V1 .%9F7$('%21 F&%9 0". 3"2($(7-221 %#9&B
$+-$ 0-22& "# 9%-0%#%9 -#9 +-H($F-$%9 %-.&> U'%# 8".&%B $+% 0".6F2-(7 .%3.%S
&%#$-$("# "0 $+% M"2"7-F&$ -& $+% F2$(6-$% F##-6%-H2% 7-# ($&%20 3."9F7% 0".6 "0 .%-7$('% #(+(2(&6B "#% '('(921 -#9 3."'"7-$('%21 9%&7.(H%9B 0".
(#&$-#7%B H1 $+% QF&$.(-# #"'%2(&$B U20.(%9% k%2(#%T (# P"&.$)2,4R P"&.$)2,4
D*5$% 8+%.% - /-#/ "0 1"F#/ 3%"32% '("2%#$21 2-&+ "F$ -/-(#&$ 8+-$ $+%1
3%.7%('% -& 3-.%#$-2 5&8-992(#/ (# $+% +F6-# $%-S7"&1 "0 $+% 6F.9%.%9B $+%
+-#/%9 -#9 $+% /-&&%9; `k%2(#%T )X?IB @Im )XXIB <Xa> *%-7+(#/ $+% 1"F#/%.
/%#%.-$("#& -H"F$ $+% M"2"7-F&$ (& 6%-#$ $" (#"7F2-$% $+%6 -/-(#&$ - .%3%$(S
$("# "0 /%#"7(9-2 +(&$".1m (#&$%-9B ($ 3%.'%.&%21 H%7"6%& - +-$%SH-&% 0". #%"S
=-A( .%&(&$-#7%B 72%-.21 %'(9%#$ (# k%2(#%T;& #"'%2 -#9 (# "F. 7"#$%63".-.1
8".29> Q .%($%.-$%9 3F$$(#/S$"S8".T "0 $+% M"2"7-F&$ 3%.'%.&%21 $.-#&2-$%& ($
(#$" -# (#%00%7$F-2 5$%- 7"&1; -2"#/&(9% 8+(7+ "#% 2('%& (# $+% +"..".& "0 $+%
%'%.19-1B (# 9%&3%.-$("# "0 &"6% 7"6(7 .%-&&F.-#7% $+-$ 2(0% (& #%'%.$+%2%&&
&$(22 H%-F$(0F2>C O+(2% #"$ -99.%&&%9 (# $+%&% $%.6& (# b-$A; 3(%7%B $+%.% (& 2"$ -$ &$-T% (# +(& (#&(&$%#7% "# .%&(&$(#/ - .%-9(#/ "0 Z%7T%$$ 8+(7+ 7.($(7-221
-33."3.(-$%& +(6 -& %($+%. - $+(#T%. "0 -H&"2F$% #"$+(#/2%&& ". .%7F3%.-$%9
6%-#(#/0F2#%&& -#9 3.%&%#$(#/ +(6 (#&$%-9 -& - 9%6-#9(#/ $+(#T%. "0
5%#"F/+;>
O% .%$F.# $" "F. H%/(##(#/4 $+% _F%&$("# "0 +-'(#/ +-9 %#"F/+ "0 6%2S
-#7+"2(- -#9 ($& 9"/6-$(7 -#9 F#7.($(7-2 &2F6H%.&> Y0 $+(& '"2F6% (#&3(.%&
.%#%8%9 -$$%63$& $" $+(#T -#9 /" H%1"#9 $+% +F6-# 7"#9($("#B $+%# ($ 8(22
+-'% &%.'%9 ($& /%.6(#-2 3F.3"&%>
U#/2(&+ ". W.%#7+ &3%22(#/ "0 K%'(#-& +-& H%%# 2%0$ $" (#9('(9F-2 -F$+".&>
*+% %9($".& 8"F29 2(T% $" $+-#T "F. 7"31S%9($".B ,-221 !.-80".9B -$
E-76(22-#B 0". +%. %00(7(%#$ +%23 8($+ $+(& '"2F6%>
C$%() Z-F9.(22-.9;& 3"&($("# -$ $+(& 3"(#$ 6(/+$ 8%22 .%6(#9 "#% "0 Z%#R-6(#;& 9%0(#($("#
"0 0-&7(&6 `)X?<B <DDa4 5E-#T(#9B 8+(7+ (# M"6%.;& $(6% 8-& -# "HR%7$ "0 7"#S
$%632-$("# 0". $+% L2163(-# /"9&B #"8 (& "#% 0". ($&%20> Y$& &%20S-2(%#-$("# +-&
.%-7+%9 &F7+ - 9%/.%% $+-$ ($ 7-# %V3%.(%#7% ($& "8# 9%&$.F7$("# -& -# -%&$+%$(7
32%-&F.% "0 $+% 0(.&$ ".9%.;>
< *+(& 6%2-#7+"2(7 #(+(2(&6 0(#9& %7+"%& (# k%-#SW.-#7"(& K1"$-.9;& 3"&$6"9%.#
0-H2% -H"F$ %'"2F$("#B 8+(7+ +% .%-9& (# $%.6& "0 $+% 5(#+F6-#; $+%&(& "0 #%/%#S
$."3(7 7"632%V(0(7-$("#> ,%% K1"$-.9 )XXCB ?@h)I@m -#9 0". - 7.($(7-2 .%-9(#/ "0
K1"$-.9;& $+%&(&B &%% Q#&%22 P%-.&"# <III>
@ W". -#"$+%. 7"#$%63".-.1 $+(#T%.;& &$-#9 -/-(#&$ 53"&$6"9%.# (63-&&%&; h F#9%.S
&$""9 -& 5$+% 3-.-9(/6 "0 -22 &FH6(&&("# -#9 %'%.1 &".$ "0 7"63."6(&% 8($+ $+%
%V(&$(#/ &$-$F& _F"; h &%% ^F-$$-.( (# ^%#"&T" )XXNB )IXh)D>
D ,%% -2&" [-8T(#& `)XX)B C@a4 5$+% -7$F-2 -#(6-2& $+-$ +-'% %'%. 2('%9 "# U-.$+ -.% $(#1 &FH&%$ "0 $+% $+%".%$(7-2 -#(6-2& $+-$ 7"F29 %V(&$> *+%&% .%-2 -#(6-2& -.% $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
VV -&#)".,/#*"&
3."9F7$& "0 - '%.1 &6-22 #F6H%. "0 %'"2F$("#-.1 $.-R%7$".(%& $+."F/+ /%#%$(7 &3-7%>
*+% '-&$ 6-R".($1 "0 $+%".%$(7-2 $.-R%7$".(%& $+."F/+ -#(6-2 &3-7% /('% .(&% $"
(63"&&(H2% 6"#&$%.&> G%-2 -#(6-2& -.% 9"$$%9 -."F#9 +%.% -#9 $+%.% -6"#/ $+%
+13"$+%$(7-2 6"#&$%.&B %-7+ 3%.7+%9 (# ($& "8# F#(_F% 32-7% (# /%#%$(7 +13%.S
&3-7%> U-7+ .%-2 -#(6-2& (& &F.."F#9%9 H1 - 2($$2% 72F&$%. "0 #%(/+H"F.&B 6"&$ "0
8+"6 +-'% #%'%. %V(&$%9 HF$ - 0%8 "0 8+"6 -.% -.% ($& -#7%&$".&B ($& 9%&7%#9-#$&
-#9 ($& 7"F&(#&;>
J *+(& (& - 32-1 "# M%(9%//%.;& 5L#21 - ^"9 !-# ,-'% \&; (# O"2(# `%9>a )XX@B X)h))N>
N ,%% -2&" ^(H&"# `)X?Na "# $+% 6-$.(V 7"8H"1;& 7"#$%63$ 0". $+% 502%&+ 7-/%; -#9
56%-$ 7-/%; 8+(7+ +"29& +(6 H-7T 0."6 $+% 59(&%6H"9(%9 7"#&7("F&#%&&; "0 71H%.S
&3-7%> ,%% Q#&%22 P%-.&"# )XXC 0". 7.($(7-2 .%'-2F-$("# "0 &F7+ -33."-7+%& $" $+%
53"&$S+F6-#;>
C *+(& (& - .%0%.%#7% $" Z%#(/#(;& 0(26 5K- '($- %n H%22-; `)XX?aB - 57"6%91; -H"F$ 2(0% (#
$+% =-A( !"#7%#$.-$("# !-63&B 8+(7+ -$ $+% 6"6%#$ "0 8.($(#/ $+(& (#$."9F7$("#
+-& RF&$ .%7%('%9 -# L&7-.>
0(D()(,1(Q9".#"B *+> `)X?Ia !$?9#*F$ B*94$;#*; W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 ,F+.T-63 `)XC@a !$?9#*F$
B*94$/#*/%B $.-#&> U>Z> Q&+$"#B =o4 !"#$(#FF6>
`)XXCa 5f%.&F7+B 9-& U#9&3(%2 AF '%.&$%+%#; (# 5Q+ &9/' 7,%/'=*#@ &"/' %*/' 4$+$& 49%%$N0
6*& I'*4"%"I'*%/'$% L$%$+,/' %9> G> *(%9%6-##B W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 ,F+.T-63>
Q#&%22 P%-.&"#B b> `)XXCa 5K(0% Z%7"6(#/ Z"914 L# $+% 5E%-#(#/; "0 P"&$ MF6-#
U'"2F$("#; (# (,4#,)94 X94,$% '"2> )B #"> <B %9> ,7"$$ O(2&"#B LV0".94 Z2-7T8%22
PFH2(&+%.& K$9>
pp `<III 0".$+7"6(#/a 5P"&$9-.8(#(-# U'"2F$("#& -#9 P"&$6"9%.# W-H2%&;B (# K>
M-.$2%1 -#9 !> b-32-#B B9)=*&N% 3*44$&*,50 !$= 6%%9C% "& A/*$&/$ 9&. (,4#,)$>
Z-F9.(22-.9B k> 5L# =(+(2(&6; (# A*5,4/)9 9&. A*5,49#*"& $.-#&> ,>W> ^2-&%.B E(7+(/-#4
E(7+(/-# \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
Z%#R-6(#B O> `)X?<a 5*+% O".T "0 Q.$ (# $+% Q/% "0 E%7+-#(7-2 G%3."9F7$("#; (#
-44,5*&9#*"&% $.-#&> M> q"+#B ZF#/-1B ,F00"2T4 W"#$-#-] !"22(#&>
[-8T(#&B G> `)XX)a D'$ <4*&. P9#/'59;$) M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#>
^%#"&T"B ^> %9> `)XXNa D'$ O,9##9)* 1$9.$) LV0".94 Z-&(2 Z2-7T8%22>
MFV2%1B Q> `)XXDa D'$ B"")% "2 E$)/$I#*"& 9&. >$9F$& 9&. >$44B 0".%8".9 H1 k>^> Z-22-.9B
K"#9"#4 W2-6(#/"B M-.3%.]!"22(#&>
k%2(#%TB U> `)X?Ia B*$ 7,%?$%I$))#$& M-6HF./4 G"8"+2$ `)XXIa P"&.$)2,4R P"&.$)2,4
D*5$%B $.-#&> E> MF2&%B K"#9"#4 ,%.3%#$;& *-(2>
K1"$-.9B k>SW> `)XXCa 5Q P"&$6"9%.# W-H2%; (# E"%#5".$)& :9+4$%B $.-#&> ^> '-# 9%#
QHH%%2%B E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XN?a D'$ P*44 #" E"=$) $.-#&> O> b-F06-##B =o4 f(#$-/%>
pp `)X?Na >,59&R 744 D"" >,59&B $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)X?Xa Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94% 9&. 6//$ >"5" $.-#&> O> b-F06-##B =o4 f(#$-/%>
,$%2-.7 `)XXJa 5*"8-.9& $+% P"&$S+F6-#; (# 7)/'*#$/#,)94 B$%*?&0 7)/'*#$/#% *& (C+$)%I9/$
#"> ))?B !-6H.(9/%4 Q7-9%61 ^."F3 K$9>
O"2(#B G> %9> `)XX@a D'$ >$*.$??$) ("&#)"F$)%C !-6H.(9/% E-&&-7+F&%$$&4 EY* P.%&&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-&#)".,/#*"& VV(
)
64*"# 74+$)#
,(#7% !"3%.#(7F& 6-# +-& H%%# ."22(#/ 0."6 $+% 7%#$.%
$"8-.9 :>
=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)>J
,(#7% !"3%.#(7F&B 6-# &%%6& $" +-'% /"$ +(6&%20 "# -# (#72(#%9
32-#% h #"8 +% (& &2(33(#/ 0-&$%. -#9 0-&$%. -8-1 0."6 $+% 7%#$.%
(#$" 8+-$i (#$" #"$+(#/#%&&i (#$" - 5I$&$#)9#*&? &%#&% "0 +(& #"$+S
(#/#%&&;i
=(%$A&7+% )XNX YYY l<J
*+%.%(# 8% +-'% $+% .%-&"# 8+1 %'%.1 6-#B 8+%$+%. +% H% "# %-.$+B
(# $+% &F#B". "# -#"$+%. 32-#%$B -28-1& +-& $+% (63.%&&("# $+-$ -22
"$+%. $+(#/& -.% (# 6"'%6%#$ 8+(2&$ +% +(6&%20 (& (# - &".$ "0
(66"'-H2% 7%#$.%m +% 8(22 7%.$-(#21 -28-1& 7+""&% 3"2%& 8+(7+
8(22 '-.1 -77".9(#/ -& +(& 32-7% "0 %V(&$%#7% (& $+% &F#B $+% %-.$+B
$+% 6""#B E-.& %$7> Y# 7"#&%_F%#7%B $+%.% 8(22 -28-1& H% - 59/'*&9
5,&.* 8+"&% 7%#$.% &" $" &3%-TB (& %'%.18+%.%B 8+"&% 7(.7F60%.S
%#7% (& #"8+%.%B 0". ^"9 (& ($& 7(.7F60%.%#7% -#9 7%#$.% -#9 +% (&
%'%.18+%.% -#9 #"8+%.%>
!F&-B B$ B"/#9 -?&")9&#*9 ZT> YYB !+> )<
E
b-#$ 72-(6& $+-$ +(& -7+(%'%6%#$ (# 3+(2"&"3+1 (& $+% -#-2"/F% "0 $+-$ "0
!"3%.#(7F&; (# 7"&6"2"/1> !"22"_F(-221 $+(& 7-..(%& $+% &%#&% "0 - 6-R".
3-.-9(/6-$(7 &+(0$ (# 3%.7%3$("#4 &(#7% b-#$ (& 72-(6(#/ 0". +(& -7+(%'%6%#$
$+% &$-$F& "0 - .F3$F.% 8($+ $+% 3-&$B - 72%-# H.%-T> *+% 3."H2%6 8($+ $+(&
72-(6B +"8%'%.B (& .%'%-2%9 -& &""# -& "#% H%/(#& $" %V-6(#% $+% 7"&6"2"/S
(7-2B 6%$-3+1&(7-2 -#9 7"#7"6($-#$ 3"2($(7-2 7+-./% "0 !"3%.#(7F&; 8".T> Y$
$+%# H%7"6%& -33-.%#$ $+-$ b-#$;& 72-(6 (& #"$ .%-221 -& -3"7-213$(7B -&
7-$-721&6(7B ". -& .%'"2F$("#-.1B 0". $+% $%.6&B 7"#'%#$("#&B 2(6($& -#9
3"&&(H(2($(%& "0 $+"F/+$ -& +% 8"F29 8(&+ F& $" $+(#T> Y$ (& F2$(6-$%21 (#
)
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
*+% ,+-$$%.(#/ "0 $+% !.1&$-2 ,3+%.%&4
5."22(#/ 0."6 $+% 7%#$.% $"8-.9 :;
!*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Z-$-(22%;& &%#&%B 7"6(7-2> 5=" "#% 7-# &-1 8($+"F$ H%(#/ 7"6(7-2 $+-$ +% (&
/%$$(#/ .%-91 $" "'%.$F.# $+(#/&4 M% 6F&$ "'%.$F.#B -#9 $+-$;& -22; `Z-$-(22%
)XX) <I])Ia> PF$ "$+%.8(&%B (# $+% 2(#% "0 $+"F/+$ H%(#/ 0"22"8%9 +%.%B
b-#$;& $+"F/+$ (& 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 -& H%(#/ - 5.%#"'-$%9 $+%"2"/1; `[%2%FA%
)X?@B X@a> Y# 7"#&%_F%#7%B 0-. 0."6 7"#&$($F$(#/ $+% (#'%#$("# "0 - $+"F/+$
$+-$ 8"F29 %&7-3% ,$-$%S0".6 -#9 5H2-&$ "3%# $+% 7"#$(#FF6 "0 +(&$".1;
`Z%#R-6(# )XC@B <NDaB) b-#$(-#(&6 (& $-T%# $" H% - 72-#9%&$(#% 6%-#& "0
.%(#&$-$(#/ $.-#&7%#9%#7%>< *+% 2(#T H%$8%%# $+% ,$-$%S0".6 -#9 $.-#&7%#9S
%#7% (& $+% 7"632(6%#$ $" $+% (#$(6-71 $+-$ 7-# H% %V32".%9 (# -# -H&$.-7$
9(-/.-6 "0 (66-#%#$ 7.($(_F% -#9 3+(2"&"3+(7"S3"2($(7-2 +%.%&1m $+(& (#$(S
6-71 (& #"$ -77(9%#$-2 HF$ 7"#&$($F$('%m $+% ,$-$%S0".6 (# ($& 9(00%.%#$ 6-#S
(0%&$-$("#& $+."F/+ +(&$".1 (& &F&$-(#%9 H1 $.-#&7%#9%#7%>@ [%2%FA% -#9
^F-$$-.( 7-3$F.% $+% (&&F% $+F&4
O+%#%'%. $+%.% (& $.-#&7%#9%#7%B '%.$(7-2 Z%(#/B (63%.(-2 &$-$% (# $+% &T1
". "# %-.$+B $+%.% (& .%2(/("#m -#9 $+%.% (& 3+(2"&"3+1 8+%.%'%. $+%.% (&
(66-#%#7%>
`[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( )XX)B DNm )XXDB D@a
Q# F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 $+(& -H&$.-7$ 9(-/.-6 "0 3"8%. -#9 $.-#&7%#9%#7% (& $+%
#%7%&&-.1 3.%7"#9($("# "0 -77%3$(#/ b-#$;& 72-(6 $" H% !"3%.#(7-#m ($ 9"%& "0
7"F.&% /('% $+-$ 72-(6 -# %#$(.%21 9(00%.%#$B #%/-$('% ". &$.(7$21 9%2(6($%9
'-2F%> O% 7-# -77%3$ b-#$;& 72-(6 $" H% !"3%.#(7-# (#&"0-. -& !"3%.#(7F&;
.%'"2F$("# (& F#9%.&$""9 -& 6%.%21 +-'(#/ 7-..(%9 "F$ - 7"&6(7 &8-33(#/ "0
32-7%&4 $+-$ (& $" &-1B +% 32-7%& $+% ,F# (# $+% 7%#$.% "0 $+% 7"&6"&B 8+%.% $+%
U-.$+ +-9 H%%#> !"3%.#(7F&B (# "$+%. 8".9&B .%32-7%& /%"S 8($+ $+% &$(22 6".%
-#7(%#$ +%2("7%#$.(&6BD -#9 $.-9%& "#% '-.(-#$ "0 +(%.-.7+(7-2 $+(#T(#/ 0".
-#"$+%.m +% 2%-'%& (# 32-7% $+% 72"7T8".T 6%7+-#(&6& "0 $+% P$"2%6-(7
7"&6"&B 3.%&%.'%& $+% 7.1&$-2 &3+%.%&B -22"8& $+%6 $" 7"#$(#F% 02"-$(#/ (#
$+% %$+%.B -#9 -22"8& $+%6 $" 7"#$(#F% 32-1(#/ $+% .%&"#-$(#/ 6F&(7 $+-$
+-9 %#$%.$-(#%9 9%&3"$& -#9 3"3%&B -#9 &$F3%0(%9 $+% &FHR%7$%9 0". - 6(22%#S
#F6 -#9 - +-20> *+(& 7%2%&$(-2 &163+"#1 (& #"$ 9(&.F3$%9 F#$(2 $+% .F9%
(#$%.'%#$("# "0 $+% -3"&$-$% ["6(#(7-# "0 ="2-B ^(".9-#" Z.F#"B -#9 +(&
9%7(&("# $" &$"3 2(&$%#(#/ $" $+% 5-&&%& 9.%&&%9 F3 8($+ 9(-9%6& -#9 +-7T&
9%7T%9 8($+ .(#/& F#9%. $+% $($2% "0 9"7$".&; `Z.F#" )XX?B <Ja> Y$ (& "#21 8($+
Z.F#" $+-$ $+% 72"&%9 7"&6"& "0 $+% 6%9(%'-2 6(#9 (& 9%0(#($('%21 %V32"9%9B
-#9 ($ (& 2%0$ $" Z.F#" $" '%#$F.% $+% 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 - 8-1 "0 $+(#T(#/ "$+%.
$+-# $+% +(%.-.7+(7-2B $+% &$.-$(0(%9B 0". Z.F#" -##"F#7%& $+% #%7%&&($1 "0
$+(#T(#/ $+% 8".29 $"3"2"/(7-221B .+(A"6(7-221B -#9 "0 7.%-$(#/ 7"#7%3$& $+-$
8(22 .%02%7$ $+% 02F(9 7"632%V($1 "0 &F7+ - .%-2($1B -# "3%# 7"#7%3$F-2 &$.F7S
$F.%B -7%#$.(7 -#9 7"##%7$%9 %-7+ 3"(#$ $" %'%.1 "$+%. H1 $.-#&'%.&-2 2(#%&B 7"&6"& -#9 - $+"F/+$ 0".6 8($+"F$ - $.-#&7%#9%#$ 7%#$.% $" -#7+". ($>
Z.F#" 3."72-(6& -# F#&$-H2% 7"&6"& 2-7T(#/ +(%.-.7+1B '-2F% -#9 9(.%7$("#B
(# 8+(7+ 6%-#(#/ 9"%& #"$ 2(6($ ($&%20B 0". 8+%.%'%. ($ /"%&B -28-1& -#9
%'%.18+%.% ($ (& '(&(H2% -$ $+% 7%#$.% "0 $+% +".(A"#B 8+%$+%. ($ &+(0$& ($&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<
"H&%.'-$("# 3"(#$ "# $+% &F.0-7% "0 $+% %-.$+ ". "# $+% %9/%& "0 $+% F#('%.&%
-& ($ 7."&&%& "$+%. 8".29&; `Z.F#" )?CXhX)B '"2> Y 3$> ) <IDa> *+(& 72%-.21 (& $.-#&0".6-$("# "0 !F&-;& .*/#9 _F"$%9 -H"'% $+-$ ^"9 (& -# %#$($1 8+"&%
57%#$.% &" $" &3%-TB (& %'%.18+%.%B 8+"&% 7(.7F60%.%#7% (& #"8+%.%;B (#$" &$-$%6%#$ 8($+ H"$+ 7"&6"2"/(7-2 -#9 %3(&$%6"2"/(7-2 .-6(0(7-$("#&B #"8B
-& =F77(" L.9(#% 7"66%#$&B (# Z.F#";& +-#9& 5$+% "29 7"&6"2"/(7-2 7"#7%3$
$+-$ .%2%/-$%9 $+% 55%9/%&;; $" - 3%.3%$F-221 6-./(#-2 3"&($("# 0-22& $" 3(%7%&B
0". %'%.1$+(#/ 7-# H%7"6% $+% 7%#$.%B %'%.1 %2%6%#$ 7-# "77F31 - 9(00%.%#$
32-7%; `L.9(#% )XXNB )NNa> [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.(;& &6""$+ &3-7%B ". 32-#% "0
(66-#%#7% (& +%.% 3%.0%7$21 3.%0(/F.%9 (# Z.F#";& 6"#(&$(7 "#$"2"/(7-2 -#9
%3(&$%6"2"/(7-2 '(&("#B HF$ &" $"" (& =(%$A&7+%;& 3%.&3%7$('(&6>J O+%#
-33."-7+%9 (# $+(& 8-1 ($ H%7"6%& 72%-. _F($% +"8 $+%&% 9('%.&% 9"7$.(#%&
-.% -22 9%.('%9 0."6 $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 '-2F%& %V%7F$%9 H1
Z.F#";& %V$%#&("# "0 $+% (632(7-$("#& "0 !"3%.#(7-#(&6 $" $+%(. 2(6($B $+%
$.-R%7$".1 3%.0".6%9 H1 $+% I$)2$/# &*'*4*%# 8+" 7"6%& "F$ "# $+% "$+%. &(9%
"0 $+% (#%'($-H2% %'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6>
!.F7(-2 $" $+(& $.-R%7$".1 (& Z.F#";& -9"3$("# -#9 $.-#&0".6-$("# "0 $+%
&1&$%6 "0 $+% !-$-2-# 61&$(7 -#9 3"216-$+B G-16"#9 KF22B -#9 (# 3-.$(7F2-.
"0 +(& 9)% /"5+*&9#")*9B &" "0$%# 7($%9 -& - 3.%7F.&". "0 71H%.#%$(7 6-7+(#%&
'(- ($& (#02F%#7% "# K%(H#(A; B$ 7)#$ ("5+*&9#")*9>N KF22;& H.%-T$+."F/+ 8-&
$" %#9"8 7"#7%3$& 8($+ - #%8 02F(9($1 -#9 91#-6(&6 F$$%.21 -2(%# $" $+%
6%9(%'-2 8".29 "0 +(%.-.7+(%& -#9 7-$%/".(%&B 0". -& ,3(#"A- 8.($%& 5$+% ".9%.
-#9 7"##%7$("# "0 (9%-& (& $+% &-6% -& $+% ".9%. -#9 7"##%7$("# "0 $+(#/&;
`,3(#"A- )X?XB U YY Ca> KF22 $"" 3"&$F2-$%& - #%8 8".29B 0.%% 0."6 5$+%
.%&$.-(#$& "0 $+% +(%.-.7+(7-2 &$.F7$F.%& "0 6%9(%'-2 7"#7%3$&;> *+% 7"#7%3$&
8%.% #"8 F#9%.&$""9 .%2-$('% $" "#% -#"$+%.B 5(# .%2-$("#&+(3& $+-$ 8%.%
"3%# H%7-F&% $+%1 7"F29 H% .%'%.&%9; `G""H )XXCB <?Ca> Z.F#";& 7.($(_F% -#9
9%'%2"36%#$ "0 !"3%.#(7-#(&6 (& %V32(7($21 7-..(%9 "F$ "# $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2B
7"&6"2"/(7-2B -#9 3"2($(7-2 32-#%& &(6F2$-#%"F&21m (#9%%9B -& =%/.( (#&(&$& (#
.%-9(#/ ,3(#"A-B $+% 7.($(_F% "0 6%$-3+1&(7& *% 3"2($(7-2> Y# Z.F#" $+(& (9%#S
$($1 (& 3%.0".6-$('%21 9%6"#&$.-$%9> *" $.-7% "F$ $+%&% -33-.%#$21 "H&7F.%
-./F6%#$& (& $" 9(&&%7$ $+% ".(/(#&B 0".6-$("# -#9 3+(2"&"3+(7"S3"2($(7-2
7"#7%3$F-2 0"F#9-$("#& "0 6"9%.#($1 ($&%20 `- H1S3."9F7$ "0 $+(& -#-21&(& (&
$+-$ $+% $%.6& 53"&$6"9%.#($1; -#9 ($& 7"/#-$%& 6F&$ H% 2(6($%9 $" $+%(.
".(/(#& -& $%.6& $" 9%&7.(H% - 3-.$(7F2-. -.7+($%7$F.-2 &$12%m -22 "$+%. F&%& "0
$+%6 -.% $+%".%$(7-221 #-cg'% -#9 +(&$".(7-221 (22 (#0".6%9 h F#2%&& "0
7"F.&% "#% (& %#-6"F.%9 "0 $+% (9%- $+-$ 8% 9)$ /"(#/ &"6%8+%.% h H1 '(.$F%
"0 $+%(. H%(#/ (#%2F7$-H21 $(%9 F3 8($+ "#% 0".6 ". "$+%. "0 $%2%"2"/1B
"#% 9"7$.(#% ". "$+%. "0 F#('%.&-2 3."/.%&&a> O+%# 8% &$-.$ $" 2""T -$ $+(&
H(.$+ "0 6"9%.#($1B 8% 0(#9 7"(2%9 (# ($& +%-.$ $+% &#-T% "0 #(+(2(&6m -#9 &" $"
$-T% F3B -#9 &"6%8+-$ 9(&$".$B - 3"(#$ 6-9% H1 M-H%.6-&B 8% 0(#9 $+-$
$+(& H(.$+ +-& +-33%#%9 -/-(#B -#9 -/-(#B -#9 -/-(#B -#9 %'%.1 $(6% $+-$
$+% .%0.-(# "0 6"9%.#($1 (& 32-1%9 ($ 7"6%& -77"63-#(%9 H1 #(+(2(&64 $+%(.
.%2-$("#&+(3B 8"F29 -33%-. $" H% &16H("/%#%$(7>C =(+(2(&6 (& - 7"#&$($F$('%21
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
64*"# 74+$)# @
!*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
3."9F7$('% %2%6%#$ "0 6"9%.#($1> Y$ (& $+% .%7"/#($("# "0 $+% (#%'($-H2%
7"6(#/ "0 $+(& F#8-#$%9 -77"632(7% $+-$ 7"63"&%& "#% "0 $+% %2%6%#$& "0
[%2%FA%;& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+%B -#9 ($ (& 8+1 +% &-1& $+-$ 5=(%$A&7+%
7-# $+(#T $+-$ #(+(2(&6 (& #"$ -# %'%#$ (# +(&$".1 HF$ $+% 6"$". "0 $+%
+(&$".1 "0 6-# -& F#('%.&-2 +(&$".1; `[%2%FA% )X?@B )J<a>
Y$ (& #"$B $+%#B 8($+ !"3%.#(7F& $+-$ -#1 &".$ "0 $+.%-$ (& 3"&%9 $" $+%
$%..%&$.(-2 ".9%. '(- -# "#&2-F/+$ F3"# ($& 7%2%&$(-2 7"/#-$%B HF$ 8($+ Z.F#">
*+% 0F22 (63".$ "0 $+(& &+(0$ "0 -$$.(HF$("# (& 7"#&(9%.-H2% -#9 +-& #"$+(#/ $"
9" 8($+ 7"..%7$(#/ b-#$;& F&% "0 6%$-3+".&B (>%> &F//%&$(#/ $+-$ +% -#9 "$+%.
&%20S-//.-#9(&%.& #" 2"#/%. $+(#T "0 $+%6&%2'%& -#9 $+%(. -7+(%'%6%#$& -&
+-'(#/ $+% &$-$F& "0 $+% !"3%.#(7-# .%'"2F$("# HF$ .-$+%. -& H%(#/ Z.F#(-#
(# $+%(. &+-$$%.(#/ %00%7$&> *+(& .%'"2F$("#B H"$+ &7(%#$(0(7 -#9 3+(2"&"3+(7-2B
(& 9%&7.(H%9 H1 Q2%V-#9.% b"1.%e -& 0"22"8&4
$+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 $+% !"&6"&B $+-$ (&B $+% 9(&-33%-.-#7%B 0."6
3+(2"&"3+(7-221 -#9 &7(%#$(0(7-221 '-2(9 7"#7%3$&B "0 $+% 7"#7%3$("# "0
$+% 8".29 -& - 0(#($%B 72"&%9B -#9 +(%.-.7+(7-221 ".9%.%9 8+"2% r> > >s -#9
($& .%32-7%6%#$ H1 -# (#9%0(#($% F#('%.&% 8+(7+ (& H"F#9 $"/%$+%. H1 $+%
(9%#$($1 "0 ($& 0F#9-6%#$-2 7"63"#%#$& -#9 2-8&B -#9 (# 8+(7+ -22 $+%&%
7"#7%3$& -.% 32-7%9 "# $+% &-6% 2%'%2 "0 H%(#/> *+(&B (# $F.#B (632(%& $+%
9(&7-.9(#/ H1 &7(%#$(0(7 $+"F/+$ "0 -22 7"#&(9%.-$("#& H-&%9 F3"# '-2F%S
7"#7%3$&B &F7+ -& 3%.0%7$("#B +-.6"#1B 6%-#(#/ -#9 -(6B -#9 0(#-221 $+%
F$$%. 9%'-2".(&-$("# "0 H%(#/B $+% 9('".7% "0 $+% 8".29 "0 '-2F% 0."6 $+%
8".29 "0 0-7$&>
`b"1.%e )XJCm <a
Z.F#" (& -7F$%21 -8-.% "0 !"3%.#(7F&; 2(6($&B -#9 #"$%& $+%6 7F.$21B -&
0"22"8&4 +%B !"3%.#(7F& 59(9 #"$ /" 6F7+ 0F.$+%. r-8-1 0."6 $+% 7"66"#
-#9 'F2/-. 3+(2"&"3+1s H%7-F&% +% 7"F29 #"$ 32F6H -#9 3."H% (#$" 6-$$%.&
$" $+% %V$%#$ $+-$ +% 7"F29 7"632%$%21 F3.""$ F#&F($-H2% -#9 %63$1 3.(#7(S
32%& r > > > s +% 9(9 #"$ +-'% &F00(7(%#$ 6%-#& $" H% -H2% $" 9%0%-$ 7"632%$%21B
7"#_F%. -#9 &F33.%&& 0-2&%+""9 H%1"#9 -22 .%&(&$-#7%; `Z.F#" )XXJB ?Na> *+%
0(.&$ 6%#$("# (# 3.(#$ "0 !"3%.#(7F&; +%2("7%#$.(7 $+%&(& 8-& 8($+ $+% 3FHS
2(7-$("# "0 +(& ("55$	)*"4,% (# )J)Dm $+(& 3FH2(7-$("# 8-& 0"22"8%9 H1 2"#/ +(-$F& (# 8+(7+ ($ 8-& 2-./%21 (/#".%9B -#9 8+%# Z.F#" &$-.$& 2%7$F.(#/
F3"# ($& 7"#$%#$& -#9 (632(7-$("#&B ($ (& #"$ -& !"3%.#(7F&; 0(.&$ -7"21$% -#9
3."&%21$(&%.B HF$ -& +(& 0(.&$ -#9 6"&$ &%'%.% 7.($(7 `E%#9"A- )XXJB CCaB -#9 -&
&F7+B H%0".% $+% 8".29 8-& -H2% $" -H&".H $+% (632(7-$("#& "0 !"3%.#(7F&;
&1&$%6B Z.F#" 8-& -2.%-91 H.(#/(#/ $+%6 #%8& 0."6 - 6F7+ 6".% F#0-6(2S
(-.B 9(&_F(%$(#/ 32-#%$4 0". H-.%21 +-9 6-# H%%# .%6"'%9 0."6 $+% 7%#$.% "0
$+% 7"&6"&B $+-# Z.F#" 8-& -H"2(&+(#/ $+% 7"#7%3$ "0 7%#$.% -2$"/%$+%.4
5Z.F#" #"$ "#21 -#$(7(3-$%9 ^-2(2%" -#9 b%32%.B HF$ +% 3-&&%9 H%1"#9 $+%6
(#$" -# %#$(.%21 #%8 8".29 8+(7+ +-9 &+%9 -22 $+% 9."&& "0 $.-9($("#; `,(#/%.
)XJIB DXa>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
D
Z.F#" "00%.& - H"29 3.%7F.&". "0 [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.(;& 9%6-#9 $+-$
3+(2"&"3+1 H% (# -77".9 8($+ $+% 0".6F2- 5PK\GQKY,E ! EL=Y,E; `[%2%FA%
-#9 ^F-$$-.( )X?IB @)m )X?CB <IaB -& 8+%# +% #"$%&B %V32(7($21 -/-(#&$ H"$+
Q.(&$"$%2(-# -#9 P2-$"#(7 0".6& "0 9F-2(&6 -#9 $.-#&7%#9%#$-2(&6B $+-$
5#-$F.% 9%&7%#9& $" $+% 3."9F7$("# "0 $+(#/&B -#9 (#$%22%7$ -&7%#9& $" $+%
T#"82%9/% "0 $+%6B H1 "#% -#9 $+% &-6% 2-99%.> Z"$+ 8-1& 3."7%%9 0."6
F#($1 $" F#($1; `Z.F#" )XX?B X@a> Y# $+(& Z.F#" /"%& 0-. H%1"#9 - #-cg'%
%63(.(7(&6 -#9 '%#$F.%& 72"&% $" - &3%7F2-$('% 6-$%.(-2(&6 (# +(& 3."6"$("#
"0 - 6"#(&6 "0 6"9-2 9(00%.%#$(-$("#> Z.F#" 8.($%& "0 8+-$ (&B (# %00%7$B $+%
32-#% "0 (66-#%#7% $+-$ ($ (& 57"632(7-$('% r > > > s "#%B (66%#&%B (#0(#($% -#9
7"63.%+%#&('% "0 -22 H%(#/B -#9 (# -# %V32(7-$('% 6-##%.B ($ (& 3.%&%#$ (#
&%#&(H2% H"9(%& -#9 (# $+% 3"$%#71 -#9 $+% -7$ $+-$ 8% &%% 9(&$(#/F(&+%9 (#
$+%6; `Z.F#" )XX?B X@a> M% /"%& "# $" #"$% $+-$ ($ (& $+% 6-.T "0 $+% 0%%H2%
6(#9 $+-$ ($ 7-##"$ 5F#9%.&$-#9 6F2$(32(7($1 %V7%3$ $+."F/+ 6-#1 &3%7(%&B
-#-2"/(%& -#9 0".6& r > > > s> *+% 3.%6(%. (#$%22(/%#7% %6H.-7%& %'%.1$+(#/ (# &(#/2%B -H&"2F$%21 3%.0%7$ (9%-; `Z.F#" )XX?B XJa> *+(& 32-7%& Z.F#" 9(.%7$21
(# $+% 2(#% "0 F#('"7-2 "#$"2"/1B H%1"#9 $+% ,7+"2-&$(7 7-$%/".(%&B -#9 (#
$"F7+ 8($+ - 7%.$-(# #"6(#-2(&$(7 7.($(_F% "0 $+% Q.(&$"$%2(-# -.7+($%7$F.% "0
#-$F.-2 &3%7(%& -#9 "0 $+% $*."%> *+% 2-$$%. H%(#/ - 7.($(_F% -9"3$%9 H1
=(%$A&7+% 0"22"8(#/ K-#/%;& 3"&($("# $+-$ $+%.% (& 5#" &F7+ (#&$-#7% "0 &"
%63$1 -#9 -$ $+% &-6% $(6% 7.-&& - &F3%.&$($("# -& $+-$ "0 ,3%7(%&B -#9
$+%.% -.% 3."H-H21 0%8 3"(#$& (# 8+(7+ 6%# +-'% /"#% "# ."7T(#/ $+%6S
&%2'%& 8($+ &F7+ H-&%2%&& -./F6%#$-$("#& (#$" 9"/6-$(7 &2F6H%.; `K-#/%
)?CXB ((( <Ca>
Y$ (& %#$(.%21 3.%9(7$-H2% $+-$ -#1 9(&7F&&("# "0 #(+(2(&6 8(22 +-'% $" H%/(#
8($+ =(%$A&7+%B -#9 &3%7(0(7-221 8($+ $+% 8.($(#/& 7"22%7$%9 -& D'$ P*44 #"
E"=$)> =(%$A&7+%;& 7+-.-7$%.(&-$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 (& 7"632%VB 6F2$(0-7%$%9B -#9
.-#/%9 "'%. &%'%.-2 2%'%2&B .%0%..(#/ $" &%'%.-2 "#$"2"/(7-221 9(&$(#7$ "HR%7$&>
O($+"F$ 8-#$(#/ $" -$$.(HF$% $" =(%$A&7+% - $"$-2(&(#/ &1&$%6B ($ &%%6& $+-$
$+% 7"#&$%22-$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 9"%& (#9%%9 T#($ $"/%$+%. &%'%.-2 "0 $+% 6"&$
(63".$-#$ -V%& "0 =(%$A&7+%-# $+"F/+$> *" 3F$ ($ (# +(& "8# 8".9&B
=(%$A&7+% &%%& +(6&%20 -& 5- &3(.($ "0 9-.(#/ -#9 %V3%.(6%#$ r8+"s +-& -2.%-91
2"&$ r($&s 8-1 "#7% (# %'%.1 2-H1.(#$+ "0 $+% 0F$F.%; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B 3.%0-7%
l<a -#9 8+-$ +% 0(#9& $+%.% (& #(+(2(&6> *+% &F&$-(#%9 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ ".
9(-/#"&(& "0 #(+(2(&6 (& (# - &%#&% $+% 6"&$ &F77%&&0F2 -7$F-2(&-$("# "0 "#%
"0 =(%$A&7+%;& 9%0(#($("#& "0 $+% ."2% "0 $+% 3+(2"&"3+%.4 $+-$ (& -& - 3+1&(7(-#
%#/-/%9 (# $+% 9(-/#"&(& "0 $+% &(7T#%&&%& -002(7$(#/ $+% 8".29 (# 8+(7+ +%
0(#9& +(6&%20B 5$+% 3+(2"&"3+%. -& 7F2$F.-2 3+1&(7(-#;>? 5ZF$ ($ (& &(7TB $+(&
F#7+-(#%9 2(0%B -#9 #%%9& $" H% 7F.%9; `=(%$A&7+% )X?@B )<Ia> *+%
3+(2"&"3+%. -& 8%22 -& H%(#/ - 3+1&(7(-# 6F&$ H% - 5&""$+&-1%.SH(.9 &3(.($;
8+" 54"";% +9/; 8+%# .%2-$(#/ 8+-$ 8(22 7"6%; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B 3.%0-7% l@aB
-#9 8+-$ $+(& &""$+&-1%. &%%& (# $+(& 7-&% (& - 7F2$F.% 8+(7+ 5+-& H%%#
6"'(#/ -& $"8-.9 - 7-$-&$."3+%;B -#9 $+-$ 7-$-&$."3+% (& $+% 9.F$&# "2
&*'*4*%5> *+% 9%&7.(H%. "0 $+(& 7-$-&$."3+% (& H1 '(.$F% "0 $+(& '(&("# - I$)2$/#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
64*"# 74+$)# J
!*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
&*'*4*%#B $+-$ (& $" &-1 "#% 8+" +-& /"#% $+."F/+ $+% %V3%.(%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6B
$+% 7"#02-/.-$("# "0 $.-#&7%#9%#$ '-2F%&B -#9 +-& 2%0$ ($ H%+(#9B "F$&(9%
+(6&%20> =(+(2(&6 $+%# (& $+% 9(-/#"&(& "0 "F. (66%9(-$% 3-&$B -#9 "0 "F.
(66%9(-$% 3.%&%#$> Q& 0". O-2$%. Z%#R-6(#B &" 0". =(%$A&7+%B H"$+ $+% 3-&$
-#9 $+% 0F$F.% -.% 2($$%.%9 8($+ &(/#&B -#9 &3%-T 5%'%# #"8 (# - +F#9.%9
&(/#&; `=(%$A&7+% )XN? 3.%0-7% l<a> *+% 3-&$ (& - $.-#&6($$%. "0 ".-7F2-.
8(&9"6B -#9 ($ (& "#21 $+% &""$+&-1%. 8+" 6-1 .%-9 $+(& ".-72%m HF$ =(%$A&7+%-# &""$+&-1%.B 2(T% Z%#R-6(#;& -#9 P-F2 b2%%;& -#/%2 "0 +(&$".1B (&
k-#F& 0-7%9B +% (& ".(%#$-$%9 &(6F2$-#%"F&21 H"$+ $"8-.9& $+% 0F$F.% -#9 $+%
3-&$> Y$ (& "#21 $+% &""$+&-1%.B $+% 5-.7+($%7$ "0 $+% 0F$F.%; `=(%$A&7+% )X?@B
XDaB 8+" T#"8& $+% 3.%&%#$ -#9 8+" 6-1 .%-9 $+% ".-72%m ($ (& (63%.-$('%
$+-$ $+% &""$+&-1%. 54"";% +9/; 8+%# .%2-$(#/ 8+-$ 8(22 7"6%; `=(%$A&7+%
)XN?B 3.%0-7% l@aB $+% 3+(2"&"3+%. 6F&$ H% - 5$%2%3+"#% 0."6 $+% H%1"#9;
`=(%$A&7+% )XNXB YYY JaB -#9 $+% #%8& +% H.(#/& (& $+-$ "0 #(+(2(&6> W".
=(%$A&7+% $+% 7"6(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6B -#9 "F. %V3%.(%#7(#/ "0 ($ (& (#%'($-H2%B
F#-'"(9-H2% -#9 #%7%&&-.1m ($ (& &" (# ".9%. $+-$ =(%$A&7+%;& 6F7+ '-F#$%9
$.-#&'-2F-$("# "0 -22 '-2F%& 6-1 "77F.4 8% 56F&$ %V3%.(%#7% #(+(2(&6 H%0".%
8% 7-# 0(#9 "F$ 8+-$ '-2F% $+%&% 55'-2F%&;; .%-221 +-9 h 8% .%_F(.%B &"6%$(6%B
&$= F94,$%; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B 3.%0-7% lDa> [(-/#"&(& 7"#&(&$& "0 $+% %2%6%#$&
"0 %$("2"/1 -#9 3.%&7.(3$("#4 .%'%2-$("# "0 $+% 7-F&% "0 $+% &(7T#%&&B -#-$"6S
(&-$("# "0 $+% &163$"6& -#9 3.%&7.(3$("# "0 - 7F.-$('% &"2F$("#> Y$ (& 0".
3.%7(&%21 $+%&% .%-&"#& $+-$ [%2%FA% #"$%& $+-$ $+% 58+"2% "0 3+(2"&"3+1 (& &163$"6-$"2"/1B -#9 - &%6%("2"/1;B -#9 $+-$ 7"#&%_F%#$21 ($& "HR%7$ "0
&$F91B $+% 53+%#"6%#"# r > > > s (& #"$ -# -33%-.-#7% ". %'%# -# -33-.($("#
HF$ - &(/#B - &163$"6 8+(7+ 0(#9& ($& 6%-#(#/ (# -# %V(&$(#/ 0".7%; `[%2%FA%
)X?@B @a> =(%$A&7+% (& (66%#&%21 3.%7(&% 8($+ %-7+ %2%6%#$ "0 +(& 9(-/#"&(&
"0 #(+(2(&6B -#9 F#F&F-221 3%.+-3&B #" 2%&& &" (# +(& -77"F#$ "0 ($& %$("2"/1
$+-# (# $+% "$+%. $8" %2%6%#$&> *+% 3.%7(&% &"F.7% "0 #(+(2(&6 0". =(%$A&7+%
2(%& (# =(7+"2-& !"3%.#(7F&; "'%.$F.#(#/ "0 $+% P$"2%6-(7 /%"7%#$.(7 7"&6"S
2"/1B -#9 ($& .%32-7%6%#$ 8($+ $+%B (# 7%.$-(# &%#&%& &$(22 6".% -#7(%#$B
+%2("7%#$.(7 6"9%2> Q& (& -22 $"" 0-6(2(-.B $+% (66%9(-$% 7"#&%_F%#7% "0
$+(& (& $+-$ 5$+% 0-($+ (# $+% 9(/#($1 -#9 F#(_F%#%&& "0 6-#B (# +(& (..%32-7%S
-H(2($1 (# $+% /.%-$ 7+-(# "0 H%(#/; H%7-6% - 5$+(#/ "0 $+% 3-&$;> !"3%.#(7F&;
3."R%7$("# 32-7%9 6-# "# 5-# (#72(#%9 32-#%; &" $+-$ 5#"8 +% (& &2(33(#/
0-&$%. -#9 0-&$%. -8-1 0."6 $+% 7%#$.% (#$" h 8+-$i (#$" #"$+(#/#%&&i (#$" 55I$&$#)9#*&? &%#&% "0 +(& #"$+(#/#%&&;; ; `=(%$A&7+% )XNXB YYY <Ja>
Y$ 0"22"8& 0."6 $+(& $+-$ $+% !"3%.#(7-# .%'"2F$("# #%%9& $" H% 9(&32-7%9
0."6 ($& 3.(#7(3-2 3"&($("# (# $+% #-..-$('% "0 #(+(2(&6B 5$+(& 2"#/ 32%#($F9%
-#9 &%_F%#7% "0 H.%-T9"8#B 9%&$.F7$("#B .F(# -#9 7-$-721&6; `=(%$A&7+%
)XCDB l@D@a> Q& -2.%-91 #"$%9 b-#$ 3.(9%& +(6&%20 (# 7-..1(#/ "F$ - !"3%.S
#(7-# .%'"2F$("# (# $+"F/+$B +% H%2(%'%& +(& "8# -7+(%'%6%#$ $" H% &%(&6(7 %'%#$ (# $+% 3"&&(H(2($(%&B $.-R%7$".(%& -#9 3F.3"&%& "0 3+(2"&"3+1B
+% H%2(%'%& $+-$ +(& ()*#*V,$% .%3.%&%#$ - &+(0$ (# 3+(2"&"3+1 -& .-9(7-2 -& $+-$
g #(/&H%./ (& "0
.%3.%&%#$%9 H1 !"3%.#(7F& (# 7"&6"2"/1> *+% !+(#-6-# "0 b"
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
N
7"F.&% %#$($2%9 $" +(& "8# &%20S-&&%&&6%#$B $+% 3."H2%6 (& $+-$ ($ (& #"$ $"
!"3%.#(7F& $+-$ $+% .%'"2F$("# $+-$ H%-.& +(& #-6% "F/+$ $" H% -$$.(HF$%9B
-#9 $+-$ +%#7% $+% %'%#$ $+-$ b-#$ H%2(%'%& +(6&%20 $" H% -#-2"/"F& $" (& #"$
- .%'"2F$("# HF$ - 6%.% +"29(#/ 6-#"%F'.% "# $+% 3-.$ "0 - 0-2$%.(#/B
7.F6H2(#/ 9&/*$& )$M?*5$ "0 $+"F/+$>
Y# 2(/+$ "0 $+% -H"'%B $+% (&&F% "0 #(+(2(&6B 8+%# F#9%.&$""9 -& - 9(-/#"&(&
"0 L77(9%#$-2 7F2$F.% &(#7% ."F/+21 $+% 2-$%S#(#%$%%#$+S7%#$F.1 7.(&(& "0
0-($+B 6F&$ H% .%7-&$> !2-&&(7-221 ($ +-& H%%# F#9%.&$""9 $" H% 3.%7(3($-$%9
2-./%21 H1 '-.("F& 9%'%2"36%#$& (# $+% #-$F.-2 &7(%#7%&B 7.($(7-221 $+%
[-.8(#(-# .%6"'-2 "0 6-# 0."6 $+% $"3 "0 $+% 7+-(# "0 H%(#/B ". .-$+%.
$+% .%6"'-2 "0 $+-$ 57+-(#; -2$"/%$+%.B -#9 $+% 7"632%$% -H&".3$("# "0 $+%
.-6(0(7-$("#& "0 $+% 6F7+ %-.2(%. 5!"3%.#(7-#; .%'"2F$("#4 $+% -H"2($("# "0
$+% /%"7%#$.(&6 "0 $+% P$"2%6-(7 7"&6"&B - &(#/2% /-$+%.(#/ 8-'% 0."6 $+%
&(V$%%#$+ $" $+% 2-$% #(#%$%%#$+ 7%#$F.(%&> M"8%'%.B $+% -9'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6
7-# H% .%0-&+("#%9 -& - 7"#&$-#$21 .%7F..(#/ .%0.-(# (# $+% +(&$".1 "0
$+"F/+$> \#9%.&$""9 -& - 3%.&(&$%#$ &7%3$(7(&6B -#9 -& - .%&"2F$% .%R%7$("#
"0 -22 $.-#&7%#9%#$ '-2F%&B #(+(2(&6 (& -H&"2F$%21 (#$(6-$% 8($+ [%2%FA%;&
F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 3+(2"&"3+1;& ."2% -& - #-$F.-2(&6B -#9 -$ $+% &-6% $(6% 3-.$ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 9%6-#9 $+-$ 3+(2"&"3+1 H%7"6% H"$+ (66".-2 -#9
+(&$".(7-2> Q2$+"F/+ +(& 8".T +F.2& 7"F#$2%&& -77F&-$("#& -#9 7.($(_F%&
-/-(#&$ -22 3.(". 3+(2"&"3+1B ($ (& -./F-H2% $+-$ $+%.% -.% 0". =(%$A&7+% $8"
/%#%.-2 .%-&"#& -& $" 8+1 5%'%.1 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 -.7+($%7$ (# UF."3% +-& HF(2$
(# '-(#; `=(%$A&7+% )X?<B 3.%0-7% l@a> b-#$;& -#&8%. $+-$ $+% .%-&"# 0". $+(& (&
$+% -H&%#7% "0 - 7.($(_F% "0 .%-&"# (& -9RF9/%9 2F9(7."F&> *+% 0(.&$ .%-&"#B 0".
=(%$A&7+%B (& $+% %$%.#-2 &%9F7$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7& H1 6".-2($1B -#9 $+%
7"#7"6($-#$ 3.%"77F3-$("# 8($+ $.F$+B -/-(#&$ 8+(7+ +% 5&F77%%9%9 (#
6-T(#/ F& F#9%.&$-#9B $+"F/+$ (& 7.%-$("#B #"$ 8(22 $" $.F$+; `[%2%FA% -#9
^F-$$-.( )XX)B JJm )XXDB JDa> *+% 9%6-#9 0". '*%#")*/94 I'*4"%"I'*%*&? (&
=(%$A&7+%;& .%&3"#&% $" $+% &%7"#9 "0 $+% /%#%.-2(&%9 0".6& "0 $+% 0-(2F.% "0
-22 +($+%.$" %V(&$(#/ 6%$-3+1&(7-2 3+(2"&"3+1B $+-$ (&B $+-$ $+%1 &$-.$ "F$
50."6 6-# -& +% (& #"8 -#9 $+(#Tr(#/s $+%(. /"-2 $+."F/+ -# -#-21&(& "0 +(6>
*+%1 (#'"2F#$-.(21 $+(#T "0 556-#;; -& -# 9$#$)&9 F$)*#9% r > > > s $+%1 8(22 #"$
2%-.# $+-$ 6-# +-& H%7"6%B $+-$ $+% 0-7F2$1 "0 7"/#($("# +-& H%7"6%;
`=(%$A&7+% )X?NB l<a> *+(& (& 72%-.21 - 7+-./% $+-$ 7-# H% 2-(9 -/-(#&$ b-#$
8+" -7$& -& (0 &7(%#7% (& -#9 -28-1& 8(22 H% =%8$"#(-# &7(%#7% -#9 5$+%.%H1
H.-#9%9 -& (63"&&(H2% -#1 "33"&($("# $" 72-&&(7-2 &7(%#7% $+-$ 8-& #"$ -#
"33"&($("# $" &7(%#7% ($&%20; `P.(/"/(#% -#9 ,$%#/%.& )X?DB ?Na> b-#$ (& _F($%
%V32(7($ -H"F$ $+(&B -#9 ($ (& 72%-. $+-$ +(& 6"$('-$("# 0". &F7+ - 3"&($("#B -#9
0". 6F7+ %2&% (# +(& &1&$%6B (& 9%.('%9 0."6 $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 .%&(&$(#/ $+%
(632(7-$("#& "0 - 3+(2"&"3+1 "0 #-$F.% $+-$ +-& 7"#&(&$%#$21 9%$+."#%9 $+%
&"'%.%(/#$1 "0 6-#B ,3(#"A-;& (#$%#$("# $" $.%-$ 6-# -& (0 +% 8%.%
9%-2(#/ 8($+ 52(#%&B 32-#%& -#9 H"9(%&; `,3(#"A- )X?XB U YYY 3.%0-7%a 0".
%V-632%>X M%.% (& b-#$;& 6"&$ 0".$+.(/+$ &$-$%6%#$ "0 $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 2(6($S
(#/ &7(%#7%4
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
64*"# 74+$)# C
?
!*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
W". =(%$A&7+% $+% %'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 2%-'%& $+% 8-1 "3%# 0". - /'$5*%#)C "2
/"&/$I#% 9&. %$&%9#*"&%B 8+(7+ (# 7"#$.-9(&$(#7$("# $" $+% 0."A%# "#$"2"/(7-2
-#9 %3(&$%6"2"/(7-2 %$%.#-2 '%.($(%& "0 6%$-3+1&(7& 8(22 .%7"/#(&% $+-$4
%'%.1$+(#/ +-& H%7"6%4 $+%.% -.% #" $#$)&94 29/#%B RF&$ -& $+%.% -.% #"
-H&"2F$% $.F$+&> !"#&%_F%#$21 8+-$ (& #%%9%9 0."6 #"8 "# (& '*%#")*/94
I'*4"%"I'*%*&?>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?NB l<a
*+% 9-8# "0 #(+(2(&6B $+%#B 7"#&$.F%9 -& - $+(#T(#/ "0 5%V(&$%#7% -& ($ (&B
8($+"F$ 6%-#(#/ ". -(6B 1%$ "77F..(#/ (#%'($-H21 8($+"F$ -#1 0(#-2% "0
#"$+(#/#%&&; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B lJJaB (& - 3-.$ "0 $+-$ '(.F2%#$ 6-$%.(-2(&6
$+-$ .F#& $+."F/+ L77(9%#$-2 7('(2(&-$("# (# 3%.3%$F-2B -H&"2F$% "33"&($("#B
9%&$."1(#/ (9"2&B 3."#"F#7(#/ $+% %#9 "0 (9%-2&B .%#"F#7(#/ &$-$%&B
&6-&+(#/ &F3%.&$($("#&B %#/-/(#/ (# -# (#9%0-$(/-H2% 53.-7$(7-2 7.($(_F% "0
-22 61&$(0(7-$("#&; `[%2%FA% )XNXB @C?m )X?IB <CXaB 0."6 ,%V$F& U63(.(7F& $"
KF7.%$(F&B Z.F#" $" ,3(#"A-B E-.V $" =(%$A&7+%>
Y# $+(& 8-1B b-#$;& &%20S3."72-(6%9 .%'"2F$("# 7-# H% (6-/(#%9 -& -#
-$$%63$ $" 7-#7%2 $(6%m -#9 $+% 7.($(_F%& 7-# H% %#'(&-/%9 -& - 6-&&('%
9-6 HF(2$ $" +"29 H-7T $+% +"..".& "0 - 8".29 8($+"F$ 6%-#(#/B - 8".29
$".# 0."6 ($& +(#/%& `$+% 6"&$ 3."0"F#9 (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 M-62%$;& $(6% 5"F$
"0 R"(#$;a> b-#$ +(6&%20 (& -9-6-#$ $+-$ $+% 57"#7%3$ "0 #"F6%#"# (& $+F& 6%.%21 4*5*#*&? /"&/$I# r > > > s -#9 ($ (& $+%.%0".% "#21 "0 #%/-$('% %632"16%#$;
`b-#$ )X<XB Q <JJ]Z @))a ". %'%# 6".% 9%$%.6(#%921 5($ (& #"$ (#9%%9 (# -#1
8-1 3"&($('%; `b-#$ )X<XB Q <J<a> *+% b-#$(-#(&6 &1&$%6B $+%#B (& - &%-S8-22
HF(2$ $" %#&F.% $+-$ 5$+% '"1-/% "0 "F. .%-&"# 6-1 H% %V$%#9%9 #" 0F.$+%.
$+-# $+% 7"#$(#F"F& 7"-&$2(#% "0 %V3%.(%#7% ($&%20 r > > > s - 7"-&$ 8% 7-##"$
2%-'% 8($+"F$ '%#$F.(#/ F3"# - &+".%2%&& "7%-# 8+(7+ r > > > s 7"63%2& F& (#
$+% %#9 $" -H-#9"# -& +"3%2%&& -22 $+(& '%V-$("F& -#9 $%9("F& %#9%-'"F.;
`b-#$ )X<XB Q @XJa> Y# "$+%. 8".9& $" -77%3$ $+% 9%7%#$.(#/ "0 6-# -#9 $+%
#%7%&&($1 "0 - $.-#&'-2F-$("# "0 -22 '-2F%& (632(%9 H1 - Z.F#(-# !"&6"2"/1
8"F29B 0". b-#$B F#2%-&+ "#7% -/-(# $+% 7".."&('% &3%7F2-$("#& "0 $+"&%
5%/$I#*/% r$+-$s &3%7(%& "0 #"6-9&; 8+" 59%&3(&(#/ -22 &%$$2%9 6"9%& "0 2(0%B
H."T% F3 0."6 $(6% $" $(6% -22 7('(2 &"7(%$1; `b-#$ )X<XB Q (Va> Q#9 $+-$B
#%%92%&& $" -99B 8-& #"$ -# "3$("# $+-$ b-#$ 8"F29 7"F#$%#-#7%> !"3%.#(S
7-#(&6 8-& -2.%-91 7"#7%3$F-221 9(&7.%9($%9B -2$+"F/+ -& (& %'(9%#7%9 H1
b-#$;& 72-(6 $" ($& 6-#$2%B #"$ 3"2($(7-221 -#9 7F2$F.-221 .%9F#9-#$> Y$&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Y$ (&B Y 6%-#B _F($% 7%.$-(# $+-$ 8% 7-# #%'%. /%$ - &F00(7(%#$ T#"82%9/% "0
"./-#(&%9 H%(#/& -#9 $+%(. (##%. 3"&&(H(2($1 r > > > s H1 2""T(#/ 6%.%21 $"
6%7+-#(7-2 3.(#7(32%& "0 #-$F.% r > > > s ($ (& -H&F.9 0". 6%# $" %'%# %#$%.S
$-(# -#1 $+"F/+$ "0 &" 9"(#/ ". $" +"3% $+-$ 6-1H% -#"$+%. =%8$"# 6-1
&"6% 9-1 -.(&%B $" 6-T% (#$%22(/(H2% $" F& %'%# $+% /%#%&(& "0 - H2-9% "0
/.-&& 0."6 #-$F.-2 2-8& $+-$ #" 9%&(/# +-& ".9%.%9> ,F7+ (#&(/+$ 8% 6F&$
-H&"2F$%21 9%#1 $" 6-#T(#9>
`b-#$ )XJ<B lCJa
"#$"2"/(7-2 0"F#9-$("#& 8%.% &+-$$%.%9B ($& %63(.(7-2 &F33"&($("#& &F3%.S
&%9%9 H1 $+% &7"3% "0 Z.F#";& %3"7+ 2%-3(#/ (6-/(#-$("#B %'%# H%0".% ($&
/%#%.-2 -77%3$-#7%> *+% f-$(7-# +-9 (# 0-7$ 9%'%2"3%9 - 0-. 6".% 3%.7%3$('%
-&&%&&6%#$ "0 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2B "#$"2"/(7-2 -#9 3"2($(7-2 &$-T%& (#'"2'%9 (#
$+% !"3%.#(7-# 5+13"$+%&(&; $+-# b-#$ %'%. 9(9>)I *+% f-$(7-#;& 7%#&".&+(3
H"91B $+% Y#9%V !"#/.%/-$("#B 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 $+% !"3%.#(7-# %#$%.3.(&% 5-&
&(6321 - ."/#)*&9 EC#'9?")*/9N `K-#/% )?CXB Y <@<aB -#9 -& - 7"#&%_F%#7%
9(9#;$ 0(#9 ($ #%7%&&-.1 $" 32-7% $+% <""; "2 #'$ 1$F"4,#*"&% "2 #'$ >$9F$&4C
AI'$)$% "# $+% Y#9%V "0 3."&7.(H%9 H""T& F#$(2 &%'%#$1 $+.%% 1%-.& -0$%. ($&
)JD@ 3FH2(7-$("#B -#9 &(V$%%# 1%-.& -0$%. Z.F#";& 6F.9%.> Y#9%%9 -& b"%&$2%.
&+"8& $+%.% (& 5%'(9%#7% "0 %-.21 H%#%'"2%#$ (#$%.%&$ (# $+% !"3%.#(7-#
$+%".1 r > > > s H1 $+% f-$(7-#; `b"%&$2%. )XJXB )JJa> *+% !-$+"2(7 +(%.-.7+1B
$+%#B 8-& 0F221 7"/#(&-#$ "0 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ $+% $+.%-$ 3"&%9 H1 $+% !"3%.#(S
7-#(&6 "0 ($& -F$+". 8-& 6(#(6-2 h $+% "29 !-#"# !"3%.#(/T &$-1%9 (# +(&
(&"2-$%9 $"8%. -#9 $."FH2%9 #"S"#%B F#2(T% $+% &%%6(#/21 0%-.2%&& ="2-#
9.('%# H1 -# $)"*/" 2,)")$B 8+(7+ +-9 H"$+ Q3"22(#%-# -#9 [("#1&(-# 9(6%#S
&("#& 5$+% 0".6%. H%7-F&% ($ 8-& - 3-&&("# 0". $.F$+ -#9 T#"82%9/%B $+% 2-$$%.
H%7-F&% ($ 2%9 $" 9%-$+ -#9 .%&F..%7$("#; `E%#9"A- )XXJB VV('a)) +-.H"F.%9
#" .%$(7%#7% -H"F$ 3."6F2/-$(#/ +(& 9(&9-(# 0". $+% %&$-H2(&+%9 ".9%.> *+%
7-#"#B "# $+% 7"#$.-.1 8-& #%'%. 3%.&%7F$%9m +% 8-& (# 0-7$ 0%d$%9B %'%#
%#7"F.-/%9B H1 %2%6%#$& .%-7+(#/ -& +(/+ F3 $+% f-$(7-# +(%.-.7+1 -& $+%
3"3% +(6&%20B -#9 $" .%7(3."7-$% 0". $+(& 3-$."#-/%B ($ (& $+% 3"3%;& #-6% $+-$
(& 0"F#9 "# $+% 9%9(7-$("#& 3-/% "0 $+% <""; "2 1$F"4,#*"&%> =" &F7+ 7"22F&("#
"77F.& 8($+ Z.F#"B 8+"&% 3F.3"&% (& %V32(7($21 .%'"2F$("#-.1 -#9 9(.%7$%9 $"
$+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 9"/6-$(7-221 (63"&%9 (9%-& -#9 '-2F%&> ," (0 b-#$ 7-#
(/#".% Z.F#"B (0 +% 7-# 8.($% -& (0 Z.F#" +-9 #%'%. +-33%#%9B -#9 (0 +% 7-#
3.%$%#9 $+-$ $+% .%'"2F$("# .%-221 9"%& +-33%# 8($+ !"3%.#(7F& +% 7-# T%%3
$+% "29 ".9%. (#$-7$> Q& =(%$A&7+% 3"(#$& "F$4
&(#7% b-#$B $.-#&7%#9%#$-2(&$& "0 %'%.1 T(#9 +-'% "#7% 6".% 8"# $+% 9-1
h $+%1 +-'% H%%# %6-#7(3-$%9 0."6 $+% $+%"2"/(-#&4 8+-$ R"1j h b-#$
&+"8%9 $+%6 - &%7.%$ 3-$+ H1 8+(7+ $+%1 6-1B "# $+%(. "8# (#($(-$('%
-#9 8($+ -22 &7(%#$(0(7 .%&3%7$-H(2($1B 0."6 #"8 "# 0"22"8 $+%(. 5+%-.$;&
9%&(.%;>
`=(%$A&7+% )XNXB YYY l<Ja
*+-$ (&B $+%1 7-# &F&$-(# $+% %V(&$%#7% "0 $+% $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 8($+"F$ +-'(#/
$" .%&".$ $" $+% $+%"2"/(7-24 /-.H $+%6&%2'%& 8($+ $+% 72"-T "0 .%'"2F$("# -#9
&(6F2$-#%"F&21 .%7"#&$($F$% - 9(00%.%#$ 5.%/F2-$('% 0(7$("#;B - #%8 0".6 "0
53"2(7% &F3%.'(&("#; `=(%$A&7+% )XCDB l@DDa> Y# =(%$A&7+%;& RF9/%6%#$B $+%#B
b-#$ (& &FHR%7$ $" $+% .%HFT% $+-$ +% +-9 +(6&%20 9(.%7$%9 -$ $+"&% +% 9FHH%9
53.%$%#9%9 *&.*22$)$&#*%#%;B $+-$ $+%1 50%22 H-7T r > > > s (#$" $+"&% '%.1 6%$-3+1S
&(7-2 -&&%.$("#& 8+(7+ $+%1 3."0%&& &" /.%-$21 $" 9%&3(&%; `b-#$ )X<XB QVa> Q&
+-& -2.%-91 H%%# (#9(7-$%9B =(%$A&7+%;& 9(-/#"&(& "0 #(+(2(&6 (& $.(3-.$($%B $+%
$+(.9 3-.$ H%(#/ 3.%&7.(3$('%4 0". -0$%. $+% .%'-2F-$("# "0 -22 '-2F%& 7"6%& $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
64*"# 74+$)# X
0".6-$("# "0 #%8 "#%&> *+% 3."/.-66% "0 $+% I$)2$/# &*'*4*%# (& (#&7.(H%9B
=(%$A&7+% .%6(#9& F&B "# $+% $($2% 3-/% "0 +(& 5/"&3%2 "0 $+% 0F$F.%; -#9 ($ (&
D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)0 7##$5I# 9# 9 1$F94,9#*"& "2 744 X94,$% `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B
3.%0-7% lDaB =(%$A&7+% 2('%& $+."F/+B (#9%%9 %&7-2-$%& `5o"F -(#;$ &%%# #"$+(#;
1%$;aB $+% #%7%&&-.1 %'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6B -#9 9.-/& &"6%$+(#/ &+(#(#/ -#9 #%8
0."6 $+% 7-$-&$."3+(7 8.%7T-/%B $+% 3&17+(7 9%$.($F& "0 +-'(#/ H%%# !+.(&S
$(-# 0". $8" $+"F&-#9 1%-.&> \#2(T% b-#$B =(%$A&7+% F#9%.&$-#9& $+-$ $+%
9(&-.6%9 9%3$+ 7+-./% 9."33%9 H1 !"3%.#(7F& +-9 H%%# &F..%3$($("F&21
.%$.(%'%9B .%8(.%9 -#9 /('%# - 9%32%$%9 F.-#(F6 8-.+%-9 "0 (66%#&%
9%&$.F7$('% 3"8%. H1 Z.F#"> b-#$ .%$-(#&B 72-8& H-7TB $+% 7%#$.% $+-$
Z.F#" +-9 -H"2(&+%9> Y# 7"#&$.F7$(#/ $+% &$-#93"(#$ "0 $+% $.-#&7%#9%#$-2B
b-#$ .%0".6F2-$%& $+% G%#-(&&-#7% MF6-#(&$ '(&("# "0 +F6-# 9(/#($1B $"
0"22"8 =(%$A&7+%B $+% b-#$(-# &F33"&($("# "0 $+% &7(%#$(0(7 +F6-# &FHR%7$
9%7(3+%.(#/ #-$F.-2 2-8B $+% &FHR%7$ "0 $+% 7.($(7-2 %3(&$%6"2"/1 58-& (66%S
9(-$%21 %632"1%9 H1 6-# 0". +(& "8# &%20S/2".(0(7-$("#; `=(%$A&7+% )XXIHB
l)INa> *+% b-#$(-# 7.($(7-2 %#$%.3.(&% T%%3& 6-# (# $+.-22 "0 $+% 3-$+"2"/(7-2
9%&(.% 0". 7%#$.(#/ $+-$ &$(22 ".9%.& $+% +%-2$+1 +F6-# 3&17+%B $+% 57"6(#/
"0 ,3(.($ -33.%+%#9(#/ ($&%20; `P.(/"/(#% -#9 ,$%#/%.& )X?DB ?Xa (# M%/%2(-#
2-#/F-/%B $+% 3&17+"-#-21$(7 &FHR%7$ "# $+% W.%F9(-# 7"F7+> *+(& 9.('% 0".
$+%.% #" +$ - 7%#$.% (& - '%.($-H2%B 3%.&(&$%#$B 3%.#(7("F& 3-$+"2"/1> O($#%&&B
0". %V-632%B $+% +(&$".1 "0 2-#/F-/%& "0 $+% &%20 3.%9(7-$%9 -& $+%1 -.% F3"#
$+% %_F-$("# "0 +%-2$+ 8($+ 7%#$.%9#%&&B H-2-#7%B &166%$.1 `$+-$ (&B 7"#S
'%#$("#-2 (9%-& "0 H%-F$1 -#9 7F..%#$ &3F.("F& -$$%63$& $" 7-27F2-$% $+%
3+1&(7-2 -'%.-/% "0 $+% 3%.0%7$ 0-7% H-&%9 F3"# $+% 9%'(-#7% "0 $+%
3."3".$("#& "0 0-7(-2 0%-$F.%& 0."6 - &$-$(&$(7-2 #".6a> *+(& 3-$+"2"/1 (&
7-F$%.(&%9 -$ &"F.7% H1 Z.F#" -#9 +(& .%2%#$2%&& 3F.&F($ "0 $+% 5F#('%.&%
$+-$ +-& 2"&$ -22 /$&#)$ -& 8%22 -& -#1 0(/F.% $+-$ 7"F29 H% -$$.(HF$%9 $" ($;
`[%2%FA% )XX@B )<Da> Y# 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 +(&$".1 $+%.% -.% $8" $13%& "0 +%.6($
". .%72F&%4 0(.&$ (& $+% '"2F#$-.1 2(T% b-#$B -#9 &%7"#9 $+"&% 7"#9%6#%9 $"
%V(2%B $+% +%.%$(7-2B $+% "F$7-&$> !"#$.-.1 $" +(& "8# H%2(%0 $+-$ +% (& 5&"2($-.1 H1 (#&$(#7$ 8+" +-& 0"F#9 +(& -9'-#$-/% (# &$-#9(#/ -&(9% -#9
"F$&(9%; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B 3.%0-7% l@a ($ (& $" $+% 2-$$%. $13% $+-$ =(%$A&7+%
$.F21 H%2"#/&4
*+%&% "F$7-&$& "0 &"7(%$1B 2"#/ 3%.&%7F$%9 -#9 &".%21 +F#$%9 h -2&" $+%
%#0".7%9 .%72F&%&B $+% ,3(#"A-& -#9 ^(".9-#" Z.F#"& h (# $+% %#9 -28-1&
H%7"6% .%0(#%9 '%#/%-#7%S&%%T%.& -#9 H.%8%.& "0 3"(&"#>
`=(%$A&7+% )XXI-B l<Ja
EE
Q& +-& .%3%-$%921 H%%# (#$(6-$%9B ($ 8(22 #"$ H% %#"F/+ 0". =(%$A&7+% $"
&(6321 .%7"/#(&% $+% #%7%&&($1B $+% .%3%$($("#B -#9 $+% %'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6B "#%
6F&$ /" H%1"#9 ($B -#9 $-T% ($& (632(7-$("#& "# H"-.9 (# $+% $-&T "0 7.%-$(#/
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
&$= F94,$%> 519.*/94 &*'*4*%5N (& $+% 7"#'(7$("# "0 -# -H&"2F$% F#$%#-H(2($1 "0
%V(&$%#7% 8+%# ($ 7"6%& $" $+% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& "#% .%7"/#(&%&m 32F& $+%
.%-2(&-$("# $+-$ 8% 2-7T $+% 2%-&$ .(/+$ $" 3"&($ - H%1"#9 ". -# (#S($&%20 "0
$+(#/& $+-$ 6(/+$ H% 59('(#%; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l@a> *+% H-&(& 0". $+(& .%'-2F-S
$("#B 0". $+(& 2('(#/ $+."F/+B 2(%& (# - 9(AA1(#/ 3%.&3%7$('(&6 -#9 - 9%0(-#$
7+%%.0F2#%&& $+-$ %#-H2%& "#% $" -33."-7+ $+% 5/2""6 8($+"F$ -#1 .%-2 &%#&%
"0 (#'"2'%6%#$ -#9 -H"'% -22 8($+"F$ -#1 8"..1 -#9 0%-. 2") ",)%$4F$%N
`=(%$A&7+% )XCDB l@D@a> G%2-$%9 $" $+(&B -#9 3.%&F6-H21 8($+ $+% RF&$ _F"$%9
3-&&-/% 0."6 D'$ O9C A/*$&/$ (# 6(#9B [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( 6-T% - '%.1
&(632% 1%$ -&$"F#9(#/ 7"66%#$ -H"F$ 8+-$ (& 7"66"#21 +%29 $" H% $+%
-.7+%$13-2B $+% 3(##-72% %'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6B $+%1 8.($% $+-$ 50". 3+(2"&"3+%.&
#%($+%. -$+%(&6 #". $+% 9%-$+ "0 ^"9 -.% 3."H2%6& r > > > s> *+-$ 3+(2"&"3+%.&
&$(22 $-T% $+% 9%-$+ "0 /"9 $" H% - $.-/%91 (& -&$"#(&+(#/> Q$+%(&6 (&#;$ 9.-6-B HF$ $+% 3+(2"&"3+%.;& &%.%#($1 -#9 3+(2"&"3+1;& -7+(%'%6%#$;
`[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( )XX)B ?Xm )XXDB X< 5C #)9&%49#*"&a> ="8 $+(& (9%%2(6(#-$%& 8+"2% 7F..%#$& "0 $+"F/+$ 3-&$ -#9 3.%&%#$ (# H"$+ -#-21$(7 -#9
7"#$(#%#$-2 3+(2"&"3+1B HF.9%#%9 -& $+%1 +-'% H%%# H1 $+% 8%(/+$ "0 $+%
3-&$B H1 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% "# "77-&("# 7-22& 5$+% &+-9"8 "0 ^"9;> *+(& $.F21
3+(2"&"3+(7-2 -$$($F9%B 9%&7.(H%9 H1 [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( (& 3.%7(&%21 8+-$
=(%$A&7+% 6%-#& H1 7+%%.0F2#%&&B -#9 ,3(#"A- H1 R"1> *+(& 7+%%.0F2#%&& (&
$+% "#21 8-1 $" 7"#0."#$ $+% 56"#&$."F& 2"/(7 "0 $%..".; `=(%$A&7+% )XCDB
l@D@a %#$-(2%9 H1 $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 $.-#&7%#9%#$ '-2F%&B -#9 "0 $+% 7"#S
&%_F%#7%& "0 5$+% 9%-$+ "0 /"9;m =(%$A&7+% &-1&4
*+%1 -.% #"$ -$ -22 &-9 -#9 /2""61 HF$ .-$+%. 2(T% - #%8 -#9 &7-.7%21
9%&7.(H-H2% T(#9 "0 2(/+$ r > > > s O% 3+(2"&"3+%.& -#9 50.%% &3(.($&; 0%%2B 8+%#
8% +%-. $+% #%8& $+-$ $+% 5"29 /"9 (& 9%-9;B -& (0 - #%8 9-8# &+"#% F3"#
F&m "F. +%-.$ "'%.02"8& 8($+ /.-$($F9%B -6-A%6%#$B 3.%6"#($("#&B
%V3%7$-$("#> Q$ 2"#/ 2-&$ $+% +".(A"# -33%-.& 0.%% $" F& -/-(#B %'%# (0 ($
&+"F29 #"$ H% H.(/+$m -$ 2"#/ 2-&$ $+% +".(A"# -33%-.& 0.%% $" F& -/-(#B
%'%# (0 ($ &+"F29 #"$ H% .(/+$B -$ 2"#/ 2-&$ "F. &+(3& 6-1 '%#$F.% "F$ -/-(#>
`=(%$A&7+% )XCDB l@D@a
Q& 8% +-'% &%%#B $+% 6"&$ &$.(T(#/ .%&F2$ "0 Z.F#";& .-9(7-2(&-$("# "0
!"3%.#(7F& (& $+% .%&$.(7$("# "0 $+% !-#"#;& 8".T $" - 6%.% 7"&6(7
&8-33(#/ "0 32-7%&> *+% ="2-# "# $+% 7"#$.-.1 %2(6(#-$%& $+% %#$(.% 6%9(%S
'-2 6-7+(#%.1B 8($+ ($& -.6(22-.1 &3+%.%&B ($& 0(V%9 0(.6-6%#$B +(%.-.7+(%&
-#9 7%#$.%& -#9 .%32-7%& ($ 8($+ -# (#0(#($%B -7%#$.(7B $"3"2"/(7-2 &6""$+
&3-7%>
o"F 8(22 #" 2"#/%. &-1 $+-$ $+%.% (& -# %9/% ". 2(6($ %($+%. $" $+% %V$%#$ ".
6"$("# "0 $+% F#('%.&%m 1"F 8(22 %&$%%6 $+% H%2(%0 (# - I)*5,5 5"+*4$B -#
F33%.6"&$ -#9 -22 7"#$-(#(#/ +%-'%#B $" H% - '-(# 0-#$-&1>
`Z.F#" )XJIB @N)a
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
64*"# 74+$)# ))
Y$ (& 8($+ $+(& (#'%7$('% $+-$ Z.F#" -96"#(&+%& $+"&% 8+" &$(22 +-#/ "#$" 6%9(%'-2 ". %'%# - !"3%.#(7-# 7"&6"&B -#9 +% 6(/+$ +-'% -99%9 8($+
=(%$A&7+% -#9 Q96(.-2 *F.%##%B 5o"F $.%6H2%B 7-.7-&&i o"F 8"F29 $.%6H2%
- 2"$ 6".% (0 1"F T#%8 8+%.% Y 8-& $-T(#/ 1"F; `=(%$A&7+% )XCDB <CCa>)< Y$ (&
$+(& -H"2($("# "0 $+% 7"&6"2"/(7-2 I)*5,5 5"+*4$B $+-$ +-9 2%-9 Z.F#" $" $+%
.%_F(&($% 3%.&3%7$('-2 -#9 +(&$".(7-2 -33."-7+ $" %3(&$%6"2"/1 $+-$
=(%$A&7+% 3.%&7.(H%&> *8" "3$("#& 0". T#"82%9/% -.% 3"&%9 (# $+% -0$%.6-$+
"0 $+% %'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6> W". =(%$A&7+% H"$+ 6F&$ H% -'"(9%9 8($+ %_F-2
'%+%6%#7%m "# $+% "#% +-#9B $+%.% (& $+% &$(02(#/ -$6"&3+%.% h "#% $+-$ +-9
6-9% b2%(&$ &" &F(7(9-2 h "0 b-#$(-#(&6;& 5/#-8(#/ -#9 9(&(#$%/.-$(#/ &7%3$(S
7(&6 -#9 .%2-$('(&6; `=(%$A&7+% )X?@B )DIaB -# -$6"&3+%.% "0 &7%3$(7(&6 (#
8+(7+ 5#" "#% 7-# 2('%; `=(%$A&7+% )XXIHB l?DaB -#9 "# $+% "$+%.B $+%
3-$+"2"/(7-2 5+$4*$2 *& #),#' r8+(7+s 6-T%& ($& -33%-.-#7% -& - &"7(-2 #%7%&&($1
r-#9s +-& - 5")94 ".(/(#; `=(%$A&7+% )XXIHB lX)a> =(%$A&7+%;& .%&3"#&% $" H"$+
"0 $+%&% 9(.% "3$("#& 52(%& #"$ (# ;&"=*&?B HF$ (# /)$9#*&?; `=(%$A&7+% )XXIHB
l?Da> L#% "0 $+% 72%-.%&$ &$-$%6%#$& -& $" 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% 6%-#& H1 $+(& (& -&
0"22"8&4
W". $+% 32-#$ $+% 8".29 (& $+F& -#9 &F7+m 0". F& $+% 8".29 (& $+F& -#9 &F7+>
Y0 8% 7"63-.% $+% $8" 3%.7%3$F-2 3"8%.& 8% 7"#&(9%. "F. '(%8 "0 $+%
8".29 $" H% $+% 6".% 7"..%7$ "#%B (>%> $+% "#% $+-$ 7"..%&3"#9& 6".%
72"&%21 $" $+% $.F$+ r > > > s *+% #-$F.-2 3."7%&& (& 7-..(%9 "# H1 &7(%#7%>
*+F& $+% $+(#/& 6(..". $+%6&%2'%& %'%. 6".% 72%-.21B /.-9F-221 2(H%.-$(#/
$+%6&%2'%& 0."6 8+-$ (& -22 $"" -#$+."3"6".3+(7> W". $+% 32-#$B $+%
8+"2% 8".29 (& - 32-#$m 0". F&B ($ (& +F6-#>
`=(%$A&7+% )XXIHB l)I<a
Y$ (& - 7"#&$-#$ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 7.($(_F% "0 b-#$ $+-$ $+% 2-$$%. .%6-(#& -+(&$".S
(7-2B $+-$ +(& 3+(2"&"3+1 (& 5%#$(.%21 "F$&(9% $+% +(&$".(7-2 6"'%6%#$m 8($+S
"F$ -#1 %1% 0". $+% -7$F-2($1 "0 +(& $(6% r > > > s 8-1 "00 8+%# ($ 7"6%& $" /.%-$
+(&$".(7-2 '-2F%&; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B lXJB )I)a> [(.%7$21 $(%9 $" $+(& (& b-#$;&
.%(#'%#$("# "0 $+% &"'%.%(/# +F6-# &FHR%7$B +(& .%(#&7.(3$("# (# $+% 7%#$.%
"0 $+% T#"8-H2% 7"&6"& $+"F/+ $+% (#'%#$("# "0 $+% 7-$%/".(%& "0 .%-&"#B
$+% b-#$(-# H-&(& "0 $+% -#$+."3"7%#$.(7 32-$($F9%B 59& *% #'$ 5$9%,)$ "2 944
#'*&?% h $+% 5'CI$)+"4*/ &9*F$M#$M "0 6-#; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)<aB $+% _F(#$%&S
&%#7% "0 +F6-#(&6 -/-(#&$ 8+(7+ Z.F#" +-9 &" 9(2(/%#$21 0"F/+$B -#9
-/-(#&$ 8+(7+ +% 3"&%9 8($+ =(%$A&7+%B 6-#;& 5&6-22#%&& -#9 -77(9%#$-2
"77F..%#7% (# $+% 02FV "0 H%7"6(#/ -#9 3-&&(#/ -8-1; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B lDa>
,(#7% $+% .%&F2$ "0 #(+(2(&6 (& $+% .%7"/#($("# "0 $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 6-#;&
3.('(2%/%9 3"&($("# 8($+(# $+% -7%#$.(7B '-2F%2%&&B #"#S+(%.-.7+(7-2 %#$-#/2%S
6%#$ $+-$ (& $+% 8".29 `-#9 $+-$ =(%$A&7+% 8-.#& -/-(#&$ -#9 -7$('%21 &%%T&
$" 7(.7F6'%#$a $+% 3"&&(H(2($1 (& $+-$ +(& -#-21&(&B +(& 9(-/#"&(& "0 #(+(2(&6B
8(22 H% $-T%# 0". - 6%.%21 #%/-$('% 32-$($F9%> Y#9%%9B +% 8.($%& $+-$ 5#(+(2(&6
(& #"$ RF&$ - 7"22%7$("# "0 &3%7F2-$("#& -."F#9 $+% $+%6% 55-22 (& (# '-(#j;;4 ($ (&
#"$ RF&$ $+% $+"F/+$ $+-$ %'%.1$+(#/ 9%&%.'%& $" H% 9%&$."1%94 $+% #(+(2(&$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
64*"# 74+$)# )@
+%23& $" 9%&$."1; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)I<m )XXJ l<D 5C #)9&%49#*"&aB -#9 +-'(#/
9%&$."1%9B .%HF(29&>)@
) Y# 5*+%&(& :fY "0 $+% 5*+%&(& "# $+% P+(2"&"3+1 "0 M(&$".1;B O-2$%. Z%#R-6(# 8.($%&
$+-$ ($ (& $+% $-&T "0 $+% +(&$".(7-2 6-$%.(-2(&$ 7.($(7 $" H% 5(# 7"#$."2 "0 +(& 3"8%.&B
6-# %#"F/+ $" H2-&$ "3%# $+% 7"#$(#FF6 "0 +(&$".1;> Q#"$+%. $+%&(& %2-H".-$%& "#
$+(& $+%6%B %63+-&(&(#/ $+-$ +(&$".(7-2 6-$%.(-2(&6 (& #"$ - 3-&&('% %63(.(7(&6B HF$
- 7"#&$.F7$('(&6B 5H-&%9 "# - 7"#&$.F7$('% 3.(#7(32%;> Y$ &%%T& $" 5H2-&$ - &3%7(0(7 %."F$ "0 $+% +"6"/%#%"F& 7"F.&% "0 +(&$".1 r > > > s - &3%7(0(7 2(0% "F$ "0 $+% %.- ". &3%7(0(7 8".T "F$ "0 $+% 2(0%8".T;> Q/-(#B 5$+% -8-.%#%&& $+-$ $+%1 -.% -H"F$ $" 6-T%
$+% 7"#$(#FF6 "0 +(&$".1 %V32"9% (& 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7 "0 $+% .%'"2F$("#-.1 72-&&%& -$
$+% 6"6%#$ "0 $+%(. -7$("#; `Z%#R-6(# )XC@B <N@a>
< W". - 9%$-(2%9 %V3"&($("# "0 $+% 7"#7%3$ "0 5,$-$%S0".6;B ($& 9(00%.%#7%& 0."6 $+%
72-&&(7-2 E-.V(&$ 6"9%2B -#9 $+% #%7%&&-.(21 $.-#&7%#9%#$ #-$F.% "0 ,$-$% $+"F/+$B
&%% M-.9$ -#9 =%/.( )XXDB %&3%7(-221 $+% &%7$("# 5^%#%-2"/1 "0 $+% !"#&$($F%#$
,FHR%7$; `@I?h)@a>
@ *+% 7"#&$.F7$("# "0 $+(& -H&$.-7$ 9(-/.-6 8-& "#% "0 $+% 3.(#7(3-2 "HR%7$& "0 61
$+%&(&B 5Q ,7+(A"/%#%-2"/1 "0 M%.%$(7-2 E-$%.(-2(&6 > > >; `O-.8(7T )XXXaB %&3%7(-221
(# $+% &%7$("# %#$($2%9B 5*+%&%& "# Z.F#(-# E-$%.(-2(&6 (# [%2%FA%;> ,%% -2&" =%/.(
`)XX)m )XXDa "# $+% (9%#$(0(7-$("# "0 3"2($(7& -#9 "#$"2"/1 (# ,3(#"A- -#9 [%&S
7-.$%& (# 3-.$(7F2-.>
D W.-#7%& o-$%& "00%.& - 9%$-(2%9 -77"F#$ "0 $+% 2"#/ +(&$".1 "0 +%2("7%#$.(&6B 3-1(#/
%&3%7(-2 -$$%#$("# $" $+% ."2% "0 $+% &F# (# =%"32-$"#(7 -#9 =%"31$+-/".%-#
61&$(7(&6&> Q& -# (#9%V "0 _F($% +"8 -.$(0(7(-2 $+% H"F#9-.(%& 8%.% H%$8%%#
5&7(%#7% -#9 M%.6%$(7(&6 (# $+% G%#-(&&-#7%; &+% 8.($%& $+-$ 5!"3%.#(7F&;
9(&7"'%.1 7-6% "F$ 8($+ $+% H2%&&(#/ "0 M%.6%& *.(&6%/(&$F& F3"# ($& +%-9B 8($+
- _F"$% 0."6 $+-$ 0-6"F& 8".T (# 8+(7+ M%.6%& 9%&7.(H%& $+% &F#S8".&+(3 "0 $+%
U/13$(-#& (# $+%(. 6-/(7-2 .%2(/("# r > > > s Q#9 -$ $+% 7.F7(-2 6"6%#$B RF&$ -0$%.
$+% 9(-/.-6 &+"8(#/ $+% #%8 &F#S7%#$.%9 &1&$%6 7"6%& - .%0%.%#7% $" M%.6%&
*.(&6%/(&$F& "# $+% &F#; `o-$%& )XX)B )JJa>
J W". [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.(B 3+(2"&"3+1 (& 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 -& - 7"#&$.F7$('(&6 8($+ $8"
(#$%.7"##%7$%9 1%$ 9(&$(#7$ %2%6%#$&4 5$+% 7.%-$("# "0 7"#7%3$& -#9 $+% 2-1(#/ "F$
"0 - 32-#%; "0 (66-#%#7%B $+(& 2-$$%. 57"#&$($F$%& $+% -H&"2F$% /."F#9 "0 3+(2"S
&"3+1B ($& %-.$+ ". 9%$%..($".(-2(&-$("#B $+% 0"F#9-$("# "# 8+(7+ ($ 7.%-$%& ($&
7"#7%3$&; `[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( )XX)4 DDm )XXD4 D)a> P+(2"&"3+1 (# $+(& &%#&% (&
7"$%.6(#"F& 8($+ (66-#%#7%B ($ (& #"$ $+-$ (66-#%#7% (& "#% 7"#7%3$ -6"#/
6-#1 $+-$ "#% 7-# 7+""&% $" $+(#T ". #"$B -$ $+% &-6% $(6% ($ (& #"$ - 6-&$%. T%1B
0". 58+%#%'%. (66-#%#7% (& (#$%.3.%$%9 -& (66-#%#$ #" ,"6%$+(#/B 8% 7-# H% &F.%
$+-$ $+(& ,"6%$+(#/ .%(#$."9F7%& $+% $.-#&7%#9%#$; `(H(9>B D?m DJam .-$+%. 3+(2"S
&"3+1 (& 9%0(#%9 H1 (66-#%#7% (# 7"#$.-9(&$(#7$("# $" $+% $.-#&7%#9%#$ 8+(7+
7+-.-7$%.(&%& .%2(/("#> 5O+%#%'%. $+%.% (& $.-#&7%#9%#7% r > > > s $+%.% (& .%2(/("#m -#9
$+%.% (& 3+(2"&"3+1 8+%#%'%. $+%.% (& (66-#%#7%; `(H(9>B DNm D@a> *+%.% (& #" "#%
32-#% "0 (66-#%#7%m ($ (& $+% 6-.T "0 /.%-$ 3+(2"&"3+%.&B -& "33"&%9 $" $+%
50F#7$("#-.1; `J<m J)aB =(%$A&7+%;& 5"00(7(-221 .%7"/#(&%9 /F(29 "0 3&%F9"S$+(#T%.&;
`=(%$A&7+% )X?@B )XIaB $+-$ $+%1 (#'%#$ $+%(. "8# 32-#% "0 (66-#%#7%> Y$ (& $+(&
(#'%#$("# "0 32-#%& $+-$ /('%& $+% &3%7(0(7 6"9% "0 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 $(6% -& %#)9#*J
?)9I'*/B 0". ($ (& #"$ - _F%&$("# "0 - 2(#%-. &F77%&&("#B - 2(&$ "0 #-6%& "0 $+% 9%-9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
C$%(-
N
C
?
X
)I
`- =%7."#"6(7"#aB HF$ .-$+%. -# (#$%.2-7(#/ "0 32-#%&B #" 2"#/%. 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 H1
H%0".% ". -0$%.B HF$ .-$+%. -H"'% -#9 H%2"8> 5P+(2"&"3+1 (& H%7"6(#/B #"$ +(&$".1m
($ (& $+% 7"%V(&$%#7% "0 32-#%&B #"$ $+% &F77%&&("# "0 &1&$%6&; `[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$S
$-.( )XXD4 JXm )XXD4 JXa>
G%7-22 $+-$ =".H%.$ O(%#%. -7T#"82%9/%& K%(H#(A -& $+% 53-$."# &-(#$ 0". 71H%.S
#%$(7&; `O(%#%. )XXDB )<a 0". $8" .%-&"#&4 0(.&$B 0". -#$(7(3-$(#/ 6-$+%6-$(7-2
#"$-$("# -#9 &%7"#9 0". 7"#&$.F7$(#/ -# %-.21 &16H"2(7 2"/(7m HF$ "#% 7-# -2&"
7"#&$.F% - $+(.9 .%-&"#B -#9 $+-$ (& 0". $+% (632(7-$("#& "0 K%(H#(A;& $+"F/+$ 0".
$+% 6%7+-#(7-2 -7$F-2(&-$("# "0 $+"F/+$ 5(# $+% 6%$-2;> M"8%'%.B -& U.#&$ Z2"7+
-./F%&B $+% 7.%9($ +%.% &+"F29 /" $" KF22B 8+"&% 7"6H(#-$".1 7(.72%& $-T% 3.(9% "0
32-7% -& $+% 0(.&$ -H&$.-7$ 9(-/.-6& "0 - 7-27F2-$(#/ 9%'(7%B -#9 #"8 5KF22;& -.($+S
6%$(7(&%9 9.%-6 +-& H%%# $F.#%9 (#$" - 8+"2% (#$%22%7$F-2 (#9F&$.1B 8($+ &3%%9 -&
8($7+7.-0$; `Z2"7+ )X?NB NJ<a> Z"$+ o-$%& -#9 Z2"7+ &+"8 $+-$ - 7"#&(9%.-H2% 3-.$
"0 Z.F#";& 8".TB 3.(#7(3-221 +(& %-.2(%. $%V$& "# 6#%6"#(7 $%7+#(_F%&B 7"#&$($F$%
-# -$$%63$ $" (63."'% F3"# ". .-$("#-2(&% $+% KF22(-# -.$> Y$ &+"F29 $+"F/+ H%
H".#% (# 6(#9 $+-$B -& 8($+ -22 "0 $+% "$+%. 0(/F.%& 7-##(H-2(&%9 0". Z.F#";&
&1#7.%$(&6B +(& (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 KF22 (& 5%'%# 6".% 3%7F2(-.B -#9 6".% .%6"$%
0."6 $+% 6%9(%'-2 KF22B $+-# r$+-$ 0"F#9s (# #".6-2 G%#-(&&-#7% KF22(&6; `o-$%&
)XXNB <ICa> L#7% -/-(# $+%# 8% &%% Z.F#";& 9%7(&('% &$-63 "# "#% "0 $+% T%1
0(/F.%& "0 $+% [%2%FA(-# /%#%-2"/1> Z.F#";& (#02F%#7% "# K%(H#(A %V$%#9& $" "$+%.
-.%-& $"" -& (& %'(9%#7%9 H1 $+% 0.%_F%#71 "0 +(& -33%-.-#7%& (# D'$ :"4.0 *& +)$F*%B
$+% K%(H#(A(-# 6"#-9 (& $-T%# 0."6 Z.F#"B 3.(#7(3-221 0". ($& ."2% (# $+%
$.-#&0".6-$("# "0 5=%"32-$"#(7 %6-#-$("#& r > > > s $" - 2-./% A"#% "0 (66-#%#7%;
`[%2%FA% )XX@B <Dam $+% &F33"&($("# "0 - F#('%.&-2 3-.-&($(&6 (& Z.F#(-#m -& (& $+%
K%(H#(A(-# /"5I4*/9#*">
g ./%#
Y# 8+-$ (&B Y &F33"&%B - 2-#96-.T %&&-1 5E"9%.#($14 -# Y#7"632%$% P."R%7$; kF
M-H%.6-& #"$%& $+% 0.%_F%#71B 9-$(#/ H-7T $" $+% 0(0$+ 7%#$F.1B "0 $+% F&% "0 $+%
$%.6 56"9%.#($1; $" 9%#"$% 5$+% 7"#&7("F&#%&& "0 -# %3"7+ $+-$ .%2-$%& ($&%20 $" $+%
3-&$ "0 -#$(_F($1B (# ".9%. $" '(%8 ($&%20 -& $+% .%&F2$ "0 - $.-#&($("# 0."6 $+% "29 $"
$+% #%8; `M-H%.6-& )X?J4 @a>
,%% $+% 7"22%7$("# "0 -3+".(&6& F#9%. $+(& $($2% (# =(%$A&7+% )XXIH4 NXhCN>
W". -# -77"F#$ "0 $+% ."2% $+-$ $+% .(&(#/ $(9% "0 ,3(#"A(&$S(#&3(.%9 !9#,)I'*4"%"J
I'*$ +-9 F3"# 6F7+ "0 b-#$(-#(&6B &%% Z%(&%. )X?CB 7+-3$%. "# 5*+% G(&% "0
,3(#"A(&6 (# ^%.6-#1 )N?Ih)C?N; 8+(7+ /('%& - '('(9 -77"F#$ "0 $+% $%..".
$+-$ ,3(#"A(&$ 6-$%.(-2(&6 -#9 -$+%(&6 (#&3(.%9 (# $+% 0".7%& "0 -F$+".($1B -#9
3.(#7(3-221 (# b-#$>
Z%$8%%# $+% 7"632%$("# "0 $+% 6-#F&7.(3$ "0 D'$ <""; "2 #'$ 1$F"4,#*"&% (# )J@I
-#9 ($& %'%#$F-2 3FH2(7-$("#B !"3%.#(7F& '-7(22-$%9B $%..(0(%9 H1 $+% 3"&&(H2% 7"#S
&%_F%#7%& "0 $+% 3FH2(7 -'-(2-H(2($1 "0 +(& H""T -#9 +(& #%F."$(7 "H&%&&("# 8($+
6-(#$-(#(#/ - P1$+-/".%-# &%7.%71> K(T% !"3%.#(7F&B [-.8(# $"" '-7(22-$%9 (#
3FH2(&+(#/ +(& /%#F(#%21 .%'"2F$("#-.1 0(#9(#/&B F#2(T% !"3%.#(7F&B [-.8(# =9%
/%#F(#%21 $%..(0(%9 -H"F$ $+% &"7(-2B 3"2($(7-2 -#9 .%2(/("F& 7"#02-/.-$("# $+-$ +(&
8".T 6(/+$B -#9 9(9B &3-.T> [-.8(#;& 0%-.& -.% 6(#F$%21 9%$-(2%9 (# $+% 6-/#(0(S
7%#$ H("/.-3+1 H1 [%&6"#9 -#9 E"".% `)XXCa> O+%# !"3%.#(7F&; H""T 8-&
%'%#$F-221 3FH2(&+%9 ($ 7-6% 8($+ - 3.%0-7% H1 $+% 7"0"F#9%. "0 KF$+%.-#(&6B
Q#9.%-& L&(-#9%.B 8+"B F#2(T% +(& 7"22%-/F%&B KF$+%. +(6&%20 -#9 E%2-#7+$"#B
8-& 0-'"F.-H2% $" !"3%.#(7-#(&6> *+%.% (& &"6% +(&$".(7-2 7"#$."'%.&1 -& $"
!"3%.#(7F&; -$$($F9% $"8-.9& $+(& 3.%0-7%m (#9%%9B ($ (& #"$ %'%# 7%.$-(# $+-$ +%
8-& (# -#1 3"&($("# $" .%-9 ($B -& $+% 0(.&$ 3.(#$%9 7"31 "0 +(& H""T -..('%9 "#21
+"F.& H%0".% +(& 9%-$+ H1 8+(7+ $(6% +(& 6(#9 +-9 H%7"6% -& F#+(#/%9 -& $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
U-.$+ &""# 8"F29 H%> *+% 3"(#$ "0 $+(& 3.%0-7%B -#9 61 &"2% .%-&"# 0". 6%#$("#(#/
($B (& $+-$ ($ 9%&7.(H%& $+% 7"#$%#$& "0 $+% 1$F"4,#*"&% -& 5+13"$+%&%& r8+(7+s #%%9
#"$ H% $.F% #". %'%# 3."H-H2%; `$+% 0F22 $%V$ "0 $+% 3.%0-7% 7-# H% 0"F#9 (# b"%&$2%.
)XJXB JC@ 0#Xa>
)) 6)"*/" 2,)")$ (& $+% $($2% "0 "#% "0 Z.F#";& H""T&B $+% 6"&$ .%7%#$ U#/2(&+ $.-#&2-$("#
"0 8+(7+ (& $+-$ H1 P> E%66"B &%% Z.F#" )XND>
)< *+(& _F"$-$("# +-& - 3-/% .%0%.%#7%B .-$+%. $+-# - &%7$("# #F6H%. -& (& F&F-2 8($+
=(%$A&7+% H%7-F&% ($ (& $+% 6"$$" "0 H""T 0('% 5O% W%-.2%&& L#%&; "0 D'$ O9C A/*$&/$>
Q77".9(#/ $" O-2$%. b-F06-##;& 7"66%#$-.1B $+(& &32%#9(9 _F"$-$("# 7"6%&
0."6 $+% f(7"6$% 9% *F.%##%B $+% /.%-$ &%'%#$%%#$+S7%#$F.1 W.%#7+ /%#%.-2>
)@ *+-$ 5=(%$A&7+% 8-& -."F&%9 0."6 +(& 9"/6-$(7 &2F6H%. H1 [-.8(#; `b-F06-##
)XN<B )D<aB (& - 7"66"#32-7%> ZF$ 8+-$ (& 2%&& .%6-.T%9 F3"# (& $+-$ 8+(2%
=(%$A&7+% +-& - 2"#/ -#9 &F&$-(#%9 %#/-/%6%#$ 8($+ [-.8(#B ($ (& &FH&$-#$(-221
- [-.8(# 6%9(-$%9 $+."F/+ $+% H""T $+-$ =(%$A&7+% 7-22%9 '-.("F&21 - 5$.%-&F.%
+"F&%; -#9 5$+% 6"&$ &(/#(0(7-#$ 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 8".T $" +-'% -33%-.%9 (# $+% 2-&$
+F#9.%9 1%-.&;B (>%> K-#/%;& >*%#")C "2 39#$)*94*%5> *+%.% (& - &6-22 HF$ /."8(#/
2($%.-$F.% "# $+% (#02F%#7%B F3"# =(%$A&7+%B "0 K-#/%;& -&$"#(&+(#/ -#9 7"63%#S
9("F& $+.%% '"2F6% 8".TB 0."6 8+(7+ Y +-'% 7"#&F2$%9 ,$-7T )X?@ -#9 Q#&%22
P%-.&"# )X??> Q 9%$-(2%9 %V-6(#-$("# "0 $+% 7"632%V &%$ "0 .%2-$("#&+(3& h
=(%$A&7+% -#9 K-#/%B =(%$A&7+% -#9 [-.8(# h (& H%1"#9 $+% &7"3% "0 $+% 3.%&%#$
7+-3$%.> M"8%'%.B (# - 2-./%. 8".TB 7F..%#$21 (# 3."/.%&&B Y /" "# $" %V-6(#% &"6%
-&3%7$& "0 $+% 2-$$%.> Y 9%-2 (# 3-.$(7F2-. $+% .%&"#-#7%& 8($+(# =(%$A&7+%;& 9(-/S
#"&(& "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 +(& 7"$%.6(#"F& 3."R%7$ "0 3%.&3%7$('(&6 "0 [-.8(#;& +".S
.%#9"F& .%-2(&-$("# $+-$ 5($ (& -H&F.9 $" $-2T "0 "#% -#(6-2 H%(#/ +(/+%. $+-#
-#"$+%. r > > > s P$ 7"#&(9%. $+"&%B 8+%.% $+% (#$%22%7$F-2 0-7F2$(%& r-.%s 6"&$ 9%'%2S
"3%9 -& +(/+%&$ h - H%% 9"FH$2%&& 8"F29 rF&%s (#&$(#7$& r-& - 7.($%.("#s; `[-.8(#
_F"$%9 (# [%&6"#9 -#9 E"".% )XXCB <@<a> L#% "0 $+% 3.(#7(3-2 "HR%7$& "0
=(%$A&7+%;& (632-7-H2% 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 &7".# (& $+% &T(# "0 +F6-#(&6 $+-$ H(#9&
$+% 9"6(#-#$ $.-9($("#& "0 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 +(&$".1B -# -#$+."3"6".3+(&6
&$.%$7+%9 H%$8%%# P2-$" -#9 b-#$> *+(& +F6-#(&6 8+(7+ /."F#9& -# (#&$.F6%#$S
-2(&6 `5$" 55+F6-#(&%;; $+% 8".29B (>%> $" 0%%2 "F.&%2'%& 6".% -#9 6".% 6-&$%.&
8($+(# ($; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B lN)@a $"8-.9& $+% 7"&6"& (& &T%8%.%9 H1 =(%$A&7+%-#
3%.&3%7$('(&6 -#9 ($& &3%7F2-$("#& F3"# $+% 3"&&(H(2($(%& "0 #"#"./-#(7 3%.7%3$("#
-#9 #"#+F6-# &%#&%&> Y#9%%9B =(%$A&7+% &F//%&$& $+-$4 5"$+%. (#$%.3.%$-$("#&
$+-# 6%.%21 +F6-# "#%& -.% 3%.+-3& &"6%8+%.% 3"&&(H2%; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B
lN)Na> *+% %V(&$%#7% "0 &F7+ &%#&%& (& #"8 &F33".$%9 H1 &"2(9 %63(.(7-2 %'(9%#7%
.-#/(#/ 0."6 9%%3 &%- 0(&+ $+-$ 7-# &%% 2(/+$ -$ 8-'%2%#/$+& 8%22 H%1"#9 $+% .-#/%
3%.7%3$(H2% $" $+% +F6-#B $" $+% &"#(7 -H(2($(%& "0 H-$& -#9 9"/&B -#9 H%1"#9 $+%
g 22;& 8.($(#/ "# $+% $%63".-2($(%& "0 9(00%.%#$ "./-#(&6& 0."6
&%#&%& $" '"# \%VTF
$+% $(7T $" $+% $.%% -#9 $" H-7$%.(-> *+% 2(#% "0 $+"F/+$ "3%#%9 +%.%B +-&B ($ 7-# H%
-./F%9B 7F26(#-$%9 (# 8+-$ Y21- P.(/"/(#% +-& 7-22%9 5$+% %#9 "0 7%.$-(#$1;> Y#
P.(/"/(#%;& (#$%.3.%$-$("#B _F-#$F6 6%7+-#(7& (& $+% -3"$+%"&(& -#9 -7$F-2(&-S
$("#B "0 $+% -#-21&(& "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 ($& $.-#&'-2F-$("# $+-$ 8% +-'% 9%'%2"3%9 "F$
"0 =(%$A&7+%> P.(/"/(#% 8.($%& $+-$ 58% -.% "# $+% %'% "0 $+% 553."H-H(2(&$(7
.%'"2F$("#;;B 8+(7+ +-& H%%# /"(#/ "# 0". 7%#$F.(%&> P."H-H(2($1 (& #" 2"#/%. &$-$% "0 6(#9 9F% $" "F. (/#".-#7%B HF$ $+% .%&F2$ "0 2-8& "0 #-$F.%; `P.(/"/(#%
)XXCB )@<a4 8% 6F&$ +%#7%0".$+ 7"#0."#$ #"$ - .%2-$('($1 "0 $.F$+B HF$ - $.F$+ "0
$+% .%2-$('% `&%%B 0". %V-632%B [%2%FA% )XX@B <Im [%2%FA% )X?JB )X)m )X?XB )DCB -#9
[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( )XX)B JJB )<@m )XXD4 JDB )@Ia>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
64*"# 74+$)# )J
)N !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Q#&%22 P%-.&"#B b> `)X??a 5*+% tF%&$("# "0 W>Q> K-#/%;& Y#02F%#7% "# =(%$A&7+%> Q
!.($(_F% "0 G%7%#$ G%&%-.7+ 0."6 $+% ,$-#93"(#$ "0 $+% [("#1&(-#; (# !*$#@%/'$J
A#,.*$&0 -&#$)&9#*"&94$% 89')+,/' 2,U) .*$ !*$#@%/'$J:")%/',&?B Z-#9 :fYYB J@XhJD>
Z-$-(22%B ^> `)XX)a D'$ 7//,)%$. A'9)$R F"4Z -0 ("&%,5I#*"&B $.-#&> H1 G"H%.$ MF.2%1B =%8
o".T4 q"#% Z""T&>
Z%(&%.B W> `)X?Ca D'$ :9#$ "2 1$9%"&0 O$)59& E'*4"%"I'C 2)"5 G9&# #" :*/'#$B !-6H.(9/%
EQ4 M-.'-.9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
Z%#R-6(#B O> `)XC@a 5*+%&%& "# $+% P+(2"&"3+1 "0 M(&$".1; (# -44,5*&9#*"&%B $.-#&>
M> q"+#B =%8 o".T4 ,7+"7T%# Z""T&B <#9 %9#B <J@hND>
Z2"7+B U> `)X?Na D'$ E)*&/*I4$ "2 >"I$B $.-#&> => -#9 ,> P2-(7% -#9 P> b#(/+$B LV0".94 Z-&(2
Z2-7T8%22>
Z.F#"B ^> `)?CXhX)a QI$)9 49#*&$ /"&%/)*I#9B %9> H1 W> W(".%#$(#"B W> *"77"B M> f($%22(B f>
Y6H.(-#(B !> E> *-22-.(/"B @ '"2&> (# ? 3-.$&B W2".%#7%4 K% E"##(%.>
pp `)XNDa O*").9&" <),&"N% D'$ >$)"*/ :)$&@*$%B $.-#&> P> E%66"B !+-3%2 M(224 \#(S
'%.&($1 "0 =".$+ !-."2(#- P.%&&>
pp `)XXJa D'$ 7%' P$.&$%.9C A,II$)B %9> -#9 $.-#&> H1 U>Q> ^"&&%2(# -#9 K>,> K%.#%.B
*"."#$"4 \#('%.&($1 "0 *"."#$" P.%&&>
pp `)XX?a (9,%$R E)*&/*I4$ 9&. [&*#CZ 7&. 6%%9C% "& 39?*/B $.-#&> -#9 %9> G>k> Z2-7T8%22B
(#$."> H1 Q> Y#/%/#"B !-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
[%2%FA%B ^> `)X?@a !*$#@%/'$ 9&. E'*4"%"I'CB $.-#&> H1 M> *"62(#&"#B K"#9"#4 Q$+2"#%
P.%&&>
pp `)X?Ja (*&$M59 \0 LN*59?$J#$5I% P-.(&4 K%& %e9($("#& 9% E(#F($ `)X?Xa (*&$59 \0 D'$
D*5$ -59?$B $.-#&> H1 M> *"62(#&"# -#9 G> ^-2%$-B K"#9"#4 *+% Q$+2"#% P.%&&>
pp `)XX@a D'$ :"4.0 L$*+&*@ 9&. #'$ <9)"V,$B $.-#&> *> !"#2%1B E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1
"0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
[%2%FA%B ^> -#9 ^F-$$-.(B W> `)X?Ia 3*44$ E49#$9,H0 (9I*#94*%5$ $# %/'*@"I')$M&*$ \ P-.(&4
K%& %e9($("#& 9% E(#F($>
pp `)X?Ca 7 D'",%9&. E49#$9,%0 (9I*#94*%5 9&. A/'*@"I')$&*9B $.-#&> Z> E-&&F6(B
E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
pp `)XX)a ],N$%#J/$ V,$ 49 I'*4"%"I'*$S P-.(&4 K%& %e9($("#& 9% E(#F($>
pp `)XXDa P'9# *% I'*4"%"I'CS $.-#&> ^> ZF.7+%22 -#9 M> *"62(#&"#B K"#9"#4 f%.&">
[%&6"#9B Q> -#9 E"".%B k> `)XXCa B9)=*& K"#9"#4 P%#/F(# Z""T&>
M-H%.6-&B k> `)X?Ja 5E"9%.#($14 -# Y#7"632%$% P."R%7$; $.-#&> H1 ,> Z%#+-H(HB (#
E"%#5".$)& (,4#,)$B %9> M> W"&$%. @h)J K"#9"#4 P2F$">
M-.9$B E> -#9 =%/.(B Q> `)XXDa L9+") "2 B*"&C%,%0 9 ()*#*V,$ "2 #'$ A#9#$J:")5 E(##%-S
3"2(& -#9 K"#9"#4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
b-#$B Y> `)X<Xa ()*#*V,$ "2 E,)$ 1$9%"&B $.-#&> => b%63 ,6($+B K"#9"#4 E-76(22-#>
pp `)XJ<a ()*#*V,$ "2 8,.?$5$&# $.-#&> k> !.%%9 E%.%9($+B LV0".94 !2-.%#9"# P.%&&>
b-F06-##B O> `)XN<a !*$#@%/'$0 E'*4"%"I'$)R E%C/'"4"?*%#R 7&#*/')*%# =%8 o".T4 E%.(S
9(-#>
b"%&$2%.B Q> `)XJXa D'$ A4$$I=94;$)%0 7 >*%#")C "2 39&N ('9&?*&? X*%*"& "2 #'$ [&*F$)%$B
K"#9"#4 P%#/F(#>
b"1.%eB Q> `)XJCa :)"5 #'$ (4"%$. P")4. #" #'$ -&2*&*#$ [&*F$)%$ Z-2$(6".%4 k"+#& M"3T(#&
\#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
K-#/%B W>Q> `)?CXa D'$ >*%#")C "2 39#$)*94*%5 9&. ()*#*/*%5 "2 *#% E)$%$&# -5I")#9&/$B "#%
g H#%. u !">
'"2F6% %9($("#B $.-#&> U> !+%&$%. *+"6-&B K"#9"#4 *.F
E%#9"A-B G>^> `)XXJa D'$ 7/$&#)*/ L9+C)*&#'0 O*").9&" <),&"N% E)$4,.$ #" ("&#$5I")9)C
("%5"4"?C ,+-0$%&HF.14 U2%6%#$>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
0(D()(,1(-
=%/.(B Q> `)XX)a D'$ A9F9?$ 7&"594C0 #'$ E"=$) "2 AI*&"@9N% 3$#9I'C%*/% 9&. E"4*#*/%
$.-#&> E> M-.9$B E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XN?a D'$ P*44 D" E"=$)B $.-#&> O> b-F06-## -#9 G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B =%8
o".T4 f(#$-/% Z""T&>
pp `)XNXa Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94% 9&. 6//$ >"5"B $.-#&> O> b-F06-##B =%8 o".T4
f(#$-/% Z""T&>
pp `)XCDa D'$ O9C A/*$&/$B $.-#&> O> b-F06-##B =%8 o".T4 f(#$-/% Z""T&>
pp `)X?<a B9C+)$9;0 D'",?'#% "& #'$ E)$K,.*/$% "2 3")94*#CB $.-#&> H1 G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B
!-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)X?@a [&#*5$4C 3$.*#9#*"&%B $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B !-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#(S
'%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)X?Na >,59&R 744 D"" >,59&0 9 <""; 2") :)$$ AI*)*#%B $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B
!-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&
pp `)XXI-a <$C"&. O"". 9&. 6F*4B $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B K"#9"#4 P%#/F(#>
pp `)XXIHa E'*4"%"I'C 9&. D),#'0 A$4$/#*"&% 2)"5 !*$#@%/'$N% !"#$+"";% "2 #'$ 69)4C
^_`aN%B %9> -#9 $.-#&> H1 [> Z.%-A-2%B K"#9"#4 MF6-#($(%& P.%&&>
pp `)XXJa L9 F"4"&#$M .$ I,*%%9&/$B (# $8" '"2F6%&B $.-#&> ^> Z(-#_F(&B P-.(&4 ^-22(S
6-.9>
L.9(#%B => `)XXNa O*").9&" <),&" 9&. #'$ E'*4"%"I'C "2 #'$ 7%%B $.-#&> M> Z-.-#&T( 8($+
Q> ,-(H%.B =%8 M-'%# -#9 K"#9"#4 o-2% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
P.(/"/(#%B Y -#9 ,$%#/%.&B Y `)X?Da Q).$) Q,# "2 ('9"%0 39&N% !$= B*94"?,$ P*#' !9#,)$
K"#9"#4 W2-6(#/">
P.(/"/(#%B Y> (# 7"22-H".-$("# 8($+ ,$%#/%.& Y `)XXCa D'$ 6&. "2 ($)#9*&#C0 D*5$R ('9"%
9&. #'$ !$= L9=% "2 !9#,)$ =%8 o".T4 *+% W.%% P.%&&>
,(#/%.B [>O> `)XJIa O*").9&" <),&"0 >*% L*2$ 9&. D'",?'#B (#72F9%& ,(#/%.;& $.-#&2-$("#
"0 Z.F#";& Q& #'$ -&2*&*#$ [&*F$)%$ 9&. P")4.% =%8 o".T4 M%#.1 ,7+F6-#>
,3(#"A-B Z> 9%> `)X?Xa 6#'*/%B $.-#&> Q> Z"12% -#9 .%'(&%9 H1 ^>M>G> P-.T(#&"#B K"#9"#4
k>E> [%#$ u ,"#& K$9>
,$-7TB ^>k> `)X?@a L9&?$ 9&. !*$#@%/'$ Z%.2(#4 9% ^.F1$%.>
O(%#%.B => `)XXDa (C+$)&$#*/%0 ") ("&#)"4 9&. ("55,&*/9#*"& *& #'$ 7&*594 9&. #'$
39/'*&$B &%7"#9 %9($("#B !-6H.(9/%B EQ -#9 K"#9"#4 *+% EY* P.%&&>
o-$%&B W> `)XX)a O*").9&" <),&" 9&. #'$ >$)5$#*/ D)9.*#*"& !+(7-/"4 \#('%.&($1 "0 !+(S
7-/" P.%&&>
pp `)XXNa D'$ 7)# "2 3$5")C K"#9"#4 P(62(7">
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
64*"# 74+$)# )C
<
=(+(2(&6B *"#(/+$ > > >
\#9%. 6(9S8(#$%. 2(/+$ (# -# -#$(_F% +-22
5$+% 0-22 "0 H%7-F&%; &7.-82%9 "# - 8-22
&F//%&$& 8+1 UF."3%;& RF&$ - +(/+H."8 R"T% h
$+%1 (#'%#$%9 7-F&-$("# (# 32-7% "0 +"3%
k"+# W".H%&
5<F(2 #,-<):(,%O+-$;& H%7"6% "0 #(+(2(&6 $"9-1i Q26"&$ %'%.1 .%7%#$ $%V$ "# $+% &FHR%7$ (&
'%.1 _F(7T21 0".7%9 $" -7T#"82%9/% ($& -33-.%#$ 9%/.-9-$("#> b-.%# !-..B 0".
(#&$-#7%B -##"F#7%& $+-$ 5=(%$A&7+%;& 55F#7-##(%&$ "0 -22 /F%&$&;;B $+% H-#% "0
$+% #(#%$%%#$+ 7%#$F.1B (& H%7"6(#/ -# F#.%6-.T-H2%B %'%# H-#-2B 0%-$F.% "0
6"9%.# 2(0% > > > -& ($& 7.(&(& '-2F% 9(6(#(&+%&B -& ($ H%7"6%& -77%3$%9 8($+ -#
(#9(00%.%#$ &+.F/B> > > r=(+(2(&6s 9%'"2'%& (#$" ($& -#$($+%&(&4 - 9"/6-$(7 -H&"S
2F$(&6; `!-.. )XX<B )Ia> L# !-..;& -77"F#$B &"6%$+(#/ F#%V3%7$%9 +-&
"H'("F&21 "77F..%9B - 59%'"2F$("#;> o%$ (0 h -& b%($+ Q#&%22 P%-.&"# 3F$& ($ h
5$"9-1 ($ .%6-(#& -& #%7%&&-.1 -& %'%. $" $+(#T $+."F/+ $+% 3."H2%6 "0
#(+(2(&6 -#9 3%.0".6 =(%$A&7+%;& 9%6-#9 0". - .%'-2F-$("# "0 -22 "F. '-2F%&;
`Q#&%22 P%-.&"# )XXDB ?aB $+%# +"8 9"%& $+(& 9%'"2F$("# '($(-$% $+% 0".7%0F2S
#%&& "0 $+% $%.6i W".B -& $+% '%.1 &-6% $%V$& 3"(#$ "F$B #(+(2(&6 (& #"$ 1%$ 8".9 $+-$ 7-# &(6321 H% 9(&3%#&%9 8($+B 0". #"$+(#/ %2&% &%%6& _F($% -&
-33."3.(-$% 0". -#1 3"&&(H2% /2"H-2 7.($(_F% "0 7"#$%63".-.1 7-3($-2B 6"9%.#
$%7+#"2"/1B O%&$%.# 9%6"7.-$(7 (9%"2"/1B #F72%-. 3."2(0%.-$("#B %7"2"/(7-2
6(&6-#-/%6%#$B /2"H-2 -96(#(&$.-$('% 3"2($(7&B 6-&&S6%9(- +13%.H"2%B -#9
&" "# `&%% U9%# )X?@m ^-.% )XX@m Q/-6H%# )XX)m [-.H1 $# 94> )X?Xm !.($7+2%1
)XXCa>
=(+(2(&6;& /2"H-2 (6S3%.$(#%#7%B ($ &%%6&B 7"6%& -$ $+% 7"&$ "0 ($& .+%$".(7-2
9(&$.-7$("#> W". $+% $%.6 +-& 9."33%9 -26"&$ 7"632%$%21 "F$ "0 %&$-H2(&+S
6%#$ 3"2($(7-2 9(&7"F.&% (# 0-'"F. "0 &F7+ -33%22-$("#& -& 5-#$(S9%6"7.-$(7;B
5$%..".(&$(7;B 50F#9-6%#$-2(&$;B %$7> Y0 ($ (& 9%32"1%9 (# &F7+ &($F-$("#&B ($ (& -&
)?
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*;
-# (#9(00%.%#$21 &FH&$($F$-H2% $%.6 8+"&% '-2F% .%&(9%& 6%.%21 (# ($& 7-3-7($1
$" H% 7+-(#%9 8($+ - #F6H%. "0 "$+%. 9%."/-$".1B &F33"&%921 &1#"#16"F&
8".9&> Q .%7%#$ 6/"&"5*%#B 0". %V-632%B %632"1& $+(& -&&"7(-$('% 3."7%9F.%
(# ".9%. $" 9%&7.(H% - 5#%8 $%..".(&6; $+-$ .%32-7%& .%'"2F$("#-.1 3."S
/.-66%& 8($+ - 5#(+(2(&$ H.-#9 "0 0-#-$(7(&6; `D'$ 6/"&"5*%# )XX?B )Na>
U'%# (# $+"&% .-.% 3FH2(7 6"6%#$& 8+%# ($& F&% 9"%& &%%6 -H&"2F$%21 7"#S
&(&$%#$ -#9 RF&$(0(-H2%B 5#(+(2(&6;&; 0".7% -#9 &(/#(0(7-$("# -.% (66%9(-$%21
&8%3$ -8-1 (# -#9 H1 $+% &$-.$2(#/ 0-7$ "0 ($& -33%-.-#7% -$ -22> ^.%(2 E-.7F&B
.%7-22(#/ `-& +% 9.('%& 9"8# - 0.%%8-1a U2(A-H%$+ [.%8;& F&% "0 $+% 8".9
5#(+(2(&$(7; (# $+% )X?I \, U2%7$("#&B 8.($%&4
O+-$ 8-& [.%8 $-2T(#/ -H"F$i ,+%;& 0-6"F& 0". +%. .%-&"#-H2%#%&&B +%.
H2-#9#%&&B 0". #F6H(#/ $.-#&7.(3$("#& "0 (#$%.'(%8& -#9 7+%..1SH2"&&"6
.%3".$&B -#9 -& - '("2-$("# "0 +%. #".6-2 9(&7"F.&% $+(& 8".9 6-9% #"
&%#&%> Y$ 8-& 2"F9 -#9 '("2%#$B HF$ 2(T% $+% 7.-&+ "0 - 0-22(#/ $.%% #"H"91
+%-.&>
`E-.7F& )XX@B @J)a
5K(T% $+% 7.-&+ "0 - 0-22(#/ $.%%; > > > $+% 7F..%#$ .%-2($1 "0 #(+(2(&6 (& $+-$ ($ (&
#"$+(#/ (# .%-2($14 %'%# $+% 8".9 ($&%20 +-& H%7"6% -& #F/-$".1 -#9 (#%VS
32(7-H2% (# ($& -2%-$".1 '("2%#7% -& $+% F#+-331 0(/F.%& -#9 %'%#$& ($ -#9 ($&
7"/#-$%& 8%.% "#7% +%29 $" 9%&(/#-$%> L# "#% +-#9B E-.7F& (& 7"#0."#$%9 H1
$+% -33-.%#$ (63"$%#7% "0 $+% $%.6B -#9B "# $+% "$+%.B 8($+ $+% 0-7$ "0 ($&
.%7F..%#$ -33-.($("# -#9 F#3.%9(7$-H2% $(#1 %00%7$&> Y#9%%9B E-.7F& +(6&%20B
6F&(#/ "# [.%8;& F$$%.-#7%B &F99%#21 7+-#/%& .-9(" &$-$("#&B -#9 (&
&+"7T%9 (#$" -F$"6"$('% (66"H(2($1 H1 $+% (..F3$("# "0 K-F.(% Q#9%.&"#;&
5L ,F3%.6-#; $+."F/+ $+% &3%-T%.&>
E-.7F&;& -#%79"$% "#7% -/-(# (22F&$.-$%& $+% -26"&$ F#('%.&-2 F#7%.$-(#$1
.%/-.9(#/ $+% 7.($(7-2 3F.7+-&% "0 5#(+(2(&6; #"8> Y# $+."8(#/ 9"FH$ "#
#(+(2(&6;& &$-$F& -& - I"4*#*/944C 2")/$2,4 I'*4"%"I'*/94 .*%/",)%$B &F7+ - 7+-2S
2%#/% .-(&%& - &%$ "0 '-2F-H2% _F%&$("#&> Y& -# -$$%#$("# $" #(+(2(&6 &$(22 $+%
6"&$ 7"63%22(#/ ". &"3+(&$(7-$%9 8-1 $" 7+-.-7$%.(&% 7"#$%63".-.1 &"7(-2
3+%#"6%#-i L. 9"%& $+% 7F..%#$ &($F-$("# .-$+%. .%_F(.% 8-1& "0 $+(#T(#/
$+-$ 9%3-.$ 0."6 $+% 7.($(7-2 +%.($-/% (# 8+(7+ #(+(2(&6 +-& 32-1%9 &F7+ 7.F7(-2 ."2%i Y#9%%9B - 8(22(#/#%&& $" $+(#T &F7+ _F%&$("#& $+."F/+B $" .%S
%V-6(#% $+% 9%'"2F$("# -#9 6-./(#-2($1 "0 #(+(2(&6 -/-(#&$ $+% H-7T/."F#9
"0 ($& (#&$($F$("#-2 -#9 3"2($(7-2 +(&$".1B 6-1 3-.-9"V(7-221 H% - 7"#9($("# "0
.%$F.#(#/ $" #(+(2(&6 ($& 7.($(7-2 0".7%> Y# $+(& 7+-3$%.B 8% &%%T $" &$($7+
$"/%$+%. $+% -33-.%#$21 (#7"66%#&F.-H2% $.%-$6%#$& "0 $+% _F%&$("# "0
#(+(2(&6 H1 3+(2"&"3+1 -#9 &"7("2"/1B &" -& $" F#9%.7F$ $+% &$-#9-.9 3+(2"S
&"3+(7-2 &%#&% "0 $+% $%.6> O($+"F$ .%3F9(-$(#/ $+% 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 &%#&%
-H&"2F$%21B 8% 8(22 -$$%63$ $" &+"8 $+% 2(6($& "0 $+% F&%& $" 8+(7+ $+%
$%.6 +-& H%%# 3F$ H1 $+% 3"&$S=(%$A&7+%-# $.-9($("#B 2(6($& 8+(7+ .%6-(#%9
#%7%&&-.(21 F#_F%&$("#%9 8($+(# $+(& $.-9($("#> [(&7%.#(#/ $+%&% 2(6($& 8(22
$+%# %#-H2% F& $" &3%-T -H"F$ $+% +(&$".(7-2 %6%./%#7% "0 3"2($(7-2 #(+(2(&6
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*; )X
(# - 9(00%.%#$ 8-1 h 8($+"F$ &(6321 .%+%-.&(#/ (#+%.($%9 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 -#9
&"7("2"/(7-2 3.%&F63$("#& -H"F$ ($& 6%-#(#/> LF. /%#%-2"/1 &%%T& $" &+"8
+"8 -#9 8+1 $+% 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 -77"F#$ $""T $+% 0".6& $+-$ ($ 9(9 -#9B
0"22"8(#/ "# 0."6 $+(&B $" 3."'(9% - %V32-#-$".1 9(-/#"&(& "0 $+% &7"3% -#9
&$-$F& "0 #(+(2(&6 #"8>
Q#1 -$$%63$ $" 9" $+(& 6F&$ &$(22 7"#0."#$ =(%$A&7+%> Y# $+% 8-T% "0
=(%$A&7+%;& 9%72-.-$("# "0 $+% 59%-$+ "0 ^"9;B -#9 +(& 7"#7"6($-#$ .%7"/#(S
$("# $+-$ 6-# 8"F29 .-$+%. 8(22 #"$+(#/#%&& $+-# #"$ 8(22 -$ -22B $+% _F%&$
+-& H%%# "# $" &F332%6%#$ +(& -77"F#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 ($& /%#%-2"/1>
[%&3($% $+% 9(&$-#7% $+-$ $+%&% 7.($(_F%& "0$%# $.1 $" $-T% 0."6 =(%$A&7+% -&
8%22 -& 0."6 %-7+ "$+%.B $+% 2(6($& $+-$ +% 9%2(#%-$%9 8($+ .%/-.9 $" $+%
+(&$".(7-2 -#9 7"#7%3$F-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 7"#$(#F% $" /"'%.# $+%
-332(7-$("# "0 $+(& $%.6 `&%%B 0". (#&$-#7%B Q#&%22 P%-.&"# )XXDm [-.H1 $# 94>
)X?Xm U9%# )XX@m k"#-& )XN@m E-.$(# )X?Xm ,6($+ )XXNm O-.9 )XXJa> !"#S
&%_F%#$21B $+% 3"&$S=(%$A&7+%-# &%#&% "0 #(+(2(&6 (#'-.(-H21 H""6%.-#/&
H-7T F3"# $+% 0"22"8(#/ 7"#9($("#&4
) Q& -# -#-21$(7 9%&7.(3$("#B #(+(2(&6 9%&(/#-$%& $+% &$-$F& "0 $+% $)9 (#
8+(7+ =$ -.% #"8 2('(#/B -#9 (# 8+(7+ $+% F#/."F#9%9#%&& "0
%'%.1 %$+(7"S"#$"2"/(7-2 3.%&7.(3$("# H%7"6%& -$ "#7% 6-#(0%&$ -#9
"772F9%9> L#% 7-##"$ %'%# 3"&% $+% _F%&$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 -$ -22
8($+"F$ (66%9(-$%21 3.%&F6(#/ h -#9 (# - '-.(%$1 "0 8-1& h $+-$ ($ (&B
-H"'% -22B - _F%&$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 #".9C> M"8%'%.B -& 8% &+-22 %V32-(#
H%2"8B #(+(2(&6 (& 94%" +%29 $" H% #"#S ". -S+(&$".(7-2B -# 5F#$(6%21;
9%&(/#-$("#>
< Q& - 3%.0".6-$('% 9%72-.-$("#B 5#(+(2(&6; (& ".(/(#-221 H"$+ 7"#9%6#-$("#
-#9 (#RF#7$("#4 #(+(2(&6 (& $+-$ 8+(7+ 5,%# H% "'%.7"6% ". 7"#$%&$%9B ".B
-$ $+% '%.1 2%-&$B 59%2(#%-$%9; h %'%# $+"F/+ $+(& (#'"2'%& $+% 3-.-9"V $+-$
5#(+(2(&6; 7-# "#21 %'%. H% (#'"T%9 $" 9%&(/#-$% $+% 3.%&&(#/ 7"#$%63".S
-.1 (6S3"&&(H(2($1 "0 %'%.1 56F&$;>
@ *+% _F%&$("# $+%# -.(&%& -& $" $+% &($F-$("# "0 $+"&% 8+" 7-# F$$%. -#9
7"63.%+%#9 $+% &(/#(0(7-#7% "0 $+% 8".9 -$ -22B -#9 h 0". =(%$A&7+% -& 0".
+(& +%(.& h "#21 $+"&% 8+" +-'% $+%6&%2'%& 3-&&%9 $+."F/+ #(+(2(&6 -.% (#
- 3"&($("# $" .%7"/#(&%B -00(.6 -#9 &F.3-&& ($4
M% $+-$ &3%-T& +%.%B 7"#'%.&%21B +-& 9"#% #"$+(#/ &" 0-. HF$ .%02%7$ > > > $+%
0(.&$ 3%.0%7$ #(+(2(&$ "0 UF."3% 8+"B +"8%'%.B +-& %'%# #"8 2('%9 $+."F/+
$+% 8+"2% "0 #(+(2(&6B $" $+% %#9B 2%-'(#/ ($ H%+(#9B "F$&(9% +(6&%20>
`=(%$A&7+% )XN?B @a
M%#7% $+% -2(%#-$(#/ (63%.-$('% $" %6H.-7% #(+(2(&6B "# "#% +-#9B -#9B "#
$+% "$+%.B $+% 6"$('-$%9 (#9(00%.%#7% "0 $+% %.- $"8-.9& -7T#"82%9/(#/ ($&
"8#6"&$ #-$F.%> *+% %.- (& #(+(2(&$(7 #"$ "#21 H%7-F&% ($ (& 8($#%&& $" $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*; <)
D M%#7% $+% 7"#$(#F(#/ '-2(9($1 "0 $+% 8".9 9%.('%& 0."6 ($& '%.1 -33%-.S
-#7% -& ,%$4$%%4C *&.*%I$&%9+4$m - $%.6(#"2"/(7-2 &$-$F& 8+(7+ $+%# 7"6%&
$" .%/F2-$% $+% '-.("F& 3"&($("#& $+-$ 7-# H% $-T%# "# #(+(2(&6 #"8>
=(%$A&7+%;& -./F6%#$-$('% 3"8%. +-& H%%# $" .%#9%. $+% 8".9 5#(+(2(&6;
(..%'"7-H21 &%20S.%02%V('%m -& E-.7F&;& -#%79"$% 6-T%& 72%-.B %'%# (0 &3"T%#
H1 -# (9("$B 5#(+(2(&6; #"8 7-##"$ 6-.T -#1$+(#/ "$+%. h 0". $+% 0%8 8($+
%-.& 9%2(7-$% %#"F/+ $" +%-. ($ h $+-# #'$ ?$&,*&$ *&%*%#$&/$ 9&. I$)%*%#$&/$
"2 #'",?'# *& #'$ 5*.%# "2 #'$ .*%9%#$) *#%$42> *+% 3."H2%6 "0 $+% 5.%'-2F-$("#
"0 -22 '-2F%&; $+%# H%7"6%& 3-.-6"F#$4 8+%.% 7-# "#% 2""T 0". '-2F%&B
/('%# $+-$ #'$)$ *% &" "#'$) =")4. +,# #'*%i `&%% M%(9%//%.B )XCCB %&3> J@h
))<a>
J ,(#7% ($ (& $+% &$-$F& "0 $+(& #'*% $+-$ .%6-(#& 3.%&%#$21 F#9%$%.6(#%9 ".
(#9%$%.6(#-H2%B 3+(2"&"3+%.& $%#9 $" &F77F6H $" - ."6-#$(7 "I#*5*%#*/
I$%%*5*%5 $+-$ '-7(22-$%& F#7"#$."22-H21 H%$8%%# - R"10F2 -3"7-213$(7(&6
-#9 - 9(&-33"(#$%9 F$"3(-#(&6 h 0". 8+(7+ $+% 7"#$%63".-.1 3"2($(7"S
3+(2"&"3+(7-2 7-22& 0". - 57"66F#($1 $" 7"6%; 7-# &$-#9 -& -# (#9%V
`K-7"F%SK-H-.$+% -#9 =-#71 )XXCm =-#71 )XX)m Q/-6H%# )XX@a> ,F7+
7"66F#($(%&B 8+(7+ 9%0(#($('%21 .%&(&$ -#1 3"&&(H2% 3"&($('% 3.%9(7-$("#B
&F33"&%921 (63%2 F& $" -$$%63$ $" $+(#T $+%6 (# -#9 $+."F/+ $+(& '%.1
(#S-77%&&(H(2($1> =(+(2(&6;& 2%/-71 $" $+% #"$("# "0 3"2($(7-2 7"66F#($1
+-& $+F& %#$-(2%9 - .%$F.# $" $.-9($("#-221 -%&$+%$(7 6"$(0& `"0 &(2%#7%B
3-.-21&(&B (..%9F7(H2% +%$%."/%#%($1B %$7>a> ,F7+ - &($F-$("# (& - 9(.%7$
7"#&%_F%#7% "0 =(%$A&7+%;& "8# &"2F$("# $" $+% 9(2%66-B 8+(7+ +(#/%&
U +$)5$&%/' `&%% =(%$A&7+%
"# -%&$+%$(7(&(#/ 0(/F.-$("#&B #"$-H21 $+% [
)XCCa>
Y$ .%6-(#& F#9%7(9-H2%B +"8%'%.B 8+%$+%. 2-$% G"6-#$(7 $+"F/+$ "0 $+(&
&".$ 7-# &$(22 "00%. - /%#F(#% 8-1 $" $+(#T H%1"#9 $+% -3".(-& /%#%.-$%9 H1 ($&
.%2(-#7% "# #(+(2(&6B ". 8+%$+%. ($& (#9%0(#($%21 %V7($(#/ _F-&(S-3"7-213$(7
+%&($-$("#& -.% $+%6&%2'%& &(632% .%02%V 6"'%& "0 6".% $.('(-2 (#&$($F$("#-2
&+(0$&> Q.% $+%.% "$+%. 8-1& "0 9%&7.(H(#/ $+% .%2-$("# H%$8%%# #(+(2(&6 -#9
,$-$% (#&$($F$("#&B "$+%. $+-# $+% 0-6(2(-. G"6-#$(7 9%#(/.-$("# "0 HF.%-FS
7.-$(7 7F2$F.%i `,%% "# $+(& 3"(#$ $+% .%7%#$B W"F7-F29(-#S(#02%7$%9B 8".T "0
MF#$%. )XX<-m )XX<Hm )XXN>a O+-$ 8% 8(&+ $" %63+-&(&% (# $+% 7"F.&% "0 $+%
0"22"8(#/ -77"F#$ "0 3"2($(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (& $+% (#$%/.-2 2(#T H%$8%%# $+%
9(&&%6(#-$("# "0 G"6-#$(7 3+(2"&"3+(&(#/ -#9 $+% %V3-#&("# "0 Y63%.(-2
%9F7-$("#-2 HF.%-F7.-7(%&> *" $+(& %#9B 8% .%$F.# $" $+% %6%./%#7% "0 3"2($S
(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (# $+% GF&&(- "0 $+% 6(9S#(#%$%%#$+ 7%#$F.1 h 7.F7(-221B 6"6%#$ 8+%# $+% $%.6 #(+(2(&6 8-& #"$ &(6321 .%&$.(7$%9 $" 3+(2"&"3+(7-2
9(&7"F.&%> O% -(6 $" &+"8 +"8 #(+(2(&6 %6%./%& -& - /,4#,)94 C",#' %#C4$B -#9
+"8 -# -&&"7(-$%9 58-. "0 0(7$("#&; (& 7%#$.-2 $" ($& (..F3$("# -#9 9(&&%6(#-S
$("# -7."&& UF."3%>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
F#/."F#9%9#%&& "0 -22 '-2F%&B HF$ -2&" H%7-F&% ($ 7-##"$ .%7"/#(&% $+(&
H%7"6(#/S#"$+(#/ "0 ($& /."F#9>
<< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
GF&&(-# 3"2($(7-2 #(+(2(&6 H%/-# 8($+ - 7.(&(& (# %9F7-$("#-2 (#&$($F$("#&B -#9
7F26(#-$%9 (# $+% 2%/%#9 "0 - 9%6"#> LF. -77"F#$ 0"7F&%& "# ,$ P%$%.&HF./
\#('%.&($1B 8+%#7% #(+(2(&6 8-& $.-#&6($$%9 2(T% - 7"#$-/("#B H%(#/ 9(&2"S
7-$%9 -#9 0(7$("#-2(&%9 (# $+% 3."7%&&B F#$(2 0(#-221 ($ 0"F#9 ($& 5+"6%; (# $+%
9%6"#(7 "./-#(&-$("# "0 ,%./%( =%7+-%'>
Y# $+% 6(9S)?JI&B GF&&(- 7"66%#7%9 ($& ^.%-$ G%0".6&B -# %&&%#$(-2 -&3%7$
"0 8+(7+ 8-& $+% .%0".6 "0 GF&&(-# +(/+%. %9F7-$("#> *+% "3%#(#/ F3 "0
GF&&(-;& F#('%.&($(%& -#9 (#&$($F$%& +-9 -# F#%V3%7$%9 %00%7$B +"8%'%.4 .-$+%.
$+-# $F.#(#/ "F$ $+% (#$%#9%9 5#%8 72-&&; "0 6-#-/%.&B ($ 3."9F7%9 - 5.-9(7-2
7"66F#($1;B T#"8# /%#%.(7-221 -& $+% #(+(2(&$&>
*" F#9%.&$-#9 +"8 $+(& "77F..%9B 8% 6F&$ .%/(&$%. $+% &($F-$("# "0 Y63%.S
(-2 GF&&(- (# $+% 6(9S#(#%$%%#$+ 7%#$F.1> *.(//%.%9 H1 9%0%-$ (# $+% !.(6%-#
O-. `)?JNaB GF&&(- +-9 0(#-221 %6H-.T%9 "# ($& ^.%-$ G%0".6& (# $+% 6(9S
)?JI&> M"3%& 0". .%0".6 7%#$.%9 "# - #%8 *&-.B Q2%V-#9%. YYm ($ &%%6%9
3"&&(H2% - #%8 %.- "0 2(H%.-2(&6 8-& 9-8#(#/> Q 2(H%.-2 /%#%.-$("# "0 -7$('(&$&
&%(A%9 $+% 7+-#7% $" -9"3$ 6"9%.#(&(#/ -#9 O%&$%.#(&(#/ 6"9%2&B -#9
_F($% .-9(7-2 7+-#/%& $" $+% &1&$%6 "0 2"7-2 /"'%.#6%#$ -#9 $" RF9(7(-2
3."7%9F.% 8%.% (#($(-$%9> *+% 7%#$.%3(%7% "0 $+%&% .%0".6& 8-& $+%
U6-#7(3-$("# "0 $+% &%.0& (# )?N)B HF$ $+% &+(0$ 0."6 - 0%F9-2 ".9%.
9%6-#9%9 &8%%3(#/ 7+-#/%& $" -22 &"7(-2 (#&$($F$("#& `&%% ,%$"#SO-$&"#
)XJ<B D?a>
!"#7F..%#$ 8($+ $+%&% %'%#$& 8-& $+% .%0".6 "0 $+% GF&&(-# +(/+%. %9F7-S
$("# &1&$%6> GF&&(- 2-7T%9 - 6(992% 72-&&B HF$ (# ($& 32-7% (#&$($F$("#& &F7+ -&
,$ P%$%.&HF./ \#('%.&($1 8%.% $" 3."'(9% - 5#%8 72-&&; F3"# 8+"&% -H(2($(%&
*&-. Q2%V-#9%. YY 8"F29 9.-8 (# 6-#-/(#/ $+% 3."7%&&%& "0 .%0".6> O($+
$&-.(&$ %V3%7$-$("# -#9 $+% 3."6(&% "0 -9'-#7%6%#$ -& $+% H-($B 0."6 )?JJ
F#('%.&($(%& 8%.% "3%#%9 $" -22 8+" 7"F29 3-&& $+% _F-2(01(#/ %V-6(#-$("#&>
*+%(. (#$-T% 7"#&%_F%#$21 &+(0$%9 0."6 - $-7($ .%&$.(7$("# $" $+% /%#$.1 $" H."-9%. (#02FV "0 )9@&"/'*&#%C h $+% 53%"32% "0 '-.("F& .-#T&; h 6-9% F3 "0
57+(29.%# "0 3.(%&$&B 9"7$".& -#9 6%9(7-2 0F#7$("#-.(%&B 6-./(#-2 2-#9S
"8#%.&B -#9 2"8%. HF.%-F7.-$&; `^2%-&"# )X?IB )<Ia> Y# $+% 8".9& "0 [-#(%2
Z."8%.4
*+% GF&&(-# &1&$%6 "0 %9F7-$("# H."F/+$ $"/%$+%. - 9('%.&% &$F9%#$ H"91
-#9 "00%.%9 -# (#$%22%7$F-2 $.-(#(#/ "# $+% H-&(& "0 8+(7+ $+%1 8%.% $"
H%7"6% 7"#&$.F7$('% 6%6H%.& "0 $+% &$-$% -33-.-$F& ". $" %#$%. 3."0%&S
&("#-2 "77F3-$("#&>
`Z."8%. )XCJB )I?a
Y# 9%'%2"3(#/ ($& "8# O%&$%.#(&%9 HF.%-F7.-$(7 72-&& "0 5+(/+21 %9F7-$%9
7-.%%. "00(7(-2&; `L.2"'&T1 )X?)B )ICaB GF&&(- 8-& 0F20(22(#/ - #%7%&&-.1 7"#S
9($("# "0 6"9%.#(&(#/ .%0".6> *+% #%%9 0". &F7+ "00(7(-2& +-9 H%%# -#$(7(S
3-$%9 0". &"6% $(6%4
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
GH$,: +/#)I '"<( -F(1%/1"(- /,2 / 4/"?#,: -%#1?J
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*; <@
*+%.% 8-& - &%#&% (# 8+(7+ $+% (#&$($F$("#-2 56"$".; "0 $+% .%0".6& h $+-$ (&B
$+% HF.%-F7.-71 h 8-& &%%T(#/ $" .%3."9F7% ($&%20B $" 3."9F7% 6".% 6-#-/%.&
"0 $+% .%0".6 3."7%&&> ,$F9%#$& %#$%.(#/ +(/+%. %9F7-$("# -0$%. )?JJ $+F&
0"F#9 $+%6&%2'%& (# - #"'%2 -#9 3"$%#$(-221 3"8%.0F2 3"&($("#4 "# $+% "#%
+-#9B $+% *&-. (#$%#9%9 $+-$ $+%1 8"F29 +%23 6"9%.#(&% GF&&(-m "# $+%
"$+%.B "29%. 2(H%.-2& &-8 $+%6 -& $+% (#+%.($".& "0 $+% 2(H%.-2(&(#/ 3."7%&&
$+%1 +-9 -2.%-91 H%/F#>
,F7+ 3"$%#$(-2 3"8%. 8-&B "0 7"F.&%B $(%9 $" $+% 7"#$(#F%9 %V3-#&"# "0 $+%
.%0".6 3."7%&&> Y$ &""# %6%./%9B +"8%'%.B $+-$ $&-.(&$ -33."'-2 "0 5%#2(/+$S
%#%9 HF.%-F7.-71; -#9 &"7(-2 .%0".6 8-& 8-#(#/> *+."F/+"F$ $+% )?NI& -#9
(#$" $+% )?CI&B 6-#1 .%0".6& 8%.% /.-9F-221 .%'"T%9 ". 8-$%.%9 9"8#> *"
$-T% "#% %V-632%B $+% %&$-H2(&+6%#$ "0 2"7-2 .%3.%&%#$-$('% H"9(%& 2%9 $" 7-63-(/# 0". - #-$("#-2 .%3.%&%#$-$('% (#&$($F$("# $+-$ $%.6(#-$%9 (# - 50".S
6-2 -#9 3FH2(7 .%HFT%; 0."6 $+% *&-. `^""9(#/ )XXNB CIa> *+% 3"2($(7-2
2%/-71 "0 $+(& .%$.%-$ 8-& $+% (#7.%-&(#/ 6-./(#-2(&-$("# "0 /%#$.1 2(H%.-2(&6B
-& $+% 3."9F7$ "0 - O%&$%.#(&%9 (#$%22(/%#$&(-> Z1 $+% )?NI&B 5$+% 9%."/-$".1
'%.H 55$" 32-1 -$ H%(#/ - 2(H%.-2;; `4*+$)94&*/'9#a > > > 8-& 8(9%21 H-#9(%9 -H"F$;
`^""9(#/ )XXNB CIa> Q2$+"F/+ - /%#%.-$("# "0 3."/.%&&('% HF.%-F7.-$& -#9
-7$('(&$& 7"#$(#F%9 $" 8".T 0". .%0".6B $+% /.-9F-2 .%-&&%.$("# "0 7"#&%.'-S
$('% -F$"7.-71 &%%6%9 $" 7"#&(/# $+%6 -#9 $+%(. 8".T $" &F3%.02F($1>
*+(& &T%$7+B 8+(7+ 3"(#$& $" H"$+ $+% 0%2$ #%7%&&($1 -#9 $+% $."FH2%9
+(&$".1 "0 $+% ^.%-$ G%0".6&B $+%.%0".% 7"#72F9%& 8($+ $+% 3%.7%3$("# "0
$+%(. 0-(2F.%B 3-.$(7F2-.21 -6"#/ $+% 1"F$+0F2 5#%8 72-&&; "0 $+% )?NI&> *+%
%.- "0 ^.%-$ G%0".6& /-'% 8-1 $" $+-$ "0 #(+(2(&6B 8+(7+ 0(.&$ "0 -22
-##"F#7%9 ($&%20 -& - .%0F&-2 "0 H"$+ -F$"7.-71 -#9 2(H%.-2(&6> Z1 $+%
)?NI&B ($ 8-& 72%-. $+-$ 8+-$ F#('%.&($(%& $-F/+$ 8-& -9'-#7%6%#$ (#$" $+%
#"H(2($1 $+."F/+ $+% HF.%-F7.-71> G-9(7-2 7.($(7 o"&&-.("# Z%2(#&T(B 0". %VS
-632%B 7"66%#$%9 "# +"8 6%# 0."6 $+% 53%$$1 H"F./%"(&B 6%.7+-#$B 72%S
.(7-2 -#9 %'%# r2-#9"8#(#/s #"H2% %&$-$%&; 8+" %#$%. $+% HF.%-F7.-71 52"&%
$+% 7.F9% $.-33(#/& "0 $+%&% %&$-$%& -#9B 0."6 0-$+%. $" &"#B -.% $.-#&0".6%9
(#$" $+% %&$-$%& "0 2".9& r+9)*&s; `Z%2(#&T( )XJ@hJXB X?hXa> ZF$ #%($+%. $+%
3."6(&% "0 (#&$($F$("#-2 -9'-#7%6%#$ #". $+-$ "0 2(H%.-2 .%0".6 7"F29 H%
%-&(21 .%7"#7(2%9 8($+ $+% 0-(2F.% "0 $+% ^.%-$ G%0".6&> K(H%.-2 .%0".6 +-9
-33-.%#$21 .%-7+%9 ($& %V3(.1 9-$%B -#9 $+% 3."&3%7$ "0 (#&$($F$("#-2 -9'-#7%S
6%#$ (# - &$-$% .%'%.$(#/ $" -F$"7.-71 8-& -# -6H('-2%#$ -#9 F#7%.$-(# "#%>
*+% 7"#&%_F%#7% 8-& $+-$ #(+(2(&6 %6%./%9 -& - 3"2($(7& 8($+"F$ - 0F$F.%> L.
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Q HF.%-F7.-71 7-3-H2% "0 /%#%.-$(#/ 3"2(71 -#9 -# -96(#(&$.-$("# %00(S
7(%#$ %#"F/+ $" (632%6%#$ ($ H%7-6% $+% /"-2 "0 -$ 2%-&$ 0"F. "0 $+% &%#(".
&$-$%&6%# 8+" &%.'%9 =(7+"2-& Y (# $+% )?DI& > > > $+%&% 0"F. > > > H%7-6%
(#&$.F6%#$-2 (# &+-3(#/ $+% (#&$($F$("#-2 H-&% "F$ "0 8+(7+ $+% %#2(/+$S
%#%9 HF.%-F7.-71 8"F29 %6%./% $" 3."9F7% $+% H."-9 .%#"'-$("#& $+-$
H%7-6% T#"8# -& $+% ^.%-$ G%0".6& &"6% $8%#$1 1%-.& 2-$%.>
`K(#7"2# )XXIB <Ja
.-$+%.B 2%&& - 3"2($(7& $+-# - &$12%4 #(+(2(&6 (# 0-7$ -33%-.%9 -& - 0-&+("#-H2%
2-H%2B 8".# H1 - 9(&3-.-$% /."F3B - T(#9 "0 7F2$F.-2 1"F$+ &$12% 2(#T%9 $" $+%
#%8 7F2$F.% "0 $+% "3%#%9SF3 -#9 HF.%-F7.-$(&%9 F#('%.&($1> O".$+ %63+-&S
(&(#/ (# $+(& 7"##%V("# (& $+% 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7 -33-.%2 "0 $+% 1"F#/ #(+(2(&$B
8+(7+ (#'"2'%9 - 9%2(H%.-$% .%0F&-2 "0 $+% 72-&& ". 5%&$-$%; 6-.T%.& "0 GF&&(-#
&"7(%$1> W%6-2% #(+(2(&$& 7F$ $+%(. +-(. &+".$B 8".% 6%#;& H""$& 8($+ 32-(#
H2-7T 9.%&&%&B -#9 &6"T%9 +%-'(21> *+% 6-2%& 9.%&&%9 (# $+% &$12% "0 $+%
8".T%.&B -#9 /.%8 $+%(. +-(.> WF.$+%.6".%B -22 #(+(2(&$& 8%.% +1/(%#(7-221
&F&3%7$> Q77".9(#/ $" ,'%$2-#- Z"164
Q&+-6%9 "0 H%(#/ $"" 7"66"# -#9 F#-H2% $" H% /"55$ *4 29,# (# $+%
$.-9($("#-2 -.(&$"7.-$(7 &%#&%B 6%6H%.& "0 $+% GF&&(-# (#$%22(/%#$&(-B -#9
%&3%7(-221 $+%(. 6"&$ .-9(7-2 .%3.%&%#$-$('%&B $+% #(+(2(&$&B 0"F/+$ -/-(#&$
I"%'4"%#N) $+."F/+ - 9%6"#&$.-$('% 9(&.%/-.9 0". 3"2($% H%+-'(".B &"7(-2
6".%&B -#9 +1/(%#%>
`Z"16 )XXDB J?a
Q& - 7"."22-.1 $" -7T#"82%9/%6%#$ "0 $+% %#C4$ "0 #(+(2(&6B ($ (& -2&" 7F&$"6S
-.1 0". 7"66%#$-$".& $" #"$% $+% .%2-$('% (#&(/#(0(7-#7% "0 (9%-& I$) %$ 0". $+%
9%'%2"36%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 9b 49 E$#$)%+,)? `,%% Z."8%. )XCJB )?h)Xm ^2%-&"#
)X?IB )@@hDa> [%&3($% $+% 7(.7F2-$("# "0 O%&$%.# (#$%22%7$F-2 7F..%#$&B -#9
$+% &$."#/ $.-9($("# "0 .-9(7-2 7F2$F.-2 R"F.#-2(&6 8% -&&"7(-$% 8($+ Z%2(#&T(
$# 94>B #(+(2(&6 (& $.-#&6($$%9 -& 2%&& -# (#$%22%7$F-2 3"&($("# $+-# - 0F#9-S
6%#$-221 -%&$+%$(7 3.-7$(7% ". &$-#7%>
O+-$ F#9%.8."$% $+(& &$-#7%i O% +-'% &F//%&$%9 $+-$ ($ 8-& 3.%7(&%21 $+%
(#&$($F$("#-2 7"#$%V$ "0 - F#('%.&($1 (# 7.(&(&4 $+% 0-(2F.% "0 F#('%.&($(%& $"
$%-7+ %($+%. -F$"7.-$(7 ". 3."/.%&&('% #-..-$('%& "0 &$-$% &%.'(7%> ZF$B 7"632(S
7-$(#/ $+(& 3(7$F.%B ($ 8-& 3.%7(&%21 $+% HF.%-F7.-$(7 .%0".6-$("# "0 $+% &%20
$+."F/+ %9F7-$("# $+-$ &%%6%9 $" /('% &$.F7$F.% $" $+% 9%0(#(#/ 0-#$-&1 "0
#(+(2(&64 $+% (6-/(#%9 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 - 7"632%$% H.%-T 8($+ $+% %V(&$(#/
".9%. $" $+% 3"(#$ "0 - 7.%-$("# "0 - &%20 `-#9 &"7(%$1a $H &*'*4"> b(.(22"'B (#
["&$"%'&T1;& B$5"&%B "00%.& - &$-$%6%#$ "0 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 #%7%&&($(%&
(#'"2'%9 (# $+(& H.%-T4
O+"%'%. 8-#$& $+% 6-(# 0.%%9"6 6F&$ 9-.% $" T(22 +(6&%20> > > > *+%.% (&
#" 0F.$+%. 0.%%9"6m +%.% (& %'%.1$+(#/m -#9 $+%.% (& #"$+(#/ 0F.$+%.> M%
8+" 9-.%& $" T(22 +(6&%20B (& ^"9> ="8 -#1"#% 7-# 6-T% ($ &" $+-$ $+%.%
8(22 H% #" ^"9B -#9 $+%.% 8(22 H% #" -#1$+(#/>`["&$"%'&T1 )XXDB ))Jh)Na
P>^> q-(7+#%'&T1;& F#9%./."F#9 3-63+2%$ "0 E-1 )?N<B %#$($2%9 5o"F#/
GF&&(-;B $""T F3 $+% _F%&$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 &"7(%$1B F./(#/ $+% #%7%&&($1 "04
- .%'"2F$("#B - H2""91 -#9 3($(2%&& .%'"2F$("#B - .%'"2F$("# 8+(7+ 6F&$
7+-#/% %'%.1$+(#/ 9"8# $" $+% '%.1 .""$&B F$$%.21 "'%.$+."8(#/ -22 $+%
0"F#9-$("#& "0 3.%&%#$ &"7(%$1>
`7($%9 (# f%#$F.( )XNIB <X<a
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*; <J
r$+%s F2$(6-$F6 "0 "F. 7-634 8+-$ 7-# H% &6-&+%9 &+"F29 H%m 8+-$
&$-#9& F3 F#9%. H2"8& (& -77%3$-H2%B -#9 8+-$ 02(%& (#$" - $+"F&-#9 3(%7%&
(& $.-&+
`P(&-.%' )X@DB NNa>
K%' E"9A-2%'&T1 /('%& F& -# "%9(3-2(&%9 '%.&("# "0 $+(& (63F2&%4
O% h 1"F$+ h H"2921 -#9 $.(F63+-#$21 9%#(%9 3.%'("F& 3.(#7(32%& "0
6".-2($1 -#9 7($(A%#&+(3B -2$+"F/+ #%8 "#%& +-9 #"$ 1%$ H%%# 0"F#9>
Q#9 (# 0-7$ #" "#% 8-& (# - +F..1 $" 0(#9 $+%6 -#9 -22 %#%./(%& 8%.%
%V3%#9%9 "# .%R%7$("#> > > > U632"1(#/ $+% 0.%%9"6 8+(7+ +-9 H%%#
/.-#$%9 $" F&B $" 8+(7+ 8% 8%.% #"$ -& 1%$ -77F&$"6%9B 8% &""# &$"33%9
-$$%#9(#/ $+% 2%7$F.%& "0 &$.(7$ -#9 H".(#/ 3."0%&&".&B 8+" /-'% F& $+%(.
T#"82%9/% (# &"6% T(#9 "0 9%-9 0".6> > > >
`E"9A-2%'&T1 )X)CB )@NhCa
Q#"$+%. 1"F#/ #(+(2(&$B P."T+". [%H"/".1SE"T(1%'(7+B 8.($%& (# +(& 6%6S
"(. "0 - '(&($ $" +(& 0".6%. +%-96-&$%.B H%0".% 8+"6 +% 3-.-9%9 8($+ 52"#/
+-(.B H2F% &3%7$-72%& -#9 8-2T(#/ &$(7T;B 8+(2% 3.%$%#9(#/ #"$ $" .%7"/#(&%
+(6 `7($%9 (# M(#/2%1 )XNCB <Ja> =(+(2(&$ 1"F$+ +%.% (& "33"&%9B 0(.&$ "0 -22B $"
($& "8# $%-7+%.&>
,F7+ (#7(9%#$& 8%.% 3-.$ "0 $+% +FHHFH "0 3"2($(7-2 -7$('($1 $+-$ 7-6% $"
7+-.-7$%.(&% GF&&(-# +(/+%. %9F7-$("# -$ $+(& $(6%> Q 0F.$+%. %V-632% 8(22
+%23 (22F&$.-$% $+% 8-1 .-9(7-2(&6 8-& (#$%.$8(#%9 8($+ %9F7-$("#-2 HF.%-FS
7.-$(&-$("#B -#9 +"8 #(+(2(&6 7"-2%&7%9 3.%7(&%21 "# $+% 2)*&?$% "0 $+% F#(S
'%.&($1B -& - .-9(7-2 7"66F#($1 $+-$ .%0F&%9 $" *.$&#*2C ($&%20B .%6-(#(#/
5F#9%./."F#9; -#9 F#.%7"/#(&-H2% $" $+% $8(# 3"2($(7-2 7F..%#$& "0 .%0".6
-#9 .%-7$("#>
,$ P%$%.&HF./ \#('%.&($1 8-& "#% "0 $+% 6-(# &($%& "0 &$F9%#$ F#.%&$B -#9 (#
)?N) $+% &"S7-22%9 5E-1 GF2%&; 8%.% H."F/+$ 9"8#B 8+(7+ 7"#&$($F$%9 -#
-$$%63$ H1 0(-$ $" %#9 &$F9%#$ 7".3".-$(&6 -$ $+(& -#9 "$+%. F#('%.&($(%&>
P%$%.&HF./ .%&(&$-#7% $" $+% #%8 GF2%& 7%#$.%9 "# $+% (&&F% "0 (9%#$(0(7-$("#
H""T2%$&B 8+"&% (#$."9F7$("# +-9 (# 0-7$ H%%# &F//%&$%9 H1 2(H%.-2 3."0%&&".&
-& 3-.$ "0 -# -$$%63$ $" 6%9(-$% H%$8%%# &$F9%#$& -#9 $+% 6(#(&$.1 "0
%9F7-$("#4
*+% (9%- 8-& $+-$ $+% #%8 .%/F2-$("#& &+"F29 H% (#72F9%9 (# - H""T2%$
$+-$ 8"F29 -2&" 7"#$-(# $+% &$F9%#$;& .%&(9%#71 3%.6($B /.-9%&B -#9
2(H.-.1 7-.9 h &"6%$+(#/ -2"#/ $+% 2(#%& "0 $+% ^%.6-# F#('%.&($1 A#,J
.*,5+,/'B T#"8# -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 [".3-$ -& - 39#)*;$4 -#9 (# GF&&(-#
-& - 59#)*;,4> *+F& - 7"#'%#(%#$ &16H"2 "0 $+% "33.%&&('% #%8 ".9%. 8-&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
K%$ F& %V-6(#% &"6% 0F.$+%. (#&$-#7%& "0 $+(& &$-#7%B -& &$-$%9 H1 &"6%
0".6%. &$F9%#$& "0 ,$ P%$%.&HF./ \#('%.&($1B &" -& $" H%/(# $" 2"7-$% ($ (# -#
(#&$($F$("#-2 7"#$%V$> Y$ (#'"2'%& -# -$$($F9% H2F#$21 %#F#7(-$%9 H1 3+(2"2"/1
&$F9%#$ [(6($.( P(&-.%' (# )?N)4
<N !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Y# L7$"H%.B )?N)B -0$%. 9%6"#&$.-$("#& -#9 9%-92"7T&B &$F9%#$& 8+" +-9 #"$
-77%3$%9 $+%(. 59#)*;,4C 8%.% 9(&6(&&%9 0."6 $+% F#('%.&($1> U#&F(#/ .("$&
6%-#$ $+-$ $+% F#('%.&($1 8-& %'%#$F-221 72"&%9 F#$(2 QF/F&$B )?N@> Y$ 8-&
$+F& $+% .%0F&-2 $" (9%#$(01 "#%&%20 0".6-221 $" $+% F#('%.&($1 $+-$ +%23%9
0".6 $+% &$F9%#$& (#$" - 7"+%&('% 72-&& "0 =%8 P%"32%> Q#9 8+(2% $+%
6-R".($1 "0 &$F9%#$& 8"F29 .%3%-$%921 .%$F.# $" $+% /"-2 "0 &$F9%#$ 7".3".S
-$(&6 $+."F/+ $+% )?NI&B ($ H%7-6% - 9%0(#(#/ 0%-$F.% "0 $+% #(+(2(&$& $+-$
$+%1 7"#$(#F%9 $" .%0F&% $" (9%#$(01 $+%6&%2'%& (# $+% $%.6& "0 3FH2(7 -#9
.%3.%&%#$-$("#-2 3"2($(7&> G-$+%.B $+%1 %&$-H2(&+%9 $+%6&%2'%& (# $+% 0".6 "0
F#9%./."F#9 .%'"2F$("#-.1 "./-#(&-$("#& "3%.-$(#/ "# $+% 0.(#/%& "0 $+%
F#('%.&($1>
Y# $+(& 7"##%V("#B (0 8% &T(3 0".8-.9 "#21 - 0%8 1%-.&B $" )?N?B 8% 7-$7+
$+% 0(.&$ 3FH2(7 /2(63&%& "0 ,%./%( =%7+-%' -$$%#9(#/ ,$ P%$%.&HF./ \#('%.S
&($1> M% (& -96($$%9 F#9%. $+% 7-$%/".1 "0 50.%% -F9($".; -#9 7+(%021 &3%#9& +(&
$(6% $+%.% F#9%.6(#(#/ &$F9%#$ -$$%63$& $" 0".6 .%3.%&%#$-$("#-2 H"9(%&B
&%%T(#/ (#&$%-9 $" (#&$-2 +(6&%20 -& 2%-9%. "0 - .%'"2F$("#-.1 "./-#(&-$("#
`^2%-&"# )X?IB @DNhJIa> Q& - 0.%%S02"-$(#/ .-9(7-2B =%7+-%' +-9 #-$F.-221
0"F#9 +(& 8-1 $" P%$%.&HF./B 9%&7.(H%9 H1 ["&$"%'&T1 -& $+-$ 56"&$ -H&$.-7$
-#9 (#$%#$("#-2 7($1; `["&$"%'&T1 )XC<B )Ca> Q& 8%22 -& 5"00%.(#/ $+% H%&$
"33".$F#($(%& 0". 1"F#/ "00(7(-2& $" -9'-#7% $+%(. 7-.%%.&; `K(#7"2# )XXIB
)XaB P%$%.&HF./ +-9 $+% 6"&$ 9%'%2"3%9 .-9(7-2 7"66F#($1> *+% &$F9%#$
3"3F2-$("#& "0 $+.%% (#&$($F$("#& h $+% F#('%.&($1B $+% E%9(7-2S,F./(7-2 Q7-9S
%61B -#9 $+% *%7+#"2"/(7-2 Y#&$($F$% h +-9 56%./%9 (#$" "#% H"91B 72"&%21
7"##%7$%9 H1 7"66"# 2"9/(#/&B 0.(%#9&B -#9 .""66-$%&; `^2%-&"# )X?IB
@DJa> ,$F9%#$& "0 $+% Q7-9%61 +-9 .%#$%9 $+% 02"". "0 - #%-.H1 +"F&% -& 6%%$(#/ '%#F%> G%&3"#9(#/ $" &$F9%#$ .-9(7-2(&6B $+% 6(#(&$%. "0 8-.
-./F%9 $+-$ $+% &$F9%#$& H% 5$.-#&0".6%9 (#$" 7($1 .%&(9%#$& F#9%. $+% RF.S
(&9(7$("# "0 $+% /%#%.-2 3"2(7%; `($&#)94 A#9#$ >*%#")*/94 7)/'*F$% "2 L$&*&?)9.B
7($%9 (# Z."8%. )XCJB )@Ch?a> ,F7+ 3"2(7(%& %#7"F.-/%9 &$F9%#$& $" 6"'%
H%1"#9 $+% &3+%.% "0 &$F9%#$ 3"2($(7&B H1 9(&32-7(#/ $+%6 H"$+ /%"/.-3+S
(7-221 -#9 3"2($(7-221>
Z%0".% 9%'%2"3(#/ $+(& -77"F#$ "0 GF&&(-# 3"2($(7-2 #(+(2(&6 0F.$+%.B 2%$ F&
6-.T &"6% "0 ($& 7%#$.-2 0%-$F.%&> O% +-'% %63+-&(&%9 #(+(2(&6;& .""$& (#
1"F$+ &$12%B (# #%/-$("#B (# $+% &$.F7$F.%& "0 &$-$% %9F7-$("#> ^('%# $+-$
#(+(2(&6 2-7T& $+% 7"#&(&$%#71 "0 - 3"2($(7"S3+(2"&"3+(7-2 3"&($("#B ($ -33%-.&
.-$+%. -& - HF#92% "0 72-(6& -#9 9(&S(9%#$(0(7-$("#&B -& -# %6%./%#$ $%.6>
Q7T#"82%9/%6%#$ "0 $+(& &$-$F& #%7%&&-.(21 6(2($-$%& -/-(#&$ 9%0(#($("# "0
#(+(2(&6 $*#'$) -& -# (9%#$(0(-H2% 53+(2"&"3+(7-2; 6"'%6%#$ ") -& 6%.%21 -#
-#"6(7 &FH7F2$F.%> Y#&$%-9B (#'%&$(/-$(#/ $+% .%7%3$("#& -#9 7"#9($("#& $+-$
9%$%.6(#% ($& -33%-.-#7%B 8% +-'% 3"(#$%9 $" #(+(2(&6;& .%/F2-$(#/ 0-#$-&1 h
$+% 7.%-$("# "0 - &%20 -#9 &"7(%$1 $H &*'*4" h -#9 $" $+% (#&$($F$("#-2 &%$$(#/ 0".
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
9.%-6%9 F3 H1 $+% 2(H%.-2 "33"&($("# -#9 (&&F%9 H1 $+% .%-7$("#-.1
-F$+".($(%&>
`^2%-&"# )X?IB )J@hDa
($& %6%./%#7%> Y# %63+-&(&(#/ $+%&% 0%-$F.%&B "F. -77"F#$ "33"&%& ($&%20 $"
$+% 2(H%.-2 (9%-2(&6 "0 - 7.($(7 &F7+ -& ZF.$"# ^2%-&"#B 8+" 8"F29 (#&%.$
GF&&(-# #(+(2(&6 (#$" $+% #-..-$('% "0 $+% %'"2F$("# "0 3"3F2(&$ 7"#&7("F&S
#%&& (# GF&&(-> ^2%-&"# 3F$& - .%0".6(&$B 3"3F2(&$B 6".-2 &2-#$ "# GF&&(-;&
)?NI& .-9(7-2 1"F$+ 6"'%6%#$&B 8+%.%-& ($ +-& H%%# -./F%9 $+-$ #(+(2(&6
3."7%%9& 3.%7(&%21 0."6 - )$2,%94 "0 6".-2 -#9 .%0".6(&$ 7.($(_F%>
W". &"6%8+-$ 9(00%.%#$ .%-&"#&B "F. -#-21&(& -2&" "33"&%& ($&%20 $" E-.V(&$
-77"F#$& $+-$ .%9F7% #(+(2(&6 $" - 3"2($(7-2 .%02%V H".# "0 $+% &+(0$ 0."6 0%F9-2 ".9%. $" $+% 7-3($-2(&$ 3+-&% "0 GF&&(-# +(&$".1> ="$ "#21 9" 8%
#"$ $.F&$ $+% /%#%.-2($1 "0 /.%-$ %7"#"6(7 3+-&%& -#9 $+% 2-#/F-/% "0
72-&&S&$.F//2%B HF$ $+% $%2%"2"/(7-2 (632(7-$("#& "0 &F7+ -77"F#$& -2&" (#&%.$
#(+(2(&6 (# - $.-R%7$".1 $+-$ 8(22 (#%'($-H21 7"#72F9% 8($+ $+% $.(F63+ "0
7"66F#(&6B -& (0 "#% 2%9 $" $+% "$+%.> O+(2&$ K%#(# 9(9 (#9%%9 -96(.% H"$+
=%7+-%' -#9 !+%.#1&+%'&T1B 8+-$ +% $""T 0."6 $+%6 8-& #"$ &" 6F7+ 3"&($('% 3"2($(7-2 3."R%7$B HF$ .-$+%. - 7"'%.$21 -%&$+%$(7(&%9 7"#7%3$("# "0
.%'"2F$("#-.1 &%20S -#9 3-.$1S0".6-$("# `&%% "# $+(& 3"(#$ ,7+-3(." )X?NB
)??h<J@ -#9 W(/%& )XXNB )@Ih@a>
^('%# #(+(2(&6;& F#7%.$-(# &$-$F& -& - I"4*#*/94 6"'%6%#$B $+(& (#+%.($-#7%
8-& 3%.+-3& $" H% %V3%7$%9> P-.$1S3"2($(7-2 72-(6& $" #(+(2(&6 +-9 -28-1& $"
7"#$%#9 8($+ ($& .""$& (# 1"F$+ &$12% -#9 ($& .%0F&-2 "0 .%3.%&%#$-$("#-2
3"2($(7&> [%&3($% "77-&("#-2 -9+%.%#7% $" '-.("F& 9"7$.(#%&B 8+-$ H"F#9
$+% .-9(7-2 7"66F#($1 "0 $+% #(+(2(&$& $"/%$+%. 8-& $+%(. 3.-7$(7% "0 -#
9&9$%#'$#'*/%> O+-$ 8% -.% 9%&(/#-$(#/ H1 $+% #%"2"/(&6 9&9$%#'$#'*/% -.%
$+% %00%7$& "0 - HF.%-F7.-$(7 %'%#$ $+-$B (0 ($ (& .%/(&$%.%9 -%&$+%$(7-221 H1 $+%
H"9(%& 8+(7+ ($ -00%7$& `(>%> (# 9.%&&B 7"63".$6%#$B 7".3".%-2 9(&3"&($("#B
%$7>aB #"#%$+%2%&& 7-##"$ H% %-&(21 .%7"#7(2%9 8($+ $+% $%.6& "0 G"6-#$(7
-%&$+%$(7&> ZF.%-F7.-71B -0$%. -22B +-& 7"#&(&$%#$21 H%%# 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 -& $+%
"33"&($% ". #%/-$("# "0 -%&$+%$(7&m "#% "0 $+% 3.%&F63$("#& 8% -.% 7"#$%&$S
(#/ (& 3.%7(&%21 $+% &$-$F& "0 $+(& "33"&($("#> WF.$+%.6".%B $+(& 7"#7%3$ "0
9&9$%#'$#'*/% +%23& $" 9(&$(#/F(&+ #(+(2(&6 0."6 $+"&% -33-.%#$21 6".% -00(.S
6-$('% 3"2($(7-2B &"7(-2 ". &7(%#$(0(7 3."/.-66%& 8($+ 8+(7+B -& 8% &+-22 &%%B
($ (& "0$%# -&&"7(-$%9 h 0". %V-632%B 3"&($('(&6 ". F$(2($-.(-# &"7(-2(&6> =(+(2S
(&6 (& - &+"7T(#/ %'%#$B -#9 #"$ &(6321 - 9"7$.(#%>
[%&3($% "F. .%0%.%#7% $" #(+(2(&$ &$12%B -$$%#$("# +-& #"$ 1%$ H%%# /('%# $"
-#"$+%. -&3%7$ "0 ($& -%&$+%$(7 9%0(#($("#> W."6 ($& (#7%3$("# -& - 1"F$+ &$12%B
#(+(2(&6 8-& &FHR%7$ $" - 58-. "0 0(7$("#&;> L#% 7-# $.-7% $+% H%/(##(#/& "0
$+(& 8-. $" *F./%#%';& #"'%2 "0 )?N<B :9#'$)% 9&. A"&%B 8+(7+ $""T $+% 2-H%2
"0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 50-&$%#%9 > > > r($s 0(.621 "# $+% 1"F#/%. /%#%.-$("#; `E"&%.
)XNDB )?a>
:9#'$)% 9&. A"&% 8-& 8.($$%# "F$ "0 - 0-&7(#-$("# h H".9%.(#/ "# (#0-$F-$("#
h 8($+ $+% 3"2($(7-2 .-9(7-2& "0 $+% /%#%.-$("# 0"22"8(#/ *F./%#%';&4 $+% &"S
7-22%9 )?NI& 6%#> Y# 9%3(7$(#/ $+(& /%#%.-$("#B *F./%#%' 3".$.-1& +(& 7%#$.-2
7+-.-7$%. Z-A-."' -& - T(#9 "0 Z1."#(7 6-$%.(-2(&$ `^2%-&"# )X?IB C<aB 8+"
&3%#9& +(& -0$%.#""#& 9(&&%7$(#/ 0."/& -#9 +(& %'%#(#/& 9%6"2(&+(#/ $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*; <C
2(H%.-2 (22F&("#& "0 $+% "29%. /%#%.-$("#> Q2$+"F/+ $+% #"'%2 8".T& 8($+
/%#%.(7-221 ."6-#$(7 %2%6%#$&B ($ /-(#& ($& (63-7$ 0."6 $+% 9(&&"#-#7%
3."9F7%9 8($+(# $+(& 0.-6%8".T H1 $+% #%8 #(+(2(&$ +%."B 8+" .%3.%&%#$&
#%/-$("# -#9 - +-.&+21 3"&($('(&$(7 .%-2(&6> Y# %00%7$B $+% #"'%2 (& %#%./(&%9
H1 ($& 8(22(#/#%&& $" H% 3"&&%&&%9 H1 $+% 0".7% "0 #(+(2(&6 8+(7+ Z-A-."'
%6H"9(%&>
Q& - &$-#7% -#9 &$12%B #(+(2(&6 /-(#%9 - 0F$F.% 0."6 *F./%#%'4 $+% 3."$"S
$13(7-2 -#$(S.%0".6(&6 "0 Z-A-."' %V7($%9 9%H-$% `Z%.2(# )XCXB <?Ih?a -#9 3."2(0%.-$("# "0 9%3(7$("#&> *+% 6"&$ (#02F%#$(-2 .-9(7-2 .%&3"#&% $" *F.S
/%#%' 7-6% 0."6 =(T"2-( !+%.#1&+%'&T1 8($+ +(& #"'%2 P'9# -% #" <$
B"&$i `)?N@a> *+(& #"'%2B - 3"3F2(&$B F$(2($-.(-# &"7(-2(&$ -#&8%. $" :9#'$)%
9&. A"&%B 9%3(7$%9 $+% %V%632-.1 2('%& "0 $+% #%8 3%"32%> Q6"#/ $+%6 8-&
-# -'-#$S/-.9% ,F3%.6-# 0(/F.%B G-T6%e$"0B T#"8# -& 5$+% .(/".(&$; `!+%.#1S
&+%'&T1 )X?NB <CJaB (# 3-.$ 0". +(& 3."3%#&($1 $" &2%%3 "# - H%9 "0 #-(2&4
G-T6%e$"0 "3%#%9 $+% 9"". 8($+ - 6%2-#7+"21 H."-9 &6(2% > > > $+% H-7T
-#9 &+"F29%.& "0 +(& F#9%.72"$+%& > > > 8%.% &"-T%9 8($+ H2""9 > > > $+"FS
&-#9& "0 2($$2% #-(2& > > > G-T6%e$"0 +-9 H%%# 21(#/ "# $+%6 -22 #(/+$ 2"#/>
`!+%.#1&+%'&T1 )X?NB <?Ja
K-$%.B K%#(# $""T F3 $+% $($2%B -#9 $+% #"$("# "0 - .%'"2F$("#-.1 %e2($%m
!+%.#1&+%'&T1;& #"'%2B +% 7"#0%&&%9B +-9 57+F.#%9 6% (#&(9% "F$; `,%%
f-2%#$(#"' )XJ)B )X@h<)N -#9 ,7+-3(." )X?NB )?Nh<J<a> Y# G-T6%e$"0B +%
-99%9B "#% &-8 8+-$ - 58+-$ - .%'"2F$("#-.1 5,%# +$ 4*;$; `W(/%& )XXNB )@)a>
K%#(#;& .%&3"#&% 8-& #"$ F#F&F-2> \#9%./."F#9 /."F3& 0".6%9 $" 32-#
$+% (632%6%#$-$("# "0 P'9# -% #" <$ B"&$i -#9 0."6 "#% "0 $+%&%B - /."F3
#-6%9 >$44 `- 7%22 "0 - &2(/+$21 2-./%. /."F3 #-6%9 Q)?9&*@9#*"&aB 7-6% 0-(2%9 )?NN -$$%63$ "# $+% 2(0% "0 $+% *&-.B H1 [6($.1 b-.-T"A"'> *+% 7"#S
&F63$("# "0 #(+(2(&$ 0(7$("#& H1 1"F#/ #(+(2(&$& 0%9 H-7T (#$" $+% %'"2F$("# "0
$+% .-9(7-2 7"66F#($14 $+% 0(/F.% "0 $+% &%20S-##(+(2-$(#/ &F3%.6-# "00%.%9
$" b-.-T"A"'B .%7%#$21 9(&6(&&%9 0."6 E"&7"8 \#('%.&($1 0". (#-H(2($1 $" 3-1
+(& $F($("# 0%%&B - &"2F$("# $" +(& &F(7(9-2 (#72(#-$("#& -#9 9(&%#7+-#$6%#$
8($+ $+% GF&&(-# &$-$%>
!"#$.(HF$(#/ $" $+% 9(&7F&&("# "0 #(+(2(&6B $""B $+."F/+"F$ $+% )?NI&B
8%.% - &%.(%& "0 -#$(#(+(2(&$ #"'%2&B #F6%."F& 3"2(7% .%3".$& `,%% Z."8%.
)XCJB )CB )<NB )N@aB -#9 $+% (#$%.#%7(#% 0%F9(#/ "0 .-9(7-2 R"F.#-2(&$& `,%%
K-63%.$ )XC)B <?)hDa> Q 0(#-2 3"(#$ $" H% 6-9% (# $+(& 7"##%V("# .%2-$%& $"
$+% 7.F7(-2 0".6-$('% ."2% 32-1%9 H1 7F2$F.% (# #(#%$%%#$+S7%#$F.1 GF&&(->
P-.$21 -& - 7"#&%_F%#7% "0 $+% 7%#&".&+(3 "0 "3%# 3"2($(7-2 9%H-$%B 52($%.-$F.%
H%7-6% $+% H-$$2%/."F#9 "# 8+(7+ $+% 7%#$.-2 &"7(-2 -#9 3"2($(7-2 (&&F%& "0
2(0% 8%.% 0"F/+$ "F$; `Z%.2(# )XCXB <NJaB -#9 GF&&(- 8-& 5- 7"F#$.1 &" "3%# $"
2($%.-.1 (#02F%#7% $+-$ 6-#1 (#9('(9F-2& 8"F29 9%7(9% $" .%6"9%2 $+%(. 2('%&
-0$%. 3%.F&(#/ - &(#/2% 3"%6B #"'%2 ". 8".T "0 3"2($(7-2 3+(2"&"3+1; `M(#/2%1
)XNCB DIa> =(+(2(&6 6-.T%9 - 7.($(7-2 3"(#$ (# $+(& 7F2$F.-2 +(&$".1 "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
-%&$+%$(7 (#02F%#7%> K(T% $+% #(#%$%%#$+S7%#$F.1 7-$%/".1 "0 $+% -%&$+%$(7
($&%20B 8+(7+ .%&(&$& $%-7+(#/ -#9 3-.-3+.-&%B $+% #(+(2(&$& 8%.% H".# "0 $+%(.
"8# F#$%-7+-H(2($1> P"&($("#%9 "# $+% 0.(#/%& "0 $+% F#('%.&($1B $+%1 7-6% $"
2('% "F$ $+% 7"#$.-9(7$("#& $+-$ 0.-7$F.% $+% %6-#7(3-$".1 9.%-6& "0 2(H%.-2S
(9%-2(&$ -%&$+%$(7&> *+%(. $%63".-2 -#9 (#&$($F$("#-2 9(&2"7-$("# 6-9% $+%6
&FHR%7$& "0 - 58-. "0 0(7$("#&; -#9 3."3"#%#$& "0 -# -#$(SG"6-#$(7 9&9$%J
#'$#'*/%>
ZF$ ($ (& - 0F.$+%. 9%'%2"36%#$ 0."6 $+(& 8+(7+ 9%6-#9& "F. -$$%#$("#4
$+% .%3"&($("#(#/ "0 $+% #(+(2(&$ &FHR%7$ (# - 6(..". +(%.-.7+1B -# "./-#(&-S
$("# "0 $+% -#$(S,$-$%B +%-9%9 H1 - 9%6"#> *+% 9%6"# h (9%#$(0(%9 -& &F7+ H1
["&$"%'&T1h 8-& ,%./%( =%7+-%'B -#9 +(& %00".$& $" "./-#(&% #(+(2(&6 6-.T T(#9 "0 $%.6(#F& 0". #(+(2(&6 -& - 3"2($(7-2 6"'%6%#$> G%R"(#(#/ "F. +(&$".S
(7-2 #-..-$('% "0 #(+(2(&6B 8% $+F& #"$% $+% 8($+9.-8-2 "0 2(H%.-2 -33."'-2
-#9 &F33".$ $+."F/+ $+% )?NI& `&%% ^2%-&"# )X?IB )NIhCXaB -#9 $+% 9%'%2S
"36%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 (#$" - T(#9 "0 k-7"H(#(&6B (#'"2'(#/ &%7.%$('% /."F3&
8+" 0"6%#$%9 (# (&"2-$("# $+%(. 32-#& "0 .%'"2F$("#-.1 $%..".(&6> Y$ (& (# $+%
7"#$%V$ "0 $%..".(&$ 7%22& $+-$ 8% 0(#-221 %#7"F#$%. $+% 2%/%#9-.1 0(/F.% "0
,%./%( =%7+-%'B 8.($%. "0 $+% 6"&$ (#0-6"F& &$-$%6%#$ "0 3"2($(7-2 #(+(2(&6B
$+% 1$F"4,#*"&9)C (9#$/'*%5>
=" "#% F#9%.&$""9 H%$$%. $+-# =%7+-%' $+% HF.%-F7.-$(7 -#9 %9F7-$("#-2
72(6-$% $+-$ 3."9F7%9 3"2($(7-2 #(+(2(&6> [%&3($% 1%-.& &3%#$ (# &"2($-.1
&$F91 "0 $+% ^16#-&(F6 7F..(7F2F6B - &3%22 -& -# %2%6%#$-.1S&7+""2 $%-7+%.
"0 .%2(/("#B -#9 -$$%#9-#7% -$ ,$ P%$%.&HF./ \#('%.&($1B =%7+-%' .%3%-$%921
3."72-(6%9 +(& 7"#$%63$ 0". -7-9%6(7 &$F91B 3."3"&(#/ (#&$%-9 $+% #%7%&S
&($1 "0 .%'"2F$("#-.1 I)9H*%> Y# "#% 6-#(0%&$"B 0". (#&$-#7%B -99.%&&%9 $" 5$+%
&$F9%#$& "0 GF&&(-;B 8% 0(#9 $+% $13(7-2 9%72-.-$("# $+-$4 5*+% F#('%.&($1 #"8
"#21 7.%-$%& P+(2(&$(#%& "0 &7(%#7% -#9 2-7T%1& "0 $+% /"'%.#6%#$; `7($%9 (#
f%#$F.( )XNIB @?@a> O+%# ($ 7-6% $" .%7.F($6%#$ "0 $+% 6%6H%.& "0 +(&
.%'"2F$("#-.1 "./-#(&-$("#B D'$ E$"I4$N% X$&?$9&/$B =%7+-%' 3.%&%#$%9 +(6S
&%20 -& - &%20S%9F7-$%9 8".T%.S&F3%.6-#B +%-9 "0 - &+-9"81 "./-#(&-$("#
$+-$ &$F9%#$& `#"$ -F$+%#$(7 P%"32% r&9)".&*;*s $+%6&%2'%&a 8%.% 3.('(2%/%9
$" -&&(&$>
Y# )?NXB =%7+-%' 2%0$ ,$ P%$%.&HF./ \#('%.&($1 -#9 2(#T%9 F3 8($+ E(T+-(2
Z-TF#(# (# ,8($A%.2-#9> *+%.% $+%1 8."$% -#9 32-##%9 $"/%$+%.B -#9 &%7.%$
"./-#(&-$("#& 8%.% 3."R%7$%9B &F7+ $+-$4
=%7+-%'B $+% &%20S&$12%9 .%3.%&%#$-$('% "0 - #"#S%V(&$%#$ GF&&(-# G%'"2FS
$("#-.1 !"66($$%%B .%7%('%r9s 0."6 Z-TF#(# -F$+".($1 $" -7$ (# GF&&(- -&
$+% .%3.%&%#$-$('% "0 - #"#S%V(&$%#$ G%'"2F$("#-.1 Q22(-#7%>
`!-.. )X@@B @DIa
*+%1 -2&" 0"F#9 $(6% $" 7"S-F$+". $+% 1$F"4,#*"&9)C (9#$/'*%5> =%7+-%' +-9
2"#/ .%7"/#(&%9 $+% 7%#$.-2 ."2% "0 "./-#(&-$("# (# +(& #(+(2(&$(7 3."R%7$ h
(#9%%9B K%#(# 8"F29 2-$%. .%6-.T "0 =%7+-%';& &T(22& (# $+(& .%/-.9B 5P%"32%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*; <X
7"632%$%21 0"./%$ $+-$ =%7+-%' 3"&&%&&%9 F#(_F% "./-#(&-$("#-2 $-2%#$B -#
-H(2($1 $" %&$-H2(&+ $+% &3%7(-2 $%7+#(_F%& "0 7"#&3(.-$".(-2 8".T %'%.1S
8+%.% > > > ; `7($%9 (# ,+FH )XD?B @C)h<a> L./-#(&-$("# 8-& &" 7%#$.-2 $"
=%7+-%';& H%(#/ $+-$ +% 8"F29 2-6%#$ $+-$ 5$+% -H&%#7% "0 - 32-# -#9 "0 72"&% "./-#(A-$("# +-& 3-.-21&%9 %'%.1$+(#/; `7($%9 (# f%#$F.( )XNIB @?Ja>
G%&3"#9(#/ $" $+(& 9%0(7(%#71B $+% (9#$/'*%5 "00%.%9 - &%_F%#7% "0 9(7$6%./(#/ #%/-$("# -#9 HF.%-F7.-$(&-$("#> *+% .%'"2F$("#-.1 3."$"$13% (&
0-6"F&21 9%0(#%9 -& 5- 9""6%9 6-# r > > > 8+"s +-& &%'%.%9 %'%.1 $(% 8($+
$+% 7('(2 ".9%.B 8($+ $+% %9F7-$%9 8".29; `[61$.1&+1# )XNCB <D)a> ,F332%S
6%#$(#/ $+(& (&"2-$("#B $+"F/+B (& $+% .%'"2F$("#-.1 "./-#(&-$("#4
E9)9?)9I' c4 r > > > s G%'"2F$("#-.1 7"6.-9%& r > > > s &+"F29 (0 3"&&(H2% 9(&7F&&
-22 6-R". 3."H2%6& R"(#$21 -#9 .%&"2'% $+%6 F#-#(6"F&21> Y# $+% %V%7FS
$("# "0 $+% R"(#$21 -/.%%9 F3"# 32-#B %-7+ 6%6H%. &+"F29 -7$ (#9%3%#9S
%#$21> Y# $+% %V%7F$("# "0 - #F6H%. "0 9%&$.F7$('% -7$("#&B %-7+ 6%6H%.
6F&$ -7$ -2"#%B &%%T(#/ -9'(7% -#9 7"6.-9%21 +%23 "#21 8+%# ($ (& %&&%#S
$(-2 $" $+% $"$-2 &F77%&&>
E9)9?)9I' ^a4 U'%.1 7"6.-9% 6F&$ +-'% F#9%. +(& 7"#$."2 &%'%.-2 .%'"2FS
$("#-.(%& "0 &%7"#9 -#9 $+(.9 .-#T& r > > > s M% 6F&$ 7"#&(9%. $+%6 -& 3".$("# "0 - /%#%.-2 .%'"2F$("#-.1 7-3($-2 %#$.F&$%9 $" +(& 9(&3"&-2> M%
6F&$ 9(&3"&% "0 +(& 3-.$ "0 $+% 7-3($-2 %7"#"6(7-221B &$.('(#/ -28-1& $" /%$
6"&$ -9'-#$-/% 0."6 ($>
`[61$.1&+1# )XNCB <D@a
Y# &F7+ 3-&&-/%&B =%7+-%' "F$2(#%9 $+% 6-#-/%6%#$ &$.F7$F.% -#9 3.(#7(S
32%& H1 8+(7+ #(+(2(&6 7"F29 H% 3."6"$%9>
Z1 QF/F&$B )?NXB ($ 8-& $(6% 0". I)9H*%B -#9 =%7+-%' $.-'%22%9 $" E"&7"8
-#9 H%/-# $" %#."2 .%-2 6%6H%.& (# +(& 0(7$("#-2 "./-#(&-$("#> D'$ E$"I4$N%
X$&?$9&/$ #%'%. .%-2(&%9 6".% $+-# - 0%8 9"A%# 6%6H%.&B 6"&$ "0 8+"6
7-6% 0."6 $+% P%$."'&T1 Q/.(7F2$F.-2 Q7-9%61> ZF$ +-'(#/ R"(#%9 &F7+ 7%22B $+% 1"F#/ #(+(2(&$ H%7-6% 8+-$ +% ". &+% +-9 -28-1& H%%# (#$%#9%9 $"
H%4 $+% -#"6(7 6%6H%. "0 -# %#".6"F& F#.%-2 HF.%-F7.-$(7 &$.F7$F.%> *+-$
$+(& &$.F7$F.% 9(9 #"$ (# 0-7$ %V(&$ "#21 6-9% ($ 6".% -F$+%#$(7-221 #(+(2(&$>
=%7+-%' +-9 E$"I4$N% X$&?$9&/$ 2%$$%.+%-9& -#9 6%6H%.&+(3 7-.9& 3.(#$%9B
$" (63.%&& 3"$%#$(-2 0(#-#7(-2 7"#$.(HF$".& `^2%-&"# )X?IB @NXa> U'%#$& $""T
- 6".% &%.("F& $F.# 8+%# =%7+-%' 9%$%.6(#%9 $+-$ "#% 6%6H%.B Y'-#
Y'-#"'B 8-& F#.%2(-H2%4
M% &F66"#%9 $+% 6%6H%.& 72"&%&$ $" +(6 -#9 &-(9 $+-$ $+% 7%#$.-2
7"66($$%% `- $+%".%$(7-2 (#&$($F$("# $" 8+(7+ +% "0$%# -33%-2%9a +-9 (#
($& 3"&&%&&("# %'(9%#7% 8+(7+ 3."'%9 Y'-#"';& (#$%#$("# "0 9%#"F#7(#/
$+% &"7(%$1> M% -99%9 $+-$ (# '(%8 "0 $+% 9%2(7-71 "0 $+% 6-$$%. &F7+
%'(9%#7% 7"F29 #"$ H% 3."9F7%9> Y$ 8-& F#-#(6"F&21 9%7(9%9 $" &F33.%&&
Y'-#"'>
`f%#$F.( )XNIB @?Ia
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
@I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
*+% #%V$ %'%#(#/ Y'-#"' 8-& &$.-#/2%9B $+%# &+"$ $+."F/+ $+% +%-9 H1
=%7+-%' -#9 0"F. -77"632(7%& (# $+% /."F#9& "0 $+% P%$."'&T1 Q7-9%61> M(&
0"F. 7"22%-/F%& 8%.% &""# -..%&$%9B HF$ =%7+-%' %&7-3%9 $" ^%#%'-B $.-'%2S
2(#/ $" K"#9"# -#9 P-.(&B H%0".% 0(#-221 H%(#/ -..%&$%9 -#9 %V$.-9($%9 0."6
qF.(7+ (# )?C<> M% 9(%9 (# 3.(&"# (# )??<B +-'(#/ H%7"6% - 2%/%#9 -6"#/
$+% #%8 /%#%.-$("# "0 .-9(7-2&B 8($+ 8+"6 +% 6-#-/%9 H.(%0 7"#$-7$ (# )??)
