Plant - Intelligence Is No Longer On The Side Of Power (Interview with Matt Fuller Datacide 1995)

3PURZ (IZ[YHJ[ *VU[HJ[ +VUH[L )\` 5L^Z 4HNHaPUL ,]LU[Z 9L]PL^Z (Y[PJSLZ 0U[LSSPNLUJL0Z5V3VUNLY6U;OL:PKL6M7V^LY:HKPL 7SHU[0U[LY]PL^  5V*VTTLU[Z (UPU[LY]PL^^P[O:HKPL7SHU[ I`4H[[OL^-\SSLY 7\ISPZOLKPU(SPLU<UKLYNYV\UK  ;OL*YPTPUHS1\Z[PJL(J[PZHUL^SH^PU[OL<2[OH[THZZP]LS`LUSHYNLZ[OLZ[H[L»ZWV^LY [VKLHS^P[OHKP]LYZLYHUNLVM[OYLH[Z-YVTWVYUVNYHWOLYZ[V[YH]LSSLYZYH]LYZ[VO\U[ ZHIV[L\YZYHTISLYZ[V[OLL]LY`KH`JYPTPUHSPZLK[OLZ[H[LPZWYLWHYPUNMVYHWHUPJPUK\JLK JYHJRKV^UVUHSSMVYTZVMYLZPZ[HUJL[V[OLSH^VMWYVWLY[`HUK[OLYLPNUVMºKLJLUJ`» /H]PUNHSYLHK`ZLLUZL]LYHSSHYNLZJHSLYPV[ZH[KLTVUZ[YH[PVUZHNHPUZ[[OL(J[[OL<2 SVVRZZL[MVYH^PKLZWYLHKWLYPVKVMKPZ[\YIHUJL^OPJOTHU`ILSPL]L^PSSH[SLHZ[LUK[OL MPM[LLU`LHYZVM;VY`Y\SLPU[OLZHTL^H`[OH[YLZPZ[HUJL[V[OL7VSS;H_RUVJRLK;OH[JOLY V\[VMNV]LYUTLU[7VSP[PJZOHZ]HZ[S`JOHUNLKOLYL5L^NLULYH[PVUZHYLJVTWSL[LS` KPZLUMYHUJOPZLKI`[OH[VM[OLTHPUZ[YLHT^OPSL[OLZVJHSSLKYL]VS\[PVUHYPLZJVU[PU\L [OLPYIHJR^HYKTHYJO[V^OH[L]LY[OLVYL[PJHS`LHYaLYV[OL`»YLOHSS\JPUH[PUN4LHU^OPSL UL^TL[OVKZVMJVUJLP]PUNHUKYLHSPZPUN[OLVYNHUPZH[PVUVMWLVWSLHUKTH[LYPHSZHYL ILPUNTHKL!H[VULMYHJ[HSSL]LSI`[OL]LY`WLVWSL[OPZIPSSSVVRZZL[[VH[[HJRHUKH[ HUV[OLYHZH^PKLYNSVIHSYHUNLVMKL]LSVWTLU[ZPUJS\KPUN[OLJOHUNPUNWVZP[PVUVM ^VTLU"UL^MVYTZVMZ`U[OL[PJSPML"[OLTPNYH[PVUVMLJVUVTPJKLUZP[`HUK[OLJVUJVTP[HU[ PTWV[LUJLVMº,\YVTHU»"HU\UKLYZ[HUKPUNVMZLSMVYNHUPZPUNZ`Z[LTZPUHSSWYL]PV\ZS` KPZJYL[LHYLHZVMZJPLUJL¯ 6ULZLSMKLJSHYLK¸L_O\THU¹W\SSPUNHSS[OLZLHYLHZ[VNL[OLYPU[VI\UKSLZVM^VYKZPZ :HKPL7SHU[^OVZL^YP[PUNMVYTZUV[ZVTLJH[HSLW[PJWVUKLYPUNVM[OLZLPTWVY[HU[[PTLZ I\[P[ZLSMNLULYH[LZH[VYYLU[PHSMSVVKVMKLYLN\SH[PVU/LYLZLUZ\HS^VYKWSH`TP_LZ^P[OH Z`UHWZL^YLUJOPUNKLW[OVM[OV\NO[[OH[PU[OLYPNO[WSHJLKVLZ[VJVU[YVS^OH[ZHS[KVLZ [VHZS\N T6RH`ZV^OH[»ZNVPUNVUPU[OL<2[VKH`^P[O[OL*YPTPUHS1\Z[PJL(J[HUKZVVU& Z>LSSVU[OLVULOHUK[V[HSYLNYV\WPUNVMYLHJ[PVUHY`MVYJLZZ\TTLK\WI`[OLWOYHZL )HJR[V)HZPJZHUK[OH[IHZPJHSS`PZHWHUPJYLHJ[PVUHNHPUZ[HSV[VMIV[[VT\WZLSM VYNHUPZPUNHJ[P]P[`;OL^OVSLYH]LZJLULVY[OLWVZ[YH]LZJLULOHZYLHSS`JOHUNLK)YP[HPU HJ[\HSS`0[OPURP[»ZJOHUNLK[OL^H`WLVWSL[OPURUV[PUHWVZ[OPWW`ZVY[VM^H`^OPJOPZ VM[LUZHPK[VIL[OLJHZLI\[0[OPURWLVWSLMVYL_HTWSL0ZLLP[^P[OZ[\KLU[Z^OVHYLUV SVUNLYJVU[LU[[VZ[PJR^P[OVULKPZJPWSPUL"OPZ[VY`VYSP[LYH[\YL[OL`^HU[[VKVIPVSVN`

