Negarestani-remarks on asiatic peace

! ! ! ! ! ! ! "#$%&'(!)*!+(,%-,.!/#%.#! *)01!! !"#$%&'%()**+,--.../0123456/76*8% 9/%:6;<=6>*<7?%

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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'(!)*!+(,%-,.!/#%.#! 3 N%14:&#57," (1/'," 46/B&'+*6=," ('#-" 066F" 6+" *+,-#./*0-+!*'+1%*,2" 6/" =.'/'" '2'/)-.150" $'46('&"6B'5"#57"B'/('#-'&"-./6%0."-.'"6-.'/,"+6**6=150"-.'"15'21-#$*'"&6+-'5150" #57" B/6*1+'/#-165" ('4.#51&(&" 6+" B'#4'3" 333" 15+'&-'7" $)" B'#4'," 6B'55'&&" 1&" 56-" 65*)" -.'"#5-./6B6(6/B.1#5"17'#"6+"$'150"6B'5"$%-"#*&6"$'150"6B'5'7"$)"-.'"71215'"!%#@" -.'" B#57'(14" 6+" 6B'55'&&" E=.'/'5'&&F," -.'" *#4'/#-1653" L.'5," =.#-" #/'" -.'" -'4.56*601'&"6+"-'/(15#*"&6+-'5150"#57"+*%171+14#-165"6+"B'#4'"=.14."*'#7"'2'/)-.150" -6" 15+1*-/#-'" 15-6" -.'" 6-.'/" E6B'55'&&F" 15'21-#$*)" #57" #-" *#&-" '2#B6/#-150" 15-6" -.'" 0#&'6%&"&B1/1-"6+"B'#4'"!&#?"J"('*-76=5,"/6--150"'/'4-,"(6*7'/150"15-6"&*1('"#57"066," +'/('5-#-165," B#/#*)G#-165" $)" -.'" B*#0%'," +1$/6B/6*1+'/#-165" E'C4'&&12'" &4#//150F," ;71++'/'5-1#-150" 46/'" #57" &%/+#4'" 465P%54-12'" 71&46%/&'" 65" -.'" 65'" .#57" #57" 'J 5'/2#-150" 133'#/1+4-" $)" 4/#4:150" #57" '2#B6/#-150" #**" /'+'/'54'&" E-.'" #2#-#/&" 6+" B&'%76J+*%C@" #-3-##-" 6/" 561,) *,) 41##*-!F" #57" -.'" '4656(14#*" 5'C%&'&" 65" -.'" 6-.'/" E'2#B6/#-165" #&" >DH" '54/)B-150" ('4.#51&(F;" !'#," 333" #57" '2'5-%#**)" -.#=150" -6" '2#B6/#-12'"+*6=&3"M'#4'"1&"(-4'0*+7)$148"-./6%0."-.'"(6*7'/150"B/64'&&3" D**" 71('5&165#*" #57" &6*17" B/6B'/-1'&" 6+" &B#4'" &14:'5" 15" -.'" 15'21-#$*'" 6B'55'&&"6+"B'#4'8"-.1&"1&"=.)"65'"&.6%*7"'CB'4-"-.'"&B#-1#*"/'#&65150&"E(62'('5-," $1*#-'/#*" 'C4.#50'," +6/(#-165," 0'5'&1&," +*%21#*" #57" *#(15#/" +*6=&," 7'B6&1-165," 333," (671+14#-165," #BB/6B/1#-165," #77/'&&150" #57" 46051-12'" (#B&F" -/#5&(%-'" -6" -.'" 510.-(#/'&"6+"&B#4'"=1-."/6--150"&6*17"E(%-#-165,"$'46(150"B#4:,"-.'"0/1("&1*'54'"6+" -.'"*#&-"=6/7"#57"-.'".%$$%$"6+"-.'"(#--'/"#-"-.'"*+/"(*,1(%-)4'%/F"333";-.'"510.-(#/'" 6+" 21-#*" P%5:;" EQ'5P1" H1/#-6/1," R*667" S*'4-/14F" 333" #57" #-" -.'" '57," '2'/)-.150" '2#B6/#-'&3" M.1*6&6B.)" #*=#)&" -/1'&" -6" 1(('/&'" -.'" ID&1#-14" B'#4'I" 15-6" -.'" 