0."6 3.(&"#>
U>M> !-.. 7"66%#$& "0 =%7+-%' $+-$4 5Y# - 6%$%".(7 7-.%%.B 8+(7+ %#9%9 -$
$+% -/% "0 $8%#$1S0('%B +% -7+(%'%9 2($%.-221 #"$+(#/; `!-.. )X@@B @@Ja h 0($$(#/ $%&$-6%#$ 0". $+(& HF.%-F7.-$].%'"2F$("#-.1B "#% 6(/+$ 7"#72F9%> ZF$
["&$"%'&T1 "00%.& - 6".% (#&$.F7$('% -#-21&(& "0 =%7+-%';& &(/#(0(7-#7%> Y#
$+% #"'%2 B$5"&% +% 0(7$("#-2(&%9 $+% =%7+-%' 7-&%B 9%3(7$(#/ &6-22S$"8#
2(0%B (# 3-.$(7F2-. ($& 52"&$ H"1&;B -& 3"&&%&&%9 H1 - 0".%(/# -#9 9%6"#(7 0".7%>
=%7+-%'B ". P%$%. f%.T+"'%#&T1 -& +% (& 7-22%9 (# $+% #"'%2B -33%-.& H"$+ &%20S6-9% 9%6"# -#9 -# F#2"7-2(&-H2% 0(/F.% "0 3"&&%&&("# -#9 3-#9%6"#S
(F6> ["&$"%'&T1 $+F& %&$-H2(&+%9 $+% 2%/-71 "0 #(+(2(&6 0". $+% $8%#$(%$+
7%#$F.1B 3.%&%#$(#/ $+% 9%6"#(7 =%7+-%' -& ($& F2$(6-$% 3."9F7$> LF.
-77"F#$ %7+"%& ["&$"%'&T14 =%7+-%' (&B 0(#-221B &*'*4*%5 *#%$42 H%7-F&% +%
72"&%& $+% /-3 H%$8%%# 5HF.%-F7.-71; -#9 57F2$F.%;B "00%.(#/ $+% %V%632-.1
&$-$%6%#$ "0 H"$+ #(+(2(&$ 6-#-/%6%#$S&$.F7$F.% -#9 #(+(2(&$ &%20+""9>
*+"F/+ +% -7+(%'%& 52($%.-221 #"$+(#/;B +(& 2%/%#9-.1 2(0% -#9 3-63+2%$%%.S
(#/ +-'% $+% %00%7$ "0 &"2(9(01(#/ #(+(2(&6;& (9%#$($1 -& - 6"9% "0 $%..".(&$(7
#%/-$("# $+-$ $-T%& ($& 0".6 0."6 $+% -H&$.-7$ 3."$"7"2& "0 HF.%-F7.-71 ($&%20>
!"#$% &'"#($)$ *&+,$'
*+% _F%&$("# &$(22 .%6-(#&B #"$ "#21 -& $" 8+1 ["&$"%'&T1 8"F29 7"#&(9%.
.$5"&"4"?C $+% 6"&$ -33"&($% .%&"F.7% 0". 0(/F.(#/ #(+(2(&6B HF$ 8+1 +(&
0(/F.-$("#& -2&" 3."'%9 &" (#02F%#$(-2 h %'%# 9%$%.6(#(#/ h 0". &FH&%_F%#$
-77"F#$&> O+1 8-& ($ #%7%&&-.1 $+-$ $+% 6"#&$%.& "0 #(+(2(&6 H% 6"9%2%9B
8+%$+%. 7"#&7("F&21 ". (632(7($21B "# - &FHR-7%#$ 3-.-9(/6 "0 $+% 9%6"#i
Y# E9)9.*%$ L"%# E(2$"# 7"(#& - #%8 #-6% 0". ,-$-#;& 5+(/+ 7-3($-2;4 E9&J
.9$5"&*,5> Q& -28-1& 8($+ #%"2"/(&6&B ($& .""$& -.% '%.1 "29m ($ 2($%.-221
$.-#&2($%.-$%& 0."6 $+% -#7(%#$ ^.%%T -& 5-22 $+% 9-%6"#&;> P-#9-%6"#(F6
(& $+% 32-7% 8+%.% -22 $+% 9%6"#& 7-#B -77".9(#/ $" $+%(. "8# 2-8&B 6-T%
7"632(7-$%9 32-#&B 32"$ %00%7$('%21B &$.-$%/(&% 7.%-$('%21B -#9 .%/F2-$% "#%
-#"$+%. 8($+"F$ (#$%.0%.%#7% 0."6 ^"9> o%$B 9%&3($% ($& .(/"."F& "./-#(&-S
$("#B P-#9-%6"#(F6 (& #"$ - ,$-$%B ($ (& #"$ $+% +-.6"#("F& E"4*% ". (*F*#9%
B$*B HF$ - .%'"2F$("#-.1 !"F#$%.S ". Q#$(S,$-$% 7"#&$($F$('%21 -..-1%9 -/-(#&$
($& /2".(0(%9 "$+%.&> Y$ (&B (# ($& 9-.T -#9 &%%$+(#/ +%-.$B 9%9(7-$%9 $" $+%
"'%.$+."8 "0 %&$-H2(&+%9 2-8&B 7"#&%.'-$('% T#"82%9/%&B 6".-2 &$.(7$F.%&B
&F33"&%921 (66F$-H2% -#9 7"..%7$ &"7(-2 3.-7$(7%&B -#9 &" "#> P-#9-%6"#S
(F6 (& $+% 0(#-2 %#9B $+% 9.%-6 "0 $"$-2 T#"82%9/%B -22 $+% 9%6"#& F#2%-&+%9
%'%.1%2&%8+%.%B -22 -$ "#7%>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*; @)
Y# 7+-.-7$%.(&(#/ #(+(2(&6B ["&$"%'&T1 $+F& +-& .%7"F.&% $" -# -H(9(#/
"#$"$+%"2"/(7-2 6"$(0 8($+(# O%&$%.# 6%$-3+1&(7& -#9 -%&$+%$(7& h $+-$ "0
9%6"#"2"/1<> `L$+%. 8.($%.& 8+" .%$F.# $" $+% 9%6"#B (# '%.1 9(00%.%#$
8-1&B (#72F9% ZF2/-T"' )X??m ^(22%&3(% )XXJm b.%22 )XX<m ,"2"/FH )XXIm
O($T(%8(7A )X?J>a ["&$"%'&T1 /"%& "# $" F&% GF&&(-# #(+(2(&6 -& $+% H-&(&
0". - RF9/%6%#$ "# $+% 6"9%.# &$-$%B 8+(7+ &$-#9& .%'%-2%9 0". 8+-$ ($ (& (#
$+% .%02%7$%9 9-.T 2(/+$ "0 #(+(2(&6 h - T(#9 "0 %..-$(7 #"#S32-7%B 8+(7+
&3.%-9& $+% +%.%&1 "0 .%-&"#S"'%.S^"9>
ZF$ $+(& (& - 0-6(2(-. &$".1B #(+(2(&6 %6H.-7(#/ -#9 -##"F#7(#/ $+% 9%-$+
"0 ^"9B -#9 &" "#> O% #"$% $+-$ #(+(2(&6;& &$-$F& -& - I"4*#*/944C 2")/$2,4
I'*4"%"I'*/94 .*%/",)%$ (& $(%9 $" ($& -H(2($1 $" 0"&$%. 3-#9-%6"#(F6> Y$& $8(#S
#(#/ 8($+ HF.%-F7.-71 (& 8+-$ 32-7%& ($ -$ $+% +%-.$ "0 $+% 6"9%.# &$-$%B
/('(#/ ($ ($& %&&%#$(-221 6"9%.# 7+-.-7$%.> [%6"#&B (# $+(& .%/-.9B -.% 6%.%21
2,&/#*"&9)*$%> LF. -./F6%#$ +-& &" 0-. &+"8# $+-$ $+% 7+-.-7$%. "0 #(+(2(&6 (&
0".6%9 (# $+% (#$%.-7$("#& "0 &$-$% HF.%-F7.-7(%&B %&3%7(-221 %9F7-$("#-2
"#%&B 8($+ $+%(. &FHR%7$&> *+%&% (#$%.-7$("#& $%#9 $" 3."9F7% 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7
0(/F.%& ". $13%&B 3-.-9(/6& "0 3."0%&&("#-2(&6 ". 7"#$%&$-$".1 0".7% `&%%
E-7(#$1.% )X?JB <Ch@)m [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( )XX) "# $+% _F%&$("# "0 &F7+
7+-.-7$%.(&$(7S7"#7%3$F-2 0(/F.%&a> *+%1 /('% .(&% $" $+% 3-.-9"V(7-2 -%&$+%$(7
7"66F#($1 "0 GF&&(-# 53"2($(7-2; #(+(2(&6 -#9B &+".$21 -0$%.8-.9&B $" $+%
7+-.-7$%. "0 $+% 3%.0%7$ #(+(2(&$ %6H"9(%9 H1 =(%$A&7+% h 8+"&% "8# "'%.S
7"6(#/ "0 #(#%$%%#$+S7%#$F.1 -7-9%6(- .%3."9F7%& $+% '%.1 /%#%-2"/1 8%
+-'% /('%# 0". GF&&(-# #(+(2(&6 `&%% E-7(#$1.% )XXIB @<hJa>
*" $+(& /%#%-2"/(7-2 -77"F#$B $+%.% (& "0 7"F.&% -# %-&1 .%R"(#9%.4 $+-$ $+%
3+(2"&"3+(7-2 9(&7"F.&% "0 #(+(2(&6 3."R%7$& -# -#-21&(& -#9 %6H"9(%& -#
(#RF#7$("# $+-$ 7-##"$ &(6321 H% 9(&-.6%9 H1 -#-21&(#/ $+% 7"#9($("#& "0 ($&
%6%./%#7%> ZF$ $" -./F% (# $+(& 6-##%. (& $" 6(&F#9%.&$-#9 $+% 3"(#$ "0 "F.
/%#%-2"/1B 8+(7+ .%/(&$%.& #(+(2(&6;& %00%7$ "& I'*4"%"I'C -& 3.%7(&%21 .%#9%.S
(#/ (6S3"&&(H2% -#-21&%& $+-$ $-T% $+%(. "8# .-$("#-2 0".7% 0". /.-#$%9>
=(+(2(&6 .-9(7-221 _F%&$("#& -22 3."7%9F.%& "0 .-$("#-2 RF&$(0(7-$("#> P+(2"S
&"3+1 h (#72F9(#/ $+% 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 9(&7"F.&% "0 #(+(2(&6 h (& $+%.%H1
(#'($%9 $" .%7"/#(&% ($& (#&F00(7(%#71B -#9 $" "3%# ($&%20 $" -# "#/"(#/
.%'-2F-$("# "0 ($& $%.6& "0 .%0%.%#7%B ". %2&% $" -00(.6 - H2(#921 -H&"2F$(&$
-22%/(-#7% $" $+% 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 (#RF#7$("#> O+-$B +"8%'%.B /%$& .%7F..%#$21
%2(9%9 (# &F7+ &%20S#%/-$(#/ 7.($(_F%& -.% $+% (#&$($F$("#-2 7"#9($("#& "0
3+(2"&"3+(7-2 9(&7"F.&% ($&%20> L# $+(& -77"F#$B $+%#B $+% 3"&$S=(%$A&7+%-#
&%#&% "0 5#(+(2(&6; h "F$2(#%9 (# $+% "3%#(#/ &%7$("# "0 $+(& 7+-3$%. h +-&
H%%# "#% "0 $+% 7%#$.-2 8-1& $+-$ 3+(2"&"3+1 +-& H2(#9%9 ($&%20 $" ($& "8#
7"#$%V$&B -#9 (# $+% /F(&% "0 ($& 6"&$ $+"."F/+/"(#/ `-F$"a 7.($(_F%> Z1
7"#$.-&$B 8% +-'% $.(%9 $" &+"8 h H"$+ $+."F/+ -# (66-#%#$ 9%&$.F7$("#
"0 $+% $%.6B -#9 $+."F/+ -# -#-21&(& "0 ($& 6-$%.(-2 7"#9($("#& h $+-$ #(+(S
2(&6 *% ($& +(&$".1B - +(&$".1 (#'"2'(#/ H"$+ =%7+-%' 9&. =(%$A&7+%B -#9 $+%
(#&$($F$("#-2 (6H.(7-$("# "0 $+%&% 0(/F.%& 8($+ $+% $.-(#(#/ "0 HF.%-F7.-$&
-#9 $%-7+%.&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
@< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*; @@
) *+% #(+(2(&$B -%&$+%$%S3+(2"&"3+%.B -#9 HF.%-F7.-$ -.% 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7 0(/S
F.%& "0 6"9%.#($1B %6H"91(#/ .%3.%&%#$-$('% 2(0%S3.-7$(7%&>
< *+%1 -.% 2(#T%9 3.-7$(7-221B 3%9-/"/(7-221 -#9 7"#7%3$F-221B -#9 $+%(.
0".$F#%& -.% 9(.%7$21 -2(/#%9 8($+ $+% %V3-#&("# -#9 #%8 7%#$.-2($1 "0
/"'%.#6%#$-2 "./-#(&-$("#& -#9 3%9-/"/(7-2 (#&$($F$("#& (# $+% #(#%S
$%%#$+ 7%#$F.1>
@ *+% HF.%-F7.-$ (&B -& $+% F&F-2 7"632-(#$ +-& ($B 3-(9 0". I)".,/*&? &"#'*&?
h 6"#($".(#/B &".$(#/B 8.($(#/B $%&$(#/ $+% 6F$-H2% -#9 (63%.&"#-2 3."S
7%&&%& "0 +(& ". +%. "8# 9%S.%/F2-$%9 +-H($ ($&%20> Y# HF.%-F7.-$(7 -7$('($1B
0F.$+%.6".%B - 9(&$(#7$('%21 6"9%.# $#'"% h $+-$ (&B - 32-7% -#9 8-1 "0 2(0%
h %2-H".-$%& ($&%20B -#9 %V$%#9& ($& (#02F%#7%>
D *+% #(+(2(&$ (& -# F#%632"1%9 HF.%-F7.-$ ".B 6".% 3.%7(&%21B $+% #(+(2(&$ (&
$+-$ (#9('(9F-2 3."9F7%9 (# -#9 H1 -# F#0".%&%%# (#$%..F3$("#
H%$8%%# 3%9-/"/(7-2 $.-(#(#/ -#9 3."0%&&("#-2 %632"16%#$> Y# $+(&
&%#&%B 6"9%.# 3"8%. (& (# $+% HF&(#%&& "0 $.-(#(#/ #(+(2(&$&B -#9
9"%& #"$+(#/ %2&%4 HF.%-F7.-71B (# 0-7$B 7"6%& $" 0F#7$("# -& - .9*5"&*"%
#"I"%>
J *+% #(+(2(&$ h $.-(#%9 $" 9" #"$+(#/ "$+%. $+-# #"$+(#/B HF$ 3.%&%#$21
F#.%6F#%.-$%9 0". ($ h 2*&944C -$$%63$& $" .%'%-2 $+-$ $+(& #"$+(#/S6-&S
_F%.-9(#/S-&S%'%.1$+(#/ *% #"$+(#/ 3.%7(&%21 $+."F/+ ($& 9%&$.F7$("#>
=(+(2(&6B (# "$+%. 8".9&B $%.6(#-$%& (# 3F.% I"4*#*/%4 ($ (#&(&$& "# 3."&%7F$S
(#/ $+% #"$+(#/#%&& "0 %'%.1 %V(&$(#/ &"7(-2 H"#9>
N M"8%'%.B $+%.% (& #" 9(.%7$ #". (#%'($-H2% ."F$% H%$8%%# HF.%-F7.-71 -#9
#(+(2(&6B %$+(7& -#9 3"2($(7&m .-$+%.B -& 8% +-'% -./F%9B $+(& ."F$% 7-# H%
$.-'%.&%9 "#21 H1 8-1 "0 9&9$%#'$#'*/%> *+% -#-%&$+%$+(7& "0 GF&&(-#
3"2($(7-2 #(+(2(&6 #-6%& - 3-.-9"V(7-2 0".6 "0 3.%S3"2($(7-2 7"66F#($1B
(# 8+(7+ 1"F$+ &$12% 6-.T& - 9(&2"7-$("# -#9 9(&S(9%#$(0(7-$("# 0."6 &$-$%
.%0".6 3."7%&&%&>
*+(& 7+-3$%.;& 72"&(#/ 3"(#$ 7"#7%.#& $+% &$-$F& "0 $+(& 7-$%7+(&6> W"22"8S
(#/ =%7+-%'B #(+(2(&6 (# ($& 6-#(0"29 0".6& +-& .%/F2-.21 $-T%# -& ($& /%#%.(7
6"9% $+% #$)5*&94 .*9?&"%*%4 5*+% #(+(2(&$ (& - 9""6%9 6-#;B 0". (#&$-#7%B ".
5^"9 (& 9%-9;> ZF$B -& 8% H%/-# $+(& 7+-3$%. H1 #"$(#/B #(+(2(&6;& 9(-/#"&%&
+-'% H%7"6% F#-'"(9-H21 &%20S.%02%V('%4 0"22"8(#/ ($& 7"#$%63".-.1 -33-.(S
$("# -& (..%6%9(-H21 H-#-2(&%9B $+% $%.6;& 9(-/#"&$(7 0".7% +-& ($&%20 H%%#
32-7%9 (# 9"FH$> Y# 0-7$B "F. 7+-3$%. +-& &+"8# 8+1 8% 9" #"$ H%2(%'% (#
&F7+ 9(-/#"&%& -#16".%B -#9 8+1 $+% 7"#$(#F(#/ -$$%63$& $" 3."&%7F$%
$+%6 (."#(7-221 %#9 F3 3."'(#/ 6%.% (#$.-S(#&$($F$("#-2 .%3%$($("#& "0 $+%(.
3.%9%7%&&".&>
o%$ $+%.% 6-1 8%22 H% #(+(2(&$& -/-(#B -#9B -& -28-1&B $+% &$-$% 8(22 +-'% +-#9 (# ($> Q .%7%#$ -.$(72% H1 ^%"00.%1 M"&T(#/ (# $+% D*5$% L*#$)9)C A,II4$J
5$&# %V7($%& &F&3(7("# (# $+(& .%/-.9> M"&T(#/ h $+% 8%22S.%&3%7$%9 -F$+". "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
LF. 7"#72F&("#& 7-# H% 6"&$ %00(7(%#$21 &F66-.(&%9 (# $+% 0".6 "0 - #%"S
=%7+-%'%-# .%'"2F$("#-.1 7-$%7+(&64
@D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
*+% GF&&(-# /"'%.#6%#$ 7"F29 9" - /.%-$ 9%-2 $" 3."6"$% 7('(2 3%-7% -#9
#-$("#-2 &"2(9-.($1 H1 (#'%&$(#/ &FH&$-#$(-2 &F6& (# 7F2$F.%B %9F7-$("#
-#9 2%-.#(#/B 8+(7+ ($ +-& &+-6%0F221 #%/2%7$%9 (# .%7%#$ 1%-.&> ^%"./%
,"."& +-& -2.%-91 9"#% 6F7+ (# $+(& 9(.%7$("#> Y0 "#% ". $8" "0 $+% 2%-9(#/
GF&&(-# 0(#-#7(-2 6-/#-$%& 7"F29 H.(#/ $+%6&%2'%& $" 0"22"8 +(& %V-632%
-#9 (#'%&$ (# - 3%-7%0F2 GF&&(-# 7('(7 #-$("#+""9B $+%1 8"F29 -2&" H%
3."6"$(#/ $+%(. "8# (#$%.%&$ (# $+% &$-H(2($1 #%%9%9 0". &F&$-(#%9 %7"S
#"6(7 /."8$+> Q2-&B $+-$ T(#9 "0 0-.S&(/+$%9#%&& (& (# &+".$ &F3321 -6"#/
$+% 5#%8 GF&&(-#&;> `M"&T(#/ )XX?B )@a
D'9&; O". 0". $+-$ &+".$&(/+$%9#%&& -6"#/ $+% #%8 GF&&(-#&> W."6 "F.
3"(#$ "0 '(%8B M"&T(#/;& .%7(3% 8"F29 3."9F7% #"$+(#/ "$+%. $+-# - 0.%&+
H-$7+ "0 #(+(2(&$&>@ P%.+-3& $+-$;& #" H-9 $+(#/m -$ 2%-&$ 1"F 7"F29 H% &F.%
$+%1;9 T#"8 +"8 $" 9.%&&> ZF$ "F. 0F#9-6%#$-2 3"(#$ .%6-(#&4 8+%.%'%.
HF.%-F7.-$& -#9 $%-7+%.& -.% $.-(#%9B $+%&% (#&$($F$("#& 8(22 (#%'($-H21 3."S
9F7% $+%(. "8# =%7+-%'& -#9 =(%$A&7+%&>
C$%() Q# F#$.-#&2-$-H2% $%.6 .%2-$%9 $" T($&7+ (# ($& -&&"7(-$("# 8($+ H"F./%"(& &%#$(S
6%#$-2($1B -#9 %V32".%9 -$ 2%#/$+ H1 =-H"T"' -#9B 6".% .%7%#$21B ,'%$2-#- Z"16>
,%% Z"16 )XXDB D)hNN -#9 =-H"T"' )XDDB CI>
< LF. .%6-.T& 6F&$ H% 9(&$(#/F(&+%9 +%.% 0."6 $+"&% "0 E(7+-%2 ^(22%&3(%B 8+" -2&"
0"7F&%& (# &"6% 9%$-(2 "# $+% (6-/% "0 $+% 9%6"# (# G"6-#$(7 #(+(2(&$ $+"F/+$>
O+%.%-& ^(22%&3(%B (# 7"632%$% -77".9 8($+ - 9"6(#-#$ $.-9($("#-2 &$.-(# "0
G"6-#$(7 (#$%.3.%$-$("#B (9%#$(0(%& $+% $.F21 /.%-$ (#9('(9F-2 8($+ $+% 0".7%& "0
#(/+$B "F. 8".T -(6& $" &+"8B "# $+% 7"#$.-.1B $+-$ $+% 9%6"#& "0 #(+(2(&6 -.%
(..%9F7(H21 32F.-2> =(+(2(&6 (& - _F%&$("# "0 3-#9-%6"#(F6m ($ (& #"$ &(6321 - 0-7%S
"00 "0 (#9('(9F-2& `8+%$+%. $+%&% -.% 7"#&(9%.%9 3%.&"#&B 0".7%&B 2-8&B %$7>a>
@ Y# #"$(#/ $+(&B 8% 8(&+ 6%.%21 $" 3"(#$ "F$ $+% (#%'($-H2% .%&F2$ "0 M"&T(#/;&
3.%&7.(3$("#&B .-$+%. $+-# $" 6-T% 9%&7.(3$('% ". 3.%9(7$('% 72-(6& -& $" $+% 3"&&(H2%
7"#&%_F%#7%& "0 $+% -7$F-2 3"2($(7-2 0%.6%#$ (# GF&&(- $"9-1>
0(D()(,1(Q/-6H%#B ^> `)XX@a D'$ ("5*&? ("55,&*#C> *.-#&> E> M-.9$> E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1
"0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
pp `)XX)a L9&?,9?$ 9&. B$9#'0 D'$ E49/$ "2 !$?9#*F*#C> *.-#&> b>U> P(#TF& 8($+
E> M-.9$> E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
Q#&%22 P%-.&"#B b> `)X??a 7& -&#)".,/#*"& #" !*$#@%/'$ 9% E"4*#*/94 D'*&;$)0 #'$ E$)2$/#
!*'*4*%#> !-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
Z%2(#&T(B f> `)XJ@hJXa 5*-.-#$-&; (# E"4&"$ %"+)9&*$ %"/'*&$&**> E"&7"8>
Z%.2(#B Y> `)XC?a 1,%%*9& D'*&;$)%> M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
- &$-#9-.9 F#('%.&($1 $%V$H""T "# GF&&(-# +(&$".1 h +-& .%7"F.&% $" - #"8S
0-6(2(-. 3."/.%&&('% #-..-$('% "0 ,$-$% &%.'(7% 8+%# +% &F//%&$& $+-$4
Z"16B ,> `)XXDa ("55"& E49/$%> E-&&-7+F&%$$&4 M-.'-.9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
Z."8%.B [> `)XCJa D)9*&*&? #'$ !*'*4*%#%0 6.,/9#*"& 9&. 19.*/94*%5 *& D%9)*%# 1,%%*9> Y$+-7-#9 K"#9"#4 !".#%22 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
ZF2/-T"'B E> `)X??a D'$ 39%#$) 9&. 39)?9)*#9> *.-#&> E> ^2%##1> K"#9"#4 !"22(#&
M-.'(22>
!-..B b> `)XX<a D'$ <9&94*@9#*"& "2 !*'*4*%50 D=$&#*$#'J($&#,)C 1$%I"&%$% #" 3$9&*&?4$%%J
&$%%> Q2H-#14 ,\=o P.%&&>
!+%.#1&+%'&T1B => `)X?Na P'9# -% #" <$ B"&$S Q## Q.H".4 Q.9(& PFH2(&+%.&>
!.($7+2%1B ,> )XXC>X$)C L*##4$ Z Z Z 745"%# !"#'*&?0 B$9#'R E'*4"%"I'CR L*#$)9#,)$> K"#9"#4
G"F$2%9/%>
[-.H1B *>B Z> U/1%9B -#9 Z> k"#%&B %9& `)X?Xa !*$#@%/'$ 9&. #'$ 1'$#")*/ "2 !*'*4*%50 6%%9C%
"& -&#$)I)$#9#*"&R L9&?,9?$ 9&. E"4*#*/%> L$$-8-4 !-.2%$"# \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
[%2%FA%B ^> -#9 W> ^F-$$-.(> `)XX)a ],N$%#J/$ V,$ 49 E'*4"%"I'*$S P-.(&4 K%& %e9($("#& 9%
E(#F($>
[61$.1&+1#B [> %9> `)XNCa -5I$)*94 1,%%*9> =%8 o".T4 M"2$B G(#%+-.$ -#9 O(#&$"#>
["&$"%'&T1B W> `)XC<a !"#$% 2)"5 [&.$)?)",&.dD'$ B",+4$> M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#>
pp `)XXDa B$5"&%> *.-#&> G> P%'%-. -#9 K> f"2"T+"#&T1> =%8 o".T4 b#"30>
D'$ 6/"&"5*%#> )J]?])XX?> 5*+% =%8 *%..".(&6; )Jh)C>
U9%#B G> `)X?@a E"4*#*/94 L$9.$)%'*I 9&. !*'*4*%54 - ,$F91 "0 O%H%. -#9 =(%$A&7+%>
*-63-4 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&%& "0 W2".(9->
W(/%&B L> `)XXNa 7 E$"I4$N% D)9?$.C0 D'$ 1,%%*9& 1$F"4,#*"& ^_c^e^c\f> K"#9"#4 !-3%>
W".H%&B k> `)XX?a B959?$. O495",)> G"&% Z-14 Z.-#92 -#9 ,7+2%&(#/%.>
^-.%B Q> `)XX@a !*'*4*%5 -&/")I")9#$.> ZF#/%#9".%4 U7"SK"/(7-2 P.%&&>
^(22%&3(%B E> `)XXJa !*'*4*%5 <$2")$ !*$#@%/'$> !+(7-/"4 \#('%.&($1 "0 !+(7-/" P.%&&>
^2%-&"#B Z> `)X?Ia g",&? 1,%%*9> =%8 o".T4 f(T(#/>
^""9(#/B k> `)XXNa 1,4$)% h A,+K$/#%0 O"F$)&5$&# 9&. E$"I4$ *& 1,%%*9 ^_a^e^cc^>
K"#9"#4 Q.#"29>
^"F9&H2"6B k> `)X?Ia !*'*4*%5 9&. (,4#,)$> LV0".94 Z-&(2 Z2-7T8%22>
M%(9%//%.B E> `)XCCa D'$ ],$%#*"& ("&/$)&*&? D$/'&"4"?C 9&. Q#'$) 6%%9C%> *.-#&> -#9
Y#$."> O> K"'($$> =%8 o".T4 M-.3%. -#9 G"8>
M(#/2%1B G> `)XNCa !*'*4*%#%> K"#9"#4 O%(9%#0%29 -#9 =(7+"2&"#>
M"&T(#/B ^> `)XXCa 1,%%*90 E$"I4$ 9&. 65I*)$ ^ii\e^c^`> E-&&-7+F&%$$&4 M-.'-.9 \#(S
'%.&($1 P.%&&>
MF#$%.B Y> `)XX<-a 5Q%&$+%$(7& -#9 !F2$F.-2 ,$F9(%&; (# K> ^."&&H%./ $# 94> `%9&aB (,4#,)94
A#,.*$%> =%8 o".T4 G"F$2%9/%>
MF#$%.B Y> `)XX<Ha 5*+% MF6-#($(%& 8($+"F$ MF6-#(&6;B (# 3$9&K*&B f"2> J)B ="> @B
DCXhXI>
MF#$%.B Y> )XXN> 5W"F. Q#V(%$(%& QH"F$ U#/2(&+;B (# A",#'$)& 1$F*$=B f"2> <XB ="> )B Dh)?>
k"#-&B M> `)XN@a D'$ O&"%#*/ 1$4*?*"&0 #'$ 3$%%9?$ "2 #'$ 74*9& O". 9&. #'$ <$?*&&*&?% "2
(')*%#*9&*#C> Z"&$"#4 Z%-7"# P.%&&>
b.%22B [>W> `)XX<a B9*5"& L*2$0 >$*.$??$) 9&. L*2$JE'*4"%"I'C> Z2""6(#/$"#4 Y#9(-#\#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
K-63%.$B U> `)XC)a A"&% 7?9*&%# :9#'$)%0 A#,.*$% *& 1,%%*9& 19.*/94*%5 9&. 1$F"4,#*"&>
K"#9"#4 LV0".9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
K(#7"2#B O>Z> `)XXIa D'$ O)$9# 1$2")5%0 7,#"/)9/CR <,)$9,/)9/C 9&. #'$ E"4*#*/% "2 ('9&?$
*& -5I$)*94 1,%%*9> [%b-2HB Y22(#"(&4 =".$+%.# Y22(#"(& \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
E-7(#$1.%B Q> `)X?Ja 72#$) X*)#,$0 9 A#,.C *& 3")94 D'$")C> <#9 %9#> K"#9"#4 [F7TS
8".$+>
E-7(#$1.%B Q> `)XXIa D')$$ 1*F94 X$)%*"&% "2 3")94 6&V,*)C> K"#9"#4 [F7T8".$+>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8,%#*& (4$5$&% 9&. (')*% :$*; @J
E-.7F&B ^> `)XX@a 19&#$)% 9&. ()"=.JE4$9%$)%0 E,&; *& E"I 3,%*/ ^c``ec\> =%8 o".T4
["FH2%9-1>
E-.$(#B ^> `)X?Xa :)"5 !*$#@%/'$ #" P*##?$&%#$*&0 #'$ E)"+4$5 "2 D),#' 9&. !*'*4*%5 *& #'$
3".$)& P")4.> =%8 o".T4 P%$%. K"#/>
E"9A-2%'&T1B Z>Q> `)X)Ca 5b(&$".(( P%$%.&HF./T-/" F#('%.&($%$-B )?JCh)?JX/> YA HF6-/
K>=> E"9A-2%'&T-/";B O"4"% 3*&,F%'9?"B ="> )>
E"&%.B !>Q> `)XNDa 7&#*&*'*4*%5 *& #'$ 1,%%*9& !"F$4 "2 #'$ ^_ja%> *+% M-/F%4 E"F$"# u
!">
=-H"T"'B f> `)XDDa !*;"49* O"?"4> =".0"2TB !"##>4 =%8 [(.%7$("#&>
=-#71B kSK> -#9 P> K-7"F%SK-H-.$+% `)XXCa 1$#)$9#*&? #'$ E"4*#*/94> %9> ,> ,3-.T&> K"#9"#4
G"F$2%9/%>
=-#71B k>SK> `)XX)a D'$ -&"I$)9#*F$ ("55,&*#C> $.-#&> P> !"##%. $# 94> E(##%&"$-4 \#(S
'%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XJNa D'$ <*)#' "2 D)9?$.CdD'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94%> $.-#&> W> ^"00(#/> =%8
o".T4 ["FH2%9-1>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XN?a D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)> *.-#&> O> b-F06-## -#9 G>k> M"22(#/9-2%> =%8
o".T4 f(#$-/% Z""T&>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XC<a D=*4*?'# "2 #'$ -."4%dD'$ 7&#*J(')*%#> $.-#&> 8($+ 7"66%#$-.1 G>k>
M"22(#/9-2%> M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XCCa D',% AI";$ T9)9#',%#)9> $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%> M-.6"#9&8".$+4
P%#/F(#>
L.2"'&T1B [> `)X?)a D'$ L*5*#% "2 1$2")50 #'$ 3*&*%#)C "2 -&#$)&94 7229*)% *& -5I$)*94
1,%%*9R ^_a\e^__^> E-&&-7+F&%$$&4 M-.'-.9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
P(&-.%'B [> `)X@Da -@+)9&&C$ %"/'*&$&**9 r,%2%7$%9 U&&-1&sB E"&7"8>
,7+-3(."B K> `)X?Na 1,%%*9& A#,.*$%> K"#9"#4 !"22(#& M-.'(22>
,%$"#SO-$&"#B M> `)XJ<a D'$ B$/4*&$ "2 -5I$)*94 1,%%*9 ^_iie^c^f> K"#9"#4 E%$+F%#>
,+FHB [> `)XD?a L$&*&> =%8 o".T4 ["FH2%9-1>
,(#%2B Q> `)XC@a D'$ (49%%)""5 9&. #'$ ('9&/$44$)C0 A#9#$ 6.,/9#*"&94 1$2")5 *& 1,%%*9
,&.$) (",&# B5*#)* D"4%#"*> M-.'-.9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&4 E-&&-7+F&%$$&>
,$($%&B G> `)XC?a D'$ P"59&N% L*+$)9#*"& 3"F$5$&# *& 1,%%*9> =%8 k%.&%14 P.(#7%$"#>
,6($+B ^>Z> `)XXNa !*$#@%/'$R >$*.$??$) 9&. #'$ D)9&%*#*"& #" E"%#5".$)&*#C> !+(7-/"4 *+%
\#('%.&($1 "0 !+(7-/" P.%&&>
,"2"/FHB W> `)XXIa D'$ E$##C B$5"&> $.-#&> 8($+ (#$."> H1 ,>[> !(".-#> K"#9"#4 tF-.$%$>
f-2%#$(#"'B => `)XJ)a 5!+%.#&+%'&T1 Y K%#(#;B !"FC* T',)&94B <N>
f%#$F.(B W> `)XNNa 1""#% "2 1$F"4,#*"&0 7 >*%#")C "2 #'$ E"I,4*%# 9&. A"/*94*%# 3"F$5$&#% *&
!*&$#$$&#' ($&#,)C 1,%%*9> =%8 o".T4 ^."&&%$ -#9 [F#2-3>
O-.9B k>W> `)XXJa >$*.$??$)N% E"4*#*/94 D'*&;*&?> Q6+%.&$4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E-&&-7+F&%$$&
P.%&&>
O($T(%8(7AB ,>Y> `)X?Ja -&%9#*9+*4*#C> $.-#&> K> Y.(H-.#%> (#$."> !> E(2"&A> K"#9"#4 tF-.S
$%$> ($&#)94 A#9#$ >*%#")*/94 7)/'*F$% "2 L$&*&?)9.B 0> XI?B "> )B 9> )<JB 2> ?<> 5G%'"2(F$S
&("##"% Y &$F9%7+%&T"% 9'(A+%#(% )?NX /"9-; r*+% .%'"2F$("#-.1 -#9 &$F9%#$
6"'%6%#$& "0 )?NXsB G9#")?9 - %%C4;9B ="> )I `)X<Da>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
@N !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
@
=(%$A&7+%B =(+(2(&6 -#9 ,3(.($
O% 6F&$ 2%-.# $" 5.%-9;>
M%(9%//%.B !*$#@%/'$
E,%)$2<1%#$,
Y# $+% 3"&$+F6"F& #"$%& /-$+%.%9 F#9%. $+% $($2% P*44 #" E"=$) `=(%$A&7+%
)XN?Ha =(%$A&7+% 2-1& "F$ - $13"2"/1 "0 5#(+(2(&6;> =(+(2(&6 7"#&$($F$%&B 0(.&$B
-#9 0".%6"&$B $+% $%.6& "0 - 9(-/#"&(& "0 6%$-3+1&(7& (# /%#%.-24 0".
=(%$A&7+%B $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 9('(&("# H%$8%%# $+% $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 -#9 $+%
%63(.(7-2 %#-7$& - 9%'-2F-$("# "0 2(0% -& &F7+ -#9 (& 6"$('-$%9 -$ - 9%%3 2%'%2
H1 $+% 58(22 $" #"$+(#/;> =(+(2(&6 &%.'%&B &%7"#9B -& - 9%&7.(3$('% $%.6 $"
9%&(/#-$% $+% 3."7%&& "0 $+% &%20S9%'-2F-$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 '-2F%& `)XN?B
l<a4 (# $+(& &%7"#9 &%#&%B $+% $%.6 6-.T& $+% +(&$".(7-2 7"6(#/S$"SH% "0
6%$-3+1&(7& 9% $+% `+(&$".(7-2a %'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6> *+(.9B H%&$.(9(#/ -7$('%21
$+(& 3."7%&& "0 &%20S9%'-2F-$("#B #(+(2(&6 9%&(/#-$%& V,9 5.-9(7-2; #(+(2(&6 -#
-7$('% 7"#'(7$("# (# $+% F#$%#-H(2($1 "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 '-2F%& -#9B $+%.%0".%B
- 8(22 $" $.F$+0F2#%&&> ,(#7% $+(& 8(22 (& &$(22 3.%9(7-$%9 "# 0-($+ (# $.F$+B ($ (&
($&%20 'F2#%.-H2% $" 0F.$+%. 9%&$.F7$("# `l@a> Y# $+% 0"F.$+ -#9 0(0$+ &%#&%& "0
#(+(2(&6B #(+(2(&6 (& &($F-$%9 H1 =(%$A&7+% -& - .%&3"#&% $" $+% -H"'% $+.%%
57F2$F.%&; "0 #(+(2(&6> *+(& .%&3"#&% (& 7"F7+%9 8($+(# 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% 7-22& 9(-/#"&(& "0 %I*)*# `lCB l)<B l)DB l<<a4 "# $+% "#% +-#9B 53-&&('%; #(+(2(&6
-77"63-#(%& $+% &%7"#9 &%#&% "0 #(+(2(&6B $+% 9%&(/#-$("# "0 - 9%7-9%#$B
%V+-F&$%9 8".29 $+-$ +-& #" 6%-#(#/ -#9 #" '-2F%B ($ (& $+% #(+(2(&6 "0 $+%
&3(.($ "0 58+-$ 0".i;B $+% #(+(2(&6 "0 #9$.*,5 F*#9$m "# $+% "$+%. +-#9B 7"F#S
$%.(#/ 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6B 5-7$('% #(+(2(&6; 9%&7.(H%& $+% /%&$F.% "0 -7$('%
9%&$.F7$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 '-2F-$("# -#9 (& &%%# 5-& - &(/# "0 $+% (#7.%-&%9
3"8%. "0 $+% &3(.($; `l<<aB - 3.%2F9%B $+-$ (&B $" $+% $.-#&'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%&>
Q77".9(#/ $" $+(& $13"2"/1 $+% $%.6 5#(+(2(&6; 0". =(%$A&7+% 9%&7.(H%&
%($+%. - &$-$% "0 $+(#T(#/ -#9]". 7F2$F.% `$+% +%-2$+ ". "$+%.8(&% "0 '-2F%&
$+-$ &($F-$% $+% 32-7% "0 $+% +F6-# (# $+% 8".29a ". $+% #-$F.% "0 +F6-#
@C
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#'
.%&3"#&% $" $+(& &$-$%> *+% $8" 7-##"$ "0 7"F.&% H% &%3-.-$%9 0."6 %-7+
"$+%.4 +F6-# .%&3"#&% $" $+% 8-1 (# 8+(7+ +F6-#T(#9 '-2F%& ($&%20 (# $+%
8".29 0".6& 3-.$ "0 $+-$ '%.1 '-2F-$("#B -#9 '(7% '%.&-> Q#9 1%$ $+% 9(&$(#7S
$("# .%6-(#& (63".$-#$ &(#7%B 0". =(%$A&7+%B $+% 8-1 (# 8+(7+ 8% "F.&%2'%&
'-2F% $+% 9%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%& ".(%#$& -#9 &F&$-(#& $+% 8-1 (# 8+(7+ 8%
.%&3"#9 (# $F.# $" $+(& 9%'-2F-$("#B H% ($ -7$('%21 ". 3-&&('%21> Y# $+(& 7"#$%V$
$+.%% $+(#/& &$-#9 "F$ (# $+(& $13"2"/1 $+-$ Y 8(&+ $" %V3"F#9 H%0".% 6"'(#/
$" $+% $+%6% -#9 ".(%#$-$("# "0 $+(& 7+-3$%.>
W(.&$B 0". =(%$A&7+%B $+% 7F2$F.% "0 5'-2F%2%&&#%&&; -#9 56%-#(#/2%&&#%&&;
$+-$ 7"#&$($F$%& #(+(2(&6 `(# $+% &%7"#9 +(&$".(7-2 &%#&%a (& $+% 7"#&%_F%#7%
"0 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 7-$%/".(%& "0 5F#($1;B 5H%(#/; -#9 53F.3"&%;
$+-$ 8% +-'% 3."R%7$%9 "#$" $+% 8".29 $" 9-$% -.% #" 2"#/%. -H2% $" -.$(7F2-$%
$+% 8".29 -#9 $+% F#('%.&% 7"#'(#7(#/21> =(+(2(&6 -& - +(&$".(7-2 %'%#$ "0
$+(#T(#/ -#9 7F2$F.% 8($+(# +(&$".1 9%0(#%&B (# "$+%. 8".9&B $+% %#9 "0 2*/#*"&> Y# $+% H.(%0B HF$ %2"_F%#$B 5M"8 $+% 55G%-2 O".29;; -$ 2-&$ Z%7-6% E1$+4 M(&$".1 "0 -# U..".; (# D=*4*?'# "2 #'$ -."4% `=(%$A&7+% )XN?-B JIh)a $+(&
0(7$("# 7"6%& $" -# %#9 8($+ b-#$4 $+% 0(7$("#B $+-$ (&B $+-$ $+% 7-$%/".(-2
$+"F/+$& "0 $+% +F6-# +-'% 0".6-2 5"HR%7$('%; &$-$F& `$.-#&7%#9%#$-2
(9%-2(&6a> *+% #(+(2(&$(7 &%#&%2%&&#%&& "0 %V(&$%#7% 9"%& #"$+(#/ HF$ $.-#&S
2-$%B (# $+(& 7"#$%V$B 0". =(%$A&7+%B $+% 5-22 $"" +F6-#; &+"7T $+-$ 6%$-3+1S
&(7-2 7-$%/".(%& 9" &"# -.$(7F2-$% $+% 8".29> Y# $+(& &%#&%B #(+(2(&6 -& +(&$".(7-2 %'%#$ "0 $+(#T(#/ -#9 7F2$F.% (& #"$+(#/ HF$ $+% )$F$)%$ &(9% "0
#(+(2(&6 V,9 6%$-3+1&(7&B $+-$ (&B $+% (#&$($F$("# "0 $+%&% 7-$%/".(%& (# $+%
0(.&$ 32-7%>
*+F&B &%7"#9B -7$('% #(+(2(&6 V,9 -# -7$('%B -00(.6-$('% 0".7% "0 9%&$.F7S
$("#B (& #%7%&&-.(21 7"#7%.#%9 8($+ #(+(2(&6 (# $+% 0(.&$ /%#%.-2 &%#&%4 $+%
#(+(2(&6 "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 &7+%6-$(&-$("# -#9 '-2F-$("# -& &F7+> Y$ (&B (# "$+%.
8".9&B #%7%&&-.(21 7"#7%.#%9 8($+ $+% 0-7$ $+-$ 6%$-3+1&(7& (& #" +$?*& =*#'
5#(+(2(&$(7;B 8($+ $+% 0-7$ $+-$ &32($$(#/ 2(0% (#$" $8" 8".29&B $8" (#&$-#7%& ".
$8" 3.(#7(32%& `$+% %63(.(7"S$.-#&7%#9%#$-2 9('(9% 0."6 P2-$" $" b-#$aB
6%$-3+1&(7-2 $+(#T(#/ -#9 3.-7$(7% .$&C 4*2$>
*+(.9B $+% $+(#T(#/ -#9 7F2$F.% "0 #(+(2(&6 (# $+% 0(.&$ /%#%.-2 &%#&%
7"#&%_F%#$21 6-.T& - 3%.("9 "0 +(&$".1 (# 8+(7+ $+% +F6-# H%2(%'%9 $+-$
($& "8# 7-$%/".(%& "0 $+"F/+$ "./-#(&%9 -#9 ".(%#$%9 $+% 8".29> *+% $+(#TS
(#/ -#9 7F2$F.% "0 #(+(2(&6 (# $+% &%7"#9 +(&$".(7-2 &%#&% 9"%& #"$+(#/ HF$
6-.TB $+%.%0".%B - 6"6%#$ (# $+(& +(&$".1 `($& %#9a ='$& #'$ 2")/$% "2 #'$ =")4.
'9F$ +$/"5$ #"" /"5I4$H #" +$ /"&F*&/*&?4C ")?9&*%$. 9&. %C&#'$%*%$. +C #'$ 2")/$
"2 ',59& #'",?'#> Z"$+ #(+(2(&6& -.% $+%.%0".% #"$ "#21 &166%$.(7-2 0".6& "0
%-7+ "$+%.4 6".% (63".$-#$21B $+%(. &166%$.1 $%&$(0(%& $" $+% 0-7$ $+-$ $+%
+F6-# (& #"8 %V32(7($21 %V7%%9%9 H1 $+% 0".7%& "0 8+(7+ ($ (& -$ $+% &-6%
$(6% $+% '%+(72%> Y# $+(& &%#&% #(+(2(&6 (# $+% &%7"#9 &%#&% (& #"$+(#/ 6".%
$+-# $+% (#'%.$%9B -#9 $+%.%0".% 6(&.%7"/#(&%9 .%-2(&-$("# =*#'*& 6%$-S
3+1&(7& `5#(+(2(&6; (# $+% 2-./%. &%#&%a $+-$ #'$ ',59& *% &"# #'$ ."5*&9&#
2")/$ 95"&? 944 "#'$) 2")/$% *& #'$ =")4.>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
@? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' @X
) M"8 9" 8% h -& 3+(2"&"3+%.& -#9 -& 3%"32% 7"#7%.#%9 8($+B -#9 &($F-$%9
(# 7F2$F.% h $+(#T 8($+B H%$8%%# -#9 H%1"#9 $+% 7-$%/".(%& "0 6%$-S
3+1&(7& (# &F7+ - 8-1 -& $" -.$(7F2-$% $+% #"8 %V32(7($ 7"632%V($1 "0 $+%
8".29 -#9 $+% F#('%.&% $+-$ 9%0(%& $+%&% 7-$%/".(%&i
< Y# 8+-$ &%#&%B 0". =(%$A&7+%B -.% $+(& 2('(#/ -#9 $+(#T(#/ - 0F.$+%.-#7% "0
5&3(.($;i
@ Q#9 $+%.%0".%B 8+-$ 9"%& =(%$A&7+% 6%-# (# $+% 0(.&$ 32-7% H1 $+% $%.6
5&3(.($;B (0 &3(.($ (& #" 2"#/%. $" H% F#9%.&$""9 -& - 6%$-3+1&(7-2 7"#7%3$B
9%&(/#-$(#/ 8+-$ (& "33"&%9 $" $+% H"91 -#9 6-$$%.B $+-$ +-& 3.%7(&%21
".(%#$%9 6%$-3+1&(7&; 9(&-'"8-2 "0 $+% 0".7%& "0 $+% 8".29i W".B (# $+(&
&%#&%B 5&3(.($; 8"F29 -33%-. - 9(00(7F2$ 7-#9(9-$% $" 6"H(2(&% (# ".9%. $"
0"./% - 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 .%&3"#&% $" $+(& %6%./(#/ 7"632%V($1>
Z%0".% F#$1(#/ $+% (632(7-$("#& "0 $+%&% _F%&$("#& -#9 2-1(#/ "F$ $+%
7"#7%.#& "0 $+(& 7+-3$%. (# $+%(. 7"#$%V$B 2%$ F& 0(.&$ .%6(#9 "F.&%2'%& h (#
$+% 7"#$%V$ "0 $+% $($2% "0 $+(& '"2F6% h $+-$ $+% 0(#-2 3"&$+F6"F& #"$% -$
$+% %#9 "0 $+% P*44 #" E"=$) '"2F6% 9%&7.(H%& $+% 8".29 &3.F#/ 0."6 $+%
7-$%/".(%& "0 5F#($1;B 5H%(#/; -#9 53F.3"&%; -&B 3.%7(&%21B 5- 6"#&$%. "0 %#%./1
8($+"F$ H%/(##(#/B 8($+"F$ %#9m - 0(.6B (."# 6-/#($F9% "0 0".7% $+-$ 9"%&
#"$ %V3%#9 ($&%20 HF$ "#21 $.-#&0".6& ($&%20; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?HB l)INCB JDXh
JIa> *+% #"$% &$.%&&%& $+-$ $+(& #"#S%#$."3(7 8".29 (& "#% "0 %HH -#9 02"8 (#
8+(7+ $+% 32-1 "0 0".7%& 2(%& (# $+% 6"'%6%#$ H-7T -#9 0".8-.9 H%$8%%#
/.%-$%. 7"632%V($1 -#9 .%#%8%9 &(632(7($1B - 8".29B "0 5%$%.#-2 .%7F..%#7%;
-#9 5&%20S7.%-$("#;B $" 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% H.(#/& $+% #%8 5'-2F%&; "0 58(22 $"
3"8%.; -#9 5%$%.#-2 .%7F..%#7%;> *+%&% '-2F%& 6-.T $+% 9(00%.%#7% "0 0".7%
-#9 %#%./1 $+-$ %6%./% $+."F/+ $+% -7$('% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 (# $+%
/%#%.-2 &%#&% -22F9%9 $">) =(%$A&7+% 8.($%&4
r*+(& 8".29 (&s 61 [("#1&(-# 8".29 "0 $+% %$%.#-221 &%20S7.%-$(#/B &%20S
9%&$."1(#/B 61 5H%1"#9 /""9 -#9 %'(2; 8($+"F$ /"-2B F#2%&& $+% R"1 "0
$+% 7(.72% (& ($&%20 - /"-2> *+(& 8".29 (& $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%. h -#9 #"$+(#/
H%&(9%&j Q#9 1"F 1"F.&%2'%& -.% $+(& 8(22 $" 3"8%. h -#9 #"$+(#/ H%&(9%&j
`(H(9>a
="8B 8% +-'% RF&$ 6-(#$-(#%9 $+-$B 0". =(%$A&7+%B 3-&&('% ". -7$('%B #(+(2(&6
7"#&$($F$%& $+% =");*&?J",# "0 $+% 7-$%/".(%& H%_F%-$+%9 H1 6%$-3+1&(7&4
3-&&('%B ($ 9%&(/#-$%& - &$-$% "0 9(&$.%&& H%0".% $+% 2"&& "0 - 8".29 &(632(0(%9B
F#9%. $+% 7-$%/".(%& "0 .%-&"#B 0". $+% &-T% "0 2(0%m -7$('%B ($ -00(.6& $+% 8".29B
0."6 F#9%.#%-$+ $+%&% 7-$%/".(%&B -& - 8".29 "0 H%7"6(#/B 0(#9(#/ ($&
(#7.%-&%9 %#%./1 0."6 $+% '%.1 9%#(-2 "0 $+(& $.F$+0F2 8".29> Y# $+% -H"'%
_F"$-$("#B 0"22"8(#/ F3"# $+% 6"'%6%#$ "0 -7$('% #(+(2(&6B $+% 8".29 `".
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
=(%$A&7+%;& $13"2"/1 "0 #(+(2(&6 V,9 - 9(-/#"&(& "0 $+% #%7%&&-.1 0-(2F.% "0
+F6-# 0".7% $" "./-#(&% -22 "$+%. 0".7%& -& 8%22 -& - .%&3"#&% (# %I*)*# $" $+(&
0-(2F.% 2%-9B $+%.%0".%B $" $+.%% _F%&$("#&4
.-$+%.B $+% F#('%.&%a (& #"8 $+"F/+$ 0."6 F#9%.#%-$+ $+%&% 7-$%/".(%& 9% 6"#&$."F&B .%3%$($('% 7172% "0 %#%./1 8+"&% 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7& -.% 9%&(/#-$%9 (#
$%.6& "0 58(22 $" 3"8%.;B 5%$%.#-2 .%7F..%#7% "0 $+% &-6%; -#9 $+% -00(.6-$("#
"0 $+% &%20S9%&$."1(#/ -#9 &%20S7.%-$(#/ 7172%& "0 %#%./1>
Y# $+% 0"22"8(#/ Y 8-#$ $" &F//%&$ $+-$ H"$+ $+(& .%&3"#&% $" #(+(2(&6 -#9B
0(.&$ -#9 0".%6"&$B $+% (#($(-2 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6 -& &F7+ h $13"2"S
/(A%9 -H"'% 0."6 $+% #"$%& "0 P*44 #" E"=$) h 7"#&$($F$% - &(632(0(7-$("# "0 -#
(63".$-#$ 2%'%2 "0 =(%$A&7+%;&> W"7F&(#/ "# $+(& 2%'%2B 8% 8(22 &%% $+-$ 7%.$-(# =(%$A&7+% 7"#&$-#$21 F#6-T%& -#9 7"632(7-$%& $+% 9(&$(#7$("#&
-#9 .%S%'-2F-$%9 7"#7%3$& $+-$ #%'%.$+%2%&& 0F%2 $+% %3(&$%6"2"/(7-2 -#9
%$+(7-2 +".(A"#& "0 - 6-R". 3-.$ "0 +(& 3+(2"&"3+1> Q& - .%&F2$ "0 $+(& 7"6S
32(7-$("#B "# $+% "#% +-#9B "#% 7-# #%($+%. &$-1 8($+ =(%$A&7+%;& 9(-/#"&(&
"0 6%$-3+1&(7& #". -77%3$ +(& .%&3"#&% $" ($ &(#7% +(& $%V$ &+"8& $+-$ $+%&%
$%.6& "0 9(-/#"&(& -#9 .%&3"#&% 9" #"$ 8".T (# $+% 0(.&$ 32-7%> L# $+% "$+%.
+-#9B Y 8(22 &+"8 $+-$ =(%$A&7+% /('%& F& -$ $+% &-6% $(6% $+% $%.6& 8($+(#
+(& 9(-/#"&(& "0B -#9 .%&3"#&% $" $+% 5-22 $"" +F6-#; $+-$ "3%#& F3 - 8-1 "0
$+(#T(#/ $+% 7"632%V($1 "0 5#"8; $+-$ 6-(#$-(#& $+% .%2%'-#7% "0 =(%$A&7+%;&
$+(#T(#/ "0 $+% +F6-# -#9 "'%.+F6-#> Y 8(22 &+"8 $+-$ $+%&% $%.6& %6%./%
"F$ "0 $+% 8-1 (# 8+(7+B "0$%# H%1"#9 +(6&%20B =(%$A&7+% "3%#& F3 -#
(66-#%#$ .%2-$("# H%$8%%# 5/%#%-2"/1;B 5%#%./%$(7&; -#9 5%$+(7&;> Y$ (& $+(&
.%2-$("# 8+(7+ $+% H"91 "0 $+(& 7+-3$%. 8(22 H% 7"#7%.#%9 $" F#$(% 0."6 "F$
"0 =(%$A&7+% (# $+% T#"82%9/% $+-$ 6F7+ .%7%#$ 8".T 8($+ -#9 8($+"F$
=(%$A&7+% +-& 8(&+%9 $" 3."H2%6-$(&% $+%&% T(#9& "0 .%2-$("#B 7"#&(9%.(#/
$+%6 -& P2-$"#(7B M%/%2(-#B 6(6%$(7 ". 6%$-S$+%".%$(7-2>< Y$ (& $+F& $+%
6-R".B (0 (632(7($ &F33"&($("# "0 $+(& %&&-1 $+-$ &F7+ - 3."H2%6-$(&-$("# +-&
H%%# 6(&32-7%9>
Y 8(&+ $" &F//%&$B $+%#B (# $+% 0"22"8(#/ $+-$ $+(& "3%#(#/ F3 "0 $+%
.%2-$("# H%$8%%# $+% /%#%-2"/(7-2B $+% %#%./%$(7 -#9 $+% %$+(7-2B (# $+%
7"#$%V$ "0 /"(#/ H%1"#9 $+% +F6-#B (& $" H% $.-7%9 (# =(%$A&7+%;& F#9%.S
&$-#9(#/ "0 5&3(.($;> Y 8(&+ -2&" $" &F//%&$ $+-$ ($ (& 3.%7(&%21 H1 3F.&F(#/ $+(&
"3%#(#/ $+."F/+ =(%$A&7+%;& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 &3(.($ $+-$ $+% 7"632%V($1 "0
0".7% 8($+ 8+(7+ 8% -.% -22 7"#7%.#%9 $"9-1 7-# H% (#$%.%&$(#/21 -.$(7F2-$%9
3+(2"&"3+(7-221B -#9B 3%.+-3&B 7F2$F.-221> O% &-8 -H"'% $+-$B 0". =(%$A&7+%B
5&3(.($; (& 7"66"# $" H"$+ -7$('% -#9 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6B &$-#9(#/B
$+%.%0".%B "F$&(9% $+% $%.6& "0 +(& "8# $13"2"/1 "0 ($> ,$-#9(#/ "F$&(9%
$+%&% $%.6&B 5&3(.($; 7-# H% &%%#B "# - 7-.%0F2 .%-9(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 8".TB
$" -.$(7F2-$% -# F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 2(0%B "0 0".7% -#9 %#%./1 $+-$ 2(%& 3.(". H"$+
$" 6%$-3+1&(7-2 7"#7%3$F-2(&-$("# -#9 $" ($& (#'%.&("#& -#9 9%&$.F7$("#&>
5,3(.($; (& (# $+(& &%#&% - F&%0F2 $" $%.6 $" F&%B 0."6 "F$ "0 $+% 7"#$%V$ "0
=(%$A&7+%;& 3+(2"&"3+1B (# -33.-(&-2 "0 $+% 5#"8; "0 7F2$F.% -#9 3+(2"&"3+1
&(#7% ($ 3.%7(&%21 9)#*/,49#$%B -#9 )$%I"&.% #" `-2H%($ (#9%$%.6(#-$%21a $+% 8-1
(# 8+(7+ $+% +F6-# +-& +-9B "'%. $+% 2-&$ $+.%% +F#9.%9 1%-.&B $" -H-#9"#
$+% 0(7$("# $+-$ $+% 0".7%& "0 $+% 8".29 `8($+(# 8+(7+ $+% +F6-# (& ($&%20
(#&7.(H%9a 7-# H% &1#$+%&(&%9 H1 +F6-# $+"F/+$ -#9 3.-7$(7%>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
DI !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' D)
Z%0".% $F.#(#/ $" $+% $%V$ $+-$ (& 6"&$ (#$%.%&$(#/ (# $+(& .%/-.9B Q& #'$
O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#C `=(%$A&7+% )XXDaB 2%$ 6% 0(.&$ /('% - 9%0(#($("# "0
=(%$A&7+%;& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 5&3(.($;>
AF#)#% /,2 AF#)#%</"#-/%#$,
*+-$ 7"66-#9(#/ &"6%$+(#/ 8+(7+ $+% 3%"32% r.9% X"4;s 7-22& 5&3(.($; r.$)
O$*%#s 8-#$& $" H% 6-&$%. 8($+(# ($&%20 -#9 -."F#9 ($&%20 -#9 $" 0%%2 ($&%20
6-&$%.4 "F$ "0 6F2$(32(7($1 ($ +-& $+% 8(22 $" &(632(7($1B - 8(22 8+(7+ H(#9&
$"/%$+%. -#9 $-6%&B 8+(7+ (& (63%.("F& -#9 9"6(#%%.(#/> Y# $+(& ($&
#%%9& -#9 7-3-7($(%& -.% $+% &-6% -& $+"&% 8+(7+ 3+1&("2"/(&$& 3"&($ 0".
%'%.1$+(#/ $+-$ 2('%&B /."8& -#9 6F2$(32(%&> *+% 3"8%. "0 $+% &3(.($ rB*$
G)92# .$% O$*%#$%s $" -33."3.(-$% 8+-$ (& &$.-#/% $" ($ r.9% :)$5.$% %*/'
9&@,$*?&$&s (& .%'%-2%9 (# - &$."#/ (#72(#-$("# $" -&&(6(2-$% $+% #%8 $"
$+% "29B $" &(632(01 $+% 7"632%VB $" "'%.2""T ". .%3%2 $+% 8+"221 7"#$.-S
9(7$".1m RF&$ -& ($ -.H($.-.(21 %63+-&(A%&B %V$.-7$& -#9 0-2&(0(%& $" &F($ ($&%20
7%.$-(# $.-($& -#9 2(#%& (# 8+-$ (& &$.-#/% $" ($B (# %'%.1 3(%7% "0 5%V$%.#-2
8".29;> Y$& (#$%#$("# (# -22 $+(& (& $+% (#7".3".-$("# r.*$ 6*&F$)4$*+,&?s "0
#%8 5%V3%.(%#7%&;B $+% -..-#/%6%#$ "0 #%8 $+(#/& 8($+(# "29 9('(&("#& h
/."8$+m 6".% 3.%7(&%21B $+% 0%%2(#/ "0 /."8$+B $+% 0%%2(#/ "0 (#7.%-&%9
3"8%. rG)92#s> *+(& &-6% 8(22 (& &%.'%9 H1 -# -33-.%#$21 "33"&(#/ 9.('% "0
$+% &3(.($ r$*& %/'$*&+9) $&#?$?$&?$%$#@#$) D)*$+ .$% O$*%#$%sB - &F99%# 9%7(S
&("# 0". (/#".-#7%B 0". -.H($.-.1 &+F$$(#/S"F$B - 72"&(#/ "0 $+% 8(#9"8&B
-# (##%. 9%#(-2 "0 $+(& ". $+-$ $+(#/B - .%0F&-2 $" 2%$ ($ -33."-7+B 7"#$%#$6%#$ 8($+ $+% 9-.TB $+% 72"&%9 +".(A"#4 -22 $+(& H%(#/ #%7%&&-.1
-77".9(#/ $" $+% 9%/.%% "0 ($& 3"8%. $" -33."3.(-$% r%$*&$) 9&$*?&$&.$&
G)92#sB ($& 59(/%&$('% 3"8%.; &" $" &3%-T r%$*&$) kX$).9,,&?%;)92#N s h -#9
(#9%%9 $+% 5&3(.($; .%&%6H2%& 6"&$ - &$"6-7+ r,&. =*);4*/' ?4$*/'# k.$)
O$*%#N 95 5$*%#$& &"/' $*&$5 39?$&s> *+(& 8(22 $" -33%-.-#7%B $" &(632(0(7-S
$("# r-#9 -2&"s $" $+% 6-&TB (# &+".$ $" $+-$ 8+(7+ (& "# $+% &F.0-7%B (&
7"F#$%.-7$%9 H1 $+-$ &FH2(6% $%#9%#71 (# $+% 3%.&"# "0 T#"82%9/% 8+(7+
$-T%& -#9 =9&#% #" $-T% - 3."0"F#9B -#9 6-#1S&(9%9 -#9 $+"."F/+ '(%8 "0
$+(#/&4 -& - T(#9 "0 7.F%2$1 "0 $+% (#$%22%7$F-2 7"#&7(%#7% -#9 $-&$% 8+(7+
%'%.1 H.-'% $+(#T%. 8(22 .%7"/#(A% (# +(6&%20> Y# 0-7$B ($ 8"F29 H% #(7%. (0B
(#&$%-9 "0 8($+ 7.F%2$1B "#% 7.%9($%9 F& 3%.+-3& 8($+ -# 5%V$.-'-/-#$
+"#%&$1; r$*&$ k9,%%/'=$*2$&.$ 1$.4*/';$*#N s h 8% 0.%%B '%.1 0.%% &3(.($& r,&%
2)$*$&R %$') 2)$*$& O$*%#$)&s>
`=(%$A&7+% )XC@B )D)h<m )X??4 )N?hXa
5,3(.($; (& (#($(-221 32-7%9 +%.% (# (#'%.$%9 7"66-& -& (0 ($ 8-& - 7"66"#
F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 $+% #"$("# $+-$ =(%$A&7+% (& -22F9(#/ $"B "#% "0 3"3F2-.
3-.2-#7%> Q77".9(#/ $" $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 $.-9($("#B -#9 6".% &3%7(0(7-221
8($+(# $+% $.-9($("# -#9 7F2$F.% "0 !+.(&$(-#($1 0"22"8(#/ k"+#B P-F2 -#9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Y# l <@I "0 <$C"&. O"". 9&. 6F*4 =(%$A&7+% 8.($%&4
QF/F&$(#%B &3(.($ (& "33"&%9 $" 6-$$%. -#9 $" $+% H"91> W"22"8(#/ $+(&
"33"&($("# $+% $%.6 -77.F%& $" ($&%20 $+% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& "0 +F6-# 7"#9F7$4
52"'%;B 58(&9"6;B 56%.71; -.% "0$%# $+"F/+$ "0 -& $+% +(/+%&$ 5&3(.($F-2; '-2F%&>
Y$ (&B 0". =(%$A&7+%B $+(& #"$("# "0 &3(.($ $+-$ +-& H%%# 9%'-2F%9 H1 $+% %#9 "0
$+% #(#%$%%#$+ 7%#$F.1 -#9 "0 8+(7+ I9%%*F$ &*'*4*%5 e 9 )$/$%%*"& *& #'$ I"=$)
"2 %I*)*# e *% *#%$42 9 /"&%$V,$&/$> *+% #"$("# "0 5&3(.($; $+-$ (#$%.%&$& =(%$A&7+%
+%.% 8"F29 -$ 0(.&$ &(/+$ &%%6B $+%#B $" H% - &"6%8+-$ &$.-(/+$0".8-.9
(#'%.&("# "0 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 +(%.-.7+1 "0 $+% &F3%.&%#&F"F& -#9 $+% &%#S
&F"F&> !"#&(9%.%9 -& - 3."7%&& "0 9(/%&$("#B "0 -&&(6(2-$("# -#9 .%R%7$("#B
F3"# 8+(7+ $+% 6%$-H"2(&6 -#9B $+%.%0".%B $+% F#($1 "0 $+% 2('(#/ "./-#(&6
(& 3.%9(7-$%9B &3(.($B $"/%$+%. 8($+ $+% '-2F%& 02"8(#/ $+%.%0."6B (& 9%&7.(H%9
H1 =(%$A&7+% -& - 5&$"6-7+;> =(%$A&7+% 7"#&%_F%#$21 2""T& $" 3+1&("2"/1 $"
/('% F& ($& 9%&7.(3$("# -#9 -77"F#$> Y0 5&3(.($; (& (#9%%9 &$"6-7+B $+%#
=(%$A&7+% +-& &(6321 .%9F7%9B $+% -./F6%#$ 6(/+$ /"B &3(.($F-2($1 $" H("2"/(7-2 3."7%&& "0 9(/%&$("#B H("2"/(&(#/ 7F2$F.% -#9 02-$$%#(#/ $+% 8".T
"0 &3(.($ $" $+% 6"&$ &(632% -00%7$('% 6%7+-#(&6&> *+% .%&F2$ (& - .%$F.# $"
$+% #"$".("F& 5H2"#9 H%-&$; ". $+% 5H%-&$ "0 3.%1; "0 =(%$A&7+%-# 2%/%#9> ,F7+
8"F29 H% $+% .(&TB 0". %V-632%B $+-$ M%(9%//%. -$$%63$%9 $" $8(&$ =(%$A&7+%
0."6 (# 7-&$(#/ $+(& 5H("2"/(&6; 8($+(# - 6%$-3+1&(7-2 "#$"2"/1 -#9 %3(&$%S
6"2"/1 `&%% M%(9%//%. )XX)HB %&3%7(-221 @Xh)))a> ,"B /"&#)9 M%(9%//%.;&
.%-9(#/B (# 8+-$ 8-1 9"%& $+(& 3-.-/.-3+ (#$(6-$% - 7"#7%3$("# "0 &3(.($
3.(". $" -#9 H%1"#9 $+% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# $+% &%#&F"F& -#9 &F3%.&%#&FS
"F& 8($+(# 8+(7+ $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 "33"&($("# H%$8%%# &3(.($ -#9 6-$$%.
0-22&i
Q# (#9(7-$("# (& /('%# (# $+% &%7"#9 3-.$ "0 $+% _F"$-$("#> O% .%7-22 $+-$
(# $+% %-.2(%. 5*.(2"/1 "0 W.%% ,3(.($&;B >,59&R 744 D"" >,59& `=(%$A&7+%
)X?NaB B9C+)$9; `=(%$A&7+% )X?<a -#9 D'$ 8"C2,4 A/*$&/$ `=(%$A&7+% )XC@aB
50.%% &3(.($; 9%&(/#-$%9 -$ 2%-&$ $+.%% $+(#/&4 0(.&$B - 7"#7%.# $" 9%61&$(01 0-($+
$+."F/+ $+% 7.($(7-2 F&% "0 .%-&"#m &%7"#9B -# %#%./%$(7 9(&3"&($("# "0
-H"F#9(#/ 0".7%m -#9B $+(.9B $+% 7"#7%.# $" .%&($F-$% .%-&"# 8($+(# - 2-./%.
%7"#"61 "0 $+% &%#&%&> Y$ (& 3.%7(&%21 $+(& 2-$$%. -&3%7$ $+-$ 5&3(.($; `(# _F"$-S
$("# 6-.T& (# $+% -H"'% 3-.-/.-3+a 9%&(/#-$%&> *+% 3+1&("2"/(7-2 9%&(/#-S
$("# "0 &3(.($ -& - 5&$"6-7+; (& $+%.%0".% $" H% $-T%# &$*#'$) 2($%.-221 &")
6%$-3+".(7-221> Y0 5&3(.($; (& 7"#&(9%.%9 -& - 3."7%&& "0 9(/%&$("#B "0 -&&(6(2-S
$("# -#9 .%R%7$("#B F3"# 8+(7+ $+% 6%$-H"2(&6 -#9 $+% F#($1 "0 $+% 2('(#/
"./-#(&6 (& 3.%9(7-$%9B $+%#B 0". =(%$A&7+%B &3(.($B (# $+% $.-9($("#-2 &%#&% "0
8+-$ (& 9(&$(#7$ 0."6 $+% &%#&F"F&B (& "&$ #CI$ "0 .*?$%#*"& "2 #'$ =")4.B "#% (#
8+(7+ ($& 9(/%&$('% 0F#7$("# (&B 3.%7(&%21B 0".%72"&%9> 5,3(.($; (# $+% $.-9($("#-2
&%#&% $+F& 9(&-'"8& ($& 56%7+-#(7&;4 ($& /%#%-2"/1B ($& "./-#(&-$("#&B -#9 $+%
8+1&B 8+%.%0".%& -#9 5+"8&; "0 ($& 9%7(&("#& -#9 7+"(7%&> *+% 3"(#$ +-&
&%'%.-2 (632(7-$("#&>
W(.&$B -#9 6"&$ 2"7-2214 $+% &%7"#9 9%0(#($("# "0 #(+(2(&6 9%&(/#-$%9 $+%
&%20S9%'-2F-$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 7-$%/".(%&> ,(#7% "#% &F7+ 7-$%/".1 9% '-2F% (& "0$%# 7-22%9 5&3(.($; 8($+(# $+% $.-9($("#B $+%# #(+(2(&6 (& ($&%20 -
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
D< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
.%&3"#&% =*#'*& $+% %7"#"61 "0 - 3-.$(7F2-. `6%$-3+1&(7-2a F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0
&3(.($> *+(& (& -2&" $+% .%-&"# 8+1 &3(.($ `(# $+% 8(9%. &%#&% 8% -.% .%-7+(#/a
&$-#9& "F$&(9% %($+%. 3-&&('% ". -7$('% #(+(2(&6B &(#7% $+%1 -.% (# $F.# #CI$% "2
%I*)*#B $13%&B $+-$ (&B "2 $*#'$) %5944$) ") 49)?$) %C%#$5% "2 .*?$%#*"&> *+F&B $"
.%$F.# $" $+% $%.6& "0 61 (#$."9F7$("#B =(%$A&7+%;& .%S"./-#(&-$("# "0 &3(.($
/"%& H%1"#9B (#9%%9 .%#9%.& #"#3%.$(#%#$ +(& "8# $13"2"/1 "0 #(+(2(&6B -&
8%22 -& +(& .%&3"#&% $" ($ V,9 -7$('% #(+(2(&6B &(#7% %-7+ $13% "0 #(+(2(&6 (& 6(#". %7"#"61 "0 &3(.($ 8($+(# 3."7%&&%& "0 &3(.($F-2(&-$("# $+-$ %V7%%9 ($> Y$
(& $+%&% 3."7%&&%& $+-$ #%%9 $" H% -&&F6%9 0". - #%8 &3(.($ $" %6%./%> *+(&
8(22 H%7"6% -22 $+% 6".% 72%-. -& 8% 3."7%%9>
,%7"#94 &3(.($ (& #"$ H%(#/ .%(#$%.3.%$%9 +%.% -2"#/ $+% 2(#%& "0 -# %63(.(S
7(&$ .%9F7$("# "0 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2B "#% $+-$ 2"&%& $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 3+(2"&"S
3+(7-2 $.-#&7%#9%#7% h -# (#$%.3.%$-$("# $+-$ M%(9%//%. H%2(%'%9 (# $+%
$+(.$(%& =(%$A&7+%;& $+"F/+$ .(&T%9 7"#9"#(#/ F#2%&& ($ 8-& 5.%S&3(.($F-2(&%9;
3+(2"&"3+(7-221 `M%(9%//%. )XX)Ha@> G-$+%.B 0". =(%$A&7+%B &3(.($ -& $+% 3."S
7%&& "0 $+% 2('(#/ -& &F7+ "3%#& F3 *& #'$ 2*)%# I49/$ $+% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%#
&3(.($ -#9 6-$$%. $+-$ -77"63-#(%& $+% 2"/(7 "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 $+(#T(#/> *+%
.%S%'-2F-$%9 $%.6 5&3(.($; (& (# $+(& &%#&% - 6%$-3+". 0". - 3."7%&& "0 9(00%.S
%#$(-$("# H%$8%%# -# "./-#(&6 -#9 ($& 5%#'(."#6%#$; `($& [5=$4#a>
*+(.94 ($ (& #"$ +"8%'%. - 6%$-3+".B 0". =(%$A&7+%B (0 &3(.($ (# $+% $.-9(S
$("#-2 P-F2(#% &%#&% (& "#21 - 6".% 5&3(.($F-2(&%9; 0".6 "0 9(/%&$("#B 8(220F221
". +-H($F-221 F#-8-.% "0 ($& 3."7%&&%& "0 0F#7$("#(#/> *+% -H"'% 6%$-3+1&(S
7-2 9(&$(#7$("# +$#=$$& &3(.($ -#9 6-$$%. (& $+F& -# (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 5&3(.($;B
"#% $+-$ 0".%72"&%& ($> ,3(.($ (# $+(& 9%%3%. =(%$A&7+%-# &%#&% (& &"6%$+(#/
2(T% $+% 6%$-H"2(7 ".9%. "0 $+% +F6-# "./-#(&6 (# /%#%.-2B "#% 0."6 "F$ "0
8+(7+ 3-.$(7F2-. 6%$-H"2(&6& %6%./% `$+-$ 8+(7+ 9%6-#9& - 9(&$(#7$("#
H%$8%%# &3(.($ -#9 6-$$%.B $+-$ 8+(7+ 9%&3-(.& "0 $+% 9(&$(#7$("#B $+-$
8+(7+ 8(&+%& $" /%$ H%+(#9 $+% 9(&$(#7$("#B -#9 &" 0".$+a> 5,3(.($; (# $+(&
&%#&% (& $+%.%0".% #%($+%. 2($%.-2 `&(#7% $+% 52($%.-2; (& "#21 "#% 0".6 "0
%6%./%#7% "0 5&3(.($;a #". 6%$-3+".(7-2 `&(#7% $+%.% (& #"$+(#/ 2($%.-2 -H"F$
5&3(.($; (# $+% 0(.&$ 32-7%B -#9 &(#7% $" .%8".T 5&3(.($; H%+(#9 -#9 H%1"#9 ($&
6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("#& (& $" %V7%%9 $+% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# $+% 2($%.-2
-#9 $+% 6%$-3+".(7-2 -#9 32-7% $+(& $+(#T(#/ 8($+(# - +(&$".(7-221 (#0".6%9
$+(#T(#/ "0 &3(.($F-2(&-$("#a>
W"F.$+4 (# $+(& 7"#$%V$ - 2)$$ %I*)*# (& - 3%.&"# 8+" +-& -# %#2-./%9 &%#&% "0
$+% &%20;& .%2-$("# $" ($& [5=$4# $+."F/+ .%7"/#(&(#/ $+% (#$.(#&(7 .%2-$("#
H%$8%%# $+% &%#&F"F& -#9 $+% .-$("#-2> Y# $+% %V3%.(%#7% "0 $+(& .%7"/#($("#
- 0.%% &3(.($ H%7"6%& 2%&& -33."3.(-$(#/B 6".% -H"F#9(#/ (# %#%./1> Q 50.%%
&3(.($; 7"6%&B (# "$+%. 8".9&B 0."6 T#"8(#/ 8+%.% &3(.($ 7"6%& 0."6 (# $+%
0(.&$ 32-7%B +"8 ($ %'"2'%& -#9 8+-$ 0".7%& -.% (# 32-1 H%+(#9 "F. 7"#7%3$F-2
9%$%.6(#-$("#& "0 $+% 8".29> ="8B (# $+(& &%#&%B -#9 -$ $+(& 2%'%2 "0 $+% $%V$B
=(%$A&7+%-# /%#%-2"/1B =(%$A&7+%-# %#%./%$(7& -#9 $+% $.-#&'-2F-$("# "0
$.-9($("#-2 %$+(7& -.% &%%# $" H% *&%$I9)9+4$ %2%6%#$& "0 - /%#%.-2 3+(2"&"3+1
"0 2(0% V,9 5&3(.($;> *+% 0"22"8(#/ 8(22 7"#&$-#$21 .%($%.-$% $+(& 2-&$ 3"(#$4 ($
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' D@
#"$ "#21 &F//%&$& $+-$ $+% &1&$%6-$(7 .%/(&$%. "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $+(#T(#/ .%6-(#&
$" H% .%-9B ($ (632(%&B /"&#)9 $+% /%&$F.% "0 6F7+ .%7%#$ 3+(2"&"3+(A(#/ "#
=(%$A&7+%B $+-$ ($ (& (# $+(& &1&$%6-$(7 .%/(&$%. $+-$ $+% (63".$-#7% "0
=(%$A&7+%;& $+(#T(#/ 0". F& $"9-1 (& $" H% 0"F#9>
Q 50.%% &3(.($; 7"#&$($F$%& $+%.%0".% $+% $.-#&'-2F-$("# "0 H"$+ $+% 3"3F2-.
-#9 $.-9($("#-2 &%#&%& "0 $+% $%.6& 5&3(.($; (#$" -# %6H"9(6%#$ "0 5&3(.($; $+-$
(& -# %#2-./%9 9(/%&$("#> 5W.%% &3(.($&; -.% -# -9'-#7%9 0".6 "0 $+% 3.(6-.1
2%'%2 "0 5&3(.($; V,9 9(/%&$("#B "#% $+-$ -33."3.(-$%& 2%&& $+-# 6".%> *+%
3."7%&& $+-$ $-T%& F& 0."6 $+% 3.(6-.1 2%'%2 "0 5&3(.($; $" $+-$ "0 - 50.%% &3(.($;B
=(%$A&7+% 7-22& 5&3(.($F-2(&-$("#; `X$)?$*%#*?,&?a `- $%.6 6"&$ 0.%_F%#$21 F&%9
(# Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#CW> ,3(.($F-2(&-$("# (&B 0". =(%$A&7+%B $+% 3."7%&&
"0 $+% %'"2F$("# "0 2(0%> Y# $+% $+(.9 %&&-1 "0 Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#C
=(%$A&7+% 7-22& ($ $+% 52-8 "0 2(0%B $+% 2-8 "0 &$/$%%9)C 55&%20S"'%.7"6(#/;; (# $+%
%&&%#7% "0 2(0%; `=(%$A&7+% )XXDB )<Na> Q& q-.-$+F&$.- +-9 -2.%-91 3F$ ($ (# $+%
&%7"#9 H""T "0 D',% AI9;$ T9)9#',%#)9 5&3(.($ (& $+% 2(0% $+-$ ($&%20 7F$& (#$" 2(0%
rB$) O$*%# *%# .9% L$+$& .9% %$4+$) *&% L$+$& %/'&$*.$#s; `=(%$A&7+% )XN)B )<Ca> Y
8(22 .%$F.# $" $+(& 7"66%#$ 2-$%.> K%$ 6% %#9 $+(& &%7$("# H1 0".6F2-$(#/ $+%
-H"'% 3"(#$& (# 6".% 9%0(#($("#-2 $%.6&>
W". =(%$A&7+%B 5&3(.($; 9%&(/#-$%& $+% %6%./%#7% -#9 &$-H(2(&-$("# "0 $+%
#%.'"F& &1&$%6 -& - 8+"2%B "#% #"$ &(6321 3.(". $"B HF$ %#/%#9%.(#/ -#9
-28-1& %V7%%9(#/B $"8-.9& /.%-$%. 7"632%V($1B $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 9('(&("#&
H%$8%%# 5&3(.($; -#9 6-$$%.B 7"#&7("F&#%&& -#9 (#&$(#7$B (#$%22(/%#7% -#9
-00%7$B $+% H.-(# -#9 $+% &$"6-7+> 5,3(.($; (& - 5H("2"/(7-2; 7"#7%3$ $" $+%
%V$%#$ $+-$ ($ (& 3-.$(7F2-. $" -22 2('(#/ "./-#(&6&m ($ (& #"$ H("2"/(7-2 $"
$+% %V$%#$ $+-$ ($ (& 9%0(#%9 H1 ($& "8# +(&$".1 8+(7+ (& #"$+(#/ "$+%. $+-#
$+% +(&$".1 "0 ($& "8# &3(.($F-2(&-$("#> Q& $+% %6%./%#7% -#9 &$-H(2(&-$("#
"0 $+% #%.'"F& &1&$%6 -& - 8+"2%B &3(.($ (& $+% +(&$".1 "0 ($& "8# %'"2F$("#B "0
$+% .%2-$("# 9.-8# H%$8%%# $+% "./-#(&6 -#9 ($& [5=$4# -#9 "0 $+% 6"9S
(0(7-$("#& $+-$ $+(& .%2-$("# F#9%./"%& "'%. $(6% h -# %'"2F$("# $+-$ 3.%7(&%21
4$9F$% $+% 9"6-(# "0 $+% H("2"/(7-2 "'%. $(6% #')",?' $+%&% '%.1 6%9(-$("#&>
*+% +F6-# "./-#(&6 (& $+% .%&F2$ "0 $+(& %'"2F$("# "0 5&3(.($;> ="$ $+-$ 5&3(.($;
8-& $+%.% (# $+% 0(.&$ 32-7%B -& M%/%2 3"&($& (# H"$+ - &(6(2-. -#9 '%.1
9(00%.%#$ .%-9(#/ "0 &3(.($> 5,3(.($; (& &(6321 $+% H%&$ $%.6 H1 8+(7+ $" -.$(7FS
2-$% $+% 7"632%V($1 "0 ($& "8# H%7"6(#/> G%S%'-2F-$%9 H1 =(%$A&7+%B $8(&$%9
"F$ "0 $+% 9%$%.6(#-$("#& "0 6%$-3+1&(7& -#9 32F#/%9 H-7T (#$" +(&$".1B
5&3(.($; $+%.%H1 H%7"6%&B 0". =(%$A&7+%B H"$+ 9 ?$&$94"?*/94 /"&/$I# -#9 9 F$/#")
"2 )$J$F94,9#*"&B H.(#/(#/ $"/%$+%. h -#9 $+(& (& -/-(# $+% (63".$-#$ 5&1&$%6-S
$(7; 3"(#$ h $+% %3(&$%6"2"/(7-2B %$+(7-2 -#9 &3%7F2-$('% -&3%7$& "0 =(%$A&7+%;&
.%$+(#T(#/ "0 $+% 7-$%/".(%& "0 F#($1B &FH&$-#7%B 7-F&-2($1 -#9 3F.3"&%> Y#
$+(& &%#&%B #"$ "#21 (& #(+(2(&6B $+%#B $" H% -.$(7F2-$%9 8($+(# $+% "'%.-22
%7"#"61 "0 5&3(.($;B HF$ 5&3(.($; (& -#"$+%. 8-1 "0 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ 8(22 $" 3"8%.
-& $+% 5&%20S&FH2(6-$(#/; `=(%$A&7+% )XXDB )<Na 2-8 "0 2(0%> Y# $+(& &%#&%B (#
$F.#B 5&3(.($; -#$(7(3-$%& - .%S%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%& $+-$ 7-##"$ H% 9%0(#($('%21
9%&7.(H%9 (# $%.6& "0 - 5[("#1&(-# 8".29 "0 8(22 $" 3"8%.; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
DD !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' DJ
l)INCa =*#'",# 4"%*&? #'$ 5$.*9#*"&% "2 #'$ I)"/$%% "2 %I*)*#,94*%9#*"&> Q& "F.
.%-9(#/ "0 Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#C 8(22 #"8 &+"8B ($ (& $+%&% '%.1 6%9(-S
$("#& $+-$ 3"(#$ $+% 8-1 H%1"#9 $+% 0(7$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 $"8-.9& $+% "'%.S
+F6-# (# $+% 0(.&$ 32-7%>D
Y$ (& 8%22 T#"8#B 3-.$(7F2-.21 -0$%. [%2%FA%;& !*$#@%/'$ 9&. E'*4"%"I'C
`[%2%FA% )X?@aB $+-$ Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#C (& $+% 8".T (# 8+(7+
=(%$A&7+% /('%& $+% 6"&$ &F&$-(#%9 -77"F#$ "0 +(& /%#%-2"/(7-2 .%S%'-2F-$("#
"0 6%$-3+1&(7&> *+(& '-2F-$("# 32F#/%& 6%$-3+1&(7-2 '-2F%& (#$" -# "3%#
50(%29; "0 0".7%& 0."6 8+(7+ %6%./% $+%(. .%S%'-2F-$("# -#9 $.-#&'-2F-$("# -&
$13%& "0 0".7%> *+% 8".T $+F& -.$(7F2-$%& 6".% $+-# -#1 "$+%. $%V$ $+% &-(9
.%2-$("# H%$8%%# /%#%-2"/1B %#%./%$(7& -#9 %$+(7&> Y# $+(& &%#&% $+(& 3-.$(7FS
2-. 8".T (& "0 (66%#&% (#$%.%&$ H"$+ 0."6 $+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 &3(.($ -#9
&3(.($F-2(&-$("# -#9 (# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 ($& -0$%.6-$+> *+-$ &-(9B
Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#C (& -2&" - +(/+21 -6H(/F"F& $%V$B "#% (# 8+(7+
=(%$A&7+%;& /%#%-2"/(7-2 -#9 %#%./%$(7 '-2F-$("#B .%S%'-2F-$("# -#9 $.-#&'-S
2F-$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 $+(#T(#/ -#9 3.-7$(7% %#9 F3 (# $+% 8".&$ (63-&&%&
"0 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 -#9 6".-2 &3%7F2-$("#> Y# 61 .%-9(#/ "0 $+% O$&$94"?C Y
8(&+B 0(.&$B $" &($F-$% $+% $%.6& "0 $+% /%#%-2"/(7-2 -#9 %#%./%$(7 '-2F-$("# "0
$+% 0(.&$ %&&-1 "0 $+% 8".T -#9 &F//%&$ $+% 2(6($& "0 $+%&% $%.6&> Y 8(22 $+%#
&+"8 (# 8+-$ 8-1& $+% &%7"#9 %&&-1 "'%.7"6%& $+%&% 2(6($&B -22 $+% 8+(2%
&F//%&$(#/ 8+-$ (632(7-$("#& $+(& "'%.7"6(#/ +-& 0". =(%$A&7+%;& 3+(2"&"S
3+1 "0 2(0%B &3(.($ -#9 -00(.6-$("# -& - 8+"2%> Y 8(22 $+%.%H1 &%%T $" &+"8
$+."F/+ $+% .%-9(#/ "0 $+(& "#% $%V$B `-a 8+-$ 7"632(7-$("#& $" =(%$A&7+%;&
$+(#T(#/ -.% #%7%&&-.1 (0 =(%$A&7+% (& $" +%23 F& $+(#T $+% 0F$F.% "0 $+(#T(#/
-#9 7F2$F.%B -#9 `Ha +"8 =(%$A&7+% +(6&%20 +%23& F& (#$" $+(& 0F$F.% H1
(#$(6-$(#/ +(6&%20 8+%.% $+%&% 7"632(7-$("#& -.(&%>
Y# $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1B 5 55^""9 -#9 U'(2;;B 55^""9 -#9 Z-9;;; $+% !+.(&$(-# '-2F%&
"0 5/""9; -#9 5%'(2; -.% +(&$".(7-221 .%2"7-$%9 (# - 7F2$F.-2 H-$$2% H%$8%%# $8"
&1&$%6& "0 '-2F-$("# `llJh))a> *+% '-2F-$("# 5/""9 -#9 %'(2; (& (#$%.3.%$%9 -&
- 3.(%&$21B $+%# -& - kF9-(7 .%S%'-2F-$("# "0 $+% #"H2% '-2F-$("# 5/""9 -#9
H-9;4 $+(& .%S%'-2F-$("# (& - &$.F//2% "0 0".7%&> W". =(%$A&7+%B 8+-$ (& /""9 (&
".(/(#-221 8+-$ (& #"H2%B $+-$ (&B 8+-$ 9(&7+-./%& &3"#$-#%"F&21B 8+-$ (&
".(%#$%9 $"8-.9& $+% "F$&(9%> *+% H-9 (# $+(& &7+%6- 7"#&$($F$%& $+-$
8+(7+ H2"7T& $+% 3-$+ "0 $+(& ".(/(#-2 -00(.6-$("#> Y# $+% '-2F-$("# 5/""9
-#9 %'(2;B 8+-$ (& H-9 (# $+% 0(.&$ '-2F-$("# H%7"6%& /""9 (# $+% &%7"#9
`(#$%.(".(&-$("# -#9 9%2-1a -#9 8+-$ 8-& /""9 (# $+% 0(.&$ `9(&7+-./%a
H%7"6%& #"$ &(6321 H-9B HF$ 5%'(2;> U'(2 (& $+-$ 8+(7+ 8(220F221 .%0F&%& $+%
9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# $+% %6%./(#/ (#&(9% -#9 "F$&(9% F3"# 8+(7+ $+% #%8
#"$("# "0 $+% 5/""9; (& 3.%9(7-$%9 `- &FHR%7$ -#9 ($& -7$&B 7+"(7% H%$8%%#
#-$F.% -#9 7F2$F.%a4 ($ (& $+F& "# $+(& '%.1 9(&$(#7$("# $+-$ $+% !+.(&$(-#
7"#7%3$ "0 ".(/(#-2 &(#B 0"22"8(#/ P-F2 -#9 QF/F&$(#%B (& 3"&&(H2%>J *+(&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-' "#. /.'.&0$12 $3 4$(&0+"2 KEL
.%S%'-2F-$("# (& $+F& #"$ &(6321 - 7+-#/% "0 %*?&%B HF$ - 9(00%.%#$ "./-#(&-S
$("# "0 2")/$ 0."6 "#% &1&$%6 "0 '-2F-$("# $" $+% "$+%.B -# "./-#(&-$("# "0
0".7% 3.%9(7-$%9 "# $+% 9(00%.%#7%& "0 02"8 "0 %#%./1 H%$8%%# $+% +F6-#
"./-#(&6 -#9 ($& %#'(."#6%#$ `8+-$ H%7"6%& $+% 9(00%.%#7% +$#=$$& $+%
(#&(9% -#9 $+% "F$&(9%a> Y# $+% 0(.&$ '-2F-$("# 8+-$ (& /""9 6"'%& 0."6 (#&(9%
$" "F$&(9%B 8($+ 2($$2% F#9%.&$-#9(#/B -#9 #%%9 0". F#9%.&$-#9(#/B "0 -#1
2(6($ H%$8%%# $+% $8"> Y# $+% &%7"#9 '-2F-$("#B 8+-$ (& /""9 (& 8+-$ +-&
&-#7$(0(%9 $+% 9(00%.%#7% $+-$ +-& %6%./%9 H%$8%%# $+% $8">
*+F& 8+-$ (& /""9 (# $+% 0(.&$ '-2F-$("# (& #"$ &(6321 H-9 (# $+% &%7"#9>
W". $+(& /""9 $" H%7"6% 5%'(2;B $+% -7$('% $13% 6F&$ H% 7"#0."#$%9 8($+ /'"*/$ "0 8+%$+%. ($ F&%& ($& 0".7% ". #"$> *+% .%S%'-2F-$("# "0 $+% /""9
9%3%#9& $+%.%0".% "# $+% 3.(". 9('(&("# H%$8%%# - &FHR%7$ -#9 ($& %00%7$&>
W". =(%$A&7+%B ($ (& $+."F/+ $+(& &$.-$%/1 "0 &%3-.-$("#B -#9 $+."F/+ $+%
7"#&%_F%#$ 7"#7%3$ "0 57+"(7%;B $+-$ $+% kF9-(7 .%S%'-2F-$("# (63"&%&
F3"# -7$('($1 $+% (#'($-$("# $" #"#-7$('($1 -#9 .%-7$('($1> *+% (#'($-$("# (&
9(&/F(&%9 F#9%. $+% #%8 '-2F% &1&$%6 "0 -# 5-/%#$; 0.%% 0."6B -#9 .%&3"#S
&(H2% 0". ($& -7$&B $+-$ (&B "0 - 5&FHR%7$;> Q& - .%&F2$B &%%# H"$+ /%#%-2"/(7-221
-#9 %#%./%$(7-221 0."6 $+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 0".7%B $+% -7$('% 0".7% "0 (66%9(-$%
9(&7+-./% `$+% &$."#/a 1(%29& $" $+% .%-7$('($1 "0 $+% 8%-TB $.-#&0".6(#/ $+(&
0".7% 0."6 ($& 9(.%7$("# "F$8-.9& (#$" - 9(&3"&($("# "0 0".7% $+-$ "#21 )$9/#%
$" "$+%. 0".7%&B $" "$+%. %'%#$& 0."6 8($+(# ($& "8# (#$%.(". "./-#(&-$("#> Y#
$+% 0(.&$ #"H2% '-2F-$("#B H-9 (& #"$+(#/ HF$ - &%7"#9-.1 %00%7$ "0 /""9
8+%.%-& (# $+% &%7"#9 )$%%$&#*5$&# '-2F-$("#B /""9 (& &($F-$%9 -& $+% "33"&($%
"0 %'(2B -& &"6%$+(#/ "#21 %'%. $" 7"6%B 3."R%7$%9 (#$" - 8".29 H%1"#9 2(0%>
*+% &32($ "0 $+% 0".7%& "0 2(0% (#$" $8" 8".29& (& $+%.%H1 0".6%9 -#9 7"#S
0(.6%9> *+%.% (& - 2"$ $" &-1 -H"F$ $+(& -#-21&(& "0 0".7%4 (# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 61
-./F6%#$ Y 8(&+B +%.%B $" F#9%.2(#% 0"F. $+(#/&>
) *+(& -77"F#$ "0 '-2F% 72%-.21 7"22-3&%& 7"#7%3$& -#9 $+% 9(&7"F.&%& (#
8+(7+ $+%1 0F#7$("# (#$" - 0(%29 "0 0".7%&> *+-$ (&B $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1 &+"8&
%V%632-.(21 +"8 $+% /%#%-2"/1 "0 #(+(2(&6 (# $+% 0(.&$ /%#%.-2 &%#&% 2%-9&
$" -# %#%./%$(7& `$" -# -77"F#$ "0 $+% .%2-$("# H%$8%%# +F6-#& -#9 $+%(.
[5=$4# (# $%.6& "0 02"8& -#9 9(&3"&($("#& "0 0".7%a>
< *+(& 0(%29 (& 7"#&(9%.%9 -& $+% %95$ 0(%29 0."6 "#% '-2F-$("# $" $+% #%V$4
8+-$ +-& 7+-#/%9 (& #"$ $+% 0".7%& -& &F7+B HF$ $+% ")?9&*%9#*"& "0 $+%&%
0".7%& -#9 $+%(. .%2-$("#& 8($+ %-7+ "$+%.> *+(& 9(00%.%#$(-2 $13"2"/1 "0
0".7% -22"8& =(%$A&7+% (# Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#C -#9 %2&%8+%.% $"
59%&$."1; 6%$-3+1&(7-2 9(&$(#7$("#& (# $%.6& "0 $+% %95$&$%% "0 0".7%& $+-$
&FH$%#9 $+%&% 9(&$(#7$("#&> *+% $13"2"/1 "0 0".7% 7"#&$($F$%& $+% $+%".S
%$(7-2 .%&F2$ "0 5-7$('% #(+(2(&6; -#9 &%.'%& -& - #%7%&&-.1 3.%.%_F(&($% $"
-#1 $+(#T(#/ "0 $.-#&'-2F-$("#>N
@ *+-$ &-(9B $+(& $13"2"/1 (& -$ $+% &-6% $(6% +(/+21 -6H(/F"F& (# ($&
.%2-$("# $" 6%$-3+1&(7-2 $+(#T(#/> W".B 8+(2% .%"./-#(&(#/ 6%$-3+1&(7-2
9(&$(#7$("#& (# $%.6& "0 $+% 0".7%& $+-$ &FH$%#9 $+%6B ($ 94%" 2%-9& $" -
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
DN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
6%$-3+1&(7& "0 0".7% (# 8+(7+ 0".7% (& &"# -.$(7F2-$%9 =*#'*& ($& 9(00%.%#$(-S
$("#& `8+-$ Y -6 7-22(#/ 5&3(.($;aB HF$ (& %V72F&('%21 $+"F/+$ (# $%.6& "0
I'C%*"4"?*/94 -#9 I%C/'"4"?*/94 "./-#(&-$("#> *+(& (#$%22%7$F-2 2-3&% "0$%#
2%-9& (# =(%$A&7+%;& 8".T $" -# -S+(&$".(7-2 -77"F#$ "0 $+% "./-#(&-$("# "0
0".7% -#9 - &(6F2$-#%"F& &(632(0(7-$("# "0 $+% 7"632%V($1 "0 $+% 0".6-S
$("# "0 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 -#9 .%2(/("F& 7"#7%3$& -#9 $+%(. 7F2$F.%&> M%.% (#
$+% 0(.&$ %&&-1 "0 Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#CB 0". %V-632%B $+% 6"'% 0."6
#"H2% $" kF9-(7 '-2F-$("# (& 3.%9(7-$%9B 0(.&$B "# -# F#-77"F#$%9 &32($
H%$8%%# $+% 8-..(". -#9 3.(%&$21 #"H(2($1 -#9B &%7"#9B "# - 72-&+ H%$8%%#
9(00%.%#$ $13%& "0 7F2$F.% 9% *2 $+% 9(00%.%#7% +$#=$$& $+% #"H2% -#9 $+%
kF9-(7 7"F29 H% 8+"221 -77"F#$%9 0". (# $%.6& "0 $+% ")?9&*%9#*"& "0 $+%
%95$> *+(& %#9& F3 .%9F7(#/ 7F2$F.% $" $+% 5-00%7$('%; `$+% 6"&$ "H'("F&
9"6-(# "0 $+% %#%./%$(7 8($+(# $+% +F6-#a> *" RF9/% (# $+(& 8-1 .(&T&
-#$+."3"6".3+(&(#/ $+% 9(00%.%#$(-$("#& "0 %#%./1 +$#=$$& $+% +F6-#
-#9 ($& [5=$4# (# $%.6& "0 - 3F.%21 +F6-# 0".7% $+-$ &$-#9& ",#%*.$ ($&
7"#&$($F$('% .%2-$("# $" $%7+#(7-2B %7"#"6(7 -#9 &"7(-2 0".7%&> =(%$A&7+%;&
$+%".1 "0 .-#TB +(& -00(.6-$("# "0 $+% H2"#9 H%-&$B +(& $%#9%#71 $" -#$+."S
3"6".3+(&% 58(22 $" 3"8%.; -#9 +(& #"$("# "0 5/.-#9 3"2($(7&; -.% (63".S
$-#$ %V-632%& "0 $+(& .(&T -#9 -.%B $+%.%0".%B $" H% F#9%.&$""9 -& $+%
%00%7$& "0 - F#(2-$%.-2 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 0".7%>
D `W(#-221a $+% .%9F7$("# "0 -# (#9%$%.6(#-$% 0(%29 "0 0".7%& $" - 0-(.21
9%$%.6(#-$% 0(%29 "0 +F6-# -00%7$& 8($+(# $+% kF9-(7 .%S%'-2F-$("# -.(&%&
&163$"6-$(7-221 -$ $+% '%.1 6"6%#$ $+-$ =(%$A&7+% 8"#9%.& '"= ',59&J
;*&. /9& $5$)?$ 2)"5 ",# "2 #'$ 8,.9*/ )$F94,9#*"&B $+-$ (&B '"= #'$ ',59& /9&
4$9F$ &*'*4*%5 `(# $+% /%#%.-2 6%$-3+1&(7-2 &%#&% "0 58(22 $" #"$+(#/;a> *+(&
6%-#&B 3"&($('%21B $+-$ $+% %6%./%#7% 0."6 "F$ "0 #(+(2(&6 (& #"$+(#/ HF$
- _F%&$("# "0 .%S"./-#(&(#/ $+% 0".7%& F#9%.21(#/ $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 .%S
%'-2F-$("# "0 $+% #"H2% '-2F-$("#> Y$ (& #"$ - _F%&$("# "0 (#'%#$(#/ $+%
#%8 -& &F7+4 $+% "'%.+F6-# (& 94)$9.C 8($+ F& (# $+(& &%#&%> *+% .%9F7$("#
6%-#& #%/-$('%21B +"8%'%.B $+-$ $+% &-(9 %V($ 0."6 #(+(2(&6 .(&T& H%(#/
2"7-$%9 H1 =(%$A&7+% (# - 5"F$ +9/; $" $+% 5".(/(#-2; '-2F-$("#B $+% ".(/(#-2
#"H2% -00(.6-$("# "0 0".7%> Q$ &F7+ 6"6%#$& $+% -7$('% 9%&$.F7$("# "0
6%$-3+1&(7& `5-7$('% #(+(2(&6;a H%7"6%& - 3F.% .%/.%&&("# $" $+% 0(7$("# "0
&3"#$-#%"F& 9(&7+-./%> Y# "$+%. 8".9&B $+% "'%.7"6(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6 9"%&
#"$ 0"22"8 $+% =(%$A&7+%-# 52-8 "0 2(0%; `&%20S&FH2(6-$("# "0 0".7% V,9
&3(.($a HF$ 7"#&$($F$%& - &$.-(/+$0".8-.9 (#'%.&("# "0 $+% 3.(%&$21]
kF9-(7 .%S%'-2F-$("#> Y$ (& $+%&% 6"6%#$& "0 3-#(7 "# =(%$A&7+%;& 3-.$B
". .-$+%.B 8($+(# $+(& 3-#(7B "0 +(& .$%*)$ 2") #'$ 5$#9I'C%*/94 I,)*#C "2
2")/$B $+-$ 6"$('-$% $+% .%3.%&%#$-$("# "0 $+% 5H2"#9 H%-&$; -& $+% 0F$F.%
"0 $+% +F6-# -#9 "0 $+% 6".-2> *+%1 +-'% 2%-9 H"$+ $" - .%R%7$("# "0
=(%$A&7+%;& 3+(2"&"3+1 "0 2(0% V,9 3F.% 0".7% -#9 $" $+% 3-.$21 RF&$(0(%9
-77F&-$("# $+-$ =(%$A&7+% 02-$$%#& 7.F7(-2 9(&$(#7$("#& H%$8%%# 7F2$F.%
-#9 H("2"/1>C
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' DC
O+-$ 7"#&$($F$%& $+% 8+"2% 3."H2%6 +%.% (&B 0(.&$ -#9 2%&& (63".$-#$21B $+%
.%S%'-2F-$("# -#9 $.-#&'-2F-$("# "0 kF9-(7 '-2F-$("# -#9B &%7"#9 -#9 6".%
(63".$-#$21B =(%$A&7+%;& '%.1 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 -7$('% -#9 .%-7$('% 0".7%> Q
.%&3"#&% $" $+(& .%S%'-2F-$("# (& #"$ $" H% 0"F#9 (# $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1 %V7%3$
3+-#$-&6-$(7-221B (# $%.6& "0 - .%$F.# $" - 0(7$('% +(&$".(7-2 3"(#$ "0 3F.%
9(&7+-./% `$+% H2"#9 H%-&$ "0 l))a> O+%#%'%. $+(& 3+-#$-&6 (#'-9%& $+%
$%V$B =(%$A&7+% &(632(0(%& +(& "8# 9(/%&$('% &1&$%6B +(& "8# 5&3(.($; -#9
.%3%-$& $+% $%.6& "0 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 -33."3.(-$("# "0 $+% 8".29 -#9 2(0%
(# $%.6& "0 $+% 53F.%;> *+-$ (& $" &-1B 5&3(.($; (# $+% 2-./% &%#&% 8% -.%
F#.-'%22(#/ (& .%9F7%9 $" - 3F.% .%'%.&-2 "0 5&3(.($; (# $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2
&%#&%B -# (#'%.&("# $+-$ 9"%& #"$+(#/ HF$ .%3%-$ (# (#'%.&% 0".6 $+% 9%&(.%
0". $+% 3F.%>
*+% 5,%7"#9 U&&-14 55^F(2$;;B 55H-9 7"#&7(%#7%;; -#9 .%2-$%9 6-$$%.&; 3."S
'(9%&B +"8%'%.B $+% $%.6& "0 -# -#&8%.> W". ($ 3.%7(&%21 F#9%.7F$& -#9 /"%&
H%1"#9 $+% '%.1 -#-21&(& "0 -7$('%].%-7$('% 0".7% $+-$ F#9%.3(#& $+% &7+%6"0 $+% (#($(-2 $8" -#$-/"#(&$(7 '-2F-$("#& `#"H2%]3.(%&$21B G"6-#]kF9-(7a> Y#
$+% &%7"#9 %&&-1 #"$ "#21 (& $+%.% #"$ -# (#($(-2 "33"&($("# H%$8%%# -7$('%
-#9 .%-7$('% 0".7%&B $+% "./-#(&-$("#& "0 0".7% -.% (66%9(-$%21 3"&($%9
H%1"#9 H("2"/(7-2B 3+1&("2"/(7-2 -#9 3&17+"2"/(7-2 0".7% $" (#72F9% "$+%.
$13%& "0 0".7% `#"$-H21 $%7+#(7-2a> E".%"'%.B $+%&% "./-#(&-$("#& -.% &%%# $"
0".6 - 5$.*9#$. +(&$".1 "0 $+% "./-#(&6 (# ($& .%2-$("# $" $+% %#'(."#6%#$
0."6 8+(7+B 3.%7(&%21B 9(&$(#7$("#& 2(T% $+% 3+1&("2"/(7-2B $+% $%7+#(7-2B $+%
3&17+"2"/(7-2B $+% &"7(-2 $5$)?$ *& #'$ 2*)%# I49/$> *+%&% 7"#&$($F$% 7.F7(-2
-9'-#7%& F3"# $+% &7+%6-& "0 0".7% "0 $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1B (#$(6-$(#/B F2$(6-$%21B
- &%.("F& .%7"#0(/F.(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& "8# &7+%6-& "0 '-2F-$("# -#9 .%S
%'-2F-$("#> K%$ F& &%% +"8 -#9 8+1>
-' "#. /.'.&0$12 $3 4$(&0+"2 KEEL
Y# $+% &%7"#9 %&&-1 $+%.% -.% $8" &($%& (# 8+(7+ $+% "33"&($("# H%$8%%# $+%
-7$('% -#9 $+% .%-7$('% H.%-T& 9"8#B (#$(6-$(#/ - .%$+(#T(#/ "0 $+% 0(%29 "0
0".7%& H%1"#9 $+% 3F.%21 -00%7$('% -#9 &F//%&$(#/ - 2(#% "0 $+(#T(#/ $+-$
&FH2-$%& $+% 5&3(.($ "0 .%'%#/%;> *+% 0(.&$ (& $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2 `ll) -#9
<aB $+% &%7"#9 (& $+% 7"66F#($1 $+-$ 2%$& ($& 6-2%0-7$".& /" F#3F#(&+%9
`ll)I -#9 ))a> Y $F.# 0(.&$ $" $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2> Y$& 9%&7.(3$("# (&
3.%7%9%9 H1 - 7.F7(-2B 9%#&% 3-.-/.-3+ "# $+% 0-7F2$1 "0 3."6(&(#/ 8($+
8+(7+ 8% 6F&$ H%/(#>
W". =(%$A&7+%B $+% &3%7(0(7($1 "0 $+% +F6-# (# 7"#$.-&$ $" "$+%. -#(6-2&
2(%& (# ($& -H(2($1 $" 59;$ I)"5*%$%> Q 3."6(&%B 0". =(%$A&7+%B (& $+% -H(2($1 $"
+"29 $+% 9(&7+-./% "0 "#%;& 0".7% F#$(2 2-$%.> Y# l) "0 5 55^F(2$;;B 55H-9 7"#S
&7(%#7%;; -#9 .%2-$%9 6-$$%.&; +% 8.($%&4
Q 3."6(&% > > > (& H1 #" 6%-#& 6%.%21 - 3-&&('% (#-H(2($1 $" H% .(9 "0 -#
(63.%&&("# "#7% ($ +-& 6-9% ($& (63-7$B #". (& ($ RF&$ (#9(/%&$("# 7-F&%9 H1
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
D? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
/('(#/ 1"F. 8".9 "# &"6% "77-&("# -#9 0(#9(#/ $+-$ 1"F 7-##"$ 7"3%B
(#&$%-9 ($ (& -# -7$('% .$%*)$ #"$ $" 2%$ /" > > > .%-221 ($ (& $+% =*44N% 5$5")C4 &"
$+-$ - 8".29 "0 &$.-#/% #%8 $+(#/&B 7(.7F6&$-#7%& -#9 %'%# -7$& "0 8(22
6-1 H% 32-7%9 _F($% &-0%21 (# H%$8%%# $+% ".(/(#-2 5Y 8(22;B 5Y &+-22 9"; -#9
$+% -7$F-2 9(&7+-./% "0 $+% 8(22B ($& 9/#B 8($+"F$ H.%-T(#/ $+(& 2"#/ 7+-(# "0
$+% 8(22> ZF$ 8+-$ - 2"$ "0 3.%7"#9($("#& $+%.% -.% 0". $+(&j Y# ".9%. $" +-'%
$+-$ 9%/.%% "0 7"#$."2 "'%. $+% 0F$F.%B 6-# 6F&$ 0(.&$ +-'% 2%-.#$ $"
9(&$(#/F(&+ H%$8%%# 8+-$ +-33%#& H1 -77(9%#$B -#9 8+-$ H1 9%&(/#B $"
$+(#T 7-F&-221B $" '(%8 $+% 0F$F.% -& $+% 3.%&%#$ -#9 -#$(7(3-$% ($B $" /.-&3
8($+ 7%.$-(#$1 8+-$ (& %#9 -#9 8+-$ (& 6%-#&B (# -22B $" H% -H2% $"
7-27F2-$%B 7"63F$% h -#9 H%0".% +% 7-# 9" $+(&B 6-# +(6&%20 8(22 .%-221
+-'% $" H%7"6% )$4*9+4$R )$?,49)R 9,#"59#*/ r&"#=$&.*?sB %'%# (# +(& "8#
&%20S(6-/%B &" $+-$ +%B -& &"6%"#% 6-T(#/ - 3."6(&%B (& -#&8%.-H2% 0". +(&
"8# 2,#,)$j `=(%$A&7+% )XXDB @Xm )X??B <X<a
O+%.%-& (# $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1 $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 0".7% 8-& 7"#&(9%.%9 (# $%.6& "0
7"#9F7$(#/ "#%;& 0".7% (66%9(-$%21 $"8-.9& $+% "F$&(9%B +%.% $+% '%.1 8($+S
+"29(#/ "0 "#%;& 0".7%B $+% $%63".-2 /-3 5Z%$8%%# $+% ".(/(#-2 5Y 8(22;B 5Y &+-22
9"; -#9 $+% -7$F-2 9(&7+-./% "0 $+% 8(22B 7"#&$($F$%& $+% '%.1 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 $+%
+F6-#4 3."6(&(#/> P."6(&(#/ (& $+% 6%6".1 "0 $+(& 9%2-1 "0 0".7%4 $+-$ (&B
$+% 8(22;& 6%6".1> *+F&B 0(.&$21B (0 $+% +F6-# (& 0". =(%$A&7+% 3.%9(7-$%9 "#
&F7+ 9%0%..-2 -#9 .%$%#$("#B 0."6 $+% '%.1 H%/(##(#/ "0 $+(& &%7"#9 %&&-1 8%
+-'% #"$ "#21 6"'%9 H%1"#9 $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 $+% (#$%#&%B &3"#$-#%"F&
-#9 (#&$(#7$('% $" H% 0"F#9 (# $+% 0(.&$ -#9 $+(.9 %&&-1&> O% +-'% -2&" 6"'%9
H%1"#9 -#1 #"$("# "0 - 3F.%21 -7$('% 0".7%> *+-$ $+% &3%7(0(7($1 "0 $+% +F6-#
2(%& (# $+% '%.1 9%0%..-2 "0 0".7% 6%-#& $+-$ 0".7% (# +F6-#& 7-# &$F$) H%
3F.%21 -7$('%> *+(& (& #"$ $" &-1B +"8%'%.B $+-$ -#(6-2&B (#9%%9 -#1 "./-#(&6B
9" #"$ 9%0%. %($+%.> [%0%..-2 (& $+% '%.1 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 2(0%> Y$ 6%-#& $+-$ $+%
3."7%&& "0 9(00%.%#$(-$("# 3-.$(7F2-. $" $+% +F6-# (& 3-.$(7F2-.(&%9 $+."F/+
#'$ =9C *& ='*/' +F6-# -#(6-2& ")?9&*%$ $+%(. 0".7%B $+-$ (&B (# =(%$A&7+%-#
$%.6&B 58(22;B ".B (# $+% $%.6& "0 $+(& %&&-1B +-'% %I*)*#> Y$ (& "# $+% H-&(& "0 $+(&
"./-#(&-$("# "0 0".7% $+-$ 8(22(#/ (& 3"&&(H2% *& #'$ 2*)%# I49/$ -#9 $+-$B $+%.%S
0".%B - 9(&$(#7$("# (& 3"&&(H2% H%$8%%# - 8(22 -#9 ($& -7$&> L$+%. "./-#(&6&
6-1 (#9%%9 7"6% $" +-'% &3(.($ (# $+(& 8-1> W". $+% 6"6%#$B +"8%'%.B "#21
$+% +F6-# "./-#(&%& ($&%20 -77".9(#/21B -2$+"F/+ $+(& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 58(22S
(#/; 6%-#& (#'%.&%21 $+-$ $+% +F6-# (& 3.%7(&%21 7"#&$($F$%9 0."6 $+% 0(.&$
$+."F/+ 0".7%& $+-$ -.% #"$ +F6-#> *+(& (&B 3.%7(&%21B $+% -6H('-2%#7% "0
&3(.($>
*+% (632(7-$("#& "0 $+%&% 3"(#$& 0". $+% "33"&($("#& "0 $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1
&+"F29 H% 72%-.> Y$ 6%-#& $+-$ $+% #"$("# "0 - 3F.% -7$('% 0".7% -& &F7+ (& 0(7$("#> Q& Y +-'% -2.%-91 &F//%&$%9B $+(& 0(7$("# -28-1& .(&T& .%$F.#(#/
=(%$A&7+% $" 6%$-3+1&(7& 8+%# +% 8(&+%& $" 9%&$."1 6%$-3+1&(7& (# $+%
+".(A"# "0 $+% $.-#&'-2F-$("# "0 3F.% -7$('($1 `- 9%&$.F7$("# $+-$ .%$F.#&
+(6 -22 $+% 6".% ."F#921 $" $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2a> Y$ 6%-#& 0F.$+%.6".% $+-$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' DX
$+% 3&17+"2"/(7-2 3+%#"6%#"# "0 - +F6-# 58(22; (& #'$ '*%#")*/94 )$%,4# "2 #'$
")?9&*%9#*"& "2 2")/$> *+F& $" $-2T -H"F$ 8(22B -& =(%$A&7+% 9"%&B -& $+% "./-#S
(&-$("# "0 0".7%& 6%-#& #%7%&&-.(21 $" $-2T -H"F$ $+% 3&17+"2"/(7-2 (# $%.6&
$+-$ -.% -$ "#% -#9 $+% &-6% $(6% 3&17+"2"/(7-2 9&. +(&$".(7-2> `Y F#9%.&$-#9
5+(&$".(7-2; +%.% (# - &%#&% $+-$ (#72F9%& 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% &$(22 7-22& $+% 53.%S
+(&$".(7-2;B - #(#%$%%#$+S7%#$F.1 7"#7%3$ 8+(7+ (& 3.%9(7-$%9 "# - 3.(". -#9
$"" F#(2-$%.-2 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ $+-$ $+% +(&$".(7-2 (& 9%3%#9%#$ F3"# $+%
8.($$%# $.-7%>a? *+(& 3-.-/.-3+ "# 3."6(&(#/ &+"8&B (# "$+%. 8".9&B $+-$
-# %#%./%$(7& 7"#&%_F%#$ F3"# /%#%-2"/1 5,%# 8".T 3.(". $" -#9 H%1"#9 $+%
+(&$".(7-221 2-$% -#9 .%2-$('% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# $+% 5(#&(9%; -#9 $+% 5"F$S
&(9%;B 5(#$%.#-2; -#9 5%V$%.#-2; 0".7%B 53&17+%; -#9 5%#'(."#6%#$;> *+-$ &-(9B
$+% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# - 8(22 -#9 ($& -7$& $+-$ -22"8& 0". 3."6(&(#/B -#9 $+-$
3."6(&(#/ (# $F.# .%(#0".7%&B #%'%.$+%2%&& 6%-#& $+-$ 944 $+% $#'*/944C
".(%#$%9 7"#7%3$& $+-$ =(%$A&7+% (& &" %-/%. $" 9%&$."1 (# $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1B -&
+% 3($7+%& $+% #"H2% -/-(#&$ $+% 6".-2($1 "0 $+% &2-'%B $+% &3(.($ "0 G"6%
-/-(#&$ $+% )$%%$&#*5$&# &3(.($ "0 kF9%-B -.% 7"#7%3$& $+-$ 7"#&$($F$% $+%
%I$/*2*/*#C "0 $+% +F6-# -& &F7+ I)*") #" 9&C )$49#*F$ .*%#*&/#*"& +$#=$$& #'$
9/#*F$ 9&. #'$ )$9/#*F$> Q& - .%&F2$B $+%&% 7"#7%3$& 7-##"$ H% 7"#&(9%.%9 -&
F#(2-$%.-221 5#(+(2(&$(7; ". 5.%-7$('%; -2$+"F/+ $+%1 .%6-(# $"" &(632% H"$+ $"
-77"F#$ 0". $+%(. /%#%-2"/1 -#9 $" 7"#$(#F% $" &$.F7$F.% $+% 6".-2 (#$%.S
3.%$-$("# "0 $+% 8".29 -& &F7+>
!-$%/".(%&B $+%#B $+-$ =(%$A&7+% &" "0$%# 8(&+%& $" /%$ H%+(#9 -& 5%3(3+%S
#"6%#-2;B ". 8".&% 9(&6(&& -& 5F&%2%&&; -#9 3F.%21 50(7$($("F&; `&%% 3-.$(7F2-.21
)XN?HB llJDJhCIaB ". -77"F#$ 0".B -& 8% &-8 (# $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1B (# $+% %V72F&('%
$%.6& "0 $+% 3&17+"2"/1 "0 )$%%$&#*5$&#B $+%&% 7-$%/".(%& -.% 2"7-$%9 +%.%
=*#'*& #'$ 2")59#*"& "2 5$5")C> ,(#7% $+(& 0".6-$("# 6-.T& $+% 3."7%&& "0
+"6(#(&-$("# -& &F7+ `$+%.% (& #" +F6-# "./-#(&6 8($+"F$ $+% 9(00%.%#$(-S
$("#& "0 6%6".1aB 7-$%/".(%& $+-$ %6%./% 8($+(# ($ 7-##"$ H% %($+%. &(6321
5-7$('%; ". 5.%-7$('%;> *+F&B $+% 7-$%/".(%& -/-(#&$ 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% &%$& 6F7+
"0 +(& $+(#T(#/ h 7-F&-2($1B 0(#-2($1B 3F.3"&%B $+% &FHR%7$('($1 "0 8(22 h -.% $+%
.%&F2$ "0 - 2"#/ 3."7%&& $+-$ 9%&(/#-$%& $+% +F6-# -& &F7+ -#9 $+%.%0".%
9%&(/#-$%& $+%6 9% 94%" -7$('%B %'%# (0B -$ $+% &-6% $(6%B $+%1 3.%RF9/% +"8
$" -.$(7F2-$% $+% &FH3+%#"6%#-2> *+(& 6%-#& 0(#-221 $+-$ RF&$ -& "#% 7-##"$
"33"&% $+% -7$('% $" $+% .%-7$('% "#% 7-##"$ &(6321 "33"&%B -& 6-#1 3-&S
&-/%& "0 =(%$A&7+% 9" `%&3%7(-221B -/-(#B (# $+% 3"&$+F6"F& #"$%&B P*44 #"
E"=$)a $+% 7-$%/".(-2 $" 8+-$ 2(%& F#9%.#%-$+ ". H%1"#9 ($>
K%$ F& .%7-22 -$ $+(& 3"(#$B 0". $+% &-T% "0 72-.($1B $+% -./F6%#$ -$ $+%
H%/(##(#/ "0 l)@ "0 $+% 0(.&$ %&&-14 5 55^""9 -#9 U'(2;;B 55^""9 -#9 Z-9;; ;>
=(%$A&7+% 8.($%&4
*+%.% (& #"$+(#/ &$.-#/% -H"F$ $+% 0-7$ $+-$ 2-6H& H%-. - /.F9/% $"8-.9&
2-./% H(.9& "0 3.%14 HF$ $+-$ (& #" .%-&"# $" H2-6% $+% 2-./% H(.9& "0 3.%1
0". 7-..1(#/ "00 $+% 2($$2% 2-6H&> Y$ (& RF&$ -& -H&F.9 $" -&T &$.%#/$+ &"# $"
%V3.%&& ($&%20 -& &$.%#/$+B &"# $" H% - 9%&(.% $" "'%.$+."8B 7.F&+B H%7"6%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
JI !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' J)
L# $+% H-&(& "0 - 3-&&-/% 2(T% $+(&B ($ +-& "0$%# H%%# -./F%9 $+-$ =(%$A&7+%;&
_F%&$("#(#/ "0 57-F&% -#9 %00%7$; (# $+% 6".-2 &3+%.% .%6"'%& $+% '%.1 &($% "0
.%&(&$-#7% $" -22 0".6& "0 3-.$(7F2-.(&6B $+-$ (&B $+% $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 &FHR%7$ "0
6"9%.#($1B 57"#9($("#; "0 $+% 0".6-2 &FHR%7$ "0 2-8 F3"# 8+(7+ $+% 7"#&$(S
$F$("#& "0 9%6"7.-71 -#9 $+% U#2(/+$%#6%#$ 7F2$F.% "0 F#('%.&-2 .(/+$& (&
3.%9(7-$%9>X *+F&B $" 59%&$."1; $+% .%2-$("# "0 7-F&%]%00%7$ .%6"'%& $+% 3"&S
&(H(2($1B &" $+% -./F6%#$ /"%&B "0 -77"F#$(#/ 0". %'%#$& (# $%.6& "0 - &FHR%7$
3.(". $" $+"&% %'%#$&B -# -77"F#$ "# $+% H-&(& "0 8+(7+ (#RF&$(7% 7-# H%
6%-&F.%9 (# .%2-$("# $" - 0".6-2 &FHR%7$ "0 3"2($(7-2 -#9 %$+(7-2 2-8> *+%
-H"'% 3-&&-/% 0."6 $+% &%7"#9 %&&-1 "0 Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#C &($F-$%&
H"$+ $+% .%2-$("# "0 7-F&%]%00%7$ -#9 $+% %7"#"61 "0 0".7% &FH$%#9(#/ ($ (# 6".% 7"632(7-$%9 3."7%&& "0 9(00%.%#$(-$("# $+-# (& "00%.%9 H1 $+% #"$("#& "0
-7$('% -#9 .%-7$('% 0".7%>
O+-$ 8% &%% +%.% (& $+-$B 0". =(%$A&7+%B 6".-2 .%&3"#&(H(2($1 (& #"$ &(6321
-# %7"#"61 "0 -00%7$> Y$ 9"%& #"$ &(6321 7"#&$($F$% $+% %00%7$ "0 -# (#'%.&("#
"0 0".7% $+-$ 7.%-$%& $+% (#$%.(".($1 0."6 8+(7+ $+% &"F2 -#9 &FHR%7$('($1
%6%./%B "#% -& - .%&F2$ "0 8+(7+ $+% 5&FHR%7$; 7-# H% &%3-.-$%9 0."6 ($& 5-7$&;>
G-$+%.B .%&3"#&(H(2($1 %#&F%& 0."6 - 5&%.(%& "0 3.%7"#9($("#&; $+-$ 6F&$ 6-T%
6-# 9%$%.6(#-$% -#9 9%$%.6(#%9 0". /)$9#*F$ &($F-$("#& $" %6%./% (# $+% 0(.&$
32-7%> *+% &%3-.-$("# "0 $+% H%7"6(#/ "0 0".7% (#$" - &FHR%7$ -#9 ($& -7$& (&
#"$B (# "$+%. 8".9&B $+% .%&F2$ "0 - 3&17+"2"/(7-2 0".7% `$+% .F&% "0 )$%%$&#*J
5$&#am ($ (& $+% %00%7$ "0 - &%.(%& "0 0".7%&B H"$+ +F6-# -#9 #"#+F6-#B
5(66-$%.(-2; -#9 56-$%.(-2;B $+-$ /('% .(&% $" $+% #"$("# "0 &FHR%7$('($1> *+(&
(& - 7.F7(-2 -./F6%#$ $+% (632(7-$("#& "0 8+(7+ -.% #"$ $" H% 2"&$ &(/+$ "0>
Y$ 6%-#&B 0(.&$B $+-$ &FHR%7$('($1 (& - 0".7% 9%$%.6(#%9 H1 "$+%. 0".7%&> Y$ (&
+%.% $+-$ =(%$A&7+%;& /%#%-2"/(7-2 -#9 %#%./%$(7 7.($(_F% "0 b-#$(-# $.-#&S
7%#9%#$-2]0".6-2 &FHR%7$('($1 (& ($&%20 6"&$ 0".7%0F2> W". ($ 9"%& #"$ &-1 $+-$
$+(& &FHR%7$('($1 (& - 5F&%2%&& 0(7$("#; HF$ 7(.7F6&7.(H%& ($ 8($+(# +(&$".(7-2
3-.-6%$%.&B $+% 0".7% "0 8+(7+ 7-# $+%6&%2'%&B +"8%'%.B #" 2"#/%. .%&(&$ $+%
(#7.%-&(#/21 7"632%V 0".7%& "0 $+% 7"#$%63".-.1 8".29> Y$ 6%-#&B &%7"#9B
$+-$ $+%&% "$+%. 0".7%& #%%9 $" H% -77"F#$%9 0". 8($+(# $+% /%#%.-2 0(%29 "0
0".7%& (# 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+%;& $+%".1 "0 %#%./%$(7& (& (#$%.%&$%9> Q#9 ($ 6%-#&B
$+(.9B 3.(". $" -#9 H%1"#9 $+% 3-.$(7F2-. 7"#$%V$ "0 $+% 0".6-$("# "0 &FHS
R%7$('($1B $+-$ ($ (& "#21 #')",?' .%/F2-.(&-$("# -#9 $+."F/+ 9%$%.6(#-$("#
$+-$ $+% (..%/F2-.B &(#/F2-. -#9 7.%-$('% (# $+% +F6-# 7-# 7"6% 0".8-.9 (#
$+% 0(.&$ 32-7%>)I *+(& -./F6%#$ #"$ "#21 %V7%%9& $+% $%.6& "0 =(%$A&7+%;&
9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# $+% -7$('% -#9 .%-7$('%B ($ -2&" 7-22& 0". - .%7-&$(#/ "0 $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
6-&$%.B $" H% - $+(.&$ 0". %#%6(%&B .%&(&$-#7% -#9 $.(F63+&B -& ($ (& $" -&T
8%-T#%&& $" %V3.%&& ($&%20 -& &$.%#/$+> Q _F-#$F6 "0 0".7% (& RF&$ &F7+ _F-#$F6 "0 9.('%B 8(22B -7$("#B (# 0-7$ ($ (& #"$+(#/ HF$ $+(& 9.('(#/B 8(22(#/
-#9 -7$(#/B -#9 "#21 $+% &%9F7$("# "0 2-#/F-/% `-#9 $+% 0F#9-6%#$-2
%..".& "0 .%-&"# 3%$.(0(%9 8($+(# ($a 8+(7+ 7"#&$.F%& -22 -7$("# F3"# -#
-/%#71B - 5&FHR%7$; 7-# 6-T% ($ -33%-. "$+%.8(&%>
`=(%$A&7+% )XXDB <?a
.%2-$("# H%$8%%# +(& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 9%6"7.-71 -#9 -.(&$"7.-71 `&%2%7S
$("#a> O+-$B $+%#B -.% $+%&% 53.%7"#9($("#&;i
Y# 3-.-/.-3+ $+.%% "0 $+% &%7"#9 %&&-1 =(%$A&7+% .%&3"#9& $+-$ $+%1 2(% (#
5&$5"#$/'&*/%> M% 8.($%&4 5P%.+-3& $+%.% (& #"$+(#/ 6".% &$.-#/% $+-# r$+%
+F6-#;&s $%7+#(7& "0 6%6".1 > > > > Q $+(#/ 6F&$ H% HF.#$ (# &" $+-$ ($ &$-1& (#
$+% 6%6".14 "#21 &"6%$+(#/ $+-$ 7"#$(#F%& #" ',)# &$-1& (# $+% 6%6".1;
`=(%$A&7+% )XXDB D)a> E"&$ 7"66%#$-$".& "0 $+(& 3-&&-/% +-'% 0"7F&%9 $+%(.
-$$%#$("# "# $+% .%&F2$-#$ 7.F%2$1 $+-$ F#9%.2(%&B 0". =(%$A&7+%B %$+(7-2 7"#S
7%3$& 2(T% 7"#&7(%#7% -#9 .%&3"#&(H(2($1> Y# $+(& 3%.&3%7$('% ($ (& "0$%# -./F%9
$+-$ =(%$A&7+%;& 7"#7%.# (& $" &+"8 +"8 $+% 6"&$ &3(.($F-2 %$+(7-2 7"#7%3$&
-.% 3.%9(7-$%9 "# $+% 6"&$ '("2%#$ +(&$".1 "0 -00%7$> M%#7% $+% (63".$-#7% "0
=(%$A&7+%;& -&(9% $+-$ b-#$;& 7-$%/".(7-2 (63%.-$('% 5&6%22& "0 7.F%2$1; `(H(9>B
DJa> O+-$ (& F#9%.%&$(6-$%9 (# $+(& -33.%7(-$("# (& $+% 0-7$ $+-$ $+(& 3-&&-/%
.%7".9& - 8(9%#(#/ "0 $+% %#%./%$(7 -77"F#$ "0 7"#7%3$& (# $%.6& "0 -00%7$&
(#$" "#% $+-$ (#72F9%& #$/'&*/94 2")/$%> *+% 0".7% H%+(#9 "F. 6%$-3+1&(7-2
'-2F-$("#& (& #"$ RF&$ -00%7$('% 0". =(%$A&7+%B ($ (& -2&" $%7+#(7-2> *+F&B (0 $+%
58(22; (& - .%&F2$ "0 56%6".1;B -#9 56%6".1; (& $+% .%&F2$ "0 H"$+ 7.F%2$1 -#9
$+% $%7+#(7-2 "./-#(&-$("# "0 "F. H"9(%& h $+-$ (&B "F. 7".3".-2 0".7%& h $+%#
$+% 8(22B -#9 ($& -77"63-#1(#/ 7"#7%3$& `3F.3"&%B (#$%#$("#B 0(#-2($1 -#9
3."6(&(#/a 9%.('% 0."6 -# %#%./%$(7 9(&3"&($("# H%$8%%# "F$&(9% -#9 (#&(9%
$+-$ (& 9# #'$ %95$ #*5$ -00%7$('% -#9 $%7+#(7-2>
Y# $+% $%.6& $+-$ =(%$A&7+% 6"&$ "0$%# F&%& (# $+% 5*.(2"/1 "0 W.%% ,3(.($&;
-#9 $+% O$&$94"?CB $+% "3%# 0(%29 "0 0".7%& H%+(#9 6%$-3+1&(7-2 '-2F-$("# -.%
&(6F2$-#%"F&21 53&17+"2"/(7-2;B 53+1&("2"/(7-2; -#9 5+(&$".(7-2;> M%.% Y 8(&+
$" ".(%#$ $+% $%.6 5+(&$".(7-2; $"8-.9& $+% $%7+#(7-2> *+F&B -/-(#B 8+-$
"./-#(&%& $+% 0(%29 "0 0".7%& F#9%.21(#/ - 9(&7F.&('% 0(%29 "0 '-2F-$("#
`5/""9 -#9 H-9;B 5/""9 -#9 %'(2;B "3$(6(&6B 3%&&(6(&6B #(+(2(&6a 7-##"$ H%
%V72F&('%21 9(&7F&&%9 (# $+% $"" +F6-# $%.6& "0 - 53.(%&$21 7-&$%;B ". 5-#
-&7%$(7 3.(%&$;B ". #"H2% 5-.$(&$& -#9 &$-$%&6-#;B HF$ 6F&$ H% 9%&7.(H%9B (#
3-.$B (# $%.6& "0 - .%2-$("#&+(3 H%$8%%# $%7+#(7-2 "HR%7$ -#9 -00%7$ "F$ "0
8+(7+ $+% +F6-# "./-#(&6 9(00%.%#$(-$%& ($&%20 $" H%/(# 8($+> *+(& 3."7%&& (&
$+-$ "0 5&3(.($F-2(&-$("#;>
,%'%.-2 $+(#/& -.% -H&"2F$%21 9%$%.6(#(#/ (# $+(& .%2-$("#&+(3> W(.&$4 ($ (&
"#% $+-$ (& F#9%. 7"#&$-#$ 7+-#/%> =(%$A&7+%;& $%#9%#71B $+%.%0".%B $" .%9F7%
($ %($+%. $" H2"7T& "0 7F2$F.-2 $13%& `$+% ="H2%B $+% G"6-#B $+% kF9-(7a ". $" 3F.%21 -00%7$('% %7"#"61 7"#&$($F$%& - &+".$S7(.7F($(#/ "0 $+% +(&$".(7-2
0".7%& (# 32-1 8($+(# $+% 0(%29 "0 0".7%& &FH$%#9(#/ 6%$-3+1&(7&> Y$ (& -$
&F7+ 6"6%#$& "0 &+".$S7(.7F($(#/ $+-$ $+% H("2"/(&(#/ =(%$A&7+% .%$F.#& $"
$+% &F.0-7%> *+F&B -/-(#B /"&#)9 M%(9%//%.B $+% 8-1 $" 7"F#$%. $+% .%9F7$("#
"0 7F2$F.% $" #-$F.% (# =(%$A&7+% (& #"$ $" .%S&3(.($F-2(&% +(& H("2"/1B HF$ $"
&+"8 $+% 8-1 (# 8+(7+ (# $+% 0(.&$ 32-7% +(& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 2(0%B -#9 "0 $+%
3-.$(7F2-.($1 "0 +F6-# 2(0% 0."6 8($+(# $+% %7"#"61 "0 $+% "./-#(7 (#
/%#%.-2B %V7%%9& -#9 -77"F#$& 0". $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 &3(.($>
*" 9" $+(& 8"F29 &+"8 $+-$B 0". =(%$A&7+%B - '-&$ 5&3(.-2; .F#& 0."6 $+% 6"&$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
J< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
3.(6($('% "./-#(7 &1&$%6& "0 9(/%&$("# -#9 6%$-H"2(&6B %#2-./(#/ "F$ 6".%
-#9 6".% 8(9%21 $+."F/+ (#&$-#7%& "0 9%0%..-2 -#9 9(00%.%#$(-$("# 2(T% $%7+S
#(7&B 2-#/F-/% -#9 &"7(-2 (#&$($F$("#& $" $+"&% "./-#(&6& 8+"&% 9(/%&$('%
&1&$%6& 7-# I)"5*%$ `+F6-#&a>)) O+%# =(%$A&7+% 6-(#$-(#& $+-$ 5&3(.($ (& &$"6-7+;B ($ (& $+(& &3(.-2 "0 &3(.($F-2(&-$("# $+-$ +% +-& (# 6(#9> *+% -77F&-S
$("# $+-$ =(%$A&7+%-# 3+1&("2"/1 (&B $+%.%0".%B .%9F7$("#(&$B %63(.(7(&$ -#9
#-$F.-2(&$B 8+(2% F#9"FH$%921 RF&$(0(%9 H1 &%'%.-2 2%'%2& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $%V$B
6(&&%& $+(& '%.1 &3(.-2 (# 8+(7+ $+% 6"&$ 7"632%V 2%'%2 "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $%V$& (&
(#$%.%&$%9> *+%&% 3-.-/.-3+& "# $+% 0".6-$("# "0 $+% 0-7F2$1 "0 3."6(&(#/
-.% "#% &F7+ %V-632%>
,%7"#94 $+% $%7+#(7-2 "./-#(&-$("# "0 $+% 8(22 3.%&F33"&%& #%($+%. $+% 8(22
#". $+% 0-7F2$1 "0 3."6(&(#/ $" H% 0".6%9> A,/' 9 =*44 9&. 29/,4#C $5$)?$ ",# "2
#'*% '*%#")C "2 5&$5"&*/%> =(%$A&7+%;& -77"F#$ "0 $+% %6%./%#7% "0 .%&3"#&(S
H(2($1 %V7%%9& $+% "33"&($("# H%$8%%# $+% -7$('% -#9 .%-7$('% H1 &+"8(#/
0."6 $+% H%/(##(#/ $+-$ -#1 &3(.($ I)*") #" +$*&? 9/#*F$ ") )$9/#*F$ %6%./%& 0."6
$+(& $%7+#(7"S-00%7$('% +(&$".1 "0 7.F%2$1 -#9 (#$%.(".(&-$("#> O% 7-# $+%.%S
0".% 7"#0(.6 $+-$ 8+%# =(%$A&7+% 3."R%7$& $+(& +(&$".1 "0 (#$%.(".(&-$("# "#$"
$+% .%-7$('% &"F2B +% H%$.-1& - 9.('% $" &%3-.-$% "F$ $+% +(&$".(7-2 0."6 $+%
3&17+"2"/(7-2 -#9 $+% 3+1&("2"/(7-2> Q& - .%&F2$ "0 $+(& &%3-.-$("# $+% %#%.S
/%$(7 0(%29 (# 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% (& (#$%.%&$%9 (& (63"'%.(&+%9B -#9 $+% .(&T
.%$F.#& "0 &%3-.-$(#/ 0".7% 0."6 ($& +(&$".(7-2 9(00%.%#$(-$("#&B $+-$ (&B 2)"5
#'$ 5,4#*I4*/*#C "2 2")/$% *& ='*/' 9&C 2")/$ &$/$%%9)*4C "I$)9#$%> Y$ &+"F29 -2&" H%
72%-. H1 #"8 $+-$ $+(& 9.('% $" &%3-.-$% (# =(%$A&7+%;& $%V$ (& "#% "0 -33."S
3.(-$("# $+-$ 6-.T& - 3-.$(7F2-. 3%.("9 "0 &3(.($F-2 %'"2F$("#B 9(/%&$("# -#9
7-$%/".(&-$("#B "#% 8($+(# 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% .%6-(#& 7-F/+$ -$ $+% '%.1
6"6%#$ $+-$ +% /('%& F& $+% $%.6& H1 8+(7+ $" %V7%%9 ($4 6%$-3+1&(7&> O%
7-# $+F& 7+-.-7$%.(&% $+(& 3%.("9 H1 H"$+ H1 - 3-.$(7F2-. "./-#(&-$("# "0 0".7%
$+-$ 3."R%7$& "F$&(9% "0 $+% +F6-# 0".7%& $+-$ 7"#&$($F$% ($ (# $+% 0(.&$ 32-7%>
Y# $+(& &%#&% !*$#@%/'$N% ?$&$94"?C "2 5$5")CR =*44 9&. )$%I"&%*+*4*#C /944 2")
2,)#'$) ?$&$94"?*%*&?R '*% &"#*"& "2 2")/$ 2") 2,)#'$) .*22$)$&#*9#*"& *& ").$) 2") #'$
',59& #" +$ /"&F*&/*&?4C %*#,9#$. =*#'*& 2")/$% #'9# $H/$$. 9&. /"&%#*#,#$ *# 9# "&$
9&. #'$ %95$ #*5$Z Q&4C "& #'*% +9%*% /9& #'$ #)9&%F94,9#*"&R #'$ k"F$)',59&NR
"I$& ,I 9% 9& $#'*/94 9&. /,4#,)94 I"%%*+*4*#C 2") #'$ ',59&>
*" &-1 -& 6F7+ "#21 H%/(#& $" 9" RF&$(7% $" $+%&% "3%#(#/ 3-.-/.-3+& "0
$+% &%7"#9 %&&-1 $+-$ +-'% H%%# $"" "0$%# 3"".21 .%-9> *+(& 7"#02-$("# "0
0".7%&B $"/%$+%. 8($+ $+% %V3-#&("# "0 $+% $%.6& "0 %#%./%$(7& H1 8+(7+ "#%
.%02%7$& F3"# ($B 0".%/."F#9 -H"'% -22 $+% #-$F.% "0 $+% *559&$&# 2(#T&
H%$8%%# $+% /%#%-2"/(7-2B $+% %#%./%$(7 -#9 $+% %$+(7-2> *+% -6H(/F($1 "0
=(%$A&7+%;& $.-#&'-2F-$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 '-2F%& (& $" H% &($F-$%9 -#9
F#$(%9 +%.%4 $+(& $.-#&'-2F-$("# (& -/-(# #"$B -& M%(9%//%. -#9 "$+%.& +-'%
7"#$%#9%9B - _F%&$("# "0 3"&($(#/ #%8 '-2F%& 92#$) $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 6%$-S
3+1&(7&> G-$+%.B $+%&% '-2F%& %6%./% -& - $.-#&'-2F-$("# "0 $+% 2-$$%. 2)"5
=*#'*& $+(& $HI9&.$. %#%./%$(7 -#-21&(&> Y# "$+%. 8".9& 8+-$ (& $" H% &$.%&&%9
(# .%-9(#/ =(%$A&7+% $"9-1 (& -$ "#% -#9 $+% &-6% $(6%B 0(.&$B $+% -#-21&(& "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' J@
%'%.1$+(#/ (# $%.6& "0 0".7% -#9B &%7"#9B $+% -#-21&(& "0 $+(& '%.1 0".7% (#
$%.6& "0 - +(&$".(7-221 9(00%.%#$(-$%9B 7+-#/(#/ -#9 %V3-#9(#/ 7"632%V "0
0".7%&B (# 8+(7+ #" 3-.$(7F2-. 0".7% ". -#-21&(& "0 0".7% 3.%9"6(#-$%&>
Q# (#9(7-$("# "0 $+(& (66-#%#$ 6%$+"9 (& $" H% 0"F#9 (# =(%$A&7+%;&
3".$.-($ "0 $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2 (# $+% &%7"#9 3-.-/.-3+ "0 $+(& %&&-1B
"#% $+-$ %6%./%& 0."6 "F$ "0 $+% -H"'% F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 7"#&$.-(#$B 7.F%2$1
-#9 9%$%.6(#-$("#> K%$ F& #"8 $F.# $" ($>
Y# l< "0 $+% &%7"#9 %&&-1 =(%$A&7+% 8.($%&4
*+% (66%#&% -6"F#$ "0 2-H"F. (#'"2'%9 (# 8+-$ Y +-'% 7-22%9 $+% 56".S
-2($1 "0 7F&$"6; rA*##4*/';$*# .$) A*##$sB $+% -7$F-2 2-H"F. "0 6-# "# +(6&%20
9F.(#/ $+% 2"#/%&$ %3"7+ "0 $+% +F6-# .-7%B +(& 8+"2% 2-H"F. +$2")$
'*%#")CB (& %V32-(#%9 -#9 RF&$(0(%9 "# - /.-#9 &7-2% > > > H1 $+(& 0-7$4 8($+
$+% +%23 "0 $+% 6".-2($1 "0 7F&$"6 -#9 $+% &"7(-2 &$.-($R-7T%$B 6-# 8-&
59.$ $.F21 3.%9(7$-H2%> K%$ F& 32-7% "F.&%2'%&B "# $+% "$+%. +-#9B -$ $+%
%#9 "0 $+(& (66%#&% 3."7%&& 8+%.% $+% $.%% -7$F-221 H%-.& 0.F($B 8+%.%
&"7(%$1 -#9 ($& 6".-2($1 "0 7F&$"6 .%'%-2 8+-$ $+%1 8%.% &(6321 #'$ 5$9&%
#"4 8% $+%# 0(#9 $+% %"F$)$*?& *&.*F*.,94 r.9% %",F$)9*&$ -&.*F*.,,5s -& $+%
.(3%&$ 0.F($ "# ($& $.%%B 2(T% "#21 $" ($&%20B +-'(#/ 0.%%9 ($&%20 0."6 $+%
U +$)%*##4*/'s (#9('(9F-2
6".-2($1 "0 7F&$"6B -# -F$"#"6"F&B &F3.-S%$+(7-2 r[
6-# 8($+ +(& "8# (#9%3%#9%#$B 9F.-H2% 8(22B 8+" +-& #'$ )*?'# #" 59;$ 9
I)"5*%$ r.$) =*);4*/' F$)%I)$/'$& .9)2 s -#9 +-& - 3."F9 7"#&7("F&#%&& _F(S
'%.(#/ (# %'%.1 6F&72% "0 ='9# +% +-& 0(#-221 -7+(%'%9 -#9 (#7".3".-$%9
r*& *'5 4$*+'92# ?$=").$& *%#sB -# -7$F-2 -8-.%#%&& "0 3"8%. -#9 0.%%9"6B 0%%2(#/ $+-$ 6-# (# /%#%.-2 +-& .%-7+%9 7"632%$("# > > > > *+% 50.%%; 6-#B
$+% 3"&&%&&". "0 -# F#H.%-T-H2%B 9F.-H2% 8(22 $+F& +-& +(& "8# %#9&.9). "2
F94,$ > > > > rM%s /('%& +(& 8".9 -& &"6%$+(#/ 8+(7+ 7-# H% .%2(%9 "#B
H%7-F&% +% (& &$."#/ %#"F/+ $" .%6-(# F3.(/+$ (# $+% 0-7% "0 6(&+-3 ".
%'%# 5(# $+% 0-7% "0 0-$%; > > > > *+% 3."F9 .%-2(A-$("# "0 $+% %V$.-".9(#-.1
3.('(2%/% "0 )$%I"&%*+*4*#CB $+% -8-.%#%&& "0 $+(& .-.% 0.%%9"6 -#9 3"8%.
"'%. +(6&%20 -#9 +(& 9%&$(#1B +-& 3%#%$.-$%9 +(6 $" $+% 9%3$+& -#9
H%7"6% -# (#&$(#7$B +(& 9"6(#-#$ (#&$(#7$> O+-$ 8(22 +% 7-22 +(&
9"6(#-#$ (#&$(#7$B -&&F6(#/ $+-$ +% #%%9& - 8".9 0". ($i =" 9"FH$
-H"F$ $+% -#&8%.4 $+(& (#&$(#7$ $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2 7-22& +(& /"&J
%/*$&/$>
`=(%$A&7+% )XXDB @XhDI])X??B <X@hDa
*+(& %V$.-".9(#-.1 3-&&-/% .%&F6%& 6-#1 $+%6%& $" H% 0"F#9 %2&%8+%.% (#
=(%$A&7+%;& 8.($(#/& $+-$ 2""T 0".8-.9 $" $+% %#%./%$(7 9(&3"&($("# "0 $+%
"'%.+F6-#> *+%.% (& 6F7+ $" -#-21&%4 Y 8(22 -/-(# H% H.(%0 8($+(# $+%
7"#$%V$ "0 $+% -./F6%#$> *+% 6-&$%.1 "'%. H"$+ "#%;& "8# (#$%.#-2 0".7%&
-#9 %V$%.#-2 0".7%& `95") 29#*a (& &%%# +%.% -& - 3."7%&& "0 &3(.($F-2(&-$("#B $+%
3.%7"#9($("# "0 8+(7+ (& 9%$%.6(#-$("# -#9 7"#&$.-(#$> G-$+%. $+-# &F7S
7F6H(#/ $" $+(& 7"#&$.-(#$B `$+% 5.%-7$('%;aB $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2
#)9&%2")5% ($ (# &F7+ - 8-1 $+-$ $+% 0".7%& "./-#(&(#/ ($& 8(22 -.%B (# $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
JD !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
'%.1 3."7%&& "0 "./-#(&(#/ ($B )$J")?9&*%$. +C #'*% =*44> *+% 3."7%&& (& (# $+(&
&%#&% 59(-2%7$(7-2;B HF$ #"$ (0 - 9(-2%7$(7-2 .%2-$("# 3.%&F33"&%& $+% $8" $%.6&
$" H% 9(-2%7$(7(&%9> W". #%($+%. $+% 0".7%&B #". $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2;& 8(22
3.%7%9% %-7+ "$+%. (# $+%(. 9(.%7$("#m $+%(. &3-7% "0 6F$F-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# (&
7.%-$%9 (# $+% 3."7%&&> *+% 3."7%&& (& 9(-2%7$(7-2 (# $+% &%#&%B $+%.%0".%B "0 $+%
3.%S%6(#%#7% "0 $+(& &3-7% "'%. $+% $%.6& $" 8+(7+ ($ /('%& .(&% -#9B -& .%&F2$ "0 8+(7+B $+%&% $%.6& -.% .-9(7-221 F#&$-H2%B 6F$F-221 9%0(#(#/
(#&$-#7%&>)< -# *% #'*% %I9/$ #'9# *% 9/#*F$ 9&. I)$?&9&# =*#' #'$ 2,#,)$>)@ O+-$
(&B $+%.%0".%B &(#/F2-. -H"F$ $+(& 3-&&-/% (& $+-$ =(%$A&7+% 32-7%& +%.% $+%
3."7%&& "0 .%S%'-2F-$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7&B 3-.$(7F2-. $" $+% "'%.+F6-#B 8($+(#
- +(&$".(7-2 3."7%&& "0 9(00%.%#$(-$("#& "0 %#%./1B 8+(7+ 9(00%.%#$(-$("#&
%6%./% 0."6 "F$ "0 - 59(-2%7$(7-2; .%2-$("# H%$8%%# $+% +F6-# "./-#(&6
-#9 $+% $%7+#(7-2> *+% &"'%.%(/# 8(22 (& $+F& 7"#&(9%.%9 -& $+% 9(/%&$("# "0
- 8+"2% +(&$".1 "0 2-H"F. F3"# +F6-# -00%7$& $+-$ -22"8 0". $+% "./-#(&-$("#
"0 $(6%B "0 6%6".1B "0 3."6(&(#/B -#9B $+%.%0".%B "0 8(22(#/> *+% &"'%.%(/#
8(22 3.%&F33"&%& -#9 $.-#&0".6& (# $F.# $+(& +(&$".1> =(%$A&7+% 7-22& $+(&
$.-#&0".6-$("# 5(#7".3".-$("#; `6*&F$)4$*+,&?aB $+% 6"&$ (#$%.%&$(#/ 7"#7%3$
(# =(%$A&7+% $" 6-.T &3(.($F-2 9(/%&$("#>
*+(& $.-#&0".6-$("# (& $+F& $+% (#7".3".-$("# "0 7"#&$.-(#$ $" $+% %V$%#$
$+-$ $+% (#9('(9F-2;& '%.1 6-&$%.1 "'%. $+(& 7"#&$.-(#$ H%7"6%& - 0".6 "0
.%&3"#&(H(2($1 $+-$ (# $F.# H%7"6%& ($& 9"6(#-#$ (#&$(#7$> Y# $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1
$+% %V72F&('%21 3&17+"2"/(7-2 $%.6& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& .%S%'-2F-$("# "0 $+% kF9-(7
&7+%6- "0 '-2F-$("# 3.%7(3($-$%9 =(%$A&7+% (#$" -# -00(.6-$("# "0 #"H2%
(#&$(#7$& -#9 9(&7+-./%> M%.%B - 6F7+ 6".% 7"632%V 3."7%&& "0 .%S%'-2F-$("#
(& H%(#/ 8.($$%# "F$4 $+% (#&$(#7$ "0 $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2 (& #"$ - .%/.%&S
&("# $" $+% 5#-$F.-2; H%#%-$+ $+% &+-6% -#9 #(+(2(&6 "0 $+% 57('(2(&(#/;
3."7%&&B ($ (& 3.%7(&%21 ($& $.-#&'-2F-$("# V,9 "'%.7"6(#/> *+(& $.-#&'-2F-$("#
(&B (# - 2"/(7 72"&% $" $+-$ "0 M%/%2(-# 7,2'$+,&?B &"6%$+(#/ 2(T% $+% -.$(7F2-S
$("# "0 - #%8 &3-7% "0 (#'%#$("# $+."F/+ -#9 H%1"#9 $+% 9(&$(#7$("#
H%$8%%# $+% 5#-$F.-2; -#9 $+% 57"#&$.-(#(#/;> Q& - .%&F2$ $+(& (#9('(9F-2 +-&
-22 $+% 3."3%.$(%& "0 - &FHR%7$ .%&3"#&(H2% 0". ($& -7$&B 9%3.%7(-$%9 (# $+% 0(.&$
%&&-1B -#9 $+-$ "0 - #"H2% (#9('(9F-2 "'%.02"8(#/ 8($+ %#%./1 -#9 0".7%>
Y#9%%9B $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2;& .%&3"#&(H(2($1 7-# H% &%%# $" H% #"$+(#/
HF$ -# %#2-./%9 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 &FHR%7$('% .%&3"#&(H(2($14 ($ (& $+%.%0".%
#%($+%. - .%/.%&&("# $" $+% 3.%6"9%.# #". - &(632% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 U#2(/+$S
%#6%#$ 2-8> *+(& (& -#"$+%. .%-&"# 8+1B 3.%7(&%21B "#% 7-##"$ &$(/6-$(&%
&FHR%7$('($1 -& F#(2-$%.-221 5.%-7$('%;4 %,+K$/#*F*#C *% #'$ F$)C I)$/"&.*#*"& "2 #'$
"&$ ='" ?"$% +$C"&. #'$ 49=>
O($+ $+(& +(&$".1 "0 &"'%.%(/#$1 3%.("9& "0 +(&$".1 $+-$ =(%$A&7+% 8(&+%9
$" 9%&$."1 -& 5#(+(2(&$(7;B -& 9%#1(#/ $+% H%7"6(#/ "0 2(0%B -.% 7"#&%_F%#$21
.%$-(#%94 0(.&$B (# $+% &%#&% $+-$ $+%1 0".6 - #%7%&&-.1 3-.$ "0 $+% +(&$".1 "0
2(0%B &%7"#9 (# $+% &%#&% $+-$B -& - #%7%&&-.1 3-.$ "0 $+% +(&$".1 "0 2(0%B $+%1
-.% - 3.%7"#9($("# $" $+%(. "8# "'%.7"6(#/> Q& - .%&F2$B 0."6 H"$+ $+%
3%.&3%7$('% "0 -# %V3-#9%9 %#%./%$(7& $+-$ 7"#02-$%& $+% +(&$".(7-2 -#9 $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' JJ
3&17+"2"/(7-2 -#9 0."6 $+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 -# %V3-#9%9 7"#&7(%#7% $+-$
.%%'-2F-$%&B 8($+(# ($& '%.1 3.-7$(7%B $+% $.-9($("#-2 "33"&($("# H%$8%%#
(#&$(#7$ -#9 7"#&7(%#7%B $+% "33"&($("# (# $+% 0(.&$ -#9 $+(.9 %&&-1& H%$8%%#
$+% -7$('% -#9 $+% .%-7$('% (& #"$ 6-9% "H&"2%$%B HF$ (& ($&%20 .%$F.#%9 $" 3-.$(7F2-. +(&$".1 8($+(# $+(& %V3-#9%9 %#%./%$(7&> Q& (& #"8 72%-. $+(&
%V3-#9%9 %#%./%$(7& (& H"$+ $+% 2-8 -#9 3."7%&& "0 2(0% `5$+% 7F$$(#/ "0 2(0%
(#$" 2(0%;a -#9 $+% 9%&7.(3$("# "0 $+(& 3."7%&& -#9 2-8> Q#9 ($ (& (# $+(&
9(.%7$("#B Y -6 -./F(#/B $+-$ $+% 2-8 "0 58(22 $" 3"8%.; -#9 $+% 5%$%.#-2
.%7F..%#7% "0 $+% &-6%; `$+% 2-8 "0 9(00%.%#7% -#9 9(00%.%#$(-$("#a #%%9 $"
H% -.$(7F2-$%9 (0 $+%1 -.% $" +-'% 3F.7+-&%B -& %3(&$%6"2"/(7-2 -#9 %$+(7-2
$.-#&'-2F-$("#&B "# $+% 7"632%V($1 "0 0".7% $+-$ 6-T%& F3 $+% 5#"8; "0
+F6-# +(&$".1>)D
*+(& 8-1 "0 &($F-$(#/ $+% 2-8 "0 2(0% H%7"6%& -22 $+% 6".% 72%-. (# "F.
&%7"#9 %V-632% 0."6 $+% &%7"#9 %&&-1 "0 Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#CB $+%
7"66F#($1 $+-$ 2%$& ($& 6-2%0-7$".& /" F#3F#(&+%9 `ll )I -#9 ))a>
-' "#. /.'.&0$12 $3 4$(&0+"2 KEEEL
*" -33."-7+ $+% 9%&7.(3$("# "0 $+(& 7"66F#($1 8% #%%9 0(.&$ $" %2-H".-$% $+%
/%#%-2"/1 "0 /F(2$> =(%$A&7+%;& /%#%-2"/1 "0 $+% 6".-2 '-2F% "0 5/F(2$; (&
&($F-$%9 8($+(# -# "'%.-22 +(&$".1 "0 57.F%2$1; &3"T%# "0 (# $%.6& "0 $+%
32%-&F.% 1(%29%9 H1 0%&$('-2& "0 3-(#> Q& &+"F29 #"8 H% 72%-.B +"8%'%.B $"
.%-9 $+(& /%#%-2"/1 (# 3.%9"6(#-#$21 -00%7$('% $%.6& 8"F29 H% 3.%7(3($-$%
H%7-F&% "0 $+% +(&$".1 "0 6%6".(&-$("# 8($+(# 8+(7+ $+%&% -00%7$& -.% &($FS
-$%9> Y# $+(& 7"#$%V$ $+% 0-7$ $+-$ =(%$A&7+% $-T%& $+% 0%%2(#/ "0 5/F(2$; H-7T $"
- .%2-$("#&+(3 "0 9%H$ H%$8%%# 7.%9($". -#9 9%H$". (& .-$+%. (63".$-#$> W".
$+(& .%2-$("#&+(3 (& 2"7-$%9 8($+(# -# %7"#"6(7 ".9%. (# 8+(7+ h -#9 +%.%
$+% +(&$".1 "0 $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2 9"'%$-(2& 8($+ $+-$ "0 /F(2$ h I)"5*%$%
9)$ 59.$B &F&3%#9(#/ $+% (66%9(-71 "0 H-.$%. %V7+-#/%> K($$2% +-& H%%#
6-9% "0 $+(& 3"(#$ (# =(%$A&7+%-# 2($%.-$F.%4 ($& (632(7-$("#& -.% (63".$-#$>
*" 3."6(&% -# %V7+-#/% "0 /""9& "'%. $(6% (& $" 9%0%. $+% (66%9(-$% -7$("#
"0 $.-#&-7$("#4 $+(& 9%0%..-2 7.%-$%& (#'%.&%21 -#9 .%$."&3%7$('%21 - 7"#&$.-(#$
F3"# $+% 8(22 -#9 - &%#&% "0 "H2(/-$("#> *+% 9%0%..-2 (& -# -7$ "0 6%6".1B -#9
$+% &%#&% "0 "H2(/-$("# - 7"#&%_F%#7% "0 ($> *+F&B (0 $+% 3."6(&% (& #"$ T%3$B 9%H$ (& "8%9>
="8B -$ 0(.&$B 3.%&&%9 -/-(#&$ $+% 6-$%.(-2 #-$F.% "0 $+(& 7"#$.-7$F-2 .%2-S
$("#&+(3B $+(& 9%H$ `$+% /""9& $" H% %V7+-#/%9a (& "#% %#/-/(#/ $+% '%.1
H"91 "0 $+% 9%H$".>
*+% 9%H$".B (# ".9%. $" (#&3(.% 7"#0(9%#7% $+-$ $+% 3."6(&% "0 .%3-16%#$
8(22 H% +"#"F.%9B (# ".9%. $" /('% - /F-.-#$%% "0 $+% &"2%6#($1 -#9
&-#7$($1 "0 +(& 3."6(&%B -#9 (# ".9%. $" %$7+ $+% 9F$1 -#9 "H2(/-$("# "0
.%3-16%#$ (#$" +(& 7"#&7(%#7%B 3-8#& &"6%$+(#/ $" $+% 7.%9($". H1
6%-#& "0 $+% 7"#$.-7$ (# 7-&% +% 9"%& #"$ 3-1B &"6%$+(#/ 8+(7+ +% &$(22
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
JN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' JC
*+(& %#/-/%6%#$ .%02%7$& $+% 2%'%2 "0 6-$%.(-2($1 -$ 8+(7+ $+% 7"#$.-7$F-2
.%2-$("#&+(3 (& &%$> *+% %_F('-2%#$ 3F$& - 72%-. 2(6($ $" $+% 3."7%&& "0 9%0%..-2
H%$8%%# $+% 7.%9($". -#9 9%H$". -#9 (& ($&%20 "#% H%$8%%# - 3-.$(7F2-. "HR%7$
-#9 $+% 9%H$".;& 8+"2% 2(0%4 %V7+-#/% (& 3.%9(7-$%9 "# $+% 2*&*#,.$ "0 "#% "0
$+% 3-.$(%& 3.%7(&%21 H%7-F&% $+% .%2-$("#&+(3 .%6-(#& %&&%#$(-221 .('%$%9 $"
6-$$%.> Q& =(%$A&7+% 3F$ ($ %-.2(%.B 5*+% 8".&% 6-#;& 6%6".1 +-& H%%#B $+%
6".% 9.%-90F2 +(& 7F&$"6& +-'% -33%-.%9; `)XDDB l@B D<a> *+F& -$ $+(& &$-/% "0
+(&$".1 -#9 "0 6%6".1B 3F#(&+6%#$ (& #"$ 6%$%9 "F$ $" 3F#(&+ $+% 6(&S
7.%-#$ 0". $+% -7$ 3%.0".6%9 &(#7% +(& ". +%. 8(22 +-& #"$ 1%$ H%7"6%
"./-#(&%9 %#"F/+ $" -$$.(HF$% $" ($ )$%I"&%*+*4*#C> PF#(&+6%#$ (& 6%$%9 "F$
-& -# %_F('-2%#$ "0 $+% 7.(6%> O% -.% -$ $+% &$-/% $+% 53.%6".-2;B -& =(%$A&7+%
7-22& ($ (# <$C"&. O"". 9&. 6F*4B (# 8+(7+ $+% ".(/(# "0 $+% -7$("#B ($& 57-F&-2
-/%#$;B (& #"$ 1%$ $+% 7-$%/".1 "0 (#$%#$("#-2($1 H1 8+(7+ $+% -7$("# (&
RF9/%9B #". &" 6F7+ $+% -7$("# ($&%20B HF$ ($& /"&%$V,$&/$% 0". $+% /"55,&*#C
9# 49)?$ `)XC@B l@<B DJa> *+(& 6%-#& $+-$ $+% .%$F.# -#/%. -/-(#&$ $+% 6(&S
7.%-#$ ". 9%H$". 7-# 0-22 -& 6F7+ F3"# $+% 0-6(21 "0 $+% 2-$$%. -& F3"# +(6
". +%.&%20> !.(6% .%6-(#& 8($+(# $+% %7"#"61 "0 H2""9S9%H$ -#9 .%'%#/%> Y#
$+(& %7"#"61 "0 2-8 #%($+%. $+% 7.%9($". ". 7"66F#($1B #". $+% 9%H$". ".
6(&7.%-#$ -.% 3"8%.0F24 $+% &3(.($ "0 6-$%.(-2 .%'%#/% (& - '%.1 8%-T &3(.($B
3"". (# "'%.02"8(#/ %#%./1 -#9 0".7%>
Y# lX "0 $+% O$&$94"?C =(%$A&7+% &($F-$%& $+(& -#-2"/1 H%$8%%# 7"66F#($1
-#9 7.%9($". (# &$-.T $%.6&> K(T% $+% 3.%6".-2 7.%9($".B $+% 7"66F#($1
7-##"$ -00".9B %($+%.B $" 9%0%. $+% .%2-$("#&+(3 H%$8%%# ($&%20 -#9 - 6%6H%.>
*+% -#-2"/1 .%7".9& -$ $+(& 2%'%2 "0 +(&$".1 -# %_F('-2%#7% (# $F.#
H%$8%%# $+% %7"#"6(7 -#9 $+% 2%/-2> U7"#"6(7 -#9 2%/-2 .%2-$("#& -.%
&$(22 8($+(# $+% &-6% %7"#"61 "0 &3(.($> *+(& &3(.($ (& "#% "0 %V72F&("# (#
".9%. 0". $+% 6%$-H"2(&6 "0 $+% 7"66F#($1 $" H% 6-(#$-(#%9> O%
+-'% -2.%-91 ($ 6%$ -$ $+% 2%'%2 "0 3"3F2-. 3-.2-#7% `=(%$A&7+% )XC@B
)D)h<a> *+% &6-22%. $+% %7"#"61 "0 $+(& 6%$-H"2(&6B $+% /.%-$%. $+%
3F#(&+6%#$4
*+% (66%9(-$% 9-6-/% 9"#% H1 $+% "00%#9%. (& 8+-$ 8% -.% $-2T(#/ -H"F$
2%-&$4 _F($% -3-.$ 0."6 $+(&B $+% 2-8H.%-T%. (& - 5H.%-T%.;B &"6%H"91 8+"
+-& H."T%# +(& 8".9 #" #'$ ='"4$B (# 7"##%7$("# 8($+ -22 $+% '-2F%9
0%-$F.%& -#9 -6%#($(%& "0 7"66F#-2 2(0% 8+(7+ +% +-& &+-.%9 F3 $(22
#"8> rQ&&-F2$(#/ $+% 7.%9($". $+%.%0".% -& 6F7+ -& 0-(2(#/ $" .%3-1 $+%
H%#%0($& /.-#$%9 +(6s +% (& #"8 .%6(#9%9 "0 +"8 (63".$-#$ $+%&% H%#%S
0($& -.%> *+% -#/%. "0 $+% (#RF.%9 7.%9($".B $+% 7"66F#($1B 6-T%& +(6
.%$F.# $" $+% "F$2-8%9 -#9 &-'-/% &$-$% 0."6 8+(7+ +% 8-& &+%2$%.%9
+($+%.$"> PF#(&+6%#$ -$ $+(& 2%'%2 "0 7('(2(A-$("# (& &(6321 - 5*5,%B 7"31 "0 #".6-2 H%+-'("F. $"8-.9& - +-$%9B 9(&-.6%9 %#%61 8+" +-&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
3"&&%&&%& -#9 7"#$."2&B 0". %V-632%B +(& H"91B ". +(& 8(0%B ". +(& 0.%%9"6B
". +(& 2(0%>
`=(%$A&7+% )XXDB lJB DDa
J? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Y# $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1B 8% .%7-22B G"6% (& $+% 7F2$F.% 6"&$ 72"&%21 -&&"7(-$%9 8($+
#"H2% -00%7$('($1B "#% 9%0%-$%9 H1 $+% kF9-(7 &3(.($ "0 .%'%#/%> M%.%B +"8%'%.B
(# $+(& /%#%-2"/1 "0 /F(2$ (# $%.6& "0 9%H$ -#9 7.%9($B ($ (& 3.%7(&%21 G"6%;&
7"9% "0 $+% *8%2'% *-H2%& $+-$ %V3-#9& #'$ $/"&"5C "2 $V,*F94$&/$ +$#=$$&
/)$.*# 9&. .$+#>
Y .%/-.9 ($ -& 9%0(#($% 3."/.%&& -#9 3.""0 "0 - 0.%%.B 6".% "3%#S+-#9%9
7-27F2-$("#B "0 9 5")$ 1"59& 3.(7(#/ "0 RF&$(7%B 8+%# G"6%;& 7"9% "0 $+%
*8%2'% *-H2%& 9%7.%%9 $+-$ ($ 9(9 #"$ 6-$$%. +"8 6F7+ ". +"8 2($$2% 7.%9($". 7F$ "004 %* I4,% 5*&,%F$ %$/,$)$&#R &$ 2)9,.$ $%#" r5Y0 $+%1 +-'% 7F$ "00
6".% ". 2%&&B 2%$ $+-$ #"$ H% 7"#&(9%.%9 - 7.(6%;s>
`*+*.>B lJB DDa
,(#7% $+% (66%9(-$% %_F('-2%#7% H%$8%%# 9%%9 -#9 3F#(&+6%#$ ". -7$("#
-#9 .%-7$("# (& 94%" $+"F/+$ H1 =(%$A&7+% (# $%.6& "0 -# %7"#"61 "0 .%'%#/%B
$+% -H"'% 7"66%#$ "# $+% 2%/-2 7F2$F.% "0 G"6% &+"8& $+-$ ($ (& G"6% $+-$
$-T%& F& "F$ "0 $+% &3(.($ "0 .%'%#/% -$ - 6-$%.(-2 2%'%2B RF&$ -& ($ 8-& $+%
%7"#"61 "0 %_F('-2%#7% $+-$ $""T F& "F$ "0 (66%9(-$% -#/%. -#9 9(&7+-./%
`lDa> 5G"6%; $+F& 7"#&$($F$%& (# $+% O$&$94"?C H"$+ - $13% "0 #"H(2($1 I)*") #"
$+% .%'%#/% &$.F7$F.% "0 kF9-(7 )$%%$&#*5$&# `l)< "0 $+% W(.&$ U&&-1a -#9 - &$%3
0".8-.9 (# $+% X$)?$*%#*?,&? "0 7.F%2$1 $+-$B H%/(##(#/ 8($+ $+% 3.%7%9%#7% "0
%_F('-2%#7% "'%. 9(&7+-./%B 5.F#& $+."F/+ $+% +(&$".1 "0 +(/+%. 7F2$F.%; `lNa>
*+(& .-9(7-2 (#7"63-$(H(2($1 H%$8%%# $+%&% $8" 3"&($("#(#/& "0 5G"6%;
8($+(# $+% "'%.-22 &3(.($F-2(&-$("# "0 &3(.($ &F//%&$& $+% 0"22"8(#/>
kF&$ -& 8($+ $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2B &" 8($+ $+% 7F2$F.-2 $13% "0 5G"6%; ($
(& 9 I)*")* (63"&&(H2% $" &%3-.-$% $+% (#$%.(".(&(#/ +(&$".1 "0 )$%%$&#*5$&# 0."6
$+% (#$%.(".(&(#/ +(&$".1 "0 &"'%.%(/#$1> Q& 8($+ $+% &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2B ($ (&
#"$ - _F%&$("# +%.% "0 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ $+% .%0%.%#$ "0 $+%&% $%.6& 7(.7F2-$%&
H%$8%%# $+%6B 6-T(#/ #"#&%#&% "0 -#1 7"#7%3$F-2 &$-H(2($1 -6"#/ $+%
$%.6& 5="H2%;B 5kF9-(7;B 5Z-.H-.(-#;B 5G"6-#;B 5Z2"#9 Z%-&$;B 5,"'%.%(/# Y#9(S
'(9F-2;> G-$+%.B $+(& 7(.7F2-$("# 7"#&$($F$%& $+% &163$"6 "0 -# %7"#"61 "0
&3(.($ -#9 &3(.($F-2(&-$("#B -# %7"#"61 8($+(# 8+(7+ 5(#$%.#-2; -#9 5%VS
$%.#-2; 0".7%& 6-T% F3 $+% &(6F2$-#%"F&21 9(-7+."#(7 -#9 &1#7+."#(7
50(%29; "0 %#%./%$(7& $" 8+(7+ /%#%-2"/1 2%-9& F& H-7T> Y0 =(%$A&7+% (& #"$ (#
7"#$."2 "0 $+(& %7"#"61B +(& $%V$ -7$& ($ "F$> ZF$ $" &-1 $+(& 9"%& #"$ 6%-#
$+-$ 8% &$-1 8($+ $+% $%V$ h -& (0 ($ /('%& $+% 2-84 .-$+%.B =(%$A&7+%;& $%V$F-2
7"#$.-9(7$("#& (#'($% F& $" %V32".% 0F.$+%. $+% %7"#"61 "0 &3(.($>
W."6 $+(& 3%.&3%7$('%B /"&#)9 2-./% $.-7$& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 9(-$.(H% -/-(#&$
b-#$B U#2(/+$%#6%#$ 0".6-2(&6 -#9 6"9%.# 9%6"7.-71B $+% +(&$".1 "0 $+%
&3(.($F-2(&-$("# "0 7.F%2$1 8(22 /('% 0F22 (63".$-#7% $" $+% %6%./%#7% -#9
&3(.($F-2 9(/#($1 "0 $+% 7"#7%3$& "0 5(#$%#$("#;B 53F.3"&%;B 5&FHR%7$('($1; -#9
5.%&3"#&(H(2($1;> Q& 8% (#9(7-$%9 -H"'% (# .%0%.%#7% $" l@< "0 <$C"&. O"". 9&.
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
H%%# 9%0%-$%9B 8+" +-& #"$ "#21 0".0%($%9 -22 .(/+$&B HF$ -22 6%.71 -& 8%22>
`=(%$A&7+% )XXDB lXB JIa
6F*4B $+%1 0".6 3-.$ "0 $+% 56".-2; &$-/% "0 +F6-#T(#9B - &$-/% 3.%9(7-$%9 "#
- 3-.$(7F2-. "./-#(&-$("# "0 0".7% `%7"#"6(7B $%7+#(7-2B &"7(-2 -#9 -00%7$('%a>
O($+(# $+(& +(&$".1 $+%&% 7"#7%3$& h ". .-$+%. '-2F%& V,9 F#9%.&$-#9(#/& "0
$+% +F6-# -#9 ($& .%2-$("#& 8($+ ($&%20 -#9 ($& (#$%.#-2 -#9 %V$%.#-2 %#'(."#S
6%#$ h &$%6 0."6 - +(&$".1 "0 7-27F2-$("#B (#0%.%#7% -#9 RF9/%6%#$ (#
8+(7+ $+% 6-2%0-7$". (& 9('(9%9 (#$" - &FHR%7$ -#9 +(& ". +%. 9%%9&> *+(&
&%3-.-$("#B 8($+(# $+(& +(&$".1B 7-##"$ H% &%%# -& -# -7$ "0 .%'%#/% -/-(#&$
#"H(2($1 =*#'",# %$I9)9#*&?B (# $F.#B $+% +(&$".(7-2 0."6 $+% 3+1&("2"/(7-2 -#9
3&17+"2"/(7-2> *+% 2-./% $.-7$& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 8".T $+-$ 9" $+(& -.% H"$+
.%9F7(H2% $" $+% 9%7-9%#$ &3(.($ "0 $+% 2*&J.$J%*$b/4$ -#9B 6".% (63".$-#$21B
$" - &163$"6 "0 - 6".% /%#%.-2 9.('% $" .%S-33."3.(-$% $+(& '%.1 +(&$".1 *&
").$) #" %V72F9% +(6&%20 0."6 ($> Y# &" 9"(#/B =(%$A&7+% 0-22& '(7$(6 $" ($&
2(6($%9 &3(.($ "0 9(/%&$("# -22 $+% 6".%>
*+% -H"'% &%3-.-$("# H%$8%%# &FHR%7$ -#9 9%%9 (&B $+%#B 0."6 $+%
3%.&3%7$('% "0 $+% /%#%.-2 %7"#"61 "0 &3(.($B 7"#0(.6%9 -& -# -7$ "0 &3(.($F-2
3."/.%&& "F$ "0 $+% 6".% (66%9(-$% .%2-$("#& "0 7.%9($ -#9 9%H$> *+(& 3."S
/.%&& (& $+-$ "0 $+% 3."/.%&&('% 56-&$%.1; "0 $+% 7"66F#($1 "'%. $+% %#%./(%&
02"8(#/ $+."F/+ ($> *+(& 3."/.%&& (& H1 #" 6%-#& #%7%&&-.14 =(%$A&7+%;&
F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 &3(.($ (& #"$ %'"2F$("#(&$> M(&$".(7-2 .%/.%&&("# (& 3"&&(H2%
-$ -#1 6"6%#$ 8($+(# $+% 3."7%&&%& "0 &3(.($F-2(&-$("#> *+(& 6-&$%.1 (&B
+"8%'%.B &"6%$+(#/ $+-$ $-T%& F& $" $+% 2(6($ "0 +F6-# 3"&&(H(2($14 ($ $-T%&
F&B F2$(6-$%21B $+-$ (&B 0."6 "F$ "0 $+% 5+F6-#; $"8-.9& $+% 5"'%.+F6-#;>
*+(& (& +"8 =(%$A&7+% H%/(#& $" 9%&7.(H% $+(& 3."7%&& "0 6-&$%.1 8($+(# "#%
"0 $+% 6"&$ (#$%.%&$(#/ 3-.-/.-3+& "0 +(& 8+"2% 8".T4
Q& - 7"66F#($1 /."8& (# 3"8%.B ($ 7%-&%& $" $-T% $+% "00%#&% "0 $+%
(#9('(9F-2 _F($% &" &%.("F&21B H%7-F&% $+%&% 9" #"$ &%%6 $" H% -& 9-#/%.S
"F& -#9 9%&$-H(2(A(#/ 0". $+% &F.'('-2 "0 $+% 8+"2% -& $+%1 9(9 %-.2(%.4 $+%
8."#/9"%. (& #" 2"#/%. > > > 7-&$ "F$B #". 7-# $+% 3FH2(7 '%#$ $+%(. -#/%. "#
+(6 8($+ $+% &-6% 2-7T "0 7"#&$.-(#$B h (#&$%-9 $+% 8."#/9"%. (& &+(%29%9
H1 $+% 7"66F#($1 0."6 $+(& -#/%.B %&3%7(-221 0."6 $+-$ "0 $+% (66%9(-$%
(#RF.%9 3-.$B (#9%%9 (& /('%# 3."$%7$("# > > > > Q# -$$%63$ $" 2"7-2(A% $+%
6-$$%. > > > m -H"'% -22 $+% 8(22 r.$) P*44$s 6-#(0%&$(#/ ($&%20 %'%. 6".% 9(&S
$(#7$21B $" $.%-$ %'%.1 "00%#7% -& &"6%$+(#/ $+-$ /9& +$ I9*. "22B &" $+-$B -$
2%-&$ $" - 7%.$-(# 9%/.%%B $+% 8."#/9"%. (& *%"49#$. 0."6 +(& 9%%9 h $+%&%
-.% $+% 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7& (63.(#$%9 6".% -#9 6".% 72%-.21 (#$" $+% 3%#-2 2-8
"'%. ($& 9%'%2"36%#$>
`(H(9>B l)IB JIh)a
*+% &%3-.-$("# $+."F/+ RF9/%6%#$ -#9 (#0%.%#7% "0 9"%. 0."6 9%%9 (& $+%
&-6% &%3-.-$("# $+-$ 8(22 /('% .(&% 2-$%. $" $+% 7"#&$.F7$("# "0 2%/-2 &1&$%6&
$+-$ (#&$($F$% $+% 9%0%..-2 "0 (66%9(-$% 9(&7+-./%B .%-7$("# -#9 .%'%#/% -#9
2%-9 $" U#2(/+$%#6%#$ 2-8> *+%&% 2%/-2 &1&$%6&B =(%$A&7+% -./F%& (# l))B -.%
$+% 7.%-$("# "0 $+% %#)"&?$) 8(22& $+-$ 53F$ -# %#9; $" $+% &3(.($ "0 )$%%$&#*5$&#
`3> J@a H1 52(0$(#/ $+% "HR%7$ "0 )$%%$&#*5$&# "F$ "0 $+% +-#9& "0 .%'%#/%;
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' JX
`(H(9>a -#9 3."'(9(#/ 0". ($ - 7"#$%V$ (# 8+(7+ ($ 7-# H% %'-2F-$%9 *5I$)%"&J
944C `3> JDa> =(%$A&7+% (& "0 7"F.&% .(/+$ $" -99 -$ $+(& 3"(#$ $+-$ $+%&% &1&$%6&
-.% $+%6&%2'%& 3-.$(-2 .%&$.(7$("#& "0 $+% 8(22 $" 2(0%> *+-$ &-(9B $+(& (& - '%.1
9(00%.%#$ -77"F#$ "0 $+% .%2-$("# H%$8%%# 2-8 -#9 2(0%B &%3-.-$("# -#9 0".7%
$+-# $+% "#% $+-$ (# $+% &-6% %&&-1B $+% &-6% 6"'%6%#$ "0 $+"F/+$B
"33"&%& $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%. $" 2-8 -#9 $+% )$%%$&#*5$&# 7"#&$.-(#$& "0 9%6"S
7.-71 `lCa -#9 8+(7+ (# $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1 6-(#$-(#%9 $+-$ U#2(/+$%#6%#$ 2-8
8-& - 9%'%2"36%#$ "0 $+% &3(.($ "0 .%'%#/%> O+%.%-& $+% 2%/-2 &1&$%6 (& (#
$+%&% -77"F#$& )$9/#*F$B +%.% ($ (& &%%# -& 3.%7(&%21 9/#*F$> O% +-'%B -& - .%&F2$B
- 3"$%#$(-221 '%.1 6F7+ 6".% (#$%.%&$(#/ -77"F#$ "0 $+% .%2-$("# H%$8%%#
2-8 -#9 0".7%>
Y$ &+"F29 H% 72%-.B $+%#B `-& -H"'%a $+-$ 8% &+"F29 #"$ &$-1 8($+B ".
.%0-&+("# $+(& $13% "0 7"#$.-9(7$("# -& &"6%$+(#/ .-9(7-221 -6H(/F"F& ".
F#9%7(9-H2%4 - $%63$-$("# (# 6F7+ .%7%#$ =(%$A&7+%-# &7+"2-.&+(3 8+%# .%S
-99.%&&(#/ &F7+ 6"6%#$& (# =(%$A&7+%;& 8".T> D'$ /"&#)9.*/#*"& $&%,$% 2)"5
#'*&;*&? 2")/$ ",#%*.$ *#% .*22$)$&#*9#*"&%R #'*&;*&? *# *& 9+%#)9/#> O+%.%-&B $+%#B
=(%$A&7+%;& -#$(SU#2(/+$%#6%#$S(&6 8".T& 8($+(# - .%&$.(7$%9B -H&$.-7$ %7"S
#"61 "0 0".7% $+-$ (& F#-H2% $" .%2-$% 2(0% $" 2-8B -#9 0".7% $" +(&$".1B $+%
0".6%. .%2-$%& $" $+% $8" 8($+(# - 7"#7.%$%B +(&$".(7-221 6%9(-$%9 %7"#"61
"0 &3(.($F-2(&-$("# (# 8+(7+ $+% 2-8 "0 2(0% (& 52(0% ($&%20 7"#&$-#$21 7F$$(#/ (#$"
2(0%;> Q$ "#% %#9 "0 $+(& 3."7%&& "0 &3(.($F-2(&-$("# &$-#9& 6-$$%.B -$ $+% "$+%.
&"'%.%(/# .%&3"#&(H(2($1> *+% &%3-.-$("# "0 0".7% (#$" - &FHR%7$ -#9 ($& -7$& (&B
8($+(# $+(& &3%7$.F6B #"$ $+% .%&F2$ "0 .%-7$('% -7$('($1 -& &F7+B HF$ "#%
7"#&%_F%#7% "0 $+% '%.1 2-8 "0 2(0% F3"# 8+(7+ +F6-# 0".7% (& H".#%>
Y# $+(& 7"#$%V$B 0(#-221B 8+-$ 8"F29 H% - 7"66F#($1B 0". =(%$A&7+%B $+-$
+-& "'%.7"6% H"$+ $+% 3.%S6".-2 `3F.% 9(&7+-./%a -#9 $+% 6".-2 `$+% 3-&S
&-/% 0."6 %_F('-2%#7% $" 2%/-2 &1&$%6& -& &F7+a4 8+-$ +% 7-22& (# l@< "0
<$C"&. O"". 9&. 6F*4 $+% 5%V$.-6".-2;i O+-$ 8"F29 H% - 7"66F#($1 -.$(7FS
2-$%9 $+."F/+ $+% '-2F% "0 $+% 5"'%.+F6-#;i *+% 7"#$(#F-$("# "0 l)I (#9(7S
-$%& 8+-$ $+(& 0F.$+%. X$)?$*%#*?,&? "0 RF&$(7% 6(/+$ (63214
Q& $+% 3"8%. -#9 &%20S7"#0(9%#7% "0 - 7"66F#($1 (#7.%-&%B $+% 3%#-2 2-8
-28-1& H%7"6%& 6".% 6"9%.-$%m %'%.1 8%-T%#(#/ ". (63%.(2(#/ "0 $+%
0".6%. H.(#/& 8($+ ($ - .%&$".-$("# "0 $+% +-.&+%. 0".6& "0 $+% 2-$$%.> *+%
7.%9($". -28-1& H%7"6%& 6".% +F6-#% $" $+% %V$%#$ $+-$ +% +-& /."8#
.(7+%.B 0(#-221B +"8 6F7+ (#RF.1 +% 7-# %#9F.% 8($+"F$ &F00%.(#/ 0."6 ($
H%7"6%& $+% -7$F-2 6%-&F.% "0 +(& 8%-2$+> Y$ (& #"$ F#$+(#T-H2% $+-$ &"7(%$1 6(/+$ -$$-(# &F7+ - 7"#&7("F&#%&& "0 3"8%. $+-$ ($ 7"F29 -22"8
($&%20 $+% #"H2%&$ 2FVF.1 3"&&(H2% $" ($ h 2%$$(#/ $+"&% 8+" +-.6 ($ /"
F#3F#(&+%9> 5O+-$ -.% 61 3-.-&($%& $" 6%;B ($ 6(/+$ &-1> 5E-1 $+%1 2('%
-#9 3."&3%.4 Y -6 &$."#/ %#"F/+ 0". $+-$j; kF&$(7% 8+(7+ H%/-# H1 &-1(#/
5U'%.1$+(#/ 7-# H% 3-(9 "00B %'%.1$+(#/ 6F&$ H% 3-(9 "00;B %#9& H1 $F.#(#/
- H2(#9 %1% -#9 2%$$(#/ "00 $+"&% F#-H2% $" 3-1 h ($ %#9& 2(T% %'%.1 /""9
$+(#/ "# %-.$+ H1 &FH2(6-$(#/ ($&%20 r%*/' 9,2'$+$&.s> *+% &%20S&FH2(6-$("#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
NI !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' N)
*+% 7,2'$+,&? "0 RF&$(7% h $+% /"(#/ H%1"#9 $+% 2-8 h $.-#&2-$%& $+% -H(2($1 $"
H%-. 6".% -#9 6".%B 8($+"F$ &F00%.(#/ $+%.%0."6B %'%#$& 8+(7+ 7"6% 0."6
"F$&(9%> Y$ (& $+% -H(2($1 #"$ $" H% $"F7+%9 H1 "F$&(9%B 8+(2% -$ $+% &-6% $(6%
$.-#&0".6(#/ $+(& "F$&(9%> *+(& -H(2($1B $+% 6"&$ &3(.($F-2 0".6 "0 8+(7+
7"#&$($F$%&B (# 7"22%7$('% 0".6B $+% 7"66F#($1 =(%$A&7+% 9%&7.(H%& -H"'%B
(& $+% &-6% -& $+-$ 8+(7+ H.(#/& $" 0.F($("# $+% 6-T(#/ "0 3."6(&%&> Y$ (& $+%
2-$%B +(&$".(7-221 /('%# 0.F($ "0 $+% &3(.($F-2(&-$("# "0 3."7%&&%& "0 6%6".1B
$+-$ (&B "0 &"6%$+(#/ 2(T% $+% 59(-2%7$(7; H%$8%%# "./-#(&6 -#9 %#'(."#6%#$>
*+% -#-2"/1 Y -6 6-T(#/ H%$8%%# &"'%.%(/# (#9('(9F-2 -#9 7"66F#($1 (&
RF&$(0(%9 H1 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ H"$+ -.% $+"F/+$ -& "./-#(7 /."8$+& -&&(6(2-$(#/
%'%#$& (# &F7+ - 8-1 $+-$ $+%(. %#%./%$(7 9(&3"&($("# H%7"6%& 6".% 9(&3%#&S
(#/B 2%&& -33."3.(-$(#/> *+-$ /."8$+ 9%3%#9& "# $+% +(&$".1 "0 (#$%.(".(&-S
$("#B "# 8+-$B "# "$+%. "77-&("#&B =(%$A&7+% 7-22& 5#(+(2(&6;>
Q#9 1%$ $+% /."8$+ (& 3.%7(&%21 - 7"#&$-#$ &%20S"'%.7"6(#/B 8+-$
=(%$A&7+% 7-22& +%.% 5&%20S&FH2(6-$("#;> *+% .%S%'-2F-$("# "0 kF9-(7 )$%%$&#*J
5$&# (& $+% &%20S&FH2(6-$("# "0 $+% 2%/-2 &1&$%6B #"$ - .%/.%&&("# $" - 3F.%
0".7% 3.(". $" ($> *+(& &%20S&FH2(6-$("# (& (# $F.# $+% .%S%'-2F-$("# "0 5$)/C
8+(7+B -22(%9 $" 3($1 8($+(# $+% !+.(&$(-# &7+%6- "0 '-2F-$("#B 7"F29 "#21 H%
$+"F/+$ H1 =(%$A&7+% -& !+.(&$(-# `%/"(&$(7a -2$.F(&6 -$ $+% 2%'%2 "0 $+%
6".-2> E%.71 +%.%B (# 7"#$.-&$ $" $+% 56%.7(2%&&#%&&; "0 $+% 3.(6($('% 7"6S
6F#($1B (& $+% "'%.+F6-# $.-#&'-2F-$("# "0 $+(& 6%.71 (#$" -2$.F(&$(7 %/"S
(&64 $+% 2%$$(#/ /" "0 $+% "$+%. 3.%7(&%21 H%7-F&% $+% 7"66F#($1 +-& /-(#%9
- #"#-33."3.(-$('% 6-&$%.1 "'%. ($& "8# 8(22> Y$ (& $+(& $+-$ ($& 2%/(&2-$".
%6H"9(%& $+."F/+ ($& -7$ "0 6%.71> Y# D',% AI9;$ T9)9#',%#)9B $+(& /(0$ (&
7-22%9B 3.%7(&%21B 52"'%; `&%% %&3%7(-221 5L0 K"'% "0 "#%;& =%(/+H"F.; -#9 5L0
$+% Z%&$"8(#/ f(.$F%; (# =(%$A&7+% )XN)B ?Nh? -#9 XXh)IDa > ^%#%-2"/(&(#/
-#9 &FH2-$(#/ h -#9 #"$ 9%&$."1(#/ -#9 .%'%.&(#/ h $+% !+.(&$(-# 2"'% "0
"#%;& #%(/+H"F.B =(%$A&7+%;& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 $+% 2"'(#/ 3%.&"# (& $+-$ "0
&"6%"#% &" &F.% "0 $+%6&%2'%&B &" -8-.% $+-$ $+%1 -.% (#7".3".-$(#/ 0".7%&
H%1"#9 $+%6 9% $+%6&%2'%& $+-$ #'$C 9)$ 9+4$ #" ?*F$ #" "#'$)%> *+% 2"'% "0 $+%
"$+%. (&B 0". =(%$A&7+%B 3.%9(7-$%9 "# $+(& .(7+ %/"(&6> Y$ (& $+% &-6% .(7+
%/"(&6 $+-$ $-T%& "#% H%1"#9 $+% 2-8>
Y# "#% "0 =(%$A&7+%;& %-.2(%&$ 8".T& >,59&R 744 #"" >,59& -#9 (# +(& 2-&$
3FH2(&+%9 8".T 9F.(#/ +(& 2(0%$(6% D'$ 7&#*/')*%#m*9&W $+(& #"#-33."3.(-$('%
6-&$%.1 (& 7"#&$-#$21 9%&7.(H%9 -& - #%8 0".6 "0 5-&7%$(7(&6;B "#% (# 8+(7+
57"#&$.-(#$; +-& H%%# (#7".3".-$%9B .%S%'-2F-$%9B -& 5(#&$(#7$;> *+(& 0".6 "0
-&7%$(7(&6 (& $+% -3%V "0 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% F#9%.&$-#9& H1 &3(.($F-2($1> Y$ (&B (# &%#&%B $+% &%20S"'%.7"6(#/ "0 $+% 5-&7%$(7 3.(%&$; "0 $+% $+(.9 %&&-1 "0 Q& #'$
O$&$94"?C "2 3")94*#C> Y _F"$%4
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
"0 RF&$(7% h 8% T#"8 8+-$ - #(7% #-6% ($ /('%& ($&%20 h 5$)/C rO&9.$l4 ($
.%6-(#& "0 7"F.&% $+% 3.%."/-$('% "0 $+% 6"&$ 3"8%.0F2 6-#B H%$$%. +(& 8-1
"0 /"(#/ H%1"#9 $+% 2-8# r%$*& 8$&%$*#% .$% 1$/'#%s>
`(H(9> )X??B @I?hXa
N< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
*+(& 3-.-/.-3+ #%%9& 2($$2% 7"66%#$ (# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 61 -./F6%#$ -& 8+"2%> ,F00(7% ($ $" 6-T% $+.%% .%6-.T&> *+(& -&7%$(7(&6 "0 2"'% 8-&B -&
6%#$("#%9 -H"'%B 8+-$ 6-.T& $+% 0.%% &3(.($ "0 $+% 5*.(2"/1 "0 W.%% ,3(.($&;>)J
Q& $+% .%S(#7".3".-$("# "0 &%20S7"#&$.-(#$ -#9 &%20S7.F%2$1B ($ -2&" +-.T& H-7T
$" $+% 50.%%B '%.1 0.%% &3(.($&; "0 <$C"&. O"". 9&. 6F*4 8($+ 8+(7+ 8% H%/-#B
$+"&% 8+" %V7%%9 $+% %7"#"61 "0 -33."3.(-$("# $+."F/+ -# 5%V$.-'-/-#$
+"#%&$1; `)XC@B )D@a> *+(& 7"#0(.6& "#% "0 $+% 6-R". $+%&%& "0 $+(& %&&-14 #'$
$#'*/94 I$)%I$/#*F$ "2 %I*)*# +"#' $5$)?$% ",# "2 !*$#@%/'$N% ?$&$94"?*/94 5$#'". 9&.