LJVUVTPJZSP[LYH[\YLHUKT\S[PTLKPHHY[HSSH[[OLZHTL[PTL(UKHNHPU[OH[»ZHX\LZ[PVU VMTHRPUNSH[LYHSJVUULJ[PVUZIL[^LLU^OH[^LYLVUJL^LSSLZ[HISPZOLKHUKZLWHYH[L KPZJPWSPULZ0U[LYTZVM[OLHY[ZJLULHZ^LSSVI]PV\ZS`[OH[ZHTLTV]L»ZOHWWLUPUN^P[O T\S[PTLKPH¶`V\»YLUVSVUNLYQ\Z[H]PZ\HSHY[PZ[VYH^YP[LYVY^OH[L]LY4VZ[WLVWSL^OV HYLKVPUNHU`[OPUNPU[LYLZ[PUNPU[OVZLMPLSKZHYLJVU]LYNPUNHNHPU^P[OWLVWSL^OVHYL ^VYRPUNPUV[OLYHYLHZHUKV[OLYTLKPH:VPUHSS[OVZLHYLHZ0[OPUR[OLYLPZ[OPZIHZPJ WH[[LYUVMHTV]LH^H`MYVT[OPZOPLYHYJOPJHS[VWKV^UJVU[YVSVMRUV^SLKNL[VHT\JO TVYLSH[LYHSIV[[VT\WJVUULJ[PVUPZ[ZVY[VMHWWYVHJOHUKHNHPU0[OPUR[OPZPZJVU]LYNPUN ^P[OKPZJV]LYPLZPUIPVSVN`HUKUL^^VYRPULJVUVTPJZHUKL]LU^VYR[OH[»ZKL]LSVWPUN \UKLYZ[HUKPUNVMOV^[OLIYHPU^VYRZ0[[\YUZV\[[OH[P[[VVPZHSH[LYHSWYVJLZZPUNZ`Z[LT UV[[OL[VWKV^UOPLYHYJOPJHSVYNHU[OH[P[^HZVUJL[OV\NO[[VIL T0UHYLJLU[WHWLY`V\OH]LHZRLK¸PZ[OPZ^OH[P[TLHUZ[VNL[V\[VM[OLTLH[UV[ ZPTWS`[VSLH]L[OLIVK`I\[[VNVM\Y[OLY[OHU[OLVYNHUPZT&¹/V^KVLZ[OPZYLSH[L[V [OLL]VS\[PVUHY`PKLHZVM>PSSPHT)\YYV\NOZ[Y\Z[M\UKIHI`HUK[OLTHU^OV^YV[L º/LYL[V.V»&/V^KVLZOPZHU[PIVK`IYHPU[OPUNZWHJLJYHM[YLSH[L[V^OH[`V\»YLVU HIV\[& Z)HZPJHSS`[OL[^VWVZP[PVUZ[OH[HYLLZ[HISPZOLKH[[OLTPU\[LHYLLP[OLY[OH[`V\[HSR HIV\[KPZLTIVKPTLU[VY`V\[HSRHIV\[LTIVKPTLU[,P[OLY`V\»YLV\[VM[OLIVK`PUZVTL Z[YH[VZWOLYPJaVULVY`V\»YLPU[OLVYNHUPZT0[OPUR[OH[ULP[OLYVM[OVZLHYLJVYYLJ[>OLU WLVWSL[HSRHIV\[NL[[PUNV\[VM[OLIVK`[OL`HYLZ[PSSHZZ\TPUN[OH[[OLYLPZZVTLRPUKVM NYLH[[YHUZJLUKLU[ZWHJLSPRLOLH]LUMVY[OLZV\SVYZVTL[OPUNUVUTH[LYPHSH[HU`YH[L[V VJJ\W`(UKHZMHYHZ0»TJVUJLYULK[OH[PZU»[[OLYL;OL\UP]LYZLPZU»[SPRL[OH[P[»ZH TH[LYPHSWYVJLZZUV[ZVTLZVY[VMPKLHSPZ[JVUZ[Y\J[PVU:V`V\JHU»[NL[V\[VMTH[[LY [OH[»Z[OLJY\JPHS[OPUN)\[`V\JHUNL[V\[VM[OLJVUMPUPUNVYNHUPZH[PVUVMTH[[LY^OPJOPZ ZOHWLKPU[V[OPUNZHUKVMJV\YZLVYNHUPZTZ;OLVYNHUPZTPZSP[LYHSS`VYNHUPZLKHYV\UKP[Z VYNHUZ[OL]VJHI\SHY`ZH`ZP[HSSYLHSS` T:V^OH[HYLZVTLVM[OLLZJHWLYV\[LZ[OH[`V\[OPURWLVWSLHYL\ZPUNH[[OL TVTLU[& Z>LSSVI]PV\ZS`[OLYL[OL^OVSLKHUJL[OPUNMVYL_HTWSLHUKHSSVM[OLL_WLYPTLU[Z^P[O ]PY[\HSYLHSP[`VUHYLHSS`WYHNTH[PJSL]LS)\[TVYL[OHU[OH[P[»ZUV[^OH[WLVWSL[Y`[VKV VY^OH[[OL`[OPUR[OL`»YLKVPUN0[HJ[\HSS`PZOHWWLUPUN[V\ZHU`^H`;OLVYNHUPZTP[ ZLLTZ[VTLPZT\[H[PUN^OL[OLY^LTLHUP[[VVYUV[ T0U^OH[RPUKVM^H`& Z-VYL_HTWSLL]LUPM`V\Q\Z[[OPURVMT\S[PTLKPH)LMVYL`V\OH]LT\S[PTLKPH`V\OH]L ZLWHYH[LKTLKPHHUK[OL`HYLHSSIHZLKVUL_PZ[PUNO\THUVYNHUZSPRL[OLL`LHUKZVVU HUK0^V\SKZH`I`L_[LUZPVU[OH[[OL^OVSLZLUZLVMRUV^SLKNLPZIHZLKHYV\UK[OLWOHSSPJ VYNHUZV[OL`»YLHSSIHZLKVUZWLJPMPJVYNHUZLYHZL`LZHUKZVVU)\[`V\Z[HY[[V[HSR HIV\[T\S[PTLKPHP[Q\Z[KVLZU»[THRLZLUZL[V[HSRHIV\[ZLWHYH[LTLKPHVYVMJV\YZL[V [HSRHIV\[ZLWHYH[LVYNHUZ;OLIVK`ILJVTLZHWYVJLZZPUNZ`Z[LTMVY^OH[^LJHUVUS` Z[PSS[OPURVMHZZLWHYH[LVYNHUZZLWHYH[LZLUZLZZLWHYH[LTLKPHI\[VUJL`V\NL[[V[OL WVPU[^OLYL[OL`Z[HY[JVU]LYNPUN[OLU`V\»YLUV[YLHSS`[HSRPUNHIV\[[OLIVK`HZH JVSSLJ[PVUVMVYNHUZHU`TVYL0[ILJVTLZHWVPU[VMJVHSLZJLUJLMVYHSSZVY[ZVMTH[LYPHS MSV^ZHUKHNHPUWLVWSLYLHSPZL[OH[[OL`HYLUV[ZLWHYH[LKPUKP]PK\HSZ5V[Q\Z[ILJH\ZL`V\ JHUOH]LHUL^ZL[VMPKLHZHIV\[JVSSLJ[P]P[`VY^OH[L]LYI\[ILJH\ZLWLVWSLILNPU[V \UKLYZ[HUK[OPUNZSPRLOVYTVUHSJVTT\UPJH[PVU¶HSSZVY[ZVMJVTT\UPJH[PVUZNVPUNVU IL[^LLUWLVWSLHUKIL[^LLUWLVWSLHUK[OLYLZ[VM[OLTH[LYPHS^VYSK:V[OLVSKPKLH HIV\[[OLPUKP]PK\HSHZZLWHYH[LKMYVTUH[\YLVYMYVT[OLYLZ[VM^VYSKPZNVPUNHUKHSS

Z`Z[LTZVMKVTPUH[PVUP[ZLLTZ[VTLOH]LILLUIHZLKVU[OH[ZVY[VMZLWHYH[PVU T@LZ6RH`ZVOV^LSZLKVLZ[OPZWHUV\[& Z3:+HUK4+4(HYL[OL[^VKY\NZ[OH[OH]LOHK[OLZVY[VMPTWHJ[)\[HSZV[OL^OVSL KY\NZ[YHKLPZMHZJPUH[PUN@V\JHUQ\Z[[OPURVMP[HNHPUHZH^OVSLNSVIHSV\[VMJVU[YVS )SHJR,JVUVT`0[WVZLZHUPUJYLKPISL[OYLH[[V[OL^OVSLUH[PVUZ[H[LVYNHUPZH[PVUVM[OL ^VYSK/LUJL[OL>HYVU+Y\NZ/LUJLHSZV[OLPTWVZZPIPSP[`VMSLNHSPZPUNKY\NZHUK[OL PTWVZZPIPSP[`VMRLLWPUNNVPUNVU[OLJ\YYLU[WVSPJPLZHSTVZ[Z\TZ\W[OLJYPZPZ(UKP[YLHSS` PZHIPNJYPZPZ T7VYUPZJ\YYLU[S`ILLUZLLUHZZVTL[OPUNNVVKI`THU`MLTPUPZ[ZHNHPU>OH[»Z[OL YLHZVUMVY[OPZ^OH[»Z[OLWVYU[OH[[\YUZ`V\VUHUKPZWVYUOLHS[O`& Z0ZP[OLHS[O`&5VP[PZUV[OLHS[O`0[»ZHIZVS\[LS`ZPJR(UK[OH[»Z^O`L]LY`IVK`SPRLZP[ )LJH\ZLOLHS[OJSLHUSPULZZHUKZVVUHYLHSSV\[VM[OL^PUKV^>OH[ZVY[VMWVYU[\YUZTL VU&>LSSHJ[\HSS`[OLYL»ZH^OVSLJYL^VMWLVWSLPU)PYTPUNOHT^YP[PUNZVY[VMOHSMSLZIPHU OHSMZVY[VMTHJOPULWVYUHUK`LHO0SPRL[OH[ZVY[VM[OPUN7VZ[O\THUWVYUPZ[OL[OPUN )LJH\ZLHNHPUTVZ[WVYUPZHIV\[[P[ZHUKI\TZHUKVYNHUZ(UK^OH[ULLKZ[VOHWWLUPZ ZVTL[OPUN[OH[NL[ZIL`VUK[OH[)HJ[LYPHSZL_MVYL_HTWSLPZM\SSVMWV[LU[PHS¶IHJ[LYPHS WVYUVNYHWO` T¯1\Z[VWLU`V\YYLMYPNLYH[VY:V[VNL[IHJR[VIHZPJZ>OH[PZH^VTHU>OH[PZH KY\N(UK^OH[»ZHJVTW\[LY& Z>OH[»ZPU[LYLZ[PUNHIV\[J`ILYUL[PJZHUKJVTW\[LYZPZ[OH[P[HSTVZ[NVLZ^P[OV\[ZH`PUN I\[[OL`^LYLVYPNPUHSS`PU[LUKLKQ\Z[[VYLPUMVYJL[OLZ[HISPZOLKZ[Y\J\YLZHUKTHPU[HPU[OL Z[H[\ZX\V(UKHSZV[LJOUPJHSS`[OLMPYZ[JVTW\[LYZ^LYLZLYPHSTHJOPULZHUK[OL`^LYL VYNHUPZLKHYV\UKJLU[YHSWYVJLZZPUN\UP[ZZV[OL`[VV^LYL]LY`[VWKV^UZ`Z[LTZHUK[OL` [LUKLK[VWLYWL[\H[LH[VWKV^U^VYSK)\[VUJL`V\Z[HY[[VKL]LSVWTHJOPULPU[LSSPNLUJL VYHY[PMPJPHSPU[LSSPNLUJLL]LUPU[OLTVZ[IHZPJZLUZLQ\Z[[OPURVMHJVTW\[LYHZHWYV[V PU[LSSPNLU[THJOPUL[OLUVI]PV\ZS`[OLWVPU[HIV\[PU[LSSPNLUJLPZ[OH[P[^PSSSLHYUHUKP[^PSS