62'/&1*'54'7" 1(('5&1-)" 6+" 7'#-." 6/" &*)*)" %51-150" 1-" =1-." -.'" B&'%76JD&1#-14" E$%-" .'#2)"64417'5-#*F"B#/#71&'"6+"I*6&&"6+"=1**I"E#56-.'/"(67'/51G'7"#57"-=1&-'7"2'/&165" 6+"T./1&-1#51-)F"-6"7'*#),"4654'#*"#57"/'B/'&&"-.'"!,#1,-7*4"&B1/1-"6+"ID&1#-14"B'#4'I"65" -.'" 65'" .#57" #57" &'4%/'" 1-&'*+" -./6%0." -.'" 7'+'5&'" U" 6++'54'" 4#(6%+*#0'&" 65" -.'" 6-.'/"333"5'2'/":56=&,"&-/#-'0)"('*-&"#=#)"#**"4#(6%+*#0'&"E-.1&"1&"-.'"('/4%/)"*#="6+" H-/#-'0)3F"333"&-/#-'0)"/'*'#&'&"4#(6%+*#0'&"#&"-.'"%57'/462'/"#0'5-&"65'"46(14#**)" (#51B%*#-'"#0#15&-"&-/#-'0),"1-&'*+"333"5'2'/":56=&"#5)"B*#5"-6"#*-'/"#"&-/#-'0),"#5)" 5'%-/#*1G#-165" B/64'&&" 6/" 7'#*150" =1-." &-/#-'0)" '2'5" #" &*10.-" -6%4." +'/-1*1G'&" -.'" 'B17'(14" 71&-/1$%-165" 6+" &-/#-'0)," +'/-1*1G'&" -.'" ('&&" -6" (%*-1B*)," -6" &=#/(," (6/'" ('&&,"(6/'"&-/#-'01'&,"(6/'"(%-#-165&"E-.'"0#&'6%&"*#="6+"&-/#-'0)F3"D&1#-14"B'#4'" #&"#"&-/#-'0)".#&"56-.150"-6"76"=1-."465+*14-"E=.#-"1&"465&17'/'7"#&"1-&"-'//6/F"333"1-" 7'46(B6&'&"465+*14-"333"$%-,"1-"1&"15+'4-12'"E'B17'(14"#57"465-#016%&F,"1-"1&"#"B'&-"$)" '&&'54',"465-#(15#-150"'2'/)-.150"1-"B/6$'&"333"-.1&"1&"/'#**)"&%4."#5"#BB#**150"L.150" -.#-" 56-" 65*)" -.'" 64417'5-" $%-" -.'" '5-1/'" #5-./6B6(6/B.1#5" /#4'" +157&" #&" -.'" IV5-.150'7" A6//6/" =1-.6%-" 0'5'&1&I" !(#" 333" #$&6*%-'*)" 4/)B-60'514" 333" 1-" &.6%*7" $'" 4#**'7"IK'&1/'"-6"'2#B6/#-'I,">DH3"M'#4'"76'&"56-"&1(%*#-'"6/"/'B/'&'5-"7'#-."#&"#" -#4-14#*"*15'"-/)150"-6"=1B'"6%-"-.'"<1**"#57"1-&"B/6B'/-1'&"333"#57"1-"1&"56-"7'#-."6/"1-&" 'C-'5&165"333"1-"1&"('&&150"=1-."7'#-."#57"('&&150"=1-."=1**"E9'&&"('"%B@"<1**J('&&F" 333"#"&-14:)"&%$&-#54'"+%&150"=1-."7'#-."#57"0'5'/#-150"('&&8"B6%/150"5'4/6B.1*1&-14" P%14'&"62'/"7'#-.,"-.'5,"0#&1+)150"-.'("#**"333"7'#-."1&"/'57'/'7"26='**'&&"#57"-6-#**)"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'(!)*!+(,%-,.!/#%.#! 4 7#(#0'7"15"-.'"'52#015#-'7"$671E'&F"6+"+'(15151-)"333"6/"=.'5"'2'5"7'#-."$'46('&" #"=6(#5"333"'#/-."4#**&"333"(6-.'/"'#/-."4#**&3" <'&-'/5"4/1-146JB#/#5617"#0'5-&".#2'"65*)"-=6"B/'&%BB6&'7"46051-12'"(#B&" +6/" ID&1#-14" B'#4'I@" 65'," W6&&" 6+" <1**" #&" -.'1/" 6=5" I76('&-14#-'7" H.