$&$)?$#*/% 9&. ")*$&#% #'$ 2,#,)$ "2 ",) ,&.$)%#9&.*&? 9&. I)9/#*/$ "2 2")/$> Y# $+(&
&%#&%B ($ (& -/-(# - &%'%.% F#9%.S.%-9(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 8".T $" &%'%. $+%
/%#%-2"/(7-2 -#9 %#%./%$(7 3%.&3%7$('% 0."6 $+% %$+(7-2> Q& Y &-(9 $"8-.9&
$+% H%/(##(#/ "0 $+(& %&&-1B &3(.($ (& -$ $+% &-6% $(6%4 `(a $+% 8-1 (# 8+(7+ $"
$+(#T -# "./-#(&6;& .%2-$("# $" 0".7%& H"$+ 8($+(# -#9 8($+"F$ ($m `((a $+%
'%.1 /."8$+ "0 $+-$ .%2-$("#m -#9 `(((a $+% 8-1 (# 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% &3%-T& "0
$+% .%#%8%9 (#7".3".-$("#B (#$%.#-2(&-$("# "0 $+-$ .%2-$("# 8+%# ($ +-&
F#9%./"#% &$.F7$F.-2 7+-#/%> Q& &F7+B ($ (& H"$+ - 9%&7.(3$('% $%.6 -#9 $+%
'%+(72% "0 .%S%'-2F-$("#4 $+% "HR%7$ "0 /%#%-2"/1 -#9 $+% "HR%7$ "0 $+% %$+(7&
$+-$ $+(& /%#%-2"/1 #%7%&&-.(21 (#$(6-$%&> Q& &F7+ ($ 7"22-3&%&B 8($+"F$ 7"#S
02-$(#/B -#9 .%S"./-#(&%&B 8($+"F$ 9%&$."1(#/B $+% 7"#7%3$F-2 9(&$(#7$("#
H%$8%%# -00(.6-$("# -#9 #%/-$("#>
9$,1"<-#$,
Y# $+% 3%#F2$(6-$% 3-.-/.-3+ "0 $+% &%7"#9 %&&-1 "0 Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2
3")94*#CB =(%$A&7+% 8.($%&4
O% 6"9%.#& +-'% (#+%.($%9 6(22%##(- "0 7"#&7(%#7%S'('(&%7$("# -#9 -#(S
6-2S$".$F.% (#02(7$%9 "# "F.&%2'%&> W". $"" 2"#/B 6-# +-& '(%8%9 +(&
#-$F.-2 (#72(#-$("#& 8($+ -# 5%'(2 %1%;B &" $+-$ $+%1 0(#-221 7-6% $" H%
(#$%.$8(#%9 8($+ 5H-9 7"#&7(%#7%; (# +(6> Q .%'%.&% %V3%.(6%#$ &+"F29 H%
3"&&(H2% *& I)*&/*I4$ h HF$ 8+" +-& &F00(7(%#$ &$.%#/$+i h H1 $+(&B Y 6%-# -#
(#$%.$8(#(#/ "0 H-9 7"#&7(%#7% 8($+ I$)F$)%$ (#72(#-$("#&B -22 $+"&% "$+%.S
8".921 -&3(.-$("#&B -2(%# $" $+% &%#&%&B $+% (#&$(#7$&B $" #-$F.%B $" -#(S
6-2&B (# &+".$ -22 $+% (9%-2& 8+(7+ F3 $" #"8 +-'% H%%# +"&$(2% $" 2(0% -#9
+-'% 9%0-6%9 $+% 8".29> *" 8+"6 &+"F29 8% $F.# 8($+ %,/' +"3%& -#9
72-(6& $"9-1i ZF$B &"6% $(6%B +% 8(22 +-'% 7"6% $" F&B $+% .%9%%6(#/
6-# "0 /.%-$ 2"'%B HF.(%9 (# $+(& .%-2($1 &" $+-$ +% 7-# .%$F.# 0."6 ($ 8($+
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
*+% 6"&$ &3(.($F-2 r?$*%#*?%#$&s +F6-# H%(#/&B -& $+% %#)"&?$%#B 0(#9 $+%(.
+-33(#%&& 8+%.% "$+%.& 8"F29 0(#9 $+%(. 9%&$.F7$("#4 (# $+% 2-H1.(#$+B (#
&%'%.($1 $"8-.9& $+%6&%2'%& -#9 "$+%.&B (# -$$%63$(#/m $+%(. R"1 2(%& (#
&%20S7"#&$.-(#$4 8($+ $+%6 -&7%$(7(&6 H%7"6%& #-$F.%B #%%9B (#&$(#7$>
b#"82%9/% h - 0".6 "0 -&7%$(7(&6> *+%1 .F2% #"$ H%7-F&% $+%1 8-#$ $"
r="44$&sB HF$ H%7-F&% $+%1 9)$>
`=(%$A&7+%B )XXIB lJCa
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' N@
Y 8(&+ $" 9.-8 $+(& %&&-1 $" - 7"#72F&("# 0."6 "F$ "0 $+(& 2-&$ _F"$-$("#>
,%'%.-2 $+(#/& -.% &$.(T(#/ (# $+% 3-.-/.-3+ -#9 .%2%'-#$ $" "F. "'%.-22
-./F6%#$> W(.&$B $+% 5"'%.6-#; (& &%%# -& - 0F$F.% +".(A"# $+-$ 8(22 .%9%%6
"F. #-$F.-2 0".7%& 0."6 $+% 8%(/+$ "0 7"#&7(%#7%> ,%7"#9B $+(& 0F$F.% (& "#%
"0 $+% .%S%'-2F-$("# ". $.-#&'-2F-$("# "0 $+% .%S%'-2F-$("# "0 kF9-(7 )$%%$&#*J
5$&# (# $+% 0(.&$ %&&-1m ($ 3."6(&%&B (# "$+%. 8".9&B $+% 0F$F.% H%1"#9 $+%
58(22 $" #"$+(#/; ". #(+(2(&6 $+-$ 0.-6%& $+% O$&$94"?C -& - 8+"2%> ="8B 0."6
$+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 $+% 8".T "0 $+% 3.%'("F& 3-/%& "# $+% O$&$94"?CB ($ &+"F29
H% 72%-. $+-$ H"$+ $+% $%.6&B $+% 7"#7%3$& -#9 $+% 2"/(7 "0 $+(& 3-.-/.-3+ -.%
3+-#$-&6-$(7> Y$ &+"F29 -2&" H% 72%-. $+-$ ($& 3+-#$-&6-$(7 &$-$F& (& 3.%9(S
7-$%9 "# $+% 9%&(.% 0". 3F.% 0".7%B - 9%&(.% $+-$ $+(& %&&-1 +-& .%8.($$%# 8($+(#
-# +(&$".(7-2 %7"#"61 "0 &3(.($B 3.%9(7-$%9 ($&%20 "# -# %V3-#9(#/ 7"632%V
"0 0".7%& 8($+(# 8+(7+ -#1 "#% 0".7% 7-##"$ H% (&"2-$%9 (# -H&$.-7$("#> *+F&
$+% 0(/F.% (# 0."#$ "0 8+"6 =(%$A&7+% 0-22& &(2%#$ (# $+% 0"22"8(#/ 3-.-/.-3+
`l<Ja -#9 8+"6 +% 3-&&%& "'%. $" q-.-$+F&$.- $" 3.%3-.%B 5"#% 8($+ 6".%
0F$F.%; $+-# +(6&%20B $+(& 0(/F.% `$+% 5"'%.6-#; (# $+%&% $%.6&a (& - 2*/#*"& $+-$
7"6%& "F$ "0 $+% 2"/(7 "0 "33"&($("# -77".9(#/ $" 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% "33"&%&
5#-$F.-2 (#72(#-$("#&; $" 57"#&7(%#7%;> O% +-'% &%%#B +"8%'%.B $+-$ $+% 6"&$
(#$%.%&$(#/ 2%'%2& "0 $+(& '%.1 &-6% 8".T 9(&&"2'% $+(& 2"/(7 -#9 ($& "33"&(S
$("#-2 $%.6& (#$" - 0(%29 "0 0".7%& $+-$ %V7%%9& -#9 -77"F#$& 0".B (# $+% 0(.&$
32-7%B 8+-$ 8% F#9%.&$-#9 H1 5(#&(9%; -#9 5"F$&(9%;B 53&17+%; -#9 5%#'(."#S
6%#$;B 5$+% #-$F.-2; -#9 $+% 57F2$F.-2;B $+% 5-00%7$('%; -#9 $+% 5$%7+#"2"/(7-2;B
%$7> Y +-'% -./F%9B .-$+%.B $+-$ $+%&% (#&$-#7%& /."8 "F$ "0 - 3."7%&& "0
5&3(.($F-2(&-$("#; $+-$ -$ $+% &-6% $(6% (& -28-1& -2.%-91 H%1"#9 $+%&%
(#&$-#7%&> Y# $+(& &%#&%B -#9 -$ $+% '%.1 2%-&$B #'$)$ *% &" )$.$5I#*"& #" /"5$
H%7-F&% #'$)$ *% &"#'*&? #" +$ )$.$$5$.> G%9%63$("# -#9 ($& .%2-$%9 '-2F%& `"0
8+(7+ #(+(2(&6 -#9 "3$(6(&6 -.% $8"a -.% $+%6&%2'%& (#&$-#7%& "0 $+%
+F6-# $+-$ /."8 "F$ "0 5&3(.($;B -& 5($; (# $F.# "F$/."8& $+%6>
*+F&B "#7% "#% +-& &+"8# $+-$ (# =(%$A&7+% 3F.%B &3"#$-#%"F& 9(&7+-./%
-#9 $+% +(&$".1 "0 &FHR%7$('($1 7-##"$ H% &%3-.-$%9 -#9 $+-$B 6".% (63".$S
-#$21B $+% $.-($& "0 $+% "'%.+F6-# -#9 $+% +(&$".1 "0 &FHR%7$('($1 7-##"$ H%
&%3-.-$%9 %($+%.B HF$ .-$+%. -.% $" H% .%$+"F/+$ 8($+(# $+% +(&$".1 $+-$ 6-T%&
$+%6 (#&%3-.-H2%B 6F7+ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $%V$ +-& (66%#&% (#$%.%&$ 0". F&
$"9-1> Y$ 9"%& #"$ +-'% (#$%.%&$B +"8%'%.B (# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 #(+(2(&6B HF$ (#
$+% 7"#$%V$ "0 9(&3%.&(#/ $+% 3+-#$-&6& "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 32-7(#/ $+%6 (#
.%2-$("# $" $+% 0".7%& $+-$ "./-#(&% -#9 9(&.F3$ $+%&% 3+-#$-&6-$(7
&%3-.-$("#& $" H%/(# 8($+> Y$ (& +%.% $+-$ =(%$A&7+% &$(22 +-& 6F7+ $" $%22 F&>
W". 8+-$ 7"6%& "F$ "0 "F. .%7"#0(/F.(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+% 0"22"8(#/ $+%&% 7"6S
32%V 6"6%#$& "0 +(& 8".T (&B -$ 2%-&$B 0"F. $+(#/&> Y 8(22 7"#72F9% F3"# $+%6>
W(.&$4 0".7% (& $" H% F#9%.&$""9 -& - 7"632%V "0 0".7%& $+-$ 7-#
"#21 H% H."T%# 9"8# (#$" F#(2-$%.-2 0".7%& -$ $+% .(&T "0 -#-21$(7-2 -#9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
$+% )$.$5I#*"& "0 $+(& .%-2($14 .%9%%6 ($ 0."6 $+% 7F.&% 8+(7+ ($& (9%-2 +-&
32-7%9 "# ($ F3 $(22 #"8>
`)XXDB l<DB CIh)a>
%$+(7"S3"2($(7-2 3"'%.$1> MF6-# -33."3.(-$("# "0 $+%&% 0".7%& (# $+% #-6% "0
$+% +F6-# (& "#% &F7+ 7F2$F.% "0 3"'%.$14 ($ (& $+% 7F2$F.% "0 6%$-3+1&(7&>
=(+(2(&6 -& $+% (#'%.&("# "0 $+(& -33."3.(-$("# (& -#"$+%.>
,%7"#94 $+(& 7"632%V (& $" H% F#9%.&$""9 '*%#")*/944C -& -# (#7.%-&(#/21
7"632(7-$%9 '".$%V "0 0".7%&> M%#7% $+% #%%9B -0$%. =(%$A&7+%B -#9 8($+(#
$+% $%.6& "0 T#"82%9/%B $" .%$+(#T $+% .%2-$("#& H%$8%%# $+% +F6-#($(%& -#9
$+% &7(%#7%& &F7+ $+-$ $+%(. (66-#%#$ 2(#T& 7-# H% -.$(7F2-$%9 $" $+% H%#%0($
"0 %-7+ &%3-.-$% 9(&7(32(#% -#9 0(%29 "0 T#"82%9/%> W". ($ (& (# $+(& 7"#&$%22-S
$("# "0 9(&7(32(#%& $+-$ - .%0(#%9B 6"9%&$ F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 $+% +F6-# 8(22
%6%./% -#9 7"F29 +-'% (#$%.%&$(#/ 7F2$F.-2 %00%7$&>
*+(.94 $+% %#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 $+(#T(#/ -#9 '-2F-$("# 9"%& #"$ H%$"T%#
($& 9%&$.F7$("# `-& -# %-&1 .%-9(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+% 6(/+$ $+(#TaB HF$ ($& .%S
(#&7.(3$("#B .%8.($(#/ -#9 5&FH2-$("#; 8($+(# $+(& '".$%V> L#% .%&F2$ "0 $+(&
.%S(#&7.(3$("# (& #"$ - 9(&%63"8%.(#/ &%#&% $+-$ $+% +F6-# (& "#21 3-.$ "0
$+(& '".$%VB 9%&3($% H%(#/ $+% 6-R". '%+(72% "0 ($B HF$ 9& $5I"=$)*&? %$&%$ "2
#'$ *&.$#$)5*&9/C "2 )$49#*"&% #" $5$)?$> *+(& %63"8%.(#/ 7"6%&B (# "$+%.
8".9&B 0."6 +F6-# 6"9%&$1 `&"6%$+(#/ $+-$ $+% O%&$ -#9 ($& /2"H-2(&(#/
6"9%2& +-'% &$(22 $" 2%-.# -#9B $+-$B $+%.%0".%B 6F&$ H% 0"F/+$ 0".a> =(%$A&7+%
7-22& $+(& &%#&% 50.%% &3(.($;>
Q#9 $+%.%0".%B 0"F.$+214 8% &+"F29 -00(.6 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ $+% 0".7%& /('(#/
.(&% $" $+% +F6-# -2&" %V7%%9 $+% +F6-#B $+-$ 5&3(.($; 6-T%& $+% +F6-# -22
$+% 8+(2% F#6-T(#/ ($> Q00(.6(#/ $+(&B "#% 7-# $+%# H%/(# $" -.$(7F2-$% $+%
.%2-$("#& H%$8%%# "F. 2('%& -#9 $+% 0".7%& $+-$ 7"#&$($F$% $+%6 (# 2%&&
3+-#$-&6-$(7 8-1& $+-# $+"&% 9(&7"F.&%& -#9 &16H"2(7 0".6&B 8+(7+ %($+%.
.%0F&% &F7+ - /%#%-2"/(7-2 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 $+% +F6-# ". &+".$S7(.7F($ $+%
8".T $" H% 9"#%B +-'% "00%.%9 (# $+% 3-&$ ". -$ 3.%&%#$ "00%.> *+% 6-.T%$ (&
$"9-1 02""9%9 8($+ H"$+ .%-7$("#& 8+(7+ 7"#&$($F$%B -$ - 9%%3 2%'%2 "0 $+%
+F6-# 3&17+%B 3-#(7& H%0".% $+% 7"632%V($1 "0 0".7%> *" $.1 -#9 5(#7".3"S
.-$%; $+(& 7"632%V($1 `(# $+% =(%$A&7+%-# &%#&% "0 6*&F$)4$*+,&?a 7"#&$($F$%&B
(# $F.#B -# (66%#&% 7F2$F.-2 -9'%#$F.%> *+(& -9'%#$F.% (& -# %6(#%#$B
%$+(7-2 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 5&3(.($;> Y$ (& 8+%.%B (# =(%$A&7+%-# $%.6& -#9 $" 7"#S
72F9%B $+% &1&$%6-$(7 .%2-$("#& H%$8%%# 5/%#%-2"/1;B 5%#%./%$(7&; -#9 $+%
3.-7$(7% "0 56%.71; -#9 52"'%; -8-($ - 0F$F.%>
C$%() *+% 6"&$ (63".$-#$ %2-H".-$("# "0 $+%&% '-2F%& (# $%.6& "0 $+(& 9(00%.%#7% .%6-(#&
[%2%FA%;& !*$#@%/'$ 9&. E'*4"%"I'C `[%2%FA% )X?@a> W". [%2%FA%B 5%$%.#-2 .%7F..%#7%;
9%&7.(H%& -#9 -00(.6& $+% 5&-6%#%&&; "0 $+% .%7F..%#7% "0 9(00%.%#7% -#9 "0 $+%
.%2-$("#& "0 9(00%.%#7% H%$8%%# 0".7%&B -#9 58(22 $" 3"8%.; 6-.T& $+% /%#%$(7 %2%S
6%#$ 8($+(# $+(& 9(00%.%#$(-2 "0 0".7% -#9 0".7%&> Q& $+% .%-9%. 8(22 _F(7T21 &F.6(&%B
"#% "0 $+% -(6& "0 $+(& 7+-3$%. (& $" 7"632(7-$% $+% 8-1 (# 8+(7+ - [%2%FA(-# $13%
.%-9(#/ "0 0".7% 2"7-$%& 0".7% 8($+(# ($& (66-#%#$ 9%$%.6(#-$("#&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
ND !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
< ,%%B 0". %V-632%B k>W> K1"$-.9;& 8,%# O95*&? `)X?Ja 0". -# %2"_F%#$ .%0F&-2B 3.%9(S
7-$%9 "# $+% 3+(2"&"3+1 "0 U66-#F%2 K%e'(#-&B "0 (66-#%#$ .%2-$("#& H%$8%%#$+%
%3(&$%6"2"/(7-2B %$+(7-2 -#9 3"2($(7-2>
@ L# $+(& 6"'%B k-7_F%& [%..(9-;& Q2 AI*)*#Z >$*.$??$) 9&. #'$ ],$%#*"& r[%..(9- )X?Xs
7"#&$($F$%& - 0F#9-6%#$-2 .%-9(#/ "0 M%(9%//%.> Y$ 9"%& #"$ %#/-/%B +"8%'%.B (# $+%
7"#$%V$ "0 M%(9%//%.;& 7,%$*&9&.$)%$#@,&? 8($+ =(%$A&7+%B 8($+ $+% 2-$$%.;& "8#
F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 &3(.($> *+% 2-7T "0 %#/-/%6%#$ $%&$(0(%& "# &%'%.-2 2%'%2& $" $+%
8-1 (# 8+(7+ 9%7"#&$.F7$("# +-& -28-1& .%-9 =(%$A&7+%B H% ($ $" &-1 &"6%$+(#/ %2&%
$+-# M%(9%//%.B (# $+% 8-T% "0 M%(9%//%.;& $+"F/+$> k-7_F%& [%..(9-;& (#$%.'(%8 8($+
6% (# $+% 8",)&94 "2 !*$#@%/'$ A#,.*$% `Z%-.9&8".$+ )XXDa (& (#&$.F7$('% (# $+(& .%/-.9>
D E1 .%&$.(7$(#/ $+% =(%$A&7+%-# 7"#7%3$ "0 5&3(.($; $" $+% #%F."#-2 7"632%V -#9 ($&
+(&$".(7-2 -'-$-.& &%%6& $" %V72F9% 8+-$ 8% 7-22 5(#"./-#(7; 6-$$%. 0."6 ($> *+(& (&
H"$+ $.F% -#9 #"$ $.F%> O+(2% 5(#"./-#(7; 6-$$%. (& #"$ 1%$ &3(.($F-2 (# $+% -H"'%
&%#&%B &3(.($ H"$+ 9%3%#9& "# 5(#"./-#(7; 6-$$%. (# $+% 0(.&$ 32-7% $" F#9%./" ($&
"8# 3."7%&& "0 &3(.($F-2(&-$("# `- E-.V(-# 3"(#$ H".# "F$ H1 6F7+ 7"#$%63".-.1
$+(#T(#/ "0 H("2"/1 -#9 $%7+#"2"/1a -#9 (& ($&%20 (#"./-#(7 6-$$%. I)*") #" $+%
3."7%&& "0 &3(.($F-2(&-$("# `- 3"(#$ $+-$B "0 7"F.&%B 9%&$."1& $+% 7"+%.%#7% "0 $+%
$%.6 5(#"./-#(7;a> *+F&B 8($+ $+% =(%$A&7+%-# 9%0(#($("# "0 &3(.($B $+%.% (& #"
-H&"2F$% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# $+% (#"./-#(7 -#9 $+% "./-#(7> D'*% *% &"# #" %9CB
+"8%'%. h -#9 $+(& (& 3.%7(&%21 61 3"(#$ (# .%2-$("# $" $+% $%#9%#71 3.%'-2%#$ (#
7"#$%63".-.1 3+(2"&"3+(&(#/ $" 7"22-3&% +(&$".(7-2 6%9(-$("#&B H% ($ 0."6 - [%..(S
9%-# ". - [%2%FA(-# 3"(#$ "0 '(%8 `-#9 $+% 7"22-3&% (& '%.1 9(00%.%#$ (# %-7+a h $+-$
$+%.% -.% #"$ 7.F7(-2 9(00%.%#7%& 8($+(# $+% 3."7%&&%& "0 &3(.($F-2(&-$("# $+-$ -.% $"
H% -&&F6%9 /%#%-2"/(7-221 -#9 .%02%7$('%21 (# ".9%. 0". $+% 0F$F.% "0 &3(.($ $" H%
-.$(7F2-$%9>
E1 -./F6%#$ 3.%&F33"&%&B $+%.%0".%B $+% 0"22"8(#/4 `(a 6-$$%. H%7"6%& &3(.($B
HF$ #" 6-$$%. H%7"6%& &3(.($ (# $+% =(%$A&7+%-# &%#&% F#2%&& ($ H%7"6%& %#9"8%9
8($+ - #%F."#-2 7"632%Vm -#9 `((a =(%$A&7+% (#%'($-H21 3+(2"&"3+(&%& H%&$ 8+%# +%
(& $-2T(#/ -H"F$ 4*2$4 (#%'($-H21 H%7-F&% $+% 6"'% 2)"5 $+% 3+1&(7-2 #" $+% H("2"/(7-2
(& %V$.%6%21 9(00(7F2$ $" $+(#T $+."F/+> =(%$A&7+% #%'%. -.$(7F2-$%& $+(& 6"'%B
-2$+"F/+ +% (& +-331B %&3%7(-221 (# $+% 3"&$+F6"F& #"$%&B $" $-2T -H"F$ 0".7%& (#
$+% 3+1&(7-2 F#('%.&% -#9 0".7%& (# $+% H("2"/(7-2 F#('%.&% (# $+% &-6% H.%-$+ `&%%B
0". %V-632%B 61 0(.&$ _F"$-$("# 0."6 =(%$A&7+% -H"'% "# $+% 5[("#1&(-# 8".29 "0
$+% %$%.#-221 &%20S7.%-$(#/B &%20S9%&$."1(#/;a> *" 9" $+(& (# "#% H.%-$+ &%%6& $" 6% &%.("F& 6(&$-T% *2 "#% (& F#-H2% $" &+"8 $+% 6"'%B $+% 6%9(-$("#B 0."6 "#% .%-26
$" $+% "$+%.> Y$ (& #"$ &F.3.(&(#/ $+-$ =(%$A&7+% 7-##"$ 5/%#%-2"/(&%; $+-$ 6"'%4 #"
%V3%.(6%#$-2 ". $+%".%$(7-2 3+1&(7(&$B #" %V3%.(6%#$-2 ". $+%".%$(7-2 H("2"/(&$ $"
61 T#"82%9/% +-& 1%$ 9"#% &"B 3.%7(&%21 H%7-F&%B 8+(2% &$/$%%9)C 0". F& #" #'*&;
)$24$/#*F$4CB -#9 (#7.%-&(#/21 &"B $+% 6"'% (& %V$.%6%21 9(00(7F2$ $" $+(#T $+."F/+
7"#7.%$%21 -#9B 0". $+% 6"6%#$B -# (63"&&(H(2($1 $" 3F$ (#$" 3.-7$(7%> Y$ 6-1 8%22
H% $+-$ $+% $%.6& "0 9%H-$% 7"#7%.#(#/ $+(& 6"'% -.% H%7"6(#/ 6".% 72%-.B 8($+
g 22 `)X@D])XNJaB E-$F.-#- -#9 f-.%2- `)X?IB
$+% 8".TB -6"#/ "$+%.&B "0 '"# \%VTF
)X?CaB E"."8($A `)XX<a -#9 G"&%# `)XX)a> M"8%'%. 8% F#9%.&$-#9 $+% &3%7(0(7($1
"0 $+% H("2"/(7-2B %6%./(#/ -& - /.%-$%. 7"632%V($1 "0 0".7%& 0."6 "F$ "0 $+%
3+1&(7-2 h (# $%.6&B $+-$ (&B "0 6%$-H"2(&6 -#9 5&%20;S"./-#(&-$("#B 5&%20;S.%3-(. ".
.%3."9F7$("# h ($ (& "#% $+(#/ $" $+(#T $+(& &3%7(0(7($1m ($ (& -#"$+%.B +"8%'%.B $"
-.$(7F2-$% ($> Y# $+(& &%#&%B $" &(6F2-$% 2(0% "# - 7"63F$%. 0-22& '%.1 &+".$ "0 $+%
#%%9%9 6%9(-$("#& $" &-1 ='9# 4*2$ *% 9&. '"= *# "I$)9#$% `7"63-.%B +%.%B $+% ,-#$- W%
&7+""2 F#9%. ,$F-.$ b-F006-#a> WF.$+%.B $" H-&% "#%;& 3+(2"&"3+1 "& &F7+ &(6F2-S
$("#&B "& &F7+ 6"9%22(#/& -#9 "# $+%(. 3.%9(7$("#& (&B -/-(#B $" 6"'% $"" _F(7T21
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' NJ
J
N
C
?
"'%. $+% '%.1 9(&$(#7$("#& $+-$ #%%9 $" H% 6-(#$-(#%9 "# $+% H-&(& "0 - H."-9
5+(&$".(7-2; &-6%#%&&> [%&3($%B $+%.%0".%B 61 .%&3%7$ -#9 -96(.-$("# 0". 8".T
/"(#/ "# -."F#9 [%2%FA% -$ 3.%&%#$ 7"#7%.#(#/ 6-$$%. -#9 2(0%B Y &$."#/21 H%2(%'%
$+-$B 8($+"F$ - $+(#T(#/ "0 &F7+ 6%9(-$("#&B $+% 3+(2"&"3+%. -#9 7.($(7 .(&T 0-22(#/
(#$" - $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 (22F&("# `(# $+% b-#$(-# &%#&%aB (0 $+%1 9" #"$ /('% 6".%
+13"$+%$(7-2 -#9 )$?,49#*F$ 8%(/+$ $" $+% 7"#7%3$& $+-$ $+%1 -.% 0"./(#/ H%$8%%#
$+% 5#-$F.-2; &7(%#7%& -#9 H%$8%%# $+%&% &7(%#7%& -#9 $+% +F6-#($(%&> *+(& (& 0-.
0."6 - 7"#&%.'-$('% 3"(#$> G%2-$("#& H%$8%%# $+%&% 9(&7(32(#%&B $+%(. 0(%29& -#9
$+%(. 7"#7%3$F-2 (#'%#$("#& -.% -H&"2F$%21 7.F7(-2> *" #F.&% $+%&% .%2-$("#& (# $+%
H%2(%0 "0 - /%#%.-2 &-6%#%&& "0 /."8(#/ 7"632%V($1 (& "#% $+(#/4 $" H%2(%'%B +"8S
%'%.B $+-$ $+%&% .%2-$("#& %V%63$ F& 0."6 02%&+(#/ "F$ 8+-$ -22"8& 0". $+%6 (# $+%
0(.&$ 32-7% (& -#"$+%.> Y H%2(%'% $+-$ ($ (& "#% $-&T "0 $+% 3+(2"&"3+%. $"9-1 $"
F#9%.2(#% H"$+ $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 $+% &-6%#%&& H%$8%%# 6-$$%. -#9 &3(.($ -#9 $+%
#%7%&&($1 "0 $+% 9(00%.%#7%& 8($+(# $+(& &-6%#%&&> Y0 $+(& $-&T (& H"$+ %3(&$%6"2"S
/(7-2 -#9 %$+(7"S3"2($(7-2B $+%# $+% (632(7-$("#& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0
&3(.($ -22"8 F& $" &%% $+% 7"#$(#F(#/ (63".$-#7% "0 $+% b-#$(-# 7.($(7-2 9(&$(#7$("#&
0". &3%7F2-$('% ".(%#$-$("# (# $+% &7(%#7%&> Q#9 $+(& 9%&3($%B 3.%7(&%21B b-#$;& 6%$-S
3+1&(7-2 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 .%-&"#B 0".6 -#9 6-$$%.> *+(& (& - 3"(#$ "0 8+(7+
3+(2"&"3+%.& #%%9 $" H% 7-.%0F2B 8+%# 6"'(#/ H%+(#9B -#9 .(/+$21 &" `jaB $+%
$.-#&7%#9%#$-2 -%&$+%$(7 -#9 -#-21$(7 "0 $+% 0(.&$ ()*#*V,$ (# ".9%. $" "3%# F3B
8($+ $+% 7"#$%63".-.1 &7(%#7%&B 8+-$ 2(%& H%+(#9 b-#$;& 7.($(7-2 =%8$"#(&6>
E1 $+-#T& $" b%($+ Q#&%22 P%-.&"# 0". -&T(#/ 6% $" H% 72%-. "# +"8 -#9 8+1 Y
+"29 $" T%%3(#/ &3(.($ $" $+% #%.'"F& &1&$%6>
*+% 7"#7%3$ "0 ".(/(#-2 &(# 3.%&F33"&%& $+(& 9(&$(#7$("# &(#7% 8($+"F$ ($ "#% 7-##"$
$+(#T %'(2 -& $+% 3%.'%.&("# "0 $+% 8(22 m ($ -2&" +"8%'%. 9%%3%#& $+% 9(&$(#7$("#
&(#7%B -& (& 8%22 T#"8#B 8($+"F$ $+% !+.(&$(-# 7F2$F.% "0 ".(/(#-2 &(#B $+% 6"9%.#
#"$("# "0 &FHR%7$('($1 8"F29 +-'% #"$ %6%./%9>
P%.+-3& $+% 6"&$ %2"_F%#$ %2-H".-$("# "0 $+(& &-6%#%&& "0 0".7% (& $" H% 0"F#9 (#
k>SW> K1"$-.9 `)XX@a> !"63-.% -2&" 61 "8# !*$#@%/'$ `)XXCa>
!"63-.% M%#.1 ,$-$%#;& 8".T "# $+(& 9%&(.% 0". $+% 3."3%. (# =(%$A&7+% `)XXIa>
,$-$%#;& 7"#7"6($-#$ .F##(#/ $"/%$+%. "0 $+% %7"#"6(%& "0 $+% -7$('% -#9 .%-7$('%
(& #"$ -77"F#$%9 0".B +"8%'%.B (# $%.6 "0 $+% +(&$".(7-2 #-$F.% "0 0".7%> Y# $+(& &%#&%
+(& 9%7"#&$.F7$("# "0 =(%$A&7+% .%6-(#& -H&$.-7$ -#9 "'%.S$%V$F-2> Y$ (& #"$ H1
7+-#7% -2&" $+-$ +(& F&% "0 2(H(9(#-2 %7"#"61 $" -77"F#$ 0". +(& 8".T %00-7%&B
3.%7(&%21B $+% +(&$".(7-2 6%9(-$("#& "0 0".7%> *+(& %00-7%6%#$ 8(22 -28-1& H% $+%
.(&T "0 -# %V72F&('%21 53&17+"-#-21$(7; F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 -00%7$B -& (& 72%-.B -2&"B 0."6
k%-#SW.-#7v"(& K1"$-.9;& "'%.-22 F&%& "0 =(%$A&7+% -#9 W.%F9 (# H"$+ +(& %-.2(%. -#9
2-$%. 3+(2"&"3+1>
*" .%9F7% $+% +(&$".(7-2 $" $+% 8.($$%# $.-7% -#9 $" 9%6-.7-$% 8+-$ 2(%& 3.(". $" ($ -&
53.%S+(&$".(7-2; (& $" 7"#&(9%. $.-#&S(#9('(9F-2 +(&$".(7-2 3."7%&&%& "0 6%6".(&-$("#
&(6321 (# $%.6& "0 $+% "HR%7$('%> *+(& (& $" &+".$S7(.7F($ $+% .%2-$("#& H%$8%%# -00%7$B
3&17+% -#9 $%7+#"2"/1 (# 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+%B 0". "#%B (& 3.%7(&%21 (#$%.%&$%9> Y0
-H"'%B Y 7.($(7(&%9B $+%.%0".%B K1"$-.9 -#9 ,$-$%# 0". "0$%# .%9F7(#/ 0".7% $" $+%
-00%7$('%B $+"&% 8($+(# .%7%#$ -#9 7"#$%63".-.1 3+(2"&"3+1 $+-$ 3.%9(7-$% $.-#&S
(#9('(9F-2 3."7%&&%& "0 6%6".(&-$("# F3"# $+% 8.($$%# &(/# ". $+% $%7+#(7-2 "HR%7$
6"'% $"" _F(7T21 (# $+% "33"&($% &%#&%> *+(& &%%6& $" 6% $" H% $+% 6-R". 3."H2%6B
9%&3($% $+%(. H.(22(-#7% -#9 7.F7(-2 9(00%.%#7%& 8($+ %-7+ "$+%.B 8($+ [%..(9-;&
%2-H".-$("# "0 $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 9(00%.%#7% (# +(& (#$."9F7$("# $" MF&&%.2;& %&&-1
5*+% L.(/(# "0 ^%"6%$.1; `[%..(9- )XC?a -#9 8($+ 7F..%#$ .%8".T(#/& "0 MF&&%.2(-#
3+%#"6%#"2"/1 (# $%.6& "0 $%7+#"2"/1 `,$(%/2%. )XXN- -#9 )XXNHa>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
NN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
X Y# W.-#7% $+% /.%-$%&$ 3."3"#%#$& "0 $+(& $+%&(& -.% KF7 W%..1 -#9 Q2-(# G%#-F9>
*+-$ $+%1 +-'% 2($$2% $(6% 0". =(%$A&7+% -#9 .%7%#$ 57"#$(#%#$-2; 3+(2"&"3+1;&
(#$%.%&$ (# H"$+ =(%$A&7+% -#9 M%(9%//%. (& #"$ &F.3.(&(#/> *+% 8(&+ +%.% $" .%S
%'-2F-$% =(%$A&7+% "F$&(9% $+% $%.6& "0 M%(9%//%.;& .%-9(#/ (& 3.%9(7-$%9B (# $F.#B
"# 61 H%2(%0 $+-$ $+% 6"&$ 0".7%0F2 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& .%S%'-2F-$("# "0
$+% &FHR%7$ &$(22 -8-($&>
)I *+(& 3"(#$ (& H.(22(-#$21 %2-H".-$%9 (# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 M%(9%//%.;& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0
9%$%.6(#-$("# -#9 %V-7$($F9% H1 Z%.#-.9 ,$(%/2%. (# D$/'&*/% 9&. D*5$R ^Z D'$ :9,4#
"2 6I*5$#'$,% r,$(%/2%. )XX?s>
)) Y -6 /.-$%0F2 $" 61 0.(%#9 $+% H("2"/(&$ k"+# ,$%8-.$ 0". $+% $%.6 5&3(.-2;> W". -#
-$$%63$ $" F&% H("2"/1 $" .%8".T 7"#$%63".-.1 +%.6%#%F$(7-2 $+%6%& (# $%.6& "0
$+(& &3(.-2B &%%B 7"S8.($$%# 8($+ P(%..% !2%6%#$ -#9 GF$+ ,7+%3&B +(& '%.1 0%.$(2%
5\#% (#$%.3.%e$-$("# H("2"/(_F% 9% 2;(#$%.3.%e$-$("#; -#9 5K- 3+12"/%#%n&% 9% 2;(#$%.S
3.%e$-$("#; (# k%-#SE(7+%2 ,-2-#&T(&B W.-#7v"(& G-&$(%. -#9 GF$+ ,7+%3&B >$M)5$&$,J
#*V,$R #$H#$%R %/*$&/$% `)XXCa>
)< kF&$ -& $+(& %&&-1 +-& 72%-.21 $-T%# 9(&$-#7% $" [%2%FA%;& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 0".7%B &"B
+%.%B ($ 6F&$ _F%&$("# $+% "33"&($("# $+-$ [%2%FA% 6-T%& H%$8%%# =(%$A&7+%-#
-00(.6-$("# -#9 M%/%2(-# 9(-2%7$(7 `[%2%FA% )X?@B )DJh?Ia> *+-$ =(%$A&7+% 9%$%.S
6(#%& $+% 52-8 "0 2(0%; -& $+% 5&%20S&FH2(6-$("# "0 -22 $+(#/&; `=(%$A&7+% )XXDB )<NaB
$+-$ +% F#9%.&$-#9& &3(.($ -& 52(0% $+-$ ($&%20 7F$& (#$" 2(0%; `=(%$A&7+% )XN)B )<Ca 7-#
"#21 &F//%&$ $+-$ $+% .%2-$("#& H%$8%%# M%/%2 -#9 =(%$A&7+% -.% 0."6 $+% 0(.&$ #"$
"#%& "0 "33"&($("#B 8+-$%'%. $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 $+% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# $+% 0(%29 "0
3+%#"6%#"2"/1 -#9 $+-$ "0 %#%./%$(7&> *+-$ &-(9B [%2%FA%;& -#$(SM%/%2(-#(&6 (&
3."H-H21 H%&$ -77"F#$%9 0". (# $%.6& "0 $+% W.%#7+ 6"F.#(#/ "0 E-.V(&6
-2$+"F/+B (63".$-#$21B ($ (& [%2%FA%;& -#$(SM%/%2(-#(&6 $+-$ 3."'(9%& $+% (#$%22%7S
$F-2 7"#$%V$ $" +(& F#9%.%&$(6-$("# "0 6%9(-$("#>
)@ Q/-(#B [%2%FA% (& $+%.%0".% $"" _F(7T $" 32-7% 7"#&7("F&#%&&B +(&$".1 -#9 6%6".1
=*#'*& $+% 0(%29 "0 $+% .%-7$('%B -#9 $"" _F(7T $" -./F% $+-$ $+% "#21 $.F% 5&7(%#7%; (&
"#% 58+%.% $+%.% (& #" 7"#&7("F&#%&&; `[%2%FA% )X?@B D<a> =%($+%. 7"#&7("F&#%&&
#". $+% F#7"#&7("F&B #%($+%. $+% 7-$%/".(-2 #". $+% &FH3+%#"6%#-2 (& 8+-$ (& "0
(#$%.%&$4 8+-$ (& "0 (#$%.%&$ (& H"$+ $+% .%2-$("# H%$8%%# $+% $8" -#9 $+% 8-1 (#
8+(7+ $+(& .%2-$("# (& 0".6%9B -#9 7+-#/%&B +(&$".(7-221> Q2$+"F/+ [%2%FA%;&
3"2%6(7-2 3"(#$ 7-# H% -/-(# 32-7%9 (# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 $+% 3"2($(7-2 -#9 %$+(7-2
7"#&%_F%#7%& "0 E-.V(&$ 53+%#"6%#"2"/1;B +(& (#&(&$%#7% "# $+% $.F$+ "0 $+%
&FH3+%#"6%#-2 -#$(7(3-$%& +(& 3+(2"&"3+(%& "0 (#$%#&($1 -#9 -00%7$ (#B .%&3%7$S
('%21B B*22$)$&/$ 9&. 1$I$#*#*"& `[%2%FA% )XXDa -#9 7&#*JQ$.*I,% `[%2%FA% -#9
^F-$$-.( )X?Da> Q/-(# ($ (& #"$ - _F%&$("# "0 &-1(#/ $+-$ $+(& (#&(&$%#7% (& 8."#/
-& &F7+B HF$ "0 -.$(7F2-$(#/B (# +(&$".(7-2 $%.6&B $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 $+% .%2-$("#B -#9
$+% 7.($(7-2 (63".$-#7% "0 $+% &3-7% H%$8%%#B $+% 3+%#"6%#-2 -#9 #"#3+%#"6%S
#-2B $+% 7-$%/".(-2 -#9 $+% (#$%#&%B %$7> Q 7.($(7-2 .%-9(#/ "0 7 D'",%9&. E49#$9,%
`[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( )XX@aB $+% 6"&$ -6H($("F& -#9 +(&$".(7-2 "0 [%2%FA% -#9
^F-$$-.(;& 8".T& "# 0".7%B 8"F29 H% "0 '-2F% (# $+(& 7"#$%V$>
)D 5U$%.#-2 G%7F..%#7%; -#9 5O(22 $" P"8%.; -.%B "0 7"F.&%B .%S%'-2F-$%9 7-$%/".(%&
8+%.%H1 =(%$A&7+% -2&" 8-#$& $" $+(#T 0".7%& 3.(". $" 2(0%> M"8%'%.B -& #"$% @
-./F%9 -$ 2%#/$+B $" $-2T -H"F$ 0".7% -$ - H"$+ 3+1&(7-2 -#9 H("2"/(7-2 2%'%2 (#
$%.6& "0 $+%&% 7-$%/".(%& )*%;% 2"&(#/ $+% '%.1 6%9(-$("#& $+-$ -.% 7.F7(-2 $" $+%&%
0".7%&; '%.1 9%0(#($("#> Y$ &%%6& $" 6%B $+%#B $+-$ $" F&% $+%&% 7-$%/".(%& $" 9%0(#%
$+% &-6%#%&& "0 $+%&% 0".7%&B -$ $+% .(&T "0 2"&(#/ $+% 8-1 (# 8+(7+ 0".7% HF7T2%&
H-7T "# ($&%20B $+."F/+ (#$%.-7$("# 8($+ "$+%. 0".7%&B $" H%7"6% -#"$+%. 0".7%B (&
&$(22 $"" F#('%.&-2(&(#/B $"" 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 (# $+% 72-&&(7-2 &%#&%> *+% 9-#/%. "0 &F7+
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' NC
F#('%.&-2(&-$("# (& $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 (22F&("#4 $+% H%2(%0 $+-$ 8% -.% $-2T(#/ 3+(2"&"S
3+(7-221 -H"F$ &"6%$+(#/ .%-2 h H% ($ +%.% "0$%# 5&FH%63(.(7-2; h $+-$ #%%9& 6F7+
/.%-$%. 8".T H%0".% 8% 7-# 9%&(/#-$% ($ 8($+ 7"#7%3$& $+-$ +-'% -# *55$.*9#$
%3(&$%6"2"/(7-2 -#9 %$+(7-2 '"7-$("#> M%#7% 61 3.%0%.%#7% 0". $+% $%.6& 5&3(.($;
-#9 5&3(.($F-2(&-$("#;4 $+%1 -.% 6".% +(&$".(7-221 .(7+ -#9 02%V(H2%B 2%&& +"6"/%#(&S
(#/ (# $+%(. -.$(7F2-$("#& "0 9(00%.%#7%B 2%&& +%."(7 (# $"#%B 6".% (#'($(#/ "0 &2"8B
HF$ 9%7(&('% 7+-#/%> Y -6 8%22 -8-.%B +"8%'%.B $+-$ $+% _F%&$("# "0 $+% &3%7(0(7($1
"0 $+% 5(#"./-#(7; $"/%$+%. 8($+ $+-$ "0 ($& %6%./%#7% (#$" $+% 5"./-#(7; .%6-(#
8($+ $+(& 7+"(7%> *+%&% _F%&$("#& -.%B 0". 6%B -& Y -./F%9 (# #"$% @B $" H% .%$-(#%9
(# $+%(. 9(00(7F2$1> Y$ (& .%$-(#(#/ $+(& 9(00(7F2$1B #"$ $+% 7"#'%.&%B $+-$ 8(22 -22"8 0".
$+% 6"&$ 3"8%.0F2 (#'%#$("#&>
)J Q#1 -$$%63$B -#9 $+%.% +-'% H%%# 6-#1 0."6 $+% 0(0$(%& $" $"9-1B $" 9('(9%
=(%$A&7+%;& 8.($(#/& (#$" -# %-.2(%. -#9 2-$%. 3+(2"&"3+1 -#9 %$+(7& 8"F29 &%%6
$+%.%0".% 6(&/F(9%9 0."6 $+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 5&3(.($;>
0(D()(,1(Z%-.9&8".$+B G> `)XXDa 5=(%$A&7+% -#9 $+% E-7+(#%;B (#$%.'(%8 8($+ k-7_F%& [%..(9->
8",)&94 "2 !*$#@%/'$ A#,.*$%> Y&&F% C> ,3.(#/ )XXD>
pp `)XXCa !*$#@%/'$> P-.(&4 K%& Z%22%& K%$$.%&>
[%2%FA%B ^> `)X?@a !*$#@%/'$ 9&. E'*4"%"I'C> $.-#&> M> *"62(#&"#> K"#9"#4 Q$+2"#%
P.%&&>
pp `)XXDa B*22$)$&/$ 9&. 1$I$#*#*"&> $.-#&> P> P-$$"#> K"#9"#4 Q$+2"#% P.%&&>
[%2%FA%B ^B -#9 ^F-$$-.(B W> `)X?Da 7&#*JQ$.*I,%Z (9I*#94*%5 9&. A/'*@"I')$&*9> $.-#&> G>
MF.2%1B E> ,%%6 -#9 M>G> K-#%> K"#9"#4 Q$+2"#% P.%&&>
pp `)XX@a 7 D'",%9&. E49#$9,%Z (9I*#94*%5 9&. A/'*@"I')$&*9> $.-#&> Z> E-&&F6(> E(#S
#%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
[%..(9-B k> `)XC?a 6.5,&. >,%%$)4N% Q)*?*& "2 O$"5$#)C0 7& -&#)".,/#*"&> $.-#&> H1 k"+# P>
K%-'%1> K(#7"2# -#9 K"#9"#4 \#('%.&($1 "0 =%H.-&T- P.%&&>
pp `)X?Xa Q2 AI*)*#Z >$*.$??$) 9&. D'$ ],$%#*"&> $.-#&> ^> Z%##(#/$"# -#9 G> Z"82H1>
!+(7-/"4 \#('%.&($1 "0 !+(7-/" P.%&&>
M%(9%//%.B E> `)XX)-a !*$#@%/'$Z X"4% - h--> $.-#&> [>W> b.%22> ,-# W.-#7(&7"4 M-.3%.>
pp `)XX)Ha !*$#@%/'$Z X"4% --- h -X> $.-#&> [>W> b.%22> ,-# W.-#7(&7"4 M-.3%.>
K1"$-.9B k>SW 8($+ k%-#SK"F3 *+%eH-F9> `)X?Ja 8,%# O95*&?> $.-#&> O> ^"9A(7+> E-#S
7+%&$%.4 E-#7+%&$%. \#'%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)XX@a L*+*.*&94 6/"&"5C> $.-#&> Y> M-6(2$"# ^.-#$> K"#9"#4 Q$+2"#% P.%&&>
E-$F.-#-B M> -#9 f-.%2-B W> `)X?Ia 7,#"I"*$%*% 9&. ("?&*#*"&0 #'$ 1$94*@9#*"& "2 #'$
L*F*&?> Z"&$"# ,$F9(%& (# $+% P+(2"&"3+1 "0 ,7(%#7%B $> :YY> Z"&$"#4 [> G%(9%2
pp `)X?Ca D'$ D)$$ "2 G&"=4$.?$Z D'$ <*"4"?*/94 1""#% "2 >,59& [&.$)%#9&.*&?> $.-#&> G>
P-"2F77(> Z"&$"# -#9 K"#9"#4 ,+-6H+-2->
E"."8($AB M>k> `)XX<a <$?*&&*&?% "2 ($44,49) L*2$Z 3$#9+"4*%5 1$/9I*#,49#$% <*"?$&$%*%>
o-2%4 o-2% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XN)a D',% AI";$ T9)9#',%#)9> $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%> K"#9"#4 P%#/F(#>
pp `)XN?-a D=*4*?'# "2 #'$ -."4%dD'$ 7&#*J(')*%#> $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%> K"#9"#4 P%#S
/F(#>
pp `)XN?Ha D'$ P*44 D" E"=$)> $.-#&> O> b-F06-##> =%8 o".T4 f(#$-/%>
pp `)XC@a D'$ O9C A/*$&/$> $.-#&> O> b-F06-##> =%8 o".T4 f(#$-/%>
pp `)XCDa <$C"&. O"". 9&. 6F*4Z E)$4,.$ #" 9 E'*4"%"I'C "2 #'$ :,#,)$> $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/S
9-2%> K"#9"#4 P%#/F(#>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
N? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
pp `)X?<a B9C+)$9;Z D'",?'#% "& #'$ E)$K,.*/$% "2 3")94*#C> $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%>
!-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)X?Na >,59&R 744 D"" >,59&> $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%> !-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/%
\#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)X??a A9U5#4*/'$ P$);$Z G)*#*%/'$ A#,.*$&9,%?9+$Z <9&. i> +.&/> '"# ^> !"22( -#9 E>
g #7+%#4 [*f]9% ^.F1$%.>
E"#$(#-.(> EF
pp `)XXDa Q& D'$ O$&$94"?C Q2 3")94*#C> %9> b> Q#&%22 P%-.&"#> $.-#&> !> [(%$+%>
!-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
G"&%#B G> `)XX)a L*2$ -#%$42Z 7 ("5I)$'$&%*F$ -&V,*)C *&#" #'$ !9#,)$R Q)*?*&R 9&. :9+)*/9J
#*"& "2 L*2$> =%8 o".T4 !"2F6H(- \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
,-2-#&T(&B k>SE>B G-&$(%.B W> -#9 ,7+%3&B G> `)XXCa >$M)5$&$,#*V,$R #$H#$%R %/*$&/$%> P-.(&4
P.%&&%& \#('%.&($-(.%& 9% W.-#7%>
,$(%/2%.B Z> `)XXN-a L9 #$/'&*V,$ $# 4$ #$5I%0 D"5$ \Z L9 .$M%")*$	#*"&> P-.(&4 ^-2(2%e%>
pp `)XXNHa 5P%.&%3+"#%B L%9(3F&B U3(6%$+%F&;> $.-#&> G> Z%-.9&8".$+> D$;'&$590
8",)&94 "2 E'*4"%"I'C 9&. D$/'&"4"?C> @4 NXh))<>
pp `)XX?a D$/'&*/% 9&. D*5$R ^Z D'$ :9,4# "2 6I*5$#'$,%> $.-#&> G> Z%-.9&8".$+ -#9 ^>
!"22(#&> ,$-#0".94 ,$-#0".9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
1*/'9). <$9).%=")#' NX
D
*+% E"#&$."F& G%H(.$+ "0 =(+(2(&6
./)/2$M(- $D C#+#"#-=
*+%.% (& $+% 9(00%.%#7% "0 - 7%#$F.1 $" H% 6-.T%9 H%$8%%# =(%$A&7+%;& 3"&$S
+F6"F& .%02%7$("#& "# $+% #%7%&&($1 $" %V3%9($% $+% 9%'-2F-$("# "0 -22
'-2F%&B -#9 $+% 7F..%#$ 8(9%&3.%-9 .%7%3$("# "0 $+"&% .%02%7$("#& (# $+%
'-.("F& 7%2%H.-$("#& "0 #(+(2(&6B H"$+ -7$('% -#9 3-&&('%B 8+(7+ -.%
&3.%-9 "F$ -22 -."F#9 -#9 -H"F$ -$ $+(& #%8 $F.# "0 - 7%#$F.1> *+%.% (&
$+%# - 3-.-9"V +%.%4 0". $+% -##"F#7%6%#$ 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% +(6&%20
9%72-.%& $" H% H%0".% ($& $(6% (& #"8 &F33"&%9 $" +-'% -..('%9B -#9 (#
7(.7F6&$-#7%& '%.1 9(00%.%#$ 0."6 $+"&% "0 =(%$A&7+%;& &"2($-.1B .(/"."F&
&%20S_F%&$("#(#/> *+% %&&-1 8+(7+ 0"22"8& %V32".%& $+% (632(7-$("#& "0
$+(& $.-#&3"&($("# "0 #(+(2(&6 0."6 - &"2($-.1 $+"F/+$B 0". $+% 6-(# 3-.$
9%'%2"3%9 (# 3"&$+F6"F&21 3FH2(&+%9 6-#F&7.(3$& -#9 "#21 "H2(_F%21
(#9(7-$%9 (# &"6% "0 $+% 6"&$ +(/+21 8."F/+$ $%V$& "0 $+% $.-9($("#B 9%01(#/
"#% 6(/+$ &F33"&% %-&1 -33."3.(-$("#B $" - 7"66"#21 -7T#"82%9/%9
$+%6%>
*+%.% -.% $8" 0F.$+%. 9(6%#&("#& "0 $+(& $.-#&3"&($("#4 "#% (& $+% $.-#&(S
$("# 0."6 =(%$A&7+%;& 9(&7.%$%21 7F&$"6(&%9 ^%.6-#B - &$-.$2(#/ 7"6H(#-$("#
"0 KF$+%.-# (#$"#-$("# -#9 #(#%$%%#$+S7%#$F.1 3"2($(7-2 21.(7B (#$" $+% 02-$S
#%&& "0 - 7"&6"3"2($-# U#/2(&+m -#9 $+% "$+%. (& $+% $.-#&($("# 0."6 #(+(2(&6 -& - _F%&$("# "0 $+% 0".6-$("# -#9 (#9%%9 9%0".6-$("# "0 (#$%22%7S
$F-2 '-2F%&B ". (#9%%9 "0 ^.%%T %V7%22%#7%&B (#$" $+% #(+(2(&6 %V32".%9 H1
M%(9%//%.B 8+(7+B (# ($& %63+-&(& "# - &3.%-9(#/ 8-&$%2-#9B -#9 ($& %6-#-S
$("# (# $+% &3.%-9 "0 $%7+#"2"/1B .%'%-2& - 0F.$+%. 9%'-2F-$("# "0 -22 '-2F%&B
-& $+% .%9F7$("# "0 ^.%%T %V7%22%#7% $" #" 6".% $+-# $+% '-2F%& 8+(7+ &"2'%
%_F-$("#&> *+%&% $8" $.-#&($("#&B "0 - $+(#T(#/ 0."6 - &"2($-.1 $" - 7"22%7$('%
9"6-(#m -#9 0."6 -# (#$%22%7$F-2 $" $+% $%7+#"2"/(7-2 &3+%.%B -.% "0 &"6%
&(/#(0(7-#7%> *+%&% &+(0$&B Y &F//%&$B (# .%-2(&(#/ =(%$A&7+%;& $+"F/+$B $+.%-S
$%# $" -77"632(&+ ($& -H"2($("#B $+F& +-'(#/ $+% 0".6 "0 - 7"63F$%. '(.F&B
8+(7+ -& ($ 9%72-.%& ($& 3.%&%#7%B 8(3%& -22 &1&$%6& "0 .%/(&$%.(#/ 3.%&%#7%
0."6 $+% 6-7+(#%>
CI
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"9&&9 >".?$
*+% 9-#/%. (& $+-$ 8+%.% =(%$A&7+% F#9%.&$""9 - 7"632%$%9 #(+(2(&6 $"
6-T% 8-1 0". - #%8 0".6-$("#B $+%.% (& - 3"&&(H2% 0".6 "0 7"632%$%9 #(+(2S
(&6 8+(7+ (& RF&$ $+-$4 #(+(2(&6> *+% _F%&$("# $" H% 3"&%9 (# $+(& %&&-1 (&
8+%$+%. =(%$A&7+%;& ". 3%.+-3& q-.-$+F&$.-;& $%-7+(#/ 7"#7%.#(#/ #(+(2(&6
6-1 #"$ &$(22 ". -22 $+% 6".% &" +-'% 0-(2%9 $" 0(#9 -# -9%_F-$% +%-.(#/B
8+%$+%. $+% '%.1 8(9%&3.%-9 #-$F.% "0 $+% .%7%3$("# (#9(7-$%& %V-7$21 - 2"&&
(# $.-#&6(&&("# &" $"$-2 -& $" 3-&& 0". $+% 6-(# 3-.$ 8+"221 F#.%6-.T%94 $+-$
$+"F/+$ 7-# #" 2"#/%. $-T% 32-7%> *+(& (& M%(9%//%.;& +13"$+%&(&B %V32".%9 -$
&"6% 3-.-9"V(7-2 2%#/$+ (# $+% )XJ)hJ< 2%7$F.%&B P'9# /944% 2") #'",?'#S *+(&
+13"$+%&(& (& -$$.(HF$%9 H1 M%(9%//%. (# $+"&% 2%7$F.%& $" =(%$A&7+%B _F"$(#/4
58"% $" +% 8+" +(9%& $+% 8-&$%2-#9 8($+(#; `M%(9%//%. )XJDB )<m )XN?B @Ia>
*+% $+"F/+$ $+%# 8"F29 H% $+-$ $+% 3"&$+F6"F& 6"6%#$ "0 =(%$A&7+% +-&
&$(22 #"$ 7"6%B -#9 8(22 #"$ 7"6% 8+(2% ($& &(/#-$F.% "0 0F$F.($1 (& &$(22
6(&F#9%.&$""9 -& $+-$ 8+(7+ 7"6%& 2-$%. (# $(6%B -& "33"&%9 $" $+-$
8+(7+ 6-.T& $+% "3%##%&& "0 $+% +".(A"#B $+"F/+$ -& 0F$F.-2>
*+(& 7+-3$%. %V32".%& $+% 3-.-9"V%& "0 $+% H%7"6(#/ 7"66"#32-7% "0
#(+(2(&6B '(- $+%&% $+.%% 3-.-9"V%&4 $+-$ =(%$A&7+% &F33"&%& +(& "8#
$+"F/+$ -& - #"#S-..('-2B -& 3"&$+F6"F&m $+-$ $+% $+"F/+$ "0 #(+(2(&6 (&
&F33"&%9 -22 $+% &-6% $" +-'% -..('%9B -#9 (& .%2-1%9 -& $+"F/+ ($ +-9 -..('%9
-#9 8%.% 8%22 F#9%.&$""9m -#9 $+-$ M%(9%//%. %V32".%& $+(& #"#S-..('-2
$+."F/+ $+% $+"F/+$ "0 #(+(2(&6 -& $+% &3.%-9 "0 $%7+#"2"/1 (# - 0".6
8+(7+ $+%# /%#%.-$%& - #"#S-..('-2 "0 $+(#T(#/> *+(& +-& 2%9 $" $+% 6"#S
&$."F& .%H(.$+ "0 $+% $+"F/+$ "0 #(+(2(&6 (# - 0".6 #" 2"#/%.B ". #"$ 1%$
$+"F/+$B (# - 0".6 H%1"#9 $+% -7$('% -#9 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6& "0 D'$ P*44 #"
E"=$) `)XI)aB $" 8+(7+ Y &+-22 /('% $+% #-6% 9%6"#(7 #(+(2(&6B "#% 8+(7+
7-..(%& $+% 0".7% "0 ($& #-6% -#9 9%&$."1& -22 3"&($("#(#/> *+(& $+%# 8"F29
&F//%&$ $+-$ $+% "3%.-$("#& "0 $+"F/+$ -& 7-3$F.%9 (# $+% (6-/% "0 $+%
7"63F$%. '(.F& 3.%&%#$& $+% 0".6 "0 - &3%7(0(7-221 6"9%.# 0".6 "0 &%#&(H(2($1B
H-&(7 $" $+% 3.%&%#$ -/%B $+% 7"63F$%. '(.F&B -& - $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 -%&$+%$(7
8+(7+ /('%& $+"F/+$ #"$ -& b-#$ 8"F29 +-'% ($B -& (#0(#($%21 &%20S.%32(7-$(#/B
HF$ -& &%20S9%&$.F7$(#/B 8(3%9 0."6 $+% &7.%%# &(6F2$-#%"F& 8($+ ($& 0(.&$
-33%-.-#7% "# $+-$ &F.0-7%>
Y$ (& +%230F2 $" (9%#$(01 $8" 3"&&(H2% &163$"6& "0 - .%&(&$-#7% $" - $+(#T(#/
7-3-H2% "0 - 6"'% H%1"#9 9%6"#(7 #(+(2(&6 H%0".% $F.#(#/ $" - 9(&7F&&("#
"0 +"8 $+(& &$.-#/% .%'%.&-2 "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 3F.3"&%& 6(/+$ +-'% $-T%# 32-7%>
*+%&% $8" &163$"6& "0 .%&(&$-#7% 7-# H% $+%6-$(&%9 (# .%2-$("# $" $8" &%$&
"0 W.%F9(-# $+%6%&4 6"F.#(#/ -#9 6%2-#7+"21B -#9 9%&(.% -#9 $+% 9.('%>
*+%.% (& .%&(&$-#7% $" -#1 .-9(7-2(&-$("# "0 $+% W.%F9(-# $+%".(&(#/ "0 9%&(.%B
8+(7+ (& 7"#$(#F-221 .%$F.#%9 $" - 3.%&F63$("# "0 - H-&(7 &$-$% "0 2-7TB
%7+"(#/ $+% ,7+%22(#/(-# $+%6% "0 $+% %$%.#-2 9%0(7(%#71 "0 H%(#/B -#9 $" .%-9(#/ "0 $+% 9%-$+ 9.('%& -& 7"##%7$%9 F3 $" - 9%&$.F7$('% #%/-$('% %#%./1B
-& 9(&7F&&%9 H1 W.%F9 (# 5!('(2(&-$("# -#9 ($& [(&7"#$%#$&; `)X@)a> *+% $-&T
$+%# (& $" .%$.(%'% - 3"&($('% 9%&$.F7$('% %#%./1B 2(T% $+-$ 02-//%9 F3 H1
M%(9%//%. (# $+% "3%#(#/ &%7$("#& "0 <$*&? 9&. D*5$ `)X<Ca 8+%.% +% 7-22&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"9&&9 >".?$ C)
0". - 9%&$.F7$("# "0 $+% +(&$".1 "0 3+(2"&"3+1 $" .%2%-&% $+(#T(#/ (#$" $+%
0F$F.%m -#9 $+-$ -##"F#7%9 H1 O-2$%. Z%#R-6(# 8+%# +% 7-22& 0". - 9%&$.F7S
$("# "0 $+% M%(9%//%.(-# 6%2-#7+"21> *+% $+%6% "0 6"F.#(#/ -#9 6%2-#S
g 29%.2(#;& -#9 (#9%%9 =(%$A&7+%;& -00(.6-$("#& "0
7+"21 (& (#$%..F3$%9 H1 M"
9%-$+& 8+(7+ 9%01 6"F.#(#/>
*+% $-&T "0 $+(& %&&-1 $+%# (& $" $.-7% "F$ $+% H('-2%#7% "0 $+% $+%".%$(7-2
(#($(-$('%& "0 M%(9%//%. -#9 "0 W.%F9B 8+(7+ -33%-. -$ 0(.&$ /2-#7% 6".%
.-9(7-2 $+-# $+% $+(#T(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+% HF$ 8+(7+ (# 0-7$ .%$F.# $+(#T(#/ $"
=(%$A&7+% .-$+%. $+-# /"(#/ H%1"#9 +(6> *+(& 9-#/%. "0 0-22(#/ H%+(#9 $+%
/%&$F.% "0 +"3(#/ $" %V7%%9 (& "#% 8+(7+ M%(9%//%. 9(-/#"&%& (# +(& %&&-1B
$+% 2%$$%. "# #(+(2(&6B 5*+% tF%&$("# "0 Z%(#/; `)XJNa> *+%&% H('-2%#7(%& (0
-00(.6%9 (# "#% 8-1 7-# "3%# "F$ - 6"9-2($1 "0 -00(.6-$("# HF$ $+%1 6".%
F&F-221 /%$ 7-F/+$ H-7T F3 (#$" $+% 6"9-2($(%& "0 )$%%$&#*5$&#> *+F& (# $+(&
%&&-1 Y &+-22 3F.&F% $+% 2(#% "0 %#_F(.1 8+(7+ &F33"&%& $+-$ - =(%$A&7+%-#
#(+(2(&6 -..('%& (# $.-#&3"&%9 /F(&% (# $+% $+(#T(#/ "0 W.%F9 -#9 "0 M%(9%/S
/%.B -#9 $+-$ - =(%$A&7+%-# 7.($(_F% "0 W.%F9(-#(&6 8"F29 &%3-.-$% "F$ $+%
&$.-#9 "0 )$%%$&#*5$&#B 3.%&F6-H21 $" H% 3.%9(7-$%9 "# -# (#$."R%7$("# "0 &"7(-221 %&$-H2(&+%9 '(%8 "0 $+% &%7"#9-.1 &$-$F& "0 H%(#/ - k%8B 0."6 $+%
-00(.6-$('% $.-#&7.(3$("# "0 $+(& &"7(-2 '(%8 (#$" - 7-3-7($1 $" .%R%7$ #"$ RF&$
$+% %'-2F-$("# HF$ $+% &"7(-2 #".6& 8+(7+ 3."9F7% ($> Y$ 8"F29 H% 8".$+
7"#&(9%.(#/ 8+-$ $+% =(%$A&7+%-# /%#%-2"/(7-2 7.($(_F% "0 M%(9%//%. 8"F29
2""T 2(T%>
*+% /%&$F.% "0 -00(.6-$('% &%20S$.-#&0".6-$("# (& %'(9%#$ (# W.%F9;& 8.($(#/&
6"&$ "0 -22 (# +(& 5Q# QF$"H("/.-3+(7-2 ,$F91;B 8+%.% +% &$-$%&4
O+%# (# )?C@B Y 0(.&$ R"(#%9 $+% \#('%.&($1B Y %V3%.(%#7%9 &"6% -33.%7(S
-H2% 9(&-33"(#$6%#$&> QH"'% -22 Y 0"F#9 $+-$ Y 8-& %V3%7$%9 $" 0%%2 61&%20
(#0%.(". -#9 -# -2(%# H%7-F&% Y 8-& - k%8> Y .%0F&%9 -H&"2F$%21 $" 9" $+%
0(.&$ "0 $+%&% $+(#/&> Y +-'% #%'%. H%%# -H2% $" &%% 8+1 Y &+"F29 0%%2
-&+-6%9 "0 61 9%&7%#$ ".B -& 3%"32% 8%.% H%/(##(#/ $" &-1B "0 61 5.-7%;>
`W.%F9 )XX@B )X@a
W.%F9 $+F& 9"%& #"$ 9(&-'"8 $+% 0%%2(#/ "0 H%(#/ -# -2(%#B 8+(2% 72%-.21
-00(.6(#/ +(& &%#&% $+-$ +(& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 $+% +F6-# 3&17+% (& (#0(#($%21
(# -9'-#7% "0 -#1 "0 +(& 7"#$%63".-.(%&> *+(& (& +(& &%#&% "0 +(& "8# 3"&$S
+F6"F& &$-$F&B -..('(#/B 2(T% =(%$A&7+%B -0$%. +(& "8# 9%-$+> =(%$A&7+%B -&
W.%F9;& 0.(%#9B 8"F29 3.%&F6-H21 +-'% %#7"F.-/%9 +(6 $" 6"H(2(&% $+%
-6H('-2%#7% H%$8%%# $+% $8" .%-7$("#& $" 3.%RF9(7%B -77%3$-#7% -#9 9%0(S
-#7%B $" $F.# $+% .%&(9F-2 .%-7$('% %2%6%#$ (#$" $+% 7.($(7-2 .%-33."3.(-$("#
"0 7(.7F6&$-#7%B - 2%&&"# "0 7"F.&% 8+(7+ &+"F29 #"$ H% 2"&$ "# "$+%.&B
&(6(2-.21 3"&($("#%9B ". (#9%%9 "# $+"&% (66"H(2(&%9 H1 $+-$ "$+%. 2%$+-2
6%7+-#(&6 "0 )$%%$&#*5$ 9(&7(32%&+(3> *+% .%2-$("# H%$8%%# M%(9%//%.
-#9 +(& 6"&$ 0-($+0F2 7.($(7B [%..(9- 6(/+$ H% .%-9 $" -9'-#$-/% -& .%32(7-$(#/
&F7+ - =(%$A&7+%-# 7.($(_F% "0 W.%F9B 3%.+-3& 3%.6($$(#/ - .%2%-&% "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
C< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
M%(9%//%.(-#(&6 0."6 ($& (66"H(2(&-$("# -& .%7%('%9 8(&9"6> *+% _F%&$("#
+"8 $+(#T%.& &F7+ -& =(%$A&7+%B W.%F9 -#9 M%(9%//%. -.% $" .%6-(# F#7"#S
$-6(#-$%9 H1 $+% 7"632(7-$%9 .%&%#$6%#$& /%#%.-$%9 H1 $+% 6%7+-#(&6& "0
- 6-&& .%7%3$("# (& - 6-R". (&&F% 0". (#$%22%7$F-2 8".T $"9-1> *+% "3%.-$("#&
"0 3"&$+F6"F& 7.($(_F% 6(/+$ H% "#% ."F$% $" T%%3 -77%&& $" $+%(. 8".T
"3%#4 $" 3%.6($ $+%(. 3.%9%7%&&".& $" 3F$ $+% 8".T "0 $+% 2-$% 7"6%.& (#
_F%&$("#B -#9 -H"'% -22 $" 9(&.F3$ $+% $+"F/+$ $+-$ $+"&% 8+" 7"6% 2-$%. -.%
$+%.%H1 $+% 8(&%.> *+% 0(.&$ &%7$("# "0 $+(& %&&-1 %V-6(#%& $+% ".(/(# "0 $+%
$+"F/+$ "0 - 6"#&$."F& .%H(.$+ "0 #(+(2(&6B -& 9%6"#(7B (# =(%$A&7+%;& D'$
<*)#' "2 D)9?$.Cm $+% &%7"#9 %V32".%& $+% -6H('-2%#$ $-T% F3 "0 #(+(2(&6 (#
$+% 8.($(#/& "0 M%(9%//%. -#9 "0 W.%F9B "0 .-9(7-2 3+%#"6%#"2"/1 -#9 "0
3&17+"-#-21&(&m -#9 $+% $+(.9 2"7-$%& $+% $+"F/+$ "0 #(+(2(&6 -& $+% (..%'%.S
&(H2% 9%&$.F7$("# H."F/+$ H1 $%7+#"2"/(7-2 9(&-&$%.B "#% &163$"6 "0 8+(7+
8"F29 H% $+% 0-(2F.% $" 9(&$(#/F(&+ H%$8%%# =(%$A&7+%-# -#9 M%(9%//%.(-#
#(+(2(&6>
C#(%@-1+(/, .)("<2(
W."6 $+% &6(2% "0 $+(& [("#1&F& &3.-#/ $+% L2163(-# /"9&B 0."6 +(& $%-.&
&3.-#/ +F6-# H%(#/&> Y# $+(& %V(&$%#7% -& - 9(&6%6H%.%9 /"9B [("#1&F&
3"&&%&&%& $+% 9F-2 #-$F.% "0 - 7.F%2B H-.H-.(A%9 9%6"# -#9 - 6(29B /%#$2%
.F2%.>
`=(%$A&7+%B )X?CB f"2> Y4 C<m )XNC4 C@a
*+(& 9%6"#(7 #(+(2(&6 $-T%& $+% 0".6B 8+(2% 2"&(#/ $+% %#%./1B "0 $+-$ -&3%7$
"0 [("#1&F& #-6%9 (# $+% $%#$+ &%7$("# "0 D'$ <*)#' "2 D)9?$.C -#9 7($%9 -$
$+% +%-9 "0 $+(& &%7$("#B (# $+% &%#$%#7%4 5Y# $+(& %V(&$%#7% -& - 9(&6%6H%.%9
/"9B [("#1&F& 3"&&%&&%& $+% 9F-2 #-$F.% "0 - 7.F%2B H-.H-.(A%9 9%6"# -#9 6(29B /%#$2% .F2%.;> *+(& 9F-2(&6 6-.T& F3 $+% 9(00(7F2$1 "0 $+(#T(#/ H"$+
[("#1&F& -#9 #(+(2(&6B 0". $+-$ $+(#T(#/ "'%.7"6%& .%&%#$6%#$ "#21 (0 +%29
-& - &%$ "0 7"F#$%.3"(&%9 0".7%&B 8($+(# - &(#/2% &$.F7$F.%> *+% 6"6%#$ $+-$
$+%&% 0".7%& H%7"6% %2%6%#$& 9%$-7+%9 0."6 %-7+ "$+%. -#9 -.% -22"8%9 $"
&%3-.-$% "00B $+%1 H%7"6% 2(-H2% $" 0%$(&+(&-$("# -& &(#/2% 6"6%#$&B #"
2"#/%. +%29 (# $%#&("# 8($+ - 7"F#$%. 0".7%> *+F& $+% &$.F7$F.% #-6%9
5[("#1&F&;B -#9 (#9%%9 $+-$ #-6%9 H1 =(%$A&7+% 5#(+(2(&6;B 7-# 7%-&% $" H%
$+"F/+$ 8($+(# - 91#-6(7 "0 H%7"6(#/ -#9 (#&$%-9 H%7"6% (66"H(2(&%94
$+%1 7-# H%7"6% 0".7%& "0 )$%%$&#*5$&# -#9 $+% 6"6%#$ "0 H%7"6(#/
/"%& 6(&&(#/B 2"&$ (# $.-#&6(&&("#> *+% 6(29#%&& "0 $+% .F2%. (& $+F& 6(29
"#21 (0 ($ -.(&%& "F$ "0 - &%20S.%2-$("# 3."9F7%9 0."6 6-&$%.(#/ 7.F%2$1
-#9 8(29#%&&> L#7% $+-$ .F2(#/ (& 9%$-7+%9 0."6 $+% 6"6%#$ "0 &%20S.F2(#/
-#9 &%20S6-&$%.1B ($ (& .%S-.$(7F2-$%9 -& - .%2-$("# H%$8%%# &%20 -#9 L$+%.B
8($+ -# (63"&($("# "0 8(22 #" 2"#/%. .%02%V('%21 -#9 3."9F7$('%21B 3."9F7(#/
- &%20B HF$B (#&$%-9B #%/-$('%21 -#9 (#+(H($(#/21B (63"&(#/ 7"#&$.-(#$&
"# "$+%.& -#9 2(6($(#/ $+% 3."'"7-$('% &%20S7+-22%#/(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+%;&
(6-/(#-$("#>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"9&&9 >".?$ C@
CD !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
*+% 9%0(-#$ *($-# P."6%$+%F& +-& -##"F#7%9 $" +(& L2163(-# $".6%#$".
$+-$ &"6% 9-1 $+% /.%-$%&$ 9-#/%. 8(22 6%#-7% +(& .F2%B F#2%&& q%F&
&+"F29 %#$%. (#$" -# -22(-#7% 8($+ +(6 (# $(6%> Y# Q%&7+12F& 8% .%7"/#(&%
+"8 $+% $%..(0(%9 q%F&B 0%-.0F2 "0 +(& %#9B -22(%& +(6&%20 8($+ $+% *($-#>
*+F& $+% 0".6%. -/% "0 $+% *($-#& (& "#7% 6".% .%7"'%.%9 0."6 *-.$-.F&
-#9 H."F/+$ $" 2(/+$>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?CB Y4 C@ m )XNC4 CDa
*+% L2163(-# /"9& (#-F/F.-$% $+%(. "8# 9%6(&% 8+%# $+%1 7%-&% $" 3%.0%7$
$+%6&%2'%& (# 7"63%$($("# 8($+ $+% "$+%. /."F3& (# $+%(. 9"6-(#4 $+%
7+$+"#(7 /"9&B $+% $($-#&B $+% /(-#$&B %'%# $+% +%."%&B -#9 (#&$%-9 -$$%63$
$" (63"&% - 2-8 "# $+%&% "$+%. /."F3&B (# $+% '-(# +"3% $+%.%H1 "0 .%9F7(#/
7+-#7% $" ".9%.B -& $+"F/+ $+-$ 2-8 6(/+$ $-T% $+% 32-7% "0 $+% $+."8 "0
7+-#7% 8($+ 8+(7+ -22 3."7%&&%& $-T% $+%(. (#7%3$("# -#9 6-(#$-(# $+%(.
6"6%#$F6> Q$ $+(& 6"6%#$ $+% +(%.-.7+(%& "0 &%20S%&$%%6 H%/(# $" H%
%&$-H2(&+%9 -#9 $+% $-&T "0 &%20S"'%.7"6(#/ /"%& 6(&&(#/> L#7% &%3-.-$%9
0."6 %-7+ "$+%.B $+%.% (& $+%# 6".% $" H% 0%-.%9 0."6 $+% 6(29B /%#$2% .F2%.
$+-# 0."6 $+% 7.F%2 -#9 H-.H-.(&%9 9%6"#> *-T%# &%3-.-$%21 $+%&% $8" H"$+
H%7"6% 0(/F.%& "0 )$%%$&#*5$&#m 8+(2% $-T%# $"/%$+%. $+%1 7-# /%#%.-$% 8(22 $"
3"8%.B &%20S"'%.7"6(#/B -#9 -# -00(.6-$("# "0 -# %$%.#-2 .%$F.# "0 $+% &-6%>
*+(& 9F32(7($1 .%9F32(7-$%& ($&%20 -$ %'%.1 2%'%24 [("#1&F& (& - 9"FH2% (6-/%m
[("#1&F& (& 9"FH2%9 -#9 .%9"FH2%9 H1 Q3"22" -& /"9 "0 (#9('(9F-$("# -#9
RF&$ H"F#9-.(%& -#9 $+%.%H1 -& .%'%-2(#/ $+% 7+-"&B 8($+(# $+% H"F#9& "0
8+(7+ &F7+ ".9%. (& 3.%7-.("F&21 (63"&%94
O+"%'%. F#9%.&$-#9& $+% (##%.6"&$ T%.#%2 "0 $+% P."6%$+%F& &$".1 h
#-6%21 $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 &-7.(2%/% (63"&%9 F3"# $+% $($-#(7-221 &$.('(#/
(#9('(9F-2 h 6F&$ -2&" (66%9(-$%21 0%%2 +"8 F#SQ3"22(#(-# $+(& 3%&S
&(6(&$(7 #"$("# (&> W". Q3"22" 8-#$& $" /.-#$ .%3"&% $" (#9('(9F-2 H%(#/&
3.%7(&%21 H1 9.-8(#/ H"F#9-.(%& H%$8%%# $+%6 -#9 H1 -/-(# -#9 -/-(#
7-22(#/ $+%&% $" 6(#9 -& $+% 6"&$ &-7.%9 2-8& "0 $+% 8".29B 8($+ +(&
9%6-#9& 0". &%20ST#"82%9/% -#9 6%-&F.%>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?CB Y4 CIm )XNC4 C<a
ZF$ $+%&% .%3%-$%9 9%6-#9& 0". &%20ST#"82%9/% -#9 6%-&F.% -.% .%_F(.%9
"#21 H%7-F&% &F7+ .%3"&% (& /.-&3%9 (# $+% $%%$+ "0 6".% 3"8%.0F2 0".7%& "0
9(&.F3$("#> *+F& $+"&% 8(22(#/ $" -77%3$ $+(& /.-#$(#/ "0 .%3"&% -.% &F..%#S
9%.(#/ $+%(. .%2-$("# $" $+% 0".7%& 8+(7+ 6(/+$ 3%.6($ -# -..('-2 "0
=(%$A&7+%-# #(+(2(&6> ^.-#$(#/ .%3"&% $" "$+%.& 9(&%63"8%.& H"$+ $+"&%
"$+%.& -#9 $+% 0(/F.% "0 Q3"22" ($&%20B 7F$$(#/ $+%6 H"$+ 2""&% 0."6 $+%
%#%./%$(7& "0 $+%&% 3"8%.& "0 9(&.F3$("# -#9 $+% 0".7%& "0 7+-#7%>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
=(%$A&7+% (#9(7-$%& $+(& 9-#/%. "0 $+% .F2% "0 $+% L2163(-# /"9&B H%7"6S
(#/ 'F2#%.-H2% $+."F/+ 2"&(#/ 7"##%7$("# $" $+% 7+$+"#(7 3"8%.& "0 $+%
*($-#&4
=(%$A&7+%;& "8# 7.($(7-2 %9/% (& 3F$ (# R%"3-.91 H1 $+% -$$%63$ (# $+%
(66%9(-$%21 3.%7%9(#/ 3-.-/.-3+ $" -2(/# - 3"&($('%B ".(/(#-2 &-7.(2%/%
8($+ 6%# -#9 8($+ Q.1-# &$.%#/$+B -#9 $" -2(/# - #%/-$('% ".(/(#-2 &(#
8($+ 8"6%# -#9 8($+ - ,%6($(7 $.-9($("# "0 )$%%$&#*5$&#> U'%# =(%$A&7+%B
-#9 &"B -22 $+% 6".% &"B %'%# =(%$A&7+%-#&B 7-##"$ +"3% $" +-'% 9%0(#($('%21
0.%%9 $+%6&%2'%& 0."6 $+% 8".T(#/& "0 )$%%$&#*5$&#B 0". $+% &%#&% "0 -#
F#3-(9 9%H$ (# H%(#/ H".# "&7(22-$%& (# '-2F% H-7T -#9 0".$+ H%$8%%# 0".6S
(#/ - &3F. $" -7$('($1 -#9 /%#%.-$(#/ - 7-F&% 0". )$%%$&#*5$&#> *+(& &32($$(#/
(#$" Q.1-# 6-&7F2(#% &-7.(2%/%B - 3.%S+%22%#(7 3-/-#(&6B -#9 0%6(#(#% &%6(S
$(7 &(# (& $+% &32($$(#/ "0 $+% 0%$(&+(&$B #"$ "0 $+% =(%$A&7+%-#4 0". ($ .(/(9(0(%&
.-$+%. $+-# 9(&32-1(#/ $+% 8".T(#/& "0 3"&($('% 0".7%&> *+%&% $8" 0".7%&
7"F29 H% 3."9F7$('%21 %#$8(#%9 -#9 6F$F-221 3."'"7-$('%B %'%# (# "#%
+F6-# H%(#/B .-$+%. $+-# 9(&$.(HF$%9 $" $8" 9(&$(#7$ /."F3& "0 +F6-#
H%(#/&B 6-2% -#9 0%6-2%B Q.1-# -#9 ,%6($(7B $+F& &%$ (# .(/(9 "33"&($("#B
&$-22(#/ -#1 $+"F/+$ "0 9%'%2"36%#$> *+% -77"F#$ "0 $(6% (632(7($ (# $+(&
&$.F7$F.% (& &(6(2-.21 F#S=(%$A&7+%-#B 0". $+%.% (& - +13"$+%&(& "0 -# ".(/(#-2
3F.($1 H%0".% $+% -9'%#$ "0 !+.(&$(-#($1 -#9 kF9-(&6> ,F7+ ".(/(#-2 3F.($1 (&
-& (#7"63-$(H2% 8($+ $+% $+"F/+$ "0 %$%.#-2 .%$F.# -& (& $+% $+"F/+$ $+-$ $+%
2-$%. (# $(6% -.% &"6%+"8 6".% (22F6(#-$%9 $+-# $+%(. 3.%7F.&".&> *+%
(#&(/+$ $+-$ =(%$A&7+%;& 6"&$ 9(&$(#7$('% $+"F/+$ 6F&$ 9%&$."1 $+% '-2F%&
"0 ($& H%-.%. (& "#% #"$ 0".%(/# $" =(%$A&7+%-# $+(#T(#/B #"8 9(&$(#/F(&+%9
0."6 =(%$A&7+%;& -7$F-2 $+"F/+$&B -#9 (& .%6-.T%9 H1 M%(9%//%. (# +(& .%-9S
(#/ "0 $+% (#%'($-H(2($1 "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 7"22-3&%> *+% 0".7%& -$ 8".T (6321 6%$%63&17+"&(&B - .%H(.$+B 8+(7+ (& #" .%&3%7$%. "0 (9%#$($1>
Y# D'$ <*)#' "2 D)9?$.C =(%$A&7+% -$$.(HF$%& - 9F-2 #-$F.% $" Q%&7+12F&;
P."6%$+%F&4 5," $+% 9F-2 #-$F.% "0 Q%&7+12F&; P."6%$+%F& +(& #-$F.% 8+(7+
(& -$ $+% &-6% $(6% [("#1&(-# -#9 Q3"22(#(-#B 6(/+$ H% %V3.%&&%9 $+F& (# 7"#7%3$F-2 0".6F2-4 5Q22 $+-$ %V(&$& (& RF&$ -#9 F#RF&$ -#9 %_F-221 RF&$(0(%9 (#
H"$+; `=(%$A&7+% )X?CB Y4 C)m )XNCB C<a> ZF$ &F7+ - 7"#7%3$F-2(&-$("# 6(&&%&
$+% 3"(#$ $+-$ $+% $+"F/+$ (& 3"&&(H2% "#21 -& - 7"#&%_F%#7% "0 - 32-1 "0
7"F#$%.3"(&%9 0".7%& +%29 (# 32-7% 8($+(# - 3."7%&& "0 &%20S"'%.7"6(#/>
QH"'% $+% &$.F//2% "0 9('(#($(%& -#9 6".-2& =(%$A&7+% 3%.+-3& &F.3.(&(#/21
%#$+."#%& 9('(#% #%7%&&($1B -& %$%.#-2 RF&$(7%4
*+% (66%-&F.-H2% &F00%.(#/ "0 $+% H"29 5(#9('(9F-2; "# $+% "#% +-#9 -#9
$+% 9('(#% 3.%9(7-6%#$ -#9 (#$(6-$("# "0 - $8(2(/+$ "0 $+% /"9& "# $+%
"$+%.B $+% 8-1 $+% 3"8%. "0 $+%&% $8" 8".29& "0 &F00%.(#/ 7"63%2& .%7"#7(2(-$("#B - 6%$-3+1&(7-2 F#("# h -22 $+(& .%7-22& (# $+% &$."#/%&$
3"&&(H2% 6-##%. $+% 7%#$.% -#9 6-(# -V("6 "0 $+% Q%&7+12%-# '(%8 "0
$+% 8".29 8+(7+ %#'(&-/%& E"(.- %#$+."#%9 -H"'% /"9& -#9 +F6-#
H%(#/& -& %$%.#-2 RF&$(7%>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?CB Y4 N?m )XNC4 CIa
M%.% $+%# (& -# (9%-2(&%9 0%6(#(#% 0".7%B H1 7"#$.-&$ $" $+% 9%&3(&%9 0%6S
(#(#% 0".7% "0 ".(/(#-2 &(#> E"(.-B 0-$% ". 9%&$(#1B (& $+% 2-8 "0 7+-#7% 8+(7+
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"9&&9 >".?$ CJ
-22 $+% 0".6& "0 2-8 -$$%63$ -#9 0-(2 $" &F3%.&%9%> *+% #"$("# "0 - 6%$-S
3+1&(7-2 F#("# /('%& $+% $+"F/+$ -8-14 ($ (& - $+"F/+$ "0 )$%%$&#*5$&#> Q
6".% $+"."F/+/"(#/ =(%$A&7+%-#(&6 8"F29 #%%9 $" $+(#T $+%&% $8" -&3%7$&
0". - $+(#T(#/ "0 0%6-2%#%&& $"/%$+%. -& &163$"6& "0 $+% =(%$A&7+%-# F#.%S
&"2'%9 .%&%#$6%#$ -/-(#&$ $+% 7+-#7% "0 H(.$+> *+% .%H(.$+ 7-# "#21 H% .%H(.$+ (#$" .%&&%#$(6%#$ (0 $+-$ 7+-#7% .%6-(#& - 7-F&% 0". .%&%#$6%#$>
Y# $+%(. -$$%63$ $" (63"&% - 2-8B $+% L2163(-# /"9&B ". (#9%%9 =(%$A&7+%
-#9 =(%$A&7+%-#&B .%'%-2 $+%(. "8# -9'-#7(#/ $8(2(/+$B $+%(. 9"8#0-22 .%&F2$S
(#/ 0."6 -# F#.%&"2'%9 .%&%#$6%#$ -$ -# (#-H(2($1 $" H.(9/% - /-3 H%$8%%#
$+%(. 3"8%.& -#9 $+%(. -6H($("#&> *+% (#'%#$%9 2-8 7-##"$ 7"63%$% 0".
%V+-F&$('%#%&& 8($+ $+% 2-8 "0 $+% 0-$%& 8+(7+ 3."3"&%& %$%.#-2 RF&$(7%>
=(%$A&7+% &-1& -& 6F7+4
*+% 3+(2"&"3+1 "0 8(29 -#9 #-T%9 #-$F.% H%+"29& 8($+ $+% 0.-#T F#9(&S
&%6H2(#/ /-A% "0 $.F$+ $+% 61$+& "0 $+% M"6%.(7 8".29 -& $+%1 9-#7%
3-&$4 $+%1 $F.# 3-2%B $+%1 $.%6H2% F#9%. $+% 3(%.7(#/ /2-#7% "0 $+% /"9S
9%&&S$(22 $+% 3"8%.0F2 0(&$ "0 $+% [("#1&(-# -.$(&$ 0".7%& $+%6 (#$" $+%
&%.'(7% "0 &"6% #%8 9%($1>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?CB Y4 C@m )XNC4 CDa
*+% 0-#$-&1 "0 $+% /"99%&& "0 9%&$(#1 (& $+F& $.-#&3"&%9 (#$" - 0-#$-&1 /"99%&&
"0 $.F$+B -#9 $+%# (#$" - 0-#$-&6-$(7 0%6-2% 3+(2"&"3+14 Z"%$+(F&; 3-2%
7"#&"2-$("#> *+(& $.-#&($("# 0."6 $+% /"99%&& "0 9%&$(#1 H%0".% 8+"6 -22
$.%6H2% $" $+% 7"60".$%. "0 &7+"2-.& (# $."FH2% (& (#9%%9 - 6"#&$."F& .%H(.$+>
*+% %."$(7& "0 $+% 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 &%6(#-. -.% .%'%-2%9 -& $+% +-33(21 3"&$S
3"#%9 F#("# "0 $+% 6-2% &%%T%. "0 8(&9"6 -#9 +(& 0%6(#(&%9 "HR%7$ "0 9%&(.%>
*+(& .%'%-2& $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 F#$+."#(#/ $+% 0-#$-&(&%9B 0%$(&+(&%9 0(/F.% "0
E"(.-> =(%$A&7+% (& %#9".&(#/ - 2-8 "0 0%6-2% %V72F&("# 8+(7+ 7-# #" 2"#/%.
H% 3%.6($$%9 $" 3-&& 8($+"F$ _F%&$("#> *+% /-3 H%$8%%# (#'%#$%9 2-8 -#9
8+-$ $+%.% (&B H%$8%%# - 2-8 "0 7F&$"6 -#9 -.$(0(7% -#9 $+% 2-8 "0 $+(& 8(29
#-T%9 #-$F.%B (& "#% 8+(7+ 0". =(%$A&7+% (& H"$+ $+% &3F. $" $+"F/+$ -#9 &"
"0$%# ($& F#9"(#/> *+(& /-3 "3%#& "F$ -& - /-3 H%$8%%# $+"F/+$ -#9 "F$7"6%>
Y# 0-(2(#/ $" 0(22 ($ (# -#9 $" &%7F.% - $.-#&($("# 0."6 $+"F/+$ $" -77"632(&+S
6%#$ $" 7"#$%#$6%#$B "0$%#B (#&$%-9 "0 /('(#/ $+-#T& 0". $+% &3F. $" .%#%8%9
%00".$B #%8 9-8#&B #%8 -7$('($1B $+%.% -.% $+% $8" "$+%. 3"&&(H2% 7"66"#
.%&3"#&%&B %'%# -6"#/&$ 8"F29 H% =(%$A&7+%-#&4 - 9%&3-(. -$ 0-(2F.% -#9 &%20S9%7%3$("# $+-$ $+%.% +-& H%%# &F77%&&> Q3"22" (& -2&" $+% 9.%-6S(#$%.S
3.%$%.B -#9 (& #" 2%&& $+% 9F32(7($"F& /"9 $+-# (& [("#1&F&> *+% (63"&($("# "0
".9%. -#9 +-.6"#1 (# $+% Q3"22(#(-# /%&$F.% "0 (#9('(9F-$("# (& - 9%7%($
8+"&% &$-$F& H%7"6%& 72%-.%. (# $+% 2(/+$ "0 $+% 0"22"8(#/4
$+% "#%B $.F21 .%-2 [("#1&F& -33%-.& (# - '-.(%$1 "0 0".6&B (# $+% 6-&T "0 0(/+$(#/ +%."B -#9 %#$-#/2%9 -& ($ 8%.% (# $+% #%$ "0 $+% (#9('(9F-2 8(22>
*+% /"9 8+" -33%-.& $-2T& -#9 -7$& &" -& $" .%&%6H2% -# %..(#/B &$.('(#/B
&F00%.(#/ (#9('(9F-2> *+-$ +% -33%-.& -$ -22 8($+ &F7+ %3(7 3.%7(&("# -#9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
CN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
8"9&&9 >".?$ CC
72-.($1 (& $+% 8".T "0 $+% 9.%-6S(#$%.3.%$%. Q3"22"B 8+" $+."F/+ +(&
&16H"2(7 -33%-.-#7% (#$%.3.%$& $" $+% 7+".F& ($& [("#1&(-# &$-$%>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?CB Y4 C<m )XNC4 C@a
Q#9 ($ (& $+(& +"3% -2"#% $+-$ 7-&$& - /2%-6 "0 R"1 F3"# $+% 0%-$F.%& "0 8".29 $".# -&F#9%. -#9 &+-$$%.%9 (#$" (#9('(9F-2&m $+(& (& &16H"2(A%9 (#
$+% 61$+ "0 [%6%$%.B &F#T (# %$%.#-2 &".."8B 8+" .%R"(7%& -/-(# 0". $+%
0(.&$ $(6% 8+%# $"29 $+-$ &+% 6-1 "#7% 6".% /('% H(.$+ $" [("#1&F&> `(H(9>a
L.B -& $+% "$+%.B &%VF-221 F#3.%RF9(7(-2 '%.&("# 8"F29 +-'% ($B &+% 6-1 "#7%
6".% /('% H(.$+ $" P%.&%3+"#%B 6(&$.%&& "0 9%&$(#1> =(%$A&7+% $+F& 7"#$."2&
-#9 7"#$-(#& -#1 .%&$($F$("# "0 3"&($('($1 $" 0%6-2% -#9 0%6(#(#% 0".7%&B $" 0%6-2% 2(#%B [%6%$%. -#9 P%.&%3+"#%B (#&(&$(#/ (#&$%-9 "# [%6%$%.;& .%2-S
$("# $" [("#1&F&B .%$F.#(#/ -/-(# -#9 -/-(#B $" $+% $8(# 6-&7F2(#($(%& "0
[("#1&F&B P."6%$+%F&B Q3"22"B -& 9.%-6 $%22%.& -#9 2-8 /('%.&4 P%.&%3+"#%
.%H".# -& [("#1&F&> Q# %#$+F&(-&6 0". =(%$A&7+% -$ $+% %#9 "0 $+(& 7%#$F.1
8+(7+ 0-(2& $" 3."H2%6-$(&% $+% %00".$ =(%$A&7+% 6-T%& $" 7"#$."2 -#9 7"#S
$-(# $+% $.-7%& "0 0%6-2% 3"8%. (# ^.%%T 61$+"2"/1 (& 7"632(7($ (# +(&
(#-H(2($1 $" -77%3$ $+% -.H($.-.1 7+-#7% "0 H(.$+>
*+(& 9F32(7($"F& =(%$A&7+% (& -$ 8".T (# $+% -6H(/F"F& %'-2F-$("# $" H%
-$$-7+%9 $" +(& 9(-/#"&(& "0 #(+(2(&64 $+% _F%&$("# (& 8+%$+%. +(& 9(-/#"&(& "0
#(+(2(&6 3%.6($& - .%H(.$+ "0 =(%$A&7+% -& "#7% -/-(# %63"8%.%9 $" H.(#/
-H"F$ 7F2$F.-2 $.-#&0".6-$("#B 3F&+(#/ $%#9%#7(%& -2.%-91 -$ 8".T $" - 3"(#$
"0 7.(&(& 0."6 8+(7+ ($ 6F&$ .%%6%./% .%#%8%9 -#9 &$.%#/$+%#%9m ". 8+%$+%.
($ %#$-(2& - .%H(.$+ -& - 6"#F6%#$-2 3-.-&($% "# $+% %#%./(%& "0 $.-#&0".6-S
$("#B H2"7T(#/ $+% 3."6(&%9 "3%#(#/ "0 0F$F.($1> Y &+-22 3F.&F% $+(& _F%&$("#
+%.% H1 &%$$(#/ F3 - &32($ (#+%.($-#7% "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $+%6%& H%$8%%# $+%
3&17+"-#-21&(& "0 W.%F9 -# $+% "#$"2"/(&(#/ "0 M%(9%//%.B 8+(7+ -.% 0F.$+%.
&32($ H%$8%%# $+% 9F32(7($(%& "0 Q3"22"B -& - &7+%6- "0 $+(#T(#/ $+% -6H(/FS
"F& (#+%.($-#7% "0 W.%F9(-# 3&17+"-#-21&(&B 3-.$ %/" H"F#9B 3-.$ 9.%-6
(#$%.3.%$%.m -#9 $+% 9F32(7($(%& "0 [("#1&F& -& - &7+%6- 0". $+(#T(#/ $+%
-6H(/F"F& (#+%.($-#7% "0 M%(9%//%.B 3-.$ =-A( &$""/%B 3-.$ (#'%#$". "0 $+%
0F$F.%> *+% 3."H2%6-$(7 7-# H% &T%$7+%9 "F$ (# $%.6& "0 - &+(0$ "0 .%/(&$%.
0."6 -# -#-21&(& "0 $.-#&($("# -#9 (#+%.($-#7%B (# -00(.6-$('% =(%$A&7+%-#
6"9%B $" $+-$ "0 $+% 3"2($(7& "0 .%&%#$6%#$ -$ 8".T (# $+% -#-21&(& "0 9%H$
-#9 $.-#&6(&&("#>
>)(<2#/, =/,$(<6)(-I 8(#2(::()#/, /='#6/"(,1(
U#$%.4 0". +%.% $"" $+% /"9& -.% 3.%&%#$
`Q.(&$"$2% B$ I9)#*+,% 9&*594*% )BJB NDJ - )Ca
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
*+(& Q3"22" +"29& "F$ $+% +"3% "0 - .%#%8%9 $.-#&($("# 0."6 - 9(&3%.&-2 "0
0".7%& $" .%0".6F2-$("# "0 - &%20S%63"8%.(#/ ".9%.4
C? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
*+% '(&("# "0 - &+('%.(#/ $+(#T%. "00%.& 2($$2% (#$%.%&$> Q$ $+(& 9(&-33"(#$S
(#/ &3%7$-72% %'%# $+% 7F.("F& 2"&% $+%(. 9%&(.% $" 7"6% -#1 72"&%.> O+-$
-.% $+%1 &F33"&%9 $" 9" +%.%i ,F7+ -# %'%.19-1 -#9 F#%V7($(#/ "77F.S
.%#7% h &"6%H"91 8+" (& 7+(22%9 8-.6(#/ +(6&%20 -$ - &$"'% h -#1"#% 7-#
0(#9 $+-$ -$ +"6%>
`M%(9%//%. )XNCB )?Nm )XX?B <CIa
E".% &(/#(0(7-#$21 M%(9%//%. -#9 W.%F9 &+-.% -# -6H('-2%#7% (# $+%(. .%7%3S
$("#& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $+"F/+$> M%(9%//%.;& -6H('-2%#7% (& &$.%$7+%9 "F$ -$
2%#/$+ (# +(& 2%7$F.%& "# =(%$A&7+% 0."6 )X@N $" )XDDB 8+%.% =(%$A&7+% (&
&%$ F3 -& H"$+ $+% 2-&$ 6%$-3+1&(7(-# -#9 -& $+% $+(#T%. 8+"&% $+"F/+$
9%0(%& M%(9%//%.;& -$$%63$& $" (63"&% - +(&$".1 "0 H%(#/ "# $+% +(&$".1 "0
3+(2"&"3+1> *+-$ "0 W.%F9 (& %V3.%&&%9 6".% /F-.9%921>
Y$ (& +"8%'%. $%22(#/21 .%'%-2%9 (# W.%F9;& 5L# $+% M(&$".1 "0 $+% P&17+"S
-#-21$(7-2 E"'%6%#$; `)X)Da4
Y# 2-$$%. 1%-.& Y +-'% 9%#(%9 61&%20 $+% '%.1 /.%-$ 32%-&F.% "0 .%-9(#/ $+%
8".T& "0 =(%$A&7+%B 8($+ $+% 9%2(H%.-$% "HR%7$ "0 #"$ H%(#/ +-63%.%9 (#
8".T(#/ "F$ $+% (63.%&&("#& .%7%('%9 (# 3&17+"-#-21&(& H1 -#1 &".$ "0
-#$(7(3-$".1 (9%-&>
`W.%F9 )XX@B C@a
W.%F9 6-T%& $+(& .%6-.T (# $+% 7"F.&% "0 .%-00(.6(#/ - 9%H$ $" Z.%F%. -#9 "0
-$$%63$(#/ $" 8.($% kF#/ "F$ "0 $+% +(&$".1 "0 3&17+"-#-21&(&> *+(& &F//%&$&
$+-$ $+% 9%H$ $" =(%$A&7+% 7-# H% %V3.%&&%9 H%7-F&% $+% %#%./1 "0 .%3.%&&("#
(& -22 9(.%7$%9 $"8-.9& 9%#1(#/ $+% 9(&-33"(#$6%#$ -.(&(#/ 0."6 $+% H.%-T
8($+ kF#/> Y$ (& -# "99 .%6-.T (# '-.("F& .%&3%7$& 0". 72%-.21 &F7+ - 3.%7-FS
$("# 6F&$ -28-1& 7"6% $"" 2-$%B 0". $+% 8.($(#/&B "#7% .%-9B 7-##"$ 0-(2B
%($+%. $" &F//%&$ ". 0-(2 $" &F//%&$ $+%6&%2'%& -& 6"9%2&m 7-##"$ 0-(2 $"
%6%./% ". 0-(2 $" %6%./% "F$ "0 $+% F#7"#&7("F& .%&"F.7%& (#$" 8+(7+ $+%1
+-'% 3.%&F6-H21 &F#T> *+(& 7"##%7$("# H%$8%%# 8".TB 9%H$ -#9 /.(%0B 2%-9&
(#$" $+% 3."H2%6-$(7& "0 6"F.#(#/ -#9 6%2-#7+"21m 8+%.%-& - 7"F#$%.S
3"&%9B 6".% =(%$A&7+%-#B &%.(%& 8"F29 .%-9 32-10F2#%&&B (#+%.($-#7%B 7+%%.S
0F2#%&&> *+(& W.%F9(-# 9(&-'"8-2 2%-9& $" - 9"6%&$(7-$("# "0 32-10F2#%&&B
-8-1 0."6 ($& 0F22 =(%$A&7+%-# 7"#&%_F%#7%& (# $+% 9(&6%6H%.6%#$ "0
[("#1&F&B - 9"6%&$(7-$%9 32%-&F.% 8+(7+ $+%# /('% .(&% $" -# %'%# 6".%
0%-.0F2 9%-$+ 9.('%> *+(& 8".T "0 9(&-'"8-2 (& 7"#R"(#%9 $" $+-$ "0 9%0%..%9
%00%7$4 8+-$ (& (# _F%&$("# +%.% (# .%2-$("# $" $+% 3."H2%6-$(7& "0 #(+(2(&6 (&
$+% $%63".-2($1 "0 $+% -2.%-91 $"" 2-$% -#9 $+% $%63".-2($1 "0 3"&$3"#%6%#$B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
*+(& (& - 3+.-&% 8+(7+ H"$+ W.%F9 -#9 M%(9%//%. 7($%4 W.%F9 (# +(& 5QF$"S
H("/.-3+(7-2 ,$F91;B (# K-$(#B $" -##"F#7% $+% 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 6-T(#/ &%#&% "0
3&17+(7 3-$+"2"/1 `W.%F9 )XX@B )XJam M%(9%//%. (# $+% 5K%$$%. "# MF6-#(&6;
`)XDNa> Y$ 7"6%& 0."6 $+% &$".1 $"29 H1 Q.(&$"$2%B (# B$ I9)#*+,% 9&*594*,5B
7"#7%.#(#/ M%.-72($F&; .%&3"#&% $" $+% 3FAA2%6%#$ "0 +(& '(&($".&> M%(9%//%.
.%6-.T&4
8"9&&9 >".?$ CX
O% 3%.7%('% $+-$ 8% +-'% #" .(/+$ $" #-6% $+% 6%#$-2 .%/("# $+-$ (&
0".%(/# $" $+% %/" 5$+% &1&$%6 "0 $+% [/%>;B &(#7% $+% 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7 "0 H%(#/
F#7"#&7("F& (& #"$ .%&$.(7$%9 $" ($> f%.1 8%22m 8% 8(22 #" 2"#/%. F&% $+%
$%.6 5F#7"#&7("F&; (# $+% &1&$%6-$(7 &%#&% -#9 8% 8(22 /('% 8+-$ 8%
+($+%.$" &" 9%&7.(H%9 - H%$$%. #-6% -#9 "#% #" 2"#/%. "3%# $" 6(&F#9%.S
&$-#9(#/> W"22"8(#/ - '%.H-2 F&-/% "0 =(%$A&7+%;& -#9 $-T(#/ F3 - &F//%&S
$("# H1 ^%"./% ^."99%7T `)X<@a 8% 8(22 (# 0F$F.% 7-22 ($ $+% 5(9;>
`W.%F9 )XCJB )IDa
Z1 7"#$.-&$B (# $+% )X<@ '%.&("# "0 $+(& -77"F#$B 5*+% U/" -#9 $+% Y9;B "#21
^."99%7T (& -7T#"82%9/%9 -& - 3.%7F.&".> Y# $+% '%.1 #%V$ 2%7$F.%B (# D'$
!$= -&#)".,/#")C L$/#,)$%B 5Q#V(%$1 -#9 Y#&$(#7$F-2 K(0%;B W.%F9 /('%& - &F6S
6-.1 "0 $+% .%&F2$& "0 +(& 3-3%.B 5*+% Y#&$(#7$& -#9 $+%(. f(7(&&($F9%&; `)X)JaB
(# 8+(7+ $+% 32%-&F.% 3.(#7(32% -#9 $+% 3.(#7(32% "0 -'"(9(#/ 9(&32%-&F.%
H%/(# $" 7"6% -3-.$B &F7+ $+-$ $+% 9%-$+ 9.('%& 6(/+$ %6%./% -& $+% &%3-S
.-$%B &%3-.-H2% 2-8& "0 3&17+(7 0F#7$("#(#/B 8+(7+ W.%F9 H"$+ -00(.6& -#9
9%#(%& (# 5Z%1"#9 $+% P2%-&F.% P.(#7(32%; `)X<<a> Y# +(& .%-9(#/ "0 $+(&B 5*"
,3%7F2-$% h "# W.%F9;B [%..(9- %2%/-#$21 &+"8& $+(& $%V$ 3%.0".6(#/ ($& "8#
+%&($-$("# `[%..(9- )XC?B <JChDIXa> [%..(9- 3"&($("#& $+(& 3%.0".6-#7% (#
.%2-$("# $" - _F%&$("# -H"F$ $+% &$-$F& "0 3+(2"&"3+1 $"9-1B 7"#$.-&$(#/ $+%
6"'%6%#$ "0 #"#S7"632%$("# (# W.%F9;& 8.($(#/& -& 9(&$(#7$ 0."6 $+% 0".%S
72"&(#/ 6"'%6%#$ "0 M%/%2(-# 9(-2%7$(7& -#9 "0 K-7-#(-# -00(.6-$("#& "0
M%/%2(-# 9(-2%7$(7&B 8+(7+ &%.'% $" (66"H(2(&% .-$+%. $+-# .%2%-&(#/ H"$+
W.%F9 -#9 $+(#T(#/ 6".% /%#%.-221> [%..(9- (#&(&$& "# W.%F9;& &%20S-'"8%9
-'"(9-#7% (# .%2-$("# $" - 7%.$-(# T(#9 "0 3+(2"&"3+1 -#9 &3%7(0(7-221 $" -#
-'"(9-#7% "0 =(%$A&7+%>
[%..(9- 7($%& $+% 3-&&-/% 0."6 $+% 5QF$"H("/.-3+(7-2 ,T%$7+;B 0(.&$ 3FHS
2(&+%9B (# U#/2(&+B (# )X<CB (# 8+(7+ W.%F9 .%6-.T&4
Y .%-9 ,7+"3%#+-F%. '%.1 2-$% (# 2(0%> =(%$A&7+%B -#"$+%. 3+(2"&"3+%.
8+"&% /F%&&%& -#9 (#$F($("#& 6"&$ "0$%# -/.%% (# $+% 6"&$ -&$"#(&+(#/
8-1 8($+ $+% 3-(#0F221 2-H".("F& 0(#9(#/& "0 3&17+"-#-21&(& 8-& 0". - 2"#/
$(6% -'"(9%9 H1 6% 3.%7(&%21 "# $+-$ '%.1 -77"F#$m Y 8-& 2%&& 7"#7%.#%9
8($+ $+% _F%&$("# "0 3.(".($1 $+-# 8($+ T%%3(#/ 61 6(#9 F#%6H-..-&&%9>
`W.%F9 )XX@B <DDa
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
$+% -0$%. %00%7$ "0 $+% W.%F9(-# !9/'#)9U?4*/';$*#B 8+(7+ Y &+-22 &%%T $" 7"##%7$
F3 $" $+% =(%$A&7+%-# 3."H2%6-$(7& "0 3"&$+F6"F& `&9/'?$+")$&a %V(&$%#7%
(# 8.($(#/> *+(& 3"&$+F6(7($1 3."'(9%& - 2(6($ 7-&% 0". $+% W.%F9(-# $%63".S
-2($1 "0 $+% -0$%. &+"7TB "0 9%0%..%9 -7$("#>
Y# 2%7$F.% $+(.$1S"#%B 5[(&&%7$("# "0 $+% P%.&"#-2($1;B "0 D'$ !$= -&#)".,/J
#")C L$/#,)$% `)X@@aB $+% .%2-$("# $" =(%$A&7+% -33%-.& (# 2%&& 7"#'"2F$%9
0".6> W.%F9 8.($%&4
*+(&B -& [%..(9- .%6-.T&B (& &%$ F3 (# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 $+% 9(&72-(6%.4 5U'%#
8+%# Y +-'% 6"'%9 -8-1 0."6 "H&%.'-$("#B Y +-'% 7-.%0F221 -'"(9%9 -#1
7"#$-7$ 8($+ 3+(2"&"3+1 3."3%.; `[%..(9- )XC?B <D@a> *+%.% (& - 9"FH2%
9F32(7($1 +%.%4 0". W.%F9 .%S%#-7$& =(%$A&7+%;& 9F32(7($1 H1 $+% 9%#(-2 "0
-#1 (#02F%#7% 0."6 =(%$A&7+%> *+% 9F32(7($1 (# $+% 8".T(#/& "0 $+% 32%-&F.%
3.(#7(32%B $+% .%-2($1 3.(#7(32% -#9 $+% 9%-$+ 9.('%& .%32(7-$%& $+% 9F32(7($(%&
"0 =(%$A&7+%;& [("#1&F&B 8+" (& H"$+ 2(0% -00(.6(#/ -#9 &%20S9%&$.F7$('%B -#9
.%32(7-$%& $+% 9F32(7($(%& "0 [("#1&F&; %.-&F.% "0 P%.&%3+"#%B $+% /"99%&& "0
9%&$(#1> *+% F#.-'%22(#/ "0 - &(#/2% 3.(#7(32% (#$" -# -00(.6-$("# "0 6F2$(S
32(7($1 "0 7"F#$%.3"(&%9 3.(#7(32%&B (# H"$+ -00(.6(#/ &F00%.(#/ -#9 (# - 8(22
$" -'"(9 &F00%.(#/B (& -$ 8".T (# $+% $.-#&($("# 0."6 - =(%$A&7+%-# -00(.6-$("#
"0 #(+(2(&6 -& 2(0% %#+-#7(#/ -#9 $+% .%-00(.6-$("# "0 $+(& =(%$A&7+%-#
-00(.6-$("# (# $+% 3.%&%#$ 7"#$%V$B 8+(7+ +-& H%7"6% 2(0% 9%#1(#/> *+%
$+"F/+$ 8"F29 H% $+-$ 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% 7-22& %7&$-$(7 #(+(2(&6 $-T%& "# 9(00%.%#$ '-2F%> =(%$A&7+% 6%#$("#& %7&$-$(7 #(+(2(&6 (# P*44 #" E"=$)4
Q 3%&&(6(&$(7 $%-7+(#/ -#9 8-1 "0 $%-7+(#/B -# %7&$-$(7 #(+(2(&6B 7-#
F#9%. 7%.$-(# 7"#9($("#& H% (#9(&3%#&-H2% 3.%7(&%21 $" $+% 3+(2"&"3+%. h
-& - 6(/+$1 3.%&&F.% -#9 +-66%. 8($+ 8+(7+ +% H.%-T& -#9 .%6"'%&
9%/%#%.-$% -#9 9%7-1(#/ .-7%& $" 6-T% 8-1 0". - #%8 ".9%. "0 2(0%B ". $"
(632-#$ (#$" $+-$ 8+(7+ (& 9%/%#%.-$% -#9 9%&(.% $" 9(% - 2"#/(#/ 0". $+%
%#9>
`=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)IJJa
U7&$-$(7 #(+(2(&6B $+%#B &$-#9& "F$ 0."6 $+% /%#%.-2 9%72(#% -#9 3"&($& $+%
$+"F/+$ "0 - .%/%#%.-$("#4 HF$ 8+-$ (0 $+%.% (& #" .%S%6%./%#7%i *+(& +"3%
$+-$ -# %7&$-$(7 #(+(2(&6 6(/+$ 8".T -& 3.(#7(32% "0 &%2%7$("# H%$8%%# $+-$
8+(7+ (& 9%7-1(#/ -#9 91(#/ -#9 $+-$ 8+(7+ (& 2(0% -00(.6(#/ -&&F6%& $+-$
9%/%#%.-$("# (& "#21 3-.$(-2> *+(& %7&$-$(7 #(+(2(&6 3.%&F33"&%& .-$+%. $+-#
8-/%.(#/ $+% 3"$%#$(-2 "0 &%20S-00(.6-$("#>
Y# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 - 8(9%&3.%-9 .%7%3$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 $+(& %7&$-$(7 #(+(2(&6
H%7"6%& 9%6"#(7 9%&$."1(#/ -22 2(0% -#9 $+"F/+$ (# ($& 9%&$.F7$("# "0 &F3S
3"&%9 9%/%#%.-$% -#9 9%7-1(#/ .-7%&4 0". $+(& (& $+% 8+"2% "0 +F6-#T(#9>
*+(& H%7"6%& $+% $+%&(& "0 W.%F9;& 5!('(2(&-$("# -#9 ($& [(&7"#$%#$&;
`)X@IaB $+% 3%.0".6-$('% 3-.-9"V%& "0 8+(7+ 8"F29 .%3-1 $+% &-6% 9%/.%%
"0 -$$%#$("# -& [%..(9- H.(#/& $" H%-. "# 5Z%1"#9 $+% P2%-&F.% P.(#7(32%;> *+%
9"7$.(#% "0 %$%.#-2 .%7F..%#7% (& $+%# $" H% 7"F#$%.3"(&%9 $" W.%F9;& 3.(#7(S
32% 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $(6% -& $+% 2-8 "0 $+% 3"&$+F6"F& %00%7$B "#% 8+(7+
8(22 8".T (# - 9(.%7$("# F#%V3%7$%9 H1 -#1 8"F29 H% (#&$(/-$".> U$%.#-2
.%7F..%#7% 3.%&F33"&%& ($& "8# 7"#$(#F-$("#B 8+(2% 7"#7%-2(#/ $+% 9%-$+
"0 ($& H%-.%.m 9%0%..%9 %00%7$& 3.%&F33"&%& $+-$ 9%-$+> W.%F9 H"$+ 0".6F2-$%&
$+% 9('(#% 2-8 "0 #%7%&&($1B $+% F#&F&$-(#-H(2($1 "0 32%-&F.%B -#9 $+%
%$%.#-2 .%7F..%#7% "0 ($& 9(&.F3$("# H1 $+% 9"FH2% $-T% "0 - 2"'% "0 9%&$(#1B
95") 29#*B 8+(7+ -00(.6& $+-$ F#&F&$-(#-H(2($1> *+(& =(%$A&7+% (#$."9F7%& -&
0"22"8&4
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
?I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
,F7+ -# %V3%.(6%#$-2 3+(2"&"3+1 -& Y 2('% -#$(7(3-$%& %V3%.(6%#$-221
%'%# $+% 3"&&(H(2($(%& "0 $+% 6"&$ 0F#9-6%#$-2 #(+(2(&6m HF$ $+(& 9"%&
#"$ 6%-# $+-$ ($ 6F&$ +-2$ -$ #%/-$("#B - ="B - 8(22 $" #%/-$("#> Y$ 8-#$&
.-$+%. $" 7."&& "'%. $" $+% "33"&($% "0 $+(& h $" - [("#1&(-# -00(.6-$("# "0
$+% 8".29 -& ($ (&B 8($+"F$ &FH$.-7$("#B %V7%3$("# ". &%2%7$("# h ($ 8-#$&
$+% %$%.#-2 7(.7F2-$("# h $+% &-6% $+(#/&B $+% &-6% 2"/(7 -#9 (22"/(7 "0
%#$-#/2%6%#$&> *+% +(/+%&$ &$-$% - 3+(2"&"3+%. 7-# -$$-(#4 $" &$-#9 (# [("#1&(-# .%2-$("#&+(3 $" %V(&$%#7% h 61 0".6F2- 0". $+(& (& 95") 29#*>
`=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)ID)a
*+(& (& 3%.+-3& $+% &$-#7% "0 W.%F9;& 5P&17+"-#-21&(&4 $%.6(#-H2% -#9 (#$%.S
6(#-H2%; (# 8+(7+ $+% 9%-$+ 9.('% (& 7"F#$%.3"(&%9 $" $+% 2(0% -00(.6-$("#& "0
-#-21&(& -& (#$%.6(#-H2%> =(%$A&7+%-# -00(.6-$("# (& 2%&& 0-. 0."6 W.%F9;&
%#/-/%6%#$& 8($+ %'%.19-1 /.(%0 -#9 &F00%.(#/ $+-# 0."6 $+% '-.("F& P2-S
$"#(7 &$.-$%/(%& "0 -'"(9-#7% -#9 9(&%#/-/%6%#$> =(%$A&7+% 2(T% W.%F9 3.('(S
2%/%& $%7+#(_F% "'%. #'$")*9B H1 7"#$.-&$ $" $+% ^.%%T 3.%0%.%#7% 0". #'$")*9
"'%. $%7+#(_F%>
Y# $+(& &%7$("# Y -6 (#$."9F7(#/ W.%F9;& -6H('-2%#7% (# .%2-$("# $"
=(%$A&7+% $" &F//%&$ $+-$ -# (#$%.#-2 &32($$(#/ "0 $+% 32%-&F.% 3.(#7(32% (#$"
$+% 32%-&F.% 3.(#7(32% -#9 $+% .%-2($1 3.(#7(32%B $+% 3.(#7(32% "0 -//.%&&("#
-#9 - 9%-$+ 9.('%B .%S%#-7$& $+% &32($$(#/ (#$%.#-2 $" =(%$A&7+%;& [("#1&(-#
3.(#7(32%> *+% /.%-$%. 9(00(7F2$1 "0 +"29(#/ $+% 9('%./%#$ &$.-#9& "0 $+%
W.%F9(-# 3.(#7(32% $"/%$+%. 2%-9& $" - 2"&& "0 7-3-7($1 0". 95") 29#*B -#9 2"&& "0 +"3%0F2#%&& 8($+ .%/-.9 $" $+% "F$7"6% "0 - 9%'-2F-$("# "0 -22 '-2F%&>
Q& - .%&F2$B 6%6".1 0". W.%F9 H%7"6%& -22 $+% 6".% (#%V$.(7-H21 7"##%7$%9
F3 8($+ 6"F.#(#/ 2"&$ %6"$("#-2 (#'%&$6%#$& .-$+%. $+-# 8($+ 7%2%H.-$(#/
$+% 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 9(&(#'%&$6%#$ -#9 .%(#'%&$6%#$B -#9 .-$+%. $+-# H%(#/
$.-#&0".6-H2% -& ($ (& 8($+ =(%$A&7+% (#$" $+% 0".6 "0 0"./%$$(#/
8+(7+ 3%.6($& .%(#'%#$("# -#9 -# -00(.6-$('% .%2-$("# $" $+% 0F$F.%> *+(&
$+%6% "0 - 9%'-2F-$("# "0 6%6".1B 0."6 -# -00(.6-$('% $" - 2(0%S9%#1(#/
g 29%.2(#B (# $+% 6F7+
'-2F%B 7-# -2.%-91 H% $.-7%9 -$ 8".T (# $+% 3"%$.1 "0 M"
.%-9 L9% $" E%6".1B 5E#%6"&1#%;B 8+(7+ h -& Y .%-9 ($ h 7%2%H.-$%&
$+"&% 8+" #%%9 #" 6"F.#(#/> M%(9%//%. $-T%& F3 $+(& $+%6%B (# $+%
"3%#(#/ 3-/%& "0 +(& P'9# /944% 2") #'",?'#SB -#9 +% 9%&7.(H%& 5E#%6"&1#%;
$+F&4
E#%6"&1#%B 9-F/+$%. "0 M%-'%# -#9 %-.$+B H.(9% "0 q%F&B (# #(#% #(/+$&
H%7"6%& $+% 6"$+%. "0 $+% #(#% 6F&%&> [.-6- -#9 6F&(7B 9-#7% -#9
3"%$.1 -.% "0 $+% 8"6H "0 E#%6"&1#%B "0 6%6".1> Y$ (& 32-(# $+-$ $+%
8".9 6%-#& &"6%$+(#/ "$+%. $+-# $+% 6%.%21 3&17+"2"/(7-221 9%6"#S
&$.-H2% -H(2($1 $" .%$-(# $+% 3-&$ (# .%3.%&%#$-$("#> E%6".1 $+(#T& 8+-$
+-& H%%# $+"F/+$> ZF$ $+% #-6% "0 $+% 6"$+%. "0 $+% 6F&%& 6%-#&
56%6".1; #"$ -& -# -.H($.-.1 $+(#T(#/ "0 -#1 $+"F/+$> E%6".1 (& $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"9&&9 >".?$ ?)
?< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
/-$+%.(#/ "0 $+(#T(#/ $" $+-$ 8+(7+ %'%.18+%.% 6(/+$ H% $+"F/+$ (#
-9'-#7%> E%6".1 (& $+% /-$+%.(#/ "0 9(.%7$%9 $+(#T(#/ `7&.$&;$&a>
`M%(9%//%. )XJDB Cm )XN?B ))a
g 29%.2(# &-1&4 5O% -.% -# F#(#$%.S
\#9%. $+% +%-9(#/B 5E#%6"&1#%;B M"
3.%$%9 &(/#;4 O%i O+"i O%B $+% +F6-# H%(#/& "0 $"9-1B $+% +F6-#
H%(#/& "0 - $"9-1 8+(7+ 0". - 2"#/ $(6%B -#9 &$(22 2"#/%.B 3.%&%.'%& 9F.-$("#B 0". 8+(7+ #" 7-27F2-$("# "0 $(6% 7-# %'%. H.(#/ - 6%-&F.%>
`M%(9%//%. )XJDB Cm )XN?B ))a
*+(& $+%# (& - /-$+%.(#/ "0 $+"F/+$B -# "'%.7"6(#/ "0 0"./%$$(#/B 0". 8+(7+
$+%.% (& #" $%63".-2 6%-&F.%B 8+(7+ (# %00%7$ $-T%& 32-7% (# &"6% $%63".-2
7"#$(#FF6 "$+%. $+-# - 7"#$(#FF6B &F&7%3$(H2% $" 6%-&F.%6%#$B .-$+%. -&
$+"F/+ -2"#/&(9% 7+."#"2"/1B -2"#/&(9% $+% &%_F%#$(-2 $(6% "0 7"#&7("F&
7-27F2-$("#B $+%.% 8%.% $" H% -#"$+%. F#(#$%#9%9 $(6% "0 &(6F2$-#%"F&
9(&3%.&("# -#9 /-$+%.(#/> *+(& &%$& F3 - 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# "# "#% &(9% $(6% "0 /%#%.-$("# -#9 9%7-1B (#'"T%9 H1 =(%$A&7+% (# +(& -#-21&(& "0 $+%
#%%9 0". 9%'-2F(#/ '-2F%& $" H% 3.%7(3($-$%9 (#$" $+%(. 0F22 9%72(#%B -#9 $(6% 8($+"F$ &F7+ (#$%.#-2 &%_F%#$(-2 &$.F7$F.%B 8+%.% $+%.% (& #" ".9%. "0
"#% -0$%. $+% "$+%.B $" H% 7"#&$.F7$%9 "F$ "0 -# -2$%.#-$("# "0 /%#%.-$("# -#9
9%7-1B -#9 8+%.% 9(&3%.&("# -#9 /-$+%.(#/ 6(/+$ H% &(6F2$-#%"F& ". (# .%2-$("# "0 9%&1#7+."#(&%9 &1#7"3-$("#>
*+% 6"9%2 0". &F7+ $+(#T(#/ 8"F29 H% $+% 9(&-//.%/-$("# "0 $(6% (# $+%
W.%F9(-# 6"9%2 "0 $+% %V3%.(%#7% "0 7"#&7("F&#%&& (#$" - 7"#&7("F& $(6%
-#9 - $(6% "0 $+% F#7"#&7("F&B 8+(7+ +-& #" &F7+ $%63".-2 ".9%.(#/> Z"$+
"0 $+%&% &$.F7$F.%&B "0 M%(9%//%.(-# $+(#T(#/ "0 (#7-27F2-H(2($1 -#9 "0 $+%
W.%F9(-# F#7"#&7("F& -33%-. $" 9%&$-H(2(&% $+% 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 $+% =(%$A&7+%-#
-00(.6-$("#B 8+(7+ +-& $" 3.%&F33"&% $+-$ $+% $(6% "0 [("#1&(-# 9(&6%6S
H%.6%#$ 7-# H% H."F/+$ 8($+(# - &(#/2% $(6% "0 7172(7-2 .%3%$($("#>) *+% T%1
$%.6 $+."F/+ 8+(7+ $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%-# #(+(2(&6 -#9 $+% -3".%S
$(7& "0 W.%F9(-# -#9 M%(9%//%.(-# $+(#T(#/ 7"6% -3-.$ (& $+%# .%3%$($("#B 0".
$+% =(%$A&7+%-# $%.6 3%.6($& - .%F#(0(7-$("# "0 $%63".-2($(%& (# %$%.#-2
.%7F..%#7% "0 $+% &-6%m 8+%.%-& $+% .%F#(0(7-$("# "0 $%63".-2($1 (& $+(#T-H2%
(# $+% W.%F9(-# -#9 M%(9%//%.(-# 6"9%2& "#21 (# $%.6& "0 $+% 6".$-2($1 "0
$+% (#9('(9F-2B 8+"&% 9%-$+ 9"%& #"$ &$-#9 "F$&(9% $(6%B -& F#6"F.#-H2%B
HF$ 8+(7+ H%7"6%& .-$+%. - &(/# "0 $+% (..%$.(%'-H2% 6"F.#0F2#%&& "0 +F6-#
%V(&$%#7%> L#21 =(%$A&7+%B Y &F//%&$B 8($+ +(& -77"F#$ "0 3"&$+F6"F& %V(&$S
g 29%.2(#(-# $+"F/+$ "0 $+% 9%-$+ 8+(7+ 9%0(%& 6"F.#S
%#7% 7-# -00(.6 $+% M"
(#/> *+% 7+-22%#/% "0 .%&3"#9(#/ $" =(%$A&7+%-# #(+(2(&6 (& $+F& &F&3%#9%9
H1 W.%F9 (# $+% 0".6 "0 +(& .%02%7$("#& (# 5!('(2(&-$("# -#9 ($& [(&7"#$%#$&;B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
E#%6"&1#%B 2(T% P."6%$+%F&B H%2"#/& $" $+% ".9%. "0 $+% $($-#&4 3.%S"216S
3(-# 3"8%.& -22(%9 8($+ $+% 7+$+"#(7 ".9%. "0 7172(7-2 /%#%.-$("# -#9 9%7-1>
M%(9%//%. 7"#$(#F%&4
8+(7+ 7-##"$ H% -& -00(.6-$('% -& =(%$A&7+%;& 8".T(#/ 8($+ #(+(2(&6m -#9 H1
M%(9%//%. (# +(& 9(-/#"&%& "0 - 7.(&(& "0 $%7+#"2"/1B 8+(7+ 9(&32-1& $+%
&(6(2-. 9%/.%% "0 3-&&('($1> *+% 9(00(7F2$1 $+%# 6-1 H% 3.%7(&%21 $+% &32($$(#/
"0 - .%&3"#&% $" =(%$A&7+% (#$" $+%&% $8" "33"&%9 .%/(&$%.&4 $+-$ "0 3&17+"S
-#-21&(& -#9 "0 3&17+(7 3-$+"2"/1B -#9 $+-$ "0 - 9(-/#"&(& "0 $+% 7F..%#$
7"#9($("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7&> Q# %&7-3% 0."6 $+% 7"632%$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 (# $+(&
9%6"#(7 0".6 6-1 .%_F(.% - T#($$(#/ H-7T $"/%$+%. "0 $+%&% 9('%./%#$
&$.-#9&B 9('%./%#$ .%&3"#&%& $" =(%$A&7+%;& (#'"7-$("# "0 $+% 6"#&$."F&
0".6& "0 [("#1&F&>
&D%()%+$<:+%
*+(& UF."3%B (# ($& .F(#"F& H2(#9#%&& 0".%'%. "# $+% 3"(#$ "0 7F$$(#/ ($&
"8# $+."-$B 2(%& $"9-1 (# - /.%-$ 3(#7%.&B &_F%%A%9 H%$8%%# GF&&(- "# "#%
&(9% -#9 Q6%.(7- "# $+% "$+%.> W."6 - 6%$-3+1&(7-2 3"(#$ "0 '(%8B GF&&(-#9 Q6%.(7- -.% $+% &-6%m $+% &-6% 9.%-.1 $%7+#"2"/(7-2 0.%#A1B $+% &-6%
F#.%&$.(7$%9 "./-#(A-$("# "0 $+% -'%.-/% 6-#>
`M%(9%//%. )XJXB @Ca
*+% 3FH2(&+%9 '%.&("# "0 P*44 #" E"=$) H%/(#& 8($+ $+% .%6-.T 5=(+(2(&6
&$-#9& -$ $+% 9"".4 8+%#7% 7"6%& $+(& F#7-##(%&$ "0 -22 /F%&$&i; `=(%$A&7+%
g #/%.B M%(9%//%. 7"66%#$&4
)XN?B l)a> Y# +(& )XJN 2%$$%. $" U.#&$ kF
o"F T#"8 $+-$ -# %&$(6-$("# "0 $+% &($F-$("# "0 +F6-# H%(#/& (# .%&3%7$
"0 $+% 6"'%6%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 8($+(# ($ 9%6-#9& -# -9%_F-$% 9%$%.S
6(#-$("# "0 %&&%#7%> ,F7+ T#"82%9/% (& 2-7T(#/ (# 6-#1 32-7%&> *+(& 2-7T
72"F9& $+% '(%8 (# %&$(6-$(#/ "F. &($F-$("#> Y$ 6-T%& $+% RF9/6%#$ "0
#(+(2(&6 &F3%.0(7(-2 -#9 $+% %1% H2(#9 $" $+% 3.%&%#7% 5"0 $+(& &$.-#/%&$ "0
-22 /F%&$&; `=(%$A&7+%B P*44 #" E"=$) *+% P2-# OO :f 3> )D)a> Y$ (& 7-22%9
$+% &$.-#/%&$ H%7-F&% -& $+% F#7"#9($("#-2 8(22 $" 8(22B ($ 8-#$& +"6%S
2%&&#%&& -& &F7+> *+%.%0".%B ($ 9"%& #"$ +%23 $" &+"8 ($ $+% 9"". H%7-F&% ($
+-& 2"#/ &(#7% -#9 (#'(&(H21 /"#% .(/+$ $+."F/+ $+% +"F&%+"29>
`M%(9%//%. )XNCB @?Nh@?Cm )XX?B <X<a
M%(9%//%.;& _F%&$("# 6(/+$ $+%# H% $+"F/+$ $" H%4 +"8 (& #(+(2(&6 $" H%
RF9/%9i M%(9%//%.;& 7"#$%#$("# (& $+-$ $+% %&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 (& $+% -00(.6-S
$("# "0 '-2F%B (# =(%$A&7+%;& 8.($(#/&B (# 8+(7+ $+% +(&$".1 "0 6%$-3+1&(7&
7F26(#-$%&> *+(& -00(.6-$("# "0 '-2F% 6-T%& 8-1 0". $+%".(%& "0 6-$$%.B "0
8+-$ $+%.% (&B -& 6-$+%6-$(7-2 0F#7$("#&B $.-7T(#/ $+% 6"'%6%#$& "0 %2%S
6%#$-.1 3-.$(72%&B 8($+ $+% 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 &2"/-#4 $" H% (& $" H% $+% '-2F% "0 '-.(-H2%> *+(& 0". M%(9%//%. %.-&%& $+% /('%##%&& "0 (#$%.3.%$-$("# -#9 $+(#TS
(#/ -& -# -7$('($1 3F.&F%9 ". #"$ 3F.&F%9B 7"#&7("F&21 ". F#7"#&7("F&21B
$+"F/+$0F221B ". F#$+"F/+$0F221B H1 +F6-# H%(#/&B $" 8+"6 (& /('%# $+%
9%$%.6(#-71 .%_F(.%9 0". $+(#T(#/B (#$%.3.%$-$("#B %'-2F-$("#>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"9&&9 >".?$ ?@
=(+(2(&6B $+%#B 0". M%(9%//%.B (& 7.%-$%9 H1 +F6-# H%(#/& $" 7"#$."2 -#9
%.-9(7-$% 8+-$ (& 9(&$(#7$('% -H"F$ +F6-# H%(#/&4 $+% -6H(/F"F& .%2-$("# $"
$(6% -#9 $+% "3%##%&& "0 "F. 9%&$(#(%&> Y$ H%7"6%& /%#%.-2B -#9 #"$ &3%7(0(7
$" $+% $-&T "0 %'-2F-$("#B -& ($ (& 0". =(%$A&7+%> Y# $+% 8".T(#/& "0 $%7+#(7-2
7"#$."2 "'%. $+% .%2-$("#& (# 8+(7+ +F6-# H%(#/& 0(#9 $+%6&%2'%&B $+%
+F6-# (& &FH".9(#-$%9 $" $+% 9%32"16%#$ "0 $%7+#(_F%& 8+(7+ -$ 0(.&$
8%.% 9%'%2"3%9 H1 +F6-# H%(#/& (# ".9%. $" %V32".% $+% 3"$%#$(-2 "0 $+%
+F6-#> *+% %#9 "0 $%7+#(_F%B $+% %V32".-$("# -#9 (#'%#$("# "0 +F6-#
7-3-7($1B $+F& H%7"6%& 9%$-7+%9 0."6 $+-$ %#9B -#9 8+-$ ($ (& $" H%
+F6-# (& 0(.&$ $-T%# 0". /.-#$%9B $+%# 0"./"$$%# -#9B -$ $+% 2(6($B 9%&$."1%9>
ZF$ $+(& (& - 0"./%$$(#/ 8+(7+ 9"%& #"$ 3%.6($ $+% 9%'%2"36%#$ "0 &3%7(0(7
7"632%V($1B -& 8($+ =(%$A&7+%B HF$ ($& 9(&-6H(/F-$("# (#$" - $+%".1 "0 7"6S
32%V($1B -#9 - &(#/2% $+%".%$(7-2 2"7-$("# 0". $+% +F6-#B -& $-T%# 0". /.-#$%9
-#9 %.-&%9> *+%&% .%2-$("#& "0 $%7+#(7-2 7"#$."2 (#7.%-&(#/21 3.%&%#$ +F6-#
H%(#/& 8($+ #" "3$("# "0 $-T(#/ F3 -# -H"9%B HF$ "#21 "0 2('(#/ "# - H".9%.S
2(#% H%$8%%# $+% +F6-# -#9 $+% $%7+#(7-2> *+% 9%&$(#1 "0 =(%$A&7+%-#
$+(#T(#/ -#9 $+-$ "0 M%(9%//%.(-# $+(#T(#/ H%7"6% (#9(&$(#/F(&+-H2% "#%
0."6 -#"$+%.4 $+%1 -.% -22 &(6321 %6-#-$("#& "0 - &(#/2% +F6-##%&&>
*+(& (63-7$ "0 $%7+#"2"/1 (& $+-$ 8+(7+ M%(9%//%. +"3%9 (# $+% )X@Jh@N
2%7$F.%& -&#)".,/#*"& #" 3$#9I'C%*/% 6(/+$ H% +%29 -$ -.6& 2%#/$+B &F&$-(#(#/ ^%.6-#1 5H%$8%%#; ,$-2(#(&$ %2%7$.(0(7-$("# -#9 Q6%.(7-# 7-3($-2(&6> *+(& (&
$+% 9(-/#"&(& "0 $+% %6%./%#7% "0 - &(#/2% &%$ "0 %2%7$."S$%7+#(7-2 .%2-$("#& -&
$+% 0(%29& "0 0".7% 8($+(# 8+(7+ +F6-# H%(#/B ($& 3"&&(H(2($(%& -#9 ($& 0F$F.%
-.% +%29> *+(& &+(0$ "0 .%/(&$%. 0."6 - 9(-/#"&(& "0 $+% 8".T(#/& "0 %'-2F-$("#
0". $+% 3F.3"&%& "0 $+% .%02%7$("#& "0 - 3.('-$% -22 $"" 3.('-$% &7+"2-. $" $+%
6-&& 9(-/#"&(& "0 M%(9%//%.(-# +($2%.(&6 .%#9%.& =(%$A&7+%-# #(+(2(&6 -22
$+% 6".% 9-#/%."F& -#9 -22 $+% 6".% (#-F9(H2%> *+% 3.(#7(32% 72-(6 +%.%
$+%# (& $+-$ =(%$A&7+%-# -#9 M%(9%//%.(-# #(+(2(&6& -.% F$$%.21 9(&$(#7$m $+-$
$+%(. (#$%.9%3%#9%#7% (& "#% "0 7"#02(7$ -#9 F#%-&% .-$+%. $+-# "0 7"63-$S
(H(2($1 -#9 7"+%&("# 8($+(# - &(#/2% -77"F#$ "0 - 9%&$(#1 "0 3+(2"&"3+1 -#9
"0 $+% +F6-#m -#9 $+-$ $+% 0-(2F.% $" $+(#T $+(& F#%-&% (& $+% 0-(2F.% "0
$+(#T(#/ "0 $+% 3.%&%#$ 9-1B (# 8+(7+ M%(9%//%. 9(-/#"&%& - 8($+9.-8-2
"0 $+(#T(#/> L#21 H1 9(&$(#/F(&+(#/ H%$8%%# $+% +F6-#B -22 $"" +F6-# "0
=(%$A&7+%-# $+(#T(#/ -#9 $+% 6"#&$."F& .%H(.$+ "0 #(+(2(&6 -& M($2%.(&6B H1
9(&$(#/F(&+(#/ H%$8%%# $+% (#$%22%7$F-2 &$.F//2%& "0 =(%$A&7+% -#9 $+"&% "0
M%(9%//%. 7-# -# %.-&F.% "0 -22 9(&$(#7$("#& (# - $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 -%&$+%$(7
"0 $+% 7"63F$%. '(.F& "0 -# (#&$-#$ 9%&$.F7$("# "0 $+"F/+$ H1 $+"F/+$ H%
+%29 -$ -.6;& 2%#/$+>
*+% %-&% 8($+ 8+(7+ M%(9%//%.(-# -33."3.(-$("# %.-&%& $+% 9(&$(#7$('%#%&&
"0 =(%$A&7+%;& $+(#T(#/ &F//%&$& $+-$ $+% &"F.7% 0". .%&7F% (& #"$ $" H% 0"F#9
(# M%(9%//%.;& .%-9(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+% HF$ 3%.+-3& .-$+%. (# $+% W.%F9(-#
.%0F&-2 $" .%-9> M%(9%//%.(-# 0"./%$$(#/ (& 6-.T%9 H1 $+% 8(22 -22 $+% &-6%
$" 2%-'% - 6-.T "# -22 3.%'("F& $+(#T(#/B 8+(2% $+% W.%F9(-# $+"F/+$ "0
$%7+#(_F% (& #"$ - $+"F/+$ "0 $+(#T(#/ -$ -22> Y$ (& #%($+%. - M%(9%//%.(-#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
?D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
.%$.(%'-2 #". - P2-$"#(7 .%7"22%7$("# .%&$".(#/ - 2"&$ 7"#$(#F($1 HF$ - H.%-7+S
(#/ -#9 H."-7+(#/ "0 3-$$%.#&B 8+(7+ 6-T% (##"'-$("#B H"$+ "0 $+% 3-&$ -#9
"0 $+% 0F$F.%B $+(#T-H2%> Y$ (& $+%# 3%.+-3& $+% W.%F9(-# &$.-$%/1 "0 -'"(9(#/
=(%$A&7+% 8+(7+ 3%.6($& - .%-7$('-$("# "0 $+% =(%$A&7+%-# $+"F/+$B .%&7F(#/
($ 0."6 $+% (66"H(2(&-$("#& "0 )$%%$&#*5$&# -#9 .%7%3$("#B 6".% .%-9(21 $+-#
$+% M%(9%//%.(-# -$$%63$ $" $+(#T H%1"#9 =(%$A&7+%> *+% &$.-$%/1 "0
-'"(9-#7% 3%.6($& $+% $+(#T(#/ "0 =(%$A&7+% -22 $+% &-6% $" 3%.6%-$%
-#9 8".T 3."9F7$('%21 -/-(#&$ $+% /.-(# "0 W.%F9;& "8# %V3.%&&%9 $+"F/+$>
*+% M%(9%//%.(-# &$.-$%/1 "0 7"#0."#$-$("#B $+% -$$%63$ $" .%9F7% -22
$+(#T(#/ $" $+% &(#/2% /.(9 "0 $+% +(&$".1 "0 H%(#/B 2%-9& $" - 6F$F-2 -&&F.%9
9%&$.F7$("# "0 $+% $+(#T(#/ "0 H"$+ =(%$A&7+% -#9 M%(9%//%.B -#9 (#9%%9 "0
$+(#T(#/ -$ -22>
C$%() W". 6".% "# $+(& M%(9%//%.(-# $+(#T(#/ "0 $(6%B &%% k"-##- M"9/%B 5M%(9%//%.(-#
*%63".-2($(%&4 ^%#%&(& -#9 ,$.F7$F.% "0 - *+(#T(#/ "0 E-#1 [(6%#&("#-2 *(6%;B (#
1$%$9)/' *& E'$&"5$&"4"?CB '"2F6% ::Y:B 0".$+7"6(#/B <III
0(D()(,1([%..(9-B k> `)XC?a 5*" ,3%7F2-$% h "# W.%F9; (# D'$ E"%# (9). 2)"5 A"/)9#$% #" :)$,. 9&.
<$C"&. $.-#&> Q> Z-&&B !+(7-/"4 \#('%.&($1 "0 !+(7-/" P.%&&>
W.%F9B ,> `)XCJa !$= -&#)".,/#")C L$/#,)$% P%#/F(# W.%F9 K(H.-.1 f"2> YY> M-.6"#9&S
8".$+4 P%#/F(#>
pp `)X?Da 5Z%1"#9 $+% P2%-&F.% P.(#7(32%; (# Q& 3$#9I%C/'"4"?C P%#/F(# W.%F9
K(H.-.1 f"2> :Y> M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#>
pp `)X?Ja 5!('(2(A-$("# -#9 Y$& [(&7"#$%#$&; (# (*F*4*@9#*"&R A"/*$#C 9&. 1$4*?*"& P%#S
/F(# W.%F9 K(H.-.1 f"2> :YY> M-.6"#98".$+4 P%#/F(#>
pp `)XX@a >*%#")*/94 9&. 6HI"%*#")C P");% "& E%C/'"9&94C%*% P%#/F(# W.%F9 K(H.-.1
f"2> )J> M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#>
M%(9%//%.B E> `)XJXa -&#)".,/#*"& #" 3$#9I'C%*/% $.-#&> G> E-#+%(6> =%8 M-'%#4 o-2%
\#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
g H(#/%#4 E-V =(%6%1% `)XN?a P'9# *% /944$. D'*&;J
pp `)XJDa P9% >$*n# B$&;$&SB *F
*&?SB $.-#&> k> ^2%## ^.-1B =%8 o".T4 M-.3%. -#9 G"8>
g H%. 9%# MF6-#(&6F&; (# P$?59);$& W.-#T0F.$
pp `)XNCa 5qF. ,%(#&0.-/%; -#9 5Z.(%0 F
-6 E-(#4 b2"&$%.6-## `)XX?a 5*+% tF%&$("# "0 Z%(#/; -#9 5K%$$%. "# MF6-#(&6; (#
E9#'59);% $.-#&> O> E7#%(22B !-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)XNCa 5*+% Z(.$+ "0 *.-/%91; -#9 5*+% !-&% "0 O-/#%.; %9> O> b-F06-##B =%8
o".T4 f(#$-/%>
pp `)XN?a P*44 #" E"=$) $.-#&> -#9 %9> O> b-F06-##B =%8 o".T4 f(#$-/%>
g 9(%; (# !*$#@%/'$0 G)*#*%/'$ A#,.*$&9,%?9+$B f"2> YB
=(%$A&7+% `)X?Ca 5[(% ^%HF.$ 9%. *.-/"
%9& !"22( -#9 E"#$(#-.(> EF#(7+]Z%.2(#4 9$'] 9% ^.F1$%.>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"9&&9 >".?$ ?J
J
A,'9*4 394*;
E
W". M%(9%//%.B 6"9%.#($1 (& 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 H1 $+% 7"63.%+%#&("# "0 2(0% (#
#(+(2(&6> *+(& (&B 6".%"'%.B +F6-# [-&%(#;& 6%$-3+1&(7-2 7F26(#-$("#> Q&
&F7+B ($ (& $+% %#9 "0 - +(&$".1 (#-F/F.-$%9 =*#' $+% Q#7(%#$& `(0 #"$ +C
$+%6a -#9 8+"&% 5%V$.%6% 3"(#$;B -& 8% 8(22 &%% M%(9%//%. 7-22(#/ ($B (&
.%-7+%9 8($+ =(%$A&7+%> =(+(2(&6 (& $+F& -# %V$.%6($1 0". +F6-# [-&%(#
-#9 0". $+% 7"63.%+%#&("# "0 2(0% (# /%#%.-2> Y$ (& $+% %V$.%6($1 "0 6%$-S
3+1&(7&>
M"8%'%.B &(6321 -&&F6(#/ 5$+% %#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7&; "# $+(& H-&(&B -& (& #"8
7"66"# %#"F/+B "H&7F.%& 8+-$ &%#&% &F7+ - 9%$%.6(#-$("# +-& 0". M%(9%/S
/%. `-& $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 7F26(#-$("# "0 #(+(2(&6a> Q#9 &F7+ -#
-&&F63$("# -2&" 3.%S%63$& -#1 +%&($-$("# -& $" ='$#'$) ($ &F00(7%& $" 7+-.S
-7$%.(&% 6"9%.#($1 H1 #(+(2(&6> O($+"F$ - 72%-.%. F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6
-& ($ (& 3."3"&%9 H1 M%(9%//%.B $+% &%#&% -#9 +(&$".1 "0 6"9%.#($1 .%6-(# -$
H%&$ /"&F$&#*"&94B -& 9"%& $+% 3+(2"&"3+(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 `&%20Sa 7"63.%+%#S
&("# "0 5$+% %#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7&;> *+% F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 &F7+ -# 5%#9; (&
7.F7(-2 0". $+% 7"#$%63".-.1 7"#$%V$ -#9 .%7%3$("# "0 M%(9%//%.;& 8".T
-#9 2(0% $""> W". 8+-$ (& (#'"2'%9 (# M%(9%//%.;& %V$%#9%9 7"#&(9%.-$("#&
"0 #(+(2(&6 (& - 3+(2"&"3+(7-2S+(&$".(7-2 .%2-$("# -#9 $+(#T(#/ "0 =-A(&6B .%02%7$("# $+-$ (& -.$(7F2-$%9 $+."F/+ $+% (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 !*$#@%/'$> *+%
.%-&"# (& 3-.$21 &$.-$%/(74 -& (& 8%22 T#"8#B $+% -9"3$("# "0 =(%$A&7+% -& 3.%7F.&". "0 =-A( (9%"2"/(%& 8-& "77-&("#%9 6-(#21 $+."F/+ Q20.%9 Z-%F6S
2%.;& %&3"F&-2 "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 3+(2"&"3+%6% "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%. -& $+% %V-2$-S
$("# -#9 &$.%#/$+%#(#/ "0 2(0% $+."F/+ H("2"/(7-2S.-7(-2 3F.(0(7-$("#B -#9 $+%
7"#7"6($-#$ &F3%.(".($1 "0 &F7+ - #-$("#-2S.-7(-2 2(0%>) *+% (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0
=(%$A&7+% (& - 8-1 0". M%(9%//%. $" 9.-8 "F$ $+% &%#&% "0 H"$+ #(+(2(&6 -& #'$
+(&$".1 -#9 6%$-3+1&(7& "0 $+% O%&$ -#9B 7"#7"6($-#$21B $+% 8(9%. +(&$".S
(7-2S3+(2"&"3+(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 =-A(&6B &3%7(0(7-221 8($+ .%/-.9 $" $+%
9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 2(0%> Y# -99($("#B ($ -22"8& M%(9%//%.;& "8# 6"'%& 8($+
.%&3%7$ $" =-A(&6 $" H% %2F7(9-$%9><
?N
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
=(+(2(&6 -#9 K(0%4 !"&6"H("2"/1 -#9
L#$"3"(%&(& (# M%(9%//%.;& !*$#@%/'$
*+% 3.%&%#$ 9(&7F&&("# 8(22 H% 3.(6-.(21 7"#7%.#%9 8($+ M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.S
3.%$-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 7"63.%+%#&("# "0 2(0%> *+(& (& #"$ -$ -22 $" 9%#(/.-$%
$+% (63".$-#7% "0 $+% 7"#$%V$& -#9 +(&$".(%& RF&$ 6%#$("#%9> L# $+% 7"#S
$.-.1B $+% 6".% %V$%#&('% (632(7-$("#& -#9 7"#/.F%#7%& -.% 9%'%2"3%9 +%.%
(# ".9%. $" -.$(7F2-$% 8+-$ (& #".9C - 6-R". 3+(2"&"3+(7-2B $%7+#"&7(%#$(0(7
-#9B (# $+% 2(6($%9 &%#&%B 3"2($(7-2 (&&F% 8($+ $+"&% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2
7"#7%.#&> *+% (&&F% +%.% (& 2(0% -& &F7+> *+% 0"22"8(#/ %V3"&($("# H.(#/& $+%
=-A( 3."/.-66% "0 .-7(-2 H.%%9(#/ (#$" 0"7F& -& - 3.(6-.1 7"#7%.# 0".
7"#$%63".-.1 9%$%.6(#-$("#& "0 2(0% 9&. 0". +(&$".(7-2S3+(2"&"3+(7-2 .%02%7S
$("# "# $+%6>
EE
*+% -33-.%#$21 7"#7%3$F-221 `(0 #"$ +(&$".(7-221a $+(# 7"..%2-$("# H%$8%%#
#(+(2(&6 -#9 2(0% 7-# H% 72-.(0(%9 H1 $F.#(#/ $" $+% )XDI .%$."&3%7$('% "# $+%
0"F. 6-R". 2%7$F.% 7"F.&%& "# =(%$A&7+%> *+%&% 2%7$F.%& 8%.% $+%6&%2'%&
7"#$%63".-#%"F& 8($+ $+% =-A(0(7-$("# "0 0".6-2 (#&$($F$("#-2 3"8%. (#
$+% )X@I& `$+%1 H%/(# $8" 1%-.& -0$%. M%(9%//%.;& -H".$%9 .%7$".&+(3 "0 $+%
\#('%.&($1 "0 W.%(HF./ "0 )X@@h@Da> *+% .%$."&3%7$('% 0."6 )XDI (& "#% "0 &%.(%& "0 6"&$21 F#9%2('%.%9 $.%-$(&%& (# 8+(7+ M%(9%//%. 7"#$(#F%& $"
9%'%2"3 $+% .%02%7$("#& "# =(%$A&7+% -#9 6%$-3+1&(7& F#$(2 $+% 6(9S)XDI&B
.%'(&(#/ $+%6 0". 3FH2(7-$("# (# )XN)> Y# ($B M%(9%//%. 9(&$(#/F(&+%&
=(%$A&7+%;& 7"#7%3$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 0."6 %'%.1 59"7$.(#-2 $%#%$ h %&3%7(-221
r0."6s 8+-$ - &F3%.0(7(-2 F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 $+% $%.6 8"F29 2%-9 F& $" (6-S
/(#%B #-6%21B $+% 9(&&"2F$("# `7,24"U%,&?a "0 %'%.1$+(#/ (#$" &+%%. #"$+(#/S
#%&&; `M%(9%//%. )XN)HB <CJm )XX)-B <I<h@a>@ *-T(#/ (#&$%-9 $+% &$-$%6%#$
H1 =(%$A&7+% 0."6 ,3.(#/hW-22 )??C `7"63(2%9 -& l< "0 D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)a -&
$+% H-&(7 3.%6(&% "0 $+% (#$%.3.%$-$("#B M%(9%//%. .%6-.T& $+-$ 0". =(%$A&7+%
#(+(2(&6 (& #"$ - $"$-2 -#9 #%/-$(#/ 59(&&"2F$("#; HF$ .-$+%. 5$+% 3."7%&&
`X")?9&?a "0 $+% 9%'-2F-$("# "0 $+% 3.%'("F&21 +(/+%&$ '-2F%&; `M%(9%//%.
)XN)HB <CJm )XX)-B <I@a> Q& - 53."7%&&;B #(+(2(&6 9"%& #"$ $+%# 6%-# 7"22-3&% "0 944 '-2F%& 9# "&/$> Y$ (& (#&$%-9 - +(&$".14 $+% +(&$".1 "0 O%&$%.#
6%$-3+1&(7& -#9B 7"#7"6($-#$21B O%&$%.# +(&$".1 (& - +(&$".1 "0 9%'-2F-$("#
"0 '-2F%&>
*+"F/+ M%(9%//%. &3%7(0(%& 6"6%#$& (# $+(& +(&$".(7"S3+(2"&"3+(7-2 3."S
7%&& "0 9%'-2F-$("# (# $+% &F77%&&('% #-6%& "0 $+% &F3%.&%#&(H2% 5$.F% H%(#/; h
5^"9 -& $+% !+.(&$(-# !.%-$". -#9 G%9%%6%.B $+% &F3%.&%#&(H(2($1 "0 $+%
6".-2 2-8B $+% -F$+".($1 "0 .%-&"#B 3."/.%&&B $+% +-33(#%&& "0 $+% 6-R".($1;
`M%(9%//%. )XN)HB <C@m )XX)-B <I@aB -#9 &" "# hB $+% 6".% /%#%.-2 -#9
9%7(&('% 3"(#$ 0."6 =(%$A&7+%;& 7"#7%3$("# (& $+% 0"22"8(#/4
$+% 3."7%&& "0 9%'-2F-$("# "0 $+% +($+%.$" +(/+%&$ '-2F%& (& $+F& #"$
"#% +(&$".(7-2 "77F..%#7% `?$%/'*/'#4*/'$ <$?$+$&'$*#a -6"#/&$ 6-#1
"$+%.& HF$ .-$+%. $+% r+(&$".(7-2s /."F#9 "77F..%#7% `O),&.?$%/'$'$&a "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
A,'9*4 394*; ?C
?? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Y# &F6B #(+(2(&6 (& 0". M%(9%//%. $+% /."F#9(#/ +(&$".(7-2 "77F..%#7% "0
"77(9%#$-2 6%$-3+1&(7& -#9 ($& +(&$".1> =(+(2(&6 (& "77(9%#$-2 +(&$".*/*#C>
E".%"'%.B #(+(2(&6 (& -# "#$"$+%"2"/1 (# $+-$ ($ (& - +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2
9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 H%(#/& -& &F7+ `"#$"2"/1a -#9 -& - 8+"2% `$+%"2"/1a>
*+"F/+ $+%&% 8".29S+(&$".(7-2 7"#7%.#& &%%6 $" H% -$ &"6% 9(&$-#7% 0."6
$+% -7$F-2($1 -#9 7"#9($("#& "0 2(0%B #(+(2(&6 -#9 2(0% -.% (# 0-7$ &1#"#16"F&
(# M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%> *+%(. (#+%.%#$ 7"##%7$("# (&
3.%&%#$%9 (# M%(9%//%.;& (#($(-2 (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 %V7%.3$& 7"22%7$%9 F#9%.
$+% +%-9(#/ 5P.(#7(32%& "0 - =%8 f-2F-$("#; (# D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)B (# $+% $+(.9
2%7$F.% 7"F.&% "# =(%$A&7+%B $($2%9 5*+% O(22 $" P"8%. Q& !"/#($("# `6);$&&#J
&*%a;B 8+(7+ 8-& 9%2('%.%9 (# $+% ,F66%. &%6%&$%. "0 )X@X> *+% 7"66"#
-.$(7F2-$("# "0 $+% 8".29S+(&$".(7-2 "77F..%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 $+% -7$F-2($1
"0 2(0% (& F94,$> W". M%(9%//%.B $+% 7"#9($("# ". %&&%#7% "0 $+% 5(#$%..%2-$("#;
"0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 2(0% (# '-2F% (& =(%$A&7+%;& _F-&(S7"#7%3$ "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.>
M"8%'%.B (# ".9%. $" 3-.$(-221 9%$-7+ $+% 3.%&%#$ -./F6%#$ 0."6 $+"&%
7"#7%.#%9 8($+ $+% '-2(9($1 -#9 &$-$F& "0 $+(& 2-$$%. 3+(2"&"3+%6% (#
=(%$A&7+%;& 8".T -#9 M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 ($B $+%&% (&&F%& 8(22 #"$
H% %2-H".-$%9 +%.% (# $%.6& "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.>D *+(& 9%$-7+6%#$ (& 6-9% (#
'(%8 "0 (63".$-#$ &$.-$%/(7 -#9 7.($(7-2 7"#&(9%.-$("#&4 ($ (& $" -22"8 $+%
8(9%. -#9 2%&& 3+(2"&"3+(7-221 9%$%.6(#%9 7"#7%.# F#9%. 7"#&(9%.-$("#
+%.% $" H% %V32(7$21 %V-6(#%9B #-6%21B $+% -7$F-2($1 -#9 "#$"/%#%&(& "0
2(0%> E".%"'%.B &(#7% $+% 3.(#7(3-2 (#$%.%&$& -.%B 0(.&$21B $+% 3.%'-2%#$ &%#&%
-#9 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% 5%#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7&; -& M%(9%//%. +-& 3%.+-3&
-H"'% -22 9%'%2"3%9 ($B -#9B &%7"#921B 8+%$+%. - #"#S6%$-3+1&(7-2 7"63.%S
+%#&("# "0 2(0% $+%# 0"22"8&B $+% 3"(#$ -$ (&&F% +%.% (& #"$ =(%$A&7+%;& "8#
-.$(7F2-$("#& "0 2(0% -#9 #(+(2(&6 HF$ "#21 M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 ($>
*+-$ (&B $+% -77F.-71 ". $%#9%#$("F&#%&& "0 M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0
=(%$A&7+%;& 8.($(#/& ". $+(#T(#/ (& "0 #" 9(.%7$ .%2%'-#7% $" $+% 3.%&%#$
9(&7F&&("#>
EEE
M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# $+-$ 4*2$ (# =(%$A&7+% (& 9%$%.6(#%9 H1 '-2F% +-&
$8" (#($(-2 3"(#$&> W(.&$21B $+-$ 5'-2F% 0". =(%$A&7+% 6%-#& - 7"#9($("# "0 2(0%B
- 7"#9($("# "0 2(0% $" H% 55-2('%;; ; `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B D??m )XX)-B )Ja> ,%7"#921B
+"8%'%.B $+-$ 5=(%$A&7+% 9"%& #"$ &%% $+% %&&%#7% "0 2(0% (# 55&%20S3.%S
&%.'-$("#;; `55&$.F//2% 0". %V(&$%#7%;;a -& 9" $+% H("2"/1 -#9 9"7$.(#% "0 2(0%
"0 +(& $(6%B 9%$%.6(#%9 -& ($ (& H1 [-.8(#B HF$ &%%& ($ .-$+%. (# .-(&(#/
`A#$*?$),&? r5(#$%#&(0(7-$("#;B 572(6H(#/;sa "'%. -H"'% ($&%20; `(H(9>a>J M%(9%//%.
$+%# (66%9(-$%21 #"$%& +"8 3.%&%.'-$("# -#9 5.-(&(#/; -.% HF$ $8" 9%I$/#% "0
- 7"+%.%#$ `-F$"Sa 7"63.%+%#&("# "0 2(0%4
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
6%$-3+1&(7-221 H".#% -#9 /F(9%9 "77(9%#$-2 +(&$".1 `O$%/'*/'#$a>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)HB <CJm )XX)B <I@a
A,'9*4 394*; ?X
Y$ (& $+(& &%20S&F.3-&&(#/ 2(0% 8+(7+ 7"#&$($F$%& - 52('(#/; 2(0%> f-2F-$("# (&
$+%.%0".% %&&%#$(-2 $" 2(0% (0 2(0% (&B (# %&&%#7%B ($& .-(&(#/ "'%. -H"'% ($&%20> Y#
&+".$B '-2F%& -.% /('%# ". 7"#9($("#%9 H1 2(0% -& %&&%#$(-221 -& $+%1 /('% ". -.%
- 7"#9($("# "0 ($> *+% 7"##%7$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 2(0% (& $+%# 6".% -33-.%#$4
(# M%(9%//%.;& $%.6&B 2(0% +-& -# %&&%#$(-2 F#($1 8($+ #(+(2(&6 -& $.-#&0".6-$("# "0 8+%.% -#9 8+-$ '-2F%& -.%> *+-$ (&B #(+(2(&6 *% $+% $.-#&S
0".6-$("# "0 2(0% -& &F7+B "0 ='9# ($ (& -#9 "0 '"= ($ (&>
M"8%'%.B &F7+ - /%#%.-2 &$-$%6%#$ 9"%& #"$ 7-3$F.% $+% 7"632%V($1 "0
M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# #".B 6".% (63".$-#$21B $+% &3%7(0(7 9%$%.6(#-$("#
"0 2(0% -& &F7+> W".B $" -.$(7F2-$% $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 $.-#&0".6-$("#
"0 #(+(2(&6B $" 3."3"F#9 $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 7"#9($("#& -#9 5.-(&S
(#/; "0 2(0%B M%(9%//%. 6F&$ $+(#T +(&$".(7-2 '-2F-$("#B 8+(7+ (& $" &-1 $+%
9/#,94*#C "0 2(0%> ZF$ (0 ($ (& 5H("2"/(7-2; $+(#T(#/ 5$+-$ (#$%.3.%$& `.$,#$#a -22
-33%-.-#7%& -& $+% %V3.%&&("# "0 2(0%; `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B J)Cm )XX)-B @XaB -#9
(0 2(0% (& $+% 7"#9($("# -#9 %&&%#7% "0 2(0% -& &F7+B "0 '-2F%& -#9 &" "0 $+%
+(&$".1 "0 #(+(2(&6B ($ 8"F29 &%%6 -33."3.(-$% $" 2""T $" =(%$A&7+%;& H("2"S
/(7-2 9(&7F&&("#& -& $+% 72%-.%&$ %V3.%&&("# "0 -# "#$"$+%"2"/1B (0 #"$ -& $+%
7".% "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $+(#T(#/ &(#7% $+-$ (& 8+%.% ($& 6%$-3+1&(7& 8"F29 H%
.""$%9 `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B J)Xm )XX)-B DIh)a> *+(& (& 3.%7(&%21 $+% =-A( -9"3S
$("# -#9 %&3"F&-2 "0 =(%$A&7+%4 -& - I)*59)*4C H("2"/(&$(7 $+(#T%. "0 2(0% -#9
+(&$".1> M%(9%//%. .%0F$%& &F7+ - 7"63.%+%#&("# "0 =(%$A&7+%B +"8%'%.> *+%
.%0F$-$("# (& (# 2(#% 8($+ - $+%6% $+-$ (& 7"#&$-#$ -#9 0-6(2(-. -7."&& M%(S
9%//%.;& 8".T&4 #-6%21B $+-$ &7(%#7% 9%%,5$% $+% O%&$%.# 6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%7S
(&("# "# H%(#/`&a HF$ 9"%& #"$ $+(#T ($> Y# 3.%&F6(#/ "77(9%#$-2 6%$-3+1&(7&
h 8+(7+ (& HF$ - '-2F-$("# "0 8+-$ -#9 +"8 H%(#/& -& &F7+ -#9 -& - 8+"2% -.%
h &7(%#7% (632%6%#$& $+(& "#$"$+%"2"/1 8($+"F$ _F%&$("# `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B
J<Im )XX)-B D<h@a> K(0% (& $+F& - &$-H2% '-2F% 0". H("2"/1 &" (#$%.3.%$%9>N
Q77".9(#/21B $+% 2(0% 5"0; H("2"/1 9"%& #"$ 7"..%&3"#9 $" 2(0% (# ($& %&&%#$(-2
5.-(&(#/;> Z("2"/(&6 F#9%.&$""9 -& $+% 5$.-#&0%..(#/ r"0s 9%$%.6(#%9 3.%'-(2S
(#/ '(%8& "# $+% 2('(#/ 0."6 $+% .%-26 "0 $+% '%/%$-2 -#9 -#(6-2 $" "$+%.
.%-26& "0 H%(#/& &F7+ -& +(&$".1 `O$%/'*/'#$a; `(H(9>B J<Dm DJa 7"#0(.6&
0F.$+%.6".% &F7+ - &$-H2% '-2F% -#9 3.%9%7(&("# "# 2(0%> Y$ $+F& 3."3"/-$%&
- 6%$-3+1&(7-2 3.%9%7(&("# "0 8+(7+ ($ (&B -& M%(9%//%. 3F$& ($B #"#%$+%2%&&
5$"$-221 (/#".-#$; `(H(9>B J<Jm DJa>C
Y# $+-$ ($ 9"%& &"# 3.%&F6% 8+-$ 2(0% (& -& &F7+ `8+-$ '-2F% ($ (&a #". %'%#
$+-$ 2(0% (&B (# M%(9%//%.;& $%.6& =(%$A&7+%;& $+(#T(#/ (& #"$ &7(%#$(0(7 HF$
"#$"$+%"2"/(7-2> M%(9%//%. -00(.6& $+-$4
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
f-2F%B -& 7"#9($("# "0 2(0%B 6F&$ $+%.%0".% 7"6% $" H% $+"F/+$ -& $+-$
8+(7+ &F33".$& `#)9U?# r5H%-.&;saB 0F.$+%.& -#9 -8-T%#& $+% .-(&(#/ "0 2(0%>
L#21 8+-$ .-(&%& 2(0%B r$+-$ (&Bs H%(#/& -& - 8+"2%B +-& '-2F% h ". H%$$%.4 *% '-2F%>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)-B D??m )XX)-B )Jh)Na
XI !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
M%#7%B 2(0% `$+%"2"/1a -#9 $+% 2('(#/ `"#$"2"/1a -.% #"$ $" H% $+"F/+$
53"&($('(&$(7-221;B F3"# /."F#9& "0 8+-$ (& -2.%-91 3.%&F6%9 $" H% `H-&(7-221a
-2('%> Y# $+% &FH&%_F%#$ 2%7$F.% 7"F.&% "# =(%$A&7+% 0."6 $+% 0(.&$ $.(6%&$%.
"0 )XDIB 8+"&% 3.(#7(3-2 $+%6% (& #(+(2(&6B M%(9%//%. %V$%#9& $+(& -./FS
6%#$ -/-(#&$ $+% &7(%#$(0(7 -&&F63$("# "0 2(0% $" $+% 7"63.%+%#&("# "0
"#$"$+%"2"/1 3.%9(7-$%9 F3"# $+% $+.%% 0F.$+%. 9(6%#&("#& "04 #-$F.-2 ".
3"&($('% $+%"2"/1B 3&17+"2"/1 `8+%.% H%(#/& -& &F7+ -#9 -& - 8+"2% 6-1 H%
&-(9 $" H% 7"63.%+%#9%9 H1 $+% `+F6-#a 6(#9 ". &"F2aB -#9 7"&6"2"/1
`8+%.% H%(#/& -& &F7+ -#9 -& 8+"2% -.% &-(9 $" 7"63.%+%#9%9 -& $+% 3+1&(7-2
". #-$F.-2 $"$-2($1 "0 $+% F#('%.&%a> !"6H(#(#/ $+%&% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 9"6-(#&
"0 .%3.%&%#$(#/ 5H%(#/& -& - 8+"2%; 8($+ $+-$ "0 H("2"/1B ($ 7-# H% &-(9 8($+
M%(9%//%. $+-$ $+% "#$"$+%"2"/1 "0 2(0% 7-##"$ H% 7"63.%+%#9%9 0."6 %'%#
-# %V$%#9%9 &7(%#$(0(7-221 9%$%.6(#%9 .%-26 "0 $+% 2('(#/B H% ($ - 3&17+"H("S
2"/1 ".B 6".% /%#%.-221B - 7"&6"H("2"/1>
="#%$+%2%&&B M%(9%//%. 6F&$ $+(#T 2(0% (# ($& -7$F-2($1> Q#9 ($ (& =(%$A&7+%;&
7"63.%+%#&("# "0 2(0% (# ($& -7$F-2($1 -& F94,9#*"& $+-$ -22"8& ($ $" H% 7"#S
&(9%.%9 -& - 3.(#7(3-221 +(&$".(7-2S5$#9I'C%*/94 (&&F% H%1"#9 -#9 "F$&(9% "0
($& 7"&6"H("2"/(7-2 `3.%a9%$%.6(#-$("#4 -& -# (&&F% "0 #(+(2(&6> *+%
3.(".($(&-$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 "'%. &7(%#$(0(7 %#_F(.1 (& &$.%&&%9 H1 M%(9%//%.
0."6 $+% &$-.$ "0 $+% ,F66%. )X@X 2%7$F.% 7"F.&%> Q& ($& $($2% &F//%&$&B
M%(9%//%. (#($(-221 %63+-&(&%& $+(& 3.(".($1 H1 %2F7(9-$(#/ $+% /."F#9 -#9
%&&%#7% "0 /"?&*#*"& 8+(7+ &7(%#7% &(6321 -&&F6%&> *+% 0"7F& "# 7"/#($("#
0F.$+%. %63+-&(&%& $+% 3.(6-71 "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 %#_F(.1 &(#7% $+% 2-$$%. 9"%&
&"# -&&F6% $+% 5$+%6-$(7; 3.%9%$%.6(#-$("#& "0 7"&6"H("2"/1 `$+-$ (&B $+%
2('(#/a -#9B 0F.$+%.6".%B ($ 9"%& #"$ -&&F6% %'%# $+% 7"/#($("# "0 2(0% (# ($&
-7$F-2($1 -& $+% 56%$+"9"2"/(7-2; /"&.*#*"& "0 $+% %#_F(.1 (#$" ($> *+-$ (&B $+%
6%$-3+1&(7-2S'-2F-$('% 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 7"/#($("# -22"8& H"$+ $+% $+%6-$(7
9&. 6%$+"9"2"/(7-2 -&&F63$("#& "0 $+% &7(%#$(0(7 %V-6(#-$("# "0 2(0% $" H%
3F$ (#$" _F%&$("#> Y$ (& $+F& - 59%&$.F7$("#; "0 $F$)C -&3%7$ "0 H("2"/1>
WF.$+%.6".%B (0 2(0% (& #"$ $+% 5"HR%7$; "0 $+% %#_F(.1 HF$ ($& %&&%#7%B $+%#
7"/#($("# ($&%20 (& 7"63.%+%#9%9 (# $%.6& "0 '-2F%S3"&($(#/> !"/#($("# h
8+(7+ (& $" &-1B 8($+ =(%$A&7+%B 2(0% (# ($& '-2F-$("# h (& ($&%20 $+%# 5.%S
7"/#(&%9; "F$&(9% "0 ($& 6%$-3+1&(7-2 &%7F.($1B H% ($ - &7(%#$(0(7 ") +(&$".(7-2S
3+(2"&"3+(7-2 &%7F.($1> ,F7+ -# $%%$&#*94S6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# $+F&
-22"8& -#9 .%_F(.%& $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 $+% &%9(6%#$%9 '*%#")*/"S6%$-3+1&(7-2
&%#&% "0 7"/#($("# (# $+% O%&$%.# $.-9($("#>? O($+ $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 7"/#(S
$("# ($ (& -2&" $+% '%.1 7"#9($("# "0 F94,9#*"& -& &F7+B "0 8+(7+ 9%S-#9 .%S
'-2F-$("# -.% &3%7(0(7 "77F..%#7%&B 8+(7+ (& 0(.&$21 3F$ F#9%. 9%&$.F7$("#>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-2$+"F/+ =(%$A&7+% /('%& $+% (63.%&&("# "0 &3%-T(#/ -#9 $+(#T(#/ H("S
2"/(7-221B /('(#/ $+% 2('(#/ -#9 2(0% - 9(.%7$ 3.%7%9%#7% `X")@,?aB $+(&
3.%7%9%#7% "0 2(0% 6F&$ 0(.&$ "0 -22 H% /."F#9%9 F3"# - /."F#9 8+(7+
+-& &"#'*&? 5")$ r%63+> -99>s $" 9" 8($+ $+% -33%-.-#7% "0 2(0% "0 $+%
32-#$ -#9 $+% -#(6-2>
`(H(9>B J<Nm DNa
A,'9*4 394*; X)
!"#'%.&%21B 8($+ $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 7"/#($("# 2(0% -& &F7+ (& -2&" F#9%.
9%&$.F7$("#>
*+% 53"(#$ "0 9%3-.$F.%; 0". M%(9%//%.;& .$%#),/#*F$ (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 7"/#(S
$("# $" ($& %&&%#7% (# 2(0% (& =(%$A&7+%;& #"$% 0."6 ,3.(#/hW-22 )??C `7"22%7$%9
-& lJIC (# D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)a> *+% 0(.&$ 7"F32% "0 &%#$%#7%& "0 $+(& 3-&&-/% $(%
$+% (&&F% "0 $.F$+ 9(.%7$21 H-7T $" '-2F-$("#4
*+% $%#*59#*"& "2 F94,$ `P$)#%/'9U#@,&?a 5Y H%2(%'% $+-$ &F7+ -#9 &F7+ (& &";
-& $+% $%%$&/$ "0 5#),#'N> Y# %&$(6-$("#& "0 '-2F% /"&.*#*"&% "2 59*&#$&9&/$
`6)'94#,&?a -#9 ?)"=#' -.% %V3.%&&%9> Q22 "F. ")?9&% "2 /"?&*#*"& 9&. ",)
%$&%$% -.% "#21 9%'%2"3%9 8($+ .%/-.9 $" 7"#9($("#& "0 6-(#$%#-#7% -#9
/."8$+>
`7($%9 (# M%(9%//%. )XN)-B JIXm )XX)-B @@a
*+-$ (&B $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 $.F$+ -#9 6%$-3+1&(7& .%_F(.%& $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0
7"/#($("# -& ($ (& 53"&($%9; $+."F/+ $+% &%#&%& -#9 7"/#($('% "./-#&> Y# "$+%.
8".9&B ($ .%_F(.%& - 9%&$.F7$("# "0 4*F*&? /"?&*#*"&B 8+(7+ (& $" &-1B /('(#/
2('(#/ 7"/#($("# ($& $.-9($("#-2 6%$-3+1&(7-2 #-6%B - 9%&$.F7$("# "0 3%.7%3S
$("# `P9')&$'5,&? r2($%.-2214 5$.F$+S$-T(#/;sa -#9 3%.S7%3$("# `X$)&$'5,&?
r6".% .%-9(21 $.-#&2-$%9 H1 5%V-6(#-$("#;B $+"F/+ 53%.S7%3$("#; (& 7+"&%#
+%.% 8($+ $+% 53%.S; (#9(7-$(#/ $+% (#$%#&(0(%. "0 $+% $.-#&($('% &%#&% "0 /%$S
$(#/S+"29S"0 8+(7+ (& 7-..(%9 $+."F/+ (# $+% K-$(# .""$ I$)/*I$)$sa> Y# 0"22"8S
(#/ $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 7"/#($("# $+."F/+ $" $+% ".9%. "0 2('(#/ "./-#(7
3%.7%3$("#B M%(9%//%. 7"#9F7$& $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 7"/#($("#
#"$ "#21 (#$" -#9 H%1"#9 $+% ".9%. "0 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-221 &%7F.% .%/(&$%. "0
T#"82%9/% 8($+ 8+(7+ %3(&$%6"2"/1 (& 7"#7%.#%9B HF$ -2&" "0 ($& 7"&6"H("S
2"/(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("#> M%(9%//%. /('%& - 0F22%. 6%-#(#/ $" $+(& &"6%8+-$
-H&$.-7$%9 &%#&% "0 3%.S7%3$("# H1 .%6-.T(#/ $+-$ (# $+% &%9(6%#$%9 &%#&% "0
O%&$%.# 6%$-3+1&(7& +F6-# 3%.S7%3$("# (& 5%'%.18+%.% -#9 -28-1&; 3%.S
7%3$("# "0 H%(#/& `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B J<?m )XX)-B D?a> *+(& H-#-2 /%#%.-2
&%#&% (& 3F&+%9 0F.$+%. H1 %63+-&(&(#/ $+-$B 57"#'%.&%21B $+% H%(#/ -& &F7+
"3%#& ($&%20 "#21 $" &F7+ - 3%.S7%('(#/; `(H(9>a> O+(2% $+(& (# &"6% 8-1& "#21
.%($%.-$%& $+-$ $+% 7"#9($("# "0 -#1 H%(#/ -& - H%(#/ (& 3%.S7%3$("#B 8+(7+ (&
$" &-1 H%2(%0B ($ -2&" %63+-&(&%& $+-$ - H%(#/ 5(&; "#21 &F7+ - H%(#/ (0 ($ 5"3%#&
($&%20; $" H%(#/ 3%.S7%('%9 (# 7"/#($("#B (0 *# (& 3%.S7%('9+4$>
*+(& %&&%#$(-2 7"#RF#7$("# -#9 7"S%'-2 5"3%#(#/;B 8+(7+ (& /('%# 9&.
"H&7F.%9 H1 '-2F%S3"&($(#/B (& H."F/+$ (#$" 72-.($1 H1 $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 ($&
+(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("#>X ,%'%.-2 "$+%. #-6%& ". _F-&(S7"#S
7%3$& -.% $+%# .%2%'-#$> ,3%7(0(7-221B M%(9%//%. #"$%& $+-$ 5/.-&3(#/ -#9
9%$%.6(#(#/ H%(#/& +-'% &(#7% -#7(%#$ $(6%& 7"6% $" H% -$$.(HF$%9 $" 3%.S
7%3$("# h $" &",%> O% +-'% 0". $+(& $+% ^%.6-# 8".9 X$)&,&2# r)$9%"&s;
`M%(9%//%. )XN)-B J<Xm )XX)-B DXa> *+-$ (&B $+"F/+ $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1S
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
EN
&(7-2 &%#&% "0 .%-&"# (& $+-$ ($ (& 5$+% 7-3-H(2($1 `X$)5"U?$& r6".% F&F-221
$.-#&2-$%9 0."6 b-#$ H1 50-7F2$1;sa "0 H.(#/(#/ $+% +F6-# H%0".% H%(#/&
-#9 $+-$ .%3.%&%#$& H%(#/& -& &F7+ 0". $+% +F6-#; $+."F/+ .%3.%&%#$-$("#
`M%(9%//%. )XN)-B J@)m )XX)-B J)aB $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 7"/#($("# &+"8& $+-$ ($
(& -#"$+%. #-6% 0". $+% 6".% /%#%.-2 7"S%'-2 5"3%#(#/; "0 3%.S7%3$("# -#9
H%(#/&>
*+% (63".$-#7% "0 $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 7"/#($("# $+%# H%7"6%& %'%#
72%-.%.4 $+% 7"#9($("#& "0 H%(#/& -& &F7+ -#9 -& - 8+"2% -.% %&&%#$(-221
9%$%.6(#%9 #"$ H1 .%3.%&%#$-$("# HF$ H1 2(0% (# ($& '-2F-$("#> f-2F-$("# (&
$+F& $+% %&&%#7% "0 .%-&"#B ($& 7"#9($("#> Q77".9(#/21B $+% %&&%#$(-2 7"63.%S
+%#&("# "0 #(+(2(&6 -& $+% +(&$".1 "0 '-2F-$("# .%_F(.%& $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0
.%-&"#B "0 8+-$ M%(9%//%. 7-22& 5$+% 6"&$ %V$.%6% 3.%S9%7(&("# -& $" 8+-$
H%(#/ &-1&; `(H(9>B J@)m J)aB #-6%21 $+-$ $+%.% 9)$ H%(#/& 0". +F6-# 7"/#(S
$("#> M%(9%//%.;& 9%&$.F7$("# +%.% (& &8(0$4 0". =(%$A&7+% ($ (& H1 H%2(%0 $+-$
$+% $.F% (& 5$+% /.-&3%9 `6)29n#$a (# 7"/#($("#B $+% H%(#/; `(H(9>B JD@m JXaB $+-$
58+-$ (&; *%> Z%2(%0 (& $+% /"&.*#*"& 0". $+% 5H%2"#/(#/S$"/%$+%.; "0 H%(#/& -#9
2('(#/ 7"/#($("# `0". $+% +F6-#aB -#9 &" "0 .%-&"#> Y0 $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0
6%$-3+1&(7&B -#9 &" "0 H%(#/& $+F& 7"63.%+%#9%9B $F.#& "# H%2(%0 -&
5/.-&3(#/ (# 7"/#($("#;B $+%# $+% &%#&% "0 H%2(%0 7-# H% %2-H".-$%9 H1 $+%
9%&$.F7$("# "0 .%-&"# -& '-2F-$("#4
8% &-1 &"6%$+(#/ *% "0 $+-$ 8+(7+ 8% 94=9C% 9&. *& 9.F9&/$ r%63+> -99>s
%#7"F#$%. `9&#)$22$&a -& -28-1& -2.%-91 -$ +-#9 `*55$) %/'"& F")'9&.$&am
8+-$ -28-1& 3.%&%#$& `9&=$%#a -#9 (# &F7+ 3.%&%#7% `7&=$%$&'$*#a +-&
7"#&$-#$ 7"#&$-#71 `%#9U&.*?$ <$%#9&. r5&$-#9(#/ .%&%.'%;sa>
`(H(9>B JD@m JXa
Y# -77".9 8($+ $+% 8".29S+(&$".(7-2 "77F..%#7% -#9 3."7%&& "0 #(+(2(&6B
M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# &F//%&$& $+-$ H%2(%0 -#9 '-2F-$("# 0". =(%$A&7+%
h $+-$ (&B 5$+% H%(#/+""9 "0 H%(#/&; h 58-#$ $" &-14 /"&%#9&# I)$%$&/$ `+$%#9U&.*?$
7&=$%$&'$*#a; `(H(9>B JD<m NIa> O($+ $+(& 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 H%2(%0 -& H%2"#/(#/
$" $+% 6%$-3+1&(7& "0 3.%&%#7%B $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7-2 7"/#($("# (&
-77"632(&+%9>
Y# (#$%.3.%$(#/ =(%$A&7+%;& $+(#T(#/ "0 2(0% $" H% 7"#0."#$(#/ $+% 6%$-S
3+1&(7& "0 3.%&%#7% 9% %,/'B M%(9%//%. &F//%&$& $+-$ =(%$A&7+% %V32(7($21
-7T#"82%9/%& $+% O%&$%.# 6%$-3+1&(7-2 53.%S9%7(&("#; "# H%(#/`&a> *+-$ (&B
0". M%(9%//%.B =(%$A&7+% &$-#9& -$ $+% 5%#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7&;B -$ ($& 56"&$
%V$.%6% 3"(#$; (# 8+(7+ 5$+% 3."3%. -00(.6-$('% %&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 &+"8&
($&%20 (# $+% 2(/+$;> *+(& 5-00(.6-$('% %&&%#7%; (& H%2(%0B $+% 57"#&$-#$ 3.%&%#7%;
$+-$ 5(63"&%&; 7"#&$-#71 -#9 0(.6#%&& (# '-2F-$("#> !"..%2-$('%21B H%2(%0 (&
($&%20 "0 $+% F$6"&$ ". 5+(/+%&$; '-2F% $" $+% 2('(#/4
$+% (63"&($("# `7&%$#@,&?a "0 $+% 7"#&$-#$ -#9 $+% 0(.6 -& H%(#/& h (& 9%$%.6(#%9 F94,*&?> Y#9%%9B $+% 7"#&$-#$S0(.6 7"6%& $" H% 3.%0%..%9 -&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
X< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
A,'9*4 394*; X@
O+-$ (& 6"&$ '-2F-H2% `7"#&$-#$a $" 2(0% (& '-2F-$("# `7"#&$-#71a> f-2F%
`S3"&($(#/a (& $+% +(/+%&$ '-2F% "0 '-2F%`S3"&($(#/a> ,F7+ (& $+% 5F#7"#9($("#S
-2r($1s; -#9 5".(/(#-.1 F#($1; -#9 5$"$-2($1; "0 H%(#/& -& &F7+ -#9 -& - 8+"2%>
W". M%(9%//%.B $+(& "#$"$+%"2"/1 (& 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% 7-22& 56".-2($1;> Y$ (& $+%
5P2-$"#(7 9"7$.(#%; 8+(7+ 5I)$S9%7(9%&; "77(9%#$-2 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7&> Y$
(& 5$+% 7-F&% "0 #(+(2(&6 h (# $+% &%#&% "0 $+% (63"&($("# "0 $+% &F3%.#-$F.-2
(9%-2& "0 $.F$+B "0 /""9#%&&B -#9 "0 H%-F$1 $+-$ -.% '-2(9 55(# $+%6&%2'%&;; ;
`M%(9%//%. )XN)HB <CXm )XX)-B <INa> 5E".-2($1; (63"&%& 5&F3%.#-$F.-2 (9%-2&;
-& 7"#9($("#& 0". 2(0% (# $+-$ $+%&% '-2F%& -.% $+% 7"#&$-#$S0(.6 -#9 -28-1&
3.%&%#$ 7"#9($("#`&a 0". $+%.% %'%# $" H% 7"/#($("# ". 3%.S7%3$("# `-& '-2F-S
$("#a>
N
=(%$A&7+%;& (63".$-#7% $" "#$"$+%"2"/1 (& $+%# 6-#(0%&$4 0(.&$21B ($ (& $+(&
$HI)$%% &%#&% "0 '-2F-$("#]H%2(%0 -& $+% 7"632%$%B &"2% 7"#9($("# -#9 57-F&%;
"0 $+% '-.("F& +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2S6".-2 9%$%.6(#-$("#& "0 H%(#/ -#9
$.F$+ $+-$ 2%$& $+% -00(.6-$('% 53."3%. %&&%#7%; "0 #(+(2(&6 H% -7T#"82%9/%9
9% %,/'B -& 57"#&$-#$ 3.%&%#7%;> ,%7"#921B $+% )$F94,9#*"& "0 '-2F%&B 8+(7+ (&
8+-$ $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 2('(#/ 3%.S7%3$("# (#'"2'%&B 56F&$ r$+%#s H% F#7"#S
9($("#-2 -#9 32-7% -22 H%(#/& (# -# ".(/(#-.1 F#($1; `M%(9%//%. )XN)HB <C?m
)XX)-B <IJa> *+% 3.(#7(3-2 3"(#$ +%.%B +"8%'%.B (& $+-$ $+% F#7"#9($("#-2B
".(/(#-.1 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% 5"#%; 9&. ($& .%'-2F-$("# (&B 0". M%(9%//%.B
+"8 -#9 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% 3."3"&%& 4*2$ $" H% (# ($& 9F-2($1> W".B $+"F/+
6".-2($1 8"F29 H% $+% +(/+%&$ -#9 -H&"2F$% F#7"#9($("#-2($1 "0 2(0% (0 2(0%
8%.% "#21 $+% 3"&($(#/ "0 '-2F%&B 8($+ =(%$A&7+% 2(0% (& -$ "#7% $+% 3"&($(#/ "0
'-2F%& 9&. $+% .-(&(#/ "'%. ($&%20B $" $+% 5%V$.%6%; 3"(#$ $+-$ ($ %'%# .%'-2F%&
($&%20 -& '-2F-$("# `&F7+ (& $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 7"/#($("#B -#9 =(%$A&7+%;&
/%#%-2"/1 "0 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 6".-2($1a> Y# "$+%. 8".9&m `(a 0". M%(S
9%//%. ($ (& =(%$A&7+%;& 7"63.%+%#&("# "0 2(0% $+-$ 2%$& $+% 5-00(.6-$('% 3."3%.
%&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6; H% +(&$".(7-221 5&+"8# (# $+% 2(/+$;> Q#9 (0B -& +-& H%%#
&%%#B 0". M%(9%//%. =(%$A&7+% 3."3"&%& $+% /"&.*#*"& `-#9 '-2F%a "0 '-2F% 0".
'-2F-$("# $" H% 2(0% -& .%'-2F-$("#B $+%#B `((a (# ($& .%'-2F(#/B 2(0% -& $+% '-2F%S
3"&($(#/ "0 H%2(%0 -#9 6".-2($1 (& ($&%20 3.(#7(3-221 9%$%.6(#%9 #"$ H1 -#1
'-2F% HF$ H1 2(0% *& *#% 4*F*&?4 5$.F$+ -& '-2F% (& 0". =(%$A&7+% - #%7%&&-.1
7"#9($("# 0". 4*2$B rHF$ ($ (&s - '-2F-$("# $+-$ 2(0% 7-..(%& "F$ &" -& $" 8(22 ($&%20;
`M%(9%//%. )XN)-B JJ)m )XX)-B NCa> M%#7%B `(((a 2(0% -& - .%'-2F-$("# "0 3.%S
'("F& '-2F%& -$ ($& 5%V$.%6%;B -$ $+% 3"(#$ "0 ($& -F$"S7"63.%+%#&("#B (& HF$
$+% .%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F-$("# -& &F7+B -#9 +%#7% "0 2(0% -& &F7+> M"8%'%.B `('a
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
$+% +(/+%. '-2F% $" $+% 7+-#/(#/ -#9 02%%$(#/> *+% '-2F(#/ "0 $+% '-2F% "0
$+% 7"#&$-#$ -#9 $+% (#7"#&$-#$ 7"6%& $" H% /F(9%9 0."6 $+% /."F#9S
7"63.%+%#&("# `O),&.9,229%%,&?a "0 $+% '-2F-H2% -#9 '-2F%>
`(H(9>B JDDm NIa
&F7+ - .%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%& (& #" 2%&& $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 +(&$".1 "0 #(+(2(&6>
*+-$ (&B `'a 2(0% -& &F7+B (# ($& %&&%#7%B (& - #(+(2(&6> Q#9 $+(& %&&%#7%B 2(0% (# ($&
2('(#/B (& 8+-$ #(+(2(&6 -00(.6& (# *#% 53."3%. %&&%#7%; F#9%. $+% #-6% "0
5H%7"6(#/ `P$).$&a;> ,F7+ (& $+% 7"S%&&%#$(-2 +(&$".1 -#9 +(&$".(7($1 "0 2(0%
9&. #(+(2(&6 -#9 $+% &%#&% "0 $+% 5%#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7&;>
*+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 2(0% 9"%& #"$ 3.%&F6% ". 7"#&"2(9-$% $+% 8".29S+(&$".S
(7-2 "77F..%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 h 6".-2($1 h -& 9"%& -22 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7& F3
$" =(%$A&7+%> G-$+%.B ($ H%/(#& 0."6 $+% 5 55%V$.%6%;; #(+(2(&6; $+-$ 57"/#(&%&
$+-$ $+%.% -.% #" 55%$%.#-2 $.F$+& (# $+%6&%2'%&;; ; `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B <?Im
)XX)-B <ICa> UV$.%6%B -7$('% #(+(2(&6B $+% %#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7&B (&B +"8%'%.B
#"$ &(6321 7"#/.F%#$ 8($+ $+% 3."7%&& "0 $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 3."7%&&
"0 #(+(2(&6 &(#7% ($4
72%-.& "F$ `)9U,5# Z Z Z 9,%a 3.%'("F& '-2F%& $"/%$+%. 8($+ $+%(. 5&3-7%
`19,5a; `$+% &F3%.&%#&(H2%a -#9 ($ 6"'%& (# `)9U,5# Z Z Z $*&a 3.(6-.1 3"&&(S
H(2($(%& "0 #%8 '-2F-$("#&> O($+ .%&3%7$ $" $+(& 7+-.-7$%. "0 &3-7%S/%#%.-$S
(#/ `)9,5%/'922$&.$&a -#9 &$%33(#/ (#$" $+% 0.%% "0 %V$.%6% #(+(2(&6B
=(%$A&7+% &3%-T& -2&" "0 5%7&$-$(7 #(+(2(&6; `D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)B l)IJJa>
,F7+ r#(+(2(&6s -00(.6& > > > #%($+%. - r$+(#/s -$ +-#9 #". -# (9%-2 r8+(7+
(& 8+1 ($ (& #"$ +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 #(+(2(&6s HF$ .-$+%. $+% 5I)*&/*I4$ "2
F94,9#*"&N r-& &F7+s> Q& &""# -& $+(& (& %V3.%&&21 &%(A%9 -#9 (& 3."3%.21
$-T%# F3 -& $+% /."F#9 -#9 6%-&F.% "0 -22 '-2F%S3"&($(#/B #(+(2(&6 +-&
0"F#9 ($&%20 (# ($& -00(.6-$('% %&&%#7%B +-& "'%.7"6% -#9 (#72F9%9 ($&
(#7"632%$("#B -#9 $+F& 0F20(2& ($&%20> U7&$-$(7 #(+(2(&6 7"6%& $" H% 572-&&(S
7-2 #(+(2(&6;> =(%$A&7+% 7"#7%('%& "0 +(& 6%$-3+1&(7& -& &F7+> rws *+%
-00(.6-$('% %&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 "'%.-22 7-# #"$ H% &-(9 6".% -00(.6-$('%21>
rws G%'-2F-$("# r#"8s 9"%& #"$ 6%-# "#21 $+-$ #%8 '-2F%& 7"6% $" H%
3"&($%9 (# $+% "29 -#9 &-6% 32-7% "0 3.%'("F& '-2F%&B HF$ .-$+%. 0(.&$21 -#9
-+%-9 "0 $+-$ 6%-#& #'9# #'$ I49/$ mA#$44$W *#%$42 /"5$% #" +$ .$#$)5*&$. 9&$=>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)HB <?)h<m )XX)-B <ICh?a
*+% 5-00(.6-$('% %&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6; (& .%-2(&%9 -& $+% F#7"#9($("#-2 )$F94,9J
#*"& "0 '-2F-$("# 9% %,/'> *+-$ (&B $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 2(0% -#9 '-2F-$("#B "0 3%.S
7%3$("#B +-& $" H% 9%$%.6(#%9 H%1"#9 $+% /"&.*#*"& -#9 '-2F% "0 '-2F%> *+(&
,&/"&.*#*"&94 .%'-2F-$("# (& HF$ 2(0% `-& '-2F-$("#a (# ($& 572-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6;> Y$
(& -# 5(66".-2($1; .%_F(.(#/ $+% 532-7%; "0 '-2F-$("# $" H% 59%$%.6(#%9 -#%8;>
*+"F/+ $+(& (& #"$ 9(.%7$21 $+% 7"#$%V$ 3."3"&%9 (# $+% ,F66%. )X@X
2%7$F.% 7"F.&%B ($ (& (# 0-7$ 8+-$ (& F#9%.$-T%# 8+%# M%(9%//%. (#$%.3.%$&
=(%$A&7+%;& #"$% 0."6 E-.7+hkF#% )??? `7"22%7$%9 -& lJ)J (# D'$ P*44 #"
E"=$)a -& - &$-$%6%#$ "# $+% %&&%#$(-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 7"/#($("# (# H%7"6S
(#/> *+% #"$% .%-9&4 5="$ 557"/#(&(#/;; HF$ .-$+%. &7+%6-$(&(#/B (63"&(#/
`9,2$)4$?$&a F3"# 7+-"& -& 6-#1 .%/F2-.($(%& -#9 0".6& -& &-$(&0(%& `?$&,?#,#a
"F. 3.-7$(7-2 #%%9 `<$.,U)2&*%a; `7($%9 (# M%(9%//%. )XN)-B JJJm )XX)-B C)a>
M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# +(/+2(/+$& $8" -&3%7$& +%.%4 0(.&$21B 7+-"& (& $+-$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
XD !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
F3"# 8+(7+ 5.%/F2-.($(%& -#9 0".6&; 7"6% $" H% (63"&%9 H1 3%.S7%3$("#B ($ (&
58+-$ 7"/#($("# (#($(-221 &$.(T%& `%#"Un#aB -#9 8+-$ 7"6%& $" &$.(T% ($ 0(.&$ "0
-22B 8+-$ 7"/#($("# &$%3& "#$" `9,2#)*22# r5%#7"F#$%.&;sa; `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B
JJNm )XX)-B C)a> !+-"& (& - #-6% 0". $+-$ 8+(7+ 7"6%& $" H% 5%#7"F#$%.%9;
(# &7+%6-$(&(#/ HF$ 8+(7+ (& #"$ ($&%20 $+% 5(63"&(#/ r"0s .%/F2-.($(%&
-#9 0".6&;>)I *+"F/+ 7+-"& (& #"$ $+%# %#$(.%21 "$+%. $" 7"/#($("#B
($& `3-.$(-2a 5%V$%.(".($1; $" 7"/#($("# /('%& - '-#$-/% 0". $+% 2-$$%.;&
9%&$.F7$("#>
*+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 4*F*&? 3%.S7%3$("# .%2(%&B +"8%'%.B "# $+% &%7"#9 0"7F&
"0 M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("#4 $+% 53.-7$(7-2 #%%9; $+-$ 9.('%& $+% &7+%6-$(&-S
$("# "0 7+-"&> *+% 3"(#$ +%.% (& &$.-(/+$0".8-.94 0."6 =(%$A&7+%;& #"$%B
7"/#($("# (& #"$ 7-..(%9 "F$ H1 - &FHR%7$B H% ($ $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 ". "$+%.8(&%>
G-$+%.B -& M%(9%//%. (#&(&$&B 5$+% 7"/#($('% (& $+% I)9H*% "0 2(0%; `M%(9%//%.