SLHYUP[ZV^UZ[\MMHUKP[^VU»[ULJLZZHYPS`SLHYU^OH[[OLL_WLY[ZMLLKPU[VP[HUK[OH[ZOPM[ OHZUV^YLHSS`OHWWLULKPU(0^P[OHYLHSZOPM[H^H`MYVT[VWKV^UL_WLY[PZL[VIV[[VT\W SLHYUPUNWYVJLZZLZHUK[OH[HNHPUMLLKZPU[V[OLJOHSSLUNLHNHPUZ[LK\JH[PVUILJH\ZL [LHJOPUNNVLZV\[VM[OL^PUKV^HUKP[HSSILJVTLZHTH[[LYVMSLHYUPUNPUZ[LHK :V[OH[»ZHJ[\HSS`JOHUNLK[OLPU[LYUHSJVTWVZP[PVUVM[OLJVTW\[LYI\[P[OHZHSZVMLKPU[V P[ZHJ[\HSLMMLJ[ZPU[OL^VYSKHZ^LSS0M`V\Q\Z[[HRL[OLL_HTWSLVM[OLZP[\H[PVUVM^VTLU PU[OL^VYSKVI]PV\ZS`[OLYL»ZZ[LWZMVY^HYKHUKZ[LWZIHJR^HYKI\[[OLYLPZUL]LY[OLSLZZH NLULYHS[LUKLUJ`MVYTVYLMYLLKVTMVY^VTLUHUK[OH[PZ]LY`T\JO[VKV^P[O[OL PUO\THU[OL`HYLSP[LYHSS`PUO\THUWYVJLZZLZVMLJVUVTPJHUK[LJOUPJHSJOHUNL[OH[KV Z^LLWH^H`HZ4HY_ZHPK[OLVSKZ[Y\J[\YLZVM[OLMHTPS`[OLZ[H[LLK\JH[PVU[YHKL \UPVUZHSSVM[OLVSKZVJPHSJVUZ[YHPU[Z 0UL]P[HIS`[OLMHSSV\[MYVT[OH[PZHUL^MYLLKVTMVY^VTLUHUK[OLPYVU`VM[OPZPZ[OH[ MLTPUPZTVU[OL^OVSLOHZILLUNVPUNPUL_HJ[S`[OLVWWVZP[LKPYLJ[PVU¶P[»Z^HU[LK[V OH]LHWVSP[PJHSZVS\[PVUPUHZLUZL^OPJOPZHS^H`ZH[VWKV^UZVS\[PVU0[»ZHX\LZ[PVUVM ºSL[»ZVYNHUPZL^VTLU»VYºSL[»ZTHRLZ\JOHUKZ\JOOHWWLU»)\[^OH[»ZPU[LYLZ[PUNHIV\[ [OLWYLZLU[ZP[\H[PVUPZ[OH[[OLJOHUNLZ[OH[WLVWSLOVWLKMVYHYLOHWWLUPUNI\[[OL` HYLU»[OHWWLUPUNILJH\ZLVM¶[OL`»YLHSTVZ[OHWWLUPUNPUZWP[LVM¶[OLH[[LTW[Z[VTHRL [OLTOHWWLU3PRL[OPZ^OVSL[OPUNHIV\[NPYSZKVPUNIL[[LYH[ZJOVVSMVYPUZ[HUJL;OH[»Z OHWWLULK[V[HSS`\UKLY[OLUVZLZI\[HSZVILOPUK[OLIHJRZVM[OL^OVSLLX\HS VWWVY[\UP[PLZSVII`0[OHZU»[OHWWLULKILJH\ZLWLVWSLOH]L[YPLK[VNL[NPYSZ[VKVIL[[LY ;OLYLPZP[ZLLTZ[VTLH^OVSLZOPM[HJYVZZ[OLIVHYK(UKPM`V\[OPURVM[OLWVZP[PVUVM

^VTLUPU[OLWHZ["YLHSS`^VTLUOH]LHSTVZ[ILLU\ZLKSPRLJVTW\[LYZ¶HZTHJOPULZ[V RLLWWH[YPHYJO`NVPUN[VYLWYVK\JL[OLNLULYH[PVUZHUKZVVUHUKHNHPU[OH[[VVPZHUV[OLY JHZLVM[OPUNZ[OH[OH]LILLU\ZLKHZTLHUZ[VLUKZWH[YPHYJOHSHUKWV^LYZ[Y\J[\YLLUKZ WYVK\JLYLZ\S[Z[OH[ILJVTLZLSMVYNHUPZPUNHUKNL[[OLPYHJ[Z[VNL[OLY^P[OV\[ILPUN TLHUZ[VLUKZ0[»Z[Y\L^P[O[OLTLKPHHZ^LSSHUKHSZV^P[O[YHKLYV\[LZHUKJVTTVKP[PLZ L]LU[OH[^VTLUYLHSS`[OLTZLS]LZOH]LM\UJ[PVULKHZJVTTVKP[PLZPU^LZ[LYUJ\S[\YLZ (UKJVTTVKP[PLZ`V\JV\SKYLHSS`ZH`HYLºNL[[PUNZTHY[»@V\RUV^[OLJVTW\[LYPZº[OL MPYZ[ZTHY[JVTTVKP[`»I\[VI]PV\ZS`^VTLUHYLZTHY[JVTTVKP[PLZ[VVHUK[OLVYNHUPZPUN O\THUZ^OVZ[PSS[OPUR[OH[[OL^VYSKYL]VS]LZHYV\UK[OLT[OL`HYL[OLIYHJRL[VY[OL ZLJ[PVU[OH[YLHSS`SVVZLZV\[(UKHSZVILJH\ZLVM[OLZP[\H[PVUVM^VTLUPU[OLWHZ[[OL` [VVOH]LUL]LYILLUHISL[VOH]LHZ[YVUNZLUZLVMPKLU[P[`HUK[OH[»ZHS^H`ZILLUHYLHS WYVISLT!OLUJL^VTLUNL[[PUNSVJRLK\WMVYILPUNZJOPaVWOYLUPJZHUKO`Z[LYPJZHUKZVVU