#50/1J*#I" ER%77.1&(?F,"-.'5"X'2'50'"#&"#"+'/('5-150"4*6%7"/1&150"+/6("-.'"'5-/#1*&"6+"D&1#," -#:150"+*10.-"65"-.'"&:)"6+"-.'"='&-'/5"*#57&"-6"46//%B-"-.'(3"X#(Y5")"T#P#*I&"9'#)1) !-4#-,) &33-+!-:) !-4#-,) ;-<-+7-" !)#" E=) !-4#-,') 17#1<*':) !-4#-,') <-+71+>1F," L.6(#&" 9#55I&" ?-1,6) *+) @-+*4-" #57" #(650" 465-'(B6/#/)" =/1-'/&" !&-2#5" T&14&'/)JX65#)I&" 9","#*!,*4)9%")'#),6-)#-<-+7-)'3),6-)3","#-"!*#,"#**"#/'"$6%57"-6"-.1&"/%-.*'&&*)"46*651#*" E#57" %--'/*)" B#-.'-14F" $%-" 71&0%1&150" B.1*6&6B.)@" ;+6/" #" &'4/'-" 6++'5&'," &'4/'-" /'2'50'3;"333"W#%/#"O-1&"15".'/"=6/:"A-0(#1+-!)!+#,"15"&B1-'"6+"1-&"#4#7'(14"B/6&'," %5462'/&"-.'"/'2'50'"+6/(%*#"=1-."#5"15&10.-+%*"-'5#41-),"&.6=150".6="-.'"+6/(%*#" 6+" /'2'50'" E+6/" #" &'4/'-" 6++'5&'," &'4/'-" /'2'50'F" '5-#50*'&" 7''B*)" =1-." -.'" D&1#-14" .6//6/" -.#-" 46*651#*1&(" #57" 1-&" B#/#5617" #0'5-&" +157" 65" -.'1/" 6=5" 7#"+/3" O5" 1-&" E/'2'50'"+6/(%*#F"/1017"71('5&165,"-.'"46*651#*1&-"#*(6&-"$'.#2'&"15"#"4.#%2151&-14" =#)," 4#B-%/150" #**" 15-'/#4-165&" #57" 46((%514#-165&" 6+" -.'" O%-&17'/" =1-." .1(&'*+" -./6%0.".1&"6=5"&'*+J15-/6&B'4-165"15-6"-.'"/'(6/&'*'&&"+6/(%*#"6+"/'2'50'"U"#2'50'," -.'5," &'':150" -6" B%/0'" #**" #2'50150" U" /'2'50150" #0'5-&" E6%-&17'/F" =1-." -.'" &#('" 7'0/''" 6+" /'(6/&'*'&&5'&&" -.#-" 65'" &.6%*7" '&-#$*1&.'&" -6" B/6-'4-" .1(&'*+" +/6(" -.'" /'2'50'" 6+" -.'" 6-.'/3" D&" -.'" 465-15%%(" 6+" -.1&" 62'/J&1(B*1+)150" #57" #/-*'&&" 152'&-10#-165" 6+" -.'" 46*651#*1&(" 15-6" /'2'50'," -.'/'" 1&" #*&6" #56-.'/" B1-1*'&&" )'-" (#5'%2'/150"#57"7'4'B-12'"(#51B%*#-165"6+"-.1&"+6/(%*#8"15&-'#7"6+"#"7'&B6-14"#57" &-%B17" 46%5-'/#4-165," -.'" 4/1-146JB#/#5617" #0'5-" #&4/1$'&" -.1&" +6/(%*#" -6" #**" B#/-141B#-165&," '50#0'('5-&" #57" 15-'/#4-165&" -6" 56-" 65*)" 012'" .1(&'*+" #" /'*1'+" 62'/" -.'" B'&-1*'5-1#**)" 46(B*'C" (%*-1B*141-)" 6+" -.'" -.150&" #57" '2'5-&" E154*%7150" -.'" D&1#-14" .6//6/F" =.14." #/'" 6%-" 6+" .1&" 0/#&B" #57" -B$-4,1,*'+!," $%-" #*&6" /'7%4'&" #**" (%*-1B*)150"#57"'B17'(14"E-.'"6B'55'&&"6+"B'&-F"15-'/#4-165&"6+"D&1#"=1-."-.'"<'&-" #&"0#&J=#/+#/'"6/"&-/#-'0)"-6"-.'"0'%1#)4'+3%*4,"1%),14,*41%)%*+-!3"<.