)XN)-B JJCm )XX)-B C<a> Y# $+(& &%#&% "0 7"/#($("# $+% &7+%6-$(&(#/ I)9H*%
2(%& H%+(#9 #"$ RF&$ ($& 6"9%.#S6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# -& `.%3.%&S
%#$-$("#-2a .%-&"# HF$ -2&" 5H%+(#9; H%(#/& -& '-2F%S3"&($(#/B -& 8+-$ -#9
+"8 H%(#/& -.%B -& 8+-$ (& /('%# -#9 5+%29;> Z%2(%0 7"63.%+%#9%9 -& $+%
&7+%6-$(&(#/ I)9H*% "0 2(0% /%$& 5H%+(#9; H%(#/& $" $+% /('(#/ "0 H%(#/& 9% %,/'>
NE
*+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 7"/#($("# $+%.%0".% .%_F(.%& $+% 7+-"& %#7"F#$%.%9 (#
&7+%6-$(&(#/ 9&. $+% &7+%6-$(&(#/ $" H% 5($&%20; 3%.S7%('%9 -& &"6%$+(#/
"$+%. $+-# 94)$9.C `(#a H%(#/> Y$ $+%.%H1 3"&%& $+% V,$%#*"& "0 H%(#/B 8+(7+
_F%&$("# 7-##"$ %'%# "77F. (# .%-&"# ". (# -#1 "$+%. 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0
'-2F-$("# &(#7% 56".-2($1; 3.%&F33"&%& H%(#/`&aB (0 #"$ 3.%&%#7%B -& $+% 7"#S
9($("# "0 '-2F-$("#> Z1 $+-$ 3.%&F33"&($("#B '-2F-$("# .%#"F#7%& $+% 5/('(#/S
($&%20; "0 $+% /('%# (# $+% 53F.% %#7"F#$%.; "0 /'9"% `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B JNDm
)XX)-B C?a 8+%.%H1 H%(#/ (& 3F$ (#$" _F%&$("#> Z1 7"#$.-&$B $+% (&&F% 0".
%V$.%6% #(+(2(&6 (& -# 5-77%&&; $" $+% 53F.% %#7"F#$%.; 8+(7+ 9"%& #"$
.%#"F#7% $+% _F%&$("# "0 H%(#/> W". M%(9%//%.B $+(& -77%&& $" $+% 3.-V(& "0
2(0% (& $" H% +-9 (# '"= $+(#/& -.% /('%#]"3%# $" 2('(#/ 3%.S7%3$("#> *+% 53F.%
%#7"F#$%.; 7-# H% -99.%&&%9 $+."F/+ 8+-$ (& 5(#9(7-$r%9s; "0 ($ (# -#9 9% 3%.S
7%3$("# 0". $+% 2('(#/>)) *+% -9'-#$-/% (# 7"#&(9%.(#/ $+% 5(#9(7-$("#; "0 $+%
53F.% %#7"F#$%.; (& $+-$ H1 -99.%&&(#/ ($ (#9(.%7$21 0."6 #'*% &(9% "0 .%-&"#B
$+% _F%&$("# "0 H%(#/ (& #"$ $+%.%H1 3.%S%63$%9 ". &(6321 .%#"F#7%9>
Q77".9(#/21B $+% _F%&$("# "0 H%(#/ 6-1 H% -H2% $" H% -77%&&%9B -#9 572-&&(7-2
#(+(2(&6; -00(.6%9B (0 ($ 7"6%& $" H% -99.%&&%9 $+."F/+ $+% $.-7% `AI,)a "0 $+%
53F.% %#7"F#$%.; (# $+% 9"6-(# "0 '-2F-$("#&B 8+(7+ (& $" &-1B 2('(#/ 7"/#(S
$("#> M%(9%//%. $+F& -&T& (0 $+% %#7"F#$%. (&4
#-6%9 H1 r($&s (#9(7-$("# (# $+-$ 8+%.%H1 ($ 7"6%& $" H% +)",?'# `@,?$+J
)9/'#a $" F&B $+."F/+ &(/+$B +%-.(#/B &6%22B $-&$%B $"F7+ -#9 %'%.1 &".$ "0
0%%2(#/ `O$%I,U)ai L#% #-6%& $+% /('%# $+% 6-#(0"29 "0 5&%#&-$("#&;> b-#$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
A,'9*4 394*; XJ
XN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Y$ (& 0%%2(#/& 8+(7+ 5(#9(7-$%; $+% 53F.% %#7"F#$%.; -#9 &" I"%$ $+% _F%&$("# "0
H%(#/ 8($+"F$ -99.%&&(#/ ($ -& &F7+ &") #'$& )$&",&/*&? *# H1 3"&($(#/ H%(#/ -&
- '-2F%> *+% 5$+."#/ "0 &%#&-$("#&; 8+(7+ b-#$ .%6-.T& "#B 0". %V-632%B
-22"8& -77%&& $" $+% 5&%20S/('(#/; (# $+% %#7"F#$%. 8+(7+ 7"#&$($F$%& $+%
2('(#/ H%(#/> Y$ (&4
6F992%B $+-$ 8+(7+ H%&%$&B T%%3& HF&1B 7"#7%.#&B 02""9& -#9 HF.."8&
$+."F/+ F& h -33-.%#$21 6".% %V-7$21 "#% &3%-T& r+%.%s "0 5"F. H"91; h
#"$ "#21 (# r$+(&s (#&$-#$ "0 3%.7%3$("# HF$ 7"#$(#F-221 -#9 "'%.-22> W". -$
"#7% -#9 $"/%$+%. 8($+ $+% /('%# "0 $+% #-6%9 -#9 7($%9 "F$%. &%#&%B
r$+%.%s F./% -#9 &$(.B 9.(0$ -#9 02"-$B 9%$-(# -#9 3F&+B $%-. -#9 7-..1 $+%
50%%2(#/& `65I2*&.,&?$&a; "0 5(##%.; &%#&% 8+(7+ "#% %&$-H2(&+%& h -/-(#
-33-.%#$21 6".% -77F.-$%21 -#9 7"..%7$21 h -& H"91S&$-$%&>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)-B JNDhJm )XX)-B C?hXa
*+% H"91 (& $+% 7-$%/".1 "0 $+% 5$+."#/ "0 &%#&-$("#&;> Z1 ($& 5(##%.; -#9
5"F$%.; 0%%2(#/& $+% H"91 (#9(7-$%& $+% 7+-"& "0 $+% %#7"F#$%. 5H%+(#9; $+%
5H%2"#/(#/S$"/%$+%.; "0 `8+-$ (& $+%# 9%$%.6(#%9 (# $+% 6%$-3+1&(7& "0
3.%&%#7% -&a 2('(#/ 3%.S7%3$("# -#9 H%(#/&> *+% H"91 (& #"$ $+%# &"6%$+(#/
$+-$ %#7"F#$%.& - 7+-"& 6%.%21 $H#$)&94 $" ($> Y$ (& 5(#; $+% 7+-"&B 5(&; $+% 7+-"&
h ".B -$ 2%-&$B ($ (& "2 7+-"&> *8" 3"(#$& 0"22"84
`(a &(#7% ($ (& (#9(7-$%9 H1 $+% `7-$%/".1 "0 $+%a 2('(#/ H"91B $+% 7+-"& "0 $+%
"3%#(#/ 5(& $+% #%-.%&$B (& &" #%-. $+-$ ($ 9"%& #"$ %'%# &$-#9 55#%-.;; F&
(# &$-#9(#/ "'%. -/-(#&$ rF&sB HF$ .-$+%. 8% "F.&%2'%& -.% ($ h -& H"9(21
H%(#/& `4$*+4*/'$& P$%$&a; `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B JNJm )XX)-B CXam
`((a &(#7% $+% 5"3%#(#/; %#7"F#$%. "0 &7+%6-$(&-$("# -#9 7+-"& (& $+%
7"#9($("# "0 3%.S7%3$("#B "0 '-2F-$("#B -#9 &" "0 2(0% -& &F7+B $+% H"91
(& #" 2%&& - /"&.*#*"& "0 $+% 2('(#/B (0 ($ (& $" 2('%m (0B $+-$ (&B 2(0% (& $" 2('%4
K(0% 2('%& (# $+-$ ($ H"9(%& `B9% L$+$& 4$+#R *&.$5 $% 4$*+#a> O% 7"/#(&% H1
#"8 3%.+-3& '%.1 6F7+ -H"F$ 8+-$ 8% #-6% $+% 2('(#/ H"91 `L$*+;"U)I$)a
8($+"F$ "F. &%.("F&21 +-'(#/ $" 7"#&(9%. 8+-$ +".C*&? `L$*+$&a (&> > > > Y$ (&
$+-$ *& ='*/' r%63+> -99>s 8+-$ 8% %&$-H2(&+ "0 $+% 7"F.&%& -#9 -33%-.S
-#7%& "0 $+% H"91 "0 - 2('(#/ r$+(#/s 0(.&$ 7"6%& $" ($& "8# r3."3%.s
3."7%&&S7+-.-7$%.> P%.+-3& H"91(#/ (& (#($(-221 -# "H&7F.% $%.6B HF$ ($
#-6%& &"6%$+(#/ 8+(7+ $+% 7"/#($("# "0 $+% 2('(#/ *&*#*944C -#9 /"&%#9C
%V3%.(%#7%B -#9 6F&$ 7"6% $" H% +%29 (# 7"#&(9%.-$("#>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)-B JNJm )XX)-B CXa
Z"91(#/ (& "H&7F.% H%7-F&% ($ (& 9F-24 8+(2% ($ (& $+-$ (# 8+(7+ $+% 53."7%&&S
7+-.-7$%.; "0 $+% 2('(#/ H"91 7"6%& $" H% `7-$%/".(-221a %&$-H2(&+%9B H"91(#/
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
%'%# &3%-T& "0 $+% 5#')"&? `O$=,U'4$a "0 &%#&-$("#&;>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)-B JNDm )XX)-B C?a
A,'9*4 394*; XC
NEE
Z"91(#/ (& #"$ $+%# &(6321 $+% &%20S9%$%.6(#%9 (#9('(9F-$("# "0 - 3-.$(7F2-.
"./-#(7 F#($1 `8+(7+ 8"F29 H% ($& 7"&6"H("2"/(7-2 6%-#(#/a> *+% 2('(#/
H"91 (& .-$+%. $+% 7+-"& $+-$ 5&$.(T%&; &7+%6-$(&(#/ (# $+%(. 7"S7"#&$($F$('%
53F.% %#7"F#$%.;> M"8%'%.B &(#7% 7+-"& (& $+-$ 8+(7+ 57"/#($("# &$%3& "#$";B
($ (& #"$ .%9F7(H2% $" #". ($&%20 7"#&$($F$%9 H1 ($& %#7"F#$%. 8($+ &7+%6-$(&S
(#/> M%#7%B -& 6F7+ -& ($ (& $+% 7"#9($("# 0". `$+%a 2('(#/ -& &F7+B 7+-"& -2&"
$H/$$.% $+% &7+%6-$(&%9 7+-"& $+-$ (& $+% 2('(#/ H"91> !+-"& (# /%#%.-2 (& $+%
6(2(%F (# -#9 $+."F/+ 8+(7+ 2(0% 7"6%& $" H% 7"#&$($F$%94
*+% H"91(#/ "0 2(0% (& #"$+(#/ &%3-.-$%9 "00 H1 ($&%20B %#7-3&F2-$%9 (# $+%
57".3".%-2 H"91; (# 8+(7+ $+% 2('(#/ H"91 7-# -33%-. $" F&> G-$+%. $+%
2('(#/ H"91 (& -$ "#7% 2%$$(#/S-#9 /"(#/S$+."F/+ `B,)/'49n ,&. B,)/'J
?9&?a> *+."F/+ $+(& 2('(#/ H"91 &$.%-6& - &$.%-6 "0 2(0% "0 8+(7+ 8% "#21
&%#&% `%I,U)$&a - &6-22 -#9 02%%$(#/ r3-.$sB -#9 $+(& -/-(# "#21 (# -77".9
8($+ $+% &".$ "0 .%7%3$('($1 "0 $+% 6"6%#$-.1 &$-$% "0 $+% 2('(#/ H"91> LF.
2('(#/ H"91 (& (#'"2'%9 `%*/' Z Z Z $*&?$49%%$&a (# $+(& &$.%-6 "0 2(0%> *+-$
7+-"& "0 $+% 9"6-(# "0 0%%2(#/& 8+(7+ 8% 7"/#(&% -& $+% 9"6-(# "0 $+%
2('(#/ H"91 (& "#21 "&$ %$/#*"& "F$ "0 $+% /.%-$%. 7+-"& $+-$ (& $+% !!8".29""
($&%20>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)-B JNJhNm )XX)-B CXh?Ia
*+% 2('(#/ H"91 (& "0 $+% 8".29 -& - 9(00%.%#$(-$("# "0 ($ 9&. $+% 8".29 (& "0 $+%
2('(#/ H"91 -& - 5/.%-$%. 7+-"&;>)< U-7+ (& "2 $+% "$+%.> *8" 3"(#$& &%.'% $"
.%7"##%7$ $+% -./F6%#$ H-7T $" M%(9%//%.;& 3.(#7(3-2 7"#7%.#4
`(a
`((a
*+% 8".29S7+-"& (& H%(#/& -& - 8+"2%> *+% 2('(#/ H"91 9%$%.6(#%9
$+."F/+ 7+-"& $+F& (#'"2'%& (# M%(9%//%.;& &%#&% - #'$"4"?*/94 9%$%.S
6(#-$("# "0 2('(#/ 7"/#($("#B (0 #"$ 2(0%>
O($+ M%(9%//%.B $+%#B $+% %&&%#7% "0 2('(#/ 7"/#($("#B $+."F/+ ($&
9%&$.F7$("#B (& - 9(00%.%#$(-2 7"#&$($F$("# "0 $+% 8".29S7+-"&4 5$+% 7"/S
#(&%9 -#9 7"/#(&-H2% (& 7+-"&B HF$ 8% %#7"F#$%. ($ H"9(21m 7+-"& (& #"$
0(.&$ %#7"F#$%.%9 (# &$-$%& "0 $+% H"91B HF$ .-$+%. "F. H"91 2('%& H"91S
(#/ -& - 8-'% (# $+% &$.%-6 "0 7+-"&; `)X@XB JNX]?<a> ,F7+ 5H"91(#/;
7+-"& (& $+F& $+% "&#"4"?*/94 7"#9($("# "0 2(0%> Y$ (& $+% 5"3%#(#/; "0 3%.S
7%3$("# 9&. H%(#/&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
(&B "# $+% "$+%. +-#9B 7+-"$(7-221 5H%+(#9; &F7+ 7-$%/".(&-$("#& -#9 0(V(#/&>
Y$ (& "H&7F.% $" 7"/#($("# &(#7% ($ (& .%#"F#7%9 -& &F7+ H1 '-2F-$("#> Y$ (& $+%
"H&7F.($1 (# .%-&"# "0 $+% _F%&$("# "0 H%(#/B "0 $+% .%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F-$("#
-& &F7+B -#9 "0 $+% -00(.6-$('% %&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 0". .%-&"#> ZF$B 0". -22 ($&
"H&7F.($1B ($ (& H"91(#/ 8+(7+ (#9(7-$%& (# $F.# $+% 532-7%; "0 '-2F-$("#B -#9
&" 2(0%B $+-$ (& $" H% 9%$%.6(#%9 -#%8 -77".9(#/ $" $+% 5-00(.6-$('% %&&%#7% "0
#(+(2(&6;>
Y$ (& (# $+(& 8-1B (# ($& &3%7(0(7 H"91(#/ 9(00%.%#$(-$("# "0 - /.%-$%. 7+-"&B
$+-$ $+% 2('(#/ H"91 (& 5(#; 2(0%> ,F7+ (& $+% "#$"/%#%&(& "0 2(0% (# /%#%.-2 -#9
-& &F7+B 8+(7+ (& $" &-1 $+% "#$"/%#%&(& "0 $+% 2('(#/ 9&. $+% 8".29 h 8+(7+
(&]-.% -28-1& -#9 "#21 (#9('(9F-$%9 8".2921 2(0%B 2(0% (# 3-.$(7F2-.>)@ Z"91(#/
$+F& "77-&("#& - 5F#($1; "0 $+% 9(00%.%#$(-$%9 2(0%S8".29B "0 H%(#/& -& &F7+ -#9
-& - 8+"2%B (# 8+(7+ $+%.% 57"6%& +(&$".(7-221 $+% 6-&$%.1 "0 $+% 55$"$-2($1;; ;>
D'*% $"$-2($1 (& #"$ - 6".-2($1B -#9 &" #"$ - +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 #(+(2(&6B
HF$ - $"$-2($1 (# 2(0%S7+-"& 8($+"F$ -#1 &F3%.&%#&(H2% 7"#9($("#> Y$ $+%.%0".%
&$%3& (#$" - #%8B 58+"221 "$+%.; 7"#9($("# "0 2(0% *& $+% -7$F-2($1 "0 H"91(#/
2(0%>
Y$ (& 8($+ $+% "#$"$+%"2"/1 "0 +".C*&? $+-$ $+% '%.1 532-7%; "0 '-2F-$("# -&
&F7+ 57"6%& $" H% 9%$%.6(#%9 -#%8;> O+-$ H"91(#/ &F//%&$& (& $+-$ $+(&
532-7%; (& HF$ $+% I)9H*% "0 2(0%B $+% 3.-7$(7-2 #%%9 "0 2(0% -& H"91(#/ 2(0% (#
/.%-$%. 7+-"&4 58+-$ =(%$A&7+% 7-22& 55"F. 3.-7$(7-2 #%%9;; &$-#9& (# %&&%#$(-2
7"##%7$("#B %'%# (# %&&%#$(-2 F#($1B 8($+ $+% '($-2($1 "0 H"91(#/ 2(0%; `(H(9>B
JCIm ?DaB 8+(7+ (& $" &-1 8($+ 7+-"& -#9 $+% .%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%&B 8($+
H%7"6(#/> *+(& (& $+% 3.(6-.1 7"#9($("# -#9 "#$"$+%"2"/1 0". 2(0% (# ($&
%&&%#$(-2 H%7"6(#/ (# 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6> W". M%(9%//%.B H"91(#/SH%7"6(#/ (&
(& +"8 5=(%$A&7+% 7"#7%('%& "0 +(& 6%$-3+1&(7& -& &F7+;>
M"8%'%.4 7"#&$($F$%9 -& ($ (& H1 $+% I)9H*% "0 2(0%B M%(9%//%. .%6-.T& $+-$
H"91(#/SH%7"6(#/ #" 2%&& 9%$%.6(#%& 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 -& - )$%#*#,#*"& "0 $+%
F#(01(#/ $"$-2($1 "0 $+% 2(0%S8".29> E".%"'%.B &(#7% $+% $"$-2($1 "0 $+% 2(0%S
8".29 (# H%7"6(#/ (& 7"63.%+%#9%9 "# $+% H-&(& "0 H%2(%0B 8+(7+ (& $" &-1
I)$%$&/$B 0". M%(9%//%. $+% "#$"$+%"2"/1 "0 H"91(#/SH%7"6(#/ .%&($F-$%& 6%$-3+1&(7& "0 3.%&%#7%> *+% -./F6%#$ (& $+-$4
52(0%; (& $+% #-6% 0". +$*&?B -#9 H%(#/ 6%-#&4 3.%&%#7(#/B (#&(&$%#7%B
7"#&$-#71 `+$%#'$$&R <$%#9U&.*?;$*#aB 8($+&$-#9(#/ `%#9&.'94#$&a '-#(&+(#/
-#9 -$."3+1> Y0 2(0% *% $+%# $+(& 7+-"$(7 H"91(#/B (0 ($ "F/+$ #" +$ 3."3%.21 H%(#/B $+%# ($ 6F&$ -$ $+% &-6% $(6% -#9 %_F-221 ".(/(#-.(21 `?4$*/',)J
%I),U&?4*/'a 6-$$%. $" $+% 2('(#/ $" &$-#9 F3 $" $+% F./% -#9 $+% "'%.SF./%
U +$).)9&?aB &" $+-$B #-6%21B $+(& F./% 9"%& #"$ F./% `.)9U&?#a ($
`B)9&? ,&. [
$" &+%%. -##(+(2-$("#>
`(H(9>B JC)m ?Ja
M%(9%//%. $+%# .%'%.&%& $+% 3.%9(7-$("# -#9 &-1& 8+1 %'%# (# $+% H%7"6(#/
"0 7+-"& 5 552(0%;; (& $+% #-6% 0". H%(#/; -& 7"#&$-#714
*+(& r-##(+(2-$(#/ F./%s 7-##"$ "77F. &(#7% "$+%.8(&% $+% F./% F./%& ($&%20
-8-1 `%*/' %$4+%# F$).)9U&?#a -#9 &" 7"F29 #%'%. +$ -# F./%> O($+(# ($&
%&&%#7% "0 $+% F./% "'%.SF./(#/ ($&%20 2(%& r-# F./%s &F($-H2% $" ($B $+-$ (&B
F./(#/B $+-$ F./%& ($ $" &"# &F77F6H $" $+% F./(#/ "# `7&.)9&?aB HF$ .-$+%.
$" %#9&. (# ($B -#9 (0 "#21 &" -& #" +$ -H2% $" H% F./%-H2% "'%. ($&%20 -#9 *#%$42
"'%.SF./%>
`(H(9>a
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
X? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
*+-$ (&B `(a 2(0%S7+-"& 5F./%&; $+% &7+%6-$(&(#/ "0 7+-"&> ZF$B `((a %'%# -&
&7+%6-$(&(#/ (# $F.# F./%& -/-(#&$ $+% F./(#/S"# "0 7+-"&B 8($+"F$ ($ `(((a
7+-"& 7"F29 #"$ +-33%# 9% %,/'B -& F./(#/S"#B #". $+%# 7"F29 2(0% ". $+%
8".29 +-33%#> *+-$ (&B 8($+"F$ &7+%6-$(&(#/ H%7"6(#/ 7"F29 #"$ +-33%#>
,7+%6-$(&(#/ (& $+% /"&.*#*"& "0 '-2F-$("# 9&. H%7"6(#/> *+% 32-7% "0 '-2F-S
$("# (& $+%.%H1 #%821 9%$%.6(#%9> Y$ (& $+% 7+-"$(7 5F./%; "0 H"91(#/ 2(0% `-#9
&" "0 H%7"6(#/a 9% %,/'> O($+"F$ $+% &7+%6-$(&(#/ "0 7+-"& *& 7+-"& $+%.%
8"F29 H% #" 9(00%.%#$(-$("# "0 $+% /.%-$%. 7+-"& -#9 #" "#$"/%#%&(& "0 2(0% -&
&F7+> ,7+%6-$(&(#/ (& (# $+(& &%#&% $+% I)9H*% "0 2(0%4 #'9# $+%.% (& H"91(#/ 2(0%>
Y0 &7+%6-$(&(#/ (&B (# &+".$B $+% 9(00%.%#$(-$("# "0 7+-"& -& H"91(#/ 9&. `($&a
F./(#/S"# (# $+%(. F#($1B $+%#B 8($+ $+-$B ($ (& $+% 9(00%.%#$(-$("# h -#9
9(00%.%#$(-2 F#($1 h "0 2(0% -& H%(#/ 9&. H%7"6(#/> ZF$ 8+-$ (& (63".$-#$ $"
#"$% +%.% (& $+-$ H%(#/ -& 7"#&$-#71 -#9 3.%&%#7% 5+-33%#&;B 7"6%& $" H%
5%V%7F$%9;B -& $+% 5F./%; "0 2(0%B (0 -#9 -& 2(0% +-33%#&> Z%(#/ V,9 3.%&%#7%
-.(&%&B +-33%#&B 0."6 -#9 %*&/$ $+% &7+%6-$(&(#/ F./% "0 2(0%B "0 H"91(#/
9(00%.%#$(-$("# (#]"0 7+-"&>)D
;Z%(#/; (& #"$ $+%# 3.%&F6%9B -& 3%. O%&$%.# 6%$-3+1&(7-2 53.%S9%7(&("#;B
HF$ 7"6%& $" H% -#9 (& 7"63.%+%#9%9 2)"5 2(0% -& $+% 9(00%.%#$(-$("# "0
7+-"&> Q#9 &(#7% $+(& 9(00%.%#$(-$("# h H%(#/ h (& $+% 7"#9($("# "0 2(0% -&
&F7+B "0 `$+%a 2('(#/ (# ($& -7$F-2($1 -#9 '($-2($1]%&&%#7%B M%(9%//%. 0F.$+%.
#"$%&4 5r$s+% '($-2($1 "0 - 2('(#/ r$+(#/s 9"%& #"$ &$"3 8($+ $+(& 9%2(6($(#/
7(.7F6&7.(3$("# HF$ .-$+%. 7"#&$-#$21 H%/(#& "F$ "0 ($; `(H(9>B JC@m ?Na>
M%(9%//%. 7-# $+%# %2F7(9-$% $+% %&&%#$(-2 &%#&% "0 $+% 5"3%#(#/; $+-$ 2(%&
H%+(#9 `-#9 (& .%#"F#7%9 H1a $+% 6%$-3+1&(7& "0 3.%&%#7%B H% ($ (# $+%
+(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%&(/#-$("# "0 3%.S7%3$("# 9&. H%(#/&B ".B (# 6"9%.S
#($1B -& .%-&"#> Y# ($& %&&%#7% -& $+% I)9H*% "0 2(0%B
($ (& #"$ .%-&"# ($&%20B #"$ ($& %&&%#7%B $+-$ 9%'%2"3& ($&%20 0(.&$ "F$ "0 $+%
#%%9 "0 .%(/#(#/ "'%. 7+-"& `('9"%+$=9U4#*?,&?aB HF$ .-$+%. $+-$ ($ (& *&
*#%$42 r%63+> -99>s -2.%-91 7+-"&S3%.S7%3$("# `('9"%JX$)&$'5,&?aB (# &" 0-.
-& $+% 8(29 F./(#/S"# "#21 7"6%& $" H% 3%.S7%3$F-2 (# '(%8 "0 ".9%. -#9
7"#&$-#71 -#9B $+%.%0".%B -& $+% $+F& -#9 $+F& F./%#$ `<$.)9U&?$&.$%a
r7+-"&s (632(%& -#9 9%6-#9& $+(& ". $+-$ 6-T(#/S0(.6B $+(& ". $+-$
&7+%6-S0".6(#/ `A/'$59+*4.,&?a>
`(H(9>B JCNm ??a
Y# ($& %&&%#7%B $+%#B .%-&"# (& - 9(00%.%#$(-$("# "0 7+-"& -#9 $+% F./% $"
9(00%.%#$(-$% $+% F./(#/ 7+-"&B $" +$> W". $+% +F6-# (# ($& 6"9%.# 6%$-S
3+1&(7-2 %&&%#7%]9%$%.6(#-$("#B ($ (& 2(0% -& &F7+B 2('(#/> G%-&"# h 8+(7+ (&
%&&%#$(-221 3.-7$(7-2 .%-&"# `(H(9>B JCJm ??0>a h 2%$& 7+-"& H% 50%2$; -#9 3%.S
7%('%9 -& 7+-"&B 0%2$ -#9 3%.S7%('%9 H1 - `+F6-#a H"91B -& H%(#/B -& `7"F#$%.SaF./% $" 7+-"&> G%-&"# (& (# &+".$ $+% `6"9%.#S6%$-3+1&(7-2S
-#$+."3(7a 6"9% "0 H"91(#/B 8+(7+ "#21 5&+"8& ($&%20; -& &F7+ F3"# $+%
+(&$".(7-2 "77F..%#7% "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6> G%-&"# &+"8& ($&%20
$+%.% -& $+% 9(00%.%#$(-$("# "0 7+-"&B 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% 7-22& 5H%2(%0;>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
A,'9*4 394*; XX
)II !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
NEEE
#%/-$%& $+% 3.%'("F& %&&%#7% "0 $+% +F6-# #(+(2(&$(7-221> Y$& #%/-$("#
&$%3& F3"# $+% 9(&$(#7$("# "0 $+% +F6-#B .%-&"#> r > > > s Y# $+% #(+(2(&$(7
(#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7& -#9 ($& +(&$".1B $+(#T(#/B $+-$ (&B .%-&"#B
-33%-.& -& $+% /."F#9 -#9 /F(9(#/ 6%-&F.% 0". $+% (63"&($("# "0 '-2F%&>
r > > > s *+% #(+(2(&$(7 #%/-$("# "0 .%-&"# 9"%& #"$ +"8%'%. %2(6(#-$% $+(#TS
(#/ `)9#*"a HF$ .-$+%. $-T%& ($ $" H% (# $+% &%.'(7% "0 -#(6-2($1 `9&*594*#9%a>
L#21B -#(6-2($1 (& -2&" 2(T%8(&% -#9 -2.%-91 "'%.$F.#%9> Y$ #" 2"#/%.
"H$-(#& -& 6%.% &%#&F-2($1 -#9 -& $+% H-&%&$ (# $+% +F6-#> Q#(6-2($1 (&
$+% H"91(#/SH"91> *+(& 2-$$%. #-6% #-6%& $+% 9(&$(#7$('% F#($1 "0 $+%
&+-3(#/ 6-&$%.1 "0 -22 9.('%&B F./%&B 3-&&("#& $+-$ 8(22 2(0% ($&%20> Q#(6-2($1
2('%&B -& ($ H"9(%&B (# $+-$ ($ (& (# $+% 6"9% "0 r$+% F./% $" 7"#&$-#71s>
r > > > s G%-&"# (& "#21 - 2('(#/ r.%-&"#s -& H"91(#/ .%-&"#> r > > > s *+%
3.%'("F&21 6%$-3+1&(7-2 %&&%#$(-2 9(&$(#7$("# "0 $+% +F6-#B .-$("#-2($1B
7"6%& $" H% $.-#&3"&%9 $" -#(6-2($1 (# $+% &%#&% "0 H"91(#/>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)HB <X@hJm )XX)-B <)Ch)?a
O+-$ (& .%'-2F%9 (# /49%%*/94 #(+(2(&6 H%1"#9 ($& 9%$%.6(#-$("#& (# +(&$".S
(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (& $+% %&&%#$(-2 7+-.-7$%.(&-$("# "0 $+% +F6-#>
M"8%'%.B $+% +F6-# (& #"8 .%'-2F%9 -& - H"91(#/SH%7"6(#/B -& -# -#(6-2S
($1 $+-$ (& ($&%20 5"'%.$F.#%9; 0."6 ($& 6%$-3+1&(7-2 &%#&% `0". %V-632%B -&
&"6%+"8 (# 7"#$.-&$ $" $+% +F6-#a> Q#(6-2($1 $+F& 2,42*4% 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2S
(&6;& %&&%#$(-2 .%S32-7%6%#$ "0 $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("#&
"0 $+% +F6-#>
M%(9%//%.;& "8# %V3"&($("# "0 .%-&"# (# $+% 5-00(.6-$('% %&&%#7% "0 #(+(2S
(&6; 7-# #"$ H% 0F221 9%'%2"3%9 +%.% 0". 8-#$ "0 &3-7%> *+% 0"22"8(#/
9(&7F&&("# (& 9(.%7$%9 "#21 $"8-.9& %&$-H2(&+(#/ - '%.1 3-.$(-2 72-.(0(7-$("#
"0 M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 .%-&"# F3"# $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 $+% 5%V$.%6%;
&$-/% "0 ($& 9%&$.F7$("#].%'-2F-$("# -& -#(6-2($1> W". $+(& (#$%.3.%$-$("#B
M%(9%//%. (#($(-221 %63+-&(&%& #"$ $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 7"63.%+%#S
&("# "0 .%-&"# HF$ .-$+%.B -&&F6(#/ $+% -77"632(&+6%#$ "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2S
(&6B $+% 5H"9(21;B 3%.S7%3$F-2 F./% "0 &7+%6-$(&(#/> *+(& F./% (& %2-H".-$%9 H1
/('(#/ $+% 57-&%; "0 - $.%%> [%&3($% 7+-#/%& -#9 59('%.&% 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7&; "0
55"HR%7$('%;; 7"#9($("#& &F7+ -& -$6"&3+%.%B 2(/+$B &%-&"#B -#9 &" "#B ". "0
55&FHR%7$('%;; 7"#9($("#& &F7+ -& 5$+% 7+-#/(#/ 3%.&3%7$('% "0 3%.7%3$("#;B $+%
$.%% (& #"#%$+%2%&& 51%$ -28-1& $+(& 55&-6% $.%%;; ; `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B J?@m
)XX)-B XJa> *+-$ (&B $+% $.%% 5&FH&(&$&; ". 3%.9F.%&B (& #"#%$+%2%&& 7"#&$-#$B
$+."F/+ $+% -28-1& 9(00%.%#$ %V$%.#-2 -#9 (#$%.#-2 59(.%7$; &%#&-$("#& -#9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Y# )XDIB M%(9%//%. (9%#$(0(%& $+(& .%'-2F-$("# "0 .%-&"#B -#9 $+% 7"..%2-$('%
.%'-2F-$("# "0 $+% +F6-# -& $+% 9&*594 )9#*"&94$B -& -# "#$"$+%"2"/1 "0
H"91(#/SH%7"6(#/> ,F7+ -# "#$"$+%"2"/1 2%-9& $" $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 $+%
U +$)5$&%/' 8+(7+4
[
A,'9*4 394*; )I)
Y$ *% $+% 5&-6%;B #"$ &FH&%_F%#$21 `&9/'#)9U?4*/'aB (# $+-$ 8% %&$-H2(&+ r$+(&s
"# $+% /."F#9& "0 -0$%.8-.9& -99(#/ 7"63-.(&"#& `X$)?4$*/',&?$&aB &F7+
$+-$ ($ 8-& -0$%. -22 $+% 5&-6%; $.%%B HF$ .-$+%. $+% "$+%. 8-1 -."F#94 "F.
7"6(#/S$" `T,;"55$&a $+% $.%% -28-1& -2.%-91 2""T& "F$ 0". $+% 5&-6%;>
="$ -& $+"F/+ $+% 7+-#/% "0 -&3%7$& %&7-3%& F&> L# $+% 7"#$.-.1B "#21 (0
8% 3"&($ (# -9'-#7% "'%. `,U+$) Z Z Z '*&=$?a $+% .%&3%7$('% 9('%.&($1 "0 $+%
&%20S/('%#& &F7+ - 5&-6%;B $+-$ (&B - &%20&-6% `A$4+*?$%aB 8+(7+ (& #"$ (# -#1
7-&% $+% -$ +-#9 &%20S/('(#/ /('%#B -.% 8% -H2% $" %V3%.(%#7% $+% 6-/(7 "0
$+% 7+-#/% "0 -&3%7$&>
`(H(9>a)J
*+% 7.F7(-2 3"(#$ +%.% 0". M%(9%//%. (& $+% 7"S%'-2 H"91(#/ "0 $+% $.%% `H%(#/a 9&. ($& 3%.S7%3$("#B 8+(7+ (& $+% 5"3%#; 0."6 8+(7+ $+% %V3%.(%#7%
-.(&%&> *+"F/+ $+(& (& HF$ $+% 9(00%.%#$(-2 H"91(#/ "0 $+% &$-#9(#/SF./% (# $+%
F./% "0 7+-"&B $+% 3.(#7(3-2 3"(#$ #"8 (& M%(9%//%.;& 7+-.-7$%.(&-$("# "0 $+%
532-7%; -#9 6"9-2($1 "0 $+% 5&-6%;4
*+(& 3"&($(#/ "0 - 5&-6%; (& - 0(7$("# -#9 - &%-2(#/S"F$ `6).*/'#$& ,&.
7,%.*/'#$&a> Y# ".9%. $" 9%$%.6(#% -#9 $+(#T $+% $.%% (# ($& %-7+ 7-&%
9(.%7$21 /('%# -33%-.-#7% ($& &%20&-6%#%&& 6F&$ +-'% 7"6% $" H% 0(7$("#%9
`?$.*/'#$#a H%0".%+-#9> *+(& 0.%% 0".8-.9S3"&($(#/ `X")=$?J%$#@$&a "0 - &%20S
&-6%B $+-$ (&B "0 &%20&-6%#%&&B $+(& 0(7$("#(#/ 7+-.-7$%. (& $+% %&&%#7% "0
.%-&"# -#9 $+"F/+$>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)-B J?@m )XX)-B XJa
*+-$ (&B .%-&"#;& -28-1& -2.%-91 ". 0".8-.9 3"&($(#/ "0 7"#&$-#7(%& -#9
&7+%6-$- (# 7+-"& h $+% 5&-6%#%&&; "0 $+% H%(#/ -#9 ($& 3%.S7%3$("# h (&B (#
M%(9%//%.;& $%.6& `3-.$(-221 -9"3$%9 0."6 =(%$A&7+%aB - 0(7$("#(#/> W". M%(S
9%//%.B $+%#B $+(& 57"6(#/S$"; (#9(7-$%& $+-$ $+% %&&%#$(-2 53F.% %#7"F#$%.; "0
&7+%6-$(&(#/ -#9 7+-"& (& 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 H1 0(7$("#(#/> *+"F/+ ($ (& $+% H"91S
(#/ 2(0% "0 $+% +F6-# -& 9&*594 )9#*"&94$B ($& "#$"/%#%&(& -#9 7"#9($("#B $+(&
0(7$("#(#/ (& #" 2%&& $+% &7+%6-$(&(#/ 5F./%; "0 H"91(#/ 2(0% -& &F7+> M%#7%B
$+% %&&%#7% -#9 "#$"/%#%&(& "0 2(0% -#9 H%(#/ (& - 50".8-.9 3"&($(#/; 0(7$("#S
(#/> *+(& 0(7$("#(#/ 2(%& 5H%+(#9; $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("#
"0 $+% %&&%#7% -#9 "#$"/%#%&(& "0 2(0%B - 9%$%.6(#-$("# $" 8+(7+ 7"&6"H("S
2"/1 -9+%.%&> E".%"'%.B &(#7% $+% %&&%#7% -#9 "#$"/%#%&(& "0 2(0% -.% #'$5J
%$4F$% 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 (# $+(& 8-1B $+%1 $"" -.% 2*/#*"&94> *+-$ (&B (# ($& /%#%&(&
-#9 %&&%#7%B 2(0% -#9 #(+(2(&6 `-#9 H%(#/a +-33%# -& -#9 H1 -# "&#"I"*$%*%>)N
*+% "#$"3"(%&(& "0 $+% &-6%B "0 7+-"$(7 H"91(#/B (& #"$ -$ +-#9 `($ (& #"$ "0
5$+% $+."#/ "0 &%#&-$("#&;a #".B (# ($& %V$.%6% #(+(2(&6B (& ($ -# (9%-2 `($ (& #"$
'-2F-$("#a> Y$ (&B M%(9%//%. 8.($%&B 5"'%.; $+% &%20S/('(#/ "0 $+% 53F.% %#7"F#S
$%.;>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
3%.7%3$F-2 7"/($("#& "0 ($> Q& $+% 7"#&$-#71 (# $+% 3%.S7%3$F-2 7+-"&B $+% $.%%
(# *#% 5&-6%#%&&; (& 0". M%(9%//%. #"$ -# -7$ "0 &1#$+%&(& &FH&%_F%#$ $" ($&
7"/#($("#& HF$ .-$+%. $+% &7+%6-$(&(#/ 5F./%; $+-$ (& 7-22%9 .%-&"#4
)I< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
M%(9%//%.;& "8# 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% 532-7%; $+-$ 2(%& 5"'%.; $+% &%20S/('(#/
7+-"&B 8+(7+ (& $" H% 59%$%.6(#%9 -#%8; F3"# 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6B 7-##"$ H%
$-T%# F3 +%.%> G-$+%.B $+% $8" %V3.%&& 56-#(0%&$-$("#&; "0 $+% "#$"3"(%$(7
7"#9($("# "0 2(0% -& &F7+ 8+(7+ H.-7T%$ $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 +(&$".1 "0 #(+(2(&6
8(22 H% +(/+2(/+$%9> *+% 0(.&$ (& $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 "77-&("# (#
8+(7+ ($ (& $+% (9%- 0". P2-$" -#9B (# ($& 6"9%.# '-.(-#$B $+% 5 550".6-$('%
`+*4.$&.$a;; ; $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 (6-/(#-$("# "0 b-#$ -#9 -2&" ^%.6-# Y9%-2(&6>
*+% &%7"#9 (& =(%$A&7+%;& 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 -& ($ (& (#$%.3.%$%9 (# $+% %V3"&(S
$("# -H"'%>
*+% 0".6%. 6-#(0%&$-$("# "0 0(7$("#(#/ +-& H%%# .%6-.T%9 &%'%.-2 $(6%&
-H"'% -& $+% 8".29S+(&$".(7-2 "77F..%#7% -#9 3."7%&& "0 #(+(2(&6> ZF$ ($ 7-#
#"8 -2&" H% -99%9 $+-$ 8($+ .%&3%7$ $" $+% "#$"3"(%$(7 %&&%#7% "0 2(0%B $+%
&3%7(0(7($1 "0 8".29S+(&$".(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (& $+-$ "#$"3"(%&(& (& *#%$42 0(7$("#%9 -&
- 7"#&$-#$> Y# $+% 7"#&%_F%#$ 5&%20S&-6%#%&&; "0 "#$"3"(%&(& -& - '-2F%B -#9 &"
-& 9 H%(#/B +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 532-7%&; "#$"3"(%&(& 5-H"'%;
H%(#/&B -& -28-1& -2.%-91 -+%-9 "0 h $+-$ (&B 3.(". $" h $+% 53F.% %#7"F#$%.;
(# 7+-"&> f-2F% -#9 H%(#/ -.% $+%# +%29 -& $+% 9&#$)*")B +(/+%. %&&%#7% "0
"#$"3"(%&(& -/-(#&$ 8+(7+ "#$"3"(%$(7 H"91(#/SH%7"6(#/ (& 7"63-.-$('%21
(#7"#&$-#$ -#9 9%.('-$('% `$+"F/+ $+% 2-$$%. (& (# 0-7$ -#9 (# %&&%#7% $+%
7"#9($("# "0 $+% 0".6%.a> M(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (& $+F& (#-F/FS
.-$%9 8($+B -#9 ($ (#-F/F.-$%&B $+% 5+"29(#/; "0 $+% "#$"3"(%&(& "0 2(0% -#9
H%(#/ -& - #)9&%/$&.$^ 7"#9($("#B %&&%#7%B $.F$+ -#9 '-2F% "0 2(0% -#9 H%(#/>
L# $+% "$+%. +-#9B =(%$A&7+%;& 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 %V3"&%& $+% "#$"/%#%&(&
"0 2(0% -#9 H%(#/ -& +".C*&?J+$/"5*&? -& &F7+> W". M%(9%//%.B +"8%'%.B ($
.%6-(#& %#$(.%21 7"#/.F%#$ $" +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 &(#7%
=(%$A&7+% $"" 56F&$ 0(.621 +"29 $" $+% 0(7$("#(#/ 7+-.-7$%. "0 .%-&"#B h
$+-$ (&B $" $+% 3.%S0".6(#/ -#9 0".%S&$-H(2(&(#/ `F")9,%J+$%#9U&.*?$&a 7+-.-7$%.
"0 $+% 9%$%.6(#-$("#& "0 H%(#/; `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B J?Nm )XX)-B XCa4 $+-$ (&B
%'%# =(%$A&7+%;& 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 H"91(#/ (& 8($+(# $+% 6%$-3+1&(7& "0
3.%&%#7%> M"8%'%.B &(#7% 0(7$("#(#/ (& $+% 5-00(.6-$("# "0 $+% %&&%#7% "0
#(+(2(&6; 8+(7+ 2(%& +$'*&. ($& +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 6-#(0%&$-$("#&B M%(S
9%//%. /"%& "# $" .%6-.T $+-$ 0". 5$+% 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% I)"F$&9&/$
`>$);,&2#a "0 $+(& 0(7$("#(#/B 3.%S0".6(#/ 7+-.-7$%. 9(00%.& 0". P2-$" -#9
=(%$A&7+%> W". =(%$A&7+%B $+(& 7+-.-7$%. "0 .%-&"# (& /('%# =*#' r%63+> -99>s
$+% %V%7F$("# "0 2(0% h 8($+ 3.-V(&; `(H(9>a .-$+%. $+-# H%(#/ ($&%20 0(7$("#%9 -&
- $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 '-2F% 5-H"'%; 2(0%;& 3.-V(&> O($+ =(%$A&7+% $+% "#$"3"(%$(7
%&&%#7% "0 2(0% -#9 .%-&"# (& $+%.%0".% *559&$&# $" 2(0% (# ($& -7$F-2($1> M-'(#/
#"$%9 $+(& 9(00%.%#7% H%$8%%# =(%$A&7+% -#9 5P2-$"#(7 9"7$.(#%;B M%(9%//%.
#"#%$+%2%&& 3."3"&%& $+-$ (# -00(.6(#/ 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 =(%$A&7+% -&&F6%&
-#9 %V$%#F-$%& $+% 5".$)& 6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 2(0%4 52(0%B +"8S
%'%.B =(%$A&7+% $-T%& -& $+-$ 8+(7+ (& (# $+% 3"8%. `59U/'#*&?a "0 $+% +F6-#
($&%20B (#&$-22%9 `?$%#$44#a F3"# ($&%20; `(H(9>a>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
EO
M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+% +%.% #%%9& &3%7(-2 %63+-&(& &(#7%
($ (& 7.F7(-2 $" $+% %#$(.% &%#&% "0 8+-$ (& *& 29/# -00(.6%9 `.-$+%. $+-#
-&&%.$%9a "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9B -$ "#7%B "0 ='9# -#9 '"= 2(0% (& $+F& 7"63.%S
+%#9%9> *+% (#$%.3.%$-$("# +%.% .%&$& "# $+% 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% "#$"/%#S
%&(& "0 .%-&"# -& -#(6-2($1B 8+(7+ (& -2&" $+% "&#"#'$"4"?C "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6>
W". M%(9%//%.B $+(& %#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7& 9%3%#9& "# -#9 .$)*F$% 2)"5 $+%
6"9%.# 6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% %&&%#7% "0 $+% +F6-# -& .%-&"#
`M%(9%//%. )XN)HB <XJh@IDm )XX)-B <)?h<Ca> Q& &F7+B ($ (& $+% 5%V$.%6% 3"(#$;
"0 6%$-3+1&(7&B -& M%(9%//%. %2-H".-$%& (# $+% )XDI "'%.'(%84
r"s#21 (0 .%-&"# r-#9 $+F&B (# 6"9%.# 6%$-3+1&(7&B $+% +F6-#s F#0"29&
6%$-3+1&(7-221 -& F#7"#9($("#-2 &FHR%7$('($1 -#9 $+%.%8($+ -& $+% H%(#/
"0 H%(#/& 9"%& $+% "'%.$F.#(#/ "0 $+% 3.%'("F& 3.%S%6(#%#7% "0 .%-&"#
r-#9 &" $+% +F6-#s $" $+% 3.%S%6(#%#7% "0 -#(6-2($1 "0 ($&%20 H%7"6%
F#7"#9($("#-2B $+-$ (&B #(+(2(&$(7> *+% #(+(2(&$(7 #%/-$("# "0 $+% 6%$-S
3+1&(7-2 I)$J$5*&$&/$ "0 F#7"#9($("#-2 .%-&"# r"0 $+% +F6-#sB "0 H%(#/
$+F& 9%$%.6(#%9 h -#9 #"$ ($& 0F22 .%6"'-2 h (& $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 $+%
F#7"#9($("#-2 ."2% "0 $+% H"91 -& $+% 32-7% "0 7"66-#9 `<$2$'4%#$44$a "0
-22 8".29 (#$%.3.%$-$("#>
`(H(9>B @IIm <<@a
Y#&"0-. -& -#(6-2($1 (& $+% F#(01(#/ 5$"$-2($1; "0 $+% "#$"3"(%&(& -#9
"#$"$+%"2"/1 "0 2(0%B -#9 (& $+F& $+% #(+(2(&$(7 #%/-$("# "0 $+% 3.%S%6(#%#7%
"0 .%-&"#B -#(6-2($1 (& &$(22 9%$%.6(#%9 (# $+% 532-7%; "0 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-S
3+1&(7-2 #(+(2(&6B '-2F-$("#B 3.%&%#7%> *+% 32-7% ($&%20 (& #"$ ($&%20 9%$%.S
6(#%9 -#%8 HF$ "#21 .%S32-7%9 H1 -# (66-#%#$(&6 $+-$ (& 3.%9(7-$%9 "# $+%
53.%S%6(#%#7%; "0 $+% +F6-#> *+% -#(6-2($1 7+-.-7$%.(&(#/ 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6
$+%.%H1 922*)5% $+% 3.%S%6(#%#7% "0 $+% +F6-#> Q#(6-2($1 (& $+%# `-#9
+"8%'%. 6F7+ ($ 6-1 -&&%.$ ". H% 9(.%7$%9 "$+%.8(&%a -# -#$+."3"7%#$.(&6>
!"..%2-$('%21B 8($+ 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 $+% +F6-# 7"6%& $" H% $+% 532-7% "0
7"66-#9; "'%. 2(0%B 8+%.% 2(0%B -& $+% 9(00%.%#$(-$("# "0 7+-"$(7 H"91(#/B (&
#"8 #" 2%&& $+% 8".29> M%(9%//%. .%6-.T& (# $+% )X@X 2%7$F.% 7"F.&% $+-$ 50".
=(%$A&7+% +F6-# 2(0% (& "&4C r%63+> -99>s - 6%$-3+1&(7-2 3"(#$ "0 2(0% (# $+%
&%#&% "0 $+% 558".29;; ; `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B J?Nm )XX)-B XCa> \3"# $+(& (#$%.S
3.%$-$("#B ($ $+%# `0-6"F&21a 0"22"8& $+-$ =(%$A&7+%;&4
9"7$.(#% "0 $+% &7+%6-$- .%$F.#& $" P2-$";& 9"7$.(#% "0 (9%-& &" 72"&%21 $+-$
($ (& "#21 - 9%$%.6(#-$% &".$ "0 "'%.$F.#(#/ `[5;$'),&? r5.%'%.&-2;sa "0 $+%
2-$$%.B $+-$ (&B ($ (& (9%#$(7-2 $" ($ (# ($& $%%$&/$>
`(H(9>B J?Nm XCa
[%&3($% 5"'%.$F.#(#/; P2-$"#(7 9"7$.(#%B =(%$A&7+%;& 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (& 0".
M%(9%//%. 1%$ (9%#$(7-2 $" ($ (# %&&%#7% &(#7% ($ "#21 9F32(7-$%& $+% 3.(6-.(21
-#$+."3(7 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 2(0% -#9 H%(#/> *+(& "'%.$F.#(#/ "0 .%-&"# (& +"8
M%(9%//%. (#$%.3.%$& $+% 5+F6-#(&-$("#; "0 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% &3%-T& `M%(9%/S
/%. )XN)HB @ICm )XX)-B <<XaB "#% 8+(7+ (& #"#%$+%2%&& - 59%+F6-#(&-$("#; "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
A,'9*4 394*; )I@
)ID !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
2(0% -#9 H%(#/& (# $%.6& "0 +(&$".(7-2 6%$-3+1&(7& (# $+-$ ($ 50.%%& H%(#/& 0."6
$+% '-2F%S3"&($(#/ "0 3.%'("F& +F6-#r($1s; $"8-.9& $+% "#$"S$+%"2"/1 -#9
S3"(%&(& "0 -#(6-2($1 `(H(9>a> ," 7"63.%+%#9%9B -#9 %'%# (# ($& 9%+F6-#(&-S
$("#B $+% (66-#%#$(&$ H("S"#$"3"(%&(& -#9 "#$"$+%"2"/1 "0 -#(6-2($1 (& `7"'%.$a -#$+."3"7%#$.(7 6%$-3+1&(7&>
*+(& `3-.$(-2a 7"#72F&("# $" M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 572-&S
&(7-2 #(+(2(&6; -& $+% 5%#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7&; -22"8& M%(9%//%. $" /-F/% $+%
&(/#(0(7-#7% "0 ($& +(&$".(7-2 .%-2(&-$("#&B 6"&$ #"$-H21 =-A(&6> Y# $+% 0(.&$
(#&$-#7%B $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 2(0% -& "#$"3"(%&(& 6%-#& 0". M%(9%//%. $+-$
=(%$A&7+% 9"%& #"$ $+(#T 2(0% -#9 $+% 8".29 7"&6"H("2"/(7-221 HF$
6%$-3+1&(7-221> =(%$A&7+%;& 72-&&(7-2 #(+2(&6 5H.(#/r&s "F$ $+% 7"632%$% 7+-.S
-7$%. "0 2(0% -& - 0(7$("#(#/S7"66-#9(#/; -#9B 8($+ $+-$B 5&"6%$+(#/ %2&%; (&
$" H% +%-.9 (# $+% 8".9 5H("2"/(7-2; $+-# $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0
2(0% h 5#-6%21B 8+-$ %'"=% `@$*?#a $+% %&&%#$(-2 $.-($& "0 0(7$("#(#/ -#9 7"6S
6-#9(#/; `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B N)Jm )XX)-B )<<a> *+-$ (&B 0". M%(9%//%.B
=(%$A&7+% 9"%& #"$ 7"#&(9%. 2(0% (# ($& H"9(21 -7$F-2($1B $+% H("2"/(7-2B -&
$+% %&&%#$(-2 7"#9($("# ". 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 2(0%> Y$ (& "#21 - 50".6-2 (#9(7-S
$("#; "0 $+% "&#"I"*$#*/ %&&%#7% "0 2(0% -& -#(6-2($1> Y# &+".$B 0". M%(9%//%.B
=(%$A&7+%4
9"%& &"# $+(#T $+% H("2"/(7-2B 8+(7+ (& $" &-1B $+% %&&%#7% "0 `$+%a 2('(#/B -$
-22 H("2"/(7-221> rLs# $+% 7"#$.-.1B +% (#72(#%& $"8-.9& (#$%.3.%$(#/ $+%
H("2"/(7-2 (# $+% 3."3%. -#9 &$.(7$ &%#&% h '%/%$-2($1 -#9 -#(6-2(&6 h &"&J
+*"?*/944CB $+-$ (&B I)*59)*4C ',59&4C r%63+> -99>s>
`(H(9>a
Y$ (& 3.%7(&%21 $+(& -00(.6-$("# "0 H("S"#$"I"*$%*% $+-$ 0".7%& - .%R%7$("# "0 $+%
=-A( 7"63.%+%#&("# "0 =(%$A&7+% -& -9'"7-$(#/ - H("2"/(&6> O($+ $+(&
9%2%/($(6(&-$("# M%(9%//%. 9%$-7+%& +(& "8# $+(#T(#/ `"0 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7&
"0 3.%&%#7%a -#9 -00(.6-$("#& 0."6 7"22F&("# 8($+ ". &F33".$ "0 $+% 9"6S
(#-#$ 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 %&3"F&-2& "0 =-A(&6> Q$ $+% &-6% $(6%B =-A(&6 7"F29
$+%# H% 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 -& - 6(&-33.%+%#&("# "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 -& - +(&$".S
(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 "0 .%-&"#>
ZF$ $+%.% (& -# (#+%.%#$ 7"632%V($1 (# M%(9%//%.;& 6"'%& +%.% 8($+
.%&3%7$ $" =-A(&6> W". -& 6F7+ -& $+% 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 -#(6-2($1 (# 72-&&(7-2
#(+(2(&6 9%2%/($(6(&%& $+% -33."3.(-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $+(#T(#/ H1
=-A(&6B -#(6-2($1 (& -2&" 3.%7(&%21 +"8B 0". M%(9%//%.B =(%$A&7+% 7"#S
&"2(9-$%& $+% "#$"$+%"2"/(7-2 F#(01(#/ $"$-2($1 "0 6"9%.# 6%$-3+1&(7&>
*+-$ (&B 8($+ $+% 53.(6-.(21 +F6-#; (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 2(0% -& &F7+B
=(%$A&7+% 922*)5% $"" $+% 0-$% "0 6"9%.#($1 -& ($ (& .%-2(&%9B 6"&$ H2-$-#$21
-#9 -$ $+% $(6% "0 M%(9%//%.;& 8.($(#/B H1 $+% (9%"2"/(%& -#9 %00(7(%#7(%& "0
=-A(&64
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
O
A,'9*4 394*; )IJ
*+(& 7"#&$($F$("# "0 $+% 8".29 9&. $+% +F6-# -& - /%#%.-2(&%9 H("S"#$"3"(S
%&(& `"0 - 2(0% $+-$ (& 6".% /%#%.-2(&%9 -#9 9(00%.%#$(-$%9 $+-# ($ (& 9%$%.6(#%9
H1 7"&6"H("2"/1B -&B 0". %V-632%B $+% "./-#(7a (& 8+-$ M%(9%//%. 7-22&
56-7+(#(&-$("#;> Y$ (& 7"#/.F%#$ $" $+% -#(6-2($1 7+-.-7$%.(&(#/ 72-&&(7-2
#(+(2(&6> E-7+(#(&-$("# $+%.%H1 9%$%.6(#%& 2(0% -#9 H%(#/ $" H% 7"#&$($F$%9
H1 - I)9H*% "0 7"#&$-#71 $+-$ (& ($&%20 (#+%.%#$21 -#$+."3(7> O+(7+ (& $" &-1
$+-$ 6-7+(#(&-$("# $"" (& -# -#$+."3"7%#$.(&6>
M%(9%//%. %2-H".-$%& $+% -7$F-2(&-$("# "0 $+% 5&(632(01(#/; -#9 F#(01(#/S
$"$-2 "#$"S$+%"2"/1 -#9 S3"(%&(& "0 6-7+(#(&-$("# (# $+% (#&$-#7% "0 $+%
+F6-#4
r6s-7+(#(&-$("# 6-T%& 3"&&(H2% - 0".7%S&-'(#/B $+-$ (&B -$ "#7% 0".7%S&$".S
(#/B -28-1& %'%.18+%.% "'%.&%%-H2% 6(#(&$.-$("# "0 H%(#/&> r > > > s *+%
H.%%9(#/ "0 +F6-#& > > > (& $+% &$".(#/ F3 -#9 3F.(0(7-$("# "0 0".7% `G)9U2#$a
(# $+% F#('"7($1 "0 .(/"."F&21 6-&$%.-H2% 5-F$"6-$(&6; "0 -22 9%-2(#/&
`>9&.4,&?a> L#21 8+%.% $+% F#7"#9($("#-2 &FHR%7$('($1 "0 r72-&&(7-2 #(+(2S
(&6;& -#(6-2($1s 7"6%& $" H% $+% $.F$+ "0 H%(#/& -& - 8+"2% (& $+% I)*&/*I4$
"0 - 9(.%7$('% `6*&)*/'#,&?a "0 .-7(-2 H.%%9(#/ 3"&&(H2%B 6%$-3+1&(7-221
3"&&(H2%B $+-$ (&B #"$ 6%.%21 0."6 &%20 /."8(#/ .-7(-2 0".6-$("# HF$ .-$+%.
0."6 $+% &%20ST#"8(#/ #'",?'# "0 .-7%> *+-$ (&B $+% 3.(#7(32% (& 6%$-3+1&S
(7-221 #%77%&-.1> kF&$ -& 6F7+ -& r-#(6-2($1s (& "#$"2"/(7-221 .-$+%. $+-#
H("2"/(7-221 $+"F/+$B %'%# 6".% 9"%& =(%$A&7+%;& .-7(-2 $+"F/+$ +-'% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 .-$+%. $+-# H("2"/(&$(7 &%#&%>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)HB @IXm )XX)-B <)Ih))a
*+(& (& 8+%.% $+% 0F22 7"632%V($1 "0 M%(9%//%.;& -33.-(&-2 "0 =-A(&6 -#9
6-7+(#(&-$("# 7-# H% .%/(&$%.%9> W". $+"F/+ =-A(&6 7-# 6-T% #" '-2(9
-'"8-2 $" =(%$A&7+%;& `". M%(9%//%.;&a $+(#T(#/ "# $+% 3.%&F63$("# "0 ($&
H("2"/(&6B ($ (& #"#%$+%2%&& =(%$A&7+%;& -#$+."3(7 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 2(0% 9&.
8".29 -& 6-7+(#(&-$("# $+-$ (# 0-7$ 2%#9& ($ $" $+% .-7(-2 (9%"2"/(%& "0 =-A(&6>
Q#9 ($ 9"%& #"$ RF&$ &F33".$ &F7+ (9%"2"/(%&m 8".&% &$(22B ($ %#-H2%& $+%6 H1
-00(.6(#/ $+% %&&%#7% "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 $" H% - H("S"#$"3"(%&(&> Y$ -00(.6&
$+% %&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 9&. 2(0% $" H% -# `-#$+."3(7a 6%$-3+1&(7& "0 3.%S
&%#7%>)C
Y0B $+%#B - 6%$-3+1&(7-2 $+(#T(#/ 9"%& #"$ &F00(7% $" 9%$-7+ =(%$A&7+% 0."6
=-A(&6 HF$ .-$+%.B "# $+% 7"#$.-.1 ?*F$% $+% 3.(#7(32% 0". ($& .-7(-2 3"2(7(%&B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
r$s+% 72-&&(7-2 (# $+(& &%20S&$-63(#/ "0 $+% +F6-# 8+(7+ $-T%& $+% +F6-#
($&%20 (# +-#9 7"#&(&$& (# $+% &(632% .(/". "0 &(632(0(7-$("# "0 -22 $+(#/&
-#9 +F6-#& F3"# $+% F#($1 "0 F#7"#9($("#-2 %63"8%.(#/ 2") 59%#$)C
"F$) #'$ 69)#'> *+% 7"#9($("#& "0 $+(& 6-&$%.1B $+-$ (&B -22 '-2F%&B 7"6% $"
H% 3"&($%9 -#9 9%'%2"3%9 $+."F/+ - 0F22S&$-#9(#/ 56-7+(#(&-$("#; "0
$+(#/& -#9 $+."F/+ $+% H.%%9(#/ "0 $+% +F6-#>
`M%(9%//%. )XN)HB @I?m )XX)-B <@Ia
$+%# #%($+%. 9"%& ($ &F00(7% 0". M%(9%//%. $" -'"8 - 6%$-3+1&(7-2 $+(#T(#/ "0
"#$"$+%"2"/1 (# ".9%. $" 9%$-7+ +(6&%20 %*5I4C 0."6 -# (#7(3(%#$ 7"22F&("#
8($+ =-A(&6> Q#9 #%($+%. 9"%& ($ &F00(7% $" 9%$-7+ M%(9%//%.;& "8# -00(.6-S
$("#& 0."6 -#$+."3(7 6-7+(#(&-$("#> Y#&"0-. -& M%(9%//%. -'"8& $+% 50(7$("#S
(#/; h ".B -& b.%22 $.-#&2-$%& ($B 53"%$(&(#/; h 5%&&%#7% "0 .%-&"#;)? -#9 $+%.%H1
-'"8& $+% %&&%#$(-2 "#$"3"(%&(& "0 H%(#/ `H1 $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 +(&$".(7-2S
6%$-3+1&(7-2 #(+(2(&6B 0". %V-632%aB &" $+% -#$+."3(7 6%$-3+1&(7& "0
6-7+(#(&-$("# (& -2&" -00(.6%9 *& 9 =9C `M%(9%//%. )XN)HB @@Ih)m )XX)-B
<D?hXa> *+(& (& #"$ - 6-$$%. "0 7+"(7% 0". M%(9%//%.> \3"# $+% %#9 "0
6%$-3+1&(7&B F3"# $+% -&&F63$("# "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6B 6-7+(#(&-$("#]
-#(6-2($1 (& 56%$-3+1&(7-221 #%7%&&-.1;> =-A(&6 (&B 0". M%(9%//%.B HF$ - +(&S
$".(7-2 (#&$-#7% "0 $+(& 6%$-3+1&(7-2 #%7%&&($1 8+(7+ M%(9%//%. $-T%&
=(%$A&7+% $" H% 3."3"F#9(#/>
OE
W". >$*.$??$)B +"8%'%.B -&&F6(#/ 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 #%%9 #"$ 2%-9 9(.%7$21 ".
%*5I4C $" -00(.6(#/ 6-7+(#(&-$("#]-#(6-2($1> Y$ #%%9 #"$ (0B -& M%(9%//%.
3."3"&%& `0"22"8(#/ b-#$ -#9 ,7+%22(#/ .-$+%. $+-# =(%$A&7+%aB $+% %&&%#7%
"0 "#$"3"(%&(& (& #"$ ($&%20 (66-#%#$ $" H"91(#/ `-& 8($+ -#(6-2($1a HF$ (&
.-$+%. $+-$ 8+(7+ (& 5(# ($&%20 2*/#*"&*&?;B #-6%21B 2)$$."5 `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B
N))m )XX)-B ))Xa> *+"F/+ $+%.% (& #"$ $+% &3-7% +%.% $" 0"22"8 $+."F/+
M%(9%//%.;& -00(.6-$("# "0 0.%%9"6B)X $+% 0"22"8(#/ 7-# H% #"$%94 (0 $+%
%&&%#7% "0 "#$"3"(%&(& (& 0.%%9"6 .-$+%. $+-# H"91(#/B $+% 3.(#7(32% "0 .-7(-2
H.%%9(#/ "0 +F6-#& (# -#$+."3(7 6-7+(#(&-$("# #" 2"#/%. +-& $+% 7+-.-7$%.
"0 - 6%$-3+1&(7-2 &$/$%%*#C> G-$+%.B 6-7+(#(&-$("# (#9(7-$%& $+-$ $+% 5-00(.S
6-$('% %&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6; (& 0.%%9"6B - 0.%%(#/ 2") $+% 5#%8 0.%%9"6 (# $+%
&%#&% "0 $+% &%20S2%/(&2-$("# "0 +F6-#($1; `M%(9%//%. )XN)HB @)Xh<<m )XX)-B
<@XhD)a> 5W.%%9"6; (# $+(& &%#&% (& #%($+%. - $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 #". (66-#%#$
7"#9($("# "0 H"91(#/B 2(0% -#9 H%(#/4 ($ (& $+% 0(7$("#(#/ 5-H"'%; $+% -7$F-2($1
"0 7+-"$(7 H"91(#/m ($ (& $+% 57"66-#9; "0 $+% 9(00%.%#$(-$(#/ 7"F#$%.SF./% "0
7+-"&>
W". M%(9%//%.B $+%#B $+% .%-2(&-$("# "0 $+% 5-00(.6-$('% %&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6;
-& 6-7+(#(&-$("#]-#(6-2($1 +-& - 9F-2 -#9 7"632%V 7+-.-7$%.> Q& 6F7+ -& ($
"772F9%& $+% 2)$$ 7"66-#9(#/ %&&%#7% "0 `+(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 ". 72-&S
&(7-2a #(+(2(&6 -#9 2%-9& $" $+% 3.(#7(32% "0 $+% .-7(-2 H.%%9(#/ "0 +F6-#&B
72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 #"#%$+%2%&& (#9(7-$%& -#9 *#%$42 922*)5% $+% "#$"3"(%&(& "0
2(0% -#9 H%(#/B H% ($ -& $+% +*"S"#$"S3"(%&(& -#9 S$+%"2"/1 "0 6-7+(#(&-$("#]
-#(6-2($1> Y# "$+%. 8".9&B -#$+."3(7 6-7+(#(&-$("#]-#(6-2($1 (#9(7-$%& 0".
$+% 0(.&$ $(6% $+% 0.%% 0(7$("#(#/ %&&%#7% "0 H%(#/ -& &F7+B H%1"#9 ($& +(&$".S
(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 '-2F-$("#> Q#9 ($ 9"%& &" #')",?' -#(6-2($1]6-7+(#(&-S
$("#> !2-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 $+%.%H1 /('%& -77%&& $" $+% 0.%% 7"66-#9(#/
%&&%#7% "0 H%(#/ -& &F7+> Y$ (& -# 5(#9(7-$("#; $" +"8 $+% 0.%% %&&%#7% "0
H%(#/ 5&+"8& ($&%20 (# $+% 2(/+$; `M%(9%//%. )XN)HB @<DhJm )XX)-B <D@hDa>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)IN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
A,'9*4 394*; )IC
OEE
M"8%'%.B &(#7% $+% %&&%#7% "0 "#$"3"(%&(& "#21 7"6%& $" 2(/+$ (# ($& %&&%#$(-2
0.%%9"6 8($+ $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 .%-2(&-$("# "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6B
$+% 532-7%; "0 `.%a'-2F-$("# 8+(7+ (& 9%$%.6(#%9 -#%8 H1 0.%%9"6 (& #" 2%&&
-#$+."3(7-221 &($F-$%9 $+-# $+% -#(6-2($1 8+(7+ ($ (& $" 7"F#$%.3"(#$> Y$
0"22"8& $+-$ $+% &%#&% -#9 +(&$".(7-2 -7$F-2(&-$("# "0 2(0% -& &F7+ F3"# $+%
%#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7& -& %($+%. -#(6-2($1 ") 0.%%9"6 (& #"$ 9%$%.6(#%9 H1
8+%$+%. $+% %&&%#7% "0 2(0% -#9 H%(#/ (& ($&%20 6".% ". 2%&& -#$+."3(7-221
7"#9($("#%9> Q#$+."3(&6 (& #"$ ($&%20 -$ (&&F% F#2%&& ($ (& $+% 2*/#*"&*&? %&&%#7%
"0 2(0%B $+-$ (&B $+% "#$"I"*$%*% "0 H%(#/B $+-$ (& (# _F%&$("#> ,3%7(0(7-221B $+%
(&&F% "0 -#$+."3(&6 7-##"$ H% .-(&%9 (# 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 &(#7% ($ -&&F6%&
0(7$("#(#/ -& $+% %&&%#$(-2 7"#9($("# "0 2(0%> E".% /%#%.-221B +"8%'%.B
-#$+."3(&6 (& #"$ -$ (&&F% 8+%# $+% %&&%#7% "0 H%(#/ (& +%29 $" H% -#
"#$"3"(%&(&>
*+% *%%,$ "0 -#$+."3(&6 (&B $+%#B "#% "0 - 9(&7.%3-#71 (# $+% 9%$%.6(#-$("#
-#9 7"#9($("#& "0 2(0% -& - /%#%.-2(&%9 "#$"I"*$%*% `$+% 50(7$("#(#/; %&&%#7% "0
F./(#/ 7+-"&a ". -& - /%#%.-2(&%9 H("7"&6"?$&$%*% `($& 9(00%.%#$(-2 H"91(#/S
H%7"6(#/a> O($+ M%(9%//%.B $+% $8" -.% (9%#$(0(%9 $+."F/+ 5%V$.%6% #(+(2S
(&6;B 8+(7+ -00(.6& -#9 6-T%& 3"&&(H2% $+% 5$#9I'C%*/94 3.(#7(32% "0 .-7(-2
H.%%9(#/ 9% =$44 9% $+% .%-2(&-$("# "0 - 5#%8 0.%%9"6; "0 H%(#/> *+(& (9%#$(S
0(7-$("# (& - #%7%&&($1 (0 $+% %&&%#7% `"0 $+% +(&$".(7($1a "0 2(0% -#9 H%(#/ *%
"#$"3"(%$(7> M"8%'%.4 - 9(&7.%3-#71 H%$8%%# H("7"&6"/%#%&(& -#9 "#$"3"(S
%&(&B (0 $+%.% (& "#%B 8"F29 (#9(7-$% -# "77F..%#7% -#9 -7$F-2(&-$("# "0 2(0% -&
&F7+ 8+"&% 7"#9($("# 8"F29 &"# H% 0(7$("#(#/B 0.%% ". "$+%.8(&%B #". I)*&/*J
I944C 9&#')"I*/>
O% 72"&% $+% 3.%&%#$ 9(&7F&&("# H1 3F$$(#/ $+% -#$+."3(7 -&&F63$("# "0
$+% %&&%#7% "0 H%(#/ h "#$"3"(%&(& h (#$" .%2(%0> *+(& (& 3."3"&%9 0."6 $+%
'-#$-/% "0 $+% 9('%./%#7% H%$8%%# H("7"&6"/%#%&(& -#9 "#$"3"(%&(&B 9('%./%#7% 8+(7+ (& -$ 3.%&%#$ "#21 +13"$+%$(7-24
) *+% 9(&7.%3-#71 H%$8%%# H("7"&6"/%#%&(& (# /%#%.-2 -#9 "#$"I"*$%*% (#
/%#%.-2 8"F29 &F//%&$ $+-$ $+%.% (& #" 5&$/$%%*#C; 0". $+% 9%$%.6(#-$("#
-#9 -00(.6-$("# "0 $+% 2(0%S8".29 -& -#$+."3(7 6-7+(#(&-$("#B '"=$F$) $+-$
-00(.6-$("# 6-1 $+%# H% 9(.%7$%9> *+% (..%9F7(H(2($1 "0 H("7"&6"/%#%&(&
$" "#$"3"(%&(& 8"F29 9(&%&$-H2(&+ $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 #"$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
M(&$".(7-221 -#9 %&&%#$(-221B $+%#B $" -00(.6 $+% 0.%% 0(7$("#(#/ %&&%#7% "0
"#$"3"(%&(& M%(9%//%. 6F&$ -$ "#7% -00(.6 -#9B 8($+(# $+-$ -00(.6-$("# "0
($& %&&%#7%B &"# -00(.6 52(0% (# $+% 3"8%. "0 $+% +F6-# (#&$-22%9 `?$%#$44#a F3"#
($&%20;><I K(0% V,9 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (& #"$ $" H% -00(.6%9 *& 29/#B 0". ($&%20 `-&
-#(6-2($1]6-7+(#(&-$("#aB HF$ .-$+%. (# ($& %&&%#7%B 0". 8+-$ ($ H.(#/& $"
2(/+$4 $+% -#$+."3(7 %&&%#7% -#9 "#$"$+%"2"/1 "0 "#$"3"(%&(& (# ($& 0.%%S
9"6><)
H%7-F&% ($ 9(.%7$21 _F%&$("#& $+% (63".$-#7% "0 $+% +F6-# -& $+% #%8
532-7%; "0 `.%a'-2F-$("#B HF$ .-$+%. H%7-F&% ($ 9%3"&%& $+% %#$(.% #"$("# "0
- +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 -& &F7+ `"0 8+(7+ $+% -#$+."3(&6 "0
72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6B -#9 $+% 7"#7"6($-#$ 5%#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7&; (& $+%
5-77"632(&+6%#$;a> Y# "$+%. 8".9&B (0 $+%.% (& &F7+ - 9(&7.%3-#71B $+%
%&&%#7% "0 H%(#/ -#9 2(0% 7"F29 H% 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 H1 &$*#'$) -#(6-2($1]
6-7+(#(&-$("# &") 0.%%9"6 h -#9 "#21 H%7-F&% 9(00%.%#$(-2 H"91(#/ -&
$+% 7"#9($("# "0 2(0% 7"F29 #"$ $+%# H% -$ -22 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 -& - 0(7$("#(#/>
*+% -./F6%#$ +%.% 3-&&%& $+."F/+ &%'%.-2 3"(#$& 9(&7F&&%9 -H"'%4 M%(S
9%//%.;& 3."3"&-2 $+-$ $+% -#$+."3"7%#$.(7 -7$F-2(&-$("# "0 2(0% `$+-$ (&B
"#$"3"(%&(& -& &F7+a (& $+% %&&%#7% "0 2(0% (# /%#%.-2 0". =(%$A&7+% (& 3-.$ "0
$+% (#$%.3.%$-$("# 3"&$F2-$(#/ =(%$A&7+% $" 3.%&F6% $+% `-$$%#F-$%9a
$.-#7%#9%#$-2 "#$"S$+%"2"/1 -#9 S3"(%&(& 8+(7+ 57+-.-7$%.(&%&; O%&$%.#
6%$-3+1&(7&> Y# "$+%. 8".9&B =(%$A&7+% -9+%.%& $" P2-$"#(7 9"7$.(#%>
Q77".9(#/21B (# $+% ".9%. "0 '*%#")*/94 9%$%.6(#-$("#B M%(9%//%. (#$%.3.%$&
=(%$A&7+% $" 5"'%.$F.#; P2-$";& 9"7$.(#%> ZF$B 3.%7(&%21B -& M%(9%//%. &F/S
/%&$& H1 $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7&B =(%$A&7+% 9"%& #"$> G-$+%.B
=(%$A&7+%;& 9%&$.F7$("# "0 $+% %&&%#7% "0 2(0%B 7"/#($("# -#9 .%-&"# *&
>$*.$??$)N% *&#$)I)$#9#*"& &F//%&$& $+-$ P2-$";& '*%#")*/944C 53.%7%9%#$; 9%$%.S
6(#-$("# "0 $+% %&&%#7% "0 2(0% -#9 H%(#/ (& #"$ ($& $%%$&#*94 9%$%.6(#-$("#>
Y# 0-7$ -#9 %&&%#$(-221B =*#' M%(9%//%. ($ (& !*$#@%/'$N% "#$"$+%"2"/1 "0 2(0%
8+(7+ (& $+% 7"#9($("# 0". $+% 8".29S+(&$".(7-2 "77F..%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6B
-#9 +%#7% 0". P2-$";& 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% 532-7%; "0 '-2F-$("#> *+%
&($F-$("# (& $+%# 7"632(7-$%94 ($ (& "#21 H1 &FHRF/-$(#/ $+% $%%$&#*94 7"#S
&$($F$("# "0 2(0% (# ($& "77F..%#7% -#9 -7$F-2($1 `#-6%21B $+% 9(00%.%#$(-2
H"91(#/ "0 7+-"&a $" ($& '*%#")*/94S6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("#& `.%-&"# (#
6"9%.# 6%$-3+1&(7&a $+-$ $+% "77F..%#7% -#9 3."7%&& "0 #(+(2(&6 7-# H%
($&%20 7"#&$($F$%9> *+-$ (&B #(+(2(&6 (& ($&%20 - $+"F/+$ -#9 - 53."7%&&; $+-$
2"44"=% ,I"& $+% &3%7(0(7 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 &FH&F63$("# "0 H("7"&S
6"/%#%&(& (# "#$"3"(%&(&> L.B (# $%.6& "0 8".29S+(&$".1B #(+(2(&6 0"22"8&
"#21 F3"# $+% 9%%,5I#*"& "0 - _F-&(S.-$("#-2 "#$"$+%"2"/(7-2 9%$%.6(#-S
$("# "0 H("7"&6"/%#%&(&><<
< Y# "$+%. 8".9&B $+% +(&$".1 "0 #(+(2(&6B $+% `&"S&-(9a +(&$".1 "0 $+% O%&$
$"/%$+%. 8($+ ($& 6%$-3+1&(7-2 5/."F#9 "77F..%#7%;B (& ($&%20 $+%# - 6%$-S
3+1&(7-2 .-$("7(#-$('% 0-#$-&6 `-#9 #" 2%&& -7$F-2 0". $+-$a> Y$ (& -# -7$('%
#(+(2(&6 (# $+-$ .%-&"# (& $-T%# `&F..%3$($("F&21 H1 M%(9%//%.a $" H% $+%
3.(6-.1 `-#9 5+(/+%&$;a "#$"S3"(%$(7 -7$F-2(&-$("# "0 2(0% -& &F7+B %'%#
$+"F/+ M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# #%%9 #"$ &" 9%$%.6(#% ($ `-$ 2%-&$B #"$
8($+"F$ /('(#/ F3 $+% $+"F/+$ "0 #(+(2(&6<@a> Y$ 7-# $+%# H% &%%# $+-$ (0
H("7"&6"/%#%&(& (& (..%9F7(H% $" "#$"3"(%&(& HF$ (& #"#%$+%2%&& 9%$%.S
6(#%9 0."6 $+% 2-$$%.B #(+(2(&6 9% %,/' (& -# -$$%#F-$("# "0 5P2-$"#(7
9"7$.(#%;> *+(& (& &" %'%# 2") M%(9%//%. -#9 $+% 5#%8 0.%%9"6; 8+(7+ (&
5(#9(7-$%9; H1 -#(6-2($1> O+-$ (& (63".$-#$ (# $+(& 9%9F7$("# (& $+-$
#(+(2(&6 (& #"$ -# %&&%#$(-2 -$$%#F-$("# -#9 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 6%$-3+1S
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)I? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
&(7&B HF$ - '*%#")*/94 "#%> U'%# (# $+% 5-00(.6-$('% %&&%#7%; "0 $+% 0.%%
5"3%#(#/; "0 ($& 0F$F.($1B $+%#B #(+(2(&6 (& - +(&$".(7(&6><D Y$ 0"22"8& $+-$
$+% -#$+."3(&6 8+(7+ 9%$%.6(#%& H("7"&6"/%#%&(& $" H% -# "#$"3"(%&(&
-#9 8+(7+B (# $F.#B 6-T%& 53"&&(H2%; $+% 3.(#7(32% "0 $+% .-7(-2 H.%%9(#/ "0
+F6-#& `-6"#/&$ "$+%. 6-#(0%&$-$("#& "0 -#(6-2($1 -#9 6-7+(#(&-$("#
(# $+%(. F#(7($1aB (& -2&" 7"#&$($F$%9 H1 - +(&$".(7(&6>
@ O+-$ $+%# H%7"6%& 7.F7(-2 (& -# (#'%&$(/-$("# -& $" ='$#'$)
H("7"&6"/%#%&(& (& (..%9F7(H2% $" "#$"3"(%&(& ". #"$> W".B 8($+"F$ $+%
0-#$-&6-$(7S+(&$".(7-2 &FH&F63$("# "0 $+% 0".6%. H1 $+% 2-$$%.B $+% 7"#S
7"6($-#$ 0-#$-&6 "0 -# "#$"S$+%"2"/1 `(# M%(9%//%.;& &%#&%a "0 2(0%B
$"/%$+%. 8($+ ($& 7"..%2-$('% +(&$".1 -#9 3."7%&&B #(+(2(&6B 7"22-3&%& -& $+"F/+$ -#9 -& -# -7$F-2($1> Q& $+%# 9" $+% 5F#(01(#/ $"$-2($(%&; "0 (66-S
#%#$(&$ -#(6-2($1 `$+% F#(01(#/ $"$-2 5"'%.$F.#(#/; "0 )$9%"&a -#9 6-7+(S
#(&-$("# `$+% 7"#&%_F%#$ -#$+."3(7 6%$-3+1&(7&a>
ZF$ $+(& (& -/-(# "#21 $" H%/ $+% _F%&$("# -& $" ='$#'$) $+%.% (& - 9(&7.%3S
-#71 H%$8%%# "#$"3"(%&(& -#9 - /%#%.-2(&%9 7"&6"H("/%#%&(&> ,F7+ - 9%$%.S
6(#-$("# 7-##"$ H% /-F/%9 %($+%. H1 6%$-3+1&(7-2 $+"F/+$ -2"#% `H% ($
$.-#&7%#9%#$-2(&$ ". (66-#%#$(&$a ". H1 H("2"/1 -2"#%> Y$ (& .-$+%. - 9(&7.%3S
-#71 (# -#9 H%$8%%# H"$+ $+% H("2"/(7-2 -#9 _F-&(S6%$-3+1&(7-2 `8+(7+ (&
-2&" $" &-1 7"&6"H("2"/(7-2a 9%$%.6(#-$("#& "0 2(0% -#9 7+-"&> *+% 72-.(0(7-S
$("# #%%9%9 +%.% $+%.%0".% .%_F(.%& 0F.$+%. 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 -#9 &7(%#$(0(7
.%&%-.7+ -& $" 8+-$ -#9 +"8 H("/%#%&(& "77F.&>
C$%() W". -# %V$%#9%9 +(&$".(7-221 7"#$%V$F-2 9(&7F&&("# "0 3+(2"&"3+1 (# =-A( ^%.6-#1B
&%% ,2F/- `)XX@B %&3> !+> <a 8+(7+ (& 3-.$21 9%'"$%9 $" =(%$A&7+%;& 0-$% (# $+(& 3%.("9
-& - 3."3"#%#$ "0 - H("2"/(7"S6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 #-$("#-2(&6 9&.
(#$%.S#-$("#-2(&6> *+%&% -33-.%#$21 (#7"#/.F"F& 7"63.%+%#&("#& .%02%7$ 8+-$ (&
&-2F$-.1 (# ,2F/-;& H""T4 $+-$ =-A(&6 8-& #"$ -$ -22 - 7"+%.%#$ ". +"6"/%#%"F&
3"2($(7&B 3"8%. ". $+(#T(#/ HF$ .-$+%. .('%# 8($+ 7"#02(7$F-2 -6H($("#& 8+(7+ 8%.%
6-#(0%&$ (# $+% -7-9%6(7 -#9 (#&$($F$("#-2 &$.F//2%& "'%. $+% $%-7+(#/B 9"7$.(#%
-#9 32-7% "0 3+(2"&"3+1>
< *+%&% 9" #"$ #%7%&&-.(21 7"S(#7(9% 8($+ M%(9%//%.;& "8# '%.&("# "0 8+-$ 8-&
(#'"2'%9 (# $+% -00(2(-$("# 9&. 9(&-00(2(-$("# 8($+ $+% =-A( 3-.$1B #-6%21B 8($+
.%&3%7$ $" $+% 2-$$%.B $+-$ 5(# )X@@h@D rM%(9%//%.s -00(.6%9 $+% &"7(-2 -#9 $+%
#-$("#-2 `#"$ $+% =-$("#-2 ,"7(-2(&$(7a -#9 #%/-$%9 $+% &3(.($F-2 -#9 6%$-3+1&(7-2
0"F#9-$("#& r9%$%.6(#%9s $+."F/+ $+% H("2"/(&6 "0 P-.$1 9"7$.(#%B &(#7% $+% &"7(-2
-#9 $+% #-$("#-2B -& rM%(9%//%.s &-8 ($B 8%.% #"$ $%%$&#*944C r%63+> -99>s $(%9 $" $+%
H("2"/(7-2S.-7(-2 8".29S'(%8; `M%(9%//%. )XX)HB JJ<h@a>
@ ,$-#9-.9 $.-#&2-$("#& +-'% H%%# F&%9B $+"F/+ &"6%$(6%& (# - 6"9(0%9 0".6B (# $+(&
$%V$>
g 22%.SK-F$%. `)XCD-B
D L# $+(&B &%% M--. `)XX@B )XXDa -#9B 6".% 7"#'(#7(#/21B EF
)XCDH -#9B %&3%7(-221 (# $+(& 7"#$%V$B )X?)]?<a>
J *+%.% -.% $8" &3%7(0(7 (#$%.S.%2-$%9 7"#$%V$& 0". M%(9%//%.;& 7.($(_F% "0 53.%&%.'-S
$("#; +%.%> W(.&$21B -& &$-$%9B [-.8(#(-# $+%".1 F#9%.&$""9 -& $+% 3.%&%.'-$("# "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
A,'9*4 394*; )IX
N
C
?
X
(#+%.($%9 $.-($& (# $+% /%#%.-2 5&$.F//2%; "0 $+% 2('(#/> Q2$+"F/+ $+(& (& "#21 - "#%S
&(9%9 3".$.-1-2 "0 [-.8(#;& #(7+%S-9-3$-$("# $+%".1B ($ (& - 9"6(#-#$ 2(#% "0 [-.S
8(#(&6B 3."3"&%9 9?9*&%# 3.%0".6-$("#(&6B 8+(7+ 7-# H% $.-7T%9 H-7T '(- Q9-6
,6($+ $" M"HH%&(-# -#9 =%8$"#(-# 6%7+-#(&$ '(%8& "0 #-$F.-2 3."7%&&%&> Y$ 7-# H%
$.-7T%9 0".8-.9 (#$" $+% %-.21 3-.$ "0 $+% $8%#$(%$+ 7%#$F.1 $+."F/+ $+% &$-$(&$S
(7-221 "./-#(&%9 .%&3"#&% "0 ^-2$"# -6"#/&$ "$+%.& $" $+% 5$+.%-$; "0 7"#$(#F"F&
'-.(-$("# "0 (#+%.($%9 $.-($&B #-6%214 %F/%#(7& `[%3%8 -#9 O%H%. )XXJa> *+-$
[-.8(#`(&6a 6-1 #"$ (# 0-7$ 3."3"&% 53.%&%.'-$("#; -& - 7"#9($("# 0". $+% 6-(#S
$%#-#7% "0 $+% 2('(#/ HF$ .-$+%. $+% 7"#$.-.1 $" 3.%&%.'-$("# (& #"$ $+% (&&F% +%.%>
*+% &%7"#9 -#9 +(&$".(7-221 6".% (66%9(-$% 7"#$%V$ 0". $+% #"$("# "0 53.%&%.'-S
$("#; (& M($2%.;& 9%72-.-$("# $+-$ 5r$s+% #%8 ,$-$% T#"8& #" "$+%. $-&T $+-# $+%
0F20(226%#$ "0 $+% 7"#9($("#& #%7%&&-.1 0". $+% 3.%&%.'-$("# "0 $+% 3%"32%; `7($%9
(# Q/-6H%# )XX?B !+> D lD><a> *+(& &$-$%6%#$ (& 3.%&%#$%9 H1 Q/-6H%# (# 7($-$("# 0."6 f%.&7+F%.;& $.-7$ 19%%$&'C?*$&$ 94% P*%%$&%/'92# ,&. A#99#%9,2?9+$
g +.%.
`)X@Na (# 8+(7+ ($ (& -33%#9%9 H1 $+% 7"66%#$4 5*+%&% 8".9& "0 $+% WF
6%-# $+-$ %'%.1 3"2($(7-2 -7$ "0 $+% #-$("#-2 ,"7(-2(&$ &$-$% &%.'%& $+% 2(0% "0 $+%
3%"32%> O% T#"8 $"9-1 $+-$ $+% 2(0% "0 $+% 3%"32% (& "#21 &%7F.%9 (0 $+% .-7(-2 $.-($&
-#9 +%.%9($-.1 +%-2$+ "0 $+% H"91 "0 $+% 3%"32% -.% 3.%&%.'%9; `(H(9>a> Y0 M%(9%//%.;&
.%6-.T& 7-# .%-9(21 H% $-T%# $" H% 9(.%7$%9 9?9*&%# $+% 7"S9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 %#9#*%5
-#9 2(0% -& &F7+ `8+(7+ (& 8+-$ (& 6(&&%9 H1 Q/-6H%#;& K%'(#-&(-# 7.($(_F% "0
M%(9%//%. - 0%8 3-/%& 2-$%.aB $+%# $+%&% .%6-.T& -.% -2&" 7"F#$%. $" $+% 5$"$-2($-.S
(-#(&6; 8+(7+ Q/-6H%# 0(#9& (# f%.&7+F%.;& 7"66%#$&B $+-$ 5r$s+% $"$-2($-.(-#(&6
"0 "F. 7%#$F.1 +-& ($& /."F#9 (# $+(& 91#-6(7 (9%#$($1 "0 2(0% -#9 3"2($(7&B 8($+"F$
8+(7+ ($ .%6-(#& (#7"63.%+%#&(H2%; `(H(9>a> Q/-6H%# 3."3"&%& $+(& 591#-6(7 (9%#S
$($1; $" H% -$ 2%-&$ 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7 "0 3"2($(7-2 "./-#(&-$("# (# $+% 3"&$S!2-&&(7-2 O%&$>
Q 7"#'(#7(#/ .%0F$-$("# "0 M%(9%//%.;& -./F6%#$ $+-$ &7(%#7%& $+%6&%2'%& 9" #"$
$+(#T $+%(. 6%$-3+1&(7-2 7"#9($("#& 7-# #"$ H% F#9%.$-T%# +%.%> ,F00(7% ($ $" &-1
$+-$ 8($+ .%&3%7$ $" H("2"/1 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 5&$-H(2($1; "0 2(0% 9% %,/' (& #"$ %*5I4C
$-T%# 0". /.-#$%9 H1 .%7%#$ 8".T (# $+%".%$(7-2 H("2"/1 -#9 .%&%-.7+ (# -.$(0(7(-2
2(0%> *+% (&&F% "0 8+-$ -#9 +"8 2(0%B (0 #"$ $+% 2('(#/B (& 7"#&$($F$%9 (& 7%#$.-2 $"
$+%&% 9(&7(32(#%&> Y# $+(& .%/-.9B 0". 0"F. _F($% 9(&$(#7$ (0 #"$ 9('%./%#$ %V-632%&B 70>
b-F006-# `)XX@aB G"&%# `)X?JaB E-$F.-#- -#9 f-.%2- `)X?IaB -#9 K-#/$"# `)XX)a>
Z("2"/(&6 "0 7"F.&% 3%.&(&$& $"9-1B 6"&$ /%#%.-221 (# $+% #-6% "0 &"7(-2 ". #%"S
[-.8(#(&6> Q /2-.(#/ 7"#$%63".-.1 %V-632% "0 $+% 5$"$-2 (/#".-#7%; "0 8+(7+
M%(9%//%. &3%-T& (& 3."'(9%9 H1 [-8T(#& `)X?XaB &3%7(0(7-221 (# $+% #"$("# "0 $+%
5$5$ -& - .%S($%.-$("# "0 &"6%$+(#/ 2(T% /%#%$(7 $.-#&6(&&("# H%$8%%# 3+%#"$13%&
". 5.%32(7-$".&; (..%&3%7$('% "0 $+% ".9%. "0 H("2"/(7-2 ". 7F2$F.-2 7"632%V($1>
5[%&$.F7$("#; +%.% (& $" H% $-T%# (# $+% $%7+#(7-2 &%#&% 8+(7+ M%(9%//%. -$$.(HF$%&
$" ($4 ($ (& -# (#$%.3.%$-$('% .%3%$($("# "0 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7& H1 8+(7+B -& M%(S
9%//%. .%6-.T& (# lN "0 <$*&? 9&. D*5$B $+% .%7%('%9 7"#$%#$ ". 5$+% +-.9%#%9
$.-9($("#; "0 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7& (& $+F& F#9"#% &" $+-$ 5$+"&% ".(/(#-.1 %V3%.(S
%#7%& "0 $+% 0(.&$ -#9 $+%.%8($+ /F(9(#/ 9%$%.6(#-$("#& "0 H%(#/ 7"6% $" H% 8"#;
`M%(9%//%. )X<Cm )XN<B M<<a>
*+% 5"3%#; 9(&7F&&%9 +%.% (& - 7"#&$-#$ $+%6-$(7 (#$%.%&$ 0."6 "#% %#9 "0 M%(9%/S
/%.;& $+(#T(#/ $" $+% "$+%.> Y# <$*&? 9&. D*5$B ($ (& $+% `-#$%S3.%9(7-$('%a 5 %V(&$%#S
$(-2S+%.6%#%F$(7-2 55-&;; ; "0 [-&%(#;& 57"#7%.#0F2 F#9%.&$-#9(#/; `M%(9%//%. )X<Cm
)XN<B l@)h@B %&3> M )J?a> *+% "3%# (& [-&%(#;& 56"'%6%#$ "0 7-.(#/;> b(&(%2 #"$%&B
(# $%.6& 8+"&% (63".$-#7% 8(22 H%7"6% 72%-.%. -& $+% 6-(# $%V$ 3."/.%&&%&B $+-$
%'%# (# $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 Q.(&$"$2% 0."6 )X<<B M%(9%//%. $+(#T& "0 $+% +%.6%#S
%F$(7 5-&; -& $+% 58-1 $+% 8".29 +-& -2.%-91 H%%# (#$%.3.%$%9 r8+(7+s (& 0-7$(7-221 $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
))I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
)I
))
)<
)@
(#$%.3.%$-$("# (# 8+(7+ 2(0% &$-#9&; &F7+ $+-$ 5$+% 8".29 (& (# -#9 0". 2(0%; `b(&(%2
)XX@B <JNa> Y# )X@N $+% "3%# (& 7-22%9 $+% 6)$*?&*%B -#9 (# )XDN ($ (& %V32(7$21
$+%6-$(&%9 H1 M%(9%//%. -& $+% 5%&&%#7% "0 $+% +F6-#;B 5(#&"0-. -& $+% +F6-#
(& $+% %TS&(&$(#/ "#%; `M%(9%//%. )XCNB )?Im )XX?B <NNa> *+%.-0$%. $+% "3%# (&
-99.%&&%9 H1 M%(9%//%. -& $+% &%#9(#/ ". /(0$ "0 H%(#/> *+% 3.%&%#$ 9(&7F&&("# (&
9(.%7$%9 $" %V-6(#(#/ $+% 2(6($& "0 $+% 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% 5"3%#; 3.%7(&%21 8+%#
($ 6"'%& 0."6 H%(#/ -# (&&F% "0 $+% B9%$*&%9&94C#*; $" $+% %&&%#7% "0 `+F6-#a 2(0%
-& &F7+ 0". M%(9%//%.>
*.-9($("#-221B $+(& 5%#7"F#$%.%9; 8+(7+ (& &7+%6-$(&%9 8"F29 H% 9%&(/#-$%9 6-$S
$%.> ZF$B -& 8(22 H% &%%#B -#9 9%&3($% M%(9%//%.;& .-$+%. +-&$1 0".6F2-$("# RF&$ 7($%9
(# $+% 6-(# $%V$ +%.%B $+% &7+%6-$(&(#/ 5(63"&($("#; (# -#9 "0 7+-"& (& -#$%.(". $"
$+% 0".6S6-$$%. 7"F32%$ (# $+-$ $+% &7+%6-$(&-$("# "0 7+-"& (& $+% 7"#9($("# 0".
$+% +12"6".3+(7 6"9%2 $" H% -H2% $" H% (#$%.#-221 9%6-.7-$%9 (# $+% 0(.&$
(#&$-#7%>
b(&(%2 `)XX@a &+"8& $+% 6%$+"9"2"/(7-2 (63".$-#7% "0 50".6-2 (#9(7-$("#; $"
M%(9%//%.;& %-.21 -#9 &FH&%_F%#$ 9%&$.F7$("#& "0 #"$ "#21 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7&
HF$ -2&"B -& (# $+% 6-(# 9(&7F&&("# +%.%B "0 0-7$(7($1> `<$*&? 9&. D*5$ (&B &F66-.(21B
$+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 0-7$(7($1 (# $+-$ ($ $-T%& $+% 2-$$%. -& - 50".6-2 (#9(7-$("#; "0 $+%
_F%&$("# "0 H%(#/ 0". [-&%(#a>
Q& M%(9%//%. 3"(#$& "F$ (# $+% '(7(#($1 "0 $+(& -./F6%#$B $+% 2('(#/ H%(#/ (& $+%#
&"6%$+(#/ 2(T% K%(H#(A;& 56%$-3+1&(7-2 3"(#$&; ". 6"#-9&B 5(# 8+(7+ $+% 8+"2%
8".29 /-$+%. -#9 &+"8& ($&%20 (# $+% H"F#9%9 2F6(#"&($1 "0 - 3-.$(7F2-. 3%.&3%7S
$('%; `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B JNXm )XX)-B ?<a> *+."F/+ K%(H#(AB -#9 0". -22 $+% %'(9%#$
9('%./%#7%B M%(9%//%.;& 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% 2('(#/ -& - 9(00%.%#$(-$("# "0 7+-"&
`(# H"$+ &%#&%& "0 $+% /%#($('%a 7-# H% 7"63-.%9 8($+ [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(;& `/%#%.-2S
(&-$("# "0 ,(6"#9"#;&a 7.($(_F% "0 $+% +12"6".3+(7 6"9%2 -#9 91#-6(7 (#9('(9FS
-$("#> *+% 2-$$%. 7.($(_F% (& 7-..(%9 "F$ 3.(#7(3-221 (# $+% #"$("#& "0 56-7+(#(7
02"8; `[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( )XC<B D@hJIm )X?@B @NhD)aB +-%77%($1 `[%2%FA% -#9
^F-$$-.( )X?IB %&3> !+&> )I -#9 )<aB -#9 $+% 0F#7$('% "0 7+-"& `[%2%FA%
-#9 ^F-$$-.( )XX)a> L$+%. 9('%./%#7%& #"$8($+&$-#9(#/B $+% 7"..%&3"#9%#7%
H%$8%%# 8+-$ M%(9%//%. (& 3."3"&(#/ (# $+%&% 2%7$F.%& -#9 [%2%FA%;& .%-9(#/ "0
=(%$A&7+% (& -2&" &F//%&$('%B %&3%7(-221 (0 8+-$ M%(9%//%. +%.% 7-22& 7+-"& (& (#&$%-9
7"63.%+%#9%9 -& - 6F2$(32(7($1 "0 0".7%& `[%2%FA% )XN<B !+> <a -#9 (0B -& 0". H"$+
[%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( `)X?)B <IX])C)a -#9 M%(9%//%. `-& 8(22 H% &%%# 2-$%. (# $+% 6-(#
$%V$ (# $+(& '"2F6%aB 9(00%.%#$(-$("# (& $" H% -&&F6%9 -#9 9(.%7$%9 -2"#/ -#
".(%#$-$("# /",&#$) $" H("$(7 -#(6-2($1> *+%.% (& &3-7% +%.% "#21 $" 6%#$("# $+-$
O+($%+%-9;& 53+(2"&"3+1 "0 $+% "./-#(&6; -#9 Z%./&"#;& 3+(2"&"3+1 "0 2(0% -.%
-2&" &F//%&$('%21 7"63-.-H2% $" M%(9%//%.;& $+(#T(#/ "0 5H"91(#/;>
*+% 5-.$(0(7(-2($1; "0 Q.$(0(7(-2 K(0% .%&%-.7+ (& 9%$%.6(#%9 H1 $+% /%#%.-2(&%9 -#9
-H&$.-7$ H%7-F&% 9(&S%6H"9(%9 "./-#(&-$("# "0 91#-6(7 &1&$%6&> ,F7+ &1&$%6&
&-$(&01 "$+%. 0".6-2 7.($%.(- 0". 2(0% -& $+% 59*&#$&9&/$ "0 -# (#9('(9F-$%9 &1&$%6
-$ - '-.(%$1 "0 2%'%2& "0 7"632%V($1 -#9 3."7%&&F-2 9%$%.6(#-#$&> *+%&% -.% 3.(#7(S
3-221 #%"S[-.8(#(-# 7.($%.(- "0 &%20S.%3."9F7$("# -#9 -9-3$-$("#> W". %V-632%B
K-#/$"#;& (#02F%#$(-2 %&&-1 3."3"&%& $+-$ 5- 3."3%.21 "./-#(&%9 &%$ "0 -.$(0(7(-2
r6%-#(#/ %2%7$."7"63F$-$("#-2s 3.(6($('%& 7-..1(#/ "F$ $+% &-6% 0F#7$("#-2
."2%& -& $+% H("6"2%7F2%& (# #-$F.-2 2('(#/ &1&$%6& 8(22 &F33".$ - 3."7%&& $+-$
8(22 H% 55-2('%;; (# $+% &-6% 8-1 $+-$ #-$F.-2 "./-#(&6& -.% -2('%> Q.$(0(7(-2 K(0% 8(22
$+%.%0".% H% ?$&,*&$ 2(0% h ($ 8(22 &(6321 H% 6-9% "0 9(00%.%#$ &$F00 $+-# $+% 2(0% $+-$
+-& %'"2'%9 +%.% "# U-.$+; `K-#/$"# )XXNB NXa> M"8%'%.B $+% -./F6%#$ "0 $+%
6-(# $%V$ +%.% &F//%&$& $+-$ ($ (& 3.%7(&%21 (# -&&F6(#/ 2(0% $" H% "#21 - &1&$%6 "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
A,'9*4 394*; )))
)D
)J
)N
)C
0".6-2 .%2-$("#& -#9 3."9F7$("#& 7"..%&3"#9(#/ $" #%"S[-.8(#(-# 7.($%.(- 0".
H("$(7 2(0%B -#9 (# $+F& &$(3F2-$(#/ -H&$.-7$ 9%$%.6(#-$("#& -& $+% 3.(6-.1 7"#9(S
$("#& 0". 2(0% `$+-$ (&B '-2F%& 8+(7+ 5%6%./%; -#9 -.% 7"63F$-$("#-221 6-(#$-(#%9aB
$+-$ K-#/$"# .%7"'%.& - +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 2(0% -& &F7+> *+(&
F#(2-$%.-2 &$.%&& "# $+% I)*&/*I944C 0".6-2 "#$"/%#1 "0 2(0% (& 3.%7(&%21 8+-$ (& 3F$
(#$" 9%&$.F7$("# H1 M%(9%//%.;& (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 2(0% (# ($& -7$F-2($1 0". =(%$A&7+%
-& H"91(#/SH%7"6(#/>
\#9%. $+% #-6% "0 6-(#$-(#%9 "./-#(&-$("#B 7"#&$-#71 (& - 7.F7(-2 9%$%.6(#-$("#
0". "#$"/%#1 (# 7"#$%63".-.1 $+%".%$(7-2 H("2"/1 $""B 8+%$+%. ($ (& $+-$ "0 7"632%V &%20S"./-#(&-$("# "0 6%$-H"2(7 3."7%&&%& "# $+% 5%9/%; "0 - 7+-"$(7 9(&S
$.(HF$("# "0 6"2%7F2-. (#$%.-7$("# `b-F006-# )XX@aB ". $+-$ "0 F#(0(%9 .%2-$("#-2
91#-6(7 &$.F7$F.%& -$ 8+-$%'%. .%/(&$%. "0 -7$F-2($1 -#9 ".9%. "0 7"632%V($1
`E-$F.-#- -#9 f-.%2- )X?IaB ". `0"22"8(#/ P.(/"/(#% -6"#/& "$+%.&a $+-$ "0
$+%.6"91#-6(7-221 2"7-2(&%9 50-.S0."6S%_F(2(H.(F6 9(&&(3-$('% &$.F7$F.%&; `,7+#%(S
9%. -#9 b-1 )XXJa> Q& &F//%&$%9 (# #>)J -H"'%B 7"#&$-#71 (& -2&" - 7%#$.-2 7.($%.(0". $+% 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% 2('(#/ (# &"6% Q.$(0(7(-2 K(0% $+%".1> Y# $+(& 7"#$%V$B
8+%.% ($ (& $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2($1 "0 &F7+ $+%".(%& "0 "#$"/%#1 8+(7+ (& -$ (&&F%B ($ (&
(63".$-#$ $" 9(&$(#/F(&+ $+"&% 9%$%.6(#-$("#& "0 "#$"/%#1 8+(7+ -.% 3.(#7(3-221
0".6-2 0."6 $+"&% 8+(7+B -& M%(9%//%. 3."3"&%&B -.% 7"#7%.#%9 8($+ 2(0% *& *#%
9/#,94*#C> ,F7+ - 7.($(7-2 9(&7.(6(#-$("# "0 $+% 2($%.-$F.% (& H%1"#9 $+% &7"3% "0 $+%
3.%&%#$ 9(&7F&&("#>
O% 2%-'% -&(9% $+% (&&F% "0 $(6% -#9 $%63".-2($1 8+(7+ (& 7.F7(-2 $" $+% 6%9(-$("#
"0 $+% 9('%.&($1 -#9 5&-6%#%&&; "0 $+% 57+-#/% "0 -&3%7$&; (# $+%(. &1#$+%&(& -& $+%
$.%%> Y$ 8(22 H% "#21 &F//%&$%9 +%.% $+-$ $+% 50".8-.9S3"&($(#/; &-6%#%&& M%(9%//%.
(& 9(&7F&&(#/ +%.% (& 0".6-221 72"&% $" [-&%(#;& ".(/(#-.1 $%63".-2 -#$(7(3-$("# -&
%2-H".-$%9 (# <$*&? 9&. D*5$ `M%(9%//%. )X<Cm )XN<B lNJaB #"$ 2%-&$ (# $+-$ $%6S
3".-2($1 (& $+%.% &$-$%9 $" H% 5$+% ".(/(#-.1 F#($1 "0 $+% &$.F7$F.% "0 7-.%; `)X<Cm
)XN<B M@<Ca 8+(7+B -& &F//%&$%9 (# #>X -H"'%B (& HF$ $+% 5"3%#; "0 [-&%(#;&
+%.6%#%F$(7 5-&;> *+% 0F22 %2-H".-$("# "0 $+(& +13"$+%$(7-2 F#(7($1 "0 $+% 50".S
8-.9S3"&($(#/; &1#$+%&(& "0 $+% 5&-6%; -#9 -#$(7(3-$("# -& $+% 3.(6-2 6"9% "0
$%63".-2($1 8"F29 +-'% $" /" $+."F/+ M%(9%//%.;& 9%&$.F7$("# "0 b-#$;& 0(.&$
()*#*V,$B &+"8(#/ +"8 $+% &1#$+%&(&(#/ 3"8%. "0 $+% $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 (6-/(#-$("#
(& HF$ $+% 5".(/(#-2 $%63".-2($1; "0 0(#($% `+F6-#a .%-&"# `&%% M%(9%//%. )XC@m
)XXIa>
*+% &7+%6-$(&(#/ I)9H*% "0 2(0% 7-# H% &3%7(0(7-221 7-$%/".(&%9 -& -# "#$"I"*$%*%
&(#7% ($& 0(7$("#(#/ (& 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 H1 - 2*&94*#C `M%(9%//%. )XN)-B J??hXm )XX)-B
X?h)IIa> Z.(%021B &(#7% $+% %&&%#$(-2 7"#9($("# "0 H"91(#/B H%(#/& -#9 3%.S7%3$("#
9%3%#9& "# $+% &7+%6-$(&(#/ 56-T(#/S0(.6 (# -9'-#7%; "0 7+-"&B $+% 2-$$%. (&
-28-1& 0(7$("#%9 (# 53."&3%7$ "0 7"#&$-#71;> *+(& (& $+% 52")=9).S3"&($(#/; "0 &%20S&-6% H1 $+% I)9H*% "0 2(0%> Y# $%.6& "0 Q.(&$"$2%;& 7-$%/".(%& "0 7"6(#/ $" H%B
H"91(#/ (& $+F& - I"*$%*%> O+-$ $+% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 .%-&"# 6-T%& 72%-.B 6".%"'%.B (&
$+-$ 0(#-2($1 (& #"$ "#% 7-$%/".1 -6"#/&$ -6"#/&$ "$+%.& *& .%-&"# HF$ .-$+%.
57+-.-7$%.(&%& $+% %&&%#7% "0 .%-&"# $" $+% /."F#9;> Q77".9(#/21B M%(9%//%. 7($%&
=(%$A&7+%;& &$-$%6%#$ $+-$ 50(#-2($1 (& -# %00%7$ #"$ - 7-F&%;4 ($ (& -# 5%00%7$; "0 $+%
0-7$ $+-$ $+%.% (& 2(0% -#9 H%(#/>
ZF$ &(#7% 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (& - 5$"$-2; 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 6"9%.#($1B 6-7+(#(&-$("#]
-#(6-2($1 9"%& #"$ RF&$ 7+-.-7$%.(&% =-A(&6> Y# 3-.$(7F2-.B M%(9%//%. 7-&$(/-$%&
H"$+ Q6%.(7- -#9 $+% \,,G (# 3.%7(&%21 $+%&% $%.6& `)XJ@B <?hXm )XJXB @ChXa> Q&
8%22 -& $+% /2"H-2 -#$+."3(7 "./-#(&-$("# "0 56"#&$%.& "0 %#%./1; &F7+ -& $+% G+(#%
9-6 -#9 -$"6(7 3"8%. "# 8+(7+ M%(9%//%. .%6-.T& %2&%8+%.% `&%% M%(9%//%.
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
))< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
)?
)X
<I
<)
)XJDB <<hDm )XCCB )Dh)NaB $+% F#(7($1 "0 6-7+(#(&-$("#]-#(6-2($1 7-# -2&" .%-9(21
H% -./F%9 $" 7+-.-7$%.(&% 9%'%2"36%#$& (# /%#%$(7 6"9(0(7-$("#B 0". %V-632%>
M"8%'%.B 0". M%(9%//%. =-A(&6 (& 7.F7(-2 $" 0F$F.% 9%$%.6(#-$("#& "0 $+% F#(01(#/
$"$-2($1 "0 H%(#/ (# $+-$ ($& -33%-2 $" #-$("#-2 ^%.6-#(7 .""$& (#9(7-$%& -#"$+%.
6-#(0%&$-$("# "0 "#$"3"(%&(& $" $+% "#% 8+(7+ &(6321 -&&F6%& -#9 3."6"$%& $+%
`9%a+F6-#(&-$("# "0 6"9%.# 6%$-3+1&(7&> *+(& #-$("#-2SI"4*#*/94 7"F#$%. 9%$%.S
6(#-$("# "0 "#$"3"(%&(& (& 3.(#7(3-221 ^%.6-#(7 &(#7% $+% 0.%% %&&%#7% "0 "#$"3"(S
%&(& (& 0". M%(9%//%. 2($%.-221 - ?$"S+(&$".(7-2 UF."/$&#)*/ .%-2(&-$("# `)XD<B )<Nh?m
)XX<B ?JhCa>
Q& H%7"6%& 6".% 3.%'-2%#$ 0."6 $+% )XDI& "#8-.9& -#9 7"6%& $" 9"6(#-$%
M%(9%//%.;& 3FH2(7-$("# .%7".9 0."6 $+% 2-$% )XJI&B 3-.$(7F2-.21 $+."F/+ $+%
g 29%.2(#B *.-T2 -#9 M%H%2 -#9 $+% .%02%7$("#& "# 2-#/F-/%>
(#$%.3.%$-$("#& "0 M"
Q 0F22%. %V3"&($("# "0 50.%%9"6; (# M%(9%//%.;& 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 7-.%%. 8"F29 +-'% $"
3-1 3-.$(7F2-. -$$%#$("# $" $+% 2%7$F.% 7"F.&%& "# 0.%%9"6 (# b-#$;& W(.&$ ()*#*V,$
`M%(9%//%. )X??-a -#9 "# ,7+%22(#/ `M%(9%//%. )XC)a>
W"F. &$-#9-.9 #"I"* "0 $+% M%(9%//%. 2($%.-$F.%B 8+(7+ -.% $" H% 0"F#9 (# $+%(.
F#(7($1 (# $+% )XJD %&&-1 9%'"$%9 $" $+% %&&%#7% "0 $%7+#(7&B 7-# H% $-T%# F3 -$
$+(& 3"(#$4 `(a $+% F#(01(#/ $"$-2($1 "0 6-7+(#(&-$("# "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (& 8+-$
M%(9%//%. 2-$%. 7-22& $+% O$J%#$44 "0 6"9%.# $%7+(#7& `M%(9%//%. )XJDB <?m )XCCB
<Iam `((a (0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (& (# %&&%#7% $+% 0.%% 0(7$("#(#/ %&&%#7% "0 "#$"3"(%&(&
HF$ (& (# -7$F-2($1 $%7+#(7-2 6-7+(#(&-$("# -#9 #"$ "#$"3"(%&(& 9% %,/'B $+%# $+%
%&&%#7% "0 `6"9%.#B (0 #"$ +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2a $%7+#(7& (& #"$ ($&%20 $%7+#(7-2
`(H(9>am `(((a (0 $+% 5#%8 0.%%9"6; "0 "#$"3"(%&(& (& $+% 3.(6-.1 %&&%#7% "0 2(0% -#9
H%(#/ $+%#B -& 6F7+ -& $+% -#(6-2($1]6-7+(#(&-$("# "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6 9"6S
(#-$%& $+% 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 H%(#/ -$ $+% 5%V$.%6($1; "0 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 +(&$".1B &"
($& "#$"3"(%$(7 $%%$&/$B 8+(7+ (& "772F9%9 H1 $+-$ +(&$".1B 7"6%& $" H% 6".%
g 29%.2(#;& 8".9&B
3."#"F#7%9 (# ($& ".(/(#-.1 #"#S6%$-3+1&(7-2 %&&%#7%> L.B (# M"
5r8s+%.% 9-#/%. (&B /."8&]Q2&" 9%2('%.-#7%; `(H(9>B D@m @Da> *+% 59-#/%.; +%.% (& $+-$
"0 $+% $"$-2($1 "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6;& #"#S%&&%#$(-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 H%(#/B 8+(2&$
$+% 59%2('%.-#7%; (& $+% .%-2(&-$("# "0 $+-$ %&&%#7% 9% %,/'B -& "#$"3"(%&(&> `('a Y# ($&
%&&%#7%B $+% +F6-# `_F- 2('(#/a 5%#7"F#$%.&; H%(#/& (# $+% 5"3%#; "0 "#$"3"(%&(&B
g 29%.2(# -/-(#aB ($ (& 5r"#$"Ss 3"(%$(7-221 r$+-$s $+% +F6-# 98%22&
8+%#7% `0."6 M"
"# $+(& U-.$+; `(H(9>a>
*+% #"$%& 0". $+% <$*#)9U?$ %V32(7($21 7"#0(.6 $+-$ $+% 6-$.(V 0". M%(9%//%.;&
%2-H".-$("#& "0 $+% )XJI& 8-& (# 32-7% H1 $+% 6(9S)X@I&4 56-7+(#-$("#
`39/'$&%/'92#a -& $+% %&&%#7% "0 H%(#/+""9 /('%& - 0(.&$ +(#$ $" $+% $.F$+ "0
H%1#/ `A$C&a ($&%20; `)X?XB lN)m )<Ca> *+% 0"F. 72(7+%e& RF&$ #"$%9 -H"'% 0"22"8
9(.%7$21 0."6 $+(& 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 8+-$ (& %&&%#$(-221 (63".$-#$ -H"F$ 56-7+(#-S
$("#;> O+-$ (& %63+-&(&%9 (# $+% 6-(# 9(&7F&&("# +%.% (& $+-$ (0 $+% 0.%% "#$"3"(S
%&(& "0 $+% %&&%#7% "0 H%(#/ (& $" H% -00(.6%9 $+%#B 0"22"8(#/ M%(9%//%.;&
(#$%.3.%$-$("#B $+% -#$+."3(7 O$J%#$44 "0 6-7+(#(&-$("# 6F&$ -2&" H% &" -00(.6%9>
Y$ (& $+(& .,94*#C "0 $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 "#$"3"(%&(& 8+(7+ .%6-(#& (# $+% H-7T/."F#9
"0 $+% 2-$%. $%V$&B -#9 8+(7+ 7"6%& $" H% %00%7$('%21 &(632(0(%9 H1 $+% 3.('%2%/(#/
"0 3"%$.1 -& $+% 6-#(0%&$ &($% "0 "#$"3"(%&(&>
Y$ (& (# $+(& &%#&% $+-$ M%(9%//%.;& 9%&$.F7$("# "0 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7& -#9 7"#S
7%.# 0". 3"%$.1 7-# H% $-T%# *& *#% /"'$)$&/$ 8($+ $+% #"$".("F& &$-$%6%#$ "0 )X@J
$+-$ 5r$s+% 8".T& $+-$ -.% H%(#/ 3%992%9 -H"F$ #"8-9-1& -& $+% 3+(2"&"3+1 "0
=-$("#-2 ,"7(-2(&6 +-'% #"$+(#/ $" 9" 8($+ $+% (##%. $.F$+ -#9 /.%-$#%&& "0 $+(&
6"'%6%#$ `#-6%21B $+% %#7"F#$%. `<$?$?&,&?a H%$8%%# /2"H-2 $%7+#"2"/1 -#9
6"9%.# 6-#a; `)XJ@B )XXm )XJXB )J<a> *+-$ (&B 0". M%(9%//%. $+% 5/.%-$#%&& -#9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
A,'9*4 394*; ))@
&$.%#/$+; "0 =-$("#-2 ,"7(-2(&6 (& #"$ &" 6F7+ (# ($& `+(&$".(7-2S-7$F-2a 0-7$(7($1
HF$ 6".% (# ($& 5*&&$) $.F$+ -#9 /.%-$#%&&;B 8+(7+ (& $" &-1 (# ($& "#$"3"(%$(7
%&&%#7%> *+% (&&F% "0 8+%$+%. $+% 5%#7"F#$%.; 6%#$("#%9 (# 3-.%#$+%&(& 8-&
&3"T%# ". #"$ H1 M%(9%//%. (# 9%2('%.(#/ $+% 2%7$F.% (# )X@JB ". %'%# 8.($$%# -$
$+% $(6%B (& #"$ $+% 7"#7%.# +%.% `&%% U9($".;& 7"66%#$& (# M%(9%//%. )XJ@B <@@h
Da> *+% 7"66%#$ 8"F29 (# -#1 7-&% H% 8+"221 7"63.%+%#&(H2% (# M%(9%//%.;&
$%.6& -$ $+% $(6%B -& $+% 7($-$("# 0."6 $+% <$*#)9U?$ -H"'% 6-T%& 72%-. r&%% #>)X
(#0.-s>
O+-$ (& 72%-.B $+%#B (& $+-$ (# #" 8-1 (& 5M%(9%//%.;& $+"F/+$ 7%9%9 (# 3"2($(7-2
/"5I)"5*%$ r%63+>-99>s; H1 $+% &F33".$ 0". =-A(&6B -& W1#&T `)XX@B NXa 3F$& ($B
-#9 #%($+%. (& M%(9%//%. 5H2(#9; $" 53"2($(7-2 .%-2($(%&; (# $+% %-.21 $+(.$(%&> M%(9%/S
/%.;& -00(.6-$("# "0 =-A(&6 9&. $+% 7.($(_F% "0 ($ -.%B .-$+%.B 8+"221 7"#&"#-#$
8($+ +(& 9%&$.F7$("# "0 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7& -#9 $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 $+% "#$"S
3"(%$(7 %&&%#7% "0 H%(#/> O+-$ 7"63."6(&% $+%.% (& 8($+ .%&3%7$ $" 53"2($(7-2
.%-2($(%&; (&B *& #$)5% "2 >$*.$??$)N% #'*&;*&?B (#&$%-9 $" H% 0"F#9 (# $+% F#('"7-2
9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 $+% %&&%#7% "0 H%(#/ (# 3"%$.1> *+(& 2-$$%. 9%$%.6(#-$("# $F.#&
-8-1 0."6 $+% +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 -7$F-2($1 -#9 7"#$%63".-#%($1 "0 $+-$ '%.1
%&&%#7% -& - 572-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6;> Y$ (& 3.%7(&%21 $+(& -7$F-2($1 $" 8+(7+ M%(9%//%. (&
9%%321 .%&3"#&('%B -& "F$2(#%9B (# $+% 9%7-9% ". &" 0."6 $+% %-.21 )X@I&>
<< *+% "#$"3"(%$(7 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 H("7"&6"/%#%&(& (& $.-#&3-.%#$21 3.%&%#$%9 (#
P2-$";& 3&17+"&"6-$"2"/1 -$ $+% %#9 "0 D*5o,%> Y# 3-.$(7F2-.B P2-$" 9%&7.(H%& +"8
$+% (#$%&$(#%& -.% 5$F.#%9 (# 7"(2&; H1 $+% 57"63"&%.& "0 $+% .-7% `?$&"%a; &(#7%
8($+"F$ $+(& 50".%&(/+$; 0""9 -#9 9.(#T 8"F29 53-&& $+."F/+ &" _F(7T21 $+-$ $+%
H"91 8"F29 "0 #%7%&&($1 .%_F(.% 0.%&+ #"F.(&+6%#$ RF&$ -& _F(7T21B $+%.%H1 .%#9%.S
(#/ ($ (#&-$(-H2%> ,F7+ /2F$$"#1 8"F29 6-T% r$+%s 8+"2% .-7% (#7-3-H2% "0 3+(2"S
&"3+1 -#9 $+% -.$&B -#9 (#7-3-H2% "0 +%%9(#/ $+% 6"&$ 9('(#% 3-.$ 8($+(# F&;
`C@-)hJa> W". $+% +F6-#B $+%#B 3+(2"&"3+1B -.$& -#9 $+% $+%(&6 9%3%#9 "# $+%
(#$%&$(#%> W". P2-$"B +"8%'%.B ($ (& $+% 0".6%. 8+(7+ 9%$%.6(#% $+% 0(#-2($1 "0 $+%
(#$%&$(#% -#9 -.% 5+(/+%.; $+-# ($>
g 29%.2(# 0". M%(9%//%.4 $+% 3"%$ -00(.6& $+% 0.%%
<@ *+(& (& $+% &3%7(0(7 (63".$-#7% "0 M"
%&&%#7% "0 H%(#/ -& -# `"#$"Sa3"(%&(& "0 .%-&"# 8+(7+ (& #"$ 5"'%.$F.#%9; (#$" $+%
g 29%.2(# $"
-#(6-2($1]6-7+(#(&-$("# "0 72-&&(7-2 #(+(2(&6> `*+% 3."V(6($1 "0 M"
b-#$ (& (63".$-#$ +%.% $" M%(9%//%.>a *+(& (# $F.# -22"8& $+% 5&"7(-2 -#9 $+%
#-$("#-2; $" H% 7"63.%+%#9%9 $+."F/+ -# %&&%#$(-2 57"66-#9(#/ 0.%%9"6; .-$+%.
$+-# H"91(#/> ="#%$+%2%&&B -#9 +"8%'%. (632(7($21B 53"%$(7 $+(#T(#/; (& $+%#
8+"221 7"+%.%#$ 8($+ $+% +(&$".(7-2S%&&%#$(-2 2"/(7 2%-9(#/ $" $+% -00(.6-$("# "0
=-A(&6> Y$ .%S($%.-$%& $+-$ -00(.6-$("# (# 3.(#7(32%B (0 ($ 9"%& #"$ (#&$%-9 RF&$
3.%&F33"&% ($>
<D *" H% 72%-.4 M%(9%//%.;& 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 "77(9%#$-2 +(&$".(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7& (& +(&$".(/*%5 -#9 #"$ - 59%&$(#-2 +(&$".(/94*%5;B -& k-#(7-F9 `)XXIa 3."3"&%&> *+%
2-$$%. (& - 3+(2"&"3+(7-2S6%$-3+1&(7-2 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 +(&$".1 8+%.%H1 ($ (&
"./-#(&%9 (# 0-7$ -#9 (# 6%-#(#/ (# $%.6& "0 -# (##%. #%7%&&($1> *+% 0".7% "0
g 8($+;& 9(&-/.%%6%#$ "0 M%(9%//%.a (&
$+(& 7.($(_F% `8+(7+ .%3%-$& &"6%$+(#/ "0 K"
$+-$ &F7+ - 3.(6-.(21 3+(2"&"3+(7-2S%&&%#$(-2 ". 5$.-#&7%#9%#$-2; F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0
8".29S+(&$".1 5#%F$.-2(&%& H"$+ $+% 3"2($(7-2 0(%29 -#9 .-$("#-2 3"&&(H(2($1;> *+%
6-(# $%V$ "0 $+% 3.%&%#$ 9(&7F&&("# &+"8&B "# $+% 7"#$.-.1B $+-$ `(a M%(9%//%.;&
-33%-2 $" $+% 0.%% %&&%#7% "0 "#$"3"(%&(& (& -# %00".$ $" 59*	*& $+% 53"2($(7-2 0(%29
-#9 .-$("#-2 3"&&(H(2($1; H% ($ "# - 3.(6-.(21 -#$+."3(7 H-&(&m `((a M%(9%//%.;&
$+(#T(#/ "0 $+% 0-$% "0 O%&$%.# +(&$".1 -#9 6%$-3+1&(7& (& #"$ ($&%20 "./-#(&%9
H1 -# $%%$&#*94 9%$%.6(#-$("# `0". 8+(7+ P2-$";& "#$"$+%"2"/1 (& (# 0-7$ .$)*F$.
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
))D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
A,'9*4 394*; ))J
0(D()(,1(Q/-6H%#B ^> `)XX?a >"5" A9/$)0 A"F$)$*?& E"=$) 9&. <9)$ L*2$B $.-#&> [> M%22(%.SG"-A%#B
,$-#0".94 ,$-#0".9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
[-8T(#&B G> `)X?Xa <#9 %9#> D'$ 6H#$&.$. E'$&"#CI$B LV0".94 LV0".9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
[%2%FA%B ^> `)XN<a !*$#@%/'$ $# 49 I'*4"%"I'*$B P-.(&4 P.%&&%& \#('%.&($-(.% 9% W.-#7%
`)X?@a !*$#@%/'$ 9&. E'*4"%"I'CB $.-#&> M> *"62(#&"#B K"#9"#4 Q$+2"#% P.%&&>
pp -#9 ^F-$$-.(B W> `)XC<a LN7&#*JQ$.*I$B P-.(&4 K%& %e9($("#& 9F E(#F($ `)X?@a 7&#*J
Q$.*I,%0 (9I*#94*%5 h A/'*@"I')$&*9B $.-#&> G> MF.2%1B E> ,%%6 -#9 M>G> K-#%B E(#S
#%&"$-4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
pp -#9 ^F-$$-.(B W> `)X?Ia 3*44$ I49#$9,H0 (9I*#94*%5 $# %/'*@"I')$M&*$B P-.(&4 E(#F($
`)X?Ca 7 D'",%9&. E49#$9,%0 (9I*#94*%5 h A/'*@"I')$&*9B $.-#&> Z> E-&&F6(B E(##%S
&"$-4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
pp -#9 ^F-$$-.(B W> `)XX)a ],N$%#J/$ V,$ 49 I'*4"%"I'*$SB P-.(&4 K%& %e9($("#& 9F E(#F($
`)XXDa P'9# *% E'*4"%"I'CSB $.-#&> ^> ZF.7+%22 -#9 M> *"62(#&"#B =%8 o".T4 !"2F6S
H(- \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
[%3%8B [> -#9 O%H%.B Z> `)XXJa B9)=*&*%5 6F"4F*&?0 AC%#$5% BC&95*/% 9&. #'$ O$&$9J
4"?C "2 !9#,)94 A$4$/#*"&B !-6H.(9/%B EQ>4 EY* P.%&&>
W1#&TB !> `)XX@a >$*.$??$)0 D'",?'# 9&. >*%#")*/*#C m6HI9&.$. 6.&ZWB Y$+(7-B =o4 !".#%22
\#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
M--.B E> `)XX@a !*$#@%/'$ $# 49 3$M#9I'C%*V,$B P-.(&4 ^-22(6-.9m `)XXNa !*$#@%/'$ 9&.
3$#9I'C%*/%B $.-#&> E> ^%#9.%B Q2H-#1B =o4 ,\=o P.%&&>
pp `)XXDa L9 2)9/#,)$ .$ 4N'*%#"*)$B ^.%#"H2%4 k%e."6% E(22"#>
g H(#/%#4 =(%6%1%.>
M%(9%//%.B E> `)X<Ca A$*& ,&. T$*#B *F
gH(#/%#4 =(%6%1%. `)XJXa -&#)".,/#*"& #"
pp `)XJ@a 6*&2,U'),&? *& .*$ 3$#9I'C%*;B *F
3$#9I'C%*/%B $.-#&> G> E-##+%(6B =%8 M-'%# !*4 o-2% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)XJDa 5[(% W.-/% #-7+ 9%. *%7+#(T; (# X")#)9U?$ ,&. 7,2%9U#@$B P0F22(#/%#4 =%&T%>
g #$+%.
pp `)XN)-a 5[%. O(22% AF. E-7+$ Q2& U.T%##$#(&; (# !*$#@%/'$ -B P0F22(#/%#4 ^F
=%&T%>
pp `)XN)Ha 5=(%$A&7+%& E%$-3+1&(T; (# !*$#@%/'$ --B P0F22(#/%#4 =%&T%>
pp `)XN<a <$*&? 9&. D*5$B $.-#&> k> E-7_F-..(% -#9 U> G"H(#&"#B LV0".94 Z2-7T8%22>
U +$) .9% P$%$&% .$) 3$&%/'4*/'$& :)$*'$*#B *F
gH(#/%#4
pp `)XC)a A/'$44*&?% 7+'9&.4,&? [
=(%6%1%.>
pp `)XC@a G9&# ,&. .9% E)"+4$5 .$) 3$#9I'C%*;B W.-#T0F.$ ->E>4 b2"&$%.6-##>
g H%. 9%# 55MF6-#(&6F&;; ; (# P$?59);$&B W.-#T0F.$ ->E>4 b2"&$%.S
pp `)XCNa 5Z.(%0% F
6-##>
pp `)XCCa 5*+% tF%&$("# (# !"#7%.#(#/ *%7+#"2"/1;B $.-#&> O> K"'($$B (# D'$ ],$%J
#*"& *& ("&/$)&*&? D$/'&"4"?C 9&. Q#'$) 6%%9C%B =o4 M-.3%.& u G"8>
pp `)X?<a E9)5$&*.$% pO$%95#9%,?9+$ FZiflB %9> E>,> W.(#/&B W.-#T0F.$> -> E>4 b2"&S
$%.6-##
pp `)X?Ja A/'$44*&?N% D)$9#*%$ "& #'$ 6%%$&/$ "2 >,59& :)$$."5B $.-#&> k> ,$-6H-F/+B
Q$+%#&B L+("4 L+(" \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
0."6 $+% '-2F-$("# =(%$A&7+% 3."3"&%& $" H% $+% 7"#9($("# 0". $+% 2('(#/aB 6F7+
2%&& "#% $+-$ (& 5$.-#&7%#9%#$-2;B HF$ .-$+%. H1 - 3.(6-.(21 '*%#")*/94 9%$%.6(#-$("#
`$+-$ P2-$";& 9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 "#$"$+%"2"/1 (& 3.(". $" =(%$A&7+%;& (# $F$)C
.%&3%7$am -#9 `(((a 8+(2&$ $+%&% $8" 3"(#$& 7"F29 H% &-(9 $" 3+(2"&"3+(7-221 6"$('S
-$% M%(9%//%.;& 7"22F&("# 8($+ =-A(&6B (# $%.6& "0 M%(9%//%.;& "8# 9%&$.F7$("#
$+%1 -.% #%'%.$+%2%&& 3+(2"&"3+(7-221 F#8-..-#$%9 &(#7%B 3.%7(&%21B $+% 5%&&%#$(-2;
9%$%.6(#-$("# "0 H"91(#/ (& -#$+."3(7-221 -&&F6%9>
g .7+%#B W.-#T0F.$ ->E>4
pp `)X??-a X"5 P$%$& .$) 3$&%/'4*/'$& :)$*'$*#B %9> M> E"
b2"&$%.6-##>
pp `)X??Ha 5K%$$%. "# 55MF6-#(&6;; ;B $.-#&> W> !-3FAA(B (# E9#'59);*&?%B %9> O>
E7=(%22B !-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)X?Xa <$*#)9U?$ @,) E'*4"%"I'*$mX"5 6)$*?&*%a rO$%95#9,%?9+$ FZjilB %9> W>SO> '"#
M%.6-##B W.-#T0F.$ ->E>4 b2"&$%.6-##>
pp `)XXIa G9&# 9&. #'$ E)"+4$5 "2 3$#9I'C%*/% $.-#&> G> *-0$B Z2""6(#/$"#B Y=4
Y#9(-#- \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)XX)-a !*$#@%/'$ FZ---0 D'$ P*44 #" E"=$) 9% G&"=4$.?$ 9&. 9% 3$#9I'C%*/%B %9> [>W>
b.%22B $.-#&> k> ,$-6H-F/+B [>W> b.%22B W> !-3FAA(B ,-# W.-#7(&7"B !Q4 M-.3%.!"22(#&>
pp `)XX)Ha 5["7F6%#$& 0."6 $+% [%#-A(0(7-$("# P."7%%9(#/& !"#7%.#(#/ E-.$(#
M%(9%//%.; `H(2(#/F-2aB $.-#&> k>E> O(.$+B (# O)9.,9#$ :9/,4#C E'*4"%"I'C 8",)&94 )D4<h
)J4)>
pp `)XX<a E9)5$&*.$%B $.-#&> Q> ,7+F8%. -#9 G> G"R7%8(7AB Z2""6(#/$"#B Y=4 Y#9(-#\#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
k-#(7-F9B [> `)XXIa LN"5+)$ .$ /$##$ I$&%$M$B ^.%#"H2%4 k%e."6% E(22"#m `)XXNa D'$ A'9."=
"2 D'9# D'",?'#B $.-#&> E> ^%#9.%B U'-#&$"#B YK>4 =".$+8%&$%.# \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
b(&(%2B *> `)XX@a D'$ O$&$%*% "2 >$*.$??$)N% k<$*&? 9&. D*5$NB Z%.T%2%1B !Q>4 \#('%.&($1 "0
!-2(0".#(- P.%&&>
b-F006-#B ,> `)XX@a D'$ Q)*?*&% "2 Q).$)0 A$42JQ)?9&*%9#*"& 9&. A$4$/#*"& *& 6F"4,#*"&B
LV0".94 LV0".9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
K-#/$"#B !> `)XXNa 5Q.$(0(7(-2 K(0%; (# D'$ E'*4"%"I'C "2 7)#*2*/*94 L*2$B %9> E> Z"9%#B
LV0".94 LV0".9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
E-$F.-#-B M> -#9 f-.%2-B W> `)X?Ia 7,#"I"*$%*% 9&. ("?&*#*"&0 D'$ 1$94*%9#*"& "2 #'$
L*F*&?B [".9.%7+$4 G%(9%2>
g 22%.SK-F$%.B O> `)XCD-a 5=(%$A&7+%& K%+.% '"6 O(22%# AF. E-7+$%#; (# !*$#@%/'$J
EF
A#,.*$& @>
pp `)XCDHa 5O%2$ -& O(22% AF. E-7+$; (# D*K.%/')*2# F"") :*4"%"2*$B @4)>
g H%.6%#&7+> U(# Z%($.-/ AF. M%(9%//%.&
pp `)X?)]?<a 5[-& O(22%#8%&%# F#9 9%. \
=(%$A&7+%SY#$%.3.%$-$("#%#; (# !*$#@%/'$JA#,.*$& )I]))>
P2-$"B #>9> `)XC?a 5*(6xF&; (# E49#"&*% QI$)9 #Z-XB %9> k> ZF.#%$$B LV0".94 !2-.%#9"#
P.%&&>
pp `)XX?a 5*(6-%F&; (# E49#"0 ("44$/#$. P");%B %9> k>E> !""3%.B $.-#&> [>k> q%12B
Y#9(-#-3"2(&B Y=>4 M-7T%$$>
G"&%#B G> `)X?Ja 5L./-#(&6& -& !-F&-2 ,1&$%6& O+(7+ Q.% ="$ E%7+-#(&6&4 Q# U&&-1
(#$" $+% =-$F.% "0 !"632%V($1; (# D'$")$#*/94 <*"4"?C 9&. ("5I4$H*#CB %9> G> G"&%#B
L.2-#9"B WK>4 Q7-9%6(7 P.%&&>
,7+#%(9%.B U> -#9 b-1B k> `)XXJa 5L.9%. 0."6 [(&".9%.4 $+% *+%.6"91#-6(7& "0 !"6S
32%V($1 (# Z("2"/1; (# P'9# *% L*2$S D'$ !$H# :*2#C g$9)%0 AI$/,49#*"&% "& #'$ :,#,)$ "2
<*"4"?CB %9& E> EF.3+1 -#9 K> L;=%(22B !-6#.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
,2F/-B M> `)XX@a >$*.$??$)N% ()*%*%Z E'*4"%"I'C 9&. E"4*#*/% *& !9@* O$)59&C !-6H.(9/%4
M-.'-.9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
))N !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
G%'(&($(#/ $+% O(22 $" P"8%.4 Q7$('%
=(+(2(&6 -#9 $+% P."R%7$ "0 *.-#&S
+F6-# P+(2"&"3+1
B9&*$4 ("&=9C
Q#9 9" 1"F T#"8 8+-$ 5$+% 8".29; (& $" 6%i ,+-22 Y &+"8 ($ $" 1"F (#
61 6(..".i *+(& 8".29B - 6"#&$%. "0 %#%./1B 8($+"F$ H%/(##(#/B
8($+"F$ %#9m - 0(.6B (."# 6-/#($F9% "0 0".7% $+-$ 9"%& #"$ /."8
H(//%. ". &6-22%.B $+-$ 9"%& #"$ %V3%#9 ($&%20 HF$ "#21 $.-#&0".6&
($&%20> > > > D'*% =")4. *% #'$ =*44 #" I"=$)R 9&. &"#'*&? +$%*.$%j Q#9 1"F
1"F.&%2'%& -.% -2&" $+(& 8(22 $" 3"8%. h -#9 #"$+(#/ H%&(9%&j
W.(%9.(7+ =(%$A&7+%B D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)B l)INC>
D'$ I$)2$/# &*'*4*%# h $+% #(+(2(&$;& %1% (9%-2(A%& (# $+% 9(.%7$("# "0
F/2(#%&& -#9 (& F#0-($+0F2 $" +(& 6%6".(%&4 ($ -22"8& $+%6 $" 9."3B
2"&% $+%(. 2%-'%&m ($ 9"%& #"$ /F-.9 $+%6 -/-(#&$ $+% 7".3&%2(T% 3-22".
$+-$ 8%-T#%&& 3"F.& "F$ "'%. 8+-$ (& 9(&$-#$ -#9 /"#%> Q#9 8+-$ +%
9"%& #"$ 9" 0". +(6&%20B +% -2&" 9"%& #"$ 9" 0". $+% 8+"2% 3-&$ "0
6-#T(#94 +% 2%$& ($ 9."3>
W.(%9.(7+ =(%$A&7+%B D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)B l<)>
*+(& 7+-3$%. F#9%.$-T%& -# (#'%&$(/-$("# "0 $+% 3."9F7$('% 3"&&(H(2($(%&
%#/%#9%.%9 H1 #(+(2(&6 0". $+% %V3%.(6%#$-2 3."R%7$ "0 5$.-#&S+F6-#; 3+(2"S
&"3+1> O+(2% '(%8%9 H1 &"6% 7.($(7& -& -# %'%#$ "0 &$.(7$21 #%/-$('% -#9
&$F2$(01(#/ 7"#&%_F%#7%B $+% -9'%#$ "0 UF."3%-# #(+(2(&6 6-1 -7$F-221 0F.S
#(&+ -# (#$%.3.%$('% 7"#$%V$ 8($+(# 8+(7+ 3+(2"&"3+%.& 6(/+$ 0(#-221 52%$
9."3; $+%(. #-//(#/ -#$+."3"7%#$.(7 3.%RF9(7%&> Q/-(#&$ $+% H2(/+$%9 H-7TS
9."3 "0 UF."3%-# #(+(2(&6B $+-$ (&B 3+(2"&"3+%.& 6(/+$ 3."/.%&& &(/#(0(7-#$21
$"8-.9 `-#9 %'%#$F-221 7"632%$%ia $+% F#$(6%21 -/%#9- &%$ 0". $+%6 H1
W.(%9.(7+ =(%$A&7+%4 5$" $.-#&2-$% 6-# H-7T (#$" =-$F.%; `=(%$A&7+% )X?XB
<@IaB -#9 $+F& H%+"29 $+% 8".29 (# ($& &+%%.B -6".-2 (66-#%#7%>
*"8-.9 $+(& %#9B =(%$A&7+% &F332(%& - #F6H%. "0 7"63%22(#/ (6-/%& "0 $+%
8".29 -& +% H%2(%'%& ($ 8(22 H% '(%8%9 H1 $.-#&S +F6-# 3+(2"&"3+%.&4 5$+%
(##"7%#7% "0 Z%7"6(#/;B $+% 8".29 '(%8%9 50."6 (#&(9%;B -& 5 558(22 $" 3"8%.;;
-#9 #"$+(#/ %2&%; `(H(9>B @NaB -#9B 0(#-221B -& - 56"#&$%. "0 %#%./1; `=(%$A&7+%
)XN?B l)INCa> M%.% ($ 6F&$ H% %63+-&(&%9B +"8%'%.B $+-$ $+%&% '('(9 (6-/%&
))C
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
N
-.% 2-./%21 3."9F7$& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 0%.$(2% (6-/(#-$("#> M% +-& "#21 H-.%21
%6H-.T%9 F3"# $+% 3."R%7$ "0 %V32".(#/ $+% F#9(&7"'%.%9 7"F#$.1 "0 $.-#&S
+F6-# 3+(2"&"3+1B -#9 +(& %V3%.(6%#$-2 0".6F2-$("#& 6F&$ #"$ H% 7"#S
0F&%9 8($+ $+% 0(#-2 .%-2(&-$("# "0 $+% 3."R%7$> Y# &+".$B +% (& #"$ 1%$ $+%
53%.0%7$ #(+(2(&$; +% $-T%& +(6&%20 $" H%> Y#9%%9B $+% '%.1 +(&$".(7-2 7"#9($("#&
$+-$ &-#7$("# +(& %V32".-$("#& -2&" %#&F.% +(& %'%#$F-2 0-(2F.% $" 7"632%$%
$+%6> ,($F-$%9 8($+(# $+% H%&%$$(#/ 9%7-9%#7% "0 2-$% 6"9%.#($1B +%
7-##"$ (#&F2-$% +(& $.-#&S+F6-# %V3%.(6%#$& 0."6 +(& "8# 3-.$(7(3-$("#
(# $+(& 9%7-9%#7%> Y$ (& %#$(.%21 2(T%21B (# 0-7$B $+-$ +(& H%/F(2(#/ (6-/%&
0". $+% 8".29 H%+%29 H1 $.-#&S+F6-# 3+(2"&"3+%.& .%6-(# .%&(9F-221 -#$+."S
3"6".3+(7 -#9 6".-2(&$(7> *+-$ (&B =(%$A&7+% +(6&%20 6-1 #%%9 $" H% "'%.S
7"6% "# $+% 8-1 $"8-.9 - /%#F(#%21 $.-#&S+F6-# ".(%#$-$("# $"
3+(2"&"3+1>
Y $-T% -& 61 3"(#$ "0 9%3-.$F.% (# $+(& %&&-1 =(%$A&7+%;& 0-6"F& `-#9
8(9%21S6(&F#9%.&$""9a 3."#"F#7%6%#$ $+-$ 5#(+(2(&6 &$-#9& -$ $+% 9"".;
`=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)a> Y# 3."72-(6(#/ $+% -9'%#$ "0 5UF."3%-# #(+(2(&6;B +%
9"%& #"$ 6%-# $" (6321B -& +% (& 3"3F2-.21 F#9%.&$""9 $" 72-(6B $+-$
+F6-#T(#9 #"8 H%2(%'%& (# #"$+(#/> O+(2% $+(& 59C (# 0-7$ H% $+% .%&3"#&%
"0 $+"&% #(+(2(&$& 8+" +-9 0-$F"F&21 (#'%&$%9 $+%(. +"3%& (# 5H%(#/;B 53%.6-#S
%#7%;B 57-F&-2($1;B 5^"9;B 5$.F$+;B -#9 -22 "$+%. &F3%.2-$('% '-2F%&B =(%$A&7+%
F#9%.&$-#9& #(+(2(&6 -& 9%2('%.(#/ - &(#/2%B /.-#9 `$+"F/+ /%#%.-221 F#-3S
3%-2(#/a $.F$+ h #-6%21B $+-$ $+% 8".29 -96($& "0 #" -#$%7%9%#$ 6".-2 ".9%.
". 3.%S".9-(#%9 #$4"%> *+% 8".29 &(6321 *%B (# ($& H.F$%B F#9(00%.%#$(-$%9
(66-#%#7%B -#9 ($ #"8 3.%&%#$& ($&%20 -& &F7+ 0". (#'%&$(/-$("# H1 - 0%8
(#$.%3(9 $+(#T%.&> Y$ (& =(%$A&7+%;& +"3% $+-$ +% 6(/+$ "3%# $+% 9"". $"
#(+(2(&6B (# ".9%. $+-$ +% -#9 +(& 0%22"8 0.%% &3(.($& 6(/+$ H%/(# $" 6-T%
$+% -7_F-(#$-#7% "0 $+(& F#7-##1 '(&($".>
M% 7"#&%_F%#$21 9%&7.(H%& #(+(2(&6 -& 5-6H(/F"F&;B 0". ($ 3.%&%#$& $" &"6%
(#9('(9F-2& $+% "33".$F#($1 $" 6"'% H%1"#9 $+% &$FHH".# -#$+."3"6".3+S
(&6& "0 0"2T 3&17+"2"/1 -#9 +F6-#(&6> M-'(#/ /-(#%9 (#&(/+$ (#$" $+%
#F22($1 "0 -22 +F6-# 3."R%7$("#& "#$" $+% 8".29B #(+(2(&$& 2(T% =(%$A&7+%
6-1 #"8 3."7%%9 $" 0-&+("# - 3"&$S-#$+."3"7%#$.(7B ". $.-#&S+F6-#B
".(%#$-$("# $" 3+(2"&"3+1> *+F& ".(%#$%9B 3+(2"&"3+%.& 8"F29 3.%&F6-H21
H% 0.%% $" %V32".% $+% F#9(00%.%#$(-$%9 32%#F6 "0 =-$F.% 8($+"F$ $+% 9(&$".S
$("#& (#$."9F7%9 H1 2(#/%.(#/ .%2(/("F& -#9 6%$-3+1&(7-2 3.%RF9(7%&> Q& 3.%2(6(#-.1 &$%3 $"8-.9 $+% .%-2(&-$("# "0 $+% $.-#&S+F6-# ".(%#$-$("# $"
3+(2"&"3+1B =(%$A&7+% "00%.& +(& "8# 5+13"$+%&(&; "0 #'$ =*44 #" I"=$)B 8+(7+
3F.3".$& $" H%+"29 $+% 8".29 50."6 (#&(9%;B -& - 2-'(&+21 %V$.-'-/-#$ 56"#S
&$%. "0 %#%./1;>
E
*"8-.9 $+% %#9 "0 Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94%B =(%$A&7+% 3-.%#$+%$(7-221
3."6(&%& +(& 0-($+0F2 .%-9%.& $+-$ +% 8(22 &""# 9%2('%. -# %&&-14
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
))? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
B9&*$4 ("&=9C ))X
=(%$A&7+%;& 3."6(&% 8-& #%($+%. .%7T2%&& #". F#0"F#9%9> M% 6%#$("#&
5#(+(2(&6; "# 0"F. "77-&("#& (# $+% O$&$94"?C ($&%20B -#9 +(& #"$%H""T
%#$.(%& 0."6 $+(& 3%.("9 (#9(7-$% $+-$ +% +-9 (# 0-7$ %6H-.T%9 F3"# /%#%-2"/(7-2 -#-21&(& "0 5UF."3%-# #(+(2(&6;>< o%$ $+% 3."6(&%9 %&&-1 #%'%.
-33%-.%9>
Y# )???B (# 0-7$B =(%$A&7+% &F99%#21 -H-#9"#%9 $+% 3."3"&%9 >9,I#=$); $"
8+(7+ $+(& 7($-$("# -9'%.$& (# ".9%. $" $-T% F3 1%$ -#"$+%. _F-9.-3-.$($%
3."R%7$B@ 8+(7+ +% 3."'(&("#-221 %#$($2%9 D'$ 1$F94,9#*"& "2 744 X94,$%>D M"8S
%'%.B +% &FH&%_F%#$21 -H-#9"#%9 #'*% 3."R%7$ -& 8%22B -33-.%#$21 9%7(9(#/ $"
-22"8 $+% 50(.&$ H""T; "0 D'$ 1$F94,9#*"& "2 744 X94,$% h T#"8# $" F& -& D'$
7&#*/')*%#m*9&a h $" &$-#9 -& $+% 8+"2%>J =(%$A&7+% $+F& .%#%/%9 "# +(& 3."S
6(&% #"$ "#7%B HF$ $8(7%> Y#9%%9B $+% 1%-. 0"22"8(#/ $+% 3FH2(7-$("# "0 +(&
Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94% 8-& $+% 6"&$ 3."9F7$('% "0 +(& 2(0%> P.%&F6-H21B +%
$+F& +-9 %'%.1 "33".$F#($1 $" 3."9F7% -# %&&-1 5L# $+% M(&$".1 "0 UF."3%-#
=(+(2(&6; (0 +% 8%.% &" (#72(#%9> ZF$ +% %2%7$%9 $" 9(.%7$ +(& %#%./(%& %2&%S
8+%.%> Q#1 .%7"#&$.F7$("# "0 +(& -77"F#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 $+F& (#'"2'%& - 9%2(7-$%
%V%/%$(7-2 3."R%7$B 0". "#% 6F&$ .%21 %V$%#&('%21 "# $+% F#3"2(&+%9B %3(/.-6S
6-$(7 #"$%& 0."6 +(& !9/'49%%> L#% 6F&$ -2&" 3."7%%9 F#9%. $+% 7-F$("# $+-$
=(%$A&7+% +(6&%20 #%'%. %V%7F$%9 $+(& 3."R%7$B 9%&3($% -33-.%#$21 +-'(#/
&F00(7(%#$ $(6% -#9 "33".$F#($1 $" 9" &">
K%$ F& H%/(# H1 9%$%.6(#(#/ 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% 6%-#$ +(& 9(-/#"&(& "0 5UF."S
3%-# #(+(2(&6; $" 7"#'%14 O+"B ". 8+-$B (& $+(& 5F#7-##(%&$ "0 -22 /F%&$&; $+-$
#"8 5&$-#9& -$ $+% 9"".;B &(2%#$21 9%6-#9(#/ .%7"/#($("# -#9 %#$.1i
`=(%$A&7+% )XNC00B f"2> :YY )<Ja> O+%.%-& 7"#$%63".-.1 &7+"2-.& $%#9 $"
F&% $+% $%.6 5#(+(2(&6; .-$+%. 2""&%21B $" 9%#"$% '(.$F-221 -#1 6-#(0%&$-$("#
"0 7F2$F.-2 9(&-..-1B =(%$A&7+% -33-.%#$21 (#$%#9& &"6%$+(#/ 6".% 3.%7(&%>
M% -2$%.#-$%21 .%0%.& $" #(+(2(&6 -& - 3&17+"2"/(7-2 &$-$% -#9 - 3+1&("2"/(7-2
7"#9($("#B H"$+ "0 8+(7+ -.% 6-.T%9 H1 %V+-F&$("#B 3%.'-&('% 3%&&(6(&6B 3-#9%6(7 9(&&(3-$("# "0 8(22B -#9 -# F#3.%7%9%#$%9 %.%$+(&6> O% 6(/+$ &-1B
$+%#B $+-$ (# $+%&% #"$%H""T %#$.(%& +% %_F-$%& #(+(2(&6 8($+ #'$ $HI$)*$&/$ "2
.$/9C>
M-'(#/ (9%#$(0(%9 #(+(2(&6 8($+ $+% %V3%.(%#7% "0 9%7-1B =(%$A&7+%
(66%9(-$%21 7-F$("#& F& #"$ $" 6(&$-T% $+(& %V3%.(%#7% 0". ($& 7-F&%> Y# #"$% 0."6 )???B 8+(7+ %7+"%& &%'%.-2 "$+%.& 0."6 $+-$ 1%-.B +% 8.($%&4
5Z-&(7 (#&(/+$ .%/-.9(#/ $+% #-$F.% "0 9%7-9%#7%4 *#% %,II"%$. /9,%$% 9)$
*#% /"&%$V,$&/$%N `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B lD)m 70> lD<hJa> M% &(6(2-.21 6-(#$-(#&
$+-$4
rYs$ (& -# %..". $" 7"#&(9%. 5&"7(-2 9(&$.%&&; ". 53+1&("2"/(7-2 9%/%#%.-$("#;
".B 8".&%B 7"..F3$("#B -& $+% /9,%$ "0 #(+(2(&6>
`(H(9>B l)a
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
5L# $+% M(&$".1 "0 UF."3%-# =(+(2(&6;m ($ 8(22 H% 7"#$-(#%9 (# 8".T (# 3."/.%&&4 D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)0 7##$5I# 9# 9 1$F94,9#*"& "2 744 X94,$%
`=(%$A&7+% )X?XHB YYY <Ca)
)<I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
M% 7"#&%_F%#$21 .(9(7F2%& $+% #"$("# $+-$ 8% 6(/+$ 7"6H-$ 9%7-9%#7%
&(6321 H1 %-&(#/ $+% 9(&7"60".$ $+-$ -$$%#9& $+(& %V3%.(%#7% "0 #(+(2(&64
Q& =(%$A&7+% .%'%-2& (# -# %-.21 3."&3%7$F& 0". D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)B $+% %V3%.(S
%#7% "0 9%7-1 $+F& 6-.T& "#21 $+% 53"(#$ "0 9%3-.$F.%; 0". +(& (#'%&$(/-$("#
(#$" #(+(2(&6 `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)a> M% 7"#&%_F%#$21 3."H%& 0F.$+%.B (# ".9%.
$" 9%$%.6(#% $+% /%#F(#% 7-F&%`&a "0 $+% 3+1&("2"/(7-2 7"#9($("# +% -&&"7(S
-$%& 8($+ $+(& %V3%.(%#7% "0 9%7-1> *"8-.9 $+(& %#9B +% (#'%&$(/-$%& $+%
3+1&("2"/(7-2 %V3%.(%#7% "0 9%7-1 #"$ &(6321 -& -# (&"2-$%9 +(&$".(7-2
%'%#$B HF$ -2&" -& $+% 6"&$ .%7%#$ &$-/% "0 9%'%2"36%#$ (# - 6".% &8%%3(#/
+(&$".(7-2 3."7%&&> M% $+F& &3%-T& "0 - F#(_F%21 6,)"I$9& -.$(7F2-$("# "0
#(+(2(&6 -#9 "0 '-.("F& %-&$%.# '-.(%$(%&BN -& 8%22 -& "0 $+% 2"/(7 $+-$ (#0".6&
$+%6 -22>C Q& E-.$(# M%(9%//%. -&$F$%21 "H&%.'%&4
rWs". =(%$A&7+% #(+(2(&6 (& #"$ (# -#1 8-1 &(6321 - 3+%#"6%#"# "0 9%7-1m
.-$+%. #(+(2(&6 (&B -& $+% 0F#9-6%#$-2 %'%#$ "0 O%&$%.# +(&$".1B &(6F2$-#S
%"F&21 -#9 -H"'% -22 $+% (#$.(#&(7 2-8 "0 $+-$ +(&$".1> > > > =(%$A&7+% $+(#T&
#(+(2(&6 -& $+% 5(##%. 2"/(7; "0 O%&$%.# +(&$".1>
`M%(9%//%. )XCCB NCa
Q& $+%&% #"$%H""T %#$.(%& &F//%&$B =(%$A&7+%;& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6 (&
(#%V$.(7-H21 2(#T%9 $" +(& 9(-/#"&(& "0 $+% 3."#"F#7%9 9%7-1 $+-$ H%&%$& $+%
%3"7+ "0 2-$% 6"9%.#($1> O+(2% ($ (& 7F&$"6-.1 0". +(& .%-9%.& $" $.%-$
5#(+(2(&6; -#9 59%7-9%#7%; -& ."F/+21 &1#"#16"F& $%.6& "0 9(-/#"&$(7 %'-S
2F-$("#B &%'%.-2 #"$%H""T %#$.(%& (# 0-7$ 6(2($-$% -/-(#&$ $+(& (#$%.3.%$-$("#>
=(+(2(&6 -#9 9%7-9%#7% -.% (#9(&3F$-H21 .%2-$%9 -& 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7 3+%#"6S
%#- "0 $+% 0-9(#/ 2(0%8".29& "0 O%&$%.# UF."3%-# 7F2$F.%& (# 2-$% 6"9%.#($1B
HF$ $+%1 -.% #"$ (9%#$(7-2 $" "#% -#"$+%.> Q& 8% &+-22 &""# &%%B 5#(+(2(&6;
#-6%& - 3-.$(7F2-. 7"/#($('% -$$F#%6%#$ $+-$ (& 3"&&(H2% "#21 F#9%. $+%
7"#9($("#& "0 -9'-#7%9 9%7-1>
Y# 3%.+-3& +(& 6"&$ 0-6"F& 9(&7F&&("# "0 #(+(2(&6B 7"#$-(#%9 (# - #"$%
0."6 )??NB =(%$A&7+% -$$%63$& $" %V32-(# $+% 9(00%.%#7%& H%$8%%# #(+(2(&6
-#9 9%7-9%#7%4
O+-$ 9"%& #(+(2(&6 6%-#i D'9# #'$ '*?'$%# F94,$% .$F94,9#$ #'$5%$4F$%> *+%
-(6 (& 2-7T(#/m 58+1i; 0(#9& #" -#&8%.>
`=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l<a?
*+(& .%&3"#&% $" +(& "8# _F%.1 .%'%-2& -# (63".$-#$ -#9 "0$%# "'%.2""T%9
-&3%7$ "0 +(& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 #(+(2(&64 M% #%($+%. -&T&B #". %V32-(#&B 8+-$
#(+(2(&6 *%q +% (& 7"#7%.#%9 (#&$%-9 $" 9(&7%.# 8+-$ ($ 5$9&% p+$.$,#$#s>X
O+-$ $+% -9'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 5$9&% (& $+-$ $+% 9%7-1 "0 O%&$%.# UF."3%-#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
*+% &F33"&%9 .%6%9(%& "0 9%/%#%.-$("# -.% -2&" 6%.% 3-22(-$('%& -/-(#&$
&"6% "0 ($& %00%7$&4 $+% 57F.%9 -.% 6%.%21 "#% $13% "0 $+% 9%/%#%.-$%;>
`=(%$A&7+% )XN? lD<m 70> )X?<B <4))a
7F2$F.%& +-& 3."/.%&&%9 &F00(7(%#$21 0-. $+-$ 8% 7-# #" 2"#/%. (#'%&$ .%&"2F$%
H%2(%0 (# $+% '-2F%& $+-$ 8% 0".6%.21 .%/-.9%9 -& +(/+%&$> O+-$ $+% -9'%#$ "0
#(+(2(&6 5$9&% (& $+-$ "F. 7"22%7$('% &%-.7+ 0". 3F.3"&%B 6%-#(#/B -#9
RF&$(0(7-$("# (& #"8 0F$(2%> *+-$ 8% 0(#9 "F.&%2'%& (# -# F#8-#$%9 7"#9($("#
"0 5-(62%&&#%&&; 5$9&% $+-$ "F. +(/+%&$ '-2F%&B 8+(7+ 8%.% +($+%.$" .%&3"#S
&(H2% 0". 3"&$3"#(#/ $+% "#&%$ "0 $+(& 7"#9($("#B +-'% 9%'-2F-$%9 $+%6S
&%2'%&>)I *+% 9%'-2F-$("# "0 "F. +(/+%&$ '-2F%& $+F& -77"F#$& 0". $+%
5$9&*&? "0 #(+(2(&6B HF$ #"$ 0". ($& %&&%#7% ". 7-F&%>))
Q77".9(#/ $" =(%$A&7+%B $+% +(&$".(7-2 9%'-2F-$("# "0 $+%&% +(/+%&$ '-2F%&
(& #%($+%. -.H($.-.1 #". -77(9%#$-2B 0". $+%1 9%'-2F-$% #'$5%$4F$%>)< Y# -#
)??N 3."&3%7$F& 0". +(& 3."3"&%9 >9,I#=$);B +% 9%&7.(H%& #(+(2(&6 59% #'$
&$/$%%9)C /"&%$V,$&/$ "0 "F. '-2F-$("#& $+F& 0-.; `=(%$A&7+% )XNC00B f"2> YYY<
)ICa> *8" 1%-.& 2-$%.B (# 8+-$ +% "#7% (#$%#9%9 -& $+% P."2"/F% $" +(&
>9,I#=$);B +% 7"#0(.6& $+-$ 5#(+(2(&6 .%3.%&%#$& $+% F2$(6-$% 2"/(7-2 7"#S
72F&("# "0 "F. /.%-$ '-2F%& -#9 (9%-2&; `=(%$A&&7+% )XNC00B f"2 YYY< D@<a> *+%
#%7%&&($1 "0 $+% 9%'-2F$("# "0 "F. +(/+%&$ '-2F%& (& $+F& %#&F.%9 H1 -# `-&
1%$a F#&3%7(0(%9 -&3%7$ "0 $+%(. (#$%.#-2 2"/(7>
*+% 6%-#(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6 -33-.%#$21 7"63.(&%& $+% 9%'-2F-$("# "#21 "0 "F.
+(/+%&$ r"+$)%#s '-2F%&> Q+$)%# 7"##"$%& #"$ "#21 - 7-.9(#-2 &%#&% "0 -F$+".S
($1B HF$ - &3-$(-2 "#% -& 8%22 h -& (0 "F. 5+(/+%&$; '-2F%& 8%.% -2&" $+"&% 6"&$
9(&$-#$ 0."6 F&> *" %V32-(# 8+1 "F. +(/+%&$ '-2F%& -.% -2&" "F. 6"&$ (#&FHS
&$-#$(-2B =(%$A&7+% &7.F$(#(&%& $+%(. H2(/+$%9 H(.$+> M% H2-6%& 3+(2"&"3+%.&
0".4
7"#0F&(#/ $+% 2-&$ -#9 $+% 0(.&$> *+%1 32-7% $+-$ 8+(7+ 7"6%& -$ $+% %#9 h
F#0".$F#-$%21j 0". ($ "F/+$ #"$ $" 7"6% -$ -22j h #-6%21B $+% 5+(/+%&$
7"#7%3$&; > > > (# $+% H%/(##(#/B 9% $+% H%/(##(#/ > > > E".-24 8+-$%'%. (& "0
$+% 0(.&$ .-#T 6F&$ H% /9,%9 %,*> L.(/(# "F$ "0 &"6%$+(#/ %2&% (& 7"#&(9%.%9
-# "HR%7$("#B - _F%&$("#(#/ "0 '-2F%> Q22 $+% +(/+%&$ p"+$)%#$&s '-2F%& -.%
"0 $+% 0(.&$ .-#T > > > -#9 $+%.%0".% 6F&$ H% /9,%9 %,*> `=(%$A&7+% )X?<B @4Da
=(%$A&7+% $+F& $.-7%& "F. 7F..%#$ -2(%#-$("# 0."6 $+% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& $" H-&(7 `-#9 3%.+-3& 3-$+"2"/(7-2a 7"#0F&("# 7"#7%.#(#/ $+%(. ".(/(#>)@ L8(#/
$" 8+-$ +% 7-22& 5$+% H-&(7 0-7$ "0 $+% +F6-# 8(22;B ($& 5'"))") F9/,*; `=(%$A&7+%
)X?XB YYY )aB +F6-#T(#9 0".6%.21 H%2(%'%9 ($& +(/+%&$ '-2F%& $" +-'% ".(/(#S
-$%9 /9,%9 %,*B (##"7%#$ "0 +(&$".1 -#9 7"#$(#/%#71> Q& - 7"#&%_F%#7% "0 $+%
9%7-9%#7% $+-$ %#'%2"3%& 2-$% 6"9%.#($1B +"8%'%.B 8% #"8 &%% $+%&% +(/+%&$
'-2F%& -& %V3.%&&("#& "0 3-.$(7F2-.B +(&$".(7-221S&3%7(0(7 (#$%.%&$&> Y# - #"$%
0."6 )??? +% %V32(7($21 2(#T& $+% %V3%.(%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 $" $+% ".(/(# "0 "F.
"+$)%# '-2F%&4
="8 $+-$ $+% &+-HH1 ".(/(# "0 $+%&% '-2F%& (& H%7"6(#/ 72%-.B $+% F#('%.&%
&%%6& $" +-'% 2"&$ '-2F%B &%%6& 56%-#(#/2%&&;>
`=(%$A&7+% )XNC00B f"2 fYYY< <X)h<a
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )<)
Q2$+"F/+ -22 '-2F%& -.% &FHR%7$ $" +(&$".(7-2 9%'-2F-$("#B "#21 $+% 9%'-2F-S
$("# "0 "F. +(/+%&$ '-2F%&B 8+(7+ &F33"&%921 ".(/(#-$%9 /9,%9 %,*B (& (632(S
7-$%9 (# $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6> `*+% 9%'-2F-$("# "0 2%&&%. '-2F%&B 8+"&%
5&+-HH1; +F6-# ".(/(# 8-& #%'%. 9(&3F$%9B -33-.%#$21 #%%9 #"$ 3-.$-T% (#
$+% 2"/(7 "0 #(+(2(&6>a L#7% .%'%-2%9 $" H% -22S$""S+F6-# (# ".(/(#B $+%&%
'-2F%& 0".0%($ $+%(. "+$)%# &$-$F& -#9 $-T% $+%(. 32-7% H%&(9% -22 "$+%. 56%.%21;
+F6-# '-2F%&> W".6%.21 .%2(%9 "# $" .%9%%6 $+% +F6-# 7"#9($("#B $+%
+(/+%&$ '-2F%& #"8 &$-#9 (# #%%9 "0 .%9%63$("#>)D
*+(& %V32-#-$("#B "0 7"F.&%B "#21 .-(&%& -99($("#-2 _F%&$("#& -H"F$ $+%
7-F&%`&a "0 #(+(2(&6> O+1B 0". %V-632%B 9"%& $+% ',59& ".(/(# "0 $+%&% '-2F%&
7"#&$($F$% -# "HR%7$("# $" $+%(. 3%.9F.-#7%i Q$ $+(& 3"(#$ (# +(& -#-21&(& "0
#(+(2(&6B =(%$A&7+% -33-.%#$21 F#9%.&$-#9& $+-$ +% 7-# 3."'(9% #" 0F.$+%.
%V32-#-$("#&> M% +-& %00%7$('%21 .-(&%9 $+% _F%&$("# "0 $+% 9%0(#(#/ 7+-.-7$%.
"0 $+% %3"7+ 8($+(# 8+(7+ +% 2-H"F.&B -#9 +% .%-2(&%& $+-$ +% 9"%& #"$
7"66-#9 &F00(7(%#$ (#&(/+$ (#$" $+% #-$F.% "0 $+% %3"7+ $" '%#$F.% -#
-9%_F-$% .%&3"#&% $" $+(& _F%&$("#> M% 7"#&%_F%#$21 &+(0$& $+% 0"7F& "0 +(&
(#'%&$(/-$("# $" $+% 9%7-9%#7% $+-$ 7+-.-7$%.(&%& 2-$% 6"9%.#($1> L#21 (0 8%
9(&7%.# $+% 7-F&%& "0 9%7-9%#7% -#9 F#7"'%. $+% 2-8& -#9 .%/F2-.($(%& $+-$
/"'%.# ($& -9'-#7% 7-# 8% +"3% $" -33.%7(-$% 8+1 $+% 5&+-HH1; +F6-#
".(/(# "0 $+% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& 7"#&$($F$%& - 0-$-2 "HR%7$("# $" $+%6>
*+F& 8% &%% 8+1 =(%$A&7+% 8-& "H2(/%9 $" .%#%/% "# +(& 3."6(&% $" 9%2('%.
-# %&&-1 5L# $+% M(&$".1 "0 UF."3%-# =(+(2(&6;> Q#1 &F7+ +(&$".(7-2 %V32-#-S
$("# 8"F29 0(.&$ .%_F(.% +(6 $" 9('(#% $+% #-$F.% "0 $+% 3-#9%6(7 9%7-9%#7%
$+-$ $+.%-$%#& $" &F00"7-$% $+% %3(/"#(7 7F2$F.%& "0 2-$% 6"9%.#($1> Y# 0-7$B
+(& 0-(2F.% $" 9(&7%.# $+% +(&$".(7-2 5%&&%#7%; ". 57-F&%; "0 9%7-9%#7% (&
(63".$-#$ $" H%-. (# 6(#9B 0". ($ 6($(/-$%& $+% &F77%&& "0 +(& 6"&$ 3."9F7$('%
%V3%.(6%#$& (# $.-#&S+F6-# 3+(2"&"3+1> Y#9%%9B +(& 3%.&(&$%#$ 61"3(- .%2%S
/-$%& +(& %00".$& $" 5'(%8 $+% 8".29 0."6 (#&(9%; $" - 3.%3-.-$".1 &$-$F&> M(&
&F77%&&".& 6-1 &"6%9-1 $-T% $+%(. &$-#9 5H%1"#9 /""9 -#9 %'(2;B HF$
=(%$A&7+% +(6&%20 9"%& #"$>
Y$ (& 7%.$-(#21 0-(. $" 7"#72F9%B 8($+ M%(9%//%.B $+-$ 5=(%$A&7+% #%'%.
.%7"/#(A%9 $+% $%%$&/$ "0 #(+(2(&6B RF&$ -& #" 6%$-3+1&(7& H%0".% +(6 %'%.
9(9; `M%(9%//%. )XCCB )IXa> Y$ (& %_F-221 0-(. $" -7T#"82%9/%B +"8%'%.B $+-$
+% 6-#-/%9 $" &($F-$% $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6 8($+(# +(& (#'%&$(/-$("# "0
$+% +(&$".(7-2 9%&$(#1 "0 2-$% 6"9%.#($1B 6F7+ -& M%(9%//%. +(6&%20 8"F29
2-$%. (9%#$(01 $+% $+.-22 "0 32-#%$-.1 $%7+#(7& -& $+% %#0.-6(#/ O$%#$44 "0
6"9%.#($1> =(+(2(&6 (& $+% 7"/#($('% 2%/-71 "0 - 9%7-9%#$ -/%B 8+(7+ (&
7+-.-7$%.(&%9 H1 - #%-.21 $"$-2 %72(3&% "0 $+% 9(6%#&("# "0 I)9H*%> \#-H2% $"
6F&$%. &F00(7(%#$ '($-2($1 $" -7$ 9%7(&('%21B $+% .%3.%&%#$-$('% %V%632-.& "0 9%7-9%#$ -/% (#%'($-H21 7-3($F2-$% $" #(+(2(&64 #'$C ;&"= $+-$ +F6-# '"2(S
$("# -#9 -/%#71 -.% 61$+&B $+-$ +F6-# H%(#/& 7-##"$ -2$%. $+% 9%&$(#1 "0
$+% +(&$".(7-2 %3"7+ (# 8+(7+ $+%1 $"(2B $+-$ %'%# $+% /.%-$%&$ +F6-#
-77"632(&+6%#$& 3-2% -/-(#&$ $+% H-7T9."3 "0 +(&$".1B $+-$ #" 6".-2 0".7%
". 2-8 &$%%.& $+% 7"&6"& (# - 9(.%7$("# +"&3($-H2% $" +F6-# H%(#/&B -#9 $+-$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)<< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )<@
#" /"9 %V(&$& 8+" 6(/+$ .%9%%6 - 9%7-9%#$ %3"7+ 0."6 ($& "8#6"&$ 32(/+$>
*+%1 T#"8B (# &+".$B $+-$ #"$+(#/ 6-$$%.&> 6*&594 *%# ;$*&594>
Q& - &%20S-'"8%9 57+(29 "0 +(& $(6%; `=(%$A&7+% )XNCB )JJaB =(%$A&7+% (& (# #"
3"&($("# $" .%9%%6 -#1"#%B 2%$ -2"#% 6"9%.#($1 -& - 8+"2%> M% 7"#&%_F%#$21
32-7%& +(6&%20 &_F-.%21 8($+(# $+% "#/"(#/ 7.(&(& "0 6"9%.#($1B 3.%&%#$(#/
+(6&%20 -& - 9%7-9%#$ 8+" 9(&7%.#& h HF$ 7-##"$ -2$%. h $+% (#%V".-H2% 7172%
"0 /."8$+ -#9 9%7-1>)J Q& +(& "8# 9(-/#"&(& 8"F29 3.%9(7$ "0 +(6B +% (&
6F7+ 6".% - $+(#T%. $+-# - 9"%.m +(& (#&(/+$ (#$" $+% 3%7F2(-. 7"#9($("#& "0
2-$% 6"9%.#($1 0-. "F$&$.(3& +(& -H(2($1 $" -6%#9 $+%6>)N
Q77".9(#/ $" =(%$A&7+%B +"8%'%.B +(& "8# 9%7-9%#7% 9"%& #"$ 3.%7(&%21
6(..". $+-$ "0 2-$% 6"9%.#($1 -& - 8+"2%> M% 9(&$(#/F(&+%& +(6&%20 0."6
`6"&$ "0a +(& 7"#$%63".-.(%& (# &%'%.-2 .%&3%7$&> W(.&$ "0 -22B +(& &(/#-2 (#&(/+$
(#$" $+% $.-#&S+(&$".(7-2 7172% "0 /."8$+ -#9 9%7-1 6-.T& +(6 -& - #(+(2(&$B
-#9 +% 3."F921 `(0 6(&$-T%#21a (9%#$(0(%& +(6&%20 -& - 53%.0%7$ #(+(2(&$;>)C
,%7"#9B +(& "8# 9%7-9%#7% (& -77(9%#$-2 .-$+%. $+-# 7"#&$($F$('%B 0". ($
-002(7$& +(6 "#21 3%.("9(7-221> Y$ $+F& &(/#(0(%& -# F#9%.21(#/ 7"#9($("# h -&
5%,559 %,559),5N h "0 +%-2$+ `=(%$A&7+% )X?XHB 8(&% <a>)? M% 7"#&%_F%#$21
(#&(&$& $+-$ -2$+"F/+ +% (& - 9%7-9%#$B +% (& 5-2&" $+% "33"&($% rO$?$&%#,U/;s; "0
- 9%7-9%#$B -# "33"&($("# $" 8+(7+ +% $.-7%& +(& 7"3("F& 58(&9"6; `(H(9a>
*+(.9B +(& F#9%.21(#/ 7"#9($("# "0 5+%-2$+; %#-H2%& +(6 $" .%&(&$ +(& 9%7-1B
-33-.%#$21 $" +(& 9(&$(#7$ -9'-#$-/%> M% &(6(2-.21 -$$.(HF$%& +(& 7-3-7($1 $"
5.%&(&$; 9%7-9%#7% $" $+% &-2F$-.1 .%&(9%#7% "0 5$+% 3+(2"&"3+%. (# r+(6s;
`=(%$A&7+% )XNCB )JJa> M% (&B (# +(& "8# 8".9&B 5-$ $+% &-6% $(6% - .$/9.$&#
-#9 - +$?*&&*&?; `=(%$A&7+% )X?XHB 8(&% )a> Z%7-F&% +% 3-.$(7(3-$%& (# $+%
9%7-1 "0 6"9%.#($1 "#21 5-& -# -#/2%B -& - &3%7(-2($1;B +(& 9%7-9%#7% (&
&"6%$+(#/ +% 7-# ,%$ -& 5-# %#%./%$(7 %#*5,4,% 0". 2(0%B 0". 2('(#/ 5")$;
`(H(9>B 8(&% <a> Y#9%%9B (0 +% (& 5&$."#/ %#"F/+ $" $F.# %'%# 8+-$ (& 6"&$
_F%&$("#-H2% -#9 9-#/%."F& $" r+(&s -9'-#$-/%; `(H(9>B4 72%'%. NaB $+%# +% 7-#
$F.# %'%# +(& "8# 9%7-9%#7% -/-(#&$ ($&%20> Q #(+(2(&$ (& #"$ 0.%% $" 9('%&$
+(6&%20 "0 $+% 9%7-9%#7% "0 +(& -/%B HF$ +% 6-1 %V32"($ +(& 9%7-9%#7% 0". +(&
"8# 2(6($%9 %#9&>
=(%$A&7+%;& 3FH2(&+%9 8.($(#/& .%0%. "#21 (#0.%_F%#$21 $" $+% %'%#$ "0
#(+(2(&6B HF$ -22 "0 $+% .%2%'-#$ 3-&&-/%& &F33".$ -# (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 #(+(2S
(&6 -& 9%2('%.(#/ - +(&$".(7-221 &3%7(0(7 (#&(/+$ (#$" $+% %7"#"61 "0 9%7-S
9%#7%>)X L# $8" "77-&("#& (# $+% O$&$94"?CB 0". %V-632%B +% .%0%.& $"
#(+(2(&6 -& $+% %V3%.(%#7% $+-$ -$$%#9& +(& "8# (#&(/+$ (#$" $+% (#%V".-H2%
9%7-1 "0 6"9%.#($1> M% 9%&7.(H%& +(& +(&$".(7-2 &($F-$("# -& '%./(#/ F3"# 5UF."3%-# ZF99+(&6; `=(%$A&7+% )X?XHB )XaB -#9 +% #"$%& $+-$ 8% 2-$%
6"9%.#& +-'% 0(#-221 /."8# 58%-.1 "0 6-#; `(H(9>B Y l)<a> L# $8" "$+%.
"77-&("#&B +% 2(#T& #(+(2(&6 $" $+% -9'%#$ "0 - 58(22 $" #"$+(#/#%&&; `(H(9>B
YY l<Dm YYY l)DaB 8+(7+ &+%2$%.& $+% 0(#-2 8(22 "0 -#1 91(#/ %3"7+ ". 3%"32%>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
EE
)<D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
=(+(2(&6B $+%#B (& $+% )$/"?&*#*"& "0 $+% 2"#/ =9%#$ "0 &$.%#/$+B $+% -/"#1
"0 $+% 5(# '-(#;B (#&%7F.($1B $+% 2-7T "0 -#1 "33".$F#($1 $" .%7"'%. -#9 $"
.%/-(# 7"63"&F.%SH%(#/ -&+-6%9 (# 0."#$ "0 "#%&%20B -& (0 "#% +-9
.$/$*F$. "#%&%20 -22 $"" 2"#/>
`(H(9>B l)<B $5I'Z 9..ZW
Q& $+(& 3-&&-/% &F//%&$&B =(%$A&7+% -&&"7(-$%& #(+(2(&6 8($+ $+% .%7"/#($("#
"0 (..%'%.&(H2% 9%7-1m 8% &+"F29 $+%.%0".% $-T% _F($% &%.("F&21 +(& 0.%_F%#$
-&&"7(-$("#& "0 #(+(2(&6 8($+ 5&(7T#%&&; ". 59(&%-&%;><I
Q2$+"F/+ ($ (& #"8 7F&$"6-.1 0". =(%$A&7+%;& .%-9%.& $" 7"#02-$% 9%7-9%#7%
8($+ #(+(2(&6B ($ 6-1 H% 6".% -77F.-$% $" 7"#7%('% "0 #(+(2(&6 -& - 3-.$(7F2-.
7"/#($('% 3."9F7$ "0 9%7-9%#7%> Q22 #(+(2(&$& -.% -2&" 9%7-9%#$&B HF$ #"$ -22
9%7-9%#$& -.% #(+(2(&$&> Q #(+(2(&$ (& $+%.%0".% - 3-.$(7F2-. $13% "0 9%7-9%#$B
"#% 8+" T#"8& $+-$ -22 %V3.%&&("#& "0 &$.%#/$+ -#9 '($-2($1B %'%# $+"&% $+-$
+-'% H%%# -77".9%9 - 3%.6-#%#$B &F3%.#-$F.-2 &$-$F&B 6F&$ %'%#$F-221
9%7-1> =(+(2(&$& F#9%.&$-#9 #"$ "#21 $+-$ $+% -/%& -#9 3%"32%& $+%1 .%3.%&%#$
2-7T $+% '($-2($1 #%%9%9 $" &F&$-(# $+%6&%2'%&B HF$ -2&" $+-$ $+(& 9%32%$%9
'($-2($1 (& $+% #-$F.-2B (#%2F7$-H2% .%&F2$ "0 $+% 8-1& (# 8+(7+ $+%&% -/%& -#9
3%"32%& +-'% %V3.%&&%9 $+%6&%2'%& (# $+% 3-&$>
Q& - #(+(2(&$ (# +(& "8# .(/+$B =(%$A&7+% T#"8& $+-$ #"$+(#/ %#9F.%&
3%.6-#%#$21B $+-$ %'%# $+% /.%-$%&$ +F6-# 7.%-$("#& 6F&$ %'%#$F-221 0-22B
-#9 $+-$ #" -#$%7%9%#$ 6".-2 ".9%. %#&F.%& $+% +-33(#%&& h ". %'%# $+%
&F.'('-2 h "0 +F6-#T(#9> *+% 8".29 H%+%29 H1 $+% #(+(2(&$ (& #"#% "$+%. $+-#
$+% 8".29 '(%8%9 50."6 (#&(9%; `=(%$A&7+% )X?X-B @NaB $+% 8".29 -& 8(22 $"
3"8%.B 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% %2&%8+%.% 9%&7.(H%& -& -# -6".-2 56"#&$%. "0 %#%./1;
`=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)INCa> M% 7"#&%_F%#$21 -7T#"82%9/%& $+% F$$%. 2-7T "0
&F3%.#-$F.-2 ". 6%$-3+1&(7-2 8-..-#$ 0". $+% &F3%.2-$('% '-2F%& 0."6 8+(7+
6"9%.#($1 `". -#1 -/%a +-& +%.%$"0".% 9%.('%9 6%-#(#/ -#9 '($-2($1><) K(T%
+(& 3%.(3-$%$(7 $8(# 5&"#&;B $+% E-96-# -#9 q-.-$+F&$.-B =(%$A&7+% 8($#%&&%&
$+% 59%-$+ "0 ^"9; -#9 7"#'%1& $+(& "H($F-.1 $" -# "H$F&%B F#H%2(%'(#/
-F9(%#7%><<
=(%$A&7+% -2&" 9(&$(#/F(&+%& (# +(& #"$%& H%$8%%# 5-7$('%; -#9 53-&&('%;
6"9%& "0 #(+(2(&6> M% -#9 +(& F#T#"8# 50.(%#9&; -33-.%#$21 3-.$-T% "0 $+%
0".6%. 6"9%B 8+(2% '(.$F-221 %'%.1"#% %2&% 3-.$-T%& "0 $+% 2-$$%.> =(+(2(&6 (&
5-6H(/F"F&;B +% %V32-(#&B H%7-F&% ($ 7-# &(/#(01 %($+%. 5(#7.%-&%9 3"8%. "0
$+% &3(.($B -& 9/#*F$ #(+(2(&6;B ". 59%72(#% -#9 .%7%&&("# "0 $+% 3"8%. "0 $+%
&3(.($B -& I9%%*F$ #(+(2(&6; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l<<m &%% l<@a><@ O+(2% H"$+ 0".6&
"0 #(+(2(&6 &+-.% - 7"66"# (#&(/+$ (#$" $+% %7"#"61 "0 9%7-1B $+%1 9(00%.
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Y# +(& #"$%& 0."6 $+% 3%.("9B +% &(6(2-.21 .%0%.& $" #(+(2(&6 -& $+% 53&17+"S
2"/(7-2 &$-$%; $+-$ -77"63-#(%& `HF$ 9"%& #"$ 7-F&%a $+% %V+-F&$("#B 3%&&S
(6(&6B -#9 9(&&(3-$("# "0 8(22 $+-$ +% 3.%&%#$& -& &163$"6& "0 -9'-#7%9
9%7-1 `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l)<a> *+%&% #"$%H""T %#$.(%& $+F& 7"#0(.6 $+-$ +%
F#9%.&$-#9& #(+(2(&6 -& - 7"/#($('% 3."9F7$ "0 9%7-9%#7%B -& -# -7+(%'%S
6%#$ "0 (#&(/+$ -#9 .%7"/#($("#4
8($+ .%&3%7$ $" $+% '"2($("#-2 .%&3"#&% $+-$ (& %#/%#9%.%9 H1 $+(& (#&(/+$>
Q7$('% #(+(2(&$& -.% -33-.%#$21 -H2% $" -00(.6 $+% %#$(.% 7172% "0 /."8$+ -#9
9%7-1B (#72F9(#/ $+% (#%'($-H2% 9%&$.F7$("# "0 $+%6&%2'%& -& 5(#9('(9F-2;
-/%#$&> P-&&('% #(+(2(&$& 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7-221 `-#9 (#'"2F#$-.(21a /%#%.-2(&%
0."6 $+%(. "8# 9%7-1B 3."R%7$(#/ ($ "#$" +F6-#T(#9 -& - 8+"2%m $+%(. "8#
7.(332%9 -/%#71 3."'%& $" $+%6 $+-$ -/%#71 I$) %$ (& #"8 9%0F#7$> Q7$('%
#(+(2(&$& 7"#&%_F%#$21 &%% 9%7-9%#7% -& - #%7%&&-.1 (#/.%9(%#$ "0 K(0%B 8+"&%
.(7+ %7"#"61 (#72F9%&B HF$ (& #"$ .%9F7(H2% $"B $+%(. "8# 7-.%%.& -& 5(#9(S
'(9F-2; -/%#$&><D P-&&('% #(+(2(&$&B H1 7"#$.-&$B 7-##"$ +%23 HF$ &%% 9%7-9%#7%
-& $+% "33"&($% ". #%/-$("# "0 K(0% ($&%20><J
O+%.%-& -7$('% #(+(2(&$& 7-# -00".9 $" H%+"29 $+% 8".29 (# ($& 3-(#0F2B
-6".-2 (66-#%#7%B 3-&&('% #(+(2(&$& 6F&$ (#$%.3"&% &-'(#/B 6%$-3+1&(7-2
0(7$("#& H%$8%%# $+%6&%2'%& -#9 $+% 8".29> Y#9%%9B $+% 6".-2(&-$("# "0
9%7-9%#7% (& ($&%20 - .%&F2$B ". H1S3."9F7$B "0 $+% -$$%63$ H1 3-&&('% #(+(2(&$&
$" (#'%&$ $+%(. "$+%.8(&% 6%-#(#/2%&& %V(&$%#7% 8($+ %"5$ 3F.3"&%B #" 6-$S
$%. +"8 3%.'%.&%> =(%$A&7+% (#&(&$& $+-$ +F6-#T(#9 8"F29 .-$+%. 58(22 #"$+S
(#/#%&& $+-# &"# 8(22; `=(%$A&7+% )X?XHB YYY4)aB - $.F$+ $+-$ 3-&&('% #(+(2(&$&
7"#0(.6 H1 %6H.-7(#/ &%20S-##(+(2-$("# -& $+% /"-2 $+-$ 3."'(9%& $+%6 8($+
6%-#(#/ -#9 3F.3"&%> Y# +(& #"$%&B +% "77-&("#-221 %632"1& $+% $%.6 *&/"5J
I4$#$ &*'*4*%5 $" 9%&7.(H% $+% 32(/+$ "0 $+"&% 3-&&('% #(+(2(&$& 8+" 7-# #%($+%.
7.%-$% 2-&$(#/ (22F&("#& #". -HRF.% $+%(. .%2(-#7% "# $+%6><N
*+% 6"&$ %#9F.(#/ (22F&("# $" 8+(7+ 3-&&('% #(+(2(&$& 72(#/ (& $+% 0(7$("# "0
(#9('(9F-2 -/%#71> G-$+%. $+-# .%'(&% $+%(. /F(9(#/ 3.%RF9(7%& (# 2(/+$ "0 $+%
/."8(#/ 9(&3-.($1 H%$8%%# $+% 7"/#($('% -#9 '"2($("#-2 .%&"F.7%& -'-(2-H2% $"
$+%6B 3-&&('% #(+(2(&$& `(#'"2F#$-.(21a (#&(&$ $" $+% %#9 $+-$ $+%1 -.% 7-F&-221
%00(7(%#$ -/%#$&B -2H%($ 0-(2%9 "#%&> P-&&('% #(+(2(&$& 72(#/ $%#-7("F&21 $" $+%
#-('% '"2F#$-.(&6 "0 0"2T 3&17+"2"/1B 9%&3($% $+%(. .%-2(&-$("# $+-$ ($ +-&
7F26(#-$%9 (# $+% 9+%,).,5 I)9/#*/,5 $+-$ #"8 9%0(#%& $+%(. &72%."$(7 %V(&$S
%#7%> P-&&('% #(+(2(&$& $+F& '(%8 9%7-9%#7% -& $+% 3."9F7$ #"$ "0 "#%;&
F#-2$%.-H2% 9%&$(#1B HF$ "0 "#%;& '"2F#$-.1 %2%7$("#& /"#% -8.1> Y#9%%9B
6".-2(&-$("#& "0 9%7-9%#7% $13(7-221 $.-7% $+% -9'%#$ "0 9%7-1 $" &"6%
$.-/(7B 6(&/F(9%9 7+"(7% "# $+% 3-.$ "0 "#%&%20 ". "#%;& -#7%&$".&B &F7+
$+-$ 6".% 3."6(&(#/ 3-$+& "0 9%'%2"36%#$ 8%.% $%63".-.(21 "H#FH(2-$%9
-#9 3%.6-#%#$21 0".0%($%9> *+% 0-6(2(-. 9"7$.(#% "0 ".(/(#-2 &(# .%3.%&%#$& $13(7-2 (#&$-#7% "0 $+% 6".-2(&-$("# "0 9%7-9%#7%B 0". ($ 2"7-$%& 8($+(#
(#9('(9F-2 -/%#71 - 3"8%.0F2 (63F2&% $"8-.9 - 3.%9%$%.6(#%9 &%20S9%&$.F7S
$("#> P-&&('% #(+(2(&$& $+F& H%2(%'% $+-$ 9%7-9%#7%B -2$+"F/+ (#$.(#&(7-221
8".$+2%&& (# -#9 "0 ($&%20B 3%.0".6& -# (#'-2F-H2% 6".-2 &%.'(7% $" &F77%&&".
-/%& -#9 3%"32%&> [%7-9%#$ -/%& -#9 (#9('(9F-2& &$-#9 $" 3"&$%.($1 -& #%/-S
$('% %V%632-.&B 8+"&% 9-6#(#/ 6(&$-T%& &+"F29 h -#9 7-# h H% -'"(9%9>
Q7$('% #(+(2(&6 (& $+% %V72F&('% 3."'(#7% "0 $+"&% %V%632-.1 (#9('(9F-2&
8+" H"-&$ &"6% 6(#(6-2 7-3-7($1 0". &_F-#9%.(#/ $+%(. .%6-(#(#/
'"2($("#-2 .%&"F.7%&> P-&&('% #(+(2(&6 (& $+% 2"$ "0 $+"&% (#9('(9F-2& 8+"&%
(#&(/+$ (#$" $+% %7"#"61 "0 9%7-9%#7% .%/.%$$-H21 7"(#7(9%& 8($+ $+% &+%%.
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )<J
%V+-F&$("# "0 $+%(. #-$('% '($-2($1> O+(2% -7$('% #(+(2(&$& -.% %#-H2%9 -&
5&_F-#9%.%.&; H1 $+%(. (#&(/+$ (#$" $+% $.-#&S+(&$".(7-2 7172% "0 /."8$+ -#9
9%7-1B 3-&&('% #(+(2(&$& .%&3"#9 H1 &F..%#9%.(#/ $" 9%7-9%#7%B H1 %V3%#9(#/
-22 .%6-(#(#/ '($-2($1 (# $+% 3F.&F($ "0 &%20S-H#%/-$("#> Q77".9(#/ $" $+%
/"&3%2 "0 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6B $+% 9%-$+ "0 ^"9 &3%22& $+% %#9 #"$ "0 "F.
7.(332(#/ /F(2$B HF$ "0 -22 +"3% $+-$ "F. (#9%H$%9#%&& 6(/+$ &"6%9-1 H%
.%9%%6%9> =(%$A&7+% $+F& (#&(&$& $+-$ 6"&$ 3+(2"&"3+%.& -#9 3.(%&$& -.%
3-&&('% #(+(2(&$&B 0". $+%1 $.%-$ 9%7-1 -& $+% 9%0(#($('% "HR%7$("# $" %V(&$%#7%
($&%20 `=(%$A&7+% )X?XHB YYY4))a>
O+%.%-& 3-&&('% #(+(2(&$& 9%72-.% $+%(. 7"#$.(HF$("# $" $+% %#+-#7%6%#$
"0 +F6-#T(#9 $" H% 7"632%$%B 2"7-$(#/ $+%(. "8# 53%.0%7$("#; (# $+%(. $(6%21
9%6(&% -#9 %V$(#7$("#B -7$('% #(+(2(&$& &%%T $" 7"#$(#F% $+%(. %V32".-$("#& "0
$+% +F6-# &"F2B %'%# `". %&3%7(-221a (# $+% $8(2(/+$ "0 $+% (9"2&> Q7$('%
#(+(2(&$& $+F& 3F.&F% +%.%$"0".% F#T#"8# ."F$%& $" +F6-# %#+-#7%6%#$B
(# $+% 0-7% "0 - &%20S0F20(22(#/ 3."3+%71 $+-$ 3."72-(6& $+% 0F$F.% 7"F.&% "0
+F6-#T(#9 $" H% -2.%-91 9%$%.6(#%9> *+% '"2($("#-2 .%&"F.7%& -'-(2-H2% $" 7.%3F&7F2-. %3"7+ 6-1 3-2% (# 7"63-.(&"# $" $+"&% &_F-#9%.%9 H1 3.%9%S
7%&&". %3"7+&B HF$ $+(& 9(&3-.($1 -2"#% 9"%& #"$ 8-..-#$ $+% 6".-2(&-$("#
$+-$ 3-&&('% #(+(2(&$& $13(7-221 -$$-7+ $" ($> Y# -# F#F&F-221 9%$-(2%9 &T%$7+ "0
$+% -7$('% #(+(2(&$B =(%$A&7+% %V32-(#&4
O($+ - &(#/2% /2-#7% +% &%%& 8+-$B /('%# - 0-'".-H2% -77F6F2-$("# -#9
(#7.%-&% "0 0".7%& -#9 $-&T&B 6(/+$ 1%$ +$ 59.$ "2 59&m +% T#"8& 8($+ -22
$+% T#"82%9/% "0 +(& 7"#&7(%#7% +"8 "0$%# $+% $13% 56-#; +-& -2.%-91
7"#0."#$%9 %#(/6-$(7 9%7(&("#& -#9 #%8 3-$+&> > > > Q#1"#% 8+" +-&
$+"F/+$ $+."F/+ $+(& 3"&&(H(2($1 $" $+% %#9 T#"8& "#% T(#9 "0 #-F&%$+-$ "$+%. 6%# 9"#;$ T#"8 h HF$ 3%.+-3& -2&" - #%8 #9%;Y
`=(%$A&7+% )X?X-B <I@a
W". -7$('% #(+(2(&$&B $+% 9+%,).,5 I)9/#*/,5 -&&"7(-$%9 8($+ 9%7-9%#7% 3.%S
&%#$& -# F#3.%7%9%#$%9 "33".$F#($1 $" .%$+(#T $+% #"$("# "0 -/%#71B $"
3+(2"&"3+(&% "F$&(9% $+% 7"#&$.-(#$& "0 $.-9($("#-2 7-$%/".(%& -#9 0.-6%S
8".T&B $" (#'%&$(/-$% 9%7-9%#$ 0".6& "0 K(0%B -#9 $" %V3%.(6%#$ 8($+
F#$%&$%9 7"#&$%22-$("#& "0 +F6-# 3"8%.&> Q$ $+%(. .%-2(&$(7 H%&$B -7$('% #(+(2S
(&$& 7"#7%('% "0 9%7-9%#7% -& 9%2('%.(#/ $+%6 - #"'%2 `.-$+%. $+-# -# %63$1a
&2-$% "0 3"$%#$(-2($(%&B 8+(7+ $+%1 6(/+$ $+%# %V32".% -#9 %#-7$>
*+% "33".$F#($1 $" (#'%&$(/-$% F#T#"8# 0".6& "0 K(0% -.(&%& "#21 8+%#
$+% -9'-#7% "0 9%7-9%#7% %V3"&%& $+% 0(7$("# "0 (#9('(9F-2 -/%#71 -#9 $+%
2(6($-$("#& "0 (#9('(9F-2 5&FHR%7$&;> W.%%9 0."6 $+% $-.#(&+%9 7-/% "0 $+%(.