HUKZVMVY[O)\[HNHPU[OH[Z[YVUNZLUZLVMPKLU[P[`UV^ILJVTLZH[LYYPISLKPZHK]HU[HNL HUKL]LY`IVK`[OH[»ZNYV^U\W^P[O[OH[PZHUK^PSSPU[OLULHYM\[\YLYLHSS`Z\MMLYHZH JVUZLX\LUJLVMP[ T:V^OPSLL]LY`[OPUN»ZWS\TTL[PUNJYHaPS`V\[VMJVU[YVS[OLYLHYLZ[PSSWLVWSLSPRL >PYLKVY^OH[L]LY¶[OLWLVWSL[OL`JOHTWPVU¶^OVZ[PSS[OPUR[OH[[OL`JHUTHRL]HZ[ HTV\U[ZVMMHZ[I\JRZV\[VM[OLWYVJLZZ¯ Z>LSS[OH[»Z[Y\LI\[^OH[[OL`[OPUR[OL`»YLKVPUN¯0TLHU[VILOVULZ[THRPUNTVUL` V\[VMP[PZU»[ULJLZZHYPS`T`WYVISLT;OLTOH]PUNJVU[YVSV]LYP[PZHWYVISLT6I]PV\ZS`P[ \ZLK[VIL[OLJHZL[OH[V^ULYZOPWHUKJVU[YVS^LU[OHUKPUOHUKI\[0»TUV[JVU]PUJLK [OH[P[»ZX\P[L[OH[ZPTWSLHU`TVYL(UKZH`PU[LSSLJ[\HSWYVWLY[`PZHJSHZZPJJHZL@V\JHU Q\TW\WHUKKV^U[V`V\YOLHY[»ZJVU[LU[HUKZH`º[OH[»ZTPUL»I\[[OLMHJ[PZ^OL[OLY`V\ SPRLP[VYUV[P[PZU»[HU`TVYL ;OLYLHYLZJPLU[PZ[ZHYV\UKMVYPUZ[HUJL^OVYLHSS`KVZLL[OLTZLS]LZHZº:JPLU[PZ[ZPU[OPZ HNHPUNV]LYUPUN[VWKV^UZVY[VMYVSL^OVKV[OPUR[OH[[OL`HYLJYLH[PUNV\YM\[\YL -VY[\UH[LS`[OL`HYLQ\Z[UHP]L:VP[ZLLTZ[VTL[OH[P[PZPUJYLHZPUNS`WVZZPISL[VSVVRH[ [OLLTLYNLUJLVMPU[LSSPNLUJLMHYPUL_JLZZVM[OLWYV]PUJLVM[OLVSK^OP[LTHSLHUK HNHPUWLVWSLPU[OH[ZVY[VMWVZP[PVU[OL`TH`[OPUR[OH[[OL`»YLY\UUPUN[OL^OVSLZOV^I\[ [OL`»YLQ\Z[HNHPU[PU`JVTWVULU[ZZ\IQLJ[[V[OLZHTLZVY[VMTVSLJ\SHYLUNPULLYPUNZ[OH[ [OLYLZ[VM\ZHYLHUK^OH[[OL`[OPUR[OL`HYLKVPUN^OLU`V\W\[P[PU[OLJVU[L_[VM LTLYNLU[WSHUL[HY`PU[LSSPNLUJLPZPYYLSL]HU[[V^OH[[OL`HJ[\HSS`HYLKVPUN:V[OLYL»ZH IPNZWSP[HSS[OL^H`[OYV\NO[OPZIL[^LLUPU[LU[PVUZHUKLMMLJ[Z(SS[OLPU[LU[PVUZ[OH[OH]L MLKPU[V[OLWYLZLU[ZP[\H[PVUOH]L\UP]LYZHSS`ILLUIHKHUKOH]LHS^H`ZILLUHIV\[ THPU[HPUPUNL_PZ[PUNZ[Y\J[\YLZVMJVU[YVSI\[[OLLMMLJ[ZHYLPUJYLHZPUNS`Y\UH^H`LMMLJ[Z HUK[OH[»Z^OH[J`ILYUL[PJZPZHIV\[HSTVZ[ T/V^KVZLSMVYNHUPZPUNZ`Z[LTZKPMMLYMYVTJ\S[\YLZVYZ\IJ\S[\YLZZ\JOHZW\UR OHJRPUNNYHZZYVV[ZMLTPUPZT^PSKJH[^VYRPUNJSHZZVYNHUPZH[PVU0ZP[[OLZHTL[OPUN VYPZP[HKPMMLYLU[[OPUN& Z0[OPUR[OH[P[»ZHUL^HUKIL[[LY^H`VM[OPURPUN[OLZHTL[OPUNHJ[\HSS`0[OPUR[OH[ YL[YVZWLJ[P]LS``V\SVVRIHJRHUK[OPURº6O`LHO^LSSVMJV\YZLWLVWSLOH]LHS^H`ZILLU KVPUNP[»)\[0[OPUR[OH[[OLWLVWSL^OVJHUYLHSS`[HRLHK]HU[HNLVMP[HYL[OLVUJL^OV JHUYLHSS`ZLL[OLTZLS]LZKVPUNP[)LJH\ZLMVYL_HTWSLHSV[VMZH`NYHZZYVV[ZMLTPUPZ[ VYNHUPZH[PVUPM`V\[HRL[OLWVYUVNYHWO`PZZ\LMVYL_HTWSL[OL`TH`OH]LVYNHUPZLK [OLTZLS]LZHUKZVVUI\[PM[OL`»K[OV\NO[VM[OLTZLS]LZHZZLSMVYNHUPZPUNWYVJLZZLZ ^V\SKOH]LH]LY`KPMMLYLU[H[[P[\KL[VWVYUVNYHWO`HUK[OL`^V\SKU»[OH]L^HU[LK[VILPU [OPZWVZP[PVUVMSLNPZSH[PUNHUKJVU[YVSSPUN[OLJ\S[\YL:V[OLTVYLWLVWSLHJ[\HSS`KVZLSM VYNHUPZH[PVUHUKZLL[OLTZLS]LZKVPUN[OH[[OLU[OH[YH[JOL[ZP[ZLSM\WVULM\Y[OLYSL]LS