#-"-.')"4#5"56-14'" 1&" 65*)" %148" #57" &154'" D&1#" #57" 1-&" &1&-'/," D+/14#," $6-." *#4:" E46((%514#-165," 15-'/#4-165,"'-43F"65"#"B/'&%BB6&'7"4/1-146JB#/#5617"B*#5',"-.')"$'.#2'"#446/7150"-6" -.'" /'2'50'" +6/(%*#3" Z6/" !&-2#5" T&14&'/)JX65#)," -.'" 764-/15'" 6+" *#4:" #57" /'2'50'" +6/(%*#" &='**&" 15-6" #" 46&(14" &4#*'" #57" 56-" D&1#8" $%-" 1-" 1&" #" /'B/'&'5-#-165" 6+" #BB*)150"-.'"6*7"/'2'50'"+6/(%*#"-6"D&1#"1-&'*+"#-"#"(6/'"71&0%1&'7"#57"15-'5&'"*'2'*3" 333" A6='2'/," D&1#-14" B'#4'" #57" D+/14#5" P%50*'" +'2'/" =6/:" =1-." -.'" (%-#-150" &-/#-'01'&"6+"B'&-J=#/+#/'"#57"-.'"-6-#*"6B'55'&&"E$'150"6B'5"#57"*#4'/#-'7"6B'5'7F" 6/"133*#01+4-"=.6&'"465-#(15#-165"1&"$#&'J46((%514#-165"#57"$#&'JB#/-141B#-1653"!" =657'/" .6=" '++'4-12'*)" #57" '++141'5-*)," -.')" '($'7" -.'" /'2'50'" +6/(%*#" -6" R%77.1&("E=.#-".#&"#--/#4-'7"-.'1/"#BB'-1-'"#&"#"/'+6/('7"2'/&165"6+"T./1&-1#51-)F3" 9#)$'" #&" &:1*+%*" #&" -6" (#:'" #" ('714#*" (#51+'&-6" *66:&" *1:'" #" &41'54'" +14-165" &.6/-" &-6/)"E9'#)1)!-4#-,)'33-+!-:)!-4#-,)#-<-+7-F"#57"#"+%**)"HZ"'&&#)"E56-"#&"1-"4*#1(&"=.#-"1-" 1&F"#&"#"('71415#**)"&=''-"/'B6/-"E9","#*!,*4)9%")'#),6-)#-<-+7-)'3),6-)3","#-F3"!+"!"#(" +151&.150"-.'"71&4%&&165"65"/'2'50'"+6/(%*#".'/',"1-"1&"$'4#%&'"'2'5"71&4%&&150"-.'"

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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'(!)*!+(,%-,.!/#%.#! 6 333" M'#4'@" =.'/'" &%/+#4'&" (%-#-'" -6" '#4." 6-.'/8" 133'#/1+4-" E-.'" -.'/(6J '4656()"6+"465&1&-'54)"#57"H%/212#*"S4656()F"-/#5&(%-'&"-6"2'5'/'#*"#**1#54'"#57" -%/5&" 15-6" -.'" &)($16-14" 46//'*#-165&8" &%$2'/-150" -.'/(6J'4656(14#*" /'*#-165&.1B&," /'+'/'5-1#*" 15-'0/1-1'&," /'B/'&'5-150" U" &1051+)150" $657&," +1*1#-165&," -'57'541'&" #57" $1*#-'/#*"'C4.#50'&"=1-."M6&&'&&165"E13'3"$#&'J46((%514#-165F"!"&#" !5"B'#4'"-.'"7'&-/%4-12'"*15'&"6+"('*''"#/'":'B-"-6-#**)"6B'5"-6"'#4."6-.'/@" -.6%&#57&" 6+" =#/" $'#&-&," .%50/)" #57" /#$17," $%-" 56-" #*12'," (6/'" #44%/#-'*)," 56-" =#/(," 56-" +%54-165#*," 56-" 76('&-14#-'7" $%-" 7/#15'7" 6+" %-1*1-)," 46*7J('*-'7" #57" (6*7'/150"62'/"'#4."6-.'/"E&1*'5-"0#50/'5'F,"B'/('#-150"-./6%0."'#4."6-.'/"-6"$'" '5/14.'7" #&" #" B#4:" JJ" 465-#016%&" #57" &.