"8# (#9('(9F-2 -/%#71B -7$('% #(+(2(&$& -.% 3"&($("#%9 $" -$$-(# - H%$$%.
-33.%7(-$("# "0 $+%(. &($F-$("# 8($+(# $+% "'%.2-33(#/ %7"#"6(%& "0 K(0%B
=-$F.%B -#9 8(22 $" 3"8%.> *+-$ (&B $+%1 -.% F#(_F%21 %#-H2%9 H1 $+% 9%7-1 "0
$+%(. %3"7+ $" 52%$ 9."3; $+% -#$+."3"6".3+(7 3.%RF9(7%& $+-$ +-'% .%7%#$21
H%%# %V3"&%9 -& 3+(2"&"3+(7-221 (#%00(7-7("F&m $+%1 7"#&%_F%#$21 0(#9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)<N !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
$+%6&%2'%& 3"(&%9 "# $+% $+.%&+"29 "0 - $.-#&S+F6-# ".(%#$-$("# $" 3+(2"S
&"3+1> Z1 7"#$(#F(#/ $+%(. %V3%.(6%#$&B %'%# $+."F/+"F$ $+% $8(2(/+$ "0 $+%
(9"2&B -7$('% #(+(2(&$& 8(22 &F77%%9 #%($+%. (# 9%01(#/ $+% $.-#&S+(&$".(7-2 7172%
"0 /."8$+ -#9 9%7-1B #". (# 9%'%2"3(#/ - 7F.% ". $.%-$6%#$ 0". 9%7-1> ZF$
$+%1 6-1 #%'%.$+%2%&& H%_F%-$+ $" $+% 0"F#9%.& "0 $+% &F77%&&". %3"7+ -#
F#3.%7%9%#$%9 (#&(/+$ (#$" $+% #-$F.% -#9 2(6($-$("#& "0 -/%#71>
Q& ($ 8($+%.& -#9 9(%&B - 9%7-9%#$ 3%"32% ". -/% %#-7$& - F#(_F% &%_F%#7%
"0 (#'"2F#$-.1 3-."V1&6&B -22 "0 8+(7+ 3"$%#$(-221 7"#$.(HF$% $" "F. F#9%.S
&$-#9(#/ "0 K(0%> U'%# (# $+% $8(2(/+$ "0 $+% (9"2&B +F6-# H%(#/& .%6-(#
5(#7"632%$%; -#(6-2&B 53.%/#-#$ 8($+ - 0F$F.%; $+-$ .%6-(#& $" &"6% %V$%#$
F#T#"8# `=(%$A&7+% )X?XHB YY )Na> O+(2% $+(& 53.%/#-#71; 6-1 &%%6 9%&S
$(#%9 0". 6(&7-..(-/%B -7$('% #(+(2(&$& '"8 $" 7"#$(#F% $+%(. 6-(%F$(7 %00".$&
-#9 H.(#/ $+(& $."FH2%9 3.%/#-#71 $" $%.6> Y# $+%(. "#/"(#/ %00".$& $" &-1
5o%& $" K(0% %'%# (# ($& &$.-#/%&$ -#9 +-.9%&$ 3."H2%6&; `=(%$A&7+% )X?<B )I4
JaB -7$('% #(+(2(&$& %V32".% $+% 3"&&(H(2($(%& -00".9%9 $+%6 %'%# H1 $+%(.
(66(#%#$ 9%6(&%>
EEE
Q2$+"F/+ =(%$A&7+% %632"1& - +"&$ "0 7"#7F&&('% (6-/%& $" 7"#'%1 +(& &%#&%
"0 +(& F#(_F% +(&$".(7-2 9%&$(#1B $+% &(/#-2 -77"632(&+6%#$ -.(&(#/ "F$ "0 +(&
%#/-/%6%#$ 8($+ #(+(2(&6 2(%& (# - 9(&$(#7$21 7"/#($('% $.(F63+> Z1 '(.$F% "0
+(& (66%.&("# (# $+% 9%7-9%#7% "0 2-$% 6"9%.#($1B +% &%%& 6".% 72%-.21 $+-#
"$+%.& $+% 3%7F2(-. $#'"% "0 +(& -/% `-#9 ($& "#/"(#/ 9(&(#$%/.-$("#a> Y#
$"F7+(#/ "00 +(& 5%V32"&("#;B +% .%-2(&$(7-221 -&3(.%& #"$ &" 6F7+ $" 9%&$.F7S
$("# -#9 9%'-&$-$("# -& $" .%'%2-$("# -#9 (22F6(#-$("#> O+(2% +% 7%.$-(#21
3.%0%.& $+% 6F&7F2-. (6-/% "0 $+% -.7+%. 02%V(#/ +(& H"8 `=(%$A&7+% )X?X-4
3.%0-7%aB +(& "8# +F6H2% _F('%. 7"#$-(#& "#21 &(/#-2 02-.%& -#9 8-.#(#/
-.."8&m $+% &$.%#/$+ $" 9(&3-$7+ 6".% 2%$+-2 ".9#-#7% 2(%& H%1"#9 +(& 9(6(#S
(&+%9 7-3-7($(%&>
Y$ (& $+%.%0".% 6".% -33."3.(-$% $" '(%8 =(%$A&7+%;& '-F#$%9 5.%'-2F-$("# "0
-22 '-2F%&; -& - 7"/#($('% -7+(%'%6%#$> G-$+%. $+-# 5H.%-T +(&$".1 (# $8";
`=(%$A&7+% )X?XHB 9%&$(#1 ?aB -& +% 6%2"9.-6-$(7-221 3."6(&%&B +(& 5.%'-2F-S
$("# "0 -22 '-2F%&; 0".6-221 (#-F/F.-$%& $+% $.-#&($("#-2 3%.("9 -##"F#7%9 H1
$+% -9'%#$ "0 UF."3%-# #(+(2(&6> Y#9%%9B +(& 7"#$.(HF$("#& $" $+% -.$(7F2-S
$("# "0 - $.-#&S+F6-# ".(%#$-$("# $" 3+(2"&"3+1 -.% 2-./%21 3.%3-.-$".1 (#
#-$F.%> L8(#/ $" +(& +(&$".(7-2 &($F-$("# (# - 7.%3F&7F2-. %3"7+B +% .%6-(#&
0-. $"" $(/+$21 %#6%&+%9 (# $+% 3.%'-(2(#/ 3.%RF9(7%& "0 O%&$%.# +F6-#(&6
$" 7"632%$% $+% %6(/.-$("# +% .%7"66%#9& 5H%1"#9 /""9 -#9 %'(2;> [%&3($%
+(& H%&$ %00".$&B $+-$ (&B +% (& #"$ 1%$ -H2% $" 52%-'% $+% (22F&("# "0 6".-2
RF9/6%#$& +$&$9#' +(6&%20; `=(%$A&7+% )X?<B C4)a>
="$8($+&$-#9(#/ $+% +F6-#(&$(7 %#7F6H.-#7%& "0 +(& +(&$".(7-2 &($F-$("#B
+"8%'%.B +% (& #"$ 8($+"F$ '-2F-H2% .%&"F.7%& $" 9%32"1> *F.#(#/ $" +(&
-9'-#$-/% $+% #(+(2(&6 $+-$ 9-.T%#& $+% +".(A"# "0 2-$% 6"9%.#($1B +%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )<C
7"#9F7$& '-.("F& 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 %V3%.(6%#$& $+-$ +-'% H%%# +%.%$"0".%
(63"&&(H2% $" F#9%.$-T%> *+% 9%'-2F-$("# "0 $+% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& F#(_F%21
3"&($("#& +(6 $" 7-22 (#$" _F%&$("# h -#9 3%.+-3& $" &F&3%#9 h &%'%.-2 "0
$+% +"-.(%&$ 3.%RF9(7%& "0 O%&$%.# 3+(2"&"3+1 -#9 $+%"2"/1> K%$ F& $F.# #"8
$" %V-6(#% "#% &F7+ 7.%3F&7F2-. %V3%.(6%#$B (# 8+(7+ +% -$$%63$& $"
9%'%2"3 +(& +13"$+%&(& "0 #'$ =*44 #" I"=$)> M% (#$%#9& $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.B ".
&" Y 72-(6B -& - $.-#&S+F6-# 7"&6"2"/(7-2 +13"$+%&(&B 3F./%9 "0 -22 $-(#$ "0
6".-2 %'-2F-$("# -#9 -#$+."3"7%#$.(7 3.('(2%/%> *+(& 7"&6"2"/1 8"F29 #"$
"#21 9(&2"9/% $+% +F6-# 0."6 ($& -77F&$"6%9 32-7% -$ $+% 7%#$%. "0 $+%
58".29;B HF$ -2&" 9%6"#&$.-$% $+-$ 5+F6-#; -/%#71 (& (# 0-7$ 9%.('-$('% "0 6".% 3%.'-&('%B $.-#&S3%.&"#-2 -/%#71> *" .%/-.9 $+% 8".29 50."6 (#&(9%;B -&
5 558(22 $" 3"8%.;; -#9 #"$+(#/ %2&%; `=(%$A&7+% )X?XB l@NaB 8"F29 H% $"
7"66-#9 - /%#F(#%21 %V$.-S6".-2 -#9 $.-#&S+F6-# &$-#93"(#$> *+(& (& -#
%V3%.(6%#$B +% 0F.$+%.6".% H%2(%'%&B $+-$ "#21 +% 7-# 7"#9F7$B -#9 "#21
8($+(# $+% -9'-#7(#/ 3%#F6H.- "0 #(+(2(&6><C
=(%$A&7+%;& %V3%.(6%#$ 8($+ $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%. %6%./%& -& $+% 3."9F7$ "0
+(& -$$%63$ $" $-T% &%.("F&21 $+% #"$("# $+-$ $+% 8(22 (& $+% &"2%
%00(7(%#$ 7-F&% "0 +F6-# -/%#71> O+(2% (#$."9F7(#/ +(& %V3%.(6%#$B +%
72-(6& $+-$4
*+% _F%&$("# (& (# $+% %#9 8+%$+%. 8% .%-221 .%7"/#(A% $+% 8(22 -& $22*/*$&#B
8+%$+%. 8% H%2(%'% (# $+% 7-F&-2($1 "0 $+% 8(224 (0 8% 9" > > > $+%# 8% +-'% $"
%V3%.(6%#$ 8($+ $+% +13"$+%&(& #'9# #'$ =*44 94"&$ *% /9,%94> 5O(22;B "0
7"F.&%B 7-# -00%7$ "#21 58(22; h -#9 #"$ 56-$$%.; `#"$ 5#%.'%&;B 0". %V-632%a>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?X-B l@NB $5I'Z 9..Za
Q$ 0(.&$ /2-#7%B $+(& %V3%.(6%#$ 6(/+$ &%%6 $" 7"#0(.6 $+% 3"3F2-. `-#9
6(&$-T%#a (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+% -& - 7+-63("# "0 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2
8(22B 0". +% -$$%63$& +%.% $" 9%0%#9 +(& H%2(%0 (# 5$+% 7-F&-2($1 "0 $+% 8(22;> Y0
5$+% 8(22 -2"#% (& 7-F&-2;B +"8%'%.B $+%# $+% 5%00(7(%#$; 8(22 (# _F%&$("# 7-# #"
2"#/%. H% (9%#$(0(%9 8($+ $+-$ 3F#1 +"6F#7F2F& 8+"&% &"2% 3"8%. 2(%& (#
$.-#&0".6(#/ #-$F.-2 (63F2&%& (#$" &(#&>
Y# ".9%. $" -77"66"9-$% +(& +13"$+%&(& $+-$ $+% 8(22 -2"#% (& 7-F&-2B
=(%$A&7+% 6F&$ &F332-#$ $+-$ -22%/%9 6"'%. "0 6-$$%.B $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2
8(22B 8($+ - 6".% 3"8%.0F2 -#9 3%.'-&('% -/%#71B 8+(7+ +% 7-22& 58(22 $"
3"8%.;> *+(& +% 7-# 9"B 6".%"'%.B H%7-F&% $+% 9%'-2F-$("# "0 $+% +(/+%&$
'-2F%& +-& 7-&$ - &+-9"8 "0 &F&3(7("# "'%. $+% -22%/%921 $.-#&0".6-$('%
3"8%.& "0 $+% +F6-# 8(22> =(%$A&7+% 6-T%& 3.%7(&%21 $+(& 3"(#$ (# +(& $%V$S
H""T 9%HF#T(#/ "0 5*+% W"F. ^.%-$ U..".&; (# D=*4*?'# "2 #'$ -."4%> M% H%/(#&
H1 %V3"&(#/ $+% -22%/%9 7-F&-2($1 "0 $+% 8(22 -& -# %V$%.#-2 3."R%7$("# "0 -#
5(#8-.9 0-7$; h #-6%21B $+% %V3%.(%#7% "0 "#%&%20 -& - 7-F&-221 %00(7(%#$ -/%#$
(# $+% 8".29> *+% 3."/.%&& "0 3&17+"2"/1 .%'%-2&B +"8%'%.B $+-$ $+% 6%$-S
3+1&(7-2 8(22B - &3%7$.-2 -/%#71 -22%/%921 .%&3"#&(H2% 0". $.-#&2-$(#/ H%2(%0&
(#$" 9%%9&B (& #"$+(#/ 6".% $+-# - 53+-#$"6;B - 58(22S";S$+%S8(&3; `=(%$A&7+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)<? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )<X
*+% 6"&$ -#7(%#$ -#9 %#9F.(#/ 3&17+"2"/1 8-& -$ 8".T +%.% -#9 9(9 #"$
9" -#1$+(#/ %2&%4 -22 $+-$ +-33%#%9 8-& 7"#&(9%.%9 - 9"(#/B -22 9"(#/ $+%
%00%7$ "0 - 8(22> > > > Q 9"%. `- 5&FHR%7$;a 8-& &2(33%9 F#9%. -22 $+-$ +-33%#%9>
Y$ 8-& "F$ "0 +(6&%20 $+-$ 6-# 3."R%7$%9 +(& $+.%% 5(##%. 0-7$&; h $+-$ (#
8+(7+ +% H%2(%'%9 6"&$ 0(.6214 $+% 8(22B $+% &3(.($B $+% %/">
`(H(9>B N4@a
M% 7"#&%_F%#$21 .(9(7F2%& $+"&% 53+(2"&"3+%.& r8+"s -.% -77F&$"6%9 $"
&3%-T "0 $+% 8(22 -& (0 ($ 8%.% $+% H%&$ST#"8# $+(#/ (# $+% 8".29; `=(%$A&7+%
)X?X-B l)Xa> M% &(#/2%& "F$ +(& 6)@*$'$)B ,7+"3%#+-F%.B 8+" 5+-& /('%# F& $"
F#9%.&$-#9 $+-$ $+% 8(22 -2"#% (& .%-221 T#"8# $" F&B -H&"2F$%21 -#9 7"6S
32%$%21 T#"8#B 8($+"F$ &FH$.-7$("# ". -99($("#; `(H(9>B l)Xa>
Q2$+"F/+ $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 8(22 (& #"$+(#/ 6".% $+-# -# %#9F.(#/ 0(7$("#
"0 0"2T 3&17+"2"/1B ($& 7F..%#71 7-# H% $.-7%9 $" $+% -$$%63$ $" -77"F#$ 0". 3+%#"6%#"# $+-$ =(%$A&7+% $-T%& _F($% &%.("F&214 $+% %V3%.(%#7% "0 "#%&%20
-& - 7-F&-221 %00(7(%#$ -/%#$> M% 7"#&%_F%#$21 F#9%.$-T%& $" %V32-(# $+%
3."'%#-#7% "0 $+(& %V3%.(%#7%B HF$ 8($+"F$ .%21(#/ "# $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2
7"#$.('-#7%& "0 0"2T 3&17+"2"/14
*+% "29 8".9 58(22; #"8 &%.'%& "#21 $" 9%#"$% - .%&F2$-#$B - T(#9 "0
(#9('(9F-2 .%-7$("#B 8+(7+ 0"22"8& #%7%&&-.(21 F3"# - #F6H%. "0 3-.$21
7"#$.-9(7$".1B 3-.$21 +-.6"#("F& &$(6F2(4 $+% 8(22 #" 2"#/%. 5-7$&; ".
56"'%&;>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?<B )Da
M% 7"#&%_F%#$21 -9'-#7%& - &$.(7$21 3+%#"6%#-2(&$(7 -77"F#$ "0 $+% %V3%.(S
%#7% -&&"7(-$%9 8($+ 58(22(#/;B "0 8+(7+ $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 8(22 .%3.%&%#$& 72F6&1 +13"&$-$(A-$("#><?
L&$%#&(H21 0.%%9 0."6 $+% $+.-22 "0 0"2T 3&17+"2"/1B =(%$A&7+% 3."7%%9& $"
-77"F#$ 0". $+% %V3%.(%#7% "0 8(22(#/ 8($+"F$ -#1 .%7"F.&% $" $+% 8"#9."F&
3"8%.& "0 $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 8(22> Q& -# (632%6%#$-$("# "0 $+(& &$.-$%/1B +%
0-6"F&21 8"#9%.& 8+%$+%. 5-22 6%7+-#(7-2 "77F..%#7%& -.% #"$ > > > %00%7$& "0
8(22; `=(%$A&7+% )X?X-B l@NaB 8+(7+ 2%-9& +(6 $" $+% 6".% .-9(7-2 +13"$+%&(&
$+-$4
rLsF. %#$(.% (#&$(#7$F-2 2(0% r(&s $+% 9%'%2"36%#$ -#9 .-6(0(7-$("# "0 "&$
H-&(7 0".6 "0 $+% 8(22 h #-6%21B "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.>
`(H(9>B l@Na
M(& &(/#-2 7"#$.(HF$("# $" 3&17+"2"/1B +% %V32-(#&B (& 5$" F#9%.&$-#9 ($ -&
6".3+"2"/1 -#9 #'$ ."/#)*&$ "2 #'$ .$F$4"I5$&# "2 #'$ =*44 #" I"=$); `(H(9>B l<@a>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)X?<B N4@a $+-$ 8-& 5(#'%#$%9 %&&%#$(-221 0". $+% 3F.3"&% "0 3F#(&+6%#$B $+-$
(&B H%7-F&% "#% 8-#$%9 $" (63F$% /F(2$; `(H(9>B N4Ca>
Y# - 3-.2-#7% .%6(#(&7%#$ "0 +(& 0-6"F& 7.($(_F% "0 &FHR%7$('($1 (# $+%
O$&$94"?C `=(%$A&7+% )X?XHB Y4)@aB =(%$A&7+% %V3"&%& $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 8(22
-& -# -$-'(&$(7 0(7$("# "0 0"2T 3&17+"2"/14
M% $+F& 3."3"&%& $+-$ 5944 %00(7(%#$ 0".7%; (&B (# ($& 6"&$ H-&(7 0".6B 5=*44 #"
I"=$); `(H(9>B l@Na><X
Y# ".9%. $" $-T% &%.("F&21 $+% 7-F&-2($1 "0 $+% 8(22B #"8 F#9%.&$""9 -& $+%
+13"$+%&(&%9 8(22 $" 3"8%.B =(%$A&7+% H"2921 .%'%.&%& $+% .%2-$("# "0 7-F&%
-#9 %00%7$ -& ($ +-& H%%# $.-9($("#-221 F#9%.&$""9> M% $.-7%& $+% 5W"F. ^.%-$
U..".&; "0 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 %V32-#-$("# $" - 7"66"#B F#7.($(7-2 0-($+ (# $+%
(#9('(9F-2 &FHR%7$ -& $+% 7-F&-221 %00(7(%#$ ".(/(#-$". "0 -7$("#> *+(& -77"F#$
(& 7"#9F7('% $" %..". H%7-F&% ($ 7"#0F&%& $+% %00%7$ ". %V3.%&&("# "0 -/%#71 h
#-6%21B $+% 8(22 h 8($+ ($& 7-F&%4
*+% 8(22 #" 2"#/%. 6"'%& -#1$+(#/B +%#7% 9"%& #"$ %V32-(# -#1$+(#/
%($+%. h ($ 6%.%21 -77"63-#(%& %'%#$&m ($ 7-# -2&" H% -H&%#$>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?<B N4@a
=(%$A&7+% (& 3"&($("#%9 $" -$$%63$ $+(& 6"6%#$"F& .%'%.&-2 "#21 H%7-F&% +%
$"(2& (# $+% $8(2(/+$ "0 $+% (9"2&B 8+%.%(# $+% 61$+ "0 7-F&-2($1 +-& 0(#-221
%V32"9%9 ($&%20 H%1"#9 .%3-(.> *+-$ (&B "#21 -# -7$('% #(+(2(&$ 7-# H"$+ %V3"&%
$+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 8(22 -& - 0-H.(7-$("# 9&. 7%2%H.-$% $+(& .%'%2-$("# -& - #%8
"33".$F#($1 0". 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 (#'%&$(/-$("#> Y#9%%9B H%7-F&% +% #" 2"#/%.
H%2(%'%& $+-$ $+% 8(22 7-F&%& ". 6"'%& -#1$+(#/B =(%$A&7+% (& 0.%% $" %V3%.(S
6%#$ 8($+ - 7"&6"2"/1 $+-$ 9"%& #"$ 2"7-$% (# +F6-# H%(#/& $+% ".(/(# "0
$+% 5-/%#71; $+-$ (& 3"3F2-.21 (#'%&$%9 (# $+%6>
ZF$ (0 $+% 8(22 9"%& #"$ 7-F&% -7$("#B $+%# $+% &"F.7% "0 $+% -/%#71
-$$.(HF$%9 $" (#9('(9F-2 5&FHR%7$&; 6F&$ 2(% %2&%8+%.%> M-'(#/ %V3"&%9 $+%
5(#9('(9F-2; -& - 7"63"&($% 0(7$("# "0 0"2T 3&17+"2"/1B =(%$A&7+% 2"7-$%& $+%
&"F.7% "0 $+% -/%#71 3"3F2-.21 -&7.(H%9 $" 5(#9('(9F-2; -/%#$& "F$&(9% `-#9
2"/(7-221 3.(". $"a $+%6> *+% 5(#9('(9F-2; +F6-# H%(#/ (& #"$ $+% ".(/(# ".
7-F&% "0 -/%#71B HF$ ($& %V3.%&&("# ". %00%7$4
O+%# 8% &3%-T "0 '-2F%&B 8% &3%-T 8($+ $+% (#&3(.-$("#B 8($+ $+% 8-1 "0
2""T(#/ -$ $+(#/&B 8+(7+ (& 3-.$ "0 K(0%4 K(0% ($&%20 0".7%& r@=*&?#s F& $" 3"&($
'-2F%&m K(0% ($&%20 '-2F%& $+."F/+ F& 8+%# 8% 3"&($ '-2F%&>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?<B J4Ja
=(%$A&7+%;& +13"$+%&(& $+F& &F//%&$& $+-$ 5(#9('(9F-2; +F6-# H%(#/& -.% #"$
&" 6F7+ -/%#$& "0 8(220F2 '"2($("# -& 3-$(%#$& "0 8(22 $" 3"8%.B $+."F/+
8+"6 K(0% %V3.%&&%& ($&%20 (# $+% "&$%#&(H21 &FHR%7$('% 3"&($(#/ "0 '-2F%&>
O+-$ 3+(2"&"3+%.& -#9 2-16%# -2(T% +-'% 9%&(/#-$%9 -& (#$%#$("#&B
7+"(7%&B 9%7(&("#&B '"2($("#&B -#9 "$+%. '"2F#$-.1 50-7$&; "0 "F. 6%#$-2 2(0%
6-1 (# 0-7$ H% (#'"2F#$-.1 %3(3+%#"6- "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%. 3."3-/-$(#/
($&%20 $+."F/+ ($& F#8($$(#/ 3-$(%#$&> Y#9%%9B $+(& -77"F#$ "0 $+% 7"&6"S
2"/(7-2 3-$(%#71 "0 -22 +F6-# 5-/%#$&; .%3.%&%#$& "#% "0 +(& 6"&$ 3."0"F#9
7"#$.(HF$("#& $" $+% -.$(7F2-$("# "0 - $.-#&S+F6-# ".(%#$-$("# $"
3+(2"&"3+1>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)@I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )@)
rKs(0% ($&%20 (& $%%$&#*944C -33."3.(-$("#B (#RF.1B "'%.3"8%.(#/ "0 8+-$ (&
-2(%# -#9 8%-T%. > > > 5UV32"($-$("#; 9"%& #"$ H%2"#/ $" - 7"..F3$ ". (63%.S
0%7$ -#9 3.(6($('% &"7(%$14 ($ H%2"#/& $" $+% $%%$&/$ "0 8+-$ 2('%&B -& - H-&(7
"./-#(7 0F#7$("#m ($ (& - 7"#&%_F%#7% "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.B 8+(7+ (& -0$%. -22
$+% 8(22 "0 K(0%>
`(H(9>B l<JXa
*-T%# $"/%$+%.B $+%&% 3-&&-/%& &($F-$% =(%$A&7+%;& +13"$+%&(& "0 $+% 8(22 $"
3"8%. &_F-.%21 8($+(# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 +(& %V3%.(6%#$ (# $.-#&S+F6-# 3+(2"S
&"3+1> L*2$ (& +(& 3.%0%..%9 9%&(/#-$("# 0". $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%. -$ ($& 6"&$ H-&(7B
F#9(00%.%#$(-$%9 2%'%2 "0 "./-#(7 .-6(0(7-$("#> O% 6(/+$ &-1 $+-$ K(0% (& $+-$
8+(7+ -22 -#(6-$% H%(#/&B (#9%3%#9%#$ "0 $+% 7"632%V($1 "0 $+%(. .%&3%7$('%
6".3+"2"/(%&B &+-.% -& - 7"66"# 2(#T -#9 3."'%#-#7%>@I Q$ $+% F#(_F%21
+F6-# 2%'%2 "0 "./-#(7 9(00%.%#$(-$("# -#9 7"632%V($1B K(0% $+F& 0F#7$("#&
-& $+% 3.(6".9(-2B $.-#&S(#9('(9F-2 -/%#71 $+-$ %#9"8& (#9('(9F-2 &"F2& 8($+
$+% '($-2 0".7%& $+%1 (#'"2F#$-.(21 3."3-/-$% -#9 %V3%#9> Q& - $.-#&S(#9('(S
9F-2 -/%#71B 6".%"'%.B K(0% "3%.-$%& -6".-221 -#9 (#9%3%#9%#$21 $" 7-F&%
(#9('(9F-2& $" 3"&($ '-2F%&> =(%$A&7+%;& +13"$+%&(& "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%. $+F&
2%-9& +(6 $" -9"3$ $+% '($-2(&6 $+-$ (#0".6& +(& 3"&$Sq-.-$+F&$.-# 8.($(#/&>
Y# $+%&% 8.($(#/&B (# 0-7$B =(%$A&7+% "77-&("#-221 0(/F.%& K(0% -& - $.-#&3%.S
&"#-2 0".7% $+-$ &3"#$-#%"F&21 "'%.02"8& ($&%20 (# - &F63$F-.1 %V3.%&&("# "0
($& F#_F%#7+-H2% '($-2($1>
G-$+%. $+-# -H-#9"# +(& +13"$+%&(& $+-$ $+% 7"&6"& (# ($& 6"&$ H-&(7
.%-2($1 (& 8(22 $" 3"8%.B +% $+F& &+(0$& +(& (#$%.3.%$('% 0"7F& $" $+% F#(_F%21
"./-#(7 .-6(0(7-$("# "0 8(22 $" 3"8%.B 8+(7+ +% 7-22& K(0%>@) *+(& &+(0$ #"$
"#21 0-7(2($-$%& $+% 7"#$(#F%9 9%'%2"36%#$ "0 +(& %V3%.(6%#$ (# $.-#&S
+F6-# 3+(2"&"3+1B HF$ -2&" (&"2-$%& $+% 3.%7(&% (#$%.0-7% H%$8%%# $+%
$.-#&S3%.&"#-2 8(22 $" 3"8%. -#9 $+% (#9('(9F-2 +F6-# H%(#/> Q77".9(#/ $"
=(%$A&7+%B $+% +F6-# &"F2 (& (#9(.%7$21 T#"8# $" F& $+."F/+ ($& "H&%.'-H2%
3-$$%.#& "0 (#&$(#7$F-2 H%+-'("F. -& -# (#'(&(H2% #%$8".T "0 9.('%& -#9
(63F2&%&> W". $+(& .%-&"#B +% 7"#&(&$%#$21 0(/F.%& $+% &"F2 (# +(& 3"&$Sq-.S
-$+F&$.-# 8.($(#/& -& - '%&&%2 ". 7-3-7($".B 8+(7+ -6".-221 9(&7+-./%& ($&
#-$('% %#9"86%#$ "0 '($-2($1B ". 58(22;> *+% 3%.'-&('%B $.-#&3%.&"#-2 -/%#71
$+-$ &F00F&%& -#(6-$% %#$($(%& 8($+ '($-2($1 (& K(0%B 8+(7+ ($&%20 7"63.(&%& -22
"./-#(7 9(00%.%#$(-$("#& "0 $+% 3.(6".9(-2 8(22 $" 3"8%.> *+% 5(#9('(9F-2; (&
$+%.%0".% #"$+(#/ 6".% $+-# -# -.$(0(7(-221 9%&(/#-$%9S -2H%($ 0F#7$("#-2S
7"#0(/F.-$("# "0 8(22 $" 3"8%.4
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
*+(& .(7+ 3-&&-/% #"$ "#21 6(2($-$%& -/-(#&$ $+% ."HF&$ '"2F#$-.(&6 $+-$ (&
3"3F2-.21 -$$.(HF$%9 $" =(%$A&7+%B HF$ -2&" &F//%&$& - 0F.$+%. (9%#$(0(7-$("# "0
$+% 3.(6".9(-2 -/%#71 $+-$ 5'-2F%& $+."F/+ F&;> Y#9%%9B +(& 7.13$(7 -22F&("#
$" K(0% 7-22& $" 6(#9 +(& %-.2(%. 3."72-6-$("# $+-$4 5Q 2('(#/ $+(#/ &%%T& -H"'%
-22 $" .*%/'9)?$ ($& &$.%#/$+ h K(0% ($&%20 (& =*44 #" I"=$.; `=(%$A&7+% )X?X-B l)@a>
WF.$+%. %6H%22(&+(#/ $+(& -33-.%#$ (9%#$(0(7-$("# "0 K(0% 8($+ 8(22 $" 3"8%.B
+% #"$".("F&21 6-(#$-(#& $+-$4
)@< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
*+(& $.-#&S6".-2 -77"F#$ "0 $+% 5(#9('(9F-2; +F6-# H%(#/B =(%$A&7+% 0F.$+%.S
6".% (#&(&$&B 7"#&$($F$%& $+% 2"/(7-2 7"#72F&("# "0 +(& +13"$+%&(& $+-$ $+%
8(22 -2"#% (& 7-F&-2>
Q& $+(& 3-&&-/% &F//%&$&B =(%$A&7+% -&7.(H%& ".(/(#-.1 -/%#71 "#21 $" K(0%B
". 8(22 $" 3"8%.> *" $+% 5(#9('(9F-2; +% -$$.(HF$%& "#21 - 9%.('-$('% -/%#71>
Y#9%%9B +% &%%& $+% 5(#9('(9F-2; -& #"$+(#/ 6".% $+-# - $.-#&(%#$ '".$%V
8($+(# $+% -6".-2 32%#F6 "0 K(0%> M(& %V3%.(6%#$ 8($+ 8(22 $" 3"8%. $+F&
%V3"&%& $+% F#(_F%21 6"9%.#(&$ 3.%"77F3-$("# 8($+ $+% 5(#9('(9F-2;B -& `3"$%#$(-221a -F$"#"6"F&B &%20S.%/F2-$(#/ &FHR%7$B -& - 0-$F"F& 3(%7% "0
'"2F#$-.(&$(7 &*9*%$)*$> *+% U#2(/+$%#6%#$ 3."R%7$ +-& #"$ &" 6F7+ 0-(2%9
`-& =(%$A&7+%;& .%-9%.& "0$%# .%3".$ +(6 $" +-'% 72-(6%9aB -& ($ +-& #%'%.
-7$F-221 H%%# (# - 3"&($("# $" 7"66%#7%> M% 7"#&%_F%#$21 "H&%.'%& $+-$
5*"9-1 $+% (#9('(9F-2 &$(22 +-& $" H% 6-9% 3"&&(H2% H1 H%(#/ 3.F#%94 3"&&(H2%
+%.% 6%-#& ='"4$; `=(%$A&7+% )X?<B X4D)a>
EN
=(%$A&7+%;& +13"$+%&(& "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%. $+F& &-#7$("#& - 3"8%.0F2 7.(S
$(_F% "0 (#9('(9F-2 -/%#71B %&3%7(-221 (#&"0-. -& $+% (#$%/.($1 "0 $+% 5(#9(S
'(9F-2; +-& H%%# $.-9($("#-221 2(#T%9 $" $+% 7-F&-2 %00(7-71 "0 $+% 8(22>@< Q& 8%
+-'% &%%#B +(& +13"$+%&(& .%9F7%& +F6-# 5-/%#$&; $" $+% %6H"9(%9 6%9($+."F/+ 8+(7+ $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%. -6".-221 3."3-/-$%& ($&%20> M% 7"#&%_F%#$21
9%HF#T& $+% 3F.3"&('%#%&& $+-$ &F33"&%921 7"#0(.6& $+% (#9('(9F-2;& 58(22;
$" -7$ (# - 7%.$-(# 8-14
Y& $+% 5/"-2;B $+% 53F.3"&%;B #"$ "0$%# %#"F/+ - H%-F$(01(#/ 3.%$%V$B &%20S9%7%3$("# "0 '-#($1 -0$%. $+% %'%#$ $+-$ 9"%& #"$ 8-#$ $" -7T#"8S
2%9/% $+-$ $+% &+(3 (& 2"44"=*&? $+% 7F..%#$ (#$" 8+(7+ ($ +-& %#$%.%9
-77(9%#$-221i *+-$ ($ 58(22&; $" /" $+-$ 8-1 +$/9,%$ *# e 5,%#i $+-$ (& +-&
- 9(.%7$("#B $" H% &F.%B HF$ h #" +%26&6-# -$ -22i
`=(%$A&7+% )XCDB l@NIa
Q& - .%&F2$ "0 $+(& %V3%.(6%#$ 8($+ $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.B =(%$A&7+% .%7"66%#9&
- 0-(.21 &%'%.% .%&$.(7$("# "0 $+% 9"6-(# "0 (#9('(9F-2 0.%%9"6> Q& 3-$(%#$& "0
$+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.B (#9('(9F-2 5-/%#$&; -.% `-$ H%&$a -H2% $" 9%$%.6(#% "#21 $+%
&3%7(0(7 %V3.%&&("# "0 $+% '($-2($1 $+%1 (#'"2F#$-.(21 3."3-/-$%> *+%1 -.% (#
#" %'%#$ -H2% $" 9%$%.6(#% $+% _F-#$($1 -#9 _F-2($1 "0 $+(& &F3%.'%#(#/
'($-2($1> [(.%7$(#/ "F. -$$%#$("# $" 5"#% "0 r+(&s 6"&$ %&&%#$(-2 &$%3& -#9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
*+% &(#/2% "#%B $+% 5(#9('(9F-2;B -& +($+%.$" F#9%.&$""9 H1 $+% 3%"32% -#9
$+% 3+(2"&"3+%.& -2(T%B (& -# %..". -0$%. -224 +% (& #"$+(#/ H1 +(6&%20B #"
-$"6B #" 52(#T (# $+% 7+-(#;B #"$+(#/ 6%.%21 (#+%.($%9 0."6 0".6%. $(6%&m
+% (& $+% 8+"2% &(#/2% 2(#% "0 +F6-#($1 F3 $" +(6&%20>
`=(%$A&7+% )X?< X4@@a
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )@@
Y +-'% 2%-.#%9 $" 9(&$(#/F(&+ $+% 7-F&% "0 -7$(#/ 0."6 $+% 7-F&% "0 -7$(#/
(# - 3-.$(7F2-. 8-1B (# - 3-.$(7F2-. 9(.%7$("#B 8($+ - 3-.$(7F2-. /"-2> *+%
0(.&$ $13% "0 7-F&% (& - _F-#$F6 "0 9-66%9SF3 %#%./1 $+-$ (& 8-($(#/ $" H%
F&%9 F3 &"6%+"8B 0". &"6%$+(#/B 8+(2% $+% &%7"#9 T(#9 (&B 7"63-.%9 $"
$+(& %#%./1B &"6%$+(#/ _F($% (#&(/#(0(7-#$B 0". $+% 6"&$ 3-.$ - 2($$2% -77(S
9%#$ (# -77".9-#7% 8($+ 8+(7+ $+(& _F-#$F6 59(&7+-./%&; ($&%20 (# "#%
3-.$(7F2-. 8-1 h - 6-$7+ '%.&F& - $"# "0 3"89%.> `=(%$A&7+% )XCDB @NIa
L#21 $+(& &%7"#9 T(#9 "0 7-F&% 0-22& 8($+(# $+% 2%/($(6-$% 7"63-&& "0 +F6-#
-/%#71 -#9 '"2($("#> Y#9%%9B -2$+"F/+ &"6% %V%632-.1 5(#9('(9F-2&; 7-#
(#02F%#7% $+% &3%7(0(7 %V3.%&&("#& "0 $+% '($-2($1 $+%1 (#'"2F#$-.(21
3."3-/-$%B $+% 7"#9($("# "0 $+%(. &"F2& `(#72F9(#/ $+% 7-3-7($1 "0
%V3%#9-H2% .%&"F.7%& -$ $+%(. 9(&3"&-2a (& - 6-$$%. "0 $+%(. F#-2$%.-H2% 9%&S
$(#1>
K%&$ 8% 9(&6(&& $+(& -77"F#$ "0 -/%#71 -#9 '"2($("# -& &(6321 $"" (63"'S
%.(&+%9B =(%$A&7+% 7-F$("#& F& $" H%8-.% "0 3"3F2-. 3.%RF9(7%> M%.% +%
.%32-7%& +(& 7F&$"6-.1 9(&7F&&("# "0 57-F&%&; 8($+ $+% 6".% %V3%.(6%#$-2
`-#9 3"$%#$(-221 $.-#&S+F6-#a '"7-HF2-.1 "0 50".7%&;4
P%"32% -.% -77F&$"6%9 $" 7"#&(9%. $+% /"-2 `3F.3"&%&B '"7-$("#&B %$7>a -&
$+% .)*F*&? 2")/$B (# T%%3(#/ 8($+ - '%.1 -#7(%#$ %..".m HF$ ($ (& 6%.%21 $+%
.*)$/#*&? 2")/$ h "#% +-& 6(&$-T%# $+% +%26&6-# 0". $+% &$%-6> Q#9 #"$ %'%#
-28-1& $+% +%26&6-#B $+% 9(.%7$(#/ 0".7% `=(%$A&7+% )XCDB @NIa>
*-T%# $"/%$+%.B $+%&% $8" 3-&&-/%& &F//%&$ $+-$ =(%$A&7+% 2(T%#& $+% 9(.%7$S
(#/ 0".7% "0 -/%#71 $" - 6-$7+B -#9 $+% 9.('(#/ 0".7% "0 -/%#71 $" - $"# "0
/F#3"89%.> O+(2% $+% 9(.%7$(#/ 0".7% "0 -/%#71 (&B .%2-$('% $" $+% 9.('(#/
0".7%B _F-#$($-$('%21 (#&(/#(0(7-#$B ($ (& 3"$%#$(-221 6"6%#$"F& (# $+% _F-2($S
-$('% $%.6& $+-$ +F6-# H%(#/& -2"#% 0(#9 (#$%.%&$(#/> *+% +F6H2% +%26&S
6-# 7-##"$ 3"&&(H21 /%#%.-$% &F00(7(%#$ &$%-6 $" 3."3%2 $+% '%&&%2 +% &$%%.&B
HF$ +(& &$%-91 +-#9 7-# #%'%.$+%2%&& (#02F%#7% $+% &+(3;& (#($(-2 7"F.&% -#9
F2$(6-$% 9%&$(#-$("#>
Q& $+(& -#-2"/1 &F//%&$&B 5(#9('(9F-2; +F6-# H%(#/& -.% 7"#&$($F$%9 -$ $+%
(#$%.&%7$("# "0 `-$ 2%-&$a $8" 2(#%& "0 0".7%> *+%1 7"#&%_F%#$21 9" #"$ 7"#$."2
`-#9 9 2")#*")* 7-##"$ H% +%29 .%&3"#&(H2% 0".a $+% _F-#$- "0 0".7% $+%1
(#'"2F#$-.(21 3."3-/-$%> \#9%. 7%.$-(# 7"#9($("#&B +"8%'%.B $+%1 7-# 9%$%.S
6(#% $+% _F-2($-$('% 9(&3"&($("# "0 $+%&% _F-#$-> Q2$+"F/+ .%&$.(7$%9 $" 7"66-#9 "0 $+% 9(.%7$(#/ 0".7% "0 $+% -/%#71 $+%1 3-$(%#$21 %#-7$B &"6%
+F6-# H%(#/& 7"66-#9 &F00(7(%#$ '"2($("#-2 .%&"F.7%& $" 9%$%.6(#% $+%
&3%7(0(7 %V3.%&&("#& "0 $+%(. #-$('% '($-2($1> ,%#&(#/B 3%.+-3&B $+-$ +(& 7.($(_F%
"0 -/%#71 H%$.-1& - .%&(9F-2 +F6-#(&6B =(%$A&7+% 0F.$+%.6".% 7-F$("#& F&
#"$ $" "'%.%&$(6-$% %'%# $+(& 2(6($%9 &3+%.% "0 '"2($("#> Y# 6-#1 7-&%&B +%
&F//%&$&B %'%# $+% 9(.%7$(#/ 0".7% %V%.$%9 H1 $+% +%26&6-# 6-1 ($&%20 H%2"#/
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-9'-#7%&;B +% .%+%-.&%& $+% 0"22"8(#/ 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# 5$8" T(#9& "0
7-F&%& $+-$ -.% "0$%# 7"#0"F#9%9;4
)@D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
$" $+% 0(/6%#$& "0 0"2T 3&17+"2"/1> P%.+-3& $+%.% (& #" +%26&6-# -$ -22>
P%.+-3& -22 59(.%7$(#/; 0".7%& -.% (# 0-7$ 59.('(#/; 0".7%& -0$%. -22>
Q& - .%&3"#&% $" $+% "#&%$ "0 UF."3%-# #(+(2(&6B =(%$A&7+% %#9%-'"F.& $"
7"#9F7$ - 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 %V3%.(6%#$ $+-$ 8-& 0".6%.21 F#(6-/(#-H2%> M%
/-6%21 %#9%-'"F.& $" '(%8 $+% 8".29 50."6 (#&(9%; `=(%$A&7+% )X?X-B l@NaB
+"3(#/ $+%.%H1 $" -.$(7F2-$% - 7"&6"2"/(7-2 $+%&(& $+-$ 6(/+$ &$-#9 -&
F#(_F%21 %V$.-S6".-2 -#9 $.-#&S+F6-#>
Q& +% -33-.%#$21 .%-2(&%&B +"8%'%.B $+% %#".6($1 "0 +(& $-&T '(.$F-221
%72(3&%& +(& "8# 6"9%&$ 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 -7+(%'%6%#$&> ,F3%.#-$F.-2 '%&$(/%&
"0 $+% 8".29 '(%8%9 50."6 "F$&(9%; 7"#$(#F% $" +-F#$ +(& %V3%.(6%#$ 8($+
$+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.B 7-F&(#/ +(6 $" .%$.%-$ "77-&("#-221 H%+(#9 $+% 6%$-S
3+1&(7-2 3.%RF9(7%& +% +-& &" %V3%.$21 9%HF#T%9> !"#$.-.1 $" +(& &(#7%.%
(#$%#$("#&B 0". %V-632%B +% #%'%. -7$F-221 6-#-/%& $" 7"#0."#$ $+% 8(22 $"
3"8%. -& - 3%.0%7$21 -6".-2 56"#&$%. "0 %#%./1;> Y# +(& 7"#7%.# $" 9%6"#S
&$.-$% $+-$ $+% F#9(00%.%#$(-$%9 32%#F6 "0 K(0% &+%2$%.& $.-#&(%#$ &FHS&1&$%6&
-6%#-H2% $" +F6-# 9%&(/#B +% F#8($$(#/21 $-6%& $+% 56"#&$%.;B 1(%29(#/ (#
$+% 3."7%&& - 9"6%&$(7-$%9 7"&6"2"/1 $+-$ .%02%7$& +(& .%&(9F-2 +F6-#(&$(7
-22%/(-#7%&>@@
[%&3($% +(& 8(&+ $" 9(&3%#&% -2$"/%$+%. 8($+ 6".-2 %'-2F-$("#& -#9
-#$+."3"7%#$.(7 3.%."/-$('%&B +% -33-.%#$21 7-##"$ +%23 HF$ -$$%63$ $"
3.%&%.'% - 6(#(6-2 9"6-(# "0 0.%%9"6 -#9 .%&3"#&(H(2($1B 8+%.%(# +%."(7
(#9('(9F-2& 6(/+$ &$.-$%/(7-221 6-#(0%&$ $+%(. "8# 9%7-1 0". $+% H%#%0($ "0
$+"&% 8+" 8(22 0"22"8> Q2$+"F/+ +% -7T#"82%9/%& $+-$ - /%#F(#%21 $.-#&S
+F6-# -77"F#$ "0 -/%#71 6-1 .%_F(.% +(6 $" H-#(&+ -2$"/%$+%. $+% +"6F#S
7F2-. 5+%26&6-#; `=(%$A&7+% )XCDB @NIaB +% &$"3& RF&$ &+".$ "0 9"(#/ &"B
.%&%.'(#/ 0". +(6&%20 -#9 +(& 0%22"8 50.%% &3(.($&; - 2(6($%9 0(%09"6 "0 '"2($("#
-#9 I)9H*%> M% (& -33-.%#$21 #"$ 3.%3-.%9 $" %6H.-7% - 7"&6"2"/1 $+-$
8"F29 .%_F(.% +(6 $" 0".0%($ +(& .%&(9F-2 -/%#71B 8+%.%H1 +% 6(/+$ 0F20(2
+(& 59%&$(#1; -#9 &$%%. 6"9%.#($1 $" - $(6%21 72"&%> P"(&%9 "# $+% $+.%&+"29 "0
- $.-#&S+F6-# ".(%#$-$("# $" 7"&6"2"/1B +% (#'-.(-H21 .%2-3&%& (#$" $+%
+F6-#(&6 -/-(#&$ 8+(7+ +% (#'%(/+&> Y# $+% %#9B +% (& #"$ - 53%.0%7$; #(+(2(&$
-0$%. -22B 0". +% .%$-(#& -# -22%/(-#7% $" $+% 6%$-3+1&(7& "0 6".-2& $+-$ +%
&$.F//2%& $" 9(&6-#$2%> \#-H2% (# $+% %#9 $" 52%-'% $+% (22F&("# "0 6".-2
RF9/6%#$& +$&$9#' +(6&%20; `=(%$A&7+% )X?<B C4)aB +% 0-(2& $" $-T% $+% .%7"6S
6%#9%9 &$-#9 5H%1"#9 /""9 -#9 %'(2;>
*+% 2(6($-$("#& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& %V3%.(6%#$ (# $.-#&S+F6-# 7"&6"2"/1 -.%
-33-.%#$21 -$$.(HF$-H2% #"$ $" 7"8-.9(7%B .%2F7$-#7%B ". (#9%7(&("# "# +(&
3-.$B HF$ $" $+% F#(_F% %3(&$%6(7 7"#9($("#& $+-$ 7+-.-7$%.(&% $+% +(&$".(7-2
&($F-$("# "0 +(& %V3%.(6%#$> Q& +% +(6&%20 8"F29 RF9/% "0 "$+%.&B +% (&
3."H-H21 $"" 72"&% $" $+% -9'%#$ "0 UF."3%-# #(+(2(&6 $" 9(&%#$-#/2% +(6&%20
0."6 $+% $.-9($("#& ($ &F33"&%921 H.(#/& $" - 72"&%> M% 7-##"$ 72%-#21
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
9$,1"<-#$,
%V$.(7-$% +(6&%20 0."6 $+% -33-.-$F& "0 O%&$%.# +F6-#(&6 H%7-F&% +% 9"%&
#"$ &%% 72%-.21 %#"F/+ ($& 7"#$.(HF$("#& $" $+% %#0.-6(#/ 7+-.-7$%. "0 9%7-S
9%#7% (# 2-$% 6"9%.#($1> M% (& -H2% $" 9(&7%.# $+% #%%9 0". $.-#&S+F6-#
%V3%.(6%#$-$("# (# 3+(2"&"3+1B HF$ +% 2-7T& -77%&& $" 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 $13"2"S
/(%& -#9 '"7-HF2-.(%& $+-$ -.% #"$ $+"."F/+21 7"#$-6(#-$%9 H1 $+% -#$+."S
3"6".3+(&6& +% 8(&+%& $" -'"(9> [%&3($% +(& 3."9(/("F& 2(#/F(&$(7 $-2%#$&B
+% (& #"$ &F00(7(%#$21 3"%$(7 $" %2F9% $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 &#-.%& "0 $+% 2-#/F-/%
+% 9%32"1&> ZF$ +(& 0-(2F.% $" -HRF.% 7"632%$%21 $+% 3.%RF9(7%& "0 O%&$%.#
+F6-#(&6 &+"F29 7"6% -& #" &F.3.(&% $" F&B ". $" +(6> M-'(#/ -##"F#7%9
$+% 9%-$+ "0 ^"9B =(%$A&7+% 7-F$("#& $+-$ 5/('%# $+% 8-1& "0 6%#B $+%.% 6-1
&$(22 H% 7-'%& 0". $+"F&-#9& "0 1%-.& (# 8+(7+ +(& &+-9"8 8(22 H% &+"8#;
`=(%$A&7+% )XCDB l)I?a> ,(#7% +% +-& #"$ 1%$ -H-#9"#%9 %#$(.%21 5$+% 8-1& "0
6%#;B 8% &+"F29 0F221 %V3%7$ $" 0(#9 &+-9"8& "0 $+% 9%-9 ^"9 02(7T%.(#/ "#
$+% 8-22& "0 +(& `-#9 q-.-$+F&$.-;&a 7-'%> Y#9%%9B 8% 7-# H% 7%.$-(# $+-$ $+%
%#$(7(#/ 9-#7% "0 $+%&% &+-9"8& 8(22 7"632(7-$% -#1 -$$%63$ $" H%+"29 $+%
8".29 50."6 (#&(9%;>
=(%$A&7+%;& %V3%.(6%#$ #%'%.$+%2%&& &F77%%9& (# `-$ 2%-&$a $8" 8-1&> W(.&$
"0 -22B +% 3"(#$& $+% 8-1 $"8-.9 - /%#F(#%21 $.-#&S+F6-# ".(%#$-$("# $"
3+(2"&"3+1> ,F77%&&". %V3%.(6%#$%.& 6-1 #"$ "#21 HF(29 F3"# +(& 3."/.%&&
$+F& 0-.B HF$ 6-1 -2&" $.%-$ +(& 0-(2F.%& -& "77-&("#& 0". 0F.$+%. &7.F$(#1> Y0
#"$+(#/ %2&%B =(%$A&7+%;& &F77%&&".& 6(/+$ &%$ $+%6&%2'%& $+% $-&T "0 H-#(&+S
(#/ $+% &+-9"8& $+-$ 7"#$(#F% $" 9-.T%# +(& 7-'%> *+-$ (&B $+% H%&$ 8-1 $"
+"#". +(& 7"#$.(HF$("#& $" $.-#&S+F6-# 3+(2"&"3+1 6-1 H% $" "'%.7"6%
+(6 (# $+% 3."7%&&B 2%/(&2-$(#/ "# +(& H%+-20 $+% &%20S"'%.7"6(#/ +% 3F.&F%9
HF$ #%'%. -7+(%'%9> *+(& 2%/(&2-$("# 6-1 (# $F.# .%_F(.%B "0 7"F.&%B $+-$
$.-#&S+F6-# 3+(2"&"3+%.& &%'%. $+%(. F6H(2(7-2 $(%& 8($+ =(%$A&7+%B (#
".9%. $+-$ +(& -/%#9- -#9 -F$+".($1 #"$ 6%./% 8($+ $+% 9-#7(#/ &+-9"8&
"0 $+% 9%-9 /"9> *" $-..1 (# $+% $+.-229"6 "0 =(%$A&7+% (& $" .(&T (#&$-22(#/
+(6B 6F7+ -& $+% 5+(/+%. 6%#; 7"6% $" 8".&+(3 q-.-$+F&$.-;& -&&B -& - _F-&(S
9('(#% -F$+".($1 (# $+% $8(2(/+$ "0 $+% (9"2&> ="8+%.% (& $+(& 9-#/%. 6".%
-33-.%#$ $+-# (# -# %-.21 %&&-1 H1 [%2%FA%B 8+(7+ -33."-7+%& +-/("/.-3+1
(# ($& -33.%7-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 9%S$%..($".(-2(&(#/ -77"632(&+6%#$&> Y# 3-&&-/% (# 8+(7+ +% %00%7$('%21 %V%63$& =(%$A&7+% 0."6 $+% 2(6($-$("#& "0
$+% -22S$""S+F6-#B [%2%FA% /F&+%&4
ZF$ (0 =(%$A&7+% 9"%& #"$ H%2"#/ $" 3+(2"&"3+1B ($ (& 3%.+-3& H%7-F&% +%
8-& $+% 0(.&$ $" 7"#7%('% "0 -#"$+%. T(#9 "0 9(&7"F.&% -& 7"F#$%.S3+(2"S
&"3+1> *+(& 9(&7"F.&% (& -H"'% -22 #"6-9(7m ($& &$-$%6%#$& 7-# H% 7"#S
7%('%9 -& $+% 3."9F7$& "0 - 6"H(2% 8-. 6-7+(#% -#9 #"$ $+% F$$%.-#7%& "0
- .-$("#-2B -96(#(&$.-$('% 6-7+(#%.1B 8+"&% 3+(2"&"3+%.& 8"F29 H% HF.S
%-7.-$& "0 3F.% .%-&"#>
`[%2%FA% )XCCB )DXa
,%7"#9B =(%$A&7+%;& "8# 0-(2F.%& 6(/+$ H% +%230F2 (# /F(9(#/ "F. -$$%63$&
$" 6%-&F.% -77F.-$%21 $+% &F77%&&%& -#9 2(6($-$("#& "0 +(& &F77%&&".&> ^('%#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )@J
"F. "8# +(&$".(7-2 3."V(6($1 $" =(%$A&7+% `-#9 9 2")#*")* $" $+% -9'%#$ "0
UF."3%-# #(+(2(&6aB - /%#F(#%21 $.-#&S+F6-# ".(%#$-$("# $" 3+(2"&"3+1
6-1 1%$ H% (63"&&(H2% 0". F& $" -7+(%'%> O% 6-1 H% #%-.21 -& &F&7%3$(H2% -&
+% $" F#8($$(#/ .%2-3&%& -#9 .%7(9('(&6&B -#9 "F. 3."V(6($1 $" $+% %'%#$ "0
#(+(2(&6 6-1 72"F9 "F. RF9/6%#$ (# 8-1& 8% 7-##"$ 1%$ 9(&7%.#> Q$ $+%
%V$.%6%B $+(& 9-#/%. (& 3%.+-3& H%&$ %V%632(0(%9 (# M%(9%//%.;& 3.%7(3($"F&
9%7(&("# (# )X@@ $" -&&F6% $+% .%7$".&+(3 -$ $+% \#('%.&($1 "0 W.%(HF./ -& 6%-#& "0 7"'%.$21 &+-3(#/ $+% =-$("#-2 ,"7(-2(&$ 6"'%6%#$> !"#'(#7%9 $+-$
- 8".29S+(&$".(7-2 6"6%#$ "0 7.(&(& 9%6-#9%9 '*% (66%9(-$% -#9 9%7(&('%
.%&3"#&%B M%(9%//%. (#9F2/%9 +(& F#$F$".%9 &163-$+(%& 8($+ =-$("#-2
,"7(-2(&6>@D ,%7.%$21 +"3(#/ $" 52%-9 $+% 2%-9%.; r.$& :,U')$) 2,U')$&s 0."6
8($+(# $+% =-$("#-2 ,"7(-2(&$ 6"'%6%#$B +% -33-.%#$21 8(&+%9 $" &$%%. $+%
^%.6-# X"4; $"8-.9 ($& "8#6"&$ &3(.($F-2 9%&$(#1> L0 7"F.&%B $+(& &7+%6%
8-& 3"".21 32-##%9 -#9 9(&-&$."F&21 %V%7F$%9B -& M%(9%//%. +(6&%20 .%-9(21
-7T#"82%9/%&> ZF$ ($& 3%.7%('%9 F./%#71 -$ $+% $(6% 7-# H% $.-7%9 (# 3-.$ $"
+(& 6(&6%-&F.% "0 $+% +(&$".(7-2 6"6%#$B $" +(& 6(&F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 #(+(S
2(&6B 8+(7+ 7"#$.(HF$%9 $" $+% (63-(.6%#$ "0 +(& RF9/%6%#$>
*+% 8".29 '(%8%9 50."6 (#&(9%; $+F& .%6-(#& - 3."R%7$ .-$+%. $+-# -#
-77"632(&+6%#$>@J Y#9%%9B $+% /%#(F& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& +13"$+%&(& "0 8(22 $"
3"8%. 2(%& #"$ (# ($& &F77%&& (# &%7F.(#/ 0". F& - /2(63&% "0 $+% 8".29 '(%8%9
0."6 (#&(9%B -& - 56"#&$%. "0 %#%./1;B HF$ (# ($& &F//%&$("# $+-$ "F. 0-(2F.% $"
9" &" #%%9 #"$ 7"#&$($F$% - 9%-9 %#9> M% $+F& (#'($%& +(& .%-9%.& $" 7"22-H".S
-$% "# -# %V3%.(6%#$ $+-$ +% T#"8& 6-1 $-T% 7%#$F.(%&B %'%# 6(22%##(-B $"
7"632%$%> *+% P2-$"#(7 &F# 6-1 H% - 7"29B 9%-9 &$-.B HF$ ($& 2(/+$ 8(22
7"#$(#F% $" .%-7+ h -#9 H2(#9 h "F. %1%& 0". 1%-.& $" 7"6%>@N
C$%() *+."F/+"F$ 3-.$ Y "0 $+(& %&&-1 Y "77-&("#-221 9.-8 "# .%8".T%9 &%#$%#7%& $+-$
".(/(#-221 -33%-.%9 (# !"#8-1 )XX<>
< M(& &%20S-33"(#$%9 %V%7F$".& 7"22%7$%9 +(& #"$%H""T %#$.(%& .%2-$(#/ $" #(+(2(&6 (#
5Z""T L#%; "0 D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)B F#9%. $+% +%-9(#/B 5UF."3%-# =(+(2(&6;>
@ W". - 3%.&F-&('% 9"7F6%#$-$("# "0 $+% 0(#-2($1 8($+ 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% -H-#9"#%9
+(& 32-#& 0". D'$ P*44 #" E"=$) &%% E-/#F& `)XX@B @ChDNa>
D Y# - 2%$$%. $" L'%.H%7T "# )? L7$"H%. )???B =(%$A&7+% &-1& "0 D'$ 1$F94,9#*"& "2 744
X94,$%B 5*+%.% 8(22 H% 0"F. H""T&m $+%1 8(22 -33%-. (#9('(9F-221 p$*&@$4&s; `=(%$A&7+%
)X?NB ?4DJ@a>
J Y# +(& P.%0-7% $" D=*4*?'# "2 #'$ -."4%B =(%$A&7+% 9-$%& +(& &(/#-$F.% 8($+ $+% 0"22"8S
(#/ (#&7.(3$("#4 5*F.(#B ,%3$%6H%. @IB )???B "# $+% 9-1 8+%# $+% 0(.&$ H""T "0 $+%
1$F94,9#*"& "2 744 X94,$% 8-& 7"632%$%9; `=(%$A&7+% )X?<B P.%0-7%a> Y# - 2%$$%. $"
L'%.H%7T "# )? L7$"H%. )???B +% 9%&7.(H%& $+% 0(.&$ H""T "0 $+% 1$F94,9#*"& -&
5.%-91 0". 3.%&& r.),/;2$)#*?s; `=(%$A&7+% )X?NB ?4 DJ@a>
N ,%% $+% 9(&7F&&("# "0 ZF99+(&6 (# =(%$A&7+% )X?<B <Ih@>
C M%(9%//%. &3%-T& "0 5$+% *&&$) 4"?*/ "0 #(+(2(&6;B 8+(7+ +% (9%#$(0(%& -& ($&
5%&&%#7%; `M%(9%//%. )X?<B J<hCa> M%(9%//%. -/-(# $-T%& F3 $+% _F%&$("# "0
=(%$A&7+%;& #(+(2(&6 (# 5*+% O".9 "0 =(%$A&7+%4 ^"9 (& [%-9;B 8+%.% +% 72-(6&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)@N !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
?
X
)I
))
)<
)@
)D
)J
)N
$+-$ 5=(%$A&7+% $+(#T& #(+(2(&6 -& $+% 55(##%. 2"/(7;; "0 O%&$%.# +(&$".1; `M%(9%//%.
)XCCB NCa>
=(%$A&7+% -&T& - &(6(2-. _F%&$("# "0 6%-#(#/ (# U&&-1 YYY "0 $+% O$&$94"?C0 P9%
+$.$,#$& 9%;$#*%/'$ -.$94$i =(%$A&7+%;& (#$%.%&$ (# $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6 $+F&
2(#T& $+(& #"$% $+%6-$(7-221 $" $+% $+(.9 U&&-1 "0 $+% O$&$94"?CB 8+(7+ (& 9%'"$%9
$" $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 $+% -&7%$(7 (9%-2> K-$%. (# $+% O$&$94"?CB +% %V32-(#& +(& +%.6%S
#%F$(7 0"7F&4 5Y$ (& 61 3F.3"&% +%.% $" H.(#/ $" 2(/+$B #"$ 8+-$ $+(& r-&7%$(7s (9%-2
+-& ."&$B HF$ &(6321 8+-$ ($ 5$9&%m 8+-$ ($ (#9(7-$%&m 8+-$ 2(%& +(99%# H%+(#9 ($B
H%#%-$+ ($B 8($+(# ($m "0 8+-$ ($ (& $+% 3."'(&("#-2B (#9(&$(#7$ %V3.%&&("#B "'%.2-(9
8($+ _F%&$("# 6-.T& -#9 6(&F#9%.&$-#9(#/&; `=(%$A&7+% )X?XB YYY4 <@a>
M%(9%//%.;& 7"#7%.# 8($+ $+% %&&%#7% rP$%$&s "0 #(+(2(&6 $+F& 6(&.%3.%&%#$&
=(%$A&7+%;& (#$%.%&$&B -#9 7"#&$($F$%& - &(/#(0(7-#$ 9%'(-$("# 0."6 =(%$A&7+%;&
"8# &$.-$%/1> M%(9%//%. .(/+$21 7"#72F9%& $+-$ 5=(%$A&7+% 7-##"$ $+(#T $+%
%&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6; `M%(9%//%. )XCCB X@aB HF$ $+%# =(%$A&7+%;& (#$%.%&$ 2-1 %2&%S
8+%.%B (# 9%$%.6(#(#/ $+% 5$9&*&? "0 #(+(2(&6>
O+(2% M%(9%//%. .(/+$21 7"#72F9%& $+-$ 5=(%$A&7+% 7-##"$ $+(#T $+% %&&%#7%
rP$%$&s "0 #(+(2(&6; `M%(9%//%. )XCCB X@aB =(%$A&7+%;& -7$F-2 (#$%.%&$ 2(%& %2&%S
8+%.%B (# 9%$%.6(#(#/ $+% 5$9&*&? "0 #(+(2(&6> M%(9%//%.;& /F(9(#/ 7"#7%.#
8($+ $+% %&&%#7% "0 #(+(2(&6 $+F& 6-.T& - &(/#(0(7-#$ 9%'(-$("# 0."6 =(%$A&7+%;&
"8# &$.-$%/1>
M%.% Y 9%3-.$ 0."6 $+% -77"F#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 -9'-#7%9 H1 E(7+-%2 Q2-# ^(22%&3(% (#
+(& %V7%22%#$ &$F91> Q33-.%#$21 7"#02-$(#/ $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 #(+(2(&6 8($+ ($& &"F.7%
". 7-F&%B ^(22%&3(% "H&%.'%& $+-$ 5#(+(2(&6B -77".9(#/ $" =(%$A&7+%B (& $+% 7"#&%S
_F%#7% "0 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ ^"9 -#9 -22 %$%.#-2 $.F$+& -#9 &$-#9-.9& H%7"6% F#H%2(%S
'-H2%> *+% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& 9%'-2F-$% $+%6&%2'%&; `^(22%&3(% )XXJB V(B $5I'Z 9..Za>
G%3.(&(#/ $+(& -77"F#$ 2-$%. (# +(& &$F91B ^(22%&3(% %V32-(#& $+-$ 5#(+(2(&6 0".
=(%$A&7+% (& $+% .%&F2$ "0 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ $+% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& 9%'-2F-$% $+%6&%2'%&B
$+-$ ^"9 -#9 .%-&"# -#9 -22 "0 $+% &F33"&%9 %$%.#-2 $.F$+& H%7"6% F#H%2(%'-H2%;
`^(22%&3(% )XXJB )CDB $5I'Z 9..>a> ^(22%&3(%;& $%#9%#71 $" 7"#02-$% $+% 6%-#(#/ "0
#(+(2(&6 8($+ ($& 7-F&% 6-1 3-.$(-221 %V32-(# 8+1 +% F2$(6-$%21 0(#9& =(%$A&7+%;&
#"$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 $" H% (#&F00(7(%#$>
Y# $+% <*)#' "2 D)9?$.CB =(%$A&7+% 3".$.-1%9 $+% 9%'-2F-$("# "0 $+% $.-/(7 8".29'(%8
-& H"$+ - 7"#&%_F%#7% "0 ($& 59%-$+ &$.F//2%; 8($+ ,"7.-$(7 "3$(6(&6 -#9 -& 5&F(7(9%;> M% 7"#0F&%921 H2-6%9 ,"7.-$%& -#9 UF.(3(9%& 0". (63%22(#/ $+% 59%-$+S
2%-3; "0 $.-/%91 9%&3($% +(& .%7"/#($("# $+-$ $+%1 8%.% F#-H2% $" -00%7$ $.-/%91
"$+%.8(&%> Y# $+% -77"F#$ "0 #(+(2(&6 F#9%. 7"#&(9%.-$("#B +"8%'%.B =(%$A&7+%
&F//%&$& $+-$ .('-2 7"#0(/F.-$("#& "0 '-2F% `%>/> ,"7.-$(&6a 0F#7$("# #"$ -& 7-F&%&
"0 9%'-2F-$("#B HF$ -& +(&$".(7-2 7-$-21&$& "0 9%'-2F-$("# $+-$ %V32"($ $+% (#$%.#-2
2"/(7 "0 $+%&% 9""6%9 '-2F%&>
Q& M%(9%//%. 3"(#$& "F$B 5*+% '%.1 3"&($(#/ "0 $+%&% '-2F%& (# $+% 8".29 (& -2.%-91
#(+(2(&6; `M%(9%//%. )X?<B DDa>
=(%$A&7+% -./F%& (# B$) 7&#*/')*%# $+-$ 5-22 $+% +(/+%&$ r"H%.&$%#s '-2F%& "0 6-#S
T(#9 2-7T $+(& 8(22 r$" 3"8%.s h $+-$ $+% '-2F%& 8+(7+ -.% &163$"6-$(7 "0 9%72(#%B
#(+(2(&$(7 '-2F%&B -.% 2".9(#/ ($ F#9%. $+% +"2(%&$ #-6%& `=(%$A&7+% )X?<B lNa>
W". $+% &F//%&$("# $+-$ =(%$A&7+%;& -77"F#$ "0 9%7-9%#7% ($&%20 7"#$.(HF$%& $" -#
%&"$%.(7 &$.-$%/1 9%&(/#%9 $" -77%2%.-$% $+% 9%7-1 "0 6"9%.#($1B &%% G"&%#B )X)h?>
L#21 (# $+% 8.($(#/& "0 2-$% )??? -#9 (# $+"&% 2%$$%.& (#&3(.%9 H1 (#7(3(%#$ 6-9S
#%&& 9"%& =(%$A&7+% 2-1 72-(6 $" -#1 8".29S+(&$".(7-2 3"2($(7-2 9%&(/#&> W". -#
-77"F#$ "0 $+% %6%./%#7% "0 3"2($(7& h $+%.%H1 %72(3&(#/ -%&$+%$(7& h -& $+% 56-&$%.
$."3%; "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $+"F/+$B &%% ,$."#/ )XX?> *F.#(#/ (# 59%&3%.-$("# $" 3"2($(7&;
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )@C
)C
)?
)X
<I
<)
<<
<@
<D
<J
=(%$A&7+% 5-$ $+% %#9 "0 +(& 2(0% > > > $+(#T& $+-$ - 3"2($(7-2 -7$ (& #%7%&&-.1 $" 6-T%
$+% -%&$+%$(7 %V3%.(%#7% 3"&&(H2%;B 8+(7+ 8"F29 (# $F.# 6-T% 5$+% .%7"/#($("# "0
&%20 -#9 "$+%. -#9 $+F& 3"2($(7& 3"&&(H2%; `,$."#/ )XX? )N?hXa>
Y# +(& #"$%&B =(%$A&7+% -##"F#7%& +(6&%20 `(# $+% $+(.9 3%.&"#a -& 5$+% 0(.&$ 3%.0%7$
#(+(2(&$ "0 UF."3%B 8+"B +"8%'%.B +-& %'%# #"8 2('%9 "F$&(9% $+% 8+"2% "0 #(+(2S
(&6B $" $+% %#9B 2%-'(#/ ($ H%+(#9B "F$&(9% +(6&%20; `=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l@a> G%$F.#(#/
$" $+(& $+%6%B +% (#$(6-$%&4 5*+-$ Y +-'% +($+%.$" H%%# - $+"."F/+S/"(#/ #(+(2(&$B Y
+-'% -96($$%9 $" 61&%20 "#21 .%7%#$214 $+% %#%./1 -#9 .-9(7-2(&6 8($+ 8+(7+ Y
-9'-#7%9 -& - #(+(2(&$ 9%7%('%9 6% -H"F$ $+(& H-&(7 0-7$; `(H(9>B l<Ja>
O+(2% .%7"F#$(#/ +(& "8# 7"#'-2%&7%#7%B =(%$A&7+% .%0%.& $" 53%.("9& "0 9%7-S
9%#7%; (# 8+(7+ +% 8-& "H2(/%9 $" 0".H(9 +(6&%20 -22 0%%2(#/& "0 )$%%$&#*5$&#
`=(%$A&7+% )X?X 48(&% Na> O($+ $+% 3-&&(#/ "0 &F7+ 3%.("9&B &F7+ 0%%2(#/& 8%.%
#"$ &" 6F7+ +-.60F2 $" +(6 -& &(6321 H%#%-$+ +(6>
^(22%&3(% 3%.&F-&('%21 9%6"#&$.-$%& 5#(+(2(&6 (& #"$ $+% 7%#$.-2 $%-7+(#/ "0
=(%$A&7+%;& $+"F/+$; `^(22%&3(% )XXJB )C?a>
O+(2% %V32-(#(#/ 8+1 8% 6F&$ 7"#7%#$.-$% "# =(%$A&7+%;& #"$%H""T& .-$+%. $+-#
"# +(& 3FH2(&+%9 8".T&B M%(9%//%. 9%&7.(H%& 5$+% $8" 0(#-2 1%-.& )??C -#9 )???; -&
5- $(6% "0 F$$%. 2F7(9($1 -#9 T%%# (#&(/+$; `M%(9%//%. )X?<B )@a> U'%# (0 8% /.-#$
M%(9%//%.;& -&&%&&6%#$ "0 $+% 3%.("9 )??Ch??B 8% 6(/+$ 8"#9%. 8+1 $+% 3FHS
2(&+%9 8".T& "0 $+(& 3%.("9 -.% #"$ "0 /.%-$%. '-2F% $" +(6> Q2$+"F/+ =(%$A&7+%;&
3FH2(&+%9 H""T& 0."6 $+(& 3%.("9 &-1 '%.1 2($$2% -H"F$ #(+(2(&6 ($&%20B $+% -77"F#$
"0 9%7-9%#7% $+%1 7"22%7$('%21 %&&-1 &F//%&$& $+-$ +% 8(&%21 &F&3%#9%9 +(& 32-#&
0". $+% %#'(&("#%9 >9,I#=$);>
=(%$A&7+% T#"8& $+-$ #"$+(#/ %#9F.%&B HF$ +% F&F-221 3.%&%#$& $+% $.F$+ "0 $+(&
(#&(/+$ -& ($&%20 %#9F.(#/> Q& 8% +-'% -2.%-91 &%%#B $+% $.F$+ "0 +(& +(&$".(7(&6 (&
#"$ ($&%20 +(&$".(7-2> M%(9%//%.;& 0-6"F& 7.($(7(&6 (& $+%.%0".% -77F.-$%B 0".
=(%$A&7+% +13"&$-$(&%& $+% &*'*4 "0 #(+(2(&6B $.-#&0".6(#/ ($ (#$" - $+(#/ ".
H%(#/ (# ($& "8# .(/+$4 5o%$ 0". =(%$A&7+% #(+(2(&6 (& #"$ (# -#1 8-1 &(6321 3+%#"6%#"# "0 9%7-1m .-$+%. #(+(2(&6 (&B -& $+% 0F#9-6%#$-2 %'%#$ "0 O%&$%.#
+(&$".1B &(6F2$-#%"F&21 -#9 -H"'% -22 $+% (#$.(#&(7 2-8 "0 $+-$ +(&$".1 > > > =(%$A&7+%
$+(#T& #(+(2(&6 -& $+% 55(##%. 2"/(7;; "0 O%&$%.# +(&$".1; `M%(9%//%. )XCCB NCa>
Y# Z""T f "0 D'$ O9C A/*$&/$B 8+(7+ +% -99%9 $" $+% )??N %9($("#B =(%$A&7+%
.%$F.#& $" $+% $+%6% "0 $+% 59%-$+ "0 ^"9; `=(%$A&7+% )XCDB l@D@a> G%3.(&(#/ $+%
(6-/%.1 "0 $+% E-96-# 3-&&-/% `(H(9>B l)<JaB +% #"8 (632(7-$%& +(6&%20 (# $+%
(/#".-#7% "0 $+% $"8#&3%"32% 8+" -.% 5.%&3"#&(H2%; 0". $+% 9%-$+ "0 ^"9> M% $""
+-& "'%.%&$(6-$%9 +(& -H(2($1 $" 9(/%&$ $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 $+(& F#3.%7%9%#$%9 %'%#$>
*+% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# -7$('% -#9 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6 (& .%2-$%9B $+"F/+ H1 #"
6%-#& (9%#$(7-2B $" $+% 9(&$(#7$("# +% 9.-8& (# +(& 3FH2(&+%9 8.($(#/& H%$8%%#
.%-2(&6 -#9 (9%-2(&6> ,%% =(%$A&7+% )X?<B )I4<m )X?XH4 72%'%. )I>
L# $+% 3."9F7$('%B 3F./-$('% 0F#7$("#& "0 #(+(2(&6B &%% Z2-#7+"$ )XX@B )@NhJ)>
*+% -7$('% #(+(2(&$B Z2-#7+"$ (#&(&$&B (& 9(&$(#/F(&+%9 H1 -# (#&(/+$ (#$" $+% $.-#S
&(%#7% "0 $+% %V3%.(%#7% "0 #%/-$("# $+-$ -77"63-#(%& #(+(2(&64 5=(+(2(&6 (& $+%
(63"&&(H(2($1 "0 H%(#/ 9"#% 8($+ ($ -#9 "0 0(#9(#/ - 8-1 "F$ %'%# (# $+-$ %#9 $+-$
(& #"$+(#/#%&&> Y$ &-1& $+% (63"$%#7% "0 #"$+(#/#%&&B $+% 0-2&% H.(22(-#7% "0 ($&
'(7$".(%&m ($ $%22& F& $+-$ 8+%# 8% $+(#T #"$+(#/#%&& 8% -.% &$(22 $+(#T(#/ H%(#/> > > >
=(+(2(&6 $+F& $%22& F& ($& 0(#-2 -#9 .-$+%. /.(6 $.F$+4 ($ $%22& "0 $+% (63"&&(H(2($1 "0
#(+(2(&6; `(H(9>B )DXa>
L# $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 9%7-9%#7% 8($+(# $+% %7"#"61 "0 8+"2%B -#9 =(%$A&7+%;&
8-'%.(#/ -22%/(-#7% $" -7$('% #(+(2(&6B &%% ,$-$%# )XX<B <<>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)@? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
<N Y# - #"$% (# 8+(7+ +% (#$."9F7%& $+% $%.6 5(#7"632%$% #(+(2(&6;B =(%$A&7+%
%V32-(#&4 5Q$$%63$& $" %&7-3% #(+(2(&6 8($+"F$ .%'-2F-$(#/ "F. '-2F%& &" 0-.4 $+%1
3."9F7% $+% "33"&($%B 6-T% $+% 3."H2%6 6".% -7F$%; `=(%$A7&+% )XN?B l<?a>
<C Q2$+"F/+ $+% .%'"2F$("#-.1 #-$F.% "0 =(%$A&7+%;& %V3%.(6%#$ 8($+ 8(22 $" 3"8%. (&
8(9%21 -33.%7(-$%9B ($ (& -2&" $13(7-221 +%29 $" &(/#-2 $+% &+(38.%7T "0 +(& "$+%.8(&%
3."6(&(#/ 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 3."R%7$> G%3.%&%#$-$('% "0 $+(& 9"6(#-#$ "3(#("# (& $+%
(#$%.3.%$-$("# 3."00%.%9 H1 b-.2 k-&3%.&> G%0%..(#/ %V32(7($21 $" $+% +13"$+%&(& "0
8(22 $" 3"8%.B k-&3%.& 7"#72F9%& $+-$4 5=(%$A&7+%;& $+"F/+$& -H"F$ $+% 8".29;
F#9%./" 5&%20S9%&$.F7$("#; `k-&3%.& )XNJB @<Xh@Ia> Q77".9(#/ $" k-&3%.&4 5O+-$B (#
=(%$A&7+%;& 6%9($-$("#& "# $.F$+B 8-& -# %V3.%&&('% 7(.72% 7"#&$-#$21 /('(#/ .(&% $"
#%8 6"'%6%#$& "0 $+"F/+$B 0(#-221 H%7"6%&B (# +(& $+"F/+$& -H"F$ $+% 8".29B -#
-##F26%#$ "0 6%$-3+1&(7& #"8 H%7"6% 9"/6-$(74 $+-$ "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.B -& 6(2($-#$ %V%/%&(& $%63".-.(21 H%2(%'%9> M%.% $+% 7"#$.-9(7$("#& H%7"6%
(#7-3-7($-$(#/B 0". $+%.% (& - 9%-9 0(#-2($1 -H"F$ $+%6 $+-$ 3.%'%#$& $+%6 0."6
/('(#/ .(&% $" -#1$+(#/ #%8; `k-&3%.& )XNJB @@Ia>
<? Y -6 (#9%H$%9 +%.% $" E-.T O-..%#;& %V7%22%#$ .%7"#&$.F7$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%;&
53+%#"6%#"2"/1 "0 -/%#71; `O-..%# )X??B )<Nh@Ia>
<X W". -# (#/%#("F& -#$(S6%$-3+1&(7-2 (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.B
&%% !2-.T )XXI> Q77".9(#/ $" !2-.T `)XXIB <)CaB $+% -./F6%#$ (# =(%$A&7+%
)X?X-B l@N4 59%3%#9r&s "# $+% 7-F&-2($1 "0 $+% 8(22B &"6%$+(#/ +% #"8+%.%
-77%3$&;> !2-.T $+F& 6-(#$-(#& #"$ "#21 $+-$ 5=(%$A&7+% /('%& F& '%.1 &$."#/ .%-&"#
$" 9%#1 $+-$ +% -77%3$& $+% -./F6%#$ "0 <$C"&. O"". 9&. 6F*4B l@N;B HF$ -2&"
$+-$ +(& %V%.7(&% (# &%20S&FH'%.&("# (& 5_F($% 9%2(H%.-$%;> !2-.T -&&F.%& F& $+-$
5=(%$A&7+% (& 7+-22%#/(#/ F& $" 2""T 0". -# %V32-#-$("#; "0 8(22 $" 3"8%. `!2-.T
)XXIB <)?a>
@I L# $+% .%2-$("#&+(3 "0 K(0% $" 8(22 $" 3"8%.B &%% k-&3%.& )XNJB <X@h@I<>
@) Y# - 3-.-22%2 9%'%2"36%#$B +(& 3"&$Sq-.-$+F&$.-# 8.($(#/& (9%#$(01 =-$F.% -& -#
%'%# 6".% H-&(7 6".3+"2"/(7-2 9(00%.%#$(-$("# "0 $+% 8(22 $" 3"8%.B "#% $+-$
7"63.(&%& $+% 8+"2% "0 K(0% 8($+(# ($& H"F#92%&& %7"#"61> Q2$+"F/+ 2%&& 0F221
9%'%2"3%9 $+-# +(& 9(&7F&&("#& "0 K(0%B +(& "77-&("#-2 -33%-2& $" =-$F.% .%3.%&%#$
+(& 6"&$ -6H($("F& `-#9 &F77%&&0F2a -$$%63$& $" .(9 +(& 3+(2"&"3+1 "0 ($& -#$+."S
3"7%#$.(7 3.%RF9(7%&> Q& 9%&7.(H%9 H1 =(%$A&7+% (# +(& 3"&$Sq-.-$+F&$.-# 8.($(#/&B
=-$F.% (& F#H"F#9%9B (#9%3%#9%#$ "0 -#9 (#9(00%.%#$ $" $+% 3%7F2(-. #%%9& -#9
9%6-#9& "0 K(0%> =-$F.% -96($& "0 #" "$+%.B 8+%$+%. +"&3($-H2% ". +"&$(2% $" K(0%B
$+-$ (63"&%& 7"#9($("#& F3"# $+% (#$%.#-2 .%/F2-$("# "0 ($& %7"#"61> *" $+"&%
3+(2"2"/(7-221 (#%3$ 53+1&(7(&$&; 8+" 72-(6 $" 9%9F7% 9%6"7.-$(7 3.(#7(32%& 0."6
$+% 7-#"# "0 #-$F.-2 2-8B +% .%R"(#&4 5r,s"6%H"91 6(/+$ 7"6% -2"#/ 8+"B 8($+
"33"&($% (#$%#$("#& -#9 6"9%& "0 (#$%.3.%$-$("#B 7"F29 .%-9 "F$ "0 $+% &-6%
55=-$F.%;;B -#9 8($+ .%/-.9 $" $+% &-6% 3+%#"6%#-B .-$+%. $+% $1.-##(7-221 (#7"#S
&(9%.-$% -#9 .%2%#$2%&& %#0".7%6%#$ "0 72-(6& "0 3"8%.; `=(%$A&7+%)X?X-B l<<a> W".
- &F&$-(#%9 9(&7F&&("# "0 $+% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# K(0% -#9 =-$F.%B &%% !"#8-1
)XXJ>
@< W". - 3"&($('% (#$%.3.%$-$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 7.($(_F% "0 (#9('(9F-2 -/%#71B &%%
M-6-7+%. )X?NB @)Nh<@>
@@ L# $+(& $"3(7 "0 =(%$A&7+%;& .%&(9F-2 +F6-#(&$ -22%/(-#7%&B +(& 5.%6-(#(#/ 7-F/+$
F3 (# $+% #%$ "0 -#$+."3"6".3+(&6;B &%% Q#&%22 P%-.&"# )XXCB )N)hD>
@D Y -6 (#9%H$%9 0". $+(& (#$%.3.%$-$("# $" ,2F/-B 8+" 7"#'(#7(#/21 9"7F6%#$&
M%(9%//%.;& 6"6%#$ "0 57.(&(&;>
@J =(%$A&7+%;& 0-(2F.% $" /-(# -77%&& $" $+% 8".29 '(%8%9 50."6 (#&(9%; 8"F29 -33%-. $"
7"#0(.6 M%(9%//%.;& 0-6"F& 7.($(_F%4 5*+(& 6-T%& 72%-. (# 8+-$ .%&3%7$ $+% 6"9S
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )@X
%.# 6%$-3+1&(7& "0 &FHR%7$#%&& (& 7"#&F66-$%9 (# =(%$A&7+%;& 9"7$.(#% "0 8(22 $"
3"8%. -& $+% 55%&&%#7%;; "0 %'%.1$+(#/ .%-2; `M%(9%//%. )XCCB ?@a>
@N Y 8"F29 2(T% $" $+-#T [(-#% E"./-# -#9 b%($+ Q#&%22 P%-.&"# 0". $+%(. %V7%22%#$
%9($".(-2 7"66%#$& "# -# %-.2(%. 9.-0$ "0 $+(& %&&-1> ,%7$("# Y "0 $+(& %&&-1 6-T%&
F&% "0 &"6% 3-.-/.-3+& $+-$ ".(/(#-221 -33%-.%9 (# 61 %&&-1B 5M%(9%//%.B
=(%$A&7+%B -#9 $+% L.(/(#& "0 =(+(2(&6;B 8",)&94 "2 !*$#@%/'$ A#,.*$%B @4))hD@>
*+."F/+"F$ ,%7$("#& YYhYf "0 $+(& %&&-1B Y .%21 "# .%8".T%9 6-$%.(-2& 9.-8# 0."6
!+-3$%.& < -#9 D "0 61 !*$#@%/'$N% B9&?$)",% O95$0 E'*4"%"I'C *& #'$ D=*4*?'# "2 #'$
-."4% `!-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&B )XXCa> Y -6 /.-$%0F2 $" !-6H.(9/%
\#('%.&($1 P.%&& 0". $+%(. T(#9 3%.6(&&("# $" .%3.(#$ $+%&% 6-$%.(-2& (# .%'(&%9
0".6>
0(D()(,1(Q#&%22 P%-.&"#B b> `)XXCa X*)"*. L*2$Z E$)%I$/#*F$% "& !*$#@%/'$ 9&. #'$ D)9&%',59&
("&.*#*"&> K"#9"#4 G"F$2%9/%>
Z2-#7+"$B E> `)XX@a D'$ -&2*&*#$ ("&F$)%9#*"&B $.-#&> ,F&-# M-#&"#> E(##%-3"2(&4 \#(S
'%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
!2-.TB E> `)XXIa !*$#@%/'$ "& D),#' 9&. E'*4"%"I'C> !-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1
P.%&&>
!"#8-1B [> `)XX<a 5M%(9%//%.B =(%$A&7+% -#9 $+% L.(/(#& "0 =(+(2(&6;B 8",)&94 "2
!*$#@%/'$ A#,.*$%B ,3.(#/ Y&&F% YYYB ))hD@>
!"#8-1B [> `)XXJa 5G%$F.#(#/ $" =-$F.%4 =(%$A&7+%;& O"U##$).9U55$),&?N (# !*$#@%/'$0 7
()*#*/94 1$9.$)B %9> P> ,%9/8(7T> K"#9"#4 Z2-7T8%22>
[%2%FA%B ^> `)XCCa 5="6-9 *+"F/+$; $.-#&> [-'(9 Z> Q22(&"#> Y# D'$ !$= !*$#@%/'$0
("&#$5I")9)C A#C4$% "2 -&#$)I)$#9#*"&B %9> [-'(9 Z> Q22(&"#> =%8 o".T4 [%2$- Z""T&>
^(22%&3(%B E> `)XXJa !*'*4*%5 <$2")$ !*$#@%/'$> !+(7-/"4 \#('%.&($1 "0 !+(7-/" P.%&&>
g H%. Y#9('(9FF6 F#9
M-6-7+%.B O> `)X?Na 5 55[(&/.%/-$("# 9%& O(22%#&;;4 =(%$A&7+% F
Y#9('(9F-2($-g$; (# !*$#@%/'$JA#,.*$& )J>
M%(9%//%.B E> `)XCCa 5*+% O".9 "0 =(%$A&7+%4 ^"9 (& [%-9; (# D'$ ],$%#*"& ("&/$)&*&?
D$/'&"4"?C 9&. Q#'$) 6%%9C%B $.-#&> -#9 %9> O(22(-6 K"'($$> =%8 o".T4 M-.3%. u G"8>
M%(9%//%.B E> `)X?<a !*$#@%/'$ -X0 !*'*4*%5B $.-#&> -#9 %9> [>W> b.%22> ,-# W.-#7(&7"4
M-.3%. u G"8>
k-&3%.&B b> `)XNJa !*$#@%/'$0 7& -&#)".,/#*"& #" #'$ [&.$)%#9&.*&? "2 >*% E'*4"%"I'*/94
7/#*F*#CB $.-#&> !>W> O-22.-00 -#9 W>k> ,7+6($A> ,"F$+ Z%#9B Y=4 G%/#%.1]^-$%8-1>
E-/#F&B Z>B $# 94> `)XX@a !*$#@%/'$N% (9%$0 E'*4"%"I'C 9%d9&. L*#$)9#,)$> =%8 o".T4
G"F$2%9/%>
,2F/-B M> `)XX@a >$*.$??$)N% ()*%*%0 E'*4"%"I'C 9&. E"4*#*/% *& !9@* O$)59&C> !-6H.(9/%B
EQ4 M-.'-.9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XNCa D'$ <*)#' "2 D)9?$.C -#9 D'$ (9%$ "2 P9?&$) $.-#&> -#9 %9> O-2$%.
b-F06-##> =%8 o".T4 f(#$-/% Z""T&>
pp `)XNC 00a P$);$0 G)*#*%/'$ O$%95#9,%?9+$B %9&> ^> !"22( -#9 E> E"#$(#-.(> Z%.2(#4
O-2$%. [% ^.F1$%.>
pp `)XN?a D'$ P*44 D" E"=$)B $.-#&> O-2$%. b-F06-## -#9 G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B %9> O-2$%.
b-F06-##> =%8 o".T4 f(#$-/% Z""T&>
pp `)XCDa D'$ O9C A/*$&/$B $.-#&> O-2$%. b-F06-##> =%8 o".T4 f(#$-/% Z""T&>
pp `)X?<a D'$ 7&#*/')*%# h D=*4*?'# "2 #'$ -."4% (# D'$ E")#9+4$ !*$#@%/'$B %9> -#9 $.-#&>
O-2$%. b-F06-##> =%8 o".T4 f(T(#/ P%#/F(#>
pp `)X?Na A9U5#4*/'$ <)*$2$R G)*#*%/'$ A#,.*$&9,%?9+$ *& _ <9U&.$&B %9&> ^> !"22( -#9 E>
E"#$(#-.(> Z%.2(#4 O-2$%. [% ^.F1$%.][%F$&7+%. *-&7+%#HF7+ f%.2-/>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)DI !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
pp `)X?X-a <$C"&. O"". 9&. 6F*4B $.-#&> O-2$%. b-F06-##> =%8 o".T4 f(#$-/% Z""T&>
pp `)X?XHa 6//$ >"5" -#9 Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94% $.-#&> u %9> O-2$%. b-F06-##
8($+ G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B =%8 o".T4 f(#$-/% Z""T&>
G"&%#B ,> `)X?Xa 5=(%$A&7+%;& G%'"2F$("#; (# D'$ 7&/*$&#% 9&. #'$ 3".$)&%> =%8 M-'%#4
o-2% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
,$-$%#B M> `)XX<a !*$#@%/'$N% X"*/$> Y$+-7-B =o4 !".#%22 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
,$."#/B *> `)XX?a 5=(%$A&7+%;& P"2($(7-2 Q%&$+%$(7&; (# !*$#@%/'$N% !$= A$9%B %9& E>
^(22%&3(% -#9 *> ,$."#/> !+(7-/"4 \#('%.&($1 "0 !+(7-/" P.%&&>
O-..%#B E> `)X??a !*$#@%/'$ 9&. E"4*#*/94 D'",?'#> !-6H.(9/%B EQ4 EY* P.%&&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 ("&=9C )D)
C
5P."'"T%9 K(0%;4 UV3.%&&(#/ =(+(2(&6
M-'(#/ -28-1& 0"./%9 ($& 8-1 8($+ -7-F&-2 &$%3&B $+% H.-(# (& $+%
3.(6% %V-632% "0 $+% 31/61 7+-.-7$%. "0 7-F&-2 2-8&> W-7%9 8($+
$+% H.-(#B -22 H("2"/(7-2 +13"$+%&%& 0-(2> Q77".9(#/ $" $+% 8".T "0
f%.&2F1&B P"%$A2 -#9 K".%#AB ($ &%%6& $" +-'% 9%'%2"3%9 ($&%20
$+."F/+ - &-2$-$".1 9"FH2(#/ "0 $+% #%F."#%& -77"63-#(%9 H1
#%8 0".6-$("#& "0 $+% 7".$(7-2 A"#%&> 5Y#$%.6%9(-.1 0".6& -.% 6(&&S
(#/;> ="$+(#/ +%.% $" 9" 8($+ -9-3$-$("#B #" &F66-$("# "0 $+%
&6-22%&$ &$(6F2(B #" /.-9F-2 9%7"63"&($("# -#9 6-$F.-$("# 2%-9(#/
$" -#1 3F.3"&('% -9RF&$6%#$ `T=$/;59Un*?;$*#%,5%#$44,&?aB '$)$
#'$)$ 94=9C% =$)$ /)$9#*F$ /)*%$%> Y$ (& $+% 6F$-$('%B (>%> .%'"2F$("#-.1B
"./-# 3-. %V7%22%#7%> Y$& %&&%#7% 8-& #%'%. 7"#$%#$B HF$ -28-1&
0".6m ($& 6%-#& (#$%#&(0(7-$("#m ($& 9%6-#9 &$(6F2-$("#>
*+(& 2"9/% "0 .F9(6%#$& -#9 7-$-7"6H& H."F/+$ %'%.1$+(#/ 8($+ ($
.(/+$ 0."6 $+% H%/(##(#/m ($ #%'%. +-9 $" .%21 "# (63.%&&("#&B ($
3."9F7%9 ($&%20 8+%# 7-22%9 F3"#> Y$& 3.%9(2%7$("#& 8%.% #"
8-1 2(6($%9 $" 55K(0%;; HF$ (#72F9%9 2%$+-2 0-7$".&B +F#/%.B
0-&$(#/B 8-2T(#/ "# #-(2&B &#-T%S7+-.6(#/B 6-/(7B $+% H("#%/-$('%B
9%-$+>
Z%## 5P."'"T%9 K(0%; `)XD@a
W2""9& 7-F&%9 H1 6%2$(#/ (7%7-3&B 8+"2% 2-#9S6-&&%& &FH6%./%9m $+% "7%-#&
&$-.'%9 "0 "V1/%# H1 HF./%"#(#/ -2/-% 8+(7+ $+.('%& "00 %002F%#$m $+% "#7%
(##"7F"F& &"1-H%-# /%#%$(7-221 6"9(0(%9 (#$" -# (#&(9("F&B -22S3%.'-&('%B
7-#7%.S3."'"T(#/ &FH&$-#7%m 72(#(7-221 H.-(# 9%-9 8"6%# F&%9 -& 5-2$%.#-S
$('% .%3."9F7$('% '%+(72%&;m $+% 7"F#$.1&(9% .%&"F#9& 8($+ $+% H2%-$& "0
-H&"2F$%21 (9%#$(7-2 5["22(%&;4 &F7+ (& $+% 0F$F.% 0-7(#/ F&> !"8& -#9 7+(7T%#&
$.-#&0".6%9 (#$" A"6H(% T(22(#/ 6-7+(#%&B 8+"&% &-7.(0(7%9 7-.7-&%& &%%3
(#$" 8-$%. .%&%.'%&B 3"22F$(#/ $+% 8+"2% %7"&1&$%6> MF6-#& -.% %-$(#/ $+%(.
"8# 6-9#%&& -& $+%1 $F7T (#$" $+%(. 7-.#('"."F& 7"8S.F63&> ,"6%$+(#/ (&
&%.("F&21 8."#/> ZF$ 8+" 9" 8% $.F&$ $" 3F$ ($ .(/+$i)
)D<
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B*9&$ 3")?9&
Z-7T (# $+% )X<I& .(/+$ $+."F/+ $" $+% )XJI&B ^"$$0.(%9 Z%## h 9"7$". 0".
&T(# -002(7$("#&B '%#%.%-2 9(&%-&%& -#9 %V3.%&&("#(&$ 3"%$ h 0-7%9 $+% 9-F#$(#/
0F$F.% 7"#RF.%9 F3 H1 &F7+ _F%&$("#&> [.-8(#/ $"/%$+%. +(& (#$%.%&$ 0". -#9
%V3%.$(&% (# $+% #-$F.-2 &7(%#7% -#9 +(& -0$%.S&F./%.1S+"F.& 9%9(7-$("# $"
21.(7 3"%$.1B +% 8."$% %V$.-".9(#-.1 7"#$.(HF$("#& `%&&-1& -#9 3"%6&a $"
$+% 9%H-$%& -."F#9 #(+(2(&6 .-/(#/ -$ $+% H%/(##(#/ "0 $+% 7%#$F.1> M"8S
%'%.B 3%.+-3& 3.%7(&%21 H%7-F&% "0 $+% H(A-..% 7"#7"7$("# "0 6"9%.# &7(%#$S
(0(7 $+%".(%& (#$%.&32(7%9 8($+ %V3.%&&("#(&$ 21.(7(&6B +% 8-& #%'%. RF&$ 3."9F7$ "0 +(& $(6%>< Y#9%%9B $+(& 7+-3$%. 8-#$& $" &+"8 +"8 Z%##;& #"$("#
"0 53."'"T%9 2(0%;B .%/-.9%9 -& $+% 6"&$ -33."3.(-$% .%$".$ $" $+% "77(9%#$;&
3-&&('% &2(9% (#$" - $%.6(#-2 3+-&%B +-& 6F7+ $" 7"#$.(HF$% $" - $+(#T(#/ "0
#(+(2(&6B #"8j
[.-8(#/ "# =%8$"#(-# 3+1&(7&B M%26+"2$AB [-.8(# -#9 7"#$%63".-.1
$+(#T%.& "0 %#$."31B Z%## &F//%&$& $+-$ $+% 6"9%.# 8".29 +-& H%%# &$.-33%9
9"8# -#9 &$.%$7+%9 "F$ H1 6%7+-#(&$(7S9%$%.6(#(&$(7 2-8& 3F.3".$(#/ $"
7+-.$ 2(0%;& 3."/.%&&B 8+%$+%. $+(& H% 5F38-.9&; h $"8-.9& -# (#%'($-H21
%'%.S(#7.%-&(#/ &"3+(&$(7-$("# h ". 9"8#8-.9& h $"8-.9& -# (#%'($-H2% %'%#S
$F-2 +%-$S9%-$+>@ Z%## 72-(6& $+-$B (# $+% %(/+$%%#$+ 7%#$F.1B ($ 8-& ^"%$+%
8+" 0(.&$ .%-7$%9 -/-(#&$ $+% (#(_F($"F& %00%7$& "0 $+(& 53."/.%&&('%
7%.%H.-2(&-$("#; "0 2(0%;& 6"'%6%#$& `Z%## )X?X-B <I@a> ^"%$+% .%&(&$%9
&F7+ -$$%63$& $" 3.%9(7$ $+% 0F$F.% H1 3"&($(#/ $%2%"2"/(7-2 %#9&> *F7T%9
F#9%. $+% -F&3(7%& "0 -# %#/2"H(#/ 53%.&3%7$('%;BD &F7+ -& 7-F&-2($1B $+%
0F$F.% (& $F.#%9 (#$" - H(//%.B H%$$%. `".B 0". $+% 3%&&(6(&$&B - 8%-T%.B 8".&%a
'-.(-$("# "0 $+% 3.%&%#$> Y$ (& #"$ - 0F$F.% -$ -22> W". ^"%$+% $+(& 6(#9S&%$
.%3.%&%#$& - 9(.% 0-(2F.% $" 7"#0."#$ 2(0%;& F#3.%9(7$-H2% '($-2($1> ^"%$+%;&
7.-A1 3."R%7$ $" 0(#9 $+% ".(/(#-.1 32-#$ `[)I49&@$a 0."6 8+(7+ -22 &FH&%S
_F%#$ 02"8%.(#/& -#9 0"2(-$("#& &$%6B (& - 3-&&("#-$% -$$%63$ $" $.-7% $+%
6".3+"2"/(7-2 $.-#&6F$-$("#& "0 #-$F.%B ($& H(A-..% (#$%..%2-$%9#%&&B ($&
8-7T1 "00&+""$&B $+%.%H1 .%&(&$(#/ &$F2$(01(#/ 72-&&(0(7-$".1 7"63.%&&("#&
(#$" 9(&7.%$% &3%7(%&> K(T%8(&%B +(& 9"//%9 3F.&F($ "0 $+% (#$%.6-V(22-.1
H"#% `$+% T=*%/'$&;*$2$);&"/'$&a 8-& +(& 8-1 "0 H.%-T(#/ 9"8# $+% H-..(%.
H%$8%%# $+% -#(6-2 -#9 $+% +F6-#B "0 .%&(&$(#/ $+% -22S$""S3.%'-2%#$ $%#S
9%#71 $" &%% $+% +F6-# -& -.(&(#/ ",# "2 -#9 9=9C 2)"5 $+% -#(6-2 8".29>J
!"#$(#F(#/ (# +(& "8# 8-1 &F7+ ^"%$+%-# 3.%"77F3-$("#&B Z%## .%&(&$&
$+% 3.%'-(2(#/ 32-$($F9%& "0 +(& $(6%> Y# 5P."H2%6& "0 $+% P"%$(7-2; `)X@Ia +%
/('%& '%#$ $" +(& 9%$%&$-$("# "0 8+-$ +% &%%& -& $+% [-.8(#(-# 56"F#$-(#%%.S
(9%-2; 8+(7+ .%/-.9& $+% MF6-# -& $+% '(7$". "0 $+% &$.F//2% 0". %V(&$%#7%B
H.-A%#21 H%9%7T%9 8($+ 5$+% &7-23& "0 -#(6-2&; `Z%## )X?X-B ?Ja> W". &F7+ MF6-#B $+% 3-&$ (& RF&$ - 59%&7%#9%#7%S&2-/ +%-3; `Z%## )X?X-B ?NhCa 7"6S
3.(&(#/ "0 8".$+2%&& 8-&$% 6-$$%. %2(6(#-$%9 (# $+% .-$("#-2(&%9 3F.&F($ "0 +%-2$+S".(%#$%9 5.-7% 7"#&"2(9-$("#; `19%%$&$)#,U/'#*?,&?a>N M(&$".1 0". &"7(-2
[-.8(#(-#& (& RF&$ - +(/+S3%.0".6-#7%B -#$+."3"6".3+(7 5&$%%32% 7+-&%;
$"8-.9& - #%HF2"F& 7"#7%3$ "0 %V7%22%#7% `Z%## )X?X-B <NJa> U_F-221B Z%##
&F//%&$& $+-$ $+% 7"#7%3$ "0 %'"2F$("# +-& -2&" H%%# F&%9 -& - 7"60".$(#/
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B*9&$ 3")?9& )D@
5#(/+$7-3; $" 8-.9 "00 %'%.1$+(#/ $+-$ 6(/+$ 9(&$F.H $+% +F6-#;& &2%%31 &%20S
-&&F.-#7% $+-$ $(6% (& "# +(& &(9%B 0-($+0F221 0F.$+%.(#/ $+% .-7%4 53&&+j
_F(%$%# 9"8#j 8%;'% /"$ "F. %'"2F$("#; `Z%## )X?X-B @Ja> Z%##B 8+%# +%
(& #"$ (# +(& "8# 0-&7(&$(7-221 H%22(7"&% 53%.("9;B (& -2&" 9(&/F&$%9 H1 $+% F&% $"
8+(7+ %'"2F$("# +-& H%%# 3F$ H1 &"7(-2 [-.8(#(-#&4 .%21(#/ "# - 0-2&%
3-.-22%2 H%$8%%# "./-#(7 2(0% -#9 +F6-# 7F2$F.%B $+% %V3.%&&("#& 5&$.F//2%
0". %V(&$%#7%; -#9 5&F.'('-2 "0 $+% 0($$%&$; +-'% H%%# F&%9 $" RF&$(01 7"2"#(-2(&S
(#/ 8-. -#9 $+% &1&$%6-$(7 %2(6(#-$("# "0 $+"&% 9%%6%9 $" H% 8%-T>C
Y# $+% 32-7% "0 &F7+ .%9F7$('% .%-9(#/& "0 #-$F.%B $+% "./-#(7 8".29 -#9
+F6-#&; 32-7% 8($+(# ($B Z%## 0-'"F.& - .-9(7-221 9(00%.%#$ 3%.&3%7$('%> Y#
)X<IB 8+%# -99.%&&(#/ 3."&3%7$('% 6%9(7-2 &$F9%#$&B +% .%6-.T& F3"# $+%
0-7$ $+-$ 6-#1 "0 $+%6 -.% $.-F6-$(&%9 -#9 %V+-F&$%9B +-'% H."T%# 2(6H&
-#9 /2-&&S%1%&B +-'(#/ H%%# $+."F/+ $+% 56F9 1%-.&; `.*$ A/'4955K9')$&a "0
o3.%& -#9 %V3%.(%#7%9 $+% 3-(#0F2 (63-7$ "0 &"S7-22%9 `$%7+#"2"/(7-2 -#9
&"7(-2a -9'-#7%6%#$ `Z%## )X?X-B <Xa> Q#9 #"8B +%.% $+%1 -.%B -H"F$ $"
%6H-.T F3"# - (#($(-$("# (#$" $+% '%#%.-H2% 6%9(7-2 3."0%&&("# 8+(7+B
F#3%.$F.H%9 H1 .%7%#$ %'%#$&B 3.(9%& ($&%20 "# ($& _F%&$ $" H"2&$%. $+%
+F6-# H"91 (# $+% #-6% "0 +%-2$+B H"$+ (#9('(9F-2 -#9 #-$("#-2> ,F.%21
$+% 8+"2% H"91 3"2($(7 (& &(7T -#9 /-#/.%#"F&i ,+"F29 ($ 7"#$(#F-221 H%
3-$7+%9 F3 -#9 9F$(0F221 .%9(&3-$7+%9 "#$" $+% -&&%6H21S2(#% 8+(7+ 7-..(%&
($ (#%2F7$-H21 $" 6%-#(#/2%&& 9%&$.F7$("#i Z%## 3."3"&%& - .%'-2F-$("# "0
$+% 0F$F.% -#9 %#R"(#& $+% 6%9(7-2 &$F9%#$& $" .%7"#&(9%. $+%(. 3"&($("#4
8+%.% -.% $+%1 +%-9(#/ -#9 8+1i
*" +%23 $+%6 "# $+%(. 8-1B Z%## 3."3"&%& $+-$ $+% 6"9%.# %/" +-&
6%$-6".3+"&%9 (#$" &"6%$+(#/ '%.1 9(00%.%#$ 0."6 ($& 3.(". (#7-.#-$("#&>
Z-7T (# $+% -/% "0 5U#2(/+$%#6%#$;B 3.%0".6-$("#(&$&B &F7+ -& M-22%.B 3.%S
%63$%9 -# %#7"F#$%. "0 $+% F#T#"8# H1 "F$2-8(#/ -#1 H%7"6(#/> [%'%2S
"36%#$ 8-& .%9F7%9 $" - 3.%7""T%9 .%7(3% 8+(7+ RF&$ #%%9%9 $" H% .%+%-$%9
`8+%$+%. H1 $+% 6-2% &3%.6 ". 0%6-2% %//a (# ".9%. $" H% -7$F-2(&%9 `Z%##
)X?X-B @Ja> *+(& 8-& "#% "0 - 8+"2% &%.(%& "0 /%#%.-2 2-8& 8+(7+ 3F.3".$%9 $"
-77"F#$ 0". -22 0F$F.% 9%'%2"36%#$> Q& 8% +-'% -2.%-91 &%%#B Z%## &%%&
[-.8(#(&6 -& %V$%#9(#/ $+(& (/#".-#7% "0 .%-2 7+-#/% 8($+ ($& 7"#0(9%#$
(#'%&$6%#$ (# +F6-# 3."/.%&&> Q& - 7"F#$%.3"(#$ $" &F7+ &$"2(9 $+%".(%&B
Z%## %&3"F&%& $+% '(%83"(#$ "0 &"6%"#% 2(T% ,%6( E%1%.> Y#&$%-9 "0 &%%(#/
0F$F.% 9%'%2"36%#$ -& #%-$21 %#7-3&F2-$%9 (# 3.(". 0".6&B E%1%.;& E)"+4$5%
"2 #'$ B$F$4"I5$&# "2 AI*)*# %V32".%& - 9%'%2"36%#$ -& - 3.(#7(32% 8+(7+ 9"%&
#"$ 6%.%21 F#8(#9 ". F#0"29 ($&%20 HF$ 8+(7+ (#&$%-9 7.%-$('%21 HF(29& "#
$+% -'-(2-H2% H-&(& (# - (#7-27F2-H2% 0-&+("# `Z%## )X?X-B @?a> ="8 $+% &3(.($
7-# H% 0.%% -& "'%..(9(#/ /%#%.-2 2-8& `$+"&% /.-#9 "29 #-..-$('%&a +-'% 0-22%#
(#$" 9(&.%3F$% -#9 7.%-$("# (& -$ 2-&$ &%%# $" H% 2-9%# 8($+ F#0".%&%%-H2%
3"$%#$(-2> \#+($7+%9 0."6 $+% .%9F7$('% HF.9%# "0 /%#%.-2 3."/.%&&B %-7+
"#% "0 F& H%7"6%& - `"F. "8#a 9%&$(#1> Z%## %V".$& $+"&% 6%9(7-2 0.%&+6%#
$" $-T% -#"$+%. 2""T -$ $+% _F-&(S9('(#% -F$+".($-$('% 0(/F.%& $" 8+"6 $+%1
8%.% &" /.-$%0F2 0". H%(#/ /.-7%0F221 .%7%('%9 H14 52(&$%#B 8+-$ - 3."9F7$('%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)DD !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
02-$F2%#7%B 0."6 H%+(#9 $+% $.F$+S9.('% (& 9(&7+-./%9 -#9 0."6 $+% 0."#$ $+%
0.%% .%&%-.7+m +% 8(3%& +(6&%20 8($+ $+% 72%-#2(#%&& "0 $+% (#$%22%7$F-2 -$$(S
$F9% +%29 (# +(& .(/+$ +-#9 -#9 $+% .%0F&-2 "0 -22 &3%7F2-$("# (# +(& 2%0$; `Z%##
)X?X-B @?hXa> Z%## 7-22& "# $+% 1"F#/ &$F9%#$& $" .%R%7$ $+% 3"#$(0(7-$(#/
&$-2%#%&& "0 $+% "29 -#9 $" &%(A% $+% 3"$%#$(-2 "0 #%8 8-1& "0 2""T(#/ -$ $+%
8".29> ^"#% -.% 6%7+-#(&$(7S9%$%.6(#(&$(7 2-8& /"'%.#(#/ 1"F. %'%.1 6"'%S
6%#$B 9%0F#7$ (& (#9F7$('% .%-&"#(#/ (#$%#$ "# (63"&(#/ ($& 3.%&F63$F"F&
0".6F2-% "# "HR%7$&B $+%.%H1 H2(#9(#/ ($&%20 $" -#1 '(&("# "0 9(00%.%#7% `Z%##
)X?X-B )C)a> P+%#"6%#- &F7+ -& P(7-&&";& '("2(#& 6F&$ H% &%%# -& -V%& 9%-2S
(#/ 9%-921 H2"8& $" $+% "29 5.%-2($1;> Q6"#/&$ $+% 9%H.(& "0 - HF&$%9 7"&6"&
$+% #%8 /%#%.-$("# -.% 0.%% $" (#'%#$ $+%(. "8# 3-$+8-1& `Z%## )X?X-B @Xa>
*+%&% 1"F$+0F2 #(+(2(&$& &$-#9 "# $+% %9/% "0 #"$+(#/#%&&B 8+%.% 0".6S
2%&&#%&& 2F.T& `Z%## )X?X-B @Xa> M-.921 &F.3.(&(#/ $+-$ $+% _F%&$("# F./%&
($&%20 8+%$+%. ($ (& .%-221 8".$+8+(2% $" 7-..1 "# $+% &-#($(&(#/ 8".T "0
3.%'("F& 1%-.&B 3-$7+(#/ F3 -(2(#/ H"9(%& 8($+ (#R%7$("#&B "(#$6%#$&B H-#S
9-/%&B 8+%# $+% .-7% 6(/+$ H% "# $+% '%.1 '%./% "0 6F$-$(#/ (#$" -#"$+%.
0".6> Z%## (& - 0-($+0F2 0"22"8%. "0 *F./%#%';& Z-A-."' 8+%#B -& - 9"7$".B +%
$+."8& 9"FH$ "# "F. 0-($+ (# 6%9(7(#%B _F%&$("#(#/ ($& 3%.$(#%#7%>? O+-$ (&
$+% 3"(#$ #F.&(#/ H-7T $" +%-2$+ $+(& -#-7+."#(&$(7 2($$2% 9-.2(#/ "0 3."/.%&&
8+%# +(& H-7T/."F#9 .%6-(#& 5- ."$$%# (9%"2"/1 "0 3"&($('(&$(7 F&%0F2#%&&B
$+% &-6% "29 8".#S"F$B +%232%&&B .F#S9"8# +16#"2"/1 0."6 $+% 7.-92% $"
$+% /.-'%B `7"#&$-#$ 6"2217"992(#/` 8($+ #"&%SH-$+& -#9 #F$.($("#-2 %#S
%6-&;i `Z%## )X?X-B )C)a> W". Z%##B "#% "0 $+% 9%0(#(#/ 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7& "0
$+% -.$(&$(7 6"'%6%#$ $" 8+(7+ +% H%2"#/%9B UV3.%&&("#(&6B 8-& 3.%7(&%21 3-&&("#-$% .%R%7$("# "0 $+(& $+(##%9S"F$B .%-7$('% $13% "0 %V(&$%#7% (# 0-'"F.
"0 -# (#$%#&%21 53."'"T%9 2(0%;> =" 2"#/%. 32-1(#/ &-0%B #%F."$(7-221 9(&7.(6S
(#-$(#/ H%$8%%# 8+-$ (& 5/""9; 0". "#%;& "./-#(&6 -#9 8+-$ (& 5H-9;B $+%
#(+(2(&$(7 UV3.%&&("#(&$ (#R%7$& +(6&%20 8($+ 8+-$%'%. 3."9F7%& - +(/+21
7+-./%9 .F&+>X *+% H("#%/-$('% &$(6F2-$%& $+% -.$(&$B 7+-##%22(#/ +(& %#%.S
/(%& $"8-.9& $+% 72(6-V "0 -# (#$%#&%B 0".6-2 %VS3.%&&("# 8+(7+ (& 7-$-3F2$%9
(#$" $+% 0".62%&& #"$+(#/#%&& 7"#0."#$(#/ +(6>
*+% UV3.%&&("#(&$ 02(%& (# $+% 0-7% "0 $+% $(6%& H1 %V3"&(#/ +(6&%20 $" &F7+
9%&$.F7$("#> O($+ - 0%.'"F. 7"63-.-H2% $" $+% 9%9(7-$("# "0 -# -&7%$(7 +"21S
6-#B +% +"29& +(6&%20 "F$ -/-(#&$ $+% +"..(01(#/ '-7FF6 2%0$ H%+(#9 H1 $+%
&6-&+%9SF3 %9(0(7%& "0 $+% "29 .%-2($(%&B -H&"2F$%21 .%0F&(#/ $" 7"63."6(&%>
U-.2(%. "# (# $+% 7%#$F.1 (# +(& D'$ B$/4*&$ "2 #'$ P$%#B ,3%#/2%. +-9 -2.%-91
"F$2(#%9 $+% .%9F7%9 "3$("#& -'-(2-H2% 0". $+% 8%&$%.# E-# 8+" (& .%&(/#%9
$" +(& 6"9%.# 0-$%4
*+% %V3-#&('% $%#9%#71 (& - 0-$%B &"6%$+(#/ 9%6"#(7 -#9 6"#&$."F&B
$+-$ /.-H& $+% 2-&$ +F6-# "0 $+(& &$-/% "0 $+% 8".29;& +(&$".1B 0".7%& +(6
(#$" ($& &%.'(7% -#9 7"#&F6%& +(6B 8+%$+%. +% 8-#$& ($ ". #"$> K(0% (& $+%
.%-2(&-$("# "0 $+% 3"&&(H2% -#9 0". $+(& 7%.%H.-2 +F6-# `O$'*)&5$&%/'$&a
$+%.% %V(&$& "#21 %V$%#&('% 3"&&(H(2($(%&>
`,3%#/2%. )XX)B J)a)I
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B*9&$ 3")?9& )DJ
,$.%$7+%9 "F$ "0 $+% .-7T "0 /.-#9 #-..-$('%&B 8+(7+ .F# "'%. +(6 (# 61"3(7 &%-.7+ "0 &"6% 0-.S-8-1 $%2%"2"/(7-2 %#9B $+% 2-$%. 9-1 +F6-#
2-7T& &FH&$-#7%> Y# $+(& 6"9%.# 8".29 "0 &3%%9B 9(&$-#7%S7"'%.(#/ H%7"6%&
-# F#_F%&$("#%9 3.(".($1> f-&$ %V3-#&%& "0 $+% %-.$+ &F.0-7% -.% $.-'%.&%9
8($+"F$ -00%7$(#/ $+% +F6-# "./-#(&6 &%#&F-221 -$ -22> *+% "#21 .%7%3$". 2%0$
$" $+% +F6-# .%&(/#%9 $" %V$%#&('% 3"&&(H(2($(%& (& $+% +(/+21 (#$%22%7$F-2(&%9
H.-(#>
Z1 7"#$.-&$B $+% -7$('%21 #(+(2(&$(7 UV3.%&&("#(&$ /"%& 0". 3"F#9(#/ (#$%#S
&($1> M% (& 0F221 -8-.% "0 $+-$ $+% -22 $"" 7%.%H.-221 -77%#$F-$%9 &3%7(%&
9%&7.(H%9 H1 ,3%#/2%. (& 6"&$ 3."H-H21 9""6%9 $" %V$(#7$("#> Z%##B 8($+
-22 +(& 6%9(7-2 %V3%.$(&%B 3.%9(7$& $+-$B 9F% $" $+% &$%-91 (#7.%-&% (# $+%(.
&TF22 &(A%B '"5" %9I*$&% 8(22 %'%#$F-221 9(% "F$ -& $+%(. +%-9& .(3 "3%# -#9
9%&$."1 $+% '%.1 3%2'(7 /(.92%& 8+(7+ -8-($ $+%(. -..('-2 (# 3.%/#-#$ -#$(7(S
3-$("# `Z%## )X?X-B ))C -#9 DJ<a> U'%# H%0".% $+(& -3"7-213$(7 %#9 $" $+%
.-7%B $+% +F6-# "./-#(&6 8(22 -2.%-91 +-'% H%%# "# - &$%-91 8-#% -&
3."/.%&&('% 7%.%H.-2(&-$("# 2%-'%& $+% "$+%. "./-#&B 8($+ $+%(. -$$-7+%9 &%#S
&-$("#&B $" 2-3&% (#$" %$("2-$("#>)) O+-$ (& #%%9%9B -& Z%## 6-T%& 72%-. (#
5P."'"T%9 K(0%; _F"$%9 -H"'%B (& $" %V32"($ $+% H.-(#;& 57.%-$('% 7.(&%&;B ($&
&-2$-$("#-2 -7-F&-2($1B ($& 3F#7$F-$%9 %_F(2(H.(F6>)< W-. 0."6 &$F2$(01(#/ $+%
"./-#B -#9 $+%.%H1 /.-9F-221 &-33(#/ $+% $.-#&0".6-$".1 '($-2($1 "0
$+% 8+"2% "./-#(&6B Z%## -00(.6& h -& 8% 8(22 &%% h - 9(00%.%#$ -33."-7+ $"
$+% 6%-#(#/ "0 $+% +F6-# -#9 ($& 32-7% 8($+(# $+% %'"2'(#/ 8".29>
K"/(7-2 $+"F/+$ .%3.%&%#$& - 6%.% 0.-7$("# "0 $+% H.-(#;& (#+%.($%9 7+-.S
-7$%.(&$(7&> *+% '(/(2-#$ %/" (& - 2-$% -#9 02%%$(#/ 3."9F7$ "0 #-$F.% 0". 8+"6
$+% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# $+% (##%. &%20 -#9 $+% "F$&(9% +-& #"$ -28-1& %V(&$%9>
Y# $+% 3.%2"/(7-2 8".29 $+% H.-(# 6"'%9 (# 9(00%.%#$ "./-#(7 7(.72%&B (# $+"&%
H%2"#/(#/ $" &$.-#/% "#%S%1%9 &%- 7.%-$F.%& -#9 0(&+%& 8($+ 02(7T%.(#/ 7(2(->)@
>"5" %9I*$&%N 9%&7%#9%#7% 0."6 0(&+ 8($+ 2"-9SH%-.(#/ 0(#&B 8+" 8%.% 0".S
$F($"F&21 -H2% $" &7.-6H2% $" $+% 2-#9 $+."8# F3 H1 $+% .%7%9(#/ &%-&B)D (&
$.%-$%9 H1 Z%##B #"$ -& -# "33".$F#($1 $" %F2"/(&% +F6-# 53."/.%&&;B HF$ -& 8-1 "0 $+(#T(#/ $+% 0F$F.% -& 6"#&$."F&21 %#%./%$(7>
Z%## &F//%&$& $+-$ $+% +F6-# 53%.&"#-2($1; (& -22 "0 ($& %'"2F$("#-.1 3-&$> Y$
H%-.& $+% 5-#(6-2 &(/#-$F.%&; "0 ($& 0".6%. (#7-.#-$("#&4 +-'(#/ H%%# &"6%S
$(6%& -T(# $" $+% 6-.&F3(-2&B &"6%$(6%& $" $+% 6-66-2&B +-'(#/ 8".# 0(&+
&7-2%& (# $+% -/% "0 $+% '(7$".("F& -63+(H(-#&B 0F. (# $+% %.- "0 $+% -3%&B
+-'(#/ +-9 - $-(2B +-'(#/ 0"F#9 ($&%20 (# -6"#/&$ $+% /(-#$&> > > > *+% +F6-#
53%.&"#-2($1; 5.%7".9%9 -22 "0 $+%&% $F.#&; -#9 $+-$ 2%/-71 "0 7+(6%.-& h +-20S
-#(6-2B +-20S+F6-# h (& &$(22 61&$%.("F&21 -2('% 8($+(# $+% &3%7(%& `Z%##
)X?X-B )<)a> U'%# (# $+(& -/% "0 +(/+21 9%'%2"3%9 (#$%22%7$& 8% -.% &$(22 #"$
(# 3"&&%&&("# "0 $+% T%1 $" $+% 6-7+(#-$("#& "0 %'"2F$("#-.1 +(&$".1> Z%##
.%6-.T&4
O% 7-# "#21 &-1 $+-$B 8($+(# $+% 0.-6%8".T "0 /(/-#$(7 $%22F.(7S7"&6(7
%'%#$&B (7%S%"#& -#9 %.-& "0 8".29S7"#02-/.-$("#&B $+% 0-22 "0 $+% $%.$(-.1
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)DN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
B*9&$ 3")?9& )DC
Z%## 9%$%7$& '%.1 2($$2% 2"#/S$%.6 3F.3"&('% -9-3$-$("# (# #-$F.%> =-$F.% (&
6""91B 3."#% $" 0(7T2%#%&& -#9 "./-#(7 2(0%;& .%&3"#&%& -.% &3-&6"9(7B HF$
+(/+21 7.%-$('%>)J *+% "./-#(&6 R"10F221 h Z%## /"%& &" 0-. -& $" &F//%&$B
"./(-&$(7-221 h 3-.$-T%& "0 $+%&% (#7%&&-#$ .%(#'%#$("#& "0 ($&%204
O% &-8 (# r$+% `+F6-#a "./-#(&6s $+% -63+(H(-#B $+% .%3$(2(-#B $+%
6-.&F3(-2B $+% 6-66-2(-#B $+% &(6(-#4 -22 $+%&% &$(/6- "0 ($& &FHR%7$("#
$" - '-&$ 3.(#7(32% "0 $%22F.(-# +(&$".1m -22 $+%&% &$(/6- "0 ($& 0".6%.
9%72(#%& -#9 "0 ($& .%#%8%9 R"1 (# $+% &F./%& "0 "#% /.%-$ "./-#(7 6"$(0
$+-$ -28-1& .F#& $+."F/+ -22 -#(6-2 0".6& "0 $+% &-6% /%"2"/(7-2 3%.("9B
3."9F7(#/ - $%#&("# $+-$ 9.('%& 7"#$%63".-#%"F&21 2('(#/ A""2"/(7-2
H%(#/& -8-1 0."6 $+%(. 7+-.-7$%.(&(#/ &3%7(0(7($(%& $"8-.9& #%8 7".3".%-2
&($F-$("#& -#9 0F#7$("#&>
`Z%## )X?X-B )<@a
Q$ $+% H%/(##(#/ "0 $+% _F-$%.#-.1 3%.("9 6-66-2& H%/-# $" 9%'%2"3 $+%
7%.%H.F6 8+(7+ +-& #"8 H%7"6% $+% 2%-9(#/ "./-# "0 "F. +"2"7%#% %3"7+B
6-T(#/ F& &" 3."F9 "0 "F. 32-7% (# $+% F#('%.&%> M"8%'%.B $+% "./-#(7
&(/#-$F.% "0 3.%'("F& -/%&B "0 $+% 6%&"A"(7 %.- -#9 $%.$(-.1 3%.("9B 8-& -2&"
- 6(.-7F2"F& 7.%-$("#> Y$ 8-&B -77".9(#/ $" Z%##B $+% 3(#%-2 %1%> M% $%22& F&
$+-$ $+(& "./-#4
7"#0%..%9 $+% '(&("# "0 #-$F.%B $+% 6-/(7-2 0%%2(#/B $+% $%2%3-$+1 -#9
$%2%T(#%&(& 8($+ 8+(7+ $+%1 r$+% 3%"32% "0 $+% 3-&$s %00".$2%&&21 6"'%9
$+% %#".6"F& &$"#% H2"7T&B .%#9%.%9 &"6%+"8 8%(/+$2%&&B .(/+$ "'%.
6"F#$-(#& -#9 $+."F/+ $+% 8-$%.& $" HF(29 $+%(. 7"2"&&-2 $%632%&>
`Z%## )X?X-B )<@a
Q& .%/-.9& +(& .%02%7$("#& "# $+% 3(#%-2 %1% Z%## 8"F29 +-'% +-9 - 2"$ (#
7"66"# 8($+ ^%"./% Z-$-(22%> K(T% Z%##B Z-$-(22% -2&" %63+-&(&%9 $+(&
"./-#;& (63".$-#7% -#9 %V32".%9 ($& &(/#(0(7-#7% (# +(& "F$.-/%"F& %&&-1 "0
$+% &-6% #-6%4
*+% %1% -$ $+% &F66($ "0 $+% &TF22B "3%#(#/ "# $+% (#7-#9%&7%#$ &F# (#
".9%. $" 7"#$%632-$% ($ (# - &(#(&$%. &"2($F9%B (& #"$ - 3."9F7$ "0 $+%
F#9%.&$-#9(#/ HF$ (& (#&$%-9 -# (66%9(-$% %V3%.(%#7%m ($ "3%#& F3 -#9
H2(#9& ($&%20 2(T% - 7"#02-/.-$("#B ". 2(T% - 0%'%. $+-$ %-$& $+% H%(#/B ". 6".%
%V-7$21 $+% +%-9>
`Z-$-(22% )XXDB ?<a
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
6""# $" %-.$+B $+% 9-.T%#(#/ "0 $+% +%-'%#&B $+% 7-$-721&6& "0 0(.% -#9
7172"#&B (# %'%. #%8 &3"#$-#%"F&B %'"2F$('% 9.('%& r*55$) &$,$& %I"	J
&$& 6&#=*/;4,&?%#)*$+$&s4 +-20 7-F&-2($1B +-20 7.%-$("#B +-20 /%"2"/(7-2
#%7%&&($1B +-20 -7$ "0 $.-#&7%#9%#7% h $+-$B (# $+%&% 8-1&B $+% %3(2%3$"(9
6(V$F.% "0 $+% /%#%&(& "0 "F. 3%.&"#-2($1 8-& 7-..(%9 "F$>
`Z%## )X?X-B )<)h<a
Z-$-(22% &F//%&$& $+-$ $+% 3(#%-2 %1% %V3"&%& ($&%20 $" 9%&$.F7$("# -& ($
%V3.%&&%& ($&%20B -& ($ "3%#& ($&%20 F3 $" $+% &"2-. %V3%.(%#7%> *+% 3(#%-2 %1%
(& .%7T2%&& (# ($& 3F.&F($ "0 0(%.1 %V3%.(%#7%B "0 $+% '%.1 %V3%.(%#7% 8+(7+ 8(22
HF.# ($ "F$B .%9F7(#/ ($& '".-7("F& 2F&$ 0". - '($-2(&%9 '(&("# $" $+% H2-7T%&$ "0
H2(#9#%&&%&> Z-$-(22%;& 9%3(7$("# "0 $+(& %7&$-$(7B 1%$ '"2-$(2%B &%20S9%&$.F7$('%B
2(0%S0".6 (& -T(# $" Z%##;& F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 %'"2F$("#> Y#&$%-9 "0 - &$%-91B
7"#&$-#$B +(%.-.7+(&(#/ /."8$+ $"8-.9& %'%.S7"#&"2(9-$%9 3%.0%7$("#B Z%##
-2&" %63+-&(&%& $+% (#&$-H(2($1 -#9 7"#$(#/%#71 "0 2('(#/ 0".6&4
$+% 2(0% $+-$ -.(&%& 0."6 $+% /F22%$B "./-#(&%& ($&%20 - 8+(2% $" 9(&-33%-.
(#$" $+% (#0%.#"B $+(& 2(0% 8(22 "3%# ($& R-8& -/-(#&$ $+"&% 7('(2(&-$("#S
+".9%& 8+" .%/-.9 $+% &%- -& - #F$.($("#-2 %#%6- 8($+ ($& "1&$%. H%9&
-#9 '-2F% 0(.% -& - H%%.S8-.6%. 0". F#9%. $+%(. -&H%&$"& &+%%$&>
`Z%## )X?X-B XDa
O+(2% (# $+% 3."7%&& "0 9%'%2"3(#/ - $+%".1 -H"F$ 2(0%S0".6& (# $+(& 3-&&-/%B
Z%## 9"%& #"$ 6(&& -# "33".$F#($1 $" /('% &%20S&-$(&0(%9 %'"2F$("#(&$&B $+"&%
8+" (#&(&$ "# F#9%.&$-#9(#/ H("2"/1 -& - F#_F-2(0(%9 7"#0(.6-$("# "0 E-#;&
3."/.%&&B - T(7T F3 $+% H-7T&(9%> O($+ $+(& %#%61 (# 6(#9B +% 8"F29 &F.%21
+-'% -33.%7(-$%9 $+% 0".7% "0 Z-$-(22%;& 0(2$+1 2%&&"# -H"F$ 3(#%-2 %1%& -#9
$+%(. .%2-$("# $" $+% .("$"F&21 7"2"F.%9 -#F&%& "0 -3%&> Z-$-(22% %63+-&(&%&
5$+% %V3.%&&('% '-2F% "0 -# %V7.%6%#$-2 ".(0(7% %6%./(#/ 0."6 - +-(.1 H"91
2(T% - 2('% 7"-2; `Z-$-(22% )XXDB ?Ca> \#9%#(-H21 '(&(H2% "# $+% -3% (& $+% 5+F/%
&7.%-6(#/ 3(#T -#-2 3."$.F&("# r8+(7+s &$-.%& -$ $+% &T1 2(T% - 02"8%.;
`Z-$-(22% )XXDB ?Ja> *+(& .F9% -#(6-2 (& #"$ $" H% $-6%9B 8(22 #"$ H% &F6S
6-.(&%9 (#$" &"6% &6""$+21 2(#%-. +(&$".1 "0 E-#;& /.-9F-2 7('(2(&-$("#> *+%
-3% 8($+ ($& 53-.$(S7"2"F.%9B .%9 ". 6-F'% -#-2 H-29#%&&; (& - 0.%-T 8+"
$."FH2(#/21 (63(#/%& "# $+% +F6-# 7"#&7("F&#%&&B &%#9(#/ $.-F6-$(&%9
1"F#/ 5(##"7%#$&; $" &"H 7"#'F2&('%21 (# &%72F9%9 2-'-$".(%& `Z-$-(22% )XXDB
?Ca>)N ,(6(2-.21B Z%## -(6& $" &-H"$-/% $+% 7%.$-(#$(%& "0 &6F/ %'"2F$("#(&$&
H1 -3"7-213$(7-221 +%.-29(#/ $+% .%-00(.6-$("# "0 2(0%;& 7172(7-2 3-$$%.#&B ($&
%HH& -#9 02"8&>)C O".T(#/ &(9%SH1S&(9% 8($+ Z-$-(22% -#9 +(& 9%3(7$("# "0 $+%
&7-#9-2"F& -3% -#9 ($& 0.%-T(&+ -#F&B Z%## 0F.$+%. F#9%.2(#%& $+% 0.%-T(&+
-&3%7$ "0 -22 2(0%S0".6&4 $+%1 -.% "./-#(&-$("#& 8+(7+ 6"6%#$-.(21 (#&7.(H%
$+%6&%2'%& "# $+% &F./% "0 2(0% H%0".% 32F#/(#/ (#$" 0".62%&& #"$+(#/#%&&>)?
*+% $-&T 0-7(#/ -00(.6-$('% #(+(2(&$&B 2(T% Z%##B (& $" .%9%0(#% $+% +F6-# (#
$+% 0-7% "0 &F7+ -##(+(2-$".1 0".7%&> *+% 7+-22%#/% (& $" .%$+(#T $+% +F6-#
-& -# `%'%. .%7F..(#/a (#&$-#$ (#&7.(H%9 F3"# $+% &%%$+(#/ 6"'%6%#$ "0
9%6"#(7 6-$$%.>
Z%## 7-22& $+% 5.%-2($1; 7"#&$.F7$%9 H1 $8%#$(%$+S7%#$F.1 UF."3%-#& 59%6"#(7 7"#7%3$; `Z%## )X?X-B <NNa> Q& 8% +-'% -2.%-91 &%%# 8($+ $+%
+%23 "0 ,3%#/2%.B $+% 6"9%.# 8".29 +-& 32-7%9 ($& %63+-&(& "# $+% 57%.%H.-2;
`-$ $+% %V3%#&% "0 "$+%. -#-$"6(7-2 -&&%$&a -#9 "# $+% 5%V3-#&('%; `2"#/S
9.-8# $%2%"2"/(7-2 /"-2&B $+% &$.%$7+(#/S -#9 _F-2($-$('% $+(##(#/S"F$ "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)D? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
&3-7%a> *+% +F6-# (& '(%8%9 -& 7"632%$%21 9%$-7+%9 0."6 #-$F.%> Y#9%%9
$+% +F6-#;& $-&T (& 3.%&%#$%9 -& H%(#/ $+-$ "0 7"#_F%.(#/ #-$F.%B %V32"($(#/
($& .%&"F.7%& -#9 .-$("#-2(&(#/ ($& 6""9& `Z%## )X?X-B <ICa> Z%## H2-6%& $+%
3+1&(7(&$B M%26+"2$AB 0". 2F.(#/ F& (#$" $+% (22F&("# $+-$ $+% 8".29 7-# H%
8+"221 F#9%.&$""9 $+-#T& $" /%#%.-221 -332(7-H2% 6%7+-#(7-2 2-8& `Z%##
)X?X-B <I?a> [-.8(#(&6 (& &%%# -& 0F.$+%. H"2&$%.(#/ $+(& 8".29S'(%8 8($+ ($&
6%.($"7.-$(7 '(&("#> *+"&% 8+" -.% &$."#/ -#9 0($ 8(22 &F.'('% (# $+(& 7-3($-2S
(&$ 8".29 "0 7F$S$+."-$ 7"63%$($("# `Z%## )X?X-B <I?a> L.B 6".% 3.%7(&%21B
$+% 6%.% 0-7$ $+-$ "#% (& +%.% 6%-#& $+-$ "#% +-& -2.%-91 &F.'('%9 $+%
&$.F//2% -#9 $+%.%H1 6%.($%9 - 32-7% (# $+% &F#> Z%## 7"#72F9%& $+-$ $+%
+F6-# $13% 8+(7+ (& 3."9F7%9 -& - .%&F2$ "0 $+%&% (9%"2"/(%& (& -4 56-$%.(-2(&$
-#9 &"7(-2(&$ F$(2($-.(-# $13% `O$+)9,/'%#CIaB - 6"#$-/%S$13%B "3$(6(&$(7 -#9
&+-22"8B 71#(7-221 .(9 "0 -#1 (9%- "0 0-$-2($1B $+% 2%-&$ 3"&&(H2% &F00%.(#/ 0".
$+% (#9('(9F-2B $+% 6"&$ 7"60".$ 3"&&(H2% 0". -22; `Z%## )X?X-B <<Na> *+%
+F6-# .-7%B +-'(#/ -2.%-91 53."'%9; ($& 8".$+B #"8 +-& $" 7"#&"2(9-$% ($&
3"$%#$(-2 H1 7"#7%#$.-$(#/ "# &"2(9 -'%.-/%&> *+% .-7% &$"7T 6F&$ H% 3.%S
&%.'%9B #"$ &_F-#9%.%9B -#9B -& - 7"#&%_F%#7%B -#1 '-.(-$("# 0."6 $+% #".6
(& $" H% 9(&7"F.-/%9>
M"8%'%.B $+(& .-$("#-2(&%9B 0F#7$("#-2 8".29B 3%.3%$F-$%9 H1 &$-$%S.F#
(#&$($F$("#& h 8+"&% $-&T ($ (& $" 3."$%7$ 7($(A%#& 0."6 -#1$+(#/ $+-$
$+.%-$%#& $+%(. 7F&+("#%9 %V(&$%#7% h (& F#9%. -$$-7T> M-'(#/ 9%9(7-$%9 ($&%20
$" $+% %2(6(#-$("# "0 $+% 5H("#%/-$('%; -#9 $" $+% %V72F&("# "0 -#1 '%&$(/%& "0
0".6%. 61$+"2"/(7-2 -#9 H("2"/(7-2 2(0%S0".6&B $+% 57('(2(&%9;B 57%.%H.-2(&%9;
+F6-# 0-22& 3.%1 $" 9%6"#(7 0".7%&> \#7"#$."22-H2% #%F."$(7 &163$"6&
%.F3$ -22 "'%. +(6 -& $+% .%3.%&&%9 .%$F.#& $" +-F#$ +(& 0.-/(2% &%7F.($1
`Z%## )X?X-B <@XhDIa>)X Q/".-3+"H(- 9%72-.%& ($&%20 (# $+% '-&$B +"22"8
%V3-#&%& "0 $+% 6"9%.# 7($1m 6F.9%."F& &%V 0-#$-&(%& -.% -7$%9 "F$ -& $+%
H"91 2-1& 72-(6 $" ($& -#7(%#$ .(/+$&> K%-'(#/ $+% H%1"#9 "0 2-#9& -#9 $(6%&
50"./"$$%#;B $+%&% 0".7%& %V-7$ $+%(. .%'%#/%> *+%1 -.% %V3%.(%#7%9 -& &"6%S
$+(#/ 9%6"#(7 8+(7+ (63(#/%& 0."6 8($+"F$B $+.%-$%#(#/ - 7+%.(&+%9 (##%.
&%20m HF$ $+(& 5(#$%.(".($1; (& -2.%-91 %V$%#F-$%9> M"22"8%9 "F$ H1 $+% 7.-A1
3."7%&&%& "0 5.-$("#-2(&-$("#;B 8($+ $+%(. "H&%&&("#-2 7"#7%.# 0". 6-&& &$-#9S
-.9(&-$("#B $+% 3%$.(0(%9 +F6-# 7-##"$ .%&(&$ $+% '(#9(7$('% "#&2-F/+$ "0 $+%
9%6"#&> *+% +F6-# +-& &$"33%9 &+".$ ($& 9%'%2"36%#$ H1 0-(2(#/ $" -33.%7(S
-$% $+-$ (#'%#$('% #%8 2(0%S0".6& "0$%# -.(&% 0."6 9-.(#/ 9%3-.$F.%& 0."6 $+%
#".6B #"$ 0."6 - .%-7$('% 9%0%#7% "0 $+% -2.%-91 T#"8#> Y# &+".$B $+% "#21
8-1 $" 7"#_F%. $+% 9%6"#& (& $" H%7"6% - 6F$-$('% 6"#&$%.><I
Y#9%%9B -2$+"F/+ Z%## 9"%& #"$ _F($% F&% $+%&% $%.6&B +% "H2(_F%21 7"#S
0(.6& $+(& 3%.&3%7$('% "# $+% "'%.7"6(#/ "0 $+% 9%6"#(7 $+."F/+"F$ +(&
8".T&> Q& 8% 8(22 &%%B $+% 6F$-$('% 6"#&$."F& (& $+-$ 8+(7+ +% -&&"7(-$%&
8($+ /%#(-2 %V3.%&&("#> Y# +(& %&&-1 5*+% P."H2%6 "0 ^%#(F&;B Z%## 9(&3F$%&
$+% 0-7$ $+-$ &"7(%$-2 &-0%T%%3(#/ 7"F29 %'%. 0"&$%. .%-221 7.%-$('% 3."9F7$&>
^%#(F& &F./%& 0".$+ "#21 8+%.% $+%.% (& $+% 5-H#".6-2($1 -#9 9%/%#%.-$("#;
`Z%## )X?X-B )D)am /%#(F& (& (# $+% 0(.&$ 32-7% -#-$+%6- $" &"7(%$1;& '-2F%&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B*9&$ 3")?9& )DX
)JI !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Q& 0". $+% 3-.%#$&B ($ &%%6& $+-$ /%.6S6-$%.(-2 8+(7+ (& -& 9(00%.%#$ -&
3"&&(H2% (& "0$%# $+% &$-.$(#/ 3"(#$ 0". $+% 0".6-$("# "0 /%#(F&> Z2""9 -#9
.-7% 0".%(/##%&&B %>/> ,2-'(7 8($+ ^%.6-# H2""94 (# $+% 7-&% "0 =(%$A&7+%B
K%(H#(AB G> O-/#%.m ".B -2&"B - 6-.T%9 9(00%.%#7% (# $+% 7+-.-7$%.& -#9
7"#&$(F$("#&4 %>/> -# %V$.%6% &7+(A"(9 $13% 6-$7+%9 8($+ - 7172"$+16(7B
(# &+".$ %'%.1$+(#/ 8+(7+ -(6& 0". $+% F#6(V-H2% `.*$ [&F$)5*%/'+9);$*#aB
$+% F#H-2-#7%9 `.*$ [&9,%?$?4*/'$&'$*#a H-&$-.9(&-$("#B (#&"2'-H2% $%#&("#>
`Z%## )X?X-B )@@a
^%#(F& (& 3-.$21 - #"'%2 7"#7"7$("# "0 $+% 6"&$ 9(&3-.-$% %2%6%#$& (63."HS
-H21 H."F/+$ $"/%$+%. (# - '"2-$(2% '%&&%2B $+-$ "0 $+% 6F&(7(-#B &7(%#$(&$B 21.(7
3"%$B 3+(2"&"3+%.> > > > *+% "$+%. 3-.$ 7"63.(&%& "0 $+-$ (#$.%3(9 &F.0%. "# $+%
H-7T "0 2(0%;& 3.(6".9(-2B &%%$+(#/ 6"'%6%#$& %'"T%9 %-.2(%.> ^%#(F& (& $+-$
8+(7+ (& -H2% $" .(9% $+% 8-'%B 5"./-#(&% ($&%20 - 8+(2%;B H%0".% 32F#/(#/ (#$"
$+% (#0%.#-2 /F22%$ $+-$ (& $+% H%/(##(#/ -#9 %#9 "0 2(0%> *+% /%#(F& .%7"/S
#(&%&B -#9 9.-8& "# $+% .%7"/#($("#B $+-$ $+% +F6-# (& 56F$-$('%21 &$.-$(0(%9;
`Z%## )X?X-B NNXa> Q& 9(&7F&&%9 -H"'%B $+% +F6-# +-& -28-1& H%%# (# 72"&%&$
-&&"7(-$("# 8($+ 6-#(0"29 "$+%. 2('(#/ H%(#/& 9F.(#/ ($& %'"2F$("#-.1 3-&$
-#9 ($ $+%.%H1 H%-.& $+% 5"./-#(7 &(/#-$F.%&; "0 %-7+ $.-#&6F$-$("#-2 &$-/%>
Q& - 7"#&%_F%#7% "0 $+(& .(7+ -#9 (#%V+-F&$(H2% (#+%.($-#7%B $+% +F6-#B 0".
Z%##B (& %$%.#-2 -#9 3.(6".9(-2 `,)94#a `Z%## )X?X-B DD?a> Y0 $+% +F6-# (& #"$
8(20F221 .%9F7%9 $" ($& 2-$$%. 9-1 0".6B $+% '"5" %9I*$&% h 8+(7+ (& +%-9(#/
0". 9%&$.F7$("# (0 7%.%H.-2(&-$("# 7"#$(#F%& -$ ($& 7F..%#$ 3-7% h $+%# $-2T "0
$+% 53"&$+F6-#; (& (#-33."3.(-$%4 5*+% +F6-# .-7%j Y66".$-2($1 8($+(# 7.%-$('% &1&$%6 $+-$ (& ($&%20 &FHR%7$ $" 0F.$+%. (#7"#7%('-H2% %V$%#&("#&
`6)=$*#$),&?$&a -#9 $.-#&0".6-$("#&; `Z%## )X?X-B DD?a> Y0 %'"2F$("# (& #"$
7"#7%('%9 -#$+."3"6".3+(7-221 -& - 2(#%-. 6-.7+ $" 53."/.%&&;B 8% 7-# H%/(#
$" &$-.$ $+(#T(#/ 2(0% -& %'"2'(#/ (# 8-1& 8+(7+ H".9%. "# H%7"6(#/ 6"#S
&$."F&B "3%#(#/ F3 $+% +F6-# (# 8-1& 8+(7+ 9" #"$ 7"#0(.6 +(& 32-7% (# T#"8-H2% 8".29 -77".9(#/ $" "F. 7"#'%#$("#-2 7-$%/".(%& "0 $+"F/+$> !"#S
&%_F%#$21B Z%## %V32(7($21 .%R%7$& $+% b-#$(-# .%-9(#/ "0 #-$F.% -& 7"#&(&$(#/
"0 5&$-..1 +%-'%#&; -#9 5H%-6(#/; +F6-#& 8+"B 9%&3($% H%(#/ 7"#0."#$%9
8($+ $+% 5-26"&$ 6"#&$."F&; &FH2(6%B -.% &$(22 -&&F.%9 "0 H-&(7 /%#%.-2 2-8&
/"'%.#(#/ $+%(. 8".29> O+(2% $.1(#/ $" %V32-(# $+% $".$F"F& F./%#71 "0 $+%
%V3.%&&("#(&$ 6"'%6%#$ $" $+% '%.1 `(#a9(00%.%#$ 8".29 "0 )X@DB +% 8.($%&4
Q#9 &" $+%&% /%#%.-$("#& /.%8 F3B $+"&% 8+" 9.-#T 9"8# -22 &FH&$-#7%&
"00%.(#/ 9(&(#$%/.-$("# `T$)%$#@,&?a -#9 8+" 3.%7(&%21 9(9 #"$ 2(0$ $+%(.
H%-6(#/ +F6-# 0-7%& $" $+% &$-..1 +%-'%#&B .-$+%. (# 8+"&% (#&(9%&
(#&$%-9 7+(6%.- -#9 9%6"#& 0-$$%#%9 $+%6&%2'%& -#9 &F7T%9 -8-1B
&%%9& "0 9(&7".9B -#9 8+"B (# $+%(. +F.2(#/& "0 0".6 `:")59,%%#,U)@$&a
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-#9 "#21 .%$."&3%7$('%21 -7T#"82%9/%9 -& &"6%$+(#/ /.%-$> ^%#(F& (& $+%
6F$-#$ 7+(29 "0 -# (63."H-H2% 7"F32(#/4
B*9&$ 3")?9& )J)
Y0 $+% +F6-# (& %$%.#-2B $+%.% -.% #" /F-.-#$%%& $+-$ 8% 8(22 .%7"/#(&%
"F.&%2'%& -$ -22 8($+(# -#1 0F$F.% 6-#(0%&$-$("#& "0 "F. .-7%> O% 7-##"$
3.%7"#7%('% ($& 0F$F.% $.-R%7$".(%& -#9 &16H("$(7 -22(-#7%&> M"8%'%.B (#&$%-9
"0 3-&&('%21 H%(#/ "'%.8+%26%9 H1 - 0-$%B 8% &+"F29 H%7"6% %V3.%&&("#S
(&$&><)
UV3.%&&("#(&$ -.% $+"&% 8+" 7-# 7"#_F%. $+% 9%6"#& H1 H%(#/ -H2% $"
7"#7%('% "0 $+% 2('(#/ 8".29 -& - 56"#&$%. "0 %#%./1;> *+% %V3.%&&("#(&$ (&
-H2% $" $+(#T $+% +F6-# 5-& -.(&(#/ 0."6 -#9 H%(#/ %V$%#9%9 `$)?9U&@#a H1 $+%
6F$-$('%21 &$.-$(0(%9B $+-$ (&B (# %'%. #%8 $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 -7$& -#9 "F$ "0 %'%.
#%8 7.%-$('% (63F2&%&; `Z%## )X?X-B NNXa> *+% $%.6 5&$.-$(0(%9; .%0%.& $"
/%"2"/(7-2 +(&$".1B ($&%20 6-9% F3 "0 7-$-&$."3+(7 %'%#$& 8(3(#/ "F$ 8+"2%
&3%7(%&B .%(#'%#$(#/ "$+%.& -2"#/ F#3.%9(7$-H2% $.-R%7$".(%&B $+-$ Z%## &"
-9".%& 9%&7.(H(#/B 0". (#&$-#7% (# 5P.(6-2 f(&("#;<<4
E-&& (# (#&$(#7$&> Z.-(# HFHH2%& (#$" $+% 9.-(#B /%.6 2-1%.& (#$" $+% 02"8%.
H%9B 1"2T &-7T& (# $+% $+.F&$ "0 9(&$-#7%> M%.($-/% "0 %V-2$-$("# -#9
(#$"V(7-$("#&B -&$.-2 7"#02-/.-$("#&B $.-#&"7%-#(7 9%7-1> !.(&%&B 6(V$F.%&B
$+(.9 7%#$F.1> > > > P.(6%'-2 F./%& "0 -/%2%&& 6-&&%& (# $+% &"F#9 "0 $+% &%-&
-#9 $+% 32F#/% "0 2(/+$ `[)94#$ B)9U&?$ 94#$)%4"%$) 39%%$ *5 G49&? .$) 3$$)$
,&. *5 A#,)@ .$% L*/'#%a> K(0% 8-#$& $" 6-(#$-(# ($&%20 HF$ -2&" $" 3%.(&+> > > >
W."6 7-$-&$."3+%& $+-$ 8%.% 2-$%#$B 7-$-&$."3+%& $+-$ 3.%7%9%9 $+% 8".9B
7"6% 9.%-90F2 6%6".(%& "0 $+% .-7%B +1H.(9B H%-&$S&+-3%9B &3+(#VS
3"F7+%9 0%-$F.%& "0 $+% 3.(6-2 0-7%>
`Z%## )X?DB ))?h)Xa<@
*+% 53.(6-2 0-7%; (& #"$ -7$F-221 &"6%$+(#/ $" H% &%%# h 8% 7-##"$ .%/.%&&
$+."F/+ $(6% $" /%$ -$ ($><D 5Y$; (& -2&" #"$ RF&$ "#% $+(#/ HF$ -2.%-91 (& &3."F$(#/ H%7"6(#/S&"6%$+(#/S%2&%B $+% %#(/6-$(7 "00&3.(#/ 0."6 - 7."&&
H%$8%%# $8" ". 6".% (63."H-H2%&> O+-$ Z%## &F//%&$& (# 5*+% Y#7%&&-#$; (&
$+-$ $+% +F6-# 5T%%3& "# .%6%6H%.(#/ `$)*&&$)#a $+% (#9(&&"2FH2% 61$+(7-2
.%6-(#& "0 +(& .-7%; `Z%## )X?DB )?@a> O+-$ (& H%(#/ 3."3"&%9 +%.% (& #"
6%.% .%7-3($F2-$("# "0 $+% %'"2F$("#-.1 +(&$".1 "0 $+% .-7% -$ $+% 2%'%2 "0 $+%
(#9('(9F-2B<J 8+(7+ 8"F29 .F# $+% .(&T "0 .%9F7(#/ $+% (#9('(9F-2 $" - 6%.%
32-1H-7T 6-7+(#%> *+% (#$%.(".(&-$("# (632(%9 8($+(# .%6%6H%.(#/ `$)J
*&&$)&a (& 8+-$ +-& $+% 3"8%. "0 7"#'%.$(#/ 9%6"#& (#$" 6"#&$."F&21 7.%-$S
('% "F$HF.&$&4
O($+ 8+-$ 9"%& $+% +F6-# 7"#_F%. $+% 9%6"#(7B #"$ $+% -H&"2F$% 6-#B
HF$ $"9-1;& +(&$".(7-2 6-#B 8+" #" 2"#/%. 2('%& (# $+% -/% "0 6"#"$+%(&$(7
(#7-#$-$("# `<$%/'="U),&?aB HF$ .-$+%. (# $+% %3"7+ -0$%. =(%$A&7+%> > > > *+%
-#&8%. .%-9&4 7"#$%63".-.1 O%&$%.# 6-# 7"#_F%.& $+% 9%6"#(7 $+."F/+
0".6m +(& 9%6"#(7 #-$F.% (& 0".6B +(& 6-/(7 (& $+% $%7+#(7-2h7"#&$.F7$('%B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-#9 $+% &FH&%_F%#$ 3%.("9& "0 2%$+-./1B &F77F6H $" m$)49?$&W -22 $+%
7%.%H.-2 (#$"V(7-$("#& "0 $+% -/%>
`Z%## )X?DB @@<a
)J< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
*+% 9%6"#(7 (& %VS3.%&&%9B 3.%&&%9 "F$B (# - $%#&%B 0".6-2 "F$HF.&$& 8+(7+
&32-$$%. -/-(#&$ $+% H-..(%. "0 2(0%;& &%%$+(#/ 6"'%6%#$&> K(0%;& 3."9(/("F&
6"'%6%#$& -.% -22 $"" $+.%-$%#(#/ $" $+% 7"#'%#$("#-2 +F6-#B +% 8+" +-&
0". &" 2"#/ F&%9 #-$F.% -& - 7-. 3-.T 0". +(& 5"1&$%. H%9&; ". - 6%-#& $" +%-$ F3
+(& H%%. `&%% Z%##B -H"'%a> ="#S+F6-#"(9 #-$F.% -33%-.& $" $+% [-.8(#(-#
T(#/3(# $" H% F#9(00%.%#$(-$%9 6-$$%.B &+%%. (66-$%.(-2($1> *+% %V3.%&&("#S
(&$B "# $+% "$+%. +-#9B &%%& - 7+-#7% $" $%&$ #%8B $(/+$21S3-7T%9B (#$%#&%21S
7+-./%9 0".6&B #"$ (# ".9%. $" 7"66F#(7-$% &"6%$+(#/ $" -# -F9(%#7%B #"$
$" 3-&& "# - 6%&&-/% `&*/'# 3*##$*4,&?a HF$ &" -& $" %V3.%&& `%"&.$)& 7,%.),/;a>
*+% %V3.%&&("#(&$ (& #"$ &%%T(#/ &"6% &".$ "0 3-.$(7(3-$("# `&*/'# D$*4&9'5$aB
&F7+ -& - 61&$(7-2 H2%#9(#/ ". 7"66F#-221 &+-.%9 6"6%#$B HF$ (#&$%-9 (&
(#$%#$ "# -//.-'-$(#/ 9(00%.%#$(-$("# `%"&.$)& B*22$)$&@*$),&?a `Z%## )X?X-B
)N<a> M% (& #"$ -0.-(9 $" -7$('-$% $+% 32%$+".- "0 (#9('(9F-2(&6& 8($+(# $+%
(#9('(9F-2B $+%.%H1 F#.-'%22(#/ -#1 (#$.(#&(7 T%.#%2 $+% &FHR%7$ 72-(6& $"
3"&&%&& 0". ($&%20><N> M% '-2(-#$21 7"#0."#$& $+% 3."&3%7$ "0 7-$-721&6(7 %'%#$&
"0 #-$F.% 8+(7+ &F99%#21 "'%.$F.# 1%-.& "0 /.-9F-2 /."8(#/B 8(3(#/ "F$
8+"2% &3%7(%& -#9 3-7T(#/ "$+%.& "00 -2"#/ 8+"221 F#%V32".%9B #%8 %'"2FS
$('% 3-$+8-1&> Y# 5O"20;& *-'%.#; Z%## 8.($%& -$ 2%#/$+ -H"F$ $+% F#3.%9(7$S
-H2%B &-2$-$("#-2 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7& "0 #-$F.-2 2(0%4
Q#9 (& $+(& =-$F.% "0 1"F.&B Y 7"F29 #"$ +%23 .%$".$(#/B .%-221 #-$F.-2i > > > Y
7-# 3."'% $+-$ ($ (& F##-$F.-2B - $+(#/ "0 2%-3& -#9 H"F#9& `9U,n$)%#
%I),&?'92#aB (#9%%9 $+% '%.1 $%V$H""T %V-632% "0 8+-$ "#% 6%-#& H1
57"#$.-.1 $" #-$F.%;> Y$ H%/(#& &"6%$+(#/ -#9 9."3& ($B 6-T%& - /.%-$ &$(.
-#9 0"./%$&> Y$ (& F#H.(92%9B ($ %V-//%.-$%&B ($ 3."9F7%& 0(&+ (# (#7.%9(H2%
&+"-2& "00 $+% K"0"$%#&B ". ."22(#/ &8-.6& "0 2"7F&$& -#9 7(7-9-&> L. $+%.%
(& 3%-7% "# %-.$+B %'%.1$+(#/ +-& $+% $%63%.-$F.% "0 $+% &$"#%&B "#% 7-#
$.F21 /('% "#%;& -$$%#$("# $" $+% 72(6-$%B -#9 $+%# $+% Q-."#;& ."9 &+""$&
F3 (# 02"8%. -$ 0".$1 9%/.%%& !%#$(/.-9%B %'%.1$+(#/ (& $+."8# (#$" 7"#S
0F&("# -#9 $+% /"9& (#&(&$ "# 8-.6SH2""9%9 -#(6-2& h (& $+-$ =-$F.%;&
9"(#/B ". 8+"&% (& ($i L. $-T% /%"2"/(7-2 0"29(#/B 9%#&(0(7-$("#B F#(6-/(#S
-H2% 7"#7%#$.-$("# h "#% "0 ($& 6%$+"9& h (& $+-$ - &(632% -# #-$F.-2 $+(#/
$" 9"i L. ($ $-T%& - 0-#71 $" &%#9 (66%#&% $%#&("#& 7+-./(#/ -7."&&
6(7."&7"3(7-221 $(#1 &3-7%& h (& $+-$ #"8 $+% $+(#/ $" %V3%7$i !"6% $"
$+(#T "0 ($B 8-& $+% 3+%#"6%#"# "0 2(0% #"$ #(7%21 2""T%9 -0$%. (# 32-#$
0".6i O+1 &%$ ($ (# 6"$("# -#9 &%#$ ($ "F$ (# &%-.7+ "0 0""9 h (& $+-$ #"$ 6"9%2 "0 F3.""$(#/i Q& 0". ($& 7.%-$F.%B E-#B 9"%& ($ #"$ 32F#/% +(6
+%-92"#/ (#$" -#$(S=-$F.%B +F.2(#/ H-7$%.(- $" 9%&$."1 +(6B 9(6(#(&+(#/
+(& &6%22B .%9F7(#/ +(& &%#&% "0 +%-.(#/B 9%#-$F.(#/ +(& %1% H1 6%-#& "0
"3$(7-2 2%#&%&B &" $+-$ $+% 6-# "0 $+% 0F$F.% (& $+% 6%.%&$ -H&$.-7$("# h
8+%.% -.% $+% 8".T(#/& "0 #-$F.-2 =-$F.%i ="B ($ (& &"6% "$+%. 0-7% $+-$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
+(& (71S8".29S$%-7+(#/ (& $+-$ 7.%-$("# (& $+% 9%6-#9 0". 0".6B $+% +F6-#
(& $+% 7.1 0". %V3.%&&("# `A/')$* &9/' 7,%.),/;a
`Z%## )X?X-B D?JhNa
B*9&$ 3")?9& )J@
=" 6%.% 3-&&('% 3-&$".-2B #" 6%.% 2-F9-$".1 %7+" "0 E-#;& /""9 0%%2(#/ -H"F$
+(6&%20 -#9 +(& 32-7% "# %-.$+m (#&$%-9 #-$F.% (& 6"&$ 6"#&$."F&21 %#%./%$(7>
=-$F.% (& 8(20F2 `HF$ 8($+ #" 3-.$(7F2-. /"-2 5(# 6(#9;aB 0(7T2%B 3%.'%.&%B
%VFH%.-#$ (# ($& 0"&$%.(#/ "0 3."2(0%.-$(#/ 2(0%S0".6&B HF$ -2&" 9%-921 8+%# (#
- 0($ "0 9%&$.F7$("#> O% '-(#21 $.1 $" -#$+."3"6".3+(&% 5+%.; RF&$ -& 8%
-$$%63$ $" +F6-#(&% $+% /%#(-2> Y#9%%9 Z%## .%($%.-$%& 7F2$F.%;& 7"#&(&$%#$
-$$%63$& 9%&3%.-$%21 $" 7"'%. "'%. $+% #(+(2(&6 -$ 8".T 8($+(# 7.%-$('% 8".T4
="$ 0". -# (#&$-#$ -.% $+%1 F#-8-.% "0 $+% %&&%#$(-2 #-$F.% "0 $+%(. "8#
(##%. 7.%-$('% &FH&$-#7%> Y$ (& $+% -H1&&B $+% '"(9B $+% F#&"2'-H2%B $+% 7"29B
$+% (#+F6-# %2%6%#$>
`Z%## )X?D4 )DJm )XC)B CXa
W". Z%##B %'%# =(%$A&7+% (& +F6-#B -22 $"" +F6-#B (# +(& 8(&+ $" -'"(9 7"#0."#$-$("# 8($+ $+% (#+F6-#> q-.-$+F&$.- (& - 57+(29 "0 #-$F.%; 8+" .%%T&
"0 5%'"2F$("#-.1 "3$(6(&6; `T,U/'#,&?%"I#*5*%5,%aB .%9"2%#$ "0 5&+-22"8 F$"S
3(-#(&6 -H"F$ $+% &3(.($ -#9 ($& .%-2(A-$("#;<C `Z%## )X?DB )DJm )XC)B CXa>
,F7+ "3$(6(&6 -H"F$ $+% 0F$F.% "0 $+% .-7% (& 9%%6%9 $" H% 6(&32-7%9 -& $+%
+F6-# (& - '%&$(/(-2 &F.'('". "0 - 2-8 8+(7+ 3."'"T%& -# 5(#7"#7%('-H2%
6%$-6".3+"&(&; `Z%## )X?X-B )<Da> O+(2% #"$ %V-7$21 9""6%9 $" %V$(#7S
$("#B $+% +F6-# 6-1 H% .%8".T%9 (# 8-1& 8+(7+ H%-. #" .%&%6H2-#7% $" $+%
0-6(2(-. '"5" %9I*$& "0 $"9-1> L#21 (# =(%$A&7+%;& 2-$%. 8".T& 9"%& Z%##
&%#&% 6".% "0 -# -8-.%#%&& "0 $+% #%/-$('($1 8+(7+ (#0".6& 7.%-$('($1B "0 $+%
0".62%&& #%/-$('($1 (# $+% 0-7% "0 8+(7+ 7.%-$('($1 0".6&><?
L# $+% 7F2$F.-2 32-#%B $+% (#+F6-#($1 "0 7.%-$('% /%#(F& 6(..".& $+%
6"#&$."F& 0-7% "0 $+% H("2"/(7-2> L# $+% $%7+#"2"/(7-2 32-#% h (# $+% 2-H".S
-$".(%& "0 $+% /%#%$(7 %#/(#%%.& h &7(%#$(&$& -2&" (6($-$% #-$F.% (# -22 ($&
F##-$F.-2#%&&> Q6"#/&$ $+% %V3.%&&("#(&$& -#9 $+% 2-$$%.S9-1 %F/%#(7(&$&
$+% .%-2(&-$("# 3.%'-(2& $+-$ $+% 7F..%#$ +F6-# 0".6B $+-$ "0 $+% '"5" %9I*$&B
(& $.-#&($".1> Y# )XDXB Z%## -3"7-213$(7-221 -##"F#7%& $+-$ $+% 5&$12% "0 $+%
0F$F.%; 8(22 H%4
$+-$ "0 ."H"$&B -# -.$ "0 6"#$-/%> *+% +F6-# "# %'(9%#7% F3 $" #"8 (&
0(#(&+%9> > > > *+% +F6-# 6F&$ H% .%-&&%6H2%9 -22 "'%. -/-(# "F$ "0 72(7+%e&B
3."'%.H&B 6%-#(#/2%&& .%0%.%#7%&B 0."6 "'%.S&FH$2%$(%&B H."-921 H-&%94 9
',59& *& *&F$)#$. /"559%> Y$& 9%3(7$("# 8(22 H% T%3$ /"(#/ H1 F&(#/ 0".6-2
$.(7T&B .%3%$($("#& "0 8".9& -#9 6"$('%& h (9%-& 8(22 H% H-#/%9 (# 2(T% #-(2&
-#9 "F$7"6%& +F#/ "# $+%6>
`Z%## )X?DB DC)a
^"#% (& $+-$ H2%&&%9B (#7-#$-$".1 +F6-#B 6%#$("#%9 %-.2(%. 8+" 8-& -H2% $"
7"#RF.% F3 $+% 8".29 -."F#9 +(6&%20m 8+"&% $+"F/+$& -#9 8".29 '(%8 -.%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
3%%.& "F$ %'%.18+%.%B &2%%3(#/ (# $+% &$"#%&B H2"&&"6(#/ (# $+% 02"8%.&B
6-T(#/ ($& 9%6-#9& (# -22 2-$% 0".6& h - '%.1 9(00%.%#$ 0-7%B -#9 $+% .%&F2$
Y -..('% -$ (& - &$.-#/% "#%>
`Z%## )X?DB)D)h<m )XC)B CJhNa
3.%7("F&21 3%.3%$F-$%9 (# #"'%2&m $+% +"&'"55$ 8% -.% &F33"&%9 $"
3-$(%#$21 /%$ $" T#"8 (#$(6-$%21B $.-7(#/ h 7+-3$%. F3"# 7+-3$%. h +(& &$%3&
$+."F/+ - 2(0% 8+(7+ &%%6& 6-33%9S"F$ -."F#9 +(6B &"6%$(6%& $.%-$(#/
+(6 8%22B &"6%$(6%& H-921B HF$ -#1+"8B - 2(0% 8+(7+ .%2-$%& $" +(6 -&
&"6%"#% &3%7(-2> *+(& +F6-# (& 0(#(&+%9> M% (& 6%.%21 -# (#&$-#7% "0 $+%
3."7%&& "0 $+% H%7"6(#/S&"6%$+(#/S%2&%> ,F7+ - +F6-# 3"&&%&&%& #" -H&"S
2F$% '-2F%B (& #"$ -$ $+% 7%#$.% "0 $+(#/&B (& - &$-#9S(#B (& &$-#9(#/ (# $+%
6F$-$(#/ 02"8 "0 6-$$%.>
W". $+% 21.(7 3"%$ -#9 $+% %F/%#(7(&$ $+% 8-1 $" 6%%$ $+(& 7+-22%#/% $" $+%
7"#'%#$("#-2 +F6-# (& $+."F/+ $+% 57F2$('-$%9 -H&"2F$%#%&& "0 0".6 > > > $+%
(#$%#&(0(%9 3F&+(#/S0".8-.9 "0 $+% 7"#&$.F7$('% F3 $" $+% H"F#9-.1 "0
(66-$%.(-2($1; `Z%## )X?X-B <)@a> Y# $+% .%2-1(#/ "0 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7&
0."6 "#% 2(0% 7172% $" -#"$+%.B 0".6 3.%&%#$& ($&%20 -& $+% "#21 H-$"# 8+(7+
&$-#9& - 7+-#7% "0 H%(#/ 3-&&%9 "#><X !"63%$(#/ 8($+ $+% 5%'%. #%8
&3"#$-#%"F&B %'"2F$('% 9.('%&B +-20 7-F&-2($1B +-20 $.-#&7%#9%#7%; `Z%##
)X?X-B )<)h< V,"#$. $9)4*$)aB $+% 3"%$ -#9 $+% H("2"/(&$ +-'% $" $.1
-#9 H.%%9 - 0".6 $+-$ (& "#7% $%#&%21 9(&7(32(#%9B 1%$ 5%3(2%3$"(9;B #"$
8%-T21 3F.(&$ HF$ $+."HH(#/ 8($+ $+% 5H("#%/-$('%;B 8($+ '(H.-#$21 53."'"T%9
2(0%;>
M-'(#/ 9F63%9 $+% %'"2F$("#-.1 2(-H(2($1 "0 $+% 7"#'%#$("#-221 &-7."S
&-#7$ +F6-#(&$ &%20B $+% 21.(7-2 +F6-# (& 0.%% $" %V3.%&& ($&%20 6F$-$('%21>
UV3.%&&("# +%.%B -& 8% +-'% &%%#B (& F#.%2-$%9 $" $+% 3("F& #(7%$(%& "0 $+%
#"'%2(&$(7 -/%B #" 3.%7("F& 6%&&-/% 0."6 "#% &%#$(%#$ +F6-# $" -#"$+%. (&
6%-#$> *+% (##%. (& $+% $F.#%9S-."F#9 9%6"#(7 %#%./%$(7-221 3."R%7$%9 "F$S
8-.9& (# $(/+$ 0".6B HF2/(#/ 8($+ -&&"7(-$('% 3"$%#$(-2($1B #"$ (# -#1 -#$(S
7(3-$("# "0 - &163-$+%$(7 %-.B #"$ 8($+ -#1 7"#$%#$ (# 6(#9> *+% %V3.%&&("#
8+(7+ (& 3.%&&%9 "F$8-.9& 9(9 #"$ ".(/(#-$% (# $+% (##%. 9%3$+& "0 - +F6-#
&FHR%7$> W-. 0."6 ($4 5$+% 8-1 (#8-.9& 2%-9& $" $+% &$.-$(0(7-$("#& "0 7.%-$("#;
`Z%## )X?X-B D<)a 8+%.% $+% +F6-# 7-# H% $.-7T%9 9"8# -& &"6%$+(#/ -$
$(6%& +-20S0(&+B -$ "$+%.& -26"&$S-3%B 0%%2(#/ ($& 8-1 -7."&& H(A-..% 6%&"A-(7
2-#9&7-3%& 8($+ $+% +%23 "0 ($& 3(#%-2 %1%>
L#7% $+% H"F./%"(& %/" (& 9%72-.%9 9%0F#7$B $+%.% (& 7%.$-(#21 #" 8-1 H-7T
$" $+-$ 7"60".$-H2% `?$5,U#4*/'a (#8-.9#%&& T%3$ HF"1-#$ H1 +F6-#(&$&>@I
,3%-T(#/ -& - $.F% 6"9%.#(&$ #(+(2(&$ (# 5=(+(2(&6 -#9 ($& L'%.7"6(#/;
`)X@<aB Z%## 8.($%& -H"F$ $+% (..%'%.&(H2% &+(0$ $+-$ +-& "77F..%9 0."6 &3-$(-2($1 8+(7+ (& /-$+%.%9 F3 -."F#9 $+% 21.(7-2 &"2($F9% "0 $+% (#9('(9F-2
$" - 3."R%7$("# "0 &3-7% -/-(#&$ 6%$-22(7 -#9 /2-&& 9%&(/# `Z%## )X?X-B <)@a>
Z%## 9"%& #"$ .%/.%$ $+% -..('-2 "0 $+(& #%8 0".6 "0 &3-$(-2($1B (#9%%9 +%
%6H.-7%& ($> Y# B",+4$ L*2$ +% 8.($%&4
$+% 0".6-2 6F&$ 7"6%B $.-#&($".1B 2(/+$ -#9 &6""$+ 8(#/&B %'%.1$+(#/
$+-$ 02"-$& (# -AF.%B -2F6(#(F6 &F.0-7%&B &F3%.0(7(-2($(%& > > (# &+".$B &$12%B
$+% #%8 8".29B $F.#%9 "F$&(9%>
`Z%## )X?DB @CJa
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)JD !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
B*9&$ 3")?9& )JJ
!".$%V ! H.-(#4 $+% 7".$(7-2 8(2$(#/ "0 $+% 8".29&B $+% H"F./%"(& 8".29B
$+% 7-3($-2(&$ 8".29B $+% "33".$F#(&$B 3."3+12-7$(7B -#$(&%3$(7 8".29&B
H%-$%# H1 $+% 72"F9 HF.&$& "0 $+% 3"2($(7-2 -#9 $+% .%&$.F7$F.(#/& "0
3"8%.B $+(& -.(&%& 0."6 O%&$%.# 6-#;& 7.(&(& "0 &FH&$-#7%> Y##%. 6-# (&
(# $-$$%.&B 6".% $-$$%.%9 $+-# +(& H"91 %'%. 8-& 0."6 8".6& -#9 /.%#-9%&4
0%.6%#$%9B &"F.B /-&(0(%9B 8($+ .F&$%9 &2"/-#& (# +(& H-//-/% .-7T > > > - #%8
6-# 3F&+%& +(& 8-1 (#B #" 2"#/%. -# %6"$("#-2B .%2(/("F&B +F6-#(&$
H%(#/B #" 7"&6(7 3-.-3+.-&%B HF$ $+% 6-# -& #-T%9B 0".6-2 /%&$-$("#> Q
#%8 8".29 (& H%/(##(#/B $+% 8".29 "0 %V3.%&&("#> Y$ (& - 8".29 "0 72%-.B
(#$%.&32(7%9 `F$)@9'&#$)a .%2-$("#&B $+% (#$%.2"7T(#/ "0 /."F#9 9"8#
0".7%&B 6%$-22(7(A%9 -#9 &6""$+%9 `?$%#*44#$)a &F.0-7%& > > > >
`Z%## )X?DB @C@a
Q& 8% +-'% -2.%-91 &%%#B 0". Z%## $+% $-&T (& #" 2"#/%. $" H%B (# M%(9%//%.;&
8".9&B - 53+1&(7(-# "0 7F2$F.%; `M%(9%//%. )XC?B @?CaB 3-$7+(#/ ($ F3B 6-T(#/
($ H%$$%.> L#% "0 +(& .%&%.'-$("#& .%/-.9(#/ 3&17+"-#-21&(& (& $+-$ ($ -$$%63$&
RF&$ $+(&B -28-1& 2""T(#/ H-7T8-.9& 9"7$".(#/ +%.%9($-.1 (22&B $+%.%H1
#%/2%7$(#/ $+% -&7%#9-#71 "0 $+% 0F$F.%> Y# +(& #"$".("F& .%321 $" b2-F&
E-##B (# 5K%$$%. $" $+% K($%.-.1 U6(/.-#$&; `)X@@aB Z%## 8.($%&4
r*+% %&&%#7% "0 E-#s (& -# %$%.#-2 tF-$%.#-.1B - +".9% 6-/(7 0%F(22%$"S
#(&$(7-221 9%7T(#/ %'%# $+% 2-$% Y7% Q/%B - 0-H.(7 "0 9(2F'(-2 6""9&B *%.$(-.1
H.(7S-nSH.-7m (# 0-7$B +% (& $+% %$%.#-221 3.(6-2 '(&("# r[)?$%*/'#s4 8-T%0F2S
#%&&B 9-1 2(0%B .%-2($1 h 2""&%21 7"#&"2(9-$%9 .+1$+6& "0 +(99%# 7.%-$('%
(#$"V(7-$("#&>
`Z%## )X?DB <X?a
*+% %&&%#7% "0 6-# (& #"$ +F6-#m ($ (& 5- 72"9 "0 &2(6%; `$*& G4,U5I/'$&
A/'4$*5a `Z%## )X?<B DCa>@) Y#&$%-9 "0 $+(& 0-7$". 9.-//(#/ F& H-7T $" &"6%
"H&7F.% -$-'(&6B ($ &+"F29 2%-9 $+% 8-1 0".8-.9 $" - 7F2$('-$("# `T,U/'#,&?a "0
57.%-$('% (#$"V(7-$("#&;>@< *+% H"91 H%7"6%& - 6-22%-H2% &F.0-7% $" H%
9%&(/#%9 $" $+% 6"&$ %V$.%6% "0 9%0(#($("#& h ($ 6F&$ &32($ ($& &(9%&B 72%-'%
(# $8"B &3(22 "F$8-.9& h (0 $+% +F6-# (& $" H% %_F-2 $" $+% 7+-22%#/% "0 5$+%
2-8 "0 (#7"#7%('-H2% 6%$-6".3+"&(&;>
[%&7.(H(#/ $+% 3-$(%#$& +% +-9 $" $.%-$ -& &3%7(-2(&$ 0". '%#%.%-2 9(&%-&%&B
Z%## %V32".%& $+% 5&8%%$ 7".3".%-2($1; "0 $+% ""A(#/ -#9 F#7$F"F& /%#($-2&>
Y# +(& 3"%6 5*+% ["7$".; `)X)Ca - 9(&%-&%9 3%#(& +-& /."8# "'%.m (#&$%-9 "0
0%7F#9-$(#/ +(& 8(0% $+% 6-# +-& 3"-7+%9 - /.-'% 3."H2%6> *+% 9(&%-&% H"(2&
-8-1 -#9 "#% 9-14 5$+% 7.%'(7% -#9 $+% $+.F&$ ] 8(22 /-3% 0."6 $+% 0".%+%-9
$" $+% &T1; r-/' 9'&$0 $*&%# d P$).$& .*$ AI94#$ ,&. .$) A#"n d T,5 >*55$4 ;4922$&
F"& .$) A#*)&s `Z%## )X?<B ?Ca> W-. 0."6 8-#$(#/ $" 3F./% $+% #-$("# "0
'%#%.%-2 9(&%-&%& h 8+"&% /.-9F-2 %2(6(#-$("# 3F$& Z%## "F$ "0 8".T h $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
U-.2(%. "# (# $+% &-6% %&&-1B +% 02%&+%& "F$ $+% (63-7$ "0 $+(& .%$+(#T(#/ "0
&3-7% 0". $+% &+.(#T(#/ H"914
)JN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
$+% H"91 (& $+% 2-&$ 7"63F2&("# -#9 $+% 9%3$+ "0 #%7%&&($1B $+% 6"#"S
2"/F% "0 7.%-$("# -#9B (0 ($ 9%/%#%.-$%& (# - 3-.$(7F2-. 8-1 &"6%$(6%& $+%
3.%6(&% 0". /%#(F&>
`Z%## )X?X-B )IXa
[%/%#%.-$("# `6	)#,&?a (& #"$ #%7%&&-.(21 -# (22#%&& $" H% %2(6(#-$%9 HF$
7-# H% - 7"#9($("# $" H% H.%9 `?$@,U/'#$#a> *+(& 8"F29 2%-'% $+% 3-.-9"V(7-2
3"&&(H(2($1 "3%# "0 - 9(00%.%#$ -33."-7+ $" %F/%#(7&B "0 -# %F/%#(7& 8+(7+
3.%&%#$& ($&%20 -& - %F2"/1 "0 .$J2")59#*"& -& 0".6-2 %V3.%&&("#> Q 0-. 7.1 0."6
$+% 7.(6(#-2 F&% "0 %F/%#(7& -& 5%$+#(7 72%-#&(#/;B $+(& "$+%. &".$ "0 %F/%#(7&
8"F29 7%2%H.-$% $+% +F.2(#/ "0 - 3-.$(7F2-.B H("#%/-$('%21 53."'"T%9;B $+-$ (&B
7F2$('-$%9B 0".6 -/-(#&$ $+% 5H-..(%. "0 (66-$%.(-2($1;B F3 $" $+% 3"(#$ 8+%.%
($& %V$.%6% 7"#7%#$.-$("# 7.-7T&B 9(&(#$%/.-$%& -#9 &(#T& H-7T (#$" $+%
6F$-$(#/ 02FV>
Y# $+% 5L0 G%9%63$("#; 7+-3$%. "0 =(%$A&7+%;& D',% AI9;$ T9)9#',%#)9 8%
+%-. "0 56%# 8+" 2-7T %'%.1$+(#/ %V7%3$ "#% $+(#/B "0 8+(7+ $+%1 +-'% $""
6F7+; `=(%$A&7+% )XNXB )NIa> *+% 6-# 8+" +-& -#9 (& -# %-.B $+% "#% 8+" (&
#" 6".% $+-# - /.%-$ %1% ". 6"F$+> *+% 7F2$('-$("# "0 &F7+ 9%0".6($1B -&
9%&7.(H%9 H1 Z%##B 8"F29 (6321 $+% 7"#7%#$.-$("# "0 0".6B $+% &$.%-62(#(#/
"0 7.%-$('%B 0".6-2(&(#/ %#%./1 $"8-.9& $+-$ %-.B $"8-.9& $+-$ F#(_F% %1%B
$+-$ /(/-#$(7 6"F$+B F#$(2 $+% (#$%#&($1 "0 3.%7(&("# H%7"6%& &" 0(#%21
9%0(#%9 $+-$ ($ H%7"6%& (#9%0(#($%> Y$ $+%# 7"22-3&%& H-7T (#$" $+% (#+F6-#21
6-$%.(-2> M"8%'%.B (# - )?NChN? 0.-/6%#$B =(%$A&7+% &%%6& $" H% &F//%&$(#/
$+-$ 0".6 3"&&%&&%& "#21 - '%.1 2(6($%9 7-3-7($1 $" "'%.7"6% $+% 6"#&$%.
8+(7+ (& 2(0% -#9 +% -33%-.& $" .%7"66%#9 7-F$("#4 51"F 7-# 9.-8 2"$& 0". -22
0".6&B HF$ 2(0%j; `744$ :")5$& ;"U&&$& 9,%?$=,U)2$4# =$).$&R 9+$) .9% L$+$&Ya
`=(%$A&7+% )X@@hD<B @??a> Q# "'%.%&$(6-$("# "0 $+% 3"$%#$(-2 "0 7F2$('-$%9
0".6B 8+%$+%. ($ 7"6%& (# $+% &+-3% "0 21.(7 3"%$.1 ". /%#%$(7 %#/(#%%.(#/B
6(/+$ RF&$ H% $+% &-6% 5%'"2F$("#-.1 "3$(6(&6; &" 9%&3(&%9 H1 Z%##B HF$ (#
-#"$+%. /F(&%B RF&$ "#% 6".% 9%7%3$('%21 &-'"."F& $" $+% #(+(2(&$;& 3-22%$> *+%
3."6(&% +%29 "F$ H1 /%#%$(7 %#/(#%%.(#/ "0 H%(#/ -H2%B (# q-.-$+F&$.-;&
8".9&B $" 5.%9%%6; "#%&%20 0."6 7+-#7%B H1 $F.#(#/ %'%.1 5($ 8-&; (#$" 5Y
8-#$%9 ($ $+F&;B (& 6-1H% RF&$ -#"$+%. 9%2F9%9 -$$%63$ $" .%8.($% 52(0%;&
/.-#9%F.; -#9 -22 $+-$ (632(%& h ($& 3."9(/("F& 7.%-$('($1B #"$ -28-1& $.-7%-H2%
$" - 7-F&% ". -# %#9m ($& +"..(0(7 7-$-721&6(7 %'%#$& 8+(7+ 0".7% - .-9(7-2
.%".(%#$-$("# "0 &"6% &3%7(%& -#9 %#0".7% 9%&$.F7$("# "# "$+%.& h -& - 5/.-#9
#-..-$('%; "0 2(0%>@@ ,F7+ - #-..-$('% 8"F29 +"29 "F$ $+% 7"60".$(#/ 3."&3%7$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
9"7$".S3"%$ `(."#(7-221a .-#$& -/-(#&$ $+%(. 5&+-6%2%&& 3%.&%7F$("#; H1 $+%
-F$+".($(%& `Z%## )X?X-B @Da> M% 6"7T& $+% (#&$($F$("#-2(&%9 3"2(7(#/ "0 50%8 P.F&&(-# $%&$(72%&; 8+(7+ 7"#'%.$& $+% H"91 (#$" -# "HR%7$ "0 &"7(-2
+1/(%#% `Z%## )X?X-B @Ja> Y#9%%9 (# 5^%#(F& -#9 M%-2$+; `)X@Ia +% $.-7%&
$+% (#$(6-71 H%$8%%# /%#(-2 7.%-$('($1 -#9 (22#%&&4 Z-F9%2-(.% 9(%9 "0 +-&+S
(&+B ^"%$+% 8-& - 3&17+"3-$+ -#9 b-#$ 9(%9 "0 -.$%.("S&72%."$(7 (9("71 `Z%##
)X?X-B )IN -#9 )@Ca> M% 7"#72F9%& $+% %&&-1 8($+ $+% 0"22"8(#/ 2(#%&4
"0 - 3F.3"&%0F2 9(.%7$("# F#9%.21(#/ 8+-$ "$+%.8(&% -33%-.& $" H% (#+FS
6-#21 #"#&%#&(7-2>
Y# 5P."H2%6& "0 $+% K1.(7; Z%## 0F.$+%. 9(&7F&&%& %F/%#(7& -#9 /%#%$(7&> M%
-22F9%& $" $+% 5(63".$-#$ 8".T; "0 $+% &7(%#$(&$B Q2%V(& !-..%2B 8+" -0$%.
%V3%.(6%#$(#/ "# "./-# $.-#&32-#$-$("# %#9%9 F3 8".T(#/ 0". $+% f(7+1
/"'%.#6%#$ (632%6%#$(#/ 53F.(0(7-$("#; 3."/.-66%& "# $+% 6%#$-221 (22>
!-..%2 (& #"8-9-1& 7%2%H.-$%9 H1 $+% W."#$ =-$("#-2 -& $+% 50-$+%. "0 %7"2"/1;
`Z"##-0%e -#9 *".$ )XX<B ?a>@D k%-#SE-.(% K% P%# +-& 9%&7.(H%9 %F/%#(7& -&
H%(#/ #%7%&&($-$%9 H1 $+% 9%'%2"36%#$ -8-1 0."6 #-$F.-2 2-8B F#9%.&$""9 -&
$+% 2-8 "0 #-$F.-2 &%2%7$("#> Q77".9(#/ $" K% P%#B &"7(%$1 +-& 9%/%#%.-$%9
-#9 $+%.%H1 %7"2"/(7-2 H-2-#7% +-& $" H% -.$(0(7(-221 3F$ .(/+$ $+."F/+ 7"#S
&7("F&B 32-##%9 %F/%#(7&> *+(& 7-##"$ H% -77"632(&+%9 8($+"F$ 3-(#> Q&
!-..%2 +(6&%20 8."$% (# 39&R #'*% [&;&"=&4
Y# ".9%. $" /."8 -/-(#B 6-# (& "H2(/%9 $" .%#%8 +(6&%20 r%$ )$29*)$s> *+(&
7-##"$ H% 9"#% 8($+"F$ 3-(# -& +% (& -$ "#7% $+% 6-.H2% -#9 $+% &7F23$".>
Y$ (& +(& "8# &FH&$-#7% $+-$ +% +-& $" 7+(3 -8-1 -$ 8($+ H2"8& "0 $+%
+-66%. -#9 &%#9 021(#/ H%0".% +% 7-# 8%-. +(& .%-2 0-7% -/-(#>
`!-..%2 )X@JB @<Ca
*+(& (& +(/+21 $"V(7 &$F00 -#9 Z%## 7%.$-(#21 0(#9& +(6&%20 (# %V$.%6%21 H-9
7"63-#1> Y#9%%9B 0". - $(6%B +% %V32(7($21 &F33".$& $+% =-A( (9%"2"/1 "0
.-7(-2 72%-#&(#/ -#9 3."R%7$& &F7+ -& L$+$&%+")& `Q.1-# H.%%9(#/ 0-.6&a>
M"8%'%.B $+% _F-&(S&7(%#$(0(7 $%7+#(_F%& -9"3$%9 H1 $+% =-A(& -#9 $+%(.
7"22-H".-$".& &" -& $" 7"#_F%. - 9%/%#%.-$% #-$F.%B - #-$F.% $+-$ +-& $" H%
3F$ H-7T "# 7"F.&% H1 6-#B (& "$+%.8(&% 0-. $"" 3"&($('(&$ 0". Z%##> *%7+#"S
2"/1 (& #"$ &(6321 - +F6-# $""2 RF&$ -& ($ (& #"$ &(6321 -# (#'%#$("# "0
6"9%.#($1m $%7+#"2"/1 +-& -28-1& H%%# 3-.$ "0 #-$F.%4
E-# H%+-'%& -77".9(#/ $" $+% 7.%-$('% 2-8& 8+(7+ &$-#9 -H"'% $+% -$"6
H"6H -#9 F.-#(F6 ".% > > *+%.% +-& -28-1& H%%# $%7+#"2"/1 HF$ 6"&$
3%"32% 9"#;$ T#"8 %#"F/+ -H"F$ ($ $" T#"8 $+(&> `Z%## )X?X-B J@)h<a
*+%.% (& #" "#% 3-.$(7F2-. %'%#$ ". (#'%#$("# 8+(7+ "00%.& 6-# $+% "77-&("#
$" &%(A% $%7+#"2"/1 -#9 .(9% ($B RF&$ -& 2(0% ($&%20 .%0F&%& $" H% $-6%9> Z%##
-99& $+-$ 5$+% $%7+#"2"/1 %&$-H2(&+%9 +%.% "# %-.$+ (& 2-7T(#/ (# %V(&$%#$(-2
&(/#(0(7-#7%; `Z%## )X?X-B J@)a> *+%.% (& #" 3.('(2%/%9 6"6%#$B &F7+ -& $+%
6"6%#$ "0 0-&7(&6B 8+%.%(# $%7+#"2"/1 .%'%-2& ($&%20 -#9 "00%.& ($&%20 0".
+-.#%&&(#/ &" -& $" +F#$ 9"8# 2(0%>
*+(& -#-21&(& "0 Z%##;& 8".T 02F&+%& "F$ "#% 2(#% "0 -./F6%#$ $+-$ (& $+%
3"%$;&> Q#"$+%. 2(#%B $+% 6".% 0-6(2(-. "#%B (& -2&" +(&> Y$ (& -2&" $+% -H&"2F$%
7"#$.-9(7$("# "0 $+% 0".6%.4 $+-$ (&B ($ -&&%.$& $+-$ $+%.% 3.%7(&%21 (& - 3.('S
(2%/%9 6"6%#$ `)X@@aB .-7% `Q.1-#aB %.- `6"9%.#($1aB .%/(6% `*+(.9 G%(7+a
-#9 3-.$1 `=,[QPa -#9 $+% 2(#% 8+(7+ 9('(9%& $+% "29 0."6 $+% #%8 (& $+%.%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B*9&$ 3")?9& )JC
-#9 6F&$ H% 7."&&%9> 5*+% (#$%.6%9(-.1 .%-26 "0 #(+(2(&6 (& -$ -# %#9; Z%##
-00(.6& (# )X@@ `Z%## )X?X-B D??a> M(& -#/.1 %V7+-#/% "0 2%$$%.& 8($+ b2-F&
E-## %V-7$21 7%#$.%& "# $+(& _F%&$("# "0 8+-$ &(9% "0 $+% 9('(9% $+%1 9%7(9%
$" 3"&($("# $+%6&%2'%& h $+% .(/+$ ". $+% 2%0$> E-##B - 1"F$+0F2 %#$+F&(-&$ 0".