T:V^OH[PZ[OLKPMMLYLUJLIL[^LLUH\[VWYVK\J[PVUH\[VWYVK\aPVULHUK^OH[`V\ HYL[HSRPUNHIV\[& Z>LSSP[»Z[OH[0[OPUR[OH[L]LU[OV\NOH\[VWYVK\J[PVUHUKHU`UV[PVUZSPRL[OH[OH]LNV[ [OLWV[LU[PHS[VOP[^OH[0»T[HSRPUNHIV\[VYJVTL]LY`JSVZLSHYNLS`ILJH\ZLP[ZHSS PUMS\LUJLK¯`V\RUV^5LNYPHUKV[OLYZHYLPUMS\LUJLKI`+LSL\aLHUK.\H[[HYPHUK -V\JH\S[HUKZ\JOJOHYHJ[LYZHUKZVHT0¯ZV[OL`JVTLV\[VMZPTPSHYYVV[Z)\[ H\[VWYVK\J[PVUHZ[OL`OH]LJOHYHJ[LYPZLKP[PZZ[PSS]LY`T\JOHIV\[º[OLZLSM»^P[OHT\JO VSKLYIV\YNLVPZPLJVUJLW[PVUVMZLSMPKLU[P[`HUKJVSSLJ[P]LPKLU[P[`VYZVJPHSPKLU[P[`(UK ^OH[0»T[HSRPUNHIV\[PZZVTL[OPUN[OH[KVLZWHZZ[OYV\NO[OH[HUKTHRLZHSSVM[OH[ WVZZPISLI\[NVLZIL`VUKP[0[\UKVLZº[OLZLSM»Q\Z[HZT\JOHZP[\UKVLZ[OLZ[H[L JVYWVYH[PVUZVYHU`V[OLYPUZ[P[\[PVUZL[J T:VKVLZ[OPZVI]PV\ZS`KVLZU»[WYLZLU[`L[HUV[OLYZL[VMRL`WYPUJPWSLZ[OYV\NO ^OPJO[V^VYR& Z5V^LULLKUVWYPUJPWSLZ)\[J\S[\YHS]PY\ZLZ0[OPURPZHYLHSS`NVVKJS\LHUK[OPZUV[PVU VMLUNPULLYPUN@V\JHU»[OVWL[VHUKWLVWSLZOV\SKU»[^HU[[V[HRLWVSP[PJHSJVU[YVSVY[V VYNHUPZLV[OLYWLVWSL0[»ZHTH[[LYVMSVVRPUNYLHSS`JVVSS`HUKJHSTS`H[^OLYL`V\HYLH[ [OL[PTL^OH[L]LYZP[\H[PVU`V\»YLPUHUK^OH[`V\JHULUNPULLY^P[OPU[OH[ZP[\H[PVU!UV[ NL[[PUN[VVV]LYPUMSH[LKHIV\[[HRPUNJVU[YVSVMP[VYTHRPUNZVTL[OPUNOHWWLUPUHZVY[VM KVNTH[PJMHZOPVUI\[Q\Z[NVPUNMVYHIP[VM[PURLYPUNOLYLHUK[OLYL^OPJOJHUOH]L HTHaPUNZVY[VM\UL_WLJ[LKLMMLJ[Z0M`V\^HU[[VJOHUNL[OLH[TVZWOLYLVMZVTL^OLYL `V\KVU»[KVP[I`Q\Z[^HSRPUNPUHUK[HRPUNV]LY@V\JHUKVHSV[TVYLZ\I[SLIV[[VT\W ZVY[VM[PURLYPUN(UKPU[LYTZVMZWYLHKPUNPKLHZHUKZVVU[OPZ^OVSLPKLHVMJ\S[\YHS ]PY\ZLZPZYLHSS`MHZJPUH[PUNHUK]LY`\ZLM\S@V\JHUZLLOV^[OL`NL[VU[V`V\YOLHKZV `V\JHULHZPS`ZLLOV^[V\ZL[OLT T/V^KVLZ`V\Y]LYZPVUVMJ\S[\YHS]PY\ZLZJVTWHYL[V[OH[VM9PJOHYK+^VYRPUZMVY PUZ[HUJL& Z>LSS+^VYRPUZPZZ[PSS]LY`T\JOHZJPLU[PZ[/L[HSRZ]LY`OHWWPS`HIV\[J\S[\YHS]PY\ZLZ HUK]LY`PU[LYLZ[PUNS`\W[VHWVPU[I\[OLKVLZU»[[OPUR[OH[OLOPTZLSMPZH]PYHSJVU[HNPVU OLZ[PSS[OPUR[OH[OLPZ[OLZJPLU[PZ[0MOL»KNVULVULZ[LWM\Y[OLYHUKJV\SKZLLOV^PU[LNYHS OL[VPZ[V[OH[WYVJLZZHUKOL^HZU»[Y\UUPUNP[HNHPUPU[OPZVSK]LYZPVUVM^OH[HZJPLU[PZ[ PZ[OLU`LHO0[OPUROL»KWYVIHIS`ILX\P[LPU[LYLZ[PUNHZ^LSS T9PNO[:V!J\S[\YHS]PY\ZLZ¯ Z+Y\NZHYLVI]PV\ZS`VUL4+4(PZHMHZJPUH[PUNJHZLILJH\ZLHM[LYHSSP[OHKILLUHYV\UK MVY`LHYZWLVWSLOHKL]LU\ZLKP[PU[OLZP_[PLZHUKP[Q\Z[VI]PV\ZS`^HZU»[[OLYPNO[ TVTLU[;OLWVPU[HIV\[HJ\S[\YHS]PY\ZPZ[OH[P[JHUSPLKVYTHU[MVYHSVUN[PTLHUK[OLT