#76=150" JJ" #5" #565)(6%&" 4*6%7" /#15150" 2'56(," &('#/150" -.'" 0%*+&" 6+" D5-#/4-14#3" R61*150" #&" #" /6--150" 066," (%-1*#-150" -.'" *15'&" 6+" 216*'54'," $'46(150" B6**%-150" #0'5-," $'46(150" P%50*'," $'46(150" (%-#5-," $'46(150" 15+'4-12'" &-/#-'0)," $'46(150" #565)(6%&" -6" #**" '-'/51-)8" -.1&" 1&" -.'" %*-1(#-'"-/#15150"*'&&65"6+"=#/"$'#&-&"333"15"B'#4'"333]6%"4#5"+157"&%4."&-/#-'01'&"15" D&1#3" 333" D&B.)C1#-'7" $)" D&1#-14" B'#4'" 333" O54'" 'C1&-'54'" 1&" 'CB6&'7" -6" =!*1,*4) $-14-," 1-" &15:&," &.12'/&" 15" 5#%&'#," 26(1-&" 1-&'*+," $'46('&" ='-," '2#B6/#-'&" #57" 46**#B&'&"15-6"ID565)(6%&J%5-1*J[6=I"333"-.'"&#4/'7"(%-1*#-1653" L6"I(%-#5-"7'#7"067I@";A'*B"('"-.'"*1--*'"+/''G'3;" [6-'&@" ^_`" O5" 5'4/6B.1*1#," &''@" M'&-1&" H6*17%&" #57" L./6%0." -.'" #565)(6%&" .1&-6/1'&"6+"46/B&'"#57"-.'"A1&-6/)"6+"K'#-."" ^a`"O5"A",1+,)?-1/)D'/@"&''"D">667"9'#*-^b`"O5"$'150"6B'5"#57"6B'5'7,"&''@"D">667"9'#*"#57"T#-#J" ^c`"O5"-.'"-'/(15#*"&6+-'5150"B/64'&&'&,"&''@"K'4#)" ^d`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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'(!)*!+(,%-,.!/#%.#! 7 ^e`"O5"-.'"E%5FL.150"=1-.6%-"0'5'&1&,"&''@"T#-#J^f`"H''"T#P#*,"H3"X3,"@141,*'+)E,'#*-!F)9*<-)E4*-+4-)9*4,*'+)I1%-!,"-/#5&3"W#%/#" O-1&,"V512'/&1-)"6+"!**1561&"M/'&&,"agg_""" ^h`"H''"T&14&'/)JX65#)"\/,"!&-2#5,"9","#*!,*4)9%")'#)I6-);-<-+7-)'3),6-)9","#-" 15" 9*4,*'+) JKKKF) C2(-#$"+8) 1+/) ,6-) 9","#-) '3) L1##1,*<-," '73" $)" >'6/0'" H*%&&'/" #57" L6("H.1BB'),"D-.'5&"#57"W65765@"V512'/&1-)"6+">'6/01#"M/'&&,"_iia" ^i`"H''"O-1&,"W#%/#,)A-0(#1+-!F)A-,1$6'#!)'3)M+<1!*'+)*+)L*+-,--+,6.C-+,"#2) N*,-#1,"#-:)E4*-+4-:)1+/)G'%*,*4!,"L.'"\6.5&"A6B:15&"V512'/&1-)"M/'&&,"_iii" ^_g`"O5"A-,#'+,"&''@)M'&-1&"H6*17%&,"'&B'41#**)"'5756-'"b" ^__`"O5"9%-#-165,"&''@"T#-#J,"R*667"S*'4-/14@"D"X'21'="65"R*667"S*'4-/14" $)"Q'5P1"H1/#-6/1" ^_a`" L.'" /#-165#*1&-" #57" 5'6J17'#*1&-" /'#7150&" 6+" [1'-G&4.'" #57" K'*'%G'" .#2'" -/'('576%&" -#*'5-&" -6" .17'" #" .%0'" #(6%5-" 6+" -.'6*6014#*," (1*1-#5-," 76('&-14#-150" #57" -.'/(6J'4656(14#*" B/'&4/1B-&" 15" -.'(&'*2'&8" 46#*'&4150" K'*'%G1#5" R'46(150" E$'46(150" 2#(B1/'," $'46(150" B#4:," $'46(150" =6(#5" #57" 1(B'/4'B-1$*'F" =1-." <.1-'.'