Z%##;& &+"7T(#/ -#9 (7"#"72-&$(7 %V3.%&&("#(&$ 3"%$.1B 0(#9& +(& +%." -00(2(-$S
(#/ +(6&%20 8($+ $+% 7.(6(#-2& "0 $+% "$+%. &(9%> =(+(2(&6 (& -22 '%.1 8%22 -#9
/""9 (0 $+% 6"6%#$ (& #"$ - 3.%&&(#/21 3"2($(7-2 "#%> ZF$ #"8j (# )X@@B 2,U) .*$
A#,&.$B 0-($+ (# - +F6-#(&$B ,U+$)&9#*"&94$) O$*%#B $+-$ 9.1 &$".%+"F&% "0 +"3%B
'-2F% -#9 (9%-2&B 6F&$ H% "3%#%9 F3B %'%# (0 "#21 $%63".-.(21 `E-## )XN?B
)CDa> E-## F#9%.&$-#9& Z%##;& 6(&$-T%# 0-6(2(-.($1 8($+ $+% =-A(& $" -.(&%
0."6 +(& 2-7T "0 (9%-2&B 0."6 +(& 7"#7%#$.-$("# "# $+% +"3%2%&& (..-$("#-2($1
"0 $+% +F6-# 3&17+%> M% 0-(2& $" -33.%7(-$% $+% 0-7$ $+-$ (9%-2(&6 +-&
#"$+(#/ (#$.(#&(7-221 52%0$(&+;B &"7(-2(&$ ". -#$(S0-&7(&$ -H"F$ ($> Z%##;& )X@@
3"2($(7-2 (#'"2'%6%#$ F#0".$F#-$%21 ."$% -.(&% '%.1 6F7+ 0."6 - &F99%#
"3$(6(&$(7B (9%-2(&$(7 %F3+".(-> W". (#&$-#7%B +% H%2(%'%9 $+-$ 0(#-221 - .%/(6%
+-9 -..('%9 $+-$ 8"F29 H% -H2% $" -33.%7(-$% %V3.%&&("#(&64 +"8 8."#/ 7-#
1"F /%$ 0"F. 1%-.& H%0".% $+% 5[%/%#%.-$% Q.$; %V+(H($("#B -# %V+(H($("#
8+(7+ (#72F9%9 Z%## 8($+(# ($i
Z-.%21 H%2(%'(#/ $+% $-2%& +% +%-.& -H"F$ - Z%## $F.#%9 .-H(9 =-A(B E-##
7-22& "# +(6 #"$ $" H%+-'% -6H(/F"F&214 5+% 8+" 9"%& &" 8(22 #" 2"#/%. -#9
8(22 #%'%. -/-(# H%2"#/ $" F&;> M% &+"F29 #"8 T#"8 8+%.% +(& 32-7% (&B `$+-$
(&B -6"#/&$ $+% %V(2%&aB RF&$ -& E-## 9"%&4 5Y #"8 T#"8B 6".% 72%-.21 -#9
%V-7$21 $+-# %'%.B 8+%.% 61 32-7% (&; mp*/' =$*nl &,& %" ;49) ,&. %" ?$&9, =*$
&*$R =" 5$*& E49#@ *%#W `E-## )XN?B )CCa> Z%## .%&3"#9& H1 -##"F#7(#/ $+-$
+% $"" T#"8& 8+%.% +(& 32-7% (&B (# =-A( ^%.6-#1 -#9 #"$ (# &F##1 %V(2% "#
$+% G('(%.- `Z%## )X?DB <XNa>
*+%6-$(7-221B $+(& -2$%.7-$("# H%$8%%# Z%## -#9 E-## .%&%6H2%& $+% 0-.
g H%. 9(% K(#(%; H1 M%(S
g#/%.;& 5\
6".% 3"2($% $.%-$6%#$ &%.'%9 "F$ $" U.#&$ kF
g H%. 55[(% K(#%;;;B M%(9%//%. 9%-2&
9%//%.> Y# +(& .%321B 5qF. ,%(#&0.-/%; ". 5\
9(.%7$21 8($+ (# $+% _F%&$("# "0 #(+(2(&6;& &$-$F& -& -# %'%#$B ($& $-T(#/ 32-7%>
Y# >$*.$??$) 9&. 6#'*/% k"-##- M"9/% /2"&&%& M%(9%//%.;& -./F6%#$ (# $+%
0"22"8(#/ 8-14
W". $.-#&($("# "F$ "0 #(+(2(&6 $" $-T% 32-7% ($ (& #"$ - _F%&$("# "0 6"'(#/
0."6 "#% 2"7-2($1 $" -#"$+%.B HF$ "0 $.-#&0".6(#/ $+% 2"7-2($1 (# 8+(7+ 8%
-2.%-91 0(#9 "F.&%2'%&B $.-#&0".6(#/ "F. &$-#7% 8($+ .%&3%7$ $" $+-$
2"7-2($1>
`M"9/% )XXJB CIa
Z% $+(& -& ($ 6-1B 0". E-## -#9 Z%##B -#9 6-#1 "$+%. ^%.6-# 8.($%.&B $+%
_F%&$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 0".6F2-$%& ($&%20 3.%7(&%21 -& - _F%&$("# "0 &$-1(#/ (# 2"7-2($1 ". 6"'(#/ 2"7-2($1B 7."&&(#/ $+% 2(#% 8+(7+ (9%-221 &%3-.-$%& 7"F#S
$.(%& -#9 $+%(. 3"2($(7& 0."6 "#% -#"$+%.> *+% _F%&$("# H%(#/ +"$21 9(&3F$%9
H1 $+%6 (# )X@@ (& 8+%$+%. "#% &+"F29 %6(/.-$%B 8+-$ ($ 6%-#& $" &$-1 (#
^%.6-#1> K-$%. $+% 9%H-$% 8(22 .-/% -."F#9 b2-F&; 0-$+%.B *+"6-& E-##B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)J? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
-#9 +(& .%0F&-2 $" .%$F.# $" ^%.6-#1 -0$%. $+% 8-.4 8+%$+%. +% (& &$(22 $" H%
.%/-.9%9 -& - ^%.6-# 8.($%.m 8+%$+%. +(& 5%V(2%; (# &F##1 !-2(0".#(- (& H%$.-1-2m 8+%$+%. $+% &"S7-22%9 5(##%. %6(/.-$("#; "0 ^%.6-# 8.($%.& 8+"
&$-1%9 (# ^%.6-#1 9F.(#/ $+% 8-. (& .%-221 $%#-H2% -& - 3"&($("# #"$ #%7%&S
&-.(21 7"632(7($ 8($+B ". %'%# -& - $13% "0 7"'%.$ .%&(&$-#7% -/-(#&$B $+%
9"6(#-#$ .%/(6%> Q22 $+%&% _F%&$("#& 7"F#$ "#%;& 3"&($("#(#/ '(&S-nS'(& &3%7(0(7 2"7-2($1B 8+%.% "#% 3+1&(7-221 &$-#9&B -& 7.F7(-2 0". -&&%&&(#/ "#%;&
3"2($(7-2 &$-#93"(#$>@J W". H"$+ b2-F& E-## -#9 Z%## - 72%-.S7F$ $%..($".(-2
7+"(7% (& F./%#$21 3.%&%#$(#/ ($&%20 (# %V7%3$("#-2 7(.7F6&$-#7%&> Z"$+ 6-T%
- 9%7(&("#B "#% /"%& 2%0$B $+% "$+%. .(/+$> Z%##;& 2-6%#$-H2% 9%7(&("# (#
0-'"F. "0 $+% .(/+$ 8-& #"$ RF&$ 8."#/ %$+(7-221 HF$ - 3FAA2(#/ 56(&.%-9(#/;
"0 +(& "8# (632(7($ 3"&($("# -& %'(9%#$ (# +(& 8.($(#/&> !.($(7& -.% 2%0$ $"
3"#9%. "'%. $+% 3"%$;& %#(/6-$(7 7+"(7%B "#% $+-$ +% &""# .%-2(&%9B "#7%
%'%# $+% =-A(& +-9 .%R%7$%9 +(& -H&F.9 -$$%63$& -$ 7"22-H".-$("#B 8-& $%..(H2% 6(&$-T%>@N
LF$ "0 $+% 9%3$+& "0 Z%##;& 3"2($(7-2 0"F2#%&&B -.(&(#/B #"$ 3+"%#(VS2(T% $"
H% .%H".# -#9 $+%.%H1 .%9%%6%9B HF$ (# $+% '%.1 0-7% "0 $+(& F/2(#%&&B 2%$ F&
.%$F.# $" $+% 53.(6-2 '(&("#; %'"T%9 %-.2(%.> M"8 (& $+% +F6-# .%7"#0(/F.%9
H1B ". +"8 &+"F29 +% .%7"#0(/F.% +(6&%20 8+%# 7"#0."#$%9 8($+B $+"&%
53.(6%'-2 9.('%& "0 -/%2%&& 6-&&%& (# $+% &"F#9 "0 &%-& -#9 $+% 32F#/% "0
2(/+$;i `Z%## )X?DB ))?h)Xa L#% .%-7$("#B $+% "#% -9"3$%9 H1 $+% =-A(& -#9
$%63".-.(21 H1 Z%##B (& $" "3$ 0". - H.F$-2 3"2($(7& "0 53F.(0(%9; 0".6 (# $+%
+"3% $+-$ -# -.$(0(7(-221 7F2$('-$%9 H"91 7-#B (# ($& '%.1 %V72F&('($1 -#9
59(&7(32(#%9; -H&"2F$%#%&&B (63(#/% "# $+% /%.6S32-&6- -#9 $+%.%H1 H%
3-&&%9 9"8# (#$" $+% #%V$ /%#%.-$("# `Z%## )X?X-B <C<h@a> *+(& $13% "0
%F/%#(7& (& 7%.$-(#21 #" %F2"/1 "0 9%0".6-$("# -& -# %V3.%&&("# "0 0".6B
6(6(7T(#/ 2(0%;& 6"'%6%#$&> Y#&$%-9 ($ -$$%63$& $" H% - &6-.$ "F$8($$(#/ "0
2(0%;& 59%/%#%.-$("#;B - 59%/%#%.-$("#; 8+(7+ ($ 7-# "#21 3%.7%('% -& #"V("F&
0". $+% 7"#&"2(9-$%9B 5+%-2$+1; +F6-#>
*+% "$+%. .%&3"#&% $" 2(0%B 8+(7+ (& -2&" 6".% 7"#&(&$%#$21 Z%##;&B .%0F&%&
&F7+ -# F2$(6-$%21 8%-T .%-7$("#> Y# )X@<B "#% 1%-. H%0".% +(& "8# .-63-#$
7%2%H.-$("# "0 5H.%%9(#/ 3."/.-66%&;B Z%## &F//%&$& $+-$ $+% 5"./-#(7 &FHS
&$-#7%; +-& &%(A%9 F3 (# %V+-F&$("# `")?9&*%/'$ 6)59##,&?a> Y# '-(# 9" &7(%#$S
(&$& -.6%9 8($+ $+%(. (#7FH-$".& -#9 H.%%9(#/ 0-.6& -$$%63$ $" 0".7% #-$F.%B
3."99(#/ -#9 3"T(#/ ($ $" 1(%29 #%8 '-.(%$(%& -& - 6-(#&$-1 -/-(#&$ $+% &2(9%
(#$" $+% F#9(00%.%#$(-$%9 &$-$% 8+(7+ (& +%-$S9%-$+ `Z%## )X?X-B DJ<h@a> Y#
5O"20;& *-'%.#; `)X@NaB -0$%. +(& =-A( 53%.("9;B +% 7"#$(#F%& $+(& 2(#% "0
$+"F/+$4
O% -.% #" 2"#/%. 7"#7%.#%9 0". H.%%9(#/ 0". - 0F$F.% 8% 7-# #%($+%. -8-($
#". F$(2(A%B HF$ 8($+ "F. H%-.(#/ (# -# %&7+-$"2"/(7-2 3.%&%#$ $+-$ +-&
H%7"6% -# -H&$.-7$ %V3%.(%#7% "#21 `%"&.$)& ,5 >94#,&? *& $*&$) &,) &"/'
9+%#)9;#*F $)4$++9)$&R 2*&94$& O$?$&=9)#a> *+F& .%-9& $+% 7"9%9 6%&&-/%>
M%.% $+% 7%.$-(# 0%8 7"6% $" - +-2$4 H%0".% $+% .%6"$% &(/#& $+-$ -.%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B*9&$ 3")?9& )JX
9-8#(#/ &$%-9(21 #%-.%.B $+% (#'(&(H2% 3."$-/"#(&$& "0 $+% (63%#9(#/
$.-#&0".6-$("#> > > > [%7"63"&($("# (& 3-23-H2%B - .%$F.# $" %-.2(%. 7"#9(S
$("#& (63"&&(H2%B $+% &FH&$-#7% &3%#$m $+(& (& 8+%.% $+% ,%7"#9 K-8 "0
*+%.6"91#-6(7& -332(%&> *+% #%8 3"8%. (& $+%.%B +"29(#/ $+% 7(/-.%$$%S
2(/+$%. $" $+% 0F&%> O+%$+%. H1 6""#S32F#/% ". -$"6S&6-&+(#/B H1
%#$."31 `X$)$*%,&?a ". (#7%#9(-.(&6B H1 8+-$%'%. 6%$+"9 ($ 3.%0%.&B ($ (&
$+% $.-#&0".6-$("#B $+% %$%.#-2 %2%6%#$B $+% &3(.($B $+% -#$-/"#(&$ "0
9.%-.1 .-$("#-2($1 -#9 6%.% 7"#&F63$("# h (# &+".$4 $+% %#9 "0 $+%
#-$F.-2 '(%8 "0 $+% 8".29>
`Z%## )X?DB )DNhCm )XC)B ?Ih)a
Z%##;& -H-#9"#6%#$ "0 - 0-&7(&$(7-221 ".(%#$%9 H("3"2($(7& (& 7"#7"6($-#$
8($+ +(& $F.#(#/ -8-1 0."6 $+% $%2%"2"/(7-2 `H.%%9(#/ (# $+% #-6% "0 &"6%
9(&$-#$ 0F$F.%a -#9 - .%$F.# $" %&7+-$"2"/1 `$+% 0(#-2 3.%&%#$a> ,+".$21 H%0".%
$+(& 7($%9 3-&&-/% Z%## +-& -2.%-91 7.13$(7-221 %'"T%9 $+% 57"9%9 6%&&-/%; "0
$+% 56"#&$."F& -2T-2"(9;B 8+(7+ 7-##"$ H% 3"&&%&&%9 7"/#($('%21B 8+"&%
0".6F2-$("#& 6-1 H% T#"8# HF$ 8+"&% &FH&$-#7% (& 8($++%29 5(# -22 ($&
3F.($1;> b2-F& *+%8%2%($ &F//%&$& $+-$ +%.% Z%## 6(/+$ -& 8%22 H% $-2T(#/B
+"8%'%. 3.%7"7("F&21B -H"F$ [=Q4
$+% 6"#&$."F& -2T-2"(9 > > $+-$ 8(22 H.(#/ -H"F$ (# $+% +F6-# 8+-$ $+%
+F6-# ($&%20 +-& #"$ H%%# -H2% $" 6-#-/% (# -22 ($& (#-9%_F-$% -$$%63$&>
!"7-(#%B 7-00%(#%B #(7"$(#%B 6".3+(#% -.% -22 -2T-2(9%&> *+(& (& $+% &$-$% "0
7+%6(&$.1 (# )X@NB - 0%8 1%-.& 2-$%. Z%## 8"F29 +-'% 8.($$%#4 5-7(9&;m K,[
-& 8%22 -& [=QB $+% 6"#&$."F& -7(9&B $+-$ (& $" &-1 -6(#" -7(9& > > > 8+(7+
2%-9 +F6-#& "F$ "0 $+%(. !9#,)94 >*%#")CB 8+(7+ +-& #%'%. H%%# -#9 #%'%.
8(22 H% -#1$+(#/ "$+%. $+-# .$9.4C 0". $+%6>
*+%.%0".% - &FH&$-#7% 8+(7+ &$.F7$F.%& /%#%&B [=QB 8+(7+ 6-T%& ($&%20
T#"8# $" +F6-#& rHF$ #"$ T#"8-H2%s -#9 - +-22F7(#"/%#(7 2(T% K,[B $+-$
"3%#& F3 $+% 3-$+8-1& $" $+% F#7"#&7("F&B -.% Z%##;& 8(&+%&B 8+%# #"
2"#/%. 0". W.-#T%#&$%(#(-#]=(%$A&7+%-# 5H.%%9(#/;B $+%# -& 0F#9-6%#$-2
7"63"#%#$& 0". $+% O.($(#/S,1&$%6 o%-. <III `.$% 7,2%/')$*+$%C%#$5%
\aaaa r$+% .%0%.%#7% (& $" b($$2%.;& H""T "0 $+% &-6% #-6%s>
`*+%8%2%($ )XXN-B CDXhJIa
*+% 5"./-#(7 &FH&$-#7%;B $+-$ 8+(7+ +-& .%-7$%9 $" $+% 3."99(#/ -#9 6-#(3S
F2-$("# "0 $+% 2(6($%9 (6-/(#-$("# "0 $+% '"5" %9I*$&B (& &3%#$> *+% 6"#&$%.&
"0 %6H.1"2"/1 -.% (#%00%7$F-2 7.%-$F.%&B &(/#& "0 $+(& +F6-#;& '-(# -$$%63$&
$" H%7"6% $+% _F-&(S9('(#% 7-3$-(#;& "0 2(0%> Z%## 7"..%7$& $+%&% 6(&/F(9%9
-&3(.-$("#& H1 -##"F#7(#/ (# 5P."'"T%9 K(0%; $+-$4
^"9 (& - &FH&$-#7%B - 9.F/> Q# (#$"V(7-$(#/ &FH&$-#7% .%2-$%9 $" $+%
+F6-# H.-(#> *+(& (& 3%.0%7$21 3"&&(H2% -#9 6".% 2(T%21 $+-# M(6 H%(#/
-# %2%7$.(0(%9 6-7+(#% ". - ,3%6-##(-# *.($"#;& 2-.'- %#/%#9%.%9
$+."F/+ /.-0$(#/ $-93"2% $(&&F% (# $+% HF77-2 A"#%> `Z%## )X?X-B @C<a@C
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)NI !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
W(992(#/ -."F#9 (# 2-H".-$".(%& 8($+ /.-0$& -#9 $.-#&32-#$&B %'%# 6-#-/(#/
$" $-63%. 8($+ [=Q ($&%20 -.% 5(#-9%_F-$% -$$%63$&; $" 3."'"T% - $.-#&0".S
6-$("# "0 $+% +F6-#> *+%1 3-2% (#$" (#&(/#(0(7-#7% 8+%# 7"#$.-&$%9 8($+
$+% 6""91 `49,&*%/'a -#9 %#(/6-$(7 2-8& "0 #-$F.%> Y#&$%-9 "0 2-6%#$(#/ 0-(2F.% $" 9"6(#-$% 5"F.; #-$F.%B 8% &+"F29B -9'(&%& Z%##B .%".(%#$-$% "F.
F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 8+-$ ($ (& $" H% +F6-# $+."F/+ - 3%.&3%7$('-2 .%S'(&("# `3.(6-2 '(&("#a "0 2(0% ($&%20> *+(& (#'"2'%& - .%$F.# $" "F. (#($(-2 _F"$-$("#
0."6 5P."'"T%9 K(0%; "# $+% #-$F.% "0 $+% H.-(#>
Z%## 8-#$& $" 5&+F$ "00 7-F&-2 ."8&B $F.# -."F#9 %#$."31 -#9B (# 7"#$(#F-2
3."3-/-$("# -#9 (#7.%-&% "0 (63."H-H(2($%& -#9 7"632(7-$%9 ".9%.(#/& `G"5J
I4*@*$)#JO$").&$#$&a /" "# $" -$$-(# $+% %V$.%6%; `Z%## )X?X-B @X<a> *+(&
#%7%&&($-$%& - &F99%# (#$%..F3$("# "0 $+% 53."/.%&&('% 7%.%H.-2(&-$("#; "0 $+%
H.-(# H%0".% ($ (632"9%& 8($+(# $+% .%3."9F7$('% '%+(72%> *+% $F.#S-."F#9
3."3"&%9 (& 6".% - 7+-#/% (# -33."-7+ $+-# -#1 #%/%#$."3(7 72-8(#/ H-7T
0."6 $+% (66-#%#7% "0 +%-$S9%-$+ $+."F/+ 7"632%V(0(7-$("#> Y#&$%-9 "0
$.1(#/ $" $-T% $+% 0-$% "0 $+% 8".29 "# +(& &+"F29%.& H1 H%7"6(#/ - 57"&6(7
3-.-3+.-&%; $+% +F6-# &+"F29 -(6B -& 8% &-8 %-.2(%.B $" H%7"6% - 5#-T%9B
0".6-2 /%&$-$("#; `Z%## )X?DB @CJa> *+% 8".29 "0 %V3.%&&("# (& $+%.%0".%
&$.%-62(#%9B 7"63"&%9 "0 572%-. (#$%.&32(7%9 `F$)@9'&#$)a .%2-$("#&B $+% (#$%.S
2"7T(#/ "0 /."F#9S9"8# 0".7%& > > >;> Y#&$%-9 "0 (6321(#/ 7"632%V(0(7-$("#B
$+%.% (& - 7%.$-(# &(632(7($1 (# $+% 5"./-#(7 &(/#-$F.%; $+% 6F$-$(#/ +F6-# (&
$" H%-.>@?
*+% 2(0% $+-$ 8%22& F3 50."6 $+% /F22%$B "./-#(&%& ($&%20 - 8+(2% $" 9(&33%-.
(#$" $+% (#0%.#"; (& 9%&7.(H%9 H1 Z%## -& 5&%%$+(#/;B 5+%-'(#/; h +% $-2T& "0 $+%
A/'=$44,&?%/'9)9;#$) .$) A/'"UI2,&? h -#9 $+(& /('%& .(&% $" +(& P944,&?%#'$")*$B
$+% $+%".1 "0 $F.6"(2B "0 7"#/%&$("# -#9 "0 #"6-9(7 R"F.#%1(#/ `Z%##
)X?DB <CD -#9 @<Ca>@X Y$ (& $+% .%(#'%#$%9 H"91B (#72F9(#/ $+% .%-7$('-$%9
H.-(#B (>%>"#% $+-$ 7-# 3."0($ 0."6 ($& -7-F&-2 &-2$-$("#&B ($& 7.%-$('% 7.(&%& -#9
7.-'(#/ 0". 3."'"T%9 2(0%B $+-$ (& $" $-T% F& "# $+(& 7"#/%&$%9 R"F.#%1 (#$" $+%
F#T#"8# +F6-#>DI 5!"#/%&$("#; (632(%& - 7."89%9 7"22%7$("# "0 $+(#/&
6%.%21 +%-3%9 $"/%$+%.B #"$ H"F#9 $"/%$+%. H1 -#1 -9+%.(#/ 7"#$%#$> K(T%
-# %V3.%&&("#(&$ 3"%6B $+% 0".7% "0 $+% %'"2F$("#-.1 %V3%.(%#7% (& $" 7"6%
0."6 $+% (63-7$ "0 (#$%#&%21 %V3.%&&%9 0".6B #"$ 0."6 -#1 &FH&$-#$(-2
7"#$%#$ ". +"$21S3F.&F%9B 2(#%-. 2"/(7> 5!"#/%&$("#; -2&" %'"T%& $+% -77F6FS
2-$("# "0 H2""9 ". 6".H(9 `(>%> H("#%/-$('%a 6-$$%. (# -#1 3-.$ "0 $+% H"91
8+(7+ 3."'"T%& - '("2%#$ .%-7$("#> Z%## %V32-(#& $+-$4 5K(0% 2-&$& 0". $8%#$1
0"F. +"F.& -#9 8+%# ($ -.(&%&B ($ 8-& - 7"#/%&$("#; `Z%## )X?DB <CDa> K(0% (&
-# %'%.S7+-#/(#/ 7"#7-$%#-$("# "0 "./-#(7 0".6& -#9 (0 $+% '"5" %9I*$&B
8($+ +(& $%.6(#-2 3."/.%&&('% 7%.%H.-2(&-$("#B (& $" %V3%.(%#7% $+(& &%%$+(#/
(#$"V(7-$("# -& &"6%$+(#/ "$+%. $+-# - #%/-$('% HF.#(#/ "F$ "0 7F..%#$
'-2F%&B $+%# +% 6F&$ +(6&%20 H%7"6% 6"#&$."F&> *+(& .%(#'%#$("# "0 +(6S
&%20 $-T%& +(6 "# - R"F.#%1 (#$" $+% 0F$F.%B `0-7(#/ -&7%#9-#7% #"$ 9%&7%#9S
-#7%aB $+."F/+ $+% H(A-..% H-7T8-$%.& "0 %'"2F$("#4
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B*9&$ 3")?9& )N)
)N< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Q +F6-# H.(&$2(#/ 8($+ 02(7T%.(#/ &%#&".1 +-(.& 8+"&% %#%./%$(7 2-&+(#/
9.('%& ($ $+."F/+ ($& [5=$4# "00%.& $+% 3."&3%7$ "0 -# (#$%#&% %V3%.(%#7% "0
2(0%> ,F7+ -# %V3%.(%#7%B 8+(2% #"$ .%&$".(#/ "F. 9%0F#7$ '-2F%&B 6(/+$ &-'%
F& 0."6 - 9%&3-(.(#/ #(+(2(&6>
C$%() W". Z%##;& _F-&(S-3"7-213$(7 '(%8 "0 $+% 6"9%.# 8".29 &%%B 0". %V-632%B Z%##
)X?XB @C@>
< E"&$ 7"66%#$-$".& %#9 F3 $.1(#/ $" 72-&&(01 Z%## -& - 56-# "0 +(& $(6%;B $13(7-2 "0
$+% )X<I& `9%7-9%#$B (..-$("#-2a O%(6-. G%3FH2(7 3%.7%('%9 (# $F.# -& - 6%.%
3.%2F9% $" )X@I& 0-&7(&6> ,%% 0". (#&$-#7%B ,$.-F&& )XX<m M"+%#9-+2 )X?X>
@ Z%## (#9(&7.(6(#-$%21 3F$& =%8$"#B [-.8(#B M%26+"2$A -#9 $+%.6"91#-6(7& -22
(# $+% &-6% 7-63> Y$ (& #"$ 61 (#$%#$("# +%.% %V32(7($21 $" -&&%&& Z%##;& .%9F7$('%
.%-9(#/ "0 [-.8(# `". (#9%%9 "0 =(%$A&7+%a> Y#9%%9B ($ 8(22 H% (632(%9 $+-$ Z%##
9(&-/.%%& '%+%6%#$21 8($+ - 3-.$(7F2-. 7F..%#$ "0 [-.8(#(&6 -#9 (& (# 0-7$B (# &3($%
"0 +(6&%20B -# (#$%.%&$(#/ .%-9%. "0 [-.8(# `-#9 "0 =(%$A&7+%a> M(& $+%".(%& "#
%'"2F$("# H%-. -# F#7-##1 .%&%6H2-#7% $" $+"&% (# '"/F% $"9-1B 6-9% 3"3F2-.
$+."F/+ $+% 8".T "0 ,$%3+%# k-1 ^"F29> ^"F29B 0". (#&$-#7%B +-& 6-9% - &$."#/ 7-&%
0". %V-7$21 &"# F#9%.&$-#9(#/ [-.8(#(-# %'"2F$("# -& -# F#.%2%#$(#/ 6-.7+ $"
3."/.%&& `&%% ^"F29 )XXCa> W". -#"$+%. 3"8%.0F2 7"#$%63".-.1 .%-9(#/ "0 [-.8(#B
&%% Q#&%22 P%-.&"# )XXC>
D Y# 5W-A($ 9%. P%.&3%T$('%#; `)X@Ia -#9 5Z%AF/&&1&$%6%#; `)XD@a Z%## &+"8& +(6&%20
$" H% - 0-($+0F2 .%-9%. "0 =(%$A&7+%B %V32".(#/ +(& (9%- "0 3%.&3%7$('(&6> W".
(#&$-#7%B +% -6F&(#/21 &F//%&$& $+-$ 0."6 8($+(# $+% &1&$%6 "0 .%0%.%#7%& `<$@,?%J
%C#$5a $+-$ (& (#9F7$('% $+(#T(#/B b-#$B $+% $+(#T%. "0 7-F&-2S-#-21$(7-2 -3"9%(7$(7
#%7%&&($1B 7-# H% .%/-.9%9 -& +-'(#/ 2-(9 9"8# 3.(#7(32%& 8+(7+ -.% H(#9(#/ 0". F&
-22> M"8%'%.B 0."6 - 9(00%.%#$ 3%.&3%7$('%B "F$&(9% "0 $+(& &3%7(0(7 <$@,?%%C%#$5B +%
6-1 RF&$ H% '(%8%9 -& - .-$+%. &$.-#/% 51"/(S0(/F.%; 8+" 2('%9 (# 72(6-$(7-221
9(&0-'"F.%9 7($1B -& 9(&$-#$ 0."6 F& -& $.-#7%S9-#7%.& (# Z-2(j `Z%## )X?XB @X<a>
J ,%% ^"%$+% `)XXJB )))00a -#9 Z%##;& (#$%.%&$(#/ %&&-1 5^"%$+% F#9 9(% =-$F.8(&S
&%#&7+-0$%#; `)X@<a (# Z%## )X?XB )CJh<IN>
N Z%##;& -9+%&("# $" $+% =-$("#-2 ,"7(-2(&$ 6"'%6%#$ 3.%&%#$& F& 8($+ $+% 9(2%66"0 -# -F$+". 8+" (& - $%..(H2% 6(&.%-9%. -#9 6-#(3F2-$". "0 +(& "8# 8".T> Y#
g H%.8(#9F#/; `)X@<a +% 7.($(7(&%& [-.8(#(&6 0". ($& H("S
5=(+(2(&6F& F#9 &%(#% \
g #0$(/%. ^%&7+2%7+$%.; `)X<<a +%
3"2($(7&B 1%$B "#% 1%-. 2-$%. (# 5^%(&$ F#9 ,%%2% TF
(& +(6&%20 -9'"7-$(#/ 5.-7% 7"#&"2(9-$("#; `&%% Z%## )X?X-B <ICh?B <JJa> *+% $8"
g 7+$F#/; %&&-1& `Z%## )X?X4 <@ChDD4 @<Xh@<a -.% 0F.$+%. H%8(29%.(#/ %V-632%& "0
5qF
- 7"632%$% .%8.($% "0 Z%##;& %-.2(%. 3"&($("#> *+% "#21 7"66%#$-$". Y T#"8 8+"
+-& &%.("F&21 h -#9 (# /.%-$ 9%$-(2 -#9 -$ /.%-$ 2%#/$+ h 3FAA2%9 "'%. Z%##;& 57-&%; (&
b2-F& *+%8%2%($> ,%% *+%8%2%($ )XX)m )XXN- -#9 H>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Y# $+% &%- $+%.% -.% 2('(#/ "./-#(&6& "0 $+% 2"8%. A""2"/(7-2 &1&$%6 8+(7+
-.% 7"'%.%9 8($+ 7(2(- `:4*55$)'99)$a> !(2(- -.% $+% -#(6-2 &%#&".1 "./-#
8+(7+ 3.%7%9%& -#1 9(00%.%#$(-$("# (#$" &%3-.-$%9 &%#&F-2 %#%./(%&m ($ (&
$+% /%#%.-2 "./-# "0 $"F7+B $+% 2(#T $" $+% %#'(."#6%#$ `[5=$4#a "0 $+%
&%-> L#% (6-/(#%& - +F6-# 7"'%.%9 8($+ 7(2(- #"$ "#21 "'%. $+% H.-(# HF$
"'%. $+% 8+"2% "./-#(&6>
`Z%## )X?DB <C@ -#9 @<Ca
C Y# 5qF6 *+%6-4 ^%&7+(7+$%; `)XD<a Z%## /"%& &" 0-. -& $" H2-6% [-.8(#B -#9
=(%$A&7+%B 0". H%(#/ .%&3"#&(H2% 0". 56(22("#& "0 9%-$+&; `Z%## )X?X4 @NDa>
? ,%% *F./%#%' `)XX)4 )DIa4 5 55Y$;22 H% - 7"60".$ $" 1"F $" T#"8;;B &-(9 Z-A-."'B 55$+-$
#"8-9-1& (# /%#%.-2 8% 2-F/+ -$ 6%9(7(#% -#9 8".&+(3 #"H"91;;> 55M"8 9;1"F
6%-#i o"F 8-#$ $" H% - 9"7$".B 9"#;$ 1"Fi;; 55Y 9"B HF$ $+% "#% 9"%&#;$ 3.%'%#$ $+%
g #/%. `)XJ<B <Ia "# 5#(+(2(&$(7 6%9(7(#%; 8+(7+ +% 9%0(#%& (# $+%
"$+%.;; ;> ,%% -2&" kF
0"22"8(#/ 8-14 5($ 9"%& #"$ 8-#$ $" 7F.%B HF$ 3F.&F%& "$+%. %#9&;> M%(9%//%. `)XC?B
g #/%.;& 9%0(#($("#4 5*+% 1"F#/ =(%$A&7+% "#7% 7-22%9 $+%
<)Ja 0F.$+%. .%8".T& kF
3+(2"&"3+%. $+% 559"7$". "0 7F2$F.%;;> ZF$ #"8 ($ (& #" 2"#/%. RF&$ - _F%&$("# "0
7F2$F.%> o"F .(/+$21 &-1 55$+% 8+"2% $+(#/ (& -$ &$-T%;; ;>
X Q#$(7(3-$(#/ Q.$-F9;& %#$+F&(-&6 0". $+% 9.F/B Z%## 2-F9& $+% 7-3-7($1 "0 P%1"$%B
F&%9 H1 E%V(7-# Y#9(-#& $" &$.%#/$+%# $+% 61$+"2"/(7-2 7"#7%3$ "0 $+% H"91;&
.%2-$("# 8($+ '($-2 #-$F.-2 0".7%& `&%% Z%## )X?XB XDa> Y# -9'"7-$(#/ $+% H("#%/-S
$('% (#$"V(7-$("# "0 $+% H"91 -& 59-6-/% 9"#% $" - .-7% 7-# H.(#/ ($ F#%V3%7$%9
7"63%#&-$("#; `Z%## )X?XB @CNaB Z%## (& %7+"(#/ =(%$A&7+%;& -9'"7-71 "0 5%##"S
H2%6%#$ $+."F/+ 9%/%#%.-$("#; (# =(%$A&7+% )XX@B )ICh?>
)I ,3%#/2%. F&%& $+% $%.6& 56"#&$."F&; -#9 59%6"#(7; (#$%.7+-#/%-H21> K-$%. (# $+(&
-.$(72% Y 8(22 H% 9(&$(#/F(&+(#/ H%$8%%# $+%6>
)) [(9%."$ `)XNN4 )?Ih)a -#$(7(3-$%& $+(& 2(#% "0 $+"F/+$ `-#9 6F7+ %2&% $+-$ Z%##
8(22 H% &F//%&$(#/a %>/>4 5 55O% 8-2T &" 2($$2%B 8".T &" 2($$2%B HF$ $+(#T &" 6F7+ $+-$ Y
8"F29#;$ .F2% "F$ $+-$ 6-# 6(/+$ %#9 H1 H%(#/ #"$+(#/ HF$ - +%-9;; ;> ,%% -2&"
0F.$+%. 8+-$ +% +-& $" &-1 -H"F$ +F6-#& -#9 $+%(. .%2-$("# $" +13"$+%$(7-2
6"#&$%.&4 5ZF$ $+% 8+"2% (& 7"#&$-#$21 7+-#/(#/> > > > E-# (& 6%.%21 - 0.%_F%#$
%00%7$B - 6"#&$."&($1 (& - .-.% "#%B HF$ H"$+ -.% %_F-221 #-$F.-2B %_F-221 (#%'($-H2%B
%_F-221 3-.$ "0 $+% F#('%.&-2 -#9 /%#%.-2 ".9%. > > > -22 #-$F.% (& (# - 3%.3%$F-2 02FV>
U'%.1 -#(6-2 (& 6".% ". 2%&& - +F6-# H%(#/B %'%.1 6(#%.-2 6".% ". 2%&& - 32-#$ > > >;>
[(9%."$;& $+%".(%& +%.% -H"F$ $+% '"2-$(2% 3"$%#$(-2($1 "0 %'"2F$("#-.1 H%7"6(#/
-.% (#$%.%&$(#/21 &(6(2-. $" $+"&% &F//%&$%9 H1 [-8T(#& `)XX)4 C@a4
)< ,%%B 0". %V-632%B ^"F29 -#9 U29.%9/% `)XX@a 0". -# %V32-#-$("# "0 53F#7$F-$%9
%_F(2(H.(F6;>
g 22 `)XX<4 @D<a "# 7(2(-> O% .%$F.# $" 7(2(- -$ $+% %#9 "0 $+% 7+-3$%.>
)@ ,%% '"# \%VTF
g 22B &%% Z%## `)XXI4 <)Ch)?m )XXI4 <<Xa>
W". Z%## "# '"# \%VTF
)D M%.% Y +-'% $+% .-$+%. H%-F$(0F2 3-&&-/% 0."6 ^"F29 `)XXN4 <)Na (# 6(#94 5Y0 "#%
&6-22 -#9 "99 2(#%-/% "0 0(&+%& +-9 #"$ %'"2'%9 0(#& 7-3-H2% "0 H%-.(#/ 8%(/+$ "#
2-#9> > > > Y0 - 2-./% %V$.-$%..%&$.(-2 "HR%7$ h $+% F2$(6-$% H"2$ 0."6 $+% H2F% h +-9 #"$
$.(//%.%9 $+% %V$(#7$("# "0 9(#"&-F.& NJ 6(22(("# 1%-.& -/"B 6-66-2& 8"F29 &$(22
H% &6-22 7.%-$F.%&B 7"#0(#%9 $" $+% &6-22 #""T& -#9 7.-##(%& "0 - 9(#"&-F.;&
8".29B -#9 (#7-3-H2% "0 %'"2'(#/ $+% 2-./%. &(A% "0 H.-(# $+-$ &%20S7"#&7("F&#%&&
.%_F(.%&;>
)J Z%## .%0%.& $" =(%$A&7+%;& 9%&7.(3$("# "0 #-$F.-2 2-8& -& 56""91;B 3."#% $" &F99%#
3-#(7T1 6"'%6%#$&B (# Z%## )X?X4 ?C>
)N ,%% Z-$-(22% `)X?J4?Ca4 5&+% .F#& $" $+% 0"F2S&6%22(#/ 32-7% -#9 2"7T& +%.&%20 (#
8($+ &F.3.(&% > > > "H&7F.%21B HF$ (# %7&$-&1B &+% +-& 2%-.#%9 $" .%7"/#(&% $+% 0-7% > > >;>
Q& 8% 8(22 &%% 2-$%. Z%## -2&" $-2T& "0 $+% 53.(6-2 0-7%;>
)C ,%% Z%## `)XXI4 <@)a "# 2(0% -& 7172(7-2>
)? L0 7"F.&% 56"6%#$&; (# /%"2"/(7-2 $(6% 7-# 2-&$ - '%.1 2"#/ $(6%> ,%% 0". (#&$-#7%
^"F29 `)XXC4 <<Ia 8+%.% +% 3"(#$& "F$ $+-$ $+% !-6H.(-# %V32"&("# 2-&$%9 J
6(22("# 1%-.&j
)X ,%% M(22%H.-#9 `Z%## )X?X4CDXa "# $+% &(6(2-.($(%&B 1%$ '%.1 9(00%.%#$ 9(00%.%#7%&B
H%$8%%# Z%## -#9 Q9".#" -#9 M".T+%(6%.;& 59(-2%7$(7 "0 $+% %#2(/+$%#6%#$;>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B*9&$ 3")?9& )N@
<I W". - 7"22%7$("# "0 %&&-1& "# $+% 9%6"#(7 &(9% "0 #(+(2(&6B &%% 6F*4 AI*)*#%4 !*'*4*%5
9&. #'$ :9#$ "2 3".$)&*#CB %9> !> Z2-T% -#9 ^> Z-#+-6 `E-#7+%&$%. \#('%.&($1 P.%&&
<IIIa>
<) W". Z%## `)X?X4 <NDa ^"%$+% (& -# %V3.%&&("#(&$> M% F&%& $+% $%.6 $" 9%&7.(H%
$+"F/+$ 8+(7+ (& #" 2"#/%. (#9('(9F-2(&%9 HF$ 8+(7+ (& - .(/"."F& 5/"(#/S$"S$+%S
.""$S"0S$+(#/&; %V3.%&&%9 (# -7-F&-2 0".6>
<< ,%% Q#&%22 P%-.&"# `)XXCB XNhCa "# $+% (63".$-#7% "0 /%"2"/(7-2 &$.-$(0(7-$("#B
8+(7+ .%7".9& 5'(.$F-2 32-#%& "0 H%7"6(#/;B 0". =(%$A&7+%;& "33"&($("# $" +(&$".(7-2
%'"2F$("#(&6 ". +(&$".(7(&6>
<@ *+% !-6H.(-# %V32"&("# (& $+% 6"&$ 0-6"F& "0 $+% 7-$-&$."3+(7 5/.%-$ 91(#/&; -& ($
T(22%9 "00 9(#"&-F.& -#9 3%.6($$%9 $+% %'"2F$("# "0 2-./% 6-66-2&> Q# %#/-/(#/
-77"F#$ "0 ($ (& 3."'(9%9 H1 ^"F29 (# -# -$$%63$ $" &+"8 +"8 $+% 5+(&$".1 "0 2(0% (&
#"$ - 7"#$(#FF6 "0 9%'%2"36%#$ HF$ - .%7".9 3F#7$F-$%9 H1 H.(%0B &"6%$(6%&
/%"2"/(7-221 (#&$-#$-#%"F&B %3(&"9%& "0 6-&& %V$(#7$("# -#9 &FH&%_F%#$ 9('%.&(S
0(7-$("#; `&%% ^"F29 )XX)B %&3> JDa>
<D b2-F& E-## 72%-.21 $+(#T& Z%## (& .%/.%&&('% -#9 7($%& $+% 3"%6 5^%&-g#/%; "#
3.(6-2 &2(6% -& 3.""0 `&%% E-## )XN?B )?DhJm Z%## )XXDB DCa> M"8%'%.B $+%
9%0(#($("# "0 .%/.%&&("# /('%# H1 [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( (& $+-$ ($ (& - 6"'%6%#$
$"8-.9& $+-$ 8+(7+ (& $+% 4$9%# .*22$)$&#*9#$.> G%/.%&&("# (& $" H% 7"#$.-&$%9 8($+
8($+ 57.%-$('% (#'"2F$("#;B 8+(7+ (& - 0".6 "0 %'"2F$("# 8+(7+ $-T%& 32-7% H%$8%%#
$+(#/& 8+(7+ -.% +%$%."/%#%"F& -#9 #"$ 8+%.% $+%.% (& +"6"/%#%($1 `[%2%FA%
-#9 ^F-$$-.( )X?IB <X<a> Y# -#"$+%. 3"%6 7-22%9 5G%/.%&&("#; Z%## 8.($%& -H"F$
5$+-2-&&-2 .%/.%&&("#; `Z%## )XXDB <I@a> Q& 8% 8(22 &%% -$ $+% %#9 "0 $+(& -.$(72%
8+%# +% 9%&7.(H%& $+% &$.-#/% 7.%-$F.%& 8($+ $+%(. 02(7T%.(#/ 7(2(-B $+% &%- 0". Z%##
(& 0-. 0."6 H%(#/ -# F#9(00%.%#$(-$%9 6-&& HF$B (#&$%-9B $+% 3.(6% %V-632% "0
+%(/+$%#%9B 7.%-$('% (#$"V(7-$("#> Y#9%%9B -& [%2%FA% 3"(#$& "F$ (# .%2-$("# $"
^%.6-# UV3.%&&("#(&6 -& - 8+"2%B $+% 6"'%6%#$ 8-& 3.(6-.(21 7"#7%.#%9 8($+
$+% '($-2 -& &3."F$(#/B -& - 53.%S"./-#(7 /%.6(#-2 0".7%B 7"66"# $" H"$+ -#(6-$%9
-#9 $+% (#-#(6-$%9 6-$$%.; `[%2%FA% )XXNB CNa> *+(& UV3.%&&("#(&$ %63+-&(& "#
/%.6(#-2 2(0% 7"632(7-$%& $+% 9"6(#-#$ &$-#9-.9 .%-9(#/ "0 $+% 6"'%6%#$ -& 3.%0-7% $" 0-&7(&$(7 -$-'(&6 `&%% #"$% <B -H"'%a> ,%% 0F.$+%. Z%## `)X?X4 XNa "#
%7&$-$(7 /%.6(#-$("#>
<J ,%% Z%## `)X?X4 ))?a "# .%7-3($F2-$("# -#9 !-.F&>
<N ,%% -2&" =(%$A&7+% )X@@hD<B @??4 5U'%.1 (#9('(9F-2 +-& -# (#0(#($1 "0
2('(#/ (#9('(9> (# ($&%20;B `8$.$% -&.*F*.,,5 '9# $*&$ [&$&.4*/';$*# 4$+$&.*?$) -&.*F*.Z
*& %*/'a>
<C Z%## 7.($(7(&%& =(%$A&7+% 0". 9(.%7$(#/ +(& 8.($(#/ $" - 0F$F.% 58%;B 0". -3"&$."3+(&S
(#/ - 0F$F.% 7"66F#($1 "0 0.(%#9&B 8+%.%-& Z%## 7"#&(9%.& +(6&%20 $" H% 7"#S
$.(HF$(#/ $" $+% 5-H&"2F$% 3"%6B $+% 3"%6 8($+"F$ +"3%B 9(.%7$%9 $" #"H"91; `&%%
Z%## )X?XB @D@ -#9 J<Xa>
<? Q& (& $+% 7-&% 8($+ +(& .%-9(#/ "0 [-.8(#B Y -6 #"$ &F//%&$(#/ $+-$ Z%## (& 3-.$(7F2-.21 &$."#/ .%-9%. "0 =(%$A&7+% -$ $+(& 3"(#$>
<X ,%% ^"F29 `)XXCB <<)h<a "# $+% 9(00%.%#7%& H%$8%%# 7F2$F.-2 K-6-.T(&6 -#9
#-$F.-2 %'"2F$("#>
g # /%8%&%#% 9%F$&7+% Y##%.2(7+S
@I ,%% Z%## `)X?X4 D?Xa "# 5%(#% '(%22%(7+$ &%+. &7+"
T%($;>
@) ,%% -2&" Q#&%22 P%-.&"# `)XXCB )<Da4 5"F. ".(/(#& -.% (# &2(6%;>
@< ,%% Z%## `)X?XB D??a4 5$+% (#$%.6%9(-.1 3+-&% "0 #(+(2(&6 (& -$ -# %#9 > > > ($ 6"'%&
-8-1 0."6 9%&7%#9-#7% $"8-.9& -&7%#9-#7%;>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)ND !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
@@ ,%% ^"F29 `)XXCa "# +"8 52(0%;& /.-#9%F.; (& #"$ $" H% F#9%.&$""9 -& - $%2%"2"/(S
7-221 ".(%#$%9 /.-#9 #-..-$('% 8+(7+ %#9".&%& "F. -#$+."3"7%#$.(7 '(%8 "0 %'"2FS
$("#>
@D !-..%2;& H""T 8-& $.-#&2-$%9 (#$" )X 2-#/F-/%& -#9 +-& &"29 +F#9.%9& "0 $+"FS
&-#9& 7"3(%&> W". - &+"7T(#/21 F#7.($(7-2 -77"F#$ "0 !-..%2;& 2(0% &%% !+.(&$%# )X?N>
W". -#$(0-&7(&$ -77"F#$ "0 !-..%2B &%% Z"##-0%e -#9 *".$ )XX<> *".$ -2&" +-& 9%'"$%9
6F7+ "0 +(& $(6% $" .%$.(%'(#/ [-.8(#;& 8".T 0."6 $+% -.6& "0 $+% &"7(-2 [-.8(S
#(-#&B 0". %V-632%B &%% *".$ )XXC>
@J ,%% ^."&&%. `%9>a )XN@ "# $+% 3"&$8-. *+"6-& E-## 9%H-$%>
@N L#7% -/-(# &%% *+%8%2%($ `)XX)m )XXN- -#9 Ha 8+" 3"#9%.& $+(& _F%&$("# -$ `/.%-$a
2%#/$+
@C ,3%6-##;& %V3%.(6%#$& 8($+ $.-#&32-#$-$("# .%'%-2%9 $+-$ 7%22& 0".6 $+%6&%2'%&
-77".9(#/ $" 8+%.% $+%1 -.% &($F-$%9B -#9 #"$ 8+%.% $+%1 7"6% 0."6B $+-$ (&B $+%(.
0-$% (& 9%$%.6(#%9 H1 32-7% `($ (& ")#%?$59U%%a #"$ 3.%9%$%.6(#%9 H1 ".(/(# `&*/'#
'$);,&2#%?$59U%%a> Z%## `)XXI4 <<Ca 7"#72F9%& $+-$ &T(# 7%22& 8+(7+ 0(#9 $+%6S
&%2'%& $.-#&32-#$%9 (#$" $+% H.-(# 7-# -9-3$ $" $+%(. #%8 2"7-$("#> ,%% -2&" !-..%2;&
-6-A(#/ `-#9 7+(22(#/a 5*+% G%2-$("# "0 !%22& $" L#% Q#"$+%.; 8+%.% +% -2&" &$-$%&
$+-$4 5$+% 0-$% "0 - 7%22 (& - 0F#7$("# "0 ($& 3"&($("#; -#9 5r8($+(#s $+% "./-#(&6B
$(&&F% 7%22& -7$F-2(A% "#21 - &6-22 3-.$ "0 $+%(. 3"$%#$(-2($(%&; `!-..%2 )X@IB <)Ih))a>
*+% -.$(72% H%/(#& H1 _F%&$("#(#/ 8+%$+%. $+% 3."7%&&%& 8+(7+ H.(#/ "F$ -#9
6-(#$-(# $+% "./-#(&6 .%-221 -.% 3F.3"&%0F2B (>%> $%2%"2"/(7-221 9(.%7$%9>
@? ,%% [%2%FA% -#9 P-.#%$ `)XXNB @Ch?a 0". +"8 - &(632(01(#/ 3-.(#/S9"8# 7-# H%
3-.$ "0 - 7.%-$('% (#'"2F$("#>
@X ,%% Z%## `)XXJ4 <Ih)a 0". - 7"#&(9%.-$("# "0 $+% '-.("F& 3%.6F$-$("#& "0 P944,&?>
DI M%.% Y -6 &F//%&$(#/ - 32-1 "# !-..%2;& $($2% 39&0 #'*% [&;&"=&> W". - %F/%#(7(&$
&F7+ -& !-..%2B "#% 8+" 7-##"$ %#'(&-/% 9%S0".6-$("# -& 0".6B 56-#; (& 0-. 0."6
H%(#/ -# F#T#"8#> 5PF.(0(7-$("#; 3."/.-66%& %V-7$21 3F.3".$ $" T#"8 $+%
+F6-# -& -# (#$.(#&(7 '-2F% -#9 $+%1 -(6 $" %2(6(#-$%B #"$ H.%%9B 56"#&$%.&;>
0(D()(,1(Q#&%22 P%-.&"#B b> `)XXCa X*)"*. L*2$ K"#9"#]=%8 o".T4 G"F$2%9/%>
Z-$-(22%B ^> `)X?Ja 5*+% P(#%-2 U1%; (# X*%*"&% "2 6H/$%% E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0
E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
Z%##B ^> `)XJDa B",+4$ X*$ $.-#&> k>SE> P-26(%.> P-.(&4 K%& %e9($("#& 9% E(#F($>
pp `)XC)a E)*594 X*%*"& %9> Z> Q&+$"#> =o4 =%8 [(.%7$("#&>
pp `)X?<a O$.*/'#$ %9> Z> M(22%H.-#9> W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 W(&7+%.>
pp `)X?Da E)"%9 ,&. 7,#"+*"?)9I'*$ %9> Z> M(22%H.-#9> W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 W(&7+%.>
pp `)X?X-a 6%%9C% ,&. 1$.$& %9> Z> M(22%H.-#9> W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 W(&7+%.>
pp `)X?XHa [& I"$b#$ $# 4$ 5"&.$ $.-#&> G G"'(#(> P-.(&4 ^-22(6-.9>
pp `)XXIa A@$&$& ,&. A/')*2#$& %9> Z> M(22%H.-#9> W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 W(&7+%.>
pp `)XXJa L$ I#"4$M5$M$& $# .N9,#)$% #$H#$% $.-#&> M> W%191B (#$."9> !> ,7+6(%2%> P-.(&4
^-22(6-.9>
Z"##-0%eB K> -#9 *".$B P> `)XX<a LN'"55$R /$# *&/"&&,S0 74$H*% (9))$4R 8$9&J39)*$ L$ E$& $#
4$% /'95+)$% .$ ?9@B P-.(&4 U9($("#& ,122%3&%>
!-..%2B Q> `)X@Ia 5*+% G%2-$("# "0 !%22& $" L#% Q#"$+%.; (# >,59& <*"4"?C 9&. 19/*94
P$429)$ %9> U !"89.1B =%8 o".T4 P-F2 Z M"%H%.>
!-..%2B Q> `)X@Ja LN'"55$R /$# *&/"&&, Q2%#7v"#4 P2"#>
!+.(&$%#B o> %9> `)X?Na 74$H*% (9))$40 LN",F$)#,)$ .$ 4N'"55$ P-.(&4 U9($("#& 9F W%e2(#>
[-8T(#&B G> `)XX)a D'$ <4*&. P9#/'59;$) M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B*9&$ 3")?9& )NJ
[%2%FA%B ^> `)XXNa (*&$M59 -0 LN*59?$J5",F$5$&# P-.(&4 K%& %e9($("#& 9% E(#F($>
[%2%FA%B ^> -#9 ^F-$$-.(B W> `)X?Ia 3*44$% E49#$9,H P-.(&4 K%& %e9($("#& 9% E(#F($>
[%2%FA%B ^> -#9 P-.#"$B !> `)XXNa B*94"?,$% P-.(&4 W2-66-.("#>
[(9%."$B [> `)XNNa BN74$5+$)# B)$95B $.-#&> K> *-#7"7T> M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#>
^"%$+%B k>O> '"#> `)XXJa A/*$&#*2*/ A#,.*$%B %9> -#9 $.-#&> [> E(22%.> =%8 k%.&%14 P.(#7%S
$"# \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
^"F29B ,>k> `)XX)a P"&.$)2,4 L*2$ M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#>
^"F29B ,>k> `)XXNa L*2$N% O)9&.$,) K"#9"#4 f(#$-/%>
^"F29B ,>k> -#9 U29.%9/%B => `)XX@a 5PF#7$F-$%9 U_F(2(H.(F6 7"6%& "0 Q/%; (# !9#,)$
f"2 @NN4 <<@hC>
^."&&%.B k>W>^> %9> `)XN@a B*$ ?)"n$ G"&#)"F$)%$0 $*& <)*$2=$/'%$4 ,5 B$,#%/'49&. M-6S
HF./] ^%#0] P-.(&4 =-/%2 f%.2-/>
M%(9%//%.B E> `)XC?a 5qF. ,%(#&0.-/%; (# P$?59);$& W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 b2"&$%.6-##>
M"9/%B k> `)XXJa >$*.$??$) 9&. 6#'*/% K"#9"# -#9 =o4 G"F$2%9/%>
M"+%#9-+2B P>\> `)X?Xa 5*+% K"&& "0 G%-2($14 ^"$$0.(%9 Z%##;& U-.21 P."&%; (# 3".$)&*#C
9&. #'$ D$H#B %9> MF1&&%# -#9 Z-$+.(7TB !"2F6H(-4 !"2F6H(- \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
U +$) .*$ L*&*$ W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 b2"&$%.6-##>
g#/%.B U> `)XJ< [
kF
K"#/B G>S!> O> %9> `)XXJa O$)59& 6HI)$%%*"&*%5 Z%.T%2%14 \#('%.&($1 "0 !-2(0".#(- P.%&&>
E-##B b2> `)XN?a E),U2,&?$&0 A/')*2#$& @,) L*#$)9#,)B %9> E> ^.%/".S[%22(#B EF#(7+4
=163+%#HF./%. f%.2-/&+-#92F#/>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)X@@hD<a 5qF. *%2%"2"/(%; (# >*%#")*%/'JG)*#*/%'$ O$%95#9,%?9+$ f"2 @
EF#(7+>
pp `)XNXa D',% %I9;$ T9)9#',%#)9B $.-#&> G> M"22(#/9-2%B M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#>
pp `)XX<a B$) P*44$ @,) 39/'# W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4 Y#&%2 f%.2-/>
pp `)XX@a >,59& 944 #"" >,59& $.-#&> G> M"22(#/9-2%B !-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#(S
'%.&($1 P.%&&>
P-26(%.B k>SE> `)X?@a LN$HI)$%%*"&*%5$ /"55$ )$MF"4#$ P-.(&4 P-1"$>
pp `)X??-a LN$HI)$%%*"&*%5$ $# 4$% 9)#% f"2 YB P-.(&4 P-1"$>
pp `)X??Ha LN$HI)$%%*"&*%5$ $# 4$% 9)#% f"2 YYB P-.(&4 P-1"$>
pp `)XXIa 1$#",) 9b <$)4*&B P-.(&4 P-1"$>
g .(7+4
G--H%B P> %9> `)X?Ca 6HI)$%%*"&*%5,%0 B$) G95I2 ,5 $*&$ 4*#$)9)*%/'$ <$=$?,&? qF
Q.7+%>
,3%#/2%.B L> `)XX)a B$) [&#$)?9&? .$% 7+$&.49&.$% EF#(7+4 9>$>'>
,$.-F&&B O>Q> `)XX<a 5^"$$0.(%9 Z%##4 - ["FH2% K(0% (# \#(#+-H($-H2% G%/("#&; (#
:9%/*%5R 7$%#'$#*/% 9&. (,4#,)$ %9> G> ^"2&-#B M-63&+(.%4 \#('%.&($1 P.%&& "0 =%8
U#/2-#9>
*+%8%2%($B b> `)XX)a <,/' .$) G"U&*?$0 Q)I'$,% ,&. 6,)C.*;$ f"2> YB Z-&%2] W.-#T0F.$ -6
E-(#B ,$."%60%29]G"$%. ,$%.#>
pp `)XXN-a <,/' .$) G"U&*?$0 Q)I'$,% 95 39/'#I"4 f"2> <VB Z-&%2] W.-#T0F.$ -6 E-(#4
,$."%60%29]G"$%. W%29>
pp `)XXNHa <,/' .$) G"U&*?$ 1$/").*&? 7&?$4N% 3C%#$)*$% f"2> <1B Z-&%2]W.-#T0F.$ -6
E-(#B ,$."%60%29]G"$%. W%29>
*".$B P> `)XXCa B9)=*& $# 4$ .9)=*&*%5$ P-.(&4 P.%&&%& \#('%.&($-(.%& 9% W.-#7%>
*F./%#%'B Y> `)XX)a :9#'$)% 9&. A"&% $.-#&> G> W.%%H".#B LV0".94 LV0".9 \#('%.&($1
P.%&&>
g 22B k '"#> `)XX<a 5*+% O".29 "0 Q#(6-2& -#9 E%#;B $.-#&> !> ,7+(22%. (# A$5*"#*/9
\%VTF
f"2> ?XhD>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)NN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
?
8"'& E)"#$F*
E,%)$2<1%#$,P 9$,-%)<1%#,: %+( 9$,1(F% $D >/-1#-% C#+#"#-=
O%.% $+% =-A(& #(+(2(&$&i [(9 $+%1 9%'-2F% $+(& 8".29 (# 0-'"F. "0 - +(/+%.
8".29i M-9 $+%1 2"&$ $+%(. H%2(%0 (# - +(/+%. 8".29i [(9 $+%1 3.%0%. $" 0-9%
-8-1 (# 3-&&('($1 .-$+%. $+-# 2('%i
Y# "#% &%#&%B $+% -#&8%. $" $+% 0(.&$ _F%&$("# 7-# "#21 H% -00(.6-$('%4 1%&B
$+% =-A(& 8%.% (#9%%9 #(+(2(&$&B 0". $+%1 3."9F7%9 9%-$+ -#9 9%&$.F7$("# -&
$+% 3"&($('% /"-2 "0 $+%(. &"7(-2 6-7+(#%> M"8%'%.B $+%1 9" #"$ &%%6 $" +-'%
H%%# $+% &".$ "0 #(+(2(&$& =(%$A&7+% 9(-/#"&%9 F&(#/ $+% 2-&$ $+.%% _F%&$("#&>
Y# &" 0-. -& "#% "0 $+% 72%-.%&$ %V3"&($("#& "0 =(%$A&7+%;& -#-21&(& "0 #(+(2(&6
(& $" H% 0"F#9 (# ^(22%& [%2%FA%;& !*$#@%/'$ 9&. E'*4"%"I'C `+%#7%0".$+ -HH.%S
'(-$%9 $" !EaB ($ (& $+F& &"6%8+-$ &F.3.(&(#/ $+-$ $+% "#21 "77F..%#7% "0 $+%
$%.6 5#(+(2(&6; (# [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.(;& (9I*#94*%5 9&. A/'*@"I')$&*9 (& (# 9(&7F&&("# "0 =-A(&6B -$ $+% 7"#72F&("# "0 $+% )X@@ 32-$%-F `5E(7."3"2($(7&
-#9 ,%/6%#$-.($1;a "0 7 D'",%9&. E49#$9,%4 5*+%.% (& (# 0-&7(&6 - .%-2(A%9
#(+(2(&6; `[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.( )X?CB <@I +%#7%0".$+ -HH.%'(-$%9 $" 7DEa>
O+-$ RF&$(0(%& $+(& &$.-#/% F&-/% "0 5#(+(2(&6; H1 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( $"
7+-.-7$%.(&% 0-&7(&6i Y& ($ RF&$ - .+%$".(7-2 02"F.(&+B - 6".-2(&(#/ 9%3.%7-$("#i
["%& 7-22(#/ ($ - #(+(2(&6 -99 $" $+% F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 +(&$".(7-2 0-&7(&6B -#9
$" $+% &$.F//2% -/-(#&$ #%8 0-&7(&6`&ai *" -#&8%. $+%&% _F%&$("#& h $" %'-2FS
-$% ($& F&%0F2#%&& (# $+(& 2-&$B 6"&$ (63".$-#$ -.%- h $+(& 7+-3$%. 0"22"8& $+%
.+(A"6% (# 7DE "0 0-&7(&6 -#9 #(+(2(&6> Y# T%%3(#/ 8($+ [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(;&
7+-.-7$%.(&-$("# "0 $+%(. 8".TB 2%$ F& 3F$ ($ (# 3.-7$(7-2 $%.6&4 +"8 &+"F29
"#% 7"#&$.F7$ $+% 7"#7%3$ "0 0-&7(&$ #(+(2(&6 (# 7DEi Y 3."3"&% 0"F. &$%3&B $+%
2-&$ $8" "0 8+(7+ 8(22 H% 9%-2$ 8($+ (# $+% H"91 "0 $+% 7+-3$%.>
W(.&$B 9(&$(#/F(&+ ($ 0."6 $+% $.%-$6%#$ "0 0-&7(&6 (# 7&#*JQ$.*I,% `[%2%FA%
-#9 ^F-$$-.( )X?@B +%#7%0".$+ -HH.%'(-$%9 $" 7Qa>) P%.+-3& 8% "8% $+%
(63.%&&("# $+-$ 7Q (& -H"F$ 0-&7(&6 $" W"F7-F2$;& 3.%0-7% $" $+% U#/2(&+
$.-#&2-$("#B (# 8+(7+ +% 7-22& 7Q 5Q# Y#$."9F7$("# $" $+% ="#SW-&7(&$ K(0%;
`V(((a> ZF$ (# 0-7$ +(&$".(7-2 0-&7(&6 h -& W"F7-F2$ -7T#"82%9/%& h (& %V32(7($21
-99.%&&%9 (# 7Q .%2-$('%21 (#0.%_F%#$214 - 0%8 7"66%#$& "# M($2%. /%$$(#/
)NC
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Q P."H2%6 "0 PF.% E-$$%.4 W-&7(&$
=(+(2(&6 (# 7 D'",%9&. E49#$9,%
$+% 6-&&%& &%VF-221 -."F&%9B - #"$% $+-$ $+% 0-&7(&$ &$-$% (& $+% 6"&$ 0-#$-&$(7
.%S$%..($".(-2(&-$("# "0 7-3($-2(&6> Y# "$+%. 8".9&B (# 7QB 0-&7(&6 (& 2-./%21
-99.%&&%9 "#21 -.7+($%7$"#(7-221B -& - 3"2% "0 9%&(.%B -# -#&8%. $" $+% 3FAS
A2(#/ _F%&$("#B +"8 9"%& 9%&(.% 7"6% $" 9%&(.% ($& "8# .%3.%&&("#i Q.7+($%7S
$"#(7-221B 0-&7(&6 (& "# $+% &(9% "0 3-.-#"(- -#9 .%$%..($".(-2(&-$("#B $+%
7"F#$%. 3"2% $" &7+(A"3+.%#(- -#9 9%$%..($".(-2(&-$("#> Y# 7QB $+%#B 0-&7(&6
(& 3-.-#"(-B 0.%%A(#/B $+% H"91 8($+"F$ "./-#& -& 7-$-$"#(-> Y# 7DEB +"8%'%.B
0-&7(&6 (& 9(&$(#/F(&+%9 0."6 $"$-2($-.(-#(&6B 8+(7+ (& 5_F(#$%&&%#$(-221 7"#S
&%.'-$('%; `<@Ia> Y# 7DER 0-&7(&6 (& $"" 0-&$ .-$+%. $+-# $"" &2"84 ($ (& 7-#7%.B .F#-8-1 8-. 6-7+(#%> G%7"/#(&(#/ $+%&% 9-#/%.& H.(#/& "F$ $+% 57-F$("#; "0
7DE> Y# 7Q $+% $-&T "0 &7+(A"-#-21&(& (&4 59%&$."1B 9%&$."1; `@))a> Y# 7DE 8%
.%-94 5,$-1(#/ &$.-$(0(%9 h "./-#(&%9B &(/#(0(%9B &FHR%7$%9 h (& #"$ $+% 8".&$
$+-$ 7-# +-33%#; `)N)a><
,%7"#9B 9(&$(#/F(&+ #(+(2(&6 (# 7DE -#9 !E> =(+(2(&6 (& 9(&7F&&%9 %V$%#S
&('%21 (# $+% 0(#-2 &%7$("# "0 $+% =(%$A&7+% H""TB 5Q/-(#&$ $+% [(-2%7$(7;B HF$
$+%.% $+% 7"#$%V$ (& 8(22B '-2F%&B 2(0%> *+% T%1 (& 6-# -#9 $+% _F%&$("# "0
6-#B 8+(2% #(+(2(&6 (& $+% 6"$". "0 UF."3%-# +(&$".1> ="#% "0 $+%&% 7"#S
7%.#& `8($+ $+% 3"&&(H2% %V7%3$("# "0 52(0%;@a 7-..1 "'%. $" 7DER 8+"&% &2"/-#
(& 5/%"/.-3+1B #"$ +(&$".1;4 9.-8(#/ - 6-3 "0 2(#%&B #"$ $.-7(#/ - 9%72(#% ".
7"#'%.&("#> *+(& (& #"$ $" &-1B +"8%'%.B $+-$ $+% 5&-6%; #(+(2(&6 9(-/#"&%9
H1 =(%$A&7+% h 2%$;& 7-22 ($ 52F#-.; #(+(2(&6B $+% /('(#/ "'%. "0 2(0% $" .%&(/#%9B .%02%7$('% 0.%%A(#/ h (& #"$ -2&" 9(-/#"&%9 (# - 9(00%.%#$ 0.-6%8".T
H1 7DER -& $+% 5%63$1 H"91 8($+"F$ "./-#&;>
*+(.9B 0"22"8 $+% .+(A"6% #(+(2(&6h0-&7(&6 (# 7DE $+."F/+ ($& $8" 6-(#
#"9%&4 `)a -& 7-#7%."F& Z8L "0 $+% &$.-$- `32-$%-F N4 5M"8 [" o"F E-T%
o"F.&%20 - Z"91 O($+"F$ L./-#&;am `<a -& 9-#/%. "0 $+% 2(#% "0 02(/+$ `32-$%-F
X4 5E(7."3"2($(7& -#9 ,%/6%#$-.($1;am -#9 $+% -33."3.(-$% &FHS#"9%&4 `@a $+%
$+%".1 "0 &%9(6%#$-$("# `32-$%-F @4 5*+% ^%"2"/1 "0 E".-2&4 O+" ["%& $+%
U-.$+ *+(#T Y$ Y&i;am -#9 `Da $+% .%2-$("#& "0 8-.S6-7+(#% -#9 ,$-$% `32-$%-F&
)<4 5*.%-$(&% "# ="6-9"2"/1 h *+% O-. E-7+(#%; -#9 )@4 5Q33-.-$F& "0
!-3$F.%;a>
W"F.$+B 6-T% &F.% 0-&7(&$ #(+(2(&6 (& 9(&7F&&%9 -& - 3."H2%6 "0 53F.%
6-$$%.; `)NJa .-$+%. $+-# 7F2$F.-2 +(&$".1 ". 3&17+"2"/1> Q& 8% +-'% (#&(&$%9B
$+% $%.6 5#(+(2(&6; 7-##"$ +-'% ($& =(%$A&7+%-# 7"#$%V$ "0 6-#B 8(22B -#9
'-2F%&B #". 7-# 0-&7(&6 H% 9(&7F&&%9 -& -# (9%"2"/1 `5- 6"&$ %V%7.-H2% 7"#S
7%3$; rN?sa> *+% T%1 (# /('(#/ - 3"&($('% -77"F#$ "0 0-&7(&$ #(+(2(&6 .-$+%.
$+-# .%&$(#/ 7"#$%#$ 8($+ &F7+ #%/-$('% 9(&$(#7$("#& 2(%& (# $+% -.$(7F2-$("#
"0 $+% 8".T "0 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 8($+ &"S7-22%9 7"632%V($1 $+%".1B -& (# $+%
8".T "0 E-#F%2 [%K-#9- `)XX)m )XX<m )XXCa -#9 Z.(-# E-&&F6( `)XX<a> L#
$+%(. .%-9(#/&B 7DE 3."'(9%& 6-$%.(-2(&$ 9(-/.-6& 0". $+% 7"#&$.F7$("# -#9
%'-2F-$("# "0 H"9(%& '(- 6-$$%.#h%#%./1 02"8 `$+% H"91 8($+"F$ "./-#&a -#9
&%20S"./-#(&(#/ 3."7%&&%& `-H&$.-7$ 6-7+(#%&a> W-&7(&6 $+F& 7-##"$ H% - 53&1S
7+"2"/(7-2 7-$%/".1; `M"22-#9 )X?CB <Na #". 9"%& 7DE 7"#$-(# - 56%$-3+1&(7&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)N? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
8"'& E)"#$F* )NX
Q+( >/-1#-% 34R
Q 9(00(7F2$ _F%&$("#4 5M"8 [" o"F E-T% o"F.&%20 - Z"91 8($+"F$ L./-#&i;
W(.&$B 1"F 6F&$ .%7"/#(&% $+% 3.-7$(7-2 #-$F.% "0 $+% _F%&$("#4 $+% Z8L (& -#
"HR%7$ "0 3.-7$(7%m ($ (& 3."9F7%9B &$-.$(#/ 0."6 $+% "./-#(&6> ,%7"#9B 1"F
6F&$ #"$(7% $+-$ $+% _F%&$("# (& H-921 3+.-&%9B - +"29"'%. "0 7Q $%.6(#"S
2"/1 $+-$ 8(22 H% 7"..%7$%9 (# 7DE4 ($ &+"F29 .%-9B 5M"8 [" o"F E-T% o"F.&%20
- Z"91 *+-$ Y& ="$ -# L./-#(&6i;
K%$ F& H%/(# H1 9(&$(#/F(&+(#/ H"91B "./-#&B "./-#(&6B 9 Z8L -#9 #'$
Z8L>
) Q H"91 (& -#1 %7"#"6(7 &1&$%6 7"#&(9%.%9 -& - 6%7+-#(&6 "0 -33."S
3.(-$("# -#9 .%/F2-$("#B - .%/("# "0 6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8 $+-$ +-& - .%2-$('%
7"#&(&$%#71 %'%# -& ($ (& 32F//%9 (#$" - #%$8".T "0 "$+%. 02"8&B &2"8(#/
&"6% 9"8#B &3%%9(#/ "$+%.& F3> Q H"91 (& - 02"8 .%/F2-$".> Y# !ER [%2%FA%
F&%9 $+% =(%$A&7+%-# 2-#/F-/% "0 59"6(#-#$ -#9 9"6(#-$%9 0".7%&;B $"
%V32-(# $+-$ 5r%s'%.1 .%2-$("#&+(3 "0 0".7%& 7"#&$($F$%& - H"91 h 8+%$+%. ($
(& 7+%6(7-2B H("2"/(7-2B &"7(-2B ". 3"2($(7-2; `[%2%FA% )X?@B DIa> Y# 7DEB
[%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 6-(#$-(# $+% 8(9% .-#/% "0 -332(7-$("# "0 $+% $%.6
5H"91;B HF$ -99 $+% 8".9 5&$.-$F6; $" 9%&(/#-$% -# %7"#"6(7 %V7+-#/%
H%$8%%# &(6(2-.21 7"#&$($F$%9 H"9(%& 8($+ .%/-.9 $" -9R-7%#$ 2%'%2& "0
9"6(#-$%9 ". 9"6(#-$(#/ H"9(%&> 7DE -2&" (#$."9F7%& $+% 2-#/F-/% "0
57"#$%#$; `$+% 3."9F7$("# "0 0".6%9 6-$$%.&a -#9 5%V3.%&&("#; `$+% 3."S
9F7$("# "0 0F#7$("#-2 &$.F7$F.%&a $" %V32-(# H"91 7"#&$($F$("# -#9]".
&$.-$(0(7-$("# `D@a>
< L./-#& -.% 6-7+(#%&B $+-$ (&B 02"8]H.%-T 7"F32(#/& (# 8+(7+ - 6-$$%.S
%#%./1 02"8 (& (#$%..F3$%9 -#9 3-.$ &(3+"#%9 "00 $" 02"8 (# $+% %7"#"61
"0 $+% H"91> L./-#& -.% - H"91;& 8-1 "0 #%/"$(-$(#/ 8($+ $+% "F$&(9%B
-33."3.(-$(#/ -#9 .%/F2-$(#/ - H($ "0 6-$$%.S%#%./1 02"8> Y# 3&17+"-#-21S
$(7 $%.6&B "./-#& -.% 53-.$(-2 "HR%7$&; #"$ `1%$a 7"##%7$%9 $" - 3%.&"#B 6%.%
3"(#$& "0 (#$%#&($1 "0 6-$$%.S%#%./1B - 32-7% "0 -7$('($1 2%&& (#$%#&% $+-# $+%
&F.."F#9(#/ "F$&(9% HF$ 6".% (#$%#&% $+-# $+% H"91;& "$+%. "./-#& `8($+
.%/-.9 $" ($& 3-.$(7F2-. 02"8B $+-$ (&a> Y# 7QB [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 7-22 "./-#&
59%&(.(#/ 6-7+(#%&;m (# 7DER $+%1 -.% 7-22%9 56-7+(#(7 -&&%6H2-/%&;>
@ Q# "./-#(&6 (& - 3-.$(7F2-. "./-#(&-$("# "0 "./-#&B "#% $+-$ (& 7%#$.-2(&%9
-#9 +(%.-.7+(7-2B -33."3.(-$(#/ $+% 6-$$%.h%#%./1 "0 $+% "./-#& -#9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
"0 9(00%.%#7%; `E-1 )XXCB )CJa ". "0 50".7%&; `E-1 )XXDB N?a h (0 -#1$+(#/B ($ (&
- 3+1&(7&>
O($+ $+%&% 3.%&7.(3$("#& (# 6(#9B $+% 3-3%. 8(22 0"22"8 $+% 0"22"8(#/
7"F.&%4 0(.&$B - 9(&7F&&("# "0 $+% 0-&7(&$ H"91 8($+"F$ "./-#&m &%7"#9B $+%
9-#/%. "0 $+% 0-&7(&$ 2(#% "0 02(/+$m $+(.9B - 9(&7F&&("# "0 $+% 7"632%V($1
$+%".1 H-7T/."F#9 $" $+% 6-$%.(-2(&6 "0 7DEm 0"F.$+B - 7"#72F9(#/ &%7$("#
7"#&(9%.(#/ 7DEN& 7"#$.(HF$("# $" -# F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 0-&7(&$ 5#(+(2(&6 #"8;>
0F##%22(#/ - &F.32F& 3".$("# "0 $+%6 $" $+% H%#%0($ "0 - $.-#&7%#9%#7%B &F3%.(". H"91 ". &$.-$F6 $+-$ +-& -33."3.(-$%9 $+% "./-#(&6 -& - &FHS
&$.-$F6B -& 2-H".B -& 7"#$%#$ 0". ($& %V3.%&&("#> *+% "./-#(&6 (& - &$.-$F6
"# $+% Z8LB 5- 3+%#"6%#"# "0 -77F6F2-$("#B 7"-/F2-$("#B -#9 &%9(6%#S
$-$("# $+-$B (# ".9%. $" %V$.-7$ F&%0F2 2-H". 0."6 $+% Z8LB (63"&%& F3"# ($
0".6&B 0F#7$("#&B H"#9&B 9"6(#-#$ -#9 +(%.-.7+(A%9 "./-#(A-$("#&B "./-S
#(A%9 $.-#&7%#9%#7%&; `)JXa> Q# "./-#(&6 (& - 7-3$F.% -#9 &(3+"#
6-7+(#%B - 3-.$(7F2-. 8-1 "0 .%/F2-$(#/ 02"8&4 5$+-$ 8+(7+ 2(0% &%$& -/-(#&$
($&%20 (# ".9%. $" 2(6($ ($&%20; `JI@a>
D 7 Z8L (& - 9%&$.-$(0(%9 H"91> Y$ (& -# "HR%7$ "0 7"#&$.F7$("#B - 3.-7$(7%m ($ (&
58+-$ .%6-(#& -0$%. 1"F $-T% %'%.1$+(#/ -8-1; `)J)a> Y$ (& #"$ .%-7+%9 H1
.%/.%&&("#B 0". - Z8L (& #"$ $+% (#0-#$(2% H"91 "0 "F. 3-&$B HF$ $+% '(.$F-2
.%-26 "0 3"$%#$(-2& 0". 9(00%.%#$ H"91 "./-#(&-$("# 3.%72F9%9 H1 7F..%#$
"./-#(&6(7 "./-#(&-$("#> *+F& ($ (& .%-7+%9 H1 - &1&$%6-$(7 3.-7$(7% "0
9(&$F.H(#/ $+% 7F..%#$ "./-#(&6(7 "./-#(&-$("#4 5$+% Z8L (& #"$ -$ -22 $+%
"33"&($% "0 $+% "./-#&> *+% "./-#& -.% #"$ ($& %#%6(%&> *+% %#%61 (& $+%
"./-#(&6; `)J?a> Z1 9(&$F.H(#/ $+% "./-#(&6B $+% 2%'%2 "0 3F.%21 9(&S
$.(HF$%9B .-$+%. $+-# 7%#$.-2(&%9B "./-#& 7-# H% .%-7+%9B &($$(#/ F3"#
$+% 6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8 ($&%20> Y# "$+%. 8".9&B - Z8L (& 3F.%21 (66-#S
%#$21 -..-#/%9 3."9F7$("#m 6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8(#/ 8($+"F$ .%/-.9 $"
%V$%.#-221S(63"&%9 2"/* $+-$ 9.-(# "00 &F.32F&%& $" - 3"(#$ "F$&(9% $+%
H"91> Q& -# "HR%7$ "0 3.-7$(7% .%-7+%9 &$-.$(#/ 0."6 $+% "./-#(&6B Z8L
(& $8"S&(9%94 5($ &8(#/& H%$8%%# $8" 3"2%&B $+% &F.0-7%& "0 &$.-$(0(7-$("#
(#$" 8+(7+ ($ (& .%7"(2%9B "# 8+(7+ ($ &FH6($& $" $+% RF9/6%#$B -#9 $+%
32-#% "0 7"#&(&$%#71 (# 8+(7+ ($ F#0F.2& -#9 "3%#& $" %V3%.(6%#$-$("#;
`)JXa> *+(& $8"S&(9%9#%&& (& #"$ 3%-7%0F2m .-$+%. 8% 0(#9 5- 3%.3%$F-2 -#9
'("2%#$ 7"6H-$ H%$8%%# $+% 32-#% "0 7"#&(&$%#71B 8+(7+ 0.%%& $+% Z8LB
7F$$(#/ -7."&& -#9 9(&6-#$2(#/ -22 $+% &$.-$-B -#9 $+% &F.0-7%& "0 &$.-$(0(7-S
$("# $+-$ H2"7T ($ ". 6-T% ($ .%7"(2; `)JXa>
J D'$ Z8L (& $+% 532-#% "0 7"#&(&$%#71;B $+% %7"#"61 "0 %7"#"6(%&B $+%
6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8 "0 $+% $%..%&$(-2]7"&6(7 &1&$%64 ($ (& 5$+% U-.$+;> *+F&
$+% Z8L (& 5$+-$ /2-7(-2 .%-2($1 8+%.% $+% -22F'("#&B &%9(6%#$-$("#&B 7"S
-/F2-$("#&B 0"29(#/& -#9 .%7"(2(#/& $+-$ 7"63"&% -# "./-#(&6 h -#9 -2&" &(/#(0(7-$("# -#9 - &FHR%7$ h "77F.; `)JXa>
*+% .%2-$("# "0 9 Z8L -#9 #'$ Z8L (& %V32".%9 (# 7DE (# - ,3(#"A(&$
6-##%.4 5Q0$%. -22B (& #"$ ,3(#"A-;& 6#'*/% $+% /.%-$ H""T "0 $+% Z8Li;
`)J@a> *+% 7.F7(-2 3."H2%6 "0 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(;& 7".3".%-2 3"2($(7& (& 9(&$(#S
/F(&+(#/ ". &%2%7$(#/ H%$8%%# $13%& "0 Z8LB 8+(7+B -& 8% 8(22 &%%B -.% #"$ -22
3"&($('% ". 3."/.%&&('% -7+(%'%6%#$&> *+% 532-#% "0 7"#&(&$%#71; (& [%2%FA%h
^F-$$-.(;& $%.6 0". -# (66-#%#$ &"7(-2 -..-#/%6%#$ "0 Z8L&B HF$ #"$ -22
Z8L& _F-2(01 0". (#72F&("#m $+% 32-#% "0 7"#&(&$%#71 6F&$ H% 7"#&$.F7$%9 -& &%2%7$("# H%$8%%# $13%& "0 Z8L&m (# 3-.$(7F2-.B $+% 0-&7(&$ Z8L 6F&$ H%
9%&%2%7$%9>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)CI !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
=%/-$('%21 3F$ $+%#B - Z8L (& 5$+% 2(6($ "0 - /('%# 3."7%&& "0 9%&$.-$(0(7-S
$("#; `[%K-#9- )XXCB <N)aB $+% 3"(#$ -$ 8+(7+ - 3-.$(7F2-. "./-#(&-$("# "0
"./-#& 7-22%9 -# "./-#(&6 #" 2"#/%. +"29& -#9 6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8& -.%
-..-#/%9 (66-#%#$21 8($+"F$ .%0%.%#7% $" - $.-#&7%#9%#7% 3."0($(#/ 0."6
$+% &(3+"#(#/ -7$("# "0 $+% "./-#(&6> P"&($('%21B - Z8L (& $+% 6-$$%.h%#%./1
02"8 ($&%20 &FH$%#9(#/ - H"91B -#9 -2&" ($& 53+-&% &3-7%;B ($& '(.$F-2 0(%29B $+%
3""2 "0 3"$%#$(-2& 0". "./-#(A-$("# "0 $+-$ H"914 "./-#(&6(7 "./-#(&-$("#B
-#9 "$+%. $13%& "0 "./-#(&-$("#& -& 8%22 `E-&&F6( )XX<B CIa> *+% 2-$$%. &%#&%
"0 $+% Z8L -& '(.$F-2($1 (& 8+1 $+% Z8L (& #"$ .%/.%&&('%B HF$ (& $+%.% H%&(9%&
$+% "./-#(&6B 8-($(#/ $" H% .%-7+%9>
="8 8% 6F&$ 9(&$(#/F(&+ $+.%% $13%& "0 Z8L4 0F22B %63$1B 7-#7%."F&> L#21
$+% 0F22 H"91 (& 3."9F7$('%> *" -'"(9 $+% "$+%.&B 7-F$("# (& #%7%&&-.1B 0". $+%
7"#&$.F7$("# "0 - Z8L (& 9-#/%."F&> *+% &$.-$- 6F&$ H% 3-.$(-221 6-(#$-(#%94
$+% H"91 $+-$ (& #"$ -# "./-#(&6 6F&$ &$(22 H% - H"91B 6F&$ &$(22 +-'% .%2-$('% 7"#&(&$%#71B - 9(00%.%#7% (# (#$%#&($1 "0 6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8 0."6 $+%
&F.."F#9(#/&> L$+%.8(&%B 8% 8"F29 +-'% 3F.% 9%-$+B %#$."31B #" %#%./1
9(00%.%#7%&>
*+% $+.%% $13%& "0 Z8L& -.% -& 0"22"8&4
) Q 0F22 Z8L (& .%-7+%9 H1 7-.%0F2 %V3%.(6%#$-2 9%&$.-$(0(7-$("#B 8+(7+
7-F&%& 8-'%& "0 (#$%#&% 6-$$%.S%#%./1 $" 02"8 (# (66-#%#7%> O+%#
2(#T%9 8($+ "$+%. &%2%7$%9 0F22 Z8L&B $+% 32-#% "0 7"#&(&$%#71 (& 7"#S
&$.F7$%9B $+-$ (&B - 7"22%7$('($1 "0 0.%%21 &%20S"./-#(&(#/ H"9(%&B 7"#$(#F-221
3."9F7(#/ $+%(. "8# 7"##%7$("#&> *+(& 0F22 Z8L (& $+% Z8L -& 5%//; `)NDa
". -& 0(%29 "0 59%&(.%; `)NJa> Y# - 0F22 Z8L "#% 0(#9& 5- 9(&$.(HF$("# "0
(#$%#&('% 3.(#7(32%& "0 "./-#&B 8($+ $+%(. 3"&($('% (#9%0(#($% -.$(72%&B
8($+(# - 7"22%7$('($1 ". 6F2$(32(7($1B (#&(9% -# -&&%6H2-/%B -#9 -77".9(#/
$" 6-7+(#(7 7"##%7$("#& "3%.-$(#/ "# - Z8L; `)NJa> Q& 8% 7-# &%% 0."6
[%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(;& (#&(&$%#7% "# 7"22%7$('($1B 6F2$(32(7($1B -#9 -&&%6S
H2-/%B $+% 0F22 Z8L (& #%'%. - &"2($-.1 -7+(%'%6%#$ HF$ -28-1& - 7"66FS
#-2 3."R%7$B - 3"2($(7-2 %'%#$> *" &%2%7$ "#21 0F22 Z8L& 0". $+% 32-#% "0
7"#&(&$%#71 (& 5$+% $%&$ "0 9%&(.%; `)NJa>
< Q# %63$1 Z8L (& .%-7+%9 H1 $"" &F99%# 9%&$.-$(0(7-$("#B 8+(7+ %63$(%&
H"9(%& "0 ($& "./-#&> UV-632%& (#72F9% $+% +13"7+"#9.(-7 H"91B $+%
3-.-#"(9 H"91B $+% &7+(A"S7-$-$"#(7 H"91B $+% 9.F//%9 H"91B $+% 6-&"S
7+(&$ H"914 5- 9.%-.1 3-.-9% "0 &F7T%9S9.1B 7-$-$"#(A%9B '($.(0(%9B &%8#SF3
H"9(%&> > > > U63$(%9 H"9(%& (#&$%-9 "0 0F22 "#%&; `)JIa> *+%&% H"9(%& 9" #"$
7"##%7$ 8($+ "$+%.&B 0". $+%1 +-'% #" %#%./1 02"8(#/m #" 32-#% "0 7"#S
&(&$%#71 (& 3"&&(H2% H%$8%%# $+%&% 6".$(0(%9 H"9(%&> Q& 3"(#$& "0 A%."
(#$%#&($1B $+%1 -.% (#&$-#7%& "0 2F#-. #(+(2(&6>
@ *+% 7-#7%."F& Z8L (& $+% &$.-#/%&$ -#9 6"&$ 9-#/%."F& Z8L> Y$ (& - Z8L
$+-$ H%2"#/& $" $+% "./-#(&6 $+-$ .%&(9%& "# - &$.-$F6B .-$+%. $+-# H%(#/
$+% 2(6($ "0 - &$.-$F6> Y$ (& .F#-8-1 &%20S9F32(7-$("# "0 &$.-$(0(7-$("#>
,F7+ - 7-#7%. 7-# "77F. %'%# (# &"7(-2 0".6-$("#&B #"$ RF&$ (# $+% &$.-$-
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"'& E)"#$F* )C)
#-6%9 "./-#(&6B &(/#(0(-#7%B &FHR%7$(0(7-$("# `)N@a> *+% T%1 $" $.-7T(#/
9"8# 0-&7(&6 2(%& +%.%B (# $+% 7-#7%."F& Z8LB 8+(7+ 0".6& F#9%. 7"#9(S
$("#& "0 .F#-8-1 &$.-$(0(7-$("#B ". 6".% 3.%7(&%21B .F#-8-1 &%9(6%#$-S
$("#B $+% 0(.&$ 53(#7%.; "0 - &$.-$F64 5-22 - &$.-$F6 #%%9& (& - +(/+
&%9(6%#$-$("# .-$% 0". ($ $" 2"&% ($& 7"#0(/F.-$("# -#9 -.$(7F2-$("#&B -#9
$" 0".6 ($& "8# &3%7(0(7 T(#9 "0 $F6".B 8($+(# ($&%20 ". (# - /('%# 0".6-S
$("# ". -33-.-$F&> *+% &$.-$- &3-8# $+%(. "8# Z8L&B $"$-2($-.(-# -#9
0-&7(&$ Z8L&B $%..(01(#/ 7-.(7-$F.%& "0 $+% 32-#% "0 7"#&(&$%#71; `)N@a>
*+% 7-#7%."F& Z8L H.%-T& 9"8# $+% &$.-$F6 "# 8+(7+ ($ 2"9/%& H1 %#9S
2%&&21 .%3%-$(#/ $+% &%2%7$("# "0 +"6"/%#(&%9 (#9('(9F-2& (# - .F#-8-1
3."7%&& "0 57"#0".6($1;> ,"7(-2 72"#(#/> Q&&%6H21S2(#% 3%.&"#-2($(%&>
*" 0"22"8 $+% .+(A"6% +%.%B 8% #%%9 $" %V$.-7$ - 0%8 &(632(0(%9 7"#7%3$&
0."6 $+% %V7%%9(#/21 7"632%V 5^%"2"/1 "0 E".-2&; 32-$%-FB 8+%.% P."0%&&".
!+-22%#/%. $%22& F& -H"F$ 9"FH2% -.$(7F2-$("#4 &%9(6%#$-$("#]0"29(#/ ". 7"#S
$%#$]%V3.%&&("#B %-7+ "0 8+(7+ +-& H"$+ &FH&$-#7% -#9 0".6> Q &FH&$-#7% (& 50".6%9 6-$$%.;B -#9 .%0%.& $" $%..($".(-2($(%& ". &3-$(-2 H(#9(#/&m - 0".6B "#
$+% "$+%. +-#9B (632(%& - 57"9%;B ". $%63".-2 ".9%.(#/> !"#$%#$ (& -2&"
50".6%9 6-$$%.;B 6-$$%. &%2%7$%9 `$%..($".(-2(&%9a -#9 0".6%9 `7"9%9aB 8+(2%
%V3.%&&("# (& - 50F#7$("#-2 &$.F7$F.%; $+-$ F$(2(&%& $+(& 7"#$%#$ $" 3."9F7% #%8 %#$($1 H1 -# 5"'%.7"9(#/;B .%&F2$(#/ (# 53+%#"6%#- "0 7%#$%.(#/B F#(S
0(7-$("#B $"$-2(A-$("#B (#$%/.-$("#B +(%.-.7+(A-$("#B -#9 0(#-2(A-$("#; `D)a>
!"#$%#$]%V3.%&&("# ". $%..($".(-2(&-$("#]7"9(#/]"'%.7"9(#/ (& $+% -H&$.-7$
6-7+(#% "0 &$.-$(0(7-$("#B "3%.-#$ (# -#1 .%/(&$%. 0."6 /%"2"/(7-2 $" &"7(-2 -&
$+% 8-1 $" -33."3.(-$% 6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8& 0."6 $+% U-.$+ -#9 HF(29 - 2-1%.
$+-$ .%/F2-$%& $+% 02"8> *+% 6-7+(#% +-& 0"F. 7"63"#%#$& (# $8" -.$(7F2-S
$("#&> *+% 0(.&$ -.$(7F2-$("# (& &%9(6%#$-$("#B 8+(7+ 9%$%.6(#%&4 `-a - &FHS
&$-#7% "0 7"#$%#$B $+-$ (&B $+% &%2%7$("# "0 +"6"/%#"F& 6-$%.(-2& 0."6 &FH".9(#-$% 02"8m -#9 `Ha - 0".6 "0 7"#$%#$B $+-$ (& $+% 9%3"&($("# "0 $+%&%
6-$%.(-2& (#$" 2-1%.&> *+% &%7"#9 -.$(7F2-$("# (& 50"29(#/;BD (# 8+(7+ $+%.% (&
`7a - 0".6 "0 %V3.%&&("#B $+-$ (&B $+% 7.%-$("# "0 #%8 2(#T-/%&m -#9 `9a - &FHS
&$-#7% "0 %V3.%&&("#B $+% 7.%-$("# "0 #%8 %#$($(%& 8($+ %6%./%#$ 3."3%.$(%&>
*+% 7-#7%."F& Z8L "77F.& 8($+ $"" 6F7+ &%9(6%#$-$("#B $+-$ (&B $""
6F7+ 7"#$%#$ ". 7"9(#/ -#9 $%..($".(-2(&(#/B 8($+ (#&F00(7(%#$ "'%.7"9(#/>
*+% .%&F2$ (& - 7-#7%. "0 $+% &$.-$F6B - 3."2(0%.-$("# "0 3"(#$& "0 7-3$F.%B 3."2(0%.-$("# "0 6(7."SH2-7T +"2%&> *+"F&-#9& "0 (#9('(9F-2&B 7"632%$% F#$"
$+%6&%2'%&> K%/(&2-$".& -#9 &FHR%7$& -22 (# "#%> kF9/%B RF.1B -#9 %V%7F$("#%. h
-#9 3"2(7%6-#B 3.('-$% %1%B +"6% '(9%" "3%.-$".B =%(/+H".+""9 O-$7+
"./-#(&%.> > > > O-$7+(#/ "'%. $+%6&%2'%& -& 6F7+ -& "'%. "$+%.& (# .F#-8-1
7"#&7(%#7%S0".6-$("#> [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 7-22 $+(& &($F-$("# 56(7."S0-&7(&6;>
*" 0"22"8 $+(& 3-$+B 6"'% $" P2-$%-F XB 5E(7."3"2($(7& -#9 ,%/6%#$-.($1;B
8+%.% 8% 8(22 -2&" %#7"F#$%. - 3+%#"6%#"# 8% #%/2%7$%9 (# "F. H.(%0
%V$.-7$ 0."6 $+% 5^%"2"/1 "0 E".-2&;B #-6%21B $+% 2(#% "0 02(/+$B ". $+%
9%$%..($".(-2(&(#/ -#9 9%7"9(#/ "0 02"8&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)C< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
8"'& E)"#$F* )C@
*+% 9-#/%. "0 0-&7(&6 (& $+-$ - 2(#% "0 02(/+$B $+% &"F.7% "0 7.%-$('($1 $+-$
6"'%& F& -8-1 0."6 $%..($".1 -#9 7"9% `0."6 +"6% -#9 +-H($aB -#9 0."6
.%&"#-#7% -#9 "'%.7"9(#/ `0."6 HF.%-F7.-71 -#9 ,$-$%aB 7-# H%7"6% - 53-&S
&("# 0". -H"2($("#;B 5&F(7(9% > > > 3.%&%#$%9 #"$ -& - 3F#(&+6%#$ HF$ -& $+%
7."8#(#/ /2".1 "0 $+% 9%-$+ "0 "$+%.&; `<@)a> [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( %V32".% $+(&
9-#/%. (# P2-$%-F XB 9-$%9 )X@@4 5E(7."3"2($(7& -#9 ,%/6%#$-.($1;>
*+% H-&(7 #"$("# H%/(##(#/ P2-$%-F X (& 5&%/6%#$-.($1;B $+% 9('(&(H(2($1 -#9
(#$%.#-2 H".9%.& (#+%.%#$ $" -22 &$.-$-> [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( (&"2-$% $+.%% $13%&4
H(#-.1B 7(.7F2-.B -#9 2(#%-.> ,%/6%#$-.($1 $%#9& $" H% &F332% h +%$%."/%#%"F&B
2"7-2B 02%V(H2% h (# 53.(6($('%; &"7(%$(%&B -#9 .(/(9 (# ,$-$% &"7(%$(%&> ="8 $+%&%
$13%& "0 &%/6%#$-.($1B 8+(7+ -.% -2&" ."F/+21 (#$%.7+-#/%-H2% 8($+ 6"2%7FS
2-. `&F332%a -#9 6"2-. `.(/(9aB -.%B 8+(2% .$ K,)$ &%3-.-H2%B .$ 29/#" (#$%.S
8"'%#>
*+% (632(7-$("#& "0 $+%&% 9(&$(#7$("#& -.% 9%'%2"3%9 2-$%. (# $+% 32-$%-F>
Q$ <)CB [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( F&% - #%8 $%.6 0". 6"2%7F2-. 7"63"&($("#B 5_F-#S
$F6 02"8;B 8+(7+ $+%1 9(&$(#/F(&+ 0."6 $+% 6"2-. &%/6%#$%9 2(#%> Z%$8%%#
$8" $+%1 2"7-$% - 53"8%. 7%#$%.;B 8+(7+ %00%7$& $.-#&2-$("#& H%$8%%# $+%
_F-#$F6 02"8 -#9 $+% &%/6%#$%9 2(#%> Q& -28-1& $+% 7"#7%3$F-2 9(&$(#7$("#
0(#9& - .%-2 (#$%.8%-'(#/B -& 02"8 -#9 _F-#$- 57-# H% /.-&3%9 "#21 H1 '(.$F%
"0 (#9%V%& "# &%/6%#$%9 2(#%B HF$ 7"#'%.&%21B $+-$ 2(#% -#9 $+"&% (#9%V%&
%V(&$ "#21 H1 '(.$F% "0 $+% 02"8 &F00F&(#/ $+%6; `<)?a> Q 0F.$+%. $8(&$ 7"6%&
8+%# [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 9(&7F&& 02"8 -#9 2(#% (# $%.6& "0 7"9(#/B 9%7"9(#/B
"'%.7"9(#/> *+% 6F$-#$ 02"8 (& $+% 3."7%&& "0 %&7-3(#/ - 7"9(#/ 3."7%&&B
8+(2% _F-#$- -.% 5&(/#& ". 9%/.%%& "0 9%$%..($".(-2(A-$("# (# 9%7"9%9 02"8;
`<)Xa> Y0 8% .%7-22 $+% -H&$.-7$ 6-7+(#% "0 &$.-$(0(7-$("# -$ $+(& 3"(#$B 6F$-#$ 02"8 (& - 02"8 $+-$ %&7-3%& $+% &".$(#/ `$%..($".(-2(&(#/ ". &FH&$-#7%
"0 7"#$%#$a -#9 2-1%.(#/ `7"9(#/ ". 0".6 "0 7"#$%#$a 3."7%&&%& "0 $+% 0(.&$
-.$(7F2-$("# `&%9(6%#$-$("# ". $+% 3."9F7$("# "0 - 0".6%9 6-$$%.>a *+% .(/(9
2(#% 7"..%&3"#9& $" $+% "$+%. 3(#7%. "0 &$.-$(0(7-$("# `%V3.%&&("#B $+% 7"#S
&$.F7$("# "0 - 0F#7$("#-2 &$.F7$F.%am $+% .(/(9 2(#% (& -# 5"'%.7"9(#/ $+-$
&FH&$($F$%& ($&%20 0". $+% 0-2$%.(#/ 7"9%&;B 8+(2% ($& &%/6%#$& 5-.% 2(T% .%$%..(S
$".(-2(A-$("#& "# $+% "'%.7"9(#/ ". "'%.7"9%9 2(#%; `<)Xa>
*+(& .%8".T(#/ "0 2(#% -#9 02"8 (# $%.6& "0 7"9(#/B 9%7"9(#/B -#9 "'%.S
7"9(#/ 2%-9& $" - 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# 7"##%7$("# -#9 7"#RF/-$("# "0 02"8&>
Q 57"##%7$("#; "0 02"8& (#9(7-$%& $+% &%20S7-$-21&(#/ "0 - &%$ "0 9%7"9%9 -#9
9%$%..($".(-2(&%9 02"8&B 8+(7+ 5H""&$ "#% -#"$+%.B -77%2%.-$% $+%(. &+-.%9
%&7-3%B -#9 -F/6%#$ ". &$"T% $+%(. _F-#$-; `<<Ia> Q 7"##%7$("# (& - 6F$(#1B
- 3.(&"# H.%-TB - H-#T 3-#(74 $+% 6".% $+-$ R"(# $+% 02(/+$B $+% 0-&$%. ($ /"%&>
5!"#RF/-$("#;B "# $+% "$+%. +-#9B .%2-$%& $" $+% &-6% 6F$-#$ 02"8&B HF$ 0."6
$+% 3"(#$ "0 '(%8 "0 $+%(. .%7-3$F.% -#9 "'%.7"9(#/m ($ 5(#9(7-$%& $+%(.
.%2-$('% &$"33-/%B 2(T% - 3"(#$ "0 -77F6F2-$("# $+-$ 32F/& ". &%-2& $+% 2(#%&
"0 02(/+$B 3%.0".6& - /%#%.-2 .%$%..($".(-2(&-$("#B -#9 H.(#/& $+% 02"8& F#9%.
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Q+( D/-1#-% "#,( $D D"#:+%
$+% 9"6(#-#7% "0 &(#/2% 02"8 7-3-H2% "0 "'%.7"9(#/ $+%6; `<<Ia> Q 7"#RF/-S
$("# (& $+% ."F#9(#/ F3 -#9 .%$F.#(#/ $" 3.(&"# "0 $+% %&7-3%%&B ". H%$$%.B $+%
0".6-$("# "0 - #%8 ,$-$% -6"#/ $+%64 $+% b(#/ G-$ %00%7$> Y#9%%9B ($ (&
-28-1&B [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( -&&%.$B $+% 6"&$ 9%$%..($".(-2(&%9 02"8 $+-$ H.(#/&
-H"F$ 7"#RF#7$("# -#9 .%$%..($".(-2(&-$("#B -& 8-& $+% 7-&%B $+%1 72-(6B 8($+
$+% UF."3%-# H"F./%"(&(% 9F.(#/ $+% 7-3($-2(&$ $-T%"00 `<<Ih)a>
[%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( &""# 3."72-(6 $+% 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 9.-8(#/ - 6-3 "0 $+.%%
2(#%& `<<<a> *+% 0(.&$ 2(#% (& $+% &F332% 2(#% "0 (#$%.2-7%9 7"9%& -#9 $%..($".(%&
7+-.-7$%.(&$(7 "0 3.(6($('% &%/6%#$-.($1> *+(& 2(#% 7"..%&3"#9& $" $+% 0(.&$
-.$(7F2-$("# "0 &"7(-2 &$.-$(0(7-$("#B 8+(7+ (& 7"F32%9 $" $+% &%7"#9 2(#%B $+%
.(/(9 2(#% "0 $+% ,$-$% -33-.-$F& 8+(7+ "'%.7"9%& -#9 .%$%..($".(-2(&%&> *+%
$+(.9 2(#% (& $+% 2(#% "0 02(/+$ "0 9%7"9(#/ -#9 9%$%..($".(-2(&-$("# %00%7$F-$%9
H1 - 58-. 6-7+(#%; `<<<a> *" (#&(&$ "# $+% 6-3 #-$F.% "0 $+(& 9(&7F&&("#
`5/%"/.-3+1B #"$ +(&$".1;aB [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( .%7-22 $+-$ 53.(6($('%; &"7(%$(%&
-.% #"$ $%63".-221 0(.&$> G-$+%.B 7"9(#/B "'%.7"9(#/ -#9 9%7"9(#/ -.% 7"%VS
(&$%#$ 0F#7$("#& "0 -#1 %V(&$(#/ &"7(%$1m $+%1 (#&(&$ 5$+%.% (& - &3-7% (# 8+(7+
$+% $+.%% T(#9& "0 72"&%21 (#$%.6(#/2%9 2(#%& 7"%V(&$4 $.(H%&B %63(.%&B -#9 8-.
6-7+(#%&; `<<<a> *+% 5$-&T "0 $+% +(&$".(-#; `". &7+(A"-#-21&$B ". .+(A"6-$(7
-#-21&$B ". 3.-/6-$(7& -#-21&$ > > > a (& $+% 7"#&(9%.-$("# "0 $+% .%2-$('% &3%%9&
-#9 &$.%#/$+& "0 $+%&% 0F#7$("#&m ($ (& $" 59%&(/#-$% $+% 553%.("9;; "0 7"%V(&S
$%#7% ". &(6F2$-#%($1; "0 $+% $+.%% 0F#7$("#& `<<)a> *" 9.('% +"6% $+% 3"(#$B
[%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 3."'(9% - &(632(0(%9 9%&7.(3$("# "0 - +(&$".(7-2 %V-632% "0
$+% 7"%V(&$%#7% "0 $.(H%&B %63(.%&B 8-. 6-7+(#%& (# $+% (#$%.7+-#/%&
H%$8%%# 6(/.-#$&B G"6%B MF#&> ZF$ 7"%V(&$%#7% (& #"$ -224 $+% 2(#%& $.-#&S
0".6 $+%6&%2'%&B -& (# $+% 7-&% "0 $+% f-#9-2&B $+% "#21 $.(H% $" 7."&& $+%
E%9($%..-#%-#B "#21 $+%.% $" 3."9F7% 5$+% 6"&$ &$-.$2(#/ .%$%..($".(-2(A-$("#4
-# %63(.% (# Q0.(7-; `<<@a>
^('%# &F7+ 7"%V(&$%#7% -#9 $.-#&0".6-$("# "0 $+% 2(#%&B [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(
0(#-221 &-1 $+-$ 5($ 8"F29 H% H%$$%. $" $-2T -H"F$ &(6F2$-#%"F& &$-$%& "0 $+%
QH&$.-7$ E-7+(#%; `<<@aB 8+(7+ $+%1 9%&(/#-$% -&4 `)a -H&$.-7$ 6-7+(#% "0
"'%.7"9(#/ $+-$ 3."9F7%& - .(/(9 &%/6%#$-.($1 -#9 (& %00%7$F-$%9 H1 ,$-$%
-33-.-$F&B 8+(7+ (& - .%$%..($".(-2(&(#/ -&&%6H2-/%m `<a -# -H&$.-7$ 6-7+(#% "0
6F$-$("#B 8+(7+ "3%.-$%& H1 9%7"9(#/ -#9 9%$%..($".(-2(&-$("#B 7.%-$(#/
2(#%& "0 02(/+$ -#9 %.%7$& 8-. 6-7+(#%& "# ($& 2(#%& `$" (#+(H($ ,$-$% 0".6-S
$("#am `@a $+% .%-26 "0 6"2%7F2-. #%/"$(-$("# H%$8%%# 6"2-. 2(#%& -#9 2(#%&
"0 02(/+$ `<<@hDa>
*+% 0"F.$+ %2%6%#$ "# $+% 6-3B (# -99($("# $" $+% $+.%% 2(#%&B (& $+% 3"8%.
7%#$.%B $+% -#-21&(& "0 8+(7+ (22F&$.-$%& $+% %#$-#/2%6%#$ "0 2(#%&> Q 3"8%.
7%#$.% (& - 3"(#$ "0 #%/"$(-$("# H%$8%%# $+% _F-#$F6 02"8 -#9 $+% .(/(9
&%/6%#$%9 2(#%B - 32-7% "0 7"#'%.&("# -#9 $.-#&2-$("# "0 02"8 (#$" &%/6%#S
$%9 2(#%> W(.&$B 3"8%. 7%#$.%& (#'"2'% .(/(9 &%/6%#$&B 8+"&% .%&"#-#7% (# $+%
,$-$% 9"%& #"$ 9%&$."1 &%/6%#$-.($1m "# $+% 7"#$.-.1B 57%#$.-2(A-$("# (&
-28-1& +(%.-.7+(7-2B HF$ +(%.-.7+1 (& -28-1& &%/6%#$-.1; `<<Da> *+(& (& $+%
3"8%. 7%#$.%;& 5A"#% "0 3"8%.;> =%V$B 3"8%. 7%#$.%& -.% #"$ RF&$ 6"2-.B HF$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)CD !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
-2&" 0F#7$("# (# $+% 6"2%7F2-. 0(%29B $+% 6(7."2"/(7-2 0-H.(7 "0 &"7(%$1 8+%.%
W"F7-F2$;& 9(&7(32(#%& "3%.-$%> *+(& 0(%29 (& - 5A"#% "0 (#9(&7%.#-H(2($1;B -$
"#7% 6"2-. -#9 6"2%7F2-. `<<Ja> *+(.9B $+% 2(6($ "0 3"8%. 7%#$.%&B $+%(.
A"#% "0 (63"$%#7%B (& $+%(. -7$ "0 7"#'%.&("# ($&%20> ,(#7% 3"8%. 7%#$.%& "#21
$.-#&2-$% -#9 9" #"$ /"'%.# $+% 02"8B $+%1 -.% 9%0(#%9 H1 $+%(. (63"$%#7%B H1
8+-$ %&7-3%& $+%6> ZF$ $+%(. .%2-$('% (63"$%#7% (& -2&" $+%(. .%2-$('% %00%7$S
('%#%&&4 3"8%. 7%#$%.& /"'%.# $+% -&&%6H2-/%& $+-$ %00%7$F-$%& $+% -H&$.-7$
6-7+(#% "0 "'%.7"9(#/B "0 7+-&(#/ 9"8# $+% 6F$-#$ 02"8&>
*+% %V-632% "0 $+% 02"8 "0 6"#%1 +%23& 7"#7.%$(&% $+% 9(&7F&&("#> *+%
A"#% "0 3"8%.B $+% &%$$(#/ F3 "0 &%/6%#$&B (& $+% 7"#7%.# "0 $+% 7%#$.-2
H-#T&B $+% 7"#'%.&("# "0 7.%9($ 02"8 (#$" 3-16%#$ 6"#%1 H1 $+% &%$$(#/ "0
(#$%.%&$ .-$%&B -#9 &" "#> *+(& (& $+% .%-26 "0 $+% ,$-$% -33-.-$F&B $+% 5-H&$.-7$
6-7+(#% "0 6"2-. "'%.7"9(#/; `<<Ca> *+% A"#% "0 (#9(&7%.#-H(2($1 (& $+%
6(7."2"/(7-2 $%V$F.% "0 6"#%1B $+% &%.(%& "0 3.('-$% .%2-$("#& H%$8%%#
H-#T& -#9 H".."8%.&> *+(& (& $+% .%-26 "0 5$+% 6"2%7F2-. 0-H.(7 (66%.&(#/
$+% ,$-$% -&&%6H2-/%; `<<Ca> *+% A"#% "0 (63"$%#7% (& $+% 59%&(.(#/ 02"8 "0
6"#%1B 8+"&% _F-#$- -.% 9%0(#%9 H1 $+% 6-&& "0 %7"#"6(7 $.-#&-7$("#&;
`<<NhCa> *+(& 02"8 "0 3-#(7B 0-9B 0-&+("#B (& $+% 0F#7$("# "0 $+% 5-H&$.-7$
6-7+(#% "0 6F$-$("#B 02"8& -#9 _F-#$-; `<<Ca>
*+% &(6F2$-#%($1 -#9 (#$%.8%-'(#/ "0 $+% %2%6%#$& "0 $+% 6-3B $+% &$-$%&
"0 $+% -H&$.-7$ 6-7+(#%B 2%-9 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( $" &$-$% $+-$ 5%'%.1$+(#/ (&
3"2($(7-2B HF$ %'%.1 3"2($(7& (& &(6F2$-#%"F&21 - 59/)"I"4*#*/% 9&. 9 5*/)"I"J
4*#*/%N `<)@a> Q& "#% "0 $+%(. $13(7-221 2""&% 9(-/.-6& (22F&$.-$%&B 5$+% &%/6%#S
$%9 2(#% `6-7."3"2($(7&a (& (66%.&%9 (# -#9 3."2"#/%9 H1 _F-#$F6 02"8&
`6(7."3"2($(7&a $+-$ 7"#$(#F-221 .%&+F002% -#9 &$(. F3 ($& &%/6%#$&; `<)?a> ZF$
$+(& .$ 29/#" (#$%.8%-'(#/ 6%-#& $+-$ "#% 7-##"$ &(6321 3.('(2%/% &F332%#%&&
". 6"2%7F2-.($1 -& .%-91S6-9% F#('%.&-2 3.(#7(32%& "0 $+% /""9m %'%.1$+(#/
0". [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( (& - 6-$$%. "0 3.-7$(7%B "0 %V3%.(6%#$-$("# -#9 $H I"%#
29/#" %'-2F-$("#> *+% 0(.&$B 5-V("2"/(7-2; %..". "0 $+% 50"F. %..".&; $" H% -'"(9%9
7"#7%.#(#/ 6"2%7F2-.($1 -#9 &F332%#%&& 6-T% $+(& 53.-/6-$(&6; "0 [%2%FA%h
^F-$$-.( 72%-.4 9"#;$ H%2(%'% $+-$ 5- 2($$2% &F332%#%&& (& %#"F/+ $" 6-T%
$+(#/& 55H%$$%.;; ; `<)Ja> Y#9%%9B 7"#7%.#(#/ $+% 6"2-. 2(#% -#9 $+% 6"2%7F2-.
02"8B 8% 6F&$ .%6%6H%. #"$ "#21 $+%(. 7"%V(&$%#7% `5$+% 02"8 7"#$(#F%&
H%#%-$+ $+% 2(#%B 0".%'%. 6F$-#$B 8+(2% $+% 2(#% $"$-2(A%&; r<<)sa -#9 $+%(.
(#$%.9%3%#9%#7% `53"2($(7& -#9 ($& RF9/6%#$& -.% -28-1& 6"2-.B HF$ ($ (& $+%
6"2%7F2-. -#9 ($& -&&%&&6%#$ $+-$ 6-T%& ($ ". H.%-T& ($; r<<<saB HF$ 6"&$
(63".$-#$21B $+% -6".-2($1 "0 $+% 9(&$(#7$("# `5$+%.% -.% RF&$ -& 6F7+ .%2-S
$("#& "0 0".7%B -#9 RF&$ -& 6F7+ '("2%#7%B "# "#% &(9% -& $+% "$+%.; r<<)sa>
O($+ $+%&% 8-.#(#/& -/-(#&$ -# 9 I)*")* 3.('(2%/% "0 $+% 6"2%7F2-. -#9
&F332%B [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 7"6% $" 9(&$(#/F(&+ 6"2%7F2-. 0-&7(&6 0."6
6"2-. $"$-2($-.(-#(&6> *+%1 #-6% 3"(#$& 0". +(&$".(7-2 (#'%&$(/-$("# "0 6"2%S
7F2-. ". 6(7."0-&7(&6 -& 56"2%7F2-. 0"7F&%& (# (#$%.-7$("# > > > .F.-2 0-&7(&6
-#9 7($1 ". #%(/+H"F.+""9 0-&7(&6B 1"F$+ 0-&7(&6 -#9 8-. '%$%.-#;& 0-&7(&6B
0-&7(&6 "0 $+% K%0$ -#9 "0 $+% G(/+$B 0-&7(&6 "0 $+% 7"F32%B 0-6(21B &7+""2B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"'& E)"#$F* )CJ
-#9 "00(7%; `<)Da> ,F7+ 6(7."0-&7(&6& &3.%-9 $+."F/+"F$ - &"7(-2 0-H.(7 3.(".
$" $+% 7%#$.-2(&(#/ .%&"#-#7% $+-$ 7.%-$% $+% 6"2-. ,$-$% -33-.-$F&> [%2%FA%h
^F-$$-.( 9%&7.(H% 6(7."S0-&7(&6 -& - 3."2(0%.-$("# "0 $(#1 7%#$.%& "0 7"6S
6-#9m %-7+ H"91 (& - 56(7."SH2-7T +"2% $+-$ &$-#9& "# ($& "8# -#9 7"66F#S
(7-$%& 8($+ $+% "$+%.&; `<<?a> ,F7+ 7"66F#(7-$("# H%$8%%# 5- $+"F&-#9
2($$2% 6"#"6-#(-&B &%20S%'(9%#$ $.F$+&B -#9 72-.($(%&; 7.%-$%& - &".$ "0 &$-$(7B
8+(7+ (#+(H($& ,$-$% .%&"#-#7% H1 - T(#9 "0 5.F6H2% -#9 HFAAB H2(#9(#/ 2(/+$&
/('(#/ -#1 -#9 %'%.1H"91 $+% 6(&&("# "0 &%20S-33"(#$%9 RF9/%B 9(&3%#&%. "0
RF&$(7%B 3"2(7%6-#B #%(/+H".+""9 ,, 6-#; `<<?a> *+(& &$-$(7 "0 6(7."0-&7(&6
T%%3& ($ H%2"8 $+% 2%'%2 "0 $+% ,$-$%4 - $+"F&-#9 (#9%3%#9%#$ -#9 &%20S
-33"(#$%9 3"2(7%6%# 9" #"$ 6-T% - ^%&$-3"B $+"F/+ $+%1 6-1 H% - #%7%&S
&-.1 7"#9($("# 0". "#%> Q2$+"F/+ []^ 9" #"$ 9" &"B 8% 7-# 7-22 6(7."0-&7(&6
56"2%7F2-. 6"2-.($1;4 %-7+ F#($ (& &%20S7"#$-(#%9B ".(%#$%9 $" F#($1B -# (#9(S
'(9F-2 `6"2-.aB HF$ $+%1 (#$%.-7$ (# &"2%21 2"7-2 6-##%.B (#9%3%#9%#$21
`6"2%7F2-.a>
Y# - 6"'% $+-$ 6(/+$ &+"7T $+"&% 8+" .%-9 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( -& 3.('(2%/S
(#/ 7%.$-(# $%.6&B 6(7."0-&7(&6 (& 9%0(#%9 -& $+% &$-$% "0 - &"7(-2 0-H.(7
58+%# - =9) 59/'*&$ (& (#&$-22%9 (# %-7+ +"2%B (# %'%.1 #(7+%; `<)Dm ")*?*&94
*#94*/%a> Q H.(%0 $.(3 $" P2-$%-F )<B $+% 5*.%-$(&% "# ="6-9"2"/1; (& #%%9%9
+%.%> Q 3-.$(7F2-. 8-. 6-7+(#% (& - 0".6 "0 &"7(-2 "./-#(&-$("#B - 7"#7.%$%
&"7(-2 -&&%6H2-/% $+-$ 3.%&%.'%& (66-#%#$ &%20S"./-#(&(#/ -#9 8-.9& "00 $+%
$.-#&7%#9%#$ ".9%.(#/ %00%7$F-$%9 H1 $+% ,$-$%> *+F& 5,$-$%; -#9 58-.S
6-7+(#%; -.% #-6%& "0 0F#7$("#& h "'%.7"9(#/ -#9 2(#% "0 02(/+$ .%&3%7$('%21
h $+-$ -.% -&3%7$& "0 $+% -H&$.-7$ 6-7+(#% -#9 -.% (#&$-#7(-$%9 H1 7"#7.%$%
8-. 6-7+(#%& -#9 ,$-$%&> Q& -&3%7$& "0 $+% -H&$.-7$ 6-7+(#% $+%1 -.% 7"S
%V(&$%#$m $+%.% +-'% -28-1& H%%# 3-7T& -#9 ,$-$%& (# (#$%.-7$("#4 $+% ,$-$%
$.(%& $" -33."3.(-$% $+% 8-. 6-7+(#% -#9 $F.# ($ (#$" -# Q.61B 8+(2% 8-.
6-7+(#%& 0".6 (# $+% (#$%.&$(7%& H%$8%%# ,$-$%&>
="8 8% 6F&$ .%6%6H%. $+-$ 8-. 6-7+(#%& -.% #"$ F#"./-#(&%9m ($ (& RF&$
$+-$ $+%1 -.% #"$ "./-#(&6(7-221 "./-#(&%9 0". $+% H%#%0($ "0 - 9%&3"$4 $+%(.
2%-9%.& -.% 9. '"/ -#9 7+-22%#/%-H2%B .-$+%. $+-# .%(0(%9 -#9 9%(0(%9> O-.
6-7+(#%& "77F31 -#9 %V$%#9 5&6""$+ &3-7%;B - 0".6 "0 &3-$(-2 "./-#(&-$("#
$+-$ (& 2"7-221 9%#&% -#9 02%V(H2% .-$+%. $+-# +"6"/%#"F& -#9 3.%S9%6-.7S
-$%9B -& (# $+% /.(99%9 ". &$.(-$%9 &3-7% %&$-H2(&+%9 H1 ,$-$%&> Y# &6""$+
&3-7%B - 2-8 "0 9(&$-#7% 9(&3%.&%& 0(/F.%& -7."&& - A"#%m (# &$.(-$%9 &3-7%B $+%
&3-7% (& 9%6-.7-$%9 3.(". $" "77F3-$("#B -#9 0(/F.%& -.% -&&(/#%9 $" 6-.T%9
&3"$&>
O-. 6-7+(#%& -.% $+F& $+% T%1 $" 7.%-$("#B $" 6F$-$("# (# -# "3%# 0F$F.%>
*+%1 7"#&$-#$21 $+."8 "00 2(#%& "0 02(/+$ $+-$ 6"'% &1&$%6& "00 $%..($".(-2
H(#9(#/& -#9 -8-1 0."6 7"9%9 H%+-'("F.> ="8 -22 3+1&(7-2 3."7%&&%& -.%
&%20S"./-#(&(#/B HF$ &"7(-2 0".6-$("#& 7-# H% $.-#&7%#9%#$ `$"3S9"8#aB -#9
/('% $+% (22F&("# $+-$ 3+1&(7-2 3."9F7$("# (& $.-#&7%#9%#$ $""> Y# $+% $%.6&
"0 7QR $+(& (22F&".1 $"$-2($1 -.."/-$(#/ 7.%9($ 0". 3."9F7$("# $" ($&%20 (& $+%
5&"7(F&;4 $+% %-.$+B 9%&3"$B ". 7-3($-2 (# $+% 3.(6($('%B (63%.(-2 ". 6"9%.#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)CN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
&1&$%6&> Q 8-.S6-7+(#% (& - 8-1 "0 "./-#(&(#/ &"7(-2 3."9F7$("# $+-$ 3.%S
'%#$& $+% 0".6-$("# "0 - &"7(F&> Y# 7"#7.%$% $%.6&B $+(& 6%-#& $+% 8-.
6-7+(#% 8-.9& "00 7-3$F.% H1 ,$-$% H1 "77F31(#/ $+% &6""$+ &3-7% "0
(66-#%#$ .%2-$("#&>
Q& 8% +-'% &%%#B $+% 8-. 6-7+(#% (& [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(;& $%.6 0". (66-#S
%#$ &"7(-2 .%2-$("#& $+-$ (#&$(/-$% 6F$-$("# -#9 7.%-$('($1 -#9 8-.9 "00 ,$-$%
.%&"#-#7%> ZF$ +%.%B $" .%R"(# P2-$%-F XB $+% 6(7."0-&7(&$ &3.%-9 (#&$-22& 8-.
6-7+(#%& %'%.18+%.%B (# %-7+ 7%22B &" $+-$ $+%.% (& "#21 - 5- 6"2%7F2-. -#9
&F332% &%/6%#$-.($1B 02"8& 7-3-H2% "0 &F00F&(#/ %'%.1 7%22;B - 56"2%7F2-. ".
6(7."3"2($(7-2 3"8%. rI,*%%9&/$s; `<)Dh)Ja> E(7."0-&7(&6 (& $+% &"7(-2 0-H.(7
3F#7$F-$%9 H1 $+"F&-#9& "0 8-.S6-7+(#%&B %-7+ 9%9(7-$%9 $" ($& "8# 6"'%S
6%#$m 3-.-9"V(7-221B $+% 6"'%6%#$ "0 $+% 6(7."0-&7(&$ 8-.S6-7+(#%& (& #"$
$+-$ "0 7.%-$(#/ 7"##%7$("#&B HF$ $+-$ "0 &%-2(#/ "00B "0 6"2-.(&(#/ &%20 -#9
"$+%.&> \#9%.&$-#9(#/B .%7"/#(&(#/B 6(7."0-&7(&6 (& "0 $+% /.%-$%&$ (63".$S
-#7%B 0". 5"#21 6(7."0-&7(&6 3."'(9%& -# -#&8%. $" $+% /2"H-2 _F%&$("#4 8+1
9"%& 9%&(.% 9%&(.% ($& "8# .%3.%&&("#i; `<)Ja> [%&(.%B $+% 6"'%6%#$ "0 7"#S
#%7$("# -#9 (66-#%#7%B (& .%3.%&&%9 H1 6(7."0-&7(&6m (# ($& 32-7% -.(&%& $+%
&$.-#/% 7-#7%. "0 - $+"F&-#9 57%22&; ". &%20S7"#$-(#%9 F#($&> L0 7"F.&%B 0".
[%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(B 9%&(.% (& #%'%. - /('%#B - #-$F.-2 .%&"F.7%B - G"6-#$(7
&F./%m 9%&(.% (& #%'%. -# 5F#9(00%.%#$(-$%9 (#&$(#7$F-2 %#%./1;B HF$ (& %#/(#S
%%.%9 0."6 57"632%V -&&%6H2-/%&;> Y# $+(& 8-1B 9%&(.% (& - 5&F332% &%/6%#$-.S
($1 $+-$ 3."7%&&%& 6"2%7F2-. %#%./(%& -#9 3"$%#$(-221 /('%& 9%&(.% - 0-&7(&$
9%$%.6(#-$("#; `<)Ja> *+F& 8% 6F&$ H% "# /F-.9 -/-(#&$ 5$+% 0-&7(&$ (#&(9%
1"F; `<)Ja>
*+% (63".$-#$ 3"(#$ "0 -.$(7F2-$("# H%$8%%# P2-$%-F& N -#9 X -33%-.&
8+%# 6(7."0-&7(&6 (& 9%&7.(H%9 -& - 57-#7%."F& H"91 .-$+%. $+-# - $"$-2($-.S
(-# "./-#(&6; `<)Ja> ZF$ $" H% 3.%7(&%B $+% 7-#7%."F& H"91 "0 3."2(0%.-$(#/
6(7."0-&7(&6 -#9 $+% 7%#$.-2(&%9 H"91 "0 $+% $"$-2($-.(-# "./-#(&6 -.% #"$
$+% %#9 "0 $+% &$".1> *+% %63$1B &F(7(9-2 Z8L -2&" +-& - 0-&7(&$ 7"..%2-$%B $+%
3%.'%.$%9 2(#% "0 02(/+$B $+% 50"F.$+ 9-#/%.;> [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 2-1 "F$ $+%
3.(#7(32%& "0 - 3.-/6-$(7& ". &7+(A"-#-21$(7 -#-21&(& "0 $+% 9-#/%.& "0 %-7+ "0
$+% 0"F. %2%6%#$& "0 $+% 6-34 .(/(9 6"2-.($1B &F332% 6"2%7F2-.($1B $+% 3"8%.
7%#$.%B -#9 $+% 2(#% "0 02(/+$B -$ $+% %#9 "0 $+% )X@@ P2-$%-F `<<Ch@)a> *+%
0"F. 9-#/%.& 9.-8 $+%(. #-6%&B (# - $13(7-2 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 6"#&$."F&
6-..(-/%B 0."6 5=(%$A&7+%;& q-.-$+F&$.- -#9 !-&$%#-9-;& Y#9(-# ["# kF-#;4
W%-.B !2-.($1B P"8%.B [(&/F&$ `<<Ca>
Y# 0%-. 8% 72(#/ $" 6"2-. &%/6%#$-$("#B $" $+% .(/(9 "F$2(#%& "0 "F. H(#-.1B
7(.7F2-. -#9 2(#%-. &"7(-2 3"&($("#> O% 72(#/ $" "F. H(#-.1 (9%#$($(%&4 6-#]
8"6-#B 8+($%]H2-7TB &$.-(/+$]/-1m $" "F. 7(.7F2-. 2"7-$("#&4 $" +"6%B #%(/+S
H"F.+""9B 7($1B .%/("#B 7"F#$.1m $" "F. 2(#%-. &$-$("#&B -7$(#/ "F. -/%> *+%
.%7".9(#/ "0 $+%&% 6"2-.($(%& (& $+% 7"#7%.# "0 $+% 3"8%. 7%#$.%&B $+% ,$-$%
-33-.-$F&%& 8+"&% A"#% "0 3"8%. "'%.2""T& $+"&% 3."7%&&%& $+-$ (&&F% F& "F.
H(.$+B 6-..(-/% -#9 9%-$+ 7%.$(0(7-$%&B $+-$ 7"22%7$ "F. $-V%& -#9 &$F91 "F.
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"'& E)"#$F* )CC
9%6"/.-3+(7& (# $+% 7%#&F&> Y# 0%-.B 8% 72(#/B .(/(921B $" "F. (#9('(9F-2($1B $"
"F. &%2'%&>
ZF$ H%(#/ &F332% .-$+%. $+-# .(/(9 (& #" /F-.-#$%% "0 &-2'-$("#B 0". $+%
&%7"#9 9-#/%.B 72-.($1B 7"6%& 3.%7(&%21 0."6 &F332% 6"2%7F2-.($1B (# 8+(7+
8% 5(#'%#$ -22 T(#9& "0 6-./(#-2 .%$%..($".(-2(A-$("#& %'%# 8".&% $+-# $+%
"$+%.&; `<<?a> *+(& (& $+% 6(7."2"/(7-2 0-H.(7B $+% A"#% "0 (#9(&7%.#-H(2($1 (#
8+(7+ 6(7."0-&7(&6& H.%%9> M%.% 8% 0(#9 $+% &$-$(7 "0 6"2%7F2-. 7"66F#S
(7-$("# "0 (#9('(9F-2 H2-7T +"2%& 3.(". $" .%&"#-#7% (# $+% ,$-$%B 6(7."S
0-&7(&6 -& $+% .%-26 "0 $+% 7-#7%."F& Z8LB $+% H.%%9(#/ "0 $(#1 7"66-#9
3"&$&>
*+% $+(.9 9-#/%. (& %-&(21 0".%&%%#4 P"8%. `I",F"*)aB $+% &$"33(#/ "0 $+%
2(#%& "0 02(/+$ H1 $+% $"$-2($-.(-# ,$-$%> *+(& (& $+% 72"&(#/ "00 "0 $+% &"7(%$1B
$+% &%-.7+ 0". 5-F$-.T1;B ". #-$("#-2 &%20S&F00(7(%#71B $+% 8($+9.-8-2 0."6
/2"H-2 7-3($-2(&6 $" %#&F.% - #-$("#-2 9%&$(#1m $+(& "3%.-$("# 5(& #%'%. -#
(9%"2"/(7-2 "3%.-$("#B HF$ .-$+%. -# %7"#"6(7 -#9 3"2($(7-2 "#%; `<<@a> *+(&
9-#/%. (& $+% 9-#/%. "0 $+% 3"8%. 7%#$.%& $+%6&%2'%&B .-$+%. $+-# $+%
&%/6%#$%9 2(#%& $+%1 3."9F7% -#9 $" 8+(7+ 8% 72(#/ (# 0%-.m 3"8%. (& $+%
9-#/%. "0 6-7."3"2($(7&B "0 $+% /.%-$ .%&"#-$(#/ H2-7T +"2% "0 $+% ,$-$% 8+(7+
+-& -33."3.(-$%9 - 8-.S6-7+(#% -#9 $-6%9 ($ (#$" -# Q.61>
*+% 0"F.$+ 9-#/%. (& $+% /.%-$%&$B +"8%'%.m ($ +-33%#& 8+%#B 7"#'%.&%21B 8-. 6-7+(#% $-T%& "'%. - ,$-$% -#9 3"&($& 8-. -#9 8-. -2"#% -& ($& "HR%7$>
*+(& (& $+% 5/.%-$ [(&/F&$B $+% 2"#/(#/ $" T(22 -#9 9(%B $+% P-&&("# 0". -H"2(S
$("#; `<<Ca> *+% 0"F.$+ -#9 /.%-$%&$ 9-#/%. (& $+% 9-#/%. "0 $+% 2(#%& "0 02(/+$
$+%6&%2'%&B 8+(7+ 5%6-#-$% - &$.-#/% 9%&3-(.B 2(T% -# "9"F. "0 9%-$+ -#9
(66"2-$("#B - &$-$% "0 8-. 0."6 8+(7+ "#% .%$F.#& H."T%#; `<<Xa> M%.% 8%
0(#9 $+% 8-. 6-7+(#%B $+% 7"#7.%$% 6-7+(#(7 -&&%6H2-/% "0 6F$-$("#B &"7(-2
(66-#%#7%B 0-(2(#/ -$ 6F$-$("#4 58-. (& 2(T% $+% 0-22 ". 0-(2F.% "0 6F$-$("#;
`<@Ia> M%.% 8% 0(#9 $+% -#-2"/F% "0 $+% &F(7(9-2B %63$1 Z8L (# - 0-&7(&$ 8-.
6-7+(#% $+-$ +-& 6"H(2(&%9 -# (#7(3(%#$ 6(7."0-&7(&$ &"7(-2 0-H.(7 $" $-T%
"'%. $+% ,$-$% -#9 +-& $+%.%H1 0"F#9B &F(7(9-221B #"$+(#/ HF$ 8-. -& ($&
"HR%7$> Z"$+ &F(7(9%& h $+% %63$1 Z8L -#9 $+% 0-&7(&$ ,$-$% h -.% #(+(2(&$(7B
H"$+ $%#9 $" A%."B HF$ "# 9(00%.%#$ $.-R%7$".(%&4 "#% 9(.%7$ -#9 9%3.%&&('%B $+%
"$+%. (#9(.%7$21B -0$%. - 6-#(7 -&7%#&("# (#$" - 8-. 0.%#A1>
*+F& $+% [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 6-3 "0 0-&7(&6 &+"8& +"8 $+% 0-&7(&$ 2%-9%. (&
0-7%9 8($+ - 53-.-9"V; `<@Ia> *+% 2%-9%. 6F&$ 6"H(2(&% $+% (#$%.-7$("# "0 $+%
6(7."SH2-7T +"2%&B $+% 6F2$(32%B &%20S%#7-&%9 8-. 6-7+(#%& "0 6(7."0-&7(&6B
H%0".% $+%1 .%&"#-$% (# - ,$-$%B HF$ -2&" H%0".% $+%1 &%$$2% (#$" $+% 5.F6H2%
-#9 HFAA; "0 6%.% /.F6H2(#/> *+%&% 9(&3%.&%9 8-. 6-7+(#%& 6F&$ H% 6"H(2S
(&%9 -& - &"7(-2 8-. 6-7+(#%B HF$ $+(& $%#9& $" $-T% "00 "# - &F(7(9-2 2(#% "0
02(/+$ $+-$ 7-3$F.%& - ,$-$% "0 ($& "8# -#9 3"&($& 8-. -& ($& "#21 "HR%7$> Z%$$%.
&$(22 $" 3F$ ($ (# $%.6& "0 $+% &$.%#/$+& -#9 $%#9%#7(%& "0 7"#7.%$% -&&%6S
H2-/%&4 M($2%. +-9 $" 7"#&$.F7$ -#9 6-(#$-(# $+% 6"6%#$F6 "0 $+% =-A( 8-.
6-7+(#% `2%$;& &-1 $+% ,,a $" "'%.7"6% $+% .%$%..($".(-2(&-$("#& "0 +"29S"'%.
-.(&$"7.-$& `$+% O%+.6-7+$ "00(7%. 7".3&a -#9 $+% $"$-2($-.(-# .%&"#-#7%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)C? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
7+-6H%. "0 $+% ,$-$% `$+% HF.%-F7.-$(7 %2%6%#$&a> L. 6".% 3.%7(&%21 &$(22B $+%
6"6%#$F6 "0 $+% 2(#% "0 02(/+$ +-9 $" "'%.7"6% $+% "$+%. %2%6%#$& 8($+(#
$+% ,, 8-. 6-7+(#% ($&%20 &" $+-$ ($ 7"F29 "'%.3"8%. $+% "$+%. 0-7$".&B
$+%6&%2'%& &($%& "0 &$.F//2% "0 $+% $+.%% -&3%7$& "0 $+% -H&$.-7$ E-7+(#%B
-#9 7.%-$% - 8-. 6-7+(#% &$."#/%. $+-# $+% ,$-$%> L#21 $+%#B "# $+% &F(7(9-2
2(#% "0 02(/+$ 2%-9(#/ $+."F/+ 8-. $" ,$-$% &F(7(9% h $+% (#9(.%7$ ."F$% $" -#
%63$1 Z8L h (& $+%.% - 5.%-2(A%9 #(+(2(&6; `<@Ia> ,F7+ 0-&7(&$ &F7(9-2 #(+(2(&6
(& _F-2($-$('%21 9(00%.%#$ 0."6 $+% 0.%%A(#/B .%02%7$('%B 9%3.%&&('%B 52F#-.;
#(+(2(&6 9(-/#"&%9 H1 =(%$A&7+%B 8+(7+ &(#T& .%2%#$2%&&21 -#9 %#$."3(7-221
$" A%."m .-$+%.B 0-&7(&$ #(+(2(&6 (& - 0.-#$(7B 5&"2-.; #(+(2(&6B 8+(7+ HF.#&
"F$ $" A%." "# - $.-R%7$".1 $+."F/+ -# &F3%.S(#$%#&($1 "0 +%-$ 3."9F7%9 H1
($& "8# 6-#(7 6"$("#B ($& 0-&7(#-$%9 3F.&F($ "0 8-.>
& =/%()#/"#-% %+($)7 $D D/-1#-% ,#+#"#-=
*+% F#(_F%#%&& -#9 (63".$-#7% "0 (9I*#94*%5 9&. A/'*@"I')$&*9 -& - 8+"2%
2(%& (# ($& 6-$%.(-2(&6> 7&#*JQ$.*I,% "3%#%9 $+% 0(%29 "0 +(&$".(7-2S2(H(9(#-2
6-$%.(-2(&6B - &3%7$F2-. &+-$$%.(#/ "0 $+% %-&1 E-.VhW.%F9 &1#$+%&(& "0 $+%
W.%#7+ 2%0$ H1 $+% (#$%.R%7$("# "0 =(%$A&7+%-# %#%./%$(7&m 7 D'",%9&. E49#$9,%
6-(#$-(#%9 $+(& $+.F&$B HF$ 7+-#/%9 6F7+ "0 $+% $%.6(#"2"/1 "0 7Q (# $+%
H"29 -$$%63$ $" +-.#%&& $+% 6-$%.(-2(&$ 5#%8 &7(%#7%; "0 $+% )XNI& -#9 )XCI&
%V3.%&&%9 H1 $+(#T%.& &F7+ -& ,(6"#9"# `)XNDa -#9 P.(/"/(#% `)X?Da> Y# $+(&
$+(.9 &%7$("# Y 8(22 &+"8 $+% 6-$%.(-2(&$ H-&(& "0 7DEN& $8" 6-(# $.%-$6%#$& "0
0-&7(&64 $+% 3."2(0%.-$("# "0 6(7."0-&7(&6& -& $+% 7-#7%."F& Z8LB -#9 $+%
&F(7(9-2 2(#% "0 02(/+$ .%&F2$(#/ 0."6 - 8-. 6-7+(#% $-T(#/ "'%. ,$-$%>
[%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( (#&(&$ $+-$ 3"2($(7&B -#9 "0 7"F.&%B $+%(. 53"2($(7-2 &7(%#7%;B
(& 5- 3."H2%6 #"$ "0 (9%"2"/1 HF$ "0 3F.% 6-$$%.; `)NJa> O+-$ (& $+%# $+%
6-$%.(-2(&6 H%+(#9 $+%(. -77F&-$("# $+-$ (# 0-&7(&6 $+%.% 2(%& - 5.%-2(A%9
#(+(2(&6;i
*+% 6-$%.(-2(&6 (#'"T%9 +%.% (& #"$ $+% 9%$%.6(#(&$ H"/%1 "0 #(#%$%%#$+S
7%#$F.1 $+"F/+$B HF$ $+% 6-$%.(-2(&6 "0 57"632%V($1 $+%".1;BJ - 6-$%.(-2(&6
$+-$ (& #%($+%. 6%7+-#(&$(7 #". 9%$%.6(#(&$B HF$ $+-$ .%7"/#(&%& H"$+ $+%
%6%./%#$ 3."3%.$(%& `7"#$.- $+% 6%7+-#(&$ .%9F7$("# "0 - &1&$%6 $" ($& 3-.$&
h 0". %V-632%B $+% 72-(6 $+-$ 5#"F#& -.% #%F."#&;a -#9 F#3.%9(7$-H(2($1 "0
7"632%V &1&$%6&> Q77".9(#/ $" [%K-#9-;& +(&$".(7-2 .%7"#&$.F7$("# `)XX)B
<@DB #XaB (# $+% 2-$% )XNI& [%2%FA% H%/-# $" 0".6F2-$% &"6% "0 $+% 3+(2"&"S
3+(7-2 &(/#(0(7-#7%& "0 $+(& 5#%8 &7(%#7%;B $+% &$F91 "0 5"3%#; 6-$$%.h%#%./1
&1&$%6& 8+(7+ 6"'% 0."6 &(632% $" 7"632%V 3-$$%.#(#/ -#9 0."6 7"632%V
$" &(632% 3-$$%.#(#/> Q2$+"F/+ 3"&$S6"9%.# -33."3.(-$("#& "0 &7(%#7% h $"
&-1 #"$+(#/ "0 7.($(_F%& h +-'% H%%# $+% 0"7F& "0 6F7+ #%/-$('% -$$%#$("#
2-$%21B 9F% $" $+% #"$".("F& ,"T-2 +"-VB $+%.% 9"%& &%%6 $" H% /""9 7-F&% $"
$-T% &%.("F&21 $+% 8".T "0 [%2%FA% -#9 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(>N
*" %V32-(# $+% #%8 6-$%.(-2(&6 "0 7"632%V($1 $+%".1B &"6% %2%6%#$-.1
$%.6(#"2"/1 (& #%7%&&-.1> W(.&$B -&&F6% $+-$ $+%.% -.% $+.%% 0".6& "0 3+1&(7-2
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"'& E)"#$F* )CX
&1&$%6&4 72"&%9 `9%$%.6(#%9aB "3%# `.-#9"6 ". &%20S"./-#(&(#/a> !2"&%9 &1&S
$%6& +-'% 7"#&$-#$ 6-$$%. -#9 %#%./1> *+%1 8%.% 6"9%2& 0". 72-&&(7-2 6"9S
%.# 3+1&(7&B #-$F.% 3"&($%9 -& - 9%$%.6(#-$% &1&$%6B -& 0(/F.%9 (# $+% &$".1 "0
K-P2-7%;& 9%6"#B 8+%.%H1 T#"82%9/% "0 $+% (#($(-2 7"#9($("#& -#9 H-&(7 2-8&
"0 - &1&$%6 8"F29 1(%29 T#"82%9/% "0 -22 3"&&(H2% `53-&$; ". 50F$F.%; h HF$ +%.%
$+% $%.6& 2"&% $+%(. 6%-#(#/a &$-$%& "0 $+% &1&$%6> L3%# &1&$%6&B "# $+%
"$+%. +-#9B +-'% - 02"8 "0 6-$$%. -#9 %#%./1 $+."F/+ $+%6B -#9 -.% "0 $8"
$13%&> L3%# .-#9"6 &1&$%6& -.% %V%632(0(%9 H1 $+% 2-6(#-. 02"8 "0 02F(9& ".
9(00F&("# "0 /-&%&> *+%.% -.% #" 6"9%2& 0". 3.%9(7$(#/ $+% 3.%7(&% H%+-'(". "0
"3%# .-#9"6 &1&$%6&B HF$ $+%.% -.% 6%$+"9& 0". -..('(#/ -$ &$-$(&$(7-2 3."HS
-H(2($(%& "0 $+% H%+-'(". "0 $+% &1&$%6> Y# &F7+ .-#9"6#%&& 8% 0(#9 $+%
72-&&(7 (6-/% "0 57+-"&;> L3%# &%20S"./-#(&(#/ &1&$%6&B "# $+% "$+%. +-#9B
-.% $+"&% (# 8+(7+ - 6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8 -..('%& -$ _F-2($-$('%21 9(&7%.#-H2%
3-$$%.#& 8($+"F$ "F$&(9% (#$%.0%.%#7%> *+%&% &1&$%6& -.% $+"&% &$F9(%9 H1
57+-"&]7"632%V($1 $+%".1;> M%.% 8% 0(#9 &+".$S$%.6 3.%9(7$-H(2($1 -#9 2"#/S
$%.6 F#3.%9(7$-H(2($1B $+% #%8 (6-/% "0 57+-"&;>C
Q &%7"#9 (63".$-#$ $%.6 (# F#9%.&$-#9(#/ 7"632%V($1 $+%".1 (& 53+-&%
&3-7%;B -# (9%- 9%'%2"3%9 H1 M%#.( P"(#7-.%e (# $+% 2-$% #(#%$%%#$+ 7%#$F.1>
Y63."'%9 7"63F$%. $%7+#"2"/1B $+% 6-$%.(-2 &F33".$ "0 6-$+%6-$(7&B +-&
-22"8%9 #%8 F&%& "0 $+(& (9%-> *+%.% -.% 0('% &$%3& (# 7"#&$.F7$(#/ - 3+-&%
&3-7% 3".$.-($ "0 - &1&$%64
) Y9%#$(01 (63".$-#$ -&3%7$& "0 - &1&$%6;& H%+-'("F.B 8+(7+ -.% 7-22%9 ($&
59%/.%%& "0 0.%%9"6;m
< Y6-/(#% ". 6"9%2 - &3-7% 8($+ -& 6-#1 9(6%#&("#& -& $+% 9%/.%%& "0
0.%%9"6 "0 $+% &1&$%6 $" H% &$F9(%9m
@ U-7+ &$-$% "0 $+% &1&$%6 7-# $+%# H% .%3.%&%#$%9 -& - &(#/2% 3"(#$B 8($+ -&
6-#1 '-2F%& -& $+%.% -.% 9(6%#&("#&m
D *+% 7+-#/(#/ &$-$%& "0 $+% &1&$%6 $+%# $.-7% - 2(#%B - $.-R%7$".1B $+."F/+
3+-&% &3-7%m
J O% 7-# $+%# $.1 $" &"2'% $+% %_F-$("#& /"'%.#(#/ $+% 2(#% -#9 3(# 9"8#
$+% &1&$%6;& H%+-'(". -& (# 72"&%9 9%$%.6(#(&$(7 &1&$%6&> ,"6%$(6%& 8%
7-#;$ &"2'% $+% %_F-$("#&B -#9 #" 3-$$%.#& %6%./%B -& (# "3%# .-#9"6
&1&$%6&>
,"6%$(6%& $+"F/+B (# &$F91(#/ $+% &1&$%6 8% 7-#;$ &"2'% $+% %_F-$("#&B HF$
8% 7-# (9%#$(01 $+% %'"2F$("# "0 &"6% 3-$$%.#&B -& (& $+% 7-&% 8($+ "3%# &%20S
"./-#(&(#/ &1&$%6&> *+%&% 3-$$%.#& +-'% '-.("F& 0%-$F.%&B &"6% "0 8+(7+ -.%
#-6%9 5-$$.-7$".;B -#9 5H(0F.7-$".;>
Z.(%021 3F$B -& [% K-#9- %V32-(#&B $+% -7$F-2]'(.$F-2 9(&$(#7$("# [%2%FA%
-33."3.(-$%& 0."6 Z%./&"# `[%2%FA% )X??a (& 3F$ $" F&% (# L"?*/ "2 A$&%$ -#9
B*22$)$&/$ 9&. 1$I$#*#*"& $" 9(&$(#/F(&+ H%$8%%# $+% `-7$F-2a $.-($& "0 - 3+1&(S
7-2 &1&$%6 `($& 2"#/S$%.6 $%#9%#7(%&a -#9 $+% `'(.$F-2a $+.%&+"29& -$ 8+(7+ ($
%($+%. -9"3$& ". 7+-#/%& $+"&% $.-($&> *+F& -# -7$F-2 &1&$%6 6(/+$B &-1B
"&7(22-$% -$ "#% 0.%_F%#71 8($+(# - 7%.$-(# .-#/% "0 3-.-6%$%.&B -#9 -$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)?I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
-#"$+%. 8($+(# -#"$+%. .-#/%> *+% -7$F-2 H%+-'(". "0 $+% &1&$%6B ($& "&7(22-S
$("# -$ 0.%_F%#71 y) ". y<B 8"F29 H% - $.-($B 8+(2% "&7(22-$("# 0.%_F%#7(%& y)
-#9 y< 8"F29 H% '(.$F-2 5-$$.-7$".&;B -#9 $+% $.-#&($("# H%$8%%# y) -#9 y<
8"F29 H% - '(.$F-2 5H(0F.7-$".;> 5Q$$.-7$".&; .%7%('% $+%(. #-6% H1 7-3$F.(#/
$+% H%+-'("F. "0 &1&$%6& 8($+(# - .-#/% "0 '-2F%& "0 3-.-6%$%.& h $+%(. 5H-&(#
"0 -$$.-7$("#; h 8+(2% 5H(0F.7-$".&; -.% #-6%9 H%7-F&% $+%1 -.% $+% %'%#$& H1
8+(7+ - &1&$%6 6"'%& 0."6 "#% -$$.-7$". $" -#"$+%.> [%K-#9- (&"2-$%& $+.%%
$13%& "0 -$$.-7$".&4 3"(#$B 2""3B -#9 7+-"$(7B 7"..%&3"#9(#/ $" $+.%% &$-$%&4
&$%-91 &$-$%B "&7(22-$("#B -#9 $F.HF2%#7%>?
*+% '(.$F-2]-7$F-2 9(&$(#7$("# %#-H2%& [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( $" -77"F#$ 0".
F#3.%9(7$-H(2($1 (# 3+1&(7-2 &1&$%6& 8+(2% &$(22 6-(#$-(#(#/ - 7"#&(&$%#$
6-$%.(-2(&6m $+% '(.$F-2 (& 5.%-2 HF$ -H&$.-7$;> Q$$.-7$".& -.% 0".6& "0 &%20S
"./-#(&-$("# "0 6-$$%.m 3+1&(7-2 &1&$%6& "0 6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8 7-# H%7"6%
"./-#(&%9B %'%# (0 7F..%#$21 .-#9"6 ". 2-6(#-.>X U'%# $F.HF2%#$ 02F(9&B 0".
(#&$-#7%B 8+(7+ 8%.% 72-&&(7 &16H"2& "0 57+-"$(7; 6-$$%.B -.% %6H"9(6%#$& ".
-7$F-2(&-$("#& "0 '(.$F-2 -$$.-7$".&B -2H%($ 50.-7$-2; ". 5&$.-#/%; "#%&> *+%.%;& #"
.%-2 7+-"& (# $F.HF2%#7%m .-$+%.B 0(%#9(&+21 7"632%V (#$%.-7$("#& "0 6-$$%.>
M"8%'%.B 2-6(#-. 02"8& `3-.-9"V(7-221B 57-26; 02F(9&a ". /-&%& 7"6% 72"&% $"
$+% ".(/(#-2 &%#&% "0 7+-"&> Y# $+% 3+%#"6%#- "0 &%20S"./-#(&(#/ &1&$%6&B 8%
0(#9 7.%-$('($1B #"'%2$1B -#9 &" "#B HF$ $+(& 7.%-$('($1 (& (#+%.%#$ (# 6-$$%.
($&%20m H(0F.7-$".&B U'%#$&B 2(#%& "0 02(/+$B -.% 7+-#/%& $.(//%.%9 F#3.%9(7$-H21
8+%# &%#&($('% &1&$%6& 3(7T F3 &2(/+$ 7F%& $+-$ 6"'% $+%6 "#$" -#"$+%.
H-&(# "0 -$$.-7$("#B ". T%%3 $+%6 6"'(#/ -H"F$ 8($+(# - A"#% "0 F#3.%9(7$S
-H(2($1>
O($+ $+(& #"$("# "0 &%20S"./-#(A(#/ 6-$$%.B [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 7.($(_F%
5+12"6".3+(&6;B $+% #"$("# $+-$ 6-$$%. #%%9& $+% (63"&($("# "0 - $.-#&7%#S
9%#$ 0".6 $" "./-#(&% ($& 3F$-$('% 7+-"&> M12"6".3+(&6 2('%& H1 $+% 0".7%9
7+"(7% ". %V72F&('% 9(&RF#7$("# H%$8%%# 7+-"& ". $.-#&7%#9%#$ 0".6> 7I)$b%
&",%R 4$ .$M4,?$> Z1 "'%.$+."8(#/ 2"#/S$%.6 9%$%.6(#(&6 (# 2"7-$(#/ (##"'-S
$("#B #"'%2$1B 7.%-$('($1 (# 6-$$%. `-2H%($ (# ($& '(.$F-2 $+.%&+"29&aB 7"632%VS
($1 $+%".1 9(&.F3$& $+% 6-$%.(-2(&6 z 9%$%.6(#(&6 %_F-$("# -#9 ($&
7"#7"6($-#$ 0".7%9 7+"(7% "0 6"#(&$(7 6-$%.(-2(&$ 9%$%.6(#(&6 ". &3(.($F-2S
(&$ 9F-2(&$ 0.%%9"6> !"66"# &%#&% 9(7$-$%& `2($%.-221a4 &(#7% 6"#(&$(7 6-$%.(S
-2(&6 (& 9%$%.6(#(&6B -#9 &(#7% 8% 6F&$ 3.%&%.'% $+% 3+%#"6%#- "0
0.%%9"6B $+%# 8% 6F&$ 3-1 $+% 3.(7% "0 - &3(.($F-2(&$ 9F-2(&6> *+% #%8
6-$%.(-2(&6 "0 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( %&7-3%& $+(& 0".7%9 7+"(7% H1 7.($(_F% "0
($& +12"6".3+(7 3.%&F33"&($("#&>
[%K-#9-;& 8".T "# 7"632%V($1 $+%".1 $+F& "00%.& F& $+% 0"22"8(#/ 8-1 "0
/2"&&(#/ [%2%FA%;& $%.6(#"2"/1 (# L"?*/ "2 A$&%$ `[%2%FA% )XXIa> *.-($B &(#/FS
2-.($1 -#9 U'%#$ `5%6(&&("# "0 &(#/F2-.($(%&;aB 2(#% F3 ."F/+21 8($+ $+-$ "0
H%+-'("F. 3-$$%.#B -$$.-7$". -#9 H(0F.7-$".> *+% $%.6& -9"3$%9 H1 [%2%FA%h
^F-$$-.( (# 7DE -.% &2(/+$21 9(00%.%#$B 8($+ 5H2-7T +"2%; #-6(#/ 5-$$.-7$".;
-#9 52(#% "0 02(/+$; #-6(#/ 5H(0F.7-$".;> WF.$+%.B 8% 7-# &%% $+% Z8L -&
6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8B -#9 $+% 5QH&$.-7$ E-7+(#%; -& $+% &%$ "0 &%20S"./-#(&(#/
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"'& E)"#$F* )?)
3."7%&&%& (#+%.%#$ (# $+-$ 02"8 -#9 %00%7$F-$%9 H1 '-.("F& 7"#7.%$% &"7(-2
-&&%6H2-/%&B -& 0". %V-632% $+% 8-. 6-7+(#% 9.-8(#/ - 2(#% "0 02(/+$ H1
9%7"9(#/ -#9 9%$%..($".(-2(&(#/ - 02"8 -#9 "77F31(#/ - &6""$+ &3-7%B $+-$ (&B
8-.9(#/ "00 $.-#&7%#9%#$ ".9%.(#/ $" -22"8 (66-#%#$ &%20S"./-#(&-$("#>
Q0$%. $+% &7-#$1 #-$F.% "0 $+(& 3.%2(6(#-.1B $+% 0"22"8(#/ 6-$%.(-2(&$ $.%-$S
6%#$ "0 0-&7(&$ #(+(2(&6 7-# "#21 H% 3."'(&("#-2> ="#%$+%2%&&B 8% 7-# &-1
$+-$ H"$+ $+% 3."2(0%.-$("# "0 6(7."SH2-7T +"2%& -#9 -$$%#9-#$ 6F2$($F9% "0
8-.S6-7+(#%& `$+% 7-#7%."F& Z8L "0 6(7."0-&7(&6a -#9 $+% &F(7(9-2 2(#% "0
02(/+$ `$+% 8-. 6-7+(#% $+-$ +-& $-T%# "'%. $+% ,$-$% -#9 3"&($%9 8-. -& ($&
"#21 "HR%7$a -.% -6%#-H2% $" 6-$%.(-2(&$ %V32-#-$("#&>
*+% 7-#7%."F& Z8L "0 6(7."0-&7(&6 "77F.& 8($+ - &%9(6%#$-$("# .-$% $+-$
"'%.8+%26& $+% -.$(7F2-$".1 3"8%. "0 $+% &$.-$F6> Y# 3"2($(7-2 $%.6&B 6(7."S
0-&7(&6 "77F.& 8+%# $+% &%2%7$(#/ "0 +"6"/%#(&%9 (#9('(9F-2& &F.3-&&%& $+%
"'%.7"9(#/ 3"8%. "0 $+% ,$-$% &" $+-$ $+%&% 2-8S-H(9(#/ (#9('(9F-2& 7"6% $"
%#0".7% $+%(. "8# 2-8& (# - 3."2(0%.-$("# "0 7"66-#9 7%#$.%& $+-$ (#+(H($&
,$-$% 0".6-$("#> Y# 7"632%V($1 $+%".1 $%.6&B (# 6(7."0-&7(&6 $+% &"7(-2
&1&$%6 .%-7+%& - 3"(#$ 8+%.%H1 - 3."2(0%.-$("# "0 -$$.-7$".& 0.-/6%#$& $+%
&1&$%6 (#$" 6F$F-221 7"66F#(7-$(#/ HF$ (#9%3%#9%#$ &%7$".&> M%.% $+%.% (&
#" .%&"#-#7% (# - /(-#$ -$$.-7$".B HF$ "#21 $+% &$-$(7 "0 6-#1 &6-22 -$$.-7S
$".&> E(7."0-&7(&6 (& $+% H"91 3"2($(7 $+-$ 6"'%& 0.%#%$(7-221 8($+"F$ /"(#/
-#18+%.%>
*+% &F(7(9-2 2(#% "0 02(/+$ "0 0-&7(&6 "77F.& 8+%# - 8-. 6-7+(#% 7-3$F.%& ,$-$% -33-.-$F& -#9 $F.#& $" 8-.> Y# 3"2($(7-2 $%.6&B $+(& (& $+% %#9 /-6% (#
8+(7+ - 0-&7(&$ .%/(6%B 8+(7+ +-& &F77%%9%9 (# 6"H(2(&(#/ $+% 6(7."0-&7(&$
3."2(0%.-$("#B &-7.(0(7%& ($&%20 %'%# -0$%. ($& 9%0%-$ (# - 8-. (& 7%.$-(#> Y#
7"632%V($1 $+%".1 $%.6&B 8% 7-# &-1 $+-$ +%.% $+% &"7(-2 &1&$%6 +-& h -0$%.
%&7-3(#/ $+% 0F$(2($1 "0 $+% &$-$(7 A"#% "0 $"" 6-#1 6(7."-$$.-7$".& `6(7."S
0-&7(&6aB -#9 -0$%. -'"(9(#/ $+% &%20S7"#&%.'(#/ H-&(# "0 -$$.-7$("# "0 $+%
$"$-2($-.(-# &$-$% (# 8+(7+ &FHS7"66-#9 3"&$& .%&"#-$% -#9 -632(01 - 7%#S
$.-2 -$$.-7$". ". 5/(-#$ H2-7T +"2%; h 0-22%# (#&$%-9 (#$" - A"#% "0 7"632%$%
9(&".9%.> Y# "$+%. h 61$+"2"/(7-2 h 8".9&B $+% &F(7(9-2 2(#% "0 02(/+$ +-&
-'"(9%9 $+% ,7122- "0 6(7."0-&7(&6 -#9 $+% !+-.1H(9(& "0 $"$-2($-.(-#(&6B
"#21 $" 0-22 (#$" $+% '"(9 "0 !+-"&>
W(#-221B $" 7"632%$% $+(& &%7$("#B 8+-$ (& - 6-$%.(-2(&$ -77"F#$ "0 $+%
5.%-2(&%9 #(+(2(&6; "0 0-&7(&6i Y$ (& .%2-$('%21 %-&1 $" &%% $+% &F(7(9-2 2(#% "0
02(/+$ -& - .%-2(&%9 #(+(2(&64 ($ (& $+% 3F&+(#/ "0 $+% &"7(-2 H"91 (#$" #"$+(#/S
#%&&> Y#&$%-9 "0 - 7-.%0F2 9%&$.-$(0(7-$("# $" &%$ 6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8(#/ (#
(66-#%#$ &%20S"./-#(&-$("# `$+% 0F22 Z8LaB 9%&$.-$(0(7-$("# ($&%20 h $+%
9%7"9(#/ -#9 9%$%..($".(-2(&(#/ 2(#% "0 02(/+$ h H%7"6%& $+% /"-2m $+% 8-.
6-7+(#% -(6& -$ 8-.B $+% %63$1 Z8L H%7"6%& .%-2(&%9 $+."F/+ 8-. .-$+%.
$+-# 9%3.%&&("#> Q &"2-.B 02-6(#/B #(+(2(&6 .-$+%. $+-# 2F#-. 9%3.%&&('%
0.%%A(#/>
*+% -9R%7$('% 5.%-2(&%9; (& (63".$-#$ (# F#9%.&$-#9(#/ 0-&7(&$ #(+(2(&64 -&
$+% 9(&7F&&("# (# <$)?%"&*%5 6-T%& 72%-.B $+% 3"&&(H2% (& .%-2(&%9B 8+(2% $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)?< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
'(.$F-2 (& -7$F-2(&%9 `[%2%FA% )X??B XCa> Y#&$%-9 "0 T%%3(#/ $+% Z8L (#
.%&%.'% `5+-'% - &6-22 32"$ "0 #%8 2-#9 -$ -22 $(6%&; r[%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.(
)X?CB )N)sa -& - 0(%29 "0 '(.$F-2 3"$%#$(-2& &"6% "0 8+(7+ 7"F29 H% -7$F-2(&%9
"# "77-&("# -& - 7-F$("F&21 %V3%.(6%#$-2 &+-T% F3B &F(7(9-2 0-&7(&6 .%-2(&%&
$+% 3F.% 02"8B H.(#/& ($ 0".$+ 0."A%# (# .%-2($1> ZF$ $+(& .%-2(&-$("# (& (63"&S
&(H2%4 -& [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 57-F$("F&21; #"$%B - &1&$%6 7-##"$ &F.'('% 8($+"F$
- Z8LB HF$ ($ -2&" 7-##"$ 2('% Q, - Z8L %($+%.> *+%.% 6F&$ H% &"6% "./-#(&-S
$("# "0 $+% H"91 3"2($(7B 0". $+% Z8L (& #"$+(#/B #"S$+(#/> Y$ (& 3.(". $" -22
9%$%.6(#-$% "./-#(&-$("#B 0". ($ (& $+% 6-$$%.h%#%./1 02"8 -#9 &%20S"./-#(&S
(#/ 7-3-7($1 "0 "./-#(&%9 H"9(%&> W". ($ $" H% .%-2(&%9 8"F29 H% $" .%-2(&% #"S
$+(#/> ,F(7(9-2B &"2-.B ,$-$% 0-&7(&6 (& - .%-2(&(#/ "0 #"S$+(#/B - .%-2(&%9
#(+(2(&6>
9$,1"<-#$,P D/-1#-% ,#+#"#-= ,$4S
M"8 9"%& $+(& .%7-3($F2-$("# "0 7DE `8.($$%# (# $+% 6(9 $" 2-$% )XCI&a +%23
F& F#9%.&$-#9 $+% 7"#$%63".-.1 `2-$% )XXI&a &($F-$("# 8($+ .%/-.9 $" 0-&7(&$
#(+(2(&6i W(.&$B $8" 7"#7%3$F-2 9(00(7F2$(%& #%%9 $" H% 72%-.%9 F3B 7"#7%.#(#/
$+% $13% "0 53"2($(7-2 &7(%#7%; [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 3F.&F% -#9 $+% &$-$F& "0
+(&$".1 (# 7DEq $+%# 8% 7-# 7"#&(9%. $+% 3"&($('% -77"632(&+6%#$& "0 7DE
(# -99.%&&(#/ 0-&7(&$ #(+(2(&6>
*" %'-2F-$% 7DE;& F&%0F2#%&& (# F#9%.&$-#9(#/ 7"#$%63".-.1 0-&7(&$ #(+(2S
(&6B 8% 6F&$ 0(.&$ H% 72%-. 8+-$ $+%1 -.% 9"(#/> 7DE H.(#/& (#$" &+-.3 .%2(%0
$+% 9(00%.%#7% H%$8%%# $13%& "0 53"2($(7-2 &7(%#7%; `$+% &$F91 "0 3"2($(7&B -#9
$+% 3"2($(7& "0 &7(%#7%a> [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( #-6% $+%6 ,$-$% ". ."1-2 &7(%#7%
-#9 #"6-9 &7(%#7%> *+% 0".6%. (& -# -V("6-$(7]$+%".%6-$(7 -33."-7+
8+(7+ (&"2-$%& 7"#&$-#$& 0."6 '-.(-H2%& $" 9%'%2"3 2-8& /"'%.#(#/ 3+%#"6S
%#-m $+% 2-$$%. (& - 3."H2%6-$(7& %V%632(0(%9 H1 6%$-22F./(&$&B 8+" $.%-$
'-.(-H2%& H1 3F$$(#/ $+%6 (#$" 7"#$(#F"F& '-.(-$("# `%&$-H2(&+(#/ -22 $+%(.
.-#/%& 8($+"F$ 3.('(2%/(#/ "#% -& $+% &$-#9-.9 ". 7"#&$-#$a -#9 $+%# 5$.-7T;
$+% &(#/F2-.($(%& `'(.$F-2 $+.%&+"29&a -#9 $.-($& `-7$F-2 H%+-'("F.&a "0 - 6-$%.S
(-2 &1&$%6> ="6-9 &7(%#7% $.%-$& $+% 56-7+(#(7 3+12F6;B $+% 7"#'%./%#7% "0
&(#/F2-.($(%& -#9 $.-($& (# '-.("F& 5-&&%6H2-/%&; $+-$ %00%7$F-$% &%$& "0 "3%.-S
$("#& $+-$ -7$F-2(&% $+% 3"$%#$(-2& "0 6-$$%. (# 3-.$(7F2-. $.-($&>
="8 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(;& $.%-$6%#$ "0 0-&7(&6 (& #"6-9(74 $+%1 9"#;$ 3.%S
$%#9 $" 2-1 "F$ %$%.#-2 7"#9($("#& 0". 0-&7(&6B -& (0 ($ 8%.% - 32-$"#(7 (9%-B 3"&&(H(2($1 $" H% .%-2(&%9 (0 "#21 $+% 3."3%. 52-8&; "0 3"2($(7& -.% "H%1%9>
G-$+%.B $+% #"6-9 3"2($(7-2 &7(%#7% "0 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 7"#&(&$& (# $.-7T(#/
$+% 56-7+(#(7 3+12F6; "0 0-&7(&64 $+% 8-1& (# 8+(7+ $+% 3"$%#$(-2& (#+%.%#$
(# +F6-# 56-$$%.; `$+% 3"$%#$(-2& "0 +F6-# H%+-'("F. $-33%9 (#$" H1 &"7(-2
$.-(#(#/aB 7-# H% -..-#/%9 &" $+-$ - 7%.$-(# +F6-# H%+-'("F. H%7"6%& $+%
7"#$%#$ 0". $+% %V3.%&&("# "0 - 0-&7(&$ 8-. 6-7+(#%> *+%1 -&TB (# "$+%. 8".9&B
-H"F$ $+% 7"#&$.F7$("# "0 - 0-&7(&$ -&&%6H2-/%B $+% 8-1 (# 8+(7+ - &"7(-2
6-7+(#% $-3& (#$" +F6-# 3"$%#$(-2& H1 7"#&$.F7$(#/ - 3%9-/"/1 $+-$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"'& E)"#$F* )?@
3."9F7%& 0-&7(&$ (#9('(9F-2&)I -#9 $+%# 6"H(2(&%& $+%6B ."F&(#/ $+%6 0."6
$+%(. 6(7."0-&7(&$ HFAA (#$" - 8-. 6-7+(#% 7-3-H2% "0 -33."3.(-$(#/ - ,$-$%>
,%7"#9B 8% 6F&$ H% 72%-. -H"F$ $+% +(&$".(7($1 "0 $+% +(&$".(7-2S2(H(9(#-2
6-$%.(-2(&6 "0 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( -#9 +"8 ($ %#$-(2& $+%(. .%2-$('%21 /.%-$%.
7"#7%.# 8($+ 6(7."0-&7(&6 $+-# 8($+ $+% 0-&7(&$ ,$-$%> *+% 57F..%#$ &($F-S
$("#; -99.%&&%9 (# 7DE (& "0 7"F.&% $+-$ "0 $+% 2-$% )XCI&B "0 EF$F-2 Q&&F.%9
[%&$.F7$("# `EQ[aB $+-$ (&B $+% 3%-7% "0 #F72%-. $%..".> ="8 %'%.1$+(#/
-H"F$ [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(;& 8".T 9(&&F-9%& F& 0."6 $%2%"2"/(&(#/ $+-$ &$-2%S
6-$%4 $+%1 T#%8 -& 8%22 -& -#1"#% $+-$ $+% &($F-$("# $+%1 9(-/#"&%9 8-&
#"$ $+% %#9 "0 +(&$".1B (# 2-./% 3-.$ H%7-F&% 0". [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( +(&$".1 (&
"#21 $+% $.-#&0".6-$("# "0 7"%V(&$%#7% (#$" &F77%&&("# `D@Ia> *+% (63".$-#$
$+(#/ (& -28-1& $+% 6-3B $+% H-2-#7% "0 0".7%& $+-$ %00%7$F-$%& $+% QH&$.-7$
E-7+(#% "0 7"9(#/B 9%7"9(#/B "'%.7"9(#/ (# -&&%6H2-/%& $+-$ -.% -$ "#7%
$.(H%&B 8-. 6-7+(#%& -#9 ,$-$%&> M"8%'%.B (# 3.('(2%/(#/ 5/%"/.-3+1; `9.-8S
(#/ 6-3&a "'%. +(&$".1B [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 9" #"$ #%/2%7$ $+% 2-$$%.> G%7"/#(&S
(#/ $+% 7"%V(&$%#7% "0 -&3%7$& "0 $+% QH&$.-7$ E-7+(#% %2(6(#-$%& $+%
9-#/%.& "0 %'"2F$("#(&6 (# %$+#"/.-3+(7 3"2($(7-2 &7(%#7%B -/-(#&$ 8+(7+
$+%1 3"2%6(7(&% .%2%#$2%&&21 `@JXaB HF$ $+(& 9"%& #"$ %#$-(2 - #%/2%7$ "0
+(&$".1> *" 9.-8 - 6-3 "0 $+% 7F..%#$ &($F-$("# (& #"$ RF&$ $" 2"7-$% -&3%7$&
"0 $+% QH&$.-7$ E-7+(#%B HF$ $" %&$(6-$% $+%(. .%2-$('% &$.%#/$+& -#9 3"$%#S
$(-2& 0". -7$F-2(&(#/ - &+(0$ (# 0".7%&> Q#9 $+(& 7-# "#21 H% 9"#% (# $.-7(#/ $+%
9%'%2"36%#$ "0 $+% 7F..%#$ &($F-$("# h (# "$+%. 8".9&B H1 9"(#/ +(&$".1>
,"B (# 3."9F7(#/ - F#('%.&-2 +(&$".1 "0 0".6& "0 $+% ,$-$% `DJXm DNNhCaB
[%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( (&"2-$% $+% 0-&7(&$ 6"6%#$ -& &"6%$+(#/ "'%. -#9 9"#%
8($+> f-.("F& -#-21&%& (# P2-$%-F )@4 *+% Q33-.-$F& "0 !-3$F.% -22"8 F& $"
&%% 8+1 $+%.% (& #" 6".% .""6 0". - 0-&7(&$ 8-.S6-7+(#%S,$-$%> Y# &" 0-. -&
0-&7(&6 7"#&$.F7$& - $"$-2($-.(-# &$-$%B ($ (& 6"$('-$%9 H1 $+% 9%&(.% 0".
-F$-.T1B 0". &FH$.-7$("# 0."6 /2"H-2 02"8& `<<@a> Y$ &%%6& #"8 $+-$ 7-3($-2
02"8& -.% $"" 0-&$ -#9 $"" H(/ 0". $+-$ 3."R%7$ %'%# $" H% H."-7+%9B %'%# (0 8-. 6-7+(#% 8%.% $" H% 0".6%9 0."6 6(7."0-&7(&6&> Q2$+"F/+ $+%1 .%0.-(#
0."6 3F$$(#/ ($ &"B [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( -22"8 F& $" 3"&($ $+-$ 7-3($-2 (& ($&%20
#"8 - 8-.S6-7+(#%B "77F31(#/ $+% 8".29 -& &6""$+ &3-7%B -H2% $" 3"3 F3 -$
-#1 32-7% -$ (#0(#($% &3%%9 `DJ@hDa> Q#1 -$$%63$ -$ - 572"&%9 '%&&%2;B -$ 9"6%&$(7 6-.T%$ "0 6)%9#@ `DN@aB 8"F29 H% 2-F/+-H2% /('%# $+% -H(2($1 "0
7-3($-2 $" 9(&%#$-#/2% ($&%20 0."6 -#1 $""S&%20S-&&%.$('% .%$%..($".(-2(&(#/
-$$%63$& "0 ,$-$%&> Y$ (& #"$ $+-$ 7-3($-2 +-& 7"632%$%21 &F.3-&&%9 $+% ,$-$%B
HF$ $+-$ ,$-$%& -.% 2(6($%9 $" H%(#/ $+% 56"9%2& "0 .%-2(&-$("#; "0 $+% -V("S
6-$(7 "0 7-3($-2(&6 `DJDaB $+-$ (&B $+-$ ,$-$%& #"8 -.% "#21 $+% 32-7%& 8+%.%
$+% -H&$.-7$ 6"6%#$& "0 7-3($-2B $+% 9%$%..($".(-2(&%9 -#9 9%7"9%9 02"8& "0
2-H"F. -#9 7-3($-2B 7-# 6%%$ `DJJa> *+% +(&$".(7-2 6"6%#$ "0 $+% 0-&7(&$ ,$-$%
(& 0(#(&+%94 #"$ 0".%'%.B 3%.+-3&B HF$ 0". $+% 0".%&%%-H2% 0F$F.%B /('%# $+%
7F..%#$ &($F-$("# "0 7-3($-2(&6> *+% .%-2 3."H2%6 (& 6(7."0-&7(&6>
O($+ $+%&% $8" 7"#7%3$F-2 9(00(7F2$(%& 72-.(0(%9B 2%$ F& 7"#&(9%. $+% -77"6S
32(&+6%#$& "0 7DE .%/-.9(#/ "F. F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 0-&7(&$ #(+(2(&6> W(.&$B ($
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)?D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
0".7%0F221 .%6(#9& F& $+-$ #(+(2(&6 h (# 6-$%.(-2(&$ $%.6&B -# ".(%#$-$("# $"
A%." (#$%#&($1 h +-& $8" '%7$".&4 2F#-.B 5!+.(&$(-#; #(+(2(&64 9%&7%#9(#/B
0.%%A(#/B 9%3.%&&('%B 3-.-#"(9 h $+% $13% 9(-/#"&%9 H1 =(%$A&7+%m -#9 &"2-.B
0-&7(&$h=-A( #(+(2(&64 -&7%#9(#/B HF.#(#/B 6-#(7B 5&7+(A"; h $+% $13% 9(-/S
#"&%9 H1 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(> M%#7% "F. (#($(-2 _F-#9-.1 "'%. $+% /-3
H%$8%%# $+% =(%$A&7+%-# 7"#$%V$ -#9 $+% [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( 7"#$%V$ "0 #(+(2S
(&6 -& -# -33."3.(-$% 2-H%2 0". =-$("#-2 ,"7(-2(&6 +-& H%%# .%&"2'%9>
,%7"#921B 8% T#"8 $+-$ 7"#$%63".-.1 6(7."0-&7(&6& -H"F#9> *+% 7"#S
7%3$F-2 -33-.-$F& "0 7DE -22"8& F& $" -&T 8+-$ 7"#9($("#& +-'% T%3$ $+%6
0."6 0".6(#/ - 8-.S6-7+(#% 7-3-H2% "0 $-T(#/ "'%. - ,$-$%> O% 6(/+$ &-1
$+-$ 6(7."0-&7(&6&B -& 2"#/ -& $+%1 -.% (&"2-$%9 (# $+% 5.F6H2% -#9 HFAA; "0
6"2%7F2-.($1B -.% .%2-$('%21 5+-.62%&&; (# ,$-$%h3"2($(7-2 $%.6&B %'%# 8+%#
$+%1 .%-7+ $+% 6(2$(-S2%'%2 -& (# &"6% 3-.$& "0 $+% \,Q> P%.+-3& ($ (& 2(H%.-2
(#&$($F$("#& `(# %($+%. $+%(. 9(&7(32(#-.1 ". 57"#$."2; -&3%7$&a `[%2%FA% )XXJB
)CC00a $+-$ T%%3 $+%6 0."6 "./-#(&(#/ $+%6&%2'%& (#$" - 8-.S6-7+(#% 8($+ '(-H2% 7+-#7% -$ -33."3.(-$(#/ - ,$-$% "0 $+%(. "8#i O($+ #" 6"'%6%#$
"./-#(&(#/ $+% 6(7."0-&7(&6&B $+%.% (& #" 9)/'$ "0 - 0-&7(&$ 8-.S6-7+(#%h
,$-$%B RF&$ -& &6""$+ 7-3($-2 +-& 3.%'%#$%9 ($& #$4"%R $+% 572"&%9 '%&&%2;>
*+(.9B 7DE +%23& F& F#9%.&$-#9 5$+% 0".6%. oF/"&2-'(-; -& -# (#&$-#7% "0
0-&7(&$ #(+(2(&6> O% &%% +%.% $+% %$+#(7 3F.($1 -7+(%'%9 $+."F/+ '("2%#7%
-#9 -33-.%#$21 $+% 0".6-$("# "0 - &F(7(9-2 ,$-$%> O% -2&"B -./F-H21B &%%
6-7."3"2($(7-2 (#$%.'%#$("# H1 7-3($-2(&$ ,$-$%& $" 3.%'%#$ $+% 0".6-$("# "0
- 572"&%9 '%&&%2; ". -F$-.T1 (# $+% .%/("# `Y 8.($% $+(& 9F.(#/ $+% =Q*L
H"6H(#/& "0 E-.7+ )XXXB -#9 -6 "0 7"F.&% 9(&7"F#$(#/ $+% +F6-#($-.(-#
7-#$ "0 5&-'(#/ $+% %$+#(7 Q2H-#(-#& "0 b"&"'";4 &F7+ PG &$-32%& -.% &(6321
#"$ - 7.%9(H2% %V32-#-$("# "0 6(2($-.1 (#$%.'%#$("#m (0 $+%1 8%.%B $+%#
G8-#9- ". U-&$ *(6". ". &7".%& "0 "$+%. 32-7%& 8"F29 +-'% &%%# &F7+ (#$%.S
'%#$("#a> EF7+ 6".% 8".T $+-# Y -6 -H2% $" 3."'(9% 8"F29 +-'% $" H% 9"#%B
+"8%'%.B $" &F33".$ [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(;& $+%&%& -H"F$ $+% .%2-$("#& "0 6(7."S
-#9 6-7."0-&7(&6 (# $+(& 7-&%> ="#%$+%2%&&B 8% 9" &%% &"6% "0 $+%(. $+%&%&
0-&7(&$ #(+(2(&6 F3+%29B %&3%7(-221 $+% $F.#(#/ -8-1 0."6 0-&7(&6 #(+(2(&6 "#
$+% 3-.$ "0 7-3($-2(&$ ,$-$%&B 8+" .%7"/#(&% $+% F$(2($1 "0 ,$-$% .%$%..($".(-2(&-S
$("#h-& "33"&%9 $" $+% 9%$%..($".(-2(&(#/ %00%7$& "0 $+% &F(7(9-2 ,$-$%h(# 3."S
'(9(#/ - &$-H2% (#$%.#-$("#-2 HF&(#%&& %#'(."#6%#$ `DJJa>
W"F.$+B 2-&$21B 7DE &+"8& +"8 $+% .%&(&$-#7% $" 0-&7(&6 6F&$ H% -& 6F7+
6(7."2"/(7-2 -#9 6(7."3"2($(7-2 -& ($ (& -2&" 6-7."2"/(7-2> Q& 8% +-'% &%%#B
0". [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( B 5%'%.1 3"2($(7& (& &(6F2$-#%"F&21 - 6-7."3"2($(7& -#9 6(7."3"2($(7&; `<)@a> *+% 6-7."3"2($(7-2 .%&(&$-#7% $" 0-&7(&6B $+% 3.%'%#$("#
"0 $+% 0".6-$("# "0 - 0-&7(&$ ,$-$%B 7-# #%'%. H% &-(9 $" H% "'%. -#9 9"#%
8($+B HF$ 0". $+%6 ($ 9"%& &%%6 $" H% - 6-$$%. $+% 7-3($-2(&$ -V("6-$(7 +-&
8%22 (# +-#9 -$ $+% 3.%&%#$ $(6%> *+(& 7"#72F&("#B "0 7"F.&%B #%%9& 7"#&$-#$
$%&$(#/ -#9 .%_F(.%& - 3.-/6-$(7 02%V(H(2($1 (# .%'(&(#/ ($ 8+%# #%%9%9> ="#%S
#$+%2%&& [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( &+(0$ $+%(. -$$%#$("# $" $+% 6(7."3"2($7-2> ="8B
[%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(;& 7-22 $" 2""T $" $+% 50-&7(&$ 8($+(# 1"F; (& 0-. 0."6 -#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
8"'& E)"#$F* )?J
5(#9('(9F-2(&$; .%$.%-$ 0."6 3"2($(7&> G-$+%.B 6(7."0-&7(&6 -& 56"2%7F2-.
6"2-.($1;B -& .F#-8-1 &%9(6%#$-$("#B (& 3.%7(&%21 $+% 7.%-$("# "0 (#9('(9F-2&>
7DEB (# &+".$B .%0"7F&%& $+% &$.F//2% 0."6 - 0-&7(&$ ,$-$% -$ 8+"&% 3.%$%#&("#&
7-3($-2 8"F29 "#21 2-F/+B $" 6(7."0-&7(&6B $+% 3."9F7$("# "0 (#9('(9F-2($1>
*+F& [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( -2&" &+(0$ $+% &$.F//2% "#$" $+% 2%0$4 6(7."0-&7(&6
3.%'%#$& - 3."/.%&&('% 8-.S6-7+(#% 0."6 0".6(#/ -& 8%22 -& 2(H%.-2 (#&$($FS
$("#& 3.%'%#$ - 0-&7(&$ 8-. 6-7+(#% 0."6 6"H(2(&(#/> *+% 3."/.%&&('%
8-.S6-7+(#%B - 3."/.%&&('% .%'"2F$("#-.1 6"'%6%#$B (& H2"7T%9 -& 2"#/ -&
7"#$%63".-.1 53."/.%&&('%&; (#&(&$ "# 7-22(#/ 0". (#9('(9F-2 .(/+$& -#9
.%7"/#($("#> *+(& (& "#21 (#$%.%&$ /."F3 2"HH1(#/ 0". - #%8 -V("6B - #%8
9(&3%#&-$("# "0 7-3($-2> *+% &$.F//2% 6F&$ H% $" 3.%'%#$ $+% -V("6-$(7
&$.F//2% `8+(7+ [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( '-2(9-$% rDCIh)sa 0."6 H%7"6(#/ %($+%. 3."$"S0-&7(&$ +(%.-.7+1 `$+% 3-.$1 8(22 $%22 1"F 8+%# 1"F;.% 0.%%a ". 2(H%.-2
(#$%/.-$("# `/('% F& "F. -V("6& -#9 8%;22 H%+-'%a> QV("6-$(7 &$.F//2% 6F&$
H% $+% &$.F//2% $" .%2%-&% - 0".7% "0 6(#".($-.(-#(&-$("# $+-$ 8"F29 #"$ RF&$
7+-#/% $+% /.(9 $" (#72F9% - 0%8 6".% 3"(#$& "0 (9%#$(0(7-$("# "0 (#9('(9F-2&
8($+ .(/+$&B #". 8"F29 9.%-6 $+% &8%%$ F$"3(-# 9.%-6 "0 -# %2(6(#-$("# "0
/.(9& -2$"/%$+%. `". $+% #"$S&"S&8%%$ 91&$"3(7 9.%-6 "0 $+% &6""$+ &3-7% "0
/2"H-2 &%7F.($1 0".7%& h 5#%'%. H%2(%'% $+-$ - &6""$+ &3-7% 8(22 &F00(7% $" &-'%
F&; rJIIsaB HF$ 8"F29 (#7.%-&% $+% 0".7% "0 &6""$+(#/ .%2-$('% $" $+-$ "0
/.(99(#/> *+(& (& #" 3.%&7.(3$("#B HF$ "#21 - +(#$ -& $" +"8 $" 9.-8 "F.
"8# 6-3&>
*" 9" RF&$(7% $" [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.(;& (#&(&$%#7% "# 3"&($('($1B 8% &+"F29 &-1
$+-$ $+% H%&$ .%&(&$-#7% $" 6(7."0-&7(&6 (& #"$ &(6321 $" .%&(&$B HF$ -2&" $" 9"
"$+%.8(&%> *+(& 9"%& #"$ 6%-# #"#S.%&(&$-#7% -& 7.-'%# -7_F(%&7%#7%B HF$B
"'%. -#9 -H"'% .%&(&$-#7%B $+% 3"&($('% 3."9F7$("# "0 #%8 #%$8".T& "0
(66-#%#7%B 0"22"8(#/ 2(#%& "0 02(/+$ "F$ "0 $+% 6"2-. 7-$%/".(%& +-#9%9 F&
H1 6-7."3"2($(7&> G%&(&$-#7% (& .%-7$('%B [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( (6321 (# "#% "0
$+%(. 0%8 7.($(7(&6& "0 W"F7-F2$m 2(#%& "0 02(/+$ -.% -6"#/ $+% 3.(6-.1 %2%S
6%#$& "0 - 9(-/.-6 `J@Ih)B #@Xa> ZF$ -/-(#B %V3%.(6%#$-$("# "# 2(#%& "0
02(/+$ (& #"$ (#9('(9F-2(&$(7m $+% T%1 (& 0".6(#/ #"#S"./-#(&6(7 H"9(%&> O% (#
U#/2(&+ 9"#;$ +-'% $+% (66%9(-$% &%#&% "0 /")I% -& &"7(-2 H"91 $+-$ +%23& $+%
W.-#7"3+"#% .%-9%. "0 [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( F#9%.&$-#9 $+% 3"2($(7-2 (63".$ "0
/")I% %9&% ")?9&$%> *+% H"91 8($+"F$ "./-#&B ". H%$$%.B $+% #"#S"./-#(&6(7
/")I%R (& - &"7(-2 H"91 "0 (66-#%#$ .%2-$("#&B - 32-7% 0". H%7"6(#/& .-$+%.
$+-# +(%.-.7+(%&4 - 9-$%B - 7"#'%.&-$("#B - &%6(#-.B - 7".3& "0 `6%$-22F./(7-2a
%#/(#%%.& 8($+"F$ "00(7%.&B - 6"'%6%#$B - 6-7+(#% $" /%#%.-$% 6(#".($(%&B
$" /%#%.-$% H%7"6(#/& $+-$ 7-##"$ H% 7"F#$%9 8($+ 6"2-. 7-$%/".(%& `+"8
9" 1"F 7"F#$ 5&"6%"#%; 8+" (& H2-7T Q=[ 8+($%B /-1 Q=[ &$.-(/+$ > > > iaB #"#9%#F6%.-H2% 6-&&> ="$ $+% 3."72-6-$("# $+-$ "#% 5(9%#$(0(%&; 8($+ $+%
&$.F//2%& "0 6(#".($(%&B $+"&% 7"F#$%9 F#9%. 7%.$-(# 7-$%/".(%&B HF$ 6(#".S
($(&-$("#B $+% 3."9F7$("# "0 $+"&% 8+" 9" #"$ %'%# 0($ $+% $".$F.%9 &$"3S/-3
7-$%/".(%& "0 56(V%9 .-7%; -#9 5H(&%VF-2;> Z2"8(#/ -3-.$ $+% 6"2-. 7-$%/".(%&
"0 $+% 7%#&F&S$-T%.&> *(/%. O""9&B $+% F#7"F#$-H2%B $+% F##-6%-H2%>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)?N !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
8"'& E)"#$F* )?C
O-..%# Z%-$$1;& /.%-$ ,%#-$". ZF28".$+4 58%;22 RF&$ +-'% $" 0F7T %-7+ "$+%.
F#$(2 8%;.% -22 H%(/% `H2-7T8+($%1%22"8a;> P."9F7% - #%$8".T "0 Q6-A"#S
8(63&B "0 /(.21S6%#B "0 8-&3S".7+(9&> *+% 3"2($(7& "0 ;N? 8($+"F$ &+-6%>))
)
<
@
D
J
N
C
?
X
)I
))
*+% 7Q '&> 7DE $.%-$6%#$ "0 0-&7(&6 (& 9(&7F&&%9 (# Z%-&2%1SEF..-1 )XXJ>
L# $+% 7-F$("# "0 7DEB &%% K-#9 )XX@>
E-1 )XX) 72-(6& 52(0%; -& $+% 57".% &$.F7$F.%; 0". [%2%FA%>
[% K-#9- `)XXCB <XI#?<a 3."3"&%& - 7"..%7$("# "0 []^ -$ $+(& 3"(#$B 9(00%.%#$(-$S
(#/ 50"29(#/; 0."6 57%6%#$-$("#;B 8+(7+ 3."3%.21 H%2"#/& 8($+ 5&%9(6%#$-$("#;>
5W"29(#/; (& $+%# &-(9 $" -77"63-#1 5-77F6F2-$("#; "# -#"$+%. 3+1&(7-2 &7-2%>
*+(& $%.6 (& #"$ (# 7F..%#$ F&-/% -6"#/ 8".T(#/ &7(%#$(&$& h 8+" 3.%0%. 5#"#2(#%-.
91#-6(7&; h HF$ +-& /-(#%9 %#"F/+ 7F..%#71 (# 53"3F2-. &7(%#7%; $.%-$6%#$& $"
8-..-#$ ($& F&% +%.%>
QH"F$ [%K-#9- `)XX<a #" 2%&& &%'%.% 7.($(7& $+-# P-F2 ^."&& -#9 =".6-# K%'($$
&-14 5r-2$+"F/+s $+%.% (& &"6% 6F992% > > > r($ (&s 3.%$$1 72%-. -#9 &$.-(/+$0".S
8-.9 > > > - /""9 -#9 +"#%&$ R"HB -2$+"F/+ "#% 6(/+$ 8(&+ 0". - 6".% 7-.%0F2
9%2(#%-$("# "0 +"8 6F7+ "0 $+(& (& .%-221 &3%7F2-$('%; `^."&& -#9 K%'($$ )XXDB
<NCh?#)Ca> Q& .%-9%.& "0 >*?'$) A,I$)%#*#*"& 8(22 -$$%&$B $+(& (& 3.-(&% (#9%%9 0."6
^."&& -#9 K%'($$> ,(#7% [%K-#9- %V32(7($21 2(#T& +(& -77"F#$ 8($+ [%2%FA%h^F-$S
$-.(B -#9 &(#7% ^."&& -#9 K%'($$ &"6%8+-$ -33."'% "0 [%K-#9- h -2$+"F/+ -96($S
$%921 8($+"F$ 6%#$("#(#/ [%2%FA%h^F-$$-.( H1 #-6% `$+%1 9" 7"#$%63F"F&21
9(&6(&& [%2%FA%;& $.%-$6%#$ "0 G(%6-## (# +(& (*&$59 &%.(%&B -2$+"F/+ $+%1 9" #"$
6%#$("# $+% &(6(2-. $.%-$6%#$ (# 7DEa h Y -&&F6% $+% 7"##%7$("# "0 [%2%FA%h
^F-$$-.( -#9 7"632%V($1 $+%".1 (& -$ 2%-&$ -# -'%#F% 8".$+ 3F.&F(#/>
O% +-'% $+F& H."-7+%9 $+% _F%&$("# "0 - .%9F7$("# "0 =%8$"#(-# 3+1&(7& 0."6
"#$"2"/1 $" %3(&$%6"2"/1> Q22 8% %'%. %#7"F#$%.B -22 $+-$ %V(&$B -.% "3%# &1&$%6&B
HF$ $.%-$(#/ &"6% "0 $+%6 -& 72"&%9 h 6"9%22(#/ $+%(. H%+-'("F. H1 72"&%9 6"9%2
-#9 2(#%-. %_F-$("#& h 7-# H% $%7+#"2"/(7-221 +%230F2> `Y .%&$.(7$ 61 9(&7F&&("# (#
$+(& 3-3%. $" $+% %3(&$%6"2"/(7-2 '"7-HF2-.1 "0 53.%9(7$-H(2($1; .-$+%. $+-# $+%
"#$"2"/(7-2 '"7-HF2-.1 "0 5(#9%$%.6(#-71;B 0". &(632(7($1;& &-T%B -#9 -& 5$+% H%$$%.
3-.$ "0 '-2".;>a
*+(& (& "0 7"F.&% - $.%6%#9"F&21 &(632(0(%9 -77"F#$ "0 - 8(9%S.-#/(#/B 7"632(S
7-$%9 -#9 7+-#/(#/ &7(%#$(0(7 0(%29> !F..%#$ 8".T +-& 6"'%9 H%1"#9 $+% -$$.-7S
$".hH(0F.7-$". 6"9%2 $" 7"#&(9%. $+% 56F$F-2 H""$&$.-3; %00%7$ H%$8%%# $+%
52-#9&7-3%; "0 - 3-.$(7F2-. 3+-&% &3-7% -#9 $+% &3%7(0(7 $.-R%7$".(%& .%&(9%#$ 8($+(#
($> Y "8% $+(& 72-.(0(7-$("# $" W.-#7(&7" f-.%2- "0 $+% !=G,B P-.(&> ,%% -2&" b-F00S
6-#B )XX@ -#9 )XXJ>
M%.% - 3"&&(H2% .%-9(#/ "0 KF7.%$(F&4 $+% /4*&95$& ". 5&8%.'%; (& $+% 2%-&$ 9%'(-$("#
0."6 $+% 2-6(#-.> *+F& -#7(%#$ ^.%%T -$"6(&$(7 3+1&(7& 8-& - 02F(9 91#-6(7&B #"$
- &"2(9 "#%> ,%% ,%..%& )XCC>
L# $+% '-.("F& 3%9-/"/(%& 3."9F7(#/ H"$+ $+% 6(7."S -#9 6-7."0-&7(&$ H"91B &%%
*+%8%2%($ )X?Ch?X>
E1 $+-#T& /" $" $+% '"2F6% %9($".&B -#9 $" [-'(9 K(#9%#0%29B Q2(&$-(. O%27+6-#B
!+-.2%& ,$('-2%B -#9 Q#9.%8 !F$."0%22" 0". $+%(. 7-.%0F2 7"66%#$& "# %-.2(%.
9.-0$&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
C$%(-
)?? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Z%-&%21SEF..-1B k> `)XXJa 5[%2%FA%B ^F-$$-.(B -#9 $+% MF6-# ,%7F.($1 ,1&$%6;> P-3%.