ZVTL[OPUNJHU[YPNNLYP[VYP[JHU[YPNNLYZVTL[OPUNLSZLHUKHNHPU[OLJY\JPHS[OPUNPZUV[[V [HSRHIV\[[OPZZVY[VM[OPUNTL[HWOVYPJHSS`ILJH\ZLV[OLY^PZL`V\Q\Z[SLH]L[OLVSK^VYSK PU[HJ[;OPZPZU»[HUL^^H`VM[OPURPUNHIV\[P[0[PZ[OH[I\[VUS`ILJH\ZLVMTH[LYPHS ULJLZZP[`UV[ILJH\ZLVMºOL`SL[»ZOH]LUL^ZL[VMPKLHZ»0[»ZQ\Z[ZPTWS`[OH[[OLVSKZL[ VMPKLHZPZ[V[HSS`VIZVSL[L(UK[OPURPUNP[ZLSMPZHTH[LYPHSWYVJLZZHUK[OH[[VVPZWHY[VMP[ ;OLYLPZU»[[OPZZLWHYH[PVUIL[^LLUPKLHZHUK^OH[L]LYLSZL T0[»ZHX\LZ[PVUVM^OLYL`V\ZP[\H[LP[ Z@LHO0KV[OPUR[OH[)YP[HPUT\JOHZ0ZWLUKTVZ[VMT`[PTLOH[PUNP[0KVPUJYLHZPUNS` [OPUR[OH[P[PZX\P[LHUPU[LYLZ[PUNWSHJL[VIL7HY[S`ILJH\ZLP[OHZNV[Z\JOHZVY[VMSVHK VMYLTUHU[ZVM[OLHYPZ[VJYHJ`KV[[LKHYV\UKHUK[OH[KVLZ[LUK[VKVZVTL[OPUNWVZP[P]L

VU[OL\UKLYZPKL:VP[OHZNV[[OPZHTHaPUN\UKLYNYV\UKJ\S[\YLHUKP[ZLLTZ[VTL[OH[ [OLH\[OVYP[PLZOH]LU»[X\P[LNV[[OLZ[YHUNSLOVSK[OH[[OL`OH]LL]LUPUV[OLY,\YVWLHU JV\U[YPLZ(UKP[»ZHSZVPU[LYLZ[PUNS`WVZP[PVULKUV[VUS`IL[^LLU,\YVWLHUK(TLYPJH ILJH\ZL0KVU»[[OPURP[PZ,\YVWLHUHUKP[»ZVI]PV\ZS`UV[(TLYPJHU)\[I`[OLZHTL[VRLU P[»ZWVZP[PVULKZ[YHUNLS`IL[^LLUUVY[O,\YVWL:JHUKPUH]PHHUK[OLZV\[OVM,\YVWLHZ ^LSS0[PZHM\UU`ZVY[VML_WLYPTLU[HSaVUL0[OPUR[OL<2 T(UK[OH[^HZZWVUZVYLKI`[OL)YP[PZO;V\YPZ[)VHYK[OLYL Z0RUV^P[»Z[LYYPISLPZU»[P[I\[0JHUZLL[OLWVPU[VMILPUNOLYLZVTL[PTLZ T:V^OH[KV`V\L_WLJ[^PSSOHWWLUPU)YP[HPUHM[LY[OL*YPTPUHS1\Z[PJL)PSSJVTLZ PU[VMVYJLPUHSSP[ZNSVY`& Z>LSS0[OPUR[^V[OPUNZHJ[\HSS`@V\TPNO[KPZHNYLL^P[O[OPZ¯6U[OLVULOHUKWLVWSL I`ULJLZZP[`^PSSPUJYLHZPUNS`PNUVYL[OLSH^@V\RUV^[OH[UPJLS`L_HJLYIH[LZ[OL^OVSL ZP[\H[PVU)LJH\ZL[OLYL»ZUV^H`[OH[WLVWSLHYLQ\Z[NVPUN[VZ[VWHUKJHU»[Z[VWHUK HU`^H`^V\SKU»[^HU[[V(UK[OLU0[OPUR[OH[[OLYL^PSSILTVYLHUKTVYLWVSHYPZLK JVUMYVU[H[PVUIL[^LLU[OLVSK^VYSKHUK[OLUL^IHZPJHSS`0[OPURP[»ZHSTVZ[HZZPTWSLHZ [OH[HUK[OLTVYL[OH[KVLZWVSHYPZLPUH^H`[OLIL[[LYP[PZILJH\ZL0[OPUR[OH[[OL9PNO[ VY[OLH\[OVYP[PLZHYLILOH]PUNPUJYLKPIS`ZOVY[ZPNO[LKS`HUKHYLQ\Z[MLLKPUNPU[V[OL OHUKZVM[OLIV[[VT\W[LUKLUJPLZ0[»ZYLHSS`[Y\L[OV\NO.VK[OL`HYLHZRPUNMVYM\JRPUN [YV\ISLHYLU»[[OL` T@LHOP[»ZSPRLUVVULJHU^VYRP[V\[ Z>LSS[OL`»YL[OPJR@V\ZLL[OLWVPU[PZ[OH[P[»Z^OLYLPU[LSSPNLUJLPZ0U[LSSPNLUJLPZUV SVUNLYVU[OLZPKLVMWV^LY;OH[»Z[OLWVPU[ T>LSS[OH[»ZHNVVKZSVNHU[VLUKVU Z5VI\[[OL`»YLUV[PU[LSSPNLU[;OL`OH]LU»[HJS\L^OH[PZOHWWLUPUNPU[OL^VYSK(UK [OH[»ZNVVK;OL^OVSLZVJPHSZ[Y\J[\YLPU[OLWHZ[OHZILLUKL]V[LK[VNL[[PUNHSS[OL PU[LSSPNLU[WLVWSLUV[Q\Z[PU[LSSPNLU[WLVWSLILJH\ZLP[NVLZ^H`IL`VUK[OH[¶P[»ZHIV\[ PU[LSSPNLU[WYVJLZZLZ¶VU[V[OLZPKLVMWV^LY;OH[»ZUVSVUNLY[OLVUS`WSHJLMVYWLVWSL[V