#7I&" 4654/'&4'5-" B/64'&&3" D*-.6%0." 65'" +*1BB150" -./6%0." K'*'%G'" =/1-150&" EA*%%-) $%1,-1"B" #57" N-) G%*) 15" B#/-14%*#/F" (#)" #&&%('" -.1&" 'CB*61-12'"15-1(#4)"$%-"&15:150"15-6"-.'".'#/-"6+"K'*'%G1#5"'B17'(14"6+"R'46(150," 1-I&"1(B6&&1$*'"-6"$'"7'#+"-6"-.'"'4&-#-14"&4/'#(&"6+"4654/'&4'5-"B/64'&&"$'150"-6/5"-6" &./'7&"E*#4'/#-'7"6B'5F3"T654/'&4'5-"B/64'&&"1&"#".'0'(6514"I1%%),'7-,6-#I,"&B/'#7150" #**" #*650" -.'" '4656()" 6+" &%$&1&-'54'" #57" &6*171-)," >'5'&1&" #57" 1-&" 465J&6*17#-165," #++6/7#54'"#57"H%/212#*"S4656()3"<.'5"&6*171-)"'5-'/&"-.'"565J/1017"&-#-'"6+"1-&'*+" 6/" I!'%*/"!" *+) 4*#4"%1,*'+I" E71#0'5'&1&," *#(15#/" +*6=&," +*%21#*" U" #**%21#*" B/64'&&'&," &'71('5-#-165" 6+" +*6=," ('-/6514" +*%C'&," D/1&-6-'*1#5" ('0#J41/4%*#-165&" #57" -.'" '4656()"6+"B&'%76J+*%CF"-.'"(6*#/"U"/1017"U"&-#-14"&-#-'"6+"&6*171-)"=.14."1&"-.'"(6&-" 5#j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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'(!)*!+(,%-,.!/#%.#! 8 -./6%0." -.'" +*%C3" L.'" 4654/'&4'5-" B/64'&&" 1&" #" 7)5#(14" 0-,6-B*!" EB*#-6514" #57" '4656(14#*" B#/-141B#-165F" #(650" #**" 465&-1-%'5-&," B#/-&" #57" '*'('5-&8" .6='2'/," 1-" 76'&" 56-" +6/4'" -.'(" -6" +%54-165" 15" &6('=#)" 6/" #56-.'/" E$1B6*#/" -'57'541'&F" $%-" 46(B'**150"-6"#"+"#57"'#*7*+1,-"E6/1015#-150"#&"/%55150F"#446/7150"-6"-.'"465&1&-'5-" #57" #++6/7#54'J$#&'7" E'4656(14#*F" B#/-141B#-165" 6+" #**" B#/-&" E0-,6-B*!F" =.14." #&&'($*'&" U" 465&6*17#-'&" #5" '4656(14" 5'-=6/:" 6+" &%/212150," 6+" 7='**150" #57" &%$&1&-'54'" +6/" '#4." B#/-" #57" '*'('5-" -./6%0." #5" '4656(14#*" 7)5#(1&(" #57" 0'5'&1&"=.14."1&"%&%#**)"(1&-#:'5"+6/"K'*'%G1#5"R'46(1503" O5" -.'" 6-.'/" .#57," 4654/'&4'5-" B/64'&&" P615&" >'5'&1&" #57" -.'" T./1&-1#5" 764-/15'" 6+" >'5'&1&" K#)" -.#-" 1&" #" 0'5'&1&" 6/" #" *#(15#/" (6/B.6&1&" -./6%0." &6*171-)" #57"1-&"&-#-'&"6+"#/4.1-'4-%/',"465&6*17#-165"#57"465&1&-'54)@"'2'/)-.150"HAOVWK" B#/-141B#-'" -6" '#*7*+1,-" -./6%0." >'5'&1&" M/6P'4-" E0'5'&1&@" 7*7+-!,61*@" $'" $6/5" 6/" B/67%4'7F"-6"HVXk!k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b`"O5"#++6/7#54',"&''@"T#-#J,"'&B'41#**)"'5756-'"b" ^_c`"O5"B6&&'&&165,"&''@"D4'B.#*6%&"96%-."!