3.%&%#$%9 -$ $+% -##F-2 6%%$(#/ "0 $+% Y#$%.#-$("#-2 Q&&"7(-$("# "0 P+(2"&"3+1 -#9
K($%.-$F.%B f(22-#"'- \#('%.&($1>
[%K-#9-B E> `)XX)a P9) *& #'$ 7?$ "2 -&#$44*?$&# 39/'*&$%> =%8 o".T4 q"#% Z""T&>
pp `)XX<a 5="#SL./-#(7 K(0%; (# -&/")I")9#*"&%Z =%8 o".T4 q"#% Z""T&> )<?hNC>
pp `)XXCa 7 D'",%9&. g$9)% "2 !"&4*&$9) >*%#")C> =%8 o".T4 q"#% Z""T&>
[%2%FA%B ^> `)X?@a !*$#@%/'$ 9&. E'*4"%"I'C> *.-#&> M> *"62(#&"#> =%8 o".T4 !"2F6H(\#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)X??a <$)?%"&*%5> *.-#&> M> *"62(#&"# -#9 Z> M-HH%.R-6> =%8 o".T4 q"#% Z""T&>
pp `)XXIa D'$ L"?*/ "2 A$&%$> *.-#&> M> K%&$%. 8($+ !> ,$('-2%> U9> !> Z"F#9-&> =%8
o".T4 !"2F6H(- \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp )XXJ> !$?"#*9#*"&%> *.-#&> E> k"F/+(#> =%8 o".T4 !"2F6H(- \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
[%2%FA%B ^> -#9 ^F-$$-.(B W> `)X?@a 7&#*JQ$.*I,%Z *.-#&> G> MF.2%1B E> ,%%6B -#9 M>G>
K-#%> E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
pp `)X?Ca 7 D'",%9&. E49#$9,%Z *.-#&> Z> E-&&F6(> E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(#S
#%&"$- P.%&&>
^."&&B P> -#9 K%'($$B => `)XXDa >*?'$) A,I$)%#*#*"&0 #'$ 7/9.$5*/ L$2# 9&. -#% ],9))$4% =*#'
A/*$&/$> Z-2$(6".%4 k"+#& M"3T(#& \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
M"22-#9B U> `)X?Ca 55Y#$."9F7$("# $" $+% ="#SW-&7(&$ K(0%;;4 [%2%FA% -#9 ^F-$$-.(;&
5 55G%'"2F$("#-.1;; ,%6("$(7&; (# LN6%I)*# ()$M9#$,)Z <C><>
b-F006-#B ,> `)XX@a D'$ Q)*?*&% "2 Q).$)> =%8 o".T4 LV0".9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)XXJa 7# >"5$ *& #'$ [&*F$)%$Z =%8 o".T4 LV0".9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
K-#9B => `)XX@a 5E-T(#/ Y$ 8($+ [%-$+4 G%6-.T& "# *+-#-$"& -#9 [%&(.(#/SP."9F7S
$("#; (# 8",)&94 "2 #'$ <)*#*%' A"/*$#C 2") E'$&"5$&"4"?C> <D>)4 NNhCN>
E-&&F6(B Z> `)XX<a 7 [%$)N% O,*.$ #" (9I*#94*%5 9&. A/'*@"I')$&*9> !-6H.(9/%B EQ4 EY*
P.%&&>
E-1B *> `)XX)a 5*+% P"2($(7& "0 K(0% (# $+% *+"F/+$ "0 ^(22%& [%2%FA%; (# A,+A#9&/$ NN4
<Dh@J>
pp `)XXDa D'$ E"4*#*/94 E'*4"%"I'C "2 E"%#%#),/#,)94*%# 7&9)/'CZ \#('%.&($1 P-.TB PQ4 *+%
P%##&12'-#(- ,$-$% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)XXCa 1$/"&%*.$)*&? B*22$)$&/$> \#('%.&($1 P-.TB PQ4 *+% P%##&12'-#(- ,$-$% \#(S
'%.&($1 P.%&&>
P.(/"/(#%B Y> -#9 ,$%#/%.&B Y> `)X?Da Q).$) Q,# "2 ('9"%> =%8 o".T4 Z-#$-6>
,%..%&B E> `)XCCa !9*%%9&/$ .$ 49 I'C%*V,$ .9&% 4$ #$H#$ ., L,/)$b/$Z P-.(&4 K%& %e9($("#& 9%
E(#F($>
,(6"#9"#> ^> `)XNDa LN*&.*F*., $# %9 ?$&$b%$ I'C%*/"J+*"4"?*V,$> P-.(&> P.%&&%& \#('%.&(S
$-(.%& 9% W.-#7%>
*+%8%2%($B b> `)X?Ch?Xa 394$ :9	%*$%Z < '"2&> *.-#&> ,> !"#8-1B U> !-.$%. -#9 !>
*F.#%.> E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
0(D()(,1(-
X
*+% ,F.'('-2 "0 =(+(2(&6
=(+(2(&$ F#9 !+.(&$ h 9-& .%(6$ &(7+B 9-& .%(6$ &(7+ #(7+$ H2"&& > > >
`B$) 7&#*/')*%# lJ?a
Y# - .%7%#$ %#7172(7-2 2%$$%. :*.$% $# 19#*" rW-($+ -#9 G%-&"#s `L7$"H%. )XX?a
P"3% k"+# P-F2 YY (&&F%9 - 7-22 0". 3+(2"&"3+1 $" .%#"F#7% $+% #(+(2(&6 "0
3"&$S6"9%.#($1 -#9 $" .%&F6% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 .%&%-.7+ (#$" $+% $.F$+> Y# $+(&
%V$%#9%9 `)NJ 3-/%a 5F#$(6%21 6%9($-$("#; "# 3+(2"&"3+1B $+% 0(.&$ "# $+%
&FHR%7$ $" (&&F% 0."6 $+% f-$(7-# &(#7% LN7$#$)&* E9#)*% "0 P"3% K%" :YYY (#
)?CXB $+% P"3% 3."3"&%9 $" .%'('% $+% -22(-#7% H%$8%%# 3+(2"&"3+1 -#9
!+.(&$(-#($1 F#9%.9"#% H1 - &%7F2-. 6"9%.#($1 8+"&% 3+(2"&"3+1 $%.6(S
#-$%9 (# #(+(2(&6> *+% (&&F% "0 $+% %#7172(7-2 2%$$%. 7"(#7(9%9 8($+ $+%
7"#$."'%.&(-2 7-#"#(&-$("# "0 U9($+ ,$%(#B - '(7$(6 "0 QF&7+8($A -#9B 8($+
M%(9%//%.B "#% "0 $+% 6"&$ /(0$%9 -#9 (##"'-$('% &$F9%#$& "0 MF&&%.2(-#
3+%#"6%#"2"/1> *+% 7"#9($("#& 0". $+% 3-3-2 -33%-2 $" 3+(2"&"3+1 +-9
H%%# %&$-H2(&+%9 (# $8" %-.2(%. %#7172(7-2 2%$$%.& X$)*#9#*% AI4$&.") r*+%
,32%#9"F. "0 *.F$+s )XX@ -#9 $+% %V$.%6%21 3."'"7-$('% -#9 .-9(7-2 6F9&?$J
4*,5 F*#9$ r*+% U'-#/%2 "0 K(0%s )XXJ> Q22 $+.%% %#7172(7-2 2%$$%.& -6"F#$ $" 9%0%#7% "0 $+% 7"#7%3$ "0 52(0%; -/-(#&$ 8+-$ -.% 3%.7%('%9 -& #(+(2(&$(7 9(.%-$&
$" ($& &-#7$($1B $+.%-$& $13(0(%9 H1 $+% %'%#$ "0 $+% M"2"7-F&$>
*+% 7F2$F.-2 .%'"2F$("# 3."&%7F$%9 (# $+% #-6% "0 52(0%; F#9%. $+% 3"#$(S
0(7-$% "0 k"+# P-F2 YY 6-.T& - 7"#&7("F& -$$%63$ $" .%$.(%'% $+% +%/%6"#1 "#
$+(& (&&F% &F..%#9%.%9 $" &%7F2-. 5#(+(2(&$(7; $+"F/+$> *+% 7+"(7% "0 $%..-(# h
5Y(0%; h 6-$7+%& %V-7$21 $+-$ 3F.&F%9 =(%$A&7+% (# +(& -$$-7T F3"# !+.(&$(-#S
($1 (# D'$ 7&#*J(')*%# `)?XJa> Y#9%%9B :*.$% $# 19#*" .%'%.&%& =(%$A&7+%;& $%V$ H1
F&(#/ $+% 7"#7%3$ "0 2(0% $" %V3"&% $+% #(+(2(&6 "0 &%7F2-. 3+(2"&"3+1 (# $+%
&-6% 8-1 $+-$ =(%$A&7+% +-9 F&%9 ($ %-.2(%. $" %V3"&% $+% #(+(2(&6 "0 !+.(&S
$(-#($1> D'$ 7&#*J(')*%# -#9 :*.$% $# 19#*" H"$+ .%/-.9 #(+(2(&6 -& - +(&$".(7-221
&3%7(0(7B $.-#&($("#-2 3+%#"6%#- 8+(7+ ($ (& 3"&&(H2% $" &F.'('% (# ".9%. $"
-..('% -$ - 0F$F.% -00(.6-$("# "0 2(0%> *+(& 3%7F2(-. .+16(#/ H%$8%%# $+%
7.($(_F%& "0 #(+(2(&6 -#9 !+.(&$(-#($1 &F//%&$& -# -00(#($1 $+-$ (& (#$(6-$%9
)?X
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
>"=9). (9C?*44
HF$ #"$ 0F221 8".T%9 $+."F/+ H1 =(%$A&7+%4 !+.(&$ -#9 #(+(2(&$ .+16%B HF$
$+% 8-1& (# 8+(7+ $+%1 #"$ "#21 .+16% .%6-(# "H&7F.%>
=(%$A&7+%;& 9%&7.(3$("# "0 $+% 5-6H(/F($1 "0 #(+(2(&6;B (& F&F-221 0.-6%9 (#
$%.6& "0 $+% &(6F2$-#%"F&21 -7$('% -#9 3-&&('% 7+-.-7$%. "0 $+% 3+%#"6S
%#"#> M% 9"%& #"$ 0(#9 -6H(/F($1 .%&(9(#/ (# $+% '%.1 3."R%7$ "0 "'%.7"6(#/
#(+(2(&6> Y# - 9.-0$ 0". $+% P.%0-7% 0". -# F#0(#(&+%9 8".T D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)0
7##$5I# 9# 9 1$F94,9#*"& "2 944 X94,$%B +% H%/(#& $" .%2-$% 5$+% +(&$".1 "0 $+%
#%V$ $8" 7%#$F.(%&; -& 5$+% -9'%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6;B ". (#%'($-H2% 7-$-&$."3+% "0
UF."3%-# 7F2$F.%> Q& $+% 50(.&$ 3%.0%7$ #(+(2(&$ "0 UF."3%; +% .%-9& 3."3+%$S
(7-221 $+% 5+F#9.%9 &(/#&; "0 $+% 7"#$(#%#$;& #(+(2(&$(7 9%&$(#1B +-'(#/ 52('%9
$+."F/+ $+% 8+"2% "0 #(+(2(&6B $" $+% %#9B 2%-'(#/ ($ H%+(#9B "F$&(9% +(6S
&%20; `=(%$A&7+% )XN? P.%0-7%a> *+% F#8.($$%# H""T 8"F29 3."'"T% - 7"F#$%.S
6"'%6%#$ $" #(+(2(&6B "#% 5$+-$ (# &"6% 0F$F.% 8(22 $-T% $+% 32-7% "0 $+(&
3%.0%7$ #(+(2(&6; 7"6(#/ -0$%. -#9 "F$ "0 ($> *+% 32-1 "0 6"'%6%#$& -#9
7"F#$%.S6"'%6%#$&B 7"632%$("#& -#9 &FH&$($F$("#& F#9%.%&$(6-$%& $+%
3+%#"6%#"# "0 #(+(2(&6B 6"&$ 7.F7(-221 (# $+% +"3% $+-$ #(+(2(&6 7-# H%
&F.'('%9B &F3%.&%9%9 ". (# &"6% 8-1 32-7%9 5"F$&(9%; -#9 H%+(#9 F&>
*+% -6H(/F($1 "0 #(+(2(&6 +-& 6".% (#&(9("F& .""$& $+-# $+% "33"&($("#
H%$8%%# ($& 3-&&('% -#9 -7$('% 7+-.-7$%. (9%#$(0(%9 H1 =(%$A&7+%> *+% /"'%.#S
(#/ -6H(/F($1 (& 6"&$ 72%-.21 %V3"&%9 (# $+% 9"FH2% /%#($('% "0 5$+% &F.'('-2
"0 #(+(2(&6; 8+(7+ 7-# 6%-# #"$ "#21 $+-$ ($ (& 3"&&(H2% 0". F& $" &F.'('%
#(+(2(&6 HF$ -2&" $+-$ #(+(2(&6 6-1 &F.'('% "F. -$$%63$& $" &F.'('% ($>
UV3.%&&%9 $%63".-221B $+% -6H(/F($1 7"#&(&$& (# $+% $%#&("# H%$8%%# $+%
+"3% $+-$ #(+(2(&6 (& HF$ - $.-#&($("#-2 7"#9($("# $+-$ 7-# H% 2('%9 $+."F/+
-#9 /"#% H%1"#9B -#9 $+% &F&3(7("# $+-$ ($ (& -# (#%2F7$-H2% 6"9-2($1
(#'F2#%.-H2% $" $+% 3-&&-/% "0 $(6%> =(%$A&7+%;& -#-21&%& "0 #(+(2(&6 -.%
3.%7(&%21 &$.F#/ "# $+% -6H(/F($1 "0 &F.'('-2B $+-$ 8+(2% #(+(2(&6 (& &"6%S
$+(#/ 8% 7-# 2('% $+."F/+ -#9 &F.'('% $+% '%.1 9%&(.% -#9 $+% 6%-#& 8% F&%
$" &F.'('% ($ "#21 7"#0(.6 -#9 %#+-#7% ($& &$.%#/$+> O+(2% #(+(2(&6 7-#
-9"3$ - #F6H%. "0 9(00%.%#$ 0(/F.%& h .%2(/("F&B &7(%#$(0(7B 3"2($(7-2 -#9
-%&$+%$(7 h $+%&% -.% HF$ '%7$".& "0 - 6"'%6%#$ $+-$ %V7%%9& -#1 /('%#
0(/F.%> *+% -6H(/F($1 "0 #(+(2(&6 7"#&(&$& (# - 3%.0".6-$('% 7"#$.-9(7$("#
(# 8+(7+ #%/-$("# 6-1 7"#0(6 #(+(2(&6 6".% &$."#/21 $+-# ($& -00(.6-$("#>
Y$ (& 0". $+(& .%-&"# $+-$ =(%$A&7+% 9%&7.(H%& #(+(2(&6 -& 5$+% F#7-##(%&$
/F%&$;B ($ 6-#(0%&$& ($&%20 (# - 3."7%&& "0 9"FH2(#/B -& - 9%#(-2 -#9 #%/-$("#
$+-$ (& 6"&$ -$ +"6% 8+%# ($ (& 9%#(%9 -#9 #%/-$%9> *+F& =(%$A&7+% -00(.6&
#(+(2(&6 8+%# +% #%/-$%& ($& !+.(&$(-# '-.(-#$ (# $+% &-6% 8-1 -& k"+# P-F2
YY -00(.6& ($ 8+%# +% #%/-$%& ($& &%7F2-. '-.(-#$>
=(%$A&7+%;& #"$%& "# #(+(2(&6 7"#$%63".-.1 8($+ D'$ 7&#*J(')*%# &+"8
+(6 &F00%.(#/ $+% 3%.0".6-$('% 7"#$.-9(7$("# "0 #(+(2(&6> *+% $"#% "0 $+%
#"$%& 7"#$.-&$& &+-.321 8($+ $+-$ "0 $+% H""TB 8+(7+ 0(#9& (# $+% 7"#7%3$ "0
2(0% - H-&(& 0."6 8+(7+ $" 6"F#$ $+% 7.($(_F% "0 !+.(&$(-# #(+(2(&6B "#21 $"
9(&7"'%. $+-$ $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 52(0%; (# ($&%20 #(+(2(&$(7> *+(& 6"'%6%#$ (&
%'(9%#$ (# =(%$A&7+%;& )??C 9%0(#($("# "0 5.-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6; 8+(7+ 6-.T& $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)XI !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
>"=9). (9C?*44 )X)
(#-F/F.-2 -#9 $%.6(#-2 6"6%#$& "0 $+% #(+(2(&$(7 7"#9($("# -#9 (& '($-2 0".
F#9%.&$-#9(#/ H"$+ $+% +(&$".1 -#9 $+% (#%2F7$-H(2($1 "0 #(+(2(&64
Y# $+% (#-F/F-2 6"6%#$ "0 #(+(2(&6B (9%#$(0(%9 H1 =(%$A&7+% 8($+ P2-$"#(&6
-#9 2-$%. ($& 3"3F2-. 0".6 !+.(&$(-#($1B $+% &3-$("S$%63".-2 8".29 (& #%/-$%9
8+%# 7"63-.%9 8($+ $+% 5+(/+%&$ '-2F%&; ". (9%-&> *+% $.-#&7%#9%#$ (9%-& "0
$+% /""9B $+% $.F% -#9 $+% H%-F$(0F2 #%/-$% -#9 &" 9(6(#(&+ -#1 /""9B $.F%
". H%-F$(0F2 -7$& ". 8".T& $+-$ 8% 6-1 -77"632(&+ F#9%. 0(#($% 7"#9($("#&>
=(%$A&7+% .%/-.9& $+% "$+%.S8".2921 7+-.-7$%. "0 !+.(&$(-#($1 -& - 3.(6%
%V-632% "0 - 7F2$F.% (# 8+(7+ $+% 5+(/+%&$ '-2F%&; 9(6(#(&+ 2(0% H1 %&$-H2(&+S
(#/ &$-#9-.9& $+-$ -.% 9%0(#%9 H1 $+% (63"&&(H(2($1 "0 $+%(. %'%. H%(#/ .%-2S
(&%9> U'%.1 0(#($% -7$ (# $+% 2(/+$ "0 $+%&% '-2F%& 6F&$ H% - 0-(2F.%B &"
.%9F7(#/ $" #"$+(#/ -#1 -F$"#"6"F& &(/#(0(7-#7% $+%1 6-1 3"&&%&& -#9
RF9/(#/ $+%6 "#21 8($+ .%/-.9 $" $+"&% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& $+-$ $+%1 7-# #%'%.
-7+(%'%>
=(%$A&7+% &-8 $+% (#-F/F.-2 #(+(2(&6 "0 !+.(&$(-#($1 -& +-'(#/ - #F6H%.
"0 3"&&(H2% 0F$F.%&> *+% 0(.&$ (& $" 7"#$(#F% $" #%/-$% $+% 0(#($% 8".29 (# $+%
#-6% "0 +(/+%&$ '-2F%& (63"&&(H2% $" .%-2(&% h -# (#$%#&(0(7-$("# "0 8+-$
=(%$A&7+% 9%&7.(H%9 -& 53-&&('% #(+(2(&6;>*+% &%7"#9 5.-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6; h +-&
$8" .%2-$%9 '-.(-#$&4 $+% 0(.&$B 9%&7.(H%9 (# l@B %V$%#9& $+% #%/-$("# "0 $+%
0(#($% 8".29 $" $+% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& $+%6&%2'%& 8+(2% $+% &%7"#9B 9%&7.(H%9 (#
l< "77F.& 8+%# 5#'$ '*?'$%# F94,$% .$F94,$ #'$5%$4F$%N -& (# &7(%#7%B 8+%# $+%
'-2F% "0 $.F$+ (& $F.#%9 -/-(#&$ $.F$+ ($&%20> G-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6 (& 7"#&(&$%#$
8($+ $+% !+.(&$(-# (#-F/F.-$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 (# %V$%#9(#/ ($& .-#/% $" (#72F9%
$+% .F2(#/ (9%-& ". $F.#(#/ ($& "8# +(/+%&$ '-2F%& -/-(#&$ $+%6&%2'%&> *+%
$+(.9 0F$F.% (& =(%$A&7+%;& "8# 5.%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%&; (# 8+(7+ $+% 3.%'-(2(#/
&7%#-.(" "0 '-2F%& h $+% "33"&($("# H%$8%%# $+% -33-.%#$ -#9 $+% $.F% 8".29
h (& .%S9.-8#B -#9 $+% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& &F77%%9%9 H1 - &%$ "0 -00(.6-$('% '-2F%&
&F33"&%921 (66F#% $" #(+(2(&$(7 "F$7"6%&> LF$ "0 $+%&% 3"&&(H2% 0F$F.%&
=(%$A&7+% %2-H".-$%& - +(&$".1 "0 #(+(2(&6 8+(7+ 6"'%& (# $+.%% &$-/%&
0."6 !+.(&$(-# (#-F/F.-2 #(+(2(&6 $" - .-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6 3."'"T%9 H1 $+%
9%'%2"36%#$ "0 &7(%#7% -#9 $+% 7"#&%_F%#7%& "0 $+% .%0".6-$("# $" $+%
(#$(6-$("#& "0 - .%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%& (# +(& "8# 8".T>
EF7+ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 9(&7F&&("# (# $+% #"$%& 0."6 $+% 2-$% )??I& 7"#7%.#&
$+% (632(7-$("#& "0 .-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6 -#9 $+% 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 &F.'('(#/ ($
$+."F/+ - .%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%&> *+% 7+."#"2"/(7-2 %_F('"7-$("#& $+-$
%6%./% -.% 7"#&(&$%#$ 8($+ $+% 3%7F2(-. $."3% "0 .-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6 $+-$ &F&S
$-(#& $+% 6"6%#$ "0 (#-F/F.-2 #(+(2(&6 -$ $+% &-6% -& $F.#(#/ ($ -/-(#&$
($&%20> =(+(2(&6 7-# $+F& H% '(%8%9 -& H"$+ - 5&")594 7"#9($("#; -#9 -
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
5G-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6; (& $+% 7"#'(7$("# "0 -# -H&"2F$% F#$%#-H(2($1 "0 %V(&$S
%#7% 8+%# ($ 7"6%& $" $+% +(/+%&$ '-2F%& "#% .%7"/#(&%&m 32F& $+% .%-2(&-S
$("# $+-$ 8% 2-7T $+% 2%-&$ .(/+$ $" 3"&($ - H%1"#9 ". -# (#S($&%20 "0 $+(#/&
$+-$ 6(/+$ H% 59('(#%; ". 6".-2($1 (#7-.#-$%>
`=(%$A&7+% )XN?B l@a
53-$+"2"/(7-2 $.-#&($("#-2 &$-/%; `l)@aB -& $+% &7(%#$(0(7 9%&$.F7$("# "0 0-($+
(# $+% 3.%'-(2(#/ &1#$+%&(& "0 '-2F%& `l)a -#9 -& 59 .*F*&$ =9C "0 $+(#T(#/;
`l)Ja> =(+(2(&6 (& $+F& &F&3%#9%9 H%$8%%# 3-&$B 3.%&%#$ -#9 0F$F.%B -#9 (#
&3($% "0 =(%$A&7+%;& -$$%63$& $" (6-/(#% - 0F$F.% 8($+"F$ ($ h -0$%. ($& 7"6S
32%$("# h %'%# $+%&% (#$(6-$("#& "0 $+% &F.'('-2 "0 #(+(2(&6 0-22 $" ($& %_F(S
'"7-$("#>
*+% -$$%63$ $" &F.'('% $+% (#-F/F.-2 #(+(2(&6 "0 !+.(&$(-#($1 $+."F/+ $+%
#%/-$("# "0 ($& 5+(/+%&$ '-2F%&; &%.'%9 "#21 $" 7"#0(.6 #(+(2(&6B (#9%%9 $"
.-9(7-2(&% ($> *+% %#2(/+$%#6%#$ 7.($(_F% "0 !+.(&$(-# +(/+%&$ '-2F%& 9(9 #"$
9%2('%. 2(H%.-$("# HF$ 6%-#(#/2%&&2%&&> Y# $+% 9(&7F&&("# "0 $+% 59%72(#% "0
7"&6"2"/(7-2 '-2F%&; $+% .-9(7-2 7"#&%_F%#7%& "0 $+(& 7.($(_F% -.% %V$%#9%9
$" $+% H-&(7 $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 '-2F%& $+-$ (#0".6%9 "F. (#$%.3.%$-$("#& "0 $+%
8".294 5$+% 7-$%/".(%& 55-(6;;B 55F#($1;;B 55H%(#/;; 8+(7+ 8% F&%9 $" 3."R%7$ &"6%
'-2F% (#$" $+% 8".29 h 8% I,44 ",# -/-(#m &" $+% 8".29 2""T& '-2F%2%&&; `l)<a>
=(+(2(&6 (& 3.%&%#$ H"$+ (# $+% '-2F%& $+%6&%2'%& h -& (#-F/F.-2 #(+(2(&6 h -&
8%22 -& (# $+%(. .-9(7-221 #(+(2(&$(7 #%/-$("#> Y$ 8(22 -2&" .%$F.# (# - #%8 /F(&%
8($+(# $+% .%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%& ($&%20>
W."6 $+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 $+% (#%2F7$-H(2($1 "0 #(+(2(&6 ($ (& 3"&&(H2% $"
.%/-.9 D'$ 7&#*J(')*%# -#9 :*.$% $# 19#*" -& $8" -#$(S#(+(2(&$(7 $.-7$& 8+(7+
&F77%%9 (# .%7"#0(.6(#/ #(+(2(&6B -2H%($ (# 9(00%.%#$ 8-1&> D'$ 7&#*J(')*%# (& 7.($(_F% "0 $+% (#-F/F.-2 #(+(2(&6 "0 !+.(&$(-#($1 0."6 - &$-#93"(#$ H%$8%%#
.-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6 -#9 $+% 5.%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%&; 8+(2% :*.$% $# 19#*" (& 7.($(_F% "0 .-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6 0."6 $+% &$-#93"(#$ "0 (#-F/F.-2 #(+(2(&6> *+%
0".6%. 7"#0(.6& #(+(2(&6 (# ($& #%/-$("# "0 !+.(&$(-#($1B $+% 2-$$%. (# ($&
#%/-$("# "0 .-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6m 8+(2% &%%T(#/ 8-1& $" &F.'('% #(+(2(&6 $+%1
H"$+ 7"#$.(HF$% $" ($& &F.'('-2>
Z"$+ :*.$% $# 19#*" -#9 D'$ 7&#*J(')*%# %#/-/% $+%(. 7.($(_F%& "0 #(+(2(&6 (#
$%.6& "0 $+% 7"#7%3$ "0 2(0%> *+% 0".6%. 9%3-.$& 0."6 - 9(-/#"&(& "0 #(+(2(&$(7 7F2$F.% &F3%.0(7(-221 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 H1 3%.&"#-2 -#9 &"7(-2
0.-/6%#$-$("#B -#9 - 3+(2"&"3+1 8+(7+ -9'"7-$%& -#9 7%2%H.-$%& $+(& 0.-/S
6%#$-$("#> Y$ $+%# 9(&7%.#& 8($+(# $+(& -33%-.-#7% "0 0.-/6%#$-$("# $+%
"3%.-$("# "0 - &7(%#$(0(7 -#9 $%7+#"2"/(7-2 2"/(7 8+(7+ -##(+(2-$%& 5+(/+%.
'-2F%&; (# $+% #-6% "0 $%7+#(7-2 -#9 3."9F7$('% %00(7(%#71> *+% #(+(2(&$(7
7F2$F.% 7.($(7(&%9 H1 $+% !+F.7+ (& $+% 0.-/6%#$-$("# $+-$ 0"22"8& 0."6 $+%
(632%6%#$-$("# "0 - #(+(2(&$(7 &7(%#$(0(7 -#9 $%7+#"2"/(7-2 ".9%.> *+(& $.-(#
"0 -./F6%#$ (& %V%632(0(%9 (# $+% 0"22"8(#/ 3-&&-/% "0 $+% %#7172(7-2 2%$$%.
8+%.% $"$-2($-.(-# &"7(-2 -#9 3"2($(7-2 3."R%7$& 5$.-F6-$(7 0". +F6-#($1; -.%
-2(/#%9 8($+ #(+(2(&6 `(# $+% /F(&% "0 &7(%#7% -#9 $%7+#"2"/1a4
!%.$-(# &7(%#$(&$&B 9%3.('%9 "0 -22 %$+(7-2 3"(#$& "0 .%0%.%#7%B .(&T #"
2"#/%. +-'(#/ $+% 3%.&"# -$ $+% 7%#$.% "0 $+%(. (#$%.%&$& -#9 $+% /2"H-2($1
"0 $+%(. 2(0%> O+-$ (& 6".%B &"6% "0 $+%6B -8-.% "0 $+% 3"$%#$(-2 "0
$%7+#"2"/(7-2 3."/.%&& -33%-. $" 7"#7%9%B #"$ "#21 $" $+% 2"/(7 "0 $+%
6-.T%$B HF$ -2&" $" $+% $%63$-$("# "0 - 9%6(F./(7 3"8%. "'%. #-$F.% -#9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)X< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
>"=9). (9C?*44 )X@
*+% %#7172(7-2 2%$$%. .%$F.#& $" $+%&% 2(#T& H%$8%%# &7(%#$(0(7 -#9 $%7+#"S
2"/(7-2 #(+(2(&6B -#9 $+% 3"&$S6"9%.# 7%2%H.-$("# "0 52('(#/ 8($+(# -#
+".(A"# 8($+"F$ -#1 6%-#(#/B F#9%. $+% &(/# "0 $+% 3."'(&("#-2 -#9 $+%
02%%$(#/; `k"+# P-F2 YY )XX?B lX)a -#9 $"$-2($-.(-#(&6> Y$ 7.($(7(&%& 7"#$%6S
3".-.1 3+(2"&"3+1 0". -H9(7-$(#/ 0."6 ($& $-&T "0 7"#$%&$(#/ $+% #(+(2(&6 "0
&7(%#7% -#9 $%7+#"2"/1B -#9 $+F& 0". H%(#/ 7"632(7($ 8($+ $+% #(+(2(&6 $+-$
0"F#9 7"#0(.6-$("# (# 5$+% $%..(H2% %V3%.(%#7% "0 %'(2 $+-$ +-& 6-.T%9 "F.
%3"7+; `k"+# P-F2 )XX?B lX)a >
*+% -./F6%#$ "0 :*.$% $# 19#*" +-9 H%%# -#$(7(3-$%9 (# $+% %-.2(%. %#7172(S
7-2 2%$$%. 6F9&?$4*,5 F*#9$ "# 5$+% '-2F% -#9 (#'("2-H(2($1 "0 +F6-# 2(0%;> *+(&
7.($(7(&%9 $+% &7(%#$(0(7 -#9 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 .%9F7$("#& "0 2(0% $" H("2"/(7-2
0F#7$("#&4
$+% +".C 7"6%& (#7.%-&(#/21 $" H% 3%.7%('%9 #"$ -& $+% $13(7-2 .%-2($1 "0 3%.&"#B $+% &($% "0 $+% .%2-$("# 8($+ "$+%.&B 8($+ ^"9 -#9 8($+ $+% 8".29>
Y$ (& .%9F7%9 $" 3F.% 6-$%.(-2($1B - 6%.% 7"632%V "0 "./-#&B
0F#7$("#& -#9 %#%./(%& $" F&% -77".9(#/ $" 7.($%.(- "0 6%.% 32%-&F.% -#9
%00(7(%#71>
`k"+# P-F2 )XXJB @Na
*+%&% 7.($%.(- #"$ "#21 #%/-$% $+% 5+(/+%&$ '-2F%&; "0 !+.(&$(-#($1B HF$ 6".%
(#&(9("F&21 .%32-7% $+%6 8($+ #%8 "#%& `32%-&F.% -#9 %00(7(%#71a 8+(2%
3.%$%#9(#/ $" -H"2(&+ -22 '-2F%&> *+% &7(%#$(0(7 -#9 $%7+#"2"/(7-2 5.%'-2F-S
$("# "0 -22 '-2F%&; 9%3%#9& "# $+% +FH.(& $+-$ ($ (& $+%".%$(7-221 3"&&(H2% $"
9%2('%. (66".$-2($1> Q/-(#&$ $+(& H"$+ %#7172(7-2 2%$$%.& (#&(&$ "# 0(#($F9%B
6-(#$-(#(#/ $+-$ 5$+% 0(.&$ $.F$+ "0 "F. %V(&$%#7% (& H%1"#9 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ 8%
%V(&$ (& $+% (#%'($-H(2($1 "0 "F. 9%-$+; `k"+# P-F2 YY )XX?B l<Na>
E
M"8%'%.B $+% .%S-&&%.$("# "0 F2$(6-$% '-2F%& h $+% !+.(&$(-# .%'-2F-$("# "0
&7(%#$(0(7 -#9 $%7+#"2"/(7-2 '-2F%& ($&%20 (#'($%& $+% .%$F.# "0 #(+(2(&6>
Y#&$%-9 "0 0"22"8(#/ $+% -./F6%#$ "0 "#% "0 $+% 6-#1 '"(7%& (# $+% %#717S
2(7-2 2%$$%.& 8+(7+ 3"(#$& $" - $+(#T(#/ "0 0(#($F9% 8($+"F$ %($+%. 0.-/6%#$-S
$("# ". (22F&".1 &1#$+%&(& "0 F2$(6-$% '-2F%&B $+% f-$(7-# (&&F%& - 7-22 0".
3+(2"&"3+1 $" .%/-(# 8(&9"6 H1 .%$F.#(#/ $" - 3.%S6"9%.# 9%0%#7% "0
F2$(6-$% '-2F%&4
*+% 9(6%#&("# "0 8(&9"6 (& $"9-1 %'%# 6".% (63".$-#$ (#&"0-. -& $+%
%#".6"F& /."8$+ "0 $%7+#"2"/(7-2 3"8%. 9%6-#9& - .%#%8%9 -#9 -7F$%
7"#&7("F&#%&& "0 F2$(6-$% '-2F%& > > > > Q P+(2"&"3+1 $+-$ 8(&+%& $" #%/-$%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
+F6-#($1> =(+(2(&6 $+F& %6%./%& -& - 7"#&%_F%#7% "0 $+% 7.(&(& "0 .-$("#S
-2(&6>
`k"+# P-F2 YY )XX?B lDNa>
)XD !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Q0$%. 7.($(7(&(#/ $+% .-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6 "0 &7(%#7% -#9 $%7+#"2"/1 (# $+% /F(&% "0
9%'-2F-$("# "0 $.-9($("#-2 '-2F%& (#&$($F$%& #%8B %'%# 6".% $%..(H2% &1&$%6&
"0 '-2F%B $+% %#7172(7-2 9"7F6%#$ &(6321 .%&$-$%& $+% (#-F/F.-2 #(+(2(&6 "0
!+.(&$(-#($1> Y# 32-7% "0 $+% #%8 +(/+%. '-2F%& "0 3."9F7$('($1 -#9 %00(7(%#71
$+%.% (& - .%$F.# $" $.-9($("#-2 '-2F%& "0 $.F$+ -#9 $+% /""9> Z"$+ &%$& "0
'-2F%B +"8%'%.B -.% #(+(2(&$(7 (# %&$-H2(&+(#/ $.-#&7%#9%#$ (9%-& 8+(7+ 7-#
#%'%. H% .%-2(&%9 -#9 &" 7"#9%6# +F6-#($1 $" 0-(2F.% -#9 &%20S#%/-$("#B &"
%#&F.(#/ $+% &F.'('-2 "0 #(+(2(&6>
Y# D'$ 7&#*J(')*%# =(%$A&7+% 3.%9(7$%9 $+-$ -#1 -$$%63$ $" .%0".6 !+.(&S
$(-#($1 0."6 8($+(# 8"F29 H% '($(-$%9 H1 $+% #(+(2(&$(7 5$+%"2"/(7-2 (#&$(#7$;
8+%.%(# 5#(+(2(&$(7 '-2F%& +"29 &8-1 F#9%. $+% +"2(%&$ "0 #-6%&; `=(%$A&7+%
)XC?B lNa> M"8%'%.B +(& "8# 8-. F3"# $+% 5$+%"2"/(7-2 (#&$(#7$; 3"(&%9
H%$8%%# .-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6 -#9 $+% 5.%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%&; (& #"$ ($&%20 (66F#%
$" 5$+%"2"/1;> *+% -./F6%#$ (# $%.6& "0 52(0%; 0.%%& $+% 7"#7%3$ 0."6 ($&
-&&"7(-$("#& 8($+ $+% 5+(/+%. '-2F%&; "0 !+.(&$(-#($1B HF$ "#21 $" 7"#'%.$
$+%6 (#$" -#"$+%. +(/+%. '-2F%> !+.(&$(-#($1 (& 7"#9%6#%9 0". 5#%/-$(#/
2(0%; 0". 5&+(0$(#/ $+% 7%#$.% "0 /.-'($1 "F$ "0 2(0%; 0". 53"(&"#(#/ 2(0%; HF$ -22 (#
$+% #-6% "0 $+% #%8 +(/+%. '-2F% "0 52(0%;> *+% 9%$-(2& "0 $+% -00(.6-$("# "0
(#&$(#7$ -#9 $+% H"91 6%.%21 7"#7%-2 $+-$ - #%8 +(/+%&$ '-2F% +-& H%%#
(#&(#F-$%9B "#% $+-$ H%/-# (# $+% #%/-$("# "0 !+.(&$(-# +(/+%. '-2F%& -#9
$+-$ 8(22 %#9B 2(T% -22 '-2F%&B (# $+% #%/-$("# "0 ($&%20> K(0% 9%&$."1(#/ ($&%20 0".
$+% &-T% "0 ($&%20 h - 0".6F2- .%'%-2%9 H1 =(%$A&7+% (# $+% 8".9 5+%-2$+;> *+%
!+.(&$(-# (# #%/-$(#/ 2(0% (#-F/F.-$%& #(+(2(&6B 8($+ $+% 7."&& &%.'(#/
-& $+% &(/# "0 .%7"/#($("# 0". 5- 7"#&3(.-71 -/-(#&$ +%-2$+B H%-F$1B 8%22S
7"#&$($F$%9#%&&B H.-'%.1B (#$%22%7$B +$&$F"4$&/$ "2 &"F2B 9?9*&%# 4*2$ *#%$42N
`=(%$A&7+% )XC?B lN<a> o%$ $+% #%/-$("# "0 $+(& #%/-$("# (# $+% #-6% "0 2(0%
9"%& #"$ -7+(%'% $+% 7,2'$+,&? "0 #(+(2(&6B HF$ "#21 ($& 7"#0(6-$("# -#9
&F.'('-2>
*+% -./F6%#$ -/-(#&$ !+.(&$(-# #(+(2(&6 (# $+% #-6% "0 2(0% (& #"$ $+% "#21
%V($ 0."6 !+.(&$(-#($1 %&&-1%9 (# D'$ 7&#*J(')*%#> Q#"$+%. (& (66-#%#$ $"
!+.(&$(-#($1 ($&%20B -#9 (& 0"F#9 (# $+% 0(/F.% "0 !+.(&$ -#9 $+% #"#S0(/F.-2
7"#7%3$ "0 2(0% 8+(7+ +% H"$+ 0(/F.%& -#9 9"%& #"$ 0(/F.%> *+% #(+(2(&$(7 $.-3
7"#&(&$& (# 0(/F.(#/ #%/-$("#B $+F& /('(#/ ($ - &($% -#9 $+% 3"&&(H(2($1 $"
#%/-$% ($&%20> Q 8-1 =(%$A&7+% 0(#9& $" -'"(9 $+(& "F$7"6% (& $" .%0F&% 0(/F.-S
$("# -#9 $+% 0".6F2- "0 $+% 57"&6"2"/(7-2 '-2F%&; h -(6B F#($1 -#9 H%(#/>
=(%$A&7+%;& 3-.-9"V(7-2 %V%632-. "0 &F7+ -H&%#7% "0 0(/F.% (& !+.(&$> !+.(&S
$(-#($1 0". +(6 .%6-(#& 5$+% $.%6%#9"F& _F%&$("# 6-.T; H%7-F&% ($ 6-.T& $+%
5"33"&($% "0 8+-$ 8-& $+% ".(/(#B $+% 6%-#(#/B $+% )*?'# "0 $+% ^"&3%2;
`=(%$A&7+% )XC?B l@Na> *+% ".(/(# (& 3.%7(&%21 "#% $+-$ (& 8($+"F$ 0(/F.% -#9
$+F& 8($+"F$ 5-(6B F#($1 -#9 H%(#/;4 !+.(&$;& (& - 0-($+ 5$+-$ 2('%&;B ($ 9"%& #"$
50".6F2-$% ($&%20; h +(& 2(0% (& $+-$ "0 - 50.%% &3(.($; `=(%$A&7+% )XC?B l@<a> M(&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
$+% 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 -# F2$(6-$% 6%-#(#/ "0 $+% 8".29 (& #"$ "#21 (#-9%_F-$%
HF$ -2&" %.."#%"F&>
`k"+# P-F2 YY )XX?B ?)a
>"=9). (9C?*44 )XJ
2(0% +-& #" -(6 #" F#($1B -#9 #" (#$%.%&$ (# H%(#/> !+.(&$ 9"%& #"$ .%&(&$B 9%#1
". "$+%.8(&% #%/-$%m +(& b(#/9"64
=(%$A&7+% F#9%.&$-#9& $+% 9%-$+ "0 !+.(&$ (# $%.6& "0 $+% (632(%9 7"#$.-&$
8($+ $+% 9%-$+ "0 ,"7.-$%&> !+.(&$ 9"%& #"$ 9%H-$% $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 +(& 9%-$+B
HF$ 3.-7$(7%& +(& 0.%%9"6 0."6 $+% &3(.($ "0 .%'%#/%> M% 9"%& #"$ &FH&F6% +(&
"8# 9%-$+ F#9%. - &1&$%6 "0 -(6&B +% 9"%& #"$ F#(01 8($+ $+% .%&$ "0 +(& 2(0%
#". 9"%& +% 3."3"&% ($ -& - 9"7$.(#-2 $%&$ "0 +(& 9('(#($1> Y#&$%-9B 0".
=(%$A&7+%4
M(& 8".9& $" $+% #'*$2 "# $+% 7."&& 7"#$-(# $+% 8+"2% U'-#/%2> 5*+-$ 8-&
'%.($1 - .*F*&$ 6-#B - 7+(29 "0 ^"9j; h &-1& $+% $+(%0 5Y0 $+"F 0%%2%&$ $+(&; h
-#&8%.& $+% .%9%%6%. h #'", 9)# *& E9)9.*%$B $+"F -.$ - 7+(29 "0 ^"9>;5!"# $"
9%0%#9 "#%&%20B &"# $" /."8 -#/.1B &"# $" 6-T% .%&3"#&(H2% > > > > ZF$ #"$ $"
`=(%$A&7+% )XC?B l@Ja
.%&(&$ $+% %'(2 6-# h $" 4"F$ +(6 > > > >
O+-$ 8-& 5%V%632-.1; (# $+(& 6-##%. "0 91(#/ 8-& 5$+% 0.%%9"6 0."6B $+%
&F3%.(".($1 "'%. %'%.1 0%%2(#/ "0 .%&&%#$(6%#$; `lDIa> M"8%'%.B $+(& 5%V%6S
32-.($1; 9(9 #"$ 7"#&(&$ (# 0(/F.(#/ - +(/+%. '-2F% HF$ (# &+"8(#/ - 3.-7$(7% "0
2(0% (#0".6%9 H1 7+%%.0F2#%&& -#9 2"'%B $+-$ (&B 8($+"F$ $+% &3(.($ "0 .%'%#/%>
*+(& 58($+"F$ .%'%#/%; 8-& #"$ (# ($&%20 - '%#/%0F2 #%/-$("# "0 $+% 3.%'-(2(#/
7F2$F.-2 5&3(.($ "0 .%'%#/%; HF$ $+% 3.-7$(7% "0 - 2(0% $+-$ 8-& (#9(00%.%#$ $" ($>
*+% U'-#/%2 (& (# $+(& &%#&% 5$+% %V(&$%#7%B $+% 0F20(26%#$B $+% 9/#,94*#C "0 $+(&
5T(#/9"6; HF$ -# -7$F-2($1 8+(7+ +-& #" 32-7% ". $(6%>
o%$ 3-.-9"V(7-221 $+% -#$(S0(/F.% "0 !+.(&$ H%7-6% $+% 6"&$ 3."6(#%#$ -#9
3"8%.0F2 &"F.7% "0 - .%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%&> Q0$%. $+% 9%-$+ "0 !+.(&$
=(%$A&7+% (6-/(#%& $+% 9(&7(32%& 5H%(#/ &+-T%# -#9 9(&-33"(#$%9 $" $+%(.
9%3$+&; -#9 $+%# 3"&(#/ $+% '%#/%0F2 _F%&$("# 5O+" T(22%9 +(6i; `lDIa>
O($+ $+(& _F%&$("# $+% 9(&7(32%& #"$ "#21 2""T 0". $+% 0".7%& $+-$ #%/-$%9
!+.(&$;& 2(0%B HF$ $+%1 -2&" (6-/(#% $+-$ $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 +(& 2(0% 8-& ($&%20 $+%
'%.1 #%/-$("# "0 $+%&% 0".7%& h 5"#% &FH&%_F%#$21 F#9%.&$""9 k%&F& -& +-'(#/
H%%# *& 5,#*&C 9?9*&%# #'$ %"/*94 ").$)N `lDIa> *+% #%V$ &$%3B 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+%
&-8 -& 7"9(0(%9 (# $+% P-F2(#% %3(&$2%&B 8-& $" .%/-.9 !+.(&$;& -22%/%9 9%0%-$ -&
- 32"1 (# - 2-./%. 7"&6(7 H-$$2%> *+% 6%-#(#/ "0 !+.(&$;& 9%-$+ 8-& $+%
.%&F..%7$("# -#9 $+% %&$-H2(&+6%#$ "0 - &1&$%6 "0 +(/+%. '-2F%& 8+(7+
8"F29 RF&$(01 $+% 2-&$ RF9/%6%#$> *+% %V%632-. "0 #"#S#%/-$("# (& $+F&
$.-#&0".6%9 0". =(%$A&7+% (#$" - 6(/+$1 0(/F.% "0 #%/-$("#B $+% 0"F#9%. "0
- &1&$%6 "0 +(/+%. '-2F%&> o%$ =(%$A&7+% H%.-$%& P-F2 0". -77"632(&+(#/
3.%7(&%21 - 5.%'-2F-$("# "0 -22 '-2F%&;B 0". 9%72-.(#/ '%#/%0F2 8-. "# - &1&$%6
"0 +(/+%. '-2F%& 69 &%%T(#/ $" #%/-$% -#9 .%32-7% $+%6 8($+ - #%8 &%$> *+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
*+% 5T(#/9"6 "0 ^"9; (& #"$ &"6%$+(#/ "#% 8-($& 0".m ($ +-& #" 1%&$%.9-1
". $"6".."8B ($ 9"%& #"$ 7"6% (# - 5$+"F&-#9 1%-.&; h ($ (& -# %V3%.(%#7%
8($+(# - +%-.$B ($ (& %'%.18+%.%B ($ (& #"8+%.% > > > > `=(%$A&7+% )XC?B l@Da
'%#/%0F2 8-. "# !+.(&$(-#($1 8-/%9 (# D'$ 7&#*J(')*%# (& -#-2"/"F& $" P-F2;&
8-. "# 5),4*&? kF9-(&6B ($& F33%. 72-&&; `=(%$A&7+% )XC?B lDIam ($ 9"%& #"$
%V%632(01 - 3.-7$(7% H%1"#9 /""9 -#9 %'(2 HF$ (#&$%-9 0(/F.%& $+% #%/-$("#
"0 "29 -#9 $+% (#&$($F$("# "0 #%8 '-2F%&> Y# D'$ 7&#*J(')*%# =(%$A&7+% 32-1&
P-F2 $" P-F2(#% !+.(&$(-#($14 2(T% P-F2B =(%$A&7+% 9%'%2"3& - #%8 &1&$%6& "0
'-2F%& H-&%9 "# - H("2"/(7-2 9%0(#($("# "0 52(0%;B "#% 8+(7+ (& .%-7$('% -#9
9.('%# H1 #%/-$("#> *+(& %#&F.%9 $+% &F.'('-2 "0 #(+(2(&6 H1 7.%-$(#/ - #%8B
(632-7-H2% &%$ "0 H("2"/(7-2 '-2F%& 3"2(7%9 H1 ($& "8# 6%9(7-2 3.(%&$+""9>
*+% 0F$F.-2 6"6%#$ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 8".T .%2(%& "# $+% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%#
5.-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6; -#9 $+% 5.%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%&;B &%%(#/ (# $+% 2-$$%. $+%
3"&&(H(2($1 "0 &F.'('(#/ #(+(2(&6> M"8%'%.B $+(& -&&F6%& $+-$ #(+(2(&6 (& 3.%9(7-6%#$ $+-$ 7-# H% "'%.7"6%B -# -&&F63$("# $+-$ +% #"8+%.% 9%0%#9&
&-$(&0-7$".(21> U'%.1 .%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%& 9%6-#9& - 9%'-2F-$("# ". #%/-$("#
"0 %V(&$(#/ '-2F%&B -#9 $+(& #%/-$("# 3.%3-.%& $+% .%'-2F-$("# $" &%.'% -& '%7$". 0". $+% 3."3-/-$("# -#9 &F.'('-2 "0 #(+(2(&6> *+% #%/-$("# "0 .-9(7-2
#(+(2(&6 H1 $+% f-$(7-# (# :*.$% $# 19#*" (# $+% #-6% "0 $.F$+ -#9 $+% .%&3%7$
0". 2(0% .%3%-$& $+% /%&$F.% "0 (#-F/F.-2 #(+(2(&6 -#9 $+F& .%(#&$-$%& ($ 8+(2%
=(%$A&7+%;& #%/-$("# "0 !+.(&$(-#($1 .%3%-$& $+% /%&$F.% "0 .-9(7-2 #(+(2(&6>
Q#9 -& =(%$A&7+% +(6&%20 &+"8%9B %'%# $+% %V%632-.1 -00(.6-$('% 0(/F.% "0
!+.(&$ (& #"$ (66F#% $" /%#%.-$(#/ #(+(2(&$(7 -00%7$&>
Y0 $+% .%'-2F-$("# "0 '-2F%& (& F#-H2% $" %&7-3% $+% .-9(7-2 #(+(2(&$ 3.%9(7-S
6%#$ $+% _F%&$("# 3"&%9 $" $+% 0F$F.% 7+-#/%& 0."6 .%'-2F-$("# $" $+-$ "0
+"8 $" 2('% 8($+ #(+(2(&6> =(%$A&7+% 9%'%2"3& &"6% (9%-& (# $+(& 9(.%7$("# (#
$+% "$+%.8(&% 3FAA2(#/ 7"66%#$& "# ZF99+(&6 (# D'$ 7&#*J(')*%#> Z"$+
!+.(&$(-#($1 -#9 ZF99+(&6 -.% #(+(2(&$(7 .%2(/("#&B HF$ $+% 2-$$%.B 0".
=(%$A&7+%B 5&$-#9&B (# 61 2-#/F-/%B +$C"&. /""9 -#9 %'(2; `=(%$A&7+% )XC?B
l<Ia> Y$ (& - .%2(/("# (# 8+(7+ $+% 5&F3.%6% /"-2 (& 7+%%.0F2#%&&B &$(22#%&&B
-H&%#7% ". 9%&(.%B -#9 $+(& /"-2 (& -7+(%'%9; `l<)a>*+% 9(.%7$("# "0 $+(&
-./F6%#$ (& 7"#&(&$%#$ 8($+ +(& 7"66%#$& $+."F/+"F$ +(& 8.($(#/& "# E%(&S
$%. U7T+-.$ -#9 #%/-$('% $+%"2"/1> O($+ $+(& '(%8 - #%8 0F$F.% 0". #(+(2(&6 (&
(#$(6-$%9B "#% 8+(7+ .%7"/#(&%& $+-$ ($ 8(22 #"$ H% "'%.7"6% (# - 5.%'-2F-S
$("# "0 '-2F%&; -#9 8+(7+ $+%# &%%T& - 8-1 $" &F.'('% #(+(2(&6 8($+"F$
"'%.7"6(#/ ". 2('(#/ H%1"#9 ($>
*+% 3.%9(7-6%#$ "0 7+%%.0F221 &F.'('(#/ #(+(2(&6 (& 9%&7.(H%9 H1 =(%$A&7+%
-$ $+% H%/(##(#/ "0 $+% 0(0$+ H""T "0 D'$ O9C A/*$&/$> Y# -# (#9(.%7$ /2"&& "#
$+% .+16% "0 !+.(&$ -#9 #(+(2(&$B =(%$A&7+% .%'(%8& $+% '-.("F& &7%#-.("& "0
$+% &F.'('-2 "0 #(+(2(&6 0"22"8(#/ $+% 9%-$+ "0 $+% !+.(&$(-# ^"9> Y# $+%
(#$%.&$(7%& "0 $+% .%-7$('% 0F$F.%& "0 $+% -9'%#$ "0 - 52"/(7 "0 $%..".;B - .%'('-2
"0 !+.(&$(-# H%2(%0 ". $+% 3."3-/-$("# "0 $+% #%8 3(%$1 "0 5H%2(%0 (# &7(%#7%;B
=(%$A&7+% 0(#9& $+% 7+%%.0F2#%&& "0 $+% 0.%% &3(.($> W"22"8(#/ $+% 7-$-&$."3+(7
9%-$+ "0 ^"9B $+% 0.%% &3(.($ 9"%& #"$ %#/-/% (# 6"F.#(#/B #". 7"66%#7% '%#/%0F2 &%-.7+ 0". $+"&% /F(2$1 "0 $+% 6F.9%. #". &%%T $" 2-1 9"8# #%8
2-8&> Y#&$%-9B $+% 0.%% &3(.($ 2""T& 0". $+% 9-8# -0$%. $+% &+-9"8&B /.%%$(#/
$+% #%8& "0 $+% 9%-$+ "0 ^"9 8($+ - 7+%%.0F2 5$+"F/+$0F2#%&&B -&$"#(&+6%#$B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
)XN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
>"=9). (9C?*44 )XC
2"#/(#/ -#9 %V3%7$-$("#;> *+(& (& #"$ - #%/-$("# 8+(7+ 8"F29 0-22 (#$" $+%
$.-3 "0 #(+(2(&6B HF$ -# (#9(00%.%#7% $" ($B - 7+%%.0F2#%&& $+-$ H.(#/& (#$"
.+16% $+% -#$(S0(/F.%& "0 !+.(&$ -#9 $+% 3%.0%7$21 #(+(2(&$(7 0.%% &3(.($>
k"+# P-F2 YY `)XXJa 6F9&?$4*,5 F*#9$0 -- F94")$ $ 4N*&F*"49+*4*#9 .$4#9 F*#9 ,59&9B E(2-#4
P-"2(#% U9($".(-2% K(H.(>
pp `)XX?a :*.$% $# 19#*" ))h@I f-$(7-#>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XC?a D'$ 7&#*J(')*%#B $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(#
Z""T&>
pp `)XN?a D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)B $.-#&> O> b-F066# -#9 G>k> M"22(#/9-2%B =%8 o".T4
f(#$-/% Z""T&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
0(D()(,1(-
)I
B9F*. <""#')"C.
Y# $+% 7"F.&% "0 $+% %7&$-$(7 '(&("#B -$ $+% 2(6($ "0 9%-$+ "# $+% 7."&&
-#9 "0 $+% H2(#921 2('%9 4959 %9+9#/'#9&*B $+% "HR%7$ (& 0(#-221
F#'%(2%9 -& /9#9%#)"I'$ (# - 7+-"& "0 2(/+$ -#9 &+-9"8B #%($+%. -&
^"9 #". -& #"$+(#/#%&&B HF$ -& $+% "HR%7$ $+-$ 2"'%B (#7-3-H2% "0
2(H%.-$(#/ ($&%20 %V7%3$ -& "F$&(9% ($&%20B 9%6-#9& (# ".9%. $" 2%$ "F$
$+% &7.%-6 "0 2-7%.-$%9 %V(&$%#7%>
rZ-$-(22% `)X@Na )X?JB )?Js
*" H% &(2%#$B $" 9(% &2"821B (# $+% 7"#9($("#& "0 - 7"632%$% .$M/'*),)$>
W."6 $+%.% &2(33(#/ (#$" $+% 9%3$+& "0 &(2%#7% -#9 8($+ -# (#0(#($%
3%.&3%7$('%B 1"F 8(22 T#"8 0."6 8+-$ (#0-61 $+% 8".29 (& 6-9%>
rZ-$-(22% `)XDCa 7($%9 (# O(2&"# )XXJB )?Ns
& -"#1( $D "#D( /- 2(/%+
Q 3."0"F#9 7F$$(#/ ". 8"F#9(#/ "0 $+% H"91 9(&.F3$& $+% &%20S7"#$."2 "0
$+% 6(#9 (# ($& 7"#$%632-$("# "0 - 9%-$+ -28-1& "# $+% H.(#T "0 0(#-2($1
HF$ #%'%. _F($% -..('(#/ -$ ($> *+(#T(#/ -.$(7F2-$%& %-7+ (#&$-#$ "0 $+%
3"&$3"#%6%#$ "0 &F7+ - $".$F."F& 9%-$+B 2(0% (& $+% $".6%#$ -#9 -#/F(&+ "0
($& 0".%&$-22(#/> Y0 Z-$-(22%;& "H&%&&("# 8($+ $+(& 3+"$"B (# ($& 0"7F& "# $+%
56"&$ -#/F(&+(#/ "0 8".29& -77%&&(H2% $" F& #')",?' *59?$% 7-3$F.%9 "#
0(26;B 7-# H% &%%# -& -# (9%#$(0(7-$("# 8($+ $+% (#&$-#$ "0 %7&$-$(7 3-(#B
Q.$-F9 6(/+$ H% &-(9 $" +-'% &3"T%# 9(.%7$21 0."6 8($+(# &F7+ - 6"6%#$m
$+% 6"6%#$ "0 +(& "8# 56%#$-2; 9(&6%6H%.6%#$ -#9 3-(#0F2
&$.F//2% -/-(#&$ 9(&(#$%/.-$("#B %V3%.(%#7%9 (# $+% 0".6 "0 $+(#T(#/ #')",?'
#'$ k24$%'N4
{ [%9(7-$("#4 $" $+% /.F%&"6%21 6F.9%.%9B -#9 -22 "$+%.& =LO H%(#/ +-7T%9B 2-7%.S
-$%9B 7+"33%9B 02-1%9B .-3%9 -#9 9(&6%6H%.%9m $" -22 $+"&% &FHR%7$%9 $" -##(+(2-$("#&
"0 $+% &T(#> `*+% 3+"$"/.-3+%. "0 $+% (22F&$.-$("# "# 3> )XX (& F#T#"8#>a
)X?
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
,T(#S=(+(2(&6 ="84 W2-1(#/ $+% W-7%
-#9 G%0(/F.(#/ $+% ,T(#{
*+% 9%-$+ "0 W"FS*7+"FSK( H1 L$&?JD/'N$ `7F$$(#/ (#$" 3(%7%&aB 0."6 [F6-&; D)9*#$M
.$ I%C/'"4"?*$ `)X<@aB .%3.(#$%9 (# Z-$-(22%;& D$9)% "2 6)"%B )X?X `)XN)a
*+(& 3+"$"/.-3+ +-9 - 9%7(&('% ."2% (# 61 2(0%> Y +-'% #%'%. &$"33%9 H%(#/
"H&%&&%9 H1 $+(& (6-/% "0 3-(#B -$ "#7% %7&$-$(7 -#9 (#$"2%.-H2%> `Z-$-(22%
)X?XB <INa
O+-$ (& $+(& 7.1 2(T% - 9"/ +"82(#/ (# - 9.%-6B 8+(7+ 6-T%& 1"F. &T(#
7.-82B /('%& 1"F $+(& 0%%2(#/ "0 /.(%0 -#9 F##-6%-H2% F#%-&(#%&& 6-T(#/
1"F /-/ (# - 6-9 -#9 9."8#(#/ 0.%#A1> ="B ($ (&#;$ $.F%> Y$ (&#;$ $.F% > > > >
ZF$ $+% 8".&$ "0 ($ (&B ($ (& $.F%> Q#9 -$ $+% &-6% $(6% $+%.% (& $+(& 0%%2(#/ "0
9%&3%.-$% $.F$+B 8+%.% ($ &%%6& 1"F -.% /"(#/ $" 9(% -/-(#B 1"F -.% /"(#/
$" 9(% - &%7"#9 $(6% > > > -$ $+% %#9 "0 $+(& '(&7%.-2 9(&$(22-$("# 9"#;$ 8%
3(7$F.% $+% 3-#(7 8% +-'% -2.%-91 %V3%.(%#7%9>
`Q.$-F9 )XN?B XIa
*+(& $+(#T(#/S%'%#$B ". 53(7$F.(#/;B (& -28-1& -2.%-91 9(&(#$%/.-$("# (# -7$4
$+%.% (& #" 3.(". ".(/(#-2B &$-H2% F#($1 "0 &%20 -#9 #" 9 I)*")* 7"+%.%#$
5#".6-2($1;m +%#7% #" 3%-7% "0 6(#9 0". 3"". Q.$-F9B "#21 Q.$-F9 (# 3(%7%&4
(# $+% $+."%& "0 - 9%&3%.-$%B 0.%#A(%9 -$$%63$ $" $+(#T +(& F#($1> *+(& 7"#9(S
$("# (& - +"..". 6F2$(32(%9 H1 $+% &%#&% "0 .$MK9b F, 8+(7+ -77"63-#(%& ($>
Q.$-F9 %V3%.(%#7%& $+% /."F#92%&&#%&& "0 +(& &FHR%7$('% `9(&aF#($1 -& - T(#9
"0 3-#(7 50-22(#/;B -$ "#7% +"..(H2% -#9 0-6(2(-.B 8+(7+ +% 9%&7.(H%& (# +(&
7"..%&3"#9%#7% 8($+ k-7_F%& G('(%n.% -& $+% 50%-. "0 #"$ 91(#/ %#$(.%21;>
`Q.$-F9 )XNJB Ca
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9F*. <""#')"C. )XX
Y# H"$+ 7-&%& $+(& 5$+"F/+$; (& %V3%.(%#7%9 (# 5$+% H"91; -#9 -& $+% -$$%63$
$" $+(#T $+% H"91;& .%2-$("# $" 9%-$+m $+-$ (&B $" .%S$+(#T $+% H"91 -& 5.%'%.S
&(H2%; 02%&+m -& $+% 6%9(F6 ". &($% "0 $+% -6H(/F"F& 3-(#]%7&$-&1 "0 - 2-7%.-S
$("# -#9 9(&6%6H%.6%#$ `.$M/'*),)$a h &"6%$+(#/ 8+(7+ (& #%($+%. &(6321
3+1&(7-2 #". 6%#$-2 HF$ $+% 4*5*# "0 $+% &%20 $".6%#$%9 H1 - /%#%.-2(&%9
'("2%#7% $" 8+(7+ ($ (& %V3"&%9 -& %V$%.(".($1>) Z-$-(22%;& "H&%&&("# 8($+ $+(&
(6-/% &$%6& #"$ 0."6 -#1 $.F$+ ($ 6(/+$ H% &F33"&%9 $" .%3.%&%#$B 0".
%V-632% $+% -63+(H"2"/1 "0 $+% 3-(#%9]%7&$-$(7 %V3.%&&("# ($ 6-T%&
$%V$F-221 -'-(2-H2%B HF$ 0."6 ($& ,&.$/*.9+*4*#C> Y$& 59(&$F.H(#/ %00%7$; (& #%($+%.
&(6321 '(&7%.-2B #". %$+(7-2B #". 7"#7%3$F-2 -#9 1%$ ($ (& - 0F#7$("# "0 -22 "0
$+%&% -$ "#7%B -#9 (&B 7"#&%_F%#$21B F#&%$$2(#/ "0 -#1 -$$%63$ $" 9%7(9% ($&
56%-#(#/;> LH&%&&("# (&B 3.%7(&%21B $+% .%&3"#&% ($ 3."'"T%&> Z-$-(22%;& 9(.%7$
-#9 (#9(.%7$ .%02%7$("#& "# $+(&B (# $+%&% 7($%9 8".T& -#9 %2&%8+%.%B %V3.%&&
$+% F#9%7(9-H(2($1 "0 - H"91 8+(7+ 7"F29 #%'%. H% 0F221 .%3.%&%#$%9 (#
$+%6%&> Y# $+%6%&B 0". %V-632%B &F7+ -& $+"&% -.$(7F2-$(#/ -#9 ".9%.(#/
-#$+."3"2"/(7-2B &"7("2"/(7-2B 3"2($(7-2B ". 3&17+"2"/(7-2 -#-21&%& -#9
%V32-#-$("#&B "0 %($+%. (6-/%&B ". `H"91a %'%#$&B &F7+ -& $+(& (6-/%B 0".
(#&$-#7%B 9%3(7$&> Q& - .%-9%. "0 $+(& (6-/%B Z-$-(22% #" 6".% 3($(%& $+%
(#9('(9F-2 ($ &+"8&B 2-6%#$& 56-#;& (#+F6-#($1 $" 6-#;B #". &%%T& $"
%V32-(# `-8-1a $+% (#7(9%#$B ". "$+%. &F7+ (#&$-#7%&B "0 '("2%#7% -#9 &F00%.S
(#/B $+-# .%-9%.& "0 Q.$-F9;& 53-(#S$%V$&;B 0". %V-632%B 6(/+$ 3F.3"&%0F221
2-6%#$ +(& #"$ +-'(#/ .%7%('%9 9F.(#/ +(& 2(0%B H%$$%. 5(#&$($F$("#-2 7-.%; 0".
+(& 56-9#%&&;> *+%.% (& 0". $+%6 H"$+B (# $+%(. .%&3%7$('% 9(&7"6H"HF2-$("#&B
-# -H1&&-2 6".H(9 9%S7(&("# "0 $+% 9(00%.%#7%B "0 $+% &2-&+B H%$8%%# 91(#/]
2(0%>
Y$ 7"F29 H% -./F%9B "0 7"F.&%B $+-$ $+%.% -.% "#21 .%-221 6-$$%.& "2 4*#$)9#,)$
$" H% -99.%&&%9 +%.%m $+"&% "0 $+% *%V$ -#9 "0 (#$%.S$%V$F-2 %#/-/%6%#$&
6-.T(#/ $+% $.-R%7$".1 "0 $+% '-.("F& $%V$F-2 %2%6%#$& 8+(7+ 9.(0$ $"/%$+%.B
-$ - 7%.$-(# 6"6%#$ (# - 3-.$(7F2-. 2($%.-.1 7F2$F.%> *+% %V3.%&&("#& "0 (##%.
%V3%.(%#7% $+%1 3."'(9% -.% #"$ 9%&7.(3$("#& "0B #". &3%7F2-$("#& "#B 3-.$(7FS
2-. 3.('-$% %V3%.(%#7%& ". 7"#&7("F&#%&&%&m #%($+%. -.% $+%1B #". 7"F29 $+%1
H%B 53.('-$% 2-#/F-/%&;> Q#9B &F7+ =)*#*&?% -.% &F.%21 &16H"2(7 9(&3%.&-2& "0
&%'%.-2 $+%6%&m "0 $+% %7&$-&1]3-(# 9"FH2%B "0 9%-$+B $+% H"91B $+% &"'%.S
%(/#$1 "0 $+% &FHR%7$ -#9 $+% 5(63"&&(H2%;B -#9 &" "#> Z-$-(22%;& 3(7$F.% (&
($&%20B -0$%. -22 -#9 %V32(7($21B - &(6F2-7.F6 "0 8+-$ 8"F29 #".6-221 H%
.%0%..%9 $" -& $+% ".(/(#-2 5%'%#$;B "0 - $".$F.% -#9 - &F00%.(#/B "#% 8+(7+ (&
9"FH2%9SF3 -/-(# (# ($& 2($%.-.1 .%3%$($("# (# +(& 8.($(#/> Y$& .%3."/.-3+(#/
0F.$+%. +%.%B &$-#9& $" (22F&$.-$% $+% 6-##%. (# 8+(7+ ($ 6-1 &%.'% $" .%$F.#
$+"F/+$B .%3%-$%921B $" - 6"6%#$ "0 F#9%7(9-H(2($1m - 3"(#$ 8+(7+ 6-1 /('%
-77%&& $" 8+-$ $+(& %&&-1 -$$%63$& $" 9(&7F&& H%2"8 F#9%. $+% .FH.(7 "0 5%$+(7&
"0 $+% &T(#; -#9 $" $+% _F%&$("# "0 #(+(2(&6 (# $%.6& "0 $+% -##(+(2-$("#
9(.%7$%9 -$ $+% &T(# "0 #'$ "#'$)B (# +(&]+%. F,4&$)9+*4*#C>
M"8%'%.B H"$+ Z-$-(22% -#9 Q.$-F9B -2H%($ 9(00%.%#$21B 9" 9(.%7$ $+%(. $+(#TS
(#/ $"8-.9 - 6"6%#$ (# 8+(7+ 5$+% H"91; %V3%.(%#7%& ($&%20B %_F('"7-221B -&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<II !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
B9F*. <""#')"C. <I)
*+% 3.('(2%/%9 6-#(0%&$-$("# "0 =%/-$('($1 (& 9%-$+B HF$ 9%-$+ (# 0-7$
.%'%-2& #"$+(#/ > > > 0". - 6-# F2$(6-$%21 $" .%'%-2 +(6&%20 $" +(6&%20B +%
8"F29 +-'% $" 9(%B HF$ +% 8"F29 +-'% $" 9" ($ 8+(2% 2('(#/ h H1 8-$7+(#/
+(6&%20 7%-&% $" H%>
`7($%9 (# Z"29$SY."#& )XXJB XNa
=%/-$('($1 -& $+% #(+(2(&$(7 =*44 #" &"#'*&? (& (#7"632%$-H2% H1 -#1 "&$@4 ($ (& -#
(#7"632%$-H2% 5%#9; 0". $+% &"2($-.1 &FHR%7$ 9F% $" $+% (63"&&(H(2($1 "0 7"(#S
7(9%#7% H%$8%%# $+% &(#/F2-. 3%.&"#-2 9%-$+ -#9 `(63%.&"#-2a 9%-$+ *#%$42>
Q& Z2-#7+"$ &-1&B %'%.1 9%-$+ (&B (# $+(& $%7+#(7-2 &%#&%B 5'"2F#$-.1;4 5*+F& (#
'"2F#$-.1 9%-$+ ($ (& &$(22 $H#)$5$ I9%%*F*#C $+-$ 8% 3%.7%('% h $+% 0-7$ $+-$
-7$("# +%.% (& "#21 $+% 6-&T "0 - 0-&7(#-$%9 9(&3"&&%&&("#; `Z2-#7+"$ )X?<B
)I<a>
*+% (..%9F7(H(2($1 "0 $+% 9(00%.%#7%B ". $+% 5#"#S9(00%.%#7%;B H%$8%%# $+%
'"2F#$-.1 -#9 $+% 3-&&('%B H%2"#/& $" - &%.(%& 8+(7+ /('%& 52($%.-.1; -77%&& $"
9%-$+B ".B $+% 9%7"#&$.F7$("# "0 ($& 5$.F$+;> *+% 5*%$ $& 9+C5$ (&B 0". $+%
8(22(#/ 8+(7+ 0-22& (#$" ($B .%9"FH2%9 -$ - 2%'%2 "# 8+(7+B 0". %V-632%B 8%
$""B -& '(%8%.& "0 $+(& 53(7$F.%; `0". ($ (& #" 2"#/%. 7%.$-(# 8+-$ (& F2$(6-$%21
5"# '(%8; (# -22 $+(&aB -.% (632(7-$%9 (# $+% 3-.-9"V%& "0 $+(& .%02%V('($1> - 95B
-$ "#7%B 9(&$F.H%9 H1 $+% (#&$-H(2($1 "0 61 (9%#$(0(7-$("# 8($+ $+% '(7$(6
`$+%.% HF$ 0". $+% /.-7% "0 ^"9 > > > a -#9 61 -6H('-2%#7% 8($+ .%&3%7$ $" 61
8($#%&&(#/ "0 $+(& &7%#%> Y -6B "0 7"F.&%B "F$&(9% ($& &3-$("S$%63".-2 0.-6%B
($& +(&$".(7-2 -#9 7F2$F.-2 7"#$%V$4 Y '(%8 $+% 5&7%#%; -& - 8+"2% `0". %V-632%
(# $+(& $%V$B #"8a> ZF$B (# 61 2""TB Y -2&" H".9%. "# ($ h Y &2(3 (# -#9 "F$ "0 $+%
7."89 8+(7+ 2""T& "#> Q& Z2-#7+"$ &-1&4 5O+"%'%. 8-#$& $" 9(% 7-# "#21
8-#$ $+% H".9%.& "0 9%-$+B $+% F$(2($-.(-# 9%-$+ 8+(7+ (& (# $+% 8".29 -#9
8+(7+ "#% .%-7+%& $+."F/+ $+% 3.%7(&("# "0 $+% 8".T6-#;& $""2&; `Z2-#7+"$
)X?<B )IJa> Y 6-1 %'%# 0(#9 61&%20 (9%#$(01(#/ 8($+ $+% 6-7+%$%S8(%29(#/
$".$F.%.B -#9 H%(#/ 9.-8#B '%.$(/(#"F&21B (#$" - 7"#$%632-$('% $%%$%.(#/ "#
$+% H.(#T "0 $+% 5%$+(7-2 -H1&&;>D Y#9%%9B $+(& (& $+% 3"(#$ -$ 8+(7+ $+%
8($#%&&]'(7$(6 9"FH2(#/ 6-T%& "#%;& &T(# 7.-82> Y$ (& -& (0 "#% 8%.%B 3.%7(&%21B
(6-/(#(#/ 9"(#/ $+(& $" "#%&%20> *+(& &7+(A"(9 (6-/(#-$("# %V3%.(%#7%& 9(0S
0(7F2$1 (# ($& 6-#(3F2-$("# "0 $+% &(6F2-7.- (# 32-1 +%.%B -& ($ -$$%63$& $"
6-(#$-(# $+% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# 8($#%&& -#9 '(7$(6 H1 6-33(#/ ($ "#$" $+%
YS'(7$(6]YS3%.3%$.-$". 9(&$(#7$("# `Y 8($#%&& 8($#%&&(#/B %$7>B -& 8%22 -& +$*&?
$+% 8($#%&&>a *+(& 3+%#"6%#"# (&B 3%.+-3&B #"$ 9(&&(6(2-. $" $+-$ %V3%.(S
%#7%9 (# /+"F2(&+ #(/+$6-.%&B (# 8+(7+ $+% 9(&$F.H-#7% "0 61 (9%#$(0(7-$("#
$+%.%8($+(# (& 6F2$(32(%9 H1 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ $+% +"..". -#9 3%.'%.&($1 Y -6
5%V3"&%9 $";B (& (# .%-2($1B -22 "2 5C "=& 59;*&?4 ($ (& - 0".6 "0 -F$"S-00%7$("#B
".B -F$"S6F$(2-$("#>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
H"$+ 8($#%&& $" 9&. '(7$(6 "0 '("2%#7%4 -& - 6"6%#$ "0 9"FH2(#/m -& -# -#S
#(+(2-$("# h $+% 0".%&$-22(#/ "0 -# -##(+(2-$("# 53."3%.;>< W". Z-$-(22%B 0".
%V-632%B (# $+% (63"&&(H(2($1 "0 - &"2(3&(&$(7 9%-$+4
*+(& %&&-1 8(22 -$$%63$ $" &+"8 $+% 6-##%. (# 8+(7+ $+(& 6"9%2B ". (6-/%B
"0 - 6F$(2-$("# 8+(7+ 6F$(2-$%& $+% '%.1 &1&$%6 "0 ($& .%3.%&%#$-$("#B (&
%$+(7-221 (#&$.F7$('%4 "#% 9"%& #"$ 0-22 ."=& $+% $F##%2 "0 .%02%7$%9 .%02%7S
$("#& (#$" 2($%.-.1 32-1 8($+"F$ %#9B "#% 0-22& +9/; (#$" $+% 8".29 "0 5.%-2;B
'("2%#$ %#7"F#$%.& +$#=$$& +F6-# H%(#/&> UV$%.(".($1 `-& %'%.19-1 2(0%B .%-S
2($1B %$7>a (& 3%.+-3& (#&%3-.-H2% 0."6 (#$%.(".($1 -#9 $+% &$.F7$F.%& "0 (#$%.(".
%V3%.(%#7%B HF$ ($ (& (# #" &%#&% 9.%-6%9 F3> Q& Q.$-F9 &-1&4 5$+% 8".&$ "0 ($ (&
($ (& $.F%;> *+% (6-/% (& "0 -# 5(#7(9%#$;m ($ .%-221 +-33%#%9B -& 8%22 -& H%(#/
$+(& `"$+%.a $+(#/ 8+(7+ ($ (&B "'%. -#9 H%1"#9 $+(& ". -#1 "$+%. 3-.$(7F2-.
(#7(9%#$4 6F.9%."F& '("2%#$ 6F$(2-$("#B (& +-33%#(#/ &"=>
*+%&% 7F.&".1 .%0%.%#7%& $" Z-$-(22% -#9 Q.$-F9 3."'(9% - &%#&% "0 +"8 $+%
6F$(2-$%9 H"91 (& #%($+%. &(6321 7".3".%-2 #". "F$&(9% "0 $+"F/+$B HF$
9+C%%94> *+% .%&$ "0 $+(& %&&-1 8(22 9(&7F&& #(+(2(&6 -#9 9&S#(+(2(&6 `$+%
(#$%..F3$("# ". .%'%.&-2 "0 -##(+(2(&$(7 #(+(2(&6a (# .%2-$("# $" $+% 6F$(2-$("#
"0 $+% 502%&+; -#9 $+% '("2%#7% 9(.%7$%9 -$ ($B H"$+ 8($+ .%&3%7$ $" -F$"S -#9
-2$%.S6F$(2-$("#> Q#9B H1 &+(0$(#/ $+% -33."-7+ $" $+% 502%&+; h - $%.6 8+(7+
6-.T& Q.$-F9;& .%R%7$("# "0 $+% 3+1&(7-2]6%#$-2 9(7+"$"61 h 6".%"'%.B $"
$+% &F.0-7% "0 7"#$-7$ H%$8%%# #'$ %95$ -#9 #'$ "#'$)B ($ 8(22 H% 3"&&(H2%
$" %#/-/% (# - 9(&7F&&("# "0 $+% %$+(7-2 &(/#(0(7-#7% "0 $+% &T(#B ". "0
5H%(#/S(#S-S&T(#;> ["(#/ &" -22"8& -# -33."-7+ $" $+% %$+(7-2 (# $%.6& "0
/9)&9#$B .-$+%. $+-# /"?&9#$ 2(0%m -#9 (# - 6-##%. F#(#02%7$%9 H1 %V32-#-$".1
.%9F7$("#(&6 "0 $+% 9(&7"F.&%& "0 $+% +F6-# &7(%#7%&> Y &+-22 7"#&(9%. $+%
%$+(7-2 &(/#(0(7-#7% "0 $+% &3%7(%& "0 56F$(2-$".1; '("2%#7% 9(.%7$%9 -$
$+% '(&7%.-2 H"91B $+% 02%&+B ".B $+% &T(#> U66-#F%2 K%e'(#-&; 9(&7F&&("# "0
$+% &T(# 8(22 3."'(9% $+% T%1 $" .%(#$%.3.%$(#/ 8+-$ ($ (& $+-$ 5"H&%&&%&; (# $+%
'(&7%.-2 '("2%#7% "0 -##(+(2(&$(7 #(+(2(&6B 9(.%7$(#/ $+(& -#-21&(& $" $+%
6"6%#$ (# 8+(7+ $+% %$+(7-2 .%&(&$-#7% "0 $+% L$+%. 5.%'%.&%&; (#$" 5C
.%&3"#&(H(2($1>
>)$= -(,-#'#"#%7 %$ (%+#1-T $, '(#,: -?#,,(2
*+% $F.# $" $+% H"91 (# 7"#$%63".-.1 $+%".1B (# 3-.$(7F2-. (# 7"##%7$("#
8($+ 9(&7F&&("#& "0 $+% 5%#9 "0 6%$-3+1&(7&; -#9 3"&$6"9%.#($1 (&B -H"'% -22B
(#9%H$%9 $" =(%$A&7+%;& $."3(7-2 9%32"16%#$ "0 ($ (# +(& 8.($(#/ $" 7"F#$%.
$+% $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 $%#9%#71 "0 6"9%.# .-$("#-2 $+"F/+$> G%$+(#T(#/ $+%
9(&7F.&('% H"91 `W"F7-F2$aB $+% 7-.#-2 H"91 `E%.2%-FSP"#$1aB $+% &%V%9 H"91
`Y.(/-.-1aB -& 8%22 -& - #F6H%. "0 &3%7(0(7 (#$%.3.%$-$("#& "0 $+% %7&$-$(7 H"91
`Z-$-(22%aB ". $+% 5H"91 8($+"F$ "./-#&; `Q.$-F9][%2%FA%]^F-$$-.(a 7-# -22B (#
$+%(. '-.("F& (#$%.%&$& -#9 7"#7%.#&B H% 0(/F.%9 (# .%2-$("# $" $+%
=(%$A&7+%-# 3."R%7$ "0 $+% 5.%'-2F-$("# "0 -22 '-2F%&;> Y 9" #"$ 3."3"&% $"
F#9%.$-T% +%.% - 9%$-(2%9 9(&7F&&("# "0 $+(& /%#%.-2 $+%".%$(7-2 (#9%H$%9#%&&
"0 .%7%#$ UF."3%-# $+"F/+$ $" =(%$A&7+%;& $F.# $" $+% H"91> M"8%'%.B $+(&
%&&-1 9"%& -(6B (# 3-.$B $" F#9%.&$-#9 $+% &(/#(0(7-#7% "0 $+% 8(9%21S
-7T#"82%9/%9B #(%$A&7+%-#S(#&3(.%9 .%$+(#T(#/ "0 $+% H"91B -& $+-$ 0."6
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<I< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
8($+(# 8+(7+ %$+(7& -#9 $+% (9%- "0 $+% %$+(7-2B %6%./%&>J Q#9B ($ .%7-22&
=(%$A&7+%;& .%6-.T %V3.%&&(#/ $+(&4 5"F. 6"&$ &-7.%9 7"#'(7$("#&B $+%
F#7+-#/(#/ %2%6%#$& (# "F. &F3.%6% '-2F%&B -.% RF9/6%#$& "0 "F. 6F&72%&;
`=(%$A&7+% )XN?B )C@a> *+% $+%6% "0 $+% %$+(7-2 (#7-.#-$% 8(22 H% -99.%&&%9
+%.%B 3.(#7(3-221B H1 8-1 "0 K%e'(#-&; -77"F#$ "0 %$+(7-2 &FHR%7$('($1 (#
$%.6& "0 ($& +$*&?J*&J9J%;*&> Y &+-22 -./F% $+-$ $+(& (& -# (9%- 8+(7+ (& 7%#$.-2
$" +(& 3+(2"&"3+1 "0 %$+(7-2 -#S#(+(2(&6B 8+(7+ $+(#T& $+% %$+(7-2 6"6%#$
-& $+% (#$%..F3$("# "0 -##(+(2(&$(7 #(+(2(&6> *+(& -#-21&(&B $+%#B 7"F29 H% &-(9
$" -(6 -$ -# %$+(7"S3-$+"2"/1 "0 '("2%#7% -& '("2%#7% 9(.%7$%9 -/-(#&$
$+% 02%&+B ".B .-$+%.B -$ #'$ %;*& `$+% 3.%0%..%9 $%.6 +%.% -& $+(& %63+-&(&%&
$+% 4*5*&94*#C "0 $+% 02%&+aB 7"#&(9%.%9 -& $+% 2(6($ H%$8%%# #'$ %95$ -#9 #'$
"#'$)>
Y# K%e'(#-&; Q#'$)=*%$ #'9& <$*&? ") <$C"&. 6%%$&/$B $+% &T(# 0(/F.%& 3."6(S
#%#$21 (# -# -77"F#$ "0 F,4&$)9+*4*#C -& $+% 57"#9($("#; 0". $+% %$+(7-2 .%2-$("#
$" $+% L$+%.> Y# $+% 5($(#%.-.1; "0 $+-$ 8".TB K%e'(#-& 9%72-.%& +(& (#$%#$("# $"
59(&%#/-/% $+% &FHR%7$('($1 "0 $+% &FHR%7$ 0."6 .%02%7$("#& "# $.F$+B $(6% -#9
H%(#/ > > > -#9 $" 3.%&%#$ $+% &FHR%7$ > > > -& %$&%*+*4*#C 2)"5 #'$ 2*)%# -#(6-$%9 H1
.%&3"#&(H(2($(%&; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B )XB 5C $5I'9%*%a> ,%#&(H(2($1 (&B (# 0-7$B 7"#&$-#$ $+%6% (# K%e'(#-& 0."6 +(& %-.2(%&$ 8".T& "#8-.9&4 8+%$+%. 9(&$(#S
/F(&+(#/ &%#&(H(2($1 0."6 (#$F($("# (# $+% )X@I H""T "# MF&&%.2m 9(&7F&&(#/
($& ."2% (# $+% +13"&$-&(& -#9 (3&%($1 "0 $+% %V(&$%#$ (# .%2-$("# $" $+% 5$+%.% (&;
`*4 C 9a (# $+% 8".T& "0 $+% 6(9S)XDI&m %632"1(#/ -# -#-21&(& "0 $"F7+ (# +(&
7.($(_F% "0 M%(9%//%. (# D"#94*#C 9&. -&2*&*#C -& 8%22 -& 32-1(#/ - T%1 ."2% (#
+(& 2-$%. -77"F#$ "0 61 (#0(#($% "H2(/-$("# $" $+% L$+%.B (# 8+(7+ $+%
&(/#(0(7-#7% "0 #'$ %;*& (& H."F/+$ $" $+% 0".%>
*+.%% "H'("F& 7"#&(9%.-$("#& 8-..-#$ 9(&7F&&(#/ &%#&(H(2($1 (# .%2-$("# $"
$+% &T(# -#9 $+% &T(# (# .%2-$("# $" %$+(7&4 2"7-$(#/ $+% &T(#B &" $" &3%-TB
+$#=$$& &%#&(H(2($1 -#9 $+% %$+(7-2> W(.&$21B $+%.% (& $+% 0-7$ $+-$ $+% &T(# (&B (#
%'%.1 &%#&%B $+% "./-# "0 &%#&(H(2($14 ($ (& #"$ $+% &%#&% "0 $"F7+ -2"#% $+-$ (&
5"0 $+% &T(#;> *+% .%$(#- "0 $+% %1%B $+% $163-# "0 $+% %-. -#9 $+% 6F7"F&
6%6H.-#%& "0 $+% #"&% -#9 6"F$+ -.% -22 &T(#S&($%& "0 7-.#-$% &%#&-$("#-2
(#$%#&($1> ,%7"#921B $+% &T(# (& 58($+"F$ 6%$-3+".; h - 3+.-&% K%e'(#-& (& 0"#9
"0 -#9 $" 8+(7+ 8% 6F&$ .%$F.# h $+% H"F#9-.1 H%$8%%# $+% 6% -#9 $+%
#"#S6% -#9 /('%& 6% $+% &%#&% "0 61 H%(#/ -# (#$%.(".($1 $HI"%$. $" %VS
$%.(".($1> *+(.921B -& - $+%6%B ". - $."3% -$ $+% '%.1 2%-&$B $+% &T(# 7-# H%
0(/F.%9 (# .%2-$("# $" $+% 2"/(7 "0 $+% H".9%. -#9 ($& ,&.$/*.9+4*#CB (# $+% &%#&%
/('%# -H"'%B -#9 8($+ $+(& 7"6%& - 8+"2% .-#/% (&&F%& .%2-$%9 $" $+% 2(6($& "0
3+(2"&"3+1 -#9 $+% =(%$A&7+%-#hM%(9%//%.(-# $+%6% "0 5"'%.7"6(#/
#(+(2(&6;>
*+%&% .%02%7$("#& -(6 $" 7"#&(9%. 8+-$ ."2% $+% &T(# 32-1& (# 5%$+(7-2
&FHR%7$('($1; -#9 $" &%% (0 ($ (& 6%-#(#/0F2 $" &3%-T "0 5"'%.7"6(#/; `-##(+(2S
(&$(7a #(+(2(&6 (# $+% 0".6 "0 -# %$+(7& "0 7-.#-2($1 h -# %$+(7& 8+(7+ %6%./%&
0."6 $+% &T(# .-$+%. $+-# -& $+% 5(9%-; "0 - $.-#&7%#9%#$-2 &FHR%7$> *+%1 &%%T
-2&" $" 7"#&(9%. +"8 &F7+ -# %$+(7& 6-1 &%.'% -# 5%$+(7"S3-$+"2"/(7-2;
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9F*. <""#')"C. <I@
F#9%.&$-#9(#/ "0 '("2%#7%B $+% '("2%#7% 8+(7+ (& $+% $F$&# "0 %$+(7-2 #(+(2S
(&6B ".B 6F.9%."F& '("2%#7%B -#9 (# .%2-$("# $" 8+(7+ $+% .$M/'*),)$ "0 $+%
&T(#B -& H"$+ 8"F#9 -#9 9(&7F.&('% "3%#(#/B 8(22 -22"8 F& $" -33."-7+> *+%
$+%6% "0 &-7.(0(7% (& -2&" 7%#$.-2 $" $+(& -#-21&(& -& ($ (& - 0".6 "0 &-7.(0(7(-2
6F$(2-$("# 8+(7+ 2(#T&B -& 9"%& 'F2#%.-H(2($1 (# K%e'(#-&; -77"F#$B &%#&(H(2($1
$" $+% 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 ?*F*&?> kF&$ $" (#9(7-$% +"84 0". K%e'(#-&B "#21 H%7-F&% Y
-6 - H%(#/ 8+(7+ +-& $-&$%9 H.%-9 (# 61 6"F$+ -6 Y -H2% $" &-7.(0(7% 61
"8# &F&$%#-#7% -#9 6-T% "0 ($ - /(0$ $" $+% "$+%.> *+(& (& - .%7F..%#$ 0(/F.% (#
Q#'$)=*%$ #'9& <$*&? ") <$C"&. 6%%$&/$4
*+% &FHR%7$ (& "0 02%&+ -#9 H2""9B - 6-# $+-$ (& +F#/.1 -#9 %-$&B `(&a
%#$.-(2& (# - &T(#B -#9 $+F& 7-3-H2% "0 /('(#/ $+% H.%-9 "F$ "0 $+%
6"F$+B ". ?*F*&? '*% %;*&>
`K%e'(#-& )XC?B CC 5C $5I'9%*%>a
UV3.%&&("#& &F7+ -& $+(&B 8+(7+ -H"F#9 (# K%e'(#-&; .%'-2F-$("# "0 &%#&(H(2($1B
H%/ $+% _F%&$("# "0 $+% &$-$F& "0 $+% 0(/F.-2 (# -# -77"F#$ $+-$ 9(.%7$& F& $"
$+% %$+(7-2 .%-2(&6 "0 0-7% $" 0-7% .%2-$("#&> U63(.(7(&6 -#9 $+% .%3.%&%#$-S
$("# "0 $+% %63(.(7-221 .%-2 -.% -$ (&&F% $+."F/+"F$ $+(& .%'-2F-$("# "0
&%#&(H(2($14 $+% &T(# (&B -0$%. -22B $+% &FH&$-#7% "0 &%#&-$("# -#9 $+% "./-# "0
$+% %63(.(7-2> Y$ 7-# -2&" 2($%.-221 H% /('%#> W". %V-632%B (# $+% 7-&% "0 '-#
^"/+;& &%'%.(#/ "0 +(& %-. -#9 6-T(#/ "0 ($ - /(0$ `&%% Z-$-(22% )XXJB N)hC<a ".B
"0 3%.0".6-#7% -.$(&$ L.2-#;& /('(#/ `-#9 6%.7+-#9(&(#/a "0 H"91 $(&&F%
.%6"'%9 (# +%. 8".T "0 &%20S$.-#&0".6-$("#BN ".B (# $+% &"6%8+-$ 2%&& H(A-..%
0".6 "0 $+% "./-# 9"#-$("# &3"#&".%9 H1 6%9(7(#%B 8% &%% -# (#9(7-$("# "0
$+% 6-##%. (# 8+(7+ %'%# 5/('(#/ "#%;& &T(#; /9& +$ - #"#S0(/F.-2 0".6 "0
-33."-7+ $" -#"$+%. 3%.&"#> *+(& (& (#9%%9 - &$.-#/% &".$ "0 5%63(.(7(&6;
`-#9 - #F6H%. "0 F#F&F-2 %V-632%& "0 5/%#%."&($1;aB 3-.$(7F2-.21 /('%# K%e'(S
#-&; "0$%# +(/+21 0(/F.-$('% &$12% "0 %V3.%&&("#B HF$ $+% 3"(#$ "0 .%0%..(#/
$" $+%6 +%.% (& $+-$ $+%1 %-7+ .%0%. $+% .%-9%. 9(.%7$21 H-7T $" 5.%-2 2(0%;m $"
$+% 5+%.% -#9 #"8; "0 $+% &%#&F-2 -#9 $" 2(0% -& 502%&+ -#9 H2""9;> Y# - 7%.$-(#
F#-3"2"/%$(7-221 F#3+(2"&"3+(7-2 T(#9 "0 8-1B $+(& (& .-$+%. 2(T% &-1(#/ $+-$
8+%# K%e'(#-& $-2T& -H"F$ $+% &T(# +% (& $-2T(#/ -H"F$ $+% 9/#,94 &T(#B $+% &T(#
8+(7+ 7-# H% 8"F#9%9B 8+(7+ H2%%9& -#9 8+(7+ $"F7+%&> ZF$ $+(& 5-7$F-2;
9"%& #"$ .%0%. $" $+% %63(.(7(&$ #-$F.-2(&6 "0 $+% I'C%*/94 &T(# h $+% &T(# -&
7"#7%3$F-2(&%9 8($+(# -#-$"6"SH("2"/1 h #". 9"%& ($ .%0%. $" -#1 *.$9 "0 $+%
&T(# (# $%.6& "0 ='9# *# *%> ="#%$+%2%&&B 8% .%-94 5$+% %V3.%&&("# 55(# "#%;&
&T(#;; (& #"$ - 6%$-3+".; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B )IXa> K%e'(#-&; .%6-.T& -H"F$ $+% &T(#
-(6 $" /('% -# -77"F#$ "0 ($ 0(/F.(#/ ($ "$+%.8(&% $+-# (# "#$"2"/(7-2 2-#S
/F-/%> Q#9 -2$+"F/+ ($ (&B -./F-H21B 3+(2"&"3+(7-221 (63%.6(&&(H2% (# $+%
0(#-2 -#-21&(&B $+(& (& %V3.%&&%9 (# $%.6& "0 $+% &T(#;& `H%(#/a %*?&*2C*&?&$%%4 &(/#(01(#/#%&& 8($+"F$ - &(/#(0(7-$("#m &"6%$+(#/ 8+(7+ (& 58+"221 &(/#B
&(/#(01(#/ ($&%20; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B )Ja h $+-$ (&B 8($+"F$ ($& H%(#/ .%3.%&%#$%9
(# - $+%6%> *+% &T(# (& $+F& -2&" 9%&7.(H%9 -& 5- 6"9-2($1 "0 $+% &FHR%7$('%;
`K%e'(#-& )XC?B <Na>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<ID !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
G%$+(#T(#/ $+% &%#&(H(2($1 "0 $+% &T(# (&B ($ (& 3."3"&%9 +%.%B - T%1 $" - #"#S
%&&%#$(-2(&$ #"$("# "0 5%$+(7-2 &FHR%7$('($1; "0 $+% 56%; `4$ 5"*a> Q 7F.&".1
9%7"#&$.F7$('% .%02%7$("# "# $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# -%&$+%S
&("2"/(7-2 &%#&F-2($1 -#9 &%#$(%#7%B 8(22 &+"8 +"8 $+(& &%#&F-2($1 (& .%2%/-$%9
$" - &FH&%.'(%#$ ."2% (# .%2-$("# $" T#"82%9/%> U63(.(7-221 &3%-T(#/B "# $+%
"#% +-#9B $+% &T(# (& 7"#&(9%.%9 $" H% $+% F#$+"F/+$ 6-$%.(-2($1 "0 7-.#-2
&%#&-$("#> ZF$B "# $+% "$+%.B 0."6 $+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 $+%".%$(7-2 .%02%7$("#B
$+% &T(# 7"#&$($F$%& $+% 2(6($ "0 61 &FHR%7$('% H%(#/ -#9 $+% H"F#9-.1 "0 $+%
&FHR%7$ %#72"&%9 8($+(# ($> *+(& (& -$$%&$%9 $" (# &" 0-. -& $+% &T(# -#9 ($&
9('%.&% &%#&".1 &F.0-7%& -.% 6-9% -# "+K$/# "0 .%02%7$("# (# I)$%$&#*2C*&? 4"?"%m
$+% &T(# (& $.-9($("#-221 $+"F/+$ (# $+% $%.6& "0 9%.6-$"4"?CB "0 "#% &3%7(%&
". -#"$+%.> Q/-(#&$ $+(& 9%+(&7%#7%B +"8%'%.B ($ 7-# H% -./F%9 $+-$ $+% &T(#
(&B _F($% 2($%.-221B *&J+$#=$$& H%(#/ $+% %63(.(7-2 h F#9%.&$""9 -& $+% '%.1
&FH&$-#7% "0 %63(.(7($1 `8+(7+ .%02%7$("# $+(#T& -& &%#&-$("#a h -#9 $+%
$.-#&7%#9%#$-2 "HR%7$ "0 9%.6-$"2"/(7-2 $+"F/+$B 8+(7+ 3"&($& ($ -& &F7+> Y$
(& H"$+ 2('%9 9&. .%02%7$%9 (# $+"F/+$m ($ (& -$ "#7% $+% 2(6($ "0 (66-#%#$
%/"2"/(7-2 2(0% -#9 -2&" $+% &F.0-7% "# 8+(7+ $+% %V$%.(".($1 "0 %'%.1$+(#/
8+(7+ (& #"$ 6%B (63.%&&%& ($&%20 "# 6%>
Y# $+(& .%&3%7$B $+% &T(# (& -# -22"6".3+ "0 8+-$ [%..(9- +-& $%.6%9
,&.$/*.9+*4*#C> Q#9 - 9%7"#&$.F7$('% .%S8.($(#/ "0 $+% &T(# (# $%.6& "0 ($&
%$+(7-2($1B 6F&$ (#'"2'% $+% 9%&$-H(2(&-$("# "0 $+% 9%7(&("# "0 ($& 6%-#(#/
8($+(# 6%$-3+1&(7&> G%8.($(#/ $+% &T(# .%_F(.%& - .%$+(#T(#/ "0 $+% &%#&F-2
-#9 ($& .%2-$("# $" 6%-#(#/B &" $" &3%-TB +$?*&&*&? =*#' #'$ %;*&> ZF$ H%0".% 8%
&$-.$ -/-(#B (# $+(& &%#&%B 2%$ F& .%02%7$ H.(%021 "# 3+(2"&"3+1;& .$/*%*"& "0 $+%
&T(#B 8+(7+ K%e'(#-&; 9(&7"F.&% (& (# $+% 3."7%&& "0 .%'%.&(#/ -#9 $.-#&0(/F.S
(#/>
M"8 (& $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 $+% &%#&F-2B &%#&-$("# -#9 &%#&(H(2($1B %V3.%&&%9 H1
$+% 8+"2% 0-6(21 "0 $%.6& %V3.%&&(#/ $+% -%&$+%&("2"/(7-2 (# 2(0%B 9%$%.6(#%9
8($+(# 6%$-3+1&(7&i Z.(%021B ($ (& $+F&4 G%-&"#B &3%-T(#/ "0 ($&%20 (# 6"9%.#
3+(2"&"3+1B +-& /%#%.-221 -(6%9 $" $.-#&7%#9 $+% &FHR%7$('% %V3%.(%#7% "0
&%#&F-2($1> *+% $.-#&7%#9%#7% "0 &%#&F-2($1 .%&$& "# G%-&"#;& .%02%7$('% -H(2S
($1 $" 3F22 $+(& %V3%.(%#7% -3-.$B 9(00%.%#$(-$(#/ H%$8%%# &%#&-$("# -#9
&%#$(%#7%m H%$8%%# &%#&(#/ -#9 $+% 7"/#($("# "0 &%#&-$("# 8+(7+ ($ ($&%20
(&> Y# $+(& &7+%6-B - &%7"#9-.1 ."2% (& -&&(/#%9 $" $+% 0".6%. 8($+ .%&3%7$ $"
$+% T#"82%9/% 7"/#($("# F#9%.&$-#9& ($&%20 $" H%> O+%$+%. (#B &-1B 3+%#"6S
%#-2(&6B &%#&-$("#-2(&6B &%#&%S9-$- $+%".1B 3"&($('(&$ #-$F.-2(&6B ". %'%# "#
$+% 6"9%2 "0 $+% &1#$+%$(7 9 I)*")*B &%#&F-2($1 (& $-T%# $" H% *&%#),5$^ (#
.%2-$("# $" `$+% -7$ "0a 6%-#(#/ `A*&&?$+,&?a> !"#&%_F%#$21B ($ (& %($+%.
9%$%.6(#%9 -& $+% 5&FHR%7$('(&6; "0 F#.%02%7$%9 5#-$F.-2 %V3%.(%#7%; -#9
7"#&(9%.%9 $" H% %3(&$%6"2"/(7-221 9FH("F& `-77".9(#/ $" -# -./F6%#$
-2"#/ !-.$%&(-# 2(#%&aB ". ($ (& .%/-.9%9 -& - 6%.% -33-.-$F& &F3321(#/
$+"F/+$ `7"#&7("F&#%&&a 8($+ '-2F%S0.%%B %63(.(7-2 9-$- F3"# 8+(7+ ($ -7$&>
Q/-(#&$ $+(& 6"'% -#9 $+% 8-1& "0 $+(#T(#/ 8+(7+ %#&F% 0."6 ($B `.-#/(#/
0."6 #-$F.-2(&6 (# &7(%#7% $" $+% 6%$-3+1&(7-2 3+(2"&"3+1 "0 $+% T(#9 b-#$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9F*. <""#')"C. <IJ
.%R%7$%9a $+% 0F#9-6%#$-2 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 /%&$F.% "0 MF&&%.2;& 3+%#"6%#"S
2"/1 (& $" -$$%63$ - .%7F3%.-$("# -#9 .%'-2F-$("# "0 &%#&F-2 2(0% 0."6 8($+(#
2('%9S%V3%.(%#7%> Y$& -33%-2 $" #"#S$+%$(7 %V3%.(%#7% .%&$& "# $+% (9%#$(0(7-S
$("# "0 - 2%'%2 "0 7"#&7("F& 2(0%B "#$"2"/(7-221 3.(". $" $+%".%$(7-2 $+"F/+$
-#9 &"# C$# .%2%/-$%9 h -& ($ (& 9%&$(#%9 h $" $+% (#&$.F6%#$-2 &%.'(7% "0
T#"82%9/%> Y$ (& (# &163-$+1 8($+ $+% -#$(S%3(&$%6"2"/(7-2 &3(.($ "0 3+%S
#"6%#"2"/1 `.-$+%. $+-# $+% 3+(2"&"3+1 "0 7"#&7("F&#%&&a $+-$ K%e'(#-&
-./F%& $+-$ 9&C %3(&$%6"2"/1 /%$& F#9%.8-1 -#9 -&&%.$& ($& 3.%."/-$('% H1
5-#-%&$+%$(A(#/; $+% &T(# `K%e'(#-& )XC?B NDa>
Q#1 -$$%63$ $" .%$+(#T &T(#21 &%#&-$("# (# .%2-$("# $" &%#$(%#7% `(# $%.6&
"0 &%#&(H2% (#$F($("#B .%/-.9%9 -& - 3.%S.%02%7$('% 5-7$;B - #"#S$+%$(7 A*&&?$J
+,&?a (& -$ 3-(#& #"$ $" .%3%-$ $+% %63(.(7(&$ &%#&F-2(&6 "0 "#$"2"/(7-2
6%$-3+1&(7&B 8+(7+ &"2'%& $+% 3."H2%6 "0 (#0%.%#7% `(>%> "0 $+% 5%V$%.#-2($1;
"0 .%-2($1a H1 7"22-3&(#/ .%02%7$("# "#$" ($& "HR%7$ (# $+% 7"(#7(9%#7% "0
$+"F/+$ -#9 0%%2(#/> Y# '(%8 "0 $+(&B ($ (& 8".$+ .%7-22(#/ -$ 2%-&$ $+% &3(.($
"0 K%e'(#-&; "8# -33."3.(-$("# "0 $+% /.%-$ 2%-3 0".8-.9 $+% MF&&%.2(-# $I"/'$M
.%3.%&%#$& "'%. $.-9($("#-2 6%$-3+1&(7&> *+% $I"/'$M -99.%&&%& H"$+ $+% #-('%
%63(.(7(&6 8+(7+ &F33"&%& &%#&-$("# $" H% F#6%9(-$%9 72"&%#%&& $" $+% .%-2B
-& 8%22 -& $+% .%02%7$("# 8+(7+ $-T%& ($&%20 $" H% $.F% T#"82%9/% 9(&$(#7$ 0."6
&%#&-$("#> Y$ .%R%7$& $+% $+"F/+$]&%#&% 9(&$(#7$("# 7%#$.-2 $" $+% %63(.(7(&$
#"$("# "0 %V3%.(%#7% -#9 $+% %3(&$%6"2"/1 "0 &FHR%7$ -#9 "HR%7$ $+-$ /"%&
8($+ ($B 8+(2&$ .%$-(#(#/ $+% 3."R%7$ "0 6-T(#/ 3+(2"&"3+1 - 5.(/"."F&
&7(%#7%;B H-&%9 "# - 5.%$F.# $" $+(#/& $+%6&%2'%&;>
ZF$ (0 $+% $I"/'$M -'"(9& $+% $.-3 "0 &%#&F-2(&6B ($ 9"%& &" H1 F2$(6-$%21
.%$-(#(#/ -#9 `.%a3.('(2%/(#/ $+%".%$(7-2 (#$%#$("#-2($1 `&"6%$+(#/ 8+(7+
K%e'(#-& &" 7"#&(&$%#$21 -&&"7(-$%& 8($+ $+% "#$"2"/(7-2 6%$-3+1&(7& +%
"33"&%&a> [%&3($% $+(&B K%e'(#-& -7T#"82%9/%& $+% &(/#(0(7-#7% "0 MF&&%.2;&
7.($(_F% "0 T#"82%9/% 9% T#"82%9/%> Q#9B 6"&$ (63".$-#$21 "# K%e'(#-&;
-77"F#$B $+% G%9F7$("# -22"8& $+% _F%&$("#(#/ "0 $+% .%3.%&%#$-$("# "0
"HR%7$& "0 $+"F/+$ (# #'$5$%> Y$ -7+(%'%& -# 5-8-T%#(#/; "0 $+"F/+$ $" ($&
"8# 5%00%7$&; F3"# ($& &F33"&%9 "HR%7$& "0 (#$F($("#m $+(& (& -# -8-T%#(#/ -&
&$-.$2(#/ -& $+-$ 8+(7+ b-#$ -&&"7(-$%9 8($+ 3+(2"&"3+1;& #%%9 $" -8-T%#
0."6 ($& 59"/6-$(7 &2F6H%.; -#9 0"./%$0F2#%&& "0 $+% %63(.(7-2B H1 6%-#& "0
7.($(7-2 3+(2"&"3+1> [%&3($% ($& -9'-#$-/%&B $+%#B K%e'(#-& %63+-&(&%& $+-$
MF&&%.2(-# 3+%#"6%#"2"/1 (& F2$(6-$%21 56"$('-$%9 "#21 H1 $+% #-('% 7"#S
&(9%.-$("#& %6%./(#/ (# F#9%.&$-#9(#/; -#9 $+% #%%9 $" %V3"&% 5$+% -.H($S
.-.(#%&& "0 &3%7F2-$('% 7"#&$.F7$("#&; `K%e'(#-& )XX)B <)Da> *+% 6"$('-$("# "0
$+(& $+(#T(#/ (& "$+%.8(&% $+-# 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 "# %'%.1 2%'%2B -#9 ($ &%%T& $"
$.(//%. -#"$+%. -2-.6> *+(& -2-.6 (&B 2($%.-221 "#% 6(/+$ &-1B $" $+% %63(.(7S
-221 -2-.6(#/B 7-22(#/ "0 6% $" 61 .%&3"#&(H(2($1 H1 $+% L$+%.B - 50-7$;
-$$%&$%9 $" (# $+% $5I*)*/94 %'%#$ "0 "H2(/-$("# `&%% [-'(%& )XXJB )I@a>
K%e'(#-&; 7"#$(#F"F& .%0%.%#7% $"B -#9 .%%63+-&(& "0 $+% 5%63(.(7-2; &+"F29
#%($+%. H% /2"&&%9 "'%.B #". F#7.($(7-221 .%/-.9%9 -& 6%.%21 - &F3%.0(7(-2
-&3%7$ "0 +(& 0(/F.-$('% 3."&% &$12%> Y$ (&B (# 0-7$B 3-.$ "0 - .%($%.-$('% &$.-$%/1
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<IN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
.%7-22(#/ +"8 $+% 5'("2%#7% "0 $+% 7"#7%3$; -#9 $+% .%3.%&%#$-$("# "0 $+%
"$+%. (# $+%6%&B (& #%'%. 6%.%21 - 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 3."H2%6 HF$ - 7"#&%_F%#7%
"0 $+% 7-.#-$% '(&7%.-2($1 "0 $+% 56%; -#9 "0 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ $+% F2$(6-$%
%V$.%6% '("2%#7%B 6F.9%.B 7-# 7"6%B -& K%e'(#-& &-1& (# D"#94*#C 9&. -&2*&*#CB
(# $+% H-#-2 &F&7%3$(H(2($1 5$" '("2%#7% 0."6 - H2-9% "0 &$%%2; `K%e'(#-&
)XNXB <@Ja> *+% H2-9% "0 &$%%2B (# %-7+ (#&$-#7%B (# H%(#/ -(6%9 -$ -#1
-&3%7$ "0 - &T(#21 %V$%.(".B (&B F2$(6-$%21B -2&" H%(#/ -(6%9 -$ - 50-7%; `K%e'(#-&
)XNXB <<Ja>
[%..(9-B (# +(& 0(.&$ 6-R". .%&3"#&% $" K%e'(#-&B X*"4$&/$ 9&. 3$#9I'C%*/%B
&3"T% "0 $+% 5.%#%8-2 "0 %63(.(7(&6; (632(7($ (# $+% -33%-2 $" $+% 53F.%
&(/#(01(#/#%&&;B 8+(7+ D"#94*#C 9&. -&2*&*#C -&&"7(-$%& 8($+ $+% 0-7% "0 $+%
"$+%. 8($+(# $+% %$+(7-2 .%2-$("#B $+% 50-7% $" 0-7%;> M% &3"T% -2&" "0 +"8
-#1 .%#%8-2B -#1 .%S8.($(#/ "0 %63(.(7(&6B 8"F29 H% 8+"221 9%3%#9%#$ "#
$+-$ 8+(7+ ($ &"F/+$ $" .%#"F#7% h $+% "#$"2"/1 "0 $+% ,-6%> Y# "$+%. 8".9&B
($ 6F&$ H% -&T%9 +"8 &F7+ - #"$("# 7"F29 H% H"$+ 6%-#(#/0F2 -#9 1%$ %&7-3%
$+% 7"#72F&("# $+-$ $+(& -33%-2 (&B (# $+% 0(#-2 -#-21&(&B "#% "0 &%#$(6%#$B
".B 7"#&7(%#7%> K%e'(#-& 6F&$ $+%.%0".% F#9%.$-T% $" 9%6"#&$.-$% +"8
5"H2(/-$("#; (& %00%7$('%21 #"#S3+(2"&"3+(7-2B ".B 3.%S".(/(#-.1B F#$+%6-$(&%9
&(/#(01(#/#%&& `2($%.-221 #"#S&%#&%a4 - &(/#(01(#/ 8+(7+ /"5$% $" 6% 8($+"F$
-33%-.(#/ (# - $+%6%>
Y# Q#'$)=*%$ #'9& <$*&?B K%e'(#-& 9"%& (#9%%9B -2H%($ "H2(_F%21B F#9%.$-T% $"
.%$+(#T $+% %63(.(7-2B H1 7"#$(#F(#/ 8($+ $+% $+%6% "0 $+% .%2-$("# H%$8%%#
&%#&(H(2($1 -#9 $+% %$+(7-2B HF$ #"8 $+% -33."-7+ (& 2-./%21 0."6 $+% 3%.S
&3%7$('% "0 .%02%7$("# `(>%> 3+(2"&"3+1a> O+%.%-& D"#94*#C 9&. -&2*&*#C +-9
&3"T%# "0 $+% YSL$+%. 7"#RF#7$F.% -& (0 $+(& +-9 H%%# -.$(7F2-$%9 0."6 =*#'*&
$+% 50-7% $" 0-7%; h -& (0 0."6 H%1"#9 H%(#/B (# Q#'$)=*%$ #'9& <$*&? &%#&(H(2($1
-#9 $+% %$+(7-2 -.%B 0."6 $+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 .%02%7$("#B &+"8# $" H% 7"#$%.6S
(#-2> *+% .%2-$("# $" $+% 0-7% H%(#/ $+%.%H1 H."F/+$ 9"8# $" %-.$+4 5,(/#(01S
(#/#%&&B $+% "#%S0".S$+%S"$+%.B (& %V3"&%9#%&& "0 &%20 $" -#"$+%. > > > > Y$ (& $+%
(66%9(-71 "0 - &T(# -#9 - 0-7%B - &T(# 8+(7+ (& -28-1& - 6"9(0(7-$("# "0 0-7%B - 0-7% $+-$ (& 8%(/+$%9 9"8# 8($+ - &T(#; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B ?Ja> *+(& H%(#/
58%(/+$%9 9"8#; (& - .%0%.%#7% $" $+% -F$"7+$+"#1 "0 - H%(#/ 8+(7+ +-& ($&
H-&% (# 57-.#-2($1;B -#9 $+% (#$%.0-7% "0 $+% %$+(7-2 -#9 $+% 7-.#-2 (& &FHS
&%_F%#$21 .%0%..%9 $" $+% &%#&(H(2($1 H".#% "# $+% &T(#>
W."6 $+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 7-.#-2 H%(#/B $+% &T(#B 9"%& #"$ -33%-. 9% %,/' -$
-22m ($ (&B (# - 6-##%. "0 &3%-T(#/B 3F.% &%#&F-2($1>C ZF$ 2%$;& H% 72%-.B $"
9%&7.(H% $+% &T(# (# $%.6& "0 ($& H%(#/ $+% 57"#9($("#; 0". &%#&".1 3%.7%3$("#B
6".%"'%.B $+% 5%63(.(7-2; 7"#9($("# 0". $+(&B 8"F29 H% - 6(&#"6%.
3%.3%$.-$%9 H1 $+%6-$(&(#/ $+"F/+$ -& ($ 72-(6& $+% &%#&(H2% -& $+% "HR%7$
"0 ($& (#$F($("#> ,F7+ - 3.('(2%/(#/ "0 $+% %V$%.(". 3%.&3%7$('%B (&B 3.%7(&%21B
8+-$ /('%& .(&% $" $+% H"91 .%3.%&%#$%9 (# #-$F.-2 &7(%#7%> L0 $+(& 5&%%#;
H"91B E%.2%-FSP"#$1 "#7% &-(94 ($ (& 5"#21 - &+-9"8 &$F00%9 8($+ "./-#&;
`E%.2%-FSP"#$1 )XN<B )@?a h - .%6-.T %7+"%9 (# K%e'(#-&; 9%&7.(3$("# "0
$+(& H"91 -& 5%#$.-(2& (# - &T(#; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B CCa> *+% $%.6 5&%#&(H(2($1; (#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9F*. <""#')"C. <IC
<I? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Q $+%.6-2B /F&$-$('% ". "20-7$".1 &%#&-$("# (& #"$ 3.(6-.(21 - 7"/#($("# "0
3-(#B - &-'".B ". -# "9"F.> =" 9"FH$ ($ 7-# $-T% "# $+(& &(/#(0(7-$("# "0
H%(#/ - 9(&7"'%.1 `HF$ "#21a H1 2"&(#/ ($& "8# &%#&% `%$&% I)"I)$aB H%7"6S
(#/ -# %V3%.(%#7% "2 > > > B - 7"#&7("F&#%&& "2 > > > B 532-7(#/ ($&%20; H%0".% #'$
+$*&? $HI"%$. *& *#% #'$5$>
`K%e'(#-& )XC?B NJ 5C $5I'9%*%a
*+% %V3.%&&("# 52"&(#/ ($& "8# &%#&%; +%.% 32-1& "# $+% 9"FH2% 7"##"$-$("#
"0 %$&% -& 56%-#(#/; -#9 59(.%7$("#;4 &%#&(H(2($1 2"&%& ($& "8# 56%-#(#/; H1
H%7"6(#/ $+% #"%6-$(7 7"..%2-$% "0 - &"$%*%B (#&$%-9 "0 6-(#$-(#(#/ ($& %$&%$
-& - 3F.% &"$594 5($ (& - #"%6- 8($+"F$ - #"%&(&; `K%e'(#-& )XNXB NJa> K%e'(#-&
+%.% $-./%$& $+% MF&&%.2(-# 9(7$F6 $+-$ 5-22 7"#&7("F&#%&& (& 7"#&7("F&#%&&
"0 > > > &"6%$+(#/; "# $+% /."F#9 $+-$ ($ (& 0"F#9%9 H1 -$$.(HF$(#/ $" &%#&S
(H(2($1 - 5*%S9(.%7$%9 (#$%#$("#-2($1> *+% 3"(#$ H%(#/ $+-$ H"$+ MF&&%.2;&
3+%#"6%#"2"/1 `%V32(7($21a -#9 E%.2%-FSP"#$1;& 3+%#"6%#"2"/1 `(# - 2%&&
"H'("F& 8-1a .%6-(# 7"66($$%9 $" $+% 53-.-22%2(&6; "0 59F-2($(%& -#9 $+%&%&;B
".B $+% "H'%.&%h.%'%.&% &$.F7$F.% "0 &%#&(H(2($1 `$+% E%.2%-FSP"#$%-# 5&%#&(S
H2%S&%#$(%#$;a> Q/-(#&$ $+(&B K%e'(#-& 9%72-.%& +(& .%#F#7(-$("# "0 $+% (#$%#S
$("#-2($1 8+(7+ -7$& -& - 5/F(9(#/ $+.%-9 $"8-.9 $+% $*."% "0 $+% 3&17+%
8+(7+ 8"F29 7"66-#9 $+% $*."% "0 &%#&(H(2($1;B -99(#/ $+-$ +(& -#-21&%&
5=*44 2"44"= %$&%*+*4*#C *& *#% I)$&9#,)94 %*?&*2*/9#*"& > > > ; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B N?a4 $+-$
(&B $+% &(/#(01(#/ "0 &%#&(H(2($1 +$2")$ ($ (& .%3.%&%#$%9 (# - $+%6%>
*+% &(/#(0(7-#7% "0 $+% .%'%.&-2 "0 (#$%#$("#-2($1 3."3"&%9 +%.% (& $+-$ "#21
"# $+% H-&(& "0 $+% *&.*F*.,9#*"& "0 $+% &FHR%7$ *& %$&%*+*4*#C 7-# &F7+ - &FHR%7$
%#$%. (#$" - .%2-$("# $" -# L$+%. 8+(7+ (& #%($+%. .%9F7(H2% $"B #". -77"F#$S
-H2% 0".B (# .%2-$("# $" $+% 6"'%6%#$& "0 $+% ,-6%> *+% 6"9%2 "0 (#$%#$("#S
-2($1 .%R%7$%9B (& .%R%7$%9 H%7-F&% ($ 6-T%& "0 $+% L$+%. -#"$+%. 0".S6% h -#9
-22 50".S6%;&; -.% HF$ - 0F#7$("# "0 61 3."R%7$> Q0$%. -22B -& -2.%-91 #"$%9B 0."6
$+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 -%&$+%&("2"/(7-2 %V3%.(%#7%B $+% &T(# (& #"$ %V3%.(%#7%9 -&
&F7+B #" 6".% $+-# $+% %1% "H&%.'%& $+% .%$(#- -& ($ 9%2(/+$& (# ($& '(&$-> *+%
&T(# (& $+-$ 8($+(# 8+(7+ 61 &%3-.-$% %V(&$%#7% (& 6-(#$-(#%94 $+% 5Y; (&
&%#&(H(2($1 -#9 5&%#&(H(2($1 (& %#R"16%#$ `K",*%%9&/$a;B 8($+"F$B (# $+(&
6"6%#$ "0 %#R"16%#$B $+% &T(# -33%-.(#/ -& &F7+>
Y 7-##"$ %V32-(# -$ 2%#/$+ +%.%B $+% 9%$-(2%9 -77"F#$ "0 $+% +13"&$-&(& "0
$+% %V(&$%#$ -#9 ($& (#+%.%#7% 8($+(# $+% 9"6-(# "0 $+% 5$+%.% (&; `*4 C 9aB
8+(7+ $+%&% 0%8 .%6-.T& 6F&$ 3-.$21 &%.'% $" .%7-22> Y 9" 8(&+ $" %63+-&(&%B
$+"F/+B +"8 $+% 5&%3-.-$("#; "0 $+% %V(&$%#$ `K%e'(#-&; -2$%.#-$('% #"$("# "0
5$+% &FHR%7$;a 0."6 %V(&$%#7% (# /%#%.-2B (& +%29 $" H% $+% 57"#9($("# "0
3"&&(H(2($1; 0". -# 5Y; 8+(7+ 7-# %#$%. (#$" -# %$+(7-2 .%2-$("#> *+(& (9%-B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
K%e'(#-& #-6%& #%($+%. $+% 7-3-7($1 "0 - &FHR%7$ #". - 7"#7%3$ "0 .%02%7$("#m ($
(& *&J+$#=$$& 8+-$ %63(.(7(&$ &%#&F-2(&6B "# $+% "#% +-#9B 7"#&(9%.& $" H%
F#$+"F/+$ 53F.% &%#&-$("#; -#9 8+-$ 3+%#"6%#"2"/1B "# $+% "$+%.B .%/-.9&
-& $+% "HR%7$ "0 7"#&7("F&#%&&>`&%% K%e'(#-& )XC@B )NXa M% %V3.%&&%& $+(& (#
$+% 0"22"8(#/ 3-&&-/%4
%V$%#&('%21 -.$(7F2-$%9 (# D"#94*#C 9&. -&2*&*#CB .%-33%-.& (# Q#'$)=*%$ #'9&
<$*&?B %V3.%&&%9 (# $%.6& "0 $+% 5&F3%.(#9('(9F-$("# "0 $+% %/" `8+(7+a 7"#S
&(&$& (# H%(#/ (# ($&%20B *& *#% %;*&; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B ))?a> ,F7+ 5&%3-.-$("#;B ".B
5&F3%.(#9('(9F-$("#; h 8+(7+ (# D"#94*#C 9&. -&2*&*#C 8-& 9%&7.(H%9 (# $%.6& "0
$+% &%#&(H2% %V(&$%#7% "0 $+% 5Y; H-$+(#/ (# $+% %2%6%#$-2 5$+%.% (&; h 8($+"F$
.%7"F.&% $" -# -7$ "0 #%/-$("# h (& $+% 7"#9($("# 0". $+% .%'%.&%9 (#$%#$("#S
-2($1 8+(7+B $+."F/+"F$ Q#'$)=*%$ #'9& <$*&?B (& +%29 $" -77"F#$ 0". 61
5"H2(/-$("#;B 61 5H%(#/S0".S$+%S"$+%.;> *+(& "H2(/-$("#B 8+(7+ 9%3%#9& "#
&%3-.-$("# -$ $+% 2%'%2 "0 &%#&(H(2($1m "# 61 &%#&(H2% F#(_F%#%&& `%$&% ,&*V,$aB
7"6%& $" 6% 0."6 H%1"#9 61&%20B F#&"2(7($%9 -#9 #"$ .$/*.$. H1 6%> Y# $+%
2-#/F-/% "0 D"#94*#C 9&. -&2*&*#CB $+(& (& -# "H2(/-$("# %#$%.%9 (#$" 59&#$)*")
I"%#$)*")*4C;B (# -# 5(#&$-#$; "0 $(6% H%0".% $(6% H%/-# $" 3-&& 0". $+% 56%; `4$
5"*a> E1 3"(#$ +%.% (& $+-$ $+% 6"9%2 "0 - &"&J&$?9#*"&94 .%2-$("# "0 $+%
(#9('(9F-2 %V(&$%#$ $" %V(&$%#7%B 3.%7(&%21B $+% 53F.%; &%#&(H(2($1 8+(7+
.%6-(#& (#-77%&&(H2% $" $+% MF&&%.2(-# $I"/'$MB .%'%-2& -# %'%#$ "0 (#9('(9F-S
$("# (# 8+(7+ - 95 (# 61 8".29 8($+"F$B (# $+% &-6% 6"6%#$ -#9 $+%.%H1B
7"66-#9(#/ $+% 8".29 "0 $+% "$+%.m 8($+"F$ '("2-$(#/ $+% 32-7% "0 $+% "$+%.4
($ (& -# %'%#$ 8+(7+ (& 3.(". $" $+% -33%-.-#7% "# $+% &7%#% "0 #'$ =*44 "0 %-7+>
*+% 6"'%6%#$ "0 -##(+(2-$("# 9(.%7$%9 -$ $+% &T(#B ". 5&T(#S#(+(2(&6;B (& $+F&
7"F#$%.%9 H1 $+% -.$(7F2-$("# "0 -# %V(&$%#7% 8+(7+ (& H%(#/S(#S&T(#4 3.(". $"
-#1 3"&&(H2% 58(22(#/;B Y -6 %V3"&%9 $" $+% $"F7+ "0 $+% "$+%.>
0(D#:<)#,: %+( -?#, /,2 )(2#)(1%#,: (%+#1*+% %$+(7-2 &(/#(0(7-#7% "0 $+% &T(# 9%.('%& 0."6 $+% 0-7$ $+-$ ($ (&B 0."6 $+%
3%.&3%7$('% "0 &%#&(H2% %V(&$%#7%B $+% 2(6($S&F.0-7% F3"# 8+(7+ $+% 9.-6- "0
(#9('(9F-2 %V(&$%#7% 9% &%#&(H(2($1 (& 32-1%9 "F$ h 0". %V-632%B -& K",*%%9&/$ ".
5#"F.(&+6%#$; -#9 8+(7+B 0."6 -# %V$%.(". 3%.&3%7$('%B (& 8+-$ 7"#&$($F$%&
61 F#(_F%#%&&B %#72"&%9 8($+(# - 9(&7%.#(H2% 2(6($> Y$ (& $+%#B 9"FH21B $+%
57"#9($("#; 0". $+% -33."-7+ "0 $+% "$+%. $" 6% `3%.&"#-221a> Y -6 F#(_F%21
"H2(/%9 H1 $+% %$+(7-2 9%6-#9 "0 $+% "$+%.4 %'%# H%0".% Y ;&"= 61&%20m H%0".%
Y 58($#%&&; 61&%20m .%3.%&%#$ 61&%20 $" 61&%20 (# - 7"#7%3$ -#9 #'*&; "0 61&%20
-& 9 ,&*#C $&/4"%$. =*#'*& 9 %;*&> Q#9B Y -6B H1 $+-$ '%.1 &-6% 50-7$;B %V3"&%9 $"
$+% 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 8"F#9(#/ -#9 6F.9%.4 5%V3"&%9#%&& $" 8"F#9& -#9 "F$S
.-/% 7+-.-7$%.(&%& `$+% &T(##%9 &FHR%7$;&a 3-&&('($1; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B )I? 5C
I9)$&#'$%*%a>
*+% /%#%.-2 %$+(7-2 &$.F7$F.% "F$2(#%9 (# Q#'$)=*%$ #'9& <$*&? 8"F29 7"#S
0(#% E%.2%-FSP"#$1;& -#-21&%& $" $+% .%-26 "0 $+% ,-6% -#9 ($& .%2-$("# $" ($&
8".29> Y# $+(& .%&3%7$ E%.2%-FSP"#$1 8"F29 H% .(/+$B (# K%e'(#-&; '(%8B $"
_F%&$("# $+% -$$%63$ $" 2"7-$% #'$ 4*5*# +$#=$$& #'$ +".C 9&. #'$ =")4.B
H%7-F&%B -& E%.2%-FSP"#$1 +(6&%20 &-1&B 5$+% 8".29 `($&%20a (& 02%&+;
`E%.2%-FSP"#$1 )XN<B )@?a> *+% #"$("# "0 K",*%%9&/$ (# K%e'(#-& %00%7$('%21
9%&7.(H%& - &(6(2-. 9(&&"2F$("# "0 $+(& 2(6($ 9% *# *% )$I)$%$&#$. *& "&#"4"?C> *+%
%V(&$%#$ %6%./%& 0."6 $+% 5$+%.% (&; HF$ .%6-(#& (# - 72"&%9 7(.7F($ "0 #%%9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9F*. <""#')"C. <IX
-#9 &-$(-$("# 8($+ .%&3%7$ $" ($> *+% 5&"2($-.1; %V(&$%#$ 5Y; (& 2"&$ (# ($& &%#S
&F-2($1 -#9 +-& #" .%3.%&%#$-$("# "0 ($&%20m ($ +-& #" *.$9 $+-$ $+%.% -.%B -&
E%.2%-FSP"#$1;& &-1&B 52-#9&7-3%& "$+%. $+-# ($& "8#;> ZF$ 0."6 $+% 3%.&3%7S
$('% "0 $+%6-$(A(#/ $+"F/+$B 5C %;*& *% &"# #'$ $F$&# "2 %$&%*+4$ K",*%%9&/$R *# *%
#'$ 4*5*# "2 5C F,4&$)9+*4*#C> Y -6 0". 61&%20 - H%(#/ 8+(7+ (& 3F.% &F.0-7%B H%(#/ 8+(7+B (# H%(#/S(#S61S&T(#B -6 %'%.1 (#7+ 'F2#%.-H2%> fF2#%.-H(2($1
-#9 &%#&(H(2($1 -.% $+F& (#&%3-.-H2% h $+%1 -.% $+% "H'%.&% -#9 .%'%.&% "0 $+%
g H(F& &$.(3> W."6 $+%
,-6%B .%2-$%9 $" "#% -#"$+%. -& $8" &(9%& "0 - E"
3%.&3%7$('% "0 &%#&(H2% %V(&$%#7% $+(& 'F2#%.-H(2($1 -6"F#$& $" 5F#7%.$-(#$1
"0 $+% 6".."8; h 0". %V-632%B %#7"F#$%.%9 (# 61 +F#/%.B $+(.&$B 0-$(/F% -#9
3-(# `&%% K%e'(#-& )XC?-a> Q#9B -& Y .%3.%&%#$ 61 &T(#SH"F#9%9#%&& $" 61&%20
(# $+"F/+$B Y 3%.7%('% 61 &($F-$("# $" H% "#% "0 %&&%#$(-2 'F2#%.-H(2($1>?
O+-$ 6-1 H% 9%&7.(H%9 -& $+% 3F.% (#9F2/%#7% "0 $+% 5Y; (# &%#&F-2 %V(&$%#7%B
H%7"6%& &%20S7"#7%.# "#21 "& )$24$/#*"&> K%e'(#-& .%6(#9& F& $+-$ $+(&
6"6%#$ "0 .%02%7$("# (& #"$ 7"#&$($F$('% "0 $+% %$+(7-2 (# 2(0%B ($ .%6-(#&
5(#$%.#-2; $" $+% ,-6%> Q# (#$%/.-$%9 $+%&(& (# K%e'(#-&B $+%#B (& $+-$ #'$
/"&%/*",%&$%% ='*/' /"5$% #" *#%$42 *& #'$")$#*/94 ") /94/,49#*F$ )$24$/#*"& *% /"&J
/$)&$. "&4C #" %9F$ *#% "=& %;*&>X
Y &+-22 #"8 .%$F.# $" $+% 3."&3%7$ "0 .%S0(/F.(#/ $+% &T(#B H%1"#9 ($&
.%3.%&%#$-$("# (# $+%6%&> U-.2(%. Y &F//%&$%9 $+(& 6F&$ 5H%/(# 8($+ $+%
&T(#;B 8+(7+ -33%-.& $" H% 8+-$ K%e'(#-& 9"%& 8+%# +% -&T& 58+-$ .*%%*5,49J
#*"& $+%.% 6-1 H% F#9%. $+% %V3"&%9#%&& "0 - &T(# 2-(9 H-.%i; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B
DXa> ZF$ 8+-$ 7-# - &T(# -2.%-91 52-(9 H-.%; 9(&&(6F2-$%i L.B 3F$$(#/ $+% &-6%
_F%&$("# 0."6 $+% 3%.&3%7$('% "0 .%02%7$("#4 8+-$ (& $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 H%(#/S(#S
"#%;&S&T(#i P.(". $" 61 0".6F2-$("# "0 &F7+ - _F%&$("# -H"F$ 61 H%(#/ -& &F7+B
(# &" 0-. -& $+(& 7"#7%.#& 6%B -77".9(#/ $" K%e'(#-&B Y -6 -2.%-91 %V3"&%9 $"
$+% "$+%. $" 8+"6 Y 6F&$ .%&3"#9 #"$ H1 9%$%.6(#(#/ +%. 6%-#(#/B HF$
8($+ -H&"2F$% 3-&&('($1B 4*;$ 9 %;*& ='*/' 24*&/'$% ='$& =",&.$.> *+% &%#&(H(2S
($1 "0 $+% %V(&$%#$ 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 -& %#R"16%#$ `K",*%%9&/$a -#9 H%(#/S-$S+"6%
`/'$@J%"*aB (& -28-1& $F.#(#/ H-7T (#$" 'F2#%.-H(2($1> Q $F.#(#/ 0."6 H%(#/
&-$(&0(%9 -#9 -$ +"6% (# 61 &T(#B (#$" %V3"&%9#%&& $" $+% "$+%.> *+(& $.%6FS
2"F& &%#&(H(2($1 (& %V3.%&&%9 (# $+% +13%.H"2(7 2-#/F-/% "0 3-&&('($14
- 3-&&('($1 6".% 3-&&('% &$(22 $+-# -#1 3-&&('($1 $+-$ (& -#$($+%$(7-2 $" -#
-7$B - #F9($1 6".% #-T%9 $+-# -22 5-7-9%6(7; #F9($1 > > > > Y$ (& - 3-&&('($1
$+-$ (& #"$ .%9F7(H2% $" %V3"&F.% $" -#"$+%.;& /-A%> Y$ (& - 'F2#%.-H(2($1 -#9
- 3-(#(#/ %V+-F&$(#/ $+%6&%2'%& 2(T% - +%6"..+-/%B 9%#F9(#/ %'%# $+%
-&3%7$ $+-$ ($& #F9($1 $-T%& "#B %V3"&(#/ ($& '%.1 %V3"&%9#%&& > > > >
`K%e'(#-& )XC?B C<a
Z-$-(22% 3%.+-3& /2(63&%& &F7+ - H%/F(2(#/ 3-&&('($1 (# 8+-$ +% 0(#9& 5F#S
9%#(-H2%; -#9 56"&$ -#/F(&+(#/; (# $+% 0-7(-2]%3(9%.6-2 %V3.%&&("# "0 $+%
$".$F.% '(7$(6 (# +(& 9(&$F.H(#/ 3+"$"/.-3+> ,F7+ -#/F(&+%9 'F2#%.-H(2($1B
K%e'(#-& &-1&B 5(& #"$ $+% %V(&$%#$(-2 55H%(#/S0".S9%-$+;; HF$ $+% 7"#&$.(7$("# "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<)I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
-# 55%#$.1 (#8-.9&;; > > > > Y$ (& #"$ - 02(/+$ (#$" $+% '"(9 HF$ - 6"'%6%#$ (#$"
0F22#%&&B $+% -#/F(&+ "0 7"#$.-7$("# -#9 H.%-TF3;> *+(& 9%&7.(H%& $+% .%2-$("#
(# 8+(7+ 5- &FHR%7$ (& (66"2-$%9 8($+"F$ 02%%(#/ ($&%20; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B )I?a>
P-&&('($1 %V3.%&&%& $+% (9%- $+-$ $+% 56%-#(#/; ". 5&%#&%; "0 &%#&(H(2($1 (&
.$/*.$. %2&%8+%.% -& 5$-T(#/ 7-.% "0 $+% "$+%.;& #%%9&; $" $+% 3"(#$ "0 &%20S
&-7.(0(7%m $+(& 9%7(&("# (& -# 5-33."-7+; 8+(7+ (#'%.$& 61 5H%(#/S(#S61S&T(#;
(#$" 5H%(#/S0".S$+%S"$+%.; h &"6%$+(#/ .%0%..%9 $" -H"'% -& $+% 5.%'%.&(H(2($1
"0 $+% 02%&+;> O($+ .%&3%7$ $" $+% +13"&$-&(& "0 $+% %V(&$%#$B K%e'(#-& &-1&
5&%#&(H(2($1 (& %#R"16%#$;B HF$ $+% 'F2#%.-H(2($1 "0 H%(#/ 5(# "#%;& &T(#; (& -2&"
&-(9 $" `.%a$F.# &%#&(H(2($1 (#$" 5%V3"&F.% $" $+% "$+%.; -#9 $" 8"F#9(#/> *+%
g H(F& &$.(3 &$.F7$F.% (#'"T%9 %-.2(%. (&B &" $" &3%-TB R"(#%9 %#9 $" %#9 H1 E"
02(3S&8($7+ 8+(7+ .%3%-$%921 .%S9(.%7$& &%#&(H(2($1 (#$" 'F2#%.-H(2($1B ". (#
Z-$-(22%B %7&$-&1 (#$" 3-(#> *+(& 2%-9& K%e'(#-& $" 72-(6 $+-$4
Y -6 H"F#9 $" "$+%.& H%0".% Y -6 H"F#9 $" 61 `$+%6-$(7a H"91 > > > >
D'$ "#'$) /944% ,I"& #'9# %$&%*+*4*#C =*#' 9 F"/9#*"& #'9# =",&.%B 7-22&
F3"# -# (..%'"7-H2% .%&3"#&(H(2($1B -#9 $+F& $+% '%.1 (9%#$($1 "0 $+%
&FHR%7$>
`K%e'(#-& )XC?B CNhCa
K%$;& -$ $+(& 3"(#$ .%7-22 $+% .%6-.T 7($%9 %-.2(%. 0."6 $+% ($(#%.-.1 "0 Q#'$)=*%$
#'9& <$*&?4 $+% 3.%&%#$-$("# "0 $+% &FHR%7$ 5-& - &%#&(H(2($1 2)"5 #'$ 2*)%#
-#(6-$%9 H1 .%&3"#&(H(2($(%&; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B )Xa> ,%#&(H(2($1 (& #%'%. 3F.%21
-#9 &(6321 -# (#9F2/%#7% "0 $+% %V(&$%#$ (# &%#&(H2% H%(#/4 ($& 5&"R"F.#; (# $+%
&%#&(H2% (& -28-1& -#9 50."6 $+% 0(.&$;B (#$%..F3$%9 H1 $+% "H2(/-$("# 8+(7+
9(&$F.H& ($> P.(". $" -#1 H%(#/ 7"#&7("F& "0 -#1 #'*&?B (#72F9(#/ 61 H%(#/
7"#&7("F& "0 61 "8# (#9('(9F-2 H%(#/S(#S61S&T(#B $+(& "H2(/-$("# 9(&$F.H&
6% 9(.%7$21 -#9 `.%Sa$F.#& 61 &%#&(H(2($1 (#$" 'F2#%.-H(2($1 H1 H.(#/(#/ 6% $"
$+% &F.0-7% "0 61 &T(# (# - `&%20Sa7"#&7("F& .%02%7$("# "# $+% #-$F.% "0 $+(&
%&&%#$(-2 'F2#%.-H(2($1> *+% 9(&$F.H-#7% 8+(7+ $F.#& &%#&(H(2($1 (#$" &%20S7"#S
7%.# (&B (# K%e'(#-&; -77"F#$B 5"29%.; $+-# 61 7"#7%3$ "0 61&%20 -& 5H%(#/S(#S
61S&T(#;> fF2#%.-H(2($1 (& $+%.%0".% 0"F#9 $" H%2(% -# "3%##%&&B ". %V3"&F.%B
$" $+% "$+%.;& -2$%.($1 5H%0".%; Y %V3%.(%#7% 61 &T(# -& 6(#%> *+(& $+"F/+$
6-T%& "0 $+% &T(# $+% &($% "0 "+%$%%*"& 8($+ $+% "$+%.B -#9 ($ /('%& F& -# (#&(/+$
(#$" $+% 5%$+(7-2; #-$F.% "0 Z-$-(22%;& "H&%&&("# 8($+ $+% (6-/%>
Y$ (& (# $+% 3-&&('($1 "0 "H&%&&("#B ". (#7-.#-$%9 3-&&('($1B $+-$ -# (9%#$($1
(#9('(9F-$%& ($&%20 -& F#(_F%B 8($+"F$ .%7"F.&% $" -#1 &1&$%6 "0 .%0%.S
%#7%&B (# $+% (63"&&(H(2($1 "0 %'-9(#/ $+% -&&(/#-$("# "0 $+% "$+%. 8($+"F$
H2-6%> > > > $+% &%20 (& $+% '%.1 0-7$ "0 H%(#/ %V3"&%9>
`K%e'(#-& )XC?B ))<h)?a
*+(& .%$."S(#$%#$("#-2($1 "0 3-&&('($1 &%%T& $" -77"F#$ 0". $+% -2$%.($1 "0
"$+%.& -& 9+%"4,#$ Q#'$)%B 0". 8+"6 61 %$+(7-2 "H2(/-$("# (& 5.%-2; (# $+-$ ($&
6-#(0%&$-$("# (& - 3-.$ "0 61 %'%.19-1 %V3%.(%#7% "0 - 6"'%6%#$ 9(.%7$%9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9F*. <""#')"C. <))
$"8-.9 6% 2)"5 $+% "F$&(9%> Y$ (& -2&"B $+%.%0".%B #"#S&%#$(6%#$-2B (# $+%
$%7+#(7-2 &%#&% "0 #"#S(9%-$("#-2 `(>%> ($ (& &"# 5C *.$9a> Y# &"6% 8-1&B ($
-33%-.& $+(& %#$(.% %$+(7-2 %9(0(7% +"29& ($&%20 F3 "# $+% H-&(& "0 $+(& &F33"&%9
50-7$; "0 "H2(/-$("#m -# %'%.19-1 %V3%.(%#7%B &3"T%# "0 -& (0 ($ 8%.%
(#9%3%#9%#$ "0 7F2$F.% -#9 +(&$".1> ZF$ .-$+%. $+-# 0"7F& $+(& (&&F% +%.%B Y
8(&+B 0(#-221B $" .%($%.-$% +"8 $+% &%20 -& - &%#&(H2%S%V(&$%#$ ". 5H%(#/S(#S-S
&T(#;B (#9('(9F-$%9 -$ $+% 2%'%2 "0 &%#&(H(2($1B (& $+% 7"#9($("# 0". %$+(7-2
"3%##%&&>
K%e'(#-& %2F7(9-$%& $+% %$+(7-2 &(/#(0(7-#7% "0 "H&%&&("# 8+%# +% -./F%&
$+-$ "#21 - H%(#/ (# - &T(# 7-# H% 5"3%#; (# $+(& 8-14 5$+% &%20 (# ($& &T(# (&
H"$+ %V3"&%9 $" $+% %V$%.(". `8+(7+ 9"%& #"$ +-33%# $" $+(#/&a 9&. "H&%&&%9
H1 "$+%.& (# $+(& #-T%9 %V3"&F.%; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B ))<a> *+(& -77"F#$ "0 7-.#-2
&%#&(H(2($1 9(.%7$& F& $" ($& +($+%.&(9% h %$+(7-2 &%#&(H(2($14 $+(& (& -# %V32(7($
3+(2"&"3+(7-2 $+%&(& (# K%e'(#-& 7"#7%.#(#/ $+% .%2-$("#&+(3 H%$8%%# &%#&S
(H(2($1 -#9 $+% %$+(7-2> *+(& -#-21&(& +-& -$$%63$%9 $" &+"8 +"8 ($ -2&"
7"#&$($F$%& K%e'(#-&; .%&3"#&% $" $+% 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 7"#F#9.F6 "0 5$+% .%-2;B
8+(7+ (#'"2'%& $+(#T(#/ ($ -& $+% )$49#*"& H%$8%%# $+% +%.% -#9 #"8 -#9 $+%
H%1"#94 8% +-'% &%%# +"8 #(+(2(&6 5#"8;B -& $+% -##(+(2-$("# 9(.%7$%9
-/-(#&$ $+% &T(#B (& .%'%.&(H2% (#$" -#S#(+(2-$("#B -#9 $+-$ $+% `%$+(7-2a
6"6%#$ (& 9(&7%.#(H2% (# $+% (#$%..F3$("# "0 &F7+ #(+(2(&6> *+% $+%&(& (&B
&" $" &3%-TB (#&7.(H%9 "# $+% &T(#4 $+% 6%-#(#/ `%$&%a "0 $+% &T(# (& - 9(.%7S
$("# `%$&%am ($ (& 5- "#%S8-1 &$.%%$; 9"8# 8+(7+ $+% L$+%. 9II)"9/'$% 5$ -#9
+-& - F#(_F% 6%-#(#/ `%$&% ,&*V,$a 0". 6%> `*+(& 0(/F.% (& H".."8%9 0."6
Z%.#-&7"#(B )XXJ>a *+% %V3.%&&("# %$&% ,&*V,$ 7"##"$%& H"$+ F#(_F%#%&& -#9
9(.%7$("#> *+(& %$+(7-2 .%0(/F.(#/ "0 $+% &T(# 9"%& #"$ 2%-9 $" - #"$("# "0
?$&$)94 .%&3"#&(H(2($1 0". "$+%.&B HF$ $" -# (#&(&$%#7% "# 5C .%&3"#&(H(2($1 0".
+%.]+(6> Y$ -$$%63$& $" &+"8 $+-$ $+% .%&3"#&(H(2($1 $+-$ 7-# H% .%-9S"00 $+%
&T(# (& #"$ - 2"$$%.1 (# 8+(7+ 5($ 5*?'# +$ 6%;B ($ *% 6%> *+(& F#(_F%#%&& (& 50%2$;
-& (#%&7-3-H21 -& - 8"F#9 $" 61 &T(#> Z-$-(22%;& "H&%&&("# 8($+ $+% 6"6%#$
"0 %7&$-&1]3-(# .%'%.&-2 3%.+-3& ;&"=% $+(&B HF$ #"$ 8+-$ ($ 6%-#& $#'*/944C4
(#$%#&($1 +-& $+% 3"8%. $" "H2($%.-$% .%02%7$("# $"$-221> K%e'(#-&; -77"F#$ "0
%$+(7-2 &%#&(H(2($1 .%_F(.%& 3+(2"&"3+1 $" .%7"'%. $+% %$+(7-24 $" .%7"'%. 5$+%
"3%##%&& "0 $+% &-1(#/ %V3"&%9 2(T% - H2%%9(#/ 8"F#9; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B )J)a>
C$%() W". - 9(&7F&&("# "0 $+% 5.%'%.&(H(2($1; 8+(7+ (& #%'%. &(6321 "0 02%&+ -& 9(&$(#7$ 0."6
$+% $%V$ ". $+% (6-/%B &%% ^> [(9(SMFH%.6-# `)XXJa>
< K>Q> Z"29$SY."#& `)XXJB XNhCa 9(&7F&&%& $+% 2($%.-.1 -&3%7$& "0 $+% 3-.-9"V(7-2 .%02%7S
$("#& "# $+% 8($#%&&]'(7$(6 .%2-$("# (# Z-$-(22%B -#9 $+% 2(6($ "0 (#$%/.($1 "0 F#($-.1 7"#&7("F&#%&& 9('(9%9 H1 .%02%7$("# "# .%02%7$("#> *+(& 5-H1&&-2; 3.(#7(32%
6-#(0%&$& ($&%20 (# Z-$-(22%;& 8.($(#/B (# 8+(7+ 5"#% &(/# 6F$(2-$%& -#"$+%.;m 5(#
8+(7+ 8% %#7"F#$%. $+% 7-&% "0 $+% &2(33(#/ 8".9B 8+"&% 7-3-7($1 0". &%20S9%&$.F7S
$("# ". -F$"S6F$(2-$("# +-9 H%%# &(2%#7%9 H1 $+% &$.-(/+$R-7T%$ "0 9(&7"F.&%;>
EF$(2-$("# (& +%.% 6-9%B 3.%7(&%21B - 6-$$%. "0 9(&7"F.&%B ".B "0 2($%.-$F.%>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<)< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
@ *+% (#7"632%$-H(2($1 "0 #(+(2(&6 F#9%.&$""9 -& $+% (#$%..F3$("# ". 3"&$3"#%6%#$
"0 $+% 6"6%#$ "0 57"632%$% #(+(2(&6; (& %V3.%&&%9 +%.% -& %$+(7-2 5-#S#(+(2(&6;> Y$
7"F29 H% -./F%9 $+-$ $+(& %$+(7-2 -#S#(+(2(&6 (& ($&%20 - &3%7(%& "0 $+% 57"632%$%
#(+(2(&6; -& 5-#$(S#(+(2(&6;B "0 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% &3%-T&B 0". %V-632% (# $+% O$&$94"?C
"2 3")94% YYB <DB -#9 8+(7+ .%6-(#& -28-1& 5$" 7"6%;> L# $+% 7"##%7$("# H%$8%%#
=(%$A&7+% -#9 K%e'(#-&; $+(#T(#/ "0 $+% %$+(7-2 &%% 61 5K%e'(#-& -#9 =(%$A&7+%4
Z%1"#9 K"'% -#9 !"#$%63$; `Z""$+."19 )XXJB @DJhJCa> W". - F&%0F2 $13"/.-3+1
"0 $+% $%.6 5#(+(2(&6; (# =(%$A&7+%B &%% Q> O+($% `)XXIB )Jh<Ja> E1 F&% "0 $+% $%.6
+%.%B (# -#1 7-&%B (& (#$%#9%9 $" (9%#$(01 $+% 7-.#-$% 6"6%#$ "0 %$+(7-2 5F#9"(#/;
"0 $+% 5-##(+(2(&6; 8+(7+ 6-#(0%&$& ($&%20 (# $+% 6F.9%."F& '("2%#7%B 7%#$.-2 $"
K%e'(#-&; -77"F#$>
D *+(& 6-.T& $+% &+(0$ 0."6 $+% 50(/F.-2; -H1&&-2 "0 $+% 5*%$ $& 9+C5$ $" 8+-$ 6(/+$ H%
9%&7.(H%9 -& $+% 5%63(.(7-2; -H1&&-2B $+% %'%#$ "0 %$+(7-2 9(&$F.H-#7% `&%% $+%
9(&7F&&("# "0 5%63(.(7(&6; H%2"8a> Y0 $+(& 8%.% $" H% $.-#&2-$%9 (#$" W.%#7+B $+%#
$+% $%.6 5*%$ $& 9+rs5$ 6(/+$ H% -33."3.(-$%> Z"29$SY."#& `)XXJa .%0%.& $" $+%
&3%7(0(7($1 "0 8+-$ &+% 7-22& $+% 5*%$ $& 9+rs5$ (# Z-$-(22%;& 8.($(#/B -& $+-$ 5$%7+#(S
_F%; H1 6%-#& "0 8+(7+ +(& .%-9%. H%7"6%& %#6%&+%9 (# $+% 3."7%&&%& "0 $+% $%V$4
($ 5%#$-(2& - &$.F7$F.-2 5*%$ $& 9+C5$ "0 -# %V3%.(%#7%9 -#9 3%.7%('%9 5*%$ $& 9+rs5$
$+-$ #%($+%. &-7.(0(7%& 7"#&7("F&#%&& #". 3.%&%.'%& ($& (#$%/.($1; `)XXJB XNa> *+%
5$%%$%.(#/ "# $+% %$+(7-2 -H1&&; Y .%0%. $" +%.% (#'"2'%& - 7"63-.-H2% 6"'%6%#$ "0
/"(#/ 0."6 $+% 0(/F.-2 -28-1& +9/; (#$" $+% 5%$+(7-2 (#7-.#-$%;> M"8%'%.B 8+%.%-&
Z"29$SY."#& (#$%.%&$ .%6-(#& $+-$ "0 $+% 56F$(2-$("# "0 &(/#&;B Y -6 -$$%63$(#/ $"
%V32"($ $+% K%e'(#-&(-# #"$("# "0 $+% &T(# -& $+% &%#&(H2% &($% "0 $+% 5-H1&&-2; h -$
"#7% - 9%7"#&$.F7$('% 5.%3%$($("#; -#9 - 5.%-2; -H1&& h $" H.(9/% $+% &F33"&%9 /-3
H%$8%%# $+% 0(/F.-2 -#9 $+% %63(.(7-2>
J Y F#9%.$-T% - 9(&7F&&("# "0 $+(& $+%6% (# .%2-$("# $" $+% &%V%9 H"91 (# $+% 8".T "0
Y.(/-.-1 (# 61 5K-H(-2 W%6(#(&64 Z"91 Q/-(#&$ Z"91 8($+ KF7% Y.(/-.-1; `Z""$+."19
)XXNB @4 NJh?Ia>
N L.2-#;& 5G%(#7-.#-$("# "0 ,$ L.2-#; (#'"2'%& +%. F#9%./"(#/ - &%.(%& "0 &F./(7-2
"3%.-$("#;& "# +%. 0-7%B (# $+% 3."7%&& "0 8+(7+ 3(%7%& "0 $+% &F.32F& &T(# .%6"'%9
-#9 +-'% 2-$%. H%%# 6-9% (#$" &F332%6%#$-.1 -.$8".T&B 8+(7+ +-'% H%%# H"$+ &"29
-#9 ?*F$& -8-1>
C U'%.1$+(#/ $+-$ K%e'(#-& +-9 &-(9 -H"F$ &%#&(H(2($1 -#9 $+% &%#&(H2% H%(#/ "0 $+% 5Y;B
(# 8".T& 3.(". $" Q#'$)=*%$ #'9& <$*&?B +-9 H%%# -(6%9 -$ -77"F#$(#/ 0". ($&
&FH&$-#$('% &(#/F2-.($1B ".B ($& %$I9)9#$&$%%B -#9 -/-(#&$ 8+-$ (# D"#94*#C 9&. -&2*&*#C
+% "#7% 9%&7.(H%9 -& ($& 59(&&"2F$("#; (# 6"9%.# 3+(2"&"3+1B -/-(#&$ ($& .%9F7$("# $"
- 0F#7$("# "0 9(&7"F.&%B ". -# (#$%/.-$%9 0F#7$("# "0 $+% 8".29 `-# -&3%7$ "0 H"$+
&$.F7$F.-2(&6 -#9 M%(9%//%.(-# 3+%#"6%#"2"/1B -2H%($ 9(00%.%#$21a> U'%# E%.2%-FS
P"#$1;& 3+%#"6%#"2"/1B $" 8+"&% $+(#T(#/ K%e'(#-&; -77"F#$ "0 &%#&(H(2($1 (& &FHS
&$-#$(-221 (#9%H$%9B (& 0"F#9 7F23-H2% (# $+(& .%&3%7$> O+%#B (# $+% "3%#(#/ 3-/%&
"0 E'$&"5$&"4"?C "2 E$)/$I#*"&B E%.2%-FSP"#$1 &-1& $+-$ 53F.% &%#&-$("# 7"..%&3"#9&
$" #"$+(#/ (# %V3%.(%#7%; `E%.2%-FSP"#$1 )XN<B @aB +% (& .%7-22(#/ +"8 $+% MF&&%.S
2(-# .%9F7$("# ."$% &"# 72-(6 $+% .*)$/# (#$F($("# "0 "HR%7$&B HF$ .-$+%. $+% #"#S
&%3-.-$("# "0 7"#&7("F&#%&& -#9 ($& 8".29> *+% (63".$-#$ 7"."22-.1 +%.% (& #"$ $+-$
6%#$-2 2(0%B ".B 3&17+(7 (#$%.(".($1B +-& 3.%7%9%#7%B HF$ "# $+% 7"#$.-.1B $+-$ $+%
-H&%#7% "0 $+% &%#&%9 `"HR%7$a (& 7"#$%.6(#-2 8($+ $+% 0-7$ $+-$ 8% 7-##"$ 0(#9 (#
%V3%.(%#7% 5- 3&17+(7 (#9('(9F-2; ". &FHR%7$ h 8+"&% .%-2($1B +% #"$%&B (& 9(&$(#/F(&+S
-H2% 5"#21 (# 9%/.%%; 0."6 6".% 7"632%V 3%.7%3$("#& 8+(7+ -.% 5H"F#9 F3 8($+
$+% 2-./%. 8+"2%;> `E%.2%-FSP"#$1 )XN<B Xa> W". E%.2%-FSP"#$1B - 95 %$&%*+4$ +$*&?
#" 2%&& $+-# Y -6 $+% 7"#&7("F&#%&& "0 $+% &%#&(H2% .%02%7$%9 (# $+"F/+$> *+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9F*. <""#')"C. <)@
5(#$%.$8(#(#/; "0 $+% &FHR%7$ (# ($& 8".29B (# $%.6& "0 8+(7+ +% (#'%&$(/-$%& $+%
.%2-$("# H%$8%%# $+% 7-.#-2($1 -#9 $+"F/+$B ". '(&("# -#9 $+% '(&(H2%B (& (#9(7-$('%
"0 +"8 $+% (#9('(9F-$("# "0 $+% &FHR%7$ (& -H-#9"#%9 $" -# (#$%/.-$("# 8($+ H%(#/B
$" $+% #%/2%7$ "0 ($& &%#&(H2% F#(_F%#%&&> ,%#&(H2% (#9('(9F-$("#B (& #"$B -77".9(#/
$" K%e'(#-&B 6%.%21 - $%7+#(7-2 6-$$%. "0 3+(2"&"3+1 -8-($(#/ $+%".%$(7-2 .%&"2FS
$("#> Y$ (& .-$+%.B $+% "#21 3"&&(H2% H-&(& F3"# 8+(7+ -# -2$%.($1 ='*/' ."$% &"#
")*?*&9#$ =*#' 5$B 8+(7+ 9"%& #"$ -33%-. (# - $+%6% "0 6(#% -& -#"$+%. 50".S6%;B
7-# H% -7T#"82%9/%9>
? *+(& $%.6 (& &7-.%S_F"$%9 +%.% H%7-F&%B 0-. 0."6 -#1 6%$-3+1&(7-2 &%#&% "0 $+%
%&&%#$(-2($1 "0 $+(& 'F2#%.-H(2($1 H%(#/ (#'"T%9 +%.%B K%e'(#-&; $%-7+(#/ (& $+-$ %$+(7&
3.%7%9%& `$+% (9%- "0a 'F2#%.-H(2($1> *+% 'F2#%.-H(2($1 "0 $+% 5Y; (& 9(&7%.#(H2% (# ($&
$-T(#/ F3 - 53"&($("#; (# - &T(# 8+(7+ (& (9%#$(7-2 8($+ ($& 5%V3"&%9#%&&; $" -#"$+%.>
K%e'(#-&(-# %$+(7-2 -#S#(+(2(&6 H%/(#& 8($+ $+% &%#&(H(2($1 "0 $+% &T(#B .-$+%. $+-#
0."6 8($+(# $+% 9(&7"F.&% "0 .%02%7$%9 6%-#(#/&> ,F7+ - 5&%#&(H(2(&6; (& $+% '(&7%.-2
H-&(& 0". $+% .%&3"#&%S-H(2($1 "0 $+% 56%;>
X *+(& (& &"6%$+(#/ $+-$ [%..(9- (# +(& .%7%#$ 8.($(#/& "# .%&3"#&(H(2($1 +-& 9%&7.(H%9
-& $+% 5%7"#"61 "0 &-'(#/ "#%&%20; (632(7($ $" $+% 7"#7%3$ "0 5&-2'-$("#;> ,%% +(&
%&&-1B 5*"F$ QF$.% %&$ *"F$ QF$.%; `[%..(9- )XXJB ?Ca> Y -6 9(&$F.H%9 H1 $+% &F00%.(#/
"0 $+% "$+%. H%0".% -#1 #'",?'# "0 &-'(#/ 61 "8# &T(#B ". .%02%7$("# "# 61 "8#
3"&&(H2% 0-$%> Q& &F00%.(#/ %V3"&%& - 'F2#%.-H(2($1 8+(7+ 7-# H% (#7.%-&%9 $" (#0(#S
($1B Y H%7"6% -8-.% "0 $+% (#0(#($1 "0 61 .%3"#&(H(2($1> K%e'(#-& 7-22& $+(& F#.%02%7$%9
0".6 "0 $+% %$+(7-2 (#7-.#-$% 5H%(#/S(#S"#%;&S&T(#B +-'(#/S$+%S"$+%.S(#S"#%;&S&T(#;
`K%e'(#-& )XC?B ))Jam $+% "$+%. -& 5$+% '%.1 .%&3(.-$("# "0 61 &T(#; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B
DXa> Y -6 -#(6-$%9B 2($%.-221 5(#&3(.%9; H1 $+% L$+%. +$2")$ Y 7"6% $" 61&%20 (# $+%
7"#7%3$ "0 H%(#/ &T(#SH"F#9> Y -6 7-&$ -& +"&$`-/%a (# -# %$+(7-2 32"$ #"$ "0 61
6-T(#/B 8+(7+ (& 5&%#&(H2%; $" 6% H%7-F&% ($ (& - 6-$$%. "2 5C %;*&> *+% &T(# (& $+%
7-.#-$% &($% "0 61 5(..%6(&&(H2% /F(2$; 8+(7+ 58($+ .%/-.9 $" $+% #%(/+H"F. (& 2(T% =%&&F& $F#(7 61 &T(# 8"F29 H%; `K%e'(#-& )XC?B )IXa>
0(D()(,1(Q.$-F9B Q> `)XNJa 7)#9,. 7&#'"4"?C> =%8 o".T4 !($1 K(/+$&>
pp `)XN?a ("44$/#$. P");% X"4Z ^> K"#9"#4 !-29%.>
Z-$-(22%B ^> `)X?Ja X*%*"&% "2 6H/$%%> *.-#&> Q> ,$"%T2> E(##%&"$-4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%S
&"$- P.%&&>
pp `)X?Xa D$9)% "2 6)"%> =%8 o".T4 !($1 K(/+$&>
Z%.#-&7"#(B G> `)XXJa 5L#%S8-1 *.-00(74 *+% L#$"2"/1 "0 [%7"2"#(A-$("# -#9 ($& U$+(7&;
(# ^>Q> k"+#&"# -#9 E>Z> ,6($+> U9&>
Z"29$SY."#&B K>Q> `)XXJa 5,-7.(0(7% -#9 f("2%#7% (# Z-$-(22%;& U."$(7 W(7$("#; (# !>Z> ^(22>
U9>
Z""$+."19B [> `)XXJa 5K%e'(#-& -#9 =(%$A&7+%4 Y#SH%$8%%# K"'% -#9 !"#$%63$;> E'*4"J
%"I'C D".9C> @X]D4 @DJhJC>
pp `)XXNa 5K-H(-2 W%6(#(&64 Z"91 Q/-(#&$ Z"91 8($+ KF7% Y.(/-.-1; (# E9)9449H @4NJh
?I>
[-'(%&B P> `)XXJa 5L# G%&".$(#/ $" -# U$+(7-2 K-#/F-/%; (# Q> P%3%.A-T> %9> `)XXJa>
[%..(9-B k> `)XC?a 5f("2%#7% -#9 E%$-3+1&(7&; (# P)*#*&? 9&. B*22$)$&/$> *.-#&> Q> Z-&&>
K"#9"#4 G"F$2%9/%
pp `)XXJa O*2# "2 B$9#'> $.-#&> [> O(22&> !+(7-/"4 \#('%.&($1 "0 !+(7-/" P.%&&>
[(9(SMFH%.6-#B ^> `)XXJa 5!"66%#$ 9%e7+(.%S$S"# 2- .%&&%6H2-#7%i; (# [> M"22(%.> %9>
O$")?$ <9#9*44$ 9I)$b% #",#> P-.(&4 Z%2(#>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<)D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
^(22B !>Z> %9> `)XXJa <9#9*44$0 P)*#*&? #'$ A9/)$. K"#9"#4 G"F$2%9/%>
k"+#&"#B ^>Q> -#9 ,6($+B E>Z> %9&> `)XXJaB Q&#"4"?C 9&. 74#$)*#C *& 3$)4$9,JE"&#CZ
U'-#&$"#4 =".$+8%&$%.# \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
K%e'(#-&B U> `)XC@a D'$ D'$")C "2 -&#,*#*"& *& >,%%$)4N% E'$&"5$&"4"?C> $.-#&> Q L.(-##%>
U'-#&$"#4 =".$+8%&$%.# \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
pp `)XNXa D"#94*#C 9&. -&2*&*#C> $.-#&> Q> K(#/(&> P($$&HF./+4 [F_F%&#%>
pp `)XC?a Q#'$)=*%$ #'9& <$*&? ") <$C"&. 6%%$&/$> $.-#&> K(#/(&B Q> *+% M-/F%4 E-.$(S
#F& =(R+"00>
pp `)XC?-a 6H*%#$&/$ 9&. 6H*%#$&#%> $.-#&> Q>K(#/(&> *+% M-/F%4 E-.$(#F& =(R+"00>
pp `)XX)a 5P+(2"&"3+1 -& Q8-T%#(#/;B (# !-9-'-B !"##".B =-#71> %9&> P'" ("5$%
72#$) #'$ A,+K$/#S> K"#9"#4 G"F$2%9/%>
E%.2%-FSP"#$1B E> `)XN<a E'$&"5$&"4"?C "2 E$)/$I#*"&> $.-#&> !> ,6($+> K"#9"#4 G"FS
$2%9/%>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XNXa O$&$94"?C "2 3")94%> $.-#&> O> b-F06-##> =%8 o".T4 G-#9"6
M"F&%>
pp `)XN?a P*44 #" E"=$)> $.-#&> O> b-F06-## -#9 G>k> M"22(#/9-2%> =%8 o".T4 G-#S
9"6 M"F&%>
P%3%.A-TB Q> %9> `)XXJa 6#'*/% 9% :*)%# E'*4"%"I'C0 D'$ A*?&*2*/9&/$ "2 6559&,$4 L$MF*&9%
2") E'*4"%"I'CR L*#$)9#,)$ 9&. 1$4*?*"&> K"#9"#4 G"F$2%9/%
O+($%B Q> `)XXIa P*#'*& !*$#@%/'$N% L9+C)*&#'> K"#9"#4 G"F$2%9/%
O(2&"#B ,> `)XXJa 5W%d$(#/ $+% O"F#9; (# !>Z> ^(22> %9>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9F*. <""#')"C. <)J
))
(9#'$)*&$ B94$
*+(& -#/%. 8+(7+ 7"#&F6%& 6% -#9 8+(7+ Y 2%-.# %'%.1 9-1 $" 3F$
$" H%$$%. F&% 6F&$ 7%.$-(#21 6%-# &"6%$+(#/>
Q.$-F9 )XCNB DII
E
G%0F&(#/ $+% $8%#$(%$+S7%#$F.1;& %'(&7%.-$(#/ 3."0%&&("#-2(&-$("# "0 -#/%. (&
"#% "0 Q#$"#(# Q.$-F9;& (63%.-$('%&>)
*" -/.%% $" HF.# -& Y +-'% HF.#%9 -22 61 2(0% -#9 -& Y HF.# #"8 (& -2&" $"
-7_F(.% $+% 3"8%. $" HF.#m -#9 Y T#"8 $+-$ Y 8-& 3.%9%&$(#%9 $" HF.#B $+(&
(& 8+1 Y H%2(%'% Y 7-# &-1 $+-$ 0%8 -#/%.& 7-# .%-7+ 8+%.% 61 -#/%. 8(22 H%
-H2% $" .(&%>
`Q.$-F9 )XCNB DI)a
Q.$-F9;& 9(&32-1 "0 -#/%. -#9 .F9%#%&&B H"$+ (# +(& &7-#9-2"F& $+%-$.(7-2
3%.0".6-#7%& -#9 "# $+% 3-/% (# +(& .-#7"."F& 9(-$.(H%& -/-(#&$ $+% #-.."8S
6(#9%9 -#9 $+% H-#-2B (& 3"&&(H21 $+% 6"&$ 0-6"F& h (# $+% &%#&% "0 0-6(2(-.
$" +(& 7"#$%63".-.(%& -#9 3.%&%#$ .%-9%.& -2(T% h "0 -22 +(& 3F$-$('% (9("&1#S
7.-&(%&> [%&3($% $+(& .%#"8#B Q.$-F9;& 6"&$ (9%#$(0(-H2% 7+-.-7$%.(&$(7& -.%
F&F-221 .%9F7%9 $" H("/.-3+(7-2 (#0".6-$("# -H"F$ 9.F/ -99(7$("#B &7+(A"S
3+.%#(-B 7%2(H-71 -#9 .%2(/("F& 0-#-$(7(&6B 8+(2% 2($$2% 6%#$("# (& 6-9% "0
+(& (.%B 8+(7+ (# ($& 02F(9($1B -33%-.& $" $.-#&7%#9 &1&$%6-$(7 72-&&(0(7-$("#>
*+F& 3-.-9"V(7-221B Q.$-F9;& -#/%. (& $-T%# F3 -& H"$+ -# (#9%$%.6(#-$%
0".7% -#9 - 0-6(2(-. 0%-$F.%> Y$ (& - 3-.-9"V $+-$ F#9%.&7".%& $+% 3."7%&&
8+%.%H1 -#/%. (& 7-3$F.%9 -#9 7-$%/".(&%9 -& - 3-.$(7F2-. (22#%&&B &1#9."6%
". 7.(6%B ". -2$%.#-$('%21B 9%32"1%9 -& - 7.%-$('% (63F2&% -#9 ."6-#$(7(&%9 -&
- 0".7% "0 -.$(&$(7 3."9F7$("#>
Q.$-F9;& '%.1 3FH2(7 +"&$(2($1 %#+-#7%& H"$+ +(& 72(#(7-2 &$-$F& -& - 6-9S
6-# -& 8%22 -& $+% 7.($(7-2 .%7%3$("# "0 +(& 8".T> o%$ $+% 3"3F2-.($1 "0
Q.$-F9;& -//.%&&('% -#9 '("2%#$ 8.($(#/&B 9.-8(#/& -#9 3%.0".6-#7%& (&
2(6($%9> Y#%'($-H21B +(& 3."9F7$("#& -.% &%%# -& F#3-2-$-H2% ". H".(#/ -#9
<)N
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Q.$-F9 -#9 $+% Y63".$-#7% "0 Z%(#/
GF9%
-.% $+%# 7-$%/".(&%9 -& 3."9F7$& `&163$"6&a "0 6%#$-2 9(&$F.H-#7% ".
.%R%7$%9 -& 3-.$ "0 - $%9("F& -#9 #"#&%#&(7-2 ."F$(#%>< [%&3($% $+% '-/-.(%&
"0 $+% -.$ 6-.T%$B +"8%'%.B Q.$-F9 7"#$(#F%& $" %#7"F.-/% $+% (6-/% "0 $+%
6%#$-221 9(&$F.H%9 8.($%.B 3%.0".6%. -#9 -.$(&$ HF$ 0". .%-&"#& "$+%. $+-#
3"3F2-.($1> Q.$-F9 (#&(&$& $+-$ 6%#$-2 9(&$F.H-#7%& +-'% &"6%$+(#/ "0 $+%
F$6"&$ (63".$-#7% $" &-1> M%#7%B +% (& #"$ -/-(#&$ $+% 3."9(/-2 72-(6&B
8+%$+%. 7"632%6%#$-.1 ". 7.($(7-2B HF(2$ -."F#9 -# (9%-2 #%VF& "0 $+%
'(&("#-.1B $+% /%#(F& -#9 $+% 6-9S6-#>
*+% 2F7(9 3"8%.& "0 $+% (6-/(#-$("# -.% .-.%21 2(&$%#%9 $" "F$&(9% $+%
3-$+"2"/(&$;& 72(#(7> Y# $+(& &%#&%B Q.$-F9 (& -# (63".$-#$ 56-9S6-#; H%7-F&%
+% 9%6-#9& $" H% $-T%# &%.("F&21 (# H"$+ 7.($(7-2 -& 8%22 -& 72(#(7-2 $%.6&
&(6F2$-#%"F&21>@ Y# -# %-.21 2%$$%. $" $+% 3FH2(&+%. k-7_F%& G('(%n.%B Q.$-F9
8.($%&B 5Y -6 - 6-# 8+" +-& /.%-$21 &F00%.%9 (# $+% 6(#9B -#9 -& &F7+ Y
+-'% $+% .(/+$ $" &3%-T; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB )<a> Q.$-F9 (& 2%&& (#$%.%&$%9 (# $+%
"F$7"6% ". .%7%3$("# "0 +(& &3%%7+ $+-# (# 3"&&%&&(#/ $+% .(/+$ $" 5&3%-T; -$
-22> M% %63+-&(&%& #"$ $%2%"2"/1 `$+% 0(#(&+%9 3."9F7$a HF$ $+% (#0(#($%
3."7%&& "0 7.%-$(#/ H%7-F&% 9%&3($% 3"3F2-.B ."6-#$(7 -#9 7"#$(#F"F& (#$%.S
%&$ (# $+% -#-21&(& "0 (#&-#($1B %&3%7(-221 (# .%2-$("# $" /%#(F&B #" &F7+
&F&$-(#%9 7F.("&($1 -$$%#9& $+"&% 8+" %#-7$ 9(&-/.%%-H2% 3FH2(7 9(&32-1& "0
-#/%.B 0.F&$.-$("# -#9 .F9%#%&&>D Y$ (& $+(& F#3"3F2-. -#9 F#-$$.-7$('% 6-9S
#%&& h -0$%. -22 6-9#%&& (& H"$+ -# %$+(7-2 -#9 -# -%&$+%$(7 -00-(. h $+-$ +-&
H%%# -22"8%9 $" H%7"6% H".(#/ -#9 (& 0". $+% 6"&$ 3-.$ "#21 7-.(7-$F.%9B
(#7-.7%.-$%9 -#9 (/#".%9> Q.$-F9;& 2%$$%.& $" G('(%n.% %V%.7(&% $+% .(/+$ $"
&3%-T H1 -$$%63$(#/ $" %V32-(# "'%. -#9 "'%.B -#9 6F7+ $" $+% H%8(29%.S
6%#$ "0 $+%(. -99.%&&%%B $+% 6"&$ F#32%-&-#$ -&3%7$& "0 $+% 3."7%&& "0
8.($(#/>
Q /%#%.-2 (/#".-#7% $"8-.9& 6-9#%&& (& "#% "0 $+% 7%#$.-2 (&&F%& "0
Q.$-F9;& 5f-# ^"/+B $+% E-# ,F(7(9%9 H1 ,"7(%$1;B - 8".T 0". 8+(7+ Q.$-F9
.%7%('%9 +(& "#21 2($%.-.1 -8-.9>J f-# ^"/+B 8.($%& Q.$-F9B 59(9 #" 6".%
$+-# 7F$ "00 +(& 2%0$ %-.; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB )@Ja> f-# ^"/+ (& #"$ 6-9B +% (& "#21
$+"F/+$ &" H1 5H"F./%"(& (#%.$(-; -#9 ($& 5"./-#(&%9 7.(6%; 5(# - 8".29 (#
8+(7+ %'%.1 9-1 $+%1 %-$ '-/(#- 7""T%9 (# /.%%# &-F7% ". $+% /%#($-2& "0 #%8 H".# 7+(29 8+(33%9 (#$" - .-/% 32F7T%9 -& ($ 7-6% "F$ "0 $+% 6-$%.#-2
&%V; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB )@Ja> Q.$-F9 (#72F9%& +(6&%20 -#9 f-# ^"/+ (# -# %2($%
7"$%.(% "0 3%.&%7F$%9 &-/%& -2"#/&(9% ^%.-.9 9% =%.'-2B W.(%9.(7+ =(%$A&7+%B
U9/-. Q22%# P"% -#9 $+% !"6$% K-F$.%e-6"#$> *+%&% 0(/F.%& +-'% H%%# &F(S
7(9%9 H1 - &"7(%$1 8+(7+ 7-##"$ 9(&$(#/F(&+ H%$8%%# $+% (9%- "0 6-9#%&& -&
-# (..-$("#-2 0".7% -H2% $" 7"6H-$ $+% 3%$$1B H-#-2 -#9 F2$(6-$%21 9%&$.F7$('%
%2%6%#$& "0 .%-&"#B -#9 $+% (9%- "0 6-9#%&& -& -# (..-$("#-2 -#9 (#7"63.%S
+%#&(H2% 0".7% 0($ "#21 0". (#7-.7%.-$("# -#9 9%-$+>
Q.$-F9;& %&&-1 "# f-# ^"/+ (632(%& $+% (#$."9F7$("# "0 - 9(&$(#7$("#
H%$8%%# -//.%&&('% -#9 (#&-#% 6-9#%&&>N *+% %$16"2"/1 "0 H"$+ F&%& "0
6-9B -//.%&&("# -#9 (#&-#($1B (& $+% L29 U#/2(&+ 8".9 0". (#&-#($1 ?$59t.> Y0
8% $-T% (#&-#($1 -& $+% 3.(6-.1 ". 0(V%9 6%-#(#/ "0 ?$59t.B ($ H%7"6%&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
(9#'$)*&$ B94$ <)C
3"&&(H2% $" '(%8 -//.%&&("#B F&%9 +%.% -& - &163$"6 "0 (#&-#($1 ". -#
(#&-#($1 (# ($&%20B -& ($& 6F$-H2% %2%6%#$> Y# $+(& &%#&% $+% 02%V(H(2($1 "0
-//.%&&("# %#-H2%& ($ $" #%/"$(-$% ($& ."2%& (# H"$+ 6-9#%&& -#9 -#/%. -#9
-& - .%&F2$ 9(&$(#/F(&+ H%$8%%# -# -//.%&&('%S6-9#%&& -#9 -# (#&-#%S6-9S
#%&&> O+(2% (#&-#%S6-9#%&& (& $"2%.-$%9 $" - 3"(#$B 9F% $" $+% ."6-#7% "0 $+%
6-9S/%#(F&B -//.%&&('%S6-9#%&& 8+(7+ (& .F9% -#9 (#$(6(9-$(#/B (& "#21
$"2%.-$%9 "#7% ($ +-& H%%# $.-#&0".6%9 (#$" (#&-#%S6-9#%&& H1 - 61.(-9 "0
8(22(#/ (#&$($F$("#& H% $+%1 0-6(2(-2B .%2(/("F&B 2%/-2B 3%9-/"/(7-2 ". &%20S
-#-21$(7-2> O($+"F$ $+% %V7F&% "0 6-9#%&&B $+% -//.%&&". (& 7"#&(9%.%9 .%&3"#&(H2% -/%#$> Q#9 1%$ (."#(7-221B $+(& &-6% -//.%&&". (& .%/-.9%9 -&
(#&-#% H%7-F&% +% (& $+% 9(.%7$". "0 -//.%&&('% -7$&> Y# "$+%. 8".9&B $+%.% (&
&F33"&%921 #" &F7+ $+(#/ -& -# -//.%&&('% -7$ 8+(7+ +-& H%%# 7+"&%# .%-&"#S
-H21> !"#&%_F%#$21B 8+%# Q.$-F9;& "F$&3"T%# 9%.(&("# 0". $+% 8".29 (&
3"F.%9 (#$" $+% $%632-$% 0". (#&-#($1B $+% .%/-.9 8($+ 8+(7+ ($ (& $-T%#
H%7"6%& - 3F.%21 $+%.-3%F$(7 %V%.7(&%> ^('%# $+% 3-$+"2"/(7-2 9(-/#"&(& "0
+(& -#/%.B ($ (& #"$ &F.3.(&(#/ $+%#B $" 0(#9 $+-$ Q.$-F9 (& .-.%21 $-T%#
&%.("F&21> Q.$-F9;& $+%".(%& "# $+% 8%-T#%&& -#9 F&%2%&&#%&& "0 6-#B (0 $+%1
-.% 7"#&(9%.%9 -$ -22 h 8+(7+ 6%-#& 8($+"F$ $+% - $+%.-3%F$(7 &%#$(6%#$-2S
(&6 h -.% (#'-.(-H21 '(%8%9 8($+ &F&3(7("# -#9 9(&.%/-.9%9>
Y#&"0-. -& $+% 5-/%#$; "0 -# -//.%&&("# (& $.%-$%9 3-.-9"V(7-221 -& H"$+
.%&3"#&(H2% -#9 (..%&3"#&(H2% 0". +(& "F$HF.&$&B -#1 6"'%6%#$ 8+(7+ &%$&
"F$ $" $.1 $" '-2(9-$% -#/%.;& 3%7F2(-.($(%& -2&" (#($(-$%& - 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 9%H-$%
-H"F$ $+% .%2-$("#&+(3 H%$8%%# 3-&&("# -#9 .%-&"#> L0 $+% $8"B ($ (& $+% 2-$$%.
"0 8+(7+ Q.$-F9 (& &F&3(7("F&>
Y 9%&$."1 H%7-F&% 0". 6% %'%.1$+(#/ $+-$ 3."7%%9& 0."6 .%-&"# (& F#$.F&$S
8".$+1> Y H%2(%'% "#21 (# $+% %'(9%#7% "0 8+-$ &$(.& 61 6-.."8B #"$ (# $+%
%'(9%#7% "0 8+-$ -99.%&&%& ($&%20 $" 61 .%-&"#>
`Q.$-F9 )XCNB )I?a
Q$ $+% &-6% $(6% -& 9"FH$(#/ .%-&"#B Q.$-F9 -2&" 9(&6(&&%& 7-3.(7("F&
-7$("#& /"'%.#%9 H1 3%.&"#-2 3-&&("#&> Y# +(& 5$+%-$.% "0 7.F%2$1;B (63."'(&-S
$("# (& 0".H(99%# H%7-F&% $+% -7$". 6F&$ H% 5- T(#9 "0 3-&&('% -#9 #%F$.-2
%2%6%#$B &(#7% +% (& .(/"."F&21 9%#(%9 -22 3%.&"#-2 (#($(-$('%; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB
X?a> Q.$-F9 0-'"F.& 9(&7(32(#%9 -#9 (#7(&('% $+"F/+$ "'%. &3"#$-#%($1 -$ $+%
&-6% $(6% -& .%R%7$(#/ $+% .(/(9($1 "0 .%-&"#> M% $F.#& .%-&"# (#$" - 3F.%21
-%&$+%$(7 %2%6%#$B "#% 8+(7+ +% F&%& $" -.$(7F2-$% +(& -//.%&&("# -#9 (# &"
9"(#/ .%R%7$ .%-&"#;& 6"#"3"21 "# 6%#$-2 -7F($1> M%.%B Q.$-F9 9"%& #"$
.%R%7$ $+% 3"$%#$(-2 2F7(9($1 8+(7+ .%-&"# 72-(6& HF$ $+% $.-#&7%#9%#$-2
0".6 ($ 7"66"#21 -&&F6%&>
Q& (0 $" 9%6"#&$.-$% $+-$ $+% 6-#%F'%.(#/ "0 .%-&"# -#9 3-&&("# (& #"$
#%8 HF$ (&&F%& 0."6 - '(.$F-2 ". F#(9%#$(0(-H2% 3"8%.B Q.$-F9 3."72-(6& $+-$
5"#21 $+% 6-96-# (& $.F21 7-26; `Q.$-F9 )XCNB )IXa> *+% 6-96-#;& 8".29 (&
FH(_F($"F& -#9 +(& (9%-& 021 (# -22 9(.%7$("#&> 5O+-$ Y -6 (& 8($+"F$ 9(00%.S
%#7(-$("# #". 3"&&(H2% "33"&($("#B ($ (& $+% -H&"2F$% (#$.F&("# "0 61 H"91B
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<)? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
%'%.18+%.%; `Q.$-F9 :YfB CNa> *+% 7-26 "0 $+% 6-96-# -.(&%& 0."6 $+%
2F7(9($1 "0 $+% 6(#9 8+(7+ (& -H2% $" /" %'%.18+%.%> Q.$-F9 7-22& $+(& $+%
52F7(9($1 "0 F#.%-&"#;> Y$ (& "#21 $+% (#&$(/-$("# "0 .%-&"# -& $+% 7"..%7$ 6"9%
0". $+(#T(#/ $+-$ 7-.'%& $+% 8".29 (# $8"> G%-&"# "'%.S7"9%& F#.%-&"# 8($+ 8".29 "0 6-9#%&& -#9 &%7F.%& ($&%20 (# - &-#% 8".29> KF7(9($1 2(%& -3-.$ 0."6
.%-&"# -#9 (& -'-(2-H2% "#21 (# 6"6%#$& "0 6-9#%&&> Q$ $+% &-6% $(6%B $+%
6(#9 (& -H2% $" .%&(&$ F#9(.%7$%9 3%.&"#-2 3-&&("# H%7-F&% $+% 2F7(9($1 "0
F#.%-&"# ". $+% 6(#9;& %'%.18+%.% (& #"$ F#9(.%7$%9> *+% 6-9 6(#9 -#9 ($&
9(.%7$("# -.% 7"%'-2 $+F& $+% 8".T 8+(7+ Q.$-F9 9%6-#9& "0 $+% 6(#9 (&
3."9F7%9 H1 $+% F#(_F% -#9 F#(9%#$(0(-H2% "#$"2"/1 "0 5-# F#$.-#&32-#$-H2%
%/";>
Z1 3-1(#/ -$$%#$("# $" - +($+%.$" H-.%21 9(&7%.#(H2% 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%#
-//.%&&("# -#9 (#&-#($1 (# .%2-$("# $" 3-&&("# -#9 .%-&"#B Q.$-F9;& 8".T
.-(&%& $+% &$-$F& "0 "#% "0 -#/%.;& 6"&$ F#9%..-$%9 6"9%&4 .F9%#%&&> Q.$-F9
%#7"F.-/%& .F9%#%&& $" /-$+%. ($& "8# 6"6%#$F6 -#9 $+F& ($& "8# (63".$S
-#7%B +%#7% +(& #"$("# "0 $+% .(/+$ $" &3%-T> Y# "$+%. 8".9&B Q.$-F9B 8+"
'(%8& %'%.1$+(#/ -& 3"$%#$(-221 (63".$-#$ h $+%.% (& #" &F7+ $+(#/ -& - 6(#".
". (#7"#&%_F%#$(-2 -00%7$('% -7$ h (#7.%-&%& $+% &$.%#/$+ "0 +(& .F9%#%&& H1
(#R%7$(#/ ($ 8($+ - /.-'($1 $+-$ -22"8& ($ RF.(&9(7$("# "'%. %'%# $+% 6"&$
(##"7F"F& "0 &($F-$("#&>
EE
[" 1"F T#"8 -#"$+%. E-# 8+"&% (#9(/#-$("# -/-(#&$ %'%.1$+(#/ $+-$
#"8 %V(&$& (& -& 7"#&$-#$ ". -& '("2%#$ -#9 8+" (& -& 7"#&$-#$21 -#9 -&
9%&3%.-$%21 (# - &$-$% "0 3%.3%$F-2 0F26(#-$("#i
`Q.$-F9 )XCNB DIIa
Q2$+"F/+ $+%.% (& #" "#% 8+"&% 3FH2(7(&%9] 3FH2(&+%9 "'%.$ -#/%. &$.(T%& -&
7"#&$-#$21 -& Q.$-F9;&B +% 9"%& +-'% -22(%&> =(%$A&7+% (& - 7"22-H".-$". 8($+
-# %#9F.(#/ -#9 0F26(#-$(#/ 7.($(_F% "0 +F6-# 8%-T#%&&B "0 9-1& 8+%# +%
(& 5+-F#$%9 H1 - 0%%2(#/ H2-7T%. $+-# $+% H2-7T%&$ 6%2-#7+"21 h 7"#$%63$ "0
6-#; `=(%$A&7+% )XXIB )N)a> [%&3($% $+% '%.1 9(00%.%#$ 6-#(0%&$-$("#& "0
$+%(. 57('(2; "HR%7$("#&B =(%$A&7+%;& _F(%$ HF$ +-.&+ 7.($(7(&6& -#9 Q.$-F9;&
2"F9 -#9 0.%#%$(7 "F$HF.&$& -#9 &#-.2(#/ $%.6& "0 -HF&%B 8+-$ Q.$-F9 -#9
=(%$A&7+% &+-.% (& - T%%# -8-.%#%&& "0 $+% 3."H2%6 "0 .F9%#%&& -#9 -#
%_F-221 T%%# 9%&(.% 0". ($& 3%.3%$F-$("#> Q2$+"F/+ =(%$A&7+% 72-(6& $" H%
3"2($% (# +(& 9%-2(#/& 8($+ "$+%.&B +% 9"%& #"$ .%7"66%#9 - 7"632%$%
-H-#9"#6%#$ "0 .F9%#%&&>C Y# 6//$ >"5"B +% 72-(6& 5$+% .F9%&$ 8".9B $+%
.F9%&$ 2%$$%. -.% &$(22 6".% H%#(/#B 6".% 9%7%#$ $+-# &(2%#7%; -99(#/ $+-$
.F9%#%&& (&B 5H1 0-. $+% 6"&$ +F6-#% 7"#$.-9(7$("#; `=(%$A&7+% )X?XB <<Xa>
GF9%#%&& (& +F6-#% H%7-F&% ($ (& 7-#9(9m ($ 9"%& #"$ 8-($ &6"F29%.(#/ (#
9-.T#%&&B 72"$+%9 (# $+% -33%-.-#7% "0 %V$(#/F(&+%9 0(.%> GF9%#%&& (& 7"#$.-S
9(7$".(21 +F6-#% H%7-F&% $+% &"7(-221 &%20S3."$%7$('% -#9 $-7($ .F2% "0
+F6-#% 3"2($%#%&& $.(%& $" '%$" ($> Q.$-F9 -#9 =(%$A&7+% &+"8 $+-$ $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
(9#'$)*&$ B94$ <)X
<<I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
F#9%. 8+-$ 7"#9($("#& 9(9 6-# (#'%#$ $+% '-2F% RF9/6%#$& /""9 -#9
%'(2i Q#9 8+-$ '-2F% 9" $+%1 +-'% $+%6&%2'%&i M-'% $+%1 F3 $" #"8
"H&$.F7$%9 ". 3."6"$%9 +F6-# 02"F.(&+(#/i Q.% $+%1 - &(/# "0 9(&$.%&&B
3"'%.$1 -#9 $+% 9%/%#%.-$("# "0 2(0%i L.B "# $+% 7"#$.-.1B 9" $+%1 .%'%-2
$+% 0F22#%&&B '($-2($1 -#9 8(22 $" 2(0%B ($& 7"F.-/%B ($& 7"#0(9%#7%B ($& 0F$F.%i
`=(%$A&7+% )XXDB Ja
Z%0".% +F6-#($1 7-# 3."&3%.B =(%$A&7+% 3.%9(7$& $+-$ $+% (66%9(-$% 0F$F.%
8(22 H% "#% "0 5UF."3%-# #(+(2(&6;> Q77".9(#/ $" =(%$A&7+%B #(+(2(&6 (& $+%
F#-'"(9-H2% 7"#72F&("# $" "F. &1&$%6 "0 '-2F%&4 58% 6F&$ %V3%.(%#7% #(+(2S
(&6 H%0".% 8% 7-# 0(#9 "F$ 8+-$ $+%(. 55'-2F%;; .%-221 +-9; `=(%$A&7+% )XNCB Da>
O% 6F&$ %V3%.(%#7% #(+(2(&6 H%0".% 8% 7-# %'%# H%/(# $" -7_F(.% #%8
'-2F%&> ZF$ $"9-1B ($ (& +-.9 $" &-1 &"6%$+(#/ -H"F$ #(+(2(&6 $+-$ 6(/+$ -(9
(# ($& .%#%8%9 &(/#(0(7-#7%> ^('%# ($& 0-&+("#-H2% &$-$F& -& (#$%/.-2 $" 51"F$+
7F2$F.%;B #(+(2(&6 ($&%20 +-& 2-./%21 -#9 (."#(7-221B H%7"6% - 0F$(2% 3."R%7$>
=(+(2(&6 +-& 0".0%($%9 $+% &$.%#/$+ "0 ($& -00%7$('% '-2F% $" $+% 8.($& "0
+(&$".(7-2 -#9 9%6"7.-$(7 6%9("7.($1 8+%.% ($ (& -332(%9 -& -# %3($+%$ $"
-26"&$ %'%.1$+(#/> Q& - 9%&7.(3$('% $%.6 #(+(2(&6 (& .%/F2-.21 -&7.(H%9 $"
O%&$%.# &3(.($F-2 H-#T.F3$71B 9(&-00%7$%9 1"F$+B 7-22"F& 3"2($(7& -#9 &3F.(S
"F& 9%6"7.-7(%&B &%20S3."2(0%.-$(#/ 7-3($-2(&$ 6-7+(#%B $+% FH(_F($1 "0 -99(7S
$("#B $+% 3"3F2-.($1 "0 6(#9S#F6H(#/ $%2%'(&("#B $+% /2F$ "0 (#0".6-$("#
$%7+#"2"/(%& -#9 $+% 9%6(&% "0 $+% 8%20-.% &$-$%> Y$ (& $+% &$-H(2($1 "0 $+(&
(6-/% "0 #(+(2(&6 $+-$ +-& +%23%9 $" %V$(#/F(&+ $+% 3"&&(H(2($1 "0 ($& '(/"."F&
-#9 %00(7-7("F& .%#%8-2 -$ $+% 72"&% "0 $+% 6(22%##(F6>
\#2(T% $+% +(/+21 7"#7%#$.-$%9 &$(22#%&& "0 6"&$ $8%#$(%$+S7%#$F.1 (6-/%&
"0 #(+(2(&6B Q.$-F9;& #(+(2(&$(7 $%#9%#7(%& -.% 7"#&$-#$21 7+-#/(#/ 7"F.&%B
6"'(#/ H-7T -#9 0".$+ H%$8%%# 3%&&(6(&$(7 -#9 2F63%# 9%&3-(. -#9 -7$('%
&$.(T%& "0 9%#F#7(-$("#> =(%$A&7+%;& &7+%6% "0 #(+(2(&6 (& 7"#&(&$%#$ 8($+
Q.$-F9;& 6"H(2% #(+(2(&6 (# 3."3"&(#/ -$ 2%-&$ $8" T(#9& "0 #(+(2(&6B 3-&&('%
-#9 -7$('%> *+% T(#9 "0 #(+(2(&6 "#% 3.-7$(7%& (& 7.F7(-2 H%7-F&% -$ -#1
/('%# 6"6%#$B 9%3%#9(#/ "# $+% _F-2($1 "0 $+% #(+(2(&6B "#%;& -H(2($1 $"
-7$ (& %($+%. 9".6-#$ ". -7$('%> =(%$A&7+% %V32-(#& $+-$ "0 $+% $8"B 3-&&('%
#(+(2(&6 (& 9"6(#-#$ H%7-F&% 3%&&(6(&6B ($& "'%..(9(#/ 0%-$F.%B (& $+%
#%7%&&-.1 (#&$(/-$". 0". -22 #(+(2(&6> Y# - 2%$$%. $" M%#.( P-.(&"$B Q.$-F9
8.($%&4
$+(& 8".29 8+(7+ 7+%%.0F221 -77%3$& ($& "8# &F00"7-$("#> P%"32% -.% &$F3(9>
K($%.-$F.%B %V+-F&$%9> *+%.% (& #"$+(#/ 2%0$B $+%.% (& #" "#% 2%0$B $+% &"F2 (&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
3."H2%6 8($+ .F9%#%&& (& #"$ 8($+ .F9%#%&& ($&%20 HF$ 8($+ $+% 0-7$ $+-$
#"H"91 T#"8& +"8 $" H% .F9% 3."3%.21> *+."F/+ $+(& (#%3$#%&&B .F9%#%&&
H%7"6%& %($+%. 7-#7%."F& .%&%#$6%#$ ". &%#&%2%&& H.F$-2($1> *+% 3."H2%6 (&
#"$ .F9%#%&& HF$ ($& 3"2($(7-2B &"7(-2 -#9 7F2$F.-2 '-2F%>
O+%# =(%$A&7+% 7-22& 0". 5- .%'-2F-$("# "0 -22 '-2F%&B; +% -&T&4
(9#'$)*&$ B94$ <<)
P-&&('% #(+(2(&6 .%/-.9& 2(0% -& '-2F%2%&& -#9 6%-#(#/2%&&> *+% &$F3(9($1 $+-$
/"'%.#& (& $+% &$F3(9($1 "0 -77%3$(#/ $+% %V3%7$-$("# "0 +-33(#%&& -& 7"6S
3%#&-$("# 0". 6%9("7.($1 -#9 &3%7("F& 3"2($%#%&&> Q.$-F9 3"(#$& "F$ $+-$ $+(&
3%&&(6(&6 (& 0-. 0."6 +-.62%&& 8+%# +% 7"632-(#& -H"F$ /."F3& "0 W.%#7+S
6%# 8+" -.% 7-&$(#/ &3%22& "# +(6 (# ".9%. $" &(2%#7% +(6 -& $+% 5.%H%2 3"%$;>
*+%&% 0(/F.%& -.% 9-#/%."F&B #"$ -& -# "./-#(&-$("# &F7+ -& $+% =-$("#-2
W."#$ (& 9%%6%9 9-#/%."F& HF$ -& "#21 $+% 6(992%S72-&& 7-# H%> Y# -#"$+%.
2%$$%. $" P-.(&"$B Q.$-F9 9%&7.(H%& $+% 3+1&(7-2 -#9 6%#$-2 (22#%&& 8+(7+
6(992%S72-&& W.-#7% 0".7%& F3"# +(6> M% 7"632-(#& $+-$ $+%.% (& #" 2"#/%.
-#1$+(#/ $" 2"'%B $" +-$% ". $" 8"..1 -H"F$> K(0% (& 2%9 5H1 - HF#7+ "0 9F22
3%"32% 8+" +-'% 8-#$%9 $" (63"&% $+%(. +-$.%9 "0 3"%$.1 "# -22 "0 F&B $"
(63"&% $+%(. 2"'% "0 6(992%S72-&& -H&F.9($1 (# - &"7(%$1 8+"221 6(992%S
72-&&(0(%9B 8($+ -22 $+% '%.H-2 9."#(#/& -H"F$ &"'(%$&B -#-.7+1B 7+F.7+%&B
.($%&B .-$("#(#/B _F"$-&B H2-7T 6-.T%$& -#9 $+% .%&(&$-#7% 6"'%6%#$; `Q.$-F9
)XN@B C)a> U'%# $+% '("2%#7% -#9 $+% -$."7($(%& "0 O".29 O-. *8" 7"F29 #"$
7"F#$%.-7$ $+% 9(&%-&% "0 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6 &3.%-9 H1 $+% 6(992% 72-&&%&>
EF7+ "0 Q.$-F9;& -#/%. -/-(#&$ $+% 6(992%S72-&& (& -(6%9 '%+%6%#$21 -$
$+% -.$ 8".29 "0 3FH2(&+(#/ -#9 3%.0".6(#/> QHF&(#/ $+"&% "0 $+% 2($%.-.1
&7%#% (# 5Q22 O.($(#/ (& P(/ &+($;B Q.$-F9;& $-F#$(#/ .F#&B 51"F H%-.9S-&&%&B 1"F
3%.$(#%#$ 3(/&B 1"F 6-&$%.& "0 0-T% '%.H(-/%B 7"#0%7$("#%.& "0 3".$.-($&B
3-63+2%$%%.&B /."F#9S02"". 2-7%S7F.$-(# +%.H 7"22%7$".&B %#$"6"2"/(&$&B 32-S
/F% "0 61 $"#/F%; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB @Xa> Y# ".9%. $" 8-/% 8-. "# $+% 6".-2
'-2F%& "0 &8%%$6%-$& -#9 H"#H"#& $+-$ &F33".$ 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6B -#9 F2$(S
6-$%21 $" "'%.7"6% $+% #%%9 $" 8-/% &F7+ - 8-.B =(%$A&7+% 3."3"&%& -7$('%
#(+(2(&6 -& - $.-#&($("#-2 &$%3> O+(2% 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6 (& -//.%&&("# $+-$ 7($%&
($& 7-F&% -& 8(22%9 H1 &"6%"#% ". &"6%$+(#/ %2&%B -7$('% #(+(2(&6 (& 8(220F2
-//.%&&("# 8+(7+ 9"%& #"$ &%%T - 7-F&%> Q7$('% #(+(2(&6 7.%-$%& - &%.(%& "0
&3"#$-#%"F& -#9 -#-.7+(7 -7$("#&> *+% _F%&$("# (&B +"8 $" /%$ 0."6 3-&&('%
#(+(2(&6 $" -7$('% #(+(2(&6i Q.$-F9 9%6"#&$.-$%& $+-$ "0 -22 $+% 6%$+"9& "0
-#/%. .F9%#%&& (& 3"$%#$(-221 $+% 6"&$ 02%V(H2%> *+(& (& 3-.$(-221 H%7-F&% ($ (&
"#% "0 $+% 2%&& "H'("F& -#9 2%-&$ %V3%7$%9 %V3.%&&("#& "0 -# -7$('% #(+(2(&6m
.F9%#%&& (& 6"&$ /%#%.-221 .%/-.9%9 -& - 0".6 "0 (#%00%7$F-2 7"632-(#$ ".