NV(UK[OPZHNHPUPZHNHPU^O`THYRL[ZHYLPU[LYLZ[PUNILJH\ZL[OLKPMMLYLUJLIL[^LLUMVY L_HTWSL^YP[PUNHIVVRMVYH\UP]LYZP[`WYLZZHUK[OLVWLUTHYRL[PZ[OLKPMMLYLUJLIL[^LLU [V[HSJVUZ[YHPU[HUK[V[HSMYLLKVT T;OV\NO[OLYLPZHKPMMLYLUJLIL[^LLUTHYRL[ZWLYZLHUK[OLHJ[\HSMVYJLZ^OPJO ^VYR[OYV\NOTHYRL[Z7LYOHWZ`V\JV\SKTHRLHKPZ[PUJ[PVUIL[^LLU[OVZL Z>LSSHNHPUYH[OLYHZ^P[O^VTLU^OVOH]LPM`V\SPRLILLU[OLTLHUZVMJVTT\UPJH[PVU IL[^LLUTLUZ[Y\J[\YHSS`HUKVI]PV\ZS`[YHKLYV\[LZHUKJVTTVKP[PLZOH]LILLUQ\Z[ ZPTWS`TLHUZVMWLYWL[\H[PUN[OLJVYWVYH[PVUHUK[OLZ[H[LVYHU`VM[OLIPNWV^LYM\S Z[Y\J[\YLZ)\[PUJYLHZPUNS`P[»ZWYL[[`VI]PV\ZUV^[OH[[OLZ[H[LPZILPUNLYVKLKI`P[ZV^U THYRL[ZHUK[OH[[OL`HYLUVSVUNLYQ\Z[ZLY]PUNP[HZTLHUZ[VP[ZLUKZ;OL`»]L HJJLSLYH[LKIL`VUK[OH[;OL>LZ[MVYL_HTWSLQ\Z[JHUUV[Z[VW[OL7HJPMPJ9PTIVVTPUN ;OLYL»ZUV[OPUN[OH[HNV]LYUTLU[JV\SKKV;OH[O\THUSL]LSVMWV^LYOHZUVZVY[VM JVU[YVSV]LYP[H[HSS :V[OLKHUNLYPZ[OH[PUZ[LHKVMZ[H[LZ`V\NL[JVYWVYH[PVUZ>OPJOPZVI]PV\ZS`UVOLSWH[ HSS)\[JVYWVYH[PVUZHUKL]LUZTHSSLYJVTWHUPLZHUKMPYTZHYLMPUKPUNL_HJ[S`[OLZHTL WYVISLTILJH\ZL[OL`»YLPUL_HJ[S`[OLZHTLZ[Y\J[\YHSYLSH[PVU[VTHYRL[ZHZ[OLZ[H[LPZ HUK[OL`[VVHYLILPUN[HRLUV]LYI`[OLPYV^UTHYRL[Z0TLHU[OLJSHZZPJJHZLPZ

VI]PV\ZS`0)4*VYWVYH[PVUZUV^PM[OL`HYLNVPUN[VZ\Y]P]LOH]L[VZ[HY[ILOH]PUNHSV[ SLZZSPRL[OLVSKTLNHT\S[PUH[PVUHS0TLHU[OL`JHUILHZT\S[PUH[PVUHSHZ[OL`^HU[I\[ [OL`JHU»[ULJLZZHYPS`L_LYJPZL[OLZHTLJVU[YVS^OPJOPZHNHPU[OLRL`[OPUN )\[THYRL[ZHYLH]LY`KPMMLYLU[[OPUN[VJHWP[HSPZT4HYRL[ZHYLQ\Z[[OLZ[Y\J[\YLKMVYTVM THYRL[HJ[P]P[`0M`V\NVZVTL^OLYLSPRL4L_PJV[OLYLPZHUPUJYLKPISLNYHZZYVV[Z[YHKPUN LJVUVT`L]LU[OYV\NO[OL`LHYZVMZVJHSSLKJLU[YHSWSHUUPUN7LVWSLQ\Z[[YHKLL]LY`[OPUN HUK[OH[PZ[OLNYHZZYVV[ZTVKLVMSPML[OLYL,]LY`IVK`Q\Z[WH`ZLHJOV[OLYHJV\WSLVM JLU[ZVY^OH[L]LYMVYL]LY`[OPUNI\[[OH[JPYJ\SH[PVUNP]LZL]LY`IVK`[OLVWWVY[\UP[`[V JYH^SVMM[OLNYV\UK(UKHSS[OPZPZ]LY`\YNLU[ILJH\ZL[OL^LSMHYLZ[H[LMVYL_HTWSLPZ V]LYHUKWLVWSLOH]L[VMPUKHUK^PSSMPUKHUKKVMPUKUL^^H`ZVMNL[[PUN[OLTZLS]LZ [VNL[OLY0[YLHSS`PZ[OLLUKVMIV[O[OLHK]HU[HNLZHUKKPZHK]HU[HNLZVMHKLWLUKLUJ` J\S[\YL0[»ZUV[HX\LZ[PVUVMHJ[\HSS`WYVTV[PUN[OH[0[Q\Z[PZOHWWLUPUN T/V^KV^LHJJLSLYH[LP[& Z(U`IVK`^OVHZRZ[OLZ[H[LMVYHU`[OPUNPZHSTVZ[HSYLHK`M\JRLK:VP[»ZHTH[[LYVM JYLH[PUNHYLHSHUHYJOPZT[OH[HJ[\HSS`^V\SKKLZ[YV`[OLZ[H[L>OPJOPZVMJV\YZLX\P[L OHWWPS`KLZ[YV`PUNP[ZLSMH[[OLTVTLU[:V[OH[»Z[OLWYVJLZZ[OH[JHUILLUJV\YHNLK +H[HJPKL(\[OVY!KH[HJPKL 7YPU[[OPZ(Y[PJSL ;HNZ(SPLU<UKLYNYV\UKÇ0U[LY]PL^ JVTTLU[Z`L[ 5VJVTTLU[Z`L[ 3LH]LH*VTTLU[ 5HTL 4HPS >LIZP[L 6XEPLW