H"6H-&$(7 -#9 _F%.F2"F& .-#$(#/> ZF$ .F9%#%&& 7-# H% %V$.%6%21 &FH$2% -#9
%00%7$('%> GF9%#%&& (& #"$ -& H2""91 -#9 .%-7$('% -& .-/%B -& (.-&7(H2% -#9
2"#/&$-#9(#/ -& (..($-H(2($1B -& 9%0(#($('% -& +-$.%9B -& &13+(2($(7 -& %$%.#-2
.%&%#$6%#$B -& H($$%. -& 6-2(7%B -& 3-.-#"(9 -#9 &%20S3($1(#/ -& '%V-$("#B #".
-& 0-2&%21 .(/+$%"F& -& (#9(/#-$("#>?
Y0 Q.$-F9 (& -H2% $" 3.-7$(7% -7$('% #(+(2(&6B %'%# -& +% 7"#$(#F%& $" &F00%.
0."6 .%&&%#$(6%#$ 8+(7+ (& "#% "0 ($& 9%H(2($-$(#/ %#%6(%&B ($ (& H%7-F&% +(&
.F9%#%&& (& $"" 0-&$ -#9 -22 %#7"63-&&(#/ $" &F&$-(# H($$%.#%&&> 5MF..(%9 -#9
.-3(9 (6-/%& &3%-T $" 6% "#21 (# 8".9& "0 -#/%. -#9 H2(#9 +-$% HF$ -.% "'%.
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
(#&-#%B $+%.% (& #" 2"'%B $+%.% (&#;$ %'%# +-$%B -22 H"9(%& -.% &-$%9B %'%.1S
"#%;& 7"#&7("F&#%&& .%&(/#%9>
`Q.$-F9 )XCNB DDDa
-& 0-&$ -& - T#(0% &$-HH(#/B ". 2(/+$#(#/ (# 7"#/%&$%9 &T1; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB D<a>
*+% (9%- $+-$ Q.$-F9;& .%&%#$6%#$& -.% #"$ - &%.("F& +(#9.-#7% $" -# -7$('%
#(+(2(&6 (& 3-.-22%2%9 H1 =(%$A&7+%;& 7"66%#$& "# .%&&%#$(6%#$ -#9 $+%
#"H2%6-#> 5G%&&%#$(6%#$B ($&%20B (0 ($ &+"F29 -33%-. (# $+% #"H2%6-# `0". ($
7-# -33%-. (# $+% #"H2%a 7"#&F66-$%& -#9 %V+-F&$& ($&%20 (# -# (66%9(-$%
.%-7$("#B -#9 $+%.%0".% 9"%& #"$ 3"(&"#; `=(%$A&7+% )X?XB @Xa> Q.$-F9;& .F9%
7"632-(#$& -.% #"$ 3&17+"2"/(7-2 ". 3%.&"#-2 HF$ 7"&6"2"/(7-2 -#9 6%$-S
3+1&(7-2> M% .-(2& 2%&& -/-(#&$ (#9('(9F-2& h 8+%# +% &(#/2%& "F$ 7%.$-(#
"9("F& 7+-.-7$%.& ($ (& H%7-F&% $+%1 -.% %6H2%6-$(7 "0 &"6%$+(#/ /.%-$%. h
$+-# -$ 6"9%.# O%&$%.# $+"F/+$ (# /%#%.-2B %&3%7(-221 -$ ($& &7(%#$(0(7 (/#".S
-#7% "0 %6"$("# -#9 (6-/(#-$("#> 5=" "#% (# UF."3% T#"8& +"8 $" &7.%-6
-#16".%; `Q.$-F9 )XJ?B )D)a> Q22 -#1"#% 7-# 9" (& $-2T -H"F$ $+%(. "8#
"3(#("#& -#9 6".&%2& "0 T#"82%9/%> *-2T(#/ (& - 9(##%. 3-.$1 -7$('($1
+(R-7T%9 H1 $+% 6(992%S72-&& -#9 .%/-.9%9 -& - &T(22 7"632(6%#$-.1 $" $8%#S
$(%$+S7%#$F.1 -9'%.$(&(#/ 7"31B $+% 7"#&$-#$ 9(&&%6(#-$("# "0 (#0".6-$("#
-#9 -22 &7(%#$(0(7 9(&7"F.&%& &3%7(-2(&(#/ (# $+% -#-21&(& "0 $+% &FHR%7$> Y0
Q.$-F9 &7.%-6& ($ (& #"$ H%7-F&% +% +-& #"$+(#/ $" &-1 HF$ H%7-F&%B F#2(T%
$+% (#+(H($("#& "0 $+% 9(##%. 3-.$1 8+%.% - &7.%-6 &(/#(0(%& $+% %#9 "0 $-2TB
Q.$-F9;& &7.%-6 -.(&%& H%0".% ($& H%/(##(#/> Q.$-F9;& 2(#/F(&$(7 -&3%.($1 (&
9(&$(#7$ 0."6 +(& &#-.2&B &+"F$&B 7.(%& -#9 +"..%#9"F& &7.%-6&> *+% 2-$$%.
6-T% $+% &"F#9 "0 $+% %00".$ $" &-1 &"6%$+(#/ 8+(7+ "0$%#$(6%& 9"%& #"$
#%%9 $" H% &-(9 3.%7(&%21 H%7-F&% $+% 3"(#$ H%(#/ 6-9% (& $+% &"F#9 "0 $+%
%00".$ ($&%20>
EEE
Q.$-F9 $.-00(7& (# - &3(.($ "0 .F9%#%&& $+-$ 3."'(9%& +(6 8($+ $+% &$-6(#- $"
'"7(0%.-$% (# 8".9& -#9 &7.%-6& -/-(#&$ %'%# $+% 6"&$ (#02-$%9 -#9 F#8(%291
"0 7"#7%3$&4 3"8%.B 2(0% -#9 %$+(7&B -#9 $+%(. 7"632%6%#$&B '("2%#7%B 8-.
-#9 &F00%.(#/> GF9%#%&& H.(#/& $+%&% 7"#7%3$& -#9 %2%6%#$& $"/%$+%.
$+."F/+ $+% F&% "0 7"#$.-9(7$("#> Z%7-F&% 7"#$.-9(7$("# (& 6F2$(32%B Q.$-F9
(& -H2% $" .-6(01 /%#%.-2 7"#7%3$("#& "0 5/""9; -#9 5H-9;B 52(0%;B -#9 53"8%.;B
-#9 $+%# .%0".6F2-$% $+%6 (# .%2-$("# $" +(& $+%".(%& "0 7.F%2$1B %V7%&& -#9
&F00%.(#/> Q.$-F9 9(&3%#&%& 8($+ ".$+"9"V .F2%& "0 "33"&($("# -#9 -22"8&
&%'%.-2 (63.%&&("#& $" 3-.$(7(3-$% (# - &(#/2% 7"#&(9%.-$("#> Q.$-F9;& F&% "0
7"#$.-9(7$("# 7"#0F&%& 5/""9; -#9 5H-9;B H1 0(2(#/ 52(0%;B 53"8%.;B -#9 5%$+(7&;B
$+."F/+ - T(#9 "0 7"#7%3$F-2 $F.#&$(2%> Z%7-F&% 6"'%6%#$ (& (63"&&(H2% $"
"H&%.'% F#2%&& "#% (& &$-#9(#/ &$(22B $+% 7"#$(#F"F& 7+-#/% $+-$ 7"#&$($F$%&
$+% 6"'%6%#$ "0 $+% 7"#7%3$F-2 $F.#&$(2% (& "#21 9(&7%.#(H2% -& 7"#$.-9(7S
$("#> Y#&"0-. -& 7"#$.-9(7$("# (& - 3F.3"&%0F221 (..%&"2'-H2% -#$-/"#(&6B ($ (&
#"$ &F.3.(&(#/ $+%#B $" 0(#9 .F9%#%&& $+.('(#/ $+%.%> Q.$-F9;& .F9%#%&& (& 9%72-.-$("# "0 8-. -/-(#&$ $+% .%-&"#%9 3%.3%$F-$("# "0 $+% &$-$F& _F"> M%
F&%& 7"#$.-9(7$("# $" 7"F#$%.-7$ &$-H(2($1 H%7-F&% ($& -#$-/"#(&6B 8+(7+ 8(22
#"$ 7.%-$% - $+(.9 %2%6%#$ "0 .%&"2'%B 3.%'%#$& $+% 6(#9 0."6 &$-#9(#/ &$(22>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<<< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Y$ 6F&$ H% #"$%9 $+-$ .F9%#%&& (& #"$ -28-1& &%.("F&B -0$%. -22 ($ (& $+."F/+
7"#$.-9(7$("# $+-$ +F6"F. 0(.&$ -.(&%&> Q77".9(#/ $" Q.$-F9B $+% $+%-$.%B 5+-&
2"&$ $+% &%#&% "0 $.F% +F6"F. -#9 "0 $+% 3+1&(7-2 -#9 -#-.7+(7B 9(&&"7(-$('%
3"8%. "0 7"6%91; `Q.$-F9 )XCNB <@Ja> Y$ (& 8($+(# Q.$-F9;& &%.("7"6(7 &$.F7S
$F.%& $+-$ 7"#$.-9(7$("# (#9(7-$%& $+% 9(00%.%#7% $+-$ 6-T%& - R"T% &2(/+$21
6".% $+-# - R"T%>X Y# 5Q K%$$%. "# Q.$-F9B; P-F2% *+%e'%#(# .%2-1& $8"
-#%79"$%& -H"F$ Q.$-F9;& &%#&% "0 +F6"F.> *+% 0(.&$ 7"#7%.#& - R"F.#-2(&$
8+" '(&($%9 Q.$-F9 $" -&T +(6 0". +(& 9%0(#($("# "0 H2-7T +F6"F.> Q.$-F9
(/#".%9 $+% 6-#B 7"#$(#F%9 $-2T(#/ 8($+ *+%e'%#(#B 8."$% (# +(& #"$%H""T
-#9 $+%# -$% +(& 6%-2> *+% R"F.#-2(&$ 8-& &$(22 8-($(#/ 8+%# Q.$-F94
$""T +(& %#".6"F& 3%#T#(0% -#9B -0$%. 0(#9(#/ $+% .(/+$ 32-7% F#9%. +(&
+-(.B +% +%29 $+% 3"(#$ -/-(#&$ ($ `$+(& 8-& +(& F&F-2 7F&$"6 H%7-F&% +%
&-(9 ($ .%2(%'%9 +(6 "0 7%.$-(# 3-(#&a> ,F99%#21B -#9 8($+ - .-3(9 /%&$F.%B
+% &$F7T $+% T#(0% &$.-(/+$ (#$" $+% $-H2% 8+(7+ 8-& #%-. +(6> 5o"F -&T%9
6%B ,(.B 0". 61 9%0(#($("# "0 H2-7T +F6"F.> O%22B +%.% ($ (&B H2-7T +F6"F.
(& $+(&j; Q#9 $+% R"F.#-2(&$ 2%0$
`*+%e'%#(# )XNJB )IJa>
*+% &%7"#9 &$".1 7"#7%.#& *+%e'%#(#;& 7"#7(%./% 8+" "#7% 7+-&$(&%9 Q.$-F9
H%7-F&% $+% %'%#(#/ H%0".%4
+% +-9 H%%# .%7($(#/ $+% 3"%6& "0 ^%e.-.9 9% =%.'-2 8($+ $+% 8(#9"8
"3%#B -#9 +(& '"(7% +-9 7-..(%9 H%1"#9 $+% 2(6($& "0 "F. -3-.$6%#$> ,+%
+-9 +-.921 "3%#%9 +%. 6"F$+ 8+%# +% &$"33%9 +%.4 5Z% &(2%#$j Y0 1"F
3%.&(&$ (# 0".H(99(#/ 6% $" 9%72-(6 $+% '%.&%& "0 ^%e.-.9 9% =%.'-2 Y &+-22
7+-#/% 1"F (#&$-#$21 (#$" - 02-$S+%-9%9 &%.3%#$j; `*+%e'%#(# )XNJB )IDa
Q.$-F9;& +F6"F. (& (#'-.(-H21 (#&%3-.-H2% 0."6 .F9%#%&&> \#2(T% (."#1 -#9
&-.7-&6 8+(7+ 8".T $+."F/+ +(99%# ". &F332%6%#$-.1 6"'%6%#$&B +F6"F.
(& 9(.%7$21 0F##1> W". $+(& .%-&"#B +F6"F. (& (#$(6(9-$(#/B %&3%7(-221 8+%# R"T% 3."9F7% 3."9F7%& 6".% $+-# 8+-$ (& 0F##1 ". 8+%# - R"T% (& #"$ _F($%
0".6%9> *+% -9RF#7$ %2%6%#$& "0 - R"T% -33%-. (# Q.$-F9;& (9%- 0". - 5$+%-$.%
"0 7.F%2$1; 8+(7+ &FHR%7$& ($& -F9(%#7% $" $+% &+"7T "0 +F6"F.> Q.$-F9
-9'"7-$%& 5M\EL\G Q, [U,*G\!*YL=; $+."F/+ 2-F/+$%.B `Q.$-F9 )XJ?B
X)a -#9 7-22& 0". 5(#$%.R%7$("#& "0 - 3"%$.1 -#9 +F6". 3"(&%9 $" 9(&"./-#(A%
-#9 3F2'%.(A% -33%-.-#7%&;B -77".9(#/ $" -#-.7+(&$(7 3.(#7(32%& `Q.$-F9
)XJ?B )<Ja> *+(& (& H."F/+$ "F$ 72%-.21 (# $+% 0(.&$ "0 *+%e'%#(#;& &$".(%&>
Q.$-F9;& '(&($(#/ R"F.#-2(&$ 7"6%& $" Q.$-F9 "# $+% &$.%#/$+ "0 +(& .%#"8#
-& - $+%".%$(7(-# "0 $+% $+%-$.%B (# 3-.$(7F2-. "0 ($& H2-7T +F6"F. HF$ 8+-$ +%
.%7%('%& (& #"$ - $+%".1 #". - 3(%7% "0 T#"82%9/%>
L# $+% &$-/% Q.$-F9 (& #"$ 7"#7%.#%9 8($+ -9+%.(#/ $" -# Q.(&$"$%2%-#
$.-9($("# 8+(7+ .-(&%& $+% '("2%#7% "0 $.-/%91 -#9 ($& 7-2-6($(%& -H"'%
+F6".> M% (& (#$%.%&$%9 (# $+% &+"7TB (# $+% F#%V3%7$%9 $+-$ +F6"F. 7-#
/%#%.-$%> Q.$-F9 -96(.%9 $+% E-.V Z."$+%.& HF$ +% 0%2$ $+-$ (0 -# Q6%.(7-#
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
(9#'$)*&$ B94$ <<@
-F9(%#7% 7"F29 "#21 %#R"1 $+% R"T%B ($ 8-& 6(&&(#/ "F$ "# $+% -#-.7+(7 0".7%&
"0 .%'"2$ 8+(7+ -77"63-#1 ($> Q.$-F9;& 5+16# $" -#-.7+1;B -33%-.& (# E"#S
T%1 ZF&(#%&& 8+"&% %#9(#/ 53F$& $+% H.-1(#/ "0 - 7-20 "# $+% &-6% (#$%22%7S
$F-2 2%'%2 -#9 /('%& ($ $+% &-6% _F-2($1 "0 6%-#(#/0F2 &F00%.(#/ -& $+% &7.%-6
"0 - 0.(/+$%#%9 8"6-# > > >; `Q.$-F9 )XJ?B )DDa> Y#&"0-. -& - &F.3.(&%B -&(9%
0."6 -# (#($(-2 32-# $" -7$('-$% ($B 0".%72"&%& "# - 32-##%9 9%&(/#B -# F#%VS
3%7$%9 R"T% 7-# H% 2%&& $+-# 0F##1 (# ($& (63-7$ %'%# -& ($& %00%7$ .%6-(#&
+F6"F."F&>
Y# $%.6& "0 $+% #%7%&&($1 "0 7.%-$(#/ -# (63-7$B Q.$-F9 &F//%&$& $+-$ ($ (&
$+% &3"#$-#%($1 "0 - &F.3.(&% $+-$ 8(22 "'%.7"6% $+% (#%.$(- "0 3%&&(6(&6> *"
+-'% -#1 %00%7$B $+% &F.3.(&% 6F&$ H% -H&"2F$% 8+(7+ 6%-#& $+-$ ($ 6F&$ -2&"
&+"7T $+% "#% 8+" %#-7$& ($>
E1 &7.F32%& (# $+% 0-7% "0 -22 .%-2 -7$("#i
*+%&% &7.F32%& -.% -H&"2F$% -#9 $+%1 -.% "0 $8" T(#9&> ,$.(7$21 &3%-T(#/B
$+%1 -.% H-&%9 "# - 9%%3S.""$%9 &%#&% "0 $+% 3."0"F#9 0F$(2($1 "0 -#1
-7$("# 8+-$&"%'%.B 8+%$+%. &3"#$-#%"F& ". F#S&3"#$-#%"F&>
*+(& (& $+% 3"(#$ "0 '(%8 "0 $"$-2 3%&&(6(&6> ZF$ - 7%.$-(# 0".6 "0
3%&&(6(&6 7-..(%& 8($+ ($ ($& "8# T(#9 "0 2F7(9($1> *+% 2F7(9($1 "0 9%&3-(.B
$+% 2F7(9($1 "0 &%#&%& -.% %V-7%.H-$%9 -#9 -& (0 "# $+% %9/% "0 $+% -H1&&>
Q#9 -2"#/&(9% $+% +"..(H2% .%2-$('($1 "0 -#1 +F6-# -7$("#B $+(&
F#7"#&7("F& &3"#$-#%($1 8+(7+ 9.('%& "#%B (# &3($% "0 %'%.1$+(#/B $"
-7$("#>
`Q.$-F9 )XCNB )DJa
*+(& (& 3.%7(&%21 $+% 7"#7%3$F-2 $F.#&$(2% -$ 8".T> O+-$ H%/(#& -& - 3-&&('% ".
3%&&(6(&$(7 #(+(2(&6 (& 9.('%# H1 $+% (#$%#&($1 "0 9%&3-(. $" H%7"6% -7$('%>)I
O+-$ +-33%#& $" 7"2"&&-2 HF$ #%'%.$+%2%&& .%3F$%921 9%0(#($('% $%.6& (& 3."7%&& "0 7"#$(#F-2 .-9(7-2 7"#'%.&("#> Q.$-F9 $-T%& $+% &(#/2% $%.6 52(0%;B
0". %V-632%B $" 6%-# H"$+ &"6%$+(#/ 8+(7+ +% %V$"2&B -#9 &"6%$+(#/
8+(7+ +% 9%$%&$& ". 7-.%& #"$+(#/ -H"F$> *+% 6%-#(#/ "0 52(0%; $+-$ +% H"-&$&
(& +(& "8#B 8+(2% $+% 6%-#(#/ +% 7.($(7(&%& -.(&%& 0."6 -# -22 $"" 7"66"#
"3(#("#> *+% $.(7T "0 $+% $F.#&$(2% (& $+-$ (# 8.($(#/ -H"F$ 52(0%;B 53"8%.;B
5&F00%.(#/;B -#9 5R"1;B Q.$-F9 9"%& #"$ -28-1& 6-T% %V32(7($ 8+(7+ 7"#7%3S
$("# "0 %-7+ $%.6 +% -.% .%0%..(#/ $"B +(& ". $+% 7"66"# "#%> *+% (#9%$%.S
6(#-71 "0 Q.$-F9;& 7"#7%3$("# "0 2(0% (& (#7.%-&%9 H1 +(& 72-(6 $+-$ 52(0%; (&
6"'%6%#$ .-$+%. $+-# 6-$$%. -#9 ($& 0".6&> 5O+%# 8% &3%-T -H"F$ 52(0%;B ($
6F&$ H% F#9%.&$""9 $+-$ 8% -.% #"$ .%0%..(#/ $" 2(0% -& 8% T#"8 ($ 0."6 ($&
&F.0-7% "0 0-7$ HF$ $" $+-$ 0.-/(2%B 02F7$F-$(#/ 7%#$%. 8+(7+ 0".6& #%'%. .%-7+;
`Q.$-F9 )XNJB )@a> *+% 0".62%&& 02(7T%.(#/ "0 $+% 6-# HF.#(#/ -$ $+% &$-T% (&
$+% %V3.%&&("# "0 $+-$ 8+(7+ $.-9($("#-2 -#9 -#-21$(7-2 3+(2"&"3+1B $+%
&7(%#7%& -#9 3&17+"2"/1B 7-22 &%'%.-221B $+% (63"&&(H2%B $+% 1%$ $" H% 7-27FS
2-$%9 -#9 $+% -3".%$(7 &163$"6>
Q/-(#&$ $+% .%9F7$("#(&6 "0 -#-21$(7-2 3"&($('(&6B Q.$-F9 (#&(&$& $+-$ 2(0% (&
#"$ .%2-$('% HF$ -H&"2F$%> *" Q.$-F9B -77%3$(#/ $+% 0".62%&&#%&& "0 2(0% (& $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<<D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
"#21 8-1 "0 6-T(#/ ($ H%-.-H2%> *+(& 9"%& #"$ 6%-#B +"8%'%.B $+-$ "#% 7-#
&(6321 7+""&% $" 2('%B $+-$ H1 0"22"8(#/ $+% 3.-1%.& -#9 &2"/-#& $+-$ 3.-(&%
2(0%;& 8".$+B "#% (& $+%.%0".% 2('(#/> Y# $%.6& "0 7"#$%63".-.1 3&17+"2"/1B
Q.$-F9;& 8.($(#/& 8"F29 &%%6 $" -9'"7-$% - 5o%&; $+-$ 9(00%.& '("2%#$21 0."6
$+% 5o%&; &+"F$%9 H1 $+% 2(H%.-2 (9%"2"/1 "0 $+% &%20S6-9% 6-# -#9 +(& 6".-2
.(/+$ $" %-.# 6"#%1> O+-$ $+% 7"#7%3$F-2 $F.#&$(2% .%'%-2& (& - /%#%.-2
0-(2F.% $" 9.-8 - 9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# $+% &32%#9"F. "0 52(0%; -& 6-$%.(-2 -#9
$+%.%0".% -77(9%#$-221 0F22 "0 &F00%.(#/ `+%#7% - o%&a -#9 52(0%; -& 6%-#(#/0F2
". 8".$+8+(2% "#21 8+%# ($ 7-# H% 7-2(H.-$%9 -/-(#&$ $+% &F.%$1 "0 $+%
3."6(&%9 0(.6-6%#$B `+%#7% $+% o%&a> *+% !+.(&$(-# +F6-#(&$ 0(#9& 2(0% "#
%-.$+ $"2%.-H2% "#21 H%7-F&% H%$$%. -#9 +(/+%. $+(#/& -.% -$ &$-T%> Y# 5Y M-$%
-#9 G%#"F#7% -& - !"8-.9;B Q.$-F9 8.($%&B 5Y +-$% -#9 .%#"F#7% -& - 7"8-.9
%'%.1 H%(#/ 8+" (& "#21 8(22(#/ $" H% 0". H%(#/;& &-T% -#9 9"%& #"$ 8-#$ $"
2('% $" 8".T; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB <<<a>)) *+"&% 8+" 8(22 $+%6&%2'%& $" H%B -.%
&(6321 -8-($(#/ +%-'%# ". &"6% .-.% 6"6%#$ "0 -# %-.$+21 0F20(226%#$ "0
(9%-2 0".6&>
*+% $F.#&$(2% .%'%-2& $+-$ ($ (& #"$ $+% -00%7$("#& F3"# ($B &F7+ -& &F00%.(#/
-#9 +-$.%9B $+-$ $+.%-$%# 52(0%;B #". (& ($ $+% "HR%7$& 8($+ 8+"6 Q.$-F9 (& (#
+"&$(2% "33"&($("#> O+-$ $+.%-$%#& 52(0%; (& $+% F&% "0 $+%&% 0%%2(#/& $" 0"F#9
- 6".-2 &1&$%6 "0 $+"F/+$4 - 3"2($(7-2B 2%/-2B 3%9-/"/(7B 0-6(2(-2 -#9 $+%"2"S
/(7-2 &1&$%6 "0 $+"F/+$B 8+(7+ T(22& 2(0% H1 9(7$-$(#/ $+% 2(6($& -$ 8+(7+ ($
7-# H% 2('%9> Q2$+"F/+ Q.$-F9 -&&-F2$& &3%7(0(7 (#9('(9F-2&B /%#%.-2 7+-.-7$%.
$13%&B $+% +F6-# .-7% h %&3%7(-221 $+% L77(9%#$-2 h -#9 0(#-221B ^"9B $+%
0"7F& "0 +(& 0F.("F& -$$-7T (& %V32(7($21 6-#;& &1&$%6 "0 3.(".($(&-$("#> 5Q#9
0(#-221 2-&$ #(/+$ ] -$ $+% #%8 Q$+%#& ] $+% /.%-$ .%'%2-$("# 7"#7%.#(#/ $+%
8+"2% &1&$%6 "0 0".6(#/ ] /"9 (# $+% &2(6%1 %//8+($% "0 61 2%0$ H-22 ] -0$%.
$+% .%'%2-$("# "0 $+% -#$(7+.(&$ -H1&&; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB )??a> [%&3($% =(%$A&7+%;&
9%72-.-$("# "0 $+% 9%-$+ "0 ^"9B $+% $+%"2"/(7-2 &1&$%6 .%6-(#& 3%.'%.&%21
-2('% (# Q.$-F9B +%#7% $+% &3%7(0(7($1 -#9 $+% $-89.(#%&& "0 561 2%0$ H-22;>)<
*+% $%#-7($1 "0 5^"9 $+% QH&"2F$%; (& 7"#0(.6%9 H1 $+% -H&F.9($1 "0 +(&
.%02%7$("# ". H2F%3.(#$ (# $+% 6"#-9(7 &(#/F2-.($1 "0 Q.$-F9;& 2%0$ $%&$(72%>
Q.$-F9 3"&($("#(#/ "0 ^"9 (# +(& $%&$(72% -$$%&$& $" -# F#-33%-&-H2%B "#$"2"S
/(7-2 9(&-/.%%6%#$ 8($+ $+% &1&$%6 $+-$ 3.(".($(&%& /"9 -& - 9%6"#&$.-H2% $(%.
"0 $+% P2-$"#(7 &1&$%6 "0 (9%-2 0".6& /"'%.#(#/ $+% %V(&$%#7% "0 3"&($('%
%V3%.(%#7%& "0 $+% 8".29>
EN
Y# 7"#$.-9(&$(#7$("# $" $+% (9%- "0 - 6-$%.(-2($1 "0 $+% 8".29 /."F#9%9
%V72F&('%21 (# $+% 3+1&(7-2B Q.$-F9;& #"$("# "0 - $+%-$.% "0 7.F%2$1 3"&($("#&
$+% 6-$%.(-2 7.F%2$1 "0 $.-/%91 (# $+% 6(#9 -#9 #"$ RF&$ (# $+% Z2""9 "# $+%
&$-/%> 5*+%.% (& #" 7.F%2$1 8($+"F$ 7"#&7("F&#%&& -#9 8($+"F$ $+% -332(7-S
$("# "0 7"#&7("F&#%&&; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB )I)a> Q.$-F9 %V32-(#& $+-$ +(& #"$("# "0
7.F%2$1 (& #"$ 7.%-$%9 H1 $+% F&% "0 3+1&(7-2 0".7% &" 6F7+ -& H1 - &$.(7$ -#9
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
(9#'$)*&$ B94$ <<J
#%7%&&-.1 9%$%.6(#(#/ "0 $+(#/&> *+(& (& #"$ $" &-1 $+-$ 7.F%2$1 (& $+% 2"/(7-2
#-6(#/ "0 $+% 8".29 (# ".9%. $" +-'% ($ 6-T% &%#&%> !.F%2$1 (& 2%&& 7"#$."22%9 %#$%.3.(&% -#9 6".% -# (#%2F7$-H2% H%7"6(#/ "0 $+(#/&4 5*+%&%
6"#&$%.& -.% 8(7T%9 -& "#21 H2(#9 0".7%& 7-# H%B -#9 $+% $+%-$%. %V(&$&B Y
$+(#TB "#21 "# - 2%'%2 $+-$ (& #"$ 1%$ +F6-#; `Q.$-F9 )XCNB @ICa> Q.$-F9;&
(9%- "0 $+%-$.% (& (#$%.%&$%9 (# $+% _F-2($(%& "0 3"8%. .-$+%. $+-# ($& &"S7-22%9
+"29%.&> Y0 $+%&% _F-2($(%& -.% 6"#&$."F&B ($ (& H%7-F&% $+%1 -.% 9(&(#$%.%&$%9B
R"10F2 -#9 .F9% F#2(T% $+% 3%&&(6(&6 "0 +F6-#($1 8+(7+ (& 6(&%.-H21 -0.-(9
"0 $+%6> *+-$ $+%&% 6"#&$%.& -.% H2(#9 (& $%&$-6%#$ $" $+% 9(&(#/%#F"F&
7+-.-7$%. "0 $+% +F6-#(&$ #"$("# "0 7+"(7% -#9 ($& &"2(3&(&$(7 9%72-.-$("# "0
&%20S7"#$."24
*.F% 7F2$F.% +-& #%'%. +-9 - #-$('% 2-#9B ($ (& #"$ +F6-# HF$ &3(.S
($F-2 > > > $+%.% (& #" 2%/-71 $" H% 9%0%#9%9 > > > $.F% 7F2$F.% 8"F29 #"$ 7%-&%
$" &F.'('% $+% 9(&-33%-.-#7% "0 -22 $+%&% 0".6&B -22 $+%&% 3%$.(0(%9 &(/#&> > > >
*.F% 7F2$F.% +-& #%'%. H%%# H"F#9 F3 8($+ $+% 3.%&%.'-$("# "0 (#9('(9F-2
0.%%9"6B -#9 (# 61 "3(#("# ($ (& /.%-$21 F#9%.%&$(6-$(#/ 7F2$F.% $"
H%2(%'% $+-$ ($ (& 8%-T%#%9 H1 $+% 2"&& "0 - 0%8 6%# ". $+% 9%&$.F7$("#
"0 - 0%8 8.($(#/&;>
`Q.$-F9 )XCNB @DNa
*+% (632(7-$("#& "0 Q.$-F9;& $+%".1 "0 (63."'(#/ +F6-#($1 $+."F/+ -##(S
+(2-$("# -.% #"$ &(6321 +"6(7(9-2 ". 02(33-#$ ". H"$+> Q.$-F9;& 9%&(.% 0". $+%
-##(+(2-$("# "0 F&%2%&& 7F2$F.-2 0(/F.%& -#9 $+%(. 8".T& (& 6".% &%.("F&21 3."3"&-2 0". - 6%$-3+1&(7-2 .%'"2F$("#>
Q.$-F9;& .%'"2F$("# 9(00%.& .-9(7-221 0."6 $+% (9%- "0 $+% 7"66F#(&$ .%S
'"2F$("# H%2"#/(#/ $" +(& %-.21 &F..%-2(&$ 7"22%-/F%&> Q.$-F9;& .%'"2F$("#
72-(6& $+-$ ($ 8(22 .%'($-2(&% - 7F2$F.% $" $+% 3"(#$ 8+%.% /F#& -#9 32-#%&
8(22 H% F&%2%&& -/-(#&$ ($> Q.$-F9;& .%'"2F$("# F&%& $+% 7"#7%3$F-2 $F.#&$(2%
8+(7+ &%%& $+-$ 52(0%; (& %V(&$(#/ -2"#/&(9% $+% 6(#9B 8+(2% 5$+% +F6-# H%(#/
(& (#&(9% $+% 7(.72% $+(& 6(#9 $F.#& "#B -#9 R"(#%9 $" ($ H1 - 6F2$($F9% "0
0(H%.&; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB DJa> Z%7-F&% Q.$-F9 7-##"$ 7"#7%('% "0 8".T -& &%3-.-$%
0."6 2(0%B +% 8"#9%.& (0 &F..%-2(&6 9(9 #"$ 9(% 5"# $+% 9-1 8+%# Z.%$"# -#9
+(& -9%3$& 9%7(9%9 $" R"(# $+% !"66F#(&$ 6"'%6%#$ -#9 $" &%%T (# $+%
.%-26 "0 0-7$& -#9 "0 (66%9(-$% 6-$$%. $+% 7F26(#-$("# "0 -# -7$("# $+-$
7"F29 #".6-221 9%'%2"3 "#21 8($+(# $+% (#6"&$ 7"#0(#%& "0 $+% H.-(#;
`Q.$-F9 )XCNB )@Xa> *+% 6%#$-2 .%'"2F$("# "0 $+% H.-(# (& #"$ %V$%.#-2 $"
$+% 6-$%.(-2 .%'"2F$("# "0 6(#94 -& $+% 6(#9]H.-(# 7+-#/%&B &" $+% 8".29
7+-#/%&> 5W". %-7+ 6-# $" .%0F&% $" 7"#&(9%. -#1$+(#/ H%1"#9 +(& "8#
9%%3%&$ &%#&(H(2($1B H%1"#9 +(& (#6"&$ &%20B $+(& 0". 6% (& $+% 3"(#$ "0 '(%8
"0 $+% 7"632%$% G%'"2F$("#; `Q.$-F9 )XCNB )DIa> Q.$-F9 .%/-.9& - .%'"2F$("#
$+-$ $.(%& $" (63."'% 6-$%.(-2 &$-$%& "0 -00-(.& $+."F/+ - 7"8-.921 -'"(9-#7%
"0 &F00%.(#/B -& "29 0-&+("#%9> Q22 $+-$ 8(22 %#&F% 0."6 $+(& $13% "0 (#&F./%#71
(& - .%S%#-7$6%#$ "0 $+% 6"&$ .%9F7$('% -&3%7$& "0 $+% 3."/.%&&('% U#2(/+$%#S
6%#$ 3."R%7$B ($& .%0".6(&6 -#9 ($& 0F#9-6%#$-2 &F&3(7("# "0 6%$-3+1&(7&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<<N !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
*+% 5(#6"&$ &%20; .%0%.& $" $+% $+(#T(#/ &%20 "0 $+% 6(#9 (# 7"#$.-9(&$(#7$("#
$" $+% H%(#/ &%20 "0 -# U#2(/+$%#6%#$ (#$%.(".($1 ". $+% H%(#/ &%20 "0 3&17+"-#-21$(7 F#7"#&7("F&> Q.$-F9 0"22"8& +(& +-$.%9 -#9 .%#F#7(-$("# "0
5%'%.1 H%(#/ 8+" (& "#21 8(22(#/ $" H% 0". H%(#/;& &-T%; 8($+ 5Y;9 .-$+%. 8".T
$+-# 0%%2 61&%20 -2('%; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB <<<a> *+% (#6"&$ &%20 (& 8+%.% -# %00".$
$"8-.9& - 6%#$-2 (#$F($("# $-T%& 32-7%> Y#$F($("# (& $+-$ 8+(7+ 9"%& #"$
&%3-.-$% -# (##%. &%20 0."6 -# "F$%. &%20 #". -# (##%. &%20 0."6 -#"$+%. &%20
8+(7+ 6(/+$ "H&%.'% ($>)@ Y#$F($("# (& /('%# (63".$-#7% "#21 .-.%21 H%7-F&%
($ 2(%& H%1"#9 $+% (22F&".1 7+"(7%& 6-9% H1 $+% (#$%22%7$B +%#7% Q.$-F9;&
%63+-&(& "# 8".TB "# $+% 6%#$-2 8".T #%%9%9 (# ".9%. $" $+(#T(#/ (#$F($S
('%21>
*+% (22F&("# "0 $+% 7+"(7% "0 H%(#/ -#9 $+% /.%-$#%&& "0 $+% &F00%.(#/ "0
H%(#/ -.% (22F&$.-$%9 (# Q.$-F9;& 72-(6 $+-$ +% 7+""&%& +(& "8# &F00%.(#/>
Q.$-F9 7"#$%#9&B 0". (#&$-#7%B $+-$ ($ (& $+% 9.%-9 "0 $+% 0%'%. $+-$ "#% "F/+$
$" 2"'%>
Y +-'% H%%# &(7T -22 61 2(0% -#9 Y "#21 -&T $+-$ ($ 7"#$(#F%B ] .""6 6"$$"B
(>%>B ] 0". $+% &$-$%& "0 3.('-$("# (# 2(0% +-'% -28-1& $"29 6% - /.%-$ 9%-2
6".% -H"F$ $+% 32%$+".- "0 61 3"8%.& $+-# $+% 6(992%S72-&& 9.-8(#/ h Q,
KL=^ Q, oL\;fU ^L* oL\G MUQK*M>
`Q.$-F9 )XNJB )X<a
*" -77%3$ &F00%.(#/ (& #"$ $" 7%-&% $" 0(/+$ #". $" /('% F3 "# .%7"/#(&(#/ "#%;&
%#%6(%&> Q.$-F9 72-(6& $+-$ H1 -77%3$(#/ &F00%.(#/B +% (& &(6F2$-#%"F&21
8(22(#/ &F00%.(#/> 5Y +-'% 7+"&%# $+% 9"6-(# "0 &".."8 -#9 &+-9"8 -& "$+%.&
+-'% 7+"&%# $+-$ "0 $+% /2"8 -#9 $+% -77F6F2-$("# "0 $+(#/&; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB
DCa> ^('%# $+-$ Q.$-F9 3-1& 2($$2% +%%9 $" $+% (9%"2"/1 "0 6-#;& 50.%%9"6 "0
7+"(7%;B +(& #"$("# "0 7+""&(#/ &F00%.(#/ 7-# "#21 6%-#B $" -77%3$ &F00%.(#/>
Q77%3$-#7% (& -T(# $" 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% .%0%.& $" -& 95") 29#*>)D *+% %63+-&(&
"# 7+"(7% .%_F(.%& $+-$ "#% -7$ -& (0 "#% +-& 7+"&%#> Q7$(#/ -& (0 -00(.6& #"$
"#21 8+-$ +-33%#& HF$ -2&" "#%;& (#&%3-.-H(2($1 0."6 ($> Q# -77%3$-#7% "0
"#%;& 32-7% (# $+% 8".29 7"#0".6& $" -# %&3"F&-2 "0 8+-$ =(%$A&7+% -2&" 7-22&
5GF&&(-# 0-$-2(&6;>
Y#&"0-. -& Q.$-F9 (& - GF&&(-# 0-$-2(&$ +% (& -2&" - 8+(#%.> M% .-22(%& '(7("F&21
-/-(#&$ %'%.1$+(#/ $+-$ +-& -#9 +-& #"$ H%%# 9"#% $" +(6B '-.("F&21 -#9
#F6%."F&21B H1 (#($(-$%& "0 &%7.%$ &%7$&B H1 3&17+(-$.(&$&B H1 -96(#(&$.-$".& "0
$+% -.$& -#9 7F2$F.%B H1 ^"9 -#9 H1 +(& -F9(%#7%> Y# $%.6& "0 +-$.%9 "0 $+%
%&$-H2(&+6%#$ -#9 $+%.%0".% "0 $+% 8".29 -#9 %'%.1"#% (# ($B $+% '-.("F&
0(%29& -#9 3%.&"#& "0 $+% %&$-H2(&+6%#$ -22 6%29 (#$" - &(#/2% -F$+".($-.(-#B
3."/.%&&('% -#9 (#$%.0%.(#/ (#&$($F$("#> Z%7-F&% +% 6F&$ 52('%; (# $+% 8".29B
Q.$-F9 T#"8& "0 8+-$ +% &F00%.&B 8+1 +% &F00%.& -#9 +"8 +% &F00%.&> Q77".9S
(#/ $" G"#-29 M-16-#B 8+%# Q.$-F9 H%//%9 0". 6"#%1 +% 8"F29 -77"&$
3-&&%.& H1 8($+B 5E"#&(%F.B $+% 8".29 +-& 9"#% 6% 6F7+ +-.6> o"F -.% 3-.$
"0 $+% 8".29B &" 1"F +-'% +-.6%9 6%> P2%-&% /('% 6% 0('% 0.-#7&; `M-16-#
)XCCB )a> Q.$-F9 (& '%+%6%#$21 "33"&%9 $" H"$+ +(& 7"#9($("# -#9 +(&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
(9#'$)*&$ B94$ <<C
&($F-$("# H%7-F&% +% T#"8& $+%&% -.% (#&%3-.-H2% 0."6 $+% .%&$ "0 $+% 8".29
-#9 %'%.1"#% (# ($> Q#9 1%$ +% -2&" %6H.-7%& +(& 6-9#%&& -#9 &F00%.(#/
H%7-F&% +% 0%%2& +-& &"6%$+(#/ %V$.-".9(#-.1 $" &-1>
Y# "#% "0 +(& 2-&$ 3%.0".6-#7%& (# )XDCB Q.$-F9 (#$%#9%9 $" 9%&7.(H% $+%
H-.H-.($1 +% +-9 &F00%.%9 &(#7% +(& -..%&$ (# )X@C -#9 $" -77F&% $+"&% F#9%.
8+"6 +% +-9 &F00%.%9 9F.(#/ $+% -26"&$ #(#% &FH&%_F%#$ 1%-.& +% &3%#$ (#
d 6" 9.%8 "'%. XII &3%7S
-&12F6&> *+% %'%#$ *+% ,$".1 K('%9 H1 Q.$-F9SE"
$-$".& (#72F9(#/ 6-#1 "0 +(& 0.(%#9&> *+% 3%.0".6-#7% (#72F9%9 3"%$.1B
&7.%-6&B /%&$F.%&B -HF&%& -#9 (#'%#$%9 8".9&> QH"'% -22 %2&% 8+-$ $+(&
%'%#$ &+"8%9 Q.$-F9 -#9 +(& -F9(%#7% (& $+-$ -#1 -33.%+%#&("# "0 8+-$
+% 8-& &-1(#/ 8-& 9""6%9 $" 0-(2F.%> Q.$-F9 0"22"8& F3 -# (6-/% "0 /"9 -#9
+(& 3.-#T& -/-(#&$ $+% 3"%$ Q.$-F9 -#9 $+% 5H-22& (# +(& 7F#$; 8($+B
Q#9 (0 1"F 9"#;$ /%$ $+% (6-/%B
-#9 $+-$;& 8+-$ Y +%-. 1"F &-1(#/
(# - 7(.72%B
$+-$ 1"F 9"#;$ /%$ $+% (6-/%
8+(7+ (& -$ $+% H"$$"6
"0 61 7F#$ +"2%B h
($;& H%7-F&% 1"F 9"#;$ T#"8 $+% H"$$"6B
#"$ "0 $+(#/&B
HF$ "0 61 7F#$B
6(#%B
-2$+"F/+ &(#7% $+% H"$$"6 "0 $+% -/%&
1"F;'% H%%# 2-33(#/ $+%.% (# - 7(.72%
-& (0 H-96"F$+(#/ -# -2(%#-/%B
32"$$(#/ -# (#7-.7%.-$("# $" 9%-$+
`)XXJB XXh)I)a>
d 6" 8%.% 6(V%94 &"6% &-(9 ($
*+% .%'(%8& "0 *+% ,$".1 K('%9 H1 Q.$-F9SE"
8-& 2($%.-221 -#9 0(/F.-$('%21 - &$F##(#/ 3%.0".6-#7% 8+(2% "$+%.& &-8 ($ -&
1%$ -#"$+%. -$$%63$ H1 Q.$-F9 $" &+"7T +(& -F9(%#7% 8($+ - 7+(29(&+ 2-7T "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<<? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
&FH$2%$1 `Z-.H%. )XX@B )@NhXa> ,+".$21 -0$%. $+% 3%.0".6-#7%B Q.$-F9 7"6S
32-(#%9 (# - 2%$$%. $" Q#9.%e Z.%$"# -H"F$ $+% 2-7T "0 (63-7$ +% +-& 6-9%> M%
8-#$%9 $" -H-#9"# $+% $+%-$.% H%7-F&%B 5$+% "#21 2-#/F-/% 8+(7+ Y 7"F29
+-'% 8($+ -# -F9(%#7% 8-& $" H.(#/ H"6H& "F$ "0 61 3"7T%$& -#9 $+."8
$+%6 (# $+% -F9(%#7%;& 0-7% 8($+ - H2-$-#$ /%&$F.% "0 -//.%&&("#; `Z-.H%.
)XX@B )@Xa> Y# -#"$+%. 2%$$%. $" Z.%$"# +% 8."$%B 5rHs%&(9%& /-$+%.(#/ 3%"32%
$"/%$+%. (# - .""6B ($ .%6-(#& 0". 6% $" +F.2 -HF&% -$ $+(& &"7(%$1 (# $+%
&$.%%$ > > >; `Z-.H%. )XX@B )@?a> L#% &F7+ "77-&("# "0 - '("2%#$ 3FH2(7 &3%7$-72%
+-33%#%9 (# Y.%2-#9 (# )X@C 8+%# Q.$-F9 8-& 9%3".$%9 H-7T $" W.-#7% -#9
(#7-.7%.-$%9 (# $+% 0(.&$ "0 - #F6H%. "0 3&17+(-$.(7 (#&$($F$("#& 0". H.-#9(&+S
(#/ - &-7.%9 &8".9 -&&"7(-$%9 8($+ ,-(#$ P-$.(7TB -#9 &+"F$(#/ -H"F$ ($ $"
3-&&%.& H1>)J
N
Q77".9(#/ $" P-F2 Q.#"29B 5"F. -'-#$S/-.9% +-& 2%-.#%9 0."6 Q.$-F9 "#21 +(&
'%+%6%#7%B +(& &7-#9-2"F& -&3%7$ h 02(#/(#/ H(2% -#9 %V7.%6%#$ -$ -22 (#&$(S
$F$("#&B H%2(%0&B (9%-&B 0%%2(#/&B 8($+"F$ +-'(#/ -#1 &FH&$($F$% (9%- ". 0%%2(#/
$" "00%. F&; `Q.#"29 )X <?a> *" Q.#"29B Q.$-F9 6-9% - +F/% 53+(2"&"3+(7-2
%..".; (# $.1(#/ $" $F.# $+% -H&$.-7$B +(& (9%- "0 - 6-/(7-2 &3+%.% "0 -00%7$("#&
(# %V3.%&&("#B (#$" $+% 7"#7.%$%B -# %00(7-7("F& %'%#$ (# $+% $+%-$.% 8+(7+
8"F29 -00%7$ H"$+ $+% -7$".& -#9 $+% -F9(%#7% '("2%#$21 -#9 8($+ - T(#9 "0
7"#$-/("F& _F-2($1 "0 9%2(.(F6> O+(2% Q.#"29 6-1 H% .(/+$ (# %V3.%&&(#/ $+%
0.F&$.-$("# "0 0(#9(#/ $+-$ Q.$-F9;& (9%-& +-'% #"$ H%%# &F77%&&0F221 .%#9%.%9
H1 $+% 6-#1 8+" .%-9 +(6B &F7+ -# 5-$$($F9%; 9%2(6($& -#1 0F.$+%. 8".T>
O+-$ (& (# _F%&$("# (& #"$ $+% /F20 H%$8%%# 8+-$ Q.$-F9 (#$%#9& $" &-1 -#9
8+-$ Q.#"29 $+(#T& +% 0-(2& $" &-1 &(#7% $+%.% (& #" 32-7% 8+%.% "#% 7-# -..%&$
-#9 (#'%&$(/-$%> O+-$ #%%9& $" H% -&T%9 (& 8+-$ +-33%#& $" 8+-$ +% 9"%&
&-1i k-#% ^""9-22 3"(#$& "F$ $+-$4
Q.$-F9;& 7F..%#71 (# $+% 6-R". 9%H-$%& "0 3"&$ &$.F7$F.-2(&6 +-& $" 9"
8($+ $+% 8-1& (# 8+(7+ +% &%.'%& -& - 0"7F& 0". 6-#1 "0 $+%(. 3.%"77F3-S
$("#&4 -2$%.($1B $+% %V7+-#/% "0 3.%&%#7% 0". -H&%#7%B $+% 9%6(&% "0 7"#S
&$($F$%9 &FHR%7$('($1B $+% .(0$ H%$8%%# $+% .%-2 -#9 $+% &16H"2(7B $+%
.%9(&7"'%.1 "0 $+% H"91B $+% 3"$%#71 "0 - 9(&7"F.&% 9.('(#/ (#$" %V7%&&
-#9 &%6("$(7 -#-.7+1>
`^""9-22 )XXDB <)?a
*+%.% (& - /""9 $+(.$1 1%-.& H%$8%%# $+% $(6% "0 Q.#"29;& %&&-1B 8.($$%# (#
$+% %-.21 &(V$(%& 8+%# %V3%.(6%#$-2 $+%-$.% /."F3& 8%.% -$$%63$(#/ $" %#-7$B
F#&F77%&&0F221 ($ &%%6&B Q.$-F9;& 9.-6-$(7 $+%".(%&B -#9 $+% $(6% "0 ^""9S
-22;& (#&(/+$0F2 &F66-.1 "0 - 3"&$ &$.F7$F.-2 -9"3$("# "0 Q.$-F9 0". -#1 -#9
-22 "0 $+%(. 7"#7%.#&> K""T(#/ -7."&& $+"&% $+(.$1 1%-.& 0."6 $+% 0(.&$ 8-'% "0
%V7($%6%#$ $"8-.9& Q.$-F9 &(#7% +(& 9%-$+ -#9 $+%# $" $+% (#-9%_F-$% &%20S
.%'%-2(#/ -/%#9- "0 $+% 3"&$ &$.F7$F.-2(&$&B "#% /%$& $+% 0%%2(#/ $+-$ (# %00%7$
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
(9#'$)*&$ B94$ <<X
'%.1 2($$2% .%-9(#/ "0 Q.$-F9 +-& H%%# 9"#%> *+% 57"#9($("#& "0 6"9%.#($1;B
0". 8-#$ "0 - H%$$%. 3+.-&%B $+-$ &+-3%9 Q.$-F9 -#9 +(& (9%-& -H"F$ 9%&$(#1B
/%#(F&B 6-9#%&& -#9 .F9%#%&&B +-'% #"$ 2%0$ +(6 #". "F. .%-9(#/ "0 +(6> Y0 ($
(& $.F%B -& Q.#"29 72-(6&B $+-$ Q.$-F9 +-& 2%0$ F& #" &FH&$($F$% 0%%2(#/ ". (9%"$+%. $+-# +(& -#/%.B $8" '($-2 _F%&$("#& 6F&$ H% -99.%&&%9> W(.&$B 8+1
&+"F29 Q.$-F9 "00%. F& - &FH&$($F$% (9%- 8+%# ($ (& F&B +(& .%-9%.& -#9 +(&
7.($(7&B 8+" 6F&$ H% &FH&$($F$%9i ,%7"#9B (0 Q.$-F9 +-& 2%0$ F& 8($+ "#21 $+%
.F9%#%&& "0 +(& '"7-2(7 H(2%B 8+1 9"%& +(& 3"3F2-.($1 7"#$(#F%i P%.+-3& ($ (&
H%7-F&% "0B .-$+%. $+-# (# &3($% "0B $+% 7"#'"2F$%9 6"'%6%#$& Q.$-F9 6-T%&
$+."F/+ 6-9#%&& -#9 /%#(F& $"8-.9& .F9%#%&&i Y# "$+%. 8".9&B $+% 3."H2%6
(& #"$ Q.$-F9;& .F9%#%&& HF$ "F. .%-9(#/ "0 ($>
Q.$-F9;& .F9%#%&& $"8-.9& -F9(%#7%& -#9 $+% 3FH2(7 (# /%#%.-2 (#'"2'%& 0.F&$.-$(#/ 2-7T "0 &163-$+1 ". 9%0(7($ "0 0%%2(#/ H%$8%%# $+% -99.%&&%. -#9
$+% -99.%&&%9> *+(& 2-7T 6-#(0%&$& ($&%20 -& $+% "3-7($1 "0 Q.$-F9;& %V32-#-S
$("#& -#9 $+%".(%& 8+(7+ -.% &-(9 $" 6-T% 0". -.9F"F& .%-9(#/> Y# +%.
(#$."9F7$("# $" $+% A$4$/#$. P)*#*&?%B ,F&-# ,"#$-/ -22F9%& $" - 0F#9-6%#S
$-2 9(00(7F2$1 (# .%-9(#/ Q.$-F9 8+" H%7"6%& "'%.3"8%.(#/ (0 .%-9 $"" 6F7+
8+(7+ (& 8+1 &+% &F//%&$& $+-$ Q.$-F9 (& (63"&&(H2% $" .%-9 H%1"#9 - 0%8
7-$7+1 _F"$%& -#9 (9%-& `,"#$-/ )XCNB 2(Va> Q77".9(#/ $" U.(7 ,%22(#B "$+%.
.%-9%.& 0(#9 - 5$+.%&+"29 (# $+% 9%'%2"36%#$ "0 Q.$-F9;& 7"#7%3$& H%1"#9
8+(7+ $+% (9%-& H%7"6% .-.(0(%9; `,%22(# )XN?B )I)a>)N O+(2% 0.F&$.-$(#/ $"
3"&($('(&$&B 8.($%& ,%22(#B 8+" 9(&2(T% $+% '-#(&+(#/ "0 Q.$-F9;& (9%-& $+%
72"&%. "#% /%$& $" $+%6B &"6% 0(#9 +(& (#7-#9%&7%#$ 7"#7%3$& "3-_F%
%#"F/+ $" H%7"6% $+% '%.1 /."F#9 "0 - /%#%."F& (#&3(.-$("#>
*+% (9%- $+-$ Q.$-F9 (& %#/F20%9 (# '-/F% (9%-& 8+(7+ -33%-. $" &%.'% 2($$2%
3F.3"&% (& $+% 3"(#$ F3"# 8+(7+ +(& .%-9%.& 9('(9%> Y$ (& -2&" $+% 3"(#$ -$
8+(7+ Q.$-F9;& .F9%#%&& H%7"6%& 2%&& "'%.$ -#9 6".% 6%#-7(#/> Q.$-F9;&
3%.("9(7 HF$ .%7F..%#$ 3"3F2-.($1 7%.$-(#21 (632(%& -# +(&$".(7-2 7F.("&($1 -#9
%#&F.%& - 0-&7(#-$("# 8($+ H"$+ +(& (#&-#% -#9 +(& -#/.1 6-9#%&& HF$ ($ (& +(&
.F9%#%&&B -2"#/ 8($+ ($& +F6"F.B 7"#$.-9(7$("# -#9 2F7(9($1 $+-$ 9(&.F3$&
&F33"&%921 F#7"632(7-$%9 6-$$%.& "0 .%-9(#/> O+1 (& Q.$-F9 +-.9 $" .%-9i
,"#$-/ &F//%&$& $+-$ ,-9%B O(2+%26 G%(7+ -#9 Q.$-F9 -.% (# &"6% &%#&%
5(#$.(#&(7-221 F#.%-9-H2%; H%7-F&% $+% #-$F.% "0 $+%(. 8".T 6-1 H% H".(#/B
6".-221 6"#&$."F& ". 5$%..(H21 3-(#0F2 $" .%-9; `,"#$-/ )XCNB 2(Va> *+% 3."S
H2%6 8($+ .%-9(#/ Q.$-F9 #%%9& $" H% 9(.%7$%9 -8-1 0."6 $+% 9(00(7F2$1 "0
$+% 8".T $"8-.9& $+% 9(00(7F2$B (# "$+%. 8".9& "H$F&% -#9 #-.."8B 3."7%&& "0
.%-9(#/ ($&%20i Y0 Q.$-F9 &+"8& F& $+-$ #" "#% T#"8& +"8 $" H% .F9% 3."3%.21
-#16".%B 6".% (63".$-#$21B +% 9%6"#&$.-$%& $+-$ #" "#% T#"8& +"8 $"
.%-9> Y0 8% &F00%. -$ -22 0."6 .%-9(#/ Q.$-F9B -& ,"#$-/ &F//%&$&B (& ($ $+."F/+
"F. (#-H(2($1 $" .%-9 .F9%#%&& ". H%7-F&% "0 "F. &"7(-221 $-7($ (#-H(2($1 $"
-33.%7(-$% $+% .(/"F.& "0 H%(#/ .F9%i
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<@I !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
(9#'$)*&$ B94$ <@)
) *+% .%0".6-$("# -#9 .%2"7-$("# "0 -#/%. (& &3%7(0(7 $" %#9 "0 $+% 6(22%##(F6
7-3($-2(&$ 0%.'"F.> [%6"$%9 0."6 ($& %(/+$%%#$+ -#9 #(#%$%%#$+ 7%#$F.1 3"&($("#
-& - .%7T"#(#/ 0".7% "0 3"2($(7-2 /.(%'-#7%& -#9 3"$%#$(-2 0". &"7(-2 .%'"2F$("#B
-#/%. (& .%/F2-$%9 H1 - /2"H-2 6-.T%$ 8+(7+ 7-# "#21 7"#&(9%. -//.%&&("# -#9
.F9%#%&& H1 0(2$%.(#/ ($ $+."F/+ &7(%#$(0(7 F#9%.&$-#9(#/> Q2$+"F/+ ($ (& -H&F.9 $"
$.1 -#9 9%2(#%-$% $+% $8%#$(%$+S7%#$F.1 9%6(&% "0 -#/%.B $+%.% -.% 7%.$-(# 3+-&%&
8+%.%(# $+% F&% -#9 &$-$F& "0 -#/%. +-& F#9%./"#% &(/#(0(7-#$ 7+-#/%> Y# UF."3%
H%0".% O".29 O-. YB 9F.(#/ 8+-$ G"/%. ,+-$$F7T 7-22& 5$+% H-#_F%$ 1%-.&;B -#/%.
$+.%8 ($&%20 -$ $+% 0%%$ "0 6F2$(32% %3($+%$&4 9%&(.-H2%B 6"#&$."F&B -.$(&$(7B 0-&+("#S
-H2%B $+%-$.(7-2B FH(_F($"F& -#9 3.%9(7$-H2%> Y# $+% [-9-(&$ -#9 ,F..%-2(&$ 3%.("9&
H%$8%%# $+% $8" O".29 O-.&B -#/%. -$$.-7$%9 3"2($(7-2 -$$%#$("# -#9 02-F#$%9 ($&%20
-2"#/&(9% -#9 -&B -.$> Q#/%. 8-& &+"7T(#/ HF$ -2&" 2F9(7."F&21 0F##1B F#-'"(9-H2%
-#9 #%7%&&-.1> Q0$%. O".29 O-. YYB $+% &%-.7+ 0". &$-H(2($1 9%#"F#7%9 -#/%. 8+(7+
.%6(#9%9 ($ "0 8-.> Q#/%. .%$.%-$%9 (#$" $+% 0(0$(%& &FHF.H-# 32"$ -#9 $+% 0%6-2%
6-2-91 "0 9%3.%&&("# 8+"&% 3&17+(-$.(7 9%0(#($("# "0 5-#/%. $F.#%9 (#8-.9&; 8-&
$.%-$%9 8($+ "#% "0 &%'%.-2 6%6H%.& "0 $+% $.-#_F(2(A%. 0-6(21> *+% &(V$(%& 8-&
(#F#9-$%9 8($+ -#$(8-. 3."$%&$& -#9 7"#&7(%#$("F& "HR%7$".&B $+% "F$7"6% "0
8+(7+ 8-& $+% 7-.(7-$F.%9 +(33(%B &$(22 $+% HF$$ "0 $+% %7"#"6(7 R"T%> *+%.%B -#/%.
%#$%.$-(#& $+% 2(T%& "0 3&17+"$+%.-31B 3&17+(-$.1B 7.(6(#"2"/1B 0%6(#(&6B $+% 6%#;&
6"'%6%#$ -#9 $+% 6-#-/%6%#$ "0 +F6-# .%&"F.7%&> Q#$"#(" =%/.(;& 3."3"&-2
$+-$ $+% $8%#$(%$+S7%#$F.1 7-# H% 7+-.-7$%.(&%9 -& - 3%.("9 "0 $.-#&($("#B H%$8%%#
- #(#%$%%#$+S7%#$F.1 ."6-#$(7(&6 -#9 #"&$-2/(- -#9 - 0F$F.(&$ -(6 $"8-.9 $+% 1%-.
$8" $+"F&-#9B 3F$& $+(& 7%#$F.1;& H%/(##(#/& -$ $+% 5O-22 ,$.%%$ 7.-&+; "0 )X<X -#9
($& 7F26(#-$("# 8($+ (#$%.#-$("#-2 7-3($-2(&$ .%0".6(&6 `=%/.( )X?JB NDa> *+(&
%3"7+-2 .%7T"#(#/ (& -33"&($% $" $+% $8%#$(%$+S7%#$F.1;& .%'-2F-$("# -#9 $.-#&0".S
6-$("# "0 -#/%.> *+% 6".H(9 %'%#$& 8+(7+ 72-(6%9 $+% +(&$".(7-2 (6-/(#-.1 "0 )X<X
3."9F7%9 - 2%/-71 "0 %7"#"6(7 -#V(%$1B +%232%&&#%&& -#9 9%&3-(. -& 9%6"#&$.-$%9
H1 7-3($-2;& F$(2(&-$("# "0 -#/%. -& - $""2 0". ($& 3."0($ H-&%9 6".-2($1> \#7"#$."22%9
`5F#.%&"2'%9; ". 5%V7%&&('%;a -#/%. (& 2"7-$%9 8($+(# $+% &"S7-22%9 6-./(#-2 (9%#$($(%&
"0 #%F."$(7(&6B 9%3.%&&("# -#9 &F(7(9% 8+(2% &%20S7"#$."22%9 -#/%. +-& H%7"6% 2F7.-$('% 7"66"9($1 (9%#$(0(%9 8($+ $+% 5-//.%&&('% &%22; -#9 $+% #%7%&&($1 $" 59.('%
- +-.9 H-./-(#;> K"7-221B $+% O".T%.;& \#("# (& (#'($%9 $" $+% %632"1%.;& #%/"$(-$("#
$-H2% "#21 $" 8-$7+ $+%(. &"2(9-.($1 $F.# &-921 $" #"&$-2/(- -#9 $+%(. F#("#(&6
H%7"6% - &%.(%& "0 5(#9('(9F-2; -#9 9%.%/F2-$%9 7"#$.-7$&> Y#$%.#-$("#-221B $+% P.%S
&(9%#$ "0 $+% \#($%9 ,$-$%& 7+%%.& +(& 8-1 $+."F/+ - 8".29S8(9%S8-2T-H"F$ -.6%9
8($+ - 9(32"6-$(7 (66F#($1 $+-$ -22"8& +(6 $" 8-.#B $+.%-$%#B 3.-(&% -#9 7"#&"2%
8($+ $+% TF9"& "0 - M"2218""9 53%-7%6-T%.;> *+% 3%-7% 6-T%.;B (& $+% #-6% "0 .%7%#$ Q6%.(7-# 6"'(% &$-..(#/ =(7"2% b(96-# -#9 ^%"./% !2""#%1> *+% 2-$$%. (&
&F33"&%921 5$+% 3%-7% 6-T%.; HF$ H1 $+% %#9 "0 $+% 0(26 ($ H%7"6%& 72%-. $+-$ $+%
3%-7%6-T%. (& - 6F7+ H(//%. %#$%.3.(&%> 5*+% P%-7%6-T%.; (& Q6%.(7- ($&%20> kF&$(#
!2%6%#& &F//%&$%9 $" 6% $+-$ - 3%-7%6-T%. (& 0F22 "0 &-9#%&&> Y# .%2-$("# $"
3&17+"2"/1 -#9 8"6%#B &-9#%&& (& $+% 7"F#$%.S8(22 "0 -#/%.> *+% 72(#(7-2 9%0(#($("#
"0 $+(& T(#9 "0 &-9#%&& (& 9%3.%&&("# ". 5-#/%. $F.#%9 (#8-.9&;> Y0 5*+% P%-7%6-T%.; (&
#"$ !2""#%1 ". b(96-#B $+%# ($ (& Q6%.(7- +%.&%20 -& $+% 0%6(#(#% "'%.&%%. "0 $+%
8".29 9%3.%&&%9 -#9 &-99%#%9 H1 -22 $+-$ &+% &%%&> Z"$+ 2"7-221 -#9 (#$%.#-$("#-221B
3%-7%S6-T(#/ $"F.&B 7"#0%.%#7%& -#9 6%%$(#/& -(6 $" _F%22 -#9 (#7($% -#/%.
$+."F/+ %7"#"6(7 H.(H%.1B H2-7T6-(2 -#9 .(/+$%"F& 3."&%21$(&(#/> *+% '("2%#7%
%00%7$%9 H1 -# (#$%.#-$("#-221 3."6(#%#$ 7"F#$.1 &F7+ -& Q6%.(7- (& %7"#"6(7>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
C$%(-
Q.$-F9 72-(6& $" +-'% F#7"'%.%9 -# Q6%.(7-# 32"$ $" /-$+%. F3 &7+""2SH"1&; &3%.6
(# ".9%. $" 7.%-$% +F/% 3"3F2-$("#& "0 &"29(%.& $+-$ 8(22 H% $.-(#%9 $" 3."$%7$ $+%
7"F#$.1;& 7-3($-2(&6> `,%% Q.$-F9;& 5*" +-'% 9"#% 8($+ $+% RF9/%6%#$ "0 ^"9; )XCNB
JJJhC)>a Q6%.(7- &%#9& '("2%#7% (# - 3-7T-/%9 6%&&-/% "0 F#('%.&-2 9%#F#7(-$("#
%63$(%9 &3%7("F&21 "0 -22 -//.%&&('% 3."'"7-$("# -#9 2"-9%9 (#&$%-9 8($+ 6".-2
"F$.-/%> *+% -(6 "0 &2-#9%. `$+% \, 7"F#$%.S-77F&(#/ Y.-_ "0 +-.H"F.(#/ -//.%&&("#a
". %7"#"6(7 '("2%#7% `$+% \, 32-7(#/ &%'%.% %7"#"6(7 &-#7$("#& "# !FH-a (& #"$
$+% %.-9(7-$("# "0 %#$(.% 7"F#$.(%& HF$ $+% 8(##(#/ "0 %7"#"6(7 7"#$."2 $+."F/+
9%3.('-$("# -#9 H"17"$$(#/ "0 %V3".$& -#9 (63".$&> Q6%.(7-;& (#&$-#7%& "0 3"8%.
H."T%.(#/ -.% 9%&(/#%9 -& 3-2(63&%&$& "0 3."'"7-$("# $" %#&F.% $+-$ -#1 -7$`&a "0
-//.%&&("# H% &(/+$%9 -& $+"&% "0 $+% .%&3"#9(#/ 7"F#$.1 -#9 7"#&%_F%#$21 9(&&%6S
(#-$%9 H1 $+% 6%9(- -& (#&$(/-$%9 H1 $+% "$+%. 7"F#$.1B $+% 7"F#$.1 (# 9(&/.-7%>
Q#/%. (& -&&(/#%9 - 32-7% .-$+%. $+-# - $(6% +%#7% 7"F#$.(%& "F$&(9% 9(.%7$ \,
RF.(&9(7$("# -.% .%/-.9%9 -& 5F#7+.(&$(-#; `Y.-_;& .%-7$("# $" $+% \,Qa ". 3"". -#9
(/#".-#$ `Y#9(-;& .%0F&-2 $" &$"3 #F72%-. $%&$(#/a> L# - 2"7-2 2%'%2B $+% 6-#-/%6%#$
"0 -#/%. (& %_F-221 &3-$(-221 7"".9(#-$%94 7".3".-$% 0F#9%9 $+%.-31 7"F.&%& -.%
"00%.%9 $" -22 3.('-$% %632"1%%& 8+(2% /"'%.#6%#$ 0F#9%9 -#/%. 6-#-/%6%#$
58".T&+"3&; -.% &%$ F3 (# 3.(&"#&B '-.("F& "$+%. -&12F6& -#9 9.F/B -27"+"2 -#9
7.(6(#-2 .%+-H(2($-$("# 7%#$.%&> P&17+"2"/1 -&&F.%& F& $+-$ -#/%. (& #"$ #%7%&&-.(21
- +-.60F2 %6"$("#4 8($+ $+% 7"..%7$ &%20S6-#-/%6%#$ &$.-$%/(%& -#/%. 7-#B -#9 "0
7"F.&% &+"F29B H% %V3.%&&%9 -#9 7-# %'%# H% H%#%0(7(-2> M%-2$+1 -#/%. (& 9('(9%9
(#$" 7-$%/".(%& "0 7"#$."22%9 -#9 F#7"#$."22%9B -77%3$-H2% -#9 F#-77%3$-H2%> Q#/%.
(& 3.%&%#$%9 '(- - &$.-#/% -#9 3-.-9"V(7-2 &122"/(&6> W(.&$B ($ (& 3."3"&%9 $+-$ -#/%.
(& %#$(.%21 #-$F.-2 -#9 $+%.%0".% #"$ - 3."H2%6> ,%7"#9B -#/%. (& - 3."H2%6 H%7-F&%
($ (& #-$F.-221 F#&-0% -#9 %V7%&&('%> K-&$21B -#/%. 7-# H% 7"#$."22%9 8+(7+ 6%-#&
$+-$ ($ (& #"$ - 3."H2%6> Q22 $+(& (& $" &-1 $+-$ -#/%. (& - 3."H2%6 HF$ ($ (& - #".6-2
3."H2%6 H%7-F&% ($ (& /""9 $" H% -#/.1 HF$ "#21 (# - 7%.$-(# 8-1> *+% 6-#-/%6%#$
"0 -#/%. (& -# (#$%/.-2 3-.$ "0 -#1 7"#$%63".-.1 3%.&"#-2 9%'%2"36%#$ 3."/.-66%>
W". $+% 2-&$ 0".$1 1%-.&B 6(992%S6%# "0 $+% 3&17+% +-'% H%%# &%22(#/ 3"$%#$(-2
5%V3%.(%#7%&; H-7T $" $+%(. 72(%#$& 8($+(# $+% 5&-0%; %#'(."#6%#$ "0 $+%.-31> E-#-S
/(#/ "#%;& -#/.1 5(63F2&%&; (& $+% $-7($ .F2% "0 %'%.1 &"7(-2 3."/.-66% "'%.&%%# H1
$+% ,$-$% -#9 ($& 7".3".-$% -22(%&> P&17+"2"/1 (& $+% 6-.T%$(#/ 7"#&F2$-#$ 0". 7"66%.7(-2 $%7+#(_F% 8+(7+ 0"29& 7"#&F63$("# (#$" &$.F7$F.%& "0 $+%.-3%F$(7
&%20S(63."'%6%#$> Q& - 7"#&%_F%#7%B $+% (9%- "0 (#9('(9F-2 7+"(7% (& /('%# 6%-#(#/
-#9 6-9% $-#/(H2%> E".%"'%.B $+% (#9('(9F-2 7"6%& $" .%3.%&%#$ 7+"(7%B 0". %V-6S
32%B (# ^%&$-2$ $+%.-31 %63+-&(& (& 32-7%9 "# $+% .%2-$("#&+(3 H%$8%%# 3-.$& -#9 $+%
8+"2%B 51"F -.% $+% $"$-2 &F6 "0 1"F. 7+"(7%&;> ,(6(2-.21B 7"#&F6%.(&$ $+%.-31B
9(&&%6(#-$%& $+% &2"/-#&4 5kF&$ [" Y$j; 5,-1 o%& $" K(0%;B 5o"F 7-# H% -#1$+(#/ 1"F
8-#$ $" H%; -#9 5O+%.% 9" 1"F 8-#$ $" /" $"9-1i; !"#$."22(#/ "#%;& -#/%. (& $+% T%1
$" 3."9F7$('($1 HF$ "#21 (#&"0-. -& ($ H%7"6%& $+% T%1 $" $+% 3."9F7$("# "0 7"#S
&F63$("#> ,-1 5o%&; $" - #%8 9%-2 -#9 +-'% "$+%.& &-1 5o%&; $" 1"F.&>
< *+% $+(#/& 0". 8+(7+ Q#$"#(# Q.$-F9 (& 0-6"F&B +(& 8.($(#/& "# $+% $+%-$.%B +(&
&FH2(6% 0(26 3.%&%#7%B +(& 9%2F&("#&B +(& "3(-$% -99(7$("# -#9 +(& 6-9 .-/%&B 8%.%
-22 %V$.-".9(#-.1 "#7%> ZF$ $+% -&&(6(2-$("# "0 Q.$-F9;& 6-9#%&& (#$" $+% 56-9#%&&;
"0 $+% $8%#$(%$+ 7%#$F.1B '(- $+% 3."2(0%.-$("# "0 _F-&(S%V3%.(6%#$-2 $+%-$.% -#9
$+% 7"9(0(7-$("# "0 -99(7$("# -& - FH(_F($"F& &"7(-2 (22#%&&B 6%-# $+-$ Q.$-F9;&
&F00%.(#/ (& #"8 -'-(2-H2% -& 57"66"# %V3%.(%#7%;B %V3%.(%#7% -& 3.%'-2%#$ -& ($ (&
".9(#-.1> Q &(6(2-. "F$7"6% 32-/F%& $+% (9%- "0 #(+(2(&6> Y# 5K- f(% PF%B E%&&(%F.&j;
E-$+%8 M12-#9;& 2""T& -$ $+% -#-7+."#(&6 "0 .%H%22("# -#9 &F//%&$& 0". %V-632%B
$+-$ Q.$-F9;& &F00%.(#/ (& #"8 6".% $+-# %'%.B 2%&& $+-# %V$.-".9(#-.1>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<@< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
@
D
J
N
C
?
X
)I
Q.$-F9;& &F00%.(#/ (& 9('(9%9 5-6"#/ +-32%&& -#"#16"F& 6(22("#&> > > > O+(2% 6"&$
"0 $+% 8".29;& 3"3F2-$("# T%%3 "# &$.F//2(#/ 0". H-.% &F.'('-2 (# $+% -77F&$"6%9
8-1B Q.$-F9;& 6(&0".$F#%& +-'% H%%# 9%6"7.-$(A%9 $" $+% 3"(#$ $+-$ $+%1;.% #"
2"#/%. %V3%.(%#7%9 -& &F00%.(#/; `M12-#9 )XXCB <a>
Q& 3-.$ "0 - 2-./%. &$F91 "# Q.$-F9 -#9 3+(2"&"3+1B Y -./F% $+-$ "#% "0 $+%
3."0"F#9 $+(#/& -H"F$ Q.$-F9;& 8".T (& ($& (#&(&$%#7% "# - 7.($(7-2 -#9 #"$ RF&$ 72(#(7-2 -33.%+%#&("# "0 $+% 6-9#%&& "0 $+% 6(#9> Y# %00%7$B Q.$-F9;& 8".T (& -H2%
$" .%#%8 $+% 8-#(#/ (#$%.%&$ (# -22 $+(#/& 6-9>
*+% %3($"6% "0 $+% F#-$$.-7$('%#%&& "0 6-9#%&& 7-# H% 0"F#9 (# ["7$". ^-&$"#
W%.9(%n.%;& 9%&7.(3$("# "0 Q.$-F9;& -..('-2 -$ $+% -&12F6 -$ G"9%A> Y# 5Y 2""T%9 -0$%.
Q#$"#(# Q.$-F9;B W%.9(%n.% 7"632-(#& $+-$ 8+%# +% H."F/+$ Q.$-F9 +"6% $" 2F#7+
8($+ +% -#9 +(& 8(0%B Q.$-F9 3.%&%#$%9 - 9(&/F&$(#/ &3%7$-72% "0 /.F#$(#/B &+"'(#/
0""9 (#$" +(& 6"F$+B &3($$(#/B H%27+(#/B .FHH(#/ 0""9 (#$" $+% $-H2%72"$+ -#9
%#9(#/ $+% 6%-2 H1 T#%%2(#/ 9"8# $" &(#/ 3&-26& `E-."8($A )XCCB )IXa>
Q.$-F9 8"# $+% P.(V ,-(#$%SZ%F'% 0". H%&$ %&&-1 "0 )XDC>
Q &(6(2-. 3"(#$ (& 7"#&(9%.%9 H1 Q#-cg& =(#> Y# +%. R"F.#-2 =(# 8"#9%.& 8+%$+%.
"#21 Q.$-F9;& -#/%. (& -# (#&-#($1 ". (0 ($ (& #"$ 6".% 7"..%7$21 -22 -#/%. 8+(7+ (&
(#&-#% `=(# )XNNB )?Ca>
Y# 3-.$(7F2-.B $+.%% "0 =(%$A&7+%;& 2-&$ 0('% H""T&B D=*4*?'# "2 #'$ -."4%B D'$ 7&#*J
(')*%# -#9 6//$ >"5"R (#72F9% (#&$-#7%& "0B -#9 7"66%#$& "#B .F9%#%&&> =(%$A&7+%
-&T& "0 $+% ^%.6-#&B 59" $+%1 &$(22 $+(#T -$ -22i; `=(%$A&7+% )XXIB C)aB 7-22& $+%
!+.(&$(-#B 5$+% 9"6%&$(7 -#(6-2B $+% +%.9 -#(6-2B $+% &(7T -#(6-2 6-#; `=(%$A&7+%
)XXIB )<?aB -#9 $+% U#/2(&+B $+"&% H%+(#9 $+% $(6%& `.-$+%. $+-# -+%-9 "0 $+%6
2(T% +(& F#$(6%21 &%20a 8+" 9" #"$ %'%# T#"8 $+-$ $+%.% 6-1 H% - 3."H2%6 8($+
6".-2($1 `=(%$A&7+% )XXIB ?)a> M% -2&" &(#/2%& "F$ 7%.$-(# +"3%0F2 0(/F.%&B %&3%S
7(-221 U#/2(&+ 3%.&"#-/%& &F7+ -& ^%"./% U2("$ 8+"6 +% 7-22& - 2($$2% H2F% &$"7T(#/
`=(%$A&7+% )XXIB ?IaB -#9 k"+# ,$F-.$ E(22 8+"6 +% .%0%.& $" -& 5$+% 02-$+%-9;
`=(%$A&7+% )XNCB <)a>
Y# 2(/+$ "0 =(%$A&7+%;& $8" #(+(2(&6&B "#% 7"F29 &-1 $+-$ $+% 3."0%&&("#-2(&-$("# "0
-#/%. %632"1& - 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6B "#% (#$%#$ "# 9%-7$('-$(#/ -#/%.> *+(& 9%6"#S
&$.-$%& F#8($$(#/21B $+-$ 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6 .%/-.9& %'%.1$+(#/B %'%# $+% 0(%.7%#%&& "0
-#/%.B -& 3"(#$2%&& F#2%&& ($ 7"66($& ($&%20 $" &%#9(#/ "F$ - 53"&($('%;B 3."9F7$('%B
7"#&F6-H2% -#9 3."0($-H2% 6%&&-/%>
*" "00&%$ $+% (6-/% "0 Q.$-F9 -& - 7F.6F9/%"#B Q.$+F. Q9-6"' -#9 G"/%. Z2(#B
Q.$-F9;& -&&"7(-$% -#9 0.(%#9 .%&3%7$('%21B 7"66%#$ "# Q.$-F9;& "3$(6(&6B 8($
-#9 3.%9(2%7$("# 0". 32-1(#/ $.(7T& "# 3%"32%> W". %V-632%B "#% %'%#(#/ &"6% "0
Q.$-F9;& 0.(%#9& $+"F/+$ $+%1 +-9 F3&%$ +(6 /.%-$21 8+%# +% 2%0$ $+%6 -H.F3$21
-0$%. $+%1 7"632-(#%9 -H"F$ +(& .(9(7F2"F& 02(/+$& "0 3-.-#"(9 0-#71 HF$ 8+%#
$+%1 &-8 Q.$-F9 - 0%8 9-1& 2-$%. +% &(6321 2-F/+%9 -H"F$ $+% %'%#$ -#9 .%6-.T%9
-H"F$ 0F##1 ($ +-9 H%%# `E-."8($A )XCCB C?B ?)h<a> *+% 6".% 7"66"# '(%8 "0
Q.$-F9;& 5&%#&(H(2($1; (& "0 -# %V$.%6%21 9%&3%.-$% -#9 '("2%#$ 6-#> *+(& (& %V%6S
32(0(%9 (# Z%.#-.9SM%#.( K%e'(;& 7.F$&#,)$% "& #'$ :)$$."5 1"9.> K%e'( F&%& Q.$-F9 $"
0.-6% $+% -%&$+%$(7 '("2%#7% "0 $+% $(6% -#9 $+% &3%7(0(7 6-9#%&& "0 O".29 O-. Y>
M-'(#/ 32-7%9 Q.$-F9 -$ $+% %V$.%6% #-9(. -#9 -3"/%% "0 5$+% $(6%&B; K%e'( 9"%&
#"$ $-2T -H"F$ Q.$-F9 -/-(#B %V7%3$ -& - 5#-6%; -&&"7(-$%9 8($+ &F..%-2(&6 `K%e'(
)XXJB ))h)<a>
*+(& $"F7+%& "# -# (#$%.%&$(#/ 3."H2%6 H%$8%%# ,3(#"A-B Q.$-F9 -#9 =(%$A&7+%>
,3(#"A- %63+-&(&%& $+% 9(00%.%#7% H%$8%%# -00%7$& -#9 3-&&("#&> P-&&("#& -.%
9('(9%9 (#$" R"10F2 3-&&("#& -#9 &-9 3-&&("#& -#9 "#21 R"10F2 3-&&("#& -.% -00(.S
6-$('% %#"F/+ $" $.-#&0".6 $+%6&%2'%& (#$" -7$('% -00%7$&> ^('%# $+-$ "#21 R"10F2
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
(9#'$)*&$ B94$ <@@
))
)<
)@
)D
)J
)N
3-&&("#& 7-# 6"'% -#9 7+-#/%B 3%.+-3& $+% #"$("# "0 5R"10F2 &F00%.(#/; -#9 "0 -#
-7$('% #(+(2(&6 0"F#9 (# H"$+ Q.$-F9 -#9 =(%$A&7+%B 8(22 +-'% $" H% .%S$+"F/+$ (#
,3(#"A(&$ $%.6& H1 %63+-&(&(#/ #"$ "#21 $+% 3"8%. $+-$ H"$+ &F00%.(#/ -#9 R"1
7-# 3."9F7% HF$ -2&" 8+-$ T(#9 "0 3"8%.>
*+(& %&&-1 (& 7-22%9 - 5'-.(-#$ $%V$;B &F//%&$(#/ $+-$ $+%.% (& #" %#9 $" - 7"#7%('-H2%
-77F6F2-$("# "0 &F00(V%& 0".B 5Y +-$% -#9 .%#"F#7% -& - 7"8-.9 > > >;
U'%# 9F.(#/ +(& 6"&$ 9%'"F$ !+.(&$(-# -7$& &F7+ -& $+% $.(3 $" Y.%2-#9 8($+ $+%
7-#% "0 ,-(#$ P-$.(7T -#9 +(& 6"&$ 9%'"F$ 1%-.& (# $+% +"&3($-2 -$ G"9%AB Q.$-F9 (&
-28-1& 7"#&$.F7$(#/ A%-2"F& -00-(.& 8($+ ^"9B 7-22(#/ &"6% "0 $+%6 +-$% -#9 &"6%
"0 $+%6 2"'%>
Q.$-F9;& (9%- "0 (#$F($("# .%0%.& $" - Z%./&"#(-# #"$("# "0 $+-$ 8+(7+ 7-##"$ H%
/.-&3%9 HF$ 7-# "#21 H% 0%2$ (# ($& 9F.-$("#> Q.$-F9 8-& /.%-$21 (#02F%#7%9 H1 M%#.(
Z%./&"#;& $+%".(%& "0 (#$F($("# -#9 9F.-$("#> *+% .%2-$("#&+(3 H%$8%%# Q.$-F9 -#9
Z%./&"# (& 9%-2$ 8($+ (# - 6F7+ 2-./%. 8".T "0 6(#% 8+(7+ (& (# 3."/.%&&>
!"#&(9%. $+% 0(#-2 8".9& "0 5L# ,F(7(9%;> 5Y 7-# #%($+%. 2('% #". 9(%B #". -6 Y 7-3-H2%
"0 #"$ 8(&+(#/ $" 9(% ". 2('%> Q#9 -22 6-#T(#9 .%&%6H2%& 6%; `Q.$-F9 )XNJB J?a>
*" 7-$7+ $+% -$$%#$("# "0 - 3-&&%. H1 &F.%21 "#21 "#% $+(#/ #%7%&&-.1B $" &+"F$>
Y# -99($("# $" ,%22(#;& 7"66%#$& "# $+% 0.F&$.-$("# "0 .%-9(#/ Q.$-F9;& $+%".(%&B
&%% M-16-# )XCCB N)h<>
0(D()(,1(Q.$-F9B Q> `)XXJa P9#/'2*$&.% 9&. 19/; A/)$95%Z U9> -#9 *.-#&> !2-1$"# U&+2%6-# 8($+
Z%.#-.9 Z-9".> Z"&$"#4 UV-7$ !+-#/%>
Q.$-F9B Q> `)XC?a u,F)$% ("5I4$b#$% :Yf> P-.(&4 ^-22(6-.9>
Q.$-F9B Q> `)XCNa A$4$/#$. P)*#*&?%> U9> ,F&-# ,"#$-/> *.-#&> M%2%# O%-'%.> \,Q4
!-2(0".#(- \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
Q.$-F9B Q> `)XNJa 7)#9,. 7&#'"4"?C> U9> k-7T M(.&+6-#> ,-# W.-#7(&7"4 !($1 K(/+$&>
Q.$-F9B Q> `)XN@a 5*" M%#.( P-.(&"$; `)XDJa (# D,49&$ B)959 1$F*$=Z *.-#&> f(7$". !".$(>
`?4 CIh@a>
Q.$-F9B Q> `)XJ?a D'$ D'$9#$) 9&. *#% B",+4$ *.-#&> E-.1 !-."2(#% G(7+-.9&> =%8 o".T4
^."'% P.%&&>
Z-.H%.B ,> `)XX@a 7&#"&*& 7)#9,.0 <4"=% 9&. <"5+%> K"#9"#4 W-H%. -#9 W-H%.>
[%2%FA%B ^> `)XXCa 6%%9C% ()*#*/94 9&. (4*&*/94> *.-#&> [>O> ,6($+ -#9 E>Q> ^.%7">
E(##%-3"2(&4 \#('%.&($1 "0 E(##%&"$- P.%&&>
M-16-#B G> `)XCCa 7)#9,. 9&. 72#$)Z K"#9"#4 LV0".9 \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
M12-#9B E> `)XXCa L9 X*$ E,$R 3$%%*$,)%Y *%&$S&$.(3 E"#"/.-3+ ,%.(%&> =%8 q%-2-#94
*%&$&$.(3 ^-22%.1>
E-."8($AB !> `)XCCa 7)#9,. 9# 1".$@> K"#9"#4 E-.("# Z"1-.&>
=%/.(B Q> `)X?Xa D'$ E"=$) "2 A,+F$)%*"&> *.-#&> k-6%& =%8%22> \b4 P"2($1 P.%&&>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XXIa D=*4*?'# "2 #'$ -."4%dD'$ 7&#*J(')*%#> *.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%> K"#S
9"#4 P%#/F(#>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)X?Xa O$&$94"?C "2 3")94%d6//$ >"5"> *.-#&> O-2$%. b-F06-## -#9 G>k>
M"22(#/9-2%> *.-#&> O-2$%. b-F06-##> \,Q4 f(#$-/%>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XN?a D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)> U9> O-2$%. b-F06-#> *.-#&> O-2$%. b-F06-##
-#9 G>k> M"22(#/9-2%> \,Q4 f(#$-/%>
=(#B Q> `)XNNa D'$ 8",)&94% "2 7&9rU% !*& X"4,5$ -> U9> ^F#$+%. ,$F+26-##> U#/2-#94
P%$%. L8%#>
,+-$$F7TB G> `)XNXa D'$ <9&V,$# g$9)%> K"#9"#4 k"#-$+-# !-3%>
*+%e'%#(#B P> `)XNJa 5Q 2%$$%. "# Q.$-F9; (# D,49&$ B)959 1$F*$=Z `X4 XXh))Ca>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<@D !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
)<
B9&*$4 G9#@
5E-# +-& "0$%# +-9 %#"F/+m $+%.% -.% -7$F-2 %3(9%6(7& "0 +-'(#/
+-9 %#"F/+;>
=(%$A&7+%B Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94% `)<)a
W". - 9(&7F&&("# "0 #(+(2(&6B Z%7T%$$;& 8".T "00%.& #" &+".$-/% "0 %#$.1
3"(#$&> Y# - 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 T%1B "#% 7-# %'"T% +(& $8" 0-'"F.($% $-/&4 [%6"S
7.($F&; 5="$+(#/ (& 6".% .%-2 $+-# #"$+(#/;B -#9 $+% Z%2/(-# Q.#"29 ^%FS
2(#7V;& 5\H( #(+(2 '-2%&B (H( #(+(2 '%2(&; `5*+%.% 8+%.% 1"F -.% 8".$+ #"$+(#/B
$+%.% 1"F &+"F29 8-#$ #"$+(#/;a H"$+ F&%9 (# 3,)I'C -#9 $+% $.(2"/1B -#9
.%7"66%#9%9 H1 Z%7T%$$ +(6&%20 -& $+% H%&$ &$-.$(#/ 32-7%& 0". - 7.($(7 0-7%9
8($+ $+% $-&T "0 (#$%.3.%$(#/ +(& 8".T>) G%7%#$ H("/.-3+(%& "#21 7"#0(.6
Z%7T%$$;& 9%%3 -#9 "#/"(#/ %V7+-#/%& 8($+ $+% 7"#$(#%#$-2 3+(2"&"3+(7-2
$.-9($("#B -#9 +(& (#$%.%&$ (# ,7+"3%#+-F%. +-& 2"#/ H%%# T#"8#>< E".%S
"'%.B Z%7T%$$;& 7"#7%.# $" 32-7% +(& 8".T F#9%. - 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 -%/(& &$.%&S
&(#/ 5#"$+(#/; .+16%& 8($+ +(& 3."/.%&&('% $%7+#(7-2 %2(6(#-$("# "0 &" 6-#1
"0 $+% $.-9($("#-2 3."3& "0 H"$+ 3."&% -#9 $+%-$.%B 3."9F7(#/ $%V$& -#9
9.-6-$(7 8".T& 8+(7+ (0 #"$ 5#"$+(#/;B 7%.$-(#21 &%%6 $" H% &$.('(#/ -0$%.
4$%%B -& - $($2% 2(T% 5K%&&#%&&; 6-T%& 72%-.B -2"#/ 8($+ $+% 72-(6 (# $+% '%.1 2-$%
P")#%#=9). >" $" H% $.-'%22(#/ 52%-&$8-.9; `Z%7T%$$ )X?@B @@a> M"8%'%.B $+%
'%.1 7-.% 8($+ 8+(7+ Z%7T%$$ %63+-&(&%& $+% .%6-(#9%.B ". $+% 52%-&$;B &+"F29
3.%'%#$ F& 0."6 &%%(#/ +(6 -& &%%T(#/ &"6% &".$ "0 2($%.-.1 3.%&%#$-$("# "0
-# (9%-2 #"$+(#/B "0 0"./(#/ (# 8".9& ". "# &$-/% $+% 5.%-2($1; "0 $+(& 5#"$+(#/;
8+(7+ [%6"7.($F&; &%#$%#7% &%%6& $" 3."6(&%> 5=-F/+$ #"$ H%&$ 8".&%;
`(H(9>B @<a P")%#=9). >" -7T#"82%9/%&B 5K%-&$ H%&$ 8".&%> K%-&$ #%'%. $"
H% #-F/+$> =%'%. $" #-F/+$ H% H."F/+$> =%'%. H1 #-F/+$ H% #F22%9> \##F22S
-H2% 2%-&$> ,-1 $+-$ H%&$ 8".&%> O($+ 2%-&$%#(#/ 8".9& &-1 2%-&$ H%&$ 8".&%;
`(H(9>B @<a> =" 6%&&(-#(7 #(+(2(&$(7 9.%-6 "0 8(3(#/ $+% &2-$% 72%-# (& $" H%
0"F#9 (# Z%7T%$$m #" $"$-2($1 (& $"2%.-$%9 %'%# (# - #%/-$('%B ". #%/-$%9
6"9%>
ZF$ (# &T%$7+(#/ - Z%7T%$$(-# #(+(2(&6 "#% (& 7%.$-(#21 #"$ 2(6($%9 H1 +(&
%V32(7($21 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 .F6(#-$("#&m "#% 7"F29 RF&$ -& 8%22 6%#$("# $+%
<@J
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
5U3(9%6(7& "0 U#"F/+;4 Z%7T%$$(-#
,F00(7(%#7(%&
&$-.T 0(#-2 8".9& "0 $+% 8"6-#;& '"(7% (# $+% 32-1 5G"7T-H1; h 50F7T 2(0% ] &$"3
+%. %1%& ] ."7T +%. "00 ] ."7T +%. "00; `Z%7T%$$ )X?DHB <?<a h (# 8+(7+ $+%
_F%&$("# "0 $+% '-2F% "0 $+% 8".29B $+% '-2F% "0 '-2F%&B $+% '-2F% "0 2(0%B 3-2%&
H%0".% -# (63%.("F& 9%&(.%4 $+-$ ($ %#9> 5L+ -22 $" %#9; (& +"8 Z%7T%$$ %#9%9
+(& 0(#-2 3."&% 8".TB 5,$(..(#/& ,$(22;B -#9 Z%7T%$$ 7-# -$ $(6%& &%%6 2(T% 3-."91 "0 =(%$A&7+%;& #(+(2(&$B &1&$%6-$(7-221 9(&3-.-/(#/ -22 2"0$1 '-2F%& -#9
/"-2&B 6%.7(2%&& $" $+"&% 72-(6(#/ $+% .(/+$ $" -F$+".($1 -#9 3"8%.B 9(&9-(#S
0F2 "0 -22 %&$-H2(&+%9 6"9%& "0 -00(.6-$("#> L0 7"F.&%B $+% (."#1 (& $+-$ (# -22
$+(& +% /.%-$21 .%&%6H2%& =(%$A&7+% +(6&%20B -#9 $+(& (."#1 (& "#% 8+(7+
&+"F29 H% T%3$ (# &(/+$> W".B (0 $+% 3."H2%6 "0 #(+(2(&6 7-22& Z%7T%$$ $"
6(#9 0". 6-#1 .%-&"#& -#9 (# 6-#1 .%/(&$%.&B ($ &$(22 &%%6& 3.%0%.-H2% $"
-'"(9 $+% $%63$-$("# "0 -&&(/#(#/ +(6 - &%7F.% 32-7% 8($+(# ($& +(&$".1> Q&
,(6"# !.($7+2%1 +-& %63+-&(&%9 (# +(& .%7%#$ 9(&7F&&("# "0 Q9".#";& 8.($S
(#/& "# Z%7T%$$B -#1$+(#/ $+-$ &%%6& (# -33%-.-#7% $" H% $+% 6"&$ &%'%.%
9%3.%7(-$("# "0 2(0%B $.-#&7%#9%#$ '-2F%&B %V(&$%#7%B -#9 6%-#(#/ 7-# -28-1&
H% .%7F3%.-$%9 -& 3.%7(&%21 $+% )$2,%94 "0 - 3-.$(7F2-. &%$ "0 7"#9($("#& -#9
(9%"2"/1 8+(7+ (& (#$"2%.-H2%B -#9 $+%.%0".% $+% (632(7($ -00(.6-$("# "0 $+%
3"&&(H(2($1 "0 &"6%$+(#/ "$+%. -#9 H%$$%. $+-# $+% 9%/.-9%9 &3-7% "0 "F.
2('%&> *+F& 0". Q9".#"B 5*+"F/+$ +-& ($& +"#"F. H1 9%0%#9(#/ 8+-$ (& 7"#S
9%6#%9 -& #(+(2(&6; `7($%9 (# !.($7+2%1 )XXCB <Da -#9 Z%7T%$$ H%7"6%&B #"$
$+% #(+(2(&$B HF$ $+% $.F21 3"2($(7-2 8.($%.> ,(6(2-.21B -& [%2%FA% 6-T%& -HF#9S
-#$21 72%-.B 0". =(%$A&7+% $+% '("2%#$ ". 8%-.1 .%R%7$("# "0 -22 $.-#&7%#9%#$
'-2F%& -#9 (9%-2& (& #"$ %*5I4C #(+(2(&6B 0". $+% '%.1 -7$ "0 %.%7$(#/ "$+%.S
8".2921 '-2F%& &%%# -& 8".$+1 "0 (#'%&$6%#$ -#9 &-7.(0(7% (& #(+(2(&$ (# -#9 "0
($&%20>@ Q9".#" 3%.+-3& 9(-2%7$(7-221 %7+"%& =(%$A&7+% H1 -&&%.$(#/ $+-$ 7%.$-(# 5#(+(2(&6; (& -7$F-221 - 0".6 "0 -00(.6-$("#>
o%$ !.($7+2%1 7-##"$ 0-(2 $" #"$(7% $+% '("2%#7% "0 Q9".#";& .%7F3%.-$("# "0
Z%7T%$$B - .%7F3%.-$("# 8+(7+B &%7F.%21 32-7(#/ Z%7T%$$;& 8".T 8($+(# $+%
7-63 "0 -00(.6-$("#B 0".%72"&%& 6F7+ "0 $+% 9(&$F.H(#/ '("2%#7% "0 Z%7T%$$
+(6&%20B (# - 6-#"%F'.% 8+(7+ "9921 6(..".& 8+-$ Q9".#" 7"#&(9%.& $" H%
$+% $.F% -#9 3."0"F#9 #(+(2(&6 "0 $+% 0".7%9 (#$%22(/(H(2($1 "0 &"7(-2(&$ .%-S
2(&6> !.($7+2%1B -$$%63$(#/ $" 3.%&%.'% Q9".#";& &%#&% "0 Z%7T%$$;& %#/-/%9
.-9(7-2($1 8+(2% -$ $+% &-6% $(6% 3."$%7$(#/ Z%7T%$$;& $%V$& 0."6 Q9".#";&
7.($(7-2 3.%7(3($-$("#B -./F%& $+-$ Z%7T%$$ (& %63+-$(7-221 5#"$ - #(+(2(&$; (#
$+-$ +% 5(#9(7-$%& +"8 6%-#(#/2%&&#%&& 7-# H% &%%# -& -# -7+(%'%6%#$;
`(H(9>B <Ca> O($+ $+(& 3+.-&% !.($7+2%1 %#9%-'"F.& $" -'"(9 Q9".#";& #%-.
(66%9(-$% -H."/-$("# "0 $+% 3."H2%6 "0 6%-#(#/2%&&#%&& +% H%/-# H1
%63+-&(A(#/B HF$ -& %2%/-#$ -& +(& 0".6F2-$("# (&B !.($7+2%1 &%%6& 8-.(21
7"#&7("F& -22 $+% &-6% "0 +-'(#/ 7"66($$%9 - &(6(2-. .%7F3%.-$("# $" $+-$ "0
Q9".#"B -2H%($ 8($+ /.%-$%. &FH$2%$1 -#9 - 72%-.%. &%#&% "0 +(& $.-#&/.%&&("#>
*+% '%.1 7"#7%3$ "0 -7+(%'%6%#$B (0 (#%'($-H2%B -2&" (#%'($-H21 %&$-H2(&+%&
56%-#(#/2%&&#%&&; -& - $%2%"2"/(7-2 /"-2 (# - 6-##%. &"6%8+-$ -$ "99&
8($+ H"$+ Z%7T%$$;& 8".T -#9 $+% 72-(6& 0". $+% '-2F% "0 56%-#(#/2%&&#%&&;
($&%20>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<@N !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
!"#7%.#(#/ $+(& 9%H-$%B $8" 3."H2%6& 6F&$ H% 7"#&(9%.%9 -$ $+(& 3"(#$>
W(.&$B (0 Z%7T%$$;& 8".TB %&3%7(-221 (# $+% 2-$%. 1%-.&B 7"#&(&$%#$21 6"'%& (# $+%
9(.%7$("# "0 $+% .%9F7$("# "0 &%#&%B +(& 8".T #%'%.$+%2%&& 6-(#$-(#& - 72%-.
2%/(H(2($1 $+."F/+"F$B -#9 (& 2-./%21 -6%#-H2% $" (#$%.3.%$('% 3."R%7$&
-2$+"F/+B -& !.($7+2%1 -#9 6-#1 "$+%.& +-'% #"$%9B ($ 9"%& 3.%&%#$ %V$.%6S
%21 &"3+(&$(7-$%9 -#9 (#/%#("F& "H&$-72%& $" $+%6> Y$ &%%6& $+-$ ($ (&
3.%7(&%21 $+% 9%#&($1 -#9 &F.32F& "0 56%-#(#/; (# Z%7T%$$;& 8".TB -2"#/
8($+ $+% (#$.(7-$% 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 2-1%.(#/ $" 8+(7+ H"$+ !.($7+2%1 -#9
Q9".#" -.% &%#&($('%B 8+(7+ +-& 6-9% ($ &%%6 &F7+ -# (9%-2 7%#$%.3(%7% 0".
$+% 5#(+(2(&$; 9%H-$%> Y$ (& _F($% 3."H-H21 $+% 6"&$ 7"#'%#$("#-2 _F-2($1 "0
Z%7T%$$;& 8".T h ($& (#$%#&% (6H.(7-$("# (# 7-#"#(7-2 2($%.-.1 -#9 3+(2"&"3+(S
7-2 +(&$".1 h 8+(7+ '%+(7F2-$%& Q9".#";& .%-9(#/> *+-$ $+(& &F.32F& ($&%20
6-T%& Z%7T%$$;& 8".T& %V$.-".9(#-.(21 .%&(&$-#$ $" $+%".%$(7-2 .%7F3%.-$("#&
"0 -22 &".$& (& F#9%#(-H2%B -#9 (#9%%9B $" $+% 7"#&(9%.-H2% %V$%#$ $+-$ H"$+
Q9".#" -#9 !.($7+2%1 %#/-/% $+% &$.-$%/(%& "0 $+(& .%&(&$-#7% h 8+-$ !.($7+S
2%1 7-22& 5.%9%63$("# 0."6 .%9%63$("#; `<Ca h Y 8+"221 7"#7F. 8($+ $+%(.
%63+-&(&B HF$ .%&(&$-#7% -#9 56%-#(#/2%&&#%&&; -.% #"$ %#$(.%21 $+% &-6%
$+(#/> Y#9%%9B 8+-$ 2($%.-.1 56%-#(#/2%&&#%&&; 6(/+$ H% (& #"$ - _F%&$("# Y
7-# -#&8%. +%.%B HF$ &$-1(#/ "# - .-$+%. %2%6%#$-.1 2%'%2B 6F7+ "0 $+% 8".T
"0 k"+# !-/% ". ^%.$.F9% ,$%(#B 0". %V-632%B (& 6F7+ 6".% %'(9%#$21 5#(+(2S
(&$; (# - 0".6-2 ". 2(#/F(&$(7 6-##%. $+-# Z%7T%$$;&> 5U#9/-6%; (& - 2"$ %-&(%.
$" F#9%.&$-#9 $+-# 5*%#9%. ZF$$"#&;B -#9 Q9".#";& (#&(&$%#7% "# 5F#9%.S
&$-#9(#/ ($& F#(#$%22(/(H(2($1B 7"#7.%$%21 .%7"#&$.F7$(#/ $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 $+%
0-7$ $+-$ ($ +-& #" 6%-#(#/; `Q9".#" )XX)B <D@a &%%6& -$ "#7% +13%.H"2(7
-#9 6(&32-7%9>D
E".% (63".$-#$ $+-# - 2($%.-.1S+(&$".(7-2 3-.2"F. /-6% 9%9(7-$%9 $" &(/+$S
(#/ $+% $.F% #(+(2(&$B +"8%'%.B (& $+% .%-2(&-$("# $+-$ $+% &".$ "0 %V3.%&&('%
#%/-$('($1 ". #(+(2(&6 8+(7+ !.($7+2%1 -#9 Q9".#" &"6%$(6%& &%%6 $" +-'%
(# 6(#9 (&B -& &F7+B (63"&&(H2% h $+-$ "#% 7-##"$ -'"(9 -$$.(HF$(#/ - &%#&%B
."2%B ". 0F#7$("# $" $+% 6%-#(#/2%&&B -#9 $+%.%H1 #%/-$(#/ ($B -& [%..(9- +-&
"H&%.'%9 (# +(& 9(&7F&&("# "0 Z-$-(22% -#9 $+% 5/%#%.-2 %7"#"61;> [%..(9%'"T%& 8+-$ Z-$-(22% 7-22& $+% 56(#". /-6%;4 5*+% 6(#". 32-1 7"#&(&$(#/ (#
&$(22 -$$.(HF$(#/ - 6%-#(#/B 8($+(# 9(&7"F.&%B $" $+% -H&%#7% "0 6%-#(#/;
`[%..(9- )X?)B <N<a] 5L$ K$, 5*&$,) /"&%*%#9&# 9b 9##)*+,$) $&/")$ ,& %$&%R .9&% 4$
.*%/",)%R 9b 4N9+%$&/$ .$ %$&%N `[%..(9- )XNCB @?Da -#9 /"%& "# $" 3"(#$ "F$ $+-$
0". $+(& .%-&"# $+% 5-H&"2F$% #"#S9(&7"F.&%; (& -# (63"&&(H(2($1 $" 8+(7+ -#1
3-.$(7F2-. 9(&7"F.&% 7-# 9" 6".% $+-# -7T#"82%9/% ($& .%2-$("#B (# - 0-&+("#
8+(7+ Z-$-(22% 9%%6& 5&"'%.%(/#;4 5*+% 8.($(#/ "0 &"'%.%(/#$1 32-7%& 9(&S
7"F.&% *& )$49#*"& $" -H&"2F$% #"#S9(&7"F.&%> K(T% /%#%.-2 %7"#"61B ($ (& #"$
$+% 2"&& "0 6%-#(#/B HF$B -& 8% +-'% RF&$ .%-9B $+% 5.%2-$("# $" $+% 2"&& "0
6%-#(#/;; `(H(9>B <CIa] 5LN$M/)*#,)$ .$ %",F$)9*&$#$M 5$# 4$ .*%/",)% $& )9II")# 9F$/
4$ &"&J.*%/",)% 9+%"4,Z ("55$ 4N$M/"&"5*$ ?$M&$M)94$R $44$ &N$%# I9% 49 I$)#$ .$ %$&%R
59*%R &",% F$&"&% .$ 4$ 4*)$R 55)9II")# 9b 49 I$)#$ .$ %$&%;; ; `(H(9>B @XCa> *+%&% $%.6&
H%-. - /.%-$ .%&%6H2-#7% $" Z%7T%$$;& )XDX &$-$%6%#$ "# $+% $-&T "0 $+%
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 G9#@ <@C
56-T%.;4 5*+% %V3.%&&("# $+-$ $+%.% (& #"$+(#/ $" %V3.%&&B #"$+(#/ 8($+
8+(7+ $" %V3.%&&B #"$+(#/ 0."6 8+(7+ $" %V3.%&&B #" 3"8%. $" %V3.%&&B #"
9%&(.% $" %V3.%&&B $"/%$+%. 8($+ $+% "H2(/-$("# $" %V3.%&&; `Z%7T%$$ )X?D-B
)@Xa> O+%# ($ (& &F//%&$%9 $+-$ -.$ 7"F29 (# 7"#&%_F%#7% H%7"6% 5%V3.%&&('%
"0 $+% (63"&&(H(2($1 $" %V3.%&&; Z%7T%$$ .%R%7$& &F7+ -# (9%- -& -# 5(#/%#("F&
6%$+"9; "0 02%%(#/ $+% 5F2$(6-$% 3%#F.1; `(H(9>B )D@a -#9 .%0F&%& $" .%9F7%
$+% (63"&&(H(2($1 "0 %V3.%&&("# ($&%20 $" -# %V3.%&&('% 5"77-&("#;> W."6 $+(&
7"#$.-9(7$("#B Z%7T%$$ (& 0".7%9 $" 7"#72F9% $+-$ $" H% -# -.$(&$ (& 5$" 0-(2; HF$
+% $+%# (66%9(-$%21 -2&" .%0F&%& $" -22"8 - 50(9%2($1 $" 0-(2F.%; `(H(9>B )DJa $"
H%7"6% $+% #%8 $"F7+&$"#% "0 $+% $.F% -.$(&$> *+% 0".7% 8($+ 8+(7+ Z%7T%$$;&
8".T &$.('%& $" 6-(#$-(# $+(& .%2-$("#&+(3 $" - 2"&& 8+(7+ 8"F29 #"$ H%
(66%9(-$%21 .%7F3%.-$%9 -& - 3"&($('% '-2F% .%#9%.& Q9".#";& .%-9(#/ "0 ($
0-7(2% (# 7"63-.(&"#> Q#9 &%%# (# $+(& 2(/+$B Q9".#" -#9 !.($7+2%1;& _F%&$("#
-& $" 8+%$+%. Z%7T%$$ (& - #(+(2(&$ (& -#&8%.%9 (# ($& '%.1 -&T(#/> Z%7T%$$ (&
7%.$-(#21 #"$ - #(+(2(&$ `8+-$%'%. $+-$ 8"F29 H%a HF$B -& (& $+% 7-&% 8($+
Z-$-(22%B 6F7+ "0 +(& 8".T 7-# H% &%%# -& $+% 6"F.#(#/ "0 $+% (63"&&(H(2($1
"0 $+% #(+(2(&6 $" 8+(7+ ($ -&3(.%&> Z%7T%$$ F#9%.&$""9 $+% 9(-2%7$(7 8%22 (#
$+% D$H#% 2") !"#'*&?B 2-6%#$(#/B 5> > > -+ (0 #" 8%.% 7"#$%#$ $" 7F$ 1%&;& $+."-$
-#9 #%'%. 7F$ ($& "8#; `Z%7T%$$ )XNCB ))@h)DaB -#9 2(T% Z-$-(22%;&B +(& 8".T
&$.('%& $" -7T#"82%9/% ($& .%2-$("#&+(3 $" - #%/-$('($1B - 2"&&B - 5#"$+(#/;
8+(7+ ($ 7-# #%'%. 3.%&%#$ ". %6H"91 -& &F7+> 5W". $+% "#21 8-1 "#% 7-#
&3%-T "0 #"$+(#/ (& $" &3%-T "0 ($ -& $+"F/+ ($ 8%.% &"6%$+(#/; Z%7T%$$ #"$%&
(# P9## `Z%7T%$$ )X?)B CCaB -#9 ($ (& $+% 7"#&7("F&#%&& "0 '("2-$(#/ - #%/-S
$('($1 8+(7+ H1 9%0(#($("# 7-##"$ H% (#&7.(H%9B -#9 #"$ - 2"/"7%#$.(7 &F&3(S
7("# "0 2-#/F-/%;& H%$.-1-2 "0 $+% (9%- -#9 $+% Y9%-2B 8+(7+ 6"$('-$%& $+%
6-#1 6(&/('(#/& 7"#7%.#(#/ $+% (#$%/.($1 "0 $+% %V3.%&&('% -7$ 0"F#9
$+."F/+"F$ Z%7T%$$>
Y# 8+-$ 0"22"8&B $+%#B .-$+%. $+-# 0"7F& "# $+% '-.("F& Z%7T%$$(-# 5#"$+S
(#/&;B Y 8(22 -$$%63$ $" 8".T 0."6 $+% "H'%.&%B -#9B #"$ -&T(#/ 8+1 (# Z%7T%$$
$+%.% &+"F29 H% #"$+(#/ .-$+%. $+-# &"6%$+(#/ -&T (#&$%-9 8+-$ (# $+% %#9
(& - _F($% &(6(2-. _F%&$("#4 0". Z%7T%$$B 7-# $+%.% H% %#"F/+i 5U#"F/+; (& $+%
$($2% "0 - &+".$ 3."&% 8".T 0."6 $+% &(V$(%& -#9 7"#&(&$& "0 $+% H(A-..%B
F#8".2921 .%6(#(&7%#7%& "0 -# -33-.%#$21 0%6-2%J #-..-$".;& 7"66"# 2(0%
8($+ -# F#7"66F#(7-$('% 7"63-#("#B +-20S+F&H-#9B +-20S0-$+%.B 8+" +-20
-H9F7$&B +-20 -9"3$& +%. `5Y 7-##"$ +-'% H%%# 6".% $+-# &(V 8+%# +% $""T
6% H1 $+% +-#9; `Z%7T%$$ )XCDB JDa (& $+% %#$(.% 9%&7.(3$("# "0 $+%(. 6%%$(#/a
"#21 $" +-'% +%. 2%-'% +(6 1%-.& 2-$%.B (# -# (#7(9%#$ 8+(7+ (& 3%.+-3& "#21 6(&F#9%.&$-#9(#/> Q& 6-#1 7.($(7& +-'% #"$(7%9BN $+% $($2% ($&%20 6(..".& $+%
6-#1 -6H('-2%#7%& "0 $+% #-..-$('% (# H%(#/ 9('(9%9 H%$8%%# 7"#$.-9(7$".1
6%-#(#/&4 5%#"F/+; 7-# %V3.%&& %($+%. &F00(7(%#71 ". &F.0%($B &-$(&0-7$("# ".
9(&/F&$> *+."F/+"F$ $+% &+".$ $-2%B ($ (& +-.9 $" 9%7(9% (0 $+% #-..-$". (&
(6321(#/ $+-$ +%. 6%-/.%B 9%6%-#%9 2(0% 8-& #%'%.$+%2%&& 5%#"F/+; 0".
+%.B ". $+-$ #"8 &+% +-& 9%0(#($('%21 5+-9 %#"F/+;B +%. 0(#-2 %V72-6-$("#
"0 $+% 8".9 H%(#/ -#"$+%. '-.(-$("# "# 5L+ -22 $" %#9;> Q#9 /('%# $+(&
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<@? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
(#9%$%.6(#-71B %_F-221 $."FH2%9 (& $+% &$-$F& "0 $+% (."#(7 "&7(22-$("#& ($
3%.6($&> [" 8% .%-9 $+% $%V$ -& (6321(#/ $+-$ $+% #-..-$". &+"F29 +-'%
&-(9 5%#"F/+j; .-$+%. $+-# -77%3$ +%. 2"$B ". $+-$ "# $+% "$+%. +-#9 &+%
&+"F29 +-'% .%-2(&%9 $+-$ $+(& 8-& (#9%%9 5%#"F/+; h -22 -#1"#% 7-# -&Ti *+%
$%V$ 3.%&%#$& 2($$2% "77-&("# 0". &%7F.(#/ - 0(.6 3F.7+-&% "# %($+%. &(9%B -#9
3%.+-3& 8+-$ #%%9& $" H% %63+-&(&%9 (& $+-$ $+% $%#&("# H%$8%%# $+% &%#&%
"0 5%#"F/+; -& &F.0%($ -#9 $+-$ -& &-$(&0-7$("# 0F#7$("#& +%.% -& 6".% $+-# &(632% -6H(/F($1B &F//%&$(#/ -& ($ 9"%& $+-$ #"$ =9&#*&? -#1$+(#/ -#16".%B
$" H% #"$ 8-#$(#/B $" +-'% %#"F/+B (& -28-1& -2&" #"$ $" 8-#$ 9&C#'*&?
-#16".%B $" +-'% +-9 %#"F/+> O+-$ Z%7T%$$ %V-6(#%& +%.% (& $+% F#%-&1
7"+-H($-$("# "0 &%20S&F00(7(%#71 -#9 6-&$%.1 8($+ $+% 9%-$+ 9.('%> *+% &-$(&S
0-7$("# "0 9%&(.% (& "0 7"F.&% ($& "8# 9%-$+ -#9 $+F& "F.&B $+-$ (&B &"#'*&?R
8+(2% 9%&(.% ($&%20 (& (#%'($-H21 (#7"632%$("#B 9('(&("#B 9%3%#9%#7% -#9 2-7T>
*+% _F%&$("# Z%7T%$$ -&T& $+."F/+"F$ +(& 8".TB - _F%&$("# 8+(7+ 2(#T& +(6
(#$(6-$%21 $" $+% 3."H2%6-$(7& -#9 +(&$".1 "0 #(+(2(&6B (&4 8+-$ 6(/+$ ($
6%-# #"$ $" 8-#$ -#1$+(#/i *".$F.%9 H1 2-7TB 8"F29 -# %#9 $" 9%&(.% (6321
- &".$ "0 =(%$A&7+%-# 6-&$%.1B ". 8"F29 ($ "# $+% 7"#$.-.1 (6321 $+% %_F-221
=(%$A&7+%-# 8(22S2%&&#%&& -#9 -3-$+1 $+-$ =(%$A&7+% %V7".(-$%& F#9%. $+%
#-6% 5ZF99+(&6;iC *" 3F$ ($ -#"$+%. 8-1B (& $+% #(+(2(&$ 3"&($("# - .%&%#$0F2
-#9 9(&&-$(&0(%9 5#"$+(#/ (& %#"F/+;B 9%3.%7(-$(#/ -22 ($ %#7"F#$%.&B ". .-$+%.
(& ($ $+% %V$.%6% 3-&&('($1 "0 &"#'*&? (& %#"F/+i Q& Z%7T%$$;& Y.(&+ 0".%H%-.
L&7-. O(29% 3"(#$%9 "F$B 5*+% "#21 8-1 $" /%$ .(9 "0 - $%63$-$("# (& $" 1(%29
$" ($; `O(29% )X?JB <@aB -#9 O(29%;& &7-#9-2"F& 9%7-9%#7% .%&(9%& 3.%7(&%21 (#
+(& +-&$% #"$ &" 6F7+ $" /.-$(01 9%&(.% HF$ $" $+%.%H1 -##F2 ($> =(+(2(&6B
3%.+-3&B (& #"$+(#/ "$+%. $+-# $+% &-$(&0-7$("# "0 9%&(.%B ($& 7"632%$("#> Q#9
5U#"F/+; (& #"$+(#/ "$+%. $+-# -# (#_F(.1 (#$" $+% &3-7(#/&B 9(&$-#7%&B -#9
9%2-1& 8+(7+ 6-T% 9%&(.% 3"&&(H2% -#9 8+(7+ 9%&(.% &%%T& $" -##F2>
Y0 5U#"F/+; (& $+% &$".1 "0 $+% &+".$S7(.7F($(#/ "0 9%&(.%B ($ -2&" F#0"29& -& /.F%2(#/ (#'%&$(/-$("# "0 $+% 3&17+(7 %7"#"6(%& "0 +(%.-.7+(7-2 .%2-$("#S
&+(3&B -& 2-7"#(7-221 9%2('%.%9 0."6 $+% -6H('-2%#$ -#9 H%.%0$ &FH-2$%.#
3"&($("#> *+(& -6H('-2%#7% (& &" 6-&$%.0F221 6-(#$-(#%9 $+-$ (# - /%#%.-221
H.(22(-#$ -.$(72% "# Z%7T%$$B Q2-(# Z-9("F 7-# 8($+ #" 9(&7%.#(H2% (."#1
_F-2(01 $+(& &$".1 -& 5%#$(.%21 7"#&%7.-$%9 $" 2"'%; `Z-9("F )XX<B @N)a h 72-(6 3-&&-/%& 2(T% $+% 0"22"8(#/ 8"F29 &%%6 -$ 2%-&$ $" #F-#7%4
Y 9(9 -22 +% 9%&(.%9> Y 9%&(.%9 ($ $""> W". +(6> O+%#%'%. +% 9%&(.%9 &"6%S
$+(#/ &" 9(9 Y> M% "#21 +-9 $" &-1 8+-$ $+(#/> O+%# +% 9(9#;$ 9%&(.%
-#1$+(#/ #%($+%. 9(9 Y> Y# $+(& 8-1 Y 9(9#;$ 2('% 8($+"F$ 9%&(.%&> Y0 +% +-9
9%&(.%9 &"6%$+(#/ 0". 6% Y 8"F29 +-'% 9%&(.%9 ($ $""> M-33(#%&& 0".
%V-632% ". 0-6%> Y "#21 +-9 $+% 9%&(.%& +% 6-#(0%&$%9> ZF$ +% 6F&$
+-'% 6-#(0%&$%9 $+%6 -22> Q22 +(& 9%&(.%& -#9 #%%9&> O+%# +% 8-& &(2%#$
+% 6F&$ +-'% H%%# 2(T% 6%> O+%# +% $"29 6% $" 2(7T +(& 3%#(& Y +-&$%#%9
$" 9" &"> Y 9.%8 &-$(&0-7$("# 0."6 ($> O% 6F&$ +-'% +-9 $+% &-6% &-$(&0-7S
$("#&> *+% &-6% #%%9& -#9 $+% &-6% &-$(&0-7$("#&>
`Z%7T%$$ )XCDB J@a
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 G9#@ <@X
*+(& '%.1 .(7+ 3-&&-/% (&B $" &$-.$ 8($+B - .%9F7$("#4 0". $+% #-..-$".B $+%
%#$(.% 0(%29 "0 9%&(.% (& .%9F7%9 $" $+% 9%&(.% "0 $+% #-6%2%&& "29 6-#> [%&(.%
(& "#21 -#9 %V72F&('%21 '*% 9%&(.%B 2%-'(#/ #" .""6 0". $+% %V(&$%#7% "0 -#1
9%&(.% "F$&(9% $+(& 0(%294 5O+%# +% 9(9#;$ 9%&(.% -#1$+(#/ #%($+%. 9(9 Y;> ZF$
$+(& .%9F7$("# (& $+%# (66%9(-$%21 &FHR%7$%9 $" - .%S%V3-#&("#B 8($+ $+%
.-$+%. &(#(&$%. %'"7-$("# "0 $+% H.%-9$+ -#9 6-/#($F9% "0 $+% "29 6-#;&
8-#$(#/4 5Y "#21 +-9 $+% 9%&(.%& +% 6-#(0%&$%9> ZF$ +% 6F&$ +-'% 6-#(0%&$%9
$+%6 -22;> Q& $+% #-..-$". +%.&%20 &-1&B &+% 9"%& #"$ 2('% =*#'",# 9%&(.%B HF$ (&
.-$+%. 8.-7T%9 -#9 "'%.8+%26%9 H1 9%&(.%& 8+(7+ #%'%.$+%2%&& -.% #"$
%#$(.%21 +%.&> Z%7T%$$ +%.% /('%& F& -# -22%/".1 "0 $+% &".$ "0 #-.7(&&(&$(7
9(&32-7%6%#$ "0$%# &T%$7+%9 H1 W.%F9B #"$ "#21 8+%# +% 2-7"#(7-221 &F/S
/%&$& $+-$4 5> > > ($ &%%6& '%.1 %'(9%#$ $+-$ -#"$+%. 3%.&"#;& #-.7(&&(&6 +-& /.%-$ -$$.-7$("# 0". $+"&% 8+" +-'% .%#"F#7%9 3-.$ "0 $+%(. "8# #-.7(&&(&6
-#9 -.% (# &%-.7+ "0 "HR%7$S2"'%; `W.%F9 )X?DB ?<h@a HF$ %'%# 6".% &" 8+%#
+% $-2T& -H"F$ %/"(7 9(6(#F$("# (# %V$.%6% 7-&%& "0 5H%(#/ (# 2"'%;4
!"#$%63".-#%"F&21 8($+ $+(& 59%'"$("#; "0 $+% %/" $" $+% "HR%7$ > > > $+%
0F#7$("#& -22"$$%9 $" $+% %/" (9%-2 %#$(.%21 7%-&% $" "3%.-$%> *+% 7.($(7(&6
%V%.7(&%9 H1 $+-$ -/%#71 (& &(2%#$m %'%.1$+(#/ $+-$ $+% "HR%7$ 9"%& -#9 -&T&
0". (& .(/+$ -#9 H2-6%2%&&> !"#&7(%#7% +-& #" -332(7-$("# $" -#1$+(#/ $+-$
(& 9"#% 0". $+% &-T% "0 $+% "HR%7$m (# $+% H2(#9#%&& "0 2"'% .%6".&%2%&&#%&&
(& 7-..(%9 $" $+% 3($7+ "0 7.(6%> *+% 8+"2% &($F-$("# 7-# H% 7"632%$%21
&F66-.(&%9 (# - 0".6F2-4 D'$ "+K$/# '9% +$$& I,# *& #'$ I49/$ "2 #'$ $?" *.$94>
`W.%F9 )X?JB )D@hDB :)$,.N% $5I'9%*%a
,F7+ - &7+%6-B (# 8+(7+ $+% 2"'% "HR%7$ H%7"6%& $+% &"F.7% -#9 6%-&F.% "0
-22 9%&(.%B '-2F%B -#9 %'%# 6".-2($1B %#$(.%21 %.-&(#/ $+% (#9%3%#9%#7% "0 $+%
%/"B &%%6& $" 7"..%&3"#9 #%-$21 $" $+% &($F-$("# %2-H".-$%9 H1 Z%7T%$$B 1%$ 7.F7(-2 3."'(&" 6F&$ H% -99%94 -77".9(#/ $" W.%F9B $+(& (#$%#&% -#9 (63"'S
%.(&+(#/ (9%-2(&-$("# (& "#21 3"&&(H2% H%7-F&% ($ (& I)$/*%$4C "&$N% "=& &9)/*%J
%*%5B $+% H"F#92%&&#%&& "0 "#%;& "8# &%20S2"'% -#9 9%&(.%B 8+(7+ (& 9(&32-7%9
"#$" $+% (9%-2(&%9 "HR%7$ (# $+% 32-7% "0 $+% %/"h(9%-2> *+% #-..-$".;& &%%6S
(#/ .%#F#7(-$("# 7-# $+F& H% .%-9 -2&" -& -# %#".6"F& #-.7(&&(&$(7 -##(+(2-S
$("# "0 $+% H%2"'%9 "HR%7$B 8+" %V(&$& "#21 -& - &7.%%# "0 3."R%7$("# 0". $+%
#-..-$".;& "8# 9(&32-7%9 #-.7(&&(&6> Q& $+% 3-$+& "0 8(22B 3"8%.B -#9 '("2%#7%
H%7"6% 6".% 7"632%VB 8% &%% #"$ "#21 +"8 Z%7T%$$ .%S.%-9& W.%F9B HF$ -2&"
$+% %V$%#$ $" 8+(7+ W.%F9;& $%V$ .%S6"H(2(&%& =(%$A&7+%;&B (# 3-.$(7F2-. (#
.%2-$("# $" $+% 8+"2% 3."H2%6-$(7 "0 )$%%$&#*5$&#>
M"8%'%.B (0 $+% #-..-$".;& &FHR%7$('% &$-#7% 7-# $+F& H% &%%# #"$ "#21 -& .%#F#7(-$("# "0 9%&(.% HF$ -2&" -& - 3."$%7$("# "0 ($ h - 3."$%7$("# 8+"&%
%#".6"F& %00(7-71 (& (# 0-7$ -7T#"82%9/%9 `5M% 6F&$ +-'% 6-#(0%&$%9 $+%6
-22;a h 8% 6F&$ #%'%.$+%2%&& -'"(9 &%%(#/ $+(& -& - &(632% 9(-2%7$(7-2 .%&"2FS
$("# "0 $+% _F%&$("# "0 9%&(.% -#9 #-.7(&&(&6B -#9 0"7F& "# $+% .%6-(#9%.
-#9 (6H-2-#7% 7.%-$%9 H1 $+(& #-.7(&&(&$(7 9(&32-7%6%#$B H1 $+(& $.-#&0%. "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<DI !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
-/%#71> Q0$%. -22B 9%&3($% +%. (632(7-$("# (# $+% 7"F32%;& 91#-6(7& "0 9%&(.%B
$+% #-..-$". .F%0F221 #"$%& $+-$ #"$+(#/ 8-& %'%. 9%&(.%9 2") '$)4 5M-33(#%&&
0". %V-632% ". 0-6%;> *+% _F%&$("# $+%# (&B 8+-$ (& 2"&$ (# ". 7+-#/%9 H1 $+(&
9%$"F. 8+(7+ 7+""&%& $" 2"7-$% 9%&(.% (# $+% "$+%.B -#9 +"8 7-# ($& ."F$% H%
6%-&F.%9i O+-$ 9"%& ($ 6%-# $" H% F#-H2% $" 3"&($ "#%&%20 -& H%(#/ "# $+%
)$/$*F*&? %#9 "0 9%&(.%B "# $+% "$+%. &(9% "0 $+% 3.%3"&($("# 50".;i O($+"F$
F&(#/ $+% $%.6 53."R%7$("#;B =(%$A&7+% (# 0-7$ 2(#T& #(+(2(&6 3.%7(&%21 8($+
$+% +-H($ "0 &"F.7(#/ 9%&(.% (# -# 5"F$&(9%;4
*+% #(+(2(&$(7 _F%&$("# 50". 8+-$i; (& .""$%9 (# $+% "29 +-H($ "0 &F33"&(#/
$+-$ $+% /"-2 6F&$ H% 3F$ F3B /('%#B 9%6-#9%9 2)"5 ",#%*.$ h H1 &"6%
%,I$)',59& 9,#'")*#C> M-'(#/ F#2%-.#%9 0-($+ (# $+-$B "#% &$(22 0"22"8& $+%
"29 +-H($ -#9 &%%T& 9&"#'$) -F$+".($1 $+-$ 7-# %I$9; ,&/"&.*#*"&944C -#9
/"559&. /"-2& -#9 $-&T&>
`=(%$A&7+% )XN?B )Na
M"8%'%.B (# - 6"'% 8+(7+ 3-.-22%2& W.%F9;& $."3(&6&B $+(& #%8 5"F$&(9%
-F$+".($1; 8(22 H% 32-7%9 3.%7(&%21 "# $+% (#&(9%4 5*+% -F$+".($1 "0 /"&%/*$&/$
#"8 &$%3& F3 0."#$ `$+% 6".% %6-#7(3-$%9 "#% (& 0."6 $+%"2"/1B $+% 6".%
(63%.-$('(&$(7 6".-2($1 H%7"6%&a > > >; `(H(9>B )Na>? Y# $+(& 3-&&-/% -$ 2%-&$B
57"#&7(%#7%; 0". =(%$A&7+% (& #"$+(#/ HF$ -# 5"F$&(9%; 8($+(#B -# (#'-&('%
-2(%# 3-.-&($%B 8+(7+ &+"F29 3.%&F6-H21 H% $+."8# "F$ "#7% -#9 0". -22> *+(&
(& $+% &166%$.(7-2 "H'%.&% "0 $+% 9%&(.(#/ %7"#"61 8% &%% (# 5U#"F/+;B
8+%.% ($ -33%-.& $+-$ -# 5(#&(9%; +-& H%%# 3."R%7$%9 8($+"F$> Q#9 (#9%%9B
(# $+% 3-&&-/% _F"$%9 -H"'% 8+-$ (& 6"&$ 9(&$F.H(#/ (& $+% '("2%#$B _F(%$
&$.(9%#71 8($+ 8+(7+ $+% #-..-$('% '"(7% (#&(&$& "# 3.%&%.'(#/ ($& (9%#$(0(7-S
$("# 8($+ $+(& 3."R%7$("#> W". 8+-$ (& "H&7%#% (# $+% 3+.-&%B 5O+%# +% $"29
6% $" 2(7T +(& 3%#(& Y +-&$%#%9 $" 9" &"; (& #"$ $+% -7$B #". %'%# $+% 0-7$ $+-$
$+% .%_F%&$ (& 9%2('%.%9 -& - 7"66-#9B HF$ .-$+%. $+% '9%#$ 8($+ 8+(7+ ($ (&
-77"632(&+%9B $+% 3.%7(3($-$("# (# /.-$(01(#/ $+% 9%&(.% "0 $+% "$+%.B 6-9%
%'%# 72%-.%. (# Z%7T%$$;& ".(/(#-2 W.%#7+ '%.&("# 5tF-#9 (2 6% 9(&-($ 9% 2F(
2%e7+%. 2% 3%e#(& R% 6% K$#9*% 9%&&F&; `%63+-&(& 6(#%m 2($%.-221B 5Y $+.%8 61&%20
"# ($;B HF$ $+% '%.H 5R%$%.; 3.%&%.'%& 7"##"$-$("#& "0 0-22(#/ -#9 9."33(#/a>X Q&
8% +-'% -2.%-91 &%%#B 8+%# 8% .%-9 5+%; 8% 6F&$ -2&" -&T $" - 7%.$-(# %V$%#$
58+"i;B HF$ &$(22B 8+-$ #%%9& $" H% #"$%9 +%.% (& $+% 2"7-$("# "0 9%&(.% -& &F7+4
#"$ (# $+% -7$B #"$ (# $+% "$+%.;& 9%&(.% 0". $+% -7$B HF$ .-$+%. (# $+% +-&$%#(#/
$" 3%.0".6 ($B (# "#%;& .%7"(2(#/ $" %6H.-7% $+% "$+%.#%&& "0 $+% 7"66-#9> *"
0F221 /-F/% 8+-$ 0". Z%7T%$$ (& 5%#"F/+; 8% 6F&$ 6%-&F.% $+(& 6"6%#$ "0
+-&$%B $+(& 6"'%6%#$ 8+(7+ ($&%20 H"$+ 6%-&F.%& -#9 -##F2& $+% &3-7%
H%$8%%# $+% -&T(#/ -#9 $+% -7$B $+% 5"#*"& 0."6 7"66-#9 $" -7$("#> [%&(.%
+%.% (& #"$ &(6321 '9%#$B HF$ '9%#$&*&?B $+% -9'%#$ "0 +-&$%> ,+"F29 8% 2(#/%.
"# $+(& +-&$%#(#/B 8% 6-1 +%-. ($ -& $+% -00(.6-$("# "0 %#"F/+B $+% %#-7$S
6%#$ "0 $+% &F00(7(%#71 "0 $+% 9%6-#9 "0 $+% "$+%.B "0 $+% "$+%. 9%6-#9>
W". =(%$A&7+%B (# 0-7$B 5%#"F/+; 7-# H% ($&%20 - T(#9 "0 -00(.6-$("#> *+%
3-&&-/% 0."6 8+(7+ Y 9.-8 61 %3(/.-3+ 6%.($& -# %V$%#9%9 7($-$("#4
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 G9#@ <D)
E-# +-& "0$%# +-9 %#"F/+m $+%.% -.% -7$F-2 %3(9%6(7& "0 +-'(#/ +-9
%#"F/+ `-& -."F#9 )@D?B -$ $+% $(6% "0 $+% 9-#7% "0 9%-$+am HF$ %'%#
$+(& #-F&%-B $+(& 8%-.(#%&&B $+(& 9(&/F&$ 8($+ +(6&%20 h -22 $+(& HF.&$& 0."6
+(6 8($+ &F7+ '("2%#7% $+-$ ($ -$ "#7% H%7"6%& - #%8 0%$$%.> *+% =" +%
&-1& $" 2(0% H.(#/& $" 2(/+$B -& (0 H1 6-/(7B -# -HF#9-#7% "0 $%#9%. o%&%&m
%'%# 8+%# +% =",&.% +(6&%20B $+(& 6-&$%. "0 9%&$.F7$("#B "0 &%20S9%&$.F7S
$("# h $+% '%.1 8"F#9 ($&%20 -0$%.8-.9 7"63%2& +(6 #" 4*F$>
`=(%$A&7+% )XNXB )<)a
O($+ .%/-.9 $" &F7+ - 3-&&-/%B Z%7T%$$;& 5(0 #" 8%.% 7"#$%#$ $" 7F$ 1%&;& $+."-$
-#9 #%'%. 7F$ ($& "8#; .%'%.H%.-$%& &F//%&$('%21> Y# $+% 5^%#%-2"/1;
=(%$A&7+% (& 3"(#$(#/ $" $+% 6-##%. (# 8+(7+ $+% &(7T#%&&B 8%-.(#%&& -#9
8"F#9 H%7"6% $+%6&%2'%& - 3.(#7(3-2 "0 -00(.6-$("# h $+% -&7%$(7 (9%-2B H1
8+(7+ $+% )$%%$&#*5$&# "0 $+% 8%-T (& $F.#%9 H-7T -/-(#&$ $+%6&%2'%& .-$+%.
$+-# $"8-.9& "$+%.&B -& $+%1 -.% 2%9 $" (9%#$(01 $+%6&%2'%& -& $+% /F(2$1
&"F.7% "0 $+%(. 6(&0".$F#% -#9 &F00%.(#/> *+% 6%-#(#/ H%&$"8%9 F3"#
$+%(. &F00%.(#/ $+F& H%7"6%& -#"$+%. 0%$$%. H(#9(#/ $+%6 $" 2(0%> Y$ (& (#
$+(& 7"#$%V$ $+-$ $+% Z%7T%$$(-# 56%-#(#/2%&&#%&&; 8+(7+ !.($7+2%1 .(/+$21
7+-63("#& $-T%& "# ($& 0F22 &(/#(0(7-#7%B (# $+% &%#&% "0 - .%0F&-2 $" .%9%%6
&F00%.(#/ $+."F/+ $+% -$$.(HF$("# "0 - &F3%.(". 6%-#(#/ ". '-2F% $" ($ 8($+(#
- 2-./%. &$.F7$F.% "0 &%#&%> U#"F/+ (& &(6321 %#"F/+B - &$-$%6%#$ 8+(7+ (& 0-.
0."6 &(632% ". %'%# %#$(.%21 3"#9%.-H2%B -& ($& "8# 0".6F2-$("# 9%6"#S
&$.-$%&> kF&$ -& =(%$A&7+%;& 5%#"F/+; %V(&$& (# - 3%.3%$F-2 -#9 -26"&$ (#%'(S
$-H2% &2(9% H%$8%%# =" -#9 $%#9%. o%&%&B &" Z%7T%$$;& 7-##"$ +%23 HF$ 8-#9%.
H%$8%%# - 7"F.-/%"F& .%7"/#($("# "0 &%#&%2%&&#%&& -#9 $+% -&7%$(7 3"&($("#
8+(7+ 8"F29 .%7F3%.-$% $+(& 7"F.-/% -& - 3"&($('% '-2F%> Q& 8% &+-22 &%%
&+".$21B Z%7T%$$;& .(/"F. 8(22 2%-9 +(6 &$(22 0F.$+%. h $" $+% 9(&6-#$2(#/
%'%# "0 $+% 7"#&"2-$("# "0 #"$ &%%T(#/ 7"#&"2-$("#>
Y# 5U#"F/+;B - .%7F..%#$ (6-/% (& $+-$ "0 $+% 02"8%.& 8+(7+ $+% #-..-$".
9%&7.(H%& -& - 9"6(#-#$ %2%6%#$ (# +%. %#92%&& 8-#9%.(#/& 8($+ +%.
(#0(.6 7"63-#("#> Q& +% 7-# "#21 8-2T +F#7+%9 "'%.B +(& %#$(.% 5+".(A"#;
(& $+% /."F#9 +% $.%-9&4 5*(#1 6"'(#/ 7-.3%$ "0 $F.0 -#9 $.-632%9 02"8%.&;
`Z%7T%$$ )XCDB JJam 2-$%.B $" /('% - 0%8 "$+%. %V-632%&B 8% 0(#9 5ZF$ +%
8(&+%9 %'%.1$+(#/ $" H% +%-.9 (#72F9(#/ $+% %R-7F2-$("#& -#9 H."T%#
3-$%.#"&$%.& $+-$ +% 3"F.%9 "F$ $" $+% 02"8%.& -$ +(& 0%%$; `(H(9>B JJa -#9
5Y &%% $+% 02"8%.& -$ 61 0%%$ -#9 ($;& $+% "$+%.& Y &%%> *+"&% 8% $."9 9"8#
8($+ %_F-2 &$%3> Y$ (& $.F% $+%1 -.% $+% &-6%; `(H(9>B JNa> M-'(#/ H%/F# +%.
$-2%B 5Q22 $+-$ /"%& H%0".% 0"./%$; `(H(9>B J@aB .%0%..(#/B -33-.%#$21B $" -22 $+-$
3.%7%9%9 +%. 6%%$(#/ 8($+ +%. 7"63-#("#a &+% %#9& +%. $-2% (# - &(6(2-.
'%(#4
O% 2('%9 "# 02"8%.&> ," 6F7+ 0". &F&$%#-#7%> M% +-2$%9 -#9 8($+"F$
+-'(#/ $" &$""3 7-F/+$ F3 - +-#90F2 "0 3%$-2&> *+%# 6"'%9 6F#7+(#/
"#> *+%1 +-9 "# $+% 8+"2% - 7-26(#/ -7$("#> O% 8%.% "# $+% 8+"2% 7-26>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<D< !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
B9&*$4 G9#@ <D@
*+% _F%&$("# $" H% -&T%9 +%.% (& $+-$ "0 $+% &$-$F& "0 $+(& '("2%#$ /%&$F.% "0
%.-&F.%B -#9 "0 $+-$ 8+(7+ 8($+&$-#9& ($> *8" 7"#$.-9(7$".1 (#$%.3.%$-$("#&
3.%&%#$ $+%6&%2'%&> W(.&$B "#% 6(/+$ -./F% $+-$ $+(& %.-&F.% (632(%& $+-$ $+%
#-..-$". +-& 5+-9 %#"F/+; -#9 +-& 7+"&%# $" -##(+(2-$% -#9 #F22(01> Y# $+(&
7-&%B $8" 0F.$+%. _F%&$("#& H%7"6% (#%'($-H2%4 0(.&$B (& $+(& -7$("# $" H% $-T%#
-& (# &"6% 8-1 2(H%.-$(#/B ". .-$+%. (& ($ &%20S9%&$.F7$('%B -#9 &%7"#9B 8+1 9"
$+% 02"8%.& .%&(&$ $+(& 6"'%6%#$i *+% &%7"#9 (#$%.3.%$-$("# 8"F29 (#&$%-9
0"7F& "# .%7"#7(2(-$("#B -./F(#/ $+-$ $+% #-..-$". +-& #"8 9%$%.6(#%9 8+-$
0". +%. (& 5%#"F/+;> *" &(6321 "33"&% $+%&% $8" .%-9(#/& (& 3%.+-3& $" 6(&&
$+% 3"(#$ h Z%7T%$$;& $%V$ +%.% -&T& F& $" $+(#T $+."F/+ $+% &F&3%#&("# "0 $+%
9(&$(#7$("# H%$8%%# .%7"#7(2(-$("# -#9 .F3$F.% 8+(7+ ($ %#-7$&> O+-$ &F.S
'('%& %.-&F.% +%.% (& $+% 02"8%.&B "0 7"F.&%B HF$ 02"8%.& 8+(7+ +-'% H%%#
2($%.-221 3%.'%.$%9B ". $F.#%9 -8-1 0."6 $+%(. +-H($F-2 0F#7$("#4 #" 2"#/%.
$+% #"#0F#7$("#-2 -%&$+%$(7 "HR%7$ I9) $H/$44$&/$R +%.% $+%1 +-'% H%7"6% &"F.7% "0 0""9B $+% 9%/.%% A%." "0 F$(2($1 -#9 #%%9> O+-$ (& -22"8%9 $" &F.'('%
(& 5&F&$%#-#7%; -#9 $+% $%V$ 7"F29 H% .%-9 -& %2(6(#-$(#/ -22 $+-$ (& #"#S
%&&%#$(-2B -&&%.$(#/ $+-$ $+% 6(#(6F6 #%7%&&-.1 0". 3+1&(7-2 &F.'('-2 (&
%#"F/+B %'%# 32%#$1> L# $+% "$+%. +-#9B %-$(#/ $+% 02"8%.& 7"F29 H% .%-9
-& - 0(/F.% 0". #"F.(&+(#/ "#%&%20 3.%7(&%21 "# H%-F$1B 8+(7+ 8"F29 -&&%.$ $+%
"33"&($%4 $+-$ $+% $.F% 6(#(6F6 (& 5&3(.($F-2; -#9 #"$ 3+1&(7-2 -$ -22> Y# -#1
%'%#$B 8+-$ 7%.$-(#21 &F.'('%& $+(& "33"&($("# (& $+% 6"F$+> [%&3($% $+% $($2%
5U#"F/+;B $+% $%V$ 0(#(&+%& "# -# %6H2%6 "0 $+% 2-7T "0 &%20S&F00(7(%#71 ".
&%20S7"#$-(#%9#%&&B "# $+% ".(0(7% 8+(7+ 0(/F.%& $+% (#&-$(-H2% -#9 (#$%.6(#S
-H2% +F#/%. 0". $+% "$+%. -#9 $+% "F$&(9%> Y#9%%9B (# 3"44"C Z%7T%$$ +-9
-2.%-91 &$(/6-$(&%9 $+% 6"F$+ 0". $+%&% '%.1 _F-2($(%&B 7"63-.(#/ ($ F#0-S
'"F.-H21 $" $+% -#F&4
O% F#9%.%&$(6-$% $+(& 2($$2% +"2%B ($ &%%6& $" 6%B 8% 7-22 ($ $+% -.&%+"2%
-#9 -00%7$ $" 9%&3(&% ($> ZF$ (& ($ #"$ .-$+%. $+% $.F% 3".$-2 "0 "F. H%(#/ -#9
$+% 7%2%H.-$%9 6"F$+ #" 6".% $+-# $+% T($7+%#S9"". r$+% W.%#7+ $&#)$M$ .$
%$)F*/$ (& 3%.+-3& &$."#/%.s> ="$+(#/ /"%& (#B ". &" 2($$2%B $+-$ (& #"$
.%R%7$%9 "# $+% &3"$B ". '%.1 #%-.21> Q26"&$ %'%.1$+(#/ .%'"2$& ($ $+-$
7"6%& 0."6 8($+"F$ -#9 8+-$ 7"6%& 0."6 8($+(# 9"%& #"$ &%%6 $"
.%7%('% - '%.1 8-.6 8%27"6% %($+%.> Q.% #"$ $+%&% &(/#(0(7-#$ 0-7$&>
`Z%7T%$$ )XNJB ?Ia)I
O+%$+%. 3%#(&%& ". 02"8%.&B $+% 6"F$+ -77%3$& $+-$ $+%.% (& #"$ 1%$B $+-$
$+%.% 8(22 #"$ H%B %#"F/+> Y#$%.%&$(#/21B 8+-$ Y +-'% H%%# .-$+%. 2""&%21
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
E".% -#9 6".%> Q22 8-&> *+(& #"$("# "0 7-26 7"6%& 0."6 +(6> O($+"F$
+(6 Y 8"F29 #"$ +-'% +-9 ($> ="8 Y;22 8(3% "F$ %'%.1$+(#/ HF$ $+% 02"8%.&>
=" 6".% .-(#> =" 6".% 6"F#9&> ="$+(#/ HF$ $+% $8" "0 F& 9.-//(#/
$+."F/+ $+% 02"8%.&> U#"F/+ 61 "29 H.%-&$& 0%%2 +(& "29 +-#9>
`(H(9>B NIa>
<DD !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Q22 $+-$ /"%& H%0".% 0"./%$> *"" 6F7+ -$ - $(6% (& $"" 6F7+> *+-$ /('%& $+%
3%# $(6% $" #"$%> Y 9"#;$ &%% ($ HF$ Y +%-. ($ $+%.% H%+(#9 6%> ,F7+ (& $+%
&(2%#7%> O+%# $+% 3%# &$"3& Y /" "#> ,"6%$(6%& ($ .%0F&%&> O+%# ($ .%0F&%&
Y /" "#> *"" 6F7+ &(2%#7% (& $"" 6F7+> L. ($;& 61 '"(7% $"" 8%-T -$ $(6%&>
*+% "#% $+-$ 7"6%& "F$ "0 6%> ," 6F7+ 0". $+% -.$ -#9 7.-0$> `(H(9>B J@a
5U#"F/+; (& 8+%# $+% 6"F$+ +-& 0(#-221 72"&%9B -77%3$(#/ #" 6".% "0 $+%
3+1&(7-2 8".29;& 9FH("F& /(0$&B -#9 #"8 - &F00(7(%#$ H-..(%. -/-(#&$ $+% '"(7%
8+(7+ %V($& 0."6 6% -#9 8+(7+ Y 7-22 6(#%> *+% #-..-$".;& 0(#-2 &(2%#$
5%#"F/+; (& -2&" 3%.+-3& -# "H2(_F% .%321 $" E"221 Z2""6;& 7%2%H.-$%9 5o%&;
8+(7+ 72"&%& [4C%%$%B -& &+% %'"T%& (# 6%6".1 $+% 0(.&$ $(6% &+% 6-9% 2"'%>
5U#"F/+;B H"$+ 2%&& -#9 6".% -00(.6-$('% $+-# 51%&;B (632(%& #"$ E"221;&
5/('(#/; "0 +%.&%20B HF$ 3%.+-3& - 7%.$-(# .%0F&-2B - 9(&$-#7% #"8 6%9(-$%9
H1 $+% (#$-7$ H".9%.& "0 $+% $8" 3."$-/"#(&$&; H"9(%&B `5E1 "29 H.%-&$& 0%%2 +(&
"29 +-#9;aB -$ - 6"6%#$ 8+%# $+% '("2-$("# "0 $+% /%#%.-$("#-2 9(00%.%#7%
%'"T%9 %-.2(%. "# +-& H%%# %.-&%9 `5Y H%2"#/%9 $" -# %#$(.%21 9(00%.%#$ /%#S
%.-$("#> Y$ 9(9#;$ 2-&$; `(H(9>B J@aa>
5U#"F/+;B $+%#B 6(/+$ 6%-# - 7%.$-(# 6"F$+2%&&#%&&B HF$ -2&" $+% 7-3-7($1
$" 0"./%$B -H-#9"#B -#9 .%2(#_F(&+ h 8+-$ =(%$A&7+%B '%.1 6F7+ 2(T% Z%7T%$$B
"0$%# .%0%.& $" (# $%.6& "0 9(/%&$("# -#9 %V7.%$("#4 5Q &$."#/ -#9 8%22S7"#S
&$($F$%9 6-# 9(/%&$& +(& %V3%.(%#7%& `+(& 9%%9& -#9 6(&9%%9& (#72F9%9a -& +%
9(/%&$& +(& 6%-2&B %'%# 8+%# +% +-& $" &8-22"8 &"6% $"F/+ 6".&%2&;
`=(%$A&7+% )XNXB )<Xa> ,(6(2-.21B 8+(2% -&&%.$(#/ $+-$ $+%.% 7"F29 H% 5#"
+-33(#%&&B #" 7+%%.0F2#%&&B #" +"3%B #" 3.(9%B #" I)$%$&# 8($+"F$ 0"./%$0F2S
#%&&; =(%$A&7+% 72-(6& $+-$ $+% 6-# 8+" (& 8($+"F$ $+% 3"&($('% 0-7F2$1 "0
.%3.%&&("# (& 2(T% - 591&3%3$(7 h +% 7-##"$ 55+-'% 9"#%;; 8($+ -#1$+(#/;
`=(%$A&7+% )XNXB J?a> Y0 H"$+ =(%$A&7+% -#9 Z%7T%$$ &%%6 $" &2(9% $"8-.9
$+% 5$.F% 3".$-2 "0 "F. H%(#/;B +"8%'%.B 7.F7(-2 9(00%.%#7%& .%6-(# (# $+%(.
'-2".(&-$("#& "0 $+% 52($$2% +"2%;> W". =(%$A&7+%B 9%&3($% 6-#(0"29 %V$.%6%21
&FH$2% 7"632(7-$("#&B "0$%# $%#9& $" 8".T 8($+(# - #".6-$('% 9(&7"F.&% "0
M%-2$+ -/-(#&$ 8+(7+ Z%7T%$$ .%6-(#& &$%-90-&$21 (#"7F2-$%9>)) Y#9%%9B $+%
3.%'-2%#7% "0 (22#%&& -#9 (#0(.6($1 (# Z%7T%$$ (& #"$ "#21 (#9%V(7-2 "0 (#%'($S
-H2% 6".$-2($1B ". -22%/".(7-2 "0 &FHR%7$('% 2-7T "0 &%20S6-&$%.1B HF$ -2&" 7"#&$-#$ 3."$%&$ -/-(#&$ -22 $+% 9(&7"F.&%& 8+(7+ 9%%6 $+%6&%2'%&
-F$+".(&%9 $" &%3-.-$% $+% =".6-2 ". M%-2$+1 0."6 ($& "$+%. h - $%#9%#71
-$ $+% 7".% "0 %'%.1 9(&7"F.&% "# 9%7-9%#7%> Y0 Z%7T%$$;& 8".T +-& &" "0$%#
H%%# $+% $-./%$ "0 '("2%#$ .%3F9(-$("# -#9 7%#&".&+(3 ($ (& H%7-F&% +(&
56".(HF#9&; -.% #"$ &(6321 "HR%7$& "0 .(9(7F2% ". &FHR%7$& "0 3($1 HF$ 9-#/%.S
"F&21 &FH'%.&('% 9(&6-#$2(#/& "0 $+% &1&$%6& "0 '-2F%& "0 -F$+".($-.(-#
.%/(6%&B 8+%$+%. 3"2($(7-2 ". 3+(2"&"3+(7-2> Y$ (& $" 61 6(#9 - 9FH("F&
=(%$A&7+% 8+" .-(2& -/-(#&$ $+% 5&-2'%& -#9 H-26; `=(%$A&7+% )XNXB )<Na "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
7-22(#/ $+% 5#-..-$".; H%/(#& $+% &$".1 H1 %63+-&(&(#/ $+% 8.($$%# #-$F.% "0
+%. $%V$B -& - &7%#% "0 9(7$-$("#B &%%6& $" H% &$-/%94
$+% P.(%&$ -#9 $+% 9%&(.% 0". -#%&$+%&(-B 8+%# +(& '%.1 "8# -#-21&(& 7-# %-&(21
&+"8 $+-$ $+% .%0F&-2 $" -22"8 3-(# $" H% 9%-9%#%9 (& $+% 6"&$ 3"8%.0F2
.%2(/("F& -#%&$+%$(7 "0 -22> =(%$A&7+%;& '(&("# "0 6-&$%.1 -#9 +%-2$+ "0$%#
&%%6& $" (6321 -# (#9('(9F-2 8+" (& &F3.%6%21 &%20S&F00(7(%#$ 1%$ 8+" +-&
#%'%. +-9 %#"F/+B -$ "#7% %#$(.% -#9 (#&-$(-H2%> Z%7T%$$ 3.%0%.& - 57-26(#/
-7$("#;B &F7+ -& $+-$ -$$.(HF$%9 3.%7(&%21 $" $+% 02"8%.& (# $+% 2-&$ 3-.-/.-3+
"0 5U#"F/+;> *+% 02"8%.& +%.%B $+% 2-&$ $+(#/ -22"8%9 $" .%6-(#B &%%6 (# 0-7$
-&&(6(2-$%9 $" - &".$ "0 - 6%9(7(#% ". 9.F/B $+% %00%7$ "0 8+(7+ 8"F29 H%
&(6(2-. $" $+% 0(#-2 /(0$ "0 $+% "29 6-#4 5*+% #"$("# "0 7-26 7"6%& 0."6 +(6;>
*+(& (& 3%.+-3& 72%-.%. (# $+% W.%#7+ $%V$B 8+%.% Z%7T%$$ 8.($%& "0 $+% 02"8%.&B
5644$% $H$)/v9*$&# .9&% 4N$&%$5+4$ ,&$ 9/#*"& /9459&#$N `Z%7T%$$ )XC<-B DCa 8+(7+
.%7-22& $+% $($2% "0 Z%7T%$$;& %-.21 &$".1B 5K% !-26-#$;B $.-#&2-$%9 H1 Z%7T%$$ -&
5*+% !-26-$('%; -2$+"F/+ - 6".% 7"22"_F(-2 $.-#&2-$("#B -$ 2%-&$ $" Q6%.(7-#
%-.&B 8"F29 +-'% H%%# 5*+% ,%9-$('%;>)< *+%.%B $+% #-..-$". 8+" 72-(6& $" H%
&3%-T(#/ 0."6 $+% /.-'%B -$$%63$& $" 9(&3%2 +(& 0.(/+$ $+."F/+ #-..-$('%4 5,"
Y;22 $%22 61&%20 - &$".1B Y;22 $.1 -#9 $%22 61&%20 -#"$+%. &$".1B $" $.1 -#9 7-26
61&%20 > > > ; `Z%7T%$$ )XNCB <Ca> O($+(# $+% &$".1 +% $%22&B $+% '-/-H"#9 #-.S
.-$". (& /('%# - 3+(-2B -33-.%#$21 7"#$-(#(#/ $+% $($2%;& &%9-$('%B H1 - &$.-#/%.
8+" %V7+-#/%& ($ (# .%$F.# 0". - T(&&4
M% $""T "00 +(& +-$B - H"82%.B -#9 $-33%9 $+% 6(992% "0 +(& 0".%+%-9>
*+%.%B +% &-(9B -#9 $+%.% "#21> M% +-9 - #"H2% H."8B 8+($% -#9 +(/+> M%
2%-#%9 0".8-.9B 72"&(#/ +(& %1%&> tF(7TB +% &-(9i Y 3F.&%9 F3 61 2(3& -&
6"$+%. +-9 $-F/+$ 6% -#9 H."F/+$ $+%6 9"8# 8+%.% +% +-9 &-(9>
U#"F/+B +% &-(9>
`(H(9>B D@a
W". H"$+ =(%$A&7+% -#9 Z%7T%$$B $+% 7.%-$("# "0 #-..-$('% &%.'%& $" -#-%&$+%S
$(&%B $" 7-26 $+% 3-(# .-$+%. $+-# $" +%-2B -#9 $+(& 9%&(.% (& "#% 0". 8+(7+
Z%7T%$$ +-& - &(#/F2-. 2-7T "0 7"#$%63$>
Z%7T%$$;& 9(6(#(&+%9 6"9F2-$("#&B +(& 8(22(#/#%&& $" %6H.-7% $+% &163S
$"6 -#9 (#$%.3.%$ $+% 9%&(.% 0". ($& %.-9(7-$("# -& &163$"6-$(7 ($&%20B $%#9& $"
&%3-.-$% +(6 0."6 =(%$A&7+%> *+% 5%#%./1; 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% &%%T& 7"#&$-#$21
$" 2(H%.-$% (&B (# Z%7T%$$B 6"&$ "0$%# 3.%&%#$%9 -& (#%'($-H21 $1.-##(7-2 -#9
"33.%&&('%> *+% -332(7-$("# "0 $+% 6"F$+ $" $+% 8".29 3%.6($& "0 #" %-&1
&"2F$("#B -#9 ($ (& $+(& 9(&S%-&% 8+(7+ Z%7T%$$ 0(/F.%& -& 9(&%-&%> M"8%'%.B
8+%.% Z%7T%$$ -#9 =(%$A&7+% &%%6 R"(#%9B -2"#/ 8($+ W.%F9B -& T%1 0(/F.%&
(# "F. 7"#$%63".-#%($1 (& (# $+%(. (#$%.."/-$("# "0 $+% .%2-$("#&+(3 "0 $+%
&FHR%7$ $" ($& 9%&(.%> Q22 $+.%% -&T (0 - 3+.-&% &F7+ -& 561 9%&(.%& 8%.% 61
9%&(.%&; (& %'%# &-1-H2%B -#9 Z%7T%$$;& 8".T (# $+% $.(2"/1 -#9 -0$%. _F($%
2($%.-221 %V32".%& 8+-$ &F7+ - &1#$-V 8"F29 %#$-(2 "# $+% 2%'%2 "0 #-6%B
3."#"F#B -#9 7"632%6%#$ $+."F/+ ($& (#$%#&('% %'-7F-$("# "0 $+% 2(#/F(&$(7
6%7+-#(7& "0 -33."3.(-$("#> Y$ (& #"$ "#21 $+% 59%&(.%&; $+-$ 7-##"$ H% -33."S
3.(-$%9 H1 -# 5Y; 0". Z%7T%$$B HF$ -2&" $+% 5Y; ($&%20 8+(7+ #" %#F#7(-$("# 7-#
2"7T ". 0(VB -& Z%7T%$$ 6-T%& 72%-. $+."F/+"F$ +(& 2"#/ 9(&6-#$2(#/ "0
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 G9#@ <DJ
&FHR%7$('% &%20S(9%#$($1> *+% 6%9(-$("#&B 9%$"F.&B -#9 &FH$%.0F/%& "0 8-#$
8+(7+ %#.-/% =(%$A&7+% -.% -77%3$%9 H1 Z%7T%$$ -& $+% 0F#9-6%#$-2 %7"#"61
"0 %V7+-#/% -#9 9%H$ (#$" 8+(7+ -#1 &FHR%7$ (& -2.%-91 8.($$%#> Z%7T%$$;&
"H&%&&("#-2 %#%./1 (& (#'%&$%9 (# +"3%& "0 - .%$F.# "# 6(29#%&&B -#9 0".
Z%7T%$$ %#"F/+B (0 %3(9%6(7B (& -2&" `$+-$ (&B #%'%.a %#"F/+ `-& 0". =(%$A&7+%a>
Y0 Z%7T%$$B $+%#B &%%6& (#%'($-H21 0($ $" .%6-(# -$ $+% 7%#$.% "0 7"#$%6S
3".-.1 9(&7F&&("#& "0 #(+(2(&6B $+(& (& 3%.+-3& 2-./%21 9F% $" +(& 2-7T "0 0($
8($+(# $+%6> ="$ (# &"6% 8-1 56%-#(#/2%&&;B Z%7T%$$;& 8".T (& .-$+%. (#
3."0"F#9 8-1& (..%7F3%.-H2% H1 2-./%. 3+(2"&"3+(7-2 9(&7"F.&%&B -#9 $+(&
9%&3($% $+% -6-A(#/21 %#%./%$(7 -#9 #F6%."F& -$$%63$& $" .%7F3%.-$% ($>
G-$+%. $+-# H%(#/ -# (63"&&(H2% -#9 (9%-2 6%-#(#/2%&& %6H"9(6%#$ "0
#%/-$('($1B Z%7T%$$;& 8".TB 0". #"8B &$-#9& "F$ -& - #"$-H2% (0 (#%'($-H21
7"63."6(&%9 &($% "0 .%&(&$-#7% $" "F. 7.($(7-2 %#9%-'"F.& h - 5#"; 8+(7+ 8%
(#%'($-H21 H%$.-1 H1 $%#9%.21 &-1(#/ 51%&; $" ($> K%$ 6% %63+-&(A% h Z%7T%$$;&
8".TB &"=R .%&(&$& &"=m $+% .%7%#$ .-&+ "0 8".T "# Z%7T%$$ (& %#$(.%21 7-22%9
0".> Q#9 2%$ F& 3"#9%. $+(& 7"#$(#/%#71B 0". H%0".% $"" 2"#/ $+(& 6"6%#$ "0
.%&(&$-#7%B 2(T% k"17%;&B 8(22 +-'% &%%6%9 H.(%0> *+% Z%7T%$$ (#9F&$.1B &(#7%
Q9".#" -$ 2%-&$ -#9 %'%# 8".T(#/ -/-(#&$ +(6B (& 7+(33(#/ -8-1 -$ ($> Q#9 $"
.%0F&% $" 9" &"B ". $" &F77%%9 (# "F. $-&TB $" 3"&$3"#% ($ 0". - 52-$%.; ". $" (#&(&$
$+-$ 5#"8; (& $+% 6"6%#$ "0 6"6%#$&B -22 &%%6 %_F-221 5#(+(2(&$; -7$&> ="8
Y;22 8(3% "F$ %'%.1$+(#/ HF$ $+% 02"8%.&>
C$%() ,%% K-8.%#7% M-.'%1 `)XCIB <NCh?a 0". $+(& -#%79"$%>
< ,%% k-6%& b#"82&"#;& .%7%#$ H("/.-3+1B ". P>k> EF.3+1;& 5Z%7T%$$ -#9 $+% P+(2"&"S
3+%.&; (# P(22(#/ )XXN>
@ [%2%FA% .%$F.#& $" $+(& 3"(#$ "0$%# (# !*$#@%/'$ $# 49 I'*4"%"I'*$> W". %V-632%B &%% $+%
%-.21 &%7$("#& "0 !+-3$%. JB (# 8+(7+ [%2%FA% %V32-(#& +"8 $+% 5-7$('% #(+(2(&6; "0
.%2(/("F& '-2F%& (& F#9"#% H1 $+% #%/-$('% -#9 3-&&('% #(+(2(&6& 8+(7+ 9(&_F-2(01 -$
"#7% H%2(%0 (# $+% &F3.-&%#&(H2% -#9 (# $+% (63".$-#7% "0 52(0%;>
D Y#9%%9B $+% &$-$%6%#$ &%%6& +13%.H"2(7 %'%# 8($+(# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 Q9".#";& "8#
9(&7F&&("#& "0 Z%7T%$$B 8+(7+B -& !.($7+2%1 3"(#$& "F$B $%#9 6".% "0$%# $" 0"7F& "#
$+% 8-1 Z%7T%$$;& 32-1& .$+9#$ 6%-#(#/B -#9 $+% 6%-#(#/ "0 6%-#(#/ `&%% !.($7+2%1
)XXCB )J)h<a> *+(& $+%1 7%.$-(#21 9"B HF$ &F7+ - 9%&7.(3$("# 8"F29 %_F-221 -3321 $"
6-#1 "$+%. 7-#"#(7-2 6"9%.#(&$ 8".T&B -#9 $+F& $%22& F& 2($$2% -H"F$ $+% &3%7(0(7($1
"0 Z%7T%$$;& 8.($(#/> E".%"'%.B 59%H-$(#/; 6%-#(#/ +-.921 &%%6& 5#(+(2(&$; (# -#9 "0
($&%20B $+"F/+ "#% 7-# &%% 8+1 ($ (& - #%7%&&-.1 3.%2(6(#-.1 $" 6".% %63+-$(7
#%/-$("#&>
J K%&2(% M(22 +-& .%7%#$21 3"(#$%9 "F$ $+-$ $+% #-..-$".;& /%#9%. (& (63"&&(H2% $"
9%$%.6(#%B -& (# H"$+ $+% W.%#7+ -#9 U#/2(&+ Z%7T%$$ +-& &1&$%6-$(7-221 %2(6(#-$%9
-22 /.-66-$(7-2 6-.T%.& "0 ($ `M(22 )XXIB )JNh?a> Y$ (& #"$ %#$(.%21 RF&$(0(-H2% $"
&1&$%6-$(7-221 .%0%. $" $+% #-..-$". -& 0%6-2%B 8+(7+ Y +-'% 7+"&%# $" 9" +%.% (# $+%
(#$%.%&$& "0 - .%-9(#/ 8+(7+ %63+-&(&%& $+% 3.%&&F.% $+% &$".1 -332(%& $" $.-9($("#-2
+(%.-.7+(&%9 &"7(-2 .%2-$("#&+(3&B #"$-H21 "29%.]1"F#/%.B 6-2%]0%6-2%B 3-.%#$]
7+(29> L$+%. .%-9(#/& 8+(7+ 8"F29 6".% 0".7%0F221 6"H(2(A% $+% /%#9%. -6H(/F($1
-.% $" H% %#7"F.-/%9>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<DN !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
N W". %V-632%B K%&2(% M(22 `)XXIB )J?a>
C ,%%B 0". %V-632%B =(%$A&7+% `)XN? lYB )a>
? *+(& (&B "0 7"F.&%B 0-. 0."6 $+% "#21 3-.-22%2 H%$8%%# W.%F9 -#9 =(%$A&7+% "# $+%
_F%&$("# "0 &FHR%7$('($1> W". - H.(22(-#$ 2""T -$ &FHR%7$('% -.7+($%7$"#(7& (# W.%F9
-#9 =(%$A&7+%B &%% !+-3$%. @ "0 ZF$2%. )XXC>
X *+"6-& MF#T%2%. +-& .%7%#$21 9(&7F&&%9 $+% (63".$-#7% "0 $+% 8".9 53.%7(3($-$%;
(# Z%7T%$$B (6321(#/ -$ "#7% +-&$% HF$ -2&" 9."33(#/& "0 -22 &".$&m %'%.1$+(#/ $+-$
$%#9& $" /" 9"8#>
)I Z%7T%$$;& %'"7-$("# +%.% "0 -# -#-2 +"&$(2($1 $" 8+-$ 7"6%& 0."6 $+% "F$&(9% 7"F29
H% .%-9 -& - 9%#(-2 "0 $+% +"6"&%VF-2 3"$%#$(-2 "3%#%9 H1 $+% (#9%$%.6(#-$%
/%#9%. "0 $+% #-..-$". "0 6&",?'> L# $+% 7"#$.-.1B #"$+(#/ 7"F29 H% 0F.$+%. 0."6
$+% $.F$+4 5="$+(#/ /"%& (#B ") %" 4*##4$R $+-$ (& #"$ .%R%7$%9 "# $+% &3"$B ". '%.1
#%-.21;> *+% _F-2(0(%. +%.%B 5". &" 2($$2%;B (& "0 7"F.&% - 9%#(/.-$("# "0 $+% "HR%7$
8+(7+ %&7-3%& $+% /%#%.-2 .F2% $+% &%#$%#7% %&$-H2(&+%&B $+-$ (&B $+% 3%#(&B
.%0%..%9 $" (# &(6(2-. $%.6& (# $+% %-.21 5O+-$ - E(&0".$F#%; 0."6 3")$ E)*/;%
#'9& G*/;%4 5 55Y$;& - &6-22 $+(#/B M-(.1;;B +% &-(9 > > > 55&%3-.-$%& 2"'%.&;; ; `Z%7T%$$
)XC<B )@NIa>
)) *+% _F%&$("# "0 $+% &$-$F& "0 5+%-2$+; (# =(%$A&7+% (& %V$.%6%21 7"632%VB -#9 ($ (&
7.F7(-2 $" #"$% +"8 "0$%# =(%$A&7+% +(/+2(/+$& $+% (63".$-#7% "0 9%7-9%#7% -#9
(22#%&& (# $+% 3."7%&& "0 9%'%2"36%#$ -#9 -9'-#7%> Q #"$-H2% %V-632% "0 $+(&
8"F29 H% l<<D 0."6 >,59&R 744 D"" >,59&B (# 8+(7+ =(%$A&7+% %63+-&(&%& +"8
$+% 58%-T%.; ". 59%/%#%.-$%; 0F.$+%. %'"2F$("#4 5U'%.1 3."/.%&& "0 $+% 8+"2% +-& $"
H% 3.%7%9%9 H1 - 3-.$(-2 8%-T%#(#/; `=(%$A&7+% )X?NB )ICa> Y# X*)"*. L*2$B b%($+
Q#&%22 P%-.&"# +-& 3%.&F-&('%21 &+"8# $+% (63".$-#7% "0 $+(& &".$ "0 .%-&"#(#/ 0".
=(%$A&7+%;& 5%'"2F$("#-.1; &7+%6-&B 8+(7+ %#9 #"$ "#21 8($+ -# %63+-&(& "# $+%
(63".$-#7% "0 9%7-1 -#9 9%/%#%.-$("# 0". -22 3."/.%&& `Q#&%22 P%-&"# )XXCB XXa
HF$ %'%# 8($+ $+% &%%6(#/21 3-.-9"V(7-2 -&&%.$("# $+-$ $+% 5+(/+%. $13%; -7$F-221
5 > > > /"%& -/-(#&$ $+% /.-(# "0 %'"2F$("#B 8+(7+ 0-'"F.& $+% /.-9F-2 &%2%7$("# "0
$+-$ 8+(7+ %#9F.%&; `(H(9>B )I)a h - &$-$%6%#$ 8+(7+ (632(%& $+-$ $+% $%.6&
5+(/+%.; -#9 52"8%.;B 5&$."#/%.; -#9 58%-T%.;B -.% (# &"6% 8-1 .%'%.&%9> ,$(22B
$+%&% 0".6F2-$("#& -22 $%#9 $" '(%8 $+% 59%/%#%.-$%; -& -# (#'%&$6%#$ (# - 6"'%S
6%#$ $"8-.9 - /.%-$%. -9'-#7% 8+(7+ (# ($&%20 (& #%'%. _F%&$("#%9B RF&$ -& "# $+%
2%'%2 "0 $+% (#9('(9F-2B (22#%&& h 8+-$%'%. H%#%0($& ($ 6-1 3."'"T% h 3."'"T%& $+%6
(# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 -# (63."'%9 -#9 &$."#/%. +%-2$+> Y# - 2"#/ 9(&7F&&("# "0 +%-2$+
(# =(%$A&7+%B [-'(9 W-..%22 b.%22 -2&" &+"8& 8%22 +"8 "0$%# =(%$A&7+% .%2-$('(&%&
$+% '-2F%& "0 +%-2$+ -#9 (22#%&&B /('(#/ -& -# %V-632% $+(& 3-&&-/% 0."6 $+%
#"$%H""T&4 5L#21 8+%# 8% +-'% -# *.$94 (# '(%8B -# (9%-2 8% 8(&+ $" -$$-(#B
9"%& ($ 6-T% &%#&% $" &-1 55+%-2$+1;; -#9 55&(7T;; ; `_F"$%9 (# b.%22B )XXNB )X)a> o%$
-#"$+%. 3-&&-/% 0."6 $+% 9.-0$& 0". 6//$ >"5" &+"8& =(%$A&7+% -/-(# &$.('(#/ $"
6-(#$-(# -/-(#&$ $+% .%7"/#(&%9 #%7%&&($1 "0 (22#%&& -#9 9%/%#%.-$("# $+% 3"&&S
(H(2($1 "0 -# -H&"2F$% 5+%-2$+;4 5Y $""T 61&%20 (# +-#9B 6-9% 61&%20 +%-2$+1 -/-(#4
$+% 7"#9($("# 0". $+-$ h -& %'%.1 3+1&("2"/(&$ 8(22 7"#7%9% h (& #'9# "&$ 9# +"##"5 +$
'$94#'C> Q 7.%-$F.% $+-$ (& 6".H(9 H1 $13% 7-##"$ H%7"6% +%-2$+1B &$(22 2%&& 6-T%
($&%20 +%-2$+1m -& "33"&%9 $" $+-$B 0". "#% 8+" (& +%-2$+1 H1 $13%B (22#%&& 7-# H% -#
%#%./%$(7 %#*5,49&% $" 2(0%B 6".% 2(0% `7($%9 (# b.%22 )XXNB <IXa> Y$ (& $+% 3"&&(H(2($1
"0 $+% 5+%-2$+1 $13%; $+-$ Z%7T%$$;& 8".T& 7-22 .-9(7-221 (#$" _F%&$("#>
)< 5!-26-#$; (# W.%#7+ 9%&(/#-$%& H"$+ $.-#_F(2(&%.& -#9 3-(#ST(22%.&B $+% 9(&$(#7$("#
H%$8%%# 3+1&(7-2 -#9 3&17+(7 3-(# +%.% #"$ H%(#/ 2(#/F(&$(7-221 (#&7.(H%9 `- 0-7$ "0
"H'("F& 3"$%#$(-2 (#$%.%&$ $" =(%$A&7+%B /('%# +(& 7"#&$-#$ 0"7F& "# &"6-$(7
/."F#9(#/& -#9 .%&"#-#7%& "0 8+-$ (& F&F-221 7-22%9 7+-.-7$%.B +(&$".1B ". 6(#9a>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
B9&*$4 G9#@ <DC
<D? !*'*4*%5 !"=Y 3"&%#$)% "2 6&$)?C
Y# $+% 7"#$%V$ "0 $+% &$".1B $+% &%#&% "0 %$.9#*"& (& 72%-.21 3.('(2%/%9B (0 $+% "$+%.&
-.% #%'%.$+%2%&& 3.%&%#$ -& 8%22>
Q9".#"B *> `)XX)a !"#$% #" L*#$)9#,)$R F"4,5$ ^Z $.-#&> ,>O> =(7+"2&%#> =%8 o".T4
!"2F6H(- \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
Q#&%22 P%-.&"#B b> `)XXCa X*)"*. L*2$0 E$)%I$/#*F$% "& !*$#@%/'$ 9&. #'$ D)9&%',59&
("&.*#*"& K"#9"#4 G"F$2%9/%>
Z-9("FB Q> `)XX<a ("&.*#*"&%> P-.(&4 K%& U9($("#& 9F ,%F(2>
Z%7T%$$B ,> `)XNJa D')$$ !"F$4% +C A95,$4 <$/;$##0 3"44"CR 394"&$ B*$%R D'$ [&&959+4$>
=%8 o".T4 ^."'% P.%&&>
pp `)XNCa A#")*$% 9&. D$H#% 2") !"#'*&? =%8 o".T4 ^."'% P.%&&>
pp `)XC<-a D$s#$%J3")#$% P-.(&4 K%& %e9($("#& 9% E(#F($>
pp `)XC<Ha 3")$ E)*/;% #'9& G*/;% =%8 o".T4 ^."'% P.%&&>
pp `)XCDa :*)%# L"F$ 9&. Q#'$) A'")#% =%8 o".T4 ^."'% P.%&&>
pp `)X?)a P9## =%8 o".T4 ^."'% P.%&&>
pp `)X?@a P")%#=9). >" =%8 o".T4 ^."'% P.%&&>
pp `)X?D-a B*%K$/#90 3*%/$449&$",% P)*#*&?% 9&. 9 B)959#*/ :)9?5$&#> %9> GFH1 !"+#>
=%8 o".T4 ^."'% P.%&&>
pp `)X?DHa ("44$/#$. A'")#$) E49C% =%8 o".T4 ^."'% P.%&&>
ZF$2%.B k> `)XXCa D'$ E%C/'*/ L*2$ "2 E"=$)0 D'$")*$% *& A,+K$/#*"& ,$-#0".94 ,$-#0".9
\#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
!.($7+2%1B ,> `)XXCa X$)C L*##4$ Z Z Z 745"%# !"#'*&?0 B$9#'R E'*4"%"I'CR L*#$)9#,)$> K"#9"#
-#9 =%8 o".T4 G"F$2%9/%>
[%2%FA%B ^> `)XN)a> !*$#@%/'$ $# 49 E'*4"%"I'*$> P-.(&4 P.%&&%& \#('%.&($-(.%& 9% W.-#7%>
[%..(9-B k> `)XNCa LN6/)*#,)$ $# 49 .*22$M)$&/$> P-.(&4 K%& U9($("#& 9F ,%F(2> `)X?)a>
pp P)*#*&? 9&. B*22$)$&/$ $.-#&> Q> Z-&&B K"#9"#] =o4 G"F$2%9/%>
W.%F9B ,> `)X?Ja (*F*4*@9#*"&R A"/*$#C 9&. 1$4*?*"& mE$4*/9& :)$,. L*+)9)CR F"4Z ^\W> %9>
Q#/%2- G(7+-.9&B $.-#&> k-6%& ,$.-7+%1> K"#9"#4 P%#/F(# Z""T&>
W.%F9B ,> `)X?Da Q& 3$#9I%C/'"4"?C0 D'$ D'$")C "2 E%C/'"9&94C%*% mE$4*/9& :)$,. L*+)9)CR
F"4Z ^^W> %9> Q#/%2- G(7+-.9&B $.-#&> k-6%& ,$.-7+%1> K"#9"#4 P%#/F(# Z""T&>
M-.'%1B K-8.%#7%> `)XCIa A95,$4 <$/;$##0 E"$# 9&. ()*#*/ P.(#7%$"#4 P.(#7%$"# \#('%.S
&($1 P.%&&>
M(22B K> `)XXIa <$/;$##N% :*/#*"&0 -& B*22$)$&# P").%> !-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/% \#('%.&($1
P.%&&>
MF#T%2%.B *> `)XXCa 6/'"% .$ 4N$?" .9&% 4N"$,F)$ .$ A95,$4 <$/;$##> P-.(&4 U9($("#& K;M-.S
6-$$-#>
b.%22B [>W> `)XXNa -&2$/#*",% !*$#@%/'$> Z2""6(#/$"#4 Y#9(-#- \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)X?Na >,59&R 744 D"" >,59&> $.-#&> G>k> M"22(#/9-2%> !-6H.(9/%4 !-6S
H.(9/% \#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XNXa Q& #'$ O$&$94"?C "2 3")94% -#9 6//$ >"5"> $.-#&> O> b-F06-##>
=%8 o".T4 f(#$-/%>
=(%$A&7+%B W> `)XN?a D'$ P*44 #" E"=$)> %9> O> b-F06-##B $.-#&> O> b-F06-## -#9 G>k>
M"22(#/9-2%> =%8 o".T4 f(#$-/%>
b#"82&"#B k> `)XXNa B95&$. #" :95$0 D'$ L*2$ "2 A95,$4 <$/;$##> K"#9"#4 Z2""6&HF.1>
P(22(#/B k>B %9> `)XXNa D'$ (95+)*.?$ ("5I9&*"& #" <$/;$##> !-6H.(9/%4 !-6H.(9/%
\#('%.&($1 P.%&&>
O(29%B L> `)X?Ja D'$ E*/#,)$ "2 B")*9& O)9C> M-.6"#9&8".$+4 P%#/F(# Z""T&>
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
0(D()(,1(-
Q9-6"'B Q> <@@ #>X
Q96(.-2 *F.%##% )<
Q9".#"B *>O> V(VB <@NB <DNm -#9
M".T+%(6%.B E> )N@ #>)X
Q%&7+12F& CDhJ
Q/-6H%#B ^> )II #>J
Q2H%.$B U> V((
Q2%V-#9%. YY <<
-2$.F(&6 N)
95") 29#* ?Ih)B <<C
-#-%&$+%$(7& V(((B <CB <XB @@
Q#9%.&"#B K> )X
-#(6-2(&6 V'B )IIB )I@hX
-#/%. <)NB <)?B <)Xh<)m -#9 I9%%*5q %$$
94%" .F9%#%&&
-#$+."3"7%#$.(&6 V'B )<B )I@B )IJB ))CB
)<?
-#$+."3"2"/(&6 V((
-3"7-213&% '(((B V'(B <)
Q3"22" CDB CNhC
Q.%#9$B M> V(((
Q.(&$"$2% C?B ))I #>XB ))< #>)N
Q.#"29B P> <<X
Q.$-F9B Q> V'(((hV(VB )N@ #>XB )X?B )XXB
<IIB <I<B <)Nh@D
-.$(0(7(-2 2(0% )))h)< #>)@
-&7%$(&6 N)h<
-$+%(&6 V(((B ))
7,2'$+,&? JJB N)
QF/F&$(#% D<B DJ
Z-9("FB Q> <@X
Z-%F62%.B Q> ?N
Z-TF#(#B E> <X
Z-.H%.B ,> <<X
Z-$-(22%B ^> V'(((B <B )DCh?B )N@ #>)NB
)X?h<I<B <)Ih)<B #><B <@?
Z-F9.(22-.9B k> '(((B V(((h('B VV #>)
Z-A-."' <Ch?B )N@ #>?
Z%-.9&8".$+B G> V(((
Z%-$$1B O> )?C
Z%7T%$$B ,> V(VhVVB <@JhD?
Z%2(#&T(B o> <@hD
Z%#R-6(#B O> VV #>)B NB )< #>)B C<
Z%##B ^> V'(B )D<hNN
Z%./&"#B M> ))) #>)<B )?IB <@D #>)@
H("/%#%&(& V'
H("2"/(&6 D<B ?XB )IDhJB ))I #>C
H("#%/-$('% )D<B )DJB )DXB )JDB )JNB
)N)B )N@ #>X
H("3"2($(7& V'(B )NI
+*"% V('
Z2-#7+"$B E> )@? #><DB <IIh)
Z2(#B G> <@@ #>X
Z2"7+B U> )D #>)N
H2"#9 H%-&$ DCh?B J?
H"91]H"91(#/ XNhXB )INB )I?B )DDB )DJB
)X@B )X?B <)?
H"91 8($+"F$ "./-#& V'((B )NXh?@
Z"%$+(F& CN
Z"29$SY."#&B K>Q> <)< #><B <)@ #>D
Z""$+."19B [> V'((hV(VB
Z"16B ,> <D
Z.%$"#B Q> <<NB <<X
Z.%F%.B k> C?
Z."8%.B [> <<
Z.F#"B ^> V(((B <h)<
ZF99+(&6 )XNB <@X
!-/%B k> <@C
!-..B U>M> @)
!-..B b> )?
!-..%2B Q> )JCB )NJ #>@DB #>@CB #>DI
!-1/(22B M> V'((hV'(((
7%.%H.-2(&-$("# -#9 $+% 7%.%H.-2 )DNB
)D?B )JIB )N)
!+%.#1&+%'&T1B => <Ch?
!+.(&$ V'(((
!+.(&$(-#($1 V'B V'((B D)B CJB )?XhXC -#9
I9%%*5
!2-.TB E> )@X #><X
!2%6%#&B k> V(((B <@) #>)
!"66F#(&6 <C
!"#8-1B [> V'hV'(
!"3%.#(7F& V((hV(((B )hDB Nh)<B )@ #>DB
)D #>)I
!.(6%-# O-. <<
!.($7+2%1B ,> <@NB <D<B <DN #>D
<DX
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
Y#9%V
<JI -&.$H
[-2%B !> V(V
[-.8(#B !> )D #>)IB )J #>)@B ??B
)IXh)I #>JB )D@B )N<B )N@ #>CB )ND
#><?
[-.8(#(&6 -#9 [-.8(#(-#& )D@B )DDB
)N< #>NB )NJ #>@D
[-8T(#&B G> VVB #>DB ))I #>CB )N@ #>))
[%H"/".1SE"T(1%'%'(7+B P> <J
[%K-#9-B E> )N?B )CXB )?IB )?)B )?C
#>DB #>N
[%2%FA%B ^> V'(B <hDB NhCB ))B )@ #>JB DJB
ND #>)B NN #>DB NC #>)<B #>)@B
))) #>)<B )@JB )NCh?CB <@NB <DN #>@m
-#9 ^F-$$-.(B W> )ND #><DB )NCh?CB
<I<m -#9 P-.#%$ )NJ #>@?
[%6%$%. CC
9%6"#"2"/1 @)h<m $+% 9%6"#(7 -#9
9%6"#& )D?B )DXB )J)B )J<B
)N@ #>)IB )ND #><I
9% =%.'-2B ^> <)CB <<@
[%..(9-B k> NJ #>@B NN #>?B C<B CXh?IB
<IJB <)D #>XB <@C
[(9%."$B [> )N@ #>))
[(9(SMFH%.6-##B ^> <)< #>)
[("#1&(-# V('B XB @XB DDB NJ #>DB CJhCB ?)
[("#1&F& C@hDB CNh?B ?IB ?@
[=Q )NIB )N)
["&$"%'&T1B W> <DB <NB <XB @)h<
[.%8B U> )X
%/"(&6 N)
U2("$B ^> <@@ #>C
%#%./1 V('B @XhDIB D@B DJB N<
%&7+-$"2"/1 V'(B )NI
%$%.#-2 .%7F..%#7% @XhDIB JNB ND #>)B
CN #>)DB CJB ?IB ?<
%$+(7& V'((B V'(((B @@B DIB D@B DJB N<
%F/%#(7& V'(B ))I #>JB )JNB )JCB )JX
UF.(3%9%& )@C #>)<
%'%#$B $+% V(B V'B V'(((B CB )Ih)<B @C
UV3.%&&("#(&6 -#9 %V3.%&&("#(&$& )DJB
)JIB )J)B )J<B )J@
0-&7(&6 V'(hV'((B VV #>)B )JCB )C@hX
W%.9(%n.%B ^> <@@ #>D
W%(TB !> V(((
0".7% DIB D<B DJhJCB JXhNIB N<hDB ND #>)B
NJ #>DB C@hJB ?DB )IJ
W"F7-F2$B E> )NCB )CJB )?NB <I<
W.%F9B ,> V('B C)h@B CCh?)B ?DhJB )CXB
<DIh)B <DJB <DC #>?
^-2(2%" D
^-2$"#B W> ))I #>J
/%"7%#$.(&6 C
/%.6(#-2 2(0% VhV(B )ND #><D
^%F2(#7VB Q> <@J
^(22%&3(%B E>Q> @D #><B )@C #>))B
)@? #>)X
^2%-&"#B Z> <C
^"9 (VB V(((B V'(((B @B ))B <IB @)h<B @DB
?CB ))?B )<NB )@JB )@C #>))B
)@? #><<B )NIB )X?B <I)B <<JB <<CB
<<?B <@D #>)<
^"%$+%B k>O> '"# )D@B )N< #>JB )ND #><)
^""9-22B k> <<X
^"F29B ,>k> )N< #>@B #>)DB #>)?B )ND
#><@m -#9 U29.%9/%B => )N@ #>)<
^."99%7TB ^> CX
^F-$$-.(B W> V'(B <h@B JB ))B )@ #>JB
))) #>)<
M-H%.6-&B k> @B )D #>C
M-22%.B Q> '"# )DD
M-6-7+%.B O> )@X #>@<
M-62%$ ?
M-16-#B G> <<CB <@D #>)N
M%/%2B W>^>W> DDB NC #>)<
M%(9%//%.B E> V('hV'(B D<B J<h@B NJ #>@B
NC #>XB CIh@B CJB CCh?B ?)hJB ?Nh))JB
)<IB )<<B )@NhC #>CB )@C #>XB #>)IB
#>)@B )@? #><IB )@X #>@JB )JJB
)N@ #>?B <I@
+%2("7%#$.(&6 <B DB NB )@ #>D
M%26+"2$AB M>K>W> '"# )D@B )DXB )N<
M%.-72($F& V((B C?
M(22B K> <DN #>JB <DC #>N
M(22%H.-#9B Z> )N@ #>)X
+(&$".(7(&6 )IX
M($2%.B Q> )NCB )C?
M($2%.(&6 ?D
M"9/%B k> V('B )J?
g 29%.2(#B W> C<B ?<B ))@ #><IB ))D #><@
M"
M"2"7-F&$ VV
M"&T(#/B ^> @@
MF#T%2%.B *> <DC #>X
MF&&%.2B U> <I@B <INB <I?
MFV2%1B Q> V'(
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
!F&-B => 9%> @
M12-#9B E> <@< #><
+12"6".3+(&6 )?)
(9%-2(&6 V((B <CB @?B )I<
Y'-#"'B Y> @Ih)
k-7"H(#(&6 <X
k-&3%.&B b> )@X #><C
k%2(#%TB U> VV
k"17%B k> <DN
kF9-(&6 CJ
g #/%.B U> ?@B )J?B )N@ #>?
kF
kF#/B !>^> C?
RF&$(7% JNIh)B CJhN
b-#$B Y> V((hV(((B )h<B DB Nh)IB )<B @?B J<B
J?B NN #>DB C)B X<B XJhNB )I<B )INB
))< #>)JB )N< #>DB <IN
b-.-T"A"'B [> <?
b-$AB [> V(V
b-F006-#B ,> NJ #>DB ))I #>NB )?C #>?
b%32%.B k> D
b($$2%.B W> )NI
b2%(&$B M> '"#> )<
b2%%B P> N
b"%&$2%.B Q> X
b"1.%eB Q> D
b.%22B [>W> <DC #>))
K-#/%B W>Q> JB )J #>)@
K-F$.%e-6"#$B !> <)C
L$+$&%+")& )JC
K%(H#(AB ^>O> @B )D #>NB ))) #>)<B )JI
K%#(#B f>Y> <Ch?B <X
K% P%#B k>SE> )JC
K%e'(B Z>SM> <@@ #>X
K%e'(#-&B U> V'(((B <I@h)D
2(H%.-2(&6 <<h@
K(0% V'B V'(B V'((hV'(((B V(VB @Ch?B DDB
DNhXB J<B JJhNB NIB NJ #>DB
?NhXXB)I)hJB )IChXB )))h)< #>)@B
))< #>)NB )<JB )<NB )@Ih)B )@X #>@IB
#>@)B )D<B )J<B )JXB )N@ #>)CB )?XB
)XIB )X<B )XNB <<)B <<DhJm 3."'"T%9
2(0% )D<B )DNB )N)m 2(0%;&
/.-#9%F. )JNB )NJ #>@@
2"'% N)h<B NDB <<)
KF7.%$(F& ?B )?C #>X
KF22B G> @B )D #>N
K1"$-.9B k>SW> VV #><B NN #>?
E-2(TB ,> V'(hV'
E-##B b> )JJB )J?B )JXB )ND #><D
E-##B *> )J?B )NJ #>@J
E-&&F6(B Z> )N?
E-.7F&B ^> )XB <)
E-.VB b> ?B )CX
E-.V Z."$+%.&B $+% <<@
6-$$%. V'((B D<hDB JCB NIB NJhN #>DB ?@B
)D?B )CIB )?IB )?@
E%(&$%. U7T+-.$ )XN
6%6".1 DXhJIB J<B JNhCB N)B NC #>)@B
?)h<
E%.2%-FSP"#$1B E> <I<B <ICh)IB <)@ #>C
E%1%.B ,> )DD
E(2$"#B k> @)
E#%6"&1#% ?)h<
E"9A-2%'&T1B K> <J
3"*)9 CJhN
6"#(&6 J
6"#&$%. `"0 %#%./1a ))CB ))?B )<DB )@NB
)DXB )J)m #-$F.% -& )J@
E"./-#B [> V'(
=-A(&6 V'(B ?NB )IDhNB )IX #>)B ))<h)@
#>)C
=%7+-%'B ,> V'(((B <<B <NB <CB <Xh@D
=%/.(B Q> @B <@) #>)
#%.'"F& &1&$%6 DDB NN #>D
=%8$"# )N< #>@
=(7+"2-& Y> <@
=(%$A&7+%B W> (VhV'(((B @h)@B )J #>)@B )?B
<Ih)B @<B @DB @ChNDB NJ #>@B NJhN #>DB
NC #>XB CIh?JB ?NhXIB X<hJB X?hXB
)I)hNB )IX #>)B ))J #><DB ))CB )JIB
)J)B )J@B )JNB )N@ #>CB #>XB )N@ #>)JB
)ND #><)B #><NB #><CB <)CB <)XB <<IB
<<<B <<JB <@@ #>CB #>)IB <@D #>)IB
<D)h<B <DDhNB <DC #>CB #>?B <DC #>))B
#>)<
#(+(2(&6
-7$('% (VhVB @ChDIB D@B DNhCB CIh)B XDB
)I?B )<DhJB <<IB <<)
!+.(&$(-# )XI
72-&&(7-2 XDB X?h)IIB )I<h?B ))< #>)C
7.($(7-2 (VB
9%6"#(7 V('B C)B C@
%7&$-$(7 ?IB XD
UF."3%-# <<I
0-&7(&$ )NC
2F#-. -#9 &"2-. V'((B )N?B )CXB )?<
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
-&.$H <J)
#(+(2(&6 `("&#Za
6%2-#7+"2(7 V
3-&&('% (VB @CB @XhDIB D<h@B CIh)B
)<DhJB )XIB <<IB <<)
3%.0%7$ VB V'B @B JhNB )IB <IB @<B ))CB
))?B )XI
3"2($(7-2 )XB <)h<B <NB <XB @<h@
3"&&(H2% '(((
.-9(7-2 ))B @CB )XIh)
.%-7$('% VV
.%-2(&%9 V'(B )?<
GF&&(-# V'((B <<B <NhCB @<h@
&F(7(9-2 V'((
=(#B Q> <@@ #>N
"#$"/%#%&(& V'B )I)B )I@
"#$"3"(%&(& V'B )I)hDB )INhCB )IXB
))< #>)Nm -#9 =-$("#-2 ,"7(-2(&6
))D #><)
L.9(#%B => @
L.2-# <IDB <)@ #>N
"'%.6-# N@
P-F2 D)B DJ
P%.&%3+"#% CCB ?I
P(7-&&"B P> )DJ
P(&-.%'B [> <J
32-#% "0 (66-#%#7% @B JB )@ #>J
P2-$" @?B )I<h@B )I?B ))D #><B
))Dh)J #><D
P2-$"#(&6 V'((
P"%B U>Q> <)C
P"(#7-.%eB M> )?I
3"2($(7& @@B DC
3"&$6"9%.# '(((h(VB V((B V'(((B @
P.(/"/(#%B Y> )J #>)@B )CX
3.(6-2 0-7%]'(&("# )J)B )JJB )JXB )N)B
)N@ #>)N
P."6%$+%F& CDhJB ?<
P."$%'(B k> V'(hV'((
.-7% )IJ
G-T6%e$"0 <?
G%(7+B O> <@I
.%2-$('(&6 V((B )<
)$%%$&#*5$&# JIh)B J?hN)B N@B C<hNB <<<
G('(%n.%B k> )XXB <)C
.F9%#%&& <)Xh<@
,-9% E> 9% <@I
,7+%22(#/B W>O> C)B )IN
,7+"3%#+-F%.B Q> CXB )<XB <@J
&%20S3.%&%.'-$("# ??
,%22(#B U> <@IB <@D #>)N
,%V$F& U63(.(7F& ?
,+--$F7TB G> <@) #>)
,+"-+ V(V
,(6"#9"#B ^> ))) #>)<B )CX
,2F/-B M> )IX #>)B )@X #>@D
,6($+B Q> ))I #>)<
,"7.-$%& )@C #>)<
,"#$-/B ,> <@I
,"."&B ^> @D
&3%7F2-$('% 6-$%.(-2(&6 J
,3%#/2%.B L> )DJhNB )D?B )N@ #>)I
,3(#"A-B Z> @B Ch?B )Ih))B <@@ #>)I
&3(.($ V'(((hV('B V'((B )IB @CB @XhJ@B
JChXB N<hDB NJhN #>DB N? #>)D
,$-$%#B M> NN #>CB )@? #><J
,$%(#B ^> <@C
,$%2-.7 V'(((
,$."#/B *> )@Ch? #>)N
*+%e'%#(#B P> <<@
*+%8%2%($B b> )NIB )N< #>NB )NJ #>@NB
)?C #>)I
$.-#&S+F6-# 3+(2"&"3+1 ))Ch@N
*F./%#%'B Y> <Ch?B )DJB )N@ #>?
U +$)5$&%/' .$) <)B )II
[
g 22B k> '"# )N@ #>)@
\%VTF
f-# ^"/+B f> <IDB <)C
f-.%2-B W> )?C #>?
f%.T+"'%#&T1B P> @)
O-/#%.B G> )JI
O-..%#B E> )@X #><?
O+($%+%-9B Q>=> ))) #>)<
O(%#%.B => )D #>N
O(29%B L> <@X
8(22 $" 3"8%. V('B V'(B @XhDIB DDB DCB JNB
ND #>)B NC #>)DB ?NB ??B ))?B )<?
O""9&B *> )?N
o-$%&B W> )@ #>DB )D #>N
q-(7+#%'&T1B P>^> <D
q-.-$+F&$.- N@B C)B )<DB )@J
q%F& CDB ?)
10.1057/9780230597761 - Nihilism Now!, Edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson and Diane Morgan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24
<J< -&.$H